Confidence in the Minister for Housing, Planning and Local Government: Motion [Private Members]
Contributions 133–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
And Fine Gael's support for cutting the-----
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Eoghan Murphy, and the Tánaiste, Deputy Coveney, had to rebuild a model that was workable on the ashes of the previous approach. That is the reality that has had to be taken on.
Comment on this
Eight years in government.
Comment on this
Homelessness is increasing every year.
Comment on this
Ten thousand homeless.
Comment on this
-----figures selectively, but the truth is that, under the Minister, we have seen for the past four years the number of houses built increasing by 25% per annum. That was 25% in 2016, 25% in 2017, 25% in 2018 and 25% in 2019. That is a housing policy that is delivering.
Comment on this
Some 10,000 people are homeless, Minister.
Comment on this
Anyone who takes a moment to consider the question of what is needed in this country-----
Comment on this
There are 10,000 homeless.
Comment on this
-----will see that it is more housing supply. I heard my good friend from the Royal County, Deputy Cassells, saying that his party was the author of local authority housing. The truth is that, at that stage, 10% at most of housing was social housing. Under the Minister, 40% of housing built this year will be social housing, as it was last year.
Comment on this
The past does not count, so.
Comment on this
Giving the money to landlords.
Comment on this
That is not true, Minister.
Comment on this
We are delivering a consistent strategy. Of course we realise that the number-----
Comment on this
The landlords' government giving money to the landlords.
Comment on this
-----that we need to reach is higher than was first thought. We must continue to pursue this policy so that we can deliver.
Comment on this
Make the landlords richer.
Comment on this
Deputy Ó Broin, whom I respect greatly,-----
Comment on this
-----often lambasted the Government in the Chamber for failing to see new social housing being built. I did not hear him comment that the number of social houses being built now is seven times what it was in 2016. That is the reality.
Comment on this
Social housing is being transformed. We have a delivery pipeline that is now delivering for people.
Comment on this
My good friend, Deputy Eamon Ryan, stated that the Government was allowing for private developers and a collapse of the well-honed policy that he wanted to deliver. This is the first Government that introduced its own land development agency.
Comment on this
We have not even passed the legislation.
Comment on this
We now have a State developer that will shape the sorts of development we want to see and-----
Comment on this
-----accumulate sites in the cities of Waterford, Cork, Galway and Limerick where we want to see compact development and growth so that we can break the perverse regional balance from which we have suffered for many years.
Far from voting no confidence in the Minister, tonight is a night when we should be endorsing the work he is doing because it will deliver.
Comment on this
I call the Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection, Deputy Regina Doherty.
Comment on this
We have a manufactured debate in the Chamber tonight. Certain Deputies on the other side of the House would like to present this debate as the very caring Opposition against the big, nasty Government as if we did not care.
Comment on this
It is a cartoon version of politics that bears no relation to the reality of what Rebuilding Ireland is achieving. We do care. I am sure that everyone in the House cares. Like every other politician, we meet families week in, week out who are trying to get on the property ladder.
Comment on this
What do Ministers say to them?
Comment on this
We meet parents who are saving for their deposits no more than Opposition Members or we did-----
Comment on this
Record homelessness.
Comment on this
-----when we were in our 20s and 30s. Owning a home, having a roof over one's head, is fundamental to the Irish psyche. That is why, when we entered into government in 2016, Fine Gael actually asked for the housing portfolio and developed a plan called Rebuilding Ireland. The Labour Party stated that its Government had no money. With respect, though, no foundations of a social housing plan were put in place when the Labour Party owned housing policy.
Comment on this
Absolutely wrong. Did the Minister not read this document?
Comment on this
The Deputies across from us tonight have trotted out loads and oodles of policies that they said they put forward but that we rejected. I would like to remind them all that we are a minority Government. The only way that this Government can get its policies passed is-----
Comment on this
-----by consensus, which clearly is something-----
Comment on this
We got them passed.
Comment on this
-----that none of them has the ability to reach. They cannot work with one another.
Comment on this
Does the Leas-Cheann Comhairle know what we will do? We will slag one another off.
Comment on this
We got money messaged. We got Bills passed and then they got money messaged.
