We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

National Recovery Plan 2011-2014: Statements

Contributions 120–256 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The principal lord of misrule in regard to the disaster that has overtaken the Irish economy might be identified as Deputy Bertie Ahern. Although he is still a Member of this House and is frequently reported as having speaking engagements in the Panama Canal area and around the world, he has remained silent in terms of explaining himself to the House, to his own political party or to the people. However, he gave an interview recently for a new book by David. J. Lynch, which I believe is aimed at Irish-Americans and people in the United States to help them understand what has gone wrong in Ireland. I wish to read part of the interview into the record of the House because I believe it to be a genuine expression of the voice of Deputy Ahern, as he once misruled this country. In explanation for the disaster he states:

At any time, had they come in and put the doomsday message I think we could have done a lot of things. But there was no sense, I can tell ya, of that. I mean, there wasn't one meeting with the Central Bank guys, not one meeting where they were putting the red lights on. Not one meeting. And never did Brian Cowen or the finance officials come over to me to say that the whole thing, the bottom, was going to fall out.

I know Deputy Bertie Ahern. That is so much his true and authentic voice. However, it also shows his cleverness. It is a crushing indictment of the Department of Finance, the Central Bank and of his anointed heir and successor, the present Taoiseach, Deputy Brian Cowen. That is the voice he wishes to leave on the history book records, never being a man not to get his retaliation in and to explain the situation in his own way.

It was crony capitalism that brought us to this — that golden circle of Fianna Fáil, the lord of misrule in the Galway tent and the bankers like Seanie FitzPatrick. Mr. FitzPatrick gave a lecture — an actual lecture — a year or so before we began to become familiar, in a way none of us would ever have wished for, with the inner workings of Anglo Irish Bank. In his lecture, Mr. FitzPatrick, as became a mega-billionnaire, lectured us that financial regulation in Ireland was the new McCarthyism. Shortly afterwards, he lectured the Irish Government, saying that old age pensioners and others should take cut after cut. We were all young and naive then, in the early days of the financial crisis and the collapse of the banks. Although I predicted the collapse of the bubble and was the first person to raise the Quinn affair, contracts for difference and the property based tax breaks, which are all on my record in the Dáil, I never thought the wrongdoings and the bust model of Anglo Irish Bank would bring down not only AIB but possibly Bank of Ireland. This week, despite all its efforts and despite the rights issue, it is almost back to where it was before. It gives me no pleasure to say that.

There, however, is the voice of Deputy Bertie Ahern. He comes in and votes in the House but never speaks although in his paid lectures he tells the world that the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Cowen told him nothing. The Department of Finance officials also told him nothing. The Central Bank told him nothing.

What would a manager in any company do? He or she would say, "Sack the lot of them." The Government has brought such incredible destruction to this country. This is what faces the Taoiseach more than anybody else. Where is the honour in continuing when it created this disaster? As early as 2006 I had a big argument with the now Taoiseach over contracts for difference and turning the Dublin Stock Exchange into a casino. Little did I know that today Paddy Power bookmakers is a bigger element on the Irish Stock Exchange than our banks. That tells all about the Celtic tiger which has turned into the Celtic tortoise. That is why people are so angry.

David McWilliams, in his book The Pope’s Children and a recent book about the crash refers to insiders and outsiders in this country. In a way, the four year plan is about insiders and outsiders. The outsiders are the little people, who have endless capacity and energy to take it on the chin and who can have a cut in the minimum wage. There is no requirement as a quid pro quo that their bosses, whether in the public or private sector — the minimum wage is mostly a matter for the private sector — should also limit their compensation packages on a parallel with what people on the lowest wage are being asked to take.

During the Dublin Theatre Festival I went to see "Enron", by a London company, in the Gaiety. It told the story of a massive energy company which became one of the biggest financial empires in the United States and which, in its destruction, has brought, among others, the state of California close to financial ruin. However, as it is in the continental US federal system it will not bring down the dollar even though it is one of the bigger states. The play told the story of Kenneth Lay and Jeffrey Skilling, the chief executive and chief accountant. The audience comprised mostly young people from banks, insurance companies and business houses who went to the theatre after work. There was a fantastic atmosphere of excitement in the theatre.

At the end of the play the chief character, Jeffrey Skilling, the accountant who organised the tricky things to inflate the books of Enron to make it a bubble company just like our bubble economy, is in an orange jumpsuit and is obviously in jail where he will spend a lot of time. One could feel in the audience a massive wave of emotion because the outcome in Ireland, which is a result of the way we have run this crony capitalism, is unimaginable. That is the problem. There is no Madoff or Enron and Jeffrey Skilling moment in Ireland. The lords of misrule have their houses in Marbella and their little tax boltholes in Switzerland. They are around the world. They are in the pricier parts of Connecticut and New England, starting afresh or else they come back for the odd match and so on like our tax exiles.

Our tax exiles do not merit a little note in the four year plan. It is the little people who have to give and who will take it on the chin while the people who lectured us and continue to do so have the luxury of not having to do their share of the heavy lifting. What is the attitude of the Irish negotiators to the European Central Bank, the European Commission and the IMF?

I, like many Irish people, had a very strange experience recently, which Deputies can try themselves. I have been texting people because I have been doing a lot of work in examining the IMF and how its structures work. When I type "IMF" into predictive text what word comes first? The word "God." Of course we have to have a rescue plan. We need rescuers and helpers but we also need to be emotionally, mentally and intellectually tough in the negotiations. I look at the sorry set of Ministers, who are mostly feeling sorry for themselves and not the rest of us. I see real emotion and pain etched on many faces but in many cases it is for themselves. I wonder about their capacity to negotiate a tough deal on behalf of this country.

Some people in the Department of Finance, and probably the Minister for Finance, have been hanging out a little bit too long and familiarly with Jean-Claude Trichet. I have listened to him and others speaking in Dublin. As a country, of course we have made terrible mistakes but if they think they can make Ireland a poster child for punishment by international finance agencies by destroying this country with terms of negotiation which are impossible to deal with, like the Germans after the Treaty of Versailles they will rue the day and set a bad example for the eurozone.

They need to pause because Ireland will not be able to pay these debts. I wish to tell the men from the IMF, the ECB and the European Commission that Ireland needs money at cheap rates of interest if it is going to have a chance to pay back, which Irish people wish and are committed to doing, the sort of financial advances which are being made to us.

We can apologise for having a Government which has dealt so ineptly with the blanket guarantee. I am sure the IMF is appalled to find that the room for manoeuvre in regard to the bondholders is probably very limited because of the blanket bank guarantee. On the statement yesterday on the four year recovery plan, what is the ghost at the feast? What is the ghost, like Hamlet's father, stalking the perimeters of the plan? The ghost is the banks and the bank debts which are on our shoulders. I ask people in the eurozone not to make this a four or five act tragedy.

Act one was Greece, act two is Ireland, act three may be Portugal and, worst of all for the strategists in the eurozone, act four could be Spain. We need a serious discussion about this. People in Europe may say: "Who is a Member of the Irish Parliament, given the state in which the country is, to even dare to question us?" Solidarity is a founding principle of the European Union and the Union I support and it is a two-way street. Mrs. Merkel made a very good point in regard to bondholders bearing part of the debts. She clarified those statements to refer to the time after 2013. However, what Mrs. Merkel had to say on that is essentially sensible and reasonable in that if a bank collapses not only the shareholders, who in Ireland lost their shirts, but the bondholders, who are risk takers, should share in the losses.

