We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna - Questions ›

Cabinet Committees

Summary

The Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy last met on 22 October and its next meeting will be scheduled shortly. The Taoiseach said the 2026 climate action plan had been approved by Cabinet and would undergo environmental assessment; he stressed the need to expand renewables and improve climate resilience, while noting efforts to speed up retrofit grants and prepare for severe weather. He also said private-wires legislation was nearing Cabinet and supported examining Youghal rail restoration, while cautioning that major rail projects face funding limits.

17. Deputy Barry Heneghan asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next. [78909/26]

Comment on this

18. Deputy Peadar Tóibín asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79025/26]

Comment on this

19. Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79097/26]

Comment on this

20. Deputy Naoise Ó Cearúil asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will meet next. [64307/26]

Comment on this

21. Deputy Louis O'Hara asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will meet next. [67765/26]

Comment on this

22. Deputy Shane Moynihan asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [64306/26]

Comment on this

23. Deputy James O'Connor asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [75863/26]

Comment on this

24. Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [77362/26]

Comment on this

25. Deputy Liam Quaide asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [75672/26]

Comment on this

26. Deputy Paul Murphy asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will meet next. [79262/26]

Comment on this

27. Deputy Michael Collins asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79370/26]

Comment on this

28. Deputy Danny Healy-Rae asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79385/26]

Comment on this

29. Deputy Roderic O'Gorman asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79396/26]

Comment on this

30. Deputy Peter 'Chap' Cleere asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79419/26]

Comment on this

31. Deputy Tony McCormack asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79418/26]

Comment on this

32. Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79415/26]

Comment on this

33. Deputy Jennifer Whitmore asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79224/26]

Comment on this

34. Deputy Ciarán Ahern asked the Taoiseach when the Cabinet committee on climate action, environment and energy will next meet. [79436/26]

Comment on this

I propose to take Questions Nos. 17 to 34, inclusive, together.

The Cabinet committee on climate action, the environment and energy oversees the implementation of programme for Government commitments relating to the environment, climate action, energy and emergency planning. The programme for Government restates our determination that Ireland, together with our European Union partners, will play its full part in tackling climate change, protecting this and future generations.

Change is under way across our economy and society to steer Ireland towards a low-carbon future. Reducing emissions is now at the heart of all our policies and sectoral plans. We are seeing real progress. However, projections from the EPA make clear that we have much more work to do.

There are encouraging signs. Ireland's emissions have been falling for the last three years and we now have lower overall emissions than at any point in the past 35 years despite our population growing by 50% over that period. The climate action plan, an updated version of which will be published in the coming weeks, is guiding our efforts and sets out sectoral policies and targets that we are working towards.

The Cabinet committee considers the wide range of issues that require action in Ireland's transition to a low-carbon, climate-resilient and sustainable future, a future in which we take full advantage of the renewable energy potential that we possess while ensuring that policies also contribute to energy affordability, energy security and competitiveness. The programme for Government committed to taking decisive action to provide warmer, more comfortable homes as part of our drive to support energy affordability, security and sustainability.

The Minister, Deputy Darragh O'Brien, launched a national residential retrofit plan for 2026, which will make home energy upgrades more affordable and accessible to many more homeowners. It provides for new and enhanced individual upgrades to support homeowners with their upgrade journeys, including new window and door grants. Increased grants and wider eligibility make it easier for homeowners to complete deep retrofits on a phased basis that suits their budgets.

It also provides for increased grants for homeowners on qualifying welfare payments. There are also new supports for first-time buyers of existing houses, increased grant supports for approved housing bodies and local authorities, and support in the community for older people. By promoting retrofitting, renewable heating and solar energy in this way, we will make homes warmer and cheaper to heat.

Last year, more than 58,000 homeowners benefited from energy upgrades under SEAI schemes. We will build on that this year, widening the net to upgrade even more homes in 2026 and making home energy upgrades more affordable and accessible to all. The number of applications to the SEAI so far in 2026 has doubled. Over 78,000 applications were processed between January and the end of July, which is up almost 120% on this time last year.

