National Recovery Plan 2011-2014: Statements
Contributions 1–119 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Today I begin a very important discussion and debate in this House regarding a four year plan which was published yesterday by the Government. I said then and now reiterate that it is part of a three-pronged strategy for the immediate period ahead, which is important for this country's vital national interests. It relates to the passing of a budget on 7 December and to the first instalment of the implementation of a programme that will not only bring order to our public finances, which is a prerequisite for growth, investment and confidence externally and domestically, but is also about a growth strategy as part of that process.
It is true to say the challenge we face is something we have not had to look at for many years, possibly for as much as a quarter of a century. The sort of correction we have to face is greatly exacerbated by an external international environment, not only in terms of economic prospects but fundamentally. The financial architecture that underpins our economic system worldwide has gained greatly in importance since our world has become far more interconnected and interdependent than was the case even 25 years ago, with capital and trade flows of a far greater volume and a far greater degree of sophistication than was then the case.
It is clear to all of us that this country has, by the provision of this plan, a signpost and a pathway to recovery which is within the recent experience of our people. The fear and uncertainty, the real concern and worry were exacerbated in many respects by some elements of what I would regard as irresponsible commentary. It was feeding a frenzy of doubt and creating a spiral of increased worry and concern rather than resolving or analysing in a dispassionate way the very serious problems we face as a country. The announcement yesterday of this plan gives people an opportunity to see what the level of adjustment will be in their own lives, to plan ahead for the future and to do so with a greater degree of confidence than in the absence of such a plan.
There are a number of things to be said about this plan and about where our people now stand in regard to the nation's business. Everybody knows from their own household budget experience that a country cannot continue in the same way in the aftermath of a serious crisis, the likes of which we have not seen, one of such magnitude and global impact that it has been compared to the Wall Street crash of 1929. That was the occurrence back in autumn 2008 which is still reverberating around the world. It is important to point out that from their own household experience people know that one cannot go on with a situation if one's revenues are back to what one earned in 2003 but one's spend is up to date in 2010 terms. People know that is not a sustainable position and, therefore, they want to know how the country can change that situation in terms of national finances and bring about a state of balance. They need to have, in some detail, an idea of how that might be done. Whatever people want in terms of the plan's detail, however, they understand the framework. They understand that the idea behind this plan is that our taxation system needs reform and we need to see increased levels of taxation coming into the national Exchequer to bring income for national purposes up to levels of the order of what we had in 2006. We also know that the level of spend in our economy has to reduce to levels people saw around 2007. That adjustment, or that closing of the accordion effect, in terms of people's understanding of what is happening, will enable people to see from their own recent experience that this does not mean they have to go back to a lifestyle or a living similar to, say, 25 years ago when, clearly, the quality of life and the standard of living we had at that time was very different from this generation's experience.
What it means, what we can glean from that understanding, is that many of the important economic and social gains we have seen under successive Governments in the previous ten or 15 years before this crisis can be maintained. There are inherent gains. Investments were made which are still with us. Sometimes the portrayal of the very serious crisis we have to confront is understood to mean that everything went out with the sea, or that all that we did was a wasteful experience from which we obtained no community, social or economic gain. That is a very misrepresentative view, a very fallacious and exaggerated view of the problems we have to face. I do not diminish those problems for a moment.
People need to know about the investments we have made in our education system, in improving our transport infrastructure and in our research and development community, the research we have done in industrial promotion and the far more diversified economy we now have. The fact is that 1.86 million go to work in this country in the aftermath of a crisis, two and a half years on from something which hit us so hard over the following two years, almost, people felt, with an economic tsunami effect. There was a reduction in output of 15% and we saw people's standard of living reduce. It hit us in terms of a crisis in confidence, given the incremental improvements we had seen year on year in the previous period. Many of those gains in infrastructural terms can be maintained. Similarly, without going into an economic history lesson because we want to focus on the present and the future, the election campaign will give us an opportunity to go over some of those issues again in more detail. However, it is also important to point out that during those good times, as a country, reflecting societal views and values, we ensured that those on the lower end of the scale benefitted. We improved our pension provisions and made sure we brought in assistants to help our teachers and mainstream those with disabilities into our education system. We are spending more than €1 billion of our €8 billion education budget to ensure that those people are integrated into our system and have potential and prospects to live inclusive lives. That may not have been the case in a prior era of institutionalisation and lack of resources, with a far less enlightened culture. There are so many things that have improved, qualitatively and quantitatively.
It is not in any way to engage in justification of the past. Let that be dealt with, in all of its ups and downs and pluses and minuses, in the context of future democratic contests.
It is important for our people to know that not all of those gains are going to seep away. There is going to be a further adjustment, in addition to the adjustment in our standard of living we have seen in the past number of years, as we try to cope with the impact of this problem. Throughout the good years when there were increases in our resources we maintained a level of spend as a percentage of our overall GNP — the overall worth and value of our economy — which was pretty static, at around 28%. In other words, whatever investments we made and increased improvements we were able to give in whatever way we could were given to help working families. This was done by increasing the rate of income which would attract income tax, from €7,500, as it was at the beginning when things began to pick up, to more than €18,000. We did whatever we could do to improve age exemption limits for people who were elderly and had pensions. Whatever we could do in all of these areas, there was a greater degree of progressivity and help for those people.
When we introduced the minimum wage, which has been increased on many occasions, there was a view that we would keep it out of the tax net. That narrowed our tax base because we had more people in that area who had to be accommodated. There are a number of people who have wages above that level but which are related to that figure.
We now have an infrastructure to train people and favourable tax policies. Credit must now be made available by fixing the banking problem. This will include providing firepower beyond the capacity of our State behind which we can bring whatever extra capitalisation is needed to the banking system, and intensify as necessary the initiatives that we have brought forward thus far. The purpose is to make our banking system work so that it is part of the integral process of growing and building confidence for the future.
The growth rate we have set out for this plan is about 2.75%, which is based on ensuring that we have a net increase in jobs of over 90,000 between 2012 and 2014, bringing unemployment down below 10% and making the adjustment of €15 billion, to be comprised of two thirds on the spending side and one third on taxation. We are proposing that balance because we believe it provides the best prospect of maintaining and growing employment. Other parties take a different view. We have set out what our proposals will mean for overall tax policy. We will have to see a sharing of the burden and those who earn most will have to pay most.
However, we cannot have a situation where more than 40% of working people are outside the tax net. There will have to be a contribution which is proportionate to their income as part of this attempt to redesign a tax system which would be sustainable for future circumstances. That can be done by respecting the principles of equity and progressivity while at the same time ensuring that everyone has to make contribution to the system.
If, for the sake of this debate, we take the Labour Party view, where half the reduction is through taxation and the other half through expenditure savings, what would that mean in terms of extra taxation? We would have to raise €7.5 billion rather than €5 billion in taxes. What would that come from? We propose a 16.5% reduction in tax bands and credits which would bring in about €1.8 billion. If the Labour Party perspective was to prevail, then to get an extra €1 billion as a contribution to the extra €2.5 billion one would have to have another 10% reduction in tax bands and credits. One would also have to double what we are doing on the site value tax, which would bring in another €500 million. One would probably have to double the carbon tax. If one wanted to see if some capital tax could be introduced, one could look at asset values, etc., and try to get another €300 million or €400 million there. One would also have to increase the VAT rate by another 2% to bring it up to 25%.
If the idea is that we can do this by taking measures, half of which fall on the taxation side and half on expenditure then the design of the programme changes significantly and the imposition of further taxes and the impact it would have on a recovering economy in terms of a growth strategy would be detrimental. We have opted for the strategy set out in the plan because we want to maintain jobs and have a growth strategy which has a prospect of working.
It is very important that we try to look at the growth strategy we have. In the real economy, even during this major correction in our economic fortunes, we are seeing an increase in exports and gains in competitiveness as a result of the policies we have already implemented. In this plan we are setting out the further sectoral policies which are needed to help in that area. The action to drive economic growth incudes the reaffirmation of the Government's unambiguous position of maintaining the 12.5% corporation tax rate, which is the cornerstone of our enterprise policy. Action has been taken to reduce costs for businesses and professional services. These will be ongoing and, together with the introduction of new and better focused business investment which will target employment schemes, they will help small businesses by transforming the old BES scheme.
We intend to maintain a high level of investment in research and development and innovation, double the number of industry-led research competence centres and target an increase in tourists to 8 million by 2015. Some of the initiatives in that respect were outlined yesterday by the Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport, Deputy Mary Hanafin. We will also liberalise visa restrictions for visitors from long-haul markets, make proposals to develop Ireland as a location for green data services, establish an international content services centre, which is at a progressed stage, and look towards our natural resources in agriculture, agritourism and agribusiness, which have shown great resilience.
I remember at the height of the crisis in 2009 people suggested 40% of our agrifood business base would go because of a lack of competitiveness. Yet, the decisions we took meant that practically all of those bases not only survived but have the prospect of thriving on the basis of the food harvest 2020 strategy, which is now being put in place. They have added value to the agrifood sector and exports by over 40% during that period. Developing Ireland as an international centre for food and making sure that we can drive forward the many advantages with the elimination of quotas and a grass-based production system is something that has been set out in great detail. Tourism and agrifood businesses will be areas of growth based on indigenous enterprise that can be scaled up and internationalised, as we have seen.
If we want to create more jobs we have to continue with the competitiveness agenda, the central object of which is to ensure that economic growth is translated into the maximum possible number of jobs, then the barriers to employment decisions have to be removed. Many of the young and semi-skilled are not in the labour market and the challenge is to ensure they are able to participate in it. In this regard the Budget Statement by the Minister for Finance will include further details in addition to those announced in the four year plan. We recognise it is not just a question of activation, it is also a question of people getting access to jobs in an environment that can create jobs. We also recognise that we have to open up the labour market measures in order to maximise employment. That is of fundamental importance and must be proceeded with. We will also extend the PRSI employers' exemption schemes which incentivise employers to create jobs for people on the live register into next year.
A number of new and expanded work placement and upskilling programs will be introduced to help those on the live register back into employment, the details of which will be announced in the budget. Major reform to activation measures will be implemented which will ensure that there is regular engagement with people on the live register and that they are offered pathways to work, training or education. There is a need for control measures to make sure that people who are entitled to support are not denied that support as a consequence of activities in the black economy or because of those who use the State to earn an income in a way which is not in compliance with the rules or regulations that apply. It will require a very focused approach on all our parts.
In regard to the reduction in expenditure, basically, we have three components in our expenditure programmes. Public sector pay and pensions is approximately one third, social welfare is approximately one third and programme costs are approximately one third. We have outlined how we will reduce it by €7 billion on the current side over the next four years. Some €1.2 billion will come from payroll and pension costs, €3 billion from programmes and €2.7 billion from social welfare.
