We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Social Welfare Bill 2026: Second Stage

Summary

The Bill gives effect to Budget 2027 social welfare measures, including €10 weekly increases to core payments and family benefits, higher supports for people living alone, and changes to employer PRSI thresholds and means tests. The Minister also announced plans to add statutory provision for fish assist and extend posthumous State pension payments, while outlining a new permanent cost-of-disability payment and expanded employment supports. Opposition speakers welcomed some measures but argued they fall short on child poverty, disability costs, carers’ means testing and the cost of living, and highlighted harsh eligibility cliffs and delays in support. Government speakers backed the increases and emphasised employment activation, with some supporting penalties for jobseekers who refuse to engage.

Bill Social Welfare Bill 2026
Current

No. 105 of 2026 ›

Dara Calleary Minister for Social Protection Fianna Fáil

Tairgim: “Go léifear an Bille an Dara hUair anois."

I move: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

The total Department of Social Protection budget for 2027 is €30.9 billion, which is an increase of 7% on budget 2026, including over €1.15 billion in new and updated measures. Its level of funding will support approximately 1.6 million recipients of weekly social protection payments as well as recipients of other schemes, such as school meals and child benefit.

The budget measures will enhance the adequacy of the overall social protection system, while also providing targeted support for pensioners, people with disabilities, carers, families at risk of child poverty and households at risk of energy poverty. Overall, the additional investment will continue to reinforce the strong social safety net that is provided by our welfare system.

Budget 2027 will provide for a weekly €10 increase in the core weekly rates of payment, in line with inflation and with proportionate increases for those on a reduced payment rate and qualified adults. The State contributory pension will exceed €300 per week for the first time, increasing to €309.30 per week. In addition, the living alone allowance has been increased for the first time in five years and will now be paid at €25 per week. This will benefit almost 260,000 pensioners and disabled people living alone, bringing the total value of their payment to €1,300 per person per year.

The package includes further increases to the child support payment, benefiting some 330,000 children, with a weekly increase of €6 for children of all ages. The payment is now €64 for children under the age of 12 and €84 for children aged 12 and over. Since 2020, the child support payment has increased by over 77% for children under 12 and by 110% for children over 12, making a real difference to the lives of 330,000 children.

Further measures to tackle child poverty include a €30 increase in weekly income thresholds for the working family payment for all family sizes, worth up to €18 per week, which will assist low-income families, many of whom are lone-parent households. In addition, working lone parents will be assisted by an increase in the earnings disregard for those on receipt of the one-parent family payment or jobseeker's transitional payment. This will increase by €10 from €165 to €175 per week.

For employers, the Bill provides for an increase in the threshold at which the lower 9.15% rate of employer PRSI applies, from €552 to €600 per week. This will ensure that employers with employees working full-time on the national minimum wage will continue to pay the lower rate when the minimum wage increases to €14.94 per hour on 1 January 2027.

For employees with children, the Bill contains provisions to increase the rate of payment for maternity, paternity, adoptive and parents benefit by €10 per week to €309 per week. These payments are an important part of a broader suite of policies that seek to support the welfare of families and children.

The Social Welfare Bill also includes a range of amendments designed to support rural communities, including an increase in the income disregard for agri-environmental schemes in respect of farm assist and the State non-contributory pension from €5,000 to €7,500 per year. These schemes have an environmental focus and support the Government's climate change agenda. Increasing the disregard that applies to income from these schemes will assist farmers who participate in them while also providing an incentive for participation.

An increase in the disregard for income from seaweed harvesting, from €1,270 per year to €2,500 per year, is the first increase in the value of disregard since it was first introduced in 1994. The weekly payment to people living on a specified island will increase by €5. From January, the weekly rate payable will be €25. This payment is made to people living on certain offshore islands to help offset the additional costs associated with island residence, including transport, access to services and the higher cost of goods and essential services.

While Dáil Standing Orders provide that pre-legislative scrutiny is not required for a social welfare Bill that gives effect to budget measures, my officials have hosted a briefing for Opposition spokespersons to assist with any questions on the provisions in the Bill. I hope that was of assistance, and my office remains open for any further questions between now and the initiation of the Bill.

I bring to the attention of Deputies that I intend to introduce an amendment to the Bill on Committee Stage to establish the fish assist scheme on a statutory footing on the same basis as farm assist. I announced this measure on budget day. It has not been included in the published Bill because of technical considerations that arose during the drafting process. Drafting on this measure is continuing through the engagement of my officials with the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel.

In tandem with this work, my officials are also working with the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel to draft the budget 2027 provision to extend the payment period of a deceased person's State pension. The payment will be extended from six weeks to ten weeks, with an additional four weeks paid at 50% of the rate previously payable. I intend to introduce an amendment to the Bill on Committee Stage to provide for this measure too.

There are a range of measures announced by the Government on budget day which do not require primary legislation in this social welfare Bill. These will be provided through regulations, and I wish to touch on some of those measures now.

Budget 2027 delivers on a programme for Government commitment to introduce an annual cost-of-disability payment. The package includes the first ever permanent cost-of-disability payment. It will start with a lump sum payment of €500 in 2027 for people receiving a long-term disability payment. Respecting the feedback from a very detailed consultative process, we are also commencing a co-design process with disabled people and their representatives on how the payment should be structured and delivered in subsequent years. This work has commenced and will intensify in the new year.

The budget provides further improvements in measures designed to support disabled people to access employment. Building on last year’s improvements to the wage subsidy scheme, this year’s budget includes a reduction in the hours worked threshold required to access the wage subsidy scheme, from 15 hours per week to eight hours per week. There will be an increase of €15,000 in the grant paid to fund employment by employers of an employment assistance officer. Eligibility for the scheme is also being extended to those moving to partial capacity benefit from illness benefit.

Further measures aimed at encouraging disabled people to take up employment include improvements to the work and access scheme, with an increase to the allocation of hours under ongoing communication support or lrish Sign Language support from 24 to 48 hours per year, and an increase in the number of induction support hours from 12 to 18 hours. These build on a €10 increase in the earnings disregard for disability allowance and blind pension recipients from €165 to €175 per week.

This year’s budget continues to progress the ambitious goal set out in the programme for Government to abolish the means test for carers over the life of this Government. To this end, further increases in the carer’s allowance weekly income disregard have been secured, with an increase of €150 to €1,150 for a single person and an increase of €300 to €2,300 for a couple. Additionally, budget 2027 provides for increases in the earnings limit for the corresponding social insurance-based carer's benefit payment from €1,000 to €1,150 to maintain the current alignment between the schemes. This means that within the Government's first two budgets, we have already increased the carer’s allowance disregard for singles and couples by 84%. As a result, a couple on over €126,000 will now be able to get a full payment without being in any way affected by the means test. In fact, they will be able to earn over €155,000 and still receive a partial payment.

The budget also provides supports to help households with the cost of energy bills. The fuel allowance will increase by €5 to €43 per week from January 2027 for some 460,000 fuel allowance recipients. In addition, there will be an improvement in the fuel allowance means test for single pensioners. From January 2027, the income limit for a single person aged 66 or over was half that of a couple; this will increase to 60%. As a consequence of this measure, the allowable means of a single person aged 66 or over will increase from €534 to €640.80, thereby allowing more older people to qualify for the fuel allowance.

Programmes such as the community employment scheme, Tús and the rural social scheme are hugely important to individuals and communities. Not only do these schemes give people a direction forward and a sense of purpose, they assist and sustain communities. Without these schemes, vital supports such as meals on wheels, Tidy Towns, enhancement schemes and many others would not exist. In budget 2027, I have been able to secure an increase to the additional payment or top-up offered to people on welfare who participate in a rural social scheme, community employment or Tús scheme to €35 for 19.5 hours per week. This measure will provide a greater incentive to participate in employment schemes and will benefit some 27,500 participants. In addition, we have secured a reduction of the requalification period on Tús from three years to two years. This will enable those who have been unsuccessful in gaining employment to re-engage with Tús after two years. In turn, this will support a participant's pathway back to employment while also helping to sustain the delivery of essential services.

The Department provides a range of income supports to jobseekers. These payments are conditional on the recipient being available for, capable of and genuinely seeking work. This reflects the concept of rights and responsibilities, whereby those who are unemployed have the right to an income support from the State and a right to be supported in their efforts to secure employment, while also having a responsibility to seek employment and to engage with the employment services offered by the State. The Bill provides for a €10 increase in the reduction in payment rates for jobseekers not engaging with the mandatory activation process from €90 per week to €100 per week in the personal rate of payment.

I highlight the Department is currently finalising the successor pathways to work strategy, which is due for publication in the coming weeks. Pathways to Work 2026-2030 will strengthen efforts to support those who are long-term unemployed and face barriers to enter the labour market. Ongoing engagement across Government has informed the commitments set out in the strategy and will help ensure a co-ordinated response to the diverse challenges faced by jobseekers. This joined-up approach is central to supporting labour market participation and enabling more people to secure and sustain employment.

Between July and October last year, an extensive public consultation process was undertaken. Approximately 430 submissions were received, with an almost 50:50 ratio on submissions from individuals and organisations. The time taken to provide for a comprehensive consultation and engagement process will ensure that the successor pathways to work strategy is evidence-based and responsive to the needs of jobseekers, employers and the wider economy. A reduced rate is the final step in the process to encourage a jobseeker to avail of the employment supports on offer. Once a jobseeker resumes engagement, the reduced rate is lifted immediately. Whether a reduced rate applies and the duration of its application is within the control of the claimant and based on their engagement with activation services.

This week, the number of people who have been on the live register for a year or more is at its lowest level in two years at approximately 52,300, of which approximately 46,400 will receive a payment. It is important to note the live register is not a stock; it is a flow. People are moving in and out of employment every week or progressing to training, education and employment placements. Some 58,800 people either entered or exited the long-term live register over the past 12 months. I do not believe that being on the dole is a way of life and I do not believe that it is one of the biggest issues facing us. It is my Department’s role to support people to break out of unemployment and to provide the supports needed for each individual person in their journey because each individual has a different journey which will require different supports.

Before I provide an outline of the Bill, I would also like to confirm that the Christmas bonus will be paid in the week commencing 1 December, on the same basis as last year, to some 1.4 million recipients of long-term social welfare payments.

I will now give an overview of the Social Welfare Bill section by section. Section 1 is the Short Title and construction, section 2 provides for definitions of the relevant Acts and section 3 provides for the increase in the threshold at which the rate of the employer social insurance contribution of 9.15% applies in respect of employee gross wages from €552 per week to €600 per week. This measure will cost approximately €67.1 million in a full year and impact some 127,000 employments. This will save employers some €682 annually on employer PRSI for each of their employees working full time on the minimum wage.

Sections 4, 5, 6 and 7 provide for a €10 weekly increase in the rates of maternity benefit, adoptive benefit, paternity benefit and parent's benefit respectively, from €299 to €309, in January 2027.

Section 8 gives effect to the increases in the graduated rates of jobseeker's benefit and jobseeker’s benefit for the self-employed. Where average weekly earnings in the governing contribution year are €300 per week or more, the full personal rate is payable.

Where average weekly earnings are less than €300, the rate payable is determined by reference to a graduated earnings band. This section provides for pro rata increases in the graduated rates.

Section 9 provides for a €10 increase, from €90 per week to €100 per week, in the reduction in the personal rate of payment for jobseekers who do not engage with the mandatory activation process.

Section 10 provides for a €30 increase in the weekly income thresholds of the working family payment for all family sizes.

Section 11 and Schedule 1 provide for the increase of €10 in the rates of social insurance benefits for the primary recipient. Also included are the proportionate increases for qualified adults and qualified children, and improvements in the living alone increase and the increase for living on a specified island.

Section 12 provides for improvements to the means test for certain schemes. They include an increase in the amount of income from agri-environmental schemes that is disregarded in the means assessments for both farm assist and the non-contributory State pension. Section 12 also includes an increase in the amount of income from seaweed harvesting that is disregarded in the means assessment for jobseeker's allowance and farm assist. It also includes a €10 increase, from €165 to €175 per week, in the employment earnings disregard for the one-parent family payment. This comes into effect from July 2027.

Section 13 and Schedule 2 provide for the rate increases in means-tested social assistance payments.

I have the honour of being a Minister in the Department of Social Protection, with more than 7,000 colleagues across the country who every day assist people facing challenges and assist people in their daily and weekly living. I thank each and every one of them for their commitment to the people they serve and to the country. It is an honour to serve as a Minister in a Department that is responsive and available to people in times of challenge, and that also provides pathways of opportunity to those seeking them. Molaim an Bille don Teach.

Comment on this

I join the Minister in commending the people who work in his Department and the work they do. We all deal with people in our constituency offices who have to engage with the Department of Social Protection and it is good that there are people there working hard. However, their job is to implement Government policy and that is where my kind words will end.

We have all seen the budget and had a good look at it, and commentators and experts with far more to say on this issue than I have given their verdict. The Parliamentary Budget Office, PBO, has said that virtually everyone, particularly workers, will be worse off under the Minister's budget. Months ago, the ESRI warned that the Minister is very far from reaching his 3% child poverty target. There are other experts in this field. They have also advised the Minister on ways he might meet the target. They have suggested a second tier of child benefit, for example, and a host of other ways to structure cash transfers to reduce child poverty in a real and meaningful way for good. They also advised him on the long-term costs of allowing so many hundreds of thousands of children to continue to grow up in poverty, including the psychological damage, the public health impact and the financial costs this will incur in the long term. There is a wealth of evidence. The Minister knows what needs to be done. He knows the impact of not doing it, yet we see children forgotten by this budget and this Bill.

It is clear that the budget went against the advice given to the Government. The ESRI has said that budget 2027, and these are not my words, will not reduce the number of children in poverty. If we can stand in this House and all agree, as we do, that one child living in poverty is too many, and certainly that the number of children growing up in poverty in this State is too many, surely the Minister would heed the ESRI when it tells him that his budget and this Bill will not reduce the number of children in poverty. If that is his ambition, he should change tack. If what he is doing is not working, I encourage him to try something else.