Improving Ireland's resilience in the face of more severe and more frequent climate impacts is one of the issues regularly considered by the Cabinet committee. Learning from the experiences of recent severe weather events, the Government has strengthened preparation and resilience ahead of possible storms and floods this winter. Significant work has been carried out to improve flood risk monitoring, enhance national co-ordination and increase operational resilience across local authorities, utilities and key response agencies. All Government Departments and agencies have reviewed their severe weather readiness and response plans. They have taken tangible actions to ensure preparation for the coming season. Local authorities have been carrying out ongoing preventative maintenance of drains, culverts and gullies. The OPW and local authorities have made arrangements for the purchase, storage at five locations around the country and deployment of mobile pumps and temporary flood barriers. These will augment the equipment already held by city and county councils. This will ensure that the right equipment can be quickly moved to where it is required. Uisce Éireann has positioned 30 large generators at key sites and has 70 additional mobile generators supplementing an existing fleet of 150 generators. A further 80 generators are planned for purchase. Some 20 dedicated wastewater pumps are available to manage disruption caused by flooding. Local authorities have identified 572 locations that can operate as community support centres, with more than 100 already equipped with generator changeover capability and approximately 200 expected by the end of the year.

Being positioned to react well and recover quickly from increasingly severe and unprecedented weather events will depend on how well we can anticipate and adapt to the impacts ahead. Ireland has an elaborate suite of resources to guide our work in this area. These include a national climate risk assessment, a national adaptation framework and a suite of sectoral adaptation plans. The Cabinet committee has been interrogating our collective efforts in this area and what more may be required to ensure we are adequately prepared for the significant changes to the climate that are under way. The Cabinet committee last met on 22 October. The next meeting of the Cabinet committee will be scheduled shortly.

Comment on this

My private wires Bill has been selected for debate on 17 December. This is one solution to three of the biggest national challenges we face. In housing, we need faster electricity connections to unlock badly needed homes. Imagine a single connection to our national grid after a developer has already put in 64 connections that are ready for people. On the cost of living, I am delighted to see that plug-in solar has been done but families and businesses should be able to share renewable-generated energy locally more easily. In healthcare, hospitals should have easier access to on-site or nearby renewable generation. Will the Taoiseach commit to working with me to progress this Bill to deliver real savings for Irish people, households, businesses and public services? It is in the programme for Government. It is the reason the Ceann Comhairle ruled me out of being a member of the Opposition. Ireland needs this. We need to do it as soon as possible.

Comment on this

Cork County Council failed to pass its annual budget last night. It has two weeks to pass a budget or the council will be dissolved and a Government administrator will have to be appointed. That is not good for the council's climate objectives. It is also not good for the county of the current Taoiseach. This happened because the council is looking for an 8% increase in commercial rates. As the Taoiseach will know, small businesses are being hammered with the increased cost of doing business. Peter O'Donoghue, an Aontú councillor, has successfully tabled a motion seeking that central government address the shortfall in the council budget to prevent pressure being put on small businesses. Small businesses are at breaking point. Will the Taoiseach step up to the mark and help them?

Comment on this

It is an ingenious move to table a motion.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach mentioned the success of and demand for home retrofitting via the SEAI. In Kildare and nationally, there are entire housing estates where houses were built to the same standard and are losing energy and heat in the exact same areas. I ask that the Taoiseach liaise with the SEAI to look at a pilot scheme for retrofitting in housing estates to reduce the cost. This would essentially be like a group scheme. Local authorities should also be able to do group schemes for social housing. This would be a pilot identifying individual housing estates and trying to get more houses completed in this way.

Comment on this

Last week, I attended a public meeting in Gort regarding the proposal to construct a large biogas plant in the area. We know that renewable energy has an important role to play but this is simply the wrong development in the wrong location. Placing a heavy industrial anaerobic digestion facility right on the edge of Gort town, adjacent to homes, schools and sensitive ecological sites, is completely unacceptable to the local community. The community has had to put a significant amount of time and resources into responding to this proposal over several years and it is now back in the planning process again. When will the Government step up and ensure proper oversight of these developments? When will we see reform of our planning frameworks to guarantee that local communities are meaningfully consulted and respected rather than forced to fight unsuitable proposals on their doorstep?

