Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The House agrees to take motions Nos. 19, 20 and 20a without debate.
Eamon Gilmore, Seán Barrett
- Compensation for vulnerable survivors 12 speeches
Seán Ó Fearghaíl seeks progress on payments for Magdalene survivors and victims of symphysiotomy and thalidomide; the Tánaiste reports progress on Magdalene payments while the other matters remain under consideration.
Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- Regulation of moneylenders 2 speeches
Jonathan O’Brien highlights the growth in moneylending and calls for action on high interest rates; the Tánaiste suggests the finance committee examine the issue.
Jonathan O'Brien, Eamon Gilmore
- Legislation on the disappeared 14 speeches
Deputies seek publication of the victims’ rights Bill and a debate on the disappeared following a recent broadcast. The Tánaiste says work is under way but gives no publication date, while the Whips will consider debate time.
Patrick O'Donovan, Kevin Humphreys, Dessie Ellis, Seán Barrett, Jonathan O'Brien
- Social welfare for self-employed people 25 speeches
Ray Butler asks about social welfare entitlements for self-employed people. The Tánaiste praises Minister Burton’s work and says the wider issue will be revisited after the Social Welfare and Pensions Bill.
Ray Butler, Seán Barrett, Michael Healy-Rae, Eamon Gilmore, Bernard Durkan
- Housing support for separated parents 7 speeches
Robert Troy asks that housing legislation protect separated parents, including people affected by domestic abuse, marital breakdown or mortgage problems. The Tánaiste says the housing Bill is due early next year.
Robert Troy, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- North-South health and infrastructure 19 speeches
Seamus Kirk asks about cross-Border hospital co-operation and the Narrow Water bridge. The Tánaiste cites existing health collaboration and says the bridge’s higher cost is being examined; subsequent exchanges include meeting arrangements and a withdrawn remark.
Seamus Kirk, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore, Mattie McGrath, Robert Troy
- Driving licences and EirGrid legislation 5 speeches
Mattie McGrath seeks an extension of the deadline for correcting omitted driving-licence categories and raises the need for EirGrid legislation. The Tánaiste says both Bills are due next year.
Mattie McGrath, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- Mayoral titles for municipal districts 8 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae asks whether municipal district chairpersons can retain the title of mayor; the Ceann Comhairle directs him to raise the matter during the local government Bill’s debate.
Michael Healy-Rae, Seán Barrett
- Planning on flood plains 12 speeches
Dessie Ellis raises the construction of Glen Ding estate and other developments on flood plains, seeking accountability for planning permissions. The Tánaiste says a planning Bill has no publication date and that builders as well as planners may bear responsibility.
Dessie Ellis, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- Deployment of telestroke machines 10 speeches
Denis Naughten asks why seven telestroke machines remain unused despite their potential clinical and financial benefits. The Tánaiste undertakes to ask the Minister for Health to respond.
Denis Naughten, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore, Robert Troy
- Shannon Airport legislation 2 speeches
Joe Carey asks when the Shannon aviation services Bill will be debated; the Tánaiste says it is due during the current session.
Joe Carey, Eamon Gilmore
- Inspection of places of detention 2 speeches
Frank Feighan asks when the inspection of places of detention Bill will be published; the Tánaiste says no date is available.
Frankie Feighan, Eamon Gilmore
- Lobbying and bail legislation 4 speeches
Bernard Durkan seeks timelines for the lobbying regulation Bill and bail Bill. The lobbying Bill’s heads have been approved and publication is expected early next year, while the bail Bill remains at an advanced drafting stage without a date.
Bernard Durkan, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- Radiological protection legislation 2 speeches
Michael P. Kitt asks about the Bill merging the radiological protection institute with the EPA and ratification of the nuclear materials convention; the Tánaiste expects the Bill next year but gives no ratification date.
Michael P. Kitt, Eamon Gilmore
- Mineral development legislation 7 speeches
James Bannon opposes State asset stripping and asks about the minerals development Bill. The Tánaiste says it was delayed from this session and is now expected early next year.