We have already gone half way to reduce by 8% the number in the public service against the high of the end of 2008. That will involve of the order of 25,000 whole time equivalents leaving the public service. We will see the number in our Civil Service going back to 2001 levels. The number in the HSE will have to go back to 2005 levels. There will be 13,000 gardaí, which will be back to 2006-07 levels. These are the sorts of changes that must take place in various parts of the public service.
If we are to meet our commitments under the Croke Park agreement, which we have set out to do, it must be on the basis of full implementation of that agreement. It will be critical in terms of redeployment and of looking at all the industrial relations issues which have arisen piecemeal for many years and which will now have to be dealt with in a comprehensive way. We must get more from less. We are not in a position to provide affordable public services on the basis of current structures.
Budgets are being cut in agencies by more than 10% as they are being amalgamated, changed or reoriented completely. We must see redeployment across the public service, not only within sectors but across sectors, whether the non-commercial semi-State bodies, the health service or education. This will be a huge challenge for everyone in the public service.
People recognise that if we proceed in the spirit and to the letter of the agreements we have reached, then there are prospects for us to make the changes. These changes must be made, otherwise we will put at risk the very services on which the vulnerable and those who require them depend. It is unacceptable in the situation in which we find ourselves not to be able to demonstrate the sort of flexibility and best practice approach across all levels of the service to ensure that with the money available from taxpayers, we minimise disruption of the services for those who require them and that we can improve services by taking on many of the technologies and practices which are evident in parts of the service but, unfortunately, not uniformly so across all aspects of the public service.
It involves a huge challenge. When one looks at this plan, the overall objective is to ensure that by 2014, we have a country in which unemployment is below 10%, in which public finances are back in order, which has been able to maintain investment, create jobs and provide prospects on a sustainable basis for all our people and which has a reformed public service provision that ensures efficiency and effectiveness in the delivery of services and the organisational changes that are required, possible and now agreed between the stakeholders, whether management, unions or Government, for the delivery of those reformed services.
The growth strategy is fundamental. Any suggestion that there is an absence of stimulus in regard to this growth strategy does not make any sense for the following reason. We have not only a deficit crisis but a debt crisis. We are not in the markets borrowing money. Currently, we are in the process of providing for a facility to provide stability for this country over the next three years and beyond and we must ensure we put in place and underpin the prospects of fixing and repairing the banking system not for the banking system itself, but because we cannot have a modern economic system without it. We must ensure those who create wealth and jobs, those with an entrepreneurial spirit and those creating enterprises which are providing jobs for our people, are supported in every way.
Despite the cutbacks in expenditure, we are maintaining and, indeed, increasing the level of investment in research, development and innovation. Those societies that will succeed in the modern world in which we live, in the post crisis world we now inhabit, must be those which are prepared to innovate most and which are able to provide cost-efficient solutions to the problems people face and goods and services at affordable prices on international markets.
We have seen an improvement in our export performance as a result of what we have done thus far and we must intensify that effort. We have seen an increase in businesses and in investment coming into this country because we are still able to be marketed as a country which is well-educated, flexible and has the ability to the use the technologies the modern multinational corporation networks now provide and which provide considerable and hugely important employment and, most importantly, bring in significant resources in tax revenues to our shores for the purposes of providing the services our people need.
As we face into a new year and we hopefully complete the important national work of having published this plan and given people an indication of the size of the adjustment they will have to make going forward and having given them a realistic and ambitious understanding of what we can achieve, we must pull together as a country in the critical times. We must recognise that we can look to the new year with a greater sense of clarity. People want a greater degree of certainty.
When people talk about renegotiation, changing plans and suggesting that all of this can be all worked out again, I make one point. What has been set out here is a realistic appraisal of what is possible, necessary and doable. If people say they want to make changes, ensure they add up and that they do not create more uncertainty at a time when this country critically needs some certainty. I say that in a constructive way to the House because everyone has a perspective on these issues and a hope that we can pull through in these difficult circumstances.
What is critical for this country is that this House rises to the challenge on 7 December and implements the budget so that our people can know that we will go forward in 2011 with the sort of support we need, the sort of facilities in place that are required and that we have a plan with which we can go forward. After all of that in 2011, we can go to the people and ask them to decide who they believe should govern them on the basis of who has the most coherent policies and the best prospect of success.
Other generations have come through other recessions. I am not for one moment diminishing the significance of what we confront but it is surmountable and possible for us to come through. In the new year, we can still live as one community, live with good neighbours, good family networks and people who are prepared to go out work for their country and their families and who are prepared to do more because they know there is less available.
People want to see fairness and equity and to see everyone contribute. That is fundamental to what Ireland is about. We will see in our budget and from this Government's perspective every effort being made to demonstrate that also is part of the equation because it must be in the interest of social solidarity and community coherence.
If we objectively analyse this plan, we will realise it is the considered view of this Government that it provides the best balance between how we close the gap between what we spend and what we earn, between what needs to be changed in terms of public service provision and how we ensure our programmes are still in place and between how we maintain jobs and an investment strategy and ensure we have a taxation policy and system which will raise sufficient revenues to meet the corrections and the adjustments that must be put in place.
All that said, we believe this plan offers the best prospects upon which to build the four annual budgets needed to get us through this crisis with growth, jobs and support for those in the productive private sector. Ultimately, we must look to such people for net job creation as we reform our public services, not because we devalue or diminish their importance and that of those working in such services, but because we need an affordable model in future with the necessary reforms outlined. That will secure the future for ourselves and our children.
Comment on this
What has the Government been doing for the past four years?
Comment on this
I listened to the Taoiseach's speech and it reminded me of a farewell speech to the local Fianna Fáil cumann in Clara or down in his own constituency.
Comment on this
The Government should just call the election.
Comment on this
——that Fianna Fáil has been in government for the past 13 years.
Comment on this
Deputy Kenny will be in the White House on St. Patrick's Day. He should tell us what he will do.
Comment on this
Deputy Kenny's parish pump politics.
Comment on this
Deputy Kenny is great at the parish pump.
Comment on this
That is coming from the biggest parish pump of them all.
Comment on this
The Deputy is good at the parish pump.
Comment on this
The most important people in this building are the people in the Gallery and their generation.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Taoiseach saw the television cameras panning across the Cabinet during the closing remarks of his speech but I have never seen such a po-faced, sombre, demotivated and beaten crowd as I saw on that screen.
Comment on this
The Deputy should look at his own Front Bench.
Comment on this
Shining from their eyes was not conviction but guilt. They know they had the responsibility, opportunity and influence to change our nation for the better but failed to do so.
Comment on this
The people will savage Fianna Fáil when they get the opportunity.
Comment on this
The Government has sunk the country.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is speaking about an election at some time in 2011. God forbid that would happen. I wish we were now in the throes of an election that would bring the certainty and clarity spoken of by the Taoiseach. I met an engineer the other day who is 23 years old and fully qualified. He told me he had a permanent visa for Australia and was going to travel to and stay there as he would get a reasonably well paid job and be able to settle down. When I asked him if he would ever return to Ireland, he said he would not because every cent of income tax he would pay in this country for the rest of his life would go towards repairing the consequences of bankers' recklessness and greed, which were allowed to happen under the Taoiseach's watch.
Comment on this
It was encouraged by the Government.
Comment on this
I saw the Minister for Finance present this document yesterday. I heard him say previously that he invited robust political debate, which I respect. I like Deputy Brian Lenihan on a personal basis. What I saw and heard yesterday was an act of supreme arrogance, as the Minister said any other plan or alternative is nonsense.
Comment on this
This Minister presided over the greatest economic catastrophe in this nation's history and along with the Taoiseach, he has invited people from abroad and the IMF to this country because the Government has led us to a position where we have never been before. The founders of the Taoiseach's party never envisaged that our economic sovereignty would be cast away.
The Minister for Finance came into the Chamber to tell us this would be the cheapest bank bailout in history. He said the Irish taxpayer would make a profit from the recapitalisation of the banks. Did I hear him correctly? He stated that Anglo Irish Bank could not be wound down because it was of systemic importance to the Irish economy. He told us the negotiations with the subordinated bondholders in Anglo Irish Bank would destroy Ireland's reputation. This is the same Minister for Finance who a week ago said we did not need any outside help. Afterwards, the Taoiseach announced that those people were invited to this country.
I will not take any lectures from a Government that, to put it mildly, was not fully in compliance with the truth when speaking to this Parliament and the Irish people. The Taoiseach and his Government have failed to live up to the charge, trust and responsibility given to them by the Irish people. They are now involved in negotiations in what amounts to a contract or agreement and the Irish people, from what I hear, will never be able to rise to meet the level of repayment involved if forced down this route. That agreement has the Government as the principal partners on what is essentially a board of directors. Under Article 29.5.2° of the Constitution, that agreement should be approved by this House. If we are talking about interest rates above 5%, the process will place this country, our taxpayers and the younger generation in a catastrophe.
I recognise there are many great elements to our country and it has enormous potential. The Government has led our country and people to the edge of this economic abyss. Nobody else had a part and it was on the Government's watch that all this happened. I listened to the Minister for Finance yesterday talking about the party having posters in the last election about more gardaí, nurses and teachers, making the extraordinary claim that my party put forward a proposition to get rid of 30,000 gardaí, teachers and nurses. How arrogant can one be? I remember posters from his party indicating that health cuts hurt the old, sick and lonely.
We have been led to a point where negotiations are to be concluded at the end of this month and early in December that may, from what I hear, place an excessive and extraordinary burden on the Irish taxpayer and generations to come. This document will not constrain or confine the next Government; it is a Fianna Fáil document. Departments and local authorities are littered with documents like this one which have never been acted upon.
This is the hallmark of what Fianna Fáil has always said in respect of reforming institutions and service delivery. This is a plan which the Taoiseach has argued will bring clarity and certainty to what is happening. He has said in respect of reforming institutions and service delivery that greater productivity must be achieved, along with greater accountability. He has argued that the performance of organisations and individuals must be better. The Minister for Social Protection has said nurses will not be sweeping the streets.
Comment on this
He asked for prayers in Donegal, and they may well be necessary. This document does not provide certainty and clarity required to get this nation back where it should be. It does not address the real potential or open itself up to receiving the contributions that Irish people are prepared to make, provided they are recognised and respected as being fair. The Government made a big point about reducing the minimum wage but it has not acted on the other end of the scale, where exceptional salaries still apply. Nothing has been done about starting the process in this place about the cost of governance and the way we do business, and the Government is refusing to do so even today. It has indicated that we will come back some time at the end of January to debate the Finance Bill, whenever and if it is produced.
Everything for this Government is akin to groundhog day.
People have had enough. As I have stated previously, the Government should have gone by now. If the traditional definition of madness is to do the same things over and over, then this Government's economic and banking policy fits into that category.