Comment on this

An EU directive prohibiting public financial incentives for new stand-alone oil and gas boilers is creating a huge number of issues for people who previously would have been able to avail of council grants. There is now no SEAI grant. I dealt with this as a Topical Issue last week. There is no possibility of a payment through an emergency needs payment.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy saying there should be an SEAI grant for oil boilers?

Comment on this

What I am saying is that, in a perfect world-----

Comment on this

I just want to get clarity.

Comment on this

In a perfect world, if people could get support from the warmer homes scheme without it taking 15 months, they could make sure they had heating in a very short period of time. However, we are talking about people whose boilers have gone and cannot be fixed and who cannot get a refurbished boiler. Supposedly, you can get these out there but I would ask anyone to try to find one. If they could, they would be able to avail of the council grants that people previously would have used. There is a huge number of people whose boilers have gone. There is no fixing them and they cannot find a refurbished one. In some cases, we are talking about people in their 70s and 80s who are on really small payments. The European directive has created an anomaly here. We need to find a solution. We all want to move to renewables and sustainable heat pumps but it is not always possible for people in severe cold.

Comment on this

There is welcome investment in Cork's commuter rail network with new stations, electrification and more frequent services planned, yet Youghal, one of east Cork's most important towns, remains excluded from these plans. Youghal residents and the residents of surrounding villages endure ever-worsening commuting misery every day. Restoring the Midleton-Youghal railway would reduce car dependency and emissions, ease congestion on the N25 and support sustainable development across east Cork. The Cork metropolitan area transport strategy is due for review, with completion targeted for mid-2027. Youghal falls outside the existing metropolitan boundary, however. Despite this, the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, recently identified this review as an opportunity to reconsider restoring the Youghal railway. Will the Taoiseach ask the Minister for Transport to engage with the National Transport Authority to ensure that restoring the Midleton-Youghal railway is fully examined as part of that review? This is a vital infrastructural link for east Cork.

Comment on this

I will ask the Taoiseach about a scandal exposed on the news website, The Currency, today. It relates to what has happened with the windfall levy on energy companies. This was introduced at a European level. The European Commission said it should be used to help vulnerable households. Instead, in Ireland, it is being used to help Denis O'Brien, J.P. McManus, Dunnes Stores, Lidl, Aldi, SuperValu and the many other companies that have received tens of millions of euros in handouts from this EU-wide levy. All of the almost €22 million in levy proceeds handed out in this State has gone to businesses. Not a single penny has gone to struggling households. This is in the country with the most expensive household electricity prices in Europe, where 500,000 households are now in arrears on their energy bills. How can the Taoiseach stand over giving €200,000 to J.P. McManus to install solar panels at Adare Manor and €40,000 to Denis O'Brien to retrofit a castle?

Why should we be paying for this?

Comment on this

A lot has been made of climate targets, and yes, we must meet our climate targets, but one of the things we must do is look at solar. While the grant that was given out in the budget recently was a top-class grant, and everybody has to acknowledge that, there is a problem. People in local authority houses are not allowed to apply, even though they qualify, and it is the same for people in private housing associations. This could be a game-changer for the whole country. Those people have the qualifying payments, but they cannot apply because the local authorities will not allow them to put solar on the roof. We need to change that policy. The extra power that will come from that will be fed back to the grid and go back to the councils, which can then, in turn, stop the 7.5% increase that was put on rates for the people of County Cork yesterday, although it was rejected by the Independent Ireland councillors. The point I am trying to make is that there is an opportunity. The local authorities and people in private housing should be included in this top-class grant.

Comment on this

Every day since Bord na Móna was closed down, the cost of electricity has gone up. It has gone up for old people and the elderly. It has gone up for businesspeople. It has gone up for everyone. Even the people who spent a lot of money buying electric cars are complaining now. If they do not have their own charger, they pay more to replenish their car than they would if they were filling it with petrol to do the same number of miles. At the same time, the electricity companies are making a fortune. I have a question for the Taoiseach. Where is the energy regulator? Does the Taoiseach know him? Did the Taoiseach ever meet him? What is he doing? Is he asleep? Is he in bed? Did he ever get out of it? I am passing doors where people cannot turn on the electricity now at night, and that is a fact. So many people are in arrears, and they are in an awful way. I am asking the Taoiseach to do something about the regulator and ensure that the energy companies are not benefiting continuously on the backs of poor people.

