Ceisteanna - Questions ›
Cabinet Committees
The Cabinet committee on water quality last met in July, with its next meeting to be scheduled shortly. The Taoiseach cited a €2.3 billion allocation for Uisce Éireann in 2027 and ongoing water-quality measures, while acknowledging failures in wastewater treatment, supply outages and communication; he said he would raise local concerns and accountability with Uisce Éireann.
1. Deputy Barry Heneghan asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [78908/26]
Comment on this
2. Deputy Peter 'Chap' Cleere asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [75628/26]
Comment on this
3. Deputy Tony McCormack asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [64303/26]
Comment on this
4. Deputy Aindrias Moynihan asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [75860/26]
Comment on this
5. Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [70052/26]
Comment on this
6. Deputy Brendan Smith asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [75862/26]
Comment on this
7. Deputy Paul Lawless asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [77535/26]
Comment on this
8. Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [77484/26]
Comment on this
9. Deputy Liam Quaide asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will next meet. [75669/26]
Comment on this
10. Deputy Michael Collins asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [79369/26]
Comment on this
11. Deputy Danny Healy-Rae asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will next meet. [79384/26]
Comment on this
12. Deputy Conor D. McGuinness asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [79355/26]
Comment on this
13. Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [79318/26]
Comment on this
14. Deputy Roderic O'Gorman asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will next meet. [79395/26]
Comment on this
15. Deputy Jennifer Whitmore asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [79223/26]
Comment on this
16. Deputy Ivana Bacik asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on water quality will meet next. [79428/26]
Comment on this
I propose to take questions Nos. 1 to 16, inclusive, together.
The Cabinet committee on water quality oversees implementation of programme for Government commitments in relation to Ireland's water, including those related to pressures from agriculture, forestry, land use and wastewater treatment. Water is vital to the well-being of our society, economy and environment and the programme for Government commits to improving the health of our rivers, lakes and estuaries and of our coastal and groundwaters.
The Environmental Protection Agency, EPA's, indicator report on water quality in 2025 noted some improvements at a local level, with 54% of rivers and lakes recorded as having good or better biological equality. Some 98% of bathing waters met or exceeded minimum standards. We continue to have concerns regarding nutrient loads in certain parts of the country. While EPA analysis shows that significant challenges remain, it is important to recognise the progress that has been made. An example of positive improvement is the Ballyteigue-Bannow catchment in County Wexford, seeing the biological quality of a number of its rivers improve.
Budget 2027 allocates almost €2.3 billion to Uisce Éireann in 2027. This includes €1.5 billion in capital funding to build essential capacity and increase the resilience and sustainability of our water supply for new water and wastewater connections, enabling the delivery of new homes, and to deliver upgrades to wastewater treatment infrastructure, improving water quality, protecting the environment and enhancing compliance with regulatory standards. This investment will progress over 400 projects across the country next year, including the eastern and midlands region water supply project, the greater Dublin drainage scheme and the wastewater treatment plant upgrades in Limerick and Waterford.
The water action plan, published last year, sets out over 150 actions to protect, improve and restore water quality. These include the implementation and tracking of the water action plans, the development of a stronger sixth nitrates action programme, the farming for water European innovation partnership, EIP, project and the national barrier mitigation programme, which will support fish migration and water quality.
The sixth nitrates action programme was published by the Minister, Deputy Browne, in December and will run until 2028. This plan gives effect to the nitrates directive, which governs the management of nitrate loss from agriculture to water bodies. On foot of the measures included in this plan, the European Commission granted Ireland a three-year extension on its nitrates derogation in December 2025. The Minister, Deputy Heydon, is working with his officials to address key conditions within the derogation decision, including the undertaking of the environmental assessments to demonstrate enhanced compliance with the nitrates derogation, the habitats directive and the water framework directive.
Additional information not given on the floor of the House
It will be important to safeguard the economic contribution of farmers in areas most affected by the derogation, as well as implementing workable solutions for water quality. The Farming for Water European Innovation Partnership with a budget of €60 million commenced in 2024 providing financial support for specific targeted water quality actions above regulatory requirements. To date over 5,500 farmers have applied for support.
Targeted agriculture modernisation scheme, TAMS, grant aid is supporting capital investments in low emission slurry spreading equipment and manure storage. Since 2015 a total of over €195 million has been paid to family farms supporting significant investments in manure storage and low emission slurry spreading technology.
