We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Bill 2018: Report Stage (Resumed)

Contributions 198–402 of 402. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Bill 2018
Enacted

No. 105 of 2018 ›

I emailed the Chairman of the committee on the eighth amendment during its hearings to ask if she would invite an abortion survivor to appear before the committee. I had met one who had undergone practically the same experience that is dealt with in the amendment. She was a grown woman who wanted to tell her story and was happy to do so to the committee. The Chairman said “No”. I approached another member of that committee and asked if he might make representations to the rest of the committee that this abortion survivor would make a presentation. He responded by asking whether there was such a thing. That individual had sat through the whole debate at the committee, had formed a particular view on the amendment, and was unaware that there are actually individuals who have survived abortions. That person made no effort to have that woman make her presentation. I would have thought that a committee such as that would have inputs from both sides of the debate, which would help the members make up their minds. We have heard ad nauseam from Deputy Durkan that he was at the committee and he heard all the information and was strengthened by it to make the decisions he made around the issue, yet people such as abortion survivors were denied access to that committee. It shocked me that would be the case but that is how politics works in this country.

Around the world, unborn children survive abortions. I do not like to talk about it in much detail as it is something that is difficult to discuss, but they survive in a very injured state. In most cases they are simply left to expire and they are not given comfort or medical treatment. Many people will say that does not happen and that I am talking baloney. It might make it easier for those people to have their opinions if they convince themselves that is the case. However, the statistics mentioned, which were produced by the departments of health in Canada and Britain, illustrate that it does happen. It happens in countries beside us and that have very similar values to us in many of these things. When one goes down the route of a competition of rights, that the primary and untouchable right is the decision to end the life of the unborn child, then resuscitating an infant which is about to expire becomes less of an objective.

I had this debate with the Minister at the committee. He stated that this would never happen here and how dare I even consider that a doctor would allow it to happen, as if to say that doctors in Ireland are somehow morally superior to their counterparts in Britain, Canada or anywhere else. The truth is that we have had a pro-life culture within the society and within the health services for decades. As a result, most doctors would find the type of situation we are discussing very difficult to deal with. It is one they would not allow to arise in the first instance. We know, however, that in countries where abortion is freely available, the culture changes. If it happens elsewhere, it will happen here. The Minister was vociferous on Committee Stage in stating that it would not happen here. The question I would ask is what it would cost the Minister to simply codify it in law. Again, why is there a difficulty in doing that?

There are many with older heads than me in this Dáil. Many Members have fought the Government in bigger battles. Everyone knows that sometimes, when a Minister just does not want to deal with an issue, he or she will think of a reason it cannot be done and why it is difficult to codify it in law. The Minister will not say, "I do not want this to be done", but will just give an excuse as to why it cannot be done. In that type of situation, most of us know it is transparently the fact the Minister does not want to codify it. My view is that we have a responsibility to do that.

This is one of those issues that resonates deeply with people. This is another amendment that does not seek to reduce access in any way. Even for people for whom access is the prime objective and ambition and those who are maximalist in the context of their wish for abortion to be made available on all occasions, this amendment does not interfere with their goals. What it does is reflect the humanity of the unborn child. I have spoken to many people who are pro-choice and who have similar views to some Deputies but they baulk at the refusal of the Government to codify this in primary legislation. The excuse is that somebody somewhere will do something about it at some point. They say that it is not our problem, not our responsibility. They say medical care for that infant is not a policy decision in some way. It is a policy decision; it is 100% a policy decision.

Anybody who looks at law will say that comparative politics is very important. We are not living in complete disconnect from the rest of the world. Obviously, some of the laws we are implementing are part of trends that have happened in other parts of the world. Logic will dictate that the way this legislation operates in Irish society is going to follow the general trends in other societies.

I again appeal to the Minister. This is a logical, humane response to a very difficult situation that does not seek to reduce access one iota. All it seeks to do is give confidence to people that if that situation were to arise here and if a clinician who had worked in the British system and was acting with regard to the cultural understanding he or she had of that system was in any doubt, he or she would know that in Ireland he or she would have no choice but to intervene to protect the life, where possible.

Comment on this

The people voted and we respect their decision. However, they depend on us to legislate and put a sensible Bill together in which we would respect humanity. It is difficult for me to stand here, hour after hour, talking about ending life because that is not what I was brought up to do. From a very young age, I was taught to appreciate life, not to hurt anyone but to do anything that could be done to help anyone. Even with cattle and other animals, I was told that if I wronged them, it would turn back on myself. I refer, for example, to situations where I might neglect animals that could not talk for themselves or defend themselves when they were tied to a stall, needed feed and so on. That is the way I was brought up by my parents and grandparents. We are supposed to legislate and that is what we have tried to do. We have tried to ensure that common sense applies in the context of this Bill.

It can happen that babies who are aborted end up alive. During my first year in the House, 2016, I met a woman downstairs in Buswells, as did other Deputies. She was 39 years of age at the time, so she must be 41 now. She told us of her experience. She had been aborted and she was placed in some kind of a vessel - a bucket. I am sure that is what she told us. Some nurse-----

Comment on this

She remembered it well, did she?

Comment on this
John Lahart Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

Deputy, please.

Comment on this

That is a disgraceful comment. It is outrageous.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is disputing what I heard the woman-----

Comment on this

How did she remember it?

Comment on this

She told me what happened.

Comment on this

The nurse who saved her life told her that.

Comment on this

It makes sense now. I am sorry. I did not understand. It all makes sense to me now. It was the nurse.

Comment on this
John Lahart Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

Order, please.

Comment on this

They have no manners.

Comment on this

That is tolerance all right.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt anyone. She told us clearly that her mother was forced into having an abortion. That is what happened. She ended up alive because some good nurse came back, took her out, saw to her and she survived. She came to Buswells to tell us her story. It frightened me to think that actually happened. We have figures on this but they are not as real to me as that person telling me her story. The figures indicate that, in 2005, 66 babies in England and Wales were born alive after failed abortions and then, breathing unaided, were left to die. This amendment makes sure that such a scandal will not happen here. Of course, the amendment will do nothing to prevent access to abortion but it will avoid the gross human rights abuse that happens when the law does not clearly protect babies who survive abortion.

The breadth of the top of my nail is the difference between being dead and being alive. A small bit of extra attention can ensure that the person is alive rather than dead, and it is likewise with a baby. This amendment provides clarity and guidance for doctors by creating a duty to save the life of a child who is born alive after an attempted abortion. The Minister said to us at the committee that this is what doctors would do in any event. All we are asking for is to be sure about that.

Heretofore, we did not have abortion in this country.

The doctors that we know were dedicated and trained, and the midwives, to ensure in the maternity ward that everything was done to ensure that they would live. We know that is what they are doing and have been doing. This is different. This is an abortion clinic and all we are asking is that the same effort is put into ensuring that if the baby arrives out alive he or she gets every chance at life the same as the baby that was born in the maternity ward. That is all we are asking. It is not unreasonable. The Minister should not criticise us or say that it is unfair of us to ask for this. It is only a small thing in all of this Bill but to us it is a very big thing, to the little baby that might come out alive it would be a chance at life and that is all we all want, a chance to live as long as we can. That is all we are asking. Until the day I die, whether I win or lose the next election or the one after that, I will never be sorry for asking for this here in this Chamber because I may never again get the chance to do that.

Comment on this

I support this amendment that all protection should be offered in the legislation to infants born alive as a result of carrying out or an attempt to carry out termination of pregnancy under this Act. It would be very cruel and wrong to allow an infant born alive simply to die when the medical professionals make every effort to save the lives of others. In addition to the medical ethics there is a moral duty to fight for every person born, regardless of the circumstances of their birth. This is a reasonable amendment. I will not go into the cases that we have heard. We have all heard and read about them and I do not want to see anything like that happening here in Ireland. We respect the decision of the Irish people and this legislation will pass here in the Dáil but we want to put in a few safeguards so that if a child is born alive and there is some hope that the child can be saved, we would like to see it in this Bill that every effort will be made to save that infant.

Comment on this

The Minister said on Committee Stage that he did not need to put anything into this Bill to ensure that doctors would give care to infants born alive as a result of a failed abortion because our doctors know how to care for the infants. However, the Minister seems to have forgotten that in this case the doctor was likely to be the doctor who had been tasked with ending the baby's life, therefore surely the Minister can appreciate that there may be a conflict as to what he or she should do at this point. The doctor was asked to end that baby's life and now the baby is born alive, possibly unwanted by their mother. This is not as cut and dried as the Minister likes to suggest.

