Order of Business
- Order of Business 16 speeches
The House agrees the scheduled business, handles procedural exchanges, and pays tribute to former Deputy P.J. Morley.
Enda Kenny, Micheál Martin, Seán Barrett, Gerry Adams
- Health Department resignation controversy 73 speeches
Deputy Martin protests the lack of an opportunity to question the Minister for Health about Deputy Shortall’s resignation, while the Taoiseach defends the Government’s handling. Deputy Adams also asks about the new Minister of State’s primary-care powers and whether the programme for Government will change; the Taoiseach says primary care is not a separately defined statutory responsibility.
Micheál Martin, Seán Barrett, Bernard Durkan, Paul Kehoe, Gerry Adams
- Cyberbullying legislation 3 speeches
Deputy Collins asks about the growing problem of cyberbullying; the Taoiseach points to forthcoming criminal justice legislation and an October conference.
Niall Collins, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Sports capital grant applications 2 speeches
Deputy Keating asks whether legislation and funding will support roughly 2,700 sports capital applications, and the Taoiseach joins him in congratulating Jim Gavin.
Derek Keating, Enda Kenny
- Bail Bill publication 8 speeches
Deputy Durkan urges early publication of the Bail Bill to address crime; the Taoiseach says its heads are being drafted and will go to Government when completed.
Bernard Durkan, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Strategic investment fund legislation 5 speeches
Deputy Doherty seeks legislation enabling the National Pensions Reserve Fund to invest in the strategic investment fund; the Taoiseach says the work has priority but gives no publication date.
Pearse Doherty, Enda Kenny, Willie O'Dea
- Noise nuisance legislation 8 speeches
Deputy McGrath asks whether the Noise Nuisance Bill will strengthen enforcement powers, but the Chair interrupts him amid joking references to the noisy Kilkenny homecoming.
Mattie McGrath, Patrick O'Donovan, Seán Barrett, Paul Kehoe
- Land and conveyancing reform Bill 14 speeches
Deputy Healy-Rae asks about publication of the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform (Amendment) Bill and online property-price information; the Taoiseach says it is expected next year.
Michael Healy-Rae, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny, Mattie McGrath, Bernard Durkan
- Gambling control Bill 2 speeches
Deputy Butler asks when legislation will regulate online gambling, particularly on social-media websites; the Taoiseach says publication is expected next year.
Ray Butler, Enda Kenny
- Minerals and health insurance legislation 7 speeches
Deputy Higgins asks about the Minerals Development Bill and Health Insurance (Risk Equalisation) Bill; the Taoiseach says both are due to be published during the session.
Joe Higgins, Seán Barrett, Billy Kelleher, Micheál Martin, Enda Kenny
- Primary care ministerial powers 15 speeches
Deputy Kelleher again asks whether powers assigned to the new Minister of State for primary care have been signed and laid before the Houses. The Taoiseach says primary care crosses departmental areas and therefore is not assigned through a narrow statutory remit.
Billy Kelleher, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny, Micheál Martin, Mattie McGrath
- Cork home insurance access 16 speeches
Deputy Buttimer raises the inability of many Cork residents to obtain affordable insurance because of flooding or subsidence and asks about legislative action. The Taoiseach acknowledges the seriousness and says the Environment and Finance Ministers are working on a solution with funding available.
Jerry Buttimer, Niall Collins, Seán Barrett, Timmy Dooley, Enda Kenny
On a point of order, is there an opportunity to discuss the Taoiseach's announcement regarding a ministerial appointment here?
Comment on this
-----No. 4, Health and Social Care Professionals (Amendment) Bill - Order for Second Stage and Second Stage.
Comment on this
We were not alerted to it. I am just pointing that out.
Comment on this
They are not being put to the House?
Comment on this
In terms of the order of the House?
Comment on this
Before we start on the Order of Business proper may I take this opportunity on my behalf and on behalf of my party to express our deepest sympathy to the family of the late Teachta Dála P.J. Morley who passed away, and to Mary, his wife, and to Patrick, Enda, Brian and Cathy, we extend our deepest sympathies. P.J. served in this House for 20 years from 1977 to 1997. He was a man of great integrity and commitment and an outstanding parliamentarian in working for his people in Mayo. He had a very close association with the late Monsignor Horan and worked extremely hard on the securing and development of Knock Airport among other achievements in the region. We sympathise with his family on their loss. I hope we will get an opportunity later to pay a more fulsome tribute but I want to pay this tribute to P.J. and to offer our sympathies and condolences to his wife and family.