Comment on this

I am asking once again where the 2026 climate action plan is. This week, the Minister, Deputy Darragh O'Brien, is travelling to COP31, where he is due to lead negotiations on behalf of the EU, something he is happy to issue a press release on, but the emperor is travelling without any clothes. Our national climate plans have yet to be updated this year, which puts us at significant risk of falling even further behind our climate targets. Will the Taoiseach confirm on which date the 2026 plan will be published? Will he also confirm if a separate 2027 plan will be published, as per the legislation?

Comment on this

It is November, and right across Carlow and Kilkenny, older people are turning up the heating. In many cases, they are still sitting in the cold because too much of that heat is going straight out through the roof and the walls. I acknowledge that the warmer homes scheme is one of the best things this Government has done, with fully funded upgrades for people on the fuel allowance and with €280 million put into it last year, 11 times what it was in 2020. That needs to be acknowledged on the floor of this House. However, the wait to get work done is brutal. The SEAI says it can take up to two years from the day someone applies to the day the work is finished. That is two winters. A pensioner in Borris or Skeoughvosteen, where I am from, cannot wait two winters. This cannot continue. When the committee next meets, will it set a clear target to get that wait to under a year to begin with, starting with older people, in particular those in rural Ireland in the coldest homes?

Comment on this

I welcome the Government’s commitment to introducing private wires legislation, allowing businesses to connect directly to renewable electricity generators. This presents an enormous economic opportunity for Ireland, particularly for counties like my own constituency of Offaly. Offaly has a proud history of producing energy for the country, and today we are seeing substantial investment in wind and solar generation, but producing electricity is only part of the opportunity. We should be using that energy to attract manufacturing, new industries and major employers to the regions that are producing it. Private wires could help businesses to access renewable electricity directly, opening up opportunities for industrial development and addressing some of the challenges with grid connections. As we progress this legislation, can we ensure that IDA Ireland and Enterprise Ireland are actively involved in identifying these opportunities? We should be turning our energy resources into investment, employment and long-term economic growth.

Comment on this

Homeowners affected by pyrite should not face further obstacles in relation to SEAI grants because of the arbitrary application dates for the pyrite remediation scheme when they originally applied. I acknowledge that the Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment recently intervened in one case that I had in Mayo, but families should not have to fight individual battles to secure what they are entitled to. For the small number of homes that have fallen through the cracks, eligibility should be presumed and not contested. Will the Taoiseach ensure a fair and consistent nationwide approach so that no affected homeowners are left behind? I also want to ask what we are doing to secure redress for pyrite homes in the North that were built using defective concrete blocks sourced in the Twenty-six Counties. They were sourced in the Twenty-six Counties, so that is where the regulation fell down.

Comment on this

I would ask the Taoiseach to read today's article in The Currency by Niall Sargent. It is a really good analysis. It clearly demonstrates where many of the Government’s solar grants are going, and the companies they are going to. Some 15% of solar grants for businesses, worth about €5.5 million, have gone to very wealthy, large corporate entities. The J.P. McManus-owned Adare Manor received €200,000 in grants. The Denis O'Brien-owned Ballynahinch Castle received just over €40,000. Dunnes Stores received more than €530,000. Lidl Ireland received €195,000. The grants for energy efficiency and for solar need to be targeted at people and businesses that need it. I do not think anyone could claim that the likes of J.P. McManus and Denis O'Brien need grants from the Government to facilitate and upgrade their hotels. Will the Taoiseach make sure the money is going to the right people?

Comment on this

I want to raise the matter of the main Midleton flood relief scheme. We know that the planning permission is due to be submitted alongside the senior counsel review that is ongoing by the local authority. I am once again reiterating the need for this to be completed. The people of Midleton and the wider east Cork area were badly affected by Storm Babet’s flooding. They need to see the Government giving its full commitment to providing support and funding to deliver this scheme. It is all about delivery. Being from Cork, the Taoiseach knows well the damage this caused to Midleton and the wider east Cork area. I would very much appreciate it if he could comment on the support, the funding and the planning process to make sure that all is well and on time, following delays that have caused huge frustration for people in the east Cork area.