During the abortion debate I spent time speaking to everybody. People would not have the same views as me but I have to respect their views. As late as two weeks ago I had a lengthy debate in my constituency office with a person who would not agree with my views but we both shook hands when it was finished and we accepted that we were each entitled to our views. I did listen with interest because I educated myself along this road. There is a lot of discussion about the Canadian lady. Did the Minister meet her? Did he spend a little bit of time with her? He has met so many people who approve of his Bill and on Committee Stage he said something along the lines that he would meet and have discussions with people who want to progress this Bill. There was no harm in meeting and listening to the other side of the story. It was an astonishing story. I will not go into the details because others have done that. There are others out there who have met different individuals. She had an extraordinary story to tell. She was an abortion that went wrong but she lived thanks to the nurse who saved her. The one good point about all of this is that she and her mother are now inseparable. That is the message for the whole of this island: sometimes abortion is not the answer; sometimes there is another answer. That lady got that little twinkle of light and that little chance to live and she and her mother are inseparable now. They have a great relationship. I can see Deputy O'Connell behind the Minister nodding away mad against what I am saying but that is because she probably did not meet this lady either and hear the other side of the story. It is necessary to talk to people, whether one agrees with them or not. It is good to listen. That is something the Minister does not want to do but that is his prerogative.

I think we all, including the Minister, agree with the principle that if an infant is born alive during a failed abortion procedure they would be guaranteed to be given the same medical care that a premature baby of that same gestation would be given. Why then can we not enshrine this principle in our legislation to ensure that no doctor will have any conflict in the area?

It is reported that in the UK 66 babies were left to die in one year with no care after being born alive during failed medical procedures. That is incredible. Unfortunately, that is the road we are now travelling. The Minister has an opportunity to turn that around and change that and at least have something enshrined in the Bill that protects the child that was born after an abortion. I hope that the Minister might give more careful and considered time to accepting this amendment. Like all the amendments we have put forward, we are fair and honest and we spent time putting them together to make sure that we did not flood the whole Bill with amendments that would not reflect the feelings of the public. This is one that does reflect those feelings and I would appreciate if the Minister gave time to considering support for this amendment.

Comment on this

We may talk about compassion. This evening we are talking about a baby who has just survived an abortion. It would be unbelievable if the Minister was to reject an amendment that does nothing to prevent access to an abortion but is all about saving lives. We cannot have a situation in Ireland where doctors in one part of the hospital are doing everything possible to save a premature baby born at say 23 weeks, while in another part of the same hospital a baby born at 24 weeks, after surviving an abortion, is left without life-saving care for whatever reason. This amendment is sought to give clarity and certainty to doctors on how to proceed when abortion does not result in the death of the baby.

It makes it clear that where there are indications of life like breathing, heartbeat, umbilical cord pulsation or a definite movement of the voluntary muscles there is a duty to act to save that life. Nothing can be more compassionate and clearer. This amendment will significantly assist doctors in carrying out their duties.

We must also be cognisant of the human rights abuse of children who survive an abortion and are left without care. This is not a theoretical problem as we have plenty of evidence of such cases in England, Canada, Wales and elsewhere, where babies born alive after botched abortions are left alone in hospitals to die without the care of medical staff. We cannot allow such human rights abuses to happen here. Abortion in Ireland will be legal up to six months into a pregnancy in some cases. We can only hope that the number of children who experience the cruel after-effects of failed abortion procedures will be few and far between. At the same time, however, we must ensure that they are cared for and that is what this amendment is all about, clarity and certainty for doctors.

Comment on this

The Constitution is clear: the second a person is born he or she becomes a citizen. Does the Minister agree with that principle?

Comment on this

Article 40.3. 2° of the Constitution states: "The State shall, in particular, by its laws protect as best it may from unjust attack and, in the case of injustice done, vindicate the life, [and] person,...of every citizen."

In fact, there is an onus on us to follow the Constitution, which includes the phrase "by its laws protect". From the beginning, the amendment has sought to do exactly what the Constitution enjoins us to do. I am surprised that the Minister did not accept the amendment in principle on Committee Stage. He would have probably got a better wording from the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel. However, the spirit of the amendment is clear and it is very much in line with our constitutional obligations as legislators.

We hear a great deal about how doctors care and I do not dispute that they do. At least, I hope all doctors care. We have had rogue doctors in the past, and we should not pretend otherwise. There have been rogue individuals in every profession. Despite the fact that we trust doctors, this land is full of laws, regulations and guidelines which doctors can be severely penalised for failing to follow. The reason is that even though we trust all of these people - just as, I hope, we politicians are trusted by them - we must ensure that no professional can act in a way that does not conform with good standards. A general question has been asked as to whether some allegation is being made here, but that is not so. Every profession is subject to the law. It is nothing new and there is no reason to make an exception in this case.

Comment on this

I thank Deputies for the debate. I am not in a position to accept this amendment which is indistinguishable from the amendment on the same subject put forward on Committee Stage. We had a long discussion and vote on that amendment then. While I can see that the amendment is proposed with the care of infants in mind - and I do not question the Deputy's bona fides in that regard at all - the purpose of the legislation is not to regulate obstetric procedures which do not constitute the termination of pregnancy nor is it to dictate the practice of obstetrics or medicine more generally. It should be borne in mind that the legislation bans termination of pregnancy once viability is reached, unlike other jurisdictions, including many referred to during the debate. Medical practitioners are bound to maintain professional standards and uphold medical ethics at all times. They are bound by their professional regulatory mechanisms to deliver medical services in accordance with best medical practice. Any Deputy who wishes to read the transcripts from the health committee to which representatives of the Institute of the Obstetricians and Gynaecologists gave evidence will see that this is already the practice.

Notwithstanding our differences on this legislation, I am very concerned that word might go out from this House that there is some question or doubt as to what a doctor would actually do if a baby were born alive. I agree with Deputy Ó Cuív that there is an obligation on all of us once someone is born. That is why we also have a ban on termination once viability is reached. I heard a reference to the idea that these might be pregnancies which are unwanted. However, in the situations we are discussing, there is a serious risk to the life of the woman or of serious harm to her health or there is a fatal foetal abnormality. This is a situation where a pregnancy has gone wrong and the medical profession is intervening to protect and save the woman. As Members have heard countless times, in doing so they will always endeavour, where possible, to protect the life of an unborn baby also. There is absolutely no question about that. It is also the case, I suggest, with the mother. The idea that a baby would be born and left in a corner of a hospital is not in accordance with what happens in the Irish health service. It is not what is allowed under Medical Council guidelines, regulatory guidelines and ethical standards. We cannot get into regulating obstetric practice, which does not relate to the termination of pregnancy in a Bill which is about access to abortion services.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to current practice. How can we ensure that practice is incorporated? We do not know exactly where these abortion clinics are going to be. As such, how can we ensure the same regulations will move over to these practices?

Comment on this

I support the amendment, to which I signed my name. This is about dignity in death and the protection of infants born alive. It is reasonable to save a child who defies the object of what is trying to be achieved, namely, his or her death. If an infant is born alive, what we are seeking here is just basic humanity. It is basic dignity for a person to have a fighting chance at life if he or she is born alive after what we term a "failed abortion." I will not repeat the horror stories such as those Deputy Mattie McGrath highlighted whereby people survived abortion, but we have to cater for such cases. The Minister would be the first to say that one has to allow for every eventuality. This is an eventuality which could happen and we should legislate for it. We should legislate for the protection of the baby who survives an abortion. I support the amendment.

Comment on this

I support the amendment also. Quite rightly, we hear in the House and at every committee people advocating strongly for support for the most vulnerable in society. It is a basic tenet which we should all support. There is no one more vulnerable than the baby catered for in this particular amendment. The protection offered if this amendment were accepted would provide support to infants born alive as a result of the carrying out or attempted carrying out of termination of pregnancy under the Act. It is important for the Minister to give favourable consideration to the very fair proposals put forward in this amendment. There is a moral duty on everyone in the medical profession and among its support staff to fight for every person born regardless of the circumstances of his or her birth. The amendment merits approval by the House. In that context, I hope the Minister can revise what he has just said.

Comment on this

I am sorry I missed some of the Minister's contribution. I had to go out to get a charger for my phone. This is a most basic request regarding an abortion which goes wrong in the eyes of the unfortunate woman who wants it for whatever reason, unfortunately, and in those of the professional engaged to carry out the act. We have cases and I have given them to the Minister. I have provided him with figures from Canada and England. Are we going to shut our eyes and ears to that evidence? We have heard from the lady from Canada who also spoke to many thousands of people across the country and all over the world. It is a wonderful story. I forgot to mention that she and her mother - who was forced to go for an abortion by her own mother - have an eternal bond and are very close. Her mother is now a grandmother. These things happen and we are not leaving it up to whim. We will be discussing conscientious objection later but no conscientious person could hear the squeaks and squalls of a little infant delivered in the middle of an abortion process. That professional should be allowed the space and encouraged in the legislation to offer human aid and should see that there is nothing wrong or harmful in doing so. It is basic humanity. The animal world would kill a third person after giving birth. I have had experiences with cows calving and sheep. Those animals would kill a person to protect their young. Are we, as a human race, going to be forced to allow our young to perish in this way?

