Defined benefit pensions gap
Deputy O'Dea asked whether solvent companies should be allowed to close defined benefit schemes without protection for pensioners. The Taoiseach said there was no Irish legislation, outlined the position in the UK and said the Minister was awaiting a Pensions Authority report.
Is that an endorsement of the policy of the Minister, Deputy Varadkar?
Comment on this
There is implied recognition in the programme for Government that the pension problem in the country needs to be dealt with. Does the Taoiseach find it acceptable that a solvent profitable company can change and close down a defined benefit pension scheme on a whim to the detriment of its pensioners and deferred pensioners and there is no provision in Irish law to deal with it? When will such a provision be put in place?
Comment on this
There is no legislation governing this in respect of Ireland. As the Deputy knows, there are two defined benefit pensions in respect of the case to which he is probably referring.
Comment on this
I am not referring to any particular case.
Comment on this
In Britain, defined benefit is based upon levies and is only used when the company involved becomes insolvent. The major company to which we are referring is not insolvent.
Comment on this
This is a matter in respect of defined benefit contributions, which have caused a number of difficulties over the period. The last actual certificates filled by defined benefit schemes with the Pensions Authority show that more than 60% meet the standard and the remaining schemes have recovery plans. There is concern the certificates due in the coming months will show significant deterioration. The operation of a pension scheme is in the first instance a matter for the trustees of the particular scheme. The Minister recently met the chairperson of the Pensions Authority. He has asked the authority to report back to him with an assessment of the current overall position on defined benefit schemes. He will report to the House when it comes back to him.