We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Mental Health Bill 2024: Committee Stage

Summary

Committee Stage of the Mental Health Bill 2024 focused on updating the 2001 Act to strengthen rights and support people to make decisions about their care, while aligning involuntary detention with human-rights obligations. The Minister proposed a revised definition of mental disorder requiring serious effects and significant impairment, and reduced the planned review period from ten years to five. Deputies urged a statutory “no wrong door” approach for people with co-existing mental health and substance-use needs, but the Minister opposed the amendments, citing existing policy and the phased development of specialist teams. The Bill also presumes that 16- and 17-year-olds have capacity to decide about their admission and treatment.

Contributions 108–228 of 228. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Mental Health Bill 2024
Enacted

No. 66 of 2024 ›

I move amendment No. 49:

In page 26, between lines 7 and 8, to insert the following:

“(14) In subsection (1), “spouse”, in relation to a person, does not include a spouse who is living separately and apart from the person, or a spouse in respect of whom—

(a) an application for an order has been made but not yet determined under the Act of 2018, or

(b) an order has been made under the Act of 2018.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:

In page 26, line 15, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:

In page 26, between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following:

“(d) is a spouse of the person, the subject of the application, who is living separately and apart from the person concerned or a spouse in respect of whom—

(i) an application for an order has been made but not yet determined under the Act of 2018, or

(ii) an order has been made under the Act of 2018,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

In page 26, line 32, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

In page 26, to delete lines 39 and 40 and substitute the following:

“(5) A direct application for a recommendation for involuntary admission shall be made in the form and manner specified by the Commission.”.

This amendment provides for a new subsection (5) to ensure that direct applications are made in a form specified by the Mental Health Commission.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 54:

In page 26, to delete line 41, and in page 27, to delete lines 1 to 3 and substitute the following:

“(6) In this section and section 18, “relevant person” means a person who—

(a) is a spouse of the person, the subject of the application, but does not include a spouse who is living separately and apart from the person or in respect of whom—

(i) an application for an order has been made but not yet determined under the Act of 2018, or

(ii) an order has been made under the Act of 2018,

(b) is a relative of the person, the subject of the application,

(c) has a bona fide interest in the mental health, safety and welfare of the person concerned, or

(d) is a mental healthcare professional (other than a consultant psychiatrist).”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:

In page 27, lines 9 and 10, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendments Nos. 56, 71, 151, 158, 175, 179, 182, 184, 192 and 198 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:

In page 27, line 13, to delete “view” and substitute “opinion”.

These are technical amendments to replace the word “view” with “opinion” at various points throughout the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 57:

In page 27, line 18, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:

In page 27, line 25, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 59:

In page 27, line 32, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 60:

In page 29, line 6, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendments Nos. 61 to 70, inclusive, 126, 170 to 173, inclusive, and 176 to 178, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 61:

In page 29, line 9, before “take” to insert “take all reasonable measures necessary to”.

Following publication of the Bill last July, officials in my Department continued to consult key stakeholders. Invaluable feedback was provided by An Garda Síochána and the Department of Justice regarding the provisions on Garda powers in the Bill.

An Garda Síochána examined the Bill in terms of operability and suggested amendments that would help improve how the new Bill could be operationalised. I will provide some detail on the proposed amendments and the rationale for moving them.

Amendments Nos. 61 and 170 provide for the term "take all reasonable measures to", which is being inserted into sections 18(1)(a) and 71(1)(a). This has been included at the request of An Garda Síochána to ensure, for the avoidance of doubt, that there is an explicit power to use reasonable force to take a person into custody. Of course, members of An Garda Síochána are bound to act within the powers granted them under this and other enactments, but also are bound by Garda policies on use of reasonable force.

Amendments Nos. 62 and 171 replace the term "a Superintendent or Chief Superintendent" with "a member ... not below the rank of Inspector" as the grade that can extend the timeframe for holding a person in custody. This was requested by An Garda Síochána because it may be difficult to get in contact with a superintendent outside of normal working hours.

Amendments Nos. 63 to 65, inclusive, are technical amendments.

Amendment No. 66 inserts the term "or a consultant psychiatrist acting on that clinical director’s behalf" in subsection 18(8). This will expand the staff members whom the Garda may contact to arrange for the person to be brought to the registered acute mental health centre. This amendment was requested to align this provision with section 19 and to reduce the possibility of delays in arranging transfers.

Amendment No. 67 is being moved in relation to section 18(9) to read, "when a member or members of An Garda Síochána exercise powers under this section or under sections 19, 39, 71, 77 or 131". Members of An Garda Síochána must apply the regulations for the treatment of persons in custody in Garda stations to any person taken into custody, including under the Mental Health Act. The wording in the Bill as initiated may cause duplication or conflict if a separate set of regulations in relation to custody are prepared. Amending the reference here allows the Minister to make broader regulations in relation to Garda powers under this legislation.

Amendment No. 68 inserts a new subsection (10) into section 18 to allow An Garda to retain a copy of the recommendation for involuntary admission, as is currently the case under the existing Mental Health Act. It is retained with the custody record of the person and used in assisting with the transfer of the person to the approved centre.

Amendment No. 69 deletes "but not later than 12 hours" from section 19(1) as members of An Garda Síochána are already compelled to bring a person to a registered acute mental health centre as soon as is practicable.

Amendment No. 70 inserts a requirement into section 19, which states that authorised officers will comply with a Garda request to consider making an application for a recommendation for involuntary admission as soon as practicable. An Garda Síochána requests that some acknowledgement be included that the HSE be compelled to respond within a timely manner to a request for an authorised officer.

Amendment No. 126 introduces a requirement that An Garda Síochána shall respond as soon as practicable to a request for assistance in bringing back to a registered acute mental health centre a person who has absconded without leave.

