Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Bill 2018: Report Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 1–197 of 402. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 105 of 2018 ›
As we all outlined and agreed, there are paternalistic cultures which may force women to have abortions on the basis of gender. We need to have safeguards against that. It is only reasonable to allow the amendment to be made to ensure we have that safeguard. It also ensures that children with disabilities are not discriminated against. We have made great progress on inclusion in this State when we consider the Special Olympics and all the positivity associated with that. It would be a shame to undo all that good progress by not agreeing to an amendment to ensure that no abortion is carried out based on disability or gender.
Comment on this
The legislation does not provide for termination of pregnancy to be carried out on the grounds of sex, race or disability. The Bill provides for termination of pregnancy to be carried out only in cases where there is a risk to the life or serious harm of the health of a pregnant woman; where there is a risk to the life, or of serious harm to the health, of a pregnant woman in an emergency; where a condition is present which is likely to lead to the death of a foetus either before or within 28 days of birth; and where the pregnancy has not exceeded 12 weeks. Terminating a pregnancy otherwise than in accordance with the provisions of the Bill is an offence which may be prosecuted.
The proposed amendment is entirely unworkable in practice and is designed, in my view, only to stigmatise women in crisis pregnancies by allowing its proposers to suggest that these are their motives. If it were to pass, its only possible intention would be to render termination services practically entirely inoperable requiring, as it does, a doctor to be able to determine a woman's thoughts which she may choose to keep private, and in fact be satisfied as to the absence of those described. This would likely have the effect of creating substantial and unnecessary difficulty for doctors in providing certification. It would make the entire premise of the early pregnancy section of the Bill inoperable.
The strong advice of the Chief Medical Officer is that this amendment must be opposed on this basis and I fully support that medical opinion. It is also my strong view that the proposed amendment is completely out of step with the decision of the people and the recommendations of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution. The legislation, as drafted, reflects the majority view that women in early pregnancy should be able to make their decisions in private with their doctor without being required to give a reason.
This is a case of the political tactic of "let them deny it". There is no ground in this Bill for termination of pregnancy in relation to disability, sex or race. It is not allowed under the provisions of the Bill. A suggestion to the contrary is not grounded in fact or in the medical advice offered to me by the Chief Medical Officer and is a serious deviation from the grounds we extensively debated during the referendum campaign.
Comment on this
I wish to put on record Sinn Féin's position with regard to terminations on the grounds of disability. Sinn Féin is opposed to terminations on the grounds of disability. As a party we debated the matter at our Ard-Fheis. More than that, as political activists, we campaign day in and day out for the rights of persons with disability. In our advice clinics at council level and at Dáil level every day of the week we deal with cases involving parents who have children with disabilities.
For our party the issue is a settled matter. We abstained in Committee because we wanted to be certain that this legislation does not provide for terminations on the grounds of disability. We abstained to give ourselves time to consider it and engage with the Minister. We have engaged with the Minister and on the basis of the assurances we have been given which accord with our party policy, we will not be supporting this amendment.
We stand up for the rights of persons with disabilities. We stand up for their families. We stand with them in our communities through our activism. We are very clear on that. We gave ourselves the time and we engaged with the Minister. I thank him for his engagement and for his assurance that this legislation does not provide for terminations on the grounds of disability. It does not and therefore we will be opposing the amendment. However, we do so because the legislation is very clear as is our position. We stand with people who have disabilities. We stand with their families and we will continue to do so.
Comment on this
The amendment was introduced by its proposers as having stemmed from meeting somebody who survived an horrendous attempt at abortion. However, the wording of the amendment has nothing to do with that, but rather is, as the Minister said, an attempt to undermine the entire sentiment of the legislation and the referendum we had to repeal the eighth amendment of the Constitution.
I am not a scientist or a medical person. I read this and spoke to a doctor friend of mine. This attempts to rule out abortion in the case of disability and gender where the pregnancy has not exceeded 12 weeks.
Until now at least, in the medical and scientific community, one could not determine the gender or the presence of disability until approximately 11 weeks. An expensive, hard to attain test called a cell-free fetal DNA test is then required. The chromosomal make-up in the foetal material is examined and if it has two X chromosomes, the foetus will be a female, or if has an XY chromosome, it will be male. If anyone tried to have that test done at 11 weeks, there is no guarantee that they will get the result, and the result would not be available within a week, which would put them outside the 12-week limit this legislation has provided for.
The reason most parents or pregnant people want to have that test is linked to genetic disorders rather than trying to eradicate all the Down's syndrome people on the planet. That is why it is called a cell-free fetal DNA test. It is carried out to identify certain diseases that are linked to the X chromosome, two of which are carried by the female gender. Rather than this being about how China or Pakistan trying to eliminate females from their society, as it was put in what I consider racist terms, the test on the female, if it is carried out, is very much linked to whether there is a genetic disposition to conditions such as muscular dystrophy, haemophilia or Hunter's syndrome. That is where a family is worried if they have a genetic disposition and want to see if it will be the case in their pregnancy. It is a rare test to have carried out. It is expensive and difficult to attain. The amendment is a ruse to try to deny women and pregnant people access to what is rightfully theirs following the May referendum.
The amendment also states: "... because of ... race". There is only one race, and that is the human race. Race is not determined by anything other than the fact that we are all human beings. After that, ethnicity is determined by the combinations of different genetic make-ups. It is shameful for anybody to try make out that race is a factor in this Bill because there is only one race. A parent might take that decision because conditions and disabilities could be detected. Is it not sad that they have to do that because they carry within the family the danger of genetic heredity factors that could limit the lives of their children?
This is a ruse. It is about trying to deny the reality that the people have voted to give women and pregnant people access to abortion without restriction up to 12 weeks. I am sorry, but it will not work. We have to vote against this amendment.
Comment on this
I do not intend to speak on some of these amendments for very long but I felt I had to come into the House to object to the racist stereotyping in the amendment and in the contributions of some speakers. The phrase was used last night-----
Comment on this
We are two minutes in, a Cheann Comhairle and the Deputies opposite are calling names again. It is incredible that we cannot have a debate without calling names.
Comment on this
The Deputy put-----
Comment on this
The effort to call names is to try to close down-----
Comment on this
If the Deputy tables an amendment that includes the word "race", he will be challenged about it.
Comment on this
The phrase "cultural people" was used last night; it did not even make sense. The Deputy was trying to say was there are people who come from cultures where abortion for sex selection is done. I utterly object to that for a number of reasons. First, I represent a constituency where one in four people was born outside Ireland, which includes people from India and Pakistan. Second, it is just not true, and I did some research following last night's comments. If we voted "Yes" to this amendment, ethnic profiling of pregnant women would be introduced. If a woman from one of these cultures enters a GP's surgery, she will be asked if she is going to have an abortion because her child might be brown or black. Can we imagine that interference in the consultation with the woman? I have researched this and this is what happens.
The other issue is sex selection. I read studies of an imbalance in the ratio between men and women in societies. The fact that sons are favoured in cultures is wrong and shameful, but it stems from the inferior position of girls and women in our world, whom the proposers of these amendments never show any interest in once the child is born. Some of that imbalance can occur after girls are born. When families are poor, girls can get less food, education and so on. There can also be infanticide if the proposers would prefer that prospect. Sex selection for abortion is horrendous, but the Deputies need to cop on. We have a system where women are utterly inferior, taking the planet as a whole. The proposers again care nothing about that.
Mention was made of Pakistan. I looked up a study that was only done in 2016 in which the author stated: "We do not find consistent and convincing evidence that sex ratios at birth (which indicate sex-selective abortion) are increasing." That is important because people who are now Irish citizens could find themselves being affected by this amendment being accepted. There is enough racism in society without people trotting this out in the national Parliament. It is difficult enough for people to integrate into society without the stereotype being thrown out that they do not like girls. The Deputies should cop themselves on. That should be kept out of the debate and we should move on and deal with the main issues.
Comment on this
When we consider whether this Bill should explicitly ban abortions on any discriminatory grounds - disability, race or gender - it is instructive to recall some of the statements the Minister made on this topic. During the referendum campaign, when he sought to reassure the public that this Bill would not allow shockingly high levels of abortions on the ground of disability that occur annually in other countries, and knowing that most Irish people wanted to provide protection against discrimination of the most vulnerable among us, he repeatedly assured voters that it would not allow abortion on the ground of disability or on the basis of the undesired sex or race of the unborn baby.
Comment on this
On 1 February, the Irish Independent reported the Minister as saying that if the electorate votes to repeal the eighth amendment in the referendum, the proposed legislation widening the grounds for abortion would not include grounds for disabilities such as Down's syndrome.
Comment on this
On 14 May, the Irish Independent reported the Minister reiterating this promise when he stated: "We've specifically excluded disability for grounds for abortion in the legislation." On Newstalk, on 22 May, just days before people were asked to vote, he said the people are grappling with this question and they want to be sure they make the right decision. He said that he can tell the people clearly that he has specifically excluded disability as a ground for termination.
Comment on this
What are we to understand from that? When the Minister made those claims, were we to understand that it would be illegal under the new legislation to abort the baby on the ground of disability? Many voters certainly did, and many reluctant "Yes" voters have said that reassurance was a big factor in the way they voted.
It must be made very clear at this point that at no stage and in none of the draft or public versions of the Bill was abortion on the ground of disability ever mentioned. The Minister took a gamble that voters would take his assurance at face value and not search the text of the legislation themselves.
Comment on this
Had they searched the legislation, they would have quickly discovered that the Bill makes no mention of disability. Unfortunately, the majority of the media also chose not to challenge the Minister on the spin that was put out. He would like all of us to believe that if it is not specifically legal to abort on the ground of disability, it will somehow not happen in Ireland. That view is very naive.
In Germany, it is not specifically legal to abort a baby on the grounds of disability, yet some 90% of babies with prenatal diagnosis of Down's syndrome are aborted there. How does that happen? These abortions are usually certified on the grounds of risk to the mental health of the mother. Section 12 allows abortion until viability and until the birth on the grounds of risk of serious harm to the mental health of the mother, in line with Dr. Peter Boylan's assertion that if a woman says the matter is serious, it is serious. It is hard to see how the German loophole will not also find its way to Ireland. Deputy Coppinger tried to make the same point in the Chamber last night that a woman should get to decide how serious a serious risk to her health is. What situation will the Bill lead to in Ireland? Will disability be a specifically allowed ground for abortion? No permission to abort is given based specifically on a disability. It is not, however, "specifically excluded", to use the Minister's words. The Bill is silent on the highly controversial matter of abortion on the grounds of disability, despite all the Minister's fine words before the referendum. His promises are not worth the paper on which they were written.