We know this is not a mistake. This is not something that is broken. It is designed. This is how the budget and the Bill are designed. At the Cabinet table, the Minister would have negotiated what is in this Bill. He is the one who accepted from the Minister for Finance and the Minister for public expenditure increases in the core rates of welfare payments that will not keep pace with inflation. He is the one Minister who put his hand up to an effective cut in the fuel allowance, because there will be €12 less for people on the fuel allowance in 2027 than there was in 2026. I understand the Government has tried to do the same with university fees but the Minister will not convince me that getting €12 less in 2027 somehow means the fuel allowance has been increased because it has not. For people who depend on this money, writing in the Minister's speech that they will be getting more when they do not physically have more money will not help them to pay their bills or heat their homes. The choices that were made were not made because of a lack of money, manpower or advice. They were made simply to allow the Government to line the pockets of vulture funds, large landlords and data centre owners. Minister after Minister appears not to want to own this choice, but you can see it.

I ask myself what the point was of setting up the child poverty unit, holding the consultation on expanding child benefit and hosting the child poverty summit. It seems pointless going through all these gestures if none of it is reflected in the pounds, shillings and pence that will be transferred to children in poverty. They are not in this legislation. Sinn Féin had proposed real measures to tackle child poverty, including a targeted second tier of child benefit, which would make a real and meaningful difference in the lives of children who need it. Some 17.4% of children are living below the poverty line. When housing is added in, a debate which we have had many times since housing cannot but be added in, that figure goes up to 22.7%, which tells me that we are going in the wrong direction and that the Government is bringing us in the wrong direction. We know what the ESRI has said but the Minister chose to ignore it. I cannot imagine that there is a person sitting at the Cabinet table who is happy and content with any level of child poverty yet we see writ large in the Minister's budget very little to help children in poverty and very little that will make a real, meaningful and lasting difference.

I try to imagine who the Minister is thinking about when he is framing the budget. On the budget as a whole, we know who the big winners were. They were vulture funds. Those lads win every time. The joke people have is, "Perhaps I will change my name to Mrs. Data Centre and then I might get some attention from the Government." Those are very real. People who are in crisis and in poverty are the ones who depend on social welfare. They are the ones who need somebody in their corner because they live on a fixed income. Often that is because they are caring for a loved one or cannot access full employment. There are many reasons.

I was surprised and happy to hear the Minister's words distancing himself from the remarks made by the Tánaiste about social welfare being a lifestyle choice. It is not unusual to hear the leader of the Fine Gael party or indeed members of the Government punch down. I thought it was particularly pathetic at the weekend to hear the Tánaiste target a group. There are many reasons for long-term unemployment and the Minister knows them too. They are complicated. They should not be reduced to a single pathetic soundbite just to get a cheer, a guffaw and a bit of whooping and hollering from the base. What do they call it? Is it red meat for the base? It is a vile phrase and it was a vile sentiment that was expressed at the Fine Gael conference. It had the effect of distracting from the other 26 minutes and 20 seconds, or whatever it was, of the address the leader of Fine Gael gave to his party. Punching down is disgusting. Working with people who are long-term unemployed is important but it is not lost on me and others that the job clubs are gone. Nobody funded them and they closed. They were a vital service that ensured that people who were long-term unemployed could find a way back to employment, but they are gone.

There is profound disappointment with disability because the Minister promised much in the run-in to this budget on a cost-of-disability payment. It might interest him to know that persons who are disabled do not stop being disabled when they start working yet they are not eligible for any of these payments.

It could be argued that those who are working face a new set of unavoidable costs, yet we do not see those people accounted for in this Bill.

Equally, the Government heard from disability advocates at the summit it held that they want co-design. This was not co-designed. It amounts to €10 per week, but it was not co-designed. They want a co-designed payment that takes care of them. They need that payment now, rather than this idea of live horse and you will get grass and that if they hang on and wait, they will get it. I am sure the Government is not so cynical as to wait until just before an election to do this, although we have seen that before. I sincerely hope we do not see it again. People with disabilities deserve more respect from the Government. Disability organisations and individual people who are experienced in this have made themselves available to work with the Government on co-design. They have offered their services and insight. They are living every day with the reality of the spiralling cost of disability. The Government took the energy supports from them, and now we see that many of them are going to be excluded from the once-off payment.

Of course, all of this money will be gratefully received. I am not suggesting otherwise. However, they were clear about the need for a payment that recognises the ongoing daily and weekly cost associated with disability. A once-off payment is not going to cut it. In our alternative budget, we in Sinn Féin proposed a proper, tiered payment. We carried out extensive consultation with persons with disabilities and their organisations. A lot could have been done in this regard. If only people with disabilities were vulture funds or data centres, perhaps they might have featured a little more predominantly in the budget. They deserve better. They deserve more than platitudes and vague promises. They deserve to be listened to and supported because, ultimately, that is the job of social welfare and social protection. It is a threshold of decency, and that threshold must be upheld. I am afraid, with the budget and with this legislation, the Government has fallen far short of doing that.

I look forward to engaging with the Minister and his officials on the Bill. We will be tabling amendments. I look forward to that debate.

Comment on this

First, I echo the comments of both the Minister and my colleague Deputy O’Reilly with regard to the staff in the Department of Social Protection. They offer a lot of support to our offices and to every other office up and down the country. To be honest, my experience of them is that they are always looking to help. They are looking to try to see how they can make the system work for people. Ultimately, however, as my colleague said, the design of the system is up to the Minister.

I will raise an issue about which I have been talking for a number of years. In the first instance, however, I wish to draw back a second and refer to the Tánaiste’s comments at the weekend. I welcome the Minister’s qualified clarification or whatever in this regard. It is not controversial to say that if someone is capable and in a position to work, he or she should go and work. However, we all know the number of people who are long-term unemployed in this State is vanishingly small. Even within that cohort, the vast majority of those people want to work. It was the actions of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Governments that led to the closure of job clubs and other similar supports.

I want to talk to about a category of people who are working and often forgotten about. In the Minister’s speech, he mentioned the threshold for the earnings disregard for the one-parent family payment or the jobseeker’s transitional payment. One of the cruellest and, as far as I am aware, sharpest cliff edges in our system is for working, single-parent households. This is often forgotten. To be honest, one of the most appalling and cynical acts of the recession was former Tánaiste Joan Burton’s attack on one-parent families. That was absolutely appalling. This issue has still not been resolved. The threshold for one-parent families has increased, and that is, of course, welcome. However, if a mother of one who is a single parent works in a shop, she will be removed from the one-parent family payment and moved to the jobseeker’s transitional payment when the child turns eight. She will lose the working family payment. I will repeat that. If she is working some 22 or 23 hours on minimum wage, she could be down as much €140 or €150 per week. That is per week, not per month. This is one of the most dramatic cliff edges in our social welfare system and it affects a category of people who are working, precisely what the Minister and the Tánaiste say they want. It is appalling and needs to be addressed. I welcome increases in the child support payments and so on but, ultimately, we still have not rectified the profound wrong that was done to one-parent families during the course of the recession.

During the most recent general election campaign, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael jumped on the need to abolish the carer’s means test almost at the last minute. I do not know whether the Government is going to achieve that at the current rate. It is in everyone’s interest to do so. It is only right. First and foremost, those people who are caring are not doing it for money; they are doing it out of love and a sense of responsibility and to care for their loved ones. If we want to sustain and support those people and ensure that family support for people at home is an integral part of the system we have, then we need to reward, incentivise and support them. The carer’s means test has to be abolished. We need to get there. At the current rate, the Government is not going to achieve that.

On the issue of disabilities, it seems that successive Governments, particularly since former Minister Heather Humphreys’ ill-fated White Paper or Green Paper, whichever colour it was, have walked away from this issue. I appreciate it is complicated, but we have to get it right. The cost of disability varies for an awful lot of people.

I will make a final point about social welfare generally. I echo what Deputy O’Reilly said regarding the need to invest in child benefit. Sometimes, the parties on the opposite side of the House are constantly trying to look at qualified and means-tested payments and so on and claiming a certain cohort of people do not need assistance. If they believe people on higher incomes do not need that assistance, then ensure that they pay their fair taxes. If we do not have a social welfare system that assists everyone but, rather, is only for the poor, then we will have a poorer social welfare system. Everyone should be able to pay in and everyone should be able to draw out at their time of need. That is a principle that is too often forgotten about.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on social welfare and the current realities facing so many people across the State. The Minister’s track record of achievement since the formation of the Government is appalling. There has been a 15% rise in the number of older people living in poverty. That amounts to more than 120,000 people. This is not just a number; it is 120,000 people who contributed to Irish society and put their trust in the State to be there for them when they got to their older age. Is this the legacy the Minister wants as the Minister for Social Protection? It is often noted that the success of a nation is measured by how we treat older people, the vulnerable and the sick. On all three fronts, the Government is failing.

The €10 increase to the old age pension has simply been wiped out by rising household bills, especially for home heating oil, which many of our pensioners are heavily reliant on. Living alone as a pensioner is not a choice; it is the reality of having lost a partner. Household bills do not simply half when a person loses a husband or wife; they remain the same. The increase of €3 to the living allowance is an insult. It ensures widowed and bereaved pensioners are most at risk of poverty.

For nearly 20 years before I was elected, I worked with Corlann, formerly the Brothers of Charity Services Ireland, in Ferrybank, providing care for adults living with disabilities. These are amazing people who live their lives at risk and are heavily reliant on having family in a position to support them throughout their lives. The CSO data for people with disabilities living in poverty is shocking. It is even bleaker than the figures for pensioners. Nearly 40% are living in poverty, and even with so many in poverty the Government still decided in budget 2026 to take €1,400 away from them. These are some of Ireland’s most vulnerable, at-risk people and they are the ones the Government picked on, while giving tax breaks and sweetheart deals to the big multinationals.

The measures announced in the budget are simply not sufficient. There are so many challenges and struggles facing Ireland.

The Minister’s colleague in government, Simon Harris, in his keynote address at the weekend, took aim at long-term unemployment, a group of approximately 11,000 people nationally. There are more people homeless in Ireland than in long-term unemployment, as well as more people classed as working poor. Under this Fianna Fáil-Fine Gael Government, these numbers have increased on all fronts. While the Government claims success in many areas, it leaves scores of groups behind. As the saying goes, a rising tide lifts all boats. However, that is no good if one is not in the boat and is struggling away while barely having a life jacket on. The reality is that people want to work and contribute. They do not want to live with that level of alienation. The State should work with people to create the material conditions required to prevent this alienation and ensure that every person has the opportunity to contribute positively in a manner big or small to Irish society. While the Government might like the look and talk of the stick over the carrot approach, it is wrong and reactionary.

The Minister is looking to put in place harsher penalties for the long-term unemployed but what is he doing to tackle those engaged in antisocial behaviour and intimidation who are terrorising communities the Government has clearly forgotten about? This is not a Dublin issue; it is across the State. At the weekend, there were shots fired in a housing estate in County Kilkenny, all connected to a feud in the estate. These people are engaging in criminal activity. Some have been convicted of intimidation but continue to live in social housing. Where is the accountability there? Why is the Department not ensuring that those who breach their social housing contracts are not held to account before communities are left in ruins?

Comment on this

There is a lot of attention on what happens in this Chamber on budget day. It has been a little over a month since the Minister for Finance and the Minister for public expenditure stood here and delivered their speeches, telling Members of this House and the country what they would do with the public finances - how they would sustain the economy, fund vital public services, and support workers and vulnerable groups like carers, disabled people, pensioners, and children living in poverty. There may not be as much attention in the Chamber this afternoon but it is no less important. Indeed, what the Minister is asking us to do with this Bill is to give effect to the announcements made on that day, and to the implications of those announcements, which have become apparent in the interim.

As I said in my response the day the budget was announced, while there are many things to be welcomed in this Bill, what the measures in it represent is a further degradation of the social contract in this country and a failure to envision a more just and equitable future for its citizens. While the measures in this Bill ostensibly contain increases to various schemes in the social protection system, few of them recover the support people received prior to recent cuts. Many of them fail to match inflation, and all represent a slippage in the floor through which we will not allow people to fall. For some, the economy is doing very well. However, for too many, austerity still persists. The Minister will say that individual payments have increased year on year but they do not keep up with inflation.

When we analyse the social protection system as a whole, and what it is doing to support people, how it interacts with our economy is too often exclusionary, particularly for women and disabled people. Too often, it is becoming less effective, not more. When we look at the child poverty figures, there are 260,000 children living below the poverty line when we take housing into account, according to the ESRI. Let us look at the disability employment gap. With only 32.6% of disabled people in employment, we are one of the worst performers against the European average of 51.3%. When we look at the lived experience of carers across the country, so many are struggling to keep their homes warm as they save the State billions of euro.

This country is a wealthy one but the great failure of this Government and previous Governments is not to leverage that wealth into a more robust system of social protection and redistribution to lift people out of poverty. Increasingly, this State is failing to support those most in need.

Beyond the most wealthy households in this country, it is true to say that everyone is struggling in some way with the cost-of-living crisis. It is consistently the most vulnerable groups who face the steepest costs, and who bear the punishment of a social protection system that is failing to keep up with inflation. Inequality is becoming increasingly entrenched in this country, and a social protection system without adequate supports is a key point of failure in the fight to tackle it.

Let me now look at some of the specific measures in this Bill. There is a provision to increase the disability allowance by €10 per week. For starters, that will not keep up with the cost of inflation, particularly with the cost of disability. While I welcome that disabled people, after decades of campaigning, will finally have access to a cost-of-disability payment, it is essential that we remember this comes after disabled people had their incomes cut by €1,400 last year. The €500 payment proposed barely covers the loss of income the Government imposed on disabled people in 2026. It simply represents a rehash of the one-off payment it removed from them last year.

We in the Social Democrats had a bolder plan to really improve the lot of disabled people by offering a substantial support with an introductory rate for the cost-of-disability payment at €40 per week. That would have amounted to four times the level of support offered by the Government’s measly one-off payment, and it would have come with an additional €15 per week for those on disability allowance, meaning a real increase in incomes beyond the level of inflation.

I also note that the cost-of-disability payment is not in this Bill, as the Minister said. Can the Minister then assure us that the payment will be established on a statutory basis, or at least on a permanent basis, so that disabled people need not fear another rug pull from this Government like they experienced last year? Comparing the provisions for disabled people included in our alternative budget with what the Minister is trying to do in this Bill would leave no one in any doubt as to who is willing to put their money where their mouth is and support disabled people in this country, who for too long have had their needs dismissed and their advocacy ignored.