James Bannon, Seán Barrett, Mattie McGrath, Eamon Gilmore
It is proposed to take No. 19, motion re proposed approval by Dáil Éireann for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending EU Regulation No. 1215/2012 on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters (back from committee); No. 20, motion re proposed approval by Dáil Éireann for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council adapting to Article 290 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union a number of legal acts in the area of justice providing for the use of the regulatory procedure with scrutiny (back from committee); No. 20a, motion re referral to joint committee of proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of the Irish Aviation Authority Act 1993 - (Amendment of Schedule) (Annex 19 to Chicago Convention) Order 2013; No. 3, Finance (No. 2) Bill 2013 - Second Stage (resumed); and No. 33, Local Government Bill 2013 - Second Stage (resumed). It is proposed, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders, that Nos. 19, 20 and 20a shall be decided without debate.
Tomorrow's fortnightly Friday business shall be Health (Fluoridation of Water Supplies)(Repeal) Bill 2013 - Second Stage; and Joint Committee on Transport and Communications report on sponsorship of sports by the alcohol drinks industry.
Comment on this
There is one proposal to be put to the House. Is the proposal for dealing with Nos. 19, 20 and 20a, without debate, agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
The programme for Government commits the Government to address the plight of three specific categories of people, first and foremost being the survivors of the Magdalene laundries. Very considerable credit is due to the Government for the work that has been done in that area, albeit that it took the Minister of State, Deputy Kathleen Lynch, to jump up and down a little bit and make it quite clear to the Taoiseach how important this issue was. Judge Quirke has issued his report and we are told that compensation will issue. I ask the Tánaiste if he can indicate when the victims can expect to receive their compensation. The victims of symphysiotomy were also included in that Government commitment. Professor Walsh has produced a report to the Minister for Health, Deputy Reilly, and I believe it is to be considered by Cabinet, after which decisions will be made. Can we be given some indication of the timescale involved? The Tánaiste and members of the Government will be particularly aware of the ageing profile of the people who were involved. We believe compensation should be paid and this should happen sooner rather than later.
There are a mere 32 survivors of the thalidomide drug and the Government, likewise, made commitments in respect of addressing that issue.
Comment on this
It is in the programme for Government.
Comment on this
I simply wish to ask the Tánaiste what is happening in respect of the victims of thalidomide. I very recently heard Dr. Austin O'Carroll, who is the chairman of one of the two representative groups-----
Comment on this
It is in the programme for Government.
Comment on this
My understanding is that under the Order of Business we are entitled to raise matters relating to the programme for Government. If the Tánaiste can very quickly tell us what is happening in that area I will be very happy.
Comment on this
The matter of the payments to the survivors of the Magdalene laundries was considered by the Government this week and there is progress on the arrangements for the payments to be made. I expect this will be progressed in the near future. On the issue of the victims of symphysiotomy and thalidomide those are matters which are still being considered by the Minister for Health and he will bring his proposals to the Government when he is in a position to do so.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste will be aware that figures released this week show that the number of people accessing the services of moneylenders has increased since 2007 by 20%.
There are approximately 360,000 people in the State who access either legal or illegal moneylenders. The Tánaiste will also recall that my colleague, Deputy Pearse Doherty, brought forward a Private Members' Bill to try to cap the interest rates being charged by legal moneylenders. During the debate there was a general consensus on all sides of the House - although the Bill was voted down - that we needed to return to the issue in order to tackle high interest rates. Does the Government plan to publish legislation to tackle the issue of high interest being charged by legal moneylenders?
Comment on this
We do not have legislation on the list for the issue but I agree with Deputy O'Brien in that this is a serious issue. The matter of people finding themselves in trouble with moneylenders requires attention but the area might be usefully addressed by the Oireachtas committee dealing with finance. It could make recommendations for consideration by the Government.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste is aware that during the week there was a broadcast relating to the disappeared. The criminal justice (victims' rights) Bill is promised but when can we expect publication? Will the Tánaiste make available time through the Whips for this matter to be debated in the House as soon as possible? The issue is of major national importance and the House should debate the issue of Tuesday night's broadcast and provide an opportunity for people who may have information within the House to make a statement to the House.
