Toll Charges and the Cost of Living: Motion [Private Members]
Sinn Féin called for the proposed January 2027 toll increases to be stopped, arguing they would deepen cost-of-living pressures on commuters, families and businesses, especially where public transport is not a viable alternative. Deputies criticised long-term PPP contracts, private operators’ profits and tolls that have not eased congestion. Transport Minister Darragh O’Brien said tolls are set by TII under existing rules and contracts, and that revenue helps fund road maintenance; he moved an amendment highlighting government supports and planned transport investment. No outcome on the motion is reported in this section.
I move:
That Dáil Éireann:
recognises that:
— there are 11 toll roads in operation across the State, ten of which are on the national roads network, with two of these being in full public ownership, and eight roads across the State are tolled under Public Private Partnerships (PPP), with the Minister for Transport holding responsibility for overall policy and funding in relation to the National Roads 2040 programme;
— households and workers across the State continue to face significant cost of living pressures, including the rising costs of rent, energy, food, insurance and transport;
— motorists are already facing substantial financial pressures arising from fuel prices, motor insurance, motor tax, vehicle maintenance and existing toll charges;
— for many workers and families, particularly those living in rural areas and communities with limited public transport, travelling by car is a necessity rather than a choice;
— toll charges represent an additional financial burden on workers who rely on the national road network to travel to and from employment, education and essential services;
— further increases in toll charges in January 2027, would add to the cumulative financial pressures facing motorists and households; and
— annual increases in carbon taxes, which have been implemented by the Government since 2020, and are set out to 2030, have raised the price of motor fuels, with the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance holding overall responsibility for tax policy;
notes that:
— private toll companies have recorded millions of euros in after tax profits in the past year, and these profits are growing to record levels;
— the existing gold-plated PPP contracts, that permit toll increases and generous traffic guarantee payments, are a legacy of bad economic policy choices and decisions made by successive Fianna Fáil led Governments, while workers who depend on tolled roads for their daily commute incur significant annual costs, simply to travel to and from work;
— motorists are being charged higher tolls year-on-year for roads that are growing increasingly congested;
— new data has shown that hiked tolls on the M50 motorway have done nothing to reduce congestion since the new toll regime began, meaning this is another punitive measure from a Government that punishes people because they have failed to provide any alternative;
— families should not face additional transport costs at a time when household budgets remain under considerable pressure;
— the Government has a responsibility to consider the cumulative impact of increases from toll hikes, and the impact on household living standards; and
— there is a precedent for this, and the Minister for Transport said, on the eve of the General Election, that toll hikes should not go ahead, and the cost of living has risen sharply since then; and
calls on the Government to:
— stop the proposed increase in toll charges scheduled for January 2027, ensuring that motorists are not subjected to additional financial pressures at a time of continuing cost of living difficulties;
— undertake a review of the cumulative financial burden of toll charges on regular commuters, workers and families, particularly those with no viable public transport alternative;
— examine measures to provide greater relief for frequent road users who depend on tolled routes for work and essential travel; and
— ensure that future decisions on toll charges take full account of affordability, household incomes and the wider cost of living pressures facing motorists.
Ordinary workers and families have had enough. They have had enough of being treated like cash machines, of being told there is no money to ease the burden on households while government after government signs off on price hikes, and enough of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael making life more expensive for ordinary people at every available opportunity. Across all of the issues that come in here, through housing, student accommodation, roads and energy, the Government’s modus operandi seems to be to facilitate profits for investors. At a time when the cost of living remains so high, the Government has decided that motorists should pay even more - more at the petrol pump, for insurance, taxes, charges and now more at the tollbooth from 1 January. The reality is the people being targeted by these increases are not wealthy executives or investors. They are healthcare workers travelling to hospitals, parents bringing children to school, tradespeople trying to get to work and small businesses keeping local economies alive.
