We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna Eile - Other Questions ›

United Nations

Summary

The Government reaffirmed Ireland’s commitment to UN peacekeeping and multilateralism, saying deployments would remain subject to constitutional and legal safeguards and be assessed case by case. It argued abolishing the triple lock would provide flexibility, while noting no decision has been made on additional missions; Deputy Gibney warned this weakens an independent safeguard and signals a shift away from peacekeeping, while Deputy Ó Muirí urged continued support for UN reform and multilateral cooperation.

103. Deputy Sinéad Gibney asked the Minister for Defence the engagement her Department has had on joining one of the ten UN peacekeeping missions outside of UNIFIL, or any global non-UN missions which have a UN mandate; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [77437/26]

Comment on this

148. Deputy Naoise Ó Muirí asked the Minister for Defence if she will reaffirm Ireland's commitment to United Nations peacekeeping; to outline the contribution made by Irish Defence Forces personnel to UN missions over recent decades; and to clarify whether the proposed legislation will in any way diminish Ireland's ability to participate in UN-led peacekeeping operations. [77494/26]

Comment on this

As I have raised already and we have all discussed many times this evening, I am very concerned about the pivot away from peacekeeping by this Government. The Minister maintains that moves to abolish the triple lock are not about sidelining the UN or peacekeeping. What has the Minister's Department done to engage with the active missions around the world that she referenced multiple times tonight and which continue to enjoy that UN mandate - there are ten, I believe - so that Irish troops can participate in them?

Comment on this

I propose to take Questions Nos. 103 and 148 together.

As Deputies will be aware, overseas deployments by the Defence Forces can only considered on a case-by-case basis. Any proposal for participation in an international mission is assessed on the basis of military advice, the nature and requirements of the mission, capabilities that we have, international law, our policy of neutrality, the safety and welfare of personnel, and our wider foreign and security policy objectives. Any deployment abroad has to have recourse to Government to decide, on the advice of the Attorney General and with Dáil approval, where that is applicable. These decisions are not taken without due consideration of the range of factors I have just set out. Some missions will be suitable for Ireland and others will not be suitable for members of the Defence Forces. That remains the case.

The Department and the Defence Forces remain in regular engagement with the UN, the European Union and international partners regarding current peace support operations. When I attended various meetings - and I am sure the Minister has had some discussions as well - the options, for example, for increasing troop numbers in KFOR have been discussed by me. No request has been received, and no decision has been taken, in relation to participation in any specific additional UN or UN-mandated mission. We will always examine opportunities to contribute to international peace and security where appropriate and where we have the capability to make a meaningful contribution.

The Minister for Defence and the Government need to be assured that the necessary safeguards and mitigations are in place when it comes to the safety of our personnel. Even though it is peacekeeping, peace enforcement and conflict prevention, it can be dangerous, as we know. Some have lost their lives and we need to continue to remember them. Defence Forces personnel continue to serve with pride with UNDOF in the Golan Heights, EUFOR ALTHEA in Bosnia and Herzegovina and KFOR in Kosovo. When I met the Prime Minister of Kosovo two weeks ago, the first thing he said to me was to thank the Irish soldiers and the thousands of soldiers who have contributed to peace in Kosovo over the years. I am happy to pass on those thanks from the Prime Minister of Kosovo. Ireland remains firmly committed to supporting international peace and security through multilateral engagement, including in UN-led and UN-mandated peacekeeping operations. All options can be explored by the Department of Defence and the Defence Forces.

Ireland has engaged with planning for the EU support mission in Lebanon. While no decision has been taken regarding participation - that requires Government approval - the mission could offer opportunities for our Defence Forces to support stability in Lebanon through training, advisory support, border security assistance and capacity-building with the Lebanese armed forces.

