We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill 2025: Report and Final Stages

Summary

Deputy Doherty sought a report on exempting the first €40,000 of earnings from USC, arguing it would give meaningful relief to workers hit by the cost-of-living crisis; the Minister rejected it, saying the proposal would sharply narrow the tax base and that the Budget’s priorities were jobs and housing. Deputy Nash proposed annual reporting on the cost of indexing tax bands, credits and social welfare payments to inflation; the Minister said the information is already published and that automatic indexation would reduce budget flexibility, though he left the door open to future engagement. A separate cross-party amendment on employee share ownership trusts was welcomed in principle, with the Minister citing an existing review and ongoing stakeholder work, but he declined to accept a further report. The House also heard a detailed plea for tax support to help people displaced by defective concrete blocks access rental accommodation, but the Minister pointed instead to existing grants, upcoming legislation and a future review of the scheme.

Contributions 109–229 of 229. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 2025
Enacted

No. 60 of 2025 ›

I do not think the Tánaiste answered the question. I asked him where was the tax break for ordinary workers in this budget. There was none. There was naught for ordinary workers. How can the Tánaiste then justify giving a tax break to people who have gold-plated pensions anyway? As Deputy Doherty has outlined, this is a tax break of €325,000. I do not know who is watching here tonight but ordinary families are talking about the cost-of-living crisis, filling cars with petrol or diesel, the increase in the cost of home heating oil and not being able to pay for their electricity or struggling to do so. People are counting every cent when they go to the shops. You see them adding everything up on their phones or other devices because they can only buy so much. No breaks were given to those families in this budget. How can the Tánaiste justify doing this at the same time? I know he is new in the job but he has been in politics and this Government for a long time. I am sure there is nothing in this budget that he is not 100% across and that he does not 100% support.

I will ask my question again. Ordinary people out there might be watching this. They might not. They might be at home worrying like that lady I spoke to on Monday who is on the verge of panic attacks. Do you know what she said to me? She told me she cannot tell her husband because she does not want to worry him because he is going out to work every day. She is looking after the kids and working part-time. She is now looking at how she could work full-time. Ordinary people cannot keep a roof over their heads if they do not have two jobs. I was talking to a woman on the phone a while ago. She is in arrears with her HAP. She pays €130 a week in rent but she has to pay €490 as a HAP tenant. She is in arrears and could be out of her house in a month-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Deputy's time is up.

Comment on this

-----and the Tánaiste is giving tax breaks.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy Gould, your time is up. We have a long night ahead of us. Before the Tánaiste speaks, I will ask Deputies to stay on point. This is an amendment they are speaking to.

Comment on this

There is an amendment. We are giving tax breaks but not to ordinary people.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

It is an amendment and not an opportunity for general cross-party questioning.

Comment on this

That is largely the point I was going to make. I am not unsympathetic to the important issues Deputy Gould raises. I see them in my own constituency. I deal with people like that every day in my role as a public representative in Wicklow and a Member of this House since 2011. That is why we took a number of measures to address child poverty and working family poverty in the budget. I will not have time to outline them and it would not be relevant to this amendment to do so but we took a number of decisions in respect of the working family payment, payments in relation to children and increases to social welfare. We made sure that all of the new expenditure measures in the budget were progressive. As the Deputy would acknowledge, we also did not bring forward additional legislative measures in this Finance Bill for some of the reasons he has mentioned such as the pressures that other workers in our economy are other. I will make any future considerations in relation to the SFT in the context of future annual budgets.

Comment on this

The Minister did not have to bring forward other amendments in respect of the SFT. The Government has legislated for it to increase every year. That is why people are getting this €320,000 tax cut from Fine Gael. I must have missed that promise the Minister made. Which plinth was he standing on? During which press occasion during the general election campaign did he tell people he would provide a €320,000 tax break to people who have gold-plated pensions? I did not see anything like that in the run-up to the election.

Comment on this

It was legislated for.

Comment on this

It was legislated for in the Finance Bill just before the election, during the campaigning. That was a promise the Minister did not even make, but it is one he kept. He broke all of his promises to ordinary people. I will press the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:

In page 36, to delete lines 19 and 20.

I believe this to be largely a technical or cleaning-up amendment. As Deputies who addressed this Bill on Committee Stage will recall, there was a commencement provision included in section 28 to allow for state aid approval for the extension of the scheme as it comes under the agricultural block exemption regulation. The commencement provision is no longer required as the necessary consent from the European Commission for the extension of the measure has now been received. Therefore, this amendment removes the commencement provision because it is no longer required. The extension of scheme will now take effect from 1 January 2026.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In page 43, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following:

“Report on policy objectives and financial safeguards for Living Cities Initiative

30.The Minister shall, within 1 month of the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before Dáil Éireann a report on policy objectives and the financial safeguards that are in place given the scale of the reform and expansion of the scheme in terms of eligibility and granting access to developers to the scheme.”.

This amendment relates to the living cities initiative. This initiative has never taken off. If I am right, it was the brainchild of John Moran when he worked with the then Minister, Michael Noonan. He is now the directly elected mayor of Limerick. I could be wrong on this but I think it was focused on Limerick, inner-city Dublin and Georgian buildings. It did not really take off. Nearly every single Finance Bill was amended to expand the scope and criteria. The scheme has had an extremely low uptake. It is now being expanded again to include five other towns. From recollection, I believe that includes a town in my own county of Donegal. I have made the point that, based on the criteria, an argument could be made to allow Ballybofey, which probably has more vacancies than any other town in the county, to benefit from the initiative. The real issue here is that the scheme is being massively expanded. It is no longer just for Georgian buildings or buildings built before 1914 or whatever it was. It now applies to buildings built before 1974 or 1975. It was a date in that range. In some cases, there is no time limit whatsoever.

When we debated this many years ago, the then Minister, Michael Noonan, said that with things like this, you bring them in, you review them, and if they are not working you get rid of them. He was making the point that you have to take a risk with some of these schemes. That is fine. I understand that you have to take a risk with schemes but you also have to ensure there are safeguards in place. The amendment is based on the scale of the reform, the expansion of eligibility for the scheme and developers being granted access to the scheme. That was an anti-avoidance measure. It was explicitly made clear that developers would not be allowed in this scheme. They are now being allowed in the scheme under the amendment included in the Finance Bill. We need to ensure that there are financial safeguards and that the objectives are met. I want to see a report in relation to that. What assessment is going to be carried out in that regard? What early warning signals will let us know if this expansion is being exploited in a way that does not meet the objectives of the scheme? When are we likely to see some concrete data in relation to all of that?

Comment on this

The Deputy's initial analysis is somewhat right. He has the corporate memory to be able to go back to the then Minister, Michael Noonan. This scheme has not seen a very significant level of uptake. We have been trying to examine ways in which more people could benefit from this scheme, which brings properties back into use. Across the political spectrum, we all share the objective of trying to use every bit of underutilised capacity we can to provide housing. The Bill provides for substantial changes to the living cities initiative. The Deputy has noted the scale of the reform and the expansion of the scheme. These are significant changes but they are consistent with our policy intent. The changes were carefully considered and have built-in restrictions to limit the amount of relief that can be claimed. There is a €300,000 limit placed on an undertaking, which may include a business or landlord, availing of the scheme by the state aid de minimis regulation. To facilitate greater uptake of the measure, the Bill removes the restriction on connected persons to broaden the reach of the relief.

This will mean that a person connected with a developer of rented residential or commercial property within the scheme will be in a position to retain the property for the purpose of letting, but it should be noted that the state aid cap will still apply over a rolling three-year period.

In addition, the relief for income taxpayers is within the scope of the high earners' restriction, and any capital allowances remaining unused at the end of the tax life of the building will be terminated. A number of other features of the scheme implicitly set an upper limit on the Exchequer cost in respect of residential premises, including that the local authority must issue a letter of certification confirming that the cost of the refurbishment seems reasonable.

It is a good question as to what towns are included or not included. Many Deputies have made representations for other towns to be added, although not on the record of this House. There are always compelling cases. Considering that this is a significant expansion, what we have decided to do is to utilise the towns identified as the five regional centres in the national planning framework. This is a scheme that I would not rule out extending to further areas in the future. That is the rationale behind what we are doing. I believe there are enough safeguards built in. As the Deputy rightly implied, as the take-up has been so low to date, the policy aim has been to increase uptake in the first instance. We will monitor it and see how it goes this year and in future finance Bills.

Comment on this

I will leave it at that.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendments Nos. 22 and 23 have been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:

In page 64, between lines 4 and 5, to insert the following:

“Report on tax expenditures for property developers

42. The Minister shall, within 3 months of the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before Dáil Éireann a report on the fiscal and housing-market effects of tax reliefs and incentives available to property developers, and on alternative approaches to achieving housing-supply objectives without such tax expenditures.”.

The situation with tax expenditure for property developers is that profits in Glenveagh more than doubled in the last year. The CEO of Glenveagh properties saw his salary increase by 80% in 2024 to a whopping €2.7 million. At the same time we see people struggling with the cost of living and more than 5,000 homeless children, yet the prioritisation here is tax expenditure that boosts the profits of developers. The wrong choices are being made here and the wrong priorities. Tá na tosaíochtaí míchearta ag an Rialtas.