The Minister deliberately misled the public about what the Bill would permit or prohibit. He remains defiant and determined to be the only lawmaker who can make any changes to the Bill. My fellow Deputies and I were all elected to shape the legislation of this country, and we have the opportunity to ensure Ireland does not follow countries like the UK, Germany, Denmark and Iceland into the eugenic black hole into which they have fallen, where the lives of more than 90% of all babies diagnosed with Down's syndrome in the womb are intentionally ended. We must not allow our unborn babies with disabilities to be discriminated against so callously.
We have made so much progress in recent years in how we treat every member of society with respect and dignity. Who could forget the Special Olympics in Ireland, when we showed the world we valued every person regardless of his or her level of ability or disability or level of additional needs? Many tourists and visitors to Ireland remark how many children and people with Down's syndrome there are. They often make the mistake of thinking it is a condition that is more prevalent here than in other countries, but the truth dawns on them when they realise it is simply because we allow these children to be born and we allow them to live. Children and adults living with Down's syndrome are nothing to be afraid of and, in many cases, bring much joy to their families and communities. That is what makes us different. A diagnosis of disability in Ireland is not an almost automatic death sentence.
Today, we will decide whether we will allow a prenatal diagnosis of a disability to put a target on a child's back or mark the child out for special protection. To think that because it is not specifically legal means it will not happen is to bury one's head in the sand. If Deputies want to ensure the people's desire to protect unborn babies with disabilities from discrimination, and if they want to protect baby girls from abortion simply because they are female, they need to support the amendment. It is not about being pro-life, pro-choice or pro-abortion; rather, it is about human rights.
Comment on this
I must take exception to what Deputy Coppinger said about the proposers of the amendment when she ascribed motives to them that were unworthy. Mentioning them by name was totally unacceptable. Most of us who do not agree with the Deputy's view of the world have always respected that view, and have always said if someone has a different view and believes it sincerely we will respect him or her for it. Unfortunately, with the treatment meted out to some Deputies and, in particular, the reference to Deputy Nolan for her views in this debate, that respect has not been reciprocated.
Comment on this
I never mentioned Deputy Nolan's name.
Comment on this
I did not say the Deputy did. I was speaking generally. Unlike the Deputy, I did not name people.
Comment on this
The names are on the amendment.
Comment on this
The Deputy did the naming. She cast aspersions as to the motives behind the amendment.
Comment on this
It is a political debate.
Comment on this
The Deputy should get over it.
Comment on this
Deputy Coppinger does not understand manners.
Comment on this
I will proceed when I have the floor.
Funnily enough, based on what Deputy Donnelly said last night and on what I understand, although I would like confirmation from the Minister, the Minister agrees with the basic thesis of the amendment. As far as I understand from what he and Deputy Donnelly said, it will be illegal to have an abortion beyond 12 weeks on the basis of race, sex or disability. The Minister agrees with the principle, therefore, that it would be an unacceptable basis for having an abortion. I welcome that because at least babies or foetuses of more than 12 weeks will have that protection in law, and because that fundamental right has been conceded. I am told, however, the vast majority of abortions or terminations are likely to take place before the 12 weeks has elapsed. The protection that the Minister so carefully inserted in the Bill, which I have not heard anyone saying should be removed, is moot. The protection is not there and it cannot be there because, as the Minister said, no reason need be given and, as a result, no inquiry into the reason a person may have can be made. I do not expect that to be changed in the Bill but nor do I expect anything in it to be changed.
I wish to highlight, however, that a protection that is there after the period of 12 weeks will not be there before the 12 weeks has passed, and that the opposite impression was given strongly by those proposing the legislation during the referendum campaign. I am delighted the amendment was tabled to highlight the inconsistency of the approach to this matter, an inconsistency that was obvious from the beginning to those who read the small print of the Bill but would not be obvious to those who did not. As I understand it, the Minister, on the one hand, agrees that abortions of unborn children of more than 12 weeks should be utterly forbidden in law with severe penalties, and that the grounds to which everyone on my right takes exception are in the law, should remain in the law and will be in the new law when the composite law on this subject is taken into account. On the other hand, however, he is saying there should be no such protection for that group of people who have not reached 12 weeks
We make law not for today but for the future, if only for a five or ten-year span. As technology advances, it will become much cheaper and much more accessible to test for disability. The argument, therefore, that people will not test for Down's syndrome, to use an example that was mentioned, or that they will not avail of testing or that they will not be allowed to do so, is fallacious.
Comment on this
I listened to the debate last night and this afternoon. The issue of abortion and disability is difficult and complex. In Britain, abortion is generally available up to 24 weeks of pregnancy but it is also legal for any detectable disability for all nine months of pregnancy. There has been discussion about Down's syndrome. Some parents do not like that debate and do not like talking about these various conditions but they are a part of the debate and need to be addressed.
We need to investigate further when such conditions can be diagnosed during pregnancy. In Britain abortion is generally allowed up to 24 weeks, and these conditions can be diagnosed up to that time. Pre-natal diagnosis is improving all the time. 3D ultrasound scans and cell-free DNA testing are now more readily available. Diagnostic tests can now detect Down's syndrome at nine to 13 weeks, or the first trimester. Even if these tests are only available privately the technology is improving all the time. In Ireland we are proposing to allow for termination of pregnancy with no restriction as to the reason during the first 12 weeks of pregnancy. Anomaly scans usually take place at 20 weeks but we need to consider this issue much more carefully.
The Minister can say over and over that this Bill does not allow for abortion on the grounds of disability but that does not make it true.
Comment on this
The Bill is as it is, it is the words we have before us. I am just not convinced by the assurances that the Minster and others have given in this regard.
Comment on this
I believe all life is precious. I have spoken before about embracing disability. I, and many others in this House, have witnessed first-hand the great warmth, ability and talent of children with disabilities, and I have followed the career paths of many. It is not being gospel greedy, but I believe that where there is life there is hope and that people can achieve what they want, whether they have a disability or not.
I believe it is dealt with in the legislation and that, as the Minister said, the only way that an abortion can be sought beyond 12 weeks is in the case of fatal foetal abnormalities. However, I share the concerns of the two previous Deputies in that I want the Minister’s categorical assurance that in the case of technology which is continuously improving, that in the event of scans for disability being possible before the 12 week period, that it would not be allowed as grounds for an abortion. Therefore, I cannot reconcile the 12 week period. My conscientious view on abortion is widely known in my constituency and beyond.
The public, unfortunately, voted to repeal the eighth amendment and mandated this House to legislate through the Health Regulation (Termination of Pregnancy) Bill to allow for abortion in certain circumstances. I am not happy that we are not making this fool-proof in relation to advances in technology that may happen, therefore I want the Minister’s reassurance that terminations will not be available on the grounds of disability, where it is identifiable prior to 12 weeks.
While my conscientious view is in conflict with the majority of those who voted, it remains the same. However, we all, I hope, in this House are democrats and accept the wish of the majority. I like many others do not intend to stand in the way of any of this legislation but I reserve my right, in the final occasion, to decide what stance I will take.
Comment on this
I am very conscious of time. People who are supporting the movement of this legislation are delaying its progress through the House because of the amount of time they took up last night. These are the very people who were dictating to us that we were delaying it. We certainly are not but they are.
On the amendment, I have grave concerns, which the Minister will be well aware of from Committee Stage. Concern is growing among the public. They are starting to become aware of what they actually voted for in repealing the eighth amendment is completely different to what the Minister is now proceeding with. It is completely different. The Members who are seeking all these changes and to make the Bill one of the most liberal abortion laws in the world are doing a grave disservice to the people who voted to repeal the eighth amendment. Those people voted for the repeal of the eighth amendment, not what is contained in many of the amendments before us now.
Comment on this
I did not speak on this amendment.
Comment on this
No, I did not speak on this amendment before.
Comment on this
Sorry. I want to reiterate the concern of many that disability would be a reason for an abortion. Down's syndrome can be diagnosed at nine weeks. We know that these children bring many people much joy, especially their parents, siblings and extended families. Many families love and cherish these children who in some people's eyes might not be 100% perfect although they are 100% perfect because they are who they are, which is themselves.
We are all proud of the many local children who have performed in the Special Olympics in recent years. We must ensure that something like this cannot be given as a reason for an abortion. In the days before the referendum, the Minister promised that he would guarantee it would not be a reason but it is not in the Bill. We are entitled to raise concern about that on behalf of many people out there. I very much resent some Deputy here from Dublin, I will not acknowledge her by naming her, telling us to cop on. We do not have to be told to cop on by anyone. We have common sense; if it is not in the Bill, we cannot be blamed for looking to ensure that it is put in the Bill, which is what we are asking for.
Comment on this
I apologise. There is some confusion as to who spoke last night. Both the record in front of me and the Clerk's record indicate that Deputy Danny Healy-Rae did speak last night and I must go by what I have before me.
Comment on this
During the referendum campaign, the Minister and the Minister for Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht, Deputy Madigan, both appeared to agree with a prohibition on abortion on grounds of disability. The Minister for Health said that disability, including Down's syndrome, would be excluded as a grounds for abortion in any legislation. However, there is absolutely nothing in the Government's Bill to rule out abortion on these grounds. He told the Irish Independent on 24 May, the day before the referendum, that the Government would specifically exclude disability as grounds for abortion in the legislation. He also told the Irish Independent on 1 February that if the electorate voted to repeal the eighth amendment in a referendum that the proposed legislation would not include grounds for disability such as Down's syndrome but would be confined to cases of fatal foetal abnormality where the unborn baby would not live. During the campaign, the Minister, Deputy Madigan, shared a graphic produced by Fine Gael Head Office on Twitter which explained the Government's abortion proposal. This said that termination on grounds of disability was prohibited. I ask the Minister to say whether both statements were totally false as there was no provision in the Bill to prohibit abortion on the grounds of disability. Why did the Minister not include a clear provision to put that into effect in legislation?
As I said yesterday, the Minister is wrong. He made a statement today that the chief medical officer has given him advice that he can amend it. Did he ask the chief medical officer before he put these statements in the newspaper telling the people of Ireland that disability would not be allowed as a ground? What is he telling me now? One week he talks to the chief medical officer and the other week he just goes away and does his own thing. Did he or did he not ask the chief medical officer's advice before he made these statements instead of leading the Irish people wrong? He is the Minister for Health. He is responsible for these people in Ireland. He has given false statements. He is totally and utterly wrong. He is trying to blame the chief medical officer for what is happening.
Comment on this
In my family circle I know two young people with disabilities who are very close to me. I ask everybody in this House and outside it to please understand the views of those of us who have some reservations in this regard. Let me make it clear that I fully accept the result of the referendum. I would never stand for damaging any woman's health in regard to this issue. However, the facts are that there has been an issue with this in England, particularly in regard to Down's syndrome, and we do not want that to happen here.