Amendments Nos. 172 and 176, in relation to Garda powers to take children into custody, replace the wording "unless it is unsafe to do so" and "it is unsafe or not in the bests interests of the child" with "there is an immediate and serious risk to the health or welfare of a child by releasing the child into the care of that person or persons". An Garda Síochána asked for greater clarity on what constitutes unsafe. The revised wording aligns closely with the current wording of section 12 of the Child Care Act 1991.

Amendment No. 173 provides for the deletion of section 71(5) in relation to where any of a parent, guardian or the Child and Family Agency request the assistance of gardaí when transferring the child following their release. An Garda Síochána stated it would be inappropriate to assign this responsibility to gardaí as it is not part of the statutory responsibility for gardaí to provide transportation outside of defined arrangements such as custody.

Amendment No. 178 inserts a new subsection (7) into section 71 to allow the HSE to step in and assist gardaí where the parent or guardian of a child cannot be located or if it is unsafe to release the child to them.

I believe the amendments I am moving today in relation to Garda powers for taking adults and children into custody make these provisions more operational and bring greater clarity to members of An Garda Síochána working under the enactment and, crucially, greater clarity to people being treated under this enactment. I thank An Garda Síochána for all its engagement on this section of the Bill.

Comment on this

I will speak briefly to the general scheme of these amendments and the important and critical issue that Garda representatives raised with the health committee this morning about the availability of authorised officers. Their asks, which are incredibly reasonable, are that there be authorised officers for them to call upon. The Mental Health Commission said it planned to bring forward a proposal to increase the numbers. There are questions still remaining as to where those staff members will come from. However, it is vital that those authorised officers be available 24-7.

Comment on this

There is no way to plan outside of 24-7, 365 days a year. I do not think the Minister of State will find an objection from anybody in this House were a proposal brought forward to do that. We all recognise the importance of them and the role and incredible work gardaí do, so when they come looking for something, we should be the ones to say that if we can, we will.

Comment on this

I support Deputy Clarke. This is an issue that mental health professionals and gardaí are bringing to us regularly. I know last year, in response to a parliamentary question, as the Minister of State knows, there was only one authorised officer between the city and county in Waterford. I have a number of questions submitted but I do not know if that situation has improved. I hope to God it has, but that will remain to be seen. It proves the point that the debate we have been having over the past 40 minutes or so is about looking after people when they are at their lowest ebb, when they are in crisis and when there is the greatest need and the greatest risk of harm. When we do not have the personnel in place to help that process, we all, unfortunately, see the outworkings of that in our respective constituencies. I add to what Deputy Clarke has said. Whatever the proposals will be, we need to see action on that and an uptake in authorised officers across the State.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputies for their appropriate questions. In 2023, 16% of applications were made by authorised officers and 32% by gardaí. That is to put it into context. The Department and the HSE recognise that for the authorised officer system to work effectively, officers must be available nationwide on a 24-7 basis. I am in 100% and total agreement. The expectation is not that an authorised officer would be available in every village, but one should be available in at least every county and in every medium to large urban centre, but I believe we have to go further than that. The CAST project in Limerick is a useful example of how the authorised officer might work in the future, with a dual Garda-health service approach.

As of the last figures I had available, from September 2024, there were 174 authorised officers trained within the HSE. All officers are mental health professionals, with the majority being either mental health nurses or social workers. At present, people work as authorised officers as an add-on to their existing job in the evenings and on weekends. The HSE also provides specific training, so some are psychiatric nurses, occupational therapists, registered psychiatrists and social workers, but they are mostly clinical nurse specialists, psychiatric nurses and social workers. The HSE has been aware of the introduction of this system for a number of years and must be satisfied and ensure all of us, me as Minister of State and the Department of Health are satisfied that it has enough authorised officers and that the system as designed can work effectively. Initial costings estimate the system for authorised officers will cost €3.5 million per year.

Following Committee Stage, the HSE must begin to make preparations for the expansion of the authorised officer system, but I know it has already begun. I heard from the Orla Keane at the Mental Health Commission today that it had provided some of this additional training already. As I have said, for all facets of the Bill there will be lead-in time, but we have to be 100% sure there are enough authorised officers to respond wherever they are requested all over the country. It is one of the areas where we will not be able to make the changes from gardaí to authorised officers until we are satisfied that we have enough of them. We have a good start with 174.

That is the most recent figure available to me. We have to at least double it, if not more. That is the most up-to-date information I have, but the figure will rise quickly. From listening to and engaging with gardaí at many levels, I am aware that nearly one third of all involuntary detentions, especially of very ill people, are made by gardaí. That is not their role. It is a role they want to move away from but that cannot happen until we have enough authorised officers. For authorised officers as we know them, it is an additional part of their work. I will not call it overtime but it is an add-on. We are going to need full-time authorised officers, especially in the larger cities.

When the legislation is amended by the Oireachtas and passed, there will be a major amount of work to be done in respect of authorised officers and the various plans to be put in place by the HSE, the Department of justice and others - the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act relates to the Department of children and disability - to make sure it is workable. There is no point in it being on paper if we do not have enough authorised officers to do exactly what we want them to do, as per the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not think there will be disagreement about the Garda request for authorised officers. It is completely logical and makes sense. They will be best suited to delivering and will be utterly au fait with what is involved, which is not always the case. Some of the issues I spoke of earlier relate to the fact that not everyone is au fait with the law and with what is required. That is why I go back to the idea of a code of practice. We all heard about the CAST system or scheme - call it what you will - in Limerick. It is not to be associated with any other systems. We see this as something that works, and that is what we want to see everywhere.

The Minister of State answered a question I was going to ask about my fears in relation to authorised officers. There is a doubling up on the work they carry out as social workers, psychologists and psychiatrists. Particularly in large urban areas or where they have to deal with a wider rural area, there will be requirements. We are not anticipating dealing with a huge number of people, but there have been failings. We want legislation that works and, beyond that, resources. The logical resource would be authorised officers who have the skill set and know best practice.

We must ensure that whomever has to deal with them from other State services and the Garda is made aware of who has what role and how it will operate. Sometimes there is a problem with communications. Part of what I spoke about previously is that people could get away from the idea that they could only sign involuntary committals on the basis of someone being a threat to themselves or others at a particular moment, when there are still major mental health issues.