Comment on this

In response to Deputy O’Hara, and as a general comment overall, this Cabinet committee is on climate action, the environment and energy. It is interesting that, although not all, quite a number of the earlier presentations did not really focus on climate or renewables, if I am honest, but rather the opposite. I would generally say that we have a huge challenge in this country. If we think we are going to solve the energy problem by saying we cannot have this, that or the other, real problems are coming down the tracks. The reason we are in a crisis of fuel cost is because of an over-reliance on fossil fuels. This has happened twice in six years, with the outbreak of war, Russia invading Ukraine, Europe ending its dependency on Russian oil, the attack on Iran, the closure of the Strait of Hormuz and the Houthis impacting on the Red Sea routes. When are we going to collectively, as a Parliament, accept the reality that we have to move to renewables and alternative forms of energy generation? Far too often now, I think, because it is challenging electorally and politically, it is far too easy to avoid trying to communicate with people and explain to people why we need this particular plant or facility, as opposed to going along and not really pursuing renewables at the end of the day. I think that is a challenge for the country, and I would make that general point overall.

In terms of the biogas facility, I do not know the specific location or the issues there. Deputy O'Hara is saying it is the wrong development in the wrong place, but there was a planning process there, and it has to go through the planning process. The Government cannot get involved in every single planning application in respect of a biogas facility, a wind farm or solar panels. The country cannot be run that way. We have local authorities. We have a planning system. There have to be proper guidelines and planning statements governing all of this.

At the end of the day, it is something that has to be dealt with through the planning process. There should be public consultation. The earlier and better the consultation on these matters, the more effective it will be at getting issues properly resolved.

I did not quite understand Deputy Ó Murchú's question. I think he was suggesting that we would have grants for oil and gas burners.

Comment on this

The grants existed before the council-----

Comment on this

I know, but-----

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Remarks should be addressed through the Chair.

Comment on this

-----the aim of the European directive is to end dependency on fossil fuels.

Comment on this

I know that, but we are dealing with people who do not have time to wait-----

Comment on this

I take the Deputy's point, but hydrotreated vegetable oil, HVO, is an option and we have to pursue that. Again, the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI, grants are for sustainable generation. It would be perverse in some respects if we were to use sustainability grants for fossil fuels.

Comment on this

I am only saying there is no grant open to those affected. That is all I am saying.

Comment on this

I know. I am simply saying that we need to be honest about it too.

Comment on this

I have no problem with that.

Comment on this

The issue involves an EU directive, so it is not easy to turn it all around, but we are looking at HVO as a potential alternative and the Minister has a boiler scrappage scheme. However, I do take the point that there are-----

Comment on this

It is for those people.

Comment on this

-----certain people in rural areas, elderly people and so on who will not be going down that road. We understand that.

Deputy Quaide raised the commuter rail network and Youghal. The challenge we have is having sufficient capital over the next decade to match the ambition that is already in the all-island rail review, including being able to complete the projects that have already been prioritised. The Cork commuter rail project is one. We do not have any issue with including Youghal in a future review, but some people think that if we include it in a review, it means it is going to get built sometime soon. We need a reality check in terms of what is possible financially from a capital point of view, because the capital outlays are going to be huge, particularly given construction inflation. We will see how MetroLink goes, and we will see how the Cork commuter rail project, which we have prioritised, goes. If we can get those projects completed efficiently, effectively and in a timely manner, it will open up other possibilities.

I am conscious that we have had the all-island strategic rail review, which the then Minister, Eamon Ryan, concluded. That review contains a whole lot of projects and a hierarchy, and it states some of the projects will not even be looked at until 2050. We have to be realistic.

Comment on this

That is a Government decision, though.