Thousands of people woke up this morning and looked at the state of their lives and their circumstances, as the Taoiseach noted. They wonder if they will be able to manage or pay for the charges that are coming, the food on the table and the medicines they need to stay well. Older people will look out at frost-bitten ground this morning and wonder whether next year will be like the past year except worse and where they will find the resources needed to heat their homes. Meanwhile, in the air-conditioned skyscrapers of Frankfurt and elsewhere they will be licking their lips at the millions to be made by betting against this country. Our country was not brought to this point only by the incompetence of the Government.
Even as the Government was outlining its plan yesterday, interest rates on Irish bonds were rising again. It is not sufficient to say it takes a while for confidence to be restored — it does — because there is no belief in the Government and it has no credibility left. That is the principal reason people do not want to invest here.
What was needed was a plan that was open and honest. The plan before us does not fit those criteria. What we got was a document which pretends to deal with the real crisis facing the country. The Government was supposed to set out the details of a four year strategy. While there is a front-loading in respect of year 1 of the strategy, where are the details the Government was supposed to provide for the subsequent years? Where is the evidence of the real and radical political reform people are crying out for and which would demonstrate some sense of leadership and understanding of what are Ministers' responsibilities? The Green Party has left Government but is still on the benches opposite. Whether it was a rush of blood to the head that caused it to make its decision, I do not know but its Ministers are still members of a Cabinet in which they have no confidence and where treachery and betrayal are on the table. This is not the way to run a country, particularly in these circumstances.
If the savings provided for in the plan are to be used for the continuation of what has been a catastrophic failure of banking policy and if this forms the entire basis of Ireland's economic deal with the European Union and International Monetary Fund, this country is clearly on a road to a decade of economic stagnation and potential insolvency. I do not yet know what is the nature of the negotiations in which the Government and IMF are involved but I would like to find out what is the IMF's analysis of the growth projections for Ireland if it believes taxpayers can pay back at what appear to be excessive and exorbitant interest rates. I intend to ask the IMF about this.
This document does not deal with the root cause of the problem, namely, the failure of the Taoiseach and his Government to get an effective public sector which delivers value for money and services for people. Page 65 of the plan states this will have to be the case. This is not the type of plan which will enliven things in such a way as to allow us to say we are on the road to recovery.
The failure to reflect the additional costs of the Government's failed banking policy makes a joke of the public finance projections underpinning the plan. Their absence makes the debt forecast nonsensical.
Comment on this
The projections will be out of date next week, even before the budget is delivered. The reckless bailouts have been at the core of the Government's failure to restore domestic and international confidence. The mantra by the Minister for Finance that bailing out reckless banks and their investors was necessary to protect Ireland's credit rating has proven to be a catastrophic misjudgment.
In previous times, the Taoiseach's predecessor wrote blank cheques to his predecessor. The Government has gone one better in that blank cheques have been written from the taxpayer to Anglo Irish Bank and other reckless lenders to bail out their investors. This blank cheque policy has destroyed Ireland's creditworthiness. If it were not for the historical and potential future losses for Irish taxpayers arising from the Government's banking policy, our public finance problems would be judged by the financial markets to be difficult but manageable.
I believe in this country but I will not be bound by the Government's four year plan. As I stated yesterday, while I accept the targets as being clear, the proposals and a number of issues in the plan will be renegotiated.
During the past two years, the Government had a clear choice between protecting the State and its people or bailing out reckless investors and even more reckless bankers. It chose the latter option every time and forced the taxpayer to take responsibility for the massive debts built up by Anglo Irish Bank and others.
I met a senior team from one of the world's largest investment companies last week. It described the National Asset Management Agency as a bureaucratic monster that was destroying value and confidence in Ireland's economy. NAMA has paralysed the property market. If one speaks to any auctioneer or anyone involved in property, one will find that nothing is moving because everything is blocked up in NAMA.
The scams that are taking place have become evident. Some developers seek to make a killing on funding from within NAMA to complete particular projects. They deliberately ask potential subcontractors to overprice works in order that a pay-off can be made. This issue needs to be addressed because NAMA has paralysed and caused gridlock in the property market.
The Fine Gael Party was the first party to argue that it was completely unfair for Irish people to shoulder all the losses arising from the banking crisis, whether through nationalisation or the establishment of the National Asset Management Agency. It was only fair that people who had lent recklessly to the banks should share the pain. It is a basic rule of capitalism that if one lends recklessly to failed institutions, one must take some of the consequences.
The European Commission has confirmed that the next Government need not be bound by the four year plan of what is now a tired, unimaginative and demotivated Government. As I stated, I accept the deficit target of 3% of GDP by 2014. What is needed to achieve this target is a Government with a strong, clear mandate from the people. Once people have given their verdict, a new Government can implement its plans by placing a strong emphasis on a number of areas. It would first cap taxpayers' exposure to further banking losses. Second, it would introduce real economic reforms to spur growth and jobs and, third, it would create a smaller, better, and more effective State, as set out in Deputy Bruton's document, Reinventing Government.
The bedrock of any credible economic plan agreed with Europe must be a new banking policy which limits the State's exposure to further losses from the banks. We all agree that we need to repair, restructure and adequately capitalise Irish banks to underpin our guarantee on savings and get credit to business flowing again. The Taoiseach should talk to the owners of small businesses. Despite what has been said, many of the conditions laid down by banks preclude businesses from securing credit. The other day, I was contacted by a man whose company has an annual turnover of €1.5 million. He had his €40,000 overdraft facility reduced to €5,000 and told me one could not run a sweet shop on such an overdraft.
While I agree with the Taoiseach's sentiment that it is necessary to free this up, he is not in a position to make it happen. Although economic reforms are really needed to spur growth and jobs, the plan does not spell this out in any detail. This is nothing like what can be achieved or like the potential that exists. In that respect, this document is both a disappointment and a failure. The Government has done nothing to overhaul the regulatory and economic bureaucratic red tape. When one sees the evidence of what is strangling those who wish to contribute to the well-being and future of the country, it is evident where the Government has been strangled by its inability to deal with this issue.
If we are to have a nation that will measure up by 2016 and beyond, we really must change the way in which we do business. This document makes no reference to leadership by example from the seat in which the Taoiseach is sitting. Throughout the Government and local authorities and right down the line, there is no evidence but only aspirations as to what can be achieved. In this sense, this document has been a gross disappointment because people expect leadership from the front. They want to see it at the centre and to be shown the way from the top down. One should appeal to Irish people, particularly that young generation whose representatives are leaving the Gallery at present, as they are the future of our country. However, the national recovery plan will not realise the potential that exists. Whenever the population decides to elect whatever Government it wishes, if I have anything to do with it issues in this plan will be renegotiated and the next Government will not be bound by them.
Comment on this
This plan is the added price the people of Ireland must pay for 13 years of Fianna Fáil misrule. It is a price that must be added to the price already paid by those who have lost their jobs, whose businesses have gone or whose pay and services have been cut. This price must be paid by pensioners and people on the lowest pay, as well as by families and households nationwide. In his speech in this House today, the Taoiseach invites us to forget about the past——
Comment on this
—— and to all round the new year together. Consider this plan as some kind of down payment or deposit on another four or five years of Fianna Fáil rule. That is what this plan is about. This plan is the direct result of the politics of the Galway tent and of "show-time". It is the result of the unbelievable political arrogance and folly of the worst Governments in the history of this State. There was another example of this arrogance yesterday from the Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, who stated that anything that is put on the table that is not contained in this plan is nonsense. This is the same Minister who told us that the bank guarantee was the cheapest in the world. This is the same Government that told us that it would not cost the taxpayer anything. It is the same Government that told us, when the Labour Party suggested the taking into temporary public ownership of the main banks rather than the NAMA strategy, that this was nonsense too. Now the banks must be taken into public ownership anyway at enormous additional cost and still are mired in NAMA. While this is the work of the Taoiseach and the Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, it also is the legacy of the former Taoiseach, Deputy Bertie Ahern, the former Minister, Mr. McCreevy and the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Harney.
It is the direct result of the bank guarantee that joined the future of the State to failed banks. This plan proposes €15 billion in budget adjustments, starting with €6 billion in 2011. It is a recipe for hardship and stagnation, for delayed ambitions, unfulfilled potential and broken dreams. Yet, for all that, the sad reality is that a programme of adjustment now is unavoidable. However, one should note from the outset that the status of this plan remains unknown. Is it a document that has been agreed with the European Union and the IMF and which will form part of the loan agreement between Ireland and the international community? Is it to be part of the memorandum of understanding for that loan? Alternatively, is it a negotiating document that is subject to change and revision before the final deal is concluded? Is it simply the Fianna Fáil manifesto for a general election that now is both inevitable and imminent but which that party will wish to delay for as long as possible into the new year? Ministers have been claiming for weeks that the plan has the blessing of the IMF and the European Union. However, a spokesperson for the Department of Finance yesterday stated otherwise, indicating that the plan can be changed in negotiations. The question is how much has been approved and agreed and how much might be changed. Members do not know the answers to these questions, just as they do not know so much else about the negotiations that are going on behind closed doors.
For example, they do not know who is negotiating on behalf of Ireland. The public now is more familiar with the principals from the IMF and European Union teams than they are with the Irish negotiators. It is known that Mr. Chopra is negotiating for the IMF and that Commissioner Rehn is in overall charge of the negotiations for the European Union but who exactly is negotiating for Ireland and exactly what are they negotiating? The size of the loan is unknown nor is it known how much of it will go straight into the banks. Moreover, the rate of interest that will be charged is unknown, which is a critical issue. Professor Karl Whelan of UCD has raised this issue and has shown calculations that suggest an interest rate of 6% or perhaps 7%. This would have enormous consequences for Ireland and the Government must reveal both what it is negotiating as a credit facility and that this is what is being negotiated, rather than some kind of sub-prime loan. There is no justification and no rationale for charging Ireland more than Greece and the Government should insist on a better deal. This is Ireland's problem but it also is a euro problem and responsibility works both ways. When the deal is concluded, will the four year plan bind the next Government, a Government of which this Fianna Fáil Cabinet is unlikely to form any part?
As I have said on many occasions, the Labour Party supports the target of cutting the deficit to 3% by 2014. It does so not because we believe it will be easy to achieve but because it is necessary for Ireland to stabilise its public finances. However, we do not support the notion that the adjustment should be front-loaded with a figure of €6 billion in 2011. This level of front-loading poses a grave risk to jobs and growth and is a risk that should not be taken. Moreover, the Labour Party is supported in this position by the leading article in today's edition of the Financial Times, which I will quote to the Taoiseach. It states:
Cuts of this magnitude could throw Ireland back into recession. That would be a tragedy: yawning as it is, Ireland's fiscal gap is the least of its challenges; a slower pace of consolidation might have been its best bet at encouraging growth.