We need to have a review of all the tax expenditure. We have had multiple tax expenditures for developers over the years and it is clear they are not working. We are seeing profits increase, house prices and rents increase, and homelessness increase. While these measures are very costly, it would be much better to invest the money directly in more affordable housing rather than measures that boost profits for developers who already have very high profits.

The fact that profit levels in the two publicly listed companies are 20% and 21% and that we see growing tax expenditures that will boost those profits further is completely unjustifiable. The former Minister for Finance, Paschal Donohoe, when pressed on this in the committee, said that further tax expenditure in terms of VAT reduction would lead to an increase in further profits for developers. He was very upfront about that, and that it would not lead to more affordable housing. He said that the way he was going to boost viability was by increasing profits for developers even further, when we know the profits are already at very high levels - 20% and 21%.

The problem with a lot of these tax expenditures as well is that they are not connected with affordability conditions. They are not tied in with making housing more affordable. That is why this review is needed urgently. As the Tánaiste knows, a huge amount has been invested by the Government in housing, through a range of measures, including tax expenditures, but it is clearly not working and we are not getting the value for money that is needed. We are taking an approach that is way out of kilter with other European countries in terms of putting so much into tax expenditures. Most other European countries that are more successful in providing more affordable housing use the money much more directly to help build affordable homes rather than by having indirect tax expenditure measures.

As I am sure the Tánaiste knows, tax expenditure measures should be targeted and very carefully used. When they are too wide, and they go on for too long in any sector, there is a huge amount of deadweight and waste. That applies in the housing sector the same as any other sector. That is simply considered to be, in terms of good governance, a good use of resources. They are considered to be the basics. A very wide approach is being taken by the Government in its approach on housing and tax expenditures. I understand that there is a need for action in this area, but the resources are not being used well.

I recently mentioned to the Tánaiste what the spending review from the Department of public expenditure said about these approaches. It said the tax breaks are priced into what developers bid for land, thereby increasing bidding rates and displacing any savings in costs achieved elsewhere. The reviews done by the Department of public expenditure and reform should be taken seriously by the Government. That is its Department giving it advice about how best to use public resources in this area, and for some reason it is not being taken on board in terms of this measure.

The fact that those kind of spending reviews have not been taking place in the last few years is highly problematic as well. Detailed spending reviews used to be carried out by the Department of public expenditure and reform and then published, but that practice stopped in recent years. That needs to be addressed as well.

As I said already to the Tánaiste in recent days, we have a situation where profits are up, subsidies are up, tax expenditures are up and productivity in the sector is going down, as is the investment in productivity year after year. That is not right and it does not make sense. That should be ringing alarm bells for the Minister in terms of his approach not being the correct one. If that was happening in another sector, he would rightly point it out as being the wrong approach. I urge him to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

In the early days of my time in this office, I agree with the Deputy's broader point on spending reviews, not monetising every problem and making sure there is value for money. I will engage with colleagues in relation to that as well.

I also acknowledge, and Deputy Doherty made this point earlier, and I was not saying it to be discourteous, that the way the rules of this place work is that people request reports by way of an amendment, but often they do that to vocalise their opposition to or, the odd time, their support for a measure coming forward. I do not believe a report into this matter in the Finance Bill per se is the best way to proceed.

Let me deal with the substance of the issues Deputy O'Callaghan raises and share my perspective on them. We do take all decisions regarding taxation measures in line with our Department's tax expenditure valuation guidelines. These guidelines do make clear that any policy proposal that involves tax expenditure should only occur in limited circumstances where there are demonstrable market failures and where a tax-based incentive is deemed more efficient than a direct expenditure intervention. I have been making this point. We know we have different political viewpoints on this but we do have a significant number of apartment developments or planning permission for apartments. In this city alone there are more than 40,000 that people who build apartments have deemed unviable to construct currently. What we are trying to do here is reduce the viability gap through a number of ways. This is just one way by which we are trying to do it.

The guidelines on tax expenditure valuations were most recently updated in 2024. They also set out the criteria that should be considered as part of the reviews of tax expenditures as well. Targeted tax incentives to encourage people to build more apartments and increased capital investment in infrastructure to support new schemes form the main housing measures of budget 2026.

The root cause of viability issues in relation to apartments is structurally high costs. Accordingly, sustainable progress on improving viability requires a relentless focus on cost reduction that maximises private sector participation. We can all have our views on the profit levels of companies and everything else, but at the end of the day, we need these companies to build apartments. That also has to be effected. If they are not building today, they have decided it is not viable to build from their commercial proposition. Do we do something to make it viable or do we just not concern ourselves with that? I believe we seek to make those developments viable because we want people to have an opportunity to be able to access those homes.

Where data exists in relation to the Exchequer cost of tax relief for housing market development, its is publicly available and is included in the Department of Finance report on tax expenditures published annually in advance of the budget, as well as in Revenue's publication on the cost of tax expenditures. The Finance Bill 2025 provides for the changes to the tax system announced on budget day that are intended to complement direct expenditure and capital investment in housing. Going forward, as data becomes available for these new schemes, it will be included in my Department's annual report on tax expenditures. In line with my Department's guidelines for tax expenditure evaluation, any expenditures that are expiring will also be subject to detailed review. These reviews are published by my Department.

As the Deputy reminded us, my predecessor committed to continuing to review the interplay of different tax schemes. I, too, commit to doing that. Having regard to the fact that indicative costings have already been prepared and published for the new measures - and, as stated, these will be included in the annual report on tax expenditures going forward and as data becomes available - I do not believe that an additional report is specifically necessary at this time. However, I am happy to engage with the Deputy on the thrust of what he is trying to get at, which is to look at the interplay between the different tax schemes and the benefit involved in terms of advancing the policy objectives. I will undertake to do that. I will also undertake to engage constructively, no doubt at the Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure, Public Service Reform and Digitisation and Taoiseach, as this issue arises in the period ahead.

Comment on this

On the spending reviews that have been stopped, we need to do something to fix that because those reviews are important in terms of value for money. I understand there is work going on, but that the results of that work are not being published to the same level as previously. As a result, we are not seeing the benefit of that analysis publicly.

Of the 90,000 planning permissions that are not being built out, more than 40,000 are in Dublin. The latter mainly relate to apartments. The one thing that has worked in the context of getting movement on apartment planning permissions that have been there for years but that have not been acted upon does not relate to the different tax expenditures. Where that has worked - it can be seen in large-scale developments like Clongriffin, where apartment planning permissions were not getting built out for years - is where the LDA has come in and built out planning permissions quite fast, incidentally. These are developments which have stalled for well over a decade or almost two decades. They are being built out now quite fast by the LDA. We can debate the affordability of those apartments, but they are certainly somewhat affordable. They are below the full market price. That is working. The money that is going into that is working, whereas there is no evidence that any of the money that is going into the various different tax expenditures is delivering. Not only is what the LDA is doing delivering in terms of build-out, but, as I said, there is an affordability element as well. That is worth thinking about. That is why this review is needed urgently, namely within three months. If the Tánaiste was in a position to state that the Department is doing the spending reviews and the proper analysis that it used to do and publishing the results, he would have a case not to accept the amendment. However, that is not happening.

Comment on this

I raised this issue earlier. We have later amendments in relation to the reduced VAT rate on apartments that have been ruled out of order. This amendment from Deputy O'Callaghan deals with the tax reliefs that have been brought in by the Government for property developers.

The former Minister made the claim at the start of the debate on this Bill that this measure was designed to reduce the cost of apartments. Nothing could be further from the truth. It is not about reducing the cost of apartments. I will again put on the record what the former Minister had to say only two weeks ago when he debated this issue with us at the finance committee. He stated:

If we were to bring forward a measure like this, which would also be an affordability measure, logically, it could not be a viability measure at the same time. It cannot be both.

He was open, transparent and, indeed, honest. This is not about reducing the cost of apartments. It is not about affordability. The former Minister made clear that it cannot be both; it is about viability. What does viability translate as? It means that profits for developers have to be sufficient for them to decide to build out at this point.

I have made the point that there is good research - this does not mean to say that it applies here - in Britain that looks at the market dominance of a number of players and how they use that dominance in terms of land hoarding, building selectively, releasing certain properties at certain times and squeezing the UK Government for more incentives. By God, did developers here squeeze the Government and get what they wanted. We talk about finance measures and an element of deadweight, basically, the effect of the measure and that maybe 30% or 40% of the activity that it is hoped to bring about would already happen even without the tax measure. Has there ever been a tax cut like this where 100% of the expenditure for next year, namely €250 million, is considered deadweight? Every apartment that will be the subject of reduced VAT is viable. Every one of them is currently under construction. The former Minister told me that, since it was introduced on budget day, this measure has already cost over €20 million. That is what it costs per month.

It is not even just next year that the deadweight will apply. It will continue into 2027. The vast majority of the €390 million that this is going to cost in 2027 relates to apartments that are already under construction. We know that because apartments cannot be built in a year. It just cannot be done. On average, it takes two years to build apartments. VAT is paid, obviously, at the point of sale in arrears. Therefore, the vast majority - if not all - of any benefit that will be accrued next year or the year after will be in respect of apartments that are either under construction or about to go to construction. That is the level of deadweight involved. That is the amount of money we are talking about.