Comment on this

No, it is not a Government decision. This was a review by experts who said what we should prioritise and so on. I am simply saying that the enormousness of what is in the document has huge implications for capital allocation. There are many projects, like Youghal, that are not even in the hierarchy set out in the all-island rail review, which was undertaken North and South. There are other projects concerning rail in the west. People think we can do it all at once. We cannot. If something is not going to happen soon, we have to be realistic about it. We have to try to do what we can. However, I do get the point.

I am probably old enough to say I was on the Cork–Youghal rail line. People from our suburb and parish would go every summer to Youghal on day trips and have egg-and-tomato sandwiches and a pot of tea. It was a very lovely trip. That is where the working class of Cork went on their holidays. They used the train way back, and it is a tragedy that it got upended. I would have an interest in the project but I just want to introduce a degree of realism about how fast we can get things done. We need to be honest with people when we talk to them in that regard.

On Deputy Murphy's point, I have not read The Currency today and I do not know whether he is twisting it a bit.

Comment on this

This is an issue relating to climate. As far as I am concerned, we want as many people in as many walks of life as possible to make the transition to being energy efficient. I have not read the article and I do not know the context of what the Deputy is referring to. We have never said, and I have never heard anyone in the House say, that we should provide solar grants only below certain thresholds and means-test accordingly. Is our priority energy transformation or is it all just about income and means testing?

Comment on this

If you are a multibillionaire, you can afford your own solar-----

Comment on this

No, I am not talking about-----

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Remarks should be addressed through the Chair.

Comment on this

That is the cheap shot.

Comment on this

That is what the reform is about.

Comment on this

No. That is great for slogans and soundbites, but it does not butter any parsnips. It does not really, and that is the cop-out. It is a cheap old shot. I have not read the article but I will. However, we need to be careful. It is the same with electric vehicles, EVs. Should we not provide grants for EVs either because it is probably middle- and upper-middle-class people who buy them?

Comment on this

For God's sake, J.P. McManus is not middle class.

Comment on this

I am not talking about him; I am talking about EVs. Does the Deputy want an honest debate? I said a similar situation arose with EVs, the argument being that if we targeted only those on low incomes, would we have had the same take-up of EVs? What is the priority? I would have thought the priority of a climate agenda was to take fossil fuels out of the equation and enable as many people as possible to do that. The more people who go solar, including big farmers who put panels on their rooftops or whatever, the better it is for the overall air quality. It is very good. It is better for emissions reduction. The Deputies need to make up their minds on whether they are about emissions reduction. Are they getting mixed up between their economic and sociological ideology and their climate ideologies?

Comment on this

No grants for billionaires.

Comment on this

Just transition is a policy of this Government.

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should address her remarks through the Chair.

Comment on this

Just transition relates to areas that had fossil fuel power stations that we got rid of.

Comment on this

Just transition is about enabling others-----

Comment on this

We had to bring alternative economic-----

Comment on this

-----who cannot afford to transition. That is what it is.

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are almost ten minutes over time. If Deputies encourage this kind of debate, we are not going to get to the end of it.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach missed out on his supporter here.

Comment on this

I apologise-----

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Taoiseach would not mind concluding-----

Comment on this

-----but I believe a good constructive debate and challenging people-----

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not for today.

Comment on this

I get tired of the soundbites.

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach should talk to the Chief Whip about the debate.

Comment on this

I will.

Comment on this

I get tired of soundbites.

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Can we just move on because the Taoiseach is out of time?

Comment on this

Where am I? On Deputy Collins's point, I believe local authorities can apply for solar panels on their houses.

Comment on this

The grant rolled out recently is not-----

Comment on this

Yes, but if there are tenants, the local authority should be applying. The local authority should run the scheme for solar.

Did I pass over Deputy Naoise Ó Cearúil?

Comment on this

Also Deputy Barry Heneghan and me.

Comment on this

Deputy Danny Healy-Rae's statement that prices have gone up since Bord na Móna closed was amazing.

Comment on this

The energy regulator is a woman. The Deputy said "he" the whole way through. That is just for the record. I did meet the regulators. The Commission for Regulation of Utilities, CRU, is the regulator. We have established an energy task force to examine the setting of prices for energy. Connection to gas is a key issue and problem.