Comment on this
They have all stood up tonight, slagged one another off and told us that this is not personal to the Minister, Deputy Eoghan Murphy, but it is exactly that - it is very personal. Slagging is not a policy, though, and does not build houses.
Comment on this
We have heard the Minister, Deputy Regina Doherty, speaking.
Comment on this
Record homelessness.
Comment on this
There is a lot of slagging going on now.
Comment on this
Let us remind ourselves of why we were in a position in 2016 of having to devise the Rebuilding Ireland policy.
Comment on this
We forced Fine Gael to change its housing policy.
Comment on this
The housing organisations in this country - the people who were building - were shattered by the great recession caused by the mismanagement of this country for years before the Fine Gael-Labour Party Government took over.
Comment on this
Fine Gael has been nearly nine years in office.
Comment on this
We have not run away from the policy. We are doing things that have shown tangible results in my own county of Meath. We had 1,000 houses built two years ago, 1,500 last year and 1,000 built this year already. I have every confidence not only in our Rebuilding Ireland project, but in the Minister who is steering the ship right now.
Comment on this
Let us call this what it is - an election stunt by the Social Democrats, who announced this motion ahead of the by-elections last Friday. The Social Democrats purposely held a photo opportunity outside the Dáil gates so that a by-election candidate could be included in the picture. We all know that an unelected representative would not have been allowed into the photo opportunity had it been held on the Dáil plinth as is normal.
The Government's plan to provide more houses and homes and to stabilise prices is working. More than 50,000 new homes have been built in the past three years. There was an 82% increase in the number of new homes completed between 2016 and 2018. That represents thousands of families and individuals who now have a place to call home when they did not at the start of this Dáil. As we near the end of this Dáil, the Opposition is getting more exercised and, dare I say, more excited. Opposition spin doctors decide that housing is a topic on which to win a few votes. The politics of housing excites the Opposition-----
Comment on this
Record rent levels.
Comment on this
-----much more than the policy or its objectives.
Comment on this
Record homelessness.
Comment on this
-----personalised attacks and cheap shots are far more the order of the day from the Opposition-----
Comment on this
-----than any detailed discussion on policy.
Comment on this
Record homelessness.
Comment on this
We have heard addresses from many Deputies this evening, including Fianna Fáil's housing spokesperson, who said that people would get to see Fianna Fáil's housing plan early next year. It has been 600 days since Fianna Fáil promised an alternative housing policy.
Comment on this
Thirteen Bills, and the Government is lucky that it is still here.
Comment on this
Deputy Cassells all but invoked the spirit of de Valera-----
Comment on this
-----by stating that Fianna Fáil was the only party to be able to deliver houses.
Comment on this
Just because Fianna Fáil keeps saying something over and over does not mean it is true.
Comment on this
Deputy Cassells identified deficiencies in our local authorities' ability to build enough homes. We face challenges in that area because Fianna Fáil, when in power, privatised the housing sector. We have been trying to re-equip our local authorities ever since.
Comment on this
The Government condemned them.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil stripped our councils of their expertise and sold it off to the private sector. The only thing that Fianna Fáil knows about the housing sector is how to destroy it and then blame us for not fixing its mess quickly enough.
Comment on this
Voters can look at Sinn Féin's record in Northern Ireland to see what little impact and opportunity to influence policy the party has had there. It has had no impact. It runs from the homelessness crisis in the North like it ran from power sharing and government. Sinn Féin is a party that only a few weeks ago tried to vote down a proposal for 800 new homes less than 4 miles from here and close to Dublin city centre.
Comment on this
With not a single affordable home on the site.
Comment on this
In places where Sinn Féin turns up to vote, it votes against housing.
Comment on this
There was not a single affordable home.
Comment on this
This is a time when the Government and all Members of the House should work together to address citizens' challenges. Alas, that will not happen because politics has taken over. Fine Gael will continue the work of government for the citizens. Fine Gael will continue to rebuild Ireland.
Comment on this
Record levels of rent and homelessness.
Comment on this
I will make a few quick points.
Comment on this
I accept that. We might criticise the Opposition for not having a plan. In all of these debates, we acknowledge that the Opposition might come forward with some ideas, one or two here and there.
