Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The Government proposes the day’s business and time limits for the Ukraine motion and social-housing statements, and the proposal is agreed.
Ruairí Quinn, Seán Barrett
- Dispute over accusation of cowardice 3 speeches
Deputies exchange accusations after Michael McGrath objects to Paul Kehoe’s criticism of Deputy Mathews.
Michael McGrath, Paul Kehoe, Patrick O'Donovan
- Fennelly inquiry and IBRC mortgage protections 2 speeches
Michael McGrath seeks progress on the Fennelly commission’s terms of reference and protection for borrowers whose IBRC mortgages were sold; the Minister promises Cabinet action and refers the issue to Finance.
Michael McGrath, Ruairí Quinn
- Domestic violence legislation and procurement rules 6 speeches
Mary Lou McDonald asks about the urgent domestic-violence Bill, citing a threatened Dundalk refuge closure, and urges implementation of new EU procurement rules for SMEs. The Minister says the legislation is targeted for completion and promises further information on procurement.
Mary Lou McDonald, Seán Barrett, Ruairí Quinn
- Credit Guarantee and children’s hospital Bills 2 speeches
Bernard Durkan requests timelines for the Credit Guarantee amendment and National Paediatric Hospital legislation; the Minister has no dates but says hospital progress is not legislation-dependent.
Bernard Durkan, Ruairí Quinn
- Maritime Area and Foreshore Bill 2 speeches
Patrick O’Donovan asks when the delayed foreshore legislation will advance; it remains queued in the Environment Department, with a timetable to follow.
Patrick O'Donovan, Ruairí Quinn
- Vehicle clamping regulation 2 speeches
Dessie Ellis seeks the promised clamping Bill, citing abuses at hospital car parks; the Minister says it remains on course before the summer recess.
Dessie Ellis, Ruairí Quinn
- Clerk of the Dáil and by-election writ 4 speeches
Barry Cowen asks whether the vacant permanent Clerk’s post affects issuing a by-election writ; the Minister offers no definitive answer but says the six-month legal deadline will be observed.
Barry Cowen, Ruairí Quinn
- Workplace Relations Bill 2 speeches
Noel Harrington asks when the Workplace Relations Bill will be introduced, and the Minister says it is expected before the summer recess.
Noel Harrington, Ruairí Quinn
- Climate Action Bill 2 speeches
Marcella Corcoran Kennedy seeks urgent climate legislation; the Minister says revised heads are due before Easter and the final Bill before summer.
Marcella Corcoran Kennedy, Ruairí Quinn
- Banking inquiry progress 16 speeches
Peter Mathews asks about the promised banking inquiry, criticising its slow progress. The Minister says planning is advanced but gives no timetable, prompting further political exchanges and disorderly interjections.
Peter Mathews, Seán Barrett, Ruairí Quinn, Thomas P. Broughan, Róisín Shortall
- Docklands and broadcasting legislation 2 speeches
Terence Flanagan asks about the Docklands dissolution and broadcasting-charge Bills; the former is expected before summer, while the latter is planned for later in the year.
Terence Flanagan, Ruairí Quinn
- Access to invasive ventilation 5 speeches
Martin Ferris raises a motor neurone disease patient’s difficulty obtaining publicly funded invasive ventilation. The Minister expresses sympathy and advises a written or oral question to the Health Minister.
Martin Ferris, Seán Barrett, Ruairí Quinn
- University and Down syndrome legislation 2 speeches
Charlie McConalogue seeks updates on university financial-autonomy legislation and a Down syndrome Bill; the first awaits committee scrutiny and drafting, while the second will receive a written response.
Charlie McConalogue, Ruairí Quinn
- Adoption records and rural schools review 2 speeches
Robert Troy asks about adoption-record access legislation and publication of a rural-schools value-for-money review; the adoption Bill is under Cabinet discussion and the review remains under consideration.
Robert Troy, Ruairí Quinn
- School admissions Bill 2 speeches
Seán Ó Fearghaíl asks when the education admissions Bill will appear; its heads are cleared and drafting is under way, with debate hoped for before summer ends.
Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Ruairí Quinn
- Dáil business delays 4 speeches
Thomas P. Broughan criticises repeated collapses in Dáil business and questions Government and Whip management; the Ceann Comhairle redirects the issue, while the Minister acknowledges delays and committee responsibility.
Thomas P. Broughan, Seán Barrett, Paul Kehoe
- Junior cycle reform debate 2 speeches
Thomas P. Broughan seeks time to debate proposed junior-cycle changes and teacher opposition; the Minister says he would welcome such a debate.
Thomas P. Broughan, Ruairí Quinn
It is proposed to take No. 11a, motion re the current crisis in Ukraine; and No. 25, statements on the supply of social housing and the Government's homelessness policy (resumed). It is proposed, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders, that the proceedings in respect of No. 11a shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion after one hour and the following arrangements shall apply: the speech of a Minister or Minister of State and of the main spokespersons for Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin and the Technical Group, who shall be called upon in that order, shall not exceed 15 minutes in each case, and such Members may share their time.
Comment on this
Before I speak, the Minister of State, Deputy Kehoe, cannot accuse Deputy Mathews of lacking courage. It was an unfair accusation of the man.
Comment on this
When he joins Fianna Fáil, it will know.
Comment on this
I wish to raise two issues on the Order of Business. First, will the Minister update the House on the terms of reference of the commission of investigation under Mr. Justice Fennelly? I understand that the Cabinet has discussed them. When does the Minister expect them to be agreed at Cabinet level and introduced in the House for a full debate?
Second, the special liquidator of IBRC, KPMG, has sold approximately two thirds of the mortgage book to two separate US hedge funds, both of which are unregulated in Ireland. Those consumers have lost the binding statutory protections that every other mortgage holder in the country has. Two items of legislation are relevant. One is a Government Bill, the heads of which are yet to be approved. It is due some time next year. Are there plans to accelerate that process in light of the fact that more than 8,000 mortgage holders are exposed and vulnerable? Alternatively, a Fianna Fáil Private Member's Bill passed Second Stage in the Dáil a number of weeks ago. The Government could progress it to Committee Stage for further debate.
Comment on this
Regarding the Deputy's question on the terms of reference of the commission of investigation, that matter will be discussed at Cabinet next week. It is our intention to have it agreed as quickly as possible with the Supreme Court judge, Mr. Justice Fennelly.
It will be then brought to the House as soon as possible.
I am aware of the concern people have expressed about the protections they might no longer have in respect of the IBRC decision. That legislation is progressing as quickly as possible. I will draw the suggestion made by the Deputy to the attention of the Minister for Finance to ensure there is statutory protection for people whose mortgages have been transferred from one lender to another.
Comment on this
I wish to raise two matters. Yesterday we heard that the consolidated domestic violence legislation will be published in the summer. Can the Minister say if there is a sense of urgency about this legislation and the timetable for it? When might we expect it to be enacted, given that it is a matter of some urgency? As I am on the subject, I draw the Minister's attention to the announcement yesterday that the Women's Aid refuge in Dundalk is due to close in June. There was a similar scenario last year in Wexford. Other places are stretched-----
Comment on this
I am making the point to the Minister. I am sure he appreciates the seriousness of it.
Second, the new directive on public procurement was agreed almost three months ago at European level. The purpose of the directive is to make better use of the procurement procedure to support wider social goals. The Government has 24 months to introduce the legislation to implement the directive. Many small and medium enterprises, SMEs, are effectively locked out of procurement because the current rules are so restrictive, so this directive is a good advance. I urge the Government to deal with it legislatively with all due haste. When does it propose to bring forward that legislation?
Comment on this
On the last matter raised by the Deputy, I will have to refer back to her with an accurate answer. She will receive a letter accordingly on the matter.
On the first matter, a letter has been sent to the Deputy by the Minister, Deputy Shatter. She might not have seen it yet, but it is dated 21 March.
Comment on this
The situation is the same as outlined in the letter. It is intended to have the heads of the Bill dealing with domestic violence completed by summer this year and to implement the legislation as quickly as possible after that.
