We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Special education system reform

Summary

Cummins criticises the Government’s record on children’s services and argues that special education needs proper, carefully planned reform. The Tánaiste agrees the current system is failing children, defends consultation rather than immediate change, and says any changes may not take effect until September 2028; they also exchange challenges over the Government’s record and his party’s report.

John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Before I call Deputy Cummins, I welcome the students from Grennan College in Thomastown, County Kilkenny, who are here as the guests of Deputy Newsome Drennan. I hope they enjoy their day in Leinster House. All of those in the Public Gallery are very welcome. It is good to see the public taking a keen interest in our debate and business.

Comment on this

I, too, welcome all of the young people in the Gallery. It is great to see them here.

An internal Fine Gael report has found that many people are confused about what the party stands for. Can I be so bold as to suggest a reason for the confusion? It is the party's repeated failure, after nearly 16 years in government, to deliver on promised commitments because it prefers to narrate the problems of this country rather than doing anything about them. We have seen that with the housing and cost-of-living crises but nowhere is it more evident than in the Government’s shameful treatment of children with additional needs and their families. They have known nothing but failure from this Government and every other Government Fine Gael has been involved in since 2011.

For those families talk is cheap and the Tánaiste's commitments are not credible because despite promise after promise, nothing gets better. Parents listen to Members of this Government insist that disability services and special education are a priority while watching their children being denied basic services and supports every single day. It is exhausting, demoralising and heartbreaking.

It should be no surprise that these families have so little faith in this Government and its plans to overhaul access to special education. It is now nearly a year since the Government announced it wanted to remove the requirement for children to have a diagnosis to access special classes and supports. There was very little information about this proposal until this week and the response has been very clear. All of the teacher unions have written to the Department to express universal opposition to these plans and I agree with their concerns. It seems that this plan is not being driven by the needs of children or their best interests but it is being introduced because the State has failed to provide them with timely access to diagnosis through the assessment of need process. Diagnoses are being presented as some kind of optional extra when the reality is that professional assessments and diagnoses are critical because they outline what the child needs to survive and thrive.

Teachers are not qualified to do this functional, clinical work. They are not psychologists. Principals are not clinicians and schools are not diagnostic centres; they are places of teaching and learning. This proposal, as outlined in documents from the Department, will mean that a child will have to display behaviours that persistently impact on attendance, achievement, participation and well-being before they receive specialist supports. Does the Government want a child to underachieve or fail before he or she gets the appropriate supports? In what world is that appropriate? Where is the care and humanity in that? It is cruel and it is a throwback to a time when this country treated the most vulnerable people with the most contempt. Does the Tánaiste accept this new proposal is more about Government convenience rather than the best interests of the child?

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

No. Quite frankly, I accept that if every time we tried to consult and engage on how we reform a system and we tried to shut down the debate before having the engagement, that would not be in the interests of the child. The Deputy provoked me in relation to my party report. If it was a secret report, we would not have emailed it to thousands of people-----

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

------and be handing out hard copies at the Ard-Fheis and having a discussion in the full glare of the media. Sometimes it is good for parties to actually look at how they can best serve this country and not be complacent about the centre holding and populism not taking hold. I look forward to that discussion.

I will debate my party's record with anyone. We will do that at the Ard-Fheis. My party’s record since I came into this House is going from a position of 15% unemployment and the IMF being in town to seeing 145 homes completed every single working day. There are 300 people getting keys to their new home every working day. We have full employment. We are reducing tax and childcare costs, we have a record number of special classes-----

Comment on this

There is record homelessness.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

Sorry, the way this works is that a Deputy does not just get to make a charge and I roll over and they tickle my belly. If somebody says something, I actually have a right to respond to it in this House.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

Do not try to shout me down.