The Taoiseach challenges the Labour Party about its statement to the effect that a €6 billion adjustment should not be undertaken in the first year but that such an adjustment should be more modest and should be balanced on a broadly 50:50 basis. The Taoiseach plucked figures from the air and suggested such an approach would mean this much more on this tax and that much more on the other tax. This misses the entire point, which is that we must allow the economy to grow and get people back to work. If this is done, tax revenues will increase because more people will be at work and the economy will be more successful. However, the more that is cut from it, the more likely one is to drive the economy further into recession.
It is important to remember where that figure of €6 billion came from, because it has become a kind of Holy Grail. It emerged in the last weeks before Ireland sought external assistance at a time when the idea was that one had to impress the markets. The argument was being made by the Government that the markets would be impressed were Ireland to get its deficit down below 10%. The claim was made that bond dealers, who work for international banks, would be fooled into believing that €9.99 is not a tenner.
Now that strategy has failed. In fact, the €6 billion figure impressed nobody, because it was clear that an adjustment on that scale would pose a grave risk to growth. Now, however, the Government does not believe it can row back on that figure, even though we are no longer in the market. How clever does the €6 billion look now?
Comment on this
This plan is called a plan for national recovery. In fact, it is a plan for austerity, not for recovery. There is no coherent jobs strategy in the plan. There is plenty of waffle about the so-called smart economy.
Comment on this
This is the same stuff we have been hearing about for almost two years.
The section on jobs is short on detail, particularly compared to the detail on cuts and tax increases. Where, for example, are the concrete numbers on training and employment programmes? The only numbers referred to are the small numbers already provided for. Where is there an investment strategy that uses what limited resources we do have? There are references to investment from the National Pensions Reserve Fund. Given the track record of the Government, it is clear that this is not serious and is not intended to happen. Instead, it is argued that the pensions reserve fund will buy Government bonds. That is code for saying we are about to liquidate what we can.
The proposals in the document are not fair and they are not balanced. Even after all the damage the Government has done, this plan provides a hard landing for PAYE workers and a soft landing for the friends of Fianna Fáil. There is no indication that those who have the most will contribute the most. There is no higher tax rate for the highest earners, no cap on high-level pensions and no cap on the highest level of public sector pay. Higher capital taxes are postponed until 2012, while PAYE taxpayers are hit immediately.
There is a cut in the minimum wage, for which no compelling logic is presented and for which there is little real demand. I can see an argument for a review of the way the joint labour committee system works and for looking, for example, at the issue of premium payments for Sunday working. However, what is the point in cutting a minimum wage that affects fewer than 50,000 people? This is being done for purely ideological reasons. If the same logic is applied to sectoral wage agreements, then what we will get is a low-wage economy; but then, we have always known that the PDs in Fianna Fáil are in favour of a low-wage economy.
In his article in the Financial Times, the Minister for Finance quotes Abraham Lincoln, but there is nothing of the “better angels of our nature” about this plan. While those on the minimum wage are being hit now, the high-flying tax exiles are exempt once more. In a reply to Deputy Shortall, the Minister for Finance admitted that the contributions sought from tax exiles in last year’s budget will not yield a single cent before October 2011. After this budget, ordinary taxpayers and social welfare will have been hit twice but the tax exiles will continue to fly in and out of the country without the inconvenience of having to pay tax.
A number of proposals in the document, however, are in line with ideas the Labour Party has advanced. For years, Fianna Fáil have been denying that there is anything to be gained from cuts in tax expenditures. At last, the plan accepts that some €1.5 billion can be achieved from curtailing tax breaks and limiting relief for pension contributions, although again, we see no real commitment. If the Government was serious, there would be a proper minimum effect tax rate to ensure that everyone pays their fair share. There would also be a clear commitment to fairness in dealing with the pension relief issue, which has more to do with how much in total can be claimed in tax relief than the rate at which the relief is given.
It is also, unfortunately, necessary to curtail the capital programme, although it is disappointing that there is no alternative strategy set out to replace this spending from other sources, such as through a strategic investment bank, as has been proposed by the Labour Party. There are a number of innovative ideas for how this can be done, but the plan does not embrace any of them.
A further shift to environmental charges through the carbon levy is sensible, although the Government should now meet its commitment on fuel poverty.
There are also aspects of the plan that, once again, disappoint. For all the hype about the preparation of this document, and all the stories we have been told about the lengthy Cabinet meetings that went into preparing it, it contains the same old approach to public expenditure. What we are getting is butchery, not surgery. Once again, the Book of Estimates has been subjected to a crude hacking exercise rather than a truly comprehensive expenditure review.
What we need to see, and what should have happened two years ago, is a proper root and branch review of expenditure, along the lines of the Canadian model. Instead of sending in an external consultant to prepare a report, a proper expenditure review would be led by Ministers and Secretaries General. Instead of asking the question, "What can we cut?", you start with the question, "What are we trying to achieve?". You sit down and ask searching questions about what it is that Government is doing in providing the service, and how it is being provided. That is not an exercise that can be conducted from Opposition. It is an exercise that must be conducted by Government, where we look at a problem from first principles and redesign public expenditure accordingly. There is a reference in the document to such an exercise. It is called Government expenditure assessment, but it is no more than an aspiration.
Some spending cuts are particularly disappointing. The plan seeks €300 million in cuts from education but is unclear about how that will be achieved. It has been reported that this will mean a loss of 1,200 teaching posts, including language teachers for newcomer pupils and teachers for Traveller children. This is a fundamental U-turn on the so-called Green Party victory of 150 extra teachers promised in the revised programme for Government. They are now "deferred".
It is hard to see any logic in the proposed €200 charge for students in further education. Many of these students are from families with modest incomes, for whom this charge could be a real disincentive. What is the point in imposing a €200 annual registration charge when the alternative might be paying €200 per week to the same person on the dole? It is just one of the many mean-spirited elements of this plan. The concept of universal access to third level education is further eroded, with another hike in the, so-called, registration charge and a non-specific cut in student support.
The plan also sets targets for reductions in the social protection bill, but offers little in the way of specifics. The clear implication is that there will be significant cuts in rates and that these, too, will be front-loaded.
The most striking feature of all of this is that the Government has no mandate for this plan. It is negotiating a deal behind closed doors that will bind the next Government in a fiscal and economic straitjacket for the duration of the IMF-EU programme. A number of commentators have suggested that there may be room for manoeuvre in how the programme is implemented and that the IMF and EU will focus only on headline targets and allow the next Government to negotiate on how those targets are achieved, but there is no certainty about that. We do not know anything concrete about the deal that is being done on the banks. We do not know what the cost of that deal will be or whether there will be burden sharing with the bondholders. We do not even know what kind of banking sector Ireland will have next year.
I quote Professor Philip Lane in this morning's edition of The Irish Times:
The plan is silent on the impact of the banking crisis on projected growth rates. While much will turn on the resolution plans that are set to be announced in the coming days, some discussion of this key issue would have been welcome.
This is a critical point. The plan is based on the idea that there is strong underlying growth potential in the Irish economy, largely as a result of Ireland's capacity to export. I agree with that viewpoint. Ireland does have many strengths, and we do have a capacity to recover from this crisis. However, there is a lot about the way the Irish economy will perform that we do not know. We do not know how consumers will behave in the months and years ahead, if the rapid increase in the savings ratio will unwind and how quickly consumers will regain confidence. Nor do we know what impact the impaired banking system will have on the performance of the domestic economy. That uncertainty further underlines the need for caution in the way the budget adjustment is implemented. There is a capacity for more consumer spending and more investment activity once growth resumes and confidence is restored. However, these are highly uncertain, while the impact of withdrawing €6 billion from the economy is pretty clear-cut.
Unfortunately, we do not seem to have a Government that is capable of making that case on behalf of the Irish people. Of all the many gaps in this plan, perhaps the most striking is the lack of vision. In many ways, this plan is the instrument of surrender, offered up by a Government that is a beaten docket. It offers no bridge to the future and no sense of what we can achieve, as a people, if we come together to work our way out of this mess. It offers no bridge to the future. It offers no sense of what we can achieve, as a people, if we come together to work our way out of this mess.
We are not the first country to find ourselves in this kind of economic crisis. Even if the scale of the Irish disaster is particularly bad, we can still learn from others who have been through similar experiences. The lesson we can learn is that we must keep and protect our bridge to the future. We must know what it is that will underpin our prosperity and our sense of national unity in the days ahead. We must protect and defend it, and invest in it.
Much has been said in recent days about the 12.5% rate of corporation tax and the importance of keeping it. I agree with these comments. The Labour Party was instrumental in introducing that rate. However, there is more to Irish sovereignty and more to our future than the corporation tax rate.
We must understand that social solidarity is not an economic cost, but a vital economic foundation. What we needed to see in this plan was not just a sense of an economy, but of a society that offers our children a decent future. We need a realistic strategy on jobs, not just repetition of the same old stuff. We need a strategy with a strong commitment to building on Ireland's competitive strengths and investing in our future, supplying credit to firms, and getting people off the live register and into meaningful training and work experience. We did not get that because Fianna Fáil is incapable of it. We are living in the ruins of its discredited philosophy and policies.
The four year plan is the price of political failure. It is a heavy price indeed. The Taoiseach invites us to consider what kind of country we will have in 2014. I agree with all the objectives he set out for us today as to the kind of country we desire in 2014, a country with people back at work, with businesses working again, with confidence restored in our domestic economy and in our country among those abroad, with good quality public services, and with a reformed public service and a reformed body politic. We will only achieve this when the political change the country is crying out for comes about. I hope that will happen sooner rather than later.
Comment on this
I respect each of the political parties in this Dáil. We all have our own histories, strengths and weaknesses, my party included. I have been a Member for approximately ten years and have developed in that time a strong sense that Members from all parties have integrity and capability. My partners in Government have shown such integrity and capability. Should Deputy Kenny's party enter government, in whatever formation, in the coming months, I have no doubt he will demonstrate the management capability the public deserves. The same applies to the Labour Party. I do not believe we should be engaging in point scoring in this regard. We all have our country's interests at heart.
Comment on this
I apologise to Deputy Morgan. I include Sinn Féin in my remarks. Although I disagree with its assessment of what we can and need to do within the four year period, and with some of the protest approaches, I acknowledge there is room for different opinions in this regard, and for the views of Independents.
In this most fearful and difficult time for our country, it is important that we begin by establishing ground rules of respect for one another. People are looking for these and want us to offer them reassurance and security, which they and we all do not have at present. We all know in our hearts that this is a very challenging and difficult time. We need to address that. We have a duty of care to the people to try to minimise the sense of fear and manage a very difficult set of circumstances.
We need to protect the people in a number of ways. We need responsible debate in the House. The members of the media present should note that we need responsible debate in the media at this time on these complex and difficult issues. It is not easy to explain some of the issues. I can understand very well the sense of anger over what has occurred, and it is absolutely right to express it. While I understand the various views and ideas presented, we need to offer the people a sense of security and reassurance to allow for a public debate just at this time that respects different opinions and allows people to give details on what are very complex issues.