Comment on this

I share the concerns expressed by others. The Mental Health Commission has recommended that a dedicated authorised officer unit be set up in the HSE. I would be interested in the Minister of State's thoughts on that.

I share the concern regarding full-time officers. What resources will be put in place to ensure that happens? It is all well and good saying we should have people available 24-7, but we need to resource that and have funding available. What resources does the Minister of State intend to put in place to ensure full-time officers are available across the country?

Comment on this

The Minister of State spoke of authorised officers per county. There has to be a better model than that. In my constituency, an authorised officer may be needed in Coole. Granard is ten minutes up the road but Athlone is an hour's drive in the opposite direction. A more open approach, as opposed to one based on restrictive county boundaries, could work much better, particularly in rural areas.

Comment on this

I agree wholeheartedly. As I said, 174 is the most recent figure I received. In order for this important aspect of the Bill to work, we need sufficient authorised officers. It is hard to judge how many will be needed. Authorised officers made 16% of applications in 2023, while gardaí made 32%. This means that one sixth of applications were made by authorised officers. I agree that we cannot take an ad hoc approach to authorised officers.

On Deputy Rice's question regarding what the Mental Health Commission said, all of this will have to be worked out before the Bill can be enacted. The quicker it is worked out, the quicker the Bill will be enacted. Geography will be a major factor. If you are in the far reaches of Donegal or down in west Cork and depend on someone coming from the closest large town or city, that will not work. We cannot adopt an ad hoc approach. Everybody agrees that the officers will play an important role. There will be a role, in my opinion, for some form of full-time office in relation to them. Then there will be a hub-and-spoke approach, perhaps. I definitely agree with Deputy Clarke that the use of county boundaries will not work in this case.

Comment on this

It is probably too early to ask the Minister of State about the timeline, given that we are having a preliminary discussion on the structure. Can she give a general indication? I accept that this all depends on funding. What will the structure look like in comparison with the current structure, the difficulties with which I have spoken about previously? I imagine that other medical practitioners will have to be involved at some point, particularly in the context of involuntary admissions.

Comment on this

The Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 did not come into place until 2023. We are looking at 2028. We have to be realistic. There are certain facets of it we want to see being implemented very quickly. There will be a formal implementation plan for the Act. It will set out timelines, the resources needed, etc. I am keen that we would start straight away. I have already written to the Mental Health Commission and asked it to come back to me on how it proposes to regulate CAMHS, for example. We have approximately 1,200 people with enduring mental health conditions who are living in households of maybe four or five people and require 24-7 support. They are not regulated, and I am keen for that to happen quickly. That is important. That is the second stage of CAMHS.

Much work has gone into this Bill. It has taken a long time to get here. I appreciate the co-operation of Deputies with previous Ministers over many years. As soon as the Bill is passed, the HSE will be tasked with a formal implementation plan.

I did not answer Deputy Rice's question on resources. At this stage, we do not know what the demand for resources will be. The preliminary figure I was given in respect of authorised officers is approximately €3.5 million. If the Mental Health Commission is to be the regulator, it will need more staff to regulate the 82 CAMHS teams we currently have, including the specialist teams, and the households across the country where people live with enduring mental health conditions. I am very keen for them to be regulated.

The change in the age verification for mental health consent is one of the things that can happen organically. This should happen more quickly. I hope to have more detail on Deputy Ó Murchú's question later in the year.

Comment on this

I have a straightforward question. If there are 174 authorised officers at present, how many does €3.5 million equate to?

Comment on this

I cannot answer that question specifically. Authorised officers are paid a kind of overtime for work additional to their regular work. I anticipate that many authorised officers will do this in addition to their day jobs. Many of these requests are made out of hours and at weekends.

Comment on this

It would be related to their existing rate of pay if it were considered overtime.

Comment on this

I am not understanding the question. What I am saying is that the estimate for the cost to get to the number we need is an additional €3.5 million. I imagine that would relate to those who are working part time. I can get more details and reply to the Deputy next week or on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I imagine the information is there somewhere. Somebody has said it is going to cost €3.5 million. What is that cost?

Comment on this

That is the cost of the additional authorised officers.

Comment on this

I do not know. I will dig into that for the Deputy.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 62:

In page 29, line 15, to delete "a Superintendent or Chief Superintendent" and substitute "a member of An Garda Síochána not below the rank of Inspector".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 63:

In page 29, between lines 26 and 27, to insert the following:

"(4) Where an authorised officer or the Executive, as the case may be, receives a Garda request for an application for a recommendation for involuntary admission, the authorised officer or the Executive, as the case may be, shall comply with that request as soon as practicable.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 64:

In page 30, line 26, to delete "the" and substitute "An".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 65:

In page 30, line 28, to delete "the" where it firstly occurs and substitute "An".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 66:

In page 30, line 29, after "centre" to insert "or a consultant psychiatrist acting on that clinical director’s behalf".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 67:

In page 30, lines 34 and 35, to delete "when a person is taken into custody under this section" and substitute the following:

"when a member or members of An Garda Síochána perform functions under this section or under section 19, 39, 71, 77 or 131".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 68:

In page 30, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:

"(10) Where a recommendation for involuntary admission is made by a registered medical practitioner under this section, a copy of the recommendation shall be provided by the registered medical practitioner to the member of An Garda Síochána who is responsible for the person who is taken into custody under subsection (1), or another member on his or her direction, for inclusion in the custody record (within the meaning of Regulation 6 of the Criminal Justice Act 1984 (Treatment of Persons in Custody in Garda Síochána Stations) Regulations 1987 (S.I. No. 119 of 1987)) in respect of the person the subject of the recommendation for involuntary admission.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 69:

In page 30, line 41, to delete “but not later than 12 hours”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 70:

In page 31, line 25, after "request" to insert "as soon as practicable".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 71:

In page 31, line 35, to delete "view" and substitute "opinion".

