We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Assisted Human Reproduction

1885. Deputy Ken O'Flynn asked the Minister for Health to set out each function assigned to the Assisted Human Reproduction Regulatory Authority under sections 202 to 225 of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 that the Authority is not currently in a position to perform; whether any of those functions could be performed in the interim under an agreement provided for by section 125 of the Act; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [76337/26]

Comment on this

1886. Deputy Ken O'Flynn asked the Minister for Health if the advice of the Office of the Attorney General that the past and prospective international surrogacy provisions of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 be commenced concurrently also extends to Chapter 1 of Part 12 of the Act concerning past domestic surrogacy; if not, the specific legal or administrative reason Chapter 1 of Part 12 cannot be commenced now, having regard to section 1(4) of the Act; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [76336/26]

Comment on this

1889. Deputy Ken O'Flynn asked the Minister for Health the timeline for the commencement of chapter 1 and chapter 2 of Part 12 of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 respectively; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [76343/26]

Comment on this

1890. Deputy Ken O'Flynn asked the Minister for Health the estimated number of children born through past domestic surrogacy and past international surrogacy arrangements who would be eligible for a parental order under Part 12 of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 on its commencement; whether her Department holds or has sought such data; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [76341/26]

Comment on this

1891. Deputy Ken O'Flynn asked the Minister for Health which provisions of Part 12 of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) (Amendment) Bill proposes to amend; the expected date of publication of that Bill; whether the commencement of chapter 1 and chapter 2 of Part 12 is each contingent on the enactment of that Bill; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [76340/26]

Comment on this

1938. Deputy Thomas Gould asked the Minister for Health the specific legal function under Part 12 which cannot currently be performed; which provisions of Part 12 require the AHRRA to have commenced exercising its wider regulatory functions before Part 12 can operate; if her Department considers that the administrative functions assigned to the AHRRA under Part 12 could be performed independently of its wider regulatory and licensing functions; and if her Department has obtained legal advice on whether Part 12 could be commenced separately from the remaining provisions of the Act, given that section 1(4) expressly permits same. [76404/26]

Comment on this

1993. Deputy Séamus McGrath asked the Minister for Health the position regarding the non-commencement of Part 12 of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024. [76619/26]

Comment on this

2035. Deputy Holly Cairns asked the Minister for Health the specific functions under Part 12 of the Assisted Human Reproduction Act 2024 currently cannot be performed; the specific Part 12 functions that require the commencement of the Assisted Human Reproduction Regulatory Authority (AHRRA) before coming into effect; whether her Department has obtained legal advice on if Part 12 could be commenced separately from the remaining provisions of the 2024 Act; if legal advice has been received indicating that the provision under Part 12 cannot be commenced before the AHRRA is fully operational; and if so, if the substance of the advice will be published. [76716/26]

Comment on this

2060. Deputy Niamh Smyth asked the Minister for Health if she will review correspondence (details supplied); and if she will provide an update on the issues raised. [76787/26]

Comment on this

2149. Deputy Erin McGreehan asked the Minister for Health when the remaining surrogacy provisions of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 will commence; the reasons for the delay in implementing same; and the timetable for families to apply for recognition of parentage. [77232/26]

Comment on this

2176. Deputy Erin McGreehan asked the Minister for Health whether all past surrogacy arrangements will have a pathway to legal recognition; and the way in which gaps affecting children already born will be addressed. [77233/26]

Comment on this

2239. Deputy Ryan O'Meara asked the Minister for Health for an update on the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024; the timeframe when it will be fully implemented; and whether the commencement of part 12 could be expedited to ensure the protection of families through surrogacy. [77646/26]

Comment on this

2325. Deputy Pádraig Rice asked the Minister for Health the status of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) (Amendment) Bill; if drafting has concluded; and the timeline for publication of the general scheme. [77930/26]

Comment on this

2327. Deputy Pádraig Rice asked the Minister for Health of the sections of the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2024 which have not been commenced, if in all cases commencement is contingent on the passing of further amendments through the Assisted Human Reproduction (Amendment) Bill; and if not, to identify the sections which have still not been commenced due to other factors. [77934/26]

Comment on this

2330. Deputy Erin McGreehan asked the Minister for Health the measures which will make retrospective parental order applications affordable and straightforward; and whether legal aid or financial assistance will be available to families. [77234/26]

Comment on this

2331. Deputy Erin McGreehan asked the Minister for Health whether the consent requirements for retrospective parental orders will be reviewed, including cases where a surrogate cannot be contacted or a biological father withholds consent; and the way in which the child’s best interests will be protected. [77235/26]

Comment on this

2337. Deputy Erin McGreehan asked the Minister for Health the way in which parentage and citizenship difficulties will be resolved for Irish families whose children were born through surrogacy while the parents were living abroad. [77236/26]

Comment on this

I propose to take Questions Nos. 1885, 1886, 1889, 1890, 1891, 1938, 1993, 2035, 2060, 2149, 2176, 2239, 2325, 2327, 2330, 2331 and 2337 together.

The Deputy will be aware that the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) Act 2004 – including Part 12, which has the heading “Past Domestic and International Surrogacy” – was enacted, having passed all stages in both Houses of the Oireachtas and then signed into law by the President, in July 2024.

While the 2024 Act was progressing through the Houses of Oireachtas, issues were identified which required further consideration and consultation with the Office of the Attorney General (AGO). The formal drafting process for a Bill to address these outstanding matters, the Health (Assisted Human Reproduction) (Amendment) Bill, is in its final stages, led by the Office of Parliamentary Counsel, along with officials from my Department, the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration (DoJHAM), and the Department of Children, Disability and Equality. I hope to be in a position to introduce the published Bill to the Dáil during the current term.