Comment on this

This is a difficult issue. I am not sure about the circumstances where Deputy Mattie McGrath and others spoke about a baby surviving a termination of pregnancy but there are four areas in this legislation where a pregnancy can be terminated.

One area is before 12 weeks, so that will not apply to this amendment. The second area is when there is an emergency and it quite possible that a woman's health would be at risk and one is on the cusp of the baby being viable. For instance, if it is at 30 weeks, the baby will be delivered as normal. There will not be a termination of pregnancy but there will be a normal delivery and at 30 weeks that baby will most likely survive quite healthily. If it is at 20 weeks, the baby is very unlikely to survive but it may be on the cusp of viability at 22, 23 or 24 weeks and there may be a possibility that it can survive. Medical ethics will of course kick in and it will be ethically required of the medical profession to do what it can to continue the life of that baby. The circumstance which is being described here is very unlikely to occur in this jurisdiction under this legislation.

The other area where a baby would be born alive is with a fatal foetal abnormality, which will have been accurately diagnosed before the delivery and some of those children will continue to live for some time, be it a few hours, a few days or maybe a few weeks. Of course, every effort will be made to help that baby to survive and for the family to interact with that baby.

What is being proposed in this amendment is not possible within this legislation but if it was to be the case that a child was delivered and it was alive, medical ethics would kick in and would give every assistance to that baby, provided there was a possibility that the baby would have a time to survive and to live. The amendment may be well intentioned but it will not arise as a practical situation in this legislation because if a baby is born alive and is viable, everything will be done to preserve the life of that child through medical ethics. I do not know if medical ethics can be introduced into this legislation but the possibility of a baby being left to die at the side of a bed without any intervention is completely unlikely in the medical system that we have today.

Comment on this

I support what Deputy Harty has just said. Perhaps those Deputies who have spoken to these alleged survivors of botched abortions in other jurisdictions would take a trip to one of the special care units in one of our maternity hospitals where every day, every effort is made to preserve life.

I have witnessed a case of a woman's life being at risk. A very good friend of mine had a baby born at 25 weeks who is now in school and every effort was made and that child survived. Instead of listening to anecdotes, fairy tales and stories that essentially have dubious sources, perhaps the Deputies could educate themselves by visiting those units and speaking to the consultants who save lives every day.

In terms of viability-----

Comment on this

That is under the current regime.

Comment on this

Viability is fluid and for those Deputies who engaged with the committee and listened, viability depends on whether it is a twin pregnancy and what weight the foetus or baby or whatever one wants to call it is. It is not up to us in these Houses to legislate on the point of viability because the experts tell us that it is not possible because hopefully with science, which we are heavy on here today, in time we will be able to assist early deliveries to survive from 22 weeks or so in the future.

This amendment might be well intentioned but it is certainly ill informed.

Comment on this

I am very disappointed that the Minister is not supporting our amendment. It is clear that he is not listening to what we are saying or does not understand what we are saying. We are simply asking for something basic and humane, which is that if a baby survives an abortion, he or she gets the same attention as a baby in a maternity ward. We are talking about two different places because when a woman goes into the maternity ward, the ambition is to ensure that the baby is born and looked after. We are not sure because we did not have abortion in this country heretofore.

A number of us, and I am sure a number of Deputies on the other side as well, definitely met this lady across the road in Buswells. She told us what happened to her, we believe her and she gave us a firm account of what happened. Herself and her mother are good friends now. The mother was forced into having the abortion by another family member and gladly, she survived all that trauma. We are simply asking that everything possible is done and every medical intervention available is utilised to ensure the baby gets a proper chance at life.

Comment on this

Again the Minister rejects one of our amendments. It is disappointing that he would reject an amendment that seeks to protect an infant born alive after an abortion. That is astonishing to say the least but it is along the same lines on which he has been travelling with omissions from this Bill to protect a baby in what is an unlikely situation, albeit one that does happen and there is proof out there.

As Deputy O'Keeffe said, what we are trying to put forward in this amendment is the same as what is in our Constitution and I fully agree with him. The Minister says that this is not what we do in our hospitals but we do not perform abortions in our hospitals yet so how do we know what will happen? There are some excellent hospitals which have brought infants into the world who have fought bravely. I have been there myself and the aftercare for children in this country is astonishingly brilliant. It is probably second to none to date, but going forward with a Bill that does not cover all aspects and leaves things wide open in our hospitals, we are now travelling on a different road because we have no protection in this Bill for infants born alive after an abortion.

My colleague Deputy Harty said that after 20, 21 or 22 weeks, it is very unlikely that a baby would be viable. There are situations where this happens and it might be very unlikely but if we can save one child in this country with this amendment, I would be very proud that it was brought forward and we have to make sure that such a protection is there.

Deputy O'Connell has left and she was going on about our fairy stories. Of course she does not want to hear the other side because she has her mind made up. I listened to the other side but she obviously did not, judging by her comments. We did meet the woman who was left to die and we discussed that and it is not fair for Deputy O'Connell to say that unless she spoke to that woman herself and was not in the same mood as ourselves. She also stated that it looks like we have not visited the special care unit but I have been there and we have all been there down through the years.

Comment on this

I have great respect for Deputy Harty and I find him to be a very decent man. I want to believe that if a child survives an abortion, the doctors will do everything they can to save the child. However, as I said earlier to the Minister, who is not in the Chamber at present, we want to give doctors clarity and certainty - that is all we want to do - to ensure they know what will happen. As one of my colleagues on the opposite side of the House said earlier, who would ever think that 66 babies born alive in the United Kingdom were left unaided to die after failed abortions. I would never think that would happen in the UK. Also, officials figures show that over a ten year period in Canada, starting in 2000, 491 babies who survived abortions were abandoned by medical staff and left to die alone in the corner of a hospital. I would not want to see that happen in this country, but it happens in the UK, in Wales and in Canada.

In terms of trying to save one life, I ask the Minister to provide clarity on this matter. I cannot understand why he will not consider accepting any of the amendments. This is a simple request. As I said from day one, this is one of the safest countries in the world in which to have a child. I have three children-----

Comment on this

The Deputy's wife had three children

Comment on this

We had three children. I am married. I love my wife and we have three beautiful children and three lovely grandchildren.

Comment on this

Congratulations.

Comment on this

We are a partnership. I hear the commentary about men and women. I have nothing but respect for women. I have nothing but respect for my wife who I have been married to for 35 years, and we are still very happy. I would do anything for my wife. All I am trying to say is that we just need clarity and certainty on this issue. That is all I have asked the Minister to do. It is a very simple request.

Comment on this

I was very disappointed with Deputy O’Connell’s contribution. It seems rather than debating the issues her approach was to attack motives and allege total ignorance with no examination of the issues. I have great respect for Deputy Harty. He strikes me as one of the most caring of people. I bow to his knowledge. I accept that, until now, the entire practise of medicine has been towards saving lives.

It was gratuitous to say we had not thought about this issue. Viability varies, as the Minister said, with the child, the mother, gestation and various other factors. We have all experienced that with family members and we see that in everything to do with the human. There are so many variables in that regard. The idea that we did not understand that is wrong. That is the reason viability is not defined in any specific term of time in the Bill, and all of us agreed on that last night.

Deputy O'Connell referred to intensive care units. If one goes to Britain, one will find some of the greatest care units for born and unborn children that one could find anywhere in the world. Twenty-five years ago, a lady in my parish went to England to have an in-the-womb operation, and that was the early days of such operations, and she now has a fully grown adult son. We all collected money for the hospital. It is also true to say that, side by side with that fantastic care, there is a very vibrant industry whose sole purpose is to take the lives of children. I believe, therefore, that we need to vindicate in the law what the Constitution states, namely, the second one is born one is a citizen and one has a right under law to the vindication of one’s life.

Comment on this

I want to make some brief points. I listened to Deputy Harty with interest and he spoke very well. What he said was that if, as the amendment seeks, it happens that a baby survives abortion, the baby will be looked after. All this amendment would do is enshrine in law that this would happen. It is not too much to ask that this can be done.

Comment on this

The Minister will not be accepting this amendment.