I heard people here complain that Mrs. Merkel's statement fluttered the bond markets. The difficulty with the bond markets is that if one says there will be pain for them, they will react by repricing up the interest rates on one's debt. They are the epitome of market forces — market forces red in tooth and claw. Many of those market forces are prepared to take a punt on the destruction of the euro and are probably making an awful lot of money. They made an awful lot of money on Greece and I am quite sure there are people counting the hundreds of millions of euro they made on Ireland. They are stalking the eurozone to see where they can strike next.

It is time for the people in charge of the eurozone to think about strategies that not only maintain countries like Ireland, but maintain the eurozone because unless they can do both, the eurozone will have a very problematic future. Up to the current debacle, the eurozone, on balance, has actually been good for Ireland.

I refer to the interest rates. The United Kingdom and the Swedish finance minister mentioned rates of 3%. The IMF normally lends at rates of approximately 3.2%. These are the kinds of rates of interest Ireland requires in terms of its debt. Ireland also needs to spread some of this over a longer period.

The Labour Party has staked a position which is not popular with Fianna Fáil, the Green Party or the former Progressive Democrat. I know it is under consideration by Fine Gael. If one frontloads too much austerity, one gets this momentary approval from the markets around the frontloading of the austerity. The difficulty is that the frontloading of the austerity, if it is accompanied by penal rates of interest, will sink the country. If the same is done in other countries in this three or four act tragedy of the peripheral countries, there will be a fifth act which will be the destruction of the euro. Let us pause to think about what is not only in Ireland's interest, but in the mutual interest of the eurozone and the euro as a currency.

I move to the contents of the report. People have spoken to me about one of the suggestions in the report in regard to labour market reforms. There will be a 10% reduction in pay for new entrants to the public service. The Government and all the parties in this House should clarify at, or after, the next election that it includes Deputies and the incoming Government. That is my view which many of my party colleagues share. It is something about which people must think but one cannot load pain on young people coming into the public service and then say that the people at the top of it are, somehow or other, exempt from it.

I agree there needs to be measures in the social welfare system which encourage people to get back to work. One cannot have a system where young people are encouraged to see life on the dole as some kind of permanent position. When the Labour Party was last in government, I was a Minister of State in the Department of Social Welfare. We created the back to work scheme and a series of returns to health, education, training and work in the community. Much of that was done away with during the years of the Celtic tiger. The feeling among agencies like FÁS was that the people on the unemployment register were somehow unfit for work. We must change all of that.

We have extraordinarily well qualified people on the register, many of whom have fine professional qualifications. The challenge for us and the smart economy, which is mentioned in the plan, is to think smart about how those people can contribute. We have suggested graduate internship schemes and various return to work experience schemes. All those options must be activated.

We have suggested rents should be reviewable downwards as well as upwards. There is a hint of that in the plan but it is not spelled out. The Government has refrained from spelling out the details of the tax and pension changes.

I was in a debate not so long ago with the Minister for Justice and Law Reform, Deputy Dermot Ahern, and I talked about property-based tax breaks being capable of producing €800 million in savings over a couple of years. As he does, the Minister got a bit annoyed and said he had advice from the Attorney General that this was impossible. I am glad the winding down of tax breaks has finally been acknowledged and included in this document. That is a bipartisan move on the part of the Government which I welcome.

There must be a new kind of bipartisan politics in which there is robust debate. Some of the Ministers who have been in government for 13 years must acknowledge that the monopoly on wisdom is not held by Fianna Fáil and that Fianna Fáil must yield to others and acknowledge that our ideas have merit. After all, we advised Fianna Fáil correctly on the bank guarantee. For its own reasons, it did not accept that advice.

People in Ireland can be very robust in their opposition to any or all of the measures. That is a democratic right. However, I plead with people not to be photo fodder for some of the international media stalking Dublin and various buildings. Ireland is not just ghost estates and piebald ponies left to run in fields, even though those images are appealing. In Greece, the impact of the violence that occurred has been to really damage its tourism trade. Tourism is a really important earner in this country and it will help it to recover. I appeal to people in some of the smaller political organisations — I know some people are mad as hell and do not want to take anymore — not to be used as photo fodder presenting the worst imagine of Ireland.

There are good things about Ireland. We are in a difficult place but we have great people and we will recover. Our Administration is acting like the Hoover administration in the Great Depression. We need a Rooseveltian administration which will produce a New Deal for this country and will help it to recover.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to address this four year plan from a Government which has, at best, two months to run. It is wrongly entitled the national recovery plan. The national destruction plan would be a considerably more appropriate name, given that it is coming from a Government which is badly broken and split, and which has no credibility either internationally or here on this island. The sooner an election comes to deal with the matter, the better.

There are two aspects to this plan with which I have considerable problems. It is littered with regressive measures that will deflate the economy and there is no stimulus in it. It is all about deflation rather than the required stimulus. I will return to that point. A second concern is that it does not deal with the banking bailout cost. The Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, told us at the beginning of this crisis two years ago that the banking bailout would not cost the taxpayer a red cent, and if it required some front-loading of charges, the banks would be levied and the overall cost would be zero. How naive is that, and how can the Government not even address the issue of the bailout, with the significant cost to the taxpayers of this State? It does not concern just one generation but several, yet the matter is not addressed.

We can consider the Government's banking strategy. Representatives from the IMF, the ECB and the European Commission are in town and I am due to meet them immediately after this contribution. They are negotiating with the Government, which still does not know the cost of the bailout two years on. It is important to point out that in those years the Government has focused almost entirely on the banking sector and has not produced any significant stimulus package to create or retain jobs. This is all about the banks, yet two years on there is still no idea of the cost of the banking bailout.

It was telling that yesterday during Leaders' Questions when Deputy Enda Kenny queried the cost, the Taoiseach was hesitant. Deputy Kenny mentioned the figure of €85 billion that has been mooted for some time and asked if the final figure would be greater. The Taoiseach replied that the figure could be close to that figure and he did not think it would go into triple figures; he mentioned that we are looking at double figures. The €85 billion consists of 11 figures, not double figures. Is it any wonder that we are where we are under this Government when it is so casual about these matters?

It is ironic that a Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, was cautioning us in his contribution to these statements. He indicated that we must be very careful with figures and should not throw them around. The Government should provide the figures if that is the case, as I believe the cost of the bailout will be well in excess of €85 billion. It will be closer to €120 billion or €140 billion. I hope it can be contained.

The Government is not good with figures as it thought the deficit was in the order of €7 billion but we now know it is €15 billion. In September the Government thought the required adjustment for this year would be €3 billion but it is now €6 billion. Imagine a member of that Government cautioning the Opposition and Members of the House to be careful with figures when that is being thrown around.

The IMF is probably serious about trying to get to grips with how much this bailout will cost. Its representatives have gone to the banks and may have had to push out some of those hanging on from the bad days who created this mess in the first place. Almost half the boards of the banks and executives who led the banks through this crisis, who brought us deep into the mire with the Government looking the other way or encouraging them in some cases, are still in place. That is completely unacceptable. There is now the prospect of the IMF trying to establish the exact figures and proposing the course of action to be followed.

I mentioned the board members and directors of the banks. More than two years later not one of these is in prison or has even been brought before the courts. I wonder why this is so. Who is blocking the justice system and what roadblocks are in place preventing some kind of inquiry? The Garda investigation has been ongoing for some time so what is preventing it from coming to a conclusion with people being charged and hauled before the courts, as happens in any other walk of life? The golden circle seems to be exempt even from the justice process of the State, which is shocking.