Comment on this
I wish to speak on the same issue.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is on about. What does he mean by "people within the House"?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donovan has just raised it.
Comment on this
It is the criminal justice (victims' rights) Bill.
Comment on this
I thank the Ceann Comhairle for allowing me to contribute at this stage. It is necessary for us to have a full debate on the disappeared, which was the issue highlighted by the broadcast during the week. We have seen a very cynical move this week as a smokescreen of tapes-----
Comment on this
-----was used to distract attention from the poor families of the disappeared.
Comment on this
There is a promised Bill on victim support and work is under way in the Department of Justice and Equality in that regard. There is no date for its publication. The second matter raised by the two Deputies would be considered by the Whips.
Comment on this
The final Stages of the Social Welfare and Pensions Bill 2013 are taking place in the Seanad and a report on the self-employed will come before the Oireachtas-----
Comment on this
I wish to speak about the self-employed.
Comment on this
I will finish by saying that the Minister, Deputy Burton, has done great work for self-employed people.
Comment on this
Will legislation be brought to the Houses for self-employed people who need social welfare entitlements?
Comment on this
Yes, she has done more than a Minister in any other Government.
Comment on this
She is wonder woman all right.
Comment on this
She even managed to take some people off boards.
Comment on this
Some 80% of self-employed people who have sought social protection have been looked after by the Minister, which is more than Fianna Fáil, the Green Party or Independents have done.
Comment on this
She has taken a few of them off boards as well.
Comment on this
We only have ten minutes left and a number of Deputies wish to ask questions. Please be fair, as there should not be a debate on the Order of Business.
Comment on this
The Deputy is right and the Minister has vindicated her position on the social welfare system in a way that is in marked contrast to the neglect of that issue under Fianna Fáil in Government.
Comment on this
When she has completed her work on the Social Welfare and Pensions Bill, I have no doubt she will return to the larger issue.
Comment on this
In the recent budget we witnessed an unfair targeting of separated parents with the abolition of single parent tax credit. Legislation in the form of a housing (miscellaneous provisions) Bill is due to come before the House and would preclude separated applicants whose names remain on a family from applying for social housing. Applicants have had to move from a family home due to domestic abuse or marital breakdown, or a family home might not be sold because a mortgage is in arrears or negative equity. Will the Tánaiste commit to prioritising the housing (miscellaneous provisions) Bill that is to come before the House so the inequity can be dealt with?
Last week we witnessed the intervention by the policy director of An Taisce with regard to the site of the national children's hospital.
Comment on this
Will the Tánaiste confirm that this critical piece of infrastructure-----
Comment on this
-----will proceed on time for the children who need it?
Comment on this
In the general health care area, what is the position in identifying cross-Border synergies between hospitals in the north east and immediately north of the Border, for example? Are there exchanges between the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and the corresponding bodies in the North with regard to developing possibilities, particularly in the context of potential savings for the Department of Health? Is the Narrow Water bridge project going ahead or is support available for it?
Comment on this
There has been considerable co-operation on a North-South basis in the health area, including the radiotherapy services at Altnagelvin Area Hospital and work being done to care for children. As it happens, there is a meeting of the North-South Ministerial Council tomorrow and I expect the issue will be addressed again. With regard to the Narrow Water bridge, the estimate was significantly higher than that which was proposed originally, and the issue is currently being examined. I expect we will have an opportunity tomorrow to discuss it with colleagues north of the Border.
Comment on this
We are also meeting as part of the North-South Interparliamentary Association tomorrow.
Comment on this
Indeed, and I congratulate the Ceann Comhairle on the work he has done with his counterpart, the Speaker, William Hay, MLA, in getting that up and running.
Comment on this
I look forward to joining the Ceann Comhairle as a substitute at that meeting.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked, across the Chamber, if I would be smoking grass. He should withdraw the remark.
Comment on this
Will he withdraw the remark? I resent it.
Comment on this
Thank you. I wish to raise a road traffic Bill, as a very serious issue has arisen with people's driving licences. It particularly affects farmers and people involved in agriculture.