Comment on this

I think this is horrific and despicable. I respect what Deputy Harty said. He is a member of my group and I respect his knowledge. I too, thankfully, have a very healthy grandchild. How dare Deputy O'Connell lecture us about fairy tales or anything else. She shut me out of the committee. I brought in a video of an animated abortion. I asked the chairperson and everybody at the committee to look at it or examine it but, no, they all knew about it. I asked that women hurt by abortion be brought before the committee. They were shut out too. The committee could not get a pro-life doctor. I complimented RTÉ on a national programme it broadcast one night and it was able to get one to participate in it, no problem. The committee could not get one.

Deputy O'Connell suggested we should visit a special care unit in one of the maternity hospitals. I have five daughters and thankfully four granddaughters and we are expecting two more grandchildren, thanks be to God. My little Amy-Berry was born at 30 weeks. Her mother, Tríona had suffered from pre-eclampsia. The care she got in South Tipperary General Hospital, formerly St. Joseph's, in Cork University Hospital and from the neonatal team there was exceptional. I accept that.

It is ill-becoming of Dr. Harty to suggest we are imagining things. We have the figures from England and Canada. Is there some precious line of protection around Ireland such that this will not happen on the island of saints and scholar, that the abortion industry will not get its greedy claws in here and that this will not be done by private industry and private people? We are putting our heads in the sand if we think that. We are appealing for the most basic humane action be taken if an abortion goes wrong.

As Deputy Ó Cuív said, this practice is happening side by side with great care in hospitals in England, and it will happen side by side in our hospitals, according to the Minister, the messiah. He is going to tell them all to do it, even though he will not meet or listen the doctors or the nurses who do not want to do it and there can be no conscientious objection. It will be happening side by side in Ireland as well.

All we want is that it would be enshrined in law, as stated in the Constitution, that every child once they are born, once they breathe their breath, would be protected, as they are supposed to be, but, no, the Minister, Deputy Harris, knows better. He is better than the Constitution now all of a sudden since he went on his journey and changed his position from pro-life to being madly pro-abortion.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 25
·
Níl 59
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Amendments Nos. 41 and 44 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 41:

In page 14, line 29, to delete "or section 14 certification" and substitute ", section 14 certification or section 23 certification".

Amendment No. 41 relates to certification of the records that are kept and the fact that practitioners and people carrying out abortion procedures will be expected to keep records. In the discussion on previous amendments, the Minister and many others set their faces against any compassion or intervention whereby the unfortunate unborn baby would be given medicine or an injection for pain relief. Amendment No. 38 dealt with the most basic human right of all time. I hate equating this with the animal world but many of us born and raised on farms, particularly on mixed farms, understand what is involved, as do people with pets. More importantly, those involved in the equine industry understand the effort, the special funds, the special scanning machines and everything else necessary to ensure the safe delivery of prize foals.

The legislation will be passed and none of the amendments - reasonable and humane as they are and so badly needed for humanity's sake - to offer pain relief where an abortion goes wrong have been accepted. We have given the figures from Canada, England and other jurisdictions where large numbers of babies have been born during abortions and survived. Deputy O'Connell and others ridiculed us for moving the amendment and told us to visit a maternity hospital or a neonatal unit. I have made such visits, as have most of my colleagues. We are all proud parents and grandparents. We also have constituents who, every day of the week, have the joy of bringing new life into this world. This is especially important because tá Mí na Nollag ag teacht Dé Sathairn and that encourages to think about our Creator and the joy Christmas brings. We have been lectured about visiting those places. We have been told that we are insensitive and inhumane and that we listened to fairy stories and fiction about the woman we met. Hundreds and thousands of other people also listened to her story. Listening to what she has to say would bring tears from a stone. She has now bonded with her mother, who was forced to have an abortion and there are now grandchildren. We saw what was forced on that woman because of financial circumstances. It was not fiction. She survived the abortion and is now able to tell that tale all over world in her 42nd year. She came here to talk about it.

The amendment makes a very small change regarding certification in order that there might be records kept and accountability and some transparency, albeit for the wrong reason as far as I am concerned, in the context of the taking of human life. We do not have carte blanche. It would not be for me anyway because I am a layperson. Earlier, Deputy Harty spoke about situations whereby it would not happen in Ireland. I will not question his medical expertise. I would not even dream of doing so. I would not be able to and it would be wrong of me to try to do so. However, I would question his judgment as to why it would never happen here. He mentioned the legislation in the context of the 12-week gestation period, but we know that, in the reckless money-grabbing industry that abortion is throughout the world, there will be late-term and surgical abortions. We know this. Our eyes and ears are closed to the facts, to the information that is there, to the records worldwide and to the industry we are discussing. It is a money-craving industry that involves the sale of body parts and everything else. How can we be sure this will not happen here? We cannot guarantee it.

The intended delivery of a baby can go wrong and, unfortunately, has gone wrong. There is great grief. Others have mentioned fatal foetal abnormality. I do not want to be repetitive but I travelled to Geneva with a brave cohort of ladies from Ireland and other countries to testify at the United Nations in order to try to get that horrible criminal terminology removed from the vocabulary relating to healthcare and children. Despite the diagnosis, some of them live to be minutes, hours, days or weeks old. I know of parishes that have had the most joyous celebrations of people with a life limiting diagnosis. The HSE has adopted the phrase "life-limiting conditions" instead of "fatal foetal abnormalities".

There have been celebrations of life.

The mother has the joyous experience of carrying the baby to full term, feeling the baby kick, the delivery, holding the baby, its first breath and giving it its first food and drink before having to part. However, she has the fingerprints and the footprints, and she has had the joy of creation even if the baby is delivered not healthy and with a life-limiting condition. She has the joy of having it for hours, days, weeks or months. Then there is the sadness, grief and trauma but, importantly, there is a funeral and a marked grave that the parents can visit. All the neighbours - ní neart go cur le chéile - and the meitheal of the community come to help at the wake. That is what we do in Ireland, certainly in rural Ireland and, indeed, in urban Ireland as well. I will not demonise urban Ireland. That is what we are about.

This amendment provides for certification of what happens in the delivery ward, which it should be, although in this case it is the destruction ward. That is the sad thing for our hospitals. I salute the midwives, nurses and the neonatal care, but the two will be side by side in small cubicles in hospitals that are overstretched, overutilised and under pressure. That is the reason I am proposing the amendment.

Comment on this

Certification and records will be very important in every way in the future. Yesterday, I mentioned that a high percentage of women in the UK have had two abortions. I do not wish to discuss that issue but the large percentage who have had up to eight abortions. I believe, and the experts believe, that a high percentage of these women are being abused. It is unknown and is not recorded. They are simply left by themselves and after each abuse are dragged in and basically forced to abort. The fact that there are no proper records of these events taking place is leaving the woman completely violated.

I hope the Minister will accept this amendment. It would provide another protection for the woman in this case, although that is true of many other parts of the Bill. To date, the Minister has not accepted any of our amendments no matter how passionate we were or how compassionate they were. We have all been in hospitals where babies have been born. Listening to Deputy O'Connell, it was as if she was the only person who ever went to one of these hospitals, but we have all been there. Thousands of babies have been born in hospitals throughout the country that are second to none and have given them excellent care. This is a new route we are travelling and, if we do not keep records of what is happening, it will be difficult for us to see the mistakes that will be made here, and it is certain they will be made.

Comment on this

This is another amendment that does not seek to change access to abortion in this country. All it seeks to do is collect information that is necessary to analyse how the service is being provided and to allow people to develop policy on how the service should perhaps change in time. The amendment seeks to broaden the level of information collected. In Britain, for example, a large amount of information is collected. That enables the health service, the government and people who are interested in the subject to analyse what is happening in the system. The development of proper certification and information would shine a light on how it is being delivered. That should be neutral, regardless of what side of the debate one is on. Whether one is pro-choice or pro-life, it is logical that we should have a good understanding of what is happening. This amendment seeks to collect information that would be collected elsewhere. It is hard to understand why the collection of information is a threat to anybody, so I ask the Government to consider supporting it.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, are we discussing amendment No. 41?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is it being discussed with another amendment?

Comment on this

Yes, it is grouped with No. 44 as they are related.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy wish to contribute?

Comment on this

It is being discussed with amendment No. 44 as well.

Comment on this

Yes, amendments Nos. 41 and 44. I am repeating myself. Does Deputy Michael Healy-Rae wish to contribute?

Comment on this

I am just indicating that I support the amendment.

Comment on this

There are no further contributions so I will call the Minister.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, I did not realise amendment No. 44 was included. Can I have a further one or two minutes?

Comment on this

It is very clear. Amendments Nos. 41 and 44 are related and will be discussed together. I already said this. If Deputies wish to contribute they have seven minutes in which to do so. I will give Deputy Tóibín two minutes.

Comment on this

I am sure the Ceann Comhairle made that statement but I did not hear it.

Comment on this

I can assure you it was made.