I believe the Minister was sincere when he gave those commitments prior to the referendum. Like many of my colleagues, all I am looking for is assurances. I do not want to go down this road. We cannot, on the one hand, rush out to the gates of Leinster House every time the disabled are out there, and have our photograph taken with them, and then, on the other, not support the parents, brothers, sisters and many others who have come to people like me seeking that we would stand up here and make this case for them.
That is my contribution. I appeal to everybody in the House to think of the families who have people, particularly young people, with disabilities. They bring such joy into homes. They may on many occasions have very short lives but they bring a lot of joy into people's lives.
Comment on this
There is a danger that the debate is drifting off in a direction which was never intended. On the Second Reading of a Bill, one can suggest what should be in the Bill, one can complain about what is not in the Bill and one can announce what one intends to do on Committee Stage. However, we are gone past that. We are now in a situation I have never seen before, where it has been suggested in an acrimonious way that the Minister did not keep his word. That is not true. The committee sat for three months. One of the first things we did was to eliminate the disability area as a reason for accessing abortion. There was no dissent and everybody agreed to it. The reasons for this have already been put forward by my colleague across the House. It would not be right. I gave an interview to a well known journal at least 20 years ago and I held the same view, and I believe the reasons for that are still good.
The suggestion that, because it is not specifically in the Bill, it is by default going to be in the Bill is not true. People should not be saying things like that. It is totally untrue. The Bill is in line with what was committed to the public in the heads of the Bill published before the referendum, and that still stands. In fact, if we did not follow that line, we could be accused of not remaining true to our word.
The other thing we took out of the proposal at that time was the ability to seek an abortion on social or economic grounds. We took that out without any question because we felt they were not grounds that should be considered and that they were way too frivolous.
I come from a family that had many losses when my siblings were very young. I would have first-hand knowledge of the little boxes some of the witnesses told us about when we heard the evidence this time last year. Far from it being, as was portrayed, that women are callous and cold-blooded and would seek an abortion as if it were for their own satisfaction, in fact, the reverse was the case. That was so in every single case, including the ones of fatal foetal abnormality, where the pregnant woman went out of her way to have her baby, but it was not to be and there was a disappointment because it was not going to happen. From announcing it to their friends in the first instance, it was suddenly an appalling disappointment. They still wanted that baby to be born. They even wanted to have a decent funeral for the baby because it was theirs. What really takes me to the fair at this stage, when I hear the begrudgery that we spent three months listening to, as well as listening to the reports from the people who were directly involved at the coalface, to be suggesting they were cold and callous-----
Comment on this
Nobody said that. He is twisting it.
Comment on this
It is implicit in what is being said. Everybody here had a mother. Everybody here has siblings - sisters and brothers. There is no use trying to get away from this. We either face up to the reality or we do not.
Comment on this
There were particular circumstances where a young woman found herself in a desperate situation, with nowhere to go, with no help from any quarter. The only place to go was across the water, to leave the country or disappear into what were once the Magdalen laundries or the mother and baby homes. It is time we grew up a little. It is time we learned that women had lives as well, that they are entitled to due and fair consideration and that they do not find themselves, at this time, in the 21st century, isolated, alone and forlorn.
We were there for three months. We listened in great detail. We were there all of the time and we missed none of the debate. We did not read about it afterwards; we got it first-hand. I compliment my colleagues, some of whom I did not always agree with, but we did what we had to do and what we were obliged to do, which was to take our responsibilities seriously and to recognise there was something that needed to be dealt with. The people responded and they made it quite clear.
Last night it was suggested that minorities have rights. Yes, they do, and so do majorities. The one has to be balanced against the other, and that is democracy; that is the way it has always been. However, we should not exclude a group of people representative of 52% of the population, whether we like it or not - that is, women - and say, "In the future, as in the past, you are not really a first class citizen. You are not equal because you do not control your own future."
I will leave Members with this. Let us assume one puts oneself in the shoes of a woman in those circumstances. I am sorry I am hoarse, a Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
Let us assume this woman found herself, as women have done before, in a hospital situation when a crisis arises, and everybody stands around saying, "What have we the right to do? Where do we go?". They ask whether this woman has any rights or whether they have been set aside for some future discussion in court or at an inquest, or whatever the case may be. I plead with the Members who are regurgitating what went on before the referendum and in the course of the referendum. This is a serious issue. We were given responsibility. We should stand up and carry that responsibility, recognise we have a job to do and do it.
Comment on this
We are a couple of minutes into the debate and the name-calling, etc. has started. Just two nights ago, a Deputy was reduced to tears as a result of the level of aggression in the Chamber. Character assassination, sneering and name-calling do not constitute political debate, they represent an effort to close down discussion and censor people.
Comment on this
That was not what was happening.
Comment on this
That type of behaviour should stop. One of the reasons I oppose abortion is because of its effect on minorities. Someone from a low-income family who is female and has a disability is far more likely to be aborted. Abortion is an inequality. People who do not believe that information should look at the Guttmacher Institute's website, which is a pro-choice site. It shows that minorities suffer most from abortion. I think it was Deputy Lisa Chambers who stated last night that gender selection abortion does not happen in this country or at all, which is patently untrue. Deputy Donnelly stated that he is against abortion in the case of disability and that the Bill does not allow for this. The Minister also stated that a few times. A ten year old child studying a Venn diagram in school will know that if abortion is made available for every reason, it will be available for cases involving disability. I cannot understand why the Minister and the people speaking on his side of the debate cannot understand the simple premise that if abortion is available without indication and on request and if it cannot be refused up to 12 weeks, then, by definition, it is available in respect of cases of disability. It is that simple.
Comment on this
What about Jean McConville's children? The Deputy did not care much about them.
Comment on this
It is very clear that abortion rates have soared in respect of cases involving disability in every country that has gone down this road. Unless other Deputies think Irish people are morally superior-----
Comment on this
-----to their counterparts in Britain, Denmark, Iceland, Norway, France and Germany, the same will happen here. The only reason they could vote against an amendment such as this is because they prioritise access to abortion in all circumstances.
Comment on this
Deputy Tóibín is a complete hypocrite. He stood over the record of the provos for years in this House.
Comment on this
Why was I asked to join Fianna Fáil if the Deputy has a problem with my political past?
Comment on this
I never asked the Deputy to come anywhere near Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I really do not think we are advancing any cause by Deputies getting involved with each other in this way.
Comment on this
He has asked everybody.
Comment on this
We have heard both sides and I am appealing for a reasoned debate. There is no need for the sideshows. This is too serious an issue as Deputy Tóibín and others have stated. We know what has happened around the world. We know the experience in Finland, where they parade the fact that they will be Down's syndrome free by 2020. That is a shocking indictment. Deputy Durkan and others seem to think that we should trust the Minister in everything he says but he has changed his stance more times than it has rained in this country in recent years. That is a fact. How are we to live horse and get grass? Unless something is written into the legislation, we cannot be expected to believe it. That is true of any legislation, whether it be the Social Welfare, Pensions and Civil Regulation Bill 2018, which we discussed earlier, the Finance Bill 2018 or whatever.
We often argue about the words "shall" and "may". Unless what we are seeking is specifically mentioned in legislation, how can we be expected to believe and trust this Minister who was elected on the basis of his pro-life stance. He wrote letters to his constituents in Wicklow, promised that he was pro-life and asked for their number one votes. I have a copy of one of those letters and can read it out if necessary. In fact, I will read it out later.
How can we be expected to believe anything the Minister or the Government say in respect of this matter, particularly as many of those who are in government were elected on the basis of the same stance? However, they have been on these so-called "journeys" in the interim. They all made these famous journeys. One of them was a journey across the River Lee in Cork and, as a result of it, we got the three days - the 72 hours. The Minister used the word "disgusting" and other adjectives when referring to the Tánaiste. That is all fine if that is the way those opposite want to deal with it. Some of us have credibility, accountability and consciences and we want to keep it that way. We are not twisting and turning to suit the times or our political masters. I thank the Ceann Comhairle for allowing us to speak in a dignified manner on this issue and not be silenced.
Comment on this
This amendment is about the period of up to 12 weeks. The debate in this regard began with references to race, sex and disability and ended up focused on disability because it is possible to tug at the heart strings of the population by consistently referring to people with Down's syndrome despite the fact that the Down Syndrome Ireland has asked people advocating what is proposed not to do so. The reason the period is up to 12 weeks without restriction relates to the existence and widespread use of the abortion pill and to the evidence given to the Joint Committee on the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution and the Citizen's Assembly on the use of that pill. The danger of letting women and girls take abortion pills in isolation without medical supervision is unconscionable. We have a duty to ensure that when these pills are administered people have support, cover and medical supervision. Deputies can table whatever amendments they like. Even if those amendments are passed, that would not stop people accessing abortion pills on the Internet and putting their health and lives at risk. It is nonsensical in the extreme for Deputies to use this to try to pull at the heartstrings of the population when they have been asked by the relevant representative organisations not to do so. The case for using this amendment in the context of race and sex has been shown to be nonsensical and the only thing those advocating it have to go on is disability. Their choice in that regard is immoral in the extreme.
Comment on this
People talk about their credibility being questioned. As one of the proponents of the 12-week limit and as someone who was a member of the Joint Committee on the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution, I think it is important to say why was proposed. There were several specific reasons for putting the 12-week limit in place. The backdrop is that the Citizens' Assembly proposed 22 weeks in most contexts. The committee considered the evidence that was presented to it and we made our individual judgments on the basis of that evidence. Having listened to much of the debate, particularly the medical evidence, most but not all members of the committee proposed that 12 weeks, the first trimester, would be a time limit in the gestational periods when terminations could take place without restriction. In other words, if a woman or a girl requested a termination up to 12 weeks, it would be granted under medical supervision. One aspect of the debate focused on the issue of rape and how defining a rape would require a conviction and so on. We believe that we should trust a woman, which I expect all of us in this Chamber do. That was one reason. The other was that women find themselves in very difficult situations for many reasons, and we will not judge those reasons but they are many and varied, individual and personal. We decided a termination should be granted, if a woman requested it, up to 12 weeks.
The committee considered disability as well and went to great lengths to assess this as a grounds for termination, bearing in mind the Citizens' Assembly had recommended that a termination could be sought in respect of a disability. What we said - this view was endorsed, regardless of whether people in this House or elsewhere accept it - was that it was central to the debate during the referendum campaign. Those who opposed the referendum were very clear in bringing it to the fore in the debate. Let us be honest about that.
Comment on this
People did know but disability is not covered in the Bill because it is not possible to have termination after 12 weeks for any reasons other than serious risk to the health or life of the woman, and fatal foetal abnormality. They are the grounds. Why would we introduce into the legislation proposals that would identify circumstances in which terminations should not be granted when the only circumstances in which they can be granted after 12 weeks involve a threat to the health and life of the woman and fatal foetal abnormality?