That is the first point. The second point is in relation to special education. It always worries me when the starting point is that the unions said it is a bad idea. Quite frankly, sometimes it is not about the unions or the politicians-----

Comment on this

That was not the starting point.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

Hang on a second, please. I fully respect Deputy Cummins and her sincerity, bona fides, and knowledge on and interest in this issue but I also know the current system is not working and it is not serving children. I think we can agree on that. I know what I am meant to do. I meant to stand up here and trot out a load of figures,say we are spending more money than ever before and we have more special classes than ever before. All of that is true but the system is still not working. Are we going to continue pumping money into a system that is letting children down or are we going to ask what inclusive education looks like?

I want to assure parents and teachers that nothing is decided here, and I am not suggesting the Deputy is not, but let us make sure there is an honesty in relation to this. Nothing is decided. We want to consult extensively with all stakeholders. That is simply where we are at. We need to ask ourselves whether there are too many hoops and hurdles and too much bureaucracy that a child has to jump through before getting a place in a special school, and I contend there absolutely is. I would look at it the other way. The Deputy said we want the child to fail but she does not believe that. Nobody wants a child to fail. However, what we are doing now is saying a child has to have this or that piece of paper and has to tick a box. If the family is fortunate enough to be able to pay for the piece of paper, that is not on either. We have to see whether the system has become overly bureaucratic because I do not believe we are getting the return on investment families expect.

Quite rightly, the figures we are spending on special education are extraordinarily large - it is good we are spending lots of money on special education - but they should not be that large with so many people still dissatisfied. What the Minister, Deputy Naughton, is doing with the Minister of State, Deputy Moynihan, is trying to have a conversation about reform alongside investment and how we get this model right. As part of that, we will have this inclusive education forum, which I think the Deputy is in favour of, which will kick off on 12 November. Let us have a discussion about what the model looks like.

In relation to this, any future proposals will involve lots of engagement with advocacy organisations, disabled persons organisations, and educational stakeholders. Of course, they will. However, we should be willing to have the conversation because the current system is not best serving children.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear the Tánaiste does not think it is working because I do not either. I respect the work he and other people in this Government are doing in this area but it is not good enough. The fact is that it is not working fast enough. There is idea after idea - we will try this or that out. There is a document going around at the moment comparing our education system to other countries but it is not like for like. We cannot make this up as we go along. There are going to be many more children coming into the system with additional needs. We need proper plans but they should not be piecemeal. That is the problem. It is not only the problem with the view in this Government of special education but it is also what is happening on the ground for children and schools.

We saw in a documentary a couple of weeks ago where children with additional educational needs are being treated as second- or even third-class citizens in this country. We are not getting it right. My quest is to make sure that I put as much pressure as possible on the Government to get this right and get the expertise and listen to people on the ground and the parents. They know what that is. I know the Government is having that forum but it has to stop kite-flying because it is scaring families, children, and education providers.

Comment on this
Simon Harris The Tánaiste Fine Gael

I am very conscious of the point the Deputy makes about kite-flying and the anxiety it can cause but I say, respectfully, that it is not kite-flying which is when you begin consultation, start to engage and somebody somewhere in the system says, "This is what we are doing." No decision has been made nor is there any plan for an immediate change. I say that genuinely.

Any changes that come about might happen in September 2028, and not this coming September.

The second exchange we are having is more productive. The Deputy should be putting us under pressure. We, collectively, need to put ourselves under pressure to do more and do better rather than just rhyming off the statistics. We have all seen the benefits of the new classes in schools. Those are real benefits but it is still not enough. I and the Government believe there is a rigidity here. I was just asked about a grandfather who is wondering whether his three-year-old grandchild will get speech and language therapy. Part of the answer to speeding up access in general will be to free up therapists to do less report writing and more provision of therapy. We have to look at how we get this right. We have to drive reform. We in this country have an addiction to spending. The answer is to spend more, spend more and spend more. We must have a similar level of obsession with the impact of that spending and the difference it is making. Let us work, whether through the education committee of these Houses or the inclusive forum, to get the model right. The Deputy should be keeping us under pressure to go faster but we should have a shared destination for where we want to get to. It has to be a better place than we are in now.

Comment on this