I have called those in this Government serial wasters in the past. My party president has raised the issue of more waste that we have seen in terms of steps in a public park that cost more than €700,000. There are many examples of this but, by God, what we are discussing here takes the biscuit. The Government is giving €640 million next year and the year after in a tax break to developers for apartments that are already being built. There are 18,000 apartments being built at present. Apartments that were sold last week benefited from this tax break. Apartments that are going to be sold next week will benefit from it. There are viable. If they were not viable, they would not be being built.

The Tánaiste is talking about a measure and disclaims the fact that this is not about selective release, house prices, pushing up prices, etc. Let us pretend that is not the case for a moment. The Tánaiste is talking about a measure that is about releasing new apartments into the system. Of the €1.5 billion that this measure is going to cost for the three years that it will be in existence, however, over €600 million will go into the pockets of developers who are already building apartments. The Government has not even attempted to hide whose side it is on.

I made the point earlier that these developers are making huge operational profits. The two largest companies in the State are publicly listed. Thankfully, they have to publish their accounts. We can see their operational profits of 20% and 21%, respectively. That is not somebody scrapping to get by; it is a massive transfer of wealth. The Government does that. The Tánaiste will defend this at a time when the Government screwed over so many people in the budget, when it left people so much worse off, when it refused to deal with the cost-of-living crisis, when so many people are under pressure with their energy costs, when so many are under pressure with their petrol and diesel costs and when so many are finding it tough to put food on the table because of grocery price increases. Of course, the Tánaiste has to balance the books. Of course, he has to make sure that the Government's priorities are to the fore. Of course, there is not an endless amount of money available to the State. However, the Government made choices. It made the choice to put €250 million into the pockets of developers next year in respect of apartments that they are already building. The Government made the choice to put €390 million into the pockets of those same developers the following year for apartments that are currently under construction. Those are the wrong choice. They are the choices of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. They are the choices of a Government that does not have the backs of ordinary workers, because it has screwed them over. Again, the Government's priorities are clear. There are always winners and losers.

Under Fine Gael, the winners in this case with this measure are the developers.

I missed the press conference before the election where the Minister promised hundreds and hundreds of millions of euro to developers. Was that just a wee side, secret, private deal with them? The Government broke all its public promises to renters, on childcare, and to the people who wanted the income tax relief it promised them.

Comment on this

The two previous speakers have summed up how we are giving massive tax breaks to developers. Hundreds of millions of euro in tax breaks are being given for apartments that are nearly built or are under construction. The Minister is an intelligent man. Why would the Government give someone a tax break when that property is already viable to be sold? Developers and builders do not construct apartments and apartment blocks if they are going to lose money, especially when we know they are making massive profits. The Minister is an intelligent guy and has an intelligent Department around him. I am trying to figure out the logic. The Minister is sitting there and this Government is sitting down and putting this plan together. Who came up with the suggestion, "Let's look after the developers. They're not making enough money"? Who suggested that €750 million?

Sometimes, when you talk to ordinary people in the street, they can get their heads around €1 million because they think of the Lotto being €2 million or €5 million this week. It is now €500,000 to buy a house, when you think of it. People can just about visualise what a million or millions are, but when you talk about hundreds of millions and €750 million, that is money people cannot get their heads around. They certainly cannot get their heads around how this Government chose to give those tax breaks on properties that were already profitable. I will ask the Tánaiste one straight question. Does he not accept that the apartments that are under construction and nearly completed were profitable? I am asking him honestly, man to man, if he does accept that, how can he justify giving them hundreds of millions of euro? How can he justify that?

As Deputy Doherty said, that commitment was never stated before the election. Can you imagine if that commitment was made four weeks before the election? Members of the Government parties came out and said they were building 40,000 houses, which they knew in their heart and soul was not right. They knew that in their heart and soul when they were doing their press conference. It was not us saying it. The ESRI, the Central Bank and people on the ground were saying it. The Department knew it because it is getting the figures in. The Taoiseach or the Tánaiste talked about Deutsche Bank or somewhere. Then, when they come in here, they use the ESRI and the Central Statistics Office when they are trying to justify certain things. Last year, when they were campaigning, which is a year ago now, they said they were going to deliver 40,000 houses, which the dogs in the street knew they were not delivering. Why did they not tell the people well before the election that they were going to give €750 million to developers who are already making vast profits? It was because they would have been run out of the boxes.

There is a question here of the Tánaiste's honour. He and members of this Government made comments during the election that were not true, or they withheld information from the public. They come in here and slag us and say, "Well, ye didn't get elected this time." At least we were open and honest with voters about what we were going to do. People might say they did not agree with it, but at least we put down on paper where we stood. The Government hoodwinked the public. Does the Tánaiste think he can justify that to the ordinary man in the street who cannot buy a house? I know families who have split up because he is going to live with his family, and she is going to live with hers, because they are trying to put a deposit together to buy a house. People are coming to me just when they have their mortgage approval, have saved hard and done everything right, but when they go to buy a house they cannot because house prices are going up faster than they can save. Does the Tánaiste think about whether he told them the Government was going to give developers and speculators vast tax breaks?

People trusted the Government and it betrayed the trust of ordinary people. People are suffering now. Every day, those people are heading to Australia, Canada and all over the world because they do not see a future here. It is obvious where the Government's priorities lie, looking after the big developers and not ordinary, hardworking people who are, as a previous Tánaiste said, getting up early in the morning. The other question people ask me is why they are getting up early in morning because they cannot buy houses, cannot look after their families and are crippled by the cost-of-living crisis.

Comment on this

I will endeavour to keep to the amendment at this late hour of the night. I have plenty I could l say about general election promises in other parties' manifestos and where the average price of €300,000 for a home in Dublin is, etc., which was promised by Sinn Féin. We will return to all that another day.

Comment on this

We are not in government so we are not breaking our promises.

Comment on this

You dropped the promise and clarified it after-----

Comment on this

No, we did not.

Comment on this

We are not in government.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Stick to the debate, Deputies.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste is encouraging it.

Comment on this

We will return to all that another day. I am just making the point-----

Comment on this

Do you want a shovel?

Comment on this

I am making the point respectfully-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Please, Deputy Doherty. Respectful, please.

Comment on this

I am making the point respectfully that I sit here and hear wrongful framing and misrepresentation of my party, our manifesto and the general election. I look forward to debating that. As the leader of Fine Gael, I will debate that with the leader of Sinn Féin in due course. I look forward to that opportunity.

In relation to the amendment before the House, I do not have a huge amount more to add other than to say that I agree on the need for spending reviews. The Minister, Deputy Chambers, does too. It is something I will take away from the points put forward by Deputy O'Callaghan.

While some have been pining for Paschal this evening, and there has been a little bit of "Paschal said this and Paschal said that", Deputy Doherty made the point about budget books being different in the past. I will constructively engage with him and Deputy O'Callaghan on that. Transparency and maximum information for the Oireachtas is a good thing in how we make sense of policy decisions, and each of us doing our job as well.

I accept there are many different views on the VAT measure but, from our perspective, it is a measure around viability and supply. The people will judge, at the end of the term of this Government, whether it has had the desired effect or not. It is about reducing the cost of building apartments. That does have benefits for housing supply. I should say, because a lot has been said about people trying to buy homes, that we are, thankfully, this year seeing the highest number of first-time buyers in this country since 2007. We are living through a housing emergency but that statistic should not be ignored.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I ask for reasonable discourse from everybody.

Comment on this

I will. I will make the point, first of all, that I am not sure whether the Tánaiste withdraws the fact that it is about affordability, or does he agree with his predecessor that it is actually about so-called viability?

Comment on this

It is the viability.

Comment on this

Okay, but you cannot have it both ways. You cannot make it up as you are going along, in fairness. It is too big an issue.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste did not address the fact that these companies are making huge profits in the first instance. I challenge the Tánaiste on this because he gave the impression in his comments that I was misrepresenting the promises he made to the electorate. In his response, will he explain? Did he not make the promise to reduce tax each year to workers? Did he not make the promise to provide a roadmap on childcare within 100 days? Did he not make the promise to reduce third level fees, which went up €500 compared with last year? Are these promises he did not make? Am I imagining things? Are the records and videos all false and AI generated?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

They are not part of the amendment.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste introduced this subject.

Comment on this

I actually did not, in fairness.

Comment on this

I responded to a mirage.

Comment on this

You introduced the subject that you did not make these promises. He introduced the subject.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Please.

Comment on this

I just wanted to remind the Tánaiste of the commitments he made-----

Comment on this

Thank you so much.

Comment on this

-----to the public that he is breaking, and the commitment he never made to developers, at least in public, that the Government was going to stuff hundreds of millions of euro into their pockets through a reduced VAT rate.

Comment on this

The Deputy should withdraw that.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste did not answer the question from Deputy Gould-----

Comment on this

Withdraw that slur. I did not make----

Comment on this

-----in relation to whether he believes that the 17,000 or 18,000 apartments that are being built are actually viable. If so, then why has the Government decided to provide hundreds of millions of euro into the pockets of developers for valuable apartments?

Comment on this

I would like that question answered.

Comment on this

Yesterday, when we took a financial resolution in this House-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I am sorry, Tánaiste, Deputy O'Callaghan is in possession.

Comment on this

-----I responded and the record of the House shows the response.

Comment on this

I thank the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Excuse me.

Comment on this

It is my amendment.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Yes, it is.