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendments Nos. 72 to 77, inclusive, 79, 81 to 87, inclusive, 90 to 93, inclusive, 114 to 116, inclusive, and 118 to 121, inclusive, are related. Amendments Nos. 75 and 76 are physical alternatives to amendment No. 74. Amendment No. 115 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 114.

Amendments Nos. 72 to 77, inclusive, 79, 81 to 87, inclusive, 90 to 93, inclusive, 114 to 116, inclusive, and 118 to 121, inclusive, may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 72:

In page 32, to delete line 38 and substitute the following:

"(3) If, upon the proposed discharging from hospital of a person the subject of a recommendation for involuntary admission—".

I will speak first to amendment No. 93. This amendment provides for a stand-alone section relating to psychosocial assessments to be carried out within two working days of the admission order being made rather than at the time of admission. Some stakeholders requested that clarity be given to the status of psychosocial assessments. The Bill, as initiated, clearly states that the psychosocial assessment is not part of the grounds for involuntary admission. This has been made clearer in the amendments to the Bill by providing for the assessments in a stand-alone section. Allowing for the psychosocial assessments to be carried out within two working days of the admission order being made will allow more allied health professions to participate in those assessments, particularly for professions that do not generally work outside normal working hours.

Amendment No. 72 is a technical amendment that rewords subsection 21(3) to include reference to the "person the subject of a recommendation for involuntary admission".

Amendment No. 73 is a technical amendment moving the word "means" in the sentence to make it clearer.

Amendments Nos. 74, 83, 114, 118 and 120 take out the reference to "psychosocial assessments" in sections 22 and 37 as these are all now moved to new section 26, under amendment No. 93.

I do not propose to accept amendment No. 75 as I do not believe it is appropriate. Reflective of recommendation 43 of the report of the expert group on the review of the Mental Health Act 2001, I am focused on bringing the psychosocial assessment of other members of the multidisciplinary team to the involuntary admission process in tandem with the examination of the consultant psychiatrist. The detail of what is contained within a psychosocial assessment can be set out by way of secondary legislation in a regulation.

I do not propose to accept amendment No. 76. However, I agree with the spirit of this amendment. This level of detail of psychosocial assessment is not required in primary legislation. It would be more beneficial for such matters to be dealt with either in secondary legislation by way of regulation or by guidance by the Mental Health Commission. The matters to be assessed as set out in the amendment are all relevant and important to any psychosocial assessment but it does not need to be reflected in the text of the Bill. As I said, however, I agree with the spirit of the amendment, and it is important to say that.

Amendments Nos. 77, 82, 84, 85, 87, 91, 92, 116 and 119 correct typographical errors.

Amendment No. 79 takes out the first reference to "involuntary admission" in section 22(2)(a) as only one reference is needed in the sentence.

I do not propose to accept amendment No. 81. I would have very grave concerns if this amendment were to be carried. It would represent a serious regression in the rights of people in the involuntary admission process. The Mental Health Act 2001 only permits a person to be held for 24 hours in an approved centre before an admission order either can be made or the person must be released. This timeframe has been retained in this Bill. It would a retrograde step to extend that period to 72 hours.

We must remember that until an admission order has been made in respect of a person, that person is not involuntarily admitted. To deprive a person of their liberty is a serious infringement on their rights and must be for as short a period as possible. Extending the period in which a person can be held with an admission order being made to 72 hours without the person being examined and determined to have a mental disorder that meets the criteria for involuntary admission would seriously diminish the rights of people. I seriously believe it would be a retrograde step.

Amendments Nos. 86 and 90 provide for new subsections 22(6) and 23(6) to ensure that an involuntary admission order and renewal order are made in a form specified by the Mental Health Commission.

I do not propose to accept amendment No. 115. The independence of the second examination by another consultant psychiatrist must be protected. This is to ensure that where a change of status is sought in respect of a voluntarily admitted person, there is an examination of the person that is independent of the service where they are receiving treatment. To provide for anything less than this would diminish the rights of the person.

Amendment No. 121 is a technical amendment to reword this subsection to give it more clarity.

There was quite a lot in that contribution.

Comment on this

I will speak briefly to amendment No. 76. This is a real missed opportunity for the Government. This amendment deals with the holistic assessment of an individual. I recognise that the Minister of State said she thinks there is something in this proposal and will consider putting it into secondary legislation. If she thinks there is something in this, it should be inserted in the primary legislation. It has been so long since the Mental Health Act has been updated to any great degree that to have this sit in secondary legislation as opposed to primary legislation would be a missed opportunity. This amendment would reinforce the rights-based, person-centred approach by requiring social and environmental contexts to be considered. Instead of just considering a person's immediate medical symptoms and needs, we must also consider whether he or she can safely live in the community and what supports need to be put in place for that to happen.

It protects individuals from unnecessary and inappropriate detention, especially where appropriately resourced community supports could meet their needs. At present, we all know that community mental health services are struggling to meet the demand and, in some cases, are almost overwhelmed by it. Such services avoid the over-reliance on institutional care.

Comment on this

This amendment is an attempt to ensure we have a holistic means of assessment. We are talking about everything that impacts on mental health issues, including the environmental, the physical and the social. It is about the idea of ensuring we are assessing everything to make sure that we are dealing with all the issues impacting on a person. As Deputy Clarke said, it is then all about ensuring we can put the best framework and best resources in play.

There is no point not saying this in respect of some of the issues we have talked about throughout this entire debate: the fact is we had a scenario where we had huge institutions, and all that was wrong with them, and the promise was that we were going to introduce a community service. That is where we have to put emphasis. In a lot of cases, we should have this community service. In some cases, these are early interventions at a very early stage and, as we all know, early interventions can stop us from needing those very expensive and acute services when people find themselves in real distress. It is an attempt on our behalf to address that. The Minister of State said she gets the idea of what we are attempting with this amendment. Again, we are looking for best practice. At this stage, I just have not seen any arguments why we would not embed this in the legislation at this point as opposed to going to secondary legislation.