For older people, the measures in this Bill have been bitterly disappointing. Since budget day, we have heard from so many people who were shocked, many of them truly offended, actually, by the €3 increase to the living-alone allowance. What is €3 a week going to do for someone facing skyrocketing energy prices as we head into another winter? A stunning 30% of older people living alone are in poverty, according to the CSO. There are too many stories from those who struggled to remain warm last winter, of turning off heaters, skipping meals, and doing whatever they could not to shiver in their beds. Some €3 a week is not going to cut it for those people, particularly when the fuel allowance next year will be cut by four weeks after the temporary extension this year, meaning a net cut for recipients year on year.

There is one very notable absence from this Bill which is the clause which abolishes the means-test for carers. I would really like to know when the Government plans to do that. It has now gone three full calendar years since the general election without meeting a commitment it campaigned on. This was a key measure in the programme for Government and not only has it not abolished it but it is not even making progress on it this year. The increase to the income limits and the means test for the carer’s allowance in this Bill barely keep up with inflation, never mind working towards reducing it to zero. The Minister is running out of time to make progress on this key promise he made to the people who are saving his Government billions of euro through the work they carry out as carers, and it is not just on the carers' allowance. As I have raised with the Minister many times, the issue of income disregards and eligibility thresholds is problematic across a number of payments in social protection. Across the board, they have not kept up with inflation, or with the increases to the minimum wage. Meaning, people are being pushed out of eligibility, particularly for vital child support interventions like the one-parent family payment.

I also want to raise the specific issue of kinship care. Our alternative budget set aside a substantial amount of money to raise the guardians' payment by €70 per week as a first step to align the payment with the level of support granted to foster carers. The work that kinship carers do in taking on care responsibilities for family members in what are very difficult circumstances, often dealing with the challenge of raising grandchildren on their own, is heroic work.

The current scheme does not recognise that work or provide them with the support they deserve. Kinship carers deserve to be supported and celebrated rather than left behind by a system which is unfair. I call on the Minister to include kinship carers in the budget negotiations next year so we can pass a 2028 version of this Bill that actually does that.

The Bill contains a clause to increase penalties related to jobseeker's payments. I am sure the Minister will agree with me, even if the Minister for Finance does not, that the social protection system is one of the shining lights of the Irish State. It supports us in our moments of most acute need. When it works, it acts to fight injustice and alleviate hardship. As workers, we contribute to it not only in the hope that support will be there if we ever need it but also so we may live in a more kind and just society. I was glad to see the Minister's comments on the 27,000 longer term unemployed in activation in Tús, CE and RSS. The comments in the past week from the Tánaiste and leader of Fine Gael on how this system of social protection is something to be devalued and those supported by it are fair game for denigration and scapegoating were deeply disappointing. I hope the Minister will condemn those comments because they were beneath contempt. Indeed, they were beneath the dignity of anyone who hopes to hold the office of Taoiseach. I would hope anyone who hopes to lead our country would be wise enough to respect all its citizens rather than make them a subject of disdain. I welcome the Minister's comments today that he does not share that disdain.

Comment on this

It is welcome that there will be increases in welfare payments, but with the cost of living I am concerned the €10 here and there will just be eaten up. I will give a few examples. I am contacted regularly, as I am sure most TDs are, by phone, by email or in clinics by people who are really struggling.

I will outline some increases in the cost of living. The increase in the price of groceries is 23.6% since 2020. If you want to go to the dentist, if you get certain payments and are on a medical card, you are entitled to some free services, but people on maternity leave, for example, may not be entitled to that. The check-up is between €60 and €80 and fillings are €100 to €150. Root canal is horrific and so is the cost: €500 to €800. If anyone wanting to go to the doctor does not have a medical card, it is about €60 to €80 for an appointment. At the moment, doctors are under massive pressure. Even getting an appointment with one involves at least two weeks' wait.

We will look at rent. In my constituency, Dublin South-Central, there are apartments and houses at €2,000, €2,500 and €3,000. These are phenomenal amounts of money. Mortgages are set to increase due to the increases in rates from the ECB.

All these things lead to huge increases in costs and it is putting people under pressure. I am education spokesperson. I think everybody knows that as I say it every time. I am delighted to be education spokesperson but the costs of education are phenomenal. Last year the Department was saying it would support 233,000 children through the back-to-school clothing and footwear allowance. That is a huge number of young people and families who need that support. They should not need it. Things should not be so dire for 233,000 children that they are dependent on a payment of €160 or €285 to help them with uniforms, bags, clothes or shoes. It is a perverse and odd way to look at the things that we are celebrating supporting these families. The reality is we should not be celebrating it; we should be ashamed of ourselves that that number of families need that support.

The average cost of primary school for a child is €1,794 per year. That is a primary school lifetime cost of about €14,000. For secondary school, the lifetime cost is about €17,500. That is when you do not pay school fees. We say education in this country is free but actually it costs families €14,000 for primary school and €17,500 for secondary school. That is not free. We have hot school meals and will debate them soon. I am happy with that and with the supports we give families. There are certain programmes that need to be universal in our schools so no one is stigmatised. That is a shining beacon of how things work. That works really well and I do not want to denigrate that. I am very proud to have that in this country.

For a single person or family, the costs of running a car are huge, up to about €3,000 per year. On the other side of that, there is an increase in transport fares. Our Private Members' motion about that is tomorrow. With increased fares for buses, trains and Luas, will people go back into their cars? If they do that, it is very expensive. People are snookered with things like this.

Increases in these payments are welcome but they will be eaten up quickly. The effect of child poverty when we have 200,000 children living below the poverty line in this country is shocking. I cannot explain it. I try to explain it sometimes to people who have never met the families I have worked with for 30 years. When I explain the level of need and poverty, they look at me as if I am mental and it is not true in such a rich country. It is true. The level of need is phenomenal. Putting all that together and considering the cost of living in this country, it is no wonder small and medium-sized businesses in this city centre are saying they will have to close down because people cannot come in and spend their hard-earned money on the nice things in life. People's social lives are being affected by the expense of getting from day to day. People are surviving; they are not living. We need to address this. I am shockingly worried as we come into winter about the effects heating and electricity bills will have on people.

Comment on this

A constituent of mine in Wicklow is a young mother, 32 years of age. She has two young children and she was diagnosed with cancer earlier this year. I spoke to her partner last week and they are appealing for help. They are struggling to keep on top of things at the moment. She has had surgery, chemotherapy and radiotherapy and is unable to work. She applied for illness benefit and her application was initially refused because she had 254 PRSI contributions, six short of the required 260. They were advised her previous employment abroad could be used to satisfy the shortfall and she has provided all the documentation for that but they have now been waiting 22 weeks for a decision. They were originally told the process would take ten weeks. The Department has repeatedly advised it is awaiting information from the revenue office in the UK, despite that documentation already being provided by the applicant. This family is relying solely on one salary, a secondary school teacher. They are not eligible for additional supports and are €16 per week over the threshold for the working family payment. They also miss out on all the related supports, such as fuel allowance and assistance for SEAI home energy upgrades. All the while, they face mounting costs from her cancer treatment, including travel, parking, scans and over-the-counter medication.

I think the Minister is aware of the case but I will get in touch and see if we can move this along. The reason I have gone into so much detail is I wanted to use this as an illustration of how inhumane the system can be - to be only €16 per week above the threshold and therefore not be eligible for anything, and to have to wait for 22 weeks for financial supports while having to deal with cancer, surgery, chemotherapy and radiation and having two babies at home.

There is the worry of the finances and having to push and pull and ask everyone for help to try to get the application seen to. Twenty-two weeks is a long time to go without any support. Our social system needs to be flexible and a level of humanity needs to be built into it. The officers and staff do what they can but sometimes it is simply computer says "No". In circumstances like this, which are extraordinary, but also extraordinarily traumatic, families should get the support they need, when they need it and not be left struggling for it, talking to everyone they can and hoping the local TD or councillor can help. I ask the Minister to look into that.

I also recognise the Minister's contribution earlier and thank him for what he said about the long-term unemployed. It was an important clarification he made. The discourse over the weekend was awful. It is difficult to see the people in those circumstances who cannot see any way out being used as a punching bag. Each of us here has a considerable platform. Our voices and what we say carry considerable weight. The more senior people are in their positions, as we go through the Government and up to the position of Tánaiste or Taoiseach, the greater the weight they carry. Their influence is much greater. We look across the world to countries we would have looked to for inspiration and their societies are crumbling; I hope they are making their way back now. As the world crumbles, it is important we use our time here and our platforms for good, for cohesion, inclusion and kindness, and to present a vision for the country that is positive. We are not perfect. There are a lot of problems, but let us hear the solutions and not use a tiny cohort of people to deflect and essentially point the finger at saying they are the problem. They are not the problem, so I thank the Minister for his contribution.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this debate on the Social Welfare Bill 2026, which gives legislative effect to a number of important measures announced in budget 2027. Our social welfare system is an essential safety net supporting people at different stages of their lives, whether they are pensioners, families raising children, people out of work, those living with disabilities or parents taking time away from employment. The measures in the Bill represent a further investment in that safety net and I am pleased to support them.

I highlight one measure of particular importance to rural Ireland and the agricultural community in Cork North-West. The increase in the income disregard for the agri-environment schemes from €5,000 to €7,500 for the farm assist scheme and the non-contributory State pension means test is welcome. Farmers who participate in these schemes make an important contribution to biodiversity, climate action and environmental protection. They should not be unfairly disadvantaged when their social welfare entitlements are assessed.

I will address another important issue, namely supporting people back to employment, particularly those unemployed for a prolonged period. Everyone who can work should do so and should have the opportunity to develop their skills and contribute to their communities. Despite a period of continuous full employment, the latest Central Statistics Office, CSO, figures for October show that more than 52,000 people have been on the live register for a year or longer. That is a significant number and one we cannot ignore. We must ensure that people who have been unemployed for a year, two years or longer are not simply left on the live register without meaningful engagement or assistance. That is why I particularly welcome the Government's intervention, publishing a new pathways to work strategy in the coming weeks, focusing on more intensive engagement with those furthest removed from the labour market.

The Department of Social Protection provides a range of supports, including back to work schemes, education and training opportunities, work placement programmes and apprenticeships. Through Intreo offices, employment advisers can also provide tailored one-to-one assistance by examining individuals' qualifications and experience and developing a personal progression plan to help them to return to employment. This is an important responsibility attaching to receiving the jobseeker's payment. The fundamental condition of these payments is that people must be available for and actively seeking employment. Where people engage with employment service and make a genuine effort to find work, they should receive every support available to them. However, when people refuse to engage with employment services, there must be consequences. That is why I support the provision in this Bill to increase the penalty to €100 for those who refuse to engage with employment services.

As Cathaoirleach of the Oireachtas Committee on Social Protection, I am conscious of the many issues raised by individuals, families and representative organisations. We must continue to examine the adequacy of social welfare payments and supports available to carers, people with disabilities and older people. Overall, this Bill provides worthwhile and timely-----

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Thank you, Deputy.

Comment on this

-----improvements to our social protection system.

Comment on this

I welcome the publication of the Bill, the Minister's contribution towards its development, which is obvious, and what it contains to assist people in our society who require assistance.

I echo the sentiments of our colleagues to the left regarding the Minister's comments earlier today about those on jobseeker's benefit, the fluidity of those who are on jobseeker's benefit and the small number who are long-term unemployed, less than 2% of the workforce. It is important that we continue to support those families and make sure no one in our society is left behind. The Minister's efforts go some way towards that.

I also welcome the introduction of the first permanent cost-of-disability payment. This is a milestone in Irish social policy. Future generations will reflect and look back on this measure in the same way as we look back on other landmark social protection initiatives that fundamentally improved people's lives. It acknowledges the reality, long understood by the Minister and our party, that people and families with members who have a disability often carry additional costs. Fairness requires that these costs be recognised by the State and they be assisted with them.

Similarly, the changes the Minister has made to the income threshold to avail of the carer's allowance is welcome. It is a €150 increase for a single income applicant and €300 increase for a family with two incomes. This is welcome. I understand we are working towards trying to eliminate any income threshold to access carer's allowance, but this will help people and enable more people to avail of the carer's allowance. Given the important work carers do on behalf of the State, that is important.

I share the sentiment of my colleague who spoke previously about the changes to the income thresholds for those who avail of agri-environment scheme payments, that is, the increase in the income disregard. That will have the impact of allowing farmers to participate in such schemes as ACRES, which will improve their income and contribute to environmental objectives while still retaining access to social protection payments, the farm assist scheme and the non-contributory pension. The measure removes a disincentive that existed for some lower income farmers to engage in schemes such as ACRES, and I welcome that.

The Minister and I spoke previously. We had many conversations about this. I welcome that he has increased the income disregard for seaweed harvesting for those applying to the farm assist scheme and jobseeker's payment from €1,270 to €2,500 per year. That will be effective from next year. People might look at that measure and say it is not substantial, but it is important for everyone in the House to remember that it is the first change to the scheme since 1994. That is significant. It is a measure-----

Comment on this
John McGuinness An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Thank you, Deputy.

Comment on this

-----we will look at and build on in the future.

Comment on this

Next year, the State will allocate €31 billion to social protection. It is the largest single area of voted expenditure. At the heart of that allocation is the principle that we should reward work and enterprise but, equally, protect those who need our support. That is the principle of the social market economy, a strong economy alongside a strong social conscience. We should never lose sight of that balance. It is a huge commitment and reflects the importance we place on supporting our citizens.

I particularly acknowledge carers in south Tipperary and changes in budget 2027 for carers. I consistently meet extraordinary people who devote themselves to caring for their loved ones, many of whom have sacrificed careers, incomes and opportunities to provide that care.

Their contribution is immeasurable. It is important we continue to recognise that contribution not simply in words but through meaningful financial support.

The same, of course, applies to those with disabilities. A person's dignity must never be measured by their capacity to work. I welcome the changes in budget 2027, particularly the cost-of-disability payment. We have a responsibility to ensure that disability does not mean a lifetime of financial insecurity or exclusion.