The Cabinet committee provides a focus to drive the improvement of water quality. It met most recently in July and the next meeting will be scheduled shortly.
Comment on this
There are 15 Members drawn to speak. I am proposing 45 seconds each. I will keep Members in check. That is to allow a decent answer.
I call Deputy Heneghan.
Comment on this
Last December, I raised the issue of flood defence being included in the Critical Infrastructure Act. I am seeking an update on that. My constituency and my constituents have waited far too long.
With regard to water quality, I raised the issue of using nature-based solutions with the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine last week. I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Moran's work with the 3D-printed bollards for flood defence, but flood defence and water quality should be going hand in hand. I thank the Minister of State, Deputy Christopher O'Sullivan, who brought me to Dún Laoghaire's oyster farms, which show that oysters can clean water at 190 litres per day.
We should be using 3D-printed flood defences that protect the oysters that clean our water. We should be breaking the waves but not breaking the ecosystem. I ask the Taoiseach for an update on that.
Comment on this
The Nore, Suir and Barrow, known as the Three Sisters, traverse the heart of Carlow and Kilkenny. Last year, the EPA found that two of the most nitrogen-polluted waterways in the whole country were right where the Barrow and the Nore met. Last week, the EPA reported that more than half of our wastewater plants were failing the standards set to stop pollution. Meanwhile, in Bennettsbridge on the banks of the River Nore, the wastewater plant upgrade was approved years ago but it will not be finished until 2030. It is not good enough and it is not acceptable that in Mullinavat and Inistioge the plants are at full capacity. Graiguenamanagh, sitting on the River Barrow, is in dire need of an upgrade too. These villages need to be looked after. They need the money locked in and they need a date. We know that Uisce Éireann is drawing up its first national wastewater plan out to 2055. When the committee meets next, will it make sure that the plan prioritises the small towns, villages and rivers that the EPA says are under pressure, with funding and clear timelines provided?
Comment on this
I want to acknowledge the significant investment that this Government is making in water infrastructure, and rightly so, but we have an opportunity now to strengthen accountability and communication from the public bodies responsible for delivering these essential services. To take the example of Birr in my own constituency, residents and businesses have endured repeated water outages, causing considerable problems. I have raised this at our infrastructure committee. What concerns me is the quality of information that we are receiving from Uisce Éireann. It is not just individual TDs who are receiving generic replies that fail to address the questions asked. Even formal requests for further information from Oireachtas committees can be met with vague responses that provide little additional detail. Could we look at introducing a formal system requiring public bodies to respond directly to each question raised by an Oireachtas committee within clear timelines and to provide further clarification where answers are inadequate?
Comment on this
We are approaching winter with the possibility of more rain, cattle inside and around the yard, and silage pits opened. Farmers are very much alive to the risks to water quality. They will be out around their yards making sure that every action is taken to ensure a safe water quality. They have even been building extra slurry capacity. They are playing their part and they expect that others, including the likes of Uisce Éireann, would also step up to the plate and play their part. It is very frustrating to see wastewater from the Ballingeary treatment plant being discharged into the River Lee by Uisce Éireann.
The nitrates derogation is hugely important for farmers. Last week, the Minister expressed concern that some farms may not be able to retain the derogation even though Ireland as a whole may. The subcatchment results are due out next year. Can we make sure that Uisce Éireann pulls its weight and delivers capacity?
Comment on this
As the Taoiseach knows, the small towns and villages growth programme provides for investment in water and wastewater infrastructure in the smaller towns and villages that are not included in Uisce Éireann's main capital plan. Such investment would enable housing developments in those small towns and villages, where we already have good social infrastructure, including schools, community centres, sporting facilities, shops and health facilities. There is a constant problem now with traffic in our larger towns, so the dispersal of the population in the future would be very beneficial. We would be adding relatively small numbers to towns and villages that already have infrastructure in place, bar water and sewerage systems of a certain standard.
Comment on this
There are major issues with Uisce Éireann right across the country. In Mayo, for example, in the Johnstown Lavellyroe group water scheme, which was taken over recently by Uisce Éireann, there have been major problems. Over the past five months, there have been 22 days of outages. This is happening at a time when Uisce Éireann has paid €18 million in performance-related bonuses to its staff and its CEO has received a pay increase of €118,000, bringing his salary to almost €400,000. How is this justifiable?