Comment on this

I support the sentiments of previous speakers on enshrining wider assessment. If the Minister of State agrees this needs to be done but does not agree with the actual amendment, I encourage her to consider inserting a Report Stage amendment that will achieve something similar. I ask her to consider doing that on Report Stage, if she agrees this is worth doing and is worthwhile.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputies for those comments. To be clear, this is for people who are involuntarily detained. It will be written into the Bill, if it passes through the Houses of the Oireachtas, that a psychosocial assessment will be provided within two days. That is actually in the Bill, but what it does not specify is what the psychosocial assessment will be, which would never be expected in primary legislation. There will be greater flexibility for amendment if it is brought to secondary legislation, if it does not fulfil the purpose of what it is meant to be.

To be very clear, this is a new introduction. It is a change from the 2001 Act. We are saying that a psychosocial assessment will be made available to somebody who is involuntarily detained within two days. The reason we moved to two days from the initial Bill is, sometimes, people are not working 7-7, and someone admitted over the weekend might not have access to that psychosocial support. That is why we moved it out to 48 hours.

The other piece is that psychosocial assessment is in the Bill. What the Deputies are looking for is clarification of what that assessment is. That will come in secondary legislation, which will also give us more opportunities if it has to be amended. It is there. It is part of the Bill. It is for those who are involuntarily detained. To Deputy Ó Murchú's point, it is not about psychosocial assessments in the community. This section just deals with the involuntary detention piece.

Comment on this

I find the Minister of State's position slightly confusing, as she wanted direct input into what a care plan was in the Bill's original iteration. I know the Government has rowed back on the layout of a care plan somewhat. However, for the Minister of State to say she wants to define what the layout of a care plan is, but not what a psychosocial assessment is, just does not add up.

Comment on this

The Minister of State should be well used to me using flexibility. I decided that I needed to mention the fact we need to put a certain emphasis on community services. That was already mentioned by Deputy Clarke, so I apologise. I did digress. I get that we are dealing with the issue of involuntary admissions, but we were trying to flesh out how to ensure we are talking about something that is holistic. That was the idea around the biopsychosocial. It is about making sure we are taking into account all the aspects that are impacting on the person.

Comment on this

In fairness, what Deputy Clarke said was a bit of a misrepresentation. The care plan is embedded in regulation but cannot be determined in the legislation. Each care plan is individual to each person who may be involuntarily detained or will be in an approved centre voluntarily. We are setting out in primary legislation that there will be a care plan. I am very keen on care plans across everything, for older people as well.

We are also setting out that there will be a psychosocial assessment, but primary legislation is not where we determine that. It is determined in secondary legislation and that is what we intend to do.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 73:

In page 33, lines 17 and 18, to delete “in relation to a person, the subject of a recommendation for involuntary admission, means” and substitute “means, in relation to a person the subject of a recommendation for involuntary admission,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 74:

In page 33, lines 23 to 32, to delete all words from and including “(1) Where” in line 23 down to and including line 32 and substitute the following:

“(1) Where a clinical director receives a recommendation for involuntary admission under section 16 in respect of a person, the clinical director shall as soon as may be arrange for a consultant psychiatrist on the staff of the registered acute mental health centre to carry out an examination of the person the subject of the recommendation.”.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendments Nos. 75 and 76 cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 77:

In page 33, line 33, to delete “subsection (1)(a)" and substitute “subsection (1)".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 78:

In page 33, lines 34 and 35, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 79:

In page 33, lines 35 and 36, to delete “for the involuntary admission”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 80:

In page 33, lines 39 and 40, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 81:

In page 34, line 4, to delete “24 hours” and substitute “72 hours”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 82:

In page 34, line 4, to delete “subsection (1)(a)” and substitute “subsection (1)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 83:

In page 34, to delete lines 7 to 9.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 84:

In page 34, line 11, to delete “subsection (1)(a),” and substitute “subsection (1) or”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 85:

In page 34, lines 12 and 13, to delete “or carrying out an assessment under subsection (1)(b), as the case may be”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 86:

In page 34, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following:

“(6) An involuntary admission order shall be made in the form and manner specified by the Commission.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 87:

In page 34, line 27, to delete “further extended” and substitute “extended”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 88:

In page 35, lines 1 and 2, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 89:

In page 35, line 4, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 90:

In page 35, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following:

“(6) A renewal order shall be made in the form and manner specified by the Commission.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 91:

In page 36, to delete lines 14 and 15 and substitute the following:

“(b) receive any information subsequently provided under paragraph (b), (c) or (d) of subsection (3), and”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 92:

In page 36, line 20, to delete “paragraphs” and substitute “paragraph”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 93:

In page 36, between lines 26 and 27, to insert the following:

“Psychosocial assessment of involuntarily admitted person

26. (1) Where an involuntary admission order has been made in relation to an involuntarily admitted person, a mental healthcare professional (other than a consultant psychiatrist) on the staff of the registered acute mental health centre who is involved in the care and treatment of the person concerned shall carry out a psychosocial assessment of the person concerned no later than 2 working days after the date of the making of the order.

(2) The conclusions of a psychosocial assessment of an involuntarily admitted person carried out under subsection (1) shall be recorded in that person’s medical record.

(3) A psychosocial assessment shall not be carried out by a relative or spouse of the person concerned.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 94:

In page 37, lines 1 and 2, to delete “(both within the meaning of section 2 of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 95:

In page 37, line 10, to delete “a registered nurse” and substitute the following:

“a person who was previously a practising solicitor or a practising barrister but is not currently practising (whether in the State or otherwise)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 96:

In page 40, line 20, to delete “the person, the subject” and substitute “the person the subject”.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendments Nos. 97 to 99, inclusive, 108, 113, 122 to 124, inclusive, 127 to 130, inclusive, 135, 200, 202 and 203 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 97:

In page 40, to delete lines 27 to 29 and substitute the following:

“(b) the attendance of the responsible consultant psychiatrist at the hearing of the review board,”.