We are discussing how much the bailout will cost but whatever it is it will be too much. We cannot afford the bailout as we do not have the industrial and economic base in this small State or across this island for it. A conclusion must be reached sooner rather than later, although how can it be sooner, given that two years have elapsed? There will either be a negotiation or a burning of bondholders. There may be a debt for equity swap. Something must be done because this State, even with the significant bailout from the IMF and ECB, cannot afford the process. A large part of our financial difficulties come from it.

In his opening contribution to this debate the Taoiseach cautioned us that the problem will require focused attention on the economic crisis. It needs somebody to figure out the problem and deal with it, which the Government has not done. We have had no leadership from the Government at all in the banking crisis, so what good is that focused attention? Ireland's banks are bust and we should decouple them from sovereign debt. We must deal with them in the way I outlined by dealing with the bondholders and finishing with the issue once and for all.

The bailout will not reduce the amount we owe by even one euro and we will still have to pay a crippling debt in return for the bailout from the ECB and IMF. That will see Ireland accept more debt, primarily because the interest rate, as speculated on currently, is in the order of 5%. We have no idea if the figure is right as it comes from speculation. The 5% figure can be compared to the figure just above 1% that we got from the ECB recently, which shows our position in real terms. The Government has indicated that as recent developments in the international bond markets have shown, persisting with the current scale of borrowing will result in interest rates remaining at unaffordable levels. We know that and sovereign bond markets are punishing Ireland while the current policy of protecting all bank bondholders remains in place. That will continue until the Government gets real on the issue.

The Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Ó Cuív, is present in the Chamber. I regard him as a person conscientious about his work and position in the Government. I hope somebody in the Cabinet will bring this message to the debate and look for the Government to wise up. I know the Government is being driven by the European Commission on saving these bondholders but it should look to what is right for the Irish people. The Government should remember them in some of these negotiations.

With regard to the regressive measures mooted in this plan, the Government has always said it will do what is fair and equitable, protect the vulnerable and go after those who can afford it. Let us have a look at that statement. I do not believe the reduction in the minimum wage is fair and equitable. As Deputy Noonan indicated, most of those earning the minimum wage are students or women in menial, tough jobs. Rather than giving poor devils who work hard a payment of €8.65 per hour, the pay of those on the minimum wage will be reduced. They also face a double whammy because they will be drawn into the tax net under the Government's taxation proposals. Instead of dealing with wealthy bondholders — the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Eamon Ryan, identified them earlier, although we knew already that they are large pension funds and insurance companies — the Government is going after those on the minimum wage by reducing their pay and hammering them for a second time through the tax code.

The document does not give any indication that the Government proposes to go after those earning big bucks such as the chief executives of semi-State companies who have salaries of more than €500,000 per annum. Perhaps the Minister will indicate the reason for this oversight. Will individual Cabinet Ministers indicate whether they contributed to the debate at Cabinet level on whether to protect those on the minimum wage or allow the extremely wealthy to continue to enjoy huge salaries? We will be told the Government went after the latter group when it reduced salaries by 7% and by a further amount thereafter. That is nonsense because those at the top of the pile are getting off virtually scot-free. It is grossly unfair that those at the bottom of the rung are hammered on every occasion. The Government is looking in the wrong place by focusing on marginalised people who can least afford cuts rather than those who can afford them.

The Government's plan proposes to reduce the threshold at which income tax is paid to bring people on the minimum wage into the tax net. The document does not propose to go after people who are earning in excess of €100,000 per annum, as proposed by Sinn Féin in the pre-budget submission it made to the Government some weeks ago. We proposed the introduction of a new tax rate of 48% for those earning in excess of €100,000. Did the Minister or any of his colleagues read the Sinn Féin document which I sent to the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

We looked at it.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will respond to the contents of our submission because I would like to debate it with a Minister, either in the House or elsewhere. The sooner we do so, the better.

The Government's agenda of going after low income families is grossly unfair. The proposal to increase the VAT rate from 21% to 23% is another regressive measure. I warmly welcomed the Minister's decision to reduce VAT by 0.5% in last year's budget. The measure had an immediate effect in reducing the number of shoppers crossing the Border into towns such as Newry, Enniskillen and Derry. The effect was almost instantaneous and helped businesses in Border towns which had been badly affected by the previous increase in the VAT rate. An increase in VAT will have a significant effect. It will result in larger car parks being built in Newry, Enniskillen and Derry, while shopping centres in those towns will be extended to cope with the influx of shoppers from this State. Businesses in the South within a large radius of Border will close their doors.

VAT is a regressive tax because lower income families pay a substantially larger part of their income in VAT on ordinary household goods than well-off families. The proposal to increase VAT is grossly unfair and completely wrong.

The Government proposes to reduce public service numbers by 24,750. While I fully support reform of the public sector, it should not be dragged out over six or seven years. We do not need more reports which will lie on a shelf for years. Public service reform should be led by a Minister who is up for the job and will act quickly to ensure efficiency in the public sector. If this involves job losses, so be it, because we need an efficient and effective public sector that will deliver the services people in this State deserve. To take an axe to the public service, as proposed in the plan, will probably result in the most competent public servants leaving the sector or retiring. A more efficient process should be introduced to ensure the public service does what it should do.

It is proposed to increase the student service charge from €1,500 to €2,000 per annum. This is despite everything we hear about the smart economy. The Green Party informed Deputies earlier that it had been successful in protecting education. However, as my colleague, Deputy Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin, addressed this issue at length, I do not propose to be repetitious.

An average growth rate of 2.75% has been projected for the four year period. Some of this growth is based on current export levels. I believe the export figures are being distorted by several percentage points as a result of the vast amount of plant and equipment leaving the State, mainly destined for Poland. I do not know if this trend, which has been particularly acute in the past 12 months, has been factored into the export figures as a dividend for the State. It is nothing of the kind. It is a short-lived phenomenon and we will shortly experience its repercussions.

Sinn Féin offered a different approach from that of the Government. We proposed to levy additional tax on those with individual incomes of more than €100,000 per annum, cap public service pay at €100,000 and introduce substantial pay cuts for Ministers, Deputies and Senators. Were our proposals considered? None of them has been included in the four year plan, which suggests the Government does not like my party's approach.

Sinn Féin also proposed substantial debt reduction measures amounting to €4.67 billion and a stimulus package in excess of €2.5 billion to promote job creation. Any amount of evidence is available that the system has capacity for jobs growth. For instance, the agrifood sector, to which several speakers referred, has major potential for jobs growth and export development. Despite this, the Government has not given any signs that it will take significant measures in the sector.

Sinn Féin's tax raising proposals focus on those who can afford to pay as opposed to those on the minimum wage. The Minister for Finance informed the House that the reductions in expenditure are "focused on the areas of greatest cost", which he proceeded to list as public sector pay and pensions, social welfare and programmes such as the public capital programme. Rather than approach expenditure reductions on the basis of identifying who can afford to pay, by his own admission the man in charge, the Minister for Finance, attacked the high-cost areas. We know the reason the Minister faced in the completely wrong direction when he sought cuts.

I took the opportunity to find out how Greece was managing its memorandum of understanding, in other words, the terms and conditions of the bailout it was provided. Among the impositions made by the EU-IMF were an increase in VAT rates, an increase in excise on fuel, tobacco and alcohol — I suppose we could live with that one——

Comment on this

It would drive more people across the Border.