Comment on this

Yes. Regarding the provision of ultrasound, again this is another issue that is difficult to understand. The issue of abortion was dressed up by the Minister as a choice which was logical and beneficial and should be introduced into Irish law. All this amendment regarding ultrasound desires is that a choice is given to a mother whereby she would be able to look at the ultrasound if she wishes. It is a choice that also can be declined if the mother so wishes. There is no effort here to force anybody to see information that the person does not wish to see.

We know that informed choices are the best choices. I have met a large number of individuals who have suffered from abortion regret. It is one of the dirty little secrets that society does not wish to talk about, but a significant proportion of individuals suffer from abortion regret. Abortion regret is a very serious issue. People often suffer great pain and anguish for their entire lives as a result. The provision of information allows people to be able to make informed decisions. I have spoken to people who told me that they did not realise the heart was beating at such a young age or that the unborn child was so well formed at 12 weeks. They did not realise the decision they were making. Asking the person if she wishes to have this information would be the logical thing to do. Ultrasound is not a threatening device in any way. It is a medical device that is designed to help in healthcare. I cannot understand why that choice is not being afforded to people.

There is also great unease among doctors about this. They are being asked to provide abortions in many cases without the technology to enable them to understand the exact health situation of the mother and unborn child. There is significant worry and fear among doctors that if they do not have an ultrasound to make the necessary decision, first, they will not be doing the best for the mothers or the unborn children concerned and, second, they will put themselves in a very exposed situation because they will be making decisions without the best clinical diagnostic tools that are necessary. It is beyond comprehension. I had this debate with the Minister previously. He admitted that in many, if not most, cases where these decisions are made, an ultrasound will probably be necessary, although he also said that he did not yet have clear information from his advisers that it would be necessary. I am asking that this amendment be considered for the protection of the mothers, the unborn children and the doctors.

Comment on this

The importance of ultrasound for determining the gestational age of the unborn child and for protecting the life or health of the woman who is undergoing an abortion cannot be overstated, particularly in circumstances where there are concerns about dating the pregnancy or where there is an ectopic pregnancy. Dr. Peter Boylan, chairperson of the Institute of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, explicitly informed the Joint Committee on Health on 19 September 2018, when it was discussing the clinical guidelines for the introduction of abortion services, that from nine to 12 weeks women will require hospital management which in turn raises the question of ultrasound as a dating mechanism.

According to Dr. Boylan’s testimony at the committee, figures can vary but in Scotland, for example, approximately 30% of women will require a scan for uncertain dates and the figure here will probably be similar. He also spoke about the risks of introducing a termination of pregnancy service without having adequate scanning facilities in place and noted current infrastructural deficits in the provision of access to ultrasound services during pregnancy in Ireland. This deficit raises very serious concerns with respect to the intention of the Minister for Health to have abortion services rolled out nationally as early as January of next year. These concerns were confirmed by Dr. John O’Brien, speaking on behalf of the Irish College of General Practitioners, ICGP, in reply to a question from Deputy Stephen Donnelly. Dr. Mary Favier of the ICGP also informed the committee that the evidence base on the need for ultrasound scanning is becoming clearer. Dr. Favier added that if ultrasound is required, rapid access to this facility, including the expert provision and interpretation of sonographs, will be a critical element of the pathway. In addition, a 24-hour helpline, staffed by appropriately trained clinical staff, will be required. Dr. Favier further noted that GPs have expressed concern regarding capacity and resourcing challenges in areas such as staffing, facilities and training, the potential lack of appropriate specialist support, the possibility of medical complications for patients, and a fear of litigation. All of these points underscore the necessity of introducing a legal obligation to perform an ultrasound for both the woman and her doctor. The taking of mifepristone and misoprostol, the so-called abortion pills, in the absence of an ultrasound can lead to potentially catastrophic blood loss for the woman concerned.

Confirmation of gestational age is also required for compliance with section 13 of the Bill, which deals with certification relating to early pregnancy, that is, prior to 12 weeks. This underscores the fact that ultrasound will become a routine part of care in this area.

In light of the experts' view of ultrasound as forming a key part of dating pregnancy and determining foetal age, it appears to be reckless in the extreme to even contemplate rolling out abortion services nationally in the face of such challenges in accessing ultrasound. It was a key concern of the Citizens’ Assembly in its ancillary recommendation that all pregnant women, regardless of geographical location or ability to pay, should have access to early scanning and testing. Amendment No. 44 seeks to ensure there is a clear framework in place regarding the duties on medical personnel to use ultrasound in a manner that is clear in law. The amendment offers clarity and certainty for medical personnel, which the Minister repeatedly insists he wants to be provided in the legislation. It also provides clarity and certainty for women and in no way restricts their access to termination of pregnancy.

Comment on this

I will first address amendment No. 41. Records are important to ensure that doctors are made aware when a woman who has already had an abortion is about to have a second or third abortion. I am sure there are implications for the women in question and they need to be protected given the level of care they need. It is very important that proper records are kept to determine if there is an external reason for a woman having more than one abortion.

On amendment No. 44, I have been asked a lot of questions about the issue of ultrasound and how a general practitioner would determine if the baby to be aborted is less than 12 weeks in gestation. Will the Minister clarify if a doctor can determine the exact number of days or weeks of a pregnancy without having access to an ultrasound? I am also aware that ultrasound scans are not available to every GP in rural areas. We are lucky to have such a facility in Kenmare but that does not mean it is available to all the GPs in the town at the same time. Will the Minister provide funding for ultrasound equipment for every GP? If so, will GPs be able to operate this equipment? This is an important issue. A woman or girl is entitled to see the ultrasound of her baby. Failure to support this amendment would mean we are not supporting a woman's entitlement to see an ultrasound of her baby if she wished to do so. It is clear that we should support the amendment. I ask Deputies to support the amendment and the important reason for tabling it.

Comment on this

We will now hear from the Deputy's brother, Deputy Michael Healy-Rae.

Comment on this

I thank the Ceann Comhairle. There was a bit of confusion because I did not realise that we were taking amendments Nos. 41 and 44 together. I was neglectful in failing to spot that. I am glad we are discussing the two amendments together and I am glad of the opportunity to speak to them.

With regard to amendment No. 41, in my honest and humble opinion having all types of clarification and certification of records is terribly important. It would be very remiss of us if we were not to make this important amendment to the Bill. As I said earlier, I cannot understand why people would not want to have certification and clear records because it is in the interests of everybody concerned, including the lady and the medical practitioners.

This leads me to amendment No. 44 and the use of ultrasound imaging. The purpose of the amendment is to provide protection for the lady and doctor. It is about facts and information and I believe the best clinical advice would be to have an ultrasound. It is amazing to see the Minister for Health agreeing to fund ultrasound services. This is great coming from a Minister who cannot fund hip operations or cataract removals. He is now able to produce money all of a sudden. That is fine. We debated that issue last night and I will not repeat the arguments. It is definitely best medical practice and it is also in the interests of everyone concerned to make provision for ultrasound imaging. One aspect of our proposal to offer a person the right to see or hear an ultrasound has been misrepresented. Nobody has said this would be compulsory, as some in the media like to portray it. There was no such proposal.

If the Minister is sincere in his wish to implement the will of the people, I see no reason to reject amendment No. 44. On Committee Stage, I stated that the importance of ultrasound in determining the gestational age of the unborn child and protecting the life or health of the woman who is undergoing an abortion cannot be overstated, especially in circumstances where there are concerns about dating of the pregnancy or in cases of an ectopic pregnancy. I cannot understand why people would be against this proposal. That is all I want to say on the matter.

Comment on this

Beidh mé ag labhairt ar leasú Uimh. 44.

I reiterate what has already been said. This is a very reasonable amendment. It is about giving choice and opportunity. Nobody is forcing anything on anybody or on any woman in a distressed situation. The woman who comes in in an emergency situation is exempt from this. We simply wish to make the point that the importance of ultrasounds for determining the gestational age of the unborn child and for protecting the life or health of the woman who is undergoing an abortion cannot be overstated, particularly in circumstances where there are concerns about the dating in the pregnancy. There was much discussion on that element through the committee and so on. It seems very reasonable that we would have this amendment provided for. It also would relate to cases of ectopic pregnancy, as has been pointed out.