Comment on this

I welcome what the Tánaiste said about spending reviews. On the profits, profit levels are 20% and 21%. The Minister's predecessor is on record saying that this will increase viability and output, and increase profits. That is what we were told in Committee. How high does he think the profits have to go? Profit levels of 20% and 21% are double what they were in the previous year for one of those companies. How much higher do they need to go to make this viable? Does the Minister accept that these measures will increase profits even further? Of course when the private sector is involved in construction, it is going to have to have a profit level, but 20% and 21% does not need additional tax relief.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 57
·
Níl 77
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Tairgim leasú Uimh. 25:

In page 68, line 26, to delete “appropriate,”,” and substitute the following:

“appropriate,

(vii) a condition that the qualifying company shall, in respect of the qualifying film concerned, comply fully with the Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000 and the Directive (EU) 2019/790 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 April 2019,

(viii) a condition that the qualifying company shall make every effort to ensure that performers, writers, composers, artists and other film workers resident within the jurisdiction will not be subject to lesser terms and conditions regarding the licencing or assignment of their intellectual property rights than persons resident outside the jurisdiction engaged in similar roles when employed on the same qualifying film, and

(ix) a condition that the qualifying company shall not require performers, writers, composers, artists or other film workers to sign away their rights to future residual payments for their work on a qualifying film, or to agree to a so-called ‘buy-out’ contract, as a pre-condition of working on the qualifying film,”,”.

Guím gach rath ar an Tánaiste ina phost nua. Tá súil agam go ndéanfaidh sé beart de réir a bhriathair. Níl mé chun dul sa mhéid a bhí an Teachta Doherty ag rá leis, ach tá jab mór roimhe agus tá súil agam go mbeidh tairbhe ann do phobal na hÉireann uilig.

This amendment is very specific. It deals with the section 481 tax relief. We have what is no longer a fledgling film industry; it is there. The Minister, in particular, will be aware of the benefits of the film industry in his county. However, there have been quite a lot of issues from a worker's point of view as to whether we get the best benefit for our buck. Tax relief is tax forgone by the State, and that means we need to make sure we are getting the full benefit. This amendment does not deal with some of the practices that have undermined workers' rights, including their protective rights. The amendment deals specifically with the contracts workers are being forced to sign. They are being asked to sign away their rights and being encouraged to bypass the European directive and Irish law, otherwise they will not get the work that is front of them. The proposal is to change the conditionality that exists for the section 481 tax relief, that is, the certification that is required to be filled in and the additional conditionality included in that, which would mean that the companies that are trying to flaunt the law in Ireland by offering lesser conditions for workers in this field would not be able to continue to do so.

I was not able to speak on this amendment when Paschal Donohoe was before the committee. In rejecting the amendment in committee, he outlined that he did "not believe it is appropriate for legal rights to be linked to only one set of circumstances where a company avails of a tax credit". It is extraordinary that the Government would oppose an attempt to ensure that a basic requirement, compliance with the law, should be a condition for receiving tax relief and that Irish workers should not face worse conditions on an Irish State-supported film than co-workers from abroad. The amendment I have set out would ensure that certificates required for the section 481 tax relief could only be issued to qualifying companies that do not treat Irish performers any worse than their peers from other jurisdictions doing the same work, to companies which comply with copyright legislation and to companies which do not engage in the practice of so-called buy-out contracts.

Serious concerns have been raised by Irish Equity over contracts being drawn up by legal advisers at the request of certain producers which both agents and the artists are required to sign in order to get work with the excuse that particular clauses are required in the interests of legal certainty. These contracts appear to be worded in a manner that sets out to diminish the Copyright and Related Rights Act and the EU copyright directive. A performer cannot agree that a sum of money amounts to a proportionate remuneration without knowing what is proportionate in advance of revenue being earned. The aim of requiring such agreement is to protect any future claim and possibly also any contractual adjustments based on subsequent revenues, and this is contrary to Article 20 of the EU copyright directive. Building in buyouts as a norm for performers and creators undermines the directive.

Transparency mechanisms should also be agreed to adapt the remuneration to subsequent revenues and trigger revision of the initial contract when revenues are disproportionately higher than the remuneration initially agreed. Terms of use must be defined in order for the assessment of the projected revenues to be properly made. There are more questionable clauses contained in those contracts that demand that artists sign away their rights for a period of ten years' unlimited use for a fixed amount. This is a buyout contract and will not provide any structure that will allow equitable or proportionate revenue share going to those artists for the ongoing exploitation of their production and their contribution.

We have also been provided with a casting advice note for a television series which was being produced or is being produced here at present, a co-production in receipt of section 481 relief. The Irish producers are using the 2016 SPI Equity indigenous television agreement which, in fact, ran out in 2019 and as a result is no longer fit for purpose, nor is it compliant with current legislation. There is a wider issue of productions marketing themselves as Pact or Equity equivalent or claiming to be in line with the Equity rate without providing the appropriate contract. This is not the same as operating under an actual registered collective agreement such as the Pact-Equity agreement itself and that distinction matters. The casting advice note specifies that the contract would be for a ten-year worldwide licence. It states:

...the Company shall have the right to use Artist’s name, voice and likeness in connection with any merchandising relating to the Series and no royalties or other additional compensation shall be payable in connection therewith.

It goes on to state that:

No additional compensation if render services on a Related Production during the Dates of Engagement. If outside of Dates of Engagement, services shall be subject only to Artists prior professional commitments (notified to the Company in advance)(Artist shall use best endeavours to accommodate Company’s schedule). To maximise effectiveness of any Related Production (and, thus, the Series), Company is entitled to use extracts from the Series within any Related Production at no additional cost.

I will continue in my second contribution.

Comment on this

Ar dtús guím ádh mór ar an Tánaiste ina phost nua. Dúirt an Teachta Ó Snodaigh an fhírinne gur post an-tábhachtach é.

I am speaking in support of Deputy Ó Snodaigh's amendment. I, Deputy Ó Snodaigh and a number of other Deputies, including Deputy Boyd Barrett, have spoken over many years about section 481. As positive as it has been in providing tax credits and ensuring we have a thriving film industry, there are particular issues with workers' rights and copyright. We believe we need to look after those who work to make films happen. We are talking about cast, crew and writers. Particularly when we are talking about writers and those who have been involved in the creative process, we need to ensure they are not forced into foregoing rights that they should have and they should not forego moneys and remuneration that should be due to them. I have made the case many times before and I will reiterate it.

We need to look at the whole sphere in relation to section 481. We all see the positives but we have all heard many cases of how people basically get employed. There have been many court cases over when an employer is not an employer. That is when it becomes a designated activity company, DAC. The whole idea is that the producers draw down the section 481 relief but then a DAC is formed and it exists for the period of the project. A particular issue relates to who can be chased down or held accountable about workers' rights. This is probably being rectified at this point in time through these court cases but I believe the State needs to make sure it steps in to ensure that workers' rights are upheld and that the working time directive and other workers' rights, which were hard fought for, are enforced when to a degree there is nobody to hold accountable to enforce them. That particular issue needs to be dealt with.

As others have, I have used the analogy of 1913 in the sense that this is a case where if somebody is to be employed, a head of department - I think that is the term - makes the call. Deputy Ó Snodaigh and I have had a number of meetings with those who have been aggrieved in relation to this. The idea is that the person who shouts too loud and looks for their rights too much will not get the phone call. The belief is that there is a serious issue with blackballing and that needs to be dealt with.

The whole idea with section 481 is that we have a thriving film industry that provides really good employment where people have their absolute rights. If we do not do that, we will have an issue with the product that is produced. There have also been complaints about the ratio of those who are in training to those who have a huge amount of experience. We have heard of instances where reshoots have had to be carried out, sometimes even abroad. Section 481 will always be worthwhile, but the State needs to ensure that we are getting a bang for our buck and that the film industry is protected. We cannot have a case of too many people taking too many shortcuts and actually undercutting the industry and undercutting the rights of workers in delivering this.

I would like to think that there would be a decent hearing of this amendment and that we would look at it as a possible solution - a small solution - in relation to the particular issues we are talking about. A wider conversation is needed and there is an absolute need to look at section 481 from the point of view of securing workers' rights and making sure we have a sustainable and thriving film industry that works for all involved into the future. I would have serious concerns. This issue has been brought up many times before and has not been resolved yet.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputies Ó Snodaigh and Ó Murchú for their good wishes. I acknowledge the input of Members of this House, including those I just mentioned, on matters concerning the audiovisual sector in recent years, including through the examination at the Committee on Budgetary Oversight.

My officials have directly engaged with all relevant representative bodies in the sector, including those representing crew, cast, and producers, to understand the issues affecting the audiovisual sector and to try to chart a pathway forward. The attention brought to issues in the sector by representative bodies, and by Members of this House, has contributed to real progress being achieved on many fronts. A key point for all of us to understand is there is a copyright directive on related legislation, which established overarching principles, in this case, the right to appropriate and proportional remuneration. The details of what exactly that entails, for example, the balance of remuneration between upfront daily rates and potential profit sharing post-release and differences between large and small productions need to be agreed between representative bodies in the industry with the overarching protection of the legislative proposals. In January 2025, an interim set of guidelines relating to copyright was agreed by a number of stakeholders in the sector in Ireland. This is a very welcome development and one I hope will lead to a permanent agreement in the sector. It is my understanding that stakeholders still continue to work proactively together and the group is working collectively on the next level of detail on the operations of the oversight committee, which will result in the implementation of these guidelines and a best practice approach to reporting. An Irish negotiated agreement, built upon the foundations already laid with the agreement of the interim set of guidelines is the best course for the sector to take.