Comment on this

——a reduction of €500 million in public investment, a broadening of the VAT base by including services currently exempted from VAT and moving a significant proportion — at least 30% — of the goods and services currently subject to the reduced rate onto the normal rate.

Again, this is a highly regressive approach. I am due to meet these IMF people within the next two minutes but so much for the memorandum of understanding that was used in Greece. This provides some idea of what we are dealing with in respect of the IMF and the ECB. However, I do not expect the Government to approach this in a constructive way on behalf of the Irish taxpayer or Irish society because its record is all wrong. The record of the Government is atrocious and the sooner there is a general election the better, to enable the people of this State to get some kind of relief from the vagaries, to put it at its mildest, of the Government.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

The next speaker is the Minister, Deputy Ó Cuív, who is being offered 20 minutes.

Comment on this
Éamon Ó Cuív Minister for Social Protection Fianna Fáil

Very good. Many times, speaking time in this Chamber can be quite curtailed. Tá áthas orm deis a bheith agam cúpla focal a rá faoin bplean a d'fhoilsíomar inné agus ar ndóigh, tá sé fíor-thábhactach go mbreathnóimid go géar ar na roghanna atá romhainn agus go mbreathnaímid ar na fíricí mar atá siad, ní mar ba mhaith linn iad a bheith. I am delighted to have an opportunity to speak on the plan and hope Deputy Morgan will wait——

Comment on this

I would love to but I have an appointment.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Allow the Minister to speak, without interruption.

Comment on this

——because he raised issues I would like to address.

Comment on this

He is meeting the IMF.

Comment on this

I apologise but I must meet the IMF and the ECB. The Minister should read the record.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

The Minister should proceed.

Comment on this

Since the difficulties with the banks started, some of the political parties in this country have resorted to constant sloganising, rather than analysing the issues. In fairness to my colleagues on the benches directly opposite, they accepted that the collapse of the banking system, the closing down of the ATMs and the inability of people to gain access to their deposits would have been an unthinkable catastrophe. Unfortunately, the Labour Party did not agree with that approach and believed there was a magic solution that would keep the ATMs going and people's deposits safe while at the same time allowing banks to close. Such a proposition is both implausible and impossible. At the time of the guarantee, there were €51 billion in deposits in Anglo Irish Bank, of which €21 billion were of Irish origin. Does the Labour Party really suggest it believes it would have been of no consequence to this economy or that it would not have caused great disruption to people and their savings, had that €21 billion been lost? I hope the Labour Party would not be so cavalier with people's money.

Moreover, that money was made up in many ways. Charitable organisations had deposits in Anglo Irish Bank, as had many commercial organisations that are providing employment. I believe many credit unions had deposits in that bank, as there also were interbank deposits. In other words, what the Labour Party has never been willing to admit is that if one allowed the collapse of a bank, the contagion throughout the system could bring down the entire banking system. Therefore, at the time the Government guaranteed the banks, the option was either to put in a wholesale guarantee to protect the system or to face the terrible consequence that everything one takes for granted every day would longer exist. The ability to withdraw one's own deposits, to get money from the ATM machines or to make payments by writing cheques no longer would exist.

However, the amazing thing about the Labour Party is that it then put forward a proposition that the Government should actually pay the shareholders to nationalise the banks. The Labour Party wanted the Government to give money to the shareholders of AIB and the Bank of Ireland. That would have cost €4 billion of taxpayers' money to bail out shareholders, had the Government followed the Labour Party's mantra. The banks will be in State ownership, more or less, but the Government will not have paid a single euro to bank shareholders for those banks, contrary to what the Labour Party wanted to do.

Comment on this

Did the Department of Finance write that note? No wonder it got the facts so wrong.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should contain herself. The Minister should proceed.

Comment on this

That is so wrong, the Department of Finance must have written that note.

Comment on this

No Deputy, I have read——

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Minister, through the Chair.

Comment on this

No wonder, God love them——

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Allow the Minister to proceed.

Comment on this

I have read the Labour Party documentation. There was a stock market valuation on the banks at the time and if one nationalises something, one must pay the market value at the time.

Comment on this

But the bank was collapsing.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Now Deputy.

Comment on this

The point is that the manner in which the Labour Party intended to do this would have forced it to pay the market value at the time.

Comment on this

Which was zero.

Comment on this

The Labour Party always has glib answers and funny money solutions that magically make money disappear.

Comment on this

No wonder the Government and the Department of Finance——

Comment on this

Now that the Labour Party is being called to account for what is actually was trying to do——

Comment on this

Can the Minister deal with the plan?

Comment on this

Yes, I will come to the plan because everything leads to it.

Comment on this

This is fantasy.

Comment on this

However, the very fact that Deputy Burton is interrupting me shows——

Comment on this

Is this the answer to the Minister's prayers?

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Deputy, the Chair is obliged to protect the Minister. The Minister is entitled to proceed.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

He does not need protection. He has a car.

Comment on this

I must be amused by the hypocrisy of this House. I understand there was a religious service for deceased Members of the House yesterday. For those who ridicule religion, it amazes me that many of them will attend such a service. Yes, I admit to having a belief in God. I do not know whether many other Members share that belief any longer and the ridicule of religion shows a certain lack of tolerance.

I hope——

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

What is the Minister talking about?

Comment on this

Who ridiculed religion?

Comment on this

Chairman, on a point of order——

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should address her remarks through the Chair if it is a point of order.

Comment on this

——no one in this House ridiculed anyone's religion. I have the height of respect for whatever religious and political convictions the Minister has.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Okay. I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Deputy was ridiculing prayer.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Minister, just a minute.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

The Minister should withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I seek clarity from the speaker as to what he is talking about when he raises religious beliefs as part of this debate. That is a private matter and has nothing to do with politics.

Comment on this

Exactly. Deputy Burton was the one who threw it up, not me.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

Will the Minister withdraw the remark?

Comment on this

It is quite amazing. Some people can dish it out but they cannot take it.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

Religion is a private personal matter.

Comment on this

Exactly. I am sure the Deputy often has said "Dia duit" or "Goodbye". Has he?

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

All the time.

Comment on this

"Dia duit" means God——

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

I understand that but the point is——

Comment on this

Sorry, I said something on a radio programme. I was asked about a policy and whether it was the final solution. I replied that I hoped and prayed that it was, which was a colloquial term. The presenter picked me up on that issue. As I noted, one often uses phrases such as "please God" or in Irish one often would say "is cuma sa diabhal", all of which use religious iconography. However, it was the Deputy who started to denigrate me because I happened to use the word "pray" in a sentence but I will leave that to the Deputy. She obviously is highly sensitive about Labour Party——

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Burton, is this a point of order?

Comment on this

——is asking the Minister whether he got an answer to his prayers a denigration of anyone's religion? It was a question. I did not make any comment on the religious views of the Minister or his party.

Comment on this

The tone of the question was self-evident but I will say no more of it.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

It is the wrath of the people the Minister should fear before the wrath of God in this case.

Comment on this

It is perfectly reasonable to ask whether the Minister had an answer to his prayers.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has made her point. I encourage the Minister to proceed and to address his remarks through the Chair.

Comment on this

I would love to proceed.

Comment on this

I do know what the rest of the country is praying for in respect of the Government.

Comment on this

I believe Members have a pretty good idea about their prayers and those of Members.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Okay Deputy.

Comment on this

Pretty soon, hopefully there will be an answer and an election.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

Beware of the risen people.