I again emphasise to the House that Ireland will always be able to participate in UN-led and UN-mandated operations where there are UN resolutions underpinning them. The reform we are doing provides what we believe to be necessary flexibility to participate where appropriate, and where those considerations are taken into account. This is not something the Government decides on a whim. These are carefully made decisions. We could take part in missions organised by other bodies such as the European Union, the OSCE or other international organisations as is the case for neutral Austria and Switzerland. The purpose of these reforms is not to weaken our commitment to UN peacekeeping or to the UN. We are one of the most committed to the UN, and that is recognised across the system. It is to ensure we have the flexibility to contribute to peace and security in a changing world. We are, and remain, neutral. We are, and remain, committed to the principles of the UN Charter and supportive of UN peacekeeping. Our Constitution provides that we are committed. We affirm our "devotion to the ideal of peace and friendly co-operation amongst nations founded on international justice and morality" and "the principle of the pacific settlement of international disputes". We "accept the generally recognised principles of international law". I have just read out of the Constitution, which is the law of the land. That is what governs all of these decisions.

Comment on this

With respect, the Minister of State has spoken a lot about the Government not making these decisions on a whim. He has talked about the Attorney General, the analysis that goes into it and the guard-rails. That is all the triple lock is. It is another guard-rail that exists outside of the control of the Government. We talk about the other elements of the decision-making. There is the Government and the Dáil, but of course the Dáil is controlled by the Government when it has a majority, which it does. It is ridiculous to suggest, as the Minister of State does, that these guard-rails are just as effective or as strong. They are not. They simply are not. We asked for this mandate so we would have that guard-rail, and the Government is just chucking it away. While I hear the Minister of State's assurances about how much this Government respects and values peacekeeping, its actions tell a completely different story. The prioritisation of participation in EU battle groups, which do not have a peacekeeping function, meant that we had to pull out of the UN-backed peacekeeping force in the Golan Heights, a UN mission that continues to this day. The Government's proposed plans after abolishing the triple lock are devoid of any proposals for peacekeeping or for new and expanded involvement in UN missions. Instead of supporting the UN and championing multilateralism we are seemingly following in the footsteps of other EU countries that pursue regional and non-neutral interests first and foremost.

Comment on this

The UN mandate is an article of faith in this House. It has been for a long time, and I have always supported that. However, it is no guarantee of success. I was in my first year of work when I watched Srebrenica unfold on television. Some 500 Dutch UN troops were totally overrun by Bosnian Serb forces and that was followed by the ethnic cleansing of 8,000 people. It was one of the worst atrocities of that entire conflict. They had a UN mandate. It did not protect them. It did not work. UNAMIR, which was a UN-mandated force, got to Rwanda in late 1993. It could not prevent the genocide that happened in 1994. By the time it got a revised mandate and the support and troops it needed it was too late. More than 400,000 Rwandans were dead.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Go raibh maith agat.

Comment on this

My question is about UN reform and our commitment to following through and looking to use our soft power to get the UN to reform itself.

Comment on this

What does reform of the triple lock do? It allows us to continue to do what we have always done, which is to service peace abroad. It allows us to undertake peacekeeping, peace enforcement and conflict prevention including in UN-led or UN-mandated operations. It allows us to participate in missions organised or led by the EU, the OSCE or other regional arrangements.

Comment on this

It allows Ireland, and Ireland alone, to make decisions on where we deploy Irish personnel in the service of peace abroad. Any decisions on peace missions will have to be done in accordance with our Constitution, in accordance with the principles of the United Nations Charter, and in accordance with international law. The guard-rails that Deputy Gibney has spoken about have been abused by the permanent members of the Security Council, most recently last week by Russia. They have been abused by China with regard to the North Macedonia peace mission. The US, working with Israel, has effectively ended UNIFIL. That is what this legislation is trying to achieve. The Deputy has complained about us leaving missions, which actually demonstrates the point. These are not easy decisions for the Government. On some occasions the Government has had to tell the UN or other people that something is not suitable for our soldiers. On some occasions they may be suitable. Bringing in the Iraq war to saying we definitely would have done that-----

Comment on this

That is not what I said. It was the opposite.