It is equally important, though, that we recognise that social protection carries responsibilities. The latest figures show that 52,000 people have been on the live register for a year or more. At a time of strong employment, we must ask whether we are doing enough to help those who can work to get back into employment. That means education, training, apprenticeships and genuine opportunities. I welcome the forthcoming pathways to work strategy and its emphasis on individual engagement, but where a person who is capable of working is offered meaningful assistance but repeatedly refuses to engage, there have to be reasonable consequences. We need to be absolutely clear, though: we are not talking about carers, people who are unable to work because of a disability or those facing genuine barriers to employment. They deserve our understanding and support.

The Tánaiste, as the Minister knows, recently spoke about opening up opportunity to all while also ensuring that social welfare remains available when life takes an unexpected turn. I agree with that principle. A society that supports those who cannot work, creates opportunities for those who can and never forgets the dignity of every individual is the balance we need to strive to achieve.

Comment on this

I welcome the debate on the Social Welfare Bill 2026. The Bill gives effect to the social welfare measures in the budget. I acknowledge the work of the Minister, Deputy Calleary, and his officials in securing a record social protection package of over €30 billion, up €2 billion on 2026, which will help the most vulnerable in our society as we deal with continued cost-of-living pressures.

At the centre of the Bill is the €10 permanent increase in core weekly rates from January. The State contributory pension will exceed €300 a week for the first time. The living alone allowance will go up to €25 a week, its first increase in five years. Taken together with the core increase and the higher fuel allowance, that is worth €816 a year to a pensioner living alone. I particularly welcome the changes to the fuel allowance. As the Minister knows, I have pressed for this on several occasions in this House. The rate will rise to €43 a week, and from January the income limit for a single person over 66 will rise by more than €100 a week. That will help older people in Dún Laoghaire and right across the country with a small occupational pension who were just over the line. Most importantly, the fuel allowance opens up access to the many SEAI retrofitting schemes, which is very helpful.

In my speech last year on the Finance Bill, I said that over the next four budgets we should move further away from strict means testing for full-time family carers. This budget takes another step in that direction, with the carer's allowance income disregard rising to €1,150 for a single person and €2,300 for a couple from July 2027.

I also welcome the first ever cost-of-disability payment. It is much welcomed.

I have one request of the Minister, though. The telephone support allowance helps older people living alone to pay for a phone or a personal alarm but only if they receive both the living alone allowance and the fuel allowance. The Minister's own figures show that almost 297,000 people over 70 on the household benefits package do not receive it. Extending it to them would cost about €36 million a year. Maybe that could be considered in 2027. I know the Minister does not want to discuss next year's budget already, but it is just a thought.

Comment on this

It is good to be here to discuss the budget and the issues with regard to social protection. I thank the Minister for the clarity he brought to the Government's position with regard to the long-term unemployed. That is important. While many people were aghast at the Tánaiste's comments, at the same time they pointed to something we need to deal with in our society. We have hundreds of thousands of people in this country who work every day, who get up, who are in low-income or medium-income employment and who struggle to pay their bills, struggle to find somewhere to live and to pay the rent or the mortgage and struggle for childcare and all those issues. They are the big issues facing our society, yet the Tánaiste chose to point to a small number of people over there and try to divide people and blame a sector of society, and that is very wrong. At the same time, however, we need to examine that.

The truth is that in my office and, I am sure, in every constituency office around the country, we have hundreds of people who come to us seeking a disability payment. Perhaps they have a mental health issue or perhaps they have other capacity issues. They find they cannot get that payment because they get back a letter saying, "We think you will be better within a year." That is basically what they are told. The only option they then have is to go onto jobseeker's, and when they go onto jobseeker's, obviously, they have a difficulty in trying to source employment because the capacity is not there. We had job clubs and other services in the past, which were of assistance to them. They were shut down, and private companies like JobPath were put in place to provide the services for them.

I will give the Minister an example. There was a woman in her late 50s in my constituency. I will give her the name Kate. Most of her life she lived with her two bachelor brothers and her elderly father, who had a severe disability. She got carer's allowance for a long period of her life looking after her father. Her father passed away when she was in her late 50s and she ended up on jobseeker's. She got a letter from JobPath sending her to get a job in a local fast food chain which was nearly 30 miles away. The woman did not drive or have a way to go there. She did go for the interview and, obviously, they saw she did not have the capacity for that job. That is the kind of thing the Tánaiste was pointing to and blaming on that woman, as if she were the problem. That issue needs to be dealt with. We need to recognise that the system does not work for people who fall into that space between having a severe disability and having a moderate issue such that they do not have the capacity to find employment. That needs to be dealt with.

As another example - and always in examples in our constituencies we can find these issues that come to the fore - I had a young man who, with his girlfriend, went to Saudi Arabia to work for a number of years to save the money to buy a house. They came back with a good lump of money saved up. He went back to work and was not very long back in work when he got cancer. He went to the State to look for assistance. As he had saved that money to buy a house, he could not get any assistance, and at the same time he could not get a mortgage because he had cancer. He could not get anything from anyone and he and his family had worked all their lives. Now, the issue was eventually resolved but it is an example of the unfairness of the system and how it needs the capacity to expand and to be nimble enough to recognise that not everyone fits into square boxes. That is one of the big issues I have with the entire system. One of the reasons that people are so concerned about what the Government is doing and so disappointed so often is that this neoliberal economic model we have in Ireland and in most of Europe is there to protect and bail out the banks and the corporations all the time, yet when the people who really try hard and really feel they contribute to society need assistance, they are turned away. That is why they turn to other dark places.

The Government has a real responsibility to look after everyone in society and those who are on the margins, who find it difficult, who will be in long-term unemployment or who have other issues that need to be looked after. For the thousands and thousands of people who work hard, try very hard and at some point in their life find they need the system to help them and want a safety net, that safety net is not there. I know - and I have had this conversation with the Minister in the past - that he is open to trying to find solutions to that, but those solutions need to be found if we are to have a society that will function adequately.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to discuss the Social Welfare Bill 2026. As other speakers have done, I will start by thanking all those who work in the Department of Social Protection. As I have said before on a number of occasions, they really contribute to us in our roles as Oireachtas Members, and I think and hope that that assistance can continue because it is a sincere help to us all in our day-to-day work.

I want to raise a number of points with the Minister tonight. Many he will not be surprised I am raising again because we have spoken about them previously in this House and at committee.

The first issue I want to raise with him is the half-rate carer's allowance and older people. I have continued to raise this issue of older people caring for an adult child getting their carer's allowance cut in half when they go onto the State pension. I remind the Government yet again that we have 600,000 family carers in Ireland who save the State over €20 billion a year in unpaid care work. That is nearly the equivalent to a second HSE. They are the invisible backbone of our health service and provide 24-7 care, often without a break. Due to the lack of long-term planning and building capacity in residential and independent living options for people with disabilities, family carers are having to pick up the shortfall.

This means that family carers aged in their 60s, 70s, 80s and even 90s are having to provide full-time care to an adult child with a disability. These family carers, upon reaching the pension age, get their carer's allowance cut in half. I know there is a programme for Government commitment to change this but there was no progress made in the recent budget on that change. The adult children of these carers should be supported to live independently. Family carers, who often go a lifetime without a break for their caring role, deserve to see their adult child live their own life.

Despite the Government finally committing to same, family carers have still not seen the means test removed. In the Labour Party's alternative budget, we prioritised this and we would have finally removed the unfair means testing of family carers. We would also increase the carer's support grant and increase the cap on the number of hours a carer can work, which is an issue I want to discuss further with the Minister. The 18.5 hours that carers are allowed work at the moment comes up time and again. It is a barrier to care and one the Government needs to look at.

I also want to talk to the Minister about older persons losing the fuel allowance and the SEAI grant. This is something I have raised with him before. First, however, I will speak about the living alone allowance. It was deeply disappointing that this was increased by only €3 per week. It has been a number of years since this payment was increased and €3 is nowhere near enough to support the households that need it most. Older people who are living alone already face higher rates of poverty, with at least 30% of them living in poverty. The €3 increase will not buy an older person a cup of coffee, let alone help them with the cost of living.

The €10 increase in the State pension is well below the €15 increase the Labour Party had proposed in our alternative budget. The latter is needed to help households, such as the older people and carers I mentioned, with the current cost of living. As we all know, these are the people who have spent their lives building this Republic.

More and more, I have seen the impact of the housing emergency on older people, often in the form of the loss of social welfare payments after an adult child has moved back home. As rent prices continue to increase and young adults get priced out of the housing market, they are having to return to the family home. This results in older parents losing payments like the fuel allowance, a vital support, especially given the current cost-of-living crisis. It also means that these older people will miss out on the €9,000 SEAI grant for solar panels, a very welcome grant that was announced recently in the budget. This is a huge issue for them. I have raised this with the Minister previously and I continue to call on him to intervene in this matter. The housing emergency is not going away any time soon, so we must adapt our social protection system to protect those who need help the most.

I submitted a number of parliamentary questions to the Department in relation to the number of people losing out on this grant as a result of a son or daughter moving home. Unfortunately, the reply I got, which I have it in front of me, states that it is only calculated on a yearly basis. This is one of the biggest issues being raised in my office, namely, people having their fuel allowance cut because their son or daughter has moved home. I will give the Minister one example of a letter I got last night in a clinic in Kildare town. It states:

Furthermore, based on the information you have provided, it has been decided by a deciding officer that you are no longer entitled to the fuel allowance as there is a qualified person resident in your household.

That qualified person was the recipient's 24-year-old daughter, who spends four days in college and three days working part time. She is the only other person living with in the home, apart from a 16-year-old child. That is why the particular person, who is on disability allowance, has had their fuel allowance cut. We have discussed before the need for all those on disabilities to have a fuel allowance given their medical condition, but this person's fuel allowance was cut because their 24-year-old daughter came back to live with them, even though the daughter is only working part time, three days per week.

These are the issues, and I can give the Minister example after example coming to my office. The problem is that these people are losing out. Whether we like it or not, they are losing out on the SEAI grants and, most importantly, they are losing the fuel allowance, which they need to heat their homes. It is very welcome that the fuel allowance went up to €43 per week, and it makes a difference for people. The Department was not able to give me the figures on this issue. We should look at it again. There are too many cases coming through my offices where people are losing out. I have given just one example from last night but, as I said, I can give the Minister more from the past couple of weeks.

I also raise the withdrawal of payments for households that have been recently bereaved. Of course, the loss of a loved one is not only felt emotionally but it places an untold financial loss on the grieving family. The fact is that the same bills have to be paid but with half the income. This can be particularly difficult for older people on the State pension, whereby the payment only continues to be paid six weeks after the loss of a loved one. The Minister mentioned a change in that regard, but this is an extremely short period of time for a grieving wife or husband to adjust to.

A number of my colleagues recently heard from and met, at the social protection committee, members of the Widowed and Bereaved Partners Ireland group, who spoke about the loss of some vital payments. One speaker told me they were unable to return to work for 18 months and the fuel allowance, again, was a great support to them, but when they returned to work, doing a few hours a week, they ended up €7.50 over the threshold for the fuel allowance. This is another example. That particular person was a nurse, and we all know how many nurses we need in this country. She has to cut her hours again to try to requalify for the fuel allowance. This example was raised at the social protection committee meeting by the Widowed and Bereaved Partners Ireland group. That is a massive loss for any person, considering the cost-of-living crisis in this country. We need to re-evaluate our social protection system to have a more compassionate policy response.

I am also aware of the little-known heat supplement, which I raised with the Minister in the House roughly five months ago. In reply, he told me that we had 231,000 people on disability income support payments and 170,000 people on caring support payments. Yet, only 692 people were in receipt of the heating supplement. This is a way of ensuring that those who need it most actually get a heating supplement. Again, I refer to those who are on a disability payment and I will come to that again shortly. These people, who are coming to my offices and the offices of other Members of this House, need help but are not getting it. There is already a grant available but it needs to be advertised and promoted and access to it needs to be made easier for those who need it most. A lot of people have difficulty accessing the heat supplement, as reflected in the fact that only 692 people are getting it. As I said, that figure is from a number of months ago.

In our alternative budget, the Labour Party put forward a package of measures to support vulnerable households. We would have increased the fuel allowance income threshold by €50 per week so more households would have qualified for the payment, while also increasing the payment by €7.50 per week and extending the payment season by another four weeks.

The Minister will not be surprised to hear me talk about the domiciliary care allowance, DCA, as this is not the first time I have raised issues relating to the allowance in the House. It is extremely disappointing for many families of children with additional needs that it is one of the few payments not to be increased in budget 2027. I ask the Minister to explain why this payment was not increased. It is €380 per month, or less than €100 per week. It was one of the few disability payments left out of the cost-of-disability payment.

I also raise the issue of eligibility. Information made available to me by the Department of Social Protection shows that from 2022 to 2025, nearly 16% of children on the DCA who applied for disability allowance were unsuccessful in their claims. This has left 1,300 children and families without this vital payment. I must stress that the DCA is a payment made in cases of severe disability. That is laid out clearly in the criteria, as the Minister will know. To leave nearly 1,300 children without this payment upon turning 16 is extremely cruel and cold. In the cases of many of the families I have been working with, their child has a lifelong disability. Unfortunately, these disabilities do not disappear when the child turns 16. That is why I continue to call on the Minister to extend the qualifying age for DCA from 16 to 18 to prevent that cliff edge. This is a vital payment for these households. The parents coming to my office in Kildare South need this payment. The DCA is used to deal with huge waiting lists and many families use it to pay for essential therapies such as occupational therapy, speech and language therapy and physiotherapy.

The Minister will be aware that I have provided his office, as he asked me to do in a previous conversation, with details of the responses to families who are in this position as regards the DCA. The number of responses is now nearing 2,000. I hope that we continue to work on this very important matter and that we revisit the extension of the qualifying age from 16 to 18.

To be fair to the Minister, who has spoken about this at the Joint Committee on Social Protection, I welcome that some progress has been made recently with regard to a cost-of-disability payment.

However, €10 is a very low starting point. In the Labour Party's alternative budget, we proposed starting the payment at three times that, at €30 per week. There also seems to be an oversight in regard to who qualifies for the payment. I understand that only those in receipt of the blind pension, disability allowance, invalidity pension and partial capacity benefit will be eligible for the €500 payment.