Comment on this
Will the Minister clarify the current position with the Credit Guarantee (Amendment) Bill? It is an issue of considerable importance at present. Similarly, what is the position with the proposed National Paediatric Hospital Development Board (Amendment) Bill relating to the national children's hospital? Again, it is an issue that has been occupying people's minds in recent times, particularly as there might be further delays arising from planning issues.
Comment on this
I have no date for either of the legislative measures. However, with regard to the national children's hospital, I assure the Deputy its progress is not dependent on the legislation. Work is continuing on implementing that policy measure. As soon as I have the information requested, I will give it to the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Maritime Area and Foreshore (Amendment) Bill is on the A list in the legislative programme. The Bill will tidy up issues relating to the foreshore and planning which are causing a huge amount of frustration, especially for ports. What progress is being made on that Bill and when can we expect it to be brought to the House?
Comment on this
I am informed that it is currently with the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government and is in a queue. There is another legislative measure ahead of it and as soon as that legislation is completed priority will be given to that Bill. I will ask the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government to write to the Deputy and to give him the precise timetable.
Comment on this
There is an urgent need to streamline the laws relating to clamping in both the public and private sectors in view of the ongoing scandal of clamping in the grounds of our public and private hospital car parks. It was promised that the Regulation of Vehicle Immobilisation Bill would be introduced in the House before the summer, but that appears to be unlikely at this stage. Can the Minister confirm the position? It is urgently required as I am constantly encountering this issue with people.
Comment on this
The Bill is on course to be brought to the House before the summer and, hopefully, it will be debated and de-clamped by the end of the session.
Comment on this
In the event of the Government being disposed to move a writ for a by-election in the coming weeks to coincide with the local and European elections, does the absence of a permanently appointed Clerk of the Dáil present a difficulty for moving such a writ? If so, will the Minister clarify the matter and when a permanent Clerk of the Dáil might be appointed to alleviate that problem?
Comment on this
I do not know what appropriate reply I can give. Perhaps the Ceann Comhairle can assist the Deputy in that regard. We will certainly abide by the legislation which provides that by-elections must take place within six months of the vacancy occurring.
Comment on this
The Clerk of the Dáil must issue the writ.
Comment on this
Our position is the same so it is a question of what are the implications of the absence of a Clerk of the Dáil.
Comment on this
Will the Minister indicate when the Workplace Relations Bill, to provide for reform of statutory workplace relations bodies, will be introduced in the House?
Comment on this
It is on course to be introduced in the House before the summer recess.
Comment on this
In light of the publication of the report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change earlier this week, when will the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Bill be published? It is required as soon as possible because 2020 is fast approaching and we are a long way from achieving our emissions targets in all sectors.
Comment on this
We all share the Deputy's concerns about this. The intention is to have the final Bill before the summer. There are revised heads due before Easter.
Comment on this
On the basis that it has been shown that the credit bubble and assets price bubble and subsequent bust that so nearly destroyed this economy were caused by the behaviour of the banking sector and the boards that did not keep to the prudential principles of-----
Comment on this
The Government promised a banking inquiry. What is happening to it?
Comment on this
I am informed that it is at a stage of advanced planning, but I cannot give a time-----
Comment on this
The next Dáil will take care of it.
Comment on this
When the Deputy was in the Department she was all talk and no action.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Kehoe know anything at all?
Comment on this
I had to ask the question because I am not a member of the committee anymore.
Comment on this
The Deputy is displaying his ignorance.
Comment on this
The Minister will be familiar with the Dublin Docklands Development Authority (Dissolution) Bill. The authority cost taxpayers hundreds of millions of euro due to engaging in reckless speculative property development. What is the position with that Bill and will it be introduced before the summer? Also, what is the position with the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill, which will change the current television licence to a broadcasting charge in the future?
Comment on this
Like the Deputy and my constituency colleague, Deputy Kevin Humphreys, I have a constituency interest in the Dublin Docklands Development Authority legislation. The heads of that Bill were passed by the Cabinet three or four weeks ago and we expect to have the legislation before the summer recess. I do not know whether it will be dealt with and completed before the recess.
The other legislative measure will be ready later this year.