Comment on this
What does the Minister mean by "responsible"?
Comment on this
By "responsible", I refer to the way in which we treat one another, and even to our tone of voice and acknowledgement that there may be different views and approaches. I refer to responsibility that would prevent the debate from degenerating into a very angry one. I can understand why people are angry but do not believe it will help our people to solve the problem.
We must be very careful with figures. It is very easy to state on the radio or in the House that a certain figure is the correct one — for example, the figure pertaining to the debt interest cost when negotiating with the national bodies. In respect of such a simple figure, one must recognise there are all sorts of variables to be considered. One must consider whether there is a variable rate or fixed rate, or a three-year, five-year or ten-year term. The figure depends very much on which of these factors is taken into account. We need to be careful of figures and realise that, in complex issues, people need balanced and intelligent debate.
I have three questions on the four year plan, as published yesterday. The first concerns debt dynamics, a term I had not heard of until recent years but which is at the very heart of our management of this issue. I refer to the payment of debt on a sustainable basis over the next four to five years.
Deputy Gilmore asked the identity of the teams or people representing the Irish people. I want to answer because it is an important question. The Department of Finance is leading the negotiations but we are well served by the staff of key agencies, who have public-interest expertise in this area. I note from my experience of dealing with Mr. John Corrigan, head of the NTMA, that he is highly capable and very straight. I have never heard figures from him that I believed were incorrect. The same applies to the new Regulator, Mr. Matthew Elderfield, whom I believe has done a very rigorous job in stress-testing our banks to try to understand the scale of the problem. He has been joined in this regard by Professor Patrick Honohan. Central Bank Governors tend not to speak very much in public, and rightly so, but the public has a certain sense that Professor Honohan has expertise. I have noted others in our system, including the Secretary General of the Department of Finance and the key people in NAMA, who are very capable and very good public servants. All parties, not just Government parties, can work with them to ensure we understand the issues and achieve a good resolution for the Irish people.
At this time, in which we are in a particularly precarious position, it may be appropriate to park the valid debate as to whether an alternative approach, such as full nationalisation or an approach based on collapse or default, may have worked two years ago. At present, we must concentrate on a public debate on what we are doing now. Debates on alternative approaches are valid and can be engaged in but we need to concentrate on the very difficult and important task now facing us. We should do so in the debate on the debt dynamics issue.
Legitimate rage is expressed by those who ask why the taxpayer, rather than the private sector, must pay everything. That is a valid argument, on which I will outline my thoughts. The private sector has taken a hit. Deputy Kenny was not correct in saying that, at every step of the way, the Government looked for the taxpayer to take the hit. That is not an accurate assessment. I present as evidence the fact that approximately €40 billion of private-sector capital was wiped out as the banks' value was lost. This has affected many Irish pensioners and savers, who believed they had most secure and solid investments. For many, this was a really hard loss; it was a private-sector loss.
To date, bonds worth approximately €7 billion have been lost or written down, and rightly so. I would like this to be maximised, particularly in the context of protecting taxpayers, where appropriate. It is not the case, therefore, that taxpayers alone have been footing the bill. All parties represented in the House would favour a situation where it would not just be taxpayers who shoulder the burden. In addition, no one wants an approach to be adopted which might appear right and proper in the short term but which might cost us more in the long term. In that context, we must listen and talk to the members of our negotiating teams who have a good sense of what is required.
I put it to those opposite that when this most sensitive issue is considered by everyone at the weekend, it is the level of real engagement to which I refer which must be employed in order that we might examine the real options. We must evaluate, therefore, whether actions which might appear to make real political sense now might actually be disadvantageous in the medium or long term. That is something which is difficult to do in public. It is difficult to explain the nature of both bonds and bondholders. People are being obliged to deal with language which they do not understand.
It is difficult to understand what constitutes a bondholder. Descriptions of bondholders vary from speculators to hedge funds to short-term speculators against the State. However, I am informed — this can be checked and verified — that almost all of the senior bondholders in the Irish banks are pension funds and insurance companies. These entities are not speculators in the sense that they are seeking a quick buck in the short term. They are actually trying to realise profits on long-term investments. I would be extremely critical of what occurred in the context of the unchecked flow of capital from——
Comment on this
Yes. The description I have just provided characterises those with whom we are dealing and to some degree it colours our approach to and the action we propose to take in respect of this matter.
It is critical to ensure that we get our relationship with our European Union partners right. We must work with our colleagues in the European Union, who have been extremely supportive. The liquidity the European Central Bank has provided to the State and the guarantee it has advanced in respect of deposits in Irish banks — which affords to people a real sense of security that those deposits are safe — shows that the European Union has assisted Ireland. We must, therefore, work with our European Union partners now in order to ensure that we achieve the right outcome from the difficult negotiations that are taking place. It is not in the interests of our European Union partners to arrive at a debt repayment amount for the Irish State that is not sustainable. Our team is negotiating, in co-operation with our European Union colleagues, to ensure that the latter does not happen because it would be in no one's interests.
We must consider the elements that would be contained in a deal to allow the State to obtain a backstop guarantee in the event that it proves difficult to obtain money from the markets and which will permit the banks obtain capital should it be necessary to do so. I have been informed that the assessment of the stress tests carried out by Mr. Matthew Elderfield and Professor Patrick Honohan to date shows that there is not a huge iceberg of further losses within the banks. In light of the scale of the losses to date, some people feared that such an iceberg was looming beneath the surface. I understand that the stress tests which have been carried out — the IMF and our European Union partners can check the position in this regard — have been shown to have produced a picture which is reasonably accurate.
The need for capital may not be as great as some may fear. In that context, what we need is a contingency fund. I have no doubt that some additional moneys will be required in the context of dealing with some of the restructuring that will have to be done in respect of the banks in order to reduce them to a scale which is manageable and which suits the purposes of the Irish economy. We need to do this quickly and in conjunction with our European partners. That is why I stated earlier that we do not have a long time. In effect, we have days. The contagion effect that has occurred has raised fears in other markets. As Members are aware, fear feeds on itself. It is better, therefore, that we should try to take action quickly and in a collaborative way.
I stand open to correction but I understand that there may have been contacts between the European Union teams and the Opposition parties.
Comment on this
I have not had any discussion with them to date in respect of these matters.
Comment on this
I am very encouraged by the fact that such meetings are taking place. I commend——
Comment on this
The Taoiseach contacted me and made an offer which I was glad to accept.
Comment on this
That was the correct approach for the Taoiseach to take. Members of the public require some sense of security and they need to know that this will not be just a deal that will be concluded on the sidelines. Public servants are involved in doing the deal. However, it is important that the political parties in this House, with their sound, solid and honourable traditions, should have an input into the negotiations and should have their say.
Comment on this
As the Green Party did in the statement it made on Monday last.
Comment on this
I would like to outline the thinking behind what was done on that day. We all understand the public mood that obtains at present: the deep anger and the great sense of fear. A number of months ago, my party referred to the need for consensus. What we did on Monday was an attempt to remove politics from the equation in respect of some of the votes relating to the budget. I accept that there will be different views on the budget and on the spending allocations that will apply. That should be the case. However, what we tried to do was make it clear that voting for the budget would not be a vote for a Government that is going to last forever and a day. There are time limitations involved here. The Green Party is of the view that in the aftermath of the key tasks which we must complete, we should face the people and present our alternative strategies.
As the Taoiseach stated, the plan before the House will form the framework for certain analyses. I accept, however, that there may be different views. Some may question our motivation and our methods. However, I assure the Deputy that the Green Party's motivation was to try to create an atmosphere in which consensus politics might work.
Comment on this
It did not really work, did it?
Comment on this
Let us give it a try. That is what the people expect and what they would want at this difficult time.
Comment on this
People have inquired, in the context of the national recovery plan and the partnership model, whether we should have reappraised the Croke Park agreement, etc. I am of the view that the onus is going to be on management in the public service to ensure that real efficiencies are achieved in order that we will be in a position to do more with less. It may be easier for us to do this in the spirit of co-operation that was evident from people's willingness to sign up to the Croke Park agreement rather than in trying to break down the latter and formulate a more efficient system in some other way. That is my personal view. It will be a crucial task for whomever is in government in the coming years to manage the public service reform process. I am of the opinion that the latter should be done by using the process of partnership which has worked to the country's benefit in the past which everyone would recognise had its failings.
In the context of social partnership, it is incredibly difficult to make decisions to cut social welfare payments and so forth. If there are other ways in which we might manage the reduction in the budget spend and increase revenues in order to bridge the €15 billion gap that exists — which is something the two main parties in opposition want to see happen — I would love someone to identify them.
Comment on this
It is the Government's job to identify such ways.
Comment on this
We have not been involved in any of what has gone on.
Comment on this
I absolutely agree that it is our job to do so. However, it is not an easy job. If there are alternative or different ways of proceeding, I would be open to their being outlined in order that we might evaluate how they might work.
Comment on this
The Government did not search very hard for alternatives.
Comment on this
In the context of growth, a strategic decision was taken to protect enterprise, investment and education in the budget. These three areas are key to encouraging growth. We need to make our debt dynamics work. A development which has been of assistance in recent weeks is the fact that the matter of our 12.5% corporation tax rate has been placed on the back burner. I commend our French and German colleagues on recognising that this is not the time to introduce fundamental changes to our approach to enterprise, which continues to work to our benefit. We will need to adhere to that approach in order that we might, in the interests of this State and those of the wider eurozone, extricate ourselves from our economic difficulties.
Investing in enterprise, an area in which we have real strengths and capabilities and people with real skills, will allow us to create the type of growth that will assist in allowing us to emerge from our current difficulties. A great deal of this investment will go to the green economy. Deputy Bruton inquired earlier about investment plans relating to the smart grid, green energy and broadband. He is correct in identifying these areas because they are critical in the context of the action we need to take. State companies and those which operate the grid are making significant investments that will assist the economy in turning the corner. As a result of this, electricity and gas prices are decreasing and this will provide us with a competitive advantage. The development of renewables is bringing down the price of electricity here, which, according to the report, is the sixth cheapest among our comparator countries in the EU. Progress is being made. There is a growth opportunity, particularly in the green economy and in areas such as retrofit where we may use new funding mechanisms to help pay our way.
I understand Deputy Gilmore when he asks if there is risk in terms of a figure being so large that it has a deflationary effect, but I listened to the Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, yesterday and he made sense to me. Unfortunately, we must get back to single figures. We would be the only eurozone country not doing so and that is the dynamic which requires a €6 billion adjustment. I believe it can be done in a way that does not deflate the economy and that there is a pent-up skill and enterprise opportunity in this country that is very real. It needs a functioning banking system, it needs a wee bit of confidence back, but the capability, ingenuity and sense of inventiveness and enterprise of the Irish people is real. Even where we are contracting the public service, I believe there is an alternative expansion that can occur in the domestic economy that will make up for that and we can work our way through this.