Comment on this

When that happens, the Labour Party will be obliged to state what it intends to do. If, as the Deputy expects, it wins the election, whenever it is held, it will be obliged to make the hard decisions it has avoided articulating over the last few years. The Labour Party no longer will be able to use a set of accountancy figures that simply do not stack up in any real sense of mathematics that I ever was taught. These are the hard facts that will face the Labour Party. At least Fine Gael has shown some realism, although I do not agree with all its policies, but the Labour Party is living in absolute fantasy land. It tries to persuade people that there are a lot of easy answers that simply do not exist in any real world.

A second point that it is important for the two Opposition parties to clarify is whether they propose that existing senior tier 1 bondholders in banks are not to be paid back the money. I believe that had the Government followed that path, bad and all as our problems now are, they would have been much more serious than they are today. It is about time the Opposition made it clear exactly what is its policy.

Comment on this

We have made it very clear. It has been clear for two years.

Comment on this

The Government has made it clear that for legal and practical reasons, to fail to honour Tier 1 bonds is not the way to go forward. I believe that is the right policy.

Comment on this

The Government has broken the country.

Comment on this

Deputy Arthur Morgan obviously has not read the plan. He obviously did not read the sections that deal with tax relief and pension contributions. In fact, there is a radical change in the way tax relief will be available on pension schemes. It will ensure that rich people will not be able to shelter large sums of money in pension relief. I quote a sentence from the plan: "Pension tax expenditures will be kept under constant review to ensure that abuse of tax sheltering does not take place." That is right. I have always believed that pension funds should not be a place where the very rich can hide their money and avoid taxation.

We are also reducing the annual earnings cap for personal contributions by almost 25%, to €115,000 per year, and introducing a lifetime cap on pension contributions. This is very significant and important because it will make those who can pay do so, including those with very large incomes that they could put into a tax shelter.

Some parties make great play of increasing the top rate of tax. One might get another 4% or 5% there but one might not. If the top rate is too low one raises no money and if it is too high it might be a disincentive, which would not be in the long-term interest of the development of the economy. It is much more advantageous to get rid of tax breaks. Tax breaks to be finished in the budget include those for patent royalties; investment in machinery and plant for exploration; approved share options and; benefits in kind. We are totally closing down many tax shelters. Increased revenue in those cases will be 41%. We have also made it clear that we will be charging PRSI and the health levy on pension contributions. The plan is radical in tackling the issue of those at the top paying a fair and equitable amount of tax, particularly those whose incomes are so large that they could avail of various tax shelters and tax avoidance measures that have been there in the past. That is an important part of the plan.

When one goes through departmental Estimates, as every Deputy does in some committee of the House, one often finds it is not so easy to make saving. I am always fascinated when I debate the Estimates for my Department in a select committee. Deputy O'Dowd and I have done so often. I cannot remember Deputy O'Dowd ever pointing out where I could save €10 million or €15 million in the Department of Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs. Most of the time he was telling me that expenditure was not half enough and that I should be spending more on the various schemes.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

I told the Minister the national drugs strategy was useless. Heroin use was spreading in Dublin and he was doing nothing about it.

Comment on this

The Deputy wanted more money spent on it.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

I wanted abuse to stop and a proper national drugs strategy.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Please, Deputy O'Dowd. I will protect you when your turn comes to speak.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

The Minister asked me a question——

Comment on this

Provoking a response.

Comment on this

When one breaks down Government expenditure, one third is related to wages. That is comprehensively dealt with in the plan, including pensions for retired public servants.

Some 38% of current expenditure relates to the Department of Social Protection, which is my Department. My Department must have a huge focus on the old, the unemployed and the invalid. Therefore, we must look at how we can reduce expenditure while minimising the impact on ordinary people.

People often ask where all the revenue from the Celtic tiger building boom went? Much of it went on improving the social welfare system. For example, expenditure in 2000 was €6.7 billion and expenditure in 2010 will be €20.9 billion. Some people, who do not do the sums, will argue that this is caused by the increase in unemployment. However, the total payment for jobseeker's allowance and jobseeker's benefit is approximately €4.5 billion, and there are always people in receipt of unemployment payments, full-time or part-time. Unemployment payments clearly account for a very small fraction of total expenditure. The rest of the increase went on improvements in schemes and a huge increase in the rates of social welfare payments. For example, we increased the average rate of payment for schemes by approximately 130% at a time of 40% inflation. There were real gains for people receiving payments from my Department. In ten years, we multiplied expenditure on carers by six, at a time of 30% inflation. How did we do that? We introduced a half-way carer's allowance, which is much prized by, for example, pensioners who are caring for other people. We also introduced the respite allowance. We increased income disregards for the means test and we increased rates. We used a lot of money during the Celtic tiger years to improve the lot of carers. The challenge in my Department is to hold onto as much of that architecture as we can in the middle of a world downturn. That is what we will seek to do.

As I indicated yesterday and as is indicated in the plan, there will, of course, be cuts in rates this year. We will also be seeking to match those with other savings that will not impact on the provision of services.

It is also our intention to cap the payment to RTE and CIE in relation to the free television licence and free travel, but that will not impinge on the existing or future rights of people to free travel or the free television licence. It is our belief that the sum we pay on behalf of people entitled to free television is more than adequate for the service being provided by the public service broadcaster.

How will we deal with the reduction of €3 billion in the spend of my Department, which will still be by far the biggest spending Department in Government, over the next four years? I take exception to the statement issued by Social Justice Ireland yesterday. It tried, totally contrary to what is said in the plan, to indicate that savings would be made solely by rate cuts. Rate cuts are the least attractive option. They will be the option of last resort and every effort will be made in 2012, 2013 and 2014, to ensure that rate cuts will not be a major contributor to savings.

How will we make these savings?

Comment on this

Minister, you have three minutes left.

Comment on this

I suppose it is five or six minutes, given all the interruptions, a Chathaoirligh.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

The Minister caused them.

Comment on this

We are not going to tell him to pray.

Comment on this

He is looking for injury time. The Government is in injury time. That is the problem.

Comment on this

We will make savings by a number of methods. First, we will introduce greatly enhanced control measures. I know "Prime Time" came up with the ridiculous figure of €2 billion that could be made in that way. I wish it were true but I do not believe it is. However, there is money to be saved by extra control measures. For example, we will be introducing the public services card next year. Other developments have taken place in the last year, some of which are subject to the enactment of the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, which is before the Dáil at present and some of which are subject to the Bill that came before the Dáil earlier this year. They will give us savings in control measures. A more modest saving than suggested by "Prime Time" would be possible. The Opposition tell me €200 million is a small figure. If that amount could be saved by my Department it would be a significant contribution to the €600 million that must be saved in 2012.

The second method of saving will be to reduce unemployment. That is very important and it is why so much of the plan has to do with competitiveness. The figures are simple. Everyone who no longer claims jobseeker's allowance or jobseeker's benefit saves the Department an average of €12,000 per year in direct expenditure. If 10,000 people were removed from the live register, there would be a saving of €120 million. A reduction of 20,000 on the live register would yield a saving of €240 million. If one added to this the PRSI and tax that would be paid, the figure would increase to €400 million, as I am told constantly by the Opposition. Therefore, when one considers the figure of €600 million, one will see there is another way.

The third point concerns a much more aggressive national employment action programme. A national employment action programme will be beefed up next year. Many more people will be called for interviews and we will increase the number of places on a number of schemes. I will implement the provisions of the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2010. Therefore, those who do not interact with the national employment action plan, either in terms of obtaining a job or training, will be subject to the penalties listed in the Bill, which will allow us to reduce the rate received by those who do not turn up for interview.