Copyright law falls within the remit of the Department of the Enterprise, Tourism and Employment. Copyright is relevant for many workers in the film sector, whether they are authors, producers, broadcasters and performers, and there are complex legal issues involved. Deputies may be aware, from previous discussions in the House and during Committee Stage of this Bill, and what I just outlined a moment ago, that a process is under way to address these issues. An independent facilitator was retained by Screen Ireland in 2023 to meet with a group of key stakeholders to identify and understand issues relevant to the digital Single Market directive, referred to as the copyright directive. As a result of that we have gotten to the point in relation to interim best practice industry guidelines while they pursue a path towards a collective bargaining agreement. There are clear precedents for this form of progress in the sector. Deputies will be aware that there has been significant progress in the terms and conditions provided to film workers over the last number of years, including negotiated crew agreements for film and construction crew. For example, the construction crew agreement, in addition to setting pay rates, provides for the extension of coverage for pension, sick leave and other benefits to industry construction workers under the construction workers pension scheme. It also provided for the establishment of a joint monitoring structure that helps to ensure the agreement is appropriately implemented.

It is appropriate for legal rights to be linked only to one set of circumstances, and I know that is not what the Deputies are hoping to achieve. We should not link legal rights only to a situation where a company avails of a tax credit. It is very important to recognise that the laws that underpin copyright apply regardless of whether a company applies for section 481, and they must apply equally. A company cannot choose to disapply the provisions of the copyright directive just because it is not applying for an allowance under the section 481. I acknowledge the constructive way in which this was put forward. I also acknowledge the work in this House and by Members, including Deputy Ó Snodaigh, has been very helpful in this regard but I am informed that good progress is being made and I do want an Irish negotiated agreement. We will continue to monitor this closely.

Comment on this

On the last point, in some ways I agree with the Minister that laws cannot be disapplied but the problem is the frustration for people when the law is being ignored. The point Deputy Ó Murchú was making is that one of the problems is that to avail of section 481, companies are set up, which then disappear, so the Minister does not have recourse to chase after them after the fact. When artists try to start a process - and the courts move very slowly - at that stage the production is completed and the vehicle that was set up to avail of section 481 has disappeared. It is quite clear.

Very few artists have the luxury of being able to challenge what is put in front of them. They are asked to sign away their rights, and I can quote contracts that artists have been asked to sign where they specifically state the artist acknowledges that the "fees payable herein constitute a complete buyout of all rights contemplated hereunder". That is a buyout and that is contrary to law, but artists are not going to be in a position if they want an income there and then or over the following couple of months to waive that because the contract I am referring to also states: "No artist can render on-camera services until the artist agreement has been signed by the artist". They are being held at ransom: "Sign this, or you will not work." That is not the type of industry we want.

I will come back to another point, which shows that there can be discrimination between people employed in England to work in Ireland and people who are contracted directly here.

Comment on this

In fairness, Deputy Ó Snodaigh has synopsised well. A designated activity company is set up. It might be the same producer. Those involved may employ the same people for a number of years but they are seen as the employer and then they suddenly disappear. Therefore they cannot be held to account. I have outlined the particular issue is if somebody does try to raise a head of steam on issues that might pertain to the ratio or the work practices.

We want to make sure we have decent work practices and that we ensure the product delivered is good and ensures a sustainable film industry. We need to find a means of dealing with this. We cannot have a scenario of people being blackballed when just looking for the enforcement of their rights. Deputy Ó Snodaigh referred to disapplication. We are dealing with a scenario where there is no real application at this point in time. Again, there are disputes even regarding what agreements have been made in the industry and who has a right to make an agreement. That is for another day. Whatever happens with this amendment, we really need to deal with this particular issue. We need to make sure we have a sustainable film industry and that means we have to look after workers' rights. We need to make sure people are not being forced into scenarios where they are signing away their residuals. We are talking about rights and ensuring we have people who we want to see in the creative process. At this point in time I have real deep worries. We need to make sure we find the means of dealing with this. This is step in the right direction, but even if this is not supported by Government, we do need a long-term solution.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputies. We have a thriving audiovisual and film sector. Deputy Ó Snodaigh made that point. It is a good thing for our country, but at the same time we also want to make sure it is working well and working well for workers and that workers' rights are always to the fore. We have seen genuine progress in stakeholders engaging with the interim guidelines and I would like a full Irish negotiated agreement.

I understand why the Deputies are bringing this up, and they are quite right in bringing it up in the Finance Bill because of the application of section 481. However, the issues the Deputies are rightly highlighting relate to employment rights. We have taken a number of steps in previous Finance Acts to reinforce the importance of adhering to employment rights legislation, including the Finance Act 2018, which amended the certification process to require that an undertaking for compliance with all relevant employment legislation is signed, that a skills development plan for workers on the production submitted and agreed, and the certification process provides that the Minister for culture, after considering the application applying a set of tests may issue a cultural certificate as well. A lot of this also falls down to how we ensure that rights are upheld. Certainly, on the foot of this debate, I will send a copy of the transcript to the Ministers for Culture, Communications and Sport and Enterprise, Tourism and Employment because organisations in the State have a statutory obligation regarding employment legislation and workers' rights.

I acknowledge the point about when a production is finished, the company can disappear.

My understanding is that the DAC must stay in existence for at least 12 months after the end of the production. Valid issues have been raised. I do not wish to link the issue of legal and employment rights to the application of section 481 of a Finance Act, but I do not dismiss the points the Deputy has made and I will undertake to carry out the actions I have set out.

Comment on this

I hear the reluctance, which has been there all along, to add conditionality to section 481. There is an acknowledgement of changes in a flourishing industry. We need to make sure that while it flourishes the message goes out from here, from the Government and from Revenue that any attempts to mislead will not be tolerated in any shape or form. This applies to only one or two companies, but it seems to be a habit to try to bypass the EU copyright directive in any way or force artists to waive their hard won rights or to waive their rights to income because a lot of this concerns residuals. If a film is successful, money comes back from it being shown over and over again. Artists have residual rights to their own work. The EU directive sets out in black and white that performers have a right to equitable remuneration which cannot be waived. That is the intention of the amendment. The contracts I quoted very clearly demanded the waiving of those rights. At least this issue has been given a hearing. If it continues in the way it is going, we will be back to this again next year if there has been no movement. We will deal with this again if Equity and other representatives of performers are able to show us that artists are being asked to work under worse conditions than those employed on the same production in England and who have the rights that pertain in England rather than those which pertain here. That means they work under lesser conditions. I am glad we have had the debate and I welcome the commitments the Minister has given.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 86, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:

“Report on taxation of bailed-out banks

50.The Minister shall, within 3 months of the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before Dáil Éireann a report on the amount of tax revenue lost as a result of bailed-out banks facing no restriction on their ability to off-set corporation taxes using historic losses related to the crash and making specific reference to the number of years the bailed-out banks will be able to avoid tax into the future as a result of these deferred tax assets.”.

This amendment relates to the fact that the banks in the State pay little or no tax as a result of a measure introduced by Fine Gael a number of years ago. As the Minister may recall, during the financial crisis, the Minister for Finance at the time, Brian Lenihan, introduced, through the NAMA Act, a measure that would ensure that banks would only be allowed to carry forward 50% of their losses, recognising, as he did at that time, that despite the fact the banks were about to incur tens of billions of euro in losses they would some day be profitable. I think it was in the Seanad he said at the time that as soon as the banks were profitable they should pay tax to the Irish taxpayer. We know that was the case for a number of years. The Fine Gael and Labour Government changed the rules to allow them to carry forward 100% of their losses. The Minister may say that is what happens with all normal companies in the State. That is fine, but these are not normal companies. These are companies that only exist today because the taxpayer was forced to rescue them at that time and the Minister for Finance made it very clear in legislation that they should be treated differently and only allowed to carry forward 50% of their losses.

In terms of what we allow in respect of carrying losses forward, we are out of kilter with competitors across the OECD. In some cases, there is a limit whereby companies can carry losses forward for ten years or cannot carry forward 100% of the losses all of the time. We do both. We allow for an undefined period of time. Companies can carry forward losses for eternity if the losses are there. We also allow them to carry forward 100% of losses.

It is a wider point, but the reality is, as I mentioned, that banks in the State such as AIB and Bank of Ireland made €5 billion in profits between them last year and did not pay any tax to the State on that level of profit. That is absolutely appalling. Much of the profit being made is being made as a result of the interest rate environment and is off the back of the fact that they charge higher mortgage interest rates than our European competitors or the EU average. It is because people are being fleeced as a result of bank charges and so on.

To add insult to injury, banks are not paying tax on that level of profit, which is not acceptable. I ask the Minister to provide clarity on the situation with AIB. We know Bank of Ireland will be able to carry forward losses for another three years until the end of 2028. It is likely that it will not be 2029 or the following year until Bank of Ireland is paying taxes because its losses can be carried forward. That is two decades after the crash.

Permanent TSB is worse. It will be able to carry forward losses for another 12 years. It will be 2037 before Permanent TSB will have to start paying tax. I do not have the figure for AIB. Perhaps the Minister will enlighten us as to how long he will allow AIB to not pay taxes in the State.