These are textual amendments to a number of subsections so that they read “responsible consultant psychiatrist”, make the provisions clearer and provide consistency throughout the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 98:

In page 42, lines 27 and 28, to delete “consultant psychiatrist responsible for the care and treatment of the person concerned” and substitute “responsible consultant psychiatrist”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 99:

In page 43, lines 17 and 18, to delete “consultant psychiatrist who is responsible for the care and treatment of the person concerned” and substitute “responsible consultant psychiatrist”.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendments Nos. 100, 101, 103, 105 and 107 are related and may be taken together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 100:

In page 43, line 36, to delete “board” and substitute “review board”.

Amendments Nos. 100, 101, 105 and 107 provide for textual amendments to a number of subsections to read “responsible consultant psychiatrist”, to make the provisions clearer and provide consistency throughout the Bill.

Amendment No. 103 provides for a mental health review board to meet within 21 days of the making of an order, or such shorter time period as might be prescribed by the Minister, to a minimum of 14 days. This means that a review board may meet to review an order earlier than 21 days if a regulation is made by the Minister to provide for a shorter period. I have asked officials in my Department to consider the making of a regulation to reduce the period from 21 days. This regulation will be examined along with other regulations that need to be in place before commencement of the enactment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 101:

In page 43, line 38, to delete “board” and substitute “review board”.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy Rice is not present, therefore amendment No. 102 cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 103:

In page 44, line 11, after “days” to insert “, or such shorter period as may be prescribed which period shall be not less than 14 days,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 104:

In page 44, line 23, to delete “presented” and substitute “presented,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 105:

In page 44, line 27, to delete “notify in writing” and substitute “notify”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 106:

In page 44, line 30, to delete “and” and substitute “and,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 107:

In page 45, line 26, to delete “notice in writing” and substitute “notice”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 108:

In page 46, to delete lines 12 and 13 and substitute the following:

“(b) the responsible consultant psychiatrist, and”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 109:

In page 48, line 8, to delete “person involuntarily admitted” and substitute “involuntarily admitted person”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 110:

In page 49, line 4, to delete “the involuntarily” and substitute “an involuntarily”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 111:

In page 49, line 7, to delete “person” and substitute “involuntarily admitted person”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 112:

In page 49, line 21, to delete “subsection (10)” and substitute “subsection (10),”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 113:

In page 49, lines 26 and 27, to delete “consultant psychiatrist responsible for the care and treatment of the person concerned” and substitute “responsible consultant psychiatrist”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 114:

In page 51, to delete lines 30 to 35 and substitute the following:

“(2) The responsible consultant psychiatrist shall carry out an examination of the person concerned under section 22(1).”.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendment No. 115, in the name of Deputy Clarke, cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 116:

In page 51, to delete lines 36 and 37.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 117:

In page 52, lines 7 and 8, to delete “a mental disorder” and substitute “mental health difficulties”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 118:

In page 52, to delete lines 13 to 15 and substitute the following:

“(6) If, following an examination of the voluntarily admitted person and consultation with the responsible consultant psychiatrist, the second consultant psychiatrist—”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 119:

In page 52, line 26, to delete “involuntary admission order” and substitute “order (in this Act referred to as an “involuntary admission order”)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 120:

In page 52, lines 28 and 29, to delete “and details of the psychosocial assessment”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 121:

In page 52, to delete lines 41 and 42 and substitute the following:

“(10) Sections 23 to 36 shall apply to a person involuntarily admitted under this section as they apply to a person involuntarily admitted under section 22 with any necessary modifications.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 122:

In page 53, line 7, to delete “consultant” and substitute “responsible consultant”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 123:

In page 53, line 13, to delete “consultant” and substitute “responsible consultant”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 124:

In page 53, to delete lines 32 to 34 and substitute the following:

“(c) fails, in the opinion of the responsible consultant psychiatrist, to comply with any condition specified in the permitted absence,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 125:

In page 53, to delete line 36 and substitute “arrange for a member or members of the staff of the centre or other person or persons,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 126:

In page 54, line 5, after “request” to insert “as soon as practicable”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 127:

In page 54, line 23, to delete “her consultant” and substitute “her responsible consultant”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 128:

In page 54, lines 26 and 27, to delete “the consultant psychiatrist responsible for the person’s care and treatment shall immediately” and substitute “the responsible consultant psychiatrist shall immediately”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 129:

In page 54, line 30, to delete “her consultant” and substitute “her responsible consultant”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 130:

In page 56, line 12, to delete “consultant psychiatrist responsible for the care and treatment” and substitute “responsible consultant psychiatrist”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 131:

In page 57, between lines 8 and 9, to insert the following:

“Definitions (consent to treatment)

42.In this Chapter—

“initial treatment period” means the period specified in section 47(1);

“further treatment period” means the period specified in section 47(3).”.

Amendments Nos. 131 to 134, inclusive, and Nos. 136 to 146, inclusive, will be taken together. Consent to treatment for involuntarily admitted people is one of the most important issues in this Bill. Officials in my Department have consulted with numerous stakeholders regarding these provisions throughout the development of the Bill and again since the publication of the Bill last summer. A small number of stakeholders raised concerns about the operability of the consent to treatment provisions, with particular consternation about the prospect that a person might be admitted, but would be unable to be treated if he or she is unable to consent to treatment and is not a risk of harm to themselves or others.

I believe the amendments being moved by the Government today represent the right balance between ensuring the rights of involuntarily admitted people to make decisions about their care and treatment are respected while also providing for timely access to care and treatment when necessary. Considering the developments in mental health policy and services over the past two decades, the 2001 Act does not fully reflect our approach to mental health services now, such as the shift towards community-based services, the adoption of a recovery approach in service delivery and the involvement of service users as partners in their own care and in the development of the services. The context in which mental health services are delivered is significantly different in 2025 to 2001 and our mental health legislation must reflect this. It is worth providing some detail on how consent to treatment works under the existing Mental Health Act, how the policy has developed over the drafting of this Bill, the policy in the Bill as initiated and the amendments being moved here today.