Comment on this
It is not easy. It is scary. However, as my colleague, the Minister, Deputy Gormley, stated on Monday last, we have a duty of care. Our party is willing to contribute to ensure we get through this difficult period — get through the budget, get through the negotiations that we must conclude with our European colleagues and give the country a sense of confidence.
I believe we will do that better through as much consensus as possible among all the parties in this House. It does not mean agreeing on everything or compromising on anything. That sort of open debate and honesty is what the people seek as we head towards a very difficult few days and weeks. My sense on meeting Deputies of different parties here over the past week or so is that they share that view and I hope our debate here takes place in that spirit because it is what the people are looking for.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin wants national recovery for Ireland. We will do everything in our power to strive day and night for that objective, to serve the real national interest, and to work side by side with the Irish people in communities up and down the length and breadth of this country. That is what we stand for. That is what we have always stood for.
For that reason, because we have the national interest at heart, we want recovery and we believe there is a better way forward, we must oppose the so-called national recovery plan published yesterday by the Fianna Fáil-Green Party Government. This is not a plan for national recovery. It is a plan for national impoverishment. It is a savage plan which will force the people to pay dearly for what I described yesterday, and I make no apology for repeating it here today, as the economic treason committed by the Fianna Fáil-Green Party Government.
This Government has no right to impose such a plan on the people. The Dáil should be dissolved now on the plan's publication, the budget should be suspended and there should be a general election. It is a travesty of democracy that a four year plan should be framed by the most reviled Government in the history of this State, a Government whose life is now measured in weeks.
It is a plan delivered by a Cabinet, which, by the admission of its two Green Party members, including the Minister, Deputy Ryan, who has just spoken, has misled and betrayed the Irish people. Yet the leader of the Green Party stood beside the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance yesterday and lauded this four year plan to high heaven, having already handed in his party's notice to quit. It would be a pantomime if it were not so tragic. If the Ministers, Deputy Gormley and Deputy Ryan, and their colleagues believe so much in this plan, why are they not staying in Government to implement it?
The truth is that we have a threefold democratic crisis as well as a political crisis. First, the State is being sold out to the International Monetary Fund, the European Central Bank and international money-lenders, and what remains of our economic sovereignty is being destroyed. Clearly, it is an attack on Irish democracy. Second, a Government with no mandate purports to impose on the people a four year plan, an IMF-ECB deal and a budget for 2011. Third, the two so-called main Opposition parties, Fine Gael and Labour, have bought into the doomed strategy on which this plan is based. Despite all their rhetoric of the past three years and their repeated votes of no confidence in the Government and the Taoiseach, they cannot tell us whether they will vote to stop the budget on 7 December and to stop this plan. That is critical information not only for this House, but for their respective electorates and the people across the State.
Sinn Féin stands clearly in opposition to the Government, this plan and the Government's budgetary intent. We have shown that there is an alternative to the consensus for cuts. We have put forward rational, costed proposals to reduce the deficit through raising and saving revenue, to retain and create jobs through a major stimulus package and to protect public services and social supports. Similar proposals have been put forward by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, by the community and voluntary sector and by many economists, all of whom have shown that there is a better, fairer way. I totally reject the arrogant assertion by the Minister for Finance yesterday that anything put forward in the next general election and not based in this plan is nonsense. That is an outrageous statement on the part of a Minister for Finance at the conclusion of the announcement of the detail of this plan.
In his budget speech in December last, the Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, like a British general in First World War circumstances, told us that the worst was over and that the budget represented one "last big push". Now, like those same generals, the Minister and his Cabinet colleagues have refused to learn the lesson of their failed strategy and are sending the Irish people over the top once again into no-man's land — perhaps it should be NAMA land — to be cannon fodder for the banks, the ECB and the IMF. Shame on the Minister and the Government.
Despite the Minister for Finance's appeals, and the appeals of the Taoiseach and the Minister, Deputy Ryan, here this morning on the part of the Green Party, my party will not be signing up to their plan. What we need now is a dissolution of this Dáil, a general election to be held immediately and then, in the new Dáil, a progressive budget that will be part of a real plan for national recovery and that will have the confidence and support of the Irish people as a whole.
We also need a total change in banking policy. This is at the heart of all our ills. There can be no national recovery while the Government's criminal and treacherous banking policy continues. The structural deficit of this State can be dealt with, not in the way this so-called national recovery plan suggests, but through the measures that we in Sinn Féin and others have set out in our pre-budget submission and in other contributions from a variety of sources.
The Government is about to embark on what can only be described as an insane course of borrowing to fund a failed banking policy. We cannot afford this banking policy or this loan. We need real negotiators to deal with the banks and to burn the bondholders. Otherwise, this and future generations will be saddled with a debt that should never have been incurred and for which, clearly, they are not responsible. Not a euro more should go into the Irish banks until their debts are restructured, whether through burning the bondholders or giving them — we can consider it — debt-for-equity swaps. If the Government proceeds with its banking plan its so-called recovery plan is redundant day one.
This plan aims to make an adjustment of €15 billion over four years. This is a figure that sits in splendid isolation from the €85 billion currently being negotiated for the bank bailout in Government Buildings. The addition of that €85 billion to the State's sovereign debt will incur debt servicing of huge proportions over the coming years, amounts that we simply cannot afford.
The premise of the plan itself is fundamentally wrong, even apart from the banking elephant in the room. In the past two years, the Fianna Fáil and Green Party Government has taken €14.5 billion out of the economy through spending cuts and tax increases. Where has it got us? The recession is worse now. Yet, under this plan, it wants to take another €15 billion out of the economy up to 2014.
In pursuit of this doomed strategy, low to middle income families are to be hit with pay cuts, social welfare cuts, water charges, local service charges and a flat-rate home tax. This is absolutely incredible. Health, education and other public services are to be savagely hit. This is an attack on the low paid and it cannot be described in any other way. The plan simultaneously lowers the minimum wage and brings people on the minimum wage into the tax net. The minimum wage is to be reduced by €1 per hour, which means a person on the minimum wage would earn €15,500 a year, while the tax band has been reduced to €15,300.
In total contrast to the attack on the low paid there is no increase in the tax rate for the highest earners. Listen to this fact; it is clear that people have noted it well. This is in accordance with the belief of the Minister for Finance that a higher top rate of tax would lead to higher earners fleeing the jurisdiction. He is not worried about our young people fleeing the jurisdiction in what can only be described as a new wave of emigration.
The standard VAT rate is to rise from 21% to 23% in 2014. This is a further grievous blow to trade and commerce, most especially in the southern Border counties. The counties of Cavan and Monaghan which I am proud to represent have been very badly hit in recent years by the flow of shoppers across the Border to the Six Counties. Today, voters in Donegal South-West go to the polls. Their local economy is to be punished further if this plan is implemented, and the same goes for counties Louth, Sligo and Leitrim in the front first line. This is what we have come to expect from a Government that has repeatedly overlooked the economic needs of the Border counties and that has no plan, and no interest in a plan, to remove the distortions created by the Border and to create an all-Ireland economy. There is where solutions to many of our problems can be found.
The cuts to health and children in the plan are truly frightening. They confirm the threat of the Minister for Health and Children to impose cuts of more than €600 million in the coming year. Our public health services simply cannot sustain this savagery. Staff and services will be slashed and patients will suffer. This is set to cause long-term and more sustained damage than the cuts of the 1980s. We await with trepidation the further details that will present in the budget and in its outworking over the period afterwards.
Unbelievably, the leader of the Green Party boasted at yesterday's press conference that the Green Party had defended education in the plan. That is some claim and some defence. Children are to be hit with a reduction of 5% in capitation grants for their schools. This will again penalise the least advantaged schools which are more dependent on Department of Education and Skills support. Higher student fees will make third level education far more inaccessible, penalising intelligent and hard-working young people and denying them the opportunity to contribute to our society because they and their families simply cannot afford to send them to college. So much for the knowledge economy that we hear about so much from Government voices.
This has been a sad and tragic week for Ireland. A week ago the Governor of the Central Bank confirmed that the IMF was coming. People are outraged that our ability to determine our own affairs has been so undermined by the Government. Ba mhaith liom críoch a chur leis an méid atá le rá agam. Cuireann sé seo i gcuimhne dom na focail sa dán "Mise Éire", a scríobh Pádraig Mac Piarais. Níl aon dabht ach go bhfuil aithne ag an Aire ar na línte seo:
Mór mo náire:
Mo chlann féin a dhíol a máthair.
I am Ireland:
Great my shame:
My own family that sold their mother.
Pádraig Mac Piarais wrote other lines and I will end with these.
And I say to my people's masters: Beware,
Beware of the thing that is coming, beware of the risen people.
We will see the first indication of a new politically aware unsubdued Irish electorate when the result of today's Donegal South-West by-election is formally declared tomorrow in Stranorlar. Let it be an indication of what is to come.
Comment on this
Pearse and those who signed the 1916 proclamation certainly had no reservations about seeking external assistance from imperial Germany at the time. The introduction of our national heroes to this debate——
Comment on this
——by Deputy Ó Caoláin has been done in a very ahistorical way.
Comment on this
They never sold out their birthright or their destiny to Germany or anywhere else.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that and I have not either.
Comment on this
I am drawing attention to the fact that our sovereign republic from 1916 on has always required external assistance.
The national recovery plan has been published as negotiations for Ireland's entry into an EU and IMF programme for financial support are taking place. The plan has been in preparation since October. It is our plan for this country and it will work. Unusually for a country that is seeking external support, Ireland is funded to the middle of next year, our economy has stabilised and we are moving into a balance of payments surplus.
As the plan points out, recovery in our economy is beginning to take shape. Our underlying budget deficit has stabilised at 11.7% of GDP and will decline to just above 9% next year. Our tax revenues are slightly ahead of target so far this year and our spending is being contained. It is now expected that GDP will record a small increase this year on the back of strong export growth. Our exports have held remarkably well through out the downturn. They are expected to grow by 6% in real terms this year.
This growth is coming not just from the multinationals. Our indigenous exporters are also growing their market share, so it is a broadly based recovery in exports that is being driven by a pick-up in demand in our trading partners and also by the significant improvements in our competitiveness over the past two years. The measures on cost competitiveness contained in the plan will build on the improvements that have already taken place and strengthen the position of our companies in the market place.
Conditions in the labour market are beginning to stabilise. Unemployment is unacceptably high at 13.6% but the number on the live register has fallen for two consecutive months for the first time since 2007. At the end of the lifetime of the plan, we expect unemployment to have fallen below 10%. Our balance of payments will record a small surplus next year, meaning the economy as a whole is paying down external debt. We are beginning to pay our way in the world.