On Deputy O'Gorman's points, the climate action plan was approved by the Cabinet today, but it has to go through an environmental assessment now. That will dictate the timeline, according to the Minister. The more important point is that the Minister is changing the way we are doing it. It was ridiculous that we had civil servants doing nothing else but writing action plans with huge detail in them. When they finished one, they started the next one. It was ridiculous. We had to change that. The Minister is changing it, stating the principles, getting the fundamentals right, being more pragmatic and getting things done. That is what he is doing.

Comment on this

But the Government is not getting things done.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Cleere refer to turning up the heating? No, that is my own note. It is very hot in here and I think the heating is too high.

Comment on this

We should cut it down to save energy and cool us all down a bit.

Comment on this

Reference was made to time being brutal. The Minister is suggesting, and I think he has already started, that the grants be paid directly to the contractors to bypass the administrative process. He is going to initiate that, if it has not been initiated already, to try to speed up grant applications and get people out to have the work done.

Deputy McCormack referred to private wires.

Deputy Heneghan was there at the beginning. How did I miss him?

Comment on this

And Deputy Tóibín.

Comment on this

Put me ar dtús.

Comment on this

I started off on the wrong page. I am sorry.

On private wires, the Deputy's Bill is in. The Minister is very shortly coming to the Cabinet with legislation on private wires as well. Presumably, it is a matter of dovetailing. We will get it done. The Deputy has been pushing this for a long time, to be fair, and we do see it as part of the solution.

On Deputy Peadar Tóibín's point, it is a matter for Cork County Council. It has to sort out its estimates. I must say I was struck by the Deputy's statement that his councillor colleague was successful in tabling a motion. There was a day when we could all table motions, but a motion is not going to solve this. The council will have to solve it.

Comment on this

But the Government has cut back on central government funding for councils.

Comment on this

On Deputy Naoise Ó Cearúil's points, there are schemes such as those mentioned that are happening already. I believe that if housing estates come together and make an approach, the SEAI will do a deal. That has happened in Cork, including in Douglas and other places. It is a very good initiative and one that should occur.

On Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh's point about pyrite, she wants a consistent approach across local authorities.

The Northern Ireland Executive will have to look after the situation in the North. We have made an unprecedented intervention both in pyrite and in defective houses and apartments in the Republic. It will cost billions by the time we are finished it and we do not have endless funding.

In response to Deputy Whitmore, I will have to read that article, but again is it climate or the redistribution of wealth we are on about? With regard to taxation-----

Comment on this

It is about solar panels and allowing people to-----

Comment on this

-----we should go after people generally. We have the most progressive taxation system in Europe-----

Comment on this

J.P. McManus knows about that because he does not pay tax here.

Comment on this

-----in terms of the highest earners paying taxes. Is it climate? Climate has to be priority. We have to get rid of fossil fuels, reduce them significantly and get solar in. I take issue with what Deputies Murphy and Whitmore said because right from the Ukraine war onwards, we have spent huge money on households through energy grants, the universal payments we made through the early part of the 2020s, fuel allowance increases and the whole range of payments we made. This idea that we have not looked after vulnerable households is a falsehood and should not be asserted. We have through substantial tax revenues and-----

Comment on this

People in energy poverty probably-----

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connor raised the issue of the Midleton flood relief scheme. I understand that it is a very complex one and we have to get it right. There has been a fair degree of public consultation. There is a lot of anxiety in Midleton and its hinterland, in particular, in the context of any upcoming storm. We saw that in the last couple of weeks. Interim measures are being taken, and the Minister of State, Deputy Boxer Moran, has been down on a number of occasions. The sooner we can get that developed the better, and we will be supporting that financially. It simply has to happen. I have rearranged things within the Cabinet subcommittees as well in terms of emergencies and adaptation. I have asked every Department to work more proactively in terms of adaptation and that our Department would lead the co-ordination of that into the future, because as a country, we can do far better on adaptation. It does not have the same urgency across the system as it should have, and that is why, in answer to the previous questions, we outlined a number of initiatives we have taken in terms of greater generator capacity. We have also taken grip of coastal erosion, which is another big issue facing the country, and we need to do that properly and effectively.

Comment on this