We have heard here already that the Amárach survey findings published last month show that 79% of adults agree with offering this choice to women on seeing an ultrasound. I do not think that survey result should be discarded or ignored. The results of it need to be respected. We cannot just decide to go with something as we please. The results of that survey are plain to see. Contrary to the false reporting that has taken place on this matter, the amendment does not oblige or force a pregnant woman to view any ultrasound image or receive any other information relating to the imaging and monitoring performed. The amendment in no way restricts women's access, as we have pointed out on a number of occasions. I feel it is worthwhile repeating this point to ensure it is not misrepresented in the media. That point has been made over and over tonight and, hopefully, it will be conveyed very clearly. As we have stated, a woman is of course entitled to see the ultrasound and not supporting this amendment means not supporting a woman's entitlement. We have heard so much about the right of a woman to information and all the rest of it and why not? I cannot see why the Minister would go against such a reasonable amendment. It is interesting that the only way to manufacture any controversy about this amendment was by false reporting, which I found very offensive as a woman. It was mentioned that we were forcing women to view ultrasounds and I find that very offensive.

Comment on this

The Deputy is forcing them to have one, though.

Comment on this

Excuse me. This is not going to start again, is it? It is just ridiculous. It is unbelievable.

Comment on this

The Deputy should relax.

Comment on this

A disgrace, that is what those Deputies are, an absolute disgrace.

Comment on this

That is an overreaction.

Comment on this

Now, Deputies-----

Comment on this

Can I please continue?

Comment on this

Let me be clear. If we have further interruptions I will suspend the House.

Comment on this

That is fine but the interruptions are coming one way, a Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this

I do not care where they come from.

Comment on this

They are coming one way.

Comment on this

I do not care where they come from. If there are further interruptions or derogatory comments, I will suspend the House.

Comment on this

Yes, and I hope the media carry that as well and report the truth. According to Dr. Boylan's testimony at the committee, figures vary. In Scotland, for example, approximately 30% of women will require a scan for uncertain dates and it will probably be something similar here. Why would we be any different from Scotland? I think that is a good indication. Dr. Boylan also spoke about the risks of introducing a termination of pregnancy service in this State without adequate scanning facilities and highlighted how at present there are infrastructural deficits in the provision of access to ultrasound in pregnancy in Ireland.

Go raibh maith agat, a Cheann Comhairle, sin na príomhphointí.

Comment on this

We hear a lot about opinion polls, Amárach being one, but we had a really big one where people went out and voted in the referendum in May. The people have made their decision. As politicians, we all take passing interest to various degrees in opinion polls but the only one that matters is the ballot. People made their decision in respect of this.

This is not an amendment about choice, far from it. This is an amendment about a bunch of politicians telling doctors what to do in terms of the diagnostic tools they use and, if they do not follow that mandate, offering them a prison sentence of up to a year. To be clear, that is what Deputy Nolan's amendment does. She is right that the woman has to have the ultrasound according to this amendment. Deputy Nolan is not going to force her to look at the heartbeat or the screen but mandatorily, under her amendment, every single woman would have to have an ultrasound and every single doctor would have to carry one out. This is about choice. Of course there is a need for ultrasound in obstetrics; that is not really the question. It is not for Deputy Nolan or me to tell our doctors when to use the ultrasound machine. The idea that we must scan every woman to date her pregnancy is kind of bizarre. Many thousands of women will have gone to their GP today in early pregnancy and with their doctor, based on their last menstrual period, LMP, will have worked out the stage of pregnancy they are at.

I get frustrated, and we also had a bit of it last night, by this idea that until every other issue in the health service is sorted out and no one is waiting for any other procedure, we cannot invest any money whatsoever in crisis pregnancies and women's healthcare; that women's healthcare must come last. Until every man has a new hip or every man has had his cataract done, we cannot invest in women's healthcare. This is healthcare and just as the Deputies come in here and demand that I should do more in all the other things, they should be demanding we do more on this and it is worrying that they are not. This amendment would force doctors, based on no medical reason but the views of politicians, to scan every women mandatorily, to face a prison sentence if they do not do it and to subject every woman to an ultrasound. It would be a terrible use of what people rightly point out is a scarce resource in the health service.

I can categorically state that Dr. Boylan would not be supporting this amendment as somebody offering me clinical advice on the implementation of this service. I am sure he would not like to be quoted in any way suggesting he is supportive of it. Dr. Boylan is absolutely right to highlight, as many doctors have, that we absolutely do need to provide ultrasound for cases when our doctors believe we need to use them, not for when politicians do. I am not in a position to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Spread the damage. Try to say we are trying to force any pregnant woman to see an ultrasound.

Comment on this

No, not see.

Comment on this

We are merely asking that ultrasounds be offered and be taken and that any professional standards be maintained. Dr. Boylan, who was quoted, has been appointed as a lead on this whole matter. I would love to know what kind of a contract he has and what kind of remuneration he is on because this is a very lucrative position.

Comment on this

That is not relevant, really, Deputy.

Comment on this

It is; he mentioned Dr. Boylan.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

It is. Dr. Boylan is rolled out as the lead-----

Comment on this

Deputy Nolan mentioned him first.

Comment on this

No, Deputy, please. Deputy Mattie McGrath has two minutes.

Comment on this

They are being wasted now. I will not be repetitive but am just saying the Minister knows of a situation in Clonmel. He visited a medical practice that wanted to provide ultrasound services for the people of south Tipperary and west Waterford and gave eight months to discussing it. After the Minister's intervention and many senior meetings, hey presto, they rang me on Friday evening and were delighted.

Comment on this

They got an offer to enable them to provide what the Minister should be doing, namely, provide for the people who are on a waiting list for six months and clogging up the accident and emergency departments in South Tipperary General Hospital and University Hospital Waterford. After eight days, the contract was pulled. The Minister told me himself when I chatted to him privately and publicly that he had no money to pay for it.

Comment on this

I do not recall that.

Comment on this

There was talk about money and leaving people go blind or to leave the hips go. We are not like that at all. We are compassionate people and have compassion for everybody. As for those appalling messes over which the Minister is presiding in the HSE, it gets worse by the hour. We want the Minister to make some effort on that and to have some impact but he is unable to do it. If he had any respect for the Parliament, he would have resigned long ago but that is another area. We make no apology for wanting to help people with cataracts or for the lads bussing them up to Belfast and getting them done under the European directive. The Minister should be ashamed. Meanwhile our medics are going out to Third World countries and doing this operation in field tents for people who are going blind out there. They are doing it voluntarily all over the world. This amendment does not say that we would coerce any pregnant woman to look at an ultrasound.

Comment on this

But to have one.

Comment on this

It does oblige women to have one, it is mandatory.

Comment on this

It does not say that anywhere. The Minister can nod all he likes but it does not.

Comment on this

Many pro-choice GPs have expressed concerns about the lack of availability of an ultrasound. It should be made available for doctors and offered to women to see the ultrasound. In many abortion clinics it is used but women are often discouraged from looking at the screen or hearing their baby's heartbeat.

Sadly this is not to protect the women because they know if a woman sees or hears the baby's heartbeat, she often changes her mind, as within the abortion industry more abortions are good. I recently attended a meeting in Bandon where this was discussed. A lady had travelled 95 miles to the clinic and after seeing the ultrasound she changed her mind because that clinic provides the opportunity to hear the ultrasound which is great. If compassion for the woman was at the heart of the vote in May, why would we not ensure women are offered information about their babies, information that has been shown to impact abortion decisions?

The Minister mentioned putting women first. He is dead right; we should put women first. I ask him to come to west Cork or parts of Kerry tomorrow morning where they will be getting up at 5 a.m. to go for cataract operations because of the efforts of Deputy Danny Healy-Rae and me. If it were not for that, they would be going blind. Those women were not put first by the Minister. He has had ample time to resolve that mess. They are going to have their hips attended to because they are in agony and cannot get a hip operation here. The Minister talks about putting women first; I ask him to look at other areas where women could be put first and have been put last. They were going blind and have got their sight back thanks to the people in Northern Ireland under the cross-Border health directive. The Minister should not tell us that we would not put women first. We certainly have, but he has failed to do so in the past few years and he will have failed to do so if he refuses to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister said that the ultrasound will not be available in all GP practices. When the girl or woman goes to her GP and he does not have ultrasound equipment but her medical card only covers her for him, what will happen then? We need an honest answer to that.

As Deputy Michael Collins said, it is regrettable that the Minister is portraying us as if we have no care for pregnant women or women who just choose not to have their baby. That is not true. We have, as we have stated, a high regard for life. Where the Minister in his role has let them down, we are doing our best to get people looked after in the North. A woman will need to leave Dingle tomorrow morning and travel all the way up to Belfast just to save her eye. We are doing our best to ensure her eyesight is saved. It is wrong for the Minister to say we have no care for women.

We have care for men too because they are facing the same dilemma. They are not being looked after and they are losing their sight as well, as we have told the Minister in this House several times over the past two years. The Minister still has not made a difference or changed anything. He is just not listening. Maybe he will look after the people in urban areas, on the east coast or inside the Pale, but he is not looking after them where we come from. We regret that he made that comparison. I am very disappointed.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy; he is over time.