Thousands of older people have moved from some disability payments to the State pension. These are disabilities that do not just disappear because someone transfers to a new payment overnight. Since 2023, 24,911 older adults have transferred from the disability allowance and invalidity pension to the State pension. That includes 8,296 transferring from the disability allowance and 16,615 transferring from the invalidity pension. That is almost 25,000 older adults who have been left out of the new cost-of-disability payment because they have transferred to the State pension, in addition to those on the DCA, as I have already flagged. This is a massive oversight for these households. These are people who are living with disabilities and are already facing additional costs due to their disabilities, which, as we all know, can cost up to €15,000 a year. I ask the Minister to answer that and come back to us on it.

I want to address the comments made by the Tánaiste, Simon Harris, regarding people who are long-term unemployed. I welcome the fact that the Minister has tonight clarified his opinion on these comments. He is correct; jobseeker's allowance is not a lifestyle choice and is far from the most important issue in the country at this time. The Tánaiste simply needs to look at the statistics. We are a country at almost full employment, and a low unemployment rate of 1.3% was recorded in quarter 2 of 2026, according to the CSO. That means that fewer than 17,500 people have been on a jobseeker's payment for five years or more. This is reduced further to 14,000 when people aged 60 to 66 are excluded, who are already struggling to find employment due to age discrimination and the need for pensions, etc., which we have spoken about previously. Additionally, the Tánaiste ignores the fact that for many single-parent households, they are struggling to find work because of the chronic lack of childcare places available in many parts of the country.

The Tánaiste went on to call out a former leader of the Labour Party, but he neglected to mention that those comments were from 15 years ago, when the unemployment rate was 15%, a fact I am sure he did not consider when he was calling out the former leader of the Labour Party. The Tánaiste could have spoken of what is actually going on in this country. He could have spoken about reducing the cost of childcare, the cost of living, the homelessness emergency or anything more constructive that the Minister and I are dealing with in the social protection committee, but he did not.

There are a lot of positive increases in this Bill, albeit not to the extent the Labour Party would have introduced. The issues I have raised with the Minister are real and are felt by so many people coming into my clinics in Kildare South. These are the issues that families, those living with disability and older people are raising with me in my clinics. I know they are also raised continuously with many Members of this House. There is a cost-of-living crisis in this country. Many households are struggling and they need their Government to help out. Unfortunately for many of those families, they will still be left seeking help following this budget. However, I look forward to working with the Minister and his officials as we make our way through this Bill. I ask him to consider those important issues I have raised with him once again tonight.

Comment on this

The Bill contains a number of positive measures and I welcome all of them. In particular, I welcome the increased investment in social protection, the €10 increase in weekly welfare payments and the targeted supports for families, pensioners, people with disabilities and, most importantly, carers. Today I will focus on carers and family carers. Across our communities, thousands of people provide care every day for elderly parents, children with disabilities, spouses and loved ones. Their dedication allows people to remain in their homes, surrounded by family and community, rather than entering long-term residential care.

I welcome the €10 increase in the carer's allowance and carer's benefit, together with the significant improvements to the income disregards announced in budget 2027. These measures recognise the enormous contribution carers make to society and our healthcare system. However, I believe we need to go further. Family carers provide service that saves the State millions of euro every year. Without them, many more people would require nursing home places, residential care and additional State supports. The programme for Government commits to phasing out the means test for the carer's allowance, and I welcome the progress made to date. I have long held the view we should continue moving towards a full abolition. Family carers should not be disadvantaged because they own a farm, a small business or an asset built up over generations. These assets do not help with day-to-day demands and the costs of caring, yet they still affect access to support.

Keeping people at home is not only what most families want; it also makes economic sense. Residential care is becoming increasingly expensive. In one case known to me, a nursing home placement would cost a family €75,000 a year. While the fair deal scheme provides support, significant costs can still arise for many families. If we provide greater support to family carers and remove barriers to accessing payments, more people will be able to continue caring for their loved ones at home for longer. That improves quality of life, strengthens families and community networks and helps reduce pressure on nursing homes and residential care facilities. In the long term, this would save the State money. Supporting carers is not simply good social policy; it is sound economic policy.

Family carers are one of the most important pillars of our health and social care system and they deserve greater recognition and support. For those reasons, while welcoming the Bill and the improvements it contains, I appeal to Government colleagues to continue building the progress already made to deliver further meaningful supports for carers and family carers and fulfil our commitment to phasing out the means test for the carer's allowance.

Comment on this

Ireland has a good social welfare system. It provides support to the people who need it. A good society looks after those who are vulnerable, and one of the ways to do this in Ireland is through the financial supports available through our social welfare system. An example of this support is the introduction of the pay-related benefit, ensuring that people who lose their jobs have a stronger safety net linked to their previous earnings. Supporting people who have lost their jobs is important. Jobseeker's payment provides financial assistance during periods of disruption, ensuring people have the support when they need it the most. However, there are cases of long-term unemployment where individuals have been living on jobseeker's payment for two and more years. That is not what jobseeker's payment, also known as the dole, is intended for. This does not refer to the people who are unable to work due to caring responsibilities, disability or illness or who are receiving other welfare payments.

Fine Gael believes that everyone who can work should work. In Ireland, we have a strong economy. Despite a period of continuous full employment, the latest CSO figures show that 172,800 people were on the live register in October 2026. Within that, 52,000 have been on the live register for a year or longer. Last year, over €1.7 billion was spent on jobseeker's payments. That is a significant amount of taxpayers' money. As part of the jobseeker's payment system, the Department of Social Protection provides tailored one-to-one support for long-term jobseekers. Employment advisers in Intreo sit down with individuals, review their qualifications and skills and help them develop a personal progression plan focused on upskilling and securing employment. The key condition of receiving jobseeker's payments is that a person must be available for and actively seeking work. The clue is in the name: jobseeker.

The programme for Government, agreed with our Fianna Fáil and Independent colleagues, commits to publishing a new employment strategy focused on intensive engagement and supports to help those furthest from the labour market to enter the workforce. The new pathway to work plan is at an advanced stage. The Department of Social Protection has undertaken significant consultation on the plan and it will be published in the coming weeks. The plan will focus on a wide range of back-to-work schemes, education and training supports, work placement programmes and apprenticeships that are available to help people into employment. My colleagues and I believe that supports should be provided to those who need them, both financial and non-financial, whether for jobseeking, illness, disability or other circumstances. A good society looks after its people through supports such as these. However, I support the work of this Bill to ensure that those who need support receive it while also ensuring that those who can work receive the assistance and encouragement they need to obtain employment.

With regard to budget 2027 and the cost-of-disability lump sum payment, which I welcome, I support the calls for financial tax breaks to be put in place in budget 2028 for persons with disabilities in the workforce who have not benefited from the cost-of-disability payment.

They face the same costs of disability in their lives as any other person even though they are in the workforce. We need to look at that in budget 2028.

Comment on this

I welcome this Social Welfare Bill. A strong social welfare system is not a sign of weakness in our society. It is a sign of strength that reflects our belief that people who fall on hard times deserve support, older people deserve security and families raising children and caring for loved ones deserve recognition. That is what this Bill delivers. It increases weekly social welfare payments by €10. This includes pensions and payments to carers and people with disabilities. It increases supports for families and children and raises the income thresholds for the working family payment. That matters enormously to families across Ireland who get up every morning, go to work, raise their children and still struggle to make ends meet. I particularly welcome the recognition of carers. I have met many families who care for children with disabilities, whose contribution to our society is extraordinary. Their work is work and our social protection system must recognise that.

There has been considerable debate about the Tánaiste's comments on long-term unemployment. I understand why people have strong feelings about this issue but we should be capable of having a reasonable conversation about the underlying principle. Sinn Féin seems to think that calling someone a Tory or accusing them of Thatcherism is a substitute for making an argument. There is nothing contradictory about believing in a strong social welfare system and believing that people who can work should be supported and encouraged to do so. Those principles belong together. Work is about more than a payslip. It provides independence, dignity, confidence and opportunity. If somebody has been unemployed for a long period, our ambition should be to help them into employment rather than simply accepting that they will remain outside the workforce indefinitely. That requires training, effective employment services and recognising the genuine barriers many people face. It also requires an expectation that people will engage with the supports that are available. We must distinguish between people who cannot work, people who face substantial barriers to employment, and those who are capable of working but who refuse to engage. The objective should never be to punish unemployment but to overcome it wherever possible. Ultimately, a good social welfare system protects those who need protection, recognises different forms of contribution and creates opportunities for people to build better lives. That is the balance we should strive for. That is why I support this Bill.

Comment on this

All of the narrative around the proposal that everyone should work and about representing those who get up early in the morning for work is quite offensive. Humanity is a messy business. It is not perfect. We should strive to do the best we can with it but there will be those who cannot work or who will need assistance. They should not be targeted by anybody. I have seen too much of that going on over the last ten years. People are saying they represent this or that. It is all about people who get up early in the morning to work casting aspersions on those who may not be able to get up, get out of bed or go to work or who do not know how to work. We should remember that. In here we talk about weakness in our society and supporting those who are weak and vulnerable. Yes, we should but we should not then, in the next sentence, say that we should get them all out to work as if we are going to jackboot them into a position where they would have to do something they are incapable of doing. We need far greater humanity and compassion in what we are saying about others. I do not like what is being said about others without real foundation or any real intent of creating a society that we can be proud of and that will support those who need to be supported.

I will raise this directly because I am going to make a submission on behalf of the two families involved. Families in Kilkenny recently experienced terrible flooding. There was a big hullabaloo about it. Television cameras turned up, as did the Taoiseach. The Minister was there. We were all there, as politicians, standing in the flooded home of two elderly people. A commitment was given that they would be supported out of the hardship they had found themselves in through no fault of their own. An elderly pensioner cannot go back into her home because she cannot get the full supports necessary to put her home in a liveable state in spite of her family giving her everything they could to support her financially. Another lady cannot go back into her home because she cannot face the endless investigations, examinations and form filling to get even the basics. Any system that has humanity and compassion as part of its thinking would reach out to those people, particularly those who were on the ground floor of their houses, to support them. It would ensure they get the level of support needed to allow them to live in their homes again. Is that asking too much? With regard to the emergency response payment and the actions of the Department of Social Welfare, they all worked very hard and we got great service from them in our offices but it must be said that the Minister has to look at this and has to ensure the appropriate level of funding is given to allow those people to go back into their homes. Is that not a basic right? Is that not the basic response of any government that has a social conscience at the centre of what it does? It is a test for the Government and those Ministers who stood in those houses to deliver what they said they would deliver for the families who are affected.

Comment on this

Budget 2027 was a cruel and callous exercise in demonstrating who in our society Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael believe to be worthy of support. If ever there was any doubt of this conscious and deliberate choice, the remarks of the Tánaiste over the weekend made it grossly clear. Out of ideas and unable to excuse the lack of support his budget provided to the ordinary Irish worker and family, the Tánaiste had to dig out the most clichéd of classic Fine Gael tactics and attack people on social welfare. His predecessor spent nearly as much on media for his attack campaign as was every recouped for the Exchequer. It was certainly only ever a fraction of the amount he touted. Those harsh facts are a reality for the Tánaiste's party. What this is really about is creating a distraction from the Tánaiste's miserable budget. It is about pointing the blame at anyone but himself. The proof is before us in this Social Welfare Bill. It enables paltry half-measures that will do little to even keep pace with inflation, let alone offset the undue financial burdens borne by our people in recent years. It is shameful that the Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael parties go along with this.

Perhaps more shocking is the utter lack of cost-of-living measures. Having previously withdrawn the energy credits, the Government's measure is simply to get over it. Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have put out the message that you should get used to living in a colder house. That is not exactly what they are telling people as regards the fuel allowance. The parties have tried to sell a €12 decrease as a €5 increase.

The once-off lump sum of €500 is a sop to the idea of a cost-of-disability payment. As opposed to Sinn Féin's proposals, it is not a blueprint to address the cost of disability in our society. It does not provide a pathway to ensure the broadest possible coverage, coverage that would include our pensioners. There was much consultation preceding the development of this payment but it seems the Government simply did not listen to the disability advocates. This is not a social welfare Bill. It will do little to improve the welfare of the most vulnerable in our society. It will not see payments keeping pace with inflation, let alone undo the damage done by the failures of recent years. For disabled people, this lump sum will do nothing but undo a fraction of the damage the Government has done by withdrawing supports. With one hand the Government gives €500 but the other hand covers its mouth so as not to speak of the €1,400 previously taken away in the budget. This budget once again leaves people worse off.

Ten euro for pensioners will be gone as quickly as it is received in the face of ongoing inflation. People deserve better than this and the suffering caused by this Government.

Comment on this

I am sure a lot of others have referred to it as well but it merits mentioning because this is a social welfare debate and the Tánaiste is the Tánaiste - the second in command in this Government. What he said at the weekend, or last week, in the run-up to the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis was outrageous. I do not know if there is anyone here from Fine Gael. Not surprisingly, they tend to come in and escape as soon as they make their comments. Fine Gael did what Fine Gael does best, which is to pick a minority group and have a go at it, especially during a cost-of-living crisis and when the bill for the national children's hospital is mounting up for which Deputy Harris is directly responsible.

It has already been referred to but this nonsense about people who get up early in the morning is ableist and classist and it has to stop. It is a disgrace. It is like the ads that have been sponsored about full attendance at school pushing children who for lots of different reasons are simply not able to go. I speak as somebody who had full attendance right through school but it is nonsense to be pushing this concept that everybody is able to fit into that. I will go into the figures in a second but I suppose attacking people on social welfare gave migrants a break. That was the only thing I was thinking of - the migrant workers and the refugees that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have been punching down on of late. I do not know why Deputy Clendennen is shaking his head. It is so blatantly obvious to everyone. The dogs on the street can see what they are doing. It used to be unmarried mothers and single parents. It is always some group that well-heeled people on very good wages in Fine Gael, of which the Tánaiste is one, have the neck to pick on.

The statistics are very revealing. First of all, the Tánaiste said the dole is a safety net and not a way of life and that it is not acceptable for any person to remain on the live register. By the way, the live register is made up of people who do work. He is not even accurate with his facts. It includes people who are laid off for periods of time, seasonal workers, etc. He gave wrong figures for the long-term unemployed. He said it was 52,000. He said he was lifting people up and that it did not include disabled and elderly people but, of course, it does because many people are disabled but cannot get disability benefit for lots of different reasons because of the criteria. They include people with mental health issues, people with temporary disabilities and older people, who are going to find it very difficult to get a job in this economy. The CSO figures for quarter two of 2026 for those who have been unemployed for over a year are 38,900 so, again, the Tánaiste was not even accurate. There are already penalties for those people. They have had penalties imposed, for example, if they missed two appointments. How does Ireland compare? What is this big problem all of a sudden with long-term unemployment? The figure was 1.1% of the Irish workforce and went up to 1.3% recently. The EU average is 1.9% so it is way below the EU average.