We have to be honest with ourselves here. Tests have been identified with the potential to identify disability in advance of the 12th week. That is a fact. However, we have said that a woman can have a termination without reason, or rather for her own reasons, up to 12 weeks. It is disingenuous, therefore, to suggest that the issue of disability was not, first and foremost, central to the debate; it was. I recall distinctly many people bringing it to the fore, rightly from their perspective. It was a robust debate and the matter has been decided emphatically with the Irish people saying that up to 12 weeks, unrestricted termination should be available under medical supervision. To introduce race and disability is against the wishes of the Irish people as expressed in the referendum in May. We can talk about this and look at why it was proposed. Those proposals were included in the heads of the Bill and adjudicated on by the Irish people. This was central. It was not put in covertly. It was the kernel of the debate that termination would be available without restriction up to 12 weeks.
Comment on this
There is a genuine concern among some Members present that terminations may be carried out on grounds of disability. I have that genuine concern. No Bill is ever perfect in its infancy. We all know that. There is no doubt that unintended consequences arise. I am looking today to the Minister for a clear commitment that any unborn foetus or baby will not be targeted for abortion because it has a disability when the law changes. While the committee spent a great deal of time discussing this particular angle, it was all blown out of the water during the campaign when the Master of the Rotunda stated that a test existed which could determine at nine weeks whether some disability was there. I was happy to go along with the notion that one could not determine a disability up to 12 weeks, but it was blown out of the water when we were told about that test. It is a private test for which one must pay approximately €1,000. However, it is there if one can afford to have it and it can determine prior to 12 weeks whether a disability is present. These are genuine concerns and we would appreciate the Minister addressing them and providing a clear commitment. That is what I am looking for today.
Comment on this
Many Deputies present are looking for assurances. That is obvious from listening to what they are saying. They want assurances that babies with disability will not be aborted. We have not been given those assurances other than verbally whereas we need it in writing in the Bill. Otherwise, we will end up like Germany, Denmark, Iceland and the UK. Every Deputy must think deeply about this. If something is not in writing, a question arises as to why it is not. The Minister is the person who told the electorate that he was opposed to abortion and we can see where those words have gone. He has done a 350o turn on this completely and changed his mind.
Comment on this
This is about following through on what most Irish people understood. The Minister promised that disability as a ground for termination would be excluded specifically. The Minister should note that this is no laughing matter.
Comment on this
A lot of things are laughing matters in here but this is certainly not one. The Minister can hang his head in shame in time, perhaps. Currently, the Bill is silent on disability and other discriminatory grounds. I ask Members to add the protections the Minister promised and failed to deliver. Will they support the amendment or open the door to eugenics? The choice is theirs but I urge that they accept this humane and compassionate amendment, which embodies equality and is in line with what the people expected when they voted in May. It is also in line with human rights law and common decency. If passed, it will be in line with our responsibility to protect the most vulnerable from discrimination. I implore the House to vote in support of the amendment.
Comment on this
Why we are rerunning the referendum tonight? Not only are these are the Final Stages of the Bill, we had a debate for months with the population in every constituency. We knocked on doors and spoke to people. I have often been in a minority and I often will be in the Dáil. People may not like the result, but it is disingenuous to come to the House and bring all of these subjects up again. Whether people intend it or not, the effect is simply to delay the Bill.
Comment on this
There are people watching. I ask Members to consider that ten people are leaving the country today or tonight. Studies show that a further five people will take abortion pills which they have sourced online. If we do not get through the debate tonight, so be it. I will be here next Tuesday. There is a reality, however, that people expected the legislation to be in place by January while some Members continue to regurgitate arguments that were rejected by two thirds of the population, including in Tipperary, Kerry and the other constituencies they represent. It is not going to go down well among the people who vote for them to bring those topics up again and again. People are paying €1,000 and €1,500 to travel and all the Members are doing is delaying the process.
As to the request for assurances, people knew what they were voting on in respect of the 12-week provision. Hopefully, someone will be able to go to the doctor and have an abortion without having to give a reason. We cannot anticipate matters and provide Deputies with the assurances they seek. It could be for any reason. After 12 weeks, unfortunately, given that it should be the person's right, the person will have to go abroad. That is the reality. Can we move on, therefore, and let the Bill progress?
Comment on this
Deputy Kelleher summed it up perfectly. This section was front and centre of the entire debate. The 12-week period was front and centre and whether one liked it or not, that is what one was voting on. These issues were unbelievably well rehearsed during the referendum and arguments were made for and against. The comfort I take is from Deputy Kelleher who I understand formulated the proposal at the committee with Deputy Chambers. Deputy Kelleher is on record as saying he is not in favour of abortion for reasons of disability. He set out the reasons for the 12-week period in the referendum, as did others while some people set out the reasons against it. However, the public voted for this section. If there is anything in the Bill that they voted for, it was this given the extent to which it was rehearsed. The 12-week limit was the signature issue in the referendum. People need to remember that. There has been an effort here to rerun the referendum and to sow confusion in the minds of ordinary, decent pro-life voters that somehow Deputy Tóibín and other colleagues are their heroes. They are not their heroes and they know that. Deputy Tóibín is an utter hypocrite.
Comment on this
He has stood over attacking the media about Máiría Cahill and he has stood over the issue in relation to Jean McConville.
Comment on this
He has then come in here, obsessed with this issue, and added nothing to the debate.
Comment on this
Deputy Byrne is worried that many Fianna Fáilers are not happy with the way the party is going at the moment. That is why he is attacking me.
Comment on this
Many Fianna Fáilers are far more concerned with Deputy Tóibín's track record in the Sinn Féin organisation.
Comment on this
Deputy Micheál Martin has gone a far distance away from Fianna Fáil's base.
Comment on this
This has nothing to do with the Bill. We need to move on.
Comment on this
The issue is not about Sinn Féin or other parties.
Comment on this
This issue has been rehearsed by the people. I was on the other side of the debate but I said that I would accept the views of the people and if any of the Deputies putting these amendments forward look at the exit polls, they will see that a tiny proportion of the people said they would not accept the results of the referendum. The Deputy should bear that in mind more as far as the vast majority of people are concerned. This issue is now settled and the people have decided. If we are to change that decision, we are taking it out of the people's hands. I am not in favour of abortion for reasons of disability-----
Comment on this
-----and I am confident that it is not provided for in the Bill. For those who are trying to sow confusion on this issue, it is downright disgraceful. It is certainly not an issue I brought up during the referendum because I did not feel there was anything to go on.
Comment on this
I hate to have to do so but I want to disassociate myself from the very personal comment made by my Fianna Fáil colleague, Deputy Thomas Byrne, because the one thing we need in this debate is respect and we should all be big enough, on any side of the House, to listen and to respect people's views.
On the other hand, the exposition by Deputy Kelleher was excellent. He was honest. Under 12 weeks there can be no protection or guarantee against any reason for having an abortion. We just will not know. That is very open and honest.
Many Deputies on this side of the House have an issue with the fact that when we look at the words of the Minister during the debate, he seemed to give a different impression. It is as simple as that.
I was not a Member of this House at the time, because I did not get elected to the Oireachtas until 1989, but I remember 1983. I remember that immediately afterwards, those who were on the losing side continued their campaign. When the law and the Constitution were different from what she wanted, Deputy Coppinger continued to campaign and promote her ideas and none of us ever said the people had spoken but she could do so. The day after, the campaign continued against-----
Comment on this
Yes, that is fine.
Comment on this
-----the eighth amendment, and quite legitimately. Those of us who are in the minority now can represent that minority of 33% and continue to try to persuade people that human life should be preserved. It is our right and we should be respected, just as in 1983, 1989 or any other time, I never said that people did not have the right not to fight on to upturn it because the people had spoken. In fact, I said the exact opposite.
Comment on this
We never said that. I am talking about the final-----
Comment on this
On that matter, the Deputies who did most of the talking last night are those who profess to be in a hurry to get this Bill through.
Comment on this
Deputy Danny Healy-Rae has the option to speak again for a third time as he moved the amendment. He has indicated that he wants to do so. Does the Minister want to respond first or does he want to wait until Deputy Danny Healy-Rae speaks?
Comment on this
It is my second time to speak. The Minister's attitude leaves a lot to be desired because we are speaking, by and large, about a matter of life and death and he is laughing at us. I regret that and the Minister shaking his head will not change my view on that because every time a Deputy on this side spoke, he was laughing and grinning at them, and that is the truth.
Comment on this
That is not true. It is a complete misrepresentation.
Comment on this
We are talking about a matter of life and death-----
Comment on this
-----and a previous speaker said we should trust the Minister because he said this or that at the committee. All we want is for it to be written into the Bill. I respect Deputy Durkan because he has been in this Chamber a lot longer than I have, but when he asks me to trust the Minister without it being written into the Bill, it puts me in mind of selling sand in the Sahara desert because I do not trust it if it is not in the Bill.
The Government has clearly not spoken to the doctors about this as they are complaining about it. We were not on the committee that met for a number of months because we were not selected for it. We did not have a vote at the Oireachtas committee we attended, so we are entitled to raise issues here and to put them to a vote. That is what we will do because I respect every life - the life of the mother and that of the child. It is absolutely terrible if a baby is aborted because it has Down's syndrome or has a disability. It remains to be decided what a disability is and how serious it must be. That is the problem for many of us, so it is not unreasonable of us to ask that this be written into the Bill. That is all that we are doing.
Comment on this
I respect everybody but it is not a matter of trusting me; it is a matter of trusting women and trusting the decision of the people-----
Comment on this
We trust women; it is the Minister that we do not trust.
Comment on this
I do not care whether the Deputy trusts me or not, he should trust women. I hear a lot about human rights and I have some breaking news. Women's rights are human rights and we have been violating them in this country for about 35 years and the people have said "No more", including in County Kerry thankfully, and we will now move ahead and legislate.
Deputy Kelleher is entirely right and he is best placed to speak on this because of the work he did on this in the Oireachtas committee. The 12 weeks proposal was debated the length and breadth of this country and the people voted on it. The issue of disability was considered at length and I gave assurances and not one word has changed from the general scheme that was published in March and the Bill, as published, in relation to disability.
This is a case of saying, "Let them deny it." It is a case of trying to make the Minister vote against putting a clause in the Bill to protect people with a disability, or trying to make Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin, the Labour, Party Fine Gael or whoever do so, but it will not work. The Deputy said I should talk to doctors. I did talk to doctors and I talked to the very top doctor, the Chief Medical Officer in the country, who says that this amendment would effectively render the 12 week provision in the Bill inoperable. Perhaps that is what the Deputy would like to do but it is not what the people voted to do.
