We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›

Legislative Measures

Summary

The Government defended the Defence (Amendment) Bill, saying it would allow Irish participation in peace missions led by the EU, OSCE or regional bodies without specific UN authorisation, while preserving neutrality and requiring compliance with the UN Charter and international law. Sinéad Gibney argued the triple lock is a vital safeguard for neutrality and peacekeeping, and urged the Government to retain it or put the change to a public vote.

95. Deputy Sinéad Gibney asked the Minister for Defence to provide an update on her plans to remove the requirement for UN authorisation via the Security Council or the General Assembly in order to deploy Irish troops overseas as part of an international force. [77487/26]

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister's email inbox, like mine, is full and chock-a-block with people asking her to urgently reconsider the plans to abolish the triple lock. They point out, as I and many others have, the generosity of the wording of the Act of 2006 and the solemn guarantees of the Nice and Lisbon treaties. The will of the people is clear. Will the Minister listen and keep the triple lock?

Comment on this
Thomas Byrne Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Fianna Fáil

As Deputies are aware, the Defence (Amendment) Bill is progressing through the Houses of the Oireachtas. The Bill will be proceeding to Committee Stage. We are awaiting a date for Committee Stage, as the Minister said.

It is important to address some of the claims that have been made about this. Much of the criticism advanced on Second Stage was based on a mischaracterisation of the legislation and an inaccurate portrayal of its consequences. The Bill does not impact on Ireland's neutrality. It does not provide for unrestricted overseas deployment of Defence Forces personnel. Nothing in the Bill does this.

Comment on this

It does allow for this.

Comment on this

The central reform contained in the Bill is set out in section 4, which replaces the existing concept of an international United Nations force with the term "relevant international force", which is then defined in the legislation. In practical terms, the law that we want to pass sets out clearly that Ireland can continue to participate in peacekeeping, peace enforcement and conflict prevention on overseas missions which, crucially, operate in accordance with the principles of the Charter of the UN and international law, whether specifically authorised by the Security Council or subject to a UN General Assembly resolution or, in addition, by organisations such as the European Union, the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe or other regional arrangements.

The reform will ensure that Ireland is not prevented from contributing to legitimate international peace support operations solely because agreement cannot be reached at UN level. The legislation will, of course, continue to permit participation in UN and UN-mandated operations. Should the Security Council authorise, or the General Assembly recommend, future peacekeeping missions, Ireland will be fully able to contribute to them but we will have greater flexibility to participate in peace missions organised or led by bodies such as the European Union, as we had in Bosnia and Herzegovina, the OSCE or other regional arrangements where such participation is considered appropriate by the Government and approved in accordance with the principles of the Charter of the UN.

Comment on this

The principles of the Charter of the UN were tested in 2003 when the US and the UK chose to go to war with Iraq. These exact principles were invoked when they went to war. The Minister's colleague in the Department of Defence said at a committee meeting in response to Deputy Murphy that had this legislation been in place in 2003, neither Article 29 or anything else would have prevented Ireland from sending troops to Iraq and engaging in what was described at the time as action in line with the principles of the UN Charter. This is exactly what was said at the time. It is the Government that is being inaccurate and disingenuous. It is putting forward this tired rhetoric about sovereignty and taking back control. Solemn guarantees were given in the Nice and Lisbon treaties. It is clear that the public view is pro-triple lock and it is clear that the current trajectory is exactly what people were afraid of when they voted in the Nice and Lisbon referendums. If the Government is confident about this legitimacy it should put it to the people.

Comment on this

It is time to call out the scaremongering and misinformation about reform of the triple lock. The Iraq war was not in conformity with the principles of the United Nations Charter.

Comment on this

The UN Secretary-General, Kofi Annan, said at the time that it was not in conformity with the charter. Therefore, this claim is false. The Opposition tells us we will end up fighting in foreign wars. This is false. It tells us that Ireland will end up in NATO. This is false. It talks about the end of Irish military neutrality. Again, this is false. Nothing in the Bill affects our neutrality. Decisions on military alliances and on the Defence Forces of this State are for the Dáil and the Dáil alone. This is what the Bill is about; it is about decisions. Either we do nothing, which is what the Opposition wants, and peacekeeping from an Irish point of view ends, or we act to reform the triple lock-----

Comment on this

-----and provide ourselves here in Dáil Éireann with the power to make decisions-----

Comment on this

-----on Irish peace work abroad, here in the Dáil and not elsewhere.

Comment on this

The example of the UN Charter being invoked in 2003 is exactly what I said; it was used by the US and the UK to justify that war. It was clear that the UN did not agree and this is the whole point. The UN is the only game in town when it comes to multilateralism. It is the only body that can offer a mandate to serve under the blue helmet or blue beret. It is the only body that can guarantee that the work of the Defence Forces is peacekeeping. The Government is taking this away. It is as though the Government does not understand what a guardrail is. Of course, the Opposition is not saying this will immediately send us to war but the point is that the guardrail is in place so that we do not go to war and we stay in line with our values of neutrality, diplomacy and peace, and achieving peace through peaceful means, which the Government seems to have forgotten completely. Once again, the Government cannot continue to maintain that removal of the triple lock, which is what the Bill proposes, in any way allows us to remain a neutral state. It is farcical.

Comment on this

The Deputy has said repeatedly that the Iraq war was in accordance with the principles of the UN Charter-----

Comment on this

No, that is not what I said. The US and the UK said it was.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

One speaker and the Minister of State has the floor.

Comment on this

The Secretary-General of the United Nations at the time said specifically that it was not. This legislation requires us to act in accordance with international law-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

The Minister of State has the floor.

Comment on this

-----with the Charter of the United Nations-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

The Minister of State has the floor.

Comment on this

-----and with our Constitution.

Comment on this

What about the principles? That is the whole point. The Minister of State will vote down amendments.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy, the Minister of State has the floor.

Comment on this

The Minister of State will vote down amendments to say it should be in line with the UN Charter. Mark my words.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy, there is only one speaker.

Comment on this

Tell us now that he will not vote down amendments that propose it will be in line with the UN Charter.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy-----

Comment on this

Tell us he will not vote down amendments to say it should be in line with the UN Charter. Tell us how he will vote on those amendments.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy, there is only one speaker.

Comment on this

I am looking forward to the answer.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Right now the only speaker is myself as Cathaoirleach and Deputy Murphy has no right to speak. The Minister of State has the floor.

Comment on this

The Deputies opposite completely ignore the Irish Constitution. As the Minister said, the Constitution prevents us from becoming part of a European Union common defence. The Leader of the Opposition talks about Ursula von der Leyen's wars but if the European Union were ever to do this, and it has never done this because it is a peace project, Ireland would not be permitted to participate under the Constitution.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

We will move on.

Comment on this

Our Constitution requires us to conduct our international relations in accordance with moral principles with the objective of friendly relations among the states of the world. The argument the Deputies are putting forward is that somehow we will all go to war. What war are we talking about? It is completely ignorant of what is in our Constitution and what legally prevents us from doing that.

Comment on this