Comment on this
Recent alarming reports from the United States confirm that hackers have targeted water infrastructure across 12 states, highlighting the growing threat to critical national infrastructure. I raised this with the Taoiseach in December 2023 and again in February 2024 when a local group water scheme in Mayo was hacked.
As Chair of the defence and national security committee, I am acutely aware of the dangers posed by cyberattacks and hybrid warfare and the need to invest in our preparedness. Water security is a national security issue. A successful attack could compromise drinking water quality, disrupt essential services and endanger public life. We cannot afford complacency or to underestimate the likelihood and potentially devastating consequences of such an attack. I want to know what proactive measures the Taoiseach is taking.
Comment on this
One of my favourite things about representing the constituency of Dublin Bay South is Dublin Bay. The Taoiseach might know that, this past summer, bathing along Dublin Bay was restricted. Imagine my shock to learn that the Ailesbury pump station pumps raw sewage onto Sandymount Strand once every month and Uisce Éireann says it will take between five and ten years to rehabilitate the situation. There is a severe issue with residential, agricultural and industrial effluent going into our waterways. What are the Taoiseach and the Government going to do to enforce the standards people need to rely on proper, clean water, including in Dublin Bay?
Comment on this
Last week, the EPA announced a figure of 11 towns and villages discharging raw sewage into clear waters. That is an absolute farce and a lie because there are 11 of them in west Cork alone, never mind 11 nationally. I cannot understand how the EPA can pull out these figures. Stop conning the people. There are the people of Goleen, Shannonvale, Ballydehob and Rosscarbery. There is the Ouvane river. There is raw sewage pouring into the rivers and people are blaming the farmers. There is something wrong here somewhere. Uisce Éireann has to get it right. The EPA certainly cannot get it right. Uisce Éireann cannot deliver a proper treatment plant. It is continuously hiding behind everything and getting well paid for doing that. It is time for delivery to these areas that in some cases are waiting 25 years.
Comment on this
As the Taoiseach is well aware, Ballyheigue has been without water for almost seven weeks. One way or another, to resolve this matter, pipe laying will have to start and water will have to be taken from Ardfert, which comes from Killarney, towards Ballyheigue. I am asking that the Glenderry system be opened again to supplement. It worked well for almost 60 years. Time is going by and people are entitled to water and should have it. I ask the Government to liaise with Uisce Éireann to put a bit of a spur to the thing and to start laying pipes immediately.
Comment on this
Communities across County Waterford are being failed by repeated water supply problems, with no sign of lasting solutions. In Tallow and Dungarvan, separate faults have led to week-long outages and "boil water" notices, and these towns continue to experience low pressure. In Glencairn, water tankers have become an almost permanent fixture. Deelish, Mount Melleray, Kilmacthomas, Touraneena, Portlaw and Bunmahon are villages and towns experiencing sporadic water outages and pressure problems. People are being left without a reliable basic service while temporary fixes replace investment in infrastructure. The system is being patched every time until the system is basically comprised of patches. Will the Taoiseach ensure that Uisce Éireann produces a properly funded long-term plan to resolve these problems and improve advance notifications of outages?
Comment on this
For the best part of six weeks, there have been 3,500 households in Kilmoyley, Causeway and Ballyheigue under a "do not consume" notice. Elected representatives have been receiving daily updates but get no answers in those updates. The updates say that the work is progressing. They say that investigations have commenced. They say that assessments are ongoing. However, the basic questions have not been answered. How was it caused? How long will it proceed? Will the perfectly good Glenderry sandstone water pump station, which was closed during the summer, be reopened to at least give temporary water to people in the Ballyheigue area? It is an easy fix to part of the problem there. Will the Taoiseach ensure that it is done as a matter of urgency?
Comment on this
I raise the ongoing environmental disaster in Lough Neagh. The lough has been severely impacted by green algae in recent years to the extent that it risks becoming an ecological dead zone. My colleagues in the Green Party Northern Ireland have been highlighting this mounting crisis for a long time, but action in Stormont has been extremely slow. Given that we share one environment on this island, is this a matter that the shared island function in the Taoiseach's Department can raise with the Northern Ireland Executive, in particular with Andrew Muir, the minister for agriculture and environment?