Comment on this
I assume we will have an opportunity to say a few words about this again. I concur with the sentiments expressed by Deputy Martin and I sympathise with the Morley family on the death of P.J. I served with him both as a councillor and a Deputy for many years. I enjoyed his company and I will have an opportunity to say some words again. He was a person who showed an extraordinary degree of practical common sense in dealing with many issues that were quite contentious over the years. To his wife Mary and family, I offer my sympathy to the family and to the party. He was a good, loyal and convivial servant of the people of my own county for many years.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom cur leis an méid a dúirt an Taoiseach agus an Teachta Martin faoin scéal brónach seo i dtaobh báis P.J. Morley. I wish to extend sympathy to the Morley family. Go ndéana Dia trócaire ar a anam dílis.
Comment on this
As has been said, we will have another opportunity to give a more detailed response later.
Comment on this
We would have wished to have had the opportunity to oppose the Order of Business and we are disappointed that this opportunity has not been facilitated. I asked the Taoiseach earlier if the Minister for Health would come to the Dáil to speak about the serious issues within his own Department, particularly in the context of the resignation of the former Minister of State, Deputy Shortall, which is, by any standards, an issue of national importance, particularly as she outlined at the weekend the difficulties in following through on the programme for Government, the degree to which any worthy initiatives were blocked by the Minister-----
Comment on this
-----and the degree to which we could again have a balanced budget this year if the Minister had followed through on the commitments that he gave to big ticket items.
Comment on this
I have to say to the Ceann Comhairle-----
Comment on this
------it is an extraordinary situation that everybody outside the House is discussing the House-----
Comment on this
Every radio station is talking about it and we do not have an opportunity to have a private notice question accepted, which would have allowed for a detailed presentation by the Minister of his position and his perspective in the aftermath of the resignation of a Minister of State in his Department. This significant controversy has been under way for some weeks. On occasion in previous Dáileanna, Ministers were inevitably brought in and asked to respond to a private notice question. That was always the standard.
Comment on this
I am not denying the Deputy any opportunities. The Standing Orders are quite clear about private notice questions and I only stick to the wording in the Standing Orders. Therefore, please get on and deal with what we can deal with.
Comment on this
This controversy has raged for weeks.
Comment on this
The Deputy is getting a good bit of mileage out of it.
Comment on this
The bottom line is the story has changed time and time again.
Comment on this
A Minister of State has resigned and it is extraordinary that we do not have an opportunity following a frank interview by her-----
Comment on this
-----to ask the Minister for Health some basic questions and hope to get some straightforward answers.
Comment on this
As a political party, we are annoyed and extremely angry at this turn of events-----
Comment on this
-----and at the failure of the Minister to come in and account for it.
Comment on this
It is a pity Fianna Fáil did not have these principles when it was in government.
Comment on this
What seems to be happening is that a very partisan approach is being taken. I just counted the opportunities the Opposition gets in the House and they are few.
Comment on this
Very little opportunity is afforded to the Opposition in this Dáil. Despite all the talk and protestations about reform, transparency and openness, it has not been forthcoming since the Government has taken up office.
Comment on this
I will not ask the Deputy a third time to please resume his seat if he has not something in order on the Order of Business.
Comment on this
I find it extraordinary that we are in this situation today where the Minister for Health will not come in and, for a minimum of time, make a presentation on the issues that have unfolded.
Comment on this
This could have been avoided if the private notice question-----
Comment on this
We have gone through all the procedures and we have been shot down in this regard in an unfair way.
Comment on this
The Deputy referred to the Chair as acting in an unfair way and I ask him to withdraw that remark forthwith.
Comment on this
No, I did not. I am not withdrawing any remark.
Comment on this
The Deputy implied in his statement that he was treated unfairly by me because I did not grant a private notice question. I ask him to withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
I am not withdrawing any remark. I asked earlier-----
Comment on this
It is a matter for the Chair to interpret the Standing Orders adopted by this House. The Standing Orders are quite clear about the granting of a private notice question. The Deputy's request did not conform with those requirements and, therefore, it is not a matter of being fair or unfair.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I asked-----
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle is making comments-----
Comment on this
I asked the Taoiseach on the Order of the House today at Leaders' Questions to facilitate and provide for the Minister for Health----
Comment on this
The Deputy may be looking at the press but I am telling him what the Standing Orders say.