Comment on this

It is not really us, but the elderly people who are travelling all that distance who need to be admired. They are trying to do their best to save their own faculties and ensure they see daylight for the bit of time they have left in this world.

Comment on this

The issue of ultrasound is quite complicated. I will try to clarify it within the four parameters the legislation proposes. Under the first parameter it is proposed that termination can occur if there is a risk to the life or health of the mother. In that instance, that baby is a much-wanted baby. Circumstances have overcome that pregnancy such that the life or health of that woman is at risk. That woman will have had several ultrasounds because her pregnancy will be monitored. There will be no necessity for her to have a compulsory ultrasound. She will have ultrasound carried out during normal obstetric practice. In the issue of the risk to the life or health of the mother, there will be ultrasounds to monitor that pregnancy. It will be a much-wanted pregnancy and it will be devastating for that mother if that pregnancy has to be terminated to preserve her life or preserve her health.

In the case of risk to life in an emergency, there may or may not be an ultrasound, or there may or may not be time for an ultrasound. It is not relevant in that situation.

When we come to the condition likely to lead to the death of a foetus or fatal foetal abnormality, again there will have been many ultrasounds in that circumstance. There will be high-definition ultrasounds to identify accurately the fatal foetal abnormality. Again it is not an issue regarding this amendment.

The fourth issue relates to early pregnancy. Ultrasound may or may not be clinically indicated in such a pregnancy. It may be necessary to have an ultrasound to date that pregnancy, but that will be a clinical decision. This amendment contains the word "shall" which means it must take place at least 24 hours before termination of pregnancy. I accept that people seeking a termination before 12 weeks' gestation may, from a clinical point of view, need an ultrasound to date their pregnancy or possibly to identify an ectopic pregnancy. Those are very reasonable reasons to seek an ultrasound. However, enshrining that in legislation is not the way to go about it. That will be a clinical decision.

I am reading one part of the amendment which may make the amendment invalid. The proposed new section 23(9)(i) states:

(i) in the case of a termination of pregnancy to be carried out in accordance with section 10 or 12, the obstetrician by whom the termination of pregnancy is to be carried out, and

Those are the wrong sections because a new section was inserted on Committee Stage. Therefore that should read section 11 or 14, I think. In the proposed new section 23(9)(ii) I believe section 13 should be section 14. There are technical issues with the amendment anyway.

Ultrasound is a complex issue, but for many of the circumstances in which women will seek a termination, ultrasounds will already have been carried out. It is only in early pregnancy that there may be a need for an ultrasound to date the pregnancy or to rule out an ectopic pregnancy.

Comment on this

The emergence of this proposed mandatory ultrasound reflects exactly the mindset of those trying to reverse the decision in the case of Roe v. Wade in the United States. We discussed this in Committee. In discussing this amendment we need to consider to whom we are doing it. This is placing a necessity on a woman to have an ultrasound in the most difficult of circumstances. The amendment in its essence is designed to inflict pain and to attempt to impose some sort of guilt. Deputy Harty outlined the scenarios, showing it is unnecessary. This is a direct derivative of the carry-on in the United States that attempts to reverse Roe v. Wade. People should be aware of where some of these notions come from.

Comment on this

We spoke about this in Committee. This and many of the other amendments are designed to shame women and make them feel bad about something that could be extremely traumatic such as a case of fatal foetal abnormality or other severe abnormality.

The Deputies want somebody to be forced to have an ultrasound and, as proposed in some of the other amendments, to watch a DVD or be shown images on a website. A relative of mine recently had a fatal foetal abnormality with twins and when she read these amendments, she contacted me. She was horrified and asked if those people had any idea about this entire situation. I had not intended to speak but that should be put on the Dáil record. I am aware it is on the record of the select committee.

It is now 8.40 p.m. It is clear we will not get this Bill passed tonight. It is now urgent that on Tuesday, or whatever day, sufficient time is provided to conclude this debate because the filibustering has an impact. Women have had to travel since May, and people have had enough. Two thirds of people voted in the referendum, including in the constituencies of the Members who are present, and that mandate has to be respected. Every amendment has been put to a vote. Every one of the proposers has taken their seven minutes and two minutes-----

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not been here.

Comment on this

The Deputy took them as well.

Comment on this

Please, Deputies.

Comment on this

They are ignoring the decision people made, having had a rigorous debate for months.

Comment on this

On a point of order-----

Comment on this

I will take the Deputy's point of order in a minute.

Comment on this

There is no other purpose to this than to delay. We have all their handmaid's tale amendments in which they propose that women be forced to do this, that and the other.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

People will have abortions. They do not like it. Let them do that and stop this shaming and punishing of women for making that decision.

Comment on this

For the record, not every amendment has been voted on. A number of amendments have been agreed.

Comment on this

The amendments from the ten Deputies have all been voted on.

Comment on this

This is a democracy.

Comment on this

She does not believe in that.

Comment on this

I will defend the Deputy's right-----

Comment on this

I am sure the Ceann Comhairle will.

Comment on this

-----to make her point to my last breath, but, equally, I will defend every other Member's right to make their point.

Comment on this

I know, but the point I was making was that every amendment they have tabled-----

Comment on this

This is a democratic Chamber. All sorts of parliamentary devices and methodologies have been used over the years and provided they are in order and appropriate, I do not see any difficulty. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae wanted to make a point of order.

Comment on this

On a point of order and for clarification, it has been incorrectly stated that every Member used his or her time.

Comment on this

That has been clarified.

Comment on this

First, if we did, we only used what we were entitled to use. Second, the Deputy is factually incorrect. For instance, I stood up here several times when I was entitled to speak for seven minutes but I spoke for less than two. The Deputy should not put lies on the record of the Dáil. She should not mislead the Dáil.

Comment on this

There are women waiting on this legislation to be passed.

Comment on this

We are not delaying anything. The Deputy is.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Healy-Rae for his advice.

Comment on this

I respect the decision made in the referendum. Two thirds of the population voted "Yes" and one third voted "No", therefore, we have to speak on behalf of more than 725,000. We have to go back to our constituencies, as do the Deputies opposite.

The Minister said a few minutes ago that he would like to start spending money. He can start by buying ultrasound machines.

He spoke about the amendment. The amendment requires a doctor, nurse or midwife to perform an ultrasound and to detect a foetal heartbeat when present. It also ensures that a woman who wishes to view the ultrasound and hear the heartbeat can do so. The amendment also includes a requirement to certify that those steps have been taken as well as specifying that certain minimum standards for the monitoring are carried out. That is to ensure clinical best practice as part of a routine monitoring procedure that ought to be carried out as a matter of course. The amendment makes it clear that it is up to the woman concerned whether she wishes to view the ultrasound image and hear the heartbeat. It is up to the woman to decide what she wants to do.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Minister said he wanted to start spending. If he wants to do that, let him buy new ultrasound machines to be allocated to hospitals throughout the country.

Comment on this

Does the Minister want to conclude this debate?

Comment on this

I think I have said it already.

Comment on this

I want to put on the record that we tabled fewer than 20 amendments out of 66. In the debate at the Select Committee on Health, we tabled one sixth of the total amendments. It is factually incorrect to say all of us spoke for seven minutes and then two minutes. I would like the House to be aware of that and the record to be corrected, but I do not think it will happen. As Deputy Fitzpatrick said, we have never said that the woman would have to look at an ultrasound image.

Comment on this

She will have to have one.

Comment on this

Can I continue? We have more of it here, a Cheann Comhairle. Where is the democracy? I appeal to the Ceann Comhairle. An offer will be made to the woman to view the ultrasound image and listen to the heartbeat. If that is impossible for some people, we do not want to be cruel about that. I was present when my wife gave birth to all my babies and it was wonderful to hear the heartbeat and see the movements. It was the most delightful occasion I could ever experience. To be told here by Deputies O'Connell and Coppinger that we have notions or that we are raving. Thankfully, we are not all backward, as they like to portray us. We have wives and families as well.

Comment on this

Backwards-----

Comment on this

Please, Deputy.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Connell had been here when we were talking about it, she would know that but she has been in and out tweeting, doing media interviews or whatever else.

Comment on this

No, Deputy-----

Comment on this

If she was here, she would have heard it.

Comment on this

On a point of order, that is defamatory. It is not true. The Deputy should retract it.

Comment on this

If the Deputies wish to engage in this bickering, I will suspend the House and they can go outside and bicker all they like.

Comment on this

I have never bickered in my life.

Comment on this

Please, Deputy.

Comment on this

Can I finish, without interruption?

Comment on this

Excuse me, a Cheann Comhairle. The Deputy cast a slur that I was doing media. I have not done any media to date so he should retract it.