There are other problems with unemployment. Youth unemployment is a real problem that this Government needs to get to grips with. Many highly qualified young people cannot get jobs. The Tánaiste knew what he was doing. He may not have got all the facts right but he knew that what he was doing was finding a group that it is very popular to attack in some quarters. The ESRI has come out and said, on arguments like this, that 58% of people believe welfare payments make people lazy, so obviously there is an audience there for it. Meanwhile back at the ranch, the housing crisis and the cost-of-living crisis go on with efforts to resolve them thwarted by this Government. There has been no action. It was a great distraction for the past five days. Hopefully, this is the last time that we will be discussing it but this has been a distraction from the real issues.

I want to talk as well about disability because disabled people were those most cruelly treated by this Government in the budget. The deficits in the payments they had lost out on had been well identified and the Government came back with €10, which basically it gave to every single group. Before the election, we heard a huge amount about carers because we know carers generally are good for voting so the Government decided, and not just the Government but many parties, to make promises it had no intention of keeping. The means test for carers is really cruel and is also extremely anti-women because it is mainly women who end up giving up their jobs and careers to become carers for their own children, many of whom need full-time care. Usually the woman may not be the best paid so she gives up her job for this. Women then find themselves dependent upon their partner, if they have one, for everything in life. They have no guaranteed income of their own. This has been raised again and again and it was used in the pre-election preamble by so many parties, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael in particular, to promise the sun, moon and stars. The Independents, who are not here tonight and who made up the Government, were leaning into it big time as well. What did the Government do? It turned around and did nothing for carers at all apart from tinker around with the reckonable income. It is not the same as getting rid of the means test. It has already been pointed out how the cost of this is very affordable if we look at the tax base in this country.

I also want to mention the cost-of-disability payment, which is a €500 lump sum that will be paid in January. Inclusion Ireland has said that it falls well short of what is required. It comes to about €962 per week, which is not enough for people who have disabilities to live on. The cost of having a disability in this society, at a very conservative estimate, is about €12,000 a year and this does not come close to the cost of the taxis that a disabled person has to order, the extra heating that he or she needs, the extra water he or she often needs to use and then of course all of the equipment and over-the-counter things that he or she has to buy that are not supported. It is incredible. Anybody who has lived with anybody with a long-term illness or a disability can see that. I believe that people who are disabled should have their own non-means tested income. Again, it is very affordable. It should be costed and we should see if it can be done because the amount of tax revenue taken in from multinationals and the wealth that we have in this society could easily be increased to pay for it.

Comment on this

This is a very wealthy country - one of the wealthiest in the world. The 2027 budget is the fifth consecutive annual budget with a surplus. There are 11 Irish billionaires, who are wealthier than more than 3,500 Irish people combined. The background to this Social Welfare Bill is a cost-of-living crisis and everybody here is well aware of that. Every family in the country is well aware of that. Over the past five years, prices for goods and services have increased by about 22%. The 2026 budget made the position far worse, as the Minister of State knows well. It abolished all cost-of-living supports and hit the poorest 10% of the population hardest. People with disabilities lost out by anything up to €1,400 in that budget but the big developers and fast food chains got huge tax reductions that came to about €680 million. PAYE workers again paid increased tax because of the freezing of income tax bands and credits.

Budget 2027 continued in the same vein.

The cost-of-living crisis is having the greatest impact on middle-income families, low-income families and social welfare recipients. Budget 2027, which is effectively being implemented by this Bill, failed those families and prioritised the golden circle of the rich and powerful in our society. Last year, it was the burger barons and big developers who got the golden handshake, and this year the reduction in capital gains tax from 33% to 31% handed almost €200 million to very wealthy landlords and property owners. These include some of the 11 billionaires I mentioned earlier who are wealthier than 3.5 million Irish people combined.

For such a wealthy country, the poverty rates here are absolutely shameful. More than 200,000 children are living in poverty in Ireland. It is worth saying that again: there are 200,000 children living in poverty in Ireland. We have 687,000 people living in poverty, with 40% of disabled people living in or below the poverty line and 256,000 people live in consistent poverty. The percentage of people at risk of poverty has increased from 11.7% to 12.6%. Low-paid workers and persons relying on social welfare support, single parents, pensioners and people with disabilities experience poverty the most. The Central Statistics Office, CSO, has said almost half of households - 44.8% - said they had some difficulty in making ends meet in 2025. Of course, this increased in 2026 due to the abolition of the cost of living supports and energy credits.

The fact that over 200,000 children live in poverty is particularly shameful. A payment of child benefit can have a significant effect on reducing child poverty, yet this Government and previous Governments have refused to increase the child benefit payment from €140 per month. It has been ten years since child benefit was last increased, in 2016. Of course, this hugely decreases the value of the payment due to inflation. This Bill should be amended to ensure child benefit is increased to at least €200 per month per child. The minimum wage and social protection payments are also below the poverty line. This Bill should ensure the adult rate of social welfare is increased to €350 per week. Pensions, disability allowance, invalidity pensions and carer's allowance must all increase to that figure to at least bring them just above the poverty line.

Family carers do a huge amount of work on behalf of the State. Since 2016, the number of family carers has increased by 53%, and the number providing care for over 43 hours per week has doubled. It is relatively accepted on all sides of this House that carers save the State something in the region of €20 billion per year. A recent survey by Family Carers Ireland showed 71% of carers find it difficult to make ends meet, 75% never receive respite, 32% have bad or very bad mental health and 49% experience extreme loneliness. Many carers become ill themselves and some even pass away before the individual they are caring for.

It has been said previously that in the run up to the last election, every party in this House promised the abolition of the means test for carer's allowance. That was a commitment given in that election but has since been broken. Family Carers Ireland also made a very modest request to have the carer's support grant, a grant paid once a year, increased by €150 - not even in line with inflation - but that was not granted. If we look back from 2021 to 2024, there was no increase in that grant. There was an increase in 2025, but that was of course ahead of a general election in November of that year. There has since been no increase in 2026 or 2027. This should be rectified in the Social Welfare Bill.

There are a huge number of unavoidable costs associated with caring, which is why the carer's allowance should be increased to €350 and why a proper cost of disability payment should be paid. For carers in particular who are involved in education or training, the 18.5 hours working outside the home should be removed for that training and education. Many elderly parents and carers over the age of 66 are being paid as half-rate carers, and this needs to be addressed. Family Carers Ireland has asked that the full rate carer's allowance be paid to pensioners who are caring.

In particular, the working family payment should be amended to ensure income from a carer's allowance is disregarded in the means test for that payment. This is a particularly cruel regulation, and I appeal to the Minister to look at, change and include the amendment in this Bill. I have encountered a very difficult situation with a constituent family whereby a son with very complex and difficult needs was being looked after at home on a 24-hour basis with the support of two family members right around the clock. That young lad passed away and the family tried to get back to some bit of normality. The father was able to get some temporary, part-time work but his working family payment was reduced when taking into account the carer's allowance his wife was receiving for another child with a disability. This needs to be addressed and changed.

The cost-of-living crisis is now worse than ever. Half a million people are in arrears for electricity and gas, and we have the highest electricity prices in Europe. We need a cost-of-living package to be included in this Bill, like the package brought forward in October 2024 in advance of the election of that year. I remind the Minister of what was in that package in an attempt to buy that election. There were two electricity credits of €125 each; a €300 fuel lump sum for those on fuel allowance; a €200 lump sum for those living alone; a €400 lump sum for carer's allowance, working family payments and disability allowance recipients; and there was double child benefit in November and December of that year. That is the type of package that is needed now and that should be put into this Bill. The cost of living crisis was bad in 2025, it is worse in 2026 and is only getting more difficult into 2027.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Social Welfare Bill 2026. It is a good opportunity to discuss just how far we have come from a social welfare and social protection perspective in recent years. This year alone, we see new measures equating to over €1.5 billion and a 7% increase year on year. I want to acknowledge the staff at the Department and the work they do in helping every TD in this House to deal with concerns, queries and, in particular, appeals. We have seen great progress. Social protection must ensure that assistance and supports are provided for people who might need them for a particular period or a particular reason, depending on the environment. It is also important that we ensure we give people the opportunity to seize opportunities for themselves, along with independence.

I do not have time to go through all of the measures, but I would highlight the phasing out of the means test. To see the income disregard increase in recent years from €450 to €1,150 shows that we are moving towards phasing out means testing for carer’s allowance. We see the changes to the State pension, the living alone allowance and also child benefit. Those in the Opposition need to make up their minds. Do they want universal supports or do they want targeted supports? In addition to child benefit, we have measures on schoolbooks, school uniforms, school meals and so on. These are all very welcome.

I know there has been a lot of debate in recent days in relation to unemployment. We have to ensure that the State does the service that it should in supporting people who have found themselves out of employment for a period of time and giving them a hand up to get going again. That should be through employment strategies such as Pathways to Work, and ensuring that Intreo, training and skills are all provided for. That is something that has to be provided as a priority at a time of full employment, and a time when we welcome migration from all corners of the world. Despite what some Deputies might believe, this is a country that is welcoming, and it is running well in terms of the economy’s strength and the jobs we have to offer.

We recognise that the domiciliary care allowance is a very important measure. However, where carers are in receipt of domiciliary care allowance, they do not get a cost of disability payment for those under 16. We need to ensure that the cost of disability payment is made available to everyone.

In the last few seconds of my time, I would ask the Minister to consider an initiative for adaptive toys for children with disabilities. Far too often, these are multiples of the price that we see on toy shop shelves, plus there is the cost of customs and postage. I ask the Minister to look at that as an initiative.

Comment on this

I welcome the Bill and the improvements the Minister, Deputy Calleary, is bringing forward for pensioners, carers, people with disabilities and working families. First, I want to focus on means testing and the impact that has on people’s independence. There are women who come to see me in County Louth and others across the country who have spent years raising children, caring for family members and working to support families, communities and the State. Yet, at retirement, some have insufficient contributions for the full contributory pension. When assessed for a non-contributory pension, household means can leave them with a reduced payment or no pension of their own. I know that changes were made previously, but many women are still locked out. They feel penalised twice, first for leaving paid employment to care, and then because their partner’s income is assessed against them. A household income does not necessarily give a woman financial independence. The programme for Government commits to a comprehensive review of means testing. That review must address these women’s circumstances and deliver practical changes.

On carers' allowance, I welcome the increased income disregards and the commitment to continue to progressively increase them with a view to phasing out the means test during the Government’s lifetime. I look forward to the further changes. We also need a dedicated kinship care payment. Grandparents, aunts, uncles and other relatives can step in to raise children, often in a time of crisis. They provide a secure home and keep children connected to their families, but can face considerable financial pressure themselves. We should be supporting these families with a reliable payment that recognises the responsibility they have taken on.

For people with disabilities, I welcome the very first cost of disability payment. It recognises additional and unavoidable costs. In the next budget, where the payment needs to increase, we must also examine support for people with disabilities who are working. Those costs do not disappear when someone takes up a job. For example, the lack of accessible transport can mean expensive journeys to work, and the potential loss of a medical card and subsequent worry of meeting ongoing medical costs can seriously affect whether taking up a job is financially manageable. We cannot encourage people into employment while leaving them to struggle to afford the supports that make work possible.

The increased earnings disregard and the reduced minimum hours under the wage subsidy scheme are positive steps. Eight hours can be an important start for someone managing a fluctuating condition. We must also support individuals to return to employment from long-term unemployment. There are schemes in place, but we must build on these, possibly by working more closely with ETBs or Skillnet networks to provide training, build confidence and offer practical support. That means recognising each person’s individual circumstances and helping them to develop the skills they need to move into sustainable employment and thrive there.

Comment on this

I wish to speak as a Government Member. I support the Bill and thank the Minister and his Department for all the effort and thought that was put into it. The budget, like any budget, was difficult because you are assessing the needs and varying wants of different areas. I feel that what we have done here will ensure that people seeking the help of the Department of Social Protection are looked after. We talk about people working, but we need to ensure that we increase the tax bands and that it pays to go to work. We also need to ensure that where there are those who cannot go to work, or where families are not in a position to be rewarded and looked after, the State supports them fully.

We are lucky. As a lot of people have noted, maybe in a different context, that we are a rich country. We are very lucky to be in the situation that we are in as a country. We are very lucky that the Government is in the situation that it is in. It means we can look after the most vulnerable, and I believe that is what this element of the budget fulfils. It fulfils the duty to those people who might be ill, who might not be in a position to go to work or who might need to care for those who are less fortunate. People might also be in a position where they are between jobs, as we know. I am sure many Members across from me and around me have found themselves in such situations at different stages, where they have looked to the arms of the State for support, and the support of the State has been there for them. Once again, that is what this budget seeks to do.

It also seeks to specifically increase the amounts that are available to people. At the same time, when we talk about €10 a week, I know that can be a challenge. I am not going to say that is salvation for everyone, because it simply is not. We know costs are increasing, much of it for reasons outside the hands of the State, and I know that is difficult for those people. However, at the same time, there is a realisation and understanding from the Government side that this money is required and that support is necessary. As I said, that can go from children’s allowance support from the State and right the way from the cradle to the elderly stages of life, so we ensure that people in need get those extra few euro. I think that is very important.

Colleagues across the floor have referenced the Tánaiste’s comments in his speech over the weekend. We have to be very careful not to take them out of context. What we are talking about here is not the people who cannot work, or the people who are between jobs, but people who simply refuse to engage. That is the term we need – it is the refusal to engage. Anybody who wants to get jobseeker’s allowance can get it, and we are going to support them as best as possible.

Comment on this

Social welfare is about providing practical support to people as they navigate the everyday and extraordinary pressures of life. It gives meaningful assistance to people at a time when many households and communities across Ireland are contending with significant costs. In particular, I want to talk today about the increase in maternity, paternity, adoptive and parents’ benefit to €309 per week. While I welcome that, I believe this House should consider how we can further strengthen support for families in the years ahead. I commend the Tánaiste on taking paternity leave and on showing leadership in this area, where it is not yet the norm. We have a way to go culturally in encouraging more fathers to take the leave that is due to them.