All of these data paint a picture of an economy that is returning to growth after a deep and prolonged recession. The purpose of this national recovery plan is to plot a course to sound, sustainable growth for our economy. The plan will dispel uncertainty and reinforce the confidence of consumers, businesses, and the international community. Taxpayers have the benefit of knowing that the changes in income tax over the life of the plan will bring us to levels we last saw as recently as 2006.
The site value tax to be paid by all householders will be introduced next year and will amount to an average of €200 per household by the end of the plan, and a maximum of €100 for a large number of households. The certainty the plan gives to taxpayers about the tax they will pay over the next four years will enable them to plan their investments and give them the confidence to spend in this economy. The revenue measures in the plan will reform and overhaul our system, broaden its base and provide revenue stability so that we can raise the resources we need to pay for our public services. It is estimated that this year, 45% of income earners will pay no tax. This is unsustainable. A fundamental principle of the reform contained in the plan is that all taxpayers must contribute according to their means. Those who can pay most will pay most. No group can be sheltered. The wholesale abolition and curtailment of tax expenditures, with a saving of €735 million, will ensure that high income earners will pay their full rate of tax. The reduction of tax relief on pensions over the period of the plan is also more equitable, because the relief is now available to all at the standard rate.
We know from our experience as well as from international evidence that a broadly based tax system is more conducive to economic growth. The plan is concerned not just with the quantity of the revenue raised, but also with the quality of the measures adopted so that at the end of the plan's lifetime, we will have a tax system that serves an advanced, growing economy. Our tax system will continue to incentivise work, entrepreneurship and innovation and our 12.5% corporation tax will remain unchanged.
Deputy Ó Caoláin intervened with regard to the position of the Border counties and their exposure for cross-Border trade. I agree that is an important issue and that is the reason firm and decisive action was taken on it in last year's budget. It is clear from VAT receipts this year that decision has had a productive effect in terms of the generation of trade on this side of the Border. However, I take note of what the Deputy has said in this regard and that is why the planned increases in VAT are left to a later period in the plan. Similar sales taxes in the United Kingdom are seeing substantial increases currently and we have given enough leeway in the plan to ensure an alignment can always take place between the relative rates of taxation on both sides of the Border.
Our day-to-day spending will be reduced by €7 billion over the next four years, bringing us back to 2007 levels. The number of public servants will be reduced by nearly 25,000 by 2014, bringing us back to levels last seen in 2005. We will not allow this reduction in numbers to be detrimental to the quality of our public services. Reforms to boost the efficiency and productivity of the public service will be delivered in accordance with the commitments contained in the Croke Park agreement.
The reductions in expenditure are focused on the areas of greatest cost, public sector pay and pensions, social welfare and programmes such as the public capital programme. I have listened since this crisis began to Deputies talking about making savings from efficiencies. Of course we can do that, and we will. However, it is simply dishonest to suggest that we can right our economic ills without taking difficult decisions affecting the main drivers of public expenditure. Over the past two years we have made substantial adjustments through tax increases and expenditure changes, amounting to €14.6 billion. These succeeded in stabilising the underlying budget deficit this year. There is still a substantial amount of ground to be made up and the plan provides the measures to achieve this. Social welfare spending, which increased two and a half fold during the boom years, will be reduced by €2.8 billion. The available resources will be concentrated on those most in need. The system will be reformed to ensure it does not create poverty traps and disincentives to work and control measures will be intensified to assist in achieving the necessary savings. Capital spending must also provide savings. We have made significant investment in our infrastructure over the past decade and it has been transformed. In the current environment, it should be possible to deliver better value from a lower level of capital investment.
The main elements of expenditure reductions will be as follows. There will be a reduction in the cost of the public sector pay and pensions bill, social welfare and public service programmes. Savings will be achieved in social welfare expenditure through structural reform measures, labour activation and, as a last resort, reduced payment rates. Public service numbers will be cut by 24,500, 8%, compared to end-2008 levels. The public sector pay bill will be reduced by approximately €1.2 billion by 2014. For new entrants to the public service, there will be a reformed pension scheme and a 10% reduction in their pay. There will be more effective use of staff resources, through redeployment within and across sectors of the public service to meet priority needs. Work practices will be reformed to provide more efficient public services with scarcer resources. The student contribution to third level education will be increased. Water metering will be introduced by 2014 and the budget system will be reformed and updated, starting with budget 2011.
Careful choices have been made in determining expenditure for the next four years and these have been guided by the need to provide public services while at the same time ensuring that we return to growth. Investment in education, innovation and enterprise will be maintained at high levels to foster the growth potential in our economy. The labour market will be reformed to remove barriers to job creation. The minimum wage will be reduced and a short and focused review of the employment agreements that apply in the agricultural, catering and construction sectors is under way to ensure that these agreements do not endanger jobs or prevent the creation of new jobs, particularly for our younger people.
Measures to reduce the cost of doing business are also contained in the plan. It also contains a number of specific actions tailored to assist the sectors of our economy which will deliver growth in the medium term. The plan is not just about cutting the budget deficit. We must demonstrate how we will achieve growth and my colleague, Deputy Batt O'Keeffe, the Minster for Enterprise, Trade and Innovation will outline and elaborate on this aspect of the plan in the coming days. Long-term sustainable growth will be export led, but domestic demand is also critical to sustainable growth.
I want to make specific reference to the impact of any assistance package we may agree. First, the size of any programme is not finally decided, but an amount of approximately €85 billion has been mentioned. Whatever amount is agreed, it will not all be drawn down at once. The final amount is not an addition to the national debt figures in the plan. The level of funds available will allow us to replace borrowing which would have had to be undertaken in any event, if that was necessary. As far as banking is concerned, no particular level of drawdown has been agreed, but the fund is intended to be large enough to deal with all possible outcomes. The interest rate is not yet set. It will be an average rate given the different rates which will apply to the funds from different sources. The calculation of the interest rate is technical and complex and this work has not yet been completed. Therefore any interest rate mentioned at this time is speculative.
On the issue of bank reorganisation, the percentage ownership of any bank after this recapitalisation will depend on a number of factors not yet decided, including the amount of capital and whether any of it can be obtained from other sources. While various options for reorganisation of the banks have been discussed, no decisions have yet been made.
The suggestion that the plan is invalid because we have not factored information that we do not yet have is nonsense. The reform proposals and the fiscal measures must be fulfilled, whatever the outcome of our current discussions with the IMF and the EU.
I would like to refer to the commentary on our macro-economic projections. Some have said we are being too optimistic, while others say we are overly conservative. I prefer to see the forecasts as prudent, balancing, optimistic and conservative assumptions. By providing certainty to consumers, the plan will build the confidence the economy so badly needs. That confidence will impact on domestic demand and expand employment in those sectors that serve retail demand, such as retailing, catering and construction. It is important for all of us to recall that this economy has had strong balanced growth in the past. This plan provides a path for us to achieve it again. The plan is fair and proportionate. It asks us to take more responsibility for ourselves, for the financing of our public services and for the payment of our children's college education. It concentrates welfare spending on those most in need and provides resources for public services to be delivered in an efficient and cost effective manner. It is a rational and sensible plan to bring us out of the steep downturn from which we are now beginning to emerge. We must all work together to implement it.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for his observations. I found the plan very disappointing. I was expecting a magnum opus, but we did not get it. Like many people who have watched the development of this particular crisis through its final stages to the appeal to Europe for bailout funds last Sunday night, I thought there would be a heavy section on bank restructuring in the plan. That was what I looked for first when I received a copy of the plan. However, the plan is silent on banking. There is a reference on page 24 to the strengths of the Irish economy, one of which strengths is claimed to be the ready availability of a good flow of credit. Somebody must have discovered that while on holiday because it is not apparent in this country.
The Minister may say he will deal with the banking crisis or that he will make an announcement on bank restructuring shortly but my primary criticism is that the cost of servicing the bank bailout is not included in the plan. When challenged on this in a television interview, he stated that he was including everything up to 30 September 2010 but I do not know what interest rate will be applied to the bailout funds.
The rumours would suggest that the interest will be unaffordable. Even if we applied a simpler rate based on standard IMF charges of 5%, the cost over two years of the estimated €10 billion needed for recapitalising AIB and Bank of Ireland would be €2 billion. The correction of €15 billion should, therefore, be €17 billion. The failure to include this interest is a serious flaw in a plan that is supposed to inspire confidence across Europe's bond markets. A first year economics student would immediately notice this flaw after a quick read. I cannot understand how the plan could be published on that basis when such a flaw is apparent so quickly.
The plan is disappointing in regard to a growth strategy. The House and the public are familiar by now with Fine Gael's position. It is not enough to commit to fiscal correction. We are committed to the targets published in the plan but we would also pursue a parallel strategy of jobs and growth. The plan, however, contains the Government's usual scissors and paste copies of extracts and concepts it announced many times in the past in Dublin Castle, the media centre or down the road at the convention centre. It proposes the same old platitudes and shibboleths. The smart economy is to be organised by the greatest bunch of dummies who ever sat in Cabinet. They are going to major on bright ideas.
Comment on this
Perhaps they will after the next election but not now.
Comment on this
I suspect they have been consuming substances.
Comment on this
The fundamental concepts of running an element of a stimulus package in parallel and, more importantly, taking a series of supply side initiatives on a sectoral basis to maximise growth and job creation are not in the plan. How many times have we argued that we could get more out of the manufacturing industry if the competitiveness agenda promoted by Dr. Don Thornhill was introduced? The Government commits to the competitiveness agenda in this plan, just as it did last year and in previous years, but the reports are put on the shelf and nothing ever happens. Even when it has the right ideas, it has not a clue about implementing them. There is nothing on information technology, research and development, pharmaceuticals or the food industry. Even in the tourism sector, the Government has such a grievance with Michael O'Leary that it cannot see the sense in abolishing the travel tax in order to bring tourists into the country. We have five star hotels, magnificent golf courses, beautiful scenery and the best of self-catering accommodation. Our main roads will bring tourists from one side of the country to the other in jig time.
Comment on this
It sounds like we are doing a good job.
Comment on this
They are all empty. That is the problem.
Comment on this
Deputy Noonan acknowledges that we have outstanding infrastructure.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is missing the point.
Comment on this
We have a big terminal at Dublin Airport. The Government is doing a great job and all it is missing are the tourists. When the Minister of State observes the empty ferries going in and out of Dún Laoghaire, he might not realise that a boat is not much use to the tourism industry unless there are people on it. The same applies to hotels, bars and restaurants. I do not know what country he is living in if he thinks the Government is doing a good job on tourism. If we attracted 100,000 extra tourists we could earn more income than what we get from the travel tax.
Comment on this
That is a very selective reading.
Comment on this
I remind the Minister of State that almost every contributor thus far has been allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
I am not supposed to respond to that.
Comment on this
It is not a term of endearment in Limerick.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has relations down there. He should not cast aspersions on my city.