Statistics recently provided to me by my Department show that 8% of people called under the national employment action programme did not attend for interview and continued to claim payments. That is intolerable. If one who is unemployed and actively seeking work is invited to an interview to try to help one get a job, the least one should do is turn up. We must stop codding ourselves in this regard and must not tolerate circumstances in which no sanction is taken against those who fail to turn up. In fairness to Fine Gael, it supports my approach. It is only if all these actions do not result in the required saving that rate reductions should become a reality.

I mentioned a figure of €600 million for the budget of 2012. It is clear that significant savings can be made by being proactive. I intend being proactive on these issues for as long as I am in the Department. If one saved €500 million of the €600 million, the rate reduction one would need to make up the balance would be in the order €1.10. Therefore, there is a massive onus on us to ensure that we stop paying social welfare payments to those who are not entitled to them. We must send a message out collectively that cheating social welfare now is putting one's hand in the pocket of the old, disabled and unemployed. This can no longer be tolerated in our society. The old approach of nodding and winking in respect of people signing on and of people with very respectable backgrounds paying such people in the knowledge that they are signing on, must now come to an end.

Comment on this

It is not unheard of for senior Fianna Fáil politicians to encourage people to do nixers at weekends while drawing social welfare.

Comment on this

I never encouraged that kind of practice.

Comment on this

I am not saying the Minister did so.

I wish to share my time with Deputies O'Dowd and Deenihan.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed. I will be happy to offer the Deputy as much protection as I can.

Comment on this

I will not interfere.

Comment on this

This is an important debate. Unfortunately, it comprises statements rather than a motion. I would like to use this democratically elected House to send a message to the European Commission. I spent three years as a Member of the European Parliament, three of my most rewarding years in public life. If there was one word I understood at the end of those three years, it was the "solidarity". It is not a word that I understood when I first became a Member of the European Parliament or that I really embraced when growing up. However, it resonated for me every week in debates in the European Parliament, many of which debates were emotive. I was a Member at a time when new member states joined the Union and when French and German MEPs were marking the end of the Second World War and the setting up of the European Union.

I remind Commissioner Rehn and others, for whom I have a lot of time, that Ireland now needs solidarity. We have not asked for it before. Ireland will never need solidarity in terms of military protection but it has a self-created catastrophe based on the debt it will have to incur in the coming years. We require understanding and solidarity from our European partners. The idea that Ireland would have to pay interest of between 6% and 7% on funds drawn from an emergency stability fund, contributed to primarily by EU member states, is totally inconsistent with the principles of the European Union, to which I am absolutely committed, and with everything I learned as a young MEP in the European Parliament. I remind the EU delegation in Ireland that this is not about teaching Ireland a lesson or sending out a signal to other countries in the Union that if they must access emergency funds, it will cost them. It should be a question of member states who can afford to do so helping out a small country that has made a mess of its finances and governance because of irresponsible banking and irresponsible political behaviour in government.

Ireland needs a solidarity fund. Unfortunately, we have had to compromise our sovereignty and independent decision-making in order to access that fund. We need a fund that we can draw on while incurring little or no interest, perhaps with increasing interest rates over time, after which we will have been given time to breathe and rebuild our economy, as we have the capacity to do. In the short term, however, we will not have the capacity to grow as a country and economy and build the kind of lifestyle we need to build here and elsewhere in Europe if we strangle the people with interest rates such that we will be spending 20% to 30% of taxation revenue repaying interest on loans we are now negotiating with EU member states. Whatever about the IMF, I want to send that message to the European Commission. The message is from a member state that has been loyal and committed to the European project from the very outset and which has worked hard to achieve certain outcomes in referenda when it was difficult to do so.

We are debating a national recovery plan. Young people were present in the Visitors Gallery for the Minister's speech. Does he believe they are leaving the House inspired in the belief that they will be more likely to get a job in two years than now? Does he believe their parents will be inspired to believe that this country, although everybody, apart from totally unrealistic people in the House, accepts we need to take pain——

Comment on this

The Deputy's potential coalition party.

Comment on this

Does the Minister believe their parents believe the pain being prescribed in the four year plan is leading Ireland to a better place? Does he believe that is a convincing argument? I do not.

Comment on this

The Deputy should show us his alternative.

Comment on this

I am about to.

Ireland's recovery will not be through necessary taxation increases and expenditure cuts. The belief the Irish need right now from the Government will come from a commitment to reform, proceeding differently, leading by example, and changing the political system before asking people to change their households. There is nothing about this in the four year plan.

Fine Gael has made a commitment to reduce the number of national public representatives by 35%. We are going to change the way this House operates and the way in which decisions are made. We are going to put in place an independent fiscal council which will give to Opposition parties resources similar to those available to Government parties. We will not keep people in the shade in the way those currently in government have done during the two years of this crisis.

Comment on this

We cannot get Fine Gael to engage with the Estimates process. Even when we provide all the information that is required, those in the Deputy's party complain.

Comment on this

I am about to attend a meeting of a select committee at which one of the Estimates will be discussed. I assure the Minister that we are engaging with the process.

Comment on this

The Minister should allow Deputy Coveney to continue.

Comment on this

The only stimulus of any note in this plan relates to capital expenditure programmes. Unfortunately, the deal the Government is currently negotiating with the IMF and with the EU institutions completely undermines the credibility of the national recovery plan. The plan states that in the next four years the ESB, a semi-State company, is going to spend €6 billion on infrastructure projects throughout the country. However, the ESB and every other State company and asset is going to be used as collateral or security for the loan in respect of which the Government is negotiating. We do not, therefore, have the capacity——

Comment on this

That is rubbish.

Comment on this

It is not rubbish. Earlier today, Standard & Poor's reduced Bord Gáis Éireann's credit rating. As a result, the latter will have a funding crisis in 18 months time.

Comment on this

That kind of talk——

Comment on this

Bord Gáis Éireann has cash reserves for the next 18 months but after that it will have a funding crisis because it no longer has a credit rating that will allow it to avail of euro bonds. The Minister does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this

I do know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

The Government is trying to sell an economic plan that is based on fantasy.

Comment on this

It is the kind of loose talk in which people such as the Deputy engage that is leading to uncertainty.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

The Minister will appreciate that the Chair is obliged to try to maintain order. The next speaker is Deputy O'Dowd.

Comment on this

Those opposite continually undermine the various agencies and seek to create uncertainty.

Comment on this

The Government lies to people all the time. That is the problem.

Comment on this

Who has been referring to——

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

I have called Deputy O'Dowd.

Comment on this
Fergus O'Dowd Deputy Fergus O’Dowd Fine Gael

Let us get matters straight. The Joint Committee on Education and Skills wrote to the Tánaiste and Minister for Education and Skills inviting her to come before it in order to discuss the headings under which the current Administration is preparing the budget for the coming year. The Tánaiste refused that invitation. The Government refuses to be accountable to the Dáil for what is happening at present and for what took place in the past.

The key point I wish to make is that our sovereignty is gone because any view we might have must be referred to Brussels. Perhaps we have reached the stage where the Government will rename Áras an Uachtaráin "Áras Rehn" because it is clear that the power relating to the governance of this State lies elsewhere. Consent and agreement must now be obtained from the European Commission in respect of any proposals of a financial nature which we wish to put forward. That is the sorry pass to which the country has come.