However, we must also be real about the fact that even with the increase to €309 per week, many families simply cannot afford for the father to take paternity leave. Median weekly earnings in Ireland are currently €759. That €309 will not pay the bills that keep coming, even more so when a new baby comes into the house. I would like to see us at some point getting to paternity leave of 20 weeks and getting all of those benefits to 80% of people's salary. That would not only help children's development by allowing both parents to be at home but would also help us take giant leaps for gender equality.

I am a proud member of the cross-party group on pregnancy loss. We are making important progress on recognising the impact of miscarriage and pregnancy loss. We are close to a baby loss certificate, which this Department is working on, and the Department of the Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment, Deputy Peter Burke, is working on a Bill on leave for pregnancy loss, which will allow five days' leave for the first time for loss before 23 weeks. I welcome that and I think employers welcome it too. However, I do not want us to forget about women who are pregnant and self-employed and who may lose a baby before 23 weeks. As the leave Bill that is working its way through the House will be for private employers, those women will be left behind. We should look at how they could be looked after within the social welfare system.

On the comments about long-term jobseekers, I agree with my colleagues here today that the Tánaiste was not pushing anybody down. This is not about people who are struggling to work for reasons of disability, health or transport. It is about ensuring that if people can work, we help them to get to work. As Chair of the Joint Committee on Children and Equality, I know that lifting children out of poverty will be easier if families have meaningful, productive jobs. This is about helping people to engage with all of the services that are there to do that.

Comment on this

Social welfare is about providing supports to individuals and families who require them for the period they are required. People are commenting on what the Tánaiste said because the Tánaiste said what he said so that people would comment on it. That is the fact. We know we are talking about a very small number of people. I believe that everybody who is fit to work should work. I could say that if the parties in government had been serious about this over the years, and about putting in the supports for those who require them, we would not have seen them get rid of the job club and the local employment service. Nor would we have seen, at times, a reliance on job activation schemes operated by private firms that did not put in the supports that were required, particularly for those with more complex cases. We all agree that work should pay. It is about making sure that the State, and the Government, does its bit to ensure that we have employment of a particular level and that we provide the supports that are required.

Let us be serious about the cost-of-disability payment. Anybody who has engaged with any of the disability advocacy organisations will say they are downright – I do not know how to put it - angry or disappointed, but this is not what they wanted. It is an abject failure. Too many times, we have come in here and said that €1,400 cut from the last budget, and €500 that will be paid only to a certain cohort of people with disabilities, is not going to cut the mustard. That is less than €10 a week.

If we are serious about job activation, and I accept there have been certain helpful changes to the wage subsidy scheme, then we need to look at the entire set of supports, whether work and access or the wage subsidy scheme, and at what is needed to facilitate both employers and those with disabilities who want to be in employment. We need to put a proper framework in place so that we can deliver real, decent employment. Many of the employers who have used the wage subsidy scheme, particularly those who employ multiple people, have given out about the rates and say they do not cut the mustard. I have had this conversation with the Minister, Deputy Calleary. We need to look at the entire sphere because we all accept that an insufficient number of people with disabilities are employed in this State and that our percentage is far too low. Alongside that, it is about providing the work and access supports, reasonable accommodations, and making it easier for individuals to apply and for companies to operate the scheme because, in fairness, we are not cutting the mustard.

I draw attention to an issue I have raised a number of times at this stage. It is the fact that an exceptional needs payment is not available to those who previously could have got a grant from the council to, let us say, replace a boiler. I am not only talking about oil and gas but about people who cannot wait the 15 months for the warmer homes scheme and who do not have the money. I also raise the case of people on fuel allowance with, let us say, a child who cannot leave the home at this point in time. They are getting screwed over, in the sense that fuel allowance has been taken for a child who cannot leave the house.

Comment on this

The central test of any social welfare Bill is whether it raises living standards. By any measure, this Bill falls extremely short. While welfare rates are increased, the withdrawal of the temporary cost-of-living supports means that many households will be significantly worse off this year than they were last year. The ESRI has said that this budget will result in an average reduction of approximately 2% in household disposable income. Those reductions will fall primarily on households on lower incomes. Those with the lowest level of disposable income will see a cut of 4.1%, while those with the highest will see a reduction of 0.3%. The households affected are those with the least capacity to absorb the additional costs they are dealing with. They are carers, pensioners, people with disabilities and lone parents. They are the people who are struggling with the rising cost of living in this country. The Government points to increases in welfare rates and, for sure, those increases are welcome. However, the relevant question is whether they will make up for the withdrawal of previous supports to families. For most families, the answer is very clearly "No".

One of the major issues we in Aontú have been raising for many years is that energy poverty is getting worse in this country. There are 330,000 families currently in electricity arrears. Some 180,000 households have been in arrears for more than 90 days, which is the highest level on record. That is a legacy of the Government and the actions it has taken. If electricity and gas arrears are included, there are 500,000 units in arrears in this country. That is a staggering figure for a country so wealthy. A total of 500,000 units equates to roughly 1.3 million people living in households that cannot afford to pay for energy. This will get worse over the coming months this winter.

My real frustration with the Government is that it is an engine of the increase in the price of fuel in this country. If a person pulls into a filling station today and puts €100 of petrol into the car, €45 of that will be tax. That is exceptional. Fuel is not a luxury good; it is a staple good. Yet, the Government is taxing it to levels people cannot reach. We are the most expensive country on the planet for electricity. We recently beat Barbados to that infamous title. One of the reasons is that the Government is charging so much in network charges. Every household in the country pays €500 every year in network charges. Just last month, the Commission for Regulation of Utilities, CRU, put up network charges by €40 or €41 a year for every household. The reason for that is the infrastructure is so decrepit we are losing much of the electricity we generate. There are so many bottlenecks in the system and that is why it is costing so much. We still have a system in this country whereby electricity is priced at the marginal price. For example, if it is produced by gas, the price goes sky-high for all of the units consumed.

I want to talk about people with disabilities. The Government has significantly let down people with disabilities in terms of the cost-of-disability payment. The Department carried out a review into the cost of disability. It wrote a report, and yet the Government refuses to implement the findings of that report. It is estimated that it requires an extra €25,000 a year to deal with the costs associated with having a disability, and it is substantially higher for people with severe disabilities. If the Government knows the information around this and refuses to provide the money for it, it is doing an enormous injustice to the people in that cohort. Disability also does not disappear with age, and the truth of the matter is that a lot of people with disabilities have a disability allowance, but then they go on to a pension and it does not help them in that situation either.

Comment on this

While there were increases in the budget and there is no point in me saying anything different, in keeping pace with the cost of living, these fell short for many people. My biggest concern in recent times is that more people who are getting disability payments and things like that are being investigated and having the payments taken off them. There were different people in my clinics over the weekend. One person's disability payment was withdrawn from them, and she did not feel well. The other person had applied for a carer's allowance, had a leg amputated and was told she would not qualify. God almighty, how do you qualify in this country? Do you have to be missing your head to qualify for a carer's allowance? It is an astonishing situation to think that a person with that type of a disability was refused. There is something wrong somewhere. It is very easy to save money or say that the Government's budget is giving out more when we are taking away the little bit of comfort that people have. To be honest, I am not sure if the Minister of State is the relevant Minister as this relates to social welfare, but it looks like he is the only one here to answer questions. The bottom line is that I would like to think that the Government would look into why people in the disability sector and their carers are having their money withdrawn from them and be a bit more caring. The Government promised that it would remove means testing from the carer's allowance. It did not deliver that. It has not delivered it yet. This affects a lot of people out there.

I was at a meeting about CoAction in Bantry on Thursday night after leaving the Dáil. There are adults with intellectual disabilities who have no respite whatsoever. In fairness, I hope to God that the tide is turning because the HSE said that it was providing funding, but that should have been provided. It is putting serious pressure on management in CoAction because they cannot deliver it if they do not get the cash. That is the bottom line, and it comes back down to the foot of the Government.

At the same time, these people, who in some cases are caring in their 80s and 90s, are being called at four, five, six or seven o'clock in the night, never mind during the day, to care for their family. That is an indictment on a country that does not care for its people. It cannot give them a little bit of respite and does not want to give them the carers. It is as a simple as that. It is watching every penny. As I said to someone, if they have an extra cow in the field, it means that their wife who is looking after the child cannot get the carer's allowance. It is most likely the wife who is doing that.

In relation to the pension, while the increases were welcome, and there is no point in me saying they were not, I find that a lot of people are still telling me that they are unable to fill the oil tank because they do not have that money. It is €1,500 or €1,600. It was maybe €800 or €900 a couple of years ago, and they were able to do it then. They are now in a desperate situation, and when the Government had a chance to give them something, the only relief they got was €40-something, so that oil tank is going to remain empty. This is what matters to the people on the ground.

In relation to USC, Fine Gael promised the people that it would abolish it, but they are still paying it. That is a huge frustration for people. It is an extra tax. The previous speaker spoke about fuel. If you fill your tank with €100 of petrol or diesel, €45.50 goes to the Government. It is making a cash cow out of motorists which is totally and utterly wrong.

We need to look after the working people. That is where we need to focus a lot of investment in relation to social welfare in the future. They are people who need a lot of help because they are keeping the country going, but they are finding it the most difficult of all, and they are all the way back from the worker to the small businessperson.

I have mentioned it several times today that, thank, God Cork County Council rejected a plan that Independent Ireland spoke very strongly against to increase the rates by 7.5%. That would have taken out businesses all over the place. They would have been taken out in Castletownbere, Allihies, Ardgroom, Eyeries, Bantry, Schull, Bandon and Bantry. All of those places cannot survive at this present time. We support and understand those businesses. Whether they are in Carrigaline, Youghal or Fermoy, we will support those businesses. Independent Ireland made sure that did not go through yesterday, but I was disappointed that the Independent councillors fell across each other to vote. Is it all for chains and chairmanships in councils instead of thinking of the people they represent? They must knock on their doors in Castletownbere and Carrigaline in time to come and is that they way they are leaving their people? It is an absolute disgrace. These people are struggling at this present time.

There is another area that I would like to spend a lot of time talking about and that is the self-employed. If he is in connection with his constituents, which I expect he is, the Minister of State knows as well as I do that people are coming and saying, "I am self-employed. I fell and broke my leg, and I cannot get anything." If a person is working for someone, they will automatically get relief, which they deserve to, but the self-employed who are delivering so much cannot get a brown cent. It is so difficult. I met somebody in a filling station the other day, a young man, and he told me that he had serious cancer. He said that he had been employed but had been self-employed longer. He applied for something to give him a chance to recover and got nothing.

Comment on this

It is ironic that Fine Gael had its Ard-Fheis in Cork and they spent more time giving out about Independent Ireland to their councillors and Deputies. They also talked about ideas that I am on the record discussing in this Chamber three or four weeks previously. They are 16 years in government, and all they can do at their Ard-Fheis is give out about Independent Ireland, which is in existence for only two years.

It is ironic that the recent poll taken by the Irish Farmers' Journal showed that Fine Gael dropped from 31% down to 6% with the agricultural sector.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Now, Deputy, we are discussing the Social Welfare Bill.

Comment on this

I am going to that, and this goes back to what the Tánaiste said when he was talking about social welfare. This is the man who was talking about social welfare and trying to copycat what we said. I will say it again, and if the Tánaiste is listening, he can copy it again. I have no problem with people in this county who are social welfare and need it. I have no problem with that. As a working person, I have no problem supporting people with disabilities who cannot work, who are unable to work, and who are trying to support their families. I have a huge problem with people who are abusing the social welfare system and who are laughing at the people in this country who are working. I have people who I know very well who have a disability. It allows them to go out and maybe work ten or 12 hours a week if they are able to do it, but they are doing it because they want to contribute. We have a small sector of society that never wanted to work a day in their lives, never will work a day in their lives and get rewarded all the time.

This is why I mentioned the Tánaiste, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. They are 16 years in government. Independent Ireland comes out with this a couple of weeks ago, and it is on the record of the Dáil, and the Tánaiste now brings it up at an Ard-Fheis. Where was he for the last 16 years? Why has he not been tackling this for the last 16 years? The only thing that this Government has been doing is targeting the people who work in this country and making it unaffordable to work - the squeezed middle. God knows, they should get a subsidy for working. They should get a break for working. Two people working in a household trying to fulfil for their family cannot make ends meet and a minority of people, who never worked a day in their lives and never want to, get rewarded.

As I have said, I am self-employed all my life, and thankfully I was given the health and hands to have a trade. I contribute as much as I can even within our own sector. I have brilliant people and their families working with me in our business. They get up every morning to get to work and ask what more they can do to help the vulnerable, elderly and people who cannot work.

They have no problem with that. They will work all day and all night to help them but we have not got one bit of help back from the Government. All it does is tax the fuel we use going to work and if we earn an extra few bob, it taxes us on it. If you are self-employed in this country and anything happens to you, you are a statistic. It is a case of "Fair play to you, thanks for helping". You might have employed as many people as you could and done brilliant work helping communities but when something happens to you, you get nothing.

Regarding those on social welfare, it is about being able to work. We have done a small bit of work on this. How many people out of the minority I am talking about have been involved in crime while they were on social welfare? If they are able to rob people, they are able to work. Why can they not join the dots regarding those people committing crimes? Everyone in this House supports people who cannot work and who need the subsidies but the ones who can work should get off their behinds, get out and help the people and do a bit of work. That is all I am asking for.

Comment on this

At face value, the increases in core social welfare rates and family supports, maternity benefit, paternity benefit, adoptive benefit and parental benefit - the €309 along with €10 for pensioners - are all positive. At face value, they are going to help people face rising costs but let us face it, they are incremental. They are barely going to keep up with inflation and other costs when people are suffering across the country, especially when the supplemental energy supports have been removed. I previously called this budget an inflationary budget that has failed to address rising costs because of taxation measures that have done nothing to improve services. Ultimately, this social welfare element lacks ambition and fails to address the real hardship that some in our society face - our most vulnerable citizens.