Comment on this
I know well what the Standing Orders are.
Comment on this
I am putting it clearly to the Chair in my opinion and I outlined what our party believes.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Party believes that the way the House is being managed and the facility being afforded to the Opposition is not fair or satisfactory.
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not have confidence in my chairmanship, he has a means of dealing with it. All he has to do is table the motion.
Comment on this
What is unfolding here is a ridiculous scenario.
Comment on this
Ceist faoi reachtaíocht atá fógraithe. I wish the Minister of State, Teachta Alex White, well in his new position.
Comment on this
Fair play to the Deputy. He has manners that others do not.
Comment on this
I wish him luck. He will need all the luck he can get, given the way Deputy Shortall was dealt with. The new Minister of State has a hard job to do and I wish him luck with it.
Last week, Deputy MacDonald asked the Taoiseach whether statutory power for primary care had been delegated to the former Minister of State, Deputy Shortall, and he replied that he thought that it had not been.
Comment on this
I think it is but I will be bound by the Chair's instruction. Will the Taoiseach confirm whether statutory power for primary care has been delegated to the new Minister of State, Deputy White, or whether the Government plans to bring forward such a statutory instrument? Has the programme for Government been changed, given Deputy Shortall's assertion that it is not being implemented? Does the Government intend to bring forward amendments to it?
Comment on this
I have no time for the false anger of Deputy Martin. In spite of the charge he made, the first Priority Question taken by the Minister for Health last Thursday-----
Comment on this
Late at night and he misled the House.
Comment on this
-----was asked by Deputy Kelleher and dealt with the issue of primary care centres. The Minister gave his answer.
Comment on this
I further remind the Deputy that the first Private Members' business following the recess was a motion of no confidence in the Minister for Health and he did not even bother to contribute to that debate.
Comment on this
Some of the Taoiseach's Labour Party colleagues did and they are not too happy now.
Comment on this
With regard to Deputy Adams's question, primary care is not based on a particular statute and cannot be delegated in the normal way-----
Comment on this
Of course it can. If the Government wants to, it can but it chooses not to.
Comment on this
------because it crosses many areas in the Department of Health and other Departments.
Comment on this
It might interfere with the Minister's portfolio.
Comment on this
From that perspective, we do not have a defined area of primary care because it is not based on a particular statute.
Comment on this
Cyber-bullying is a phenomenon of growing concern to many people and communities. It is not just an issue for young people, as there are many well documented cases of adults and elderly people who were victims of this crime. Is the Taoiseach aware of the extent of this phenomenon? Has he any legislative proposals to deal with this crime?
Comment on this
Yes, the criminal justice (cybercrime) Bill is listed but there is no date for publication. The Minister for Education and Skills is concerned about this. There is a conference on 19 October dealing with this issue. The Minister will reflect on the contributions made at it and will bring forward his proposals for updated legislation dealing with what is a serious matter.
Comment on this
The office of the Minister of State at the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport, Deputy Ring, has received approximately 2,7000 applications for sports capital grants. Given decisions in this regard are imminent, will legislation be required and will funding be secured for them?
The Taoiseach might join me in wishing Jim Gavin from Round Towers every success as the newly appointed Dublin manager.
Comment on this
In view of the oft expressed concerns about crime and the ongoing spate of crime, I used to raised the question of the bail Bill-----
Comment on this
I am reminding the Ceann Comhairle that when I was on the Opposition benches and Deputies Micheál Martin and Mattie McGrath were in government, I raised questions about the bail Bill and the need to introduce it at an early date to combat the problem-----
Comment on this
The bail Bill. To show serious intent, since the previous Administration did not show any intent in that area, would it be possible to bring that important legislation to the House ahead of schedule?
Comment on this
Let me reflect Deputy Durkan's concern. The heads of the Bill are being drafted in the Department of Justice and Equality and it is the intention of the Minister for Justice and Equality to bring the heads of the Bill to the Government as soon as he has completed the work.
Comment on this
One year ago last week, the Taoiseach announced the establishment of the strategic investment fund and he is well aware that we need an amendment to the existing legislation, the National Pensions Reserve Fund Act 2000, to allow the National Pensions Reserve Fund to invest in the strategic investment fund that is supposed to help venture capital and long-term capital for small and medium-sized enterprises, SMEs. Given that it is a cornerstone of the job creation strategy one year on, amendments have not been coming forward and it is not on the list for the rest of the year. When are we likely to see legislation brought forward in order that the strategic investment fund announced by the Government on 28 September last year can finally be established?