The AHR Amendment Bill is a very substantive piece of legislation. It is largely concerned with outstanding issues of parentage and citizenship, particularly in respect of children born as a result of a donor-assisted human reproduction (DAHR) procedure or surrogacy arrangement undertaken abroad by Irish resident parents or undertaken by Irish citizen parents living abroad. It also seeks to make other necessary amendments to various other sections of the 2024 Act, including in respect of Part 12. While drafting of the Bill is in its final stages, the process has not yet been completed, and as the provisions contained in the Bill as enacted will ultimately be a matter for the Oireachtas, it is not possible to state definitively at this time what will be in the legislation when enacted and how the provisions will apply in practice.

Some sections of the 2024 Act relating to the administrative functions of the Assisted Human Reproduction Regulatory Authority (AHRRA) were commenced to formally establish the body. I also signed an Order in April to commence three subsections of section 232 of the 2024 Act. This allows for the parentage of some donor-conceived children not covered by the Children and Family Relationships Act 2015 to be recognised.

However, the remaining provisions in the 2024 Act, are inter-connected, largely contingent on the AHRRA becoming suitably operational and subject to further amendment through the AHR Amendment Bill.

Part 12 of the 2024 Act allows for parents of children born as a result of a surrogacy agreement which was “entered into” and where the relevant embryo transfer took place before the commencement of section 204 and section 216 (applicable to past domestic surrogacy and past international surrogacy agreements, respectively) to apply to the Courts for a Parental Order in respect of that child. Following extensive discussions with the AGO, it was decided that the prospective and past international surrogacy provisions in the complete AHR legislation (as amended by the forthcoming Amendment Bill) must be commenced concurrently to ensure the proper operation of what are comprehensive and complex provisions. This decision was taken as the result of a concern that a legal “lacuna” will be created in respect of surrogacy arrangements undertaken in any “interim” period between the time of the commencement of the prospective provisions and the time of the commencement of the past provisions, if the latter were to be commenced at an earlier point in time. Therefore, the commencement dates of section 204 and section 216 will be aligned with the commencement dates for the prospective surrogacy provisions in Parts 7 & 8 of the 2024 Act to ensure that no child born as a result of a surrogacy agreement cannot be potentially “covered” under either the past or prospective surrogacy provisions. Any advice from the AGO in this regard is, of course, provided on a strictly confidential basis.

It is not possible to provide figures for the number of individuals/couples in Ireland who already have children who were born as a result of a domestic or international surrogacy arrangement. It would not be possible in any event to determine how many of these parents would or will actually choose to apply to the High Court under Part 12 for a Parental Order in respect of their children.

The Courts Service will be responsible for the operation of the Parental Order application process in relation to past surrogacy arrangements.

I have been advised by officials at the DoJHAM that the Legal Aid Board is the statutory, independent body responsible for the provision of civil legal aid and advice to qualifying individuals. Eligibility for the Civil Legal Aid Scheme is determined by reference to a financial assessment and the merits of the case being taken. In accordance with the provisions of the Civil Legal Aid Act 1995 (as amended) and associated Regulations, the Legal Aid Board calculates financial eligibility with reference to the applicant’s disposable income and disposable assets after certain allowances are applied to both. Civil legal aid and advice is provided primarily through a network of law centres by solicitors employed by the Board. The Board operates a total of 34 full-time law centres and dedicated units along with three part-time centres, and three specialist legal offices. The Board also operates 19 family mediation centres with a number of law centres and family mediation offices co-located.  In addition, the Board engages private solicitors to supplement the services provided by Board solicitors in certain areas of law on a case-by-case basis. These areas include District Court family law matters, Circuit Court judicial separation and divorce cases, international protection cases, and cases arising under the Abhaile scheme. Under Budget 2027, Minister Jim O’Callaghan secured a historic investment of €14.5 million for reforms to the Civil Legal Aid scheme. This will include widening eligibility for civil legal aid, operated by the Legal Aid Board in line with the recommendations of the Civil Legal Aid Review. This will enable more people to seek justice and supports through the civil courts.

The 2024 Act includes provisions in respect of circumstances pertaining in a Parental Order application related to a past domestic or international surrogacy arrangement whereby the surrogate mother concerned cannot be contacted. Also, it is intended through the AHR Amendment Bill to provide for circumstances whereby an intending parent is deemed to be unreasonably withholding consent for the granting of a Parental Order application in respect of a past surrogacy arrangement.

The importance of ensuring that parentage can be recognised in a wide set of circumstances is acknowledged.

My officials inform me that the current position in respect of the parentage of a child born as a result of a surrogacy arrangement, for example, is that most commonly an intending male parent who is genetically related to the child applies to the Courts for a Declaration of Parentage based on being the biological father of that child.

It is also worth noting that the partner or spouse of the biological father of a child born as a result of a surrogacy arrangement, if parentage has not been formally assigned to that partner or spouse, can apply for guardianship of the child, which affords many of the responsibilities of a parent and the protections that come with it.

Furthermore, my officials inform me that it is their understanding of current arrangements that in at least some instances it may be the case that if the intending parent(s) who have undertaken a surrogacy arrangement abroad were issued with a birth certificate by the jurisdiction in which the child was born which names the intending parent(s) as the parents of that child, the parental status of those so named on such a foreign birth certificate may be accepted by public or State bodies.

Finally, I want to assure you that further progressing the AHR legislation is a Government priority and a key commitment in the Programme for Government. Although it is not possible to set definitive timelines in this regard at this juncture, every effort is being made to ensure that outstanding work is concluded as soon as practicable.

Comment on this