Part 4 of the Mental Health Act 2001 sets out how consent to treatment works in relation to involuntary patients under that Act. The Act states that, for a person to be able to consent, the responsible consultant psychiatrist must be satisfied the person is capable of understanding the treatment and the consultant psychiatrist has given adequate information to the patient. Furthermore, the Act states that a consultant psychiatrist can treat a person without consent only where the person is incapable of giving consent and where "the treatment is necessary to safeguard the life of the patient, to restore his or her health, to alleviate his or her condition, or to relieve his or her suffering". Under the existing Act, where, in the view of the responsible consultant psychiatrist, the person has the capacity necessary to consent to treatment, then the person cannot be treated against his or her will. It is only where a person lacks capacity to consent to treatment that it can be given without the person’s consent. Part 4 of the Act also contains provisions in relation to the administration of psychosurgery, electroconvulsive therapy and medicines.

In 2015, an expert group published a list of 165 recommendations to amend the Mental Health Act 2001. Among those were a series of recommendations that sought to fundamentally change how consent to treatment works. These recommendations were that people should be supported to give informed consent to or to refuse treatment, that relevant decision supports under the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 be available to involuntarily admitted persons and that treatment could be administered to people who lack capacity in limited circumstances.

Officials in my Department carried out extensive consultation over a number of years on all aspects of the Bill, including on consent to treatment. Consultation included key stakeholders such as the Mental Health Commission and the HSE, as well as the Office of the Attorney General, and other key Departments, including the Department of Children, Disability and Equality. Furthermore, careful consideration of the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 was required to ensure that the Mental Health Bill aligned appropriately with that Act. Ireland ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in March 2019, and Department officials had to carefully consider how best to align the Mental Health Bill with the principles of the convention.

The Bill, as initiated, provides for an overhauled approach to consent to treatment. The Bill links into the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act as appropriate, such as where a person has been assessed as lacking capacity to make a decision under this Bill, an application under Part 5 of the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act must be made by or on behalf of the responsible consultant psychiatrist of the person concerned to request a decision-making representative be appointed or a decision-making order be made.

The Bill provides for treatment without consent to be given in certain circumstances, where the person has been assessed as lacking the capacity to consent to or refuse treatment: within 21 days of the person’s admission; where the person has a relevant decision support under the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act; or where the health or life of the person or others is at risk, either during the capacity assessment process or after the assessment process has concluded where an application under the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act has been made to the Circuit Court or will be made.

The Bill also provides for involuntary treatment to be provided in very limited circumstances where a person is a risk of serious and immediate harm to another person and refuses to consent to treatment, or a relevant substitute decision-maker refuses to consent to treatment. In such cases, an application for a treatment order to the High Court must be made to determine whether the limited criteria have been met. As I noted earlier, a small number of stakeholders contacted my Department to raise concerns about the operability of provisions related to consent to treatment. These concerns were primarily focused on the fear that people would be detained without being able to be treated if they were not a risk of harm to themselves or others and where they lacked capacity or a substitute decision-maker to consent to treatment. I have listened to those concerns and the amendments I am moving here today address these concerns.

Where a person has a valid, relevant substitute decision-making arrangement under the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015, that decision-maker can consent to or refuse treatment. That includes an advance healthcare directive, a designated healthcare representative, and a decision-making representative appointed by the court. If any of those substitute decision-making arrangements are in place regarding a specific treatment decision, then the consent of that directive or representative is required. In cases where a person lacks capacity and does not have a relevant, valid substitute decision-making arrangement, the amendments to the Bill will ensure that those people will have appropriate access to treatment.

I will give a quick overview of the Government’s amendments. Amendment No. 131 provides for the insertion of a new section 42 that sets out definitions which are used in Chapter 3 of Part 3. Amendment No. 132 is a technical amendment to delete a term that is unnecessary. Amendment No. 133 replaces subsection (2) of section 43 to clearly state that a person with capacity may refuse any treatment and withdraw consent to any treatment at any time. Amendment No. 134 inserts a new subsection (5) in section 43 stating that consent or refusal or treatment must be granted for specific treatment, rather than a general consent or refusal. Amendment No. 136 is a technical amendment to correct a typographical error. Amendment No. 137 is a technical amendment to include reference to the first capacity assessment to be carried out by a responsible consultant psychiatrist if he or she thinks that the involuntarily admitted person may lack capacity to consent to or refuse treatment. Amendment No. 138 is a technical amendment to include reference to refusal of treatment, along with consent, to provide consistency throughout the Bill. Amendment No. 139 inserts a new section 46, which provides for treatment of people who have been assessed as lacking capacity by the granting or refusal of treatment by a substitute decision-making arrangement under the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015.

These include a court appointed decision-making representative, a decision-making order from the Circuit Court, or an advance healthcare directive or a designated healthcare representative appointed by a directive.

Amendment No. 140 inserts a new section 47 which allows for treatment to be administered to an involuntarily admitted person who has been assessed as lacking capacity, or who is undergoing capacity assessments, for a period of 21 days or 42 days following admission. A person must meet criteria for treatment set out in this section.

Amendment No. 141 inserts a new section 48 which provides for an application to be made to the Circuit Court to seek the appointment of a decision-making representative or the making of a decision-making order where a person lacks capacity and does not have a valid substitute decision-making arrangement. The application to the Circuit Court must be made at any point within the 21 or 42 days following admission, and treatment may be administered before the application is made to the court. This is important.

Amendment No. 142 inserts a new section 49 which provides for treatment to continue to be administered when awaiting the outcome of an application to the Circuit Court.

Amendment No. 143 inserts a new section 50, which was formerly section 51 of the Bill as initiated. This section provides for applications for treatment orders to the High Court in very limited circumstances.