The greatest protector of a pregnancy is not Deputy Danny Healy-Rae, it is a pregnant woman. Women protect their pregnancies day in, day out and they will continue to do so long after the eighth amendment has been repealed. This would make the legislation inoperable. Perhaps that is the intention or perhaps it is not but it is the reality. It cannot be accepted and we cannot continue to drag up the same issues that were debated the length and breadth of the country. The people have spoken and I have no intention of accepting this amendment.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
Amendment No. 29 in the name of the Minister arises out of committee proceedings and was discussed with amendment No. 13.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 10, to delete lines 34 to 38 and substitute the following:
"(2) A termination of pregnancy shall not be carried out under this section unless the medical practitioner referred to in subsection (1) has certified his or her opinion as to the matter referred to in that subsection".
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 30 to 34, inclusive, cannot now be moved because amendment No. 29 has been agreed,.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 35 arises out of committee proceedings. Amendments Nos. 35 and 36 are related. Amendment No. 36 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 35. Amendments Nos. 35 and 36 will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 11, to delete lines 1 to 4 and substitute the following:
"(3) The termination of pregnancy shall not be carried out by a medical practitioner unless a period of not less than 3 days has elapsed from—
(a) the date of certification under subsection (2) by that medical practitioner, or
(b) where a certification was previously made in respect of the pregnancy by another medical practitioner for the purposes of subsection (2), the date of that previous certification.
(4) A termination of pregnancy to which the certification referred to in subsection (2) relates shall be carried out as soon as may be after the period referred to in subsection (3)(a) or (b), as the case may be, has elapsed but before the pregnancy has exceeded 12 weeks of pregnancy.".
I previously spoke to amendments Nos. 13 and 29, both of which preceded this grouping, and set out the substance of my amendment, which aims to address the difficulty that arises if the certifying medical practitioner is, without exception, required to carry out the termination of pregnancy, specifically when we considered the rostering issues and practical realities of medical practice in a hospital setting following a three-day period. For this reason, I propose this amendment to section 14, which would allow a second medical practitioner to become involved following a three-day period should the first be unavailable. The amendment keeps the safeguards and legal requirements that section 14 currently contains but aims to clarify the pathway for accessing the service and to avoid creating an additional barrier. The effect of the amendment I have tabled is to provide that where a medical practitioner has formed the reasonable opinion, in good faith, that a woman's pregnancy has not exceeded 12 weeks, and certified that opinion, and the woman has fulfilled the three-day period, a second medical practitioner may carry out the procedure without a further time period needing to elapse where he or she has formed the reasonable opinion, in good faith, that the pregnancy has not exceeded 12 weeks and has certified that opinion. From a substantive point of view, we debated many of these issues last night.
Amendment No. 36 is a different version of that. I propose my amendment, No. 35, for the reasons we discussed last night with regard to amendments Nos. 13 and 29.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 30 to 34, inclusive, relate to the three-day waiting period. Members were under the impression that we would at least be able to vote on them. The Ceann Comhairle moved quite fast and I want to clarify what he is saying. Many Members tabled amendments. He said that they could not be taken because amendment No. 29 had been agreed. We have had the debate and I do not propose that we reopen it but I thought we would put those amendments to a vote.
Comment on this
We are not voting on them because they cannot be moved given that amendment No. 29 has been agreed.
Comment on this
The debate on amendment No. 35 is similar to the debate we had yesterday. If we cannot vote on that, we might vote on this. Many of us made points on this earlier in the debate and on Committee Stage. As is the way with these issues, many people are only now focusing on the details of it and there is a great deal of speculation on social media and in society about it. Many people are pointing out that they rang their general practitioner, GP, and asked when their next appointment time would be. Many women have posted on social media that they rang their GP and the next appointment time is next Monday. They tested this. This three-day waiting period will be problematic. It will be much longer than a three-day wait. I will not rehearse the argument again but I wanted to register that point with the Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 11, between lines 7 and 8, to insert the following:
“Administration of anaesthetic or analgesic to foetus
15. (1) A medical practitioner who carries out a termination of pregnancy shall take all steps as may be appropriate and practicable to avoid causing pain to the foetus.
(2) Where the medical practitioner who is carrying out a termination of pregnancy is of the reasonable opinion formed in good faith that the gestational age of the foetus is 20 weeks or more, he or she shall administer or ensure the administration of an anaesthetic or analgesic to the foetus prior to the carrying out of the termination of pregnancy.
(3) Subsection (2) shall not apply where—
(a) 2 medical practitioners certify that they are of the reasonable opinion formed in good faith that the administration of an anaesthetic or analgesic to the foetus would pose a risk to the life, or of serious harm to the health, of the pregnant woman in respect of whom the termination of pregnancy is being carried out, or
(b) a medical practitioner proposes to carry out a termination of pregnancy in accordance with section 11 and it is not practicable to comply with the obligation in subsection (2) because of the particular circumstances of the case.
(4) Where—
(a) an anaesthetic or analgesic is administered to a foetus in accordance with subsection (2), or
(b) subsection (3) or (4) applies,
the medical practitioner who carries out the termination of pregnancy shall include this information in the notification forwarded or caused to be forwarded to the Minister under section 21(1).”.
This amendment relates to the giving of pain relief to an unborn baby before an abortion is carried out. When I spoke on this on Committee Stage and we discussed it, I was taken aback by people's unwillingness to allow a baby the relief from pain that would definitely be endured during the course of an abortion. I believe in compassion and not wanting to hurt anybody or anything purposely. Who here can say that it is not true that when an abortion is taking place, a baby could feel pain? I would consider it only human to say it would be right and proper to offer and give pain relief to somebody who cannot ask for it.
As legislators and human beings we should be willing to offer it. I cannot see what harm this would do. If anybody can stand up here right now and criticise me and say what I am saying is wrong and that I am not right in what I am saying I beg them to do so. I beg them to tell me where am I wrong in looking for pain relief for an unborn baby. How am I out of order in looking for that?
The one thing that has been said to me by knowledgeable people is that the reason other people do not want to agree to this is because to do so would be to recognise this is a person we are talking about and that it is a baby. They do not want to recognise this fact. Surely after all we have gone through for people to stand up here today to ask the Minister and others to allow for this to go ahead and that pain relief would and could be given to stop an unborn baby feeling pain during an abortion is to make an ordinary request. I plead with the Minister and others to allow the amendment to be passed. If they will not do so and if they will fight against it I would love them to explain why. I would love them to tell me why I am wrong and why it is not a proper human thing to do and to educate me if they are able.
Comment on this
The amendment requires that the doctor performing an abortion takes all appropriate and practical steps to avoid causing pain to the foetus. Where the gestational age of the baby is 20 weeks or more the doctor must ensure the administration of an anaesthetic or analgesic to the foetus prior to carrying out a termination of pregnancy. However, this obligation does not apply in an emergency case, which is quite obvious, where it is not practical or where it is believed the administration of either of these treatments to that baby might pose a risk to life or serious harm to the health of the pregnant woman. This is not in any way our intention with this very reasonable amendment, as Deputy Michael Healy-Rae has said.
Amending the Bill to provide pain relief where an unborn baby may otherwise experience pain is a matter of the most basic humanity. The fact there is a dispute about whether to include such a provision in my opinion is appalling. The amendment merely seeks to ensure that in most cases, not even in all cases, doctors ensure the unborn child is not subjected to pain. The fact this is not already in the Bill and that it is actually necessary to propose an amendment to deal with it is gravely disturbing to me and to many young and old people who have spoken to me.
Some abortion advocates claim the unborn child cannot feel pain until the third trimester but this claim is flatly contradicted by modern evidence. There is increasing scientific evidence from around the world that babies in the womb feel pain before 20 weeks. Anaesthetics and pain relief for babies undergoing surgery in the womb is generally recommended and has been called for in late-term abortions. Some say it should be done from as early as 18 weeks gestation. Surgeons recognise unborn babies as patients and anaesthetics are routinely used for babies undergoing surgery in the womb. Surely the same should apply in the case of surgical abortions. It is a no-brainer, as Deputy Michael Healy-Rae has said. Members should just tell us why they feel it should not or would not be done. Where are we going in humanity? It would be horrific and unnecessary for unborn children to suffer needlessly during an abortion. To prevent this, the amendment, which we have carefully considered, should be accepted without any difficulty. It is clearly the duty of compassionate and humane doctors to act on the precautionary principle of prevention of pain where there is a risk that it may be experienced. I am sure this is the way that all doctors operate under the Hippocratic oath on a daily basis to deal with a wide range of ailments and when patients present with any issue, whether young or old, from the cradle to the grave.
The amendment would not prohibit abortion where the baby can feel pain. It merely requires the administration of pain relief. Who in his or her right mind would not accept the amendment? As I said, we are appalled and aghast it is not included in the Bill in the first instance - appalled and aghast are mild words - and we feel it is totally necessary. We appeal for support from any Member who thinks like us. Many people of all denominations, including people who voted "Yes" in the referendum, have contacted me and others, including other Members, to appeal for this. My goodness, we get emails on an hourly basis on anti-fur farming and anti-hare coursing. Today there was opposition to a Bill on funding the horse and greyhound industries. People are right to feel like this. How can we have these and not want to administer pain relief to an unborn baby? I cannot get that through my thought process. It is unimaginable. Anyone I have asked just shakes his or her head. People have come to me and appealed on this. Other Members have also received the emails. The thought process is just unthinkable. As I have said, doctors routinely do this, as do surgeons on a hourly basis for other procedures. Why would they refuse to do it for an unborn baby before it will be killed?
I appeal to people to listen and respect where we are coming from in the interest of basic humanity. We should try to be as humane as possible. We do not have many amendments in the overall scale of the Bill. We are not delaying it. We have 16 amendments in total, which is the same as on Committee Stage. We listened to the people who voted. Very few people voted for a baby to be destroyed in the womb without administering pain relief. I cannot generalise but I cannot believe people voted for it. This is why we have tabled these amendments. I do not want to be repetitious but for the sake of anybody watching we are not delaying the Bill. We are doing what we have been elected to do with regard to any legislation. We had no pre-legislative scrutiny as the Minister waved it. It is a very valuable tool that was independently reviewed recently. We are trying to table amendments without being scoffed at and scorned and without laughter coming from the other side of the House. This is the most serious issue I will ever deal with in the House. If I am not here after the next election I will be happy to leave it to history to evaluate and see what we have been about here. We are not anti-woman or anti-child. We are pro-humanity.
Comment on this
I am glad to have an opportunity to speak on the amendment. It is a fairly reasonable request to ensure the little baby will not suffer any pain and that any avenues open to the medical profession are used to ensure these children will not suffer pain for the last few seconds of their lives in this world. It is a minimal request. We all have or have had people belonging to us who suffered pain. It is terrible to see people suffering. Many people in many families are suffering pain as we speak here.
We are talking about poor defenceless little babies in their last few seconds. It has been proven beyond a shadow of doubt that they have feelings and that pain affects them. Whether it is anaesthetic or some other avenue available to the medical profession, it is not unreasonable to ask that something be used to ensure that they do not suffer.