Comment on this

I remember the financial crisis and the destruction that came. People lost businesses and homes. Some lost everything. There were marriage breakups. In some tragic cases, people died by suicide as a result of the financial crash. Fast forward to 2025 and the banks are making vast profits. Where is the fairness? Where is the justice? The people at the heart of the financial crash who were bailed out by the State – every man, woman and child bailed out the banks – are allowed to write off 100% of their losses until they run out of losses for which they can claim. Ordinary people could not do that.

In 2009, Phil Hogan was the Minister for housing and €1.6 billion was given to local authorities in central Government funding. In this budget, €670 million is being given, almost €1 billion less than in 2008 and 2009. The Minister will ask what this has to do with anything. I will tell him. People in every local authority area in the State are living in apartments and houses with windows that leak, doors that do not close properly, mould, damp and leaks. People are living in cold houses. Rents in Dublin increased this week.

The Minister will ask how this is related. If we collected tax from the banks, we would be able to give local authorities the funding they need so that people would not live in cold and damp houses. We would be able to give people money for energy credits so that they could keep the heating on this winter. When people ask what this has to do with anything, it has to do with everything because if the banks paid tax on the profits they are making it would fund energy credits and there would be no need for students to have to pay an extra €500. The Government may have been able to deliver childcare at a cost of €200 per week in the budget, a commitment it gave. By allowing the banks to claim 100% on their losses, we are denying people in this State money which is badly needed.

I hold a clinic every Monday. Originally when I started it was 12.50 p.m. and now it is 1.50 p.m. and stretches to 3 p.m. I spend the whole of Monday dealing with people. A major issue outside of housing is housing maintenance.

There are people living in substandard accommodation. I know volunteers who fix up people's houses because local authorities' staff were slashed during the austerity years and they do not have the funding to put into accommodation.

Local authorities get blamed for a lot but this is about choices. The Government chose to give the banks tax breaks. A choice was made not to tax them properly on their profits. That means ordinary men and women, who are struggling with the cost-of-living crisis arising from Government decisions, very like other decisions that were made earlier in regard to developers and banks, have to pay. People ask what is the difference. The difference is we are standing here wanting equality. We want the banks to pay their fair share. Is that too much to ask? Is it too much to ask the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance that the banks pay their fair share? If ordinary men and women must pay their fair share, why should the banks not have to do so? We could use that money in so many good ways that would help people. It is about quality of life. The Government's choices are negatively impacting on people's quality of life. I ask the Tánaiste to reconsider.

Comment on this

The restriction on the amount of loss relief available to NAMA-participating institutions, which was introduced by the National Asset Management Agency Act 2009, as Deputy Doherty correctly recalls, limited the offset of losses carried forward to a maximum of 50% of the trading profits for each accounting period. The cap only affected the timing of the relief; it did not affect the overall quantum of relief, with restricted losses in any given year being carried forward to subsequent years. The only remaining NAMA-participating banks are Bank of Ireland and AIB. As tax losses forward are included as a deferred tax asset on a company's balance sheet, this restriction meant those assets would have stayed on the bank's balance sheets for longer.

When the restriction was introduced in 2009, the Government had limited involvement in the banking system. However, by the introduction of the Finance Bill 2013, the State had acquired substantial shareholdings in the banking sector, specifically, 99.8% of AIB and 15% of Bank of Ireland. Furthermore, as a result of the EU's capital requirements directive, CRD, IV rules, deferred tax assets in respect of trading losses were no longer to be considered core tier 1 capital. Taking these factors into account, the restriction no longer served its original purpose and, indeed, worked against the Irish taxpayer. It created the risk that the accounting value of these tax losses could be reduced on foot of auditor recommendations, which would impact negatively on the State's equity investments. It increased the risk the State might have had to put more capital into one or more of the participating institutions as a result. That was the advice available to the Government of the day. The repeal of the loss restriction shortened the timeframe over which the losses were likely to be used and greatly reduced the deduction from capital required under CRD IV. It put the institutions in a stronger position when being assessed by regulators and investors and reduced the risk of a future requirement for State support.

Deputy Doherty asked a specific question about the length of time for which AIB intended to utilise the losses. The information available to me, according to the most recent financial statements for the year ending 31 December 2024, is that Bank of Ireland projected it to be utilised in full by the end of 2028, Permanent TSB in approximately 12 years and AIB in less than ten years. However, it should be noted that this is tied to growth and a decrease in growth will result in the utilisation period increasing by approximately one year. That is the latest information available to me.

As Deputies are aware, corporation tax relief is a long-standing feature of the Irish corporate tax system. It is a standard feature of corporation tax systems in most OECD countries. It recognises that a business cycle runs over several years and beyond and that tax income earned in one year will not allow relief for losses incurred in another. In 2018, officials from my Department produced a detailed technical note for the then Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform, and Taoiseach on the subject of both bank losses and corporation tax losses more generally. The technical note considered in some detail the potential implications of restricting the use of losses carried forward or the introduction of a specific time limit on loss relief as they might apply to Irish banks, the wider banking sector or, indeed, the corporate sector as a whole. Among other considerations, it examined the possible effect of such a restriction on consumers, with the probability that an increased cost base for the banks would be passed on to consumers in the form of higher fees and interest rates on loans or lower deposit rates. It also considered potential effects on competition within the banking sector in Ireland, which is a factor of increasing relevance as banks have since left the Irish market. The paper also noted potential negative consequences for capital levels in the banks, with possible resulting regulatory impacts.

In the case of the banks, it is also important to acknowledge that the value of these tax losses to the State has been and will continue to be realised through share sales. The banks' share prices recognise a certain value for the tax losses and, as such, the State receives value for the balance of tax losses if share sales are completed. As we all know, the State retains approximately a 57.5% shareholding in Permanent TSB.

Reference was made to what other countries do. While other jurisdictions may have restrictions on loss relief, direct comparisons are of limited value. This is due to the tax system in Ireland being a scheduler system of taxation in which income and gains are divided into different categories based on resource. Under this system, losses carried forward can only be used against profits from the same source. In many other jurisdictions, the tax system allows losses carried forward to be used to produce taxable income from other income sources. Therefore, Ireland's loss relief system includes features that are more restrictive than in other countries, notwithstanding that we do not have a cap or a sunset clause.

I say all this in full acknowledgement that this was an extraordinarily painful time in our country for which many people - in fact, almost every person in every community in the country - paid a heavy price. Deputy Gould is right to remind us of the human cost and consequences of the failures of our banks in the past. The decisions made by Governments at that time, with the Deputy referencing from 2013 onwards, were guided by the best advice available, which was given to Governments by the Department of Finance and others, in terms of how to endeavour to provide some degree of protection to the taxpayer in what was a most horrifically difficult period.

Comment on this

I intend to press this amendment. I do not dispute the history the Tánaiste outlined. The issue of capitalisation of the banks or the State having to provide additional capital, which was the excuse used at the time, does not pertain any more. The paper he referenced is a number of years old. The idea in it was about dividends to the State as a result of our shareholding and also recognising asset value. There is no asset value to be recognised now in AIB or Bank of Ireland. We do not get any dividends from them and the State is about to disengage entirely from Permanent TSB as well.

This is about ensuring banks that are absolutely creaming it off the back of the Irish public and making €5 billion in profits pay a portion of tax. It is reverting back to what the late Brian Lenihan proposed, which was that as soon as they were profitable, they should be paying tax. It is unbelievable that there will be no tax paid. I understand how it works; if it is 50%, they will have the deferred assets for longer, but the fact is there will be no tax. We would be looking at AIB, 25 or 26 years on from the financial crisis, still not paying a cent in taxes, while making billions of euro in profits every year. It is ridiculous.

Comment on this

The question is whether what is happening is fair. I do not think it is. At this stage, after all these years, the Government cannot stand over what is being done. It is wrong.

Comment on this

The advice available to me is that the proposed amendment would possibly have a negative effect on consumers. I accept that is not Deputy Doherty's intent but there is the probability of an increased cost base for the banks, which would be passed on to consumers in the form of higher fees and interest rates on loans or lower deposit rates. Therefore, our view, as per the advice available to me, is that the effect of this, albeit inadvertent, would be negative for consumers in Ireland. That is not something I want to do.

Comment on this

That is the most ridiculous comment. I presume the Tánaiste was handed it in good faith but it was obviously provided by bankers or people sympathetic to them.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Let me finish.

Comment on this
Mairéad Farrell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

This is not an over-and-back exchange. Remarks should be addressed through the Chair. Please continue, an Teachta Doherty.

Comment on this

If I may finish, it is obvious the advice was given to the Tánaiste by bankers or somebody who is sympathetic to their situation. What does it translate to? If we ask banks to pay corporation tax on their €5 billion profit, they will increase the charges on Irish people. That is what the Tánaiste is saying. It is why the Government does not want to do anything and will allow the banks not to pay tax for another decade in some cases. That is the threat.

God forbid we ask banks that are making €5 billion profit to pay the appropriate level of tax that everyone else pays. Indeed, under this measure, they would still be able to reduce their tax significantly because they would be able to carry 50% of their losses forward. It is just unbelievable that this has happened. The Government will not do it to banks, but it will put up the price for ordinary people. Motorists will have to pay more for home heating oil, petrol, diesel and the local property tax. They will have to pay more for bloody everything but when it comes to banks that are making €5 billion profit, the excuse the Minister for Finance is using to not do what I and Sinn Féin are asking is that he is protecting the public. He is not protecting the banks but, rather, the public - wink wink, nod nod. That is why he is allowing these two banks that make €5 billon profit to pay no tax. Some banks will not pay any tax for another ten years. Honest to God, Waterford Whispers News would not have a look in.