Amendment No. 144 inserts a new section 51, which was formerly section 48 of the Bill as initiated. This section provides for the administration of ECT, subject to the consent of the person and only in accordance with the regulations made by the Mental Health Commission.

Amendments to section 46 make clear that valid substitute decision-making arrangements must be respected if in place.

Amendments to section 47 provide for treatment of involuntarily admitted people lacking capacity following their admission. Such people may be treated for a period of up to 42 days, increasing from 21 days in the Bill as initiated. An initial 21-day treatment window is provided for in the amendments, which can be extended by one further period of 21 days where it is approved by a second consultant psychiatrist.

The criteria under which a person can be treated within that initial treatment window has been expanded to include criteria based on the need for treatment. In the Bill as initiated, the criteria are restricted to risk of harm to self or others. Without amendment, this may give rise to scenarios where a person can be involuntarily admitted on the grounds of treatment but cannot be treated without consent on admission if they do not also meet the risk criteria. It should be noted that a person's capacity should be regularly assessed during their involuntary admission and if found to be capacitous, treatment cannot be given without their consent.

Section 48 provides for an application to be made to the Circuit Court to seek the appointment of a decision-making representative or a decision-making order from the court to vindicate the will and preferences of the person lacking capacity. The amendments allow for that application to be made at any stage within the initial treatment period of 21 to 42 days but require that the application be made before the end of the period. The amendments also allow for treatment to be administered to an involuntarily admitted person lacking capacity prior to the application being made.

Amendments to section 49 allow for treatment to be administered according to the treatment criteria of either risk or need for treatment while awaiting the determination stakeholders that the criteria for treatment for people who lack capacity in the amendments are different from the criteria for involuntary admission. On closer examination of the amendments, these stakeholders will clearly see that the criteria for admission and treatment are effectively the same. In fact, in relation to the risk criteria, the criteria for treatment are only that the person is at risk of serious and immediate harm to self or others and does not require the additional criteria for admission as set out in section 12(a)(ii). This means that any involuntarily admitted person lacking capacity may be treated, subject to the provisions of Part 3 Chapter 3, if he or she meets the criteria for involuntary admission.

Comment on this

In fairness, a considerable number of people were worried. As the Minister of State said, they were sufficiently worried to come to her on that basis. It was said to me that we could be looking at a case where someone was involuntarily admitted and then they could not get treatment. I still have a fear when we are talking about making applications to courts and to the High Court. We all know that there are issues with the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act that need to be looked at, particularly when we start putting things through a court system this is experiencing a logjam. That is necessary.

What the Minister of State has spoken to regarding these amendments all sounds positive. I am not sure that we are quite where we need to be on this. As the Minister of State knows, a selling job needs to be done. A piece of work needs to be done on interaction with stakeholders, particularly those stakeholders who had an issue with this. I ask that this would happen. Beyond that, people could be offered an explanation as to how this will work. I get that we are talking about a small cohort of people who could be involuntarily admitted and then because of their situation and circumstances - and I have it seen it - down to paranoia or whatever else, they are not going to take treatment. In some cases, they will refuse food and all of the rest of it. We are talking about people who are in a very distressed circumstance. We need to ensure that all of the protections are there from a human rights point of view. That goes without saying. We need to make sure this is operational. That was the fear of those who work in mental health services. There has been a good piece of work done here. It was a necessary piece of work. More needs to be done. What are the Minister of State's plans for engagement with those stakeholders? I ask that if there are further pieces needed that we could have that done, I would say on Report Stage but it looks like this Stage is going to go on for a wee while longer.

Comment on this

The Minister of State mentioned ECTs in her remarks. The Social Democrats will oppose section 83 which allows for ECT for children. According to the Psychological Society of Ireland, it has not been used in the State on children in more than two decades. It is still contained in the Bill. I accept that ECT is subject to the approval of the High Court. We believe that it should never be used. In 2023, the WHO and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights advised against the use of ECT on children and young people and recommended its prohibition by legislative. The Ombudsman for Children has also raised concerns and said that further consideration must give to its inclusion in this new Bill.

Comment on this

What can be seen in these amendments is that the Minister of State has listened to the stakeholders who have come forward. When I spoke with them, I was really struck that the concerns that they were raising were coming from a place where they wanted the best possible treatment for the patients, particularly in respect of that gap that was emerging between the involuntary admission versus the treatment. That gap needed to be addressed. I welcome that move in those areas. There are still significant concerns when it comes to any court application, but again most of that comes from a place of concern. It comes from a place of wanting the best possible outcome for the patient. We will be back again at a later point to the discuss the other areas in more detail. I wanted to put on the record that the Government has moved considerably towards meeting the concerns of the stakeholders, if not in their entirety but in a significant way.

Comment on this

Deputy Rice's amendment relating to ECT and children will be discussed at a later date. I take on board what he said. I thank those opposite for their support. No legislation is perfect when it is first drafted. There are always going to be unintended consequences. We have to listen to the sector. It is important that the Bill will be operational. It will be no good otherwise. I thank my officials because there has been a huge amount of engagement since the Bill went through Second Stage last September. That work was ongoing during the time that we were off getting elected, and we did not have a government in place. I saw the list and there were more than 500 engagements. I saw the list of the amount of work that was carried out, which was unbelievable. It is important that we listen. In some of the commentary in the past few weeks, people were not aware of the amendments, because that is just the way the system works, whereas now I hope that when they see the amendments and they see that they have been drafted in good faith to try to address the issues, they will realise that what we want is a Bill that is patient-focused but that is patient-centred and workable as well for those who deliver the care.

We are talking about the most vulnerable people in society. Is our time up?

Comment on this

Is the Minister requesting further time?

Comment on this

We are to resume next Wednesday. I will be back.

Comment on this

I know but I meant this evening.

Comment on this

Four hours is enough. We will be back next week. I thank all the Members for the positive engagement so far. We have covered a huge amount of ground. I thank the Leas-Cheann Comhairle for being here for most of the debate.

Comment on this