Being a Member of the Dáil is an honour. However, if we did not do our best to ensure these infants would not suffer pain by asking for this on their behalf, we would not be worth anything and our lives would not mean anything. I support the amendment. It is not too much to ask. The Minister is providing €12 million for the abortion service. Surely he can dedicate some of that money to ensure that the pain of these little babies, whom the medical profession has said can feel pain, be minimised so they are not hurt. It is not much to ask the Minister to use some of the money, wherever he got it, to ensure that these babies would not be allowed to suffer pain.
Comment on this
It is hard to understand why anybody would be opposed to providing pain relief to a human being about to undergo a painful procedure. I am not sure any Member is actively against pain relief in principle. Sadly, however, many have spoken out against this amendment in recent weeks. When this was raised at the recent health committee meeting, the Minister said this type of detail is best set out by clinicians in their clinical guidelines rather than by politicians in primary legislation, and that it was not for the Oireachtas to prescribe medication or treatments. Although he said it is not for the Oireachtas to prescribe medication or treatments, this Bill does that in many cases by legalising a range of unspecified procedures or treatments to end the life of an unborn child, even though there is no medical condition in a mother where the intentional ending of her baby's life is a medically indicated treatment.
We recognise that there are times when it is medically indicated to end a pregnancy early to protect the life or the health of the mother. However, the Bill seeks to legalise a wide variety of procedures aimed at intentionally ending the life of the unborn baby. Why is it so inconceivable that the Minister would also include a measure of legislative oversight to ensure that if any of these procedures could cause pain to a tiny human being, the medical personnel would be obliged to mitigate that possibility? People voted as they did out of compassion and for what they believed was best for the mother involved, be they "Yes" or "No" voters. It was not a vote against babies. However, the Minister appears to be interpreting it now. It was not a vote to ensure babies would be treated as inhumanely as possible. It was not a vote on any specific legislation, as he was at pains to remind us when he introduced his draft legislation in March, and as the Referendum Commission and the High Court have reminded us since. It was a vote to allow the Oireachtas to legislate and that is what we are trying to do.
The Minister seems to think that he is the only politician in the Chamber whose views on sections of the legislation should be considered. That is not the case for any other legislative measure and it should not be the case for this one. We are all elected to help shape legislation on behalf of the electorate and I believe there are few among the electorate who do not want unborn babies who are capable of feeling pain to be denied the most basic concessions to their human dignity and to be protected from unnecessary pain as far as practicable. This legislation is the right place to enshrine the principle that the unborn baby who may be subjected to a painful procedure should be protected and given pain relief. The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child is clear that children deserve special safeguards and care before as well as after birth. The convention, which Ireland ratified in 1992, states: "The child, by reason of his physical and mental immaturity, needs special safeguards and care, including appropriate legal protection, before as well as after birth." An amendment seeking to ensure that a pain capable human being would be guaranteed pain relief, where possible, is reasonable. Special safeguards should be enshrined in our laws.
The amendment also specifies that an analgesic or anaesthetic should be administered where the baby is determined to be at a gestation of 20 weeks or more. Pain relief is typically given to unborn babies when they undergo prenatal surgery in the womb from 20 weeks on and, therefore, it does not seem unreasonable to seek that the same would be guaranteed for unborn babies about to undergo a painful procedure. Nurses who have treated extremely premature babies have testified that these babies react to painful stimuli such as inserting needles and so forth. Why would we not assume that babies of a similar gestation who are still in the womb would also feel pain? Let us be very clear. Dismemberment is painful and fatal poisoning is painful. It would be a gross abuse of human rights not to ensure that tiny human beings were guaranteed pain relief before undergoing a painful procedure.
The Minister said he does not wish to specify what doctors must do, but if he had done any international research on this, he would have quickly discovered that in other countries where this is not specified in legislation, pain relief is not considered for, or given to, unborn babies. In recent weeks, a court case has been ongoing in Texas in the United States, where live dismemberment abortion procedures are routinely performed without pain relief. The state of Texas is trying to outlaw live dismemberment because it causes intense distress to a foetus or unborn baby, but abortion providers are arguing that it would restrict access to abortion. Does that sound familiar? Do we want to have such a case here? If this will happen anyway, there should be no objection in principle to the consideration of pain relief for an unborn baby where appropriate. This legislative safeguard will not cause any harm. However, if the amendment is opposed, it is likely that in future we will back to debate the issue in the type of detail in which people are being forced to debate it in Texas because "abortion doctors" there, and I use the term loosely, deemed that no pain relief was necessary before tearing a child apart.
I apologise if this language is distressing for anybody present or anybody watching these proceedings, but that is the unpleasant and unsavoury reality of some choices being discussed in the Chamber. This procedure is more commonly known as a D&E procedure, which portrays the horror of what it involves. It is not a rare procedure in the UK. In 2017 alone, 13,000 babies died this way. This included 1,800 at a gestation over 20 weeks when pain was likely to be felt. Perhaps even today, as we speak, an Irish unborn baby is having its limbs taken apart in the UK. Would that procedure be any more palatable if was being done in Letterkenny instead of London? It is not easy to ask these questions or to mention these things here but they are facts in other countries. We must prevent that from happening here. I support the amendment to put those safeguards in place.
Comment on this
The amendment imposes a duty to minimise pain for the unborn child where appropriate and practical.
Yet, we seem to have some pushback with this. Most people would understand the scientific definition that an unborn child is an individual, living, human being. Science will tell us there is a physical and biomedical response to injury and research shows us that pain and stress may affect the unborn child in its development. What does it say about this country and this Chamber that anybody would have to fight for that? It is dumbfounding that anybody would have to fight any government to seek for pain relief to be introduced in that regard.
There is disbelief around the country with the stubbornness of the Government to move on this, even among those people who are solidly pro-choice, and that the humanity of this amendment is completely unrecognised by the Government. The stubbornness of the Government is preventing it from putting this measure into the Bill.
The nervous system develops at around six weeks. Sensory receptors, which allow pain to be felt, start to develop at around seven weeks and are across the body at 18 weeks. In 2010, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists report, Fetal Awareness, inferred that the unborn child has the capacity to feel pain from 24 weeks. The further the research and investigation goes into this issue, that age understanding is falling.
Even if a person was unsure about this, would the Minister not, on the precautionary principle alone, instinctually say, "Let us make sure this does not happen"? On the precautionary principle alone, would the Minister's very nature not say, "I need to put this into the Bill"? The Minister will state it is not up to him to do this and that somebody somewhere sometime will do something around this. This Chamber of elected representatives of the South of Ireland are to stand back and say, "Okay, we trust you to do this" and to let it happen. During the Committee Stage debate, we went back and forth a rake of times around the fact that a measure in primary legislation is far stronger than if it is in guidelines elsewhere. I put it to the Minister that this is the place to put such a measure. What would it cost the Minister to put it into the Bill? Does he support the fact that there should be pain relief in all cases of abortion? If so, what is the cost to the Minister to do that?
I can think of absolutely no cost to any Member of this Chamber of including such a measure. This amendment does not seek to reduce access in any fashion. The only reason I can think of as to why the Minister would not want to include it in the Bill is that in some way it reflects a humanity to the unborn child in the womb. This is the only reason I can see that the Minister would be cautious about introducing this into the Bill.
I ask the Minister and the political parties in the Chamber to reconsider. Even those who are instinctually pro-choice and who feel in their hearts and souls that access is the primary issue in this abortion debate, that access is supreme and that nobody should even think about denying access, should have no reason not show the humanity to make sure this goes into the legislation.
Comment on this
I will add to what my colleagues have already outlined in a very articulate and clear manner. I was shocked to find that the Bill did not already cover such a provision. It seems that we have totally lost our way as a society. We have heard much about compassion and human rights. I agree with that wholeheartedly; everyone needs compassion and human rights need to be respected. The sanctity of life needs to be respected. We are talking about the most vulnerable in our society - an unborn baby who is a weak, vulnerable human being.
I am in disbelief that this is not already included in the Bill and I have been contacted by constituents who are on both sides. Some voted "Yes" in the referendum but are stunned this is not provided for in the Bill as are the pro-life constituents, but that goes without saying. I appeal to the Minister to please show compassion and humanity by including this amendment in the Bill. Why would he not do that? It is not good enough to pass the buck and say that it is up to clinical opinion. The Minister, Deputy Harris, is the Minister for Health and has spoken about compassion, human rights and healthcare. Let us give those to the unborn baby who is the most vulnerable in our society.
Comment on this
I will be brief but I did not want to let amendment No. 37 pass without speaking on it. It is a very reasonable request that the Minister should consider pain relief in this case, given that we are referring to babies over 20 weeks. When one considers that a baby is viable at 22 weeks it is imperative that the baby is given pain relief. There is no point in having the baby suffer needlessly. I am sure it would also be of great benefit and cause less stress for the mother. Even if he does not think about the baby in this case the Minister should definitely consider the mother and, hopefully, a reduction in the stress that she might be experiencing at that stage. I ask that the Minister shows compassion with regard to this amendment. It is a reasonable amendment and while the Minister has not accepted too many, perhaps this is one that should be accepted by every Member of the House.
Comment on this
There is increasing scientific evidence from around the world that babies in the womb feel pain before 20 weeks. The nervous system begins to develop at six weeks. Sensory receptors that allow pain to be felt develop at seven weeks and they are present across the body by 18 weeks. It is important that doctors who perform abortions must take all appropriate and practical steps to avoid causing pain to the foetus. This does not apply in an emergency case where it may not be practicable or where the administration of an anaesthetic to the foetus might pose a risk to the life, or serious harm to the health, of the pregnant woman.
Irish people inherently recognise the humanity of unborn children. We need to acknowledge this humanity by obliging the medical professionals to minimise the pain of abortion procedure. Surgeons recognise unborn babies as patients and anaesthetic is routinely used for babies undergoing surgery in the womb. Surely the same should apply in cases of surgical abortion. The Bill envisages surgical abortions in certain circumstances beyond 12 weeks gestation. Clearly, there is a possibility that some of these unborn children are capable of feeling pain, and yet the Bill as it stands has no requirement that unborn children are given appropriate protection from pain during an abortion. It would be horrible and unnecessary for unborn Irish children to suffer needlessly during an abortion. To prevent this the Government must accept amendments requiring that unborn children be given pain relief before an abortion procedure wherever there is a reasonable possibility of their experiencing pain. As I said during the Committee Stage of the debate, abortion by its nature is very violent and invasive. We must ensure that all unborn children are not subject to pain.