Comment on this
Mairéad Farrell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

I apologise but there is a way that this is done. The Minister will have another chance to come in on another amendment.

Comment on this
Mairéad Farrell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

Amendment No. 27 has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:

In page 91, between lines 1 and 2, to insert the following:

“Report on legislated increase to rates of Mineral Oil Tax

53. The Minister shall, within six months of the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before Dáil Éireann a report on the legislated increase to rates of mineral oil tax, including an analysis of the distributional impact.”.

I have raised and referenced over and over again the issue of the continued increases in the carbon tax by this Government on petrol, diesel and home heating oil. This week, we see that the cost of a fill of home heating oil has gone up by €80 as a result of external factors, but that does not take away from the fact that the Government has been instrumental in pushing up the cost of a fill of home heating oil by a significant amount, €220, in terms of carbon tax so far. Worse than that, the Government plans over the next five years to increase the cost of a fill of home heating oil by another €150.

I have made the point that there are two ways to bring taxes in. Taxes are brought in either to raise revenue for the State to provide services that are required by its population and people or to affect behavioural change. Alternatively, they can be brought in for behavioural change, which is absolutely valid. I have agreed with it on different occasions in different areas, such as the sugar-sweetened drinks levy or the plastic bag levy. There are examples where it can work and all the rest. Increasing carbon tax on home heating oil, however, just makes homes and households poorer. That is the reality of it. That is the effect of it at this point in time because people do not have the resources to provide the alternative types of heating that are required. That is the reality.

We also see it when it comes to petrol and diesel. I come from and represent a Border county. It has been pointed out by Fuels for Ireland and others that the difference between the cost of a fill of home heating oil in Lifford compared with Strabane is €300. It is mad. What makes that difference? All the same global factors that are pushing up home heating oil prices, such as the war in Ukraine and the illegal invasion by Russia, are also pushing prices up in Strabane. The reason there is a €300 difference is that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have decided to increase taxes significantly on the cost of trying to keep your house warm. In my county, two thirds of people rely on home heating oil to keep their house warm in winter. Across the west of Ireland in counties like Galway, Roscommon, Mayo and Leitrim, two thirds of people - over 1 million households across this State - are being penalised as a result of the Government’s measures.

We see increases over and over again, not only with home heating oil but also with petrol and diesel. It could be argued that it is about trying to get people into electric vehicles, as if everyone has €40,000 or €50,000 to spend on a new electric vehicle, even if the infrastructure were there for them in areas. For those who can afford it and make that change, it is excellent. The Government is way off its targets in this regard, however. It is aiming for 1 million new electric vehicles by the end of 2030. I could be wrong on this because I have not really looked in detail at the figures but probably every single car in the State, from now until then, would have to be an electric vehicle for us to actually meet that target. It is so far off. The reality is that people do not have that type of money to make that type of investment.

We have seen petrol prices sky-rocket during the illegal invasion of Ukraine. They went up to €2.20 per litre and measures were introduced by the Government that brought them down below €2. It did not force people to stay at home, go off the road and all the rest, however. Indeed, the number of cars on the roads is actually increasing. This experiment happened in the last couple of years. Again, behavioural taxes work if alternatives are available and affordable to individuals. This is putting the cart before the horse.

I call this the Healy-Rae amendment. I was telling Deputy Danny Healy-Rae that he was going to be the star of the show in relation to this. Maybe he will come into the Chamber, wherever he is. This is the Healy-Rae amendment because, by God, the Healy-Raes gave it hammer and tongs on the issue of petrol and diesel. I must say, if awards were going – Miriam Lord gives out awards every year - the “brass neck award” has to go to Deputy Danny Healy-Rae. Did the Minister hear him on the Order of Business today? He stood up and asked the Taoiseach whether there was any chance he could do something about the cost of petrol and diesel, as well as the carbon tax and all the rest of it. Just this week, he voted against measures from Sinn Féin that would actually reduce carbon tax. I am sure he will trot out later not knowing what is happening and vote again with and in support of the Government, as his brother, the Minister of State, Deputy Michael Healy-Rae, will do. They will vote to put up the price of petrol and diesel on farmers, motorists and commuters in County Kerry and elsewhere because that is the reality of them. They got their 30 pieces of silver and they have sold their soul and abandoned any integrity they had on this issue. I will press the Healy-Rae amendment tonight.

Comment on this

I am very pleased that Deputy Doherty has put down this amendment because it will give those Deputies whom I hear in my constituency and right across the constituencies, particularly rural ones, regularly talking about the unfairness of carbon tax and the lunacy of increasing the price of petrol, diesel and home heating oil at a time when people are at the pin of their collar.

My fundamental difficulty with carbon tax is that it does not work. It does not bring people to alternatives because for many of them, the alternatives do not exist. For people who live where I live and work anywhere beyond walking distance, they have no choice but to use their car. If they are lucky enough to work in Dublin city centre in a nine-to-five job, they can drive into the nearest town and get a bus to and from work, but God forbid they work the nightshift in a hospital because there is no public transport available to them and they have to drive to Dublin. If they work anywhere other than the artery from Letterkenny and Derry to Dublin, there is no public transport available for them at all. They have no choice but to use their car. That is also the case if their children are taking part in any after-school activity, if they have a hospital or health appointment or if they want to go to watch their local football team play in game, usually home or away. They have no choice.

What is the alternative? It may be to purchase an electric car, but most of the people I represent do not have the funds to purchase one. The car is not a luxury or something they can just decide to leave at home. Rather, it is an essential part of their life. It is the exact same as a light switch in their home and the water coming out of their tap. It is something they need in order to run their family. What are we, as legislators, doing in this House? We are making their lives more difficult. Carbon tax does not help the environment; it makes people’s lives harder. Increasing it at this time is absolute folly and cannot be justified by anyone.

For the past five years before the last election, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael representatives in my county and right across the place were saying it was those dastardly Greens who were forcing them to do it. They said they were in government with them and that they were insisting on carbon tax increases every year. During debates like this every single year, you could hardly hear yourself with Deputies Michael and Danny Healy-Rae and the Rural Independents slamming the Green Party for forcing poor Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael to make people’s lives harder.

The Green Party was given its answer by the electorate and Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael can no longer hide behind its skirts. Tonight, Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Independent TDs will have an opportunity to say whose side they are on. Are they on the side of making people's lives harder or on the side of making people's lives just a little more tolerable by not increasing the essential cost of using their car each day to go to work, drive their children to school or whatever the case may be? We will find out fairly soon. There will be an opportunity for people to put their money, and their vote, where their mouths have been for the past five years or more.

I know what the Tánaiste will say in his response. He will say the carbon tax funding is ring-fenced and kept aside to support vulnerable people through hardship schemes and other social welfare benefits. He is actually going to tell lies and mistruths. He is going to repeat the mistruth-----

Comment on this

Deputy Carthy should withdraw that comment.

Comment on this

I will rephrase it. He is going to say, in the same way many representatives in this House say, that, in fact, the money from the carbon tax is used to support farmers under environmental schemes.

Comment on this

Deputy Carthy is Mystic Meg.

Comment on this

What is not said is that the Government agreed at an EU level to a multi-annual financial framework that actually fleeced farmers. Whatever funding is reimbursed through the carbon tax, and I contend it is very little, does not make up for the shortfall. We do not have a good rural environment protection scheme, REPS, like we had in the past. We have an agri-climate rural environment scheme, ACRES, that farmers find very difficult to enter and, if they do get in, find it very difficult to receive payments. The Tánaiste should not give us the folly that the carbon tax pays for the fuel allowance and other supports. Those supports should and could be in place without increasing the carbon tax this year. The carbon tax is supposed to be an environmental tax but it does not work because the alternatives are not there.

I say categorically that no person who represents a constituency, knowing their constituents are finding it very difficult to meet the cost of groceries, energy and virtually every single thing, on the back of a budget from which those people who are struggling got no support, can stand over the fact those working families not on social welfare and who are not mega-wealthy developers got nothing-----

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

They got nothing in tax, energy credits or any other supports. They got nothing. Members opposite voted for a budget that gave them nothing. Worse than that, they are about to vote to make their cost of driving to work even more expensive.

I commend Deputy Doherty on tabling this amendment. I absolutely look forward to the people of Ireland seeing how their Teachtaí Dála vote. They are the messengers of the people but the question is whether they have actually heard the message from the people that they cannot take any more burden.

Comment on this

The Deputy presumed to deliver my lines. Let me have a go at responding to him. First, as we have discussed, and I understand and acknowledge that this is how the rules of the House work, nobody is about to vote on anything other than an amendment to have a report on mineral oil tax. We need to be honest about the effect of this. No matter what way anybody votes, this is an amendment to request a report on mineral oil tax. It will not help anybody tomorrow in Cavan-Monaghan or elsewhere across the country.