We have been reduced to a terrible state. Under the current Government, there is no hope. It has put before us a plan for the next four years which it will never be allowed to implement because the wrath of the people will be visited upon it in the forthcoming general election. The Government is setting in stone certain things which we do not accept. As Deputy Kenny stated last night, one of the key attacks it is making is on the poorest and most vulnerable in our society, namely, the lowest paid. Those who earn least will suffer disproportionately under the proposals contained in this plan. That will have to be changed. A new Government will be obliged to put in place a plan for the nation. It will not be the current Administration which will be doing this. That is why a general election must be held as soon as possible.

The plan does not contain any of the reforms that are required in respect of the public sector. Such reforms could be easily insisted upon by any or all Ministers. In the area of education, there has been a disgraceful situation whereby those at the top levels in universities have been paying themselves moneys to which they were never legally entitled. For example, three presidents of the University of Limerick, concurrently and over a period of three years, drew down the full salary relating to the position of president. A former president of University College Galway was obliged to repay more than €250,000. In addition, staff at UCD were paid in excess of €1 million to which they were not entitled. In circumstances where people at the top are being paid money to which they are not entitled — even under law — and where the poorest and most disadvantaged are being screwed to the wall, it is obvious that there are grave inequalities in our society.

When I was a member of the Joint Committee on Transport, we tried to examine the position regarding bonuses in the public sector, particularly those paid out by the harbour authorities. We challenged the latter to outline the bonuses that were being paid and representatives from one of the authorities stated that we had no right to request such information. Bonuses are being paid to people in the public sector about which we do not know and about which the relevant individuals will not provide information. Harbour authorities are unaccountable and will not provide details in respect of their budgetary affairs to properly constituted Oireachtas committees. Some in the universities are running riot while seeking to look after themselves and now the Government is proposing to tax the very people who require to be retrained. More than 40,000 students are currently attending plc colleges and the Government is proposing to impose a tax on entry of €200 per head on those who, having lost their jobs, are seeking to enter these institutions in order to try to improve their job prospects. Neither adequate nor proper consideration has been given to what is being proposed.

The Government proposes to tax people on the lowest rung in society who are paid the least. In that context, I wish to read into the record a letter I received from a constituent. All Deputies receive letters of this nature, but the one which was sent to me is exceptional. It was written by a man who is in his nineties and whose wife is also in her nineties. The letter states:

When I pay the State and the home [which his wife is in] I have nothing left at the end of each month. I live on my own, partly disabled, with the prospects of continued misery.

As already stated, the letter from which I am quoting was written by a man in his nineties who is in a state of despair regarding the way he is being treated and the way in which his wife is being treated in the nursing home in which she resides. There is no doubt that these people are being treated in a shameful and disgraceful manner. I accept that the Government put the fair deal scheme in place. However, the man and woman to whom I refer are being obliged to pay additional charges in respect of occasional concerts, baking demonstrations, flower arranging and mass. These people are being charged for things to which they should be automatically entitled or of which they will never be in a position to avail.

That which I have outlined is happening because the Government has allowed those who operate nursing homes, employees of State bodies and the chief executive officers of organisations such as Coillte to pay themselves enormous sums — in some cases up to €500,000 per year. The head of the Dublin Airport Authority is paid €750,000 per year. Despite this, the Government expects ordinary people to take it in the neck. That will not happen. The Government will be rejected by the electorate and will never be in a position to implement the national recovery plan, which is fundamentally wrong in respect of certain core issues.

Comment on this

Before I entered the Chamber, I received an e-mail from Baghdad which states:

All moving along here and with a government starting to form here, business and investment will get back on track once the new government is announced. I have been watching the goings on at home and the way things seem to be coming out. We have not improved our reputation with the way the Government has handled the whole affair. I am asked daily by colleagues here about how this could have happened.

As already stated, this message was sent from Baghdad, which is located in one of the most unsettled regions in the world. Those in that city are looking forward to a new government while we have chaos here. The person who sent the e-mail proceeds to state, "If I had to describe it, I would describe it as reckless banking, no regulation and failure of Government, who were totally complacent and indifferent."

When I think of Baghdad, I am reminded of Chemical Ali who, when American forces were approaching that city, appeared on live television and stated that there was no problem and that the Americans had been surrounded and destroyed. The position with the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance is somewhat similar. For a long period they made public statements to the effect that there was no problem here, that matters were under control and that there were no difficulties with the banks or the economy. The American invasion of Baghdad provides a good analogy for what happened in respect of our crumbling economy.

On this recovery plan which, ironically, this Government will not be implementing, there are a few matters I want to mention briefly. As regards tourism — my area of responsibility — I thought there would be some mention of the travel tax, which has been a disaster for tourism. Tourist numbers will be down by 1 million this year and we will lose €1 billion in revenue. The travel tax was supposed to yield €120 million but it will yield only €80 million. Whereas Mr. Michael O'Leary might say much that suits himself, I agree with him in this regard. People are influenced by that cost when booking tickets. The travel tax has been a major stumbling block for Irish tourism. In Holland, they were getting more than €300 million from a travel tax, they abolished it and they reckon they have gained €1 billion, in other words, a net gain of €700 million. This tax is daft and should be removed immediately. We could make it a condition that both Aer Lingus and Ryanair will bring in the passengers, something to which Mr. O'Leary has given a commitment. He has stated he will bring in 5 million to 6 million extra passengers over a short period of time and create up to 6,000 jobs.

The plan does not mention that hotels and restaurants all over the country are under considerable pressure from costs and charges. In the good times of the Celtic tiger I argued here with a previous Minister for tourism, my county colleague, Deputy O'Donoghue, that excise duty and every other cost was higher in Ireland than all over Europe. We lost our competitiveness, and that is another reason people are not coming here.

One issue about which we could do something is that of rates. The Valuation Act 2001 envisaged that every rateable property would have its valuation revised every five to ten years. The Commissioner of Valuation has carried out revisions in only three of the 88 rating areas in the country and where he has carried them out, the rates have been reduced on average by 30%.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Deenihan has one minute remaining.

Comment on this

On another matter, page 96 of the plan refers to the income tax exemption on patent royalties. This will have a detrimental effect on enterprise. If the tax relief measures relate to the removal of the income tax exemption on patent royalties, it certainly will cost this country. This provision has been a significant driver of innovation and growth within many Irish companies and for inventors resident in Ireland. If a company develops the product and gains patent royalties as a result of the sale of a product, it means the inventors can receive a share of that royalty tax free. The company must develop the product which results in the employment of high-skilled individuals and each of these individuals must pay income tax on his or her salary. The innovation must be of such significance that it is patentable and significant costs are incurred in the patenting process. The benefit of patenting the invention is to protect it from being copied and to ensure the economic benefit goes to the inventing company and, therefore, to the Irish economy.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

I thank Deputy Deenihan.

Comment on this

If I may finish, other countries have similar provisions in their tax legislation, for example, in April 2010, Malta introduced a similar provision. This income tax exemption on patent royalties should be maintained if the objective of the plan is to drive growth within the economy.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Go raibh maith agat.

Comment on this

On page 40, there is a range of initiatives and incentives for creating the enterprise economy. Then one sees this ridiculous provision on page 96. I ask the Minister——

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

Briefly.

Comment on this

——not to introduce this. I will give him further details. I will give examples of companies, in particular, one company in Kerry that has been able to expand based on this alone.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

The next speaker is the Minister of State, Deputy Mansergh. There is 20 minutes in the slot but he will be interrupted at 3.30 p.m. for Question Time.

Comment on this
Dr Martin Mansergh Minister of State at the Department of Finance (Deputy Martin Mansergh) Fianna Fáil

I am glad to be able to contribute to this debate, not to be giving the official reply or wind-up but to be able to give some of my own thoughts on the subject.