Comment on this
Last year, 55% of wastewater treatment plants in Ireland discharged polluted water into our rivers and seas. Some 50% of those failures were simply due to operational issues, such as not maintaining equipment and not having sufficient training in place. It is clear that Uisce Éireann is not doing its job properly. Will the Taoiseach explain to me again how it is the case that the CEO of Uisce Éireann got nearly €120,000 extra in their salary this year and nearly €18 million was given to staff last year in performance-related bonuses? There is someone in senior management at Uisce Éireann who cannot even ensure that equipment is being maintained and they are allowing our waters to be polluted by their failures. How are they being paid to do that?
Comment on this
We started with Deputy Heneghan in terms of flood defences, nature-based solutions and the utilisation of oyster farms. First of all, in terms of flood defence, we have extensive investment under way in terms of flood defences, but they take time. There has to be significant public consultation. There can be a lot of objections to flood defences, as we know and as we have experienced all over the country, but the plans are detailed and it is important to get them right. The problem is the timeline that is involved. I will talk to the Minister. The Minister has identified some public transport projects and he has listed them as part of the Critical Infrastructure Act. However, if you list everything, then it is no longer a priority. That is a challenge with the legislation. We have quite a number of critical flood defences that we want in place, but the Office of Public Works, OPW, is working on those with the county councils and with the public. Some of them are intricate, complex and so on.
The EPA has approved nature-based solutions for wastewater treatment, particularly for new housing developments in small towns and villages. The uptake on that has not been strong, but it is now available.
The Deputy said that the Minister of State, Deputy Christopher O'Sullivan, had taken him to the oyster farm. He is very enthusiastic about that. There is potential there, without question, and we will be expanding those types of approach into the future.
In terms of the Nore, the Suir and the Barrow, and in response to Deputy Cleere, first of all, I will engage with Uisce Éireann. The Deputy is saying that half the plants are failing. I suppose the backdrop to many of the questions is that Uisce Éireann was established more than a decade ago. I was in opposition at the time, just to clarify. We reached an agreement around 2016, but it seems to me that we lost a bit of local knowledge in the local authorities, which could have been valuable. Equally, to be fair to Uisce Éireann, it inherited a substantial deficit in terms of historic deficiency in the existing water supply, pipelines and so on, and that has to be caught up on.
This Government has allocated very substantial moneys to Uisce Éireann and we have said that there has to be better communication with Deputies in respect of how it communicates to the public at large in terms of outages, water being switched off and so on. That is something that we are constantly on to Uisce Éireann about. It has established a unit within its organisation.
The budget for 2027 is €2.3 billion and that includes €1.5 billion in capital funding. That is for essential capacity, increased resilience, sustainability of the supply, new water and wastewater treatment connections, and the delivery of upgrades to wastewater treatment plants improving water quality. There is a lot of money allocated, but I accept the point that Deputy Cleere and others have made in terms of outcomes and outputs and I will talk to Uisce Éireann in respect of that Nore-Barrow intersection that the Deputy described as being particularly difficult.
I am not in a position to give the Deputy dates now. Sometimes, I am careful of when organisations are asked to give dates because the dates can be too long into the future. We need to keep the pressure on to get interim solutions as well as the more longer term solutions.
Deputy McCormack spoke about accountability, communication, Birr and so on. A unit was established in Uisce Éireann following representations from Members of the House and, indeed, local councillors. We have to look at this again regarding what the Deputy said and to develop some system. What I do not want, to be frank, is a system that overloads the administration with hundreds of questions. That can snarl up. However, there is clearly a gap from what I am hearing from everyone in the House on a repeated basis.
As to Deputy Moynihan’s point, winter is approaching. Some days it is winterish, other days it is not. However, I take his point. Farming communities are very aware of the issues, particularly in the context of the nitrates directive. Some catchment areas are more vulnerable and challenging than others. I have repeatedly told Uisce Éireann representatives when they attend Cabinet subcommittee meetings that Uisce Éireann needs to get its house in order first. It must stop failures in its own wastewater treatment plants. Uisce Éireann above everybody else should not be polluting water through negligence, lack of attention or various incidents that have occurred in the past. It is conscious of that, to be fair, and it is working on it.