Comment on this
The public service reform section of the plan is weak when compared with Deputy Bruton's document on reinventing politics. Again, the Government does a magician's trick by claiming the numbers employed in the public service will be reduced by 24,750 based on 2008 levels. If one works from 2010, however, the reduction will only be 12,000 out of 300,000, or 3,000 per year over the lifetime of the plan. How is that a plan for reducing public service numbers?
The Government's entire strategy for the public service is very weak. A functioning and motivated public service will be crucial to revitalising this country but the plan is very tentative in this regard. We will face additional taxes and cuts to front-line services because it is so lame on public service reform. Everything is joined together in public administration and we will pay elsewhere for an overly heavy public service.
The labour market initiatives are very weak. The plan waves the flag of abolishing the minimum wage to impress the bond markets of Europe. Thank God, nearly 1.9 million people continue to work in Ireland and fewer than 4% of these are on the minimum wage. Minimum wage earners are for the most part young people, students or immigrant labourers. They are all vulnerable and this measure will do nothing for them. There are other ways to address the issue. In speaking about labour market initiatives several weeks ago, the UK Prime Minister, David Cameron, put it succinctly when he stated that his primary objective is to ensure work is always more valuable than welfare. The first thing one should consider is tax on work. If, for example, we reduced employers' PRSI contribution, we would get a better bang for our buck than reducing the minimum wage. The real issue is the poverty trap. We must make it easy for people to move into and out of the workforce. Leaving aside temporary blips, it must always be worthwhile over the long term for an individual to go to work rather than stay on welfare. Once that principle is applied, we can get labour market initiatives up and running and we will not have to touch the most vulnerable in society.
When this debate started six months ago, Fine Gael laid out two principles for fiscal correction, which we acknowledged was necessary. The first principle is that it should be fair across society, with no easy ride for friends of the Government in the Galway tent. The second principle is that it should protect the most vulnerable. Those on the minimum wage are vulnerable people and they should be protected.
The provisions on pensions are narrow in focus and they run counter to the submissions made by the industry. The effect of reducing tax relief to the standard rate of 20% will be to discourage people from making provision for their pensions.
It will be ordinary middle-income people who will be discouraged from making provision for their pensions. It is being presented as the people at the top of salary scales, with enormous amounts of money, who will put big chunks of that money into pension funds. However, in that small minority of jobs where people are paid extravagant amounts, those people are key to their workplaces and they will negotiate a package where the company will make the pension contribution rather than the individual. At a 12.5% rate, which is being preserved, the company will get tax relief on the pension contribution and the individual will pay the standard rate, but big chunks of money will still go into pension funds.
The alternative approach is to cap the funds at approximately €1.5 million and cap the contribution at somewhere between €40,000 and €50,000 — I will not nominate an exact figure — then continue with the tax relief and put a temporary levy on the fund. If a temporary levy is put on the fund for the duration of the plan, there is a very significant yield but actuaries will not take it into account when calculating the actual value of the fund because it is temporary. If one considers the literature produced by those companies like Zurich or Irish Life & Permanent, which are very strong in the market, this is the formula they are opting for. It is very easy to collect the levy because the pension industry is collecting management fees already, and all it has to do is to collect the 0.5% levy on top of the management fee and send it to Revenue.
It would be a better model. This model will not work because it discourages people from taking out pensions. I am not sure what it will yield because many people will discontinue their contributions if it is done this way. Again, we have a disagreement on the specific in this regard.
There is always an argument for increasing VAT but it is one of the flaws in the plan that the Government is taking individual decisions without restructuring. Again, it is as with the case of public service reform. The Government should be restructuring because it is by restructuring that it will get the economy moving again. When it decided to increase VAT by two points, it should have reduced the lower VAT rate of 13.5%. If the standard of VAT is increased by 1% and the 13.5% rate is reduced to 10%, there would still be some €200 million to €250 million going into the Exchequer. The Government should have used the opportunity to reform VAT rather than just state we are taking the increases for revenue collection.
Nobody likes VAT increases and the retail sector is under pressure at present. However, much of that to which the 21% VAT rate applies is imported whereas the 13.5% rate applies to the newspaper industry, the building industry and the food section of the hospitality industry, which includes restaurants, bars and so on. All of those sectors are major employers in the economy. If the Government is looking at supply side initiatives across sectors to get the economy moving and create more jobs, a restructuring of VAT rather than an increase is the better way to do it.
The Government signalled forward the VAT announcement, as it has with everything in the plan. It states it is not bringing in any VAT increase in 2011. The economic reason for signalling tax increases forward has always been to change behaviour, for example, people will go out and buy the washing machine, fridge or car before the increase comes in. What we need more than anything else at present is consumer confidence to get things moving again. If a market economist was looking at this and saw we were increasing VAT, the advice would be to change the two points at the same time in 2012, which would increase it to 23%, and to announce this now to try to get consumption going in 2011, when it will be badly needed and when the Government is predicting a growth rate of 1.75%, whereas in 2012 it is predicting a growth rate of 3.5%. To do that would get consumer spending moving.
I do not know what Fine Gael's decision will be in this regard. I am outlining the theory of changing tax rates such as VAT, and what works and does not work, as well as the difference between taking a series of individual decisions and taking reasoned decisions where one is trying to restructure tax rates to get a change in behaviour and a boost in the economy.
A big chunk of money will be taken out of social welfare. In general terms with regard to tax and social welfare, the tax corrections are front-loaded, with 65% of the income tax adjustments being taken next Tuesday week in the budget. However, the social welfare adjustments, which are more politically sensitive, are back-loaded. This is interesting in terms of getting the budget through the Dáil. We all know that on budget night there will be a series of financial resolutions but they concern tax increases. I have yet to hear a Deputy who supports the Government say he or she will vote against the Government on the basis of a tax increase. Fianna Fáil was always happy to raise taxes and it does not regard it as a no-go area. I presume that by doing it this way, budget night is looking increasingly safe.
If one considers the tables at the back of the plan, however, and the rolling budget for social welfare, one will see there is a small increase in the social welfare budget shown for 2011. I am not suggesting the Government will not do anything in this regard. Clearly, extra people will come in to the welfare net through unemployment. Following this, there is to be a big drop in 2012 and another in 2013. It seems the Government is organising its welfare adjustments as a legacy from a kind uncle to the incoming Government, and it is hoping there will be no key votes on budget night.
Comment on this
When the Minister replies, he might tell us what specific welfare adjustments he intends for the Social Welfare Bill before Christmas and how much he is leaving behind out of the kindness of his heart as adjustments for an incoming Government.
The cuts in expenditure are revealing. The political discussion in Cabinet was clearly centered on what to do on taxation and on welfare. I am sure that is well specified, although the full hand has not been shown in the plan. The expenditure profiles for 2011 have been carefully worked out because it would not be possible to bring in a credible budget without them. This is like the residue of a will. There is a big chunk of expenditure cuts, approximately €7.5 billion, which are effectively unspecified and have no policy decisions underpinning them. There is just a series of departmental tables taking out chunks of money. This is a clever way of doing it but if anybody thinks in analysing this document that it explains how €15 billion in savings will be arrived at, it does not; it explains about half of it. The other half refers only to, say, the Department of Health and Children or the Department of Defence where it will be a case of removing a big sum of money. It is revealing of the process which went on in Government.
I have two other points to make on the global figures. First, it seems the correction is not €6 billion but €5.3 billion because €700 million is included for the sale of State assets. This is clever, and I presume it has the permission of the Commission. This sum is being transferred across as a dividend to the Exchequer so it can be included in the figure. Therefore, €6 billion is now €5.3 billion, which will be good news for the Labour Party as it is coming down towards its €4.5 billion. They are closing the gap.
Comment on this
Do not worry. I will be able to do even better.
Comment on this
The other point is that I do not know what is the opening position. If the race starts from the line, it is 100 yards, but if the race starts ten yards up the field, it is only 90 yards.
Comment on this
We do not know what they will put in by the end of this year.
Comment on this
That is correct, and we do not know the starting position either. The Government has been under-spending the capital budget and it has been getting in a little extra in taxation for the first ten months of the year. If the race starts at €500 million, then up the line the €5.3 billion figure will fall a little and the adjustment will be smaller. It is like the secrets of Fatima until we see the tables on budget day. However, I would not take anything at face value from this Government because I have been misled too often. We will have to go through everything very carefully.
I am very——
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle is enjoying this.
Comment on this
I understand the memorandum of understanding which will accompany the bailout agreement from Europe will be quite specific. Recently I was briefed that it would deal in generalities but now it appears it will be specific about 2011 and, although it will be less specific about the following years, it will still be specific. Items will be included that effectively will be mandatory.
I want to tell the Commission we are not a colony but a sovereign Government. I want to tell those clever anonymous spokespersons from the European institutions that the way we behave here is governed by the European treaties and they should not advocate solutions for Ireland that are beyond the scope of the treaties. There will be a new Government, whatever its composition may be. I do not believe a new Government should be tied to the specifics of a plan negotiated by an outgoing Government that has lost all credibility at home and abroad. I want to tell the Commission straight out that will not work. We are committed to the targets but not to the specifics. If the budget goes through obviously that will change the status of the specifics for 2011 but for the subsequent years we will sit down with the Commission and renegotiate specifics. We will not accept any other arrangement from the Commission.
My final remark concerns the euro. The euro brought wealth to Ireland. It was a great idea and it helped trade and the economy. It also brought a wash of cheap credit to Ireland which did not suit our position in the economic cycle, caused us a great deal of grief and was a big contributory factor to the bubble. I do not believe the eurozone has been developed as a proper fiscal zone. One may look at the system in the United States which has automatic stabilisers for when things go wrong in a particular state and where there can be fiscal flows from one part of the country to another to maintain an economy.
The eurozone is a very undeveloped common currency area that must be developed further. I do not believe that addressing fiscal imbalances in the peripheral states and deflating them is going to stabilize it. The big countries such as Germany and France have a responsibility to get demand going in the economy. Why do they not cut their taxes, get consumer spending going and give us a chance to export to them? Was not the entire basis of the new Europe that there would be an interchange, with countries buying and selling to each other to get the economy going? The view advocated by the policy makers in Europe is incredibly narrow and I do not believe it will work. There is no point in blaming Ireland because the euro is under pressure. The euro is under pressure because it has fundamental flaws in its composition.
Comment on this
I have a last sentence. It is probably not known in this country that Germany has gained a lot from the crisis. German bonds are a safe haven for the savings of Europeans, particularly in peripheral countries. A reasonable calculation would suggest that German debt servicing has gone down by between €15 billion and €20 billion since the start of this crisis because of the inflow of funds from elsewhere. This pitch is very uneven at present and I am growing increasingly concerned about the weight of what is being imposed on Ireland and the lack of understanding, in particular, on the part of the European institutions although the IMF, which has experience in this area, seems to be taking a more tolerant view.