Written answer
Child Protection
The Department is considering 21 recommendations from a 2025 independent review of the in-camera rule and examining practices in other jurisdictions, with reforms to balance transparency and public confidence against protecting families’ privacy. A three-year Family Law Reporting Project has begun, publishing its first volume of case reports in August 2026.
92. Deputy Gary Gannon asked the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration if his Department has examined the approaches taken in other jurisdictions, including England and Wales, to balancing transparency in family law proceedings with the protection of children; and whether any such approaches are being considered for introduction in Ireland. [78071/26]
Comment on this
93. Deputy Gary Gannon asked the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration if he has considered reforms to the in-camera rule that would allow for greater transparency and independent scrutiny of family law proceedings, while maintaining strict safeguards to protect the identities, privacy and welfare of children and vulnerable parties. [78070/26]
Comment on this
94. Deputy Gary Gannon asked the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration if any review has been undertaken into the operation of the in-camera rule in family law proceedings, particularly regarding its impact on transparency, accountability and public confidence in the family courts; and whether further reviews or reforms are being considered. [78069/26]
Comment on this
95. Deputy Gary Gannon asked the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration the rationale for the continued application of the in-camera rule in family law proceedings; and whether his Department has assessed the effectiveness of the rule in protecting children and vulnerable parties. [78068/26]
Comment on this
105. Deputy Gary Gannon asked the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration the mechanisms that currently exist to ensure transparency and accountability in family law proceedings conducted under the in-camera rule; if his Department collects data on the operation and outcomes of such proceedings; and whether consideration has been given to increasing the publication of anonymised judgments and information relating to family law cases. [78072/26]
Comment on this
I propose to take Questions Nos. 92, 93, 94, 95 and 105 together.
Ensuring transparency and promoting a greater understanding of the family law system is critical to maintaining and building trust in it. At the same time, those who seek the assistance of the courts in resolving their family justice disputes need to be assured that their privacy, and that of their children, will be maintained at what can be a very difficult time. In recognising the need for a balance between these two positions, the Family Justice Strategy commits to undertaking a review of the operation of the in-camera rule in family law proceedings.
Further to this commitment, an independent research report, entitled The Operation of the In Camera Rule in Family Law Proceedings, was published in 2025. The extensive report contains 21 detailed recommendations. Officials from my Department are currently considering the findings and recommendations of the report in the context of developing policy proposals for reform. This detailed work is ongoing, and policy proposals for reform will be submitted to me for consideration when finalised. Any policy proposals developed will need to ensure the privacy of parties involved continues. At the same time, such proposals will also consider how clarity can be provided regarding the scope of the rule and its impact for those involved in proceedings and enhance understanding of family law proceedings across society. Officials are also examining how family court proceedings operate in other jurisdictions, to see what can be learned from them.
Following on from the findings of the report, I commissioned the Family Law Reporting Project. Previously, there was no comprehensive system in Ireland for regularly and systematically reporting on private family law proceedings. The overall aim of the Project, which will be delivered over three years, is to provide transparency for the public, while ensuring that children’s and parents’ rights to privacy are upheld. It will also increase awareness and understanding of family law proceedings, while building confidence and trust in the judicial determination of such disputes. The first volume of case reports was published by my Department on the 19 August 2026, and is available here www.gov.ie/en/department-of-justice-home-affairs-and-migration/campaigns/family-law-reporting-project/.
In addition, significant progress has been made in respect of the Family Justice Strategy 2022-2025. Key actions include:
• the development of the Voice of the Child Report Template and Guidelines, launched on 8 October 2026, which will promote consistency in how children's views are gathered and presented and the ongoing work being undertaken by officials to establish a panel of family law assessors;
• the development of Judicial Guidelines on the Commissioning, Preparation, Content and Usage of Expert Reports in Family Law Proceedings. These guidelines were published on 16 April 2026 and are intended to promote consistency and best practice in the use of welfare reports in private family law proceedings in Ireland; and
• the establishment of the Children’s Court Advocate Pilot Project, which will assist children in having their voice heard in family law proceedings.
These actions will serve to further support transparency and fairness in how family law proceedings are conducted.