As for Deputy Smith’s points regarding small towns and villages and wastewater treatment, we are putting pressure on. Apart from the nature-based solutions, we need plug-in solutions as well, particularly for small builders, so that we can get housing into towns and villages across the country. That would make a difference to housing and to villages and towns that have all the services and networks to grow naturally and properly. That is something we are working on.
I do not know whether it is the water quality or salaries that Deputy Lawless is interested in.
Comment on this
However, he said the group water scheme had been taken over recently. That suggests to me it is not Uisce Éireann's problem if there are outages emanating from that group water scheme. It might suggest that there were historic problems building up there - I do not know the specifics - but I do not think we can blame Uisce Éireann if it was only taken over recently. I do not think that would be fair.
Deputy Conway-Walsh referred to a group water scheme that had been hacked in County Mayo and cybersecurity. We are very alive to this. That National Cyber Security Centre guides both public utilities and private companies. It provides guidance and advice. If anyone suffers an incident, he or she should immediately refer it to the Garda and the National Cyber Security Centre. We are building resilience in cybersecurity. It is very challenging and the Deputy is correct in saying that all utilities are vulnerable, particularly in an AI-enabled world. AI-enabled cyberattacks can be far more dangerous. We have to be very resilient in response to that. We have built up a very strong National Cyber Security Centre in a relatively short period of time and I have a lot of confidence in the leadership of that centre.
In terms of raw sewage into Sandymount Strand, if we were to go back ten or 20 years, there was an extraordinary amount of raw sewage going into water all over the country. There have been substantial improvements, it has to be said, but until we stop it all everywhere, we will not be satisfied. That is the bottom line. I will discuss the Sandymount area and what is happening there with Uisce Éireann when we meet next. I will make the point that Deputy Hayes raised the issue.
I make the same point to Deputy Collins. There was a lot more discharge of raw sewage into harbours and rivers ten, 15 and 20 years ago than there is today. That means we have to keep on working and providing treatment facilities in as many towns and villages as we possibly can. The Deputy and I both know that there can be many rows about location of treatment plants in villages and towns, which can often delay the provision of such plants for years. I am a great believer in trying to seize the moment when an investment is available, and sometimes towns and villages miss that moment by objecting to a particular plant in a particular location, believing it will smell or whatever. The challenge is the area then does not get the plant or investment. That is a real issue.
Deputies Healy-Rae and Daly raised Ballyheigue. Uisce Éireann has told them that work is progressing and investigations are ongoing.
Those are the facts. If that is what Uisce Éireann is telling the Deputies, that is what is happening. I will check with Uisce Éireann what the story is with Glenderry. It is probably not as simple as the Deputies say because if it were that simple, why would Uisce Éireann not do it? There must be problems and challenges to it, but I will pursue it with Uisce Éireann. The note I had last week or the week before was that it was a serious enough matter that would not lend itself to an easy solution. I will get an up-to-date position from Uisce Éireann and relay it to both Deputies later.
Deputy McGuinness mentioned the water supply problems in towns and villages. He listed a number of areas across Waterford. I will discuss that with Uisce Éireann. There is a common refrain here. We have a capital programme of approximately €1.5 billion. The challenge is to balance that between the big, new projects and the smaller projects where upgrades are required or where extensions are required.
What we are witnessing is a clash. We are trying to catch up historically but are also matching an unprecedented increase in population growth over the past 20 years and the growth of towns and villages across rural Ireland. People often talk about rural decline but what is symptomatic of the representations today is the growth of the population in rural towns, increased capacities and so on.
Deputy O'Gorman may not be aware that we have already allocated substantial moneys from the shared island fund to the Northern Ireland Executive for the clean-up of Lough Neagh. That is matched by funding from Andrew Muir's department. That is my understanding. Off hand, I think we are talking about €20 million, if not more, from the shared island fund, recognising the wider catchment areas. These are our problems as well as theirs. It is also to help out, because it is a catastrophic situation that has proved difficult for the Executive to deal with. We have already allocated. The issue now is to get the work started and to use the funding that we have made available. I can get the Deputy the details of the scheme.
Deputy Whitmore spoke about Uisce Éireann not doing its job, failures in certain plants and pollution as a result of outflow from the plants. I have highlighted the issue with Uisce Éireann. It believes that some of the issue has to do with the transition from a local authority system to a nationally organised system. Nonetheless, as far as I am concerned, this should be the number one priority of Uisce Éireann because it must set the standards for others to follow.