Justice email review
Róisín Shortall pressed for an independent review into missing Department of Justice emails and non-compliance with a tribunal disclosure order, saying an internal review would lack public confidence. The Taoiseach accepted that point and announced that an independent senior counsel would be appointed to carry out the review.
Last week the Taoiseach announced a review into the handling of critical emails which went astray in the Department of Justice and Equality and the Department's failure to comply with a disclosure order from the Charleton tribunal. The Taoiseach suggested that the review would be headed up by the Secretary General to the Government. I, as did many others, made the point that this would not be acceptable as it is important that we would have public confidence in such a review. For that reason, it would need to be an independent review carried out by an independent person and not an internal Civil Service review.
Has he had time to reflect on that point? Is he now proposing that an independent person will head up that review?
Comment on this
I have had time to reflect on it. I heard the arguments the Deputy made and saw the letter she sent to me. The Minister for Justice and Equality, Deputy Flanagan, and I have reflected on and discussed this and we agree that the Deputy is correct. Therefore, we are going to commission an independent senior counsel to carry out the review into why the emails were not sent to the tribunal. We expect to be able to release the name of the person who will carry out that review in the next couple days.