Mineral oil tax comprises a non-carbon and a carbon component, commonly referred to as the carbon tax. Legislation passed by this House provides for multi-annual increases to the carbon component of the mineral oil tax. I assume the Deputies are requesting a report on legislated increases in the carbon tax, including a distributional impact analysis of same. As they will be aware, the programme for Government committed to continue with the planned carbon tax increases, aligning with recommendations from the Climate Change Advisory Council and scientific experts, and to use the resulting revenues raised to support climate action measures and ensure the most vulnerable benefit from those measures and are protected from unintended impacts of the tax increase. This includes funding for retrofitting but also agri-environmental schemes, alongside targeted social welfare and other initiatives to prevent fuel poverty and ensure a just transition. These measures are designed to be progressive.

To give effect to the programme for Government commitment to protect the vulnerable, a targeted package of social protection interventions has been developed. This was informed by ESRI research that was commissioned to address this specific issue. The allocation from within agreed expenditure allocations for 2026 is more than €1.1 billion, which is an additional €163 million on the previous budget. A total of €350 million of this is allocated to targeted social protection interventions.

The Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation issues an annual publication on budget day entitled The Use of Carbon Tax Funds. This contains further detail on these allocations and includes information on the programmes funded from carbon tax revenues. Analysis undertaken using SWITCH, the ESRI's tax and benefit model, to simulate the impact of the carbon tax increase and the compensatory welfare package, estimates that the net impact of the combined measures is progressive. Half of households are better off due to the measures part-funded by additional carbon tax funds, with households in the bottom four income deciles benefiting the most.

Furthermore, as part of budget 2026, my Department published the Beyond GDP - Quality of Life Assessment report. This publication complements economic and fiscal analyses with an assessment of qualify-of-life indicators. The report looks at a wider set of indicators that contribute to well-being, such as environmental, income and wealth distribution, and equality indicators and documents, to see how Ireland is performing in these areas. The taxation of fossil fuel products was also recently examined in the tax strategy group paper, Energy, Environmental and Vehicle Tax, published by the Department of Finance in July. All budget day publications and tax strategy group papers are publicly available. Therefore, I believe there are sufficient reports available in this area and there is no need for an additional report.

As my colleague, the Chief Whip, pointed out, there are lots of benefits in this budget for people and families right across the country. Deputies opposite seem to find that funny but I do not think it is funny at all; it is important.

Comment on this

If we do not laugh, we will cry.

Comment on this

It is about the record level of funding for disability and health services, making sure we were able to increase the State pension and ensuring more people qualify for the carer's allowance. People in the Deputies' constituencies benefit from those measures.

Comment on this

No matter how much they wish to reduce the budget to a conversation simply about one element of economic policy in terms of the cost of living, every measure in the budget, right across Departments, is about trying to help people in this country. Indeed, there are many measures in areas Deputies highlighted and where they asked for increased spending. They have seen today, with the publication of the national development plan and revised plans for transport. Tomorrow, in regard to childcare, which the Deputies regularly raise with me, I look forward to seeing very significant capital investment in State-led childcare funding, and more disability capital funding as well.

Comment on this

Do not get me started on disability services. The Government is breaking the law every day.

Comment on this

As Deputies would expect, I reject how they frame our budget.

Comment on this

I will press the amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 56
·
Níl 75
·
Staon 1
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

This debate is due to end at 12.28 a.m. We will probably get to discuss one more amendment. I suggest that it would probably be safer for Deputies to stay and that we move into the voting block from here.

Amendments Nos. 29 and 30 are out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:

In page 97, to delete lines 36 and 37, and in page 98, to delete lines 1 to 19 and substitute the following:

“ “Supply and construction of housing as part of a social policy.

9B. (1) In this paragraph—

‘apartment block’ means a multi-storey building that comprises, or will comprise, not less than 3 apartments with grouped or common access;

‘completed’ has the same meaning as it has in section 94.

(2) The supply of immovable goods, as part of a social policy, which are or, when completed, will be—

(a) one or more than one apartment, used or to be used for residential purposes, in an apartment block, or

(b) an apartment block, used or to be used for residential purposes, but excluding any part of the apartment block that is not used or to be used for residential purposes.

(3) Services consisting of the development, until completed, of immovable goods to which subparagraph (2) applies.”,

(ii) in Part 3, by the substitution of the following paragraph for paragraph 14 (amended by subsection (1)(b)(ii)):

“Housing.

14. The supply of immovable goods used or to be used for residential purposes, other than immovable goods to which paragraph 9A or 9B(2), as the case may be, applies.”,”.

As I noted earlier, this section which was amended on Committee Stage provides for a temporary 9% rate of VAT in respect of the supply and construction of apartments and apartment blocks, as per our social policy. The temporary 9% rate of VAT on the supply of apartments came into effect on budget night, but the extension to the construction of apartments and supply and construction of apartment blocks, including student accommodation, came into effect today. The 9% rate will apply until 31 December 2030.

The VAT treatment of goods and services is subject to EU VAT law, with which Irish VAT law is required to comply. In general, the EU VAT directive provides that all goods and services are liable to VAT at the standard rate, which, in Ireland is currently 23%, unless they come within provisions that permit the application of a lower rate. Under the EU VAT directive, member states may apply a reduced rate to the supply and construction of housing as part of a social policy. Ireland has currently two reduced rates – 13.5% and 9%. In order to stimulate the development of apartments, which is high-density housing, it has been decided, on social policy grounds, to apply the second reduced rate of 9% to the supply and construction of apartments and apartment blocks.

The legislation around VAT and property is complex. As such, I am bringing forward some further amendments to this section to ensure that the text is in line with VAT legislation and that it achieves the policy intention of the measure. It should be noted that the amendments brought forward on Committee and Report Stages do not increase the estimated cost of the measures because the changes do remain in line with the original policy intention. As data on actual sales of apartments is received, the Estimates may be revised over the coming years. My officials will continue to monitor the relevant data as it becomes available.

Affordability and the chance to own a home lie at the heart of our housing policy. The Government has introduced a comprehensive implementation strategy, which is in place to support the various affordable housing schemes now being delivered by a range of partners. A record €6 billion capital investment in housing was announced in budget 2025. This is made up of €3.1 billion in Exchequer funding, €1.25 billion allocated to the Land Development Agency and €1.65 billion for the Housing Finance Agency. This is the highest ever capital investment in the history of our country. In order to meet the housing needs of our people, however, there needs to be private sector involvement too. Private sector involvement is not a dirty phrase. It is important as we seek to increase the supply of homes right across this country. That is what this VAT measure does. It endeavours to reduce the viability gap that those who build apartments face when considering whether to advance projects across the country that have planning permission but where the sale of apartments may not have been deemed viable. That simply is what this is about.

Over the course of the past number of days we have taken measures to ensure that this reduced VAT rate applies to student accommodation, an issue that I know is very important to the Minister for further and higher education, making sure that the lower rate of VAT will also apply to purpose-built student accommodation and to approved housing bodies. This measure, which is consistently and constantly misrepresented by others, will actually have a benefit for people building social and affordable homes and student accommodation.

We have also made a change in the resolution that came before the House yesterday - obviously, it is linked to these VAT amendments - to make sure that the help to buy scheme can continue to be accessed by first-time buyers who are purchasing apartments that have been built at the lower rate. This measure cannot be seen in isolation. It is one of a number of measures we are taking to reduce the viability gap. While we are living through a housing emergency and while many measures to address that are being taken to address by the Minister for housing, Deputy Browne, and all of Government, it is worth noting that we have seen the highest number of first-time home buyers this year since 2007. This latest measure needs to be seen as part of the overall policy jigsaw that has been put together to significantly increase supply. I commend the amendment to the House.

Comment on this

I am glad the Tánaiste has changed his tune and stated that this is a viability measure, because he started off this evening by saying-----

Comment on this

No, I did not.

Comment on this

-----that this was to reduce-----

Comment on this

No, he did not.

Comment on this

Read the transcript.

Comment on this

The record of the House will show it, folks.

Comment on this

I wrote it down because it was so laughable. The Tánaiste stated that this is about "reducing the cost of building apartments".

Comment on this

It does reduce the cost of apartments.

Comment on this

It was only when we pointed out that Paschal Donohoe made it very clear that this is not about affordability or reducing the cost of apartments-----

Comment on this

It does reduce the cost of apartments.

Comment on this

I cannot hear the Tánaiste.

Comment on this

It does reduce the cost of constructing apartments.

Comment on this

This was not about reducing the cost of apartments. This was about so-called viability.

Maybe this time next year the Tánaiste will be able to show me one apartment that is going to be sold, either in this city or anywhere else in the State, that was not viable at this point. This measure is going to cost us €250 million next year. Every apartment that is going to be sold next year - in the context of a measure that will cost €250 million - is already under construction. This is the biggest tax deadweight measure ever introduced.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

One hundred per cent of it is going to developers who are already building these properties. Apartments that were sold last week benefited from this. The Tánaiste told us that this has already cost us €20 million since it was introduced on budget night. This is about filling the pockets of developers. It is doing what Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael do. At the same time, those in government have shafted ordinary people during a cost-of-living crisis. Shame on them all.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The-----

Comment on this

The 15th report.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

-----the time permitted for this debate-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Excuse me, sorry.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I ask for decorum, please. It is very late. The time permitted for this debate having expired, I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 25 November: "That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance and not disposed of are hereby made to the Bill; Fourth Stage is hereby completed; and the Bill is hereby passed." Is that agreed?

Comment on this
Division

Question put

Tá 76
·
Níl 60
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

This Bill, which is certified to be a money Bill in accordance with Article 22.2.1° of the Constitution, will be sent to the Seanad.

Comment on this