Comment on this
Some. No one is denying that,-----
Comment on this
-----but the job is to put a plan in place,-----
Comment on this
Is the Minister of State not very good?
Comment on this
-----action by action, and drive it.
Comment on this
If the Government does not provide money messages for our Bills, we cannot.
Comment on this
The job of the Minister, Deputy Eoghan Murphy, is to put a housing plan in place. Rebuilding Ireland is a five-year plan and we are in the third year. His job is to implement it and go site by site to ensure that the houses are being built. That is his job, not to make an odd statement in the Chamber calling for some kind of action.
It is actually to drive the plan and make it happen. That plan is three years old. It has already helped 100,000 households into a home.
Comment on this
You have been in government for nine years.
Comment on this
Nine long years.
Comment on this
That plan is fully factual and not spin. Deputies can track it. I have a chart for each county for each scheme.
Comment on this
Is there one for everybody in the audience?
Comment on this
Show it to the long-term homeless people.
Comment on this
I would like to see every other party come in here with a full plan that goes site by site throughout the country.
Comment on this
With respect, Sinn Féin talks about the ambitious plan it has. If the figures in that so-called ambitious plan are added up-----
Comment on this
That is not true. The Minister of State knows that is not true.
Comment on this
-----they do not match the amount of money the Government has ring-fenced.
Comment on this
The Minister of State can look to his colleagues if he only got a minute. I gave him a minute and a half.
Comment on this
I ask the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to protect my minute.
Comment on this
If everybody else here commits to our plan, ring-fences the same amount of money and makes sure to deliver over the coming years-----
Comment on this
I will start by thanking all of the contributors to the debate. I have to say I was somewhat amused by the similarity of scripts between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.
Comment on this
It was the single transferable script. They do come from the same background and hold the same type of ideology. There is not a cigarette paper between them.
Deputy Heydon should know we were required to submit our Private Members' motion last Wednesday so it was not a question of looking for publicity.
Comment on this
It was two days before the by-election.
Comment on this
We were required to have it in last Wednesday and we did that.
I have to say I am somewhat concerned and I wonder about the memory of the Minister, Deputy Eoghan Murphy. This morning, I heard him having a right swipe at me on "Morning Ireland". He referred to hypocrisy. He said our party never tabled amendments on the rent reform Bill earlier this year. What is wrong with the Minister's memory? In January 2018, it was the Social Democrats that introduced the residential tenancies Bill. At that stage, the Minister thanked Deputy Catherine Murphy and me for bringing forward the Bill. He acknowledged the substance of the Bill and its genuine motivation to improve the situation for tenants at a time of undersupply in the residential sector. Does the Minister not remember that?
The Minister undertook to introduce legislation to do what our Bill would do. We had to wait a year for him to do it because it was a full year before he introduced the Government Bill to do what we had proposed a year earlier. The Minister said we did not propose amendments. Does he not remember us having a conversation across the floor of the housing committee on how we might improve his legislation? Does he not remember that when his Bill was brought to the floor of the House several of us signed an all-party Focus Ireland amendment to improve the legislation the Minister had introduced? Unfortunately, he had watered down the Social Democrats' Bill from a year earlier. Does the Minister not remember all of this? He should try to jog his memory because he owes us an apology.
Comment on this
There is no doubt the housing crisis is one of the main challenges facing the country and the failure to address this crisis represents a major failure of responsibility on the part of the Minister. Ensuring an adequate supply of housing at affordable cost is a basic responsibility of any Government. The Minister has abdicated this responsibility by outsourcing it to the market. The market is only concerned with the profit margin and, therefore, takes no responsibility for the social and economic welfare of people. That should be the job of politics.
With regard to housing, the Minister speaks a lot about supply. While it is important to maintain a strong supply, the basic rules of supply and demand do not apply to housing. The reason for this is that the cost of land is the key determining factor when it comes to the cost of housing. While supply is obviously very important so too is affordability. This is a reality that is ignored by the Minister. We only have to recall what happened in the boom. There was an oversupply of housing but critically prices kept spiralling. More supply in the absence of affordability means many people overextend themselves with borrowing. We saw the awful consequences of this during the crash.