I was present for the first two hours of a debate in the Seanad which adopted a reasoned and constructive tone on all sides of the House whereas some of what I have heard here has been very much the cockpit of politics. That is one of the reasons the Seanad should be maintained, contrary to the position of the main Opposition party.

As the question of responsibility for the situation constantly arises, I want to give two short quotations from the international newspapers of the past couple of days. For those who think the Government is to blame, Mr. Martin Wolf, in the Financial Times, pointed out yesterday, “It was not the public but the private sector that went haywire in Ireland and in Spain.” Of course, it is when that private borrowing, and the basis of it, collapsed that the gulf in revenues arose.

The Wall Street Journal, on 23 November, reported:

Ireland's plight is not the result of collecting too little tax. The country is a victim of the global credit bubble, which tended to hit hardest the countries that had the largest and most innovative financial industries: Ireland, the U.K., Spain, the U.S. and, in its especially perverse way, Iceland.

The Government accepts its responsibility in the sense that we believed — it was the belief of nearly everybody and it was the advice — that there would be a soft landing. We were wrong, but so was nearly everyone else.

We had a vision in this country, which was shared far beyond the ranks of my party, of a dynamic economy with low tax rates but flowing revenues because of its dynamism, and with good social services and infrastructure. Unfortunately, it was not sustainable. The favourite mantras of the Labour Party a few years ago were that the country is awash with money and Ireland was the second richest country in the EU, although that was only statistically the case, and the implication was that we should be spending much more money.

I pay tribute to the courage of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance in the way they have battled against enormous difficulties in the past two and a half years. One can say the situation was partly of our making but it was also triggered by an international crisis.

I have some sympathy with a letter that appeared in The Irish Times this morning from Ms Irene Houlihan in Birr, which states:

The constant pillorying of this country's Taoiseach by a frenzied media whipping up anti-Government mob hysteria is shameful and reprehensible. The words keep coming to mind — and still the crowd shouted "Crucify him! Crucify him!" Was it for this indeed?

Certainly, as a survey recently showed, we have the freest media in the world which is something of which we should be proud, although I doubt if there is a State broadcasting station anywhere in the world that would allow itself some of the liberties that certain broadcasters permit themselves.

There are certainly some columnists and broadcasters whose coverage can be summed up as "aux barricades, citoyens". I was in Brussels at the end of the first day of a Council of Ministers meeting when I saw the leading voice of The Irish Times scarcely able to contain a grin at the thought, as it looked then, that a dissolution might be about to take place. At the same time, it is not fair to criticise the media if one is not also prepared to engage in self-criticism and I regret that I have a colleague in Tipperary South to whom is attributed in a headline the phrase “worse than Cromwell”, which he applied to the Taoiseach and his predecessor. I hope on reflection that imputation will be withdrawn.

Comment on this

Is the Minister of State suggesting the economic, fiscal and banking collapse was caused by the media?

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

I ask Deputy Shatter to resist the temptation——

Comment on this

I did for a while.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Acting Chairman (Deputy Charlie O’Connor) Fianna Fáil

——and allow the Minister of State to proceed. Deputy Shatter will have his chance.

Comment on this

I suppose The Irish Times has brought the country down, has it?

Comment on this
Dr Martin Mansergh Deputy Martin Mansergh Fianna Fáil

I wish to repeat a very good point made yesterday by a Fine Gael Senator in the Seanad. One of the principal merits of the plan is that providing a future outline of how we can reach a target of less than 3% of GDP will create confidence. Of course detailed provisions can be changed or substituted by the next government. If the Government was remaining in office it would probably have to change and substitute some details itself. However, the broad thrust is there and I believe the next government will broadly adopt it as an outline. Given the circumstances of the assistance that is required from the EU and the IMF, it will need to do so but, as I say, this is subject to the caveat that alternatives can be substituted.

It needs to be understood by the public that with a gap of €18.5 billion, it is not open to us to continue borrowing except on the basis of a plan such as this. We need to be able to borrow if we are to pay out all of the cheques which a government pays out, including to social welfare recipients, public servants and contractors.

Much play has been made of the question of sovereignty. I would like to make the point, and it has been made by several commentators already, that this is our own plan which was prepared largely before we entered into discussions with the IMF and the EU. This is not an IMF or EU diktat, although I think there are one or two sectors of opinion who wish it were. Certain columnists associated with a particular Sunday newspaper seem to be raging that the IMF and EU have not insisted on tearing up the Croke Park deal and social partnership with it.

I see the reduction of the minimum wage not in a negative, but in a positive light. The extent that it makes more jobs available is of benefit to people and not a detriment to them. I know it is particularly important to the hotel and hospitality industries. It is by no means the case that it is always the poorest people on the minimum wage. Many students taking part-time employment are on the minimum wage to supplement their income. If all other wages and incomes in the economy have been reduced, it is logical that the minimum wage, which was the second highest in Europe, be adjusted also.

I could not help but contrast the attitude of the Labour Party spokesperson on the economy in the Seanad yesterday, who criticised it mildly and stated he would like to see more evidence to support its merits as it has no direct impact on the public finances, with that of the Fine Gael spokesperson, Deputy Bruton, who spoke on radio this morning and who was much more hard line in opposition. I would like to make a prediction. In my belief, the incoming government, regardless of what may be said during an election campaign, will not alter this decision.

From the late 1990s through to 2008 there were increases in social welfare way above the rate of inflation. We have had some deflation in our economy over the past couple of years. I am not in the least suggesting that there is not some real reduction taking place but it has to be set in the context of the large increases previously.

A point is made quite frequently about political salaries, which have been reduced by approximately 20% at ministerial level. People are asking what further sacrifices will be made. The answer is in higher levels of taxation. The salary of a Deputy is tied to that of principal officer and that of Senator is tied to assistant principal officer. Under the Croke Park agreement no further reductions in salaries are contemplated.

A question was asked about the basis of the projections of growth. The answer is partly the background of a recovering world economy, but in particular the improvements in export competitiveness, where our exports have increased in real terms by 6% in the past year.

There is to be a moratorium on new road starts in 2012 and 2013. Even though this will affect my constituency, I think it is understandable. A huge amount has been done. The most recent analysis showed there is spare capacity on our roads and this is an area that in the current circumstances has to wait. I am glad metro north will go ahead. It is important, not least for our tourism industry, that our airport like other European airports should be rail connected to the city centre.

I am glad to see that agriculture is relatively unscathed. I am also pleased that my office, the Office of Public Works, despite having a cut in expenditure of more than one third, is able to undertake the essential jobs it is tasked with doing, especially flood relief which I have protected, and also ongoing heritage and building works. As Minister of State, I am happy to stand over what is in the national recovery plan with regard to the Office of Public Works.

All of this takes place against a much larger canvas, which is, as the German Government pointed out, an existential battle to maintain the eurozone in which we happen to be in the front line currently. It is in our essential interest that this battle is won. We, as eurozone members, must play our part. We need to internalise the logic and the disciplines of belonging to the eurozone. Perhaps in the early years we felt we did not have to or it all seemed to go more smoothly than we expected. We have now seen the hard side of eurozone membership, but it is well worth persisting with it. I have great hopes for the future of the economy and believe that despite the reservations that have been expressed about various parts of this plan by Opposition parties, the next Government — if it is the current Opposition — will largely adopt this plan and work with it as if it was their own.

Comment on this