Comment on this
A great deal of work has been done on this. It is to give effect to that commitment for investment in Irish infrastructure for Irish jobs. I cannot give an accurate date for publication but it is receiving priority. The use of the NewERA concept and the National Pensions Reserve Fund for investment in Irish infrastructure has been the subject of a great deal of discussion.
Comment on this
I cannot give an accurate date for its introduction but it is moving along. It is not too far away.
Comment on this
Regarding the noise nuisance Bill-----
Comment on this
No, seriously. This is in section C of the Government legislation programme. Can the Minister extend or improve the powers available to the enforcement authorities to prevent noise or to reduce and abate noise? Last night, at the homecoming of the victorious Kilkenny team, which I congratulate, the noise of the booing broke all decimal levels when the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government, Deputy Phil Hogan-----
Comment on this
Will Deputy McGrath please resume his seat? This is a House of Parliament. I call Deputy Healy-Rae.
Comment on this
They were so jubilant but they booed the Minister, Deputy Hogan.
Comment on this
Was Deputy McGrath at the gate collecting fivers?
Comment on this
I called Deputy Healy-Rae. It is bad enough the way things are going without making a total show of ourselves in here.
Comment on this
I congratulate the new Minister of State and I wish him well. Regarding the new land and conveyancing law reform (amendment) Bill, can we ensure that when the Bill is brought before the House, the new practice of-----
Comment on this
When it comes before the House, Deputy Healy-Rae can have a long debate on it. When is the legislation due?
Comment on this
Can I just say to the Taoiseach-----
Comment on this
Everyone else gets to say-----
Comment on this
Very briefly, the Taoiseach knows that in recent days there has been a practice of the value of properties being put online showing what people paid for properties.
Comment on this
I ask Deputy Healy-Rae to resume his seat and not to make a farce out of the House. He should table a parliamentary question. What item of legislation does this concern?
Comment on this
It is the land and conveyancing law reform (amendment) Bill.
Comment on this
It will be next year before it is published. Deputy Healy-Rae will have the opportunity to make comments at that point. I hope the man beside him does not suffer from tinnitus from all the noise.
Comment on this
I will bring some normality back to the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Durkan needs some of that treatment.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy McGrath. When is publication expected of the gambling control Bill? I refer especially to the gambling done on websites. Facebook put up a website in England and we could have the same site in Ireland. Many young people are on Facebook and we need control of websites and gambling.
Comment on this
This refers to the gambling control Bill. The Government approved the preparation of the heads of the Bill but it has not yet come to Government. It will be next year before it is published.
Comment on this
I refer to the minerals development Bill and, in view of alarming reports today of sharp increases in health insurance, the health insurance (risk equalisation) Bill. I had hoped to advise Minister of State, Deputy Alex White, before he left the Chamber-----
Comment on this
In his new dispensation, he might be able to use his youthful political training in how to deal successfully with an entrenched Stalinist regime.
Comment on this
The minerals development Bill and health insurance risk (equalisation) Bill will be published this session.
Comment on this
In wishing the Minister of State, Deputy White, the best of luck, I want to inquire if the instruments assigning power to the Minister of State have been signed. Will the instruments be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas?
Comment on this
Will it include primary care and will the delegated functions be in the tenure of Minister of State?
Comment on this
There was no answer the previous time when Deputy Adams raised it.
Comment on this
The answer is that I have already made an announcement in the House for the information of Deputies, including Deputy Kelleher, that Deputy Alex White has been nominated and approved by the Government as a Minister of State at the Department of Health with responsibility for primary care.
Comment on this
Primary care is not contained in a particular statute because it crosses many areas of the Department so powers are not assigned in the normal way because the statutory remit is not that narrow.
Comment on this
That is why reform did not happen. What was the Tánaiste doing?
Comment on this
There were many Ministers of State in the previous Government.
Comment on this
Deputy Buttimer is getting too much for the rest of us.
Comment on this
In the city of Cork, many people cannot obtain insurance due to flooding or subsidence-----
Comment on this
Has the Government a plan? I wrote to the Joint Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform on this issue.
Comment on this
I am being heckled but it is a serious matter. There are people in the city of Cork who do not have house insurance or whose house insurance has increased by 150%-----
Comment on this
Can the Government, through European or other means, introduce legislation regarding that point?