Comment on this
I wish to speak to the principle of the amendment, but I will be brief. I approach this amendment from a compassionate and humane point of view. The amendment proposed seeks to ensure that in most cases, not even in all cases, doctors would ensure that the unborn child is not subjected to pain. It is after the gestational age of the foetus is 20 weeks or more. This amendment does not prohibit abortion where the baby can feel pain, it merely requires the administration of pain relief. I look forward to hearing from the Minister in respect of the medical guidelines on this.
Comment on this
I will be supporting this amendment. Even if one was just to go on the precautionary principle, be the person young, middle aged or older, we never want to see or hear of anyone in pain. This will go down and be remembered. Knowledge in medicine is changing constantly.
I do not think we can risk not putting this in the Bill. A few years down the road, if more evidence comes out proving that we neglected to do something here this evening it will not bode well for us. We should support this amendment to make sure nobody and no baby is put under any pain.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. Any of us who have been involved in motherhood or fatherhood and have been involved watching the birth of our children and as they grow up, particularly in the early days, even when we could not understand why they were crying, the one thing that would cross our minds is worry that the child was in pain. I have checked this out medically in terms of what pain may apply to the baby in the womb and it is a fact that pain does apply. I think a lot of people in this Chamber are thinking of not opposing this amendment. I urge the Minister to try to support it out of all the amendments.
Comment on this
I am delighted to speak on this amendment and to have put my name to it. Around my county since the vote, this is one of the issues that has been discussed by a lot of people. It is not unreasonable to require the administration of an anaesthetic to a foetus where the medical practitioner who is carrying out the termination is of the reasonable opinion, formed in good faith, that the gestational age of the foetus is 20 weeks or more. This is an advanced pregnancy and extra steps must be taken to ensure no pain is caused during the termination process. This obligation would not apply in an emergency case where it is not practicable or where it is believed that the administration of an anaesthetic to the foetus might pose a risk to the life or to the health of the pregnant woman. If there is no harm to the woman in this situation, there is no reason this cannot be administered. Anaesthetic and pain relief for babies undergoing surgery in the womb is generally recommended and this is simply an extension of that medical practice. I ask that the Government to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. One thing we all try to avoid is pain, as adults or in any walk of life. We are speaking for those who cannot speak for themselves, the foetuses or babies, whatever you like to call them. It is a medically proven fact that from 20 weeks onward, foetuses are affected and can feel pain. The Minister should take this on board. It will not affect the referendum in any way and it will protect against something that should not happen, namely, pain when abortions take place.
Comment on this
I request that the Minister support the thrust of this amendment. As previous speakers have said, it in no way hinders or jeopardises the movement of the legislation through the Dáil whether we like it or not. We are coming a long way. At one stage we had the right to life and we are coming to the reverse stage. I listened to some speakers in the last couple of days, yesterday in particular, and they likened an unwanted pregnancy in terms of women's healthcare to that of women having cancer. I feel very saddened about that kind of comparison. We have come a long way from the right to life and maybe a person should have the right to a termination in an orderly and medically approved formula. I would say that we support this amendment.
Comment on this
I support the very reasonable requests put forward by colleagues in respect of this very important amendment. It is very reasonable and I do not know how anyone could have grounds to object to it. I sincerely hope the Minister can accede to this amendment. It is important from the point of view that everything is stressful enough. There is enough of pain and suffering in the termination process so the least that could be done is to try to ease the pain where possible and practicable. I fully support the amendment.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputies for raising the matter. I understand the points they are trying to raise but, as I did outline clearly on Committee Stage, I cannot accept the proposal to include a separate section in the Bill which would provide for the administration of an anaesthetic to a foetus where the gestational age of the foetus is 20 weeks or more because, as I explained on Committee Stage when the Deputies first submitted this amendment, the purpose of this legislation is not to regulate or dictate the practice of obstetrics. That is not what we do in this House. There is a very thin line that we should not cross where we move from being policy makers to being doctors. We have to be very conscious of that.
Medical practitioners are bound through professional regulatory mechanisms to operate in accordance with best medical practice. The requirements in sections 11 to 14, inclusive, for medical practitioners to be of the reasonable opinion, formed in good faith, emphasise that doctors must maintain professional standards and must uphold medical ethics. It is simply not appropriate to include detailed medical treatment, compulsory care pathways or treatment plans in legislation. There are no such provisions in respect of the woman's health or care in this legislation because that would not be appropriate either. It is not where we put a detailed care pathway. It is not where we put information about medication. This type of detail is set out by doctors as they go about their obstetric practice through clinical guidelines rather than primary legislation. I have previously assured colleagues in this House that in parallel with the service planning and expansion work, clinical guidelines for medical practitioners on termination of pregnancy are also in preparation. It is right and proper that clinical guidelines are drawn up by clinicians and not by politicians. My Department has provided a grant to support this work to enable the timely and efficient completion of the guidelines.
Comment on this
I am extremely disappointed and flabbergasted that is all the Minister would say, that he could just say we would be interfering with the clinicians and obstetricians. It is a feeble answer. Am I surprised? No. Why do we want to see this in the Bill? Because we do not trust you. A sizeable majority of people do not want you, even people who voted yes do not trust you. How could they? I am going to read something to the Minister-----
Comment on this
The Deputy is not speaking to the amendment.
Comment on this
-----that was sent out in 2011 by him, when he was Councillor Simon Harris, to pro-life people in Wicklow. "Dear [whoever], I am contesting the general election in Wicklow for Fine Gael and am happy and proud to assure you that I am pro-life."
Comment on this
Deputy Mattie McGrath should speak to the amendment.
Comment on this
"In response to your two direct questions, ... yes, if elected to the Dáil I will oppose any legislation to introduce abortion in Ireland. ... Yes, I will support legislation that protects the human embryo from deliberate destruction and I will oppose any legislation that does not. Please be assured of my support. I need number 1 votes on Friday so I can be in a position to support these positions in Dáil Éireann."
Comment on this
Acting Chairman, this is not on the amendment.
Comment on this
That was signed by the Minister when he was a councillor in 2011.
Comment on this
I am speaking to the amendment. I am horrified that the Minister will not accept the amendment. I have a copy of the letter in my hand to give to him when I finish. Many thousands more letters were sent out by Phil Hogan. I will ask this Parliamentary Usher to please pass the letter to the Minister for Health. I thank the Usher. That is what it is. It is just a mockery. If people know the Minister cannot be trusted in his writing, how can they trust any utterance that would come from his mouth? None. I do not think the Minister of State, Deputy McEntee, can stop me from asking an Usher to hand a letter to the Minister. That is standard practice here.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. How can we trust him if that is all the Minister can say after all the passionate pleas that were made to him here by the Members?
Comment on this
I am very disappointed with the Minister's reply to our amendment and our request to ensure pain relief for a little infant and for the little infant's last seconds in the world. He gave us an answer that it is up to the medical profession; that is not acceptable.
It is not unreasonable for us to table this amendment because we did not have abortions in this country up to now. It is not just a few of us in this House who are asking for this; many more people outside in our constituencies are really concerned about this since it was raised at the Oireachtas committee a number of weeks ago. It is not too much to ask for an assurance from the Minister that pain relief would be given to these little infants. We are very sorry and disappointed that he is not acceding to this. We will be putting it to a vote because it is the last thing we can do given that the Minister is not agreeable. We will be doing that to ensure that we have tried our best on behalf of those little infants we are talking about.
Comment on this
I seek clarity on the Minister's reply. He said "in parallel" clinical guidelines are being drawn up. Is it his understanding that this issue will be dealt with in the clinical guidelines?
Comment on this
The point on compassion has been well made on this amendment. The amendment appears very reasonable and it even takes into account cases where there are issues and it is not practical. I listened to what the Minister had to say on the matter. It would be reasonable and compassionate to give pain relief in this situation. I ask him to clarify the point Deputy Butler raised.
Comment on this
I repeat a question I asked earlier. Does the Minister think pain relief should happen in all cases? There is another question we, as politicians, are all asked. Do we accept the answer that someone somewhere will do something about this sometime or do we understand that it is our responsibility to do it now? If the Minister thinks it is someone else's responsibility, by all means he should not put this into the Bill. However, if he feels he should have a role in ensuring there is some level of humanity in this, then the answer is clear.
Comment on this
Up to now 450 nurses and midwives have signed the petition saying that they are outraged at what is being proposed and the fact that pain relief will not be offered. It is a bit rich for the Minister to say that he, as Minister and a legislator, thinks we should not be interfering with the medical profession. It is a human right for somebody who might suffer pain to be offered pain relief. I asked the Minister to give an intelligent and thoughtful response as to why he believes we are wrong. I still have not heard that from him. I would still dearly like to hear that from him. He should give me a factual reason it is wrong to offer pain relief to an unborn child. I want a straight answer to that.
I saw the horror and shock. I saw how the Minister tried to interfere with the Acting Cathaoirleach. He tried to stop Deputy Mattie McGrath from reading out this letter. Other people may not have noticed it. In case anyone was not looking at the Minister, he badgered the Acting Cathaoirleach to try to stop Deputy Mattie McGrath from reading out this letter. The Minister refused to accept a copy of the letter when it was given to him. This happens to Ministers every day; they are handed letters. The Minister did not want this letter because it contained the commitment and promise he gave to the electorate when he said he was pro-life. He has gone a long way from that now, but he showed an awful lot when he showed how shocked and horrified he was at the idea of Deputy Mattie McGrath reading into the record of the Dáil the letter the Minister sent to thousands of people saying, "Dear pro-life campaign" and signed "Kind regards, Simon". Well Simon has changed an awful lot since then.
Potassium chloride is an extremely corrosive and painful thing to have going into anybody. All we are asking is to have pain relief for that. My God, it does not get any simpler or more humane than that.
Comment on this
I will not ask it again tonight. I am asking the Minister for the last time to give an intelligent response-----
Comment on this
----- explaining why we are wrong.
Comment on this
I am also very disappointed the Minister is refusing to accept our amendment. We can no longer bury our heads in the sand. The Bill currently passing through the Dáil would legalise the procedures I mentioned in my previous speech, with no regard for any human rights of the child, with no regard for any human dignity of that child and with no regard for any pain or suffering those procedures may cause to those children. The intention of this amendment is to recognise that these procedures often cause suffering to unborn babies. The very least we owe those babies is to protect them from pain.
It is worth reminding ourselves that despite the misleading Title of the Bill as the Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Bill, the definition of that phrase in the Bill makes it clear that the Bill is all about the termination of life. Section 2 defines termination of pregnancy as a medical procedure which is intended to end the life of a baby. The Minister would like us to believe that doctors who want to participate in the intentional ending of a child's life usually on the request of the mother, would then, of course, also consider the matter of pain relief for the baby, but this is just not logical.