Sadly, the Government continues to underestimate the additional costs faced by people living with disabilities so while the once-off payment may provide temporary assistance and is more than last year's amount, it clearly does not address the reality that many disabled people face massively higher daily living costs every week. Annually, that would be up to €25,000 in some cases as some of my colleagues have said. Whether it involves transport costs, energy usage, assistive technology, specialised equipment, medical expenses or personal supports, the additional cost of living with a disability is substantial. We have had multiple debates on this and the advocates for disabled people have worked hard to get the message across as have people living with disabilities that we need a long-term commitment to recognise these costs rather than relying on periodic lump sum measures.

I welcome the increase in the carer's allowance in terms of the income disregard but I think this budget forgot that carers are continuing to save the State billions of euro through their personal contributions to their family and friends, often at financial sacrifice. Many carers remain excluded from support because of the way the means testing arrangements are carried out and they struggle to balance these caring responsibilities with employment so, again, while one has to give some credit, it is incremental and is not enough.

I want to raise an issue that is not addressed in this Bill, namely, the position of women who face redundancy during pregnancy. Across the House, we welcome the increase in maternity-related benefits but I did not see anything in the legislation for a woman who loses her job through a genuine redundancy while preparing for the arrival of a child. There is a 16-week period where these women can get some sort of maternity benefit if the birth is pending but other than that, women face enormous financial uncertainty during one of the most vulnerable periods in their lives, so we need to look at additional measures. Germany has what would be described as the best practice situation. I have put down a few parliamentary questions in this regard and will be examining the responses in due course.

I refer to the Tánaiste's comments at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis where I would say he punched down and went for the cheap sound bite criticising people in receipt of social welfare. We all know there are people who need incentives. We all know there is fraud in the welfare system but I got quite a few emails after my appearance on "A Week in Politics" where I pointed out that due to AI and not being given the opportunities to gain experience, young people are not being offered jobs. These people are graduates and people with master's qualifications but they cannot get a job for the simple reason that they have not built up the experience and after a couple of years, it gets harder and harder and it gets even more difficult to get ancillary jobs to keep things going while they get the job they train for. They felt quite insulted by what the Tánaiste put out there, so instead of punching down, we should try to create new supports for young people because while there are some measures out there, graduates and people who have just done their leaving certificate are not being given the opportunities to gain the experience. We need some sort of a hybrid model for all types of people working in those type of environments.

Comment on this

I refer to two previous speakers. I was self-employed for 18 years. I took the decision to go into self-employment. The tax code was clear and the PRSI and the welfare rates were clear in terms of contributions. It was my decision to take a risk. I never expected anything major back from that system and I think most people who go into self-employment do not have any expectation. They are very clear about the risks and what the systems and the supports the State can provide will do for them. I just wanted to say that because some people do not seem to get that

The Bill is about recognising the pressures that many people continue to face and the true test of any society is how it responds to those pressures and tries to give people some support. We are fortunate in Ireland to be in a position that many of our European counterparts are not in. In Europe, governments are facing difficult decisions and are trying to scale back public spending. In Ireland, we have over €30 billion to spend on social welfare for this coming year, including almost €1.15 billion on new measures.

One of the most significant measures in this Bill is the introduction of the first-ever cost-of-disability payment, which is expected to help over 240,000 recipients. I mentioned this last year and it is great to see it coming to fruition. People with disabilities have extra costs that I or others may never even have to think about. This payment acknowledges as a first step that those costs are real and the State has an important responsibility to help people address them. While it is a welcome first step, we can do a lot more in this area and I look forward to further progress.

We are also strengthening support for carers. The carer's allowance supports over 112,000 people. From January, the carer's allowance will go up by €10 per week and from July 2027, the weekly carer's allowance income disregard goes up to €1,150 for a single person and twice that for a couple. These changes will effectively allow more carers to qualify for and benefit from this really important support.

The Bill also gives supports for parents and families. The increase in child support payments will help and the increase in the working family payment income threshold widens it a bit and means that an estimated 63,000 people will now benefit. Older people will also benefit with changes in the State pension.

One issue I want to raise is VHI fees and charges. It is not necessarily directly relevant to this Bill but older folks in particular worry a lot about escalating VHI charges and we really need to look at that. In conclusion, these measures are only possible because the economy is doing so well. There is lots more to do but I support the Bill.

Comment on this

I welcome the Social Welfare Bill 2026. I listened with interest to previous speakers. I am a new TD but I am totally taken aback by the memory of some TDs when they spoke as though we have done nothing in the past 15 years.

Look at the statistics. I was in business when the unemployment rate was at 15% and people were kicking down the doors of my hotels to try to get employment. Now, we are 1.5%. If that is not a step in the right direction, then I am lost in debates. It is simply wrong to say that nothing has been done. Looking at other countries in Europe, the unemployment rate is at 10% in Spain. In the UK, it is at 5%, while it is at 6.5% and 32% in Canada and South Africa respectively. We must look at where we have come from. Some people in the Opposition have short memories based on the conversation and debate held in this Chamber today. We have to deal with the facts.

The fact we have reached an unemployment rate of 1.3% is hugely positive, but it is costing the State €1.7 billion. The Tánaiste was correct to bring a start to the debate in this regard. He is not discussing people with disabilities, carers or people who have just lost their jobs. Rather, he is discussing the long-term unemployed, namely, people who are unemployed for at least one year. He is questioning why they are in that situation and what supports we can give them. Able-bodied men and women are sitting at home. Is that healthy? That is the question the Tánaiste is asking. Why are they not working? Let us engage with these people, put courses and programmes in place and develop personal progression plans for them. That is what we are talking about. It cannot be healthy for someone, whether a parent or child, to be sitting at home when they are fully able to work. That is the question the Tánaiste was asking on Saturday night. We should have that debate. It is healthy to do so.

We also must look to the future. We must continue to engage on the issue of unemployment. There is a serious fear about what might happen down the road with artificial intelligence, AI. Some people are in two minds about it. Is the glass half full or half empty? Are we going to have massive job losses that will be replaced by AI?

With regard to the carer’s allowance, the programme for Government clearly commits to abolish the means test for the carer’s allowance. I hope we stand firm with that commitment.

Comment on this

I welcome the social welfare budget for 2027. I welcome the increase of €2 billion, bringing the total budget to €30 billion. I note that, within nine years, we have moved from €19 billion to almost €30 billion in social welfare payments, despite a burgeoning economy and an almost full employment rate. Of course, we have to recognise that we would not be able to afford the supports contained in this budget without the industrial dynamo of the Irish economy, which has been nurtured by successive Irish Governments with forward-looking policies.

I wish to reflect on some of the commentary made. We have an unemployment rate of 1.3%. We need to be careful that the tone we use regarding that unemployment rate is one of encouragement, rather than one of beating down on people who may not have the resources or time. We want to arrive at a situation where people who can work should work, but we must also reflect on the last time this issue was raised in 2017. Claims were made of widespread welfare fraud when that turned out not to be the case. In fact, it was less than 0.2% of the social welfare budget. We have to reiterate that our social welfare system is, by and large, absolutely legitimate, supportive and progressive. It looks after our old people, our children and people who simply cannot work due to disability, as well as those people who are out of work short term.

I welcome the increases to the domiciliary care allowance and the wage subsidy scheme.

In the time remaining to me, I will comment on the carer’s allowance income disregard. It has been increased substantially over the past two years. I would like to see, in the lifetime of the Government, the end of the means test for the carer’s allowance. I also ask that further consideration be given to allowing more flexibility around the 18 hours individuals in receipt of the carer’s allowance are allowed to work. We should make every effort to allow people to work those 18 hours in a flexible way without losing benefits.

Comment on this

I raise an issue that is having a real and, in some cases, devastating impact on people in receipt of disability allowance and the non-contributory State pension. Both of these are means-tested payments. The current treatment of inherited shares in Kerry Co-operative Creameries under the means assessment rules is fundamentally unfair. At present, the market value of a person’s Kerry co-operative shares can be assessed as means, regardless of whether the person has received any money from them or has the ability to sell or access them or their value.

A constituent of mine lives with a disability and inherited Kerry co-operative shares. He is not in a position to fully understand or manage those shares, yet their assessed value has resulted in his weekly disability allowance payment being stopped. That is completely unacceptable. One is either disabled or not. These shares are not money in someone’s bank account. They are not necessarily accessible funds that can be used to pay household bills, put food on the table or meet the rising cost of living.

The situation is particularly concerning for pensioners. The €20,000 capital disregard under the State pension non-contributory means test can quickly be exceeded when the market value of these shares is assessed and added to even modest personal savings. People who have worked hard or inherited a small shareholding should not find themselves penalised or potentially deprived of essential social welfare support. Every pensioner looks forward to receiving their pension. To deprive them of that is sinful. At the very least, they should receive a partial payment.

There is also the question of taxation if those shares are sold. Tax liabilities may arise, meaning the individual will not receive the full market value that is being attributed to them in the means assessment. I ask the Minister of State to urgently review this approach. At an absolute minimum, the value assessed should take account of the tax payable on disposal. However, a fairer and more practical approach would be to assess the actual dividend income received from these shares, rather than their total theoretical market value. People with disabilities and older people should not be left without essential supports because of shares they may have inherited but cannot readily access. The Minister must address this anomaly and ensure the social welfare system treats these people fairly. The current system is an attack on our elderly and those with a disability. I ask the Minister of State to intervene to address this anomaly.

Comment on this

First, I want to publicly put on the record my sympathies to the Minister of State, Deputy Collins, on the loss of his uncle, the late Gerry Collins. Like the Minister of State, he was a man who gave a great contribution to politics, both locally and nationally, for many years. He should be respected, and so should the Minister of State. He is an awful loss to you all.

Turning now to this important issue, the work that has been done and is continuing to be done by the Government on the carer’s allowance and the means test is important. Over the past two budgets, more and more people have been able to come into the net, as I call it, and qualify for the carer’s allowance. We have to get to that stage for every person who is caring for someone. The strict means testing that was in place meant that people who were providing care were still not entitled to get the allowance. That was wrong. These people are doing a great service to their communities and families by taking care of relatives and, indeed, people who are not related to them at all. That is important.

I wish to again raise the issue of couples who have been left out of this budget through the inheritance tax. I am talking about parents and couples who, for one reason or another, do not have a direct heir of their own.

Comment on this

I too commiserate with the Minister on the death of the former Minister, Gerard Collins. He was a regular visitor to our house at different times. I extend my sympathies to all the family.

I welcome the increases in the budget to welfare payments and benefit payments, including jobseeker's benefit and maternity benefit. I also welcome the payment for people with disabilities because it costs them more to live. It is an important payment.

I thank all the social welfare workers, those in the offices who help us all daily and those in different roles who help people with disabilities. The benefit payments, so it is clear, are payments people are entitled to based on their contributions. People who work for years and pay their taxes should be entitled to a payment when they need it. I have raised this before and ask again today why it is that those on a benefit payment do not qualify for the fuel allowance. Women on maternity benefit at home with a small baby are not entitled to fuel allowance. It should be paid with the benefit payment as those people have paid their fair share of taxes down through the years. I ask that this is be looked at and ensured.

For example, a pensioner living with a cancer patient on illness benefit does not qualify for fuel allowance, although the combined State pension and illness benefit payments are considerably below the fuel allowance means threshold. It is wrong that those getting benefit payments do not get the fuel allowance. The cost of fuel is exorbitant at present, whether it is heating oil, coal, electricity or foreign briquettes - we do not have our own briquettes any more. It is unfair that they do not get the fuel allowance.

There are 1.8 million additional home support hours for elderly people in the budget and we are told that home help hours increased in previous budgets. This is welcome. However, it is a fact that every day people are approved for home help, but it is not happening because the people do not come. They are waiting for months. They have been let out of hospitals on the strength of getting help at home and it is not happening. It has to be addressed.

I know one elderly lady who is 83 years of age. She was approved for home help in May 2025 and it still has not been put in place - imagine - 18 months later. She is living alone in dreadful pain. She cannot get out of bed on her own or dress herself and is prone to falls. I have made representations more than once on her behalf to the HSE and as recently as 22 October, I got the same reply saying it does not have sufficient capacity to meet her home support needs. This is unacceptable. It is sad to think an 83-year-old person who dearly wants to live out her life in her own home cannot get help. I will initiate a serious investigation into this, to see why it is has happened like this.

The community employment, CE, scheme is a great scheme for workers. It gets them out and improves their social activity. They are generally paid a small sum of money. They do great work in their communities. However, when workers get to pension age, they have to stop working and coming into the CE scheme, which gives many workers a lot of heartache. They have been told they can continue working, but they will not get one extra cent of pay. This is carrying the thing to the fair altogether.

It is totally unfair. No one should have to work for nothing. No pay is not fair. Enough money is being wasted and likes of Mother Teresa are long gone. This is a ridiculous situation.

Another sector that is hard done by is the self-employed. I have been one of them for many years and I know what it is like to be injured or out of action and to get nothing from anywhere. There are people with young families who are struggling to survive. They do employ people and have paid a lot of taxes so it is wrong that they cannot get disability or anything. They get nothing.

The working family payment is there to bridge the gap for those on a minimum wage or low income. It is very unfair that this payment can then put a family over the threshold for social housing. I have come across this on several occasions where families have been thrown off the list because they got the family income supplement and that can put them over the threshold for social housing. It is proof when they get it that they need it to live, survive and put food on the table. It should not be treated as raw income and force them off the social housing list. I have often had people who were on the housing list for nine or almost ten years. They were almost there but just because they qualified for the family income supplement they were thrown off the list and had to start again when the family income supplement stopped. That is totally unfair. I hope the officials are listening because I want this to be addressed. It is totally unfair when people have given that length of time, and often longer, on the housing list only to be written off it and have to start all over again.

I will go back to the self-employed and something that is very unfair. In 2012, a Minister or Tánaiste in a different government promised that she would address this. I will not mention her name as she is not here tonight to hear me. Over the years so many Ministers have promised to do something to help the self-employed. God damn it, they are employing people and have employed people. They put everything at risk to employ people and to work but when they come a cropper for an accident or something that puts them out of commission, they still do not qualify for an illness benefit payment or something of that kind. It might be 12 months before they qualify for any payment of any kind.

There are things we welcome in the budget but there was something that gave a lot of insult to me and a lot of people: €3 extra a week for people on the living alone allowance. That is neither here nor there, as I said at the time. It would not buy a cup of tea or a bar of chocolate. It would have been better not to mention it at all because it insulted so many people. An extra €3 is a very small amount for people who have been waiting for something a long time.

Comment on this