Comment on this
The Minister might have received an e-mail yesterday from a woman named Elaine regarding her friend Eimear, who is suffering from rapid and aggressive motor neurone disease, and her fight to have a right to invasive ventilation when the time comes.
The problem is that she has been told by her professor and the person treating her-----
Comment on this
-----that she does not have the financial means for invasive ventilation, and that this was HSE policy. However, the HSE states that it is up to the professor or the consultant treating her who has responsibility for providing invasive ventilation for the lady in question.
Comment on this
I think everyone in the House got a similar e-mail and all of us cannot but empathise with her difficulty. I do not have the information, but I suggest the Deputy table a written question or raise it by way of an oral question with the Minister for Health.
Comment on this
Does the Minister have an update on his plans for proposed changes to the financial autonomy of universities in the universities Bill? Deputy Finian McGrath introduced in Private Members' time a Bill for children with Down's syndrome. It was accepted on Second Stage and I know the Joint Committee on Education and Social Protection has written to the Minister seeking permission that it would move to Committee Stage. Can the Minister give an update on that? We do not want it to sit there indefinitely and go nowhere.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is referring to the technological universities legislation. The draft heads of that Bill have gone to the Joint Committee on Education and Social Protection for scrutiny. I am hoping to get a report back from the committee as soon as possible, but realistically sometime between May and June. Then it will go to the Parliamentary Counsel for drafting. I do not expect to have it on the floor of this House until the autumn.
I am not in a position to give the Deputy an answer to the second matter. I will make inquiries and I will write to him.
Comment on this
The adoption (tracing and information) Bill has been long promised and is important because it will give people their basic fundamental right, which is the right to their identity. There are 50,000 people currently who are looking to explore their adoption records, and we await the legislation on that to come from the Government.
The Minister undertook a value for money review on small rural schools over 12 months ago. I understand he has had that report for a considerable period. When will it be laid before the House in order that we can have a full and frank debate on the future of small rural schools? They are facing a lot of uncertainty in not knowing where their future lies. Perhaps the Minister could enlighten me today.
Comment on this
The first matter in respect of adoption is up for discussion within the Cabinet. There are issues with it that I know the Minister, Deputy Fitzgerald, is anxious to resolve and to bring forward the legislation as quickly as possible. The other matter raised is still under consideration.
Comment on this
I understand the Joint Committee on Education and Social Protection has considered the heads of the education (admission to schools) Bill, and has reported to the Minister on it. When might we expect to see that important Bill coming before the House?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for raising the matter. It is something in which all of us, especially those of us on the Joint Committee on Education and Social Protection, have a big interest. It has gone to the Parliamentary Counsel for drafting. The content and the heads of the Bill have been agreed and cleared. Much work has been done prior to this and there are about 15 sections in the Bill. I hope to have it debated in the House and dealt with before the end of the summer session.
Comment on this
Yesterday we had no business in the Dáil for more than three hours. It seems to have become a characteristic of this Government in recent months where we have long stretches when business collapses. It may be the responsibility of the Chief Whip, and of the other Whips, but for some reason he is not able to manage the business of the House in such a way as to keep the business flowing.
Comment on this
Is there a problem here? Is it a problem with draftspeople in the Office of the Attorney General? What is happening to the Government on this issue? It seems to be in the process of closing down the Dáil and its input.
I would like to ask the Minister a question about his own portfolio.
Comment on this
Did Deputy Shortall get the Deputy to ask that question?
Comment on this
Given that we have so much time that the Chief Whip does not bother to fill, will we have a chance to discuss the Minister's plans for the junior certificate, the way he has tried to change it and the general unhappiness of the teaching profession?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his question. I share his sense of frustration that we are not processing business as quickly as we would like. One of the factors that has surprisingly caused us a delay has been the length of time that some committees are taking to process legislation, but ultimately responsibility rests with us. There are Bills ready to go and I think the Whips can discuss this in some detail.
If the Deputy would like to have a debate on the junior cycle reforms that I have proposed and which were discussed in this House about two years ago, I would be more than happy to have such a discussion. That is a matter to be raised with the Whips.