Comment on this

-----and on the other hand asking why we are not doing other UN peacekeeping missions-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

The Minister of State has the floor.

Comment on this

-----I think shows the absurdity this debate is reaching.

Comment on this

I think it shows the Minister of State does not understand-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

The Minister of State has the floor, Deputy. You will have an opportunity in a moment.

Comment on this

I am looking forward to Committee Stage of this legislation where we can go through it line by line and test the assertions of the Opposition, which I think are complete and utter bunkum.

Comment on this

First, it is not reform. It is the abolition of the triple lock. It is not reform of the triple lock. The Minister of State talks about accordance with the Constitution and international law, etc. The Minister of State mentioned the proposed new mission in Lebanon, which he will consider, and which has no peacekeeping function. When he spoke to Deputy Murphy about that new EU training mission in Lebanon, he assured us that it is just training and that any claims otherwise are scaremongering and he referred to mission creep. I draw everyone's attention to a previous EU training mission in Mali introduced in 2013, which ended up supporting not one but two military coups by the Malian army. It was suspended in 2024. If that is the track record in EU training missions I think we need to question that.

The other point is that we are not saying that we would not go to the Constitution with the EU defence army. However, the Minister of State has to acknowledge the €800 billion of EU ReArm funding and the ways in which Kubilius, the EU Commissioner speaks about-----

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Thank you, Deputy. I call Deputy Ó Muirí.

Comment on this

-----European defence union. This is not scaremongering. That is the direction of travel of the European Union.

Comment on this
Aindrias Moynihan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Teachta Ó Muirí has the floor.

Comment on this

I say again that I want to hear a strong commitment to the UN from Ireland, which I think does exist. I want to hear a strong commitment to multilateral co-operation and the development of multilateral relations, which as far as I recall we have always tried to do. We have always boxed above our weight, to use that awful cliché. We have done that. I want to hear that we accept the UN has to reform itself. It has a big job of work to do. It is hard to see how it can be delivered, but we are committed to it. Obviously, we have a commitment to the International Criminal Court, ICC. These are all important commitments from this House, the Government and the State. I want to hear that we are committed to multilateralism on all its fronts, working with international partners.

Comment on this

First, I pay tribute to four Italian military personnel who were killed last week in Bosnia taking part in Operation Althea. It is important to remember them. That is an EU mission keeping the peace in Bosnia-Herzegovina. Irish people have died over the years too.

Ireland has one of the strongest commitments to the United Nations. That is why we have consistently been elected to the UN Security Council. We have pushed for reform of the United Nations. We are well known as advocates for reform. We work on issues of international justice all around the world. We are well known for it and we are highly respected for it. We are highly respected because we are seen as a neutral country. There is nobody outside this country saying our neutrality is going to change in any way because of this legislation. None of the member states of the United Nations that sometimes depend on us to be advocates for them have ever said that, and they are not saying that. They do not agree with what the Opposition is saying. Ireland has the strongest commitment to the UN. We have an incredibly strong commitment to multilateralism. We have strong teams of diplomats in the UN, the OSCE and all of the multilateral organisations. We have just joined the United Nations Human Rights Council. We are such an important player because we put the effort in.

I pay tribute to all of our civil servants who work really hard in the multilateral bodies to which they are assigned, with the support of the Minister, the Minister of State, Deputy Richmond, myself, the Taoiseach and the entire Government. They do incredible work. One is so proud when one goes to these multilateral organisations and sees our officials or diplomats with "Ireland" in front of them, or on occasion when "Ireland" has been in front of me. It is an incredibly proud moment.

We are all conscious of the history we have and we will continue to work within the system that is there - the international multilateral system - but we are very much convinced of the need to reform the UN. However, in the meantime, while that veto remains, we have to be able to make our own decisions and not allow them to be made by Russian, China, the US, the UK or France.

Comment on this