Surely that means it is up to us to ensure the child's interests are represented in some small way in the Bill. These procedures are in stark contrast to procedures specifically intended to deliver a baby early to end a pregnancy that way. We are speaking here of the only procedures regulating this Bill - those intended to end the life. I am sure the Minister is well aware that he has not made it clear exactly which procedures to end the life of that defenceless baby would be legal. Therefore, we can only assume that the most barbaric and inhumane ones would be legal unless the Minister outlaws them. Up to now the Minister has neglected to put any protections for unborn babies in the Bill. We will not hold our breaths on that one.
It is already horrific enough that we are even discussing how we would end the life of an unborn child. As Members will all know at this stage, I would always favour trying to help every unborn baby to live as well as helping the mother through whatever difficult situation she is in.
Comment on this
However, I reluctantly accept that the principle of protecting the life of the unborn baby has been rejected wholesale in this Chamber.
Comment on this
That leaves us in the position of trying to provide at least some shred of dignity-----
Comment on this
-----in consideration of this tiny human being-----
Comment on this
----- before they are painfully dismembered.
Comment on this
I have a very brief point to make. I was not going to say this, but over the past couple of weeks I spoke to the Minister privately about different parts of this legislation. I like to be honest. On every occasion I spoke to him, he gave me time. He explained things to me as late as today. We need to speak to the amendments. We are all trying to get solutions here and do the right thing from the perspective of our own conscience.
I would like the Minister to give us more clarification on the medical guidelines. I reiterate that neither I nor any of my colleagues would do anything that would damage women's health. We should all be honest and honourable. I will not publicly run down the Minister because every time I approached him he tried to explain things to me.
Comment on this
Since the referendum I have spoken to many people - people who voted "Yes" and people who voted "No". Since the referendum, I have not met one person who would begrudge giving painkillers to a foetus. I cannot understand what the Minister is doing. Is he going by the recommendations of the Chief Medical Officer again? I cannot understand it. Anyone who has any kind of compassion whatsoever would agree. If one saw a cat or dog in pain on the street, one would take them to the vet to help them out. I cannot understand why a foetus that is in pain is not being allowed to have an anaesthetic. I ask the Minister to stop blaming the Chief Medical Officer.
Comment on this
I am not blaming him; I just tend to take medical advice from him, which I think is a better idea than-----
Comment on this
Does the Minister think medical advice is-----
Comment on this
I think it is better than taking medical advice from politicians, including me, who are not medically qualified in how to carry out obstetric practice. However, that is just my view of the world.
This unearthing of a commitment I made in 2011, which obviously does not relate to the amendment, but which a number of people are referencing, is no unearthing. The Deputy is right; that was my position in 2011. It is my party's position; it echoes in it. I have changed my view. I am delighted I changed my view. I am delighted I campaigned and voted to repeal the eighth amendment of the Constitution.
Comment on this
How can they trust in the Minister?
Comment on this
I am delighted we are going to live in a country with compassion and care.
Comment on this
How can anyone trust the Minister?
Comment on this
I hope the Deputy will also change his view one day.
Comment on this
He does not believe they have any rights.
Comment on this
My constituents have endorsed my view by voting overwhelmingly in favour of repealing the eighth amendment, as did Deputy Mattie McGrath's.
To answer Deputy Tóibín's question, it is somebody else's job to do this. It is the job of the obstetric community. Those pro-life Deputies in the House - and I think we all consider ourselves to be pro-life - who are against the legislation must agree with that also. If they believed that a pain relief provision must be included in primary legislation, surely to God they would have included it for women as well. They have not done so, however, because they know doctors will do that, just as doctors will also take every appropriate step to protect babies. That is what they do. To suggest anything else would be a slur on their profession.
Deputies Butler, Aindrias Moynihan and Eugene Murphy asked for assurances. I cannot write the clinical guidelines, nor would anybody want me to, but I can assure them that our clinicians know how to carry out procedures and operate in an ethical manner in accordance with the Medical Council. I have absolutely no doubt about that. Our doctors go into hospitals every day to ease pain and I have no doubt that all these issues will be considered when the clinical guidelines are being drawn up. What we cannot do in this House is don the white coats and the stethoscopes and become obstetricians and gynaecologists. We are policymakers. Pain relief and care pathways come from doctors, not politicians.
Comment on this
I will defer to Deputy Mattie McGrath.
Comment on this
I am saddened and shocked - we all are. We said all along - and I repeated it earlier - that we accept totally where an intervention has to be made in an emergency in terms of anything that would affect the health or the life of the mother. The Minister does not have to pick up on that. That is quite clear and understood by all of us.
Some abortion advocates claim that the unborn child cannot feel pain until the third trimester. However, that claim is contradicted by the modern evidence to which, increasingly, the Minister does not want to listen. There is growing scientific evidence from around the world that babies in the womb feel pain before 20 weeks. Anaesthetic and pain relief for babies undergoing surgery in the womb is generally recommended and has been called for in late-term abortions. Some say that should be done from as early as 18 weeks' gestation. Surgeons recognise unborn babies as patients, yet the Minister tells us that the reason he is refusing to accept this amendment is that we might be interfering with that. Surgeons understand this issue. All the people in labour wards understand it. We are not trying to be cruel. I did not want to say it but Deputy Fitzpatrick said that if there was a dog, a pup or a kitten lying on the street, we would lift it up and mind it by providing warmth, pain relief or whatever. It would be horrific and unnecessary for unborn children to suffer needlessly during an abortion.
To prevent that, this amendment should be accepted without any difficulty. It is a clear duty of compassionate and humane doctors to act on the precautionary principle of prevention of pain where there is a risk that it may be experienced. This amendment does not prohibit abortion where the baby can feel pain; it merely requires the administration of pain relief. It is the most humane request in the world and the Minister has set his face against it. I am shocked.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 38:
In page 11, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following:
“Protection of Infants born alive
16. (1) In this section, “born alive” means the complete emergence of a foetus from the body of the woman, regardless of the state of gestational development, who, after emergence, whether or not the umbilical cord has been cut or the placenta is attached, and regardless of whether the emergence occurs as a result of natural or induced labour, caesarean section, termination of pregnancy or otherwise, shows any evidence of life including, but not limited to, one or more of the following:
(a) breathing;
(b) a heartbeat;
(c) umbilical cord pulsation; or
(d) definite movement of voluntary muscles.
(2) In this section, “infant” means a foetus who has been born alive as a result of the carrying out or attempted carrying out of a termination of pregnancy under this Act.
(3) A medical practitioner shall take all steps as may be appropriate and practicable to preserve the life of an infant.
(4) For the avoidance of doubt, the fact that the infant has been born alive as a result of the carrying out or attempted carrying out of a termination of pregnancy under this Act shall not be a relevant consideration for a medical practitioner when determining what constitutes an appropriate and/or practicable step under subsection (3).”.
The amendment requires that a doctor take all appropriate and practical steps to preserve the life of an infant who is born alive as a result of the carrying out, or attempted carrying out, of a termination of pregnancy. It provides for a basic humanity that should have been included in the Bill from the outset, and it is strange and perverse that it was not. It gives clarity and certainty to doctors on how to proceed where an abortion does not result in the death of a baby. It makes clear that where there are indications of life after birth there is a duty to act to save that life. It does not dictate to medical practitioners what steps are appropriate in any given case. This will vary in the circumstances, particularly the stage of gestation.
Different considerations will apply, such as if the infant is born alive after the point of viability. That will be a matter for clinicians at each delivery.
Abortion survivors being left without care is not a theoretical problem Official figures show in a ten year period starting in 2000, 491 babies who survived botched abortions were abandoned by medical staff and left to die alone without care in Canadian hospitals. In the UK the confidential inquiry into maternal and child health revealed that in 2005, 66 babies in England and Wales were born alive and left, unaided, to die after failed abortions. The amendment, if accepted by the Minister and his colleagues, would ensure that such a scandal will not happen here. It will do nothing to prevent access to abortion but it will avoid the gross human rights abuse that happens when a law does not protect babies who survive abortions. It is unimaginable and unthinkable that such a thing can happen in any right-thinking hospital or care situation where there are medics who have taken the Hippocratic oath, and love what they do and do it well, and where what they do 99% of the time is save lives.
The Minister used the word "compassion" often during the referendum campaign and since. The amendment is all about compassion and care for one of the most vulnerable in our society, the tiny vulnerable baby who just survived the trauma of an abortion. There is no justification for a cold conclusion that the baby does not deserve compassion.
Amárach Research conducted polling in the wake of the referendum which showed that 69% of respondents believed that where an unborn baby survives an abortion procedure and is born alive that doctors should be obliged to give it medical care to preserve his or her life; only 9% disagreed and the others said they did not know. These and the figures from Canada and the UK inquiry shine a light on the chilling reality of legalised abortion without protection against practices that are rarely discussed in public. However, it is a conversation that we must have.
It is no good for the Minister to say that this will not happen in Irish hospitals when we all know that abortion clinics will inevitably become the main providers. It is happening across the water and in many other jurisdictions. Any mealy-mouthed assurances from the Minister will cut no cloth with any of us or with most right-thinking people, including the 69% in the Amárach poll.
I have stood outside the gates of this House and heard a very brave woman in her 40s tell her story of her botched abortion. Thankfully, she survived and is able to talk about it all over the world. She has a family of her own and is expecting grandchildren. As I said last night, I have heard about more than one case and I have heard many others give testimony. We know there are countless numbers of people. Anything can go wrong in a safe delivery but when one is out to destroy life, one might not always succeed. I have seen the evidence. It was a pity that when that woman came to Dublin during the summer and hotels were booked for her to tell her story, they were forced to cancel the bookings. That was not the case in Cork, however, where we held the event in an hotel without a problem. In Dublin, it had to be held in candlelight, where she gave her testimony on the street in front of an hotel. We talk about democracy and about choice, but what of the choice adults might make to go and listen to this woman whose name eludes me? I should have read it into the record. I salute her telling her story about the trauma she went through for days, after saline material was injected into her. A caring nurse was passing and heard her squeals for protection, like any infant born, or animal, for that matter, and had compassion and took her into her care and gave her heat and liquids. Now she has life to tell the tale. What a wonderful story. To think that after meetings were booked, arranged and deposits paid, hotels in this city were bulldozed and intimidated and staff followed home to ensure that woman could not deliver her story in three different quasi-public places and that the meeting had to be held in candlelight. It was more powerful in candlelight by the Liffey in Dublin, where hundreds of people with compassion and humanity listened to the story. We are asking for nothing more than some shred of humanity to be put into this barbaric legislation. All we are asking with these amendments is for some shred of humanity. We will not be ridiculed for doing so as we do so honestly and respectfully.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. As the previous Deputy said, it is basic humanity that if a baby survives and is seen to be viable that there is an onus on everyone, obstetricians and all other medical personnel, to ensure they are given every chance to survive. The Minister should take this on board. It is only giving basic rights to an infant that was born and was breathing, that they should be given the opportunity to live.