Comment on this
There is a deadline tomorrow evening for people to update their licences where categories were omitted. Will the Tánaiste ask the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport to extend the deadline for a few weeks as these categories have been omitted through no fault of the people affected or the officials involved? There is legislation to establish EirGrid in primary legislation but we must do something as it will have the country destroyed before the Bill is brought in.
Comment on this
That is a different issue altogether. That matter could be dealt with at committee level.
Comment on this
There is no provision in the local government Bill for the retention of the title of mayors of towns. Could an amendment be made to the Bill to allow the chairpersons of municipal districts have the title of mayor?
Comment on this
The provision is not in the Bill. I am asking whether the Tánaiste is taking the point. A chairperson of a municipal district-----
Comment on this
-----could have the title of mayor of a town.
Comment on this
On Saturday I visited Glen Ding estate in Blessington which was built six years ago on a flood plain, with a river flowing underground through it. Planners in Wicklow County Council gave permission for it. The proposed planning Bill will contain measures based on recommendations by the Mahon tribunal. We must get to grips with all these planning permissions.
Comment on this
Planning permissions have been given on flood plains. I have seen several of them.
Comment on this
There must be some accountability in that regard.
Comment on this
There is no date for its publication. Deputy Ellis is correct. Housing estates and developments were built and it was not just the planners that were at fault.
Comment on this
One person every hour suffers from a stroke in this country. I raised with the Taoiseach in connection with secondary legislation on 25 September the fact that there are seven telestroke machines in cardboard boxes in a warehouse in Cork that could save the HSE €55 million. In the UK they are used for the diagnosis of burns, in urology and for orthopaedic patients.
Comment on this
The Minister for Health was to explain why the machines are still in cardboard boxes, why they have not been rolled out across the country and why they are not saving money.
Comment on this
Would someone revert to me and let me know what is going on?
Comment on this
My question is on secondary legislation, the Health (Amendment) Act 2013.
Comment on this
He could put it in writing like the promises on Roscommon Hospital.
Comment on this
Shannon Airport has recorded a fifth successive month of passenger growth. When will the Shannon aviation services and miscellaneous provisions Bill come to the House for debate? It is the final piece in the jigsaw in the restructuring of Shannon Airport.
Comment on this
Deputy Carey is correct. Shannon Airport is experiencing growth. I was there two weeks ago and saw the situation at first hand. The Shannon aviation services and miscellaneous provisions Bill is due this session.
Comment on this
Deputy Troy mentioned Roscommon Hospital. I will bring him by the hand to it and show him a really good hospital if he wants to see it. When is the inspection of places of detention Bill due? The prison inspectorate must be ramped up. The Bill will also address visiting committees.
Comment on this
Given the sad experiences we have had in this country arising from uncontrolled lobbying in the past 20 years, could I ask the Tánaiste the progress to date in the preparation of the control of lobbying Bill, whether it has been discussed in Cabinet, if the heads of the Bill have been approved and when it is likely to come before the House? Similarly, I wish to inquire about that old friend of mine, the bail Bill, which has been hanging around longer than some of the Members sitting on the benches opposite, and in their time as well. Could I ask the extent to which final agreement has been reached on the heads of the Bill and when it is likely to come before the House?
Comment on this
The heads of the regulation of lobbying Bill have been approved by Government and the Bill is expected to be published early in the new year. The draft heads of the bail Bill are at an advanced stage and it is not possible to indicate when it will be published.
Comment on this
When is publication expected of the radiological protection (amendment) Bill to provide for the merger of the Radiological Protection Institute of Ireland, RPII, and the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA? When will the convention on the physical protection of nuclear materials and nuclear facilities arising from the legislation be ratified by this country?
Comment on this
The radiological protection Bill is expected next year. I do not have a date for the ratification of the convention.
Comment on this
We must take State asset stripping off the agenda and try to give a firm commitment that power stations, the fishing industry and minerals-----
Comment on this
-----keep working for people in this country.
Comment on this
When will the mineral developments Bill come before the House?
Comment on this
What about the big houses in Longford?