If the Minister were serious about the housing crisis he would set out to drive down the cost of housing for buyers and renters but this Government and the previous Government set out to do the very opposite. The former Minister for Finance, Deputy Noonan, admitted as much. Government policies set out to bolster house prices rather than drive them down. The help-to-buy scheme is a case in point. So too is the new affordable scheme. Both of them accept the inherent unaffordability of housing as a given and merely offer some discounting on these inflated prices so the root cause, the high land cost, is not tackled. It is quite clear the balance sheets of the banks have been of much more concern to the Government than ensuring people have homes.
The Minister is very fond of referring to the Opposition's criticism as ideological but his heavy reliance on the private sector is entirely ideological. Fine Gael never sees itself as having any responsibility for the public good or public provision. It sees housing as a commodity to be bought and sold for profit rather than an essential part of people's lives. Not only is Fine Gael leaving housing to the market but the policies it is pursuing are clearly designed to maintain the high cost of housing and there are umpteen examples of this. The Minister refuses to fund local authorities adequately and instead pours hundreds of millions of euro of public money into the pockets of landlords through the housing assistance payment. This in turn drives up rents. It means private renters must compete with housing assistance payment tenancies. It also means house buyers, particularly first-time buyers, are squeezed out as they cannot compete with landlords. The recent practice of local authorities being encouraged to buy rather than build social housing also squeezes first-time buyers. All of this conspires to keep house prices and rents high while guaranteeing high returns for investors.
Equally, the failure of the Minister to tackle land hoarding in any effective way means people struggling to buy a home are at the mercy of developers who bought land at inflated prices during the boom and are now slowly releasing it in a way that maintains high land values. The site cost is now a major factor in high house prices. This is a far greater factor than the cost of building. I do not recall the Minister ever identifying the high cost of land and the problem of land hoarding as a factor of the housing crisis. I wonder why this is the case.
Comment on this
The experience with the Ó Cualann housing co-operative in Ballymun has demonstrated how very good-quality, carbon-neutral, three-bedroom houses can be built for €200,000.
Comment on this
That is what we are saying.
Comment on this
You just spent the past two hours saying we were not doing it. Make up your minds.
Comment on this
There is no reason we cannot build large numbers of houses at that price on the very many publicly-owned sites available in Dublin and throughout the country. This is the type of approach taken by many Governments in the past, even when times were very hard. It is a cruel irony that at a time when the country was never wealthier, so many people are locked out of housing completely. There is now an entire generation of young people in their 20s and 30s who are denied human aspirations their parents took for granted.
They are denied the right to stay in this country, for example, the right to settle down and the right to consider starting a family - all due to the enormous struggle that faces them in trying to access decent housing. The cost of housing is the single greatest contributor to our high cost of living and employers cite it as a significant issue in attracting people to come to this country or to return here to fill key job vacancies. The lack of affordability has impacts beyond that generation, as their parents try to bail them out and support them financially, or try to accommodate them in an overcrowded home.
The tragedy is it does not have to be like this. If the Minister was serious about ensuring people could have access to a decent home, he would ensure we used public land for the public good. The Social Democrats has called for a housing delivery agency to develop well planned, mixed housing developments on all large public sites. This is the kind of sustainable and fair approach that is needed, unlike the Land Development Agency, LDA, as proposed by the Government, which would use public land to achieve private profit. It is clear that what the Minister has in mind for the LDA is not an agency that is socially focused, just as the National Asset Management Agency was not either. Claims by the Minister he is implementing the Kenny report are laughable. The State needs to take control of land prices and the Minister should stop hiding behind the Constitution in that regard.
Having a place to call home is a fundamental issue to us all as humans. For that reason, it is the fundamental responsibility of a Minister for Housing, Planning and Local Government to ensure everyone can have access to a home at a reasonable cost. The Minister has failed to do that. It is time for him to go and it is time for change. I commend this motion to the House.
Comment on this
Before I put the question, I have been requested by Deputy Lowry, as is his right, to make a personal statement at an early date to address accusations by Deputy Paul Murphy. I advised Deputy Paul Murphy at the time he should be careful. Deputy Lowry will get that opportunity at an early date. He will not do so tonight but he will get an opportunity-----