Comment on this

I said the Deputy left the Chamber and, therefore, she did not hear our contributions.

Comment on this

I heard their contributions. I am listening to the Deputy's contributions for years.

Comment on this

I could say other places as well.

Comment on this

It is the fourth time around the block-----

Comment on this

Can we all just treat each other with a modicum of respect please?

Comment on this

He must retract.

Comment on this

Retract what?

Comment on this

He said I was out doing media. That is not true.

Comment on this

She is looking for headlines again.

Comment on this

The Deputy is the one doing that, coming up to 9 o'clock.

Comment on this

First, it is not a sin to be out doing media.

Comment on this

It is not a sin but it is not true.

Comment on this

If it were, many people here would be in serious difficulty.

Comment on this

The point is that it is not true. The Deputy should retract it.

Comment on this

Can I continue? It was said we had notions in our heads and that we were dreaming up these amendments. Deputy Harty pointed out that they might be on the wrong sections.

Comment on this

The Deputy is over time now.

Comment on this

I do not believe they are, but I was interrupted.

Comment on this

The Deputy was.

Comment on this

We have given careful consideration to these amendments. We tabled a limited number and we are not coercing anybody to do anything. I thank the Ceann Comhairle for protecting our right to speak. Some would like to silence us.

Comment on this

I will be brief. I did not intend to speak on amendment No. 44 but its proposers and those who spoke in favour of it are being deliberately disingenuous and selective in what they have read from to the House. I ask them to note the first point in it, namely, "The relevant medical practitioner shall perform ultrasound imaging of the foetus".

Comment on this

It states "shall", not "may". That signifies absolute compulsion.

Comment on this

Not to look at it.

Comment on this

Not to look at it. I will not go into any personal details but that implies compulsion. If that does not happen, the amendment further states: "...the relevant medical practitioner shall obtain the signature of the pregnant woman on the certification referred to in subsection (5) verifying that it is factually correct". Do the Deputies believe that is the appropriate time to ask an expectant mother who might be going through a crisis pregnancy to do that? Furthermore, if the practitioner does not do it, the amendment states that a person who is guilty of a criminal offence is liable to 12 months in prison or "on conviction on indictment to a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding 4 years, or both,". That is for not carrying out an ultrasound. The practitioner then may ask the woman if she wants to see the image. Are they being serious? There is compulsion implied in that amendment and we should be straight and honest with people about that.

Comment on this

I had not intended to speak on this amendment either but, to be brutally frank, despite the play and messing around with words, the amendment is clear. It states: "...the relevant medical practitioner or a qualified person assisting the relevant medical practitioner shall perform [an] ultrasound".

For the benefit of those who signed their names to the amendment, there is no version of ultrasound that does not involve the woman being present. A pregnant woman cannot have an ultrasound in another room and, therefore, it is clear that she will be present and she will hear and see. In case she does not, she must sign at the end anyway.

I struggle with this because I am not sure what the point is. Any pregnant woman can ask for an ultrasound. Nobody in the Chamber has asked more questions about the provision of scanning facilities than me, which the Minister will know.

Comment on this

It is woefully inadequate and, as an Opposition spokesperson on health, I intend to hold the Government to account in this regard, but that is not what the amendment is about. There is an element of shaming or judgment in it, and there is no version of this that does not involve causing distress for a pregnant woman. Any pregnant woman can ask for an ultrasound if she feels she needs one or if she needs help making her decision and has not fully made up her mind. It is the job of the Minister to ensure the facilities are there, and we will do all we can do make that happen. To suggest, however, that somehow there must be an ultrasound is unfair and judgmental, and no good can come from it.

There is no choice in the amendment because it states "the medical practitioner shall perform ultrasound imaging of the foetus". We must be clear about that.

Comment on this
Deputy Stephen S. Donnelly

I did not intend to speak on the amendment either and I will be brief. This country has a dark and shameful history in its control of women, their health and their reproductive rights. It all comes down to controlling women, their bodies and their reproductive health. It has gone on for a long time and we are still finding out some dark things about our past.

Whether or not it is the intention of those tabling it, the amendment feels like the foregoing. The amendment provides that a woman who presents at her general practitioner, or as Deputy Harty - a doctor - said, a woman who gets in trouble and whose life or health is at serious risk, will be forced to travel to a hospital, undergo multiple diagnoses and, when she says that she does not want to see an ultrasound, she will be forced to sign a form confirming that she has refused to see these forced diagnoses. If the doctor does not do all of that, he or she will go to jail, which is what the amendment states. It is deeply regrettable that we must have a debate about treating women and trying to control them in this way during the debate about this legislation or any debate about legislation.

Comment on this

I intend to make the majority of my contribution on the section which is related to conscientious objection, on which I have strong feelings.

Subsection (7) of the amendment states: "A medical practitioner who contravenes subsection (1), (4), (5) or (6) shall be guilty of an offence." In a few days, I will contribute to the debate about the rights of medical practitioners, including doctors, pharmacists and midwives, to conscientiously object and opt out of the legislation. I cannot make an argument, nor can I see how anyone could, that a medical practitioner who contravenes the amendment shall be guilty of an offence. The amendment is poorly thought out and I ask those who moved it to withdraw it because it significantly weakens other arguments which they and I may have. It makes no sense to me.

Comment on this

I wish to provide some clarification on this issue. Professor Boylan gave testimony to the Joint Committee on the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution to the effect that he felt it would be necessary for an ultrasound to be available to women in the provision of abortion services. He also stated that it would be logical for an ultrasound to be a device used in the provision of the service. An ultrasound is a medical device used to help people; it is not threatening in any way. Many doctors have stated that, in cases of ectopic pregnancy or other situations where women may present at the surgery and may be provided with an abortion pill and so on, it is important for those doctors to have the diagnostic tools to ensure their care for the woman in those scenarios is care they can confidently stand over. We had this conversation in the committee, which was a more reasonable debate on this. There was not any suggestion that this would in some way be a threat to an individual-----

Comment on this

Yes, there was.

Comment on this

-----by most people in that regard. The ultrasound is useful for establishing the gestational age of the unborn child, which is necessary, and the woman will be asked whether she wants to see it. It is included in the amendment because abortion regret is a significant issue.

Comment on this

No, it is not. It is nothing.

Comment on this

This is about making the woman regret what happened to her. The Deputy admitted it himself. There is a contradiction in what he said.

Comment on this

Will Deputies please stop interrupting the Deputy in possession?

Comment on this

Deputy Tóibín is making up abortion regret.

Comment on this

Why must the Deputies shout down people with different opinions? If they did not shout, people would be finished here already.

Comment on this

It is my fault, in that case.

Comment on this

Deputy Coppinger cannot help but get the last word every time.

Comment on this

Abortion regret-----

Comment on this

Abortion regret does not exist.

Comment on this

People may disagree with me about abortion regret.

Comment on this

It is not a condition. It is made up.

Comment on this

It is clear that some Deputies have certain views about abortion regret. I have been told by many women that they have experienced it.

Comment on this

They all come knocking on the Deputy's door.

Comment on this

There is something fundamentally undemocratic in refusing to allow people speak, simply because one is in disagreement with them. Deputy Tóibín, without interruption.

Comment on this

It is difficult for women to sit and listen to this.

Comment on this

It might be difficult but much of life is difficult and we must put up with it. Will Deputy Tóibín conclude if he has not done so?

Comment on this

We represent citizens who have told us they have experienced abortion regret. On many occasions, abortion regret is significant, and some of those individuals have told us they did not know all the information at the time and they would prefer to have had more information. The amendment is simply to provide information to the woman.

Comment on this

Abortion regret is made up and it does not exist. The amendment is faux concern for women and what it suggests is frightening, namely, mandating ultrasound. There is no choice for women. It is not about protecting women but rather judging, embarrassing and making them feel bad in the hope that if they are shamed, they might continue with the pregnancy because it suits the Deputies and their agenda.

The amendment goes on to mandate prison sentences for doctors who do not comply with it. It states "Before or during the imaging" the woman will be asked whether she wants to look at the ultrasound. In practice, is the doctor supposed to rock up, scan her stomach and ask if she would like to take a look at it? It is utterly ridiculous. If the screen is there, it is hard to avert one's eyes. There is nothing in the amendment that speaks to consent, permission, bodily autonomy or the woman and what is best or right for her.

Ultrasound is a diagnostic tool and it is for the doctors to decide. Many Deputies seem to believe they have acquired the expertise of medical professionals but they have not. We have all discussed the issue for some time, but I am not a doctor and nor are most of the Deputies, although there are some. The suggestion that the Deputies know what is best about how a diagnostic tool should and can be used is utterly ridiculous. The concern for women is misplaced at best.

Comment on this