Endlessly, the Government talks about public transport options but in huge parts of rural Ireland these options simply do not exist. There have been new bus services put on in the recent years but these are decreasing year on year where now only four new services were introduced this year. What makes this decision even more outrageous is that motorists are already paying extraordinary amounts in toll charges. There is a double indemnity in the deal that was done with the Government because they get huge increases in traffic, profit and income and built into it is the guarantee that with the cost of inflation that will go up and up. Last year alone, the M50 generated €216 million in toll income. The M50 and the Dublin Port Tunnel together generated €251 million. That is about €688,000 every single day. Across the State, toll roads generated about €476 million in one year. Despite this, motorists are still stuck in traffic, congestion is rampant, journeys are getting longer and now the Government wants people to pay even more for a deteriorating service.
We are told that these increases are necessary but for what? They are not reducing congestion and the evidence shows that previous toll increases on the M50 in particular failed to deliver any meaningful reduction in traffic volumes because people still have to make the same journeys. The truth is that these tolls are increasingly nothing more than a revenue-raising exercise. They are attacks on getting to work, on bringing your child to school and on participating in society. The Government is not managing transport demand - it is monetising necessity. Private operators are continuing to record substantial profits. The operator of the Limerick tunnel reports an operating profit of almost €12 million. Toll hikes helped to push profits up by 10% and this year they increased again at a rate significantly above inflation. Let us be honest about what is happening. The increases are not about protecting struggling motorists, helping families or tackling congestion but protecting revenue streams and protecting profits.
The Minister argued before the last general election that toll increases were too high and should not proceed. Now, when he is in the Cabinet he is standing over exactly the same policy that was criticised. He has the power to stop this. Increasing tolls is not a fait accompli – it is a political choice. The Government did it before following a motion introduced by Sinn Féin in 2022 when toll increases due in January of 2023 were deferred. That can happen again. The only thing missing now is the political will. Which side is the Minister on? Is he on the side of the workers and the people going to school or college or is he standing with the operators who are recording millions in profits while families are struggling with household bills? Government TDs also have a choice to continue down the road of endless increases and endless excuses or to stop the toll hikes. They can finally start addressing the fundamental injustice of forcing people to pay more and more for a system that they have no choice but to use. We say scrap the toll hikes and support this motion. Workers and families have paid enough.
I will mention some of what is in the Minister’s counter-motion. "Lies, damn lies and statistics" is the old phrase. The Minister's amendment mentioned that the Government has implemented significant reforms under the action plan for insurance reform December 2020. He says boldly that average motor insurance premiums have fallen by 34% since 2016 but what he did not say is to look at the 2014 figure.
According to the Central Bank, the average cost of insurance was €431 then and is now €655 - an increase.
Comment on this
The recent announcement of toll hikes across the State comes as yet another blow for drivers, hauliers and commuters but good news for private toll companies, which will continue to see their profits increase while drivers pay the price. Year after year, we have seen congestion grow on our motorway network and the cost of road transport increase, especially for those who operate haulage businesses. Following the latest announcement, the Irish Road Haulage Association warned that toll increases will increase operating costs for freight operators and these costs will inevitably be paid by consumers buying everyday essentials.
These increases will have a significant impact on every driver who uses the motorway network. Somebody driving from Galway to Dublin must pass through two tolls, or three if they are travelling to Dublin Airport. This all adds up. These toll hikes come at a time when drivers have seen significant increases in the cost of fuel, insurance and other basics associated with running a car. For many people, especially those living in rural areas, driving is not a luxury. The Minister knows that many people simply do not have a viable public transport alternative and they have to use their cars and the motorway network daily to access employment, education, healthcare and other essential public services. The cost of driving has become a major pressure on families and households across the State, yet over recent months the Government has failed to deliver the measures needed to support households with that cost. When it comes to toll hikes, it is increasing the pressure on families.
Four years ago, following pressure from Sinn Féin, the then Minister for Transport acted to halt toll increases due to take place in 2023. It can and should be done again now. People will remember that on the eve of the general election in 2024, the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, called for toll increases to be scrapped. In 2025, he said in the Dáil that toll increases were far too high but allowed them to go ahead anyway. He has offered nothing but spin and soundbites, promising one thing and doing the complete opposite. He has the same powers to stop toll hikes that his predecessor had in 2022. He must use these powers and ensure motorists do not face yet another increase in the cost of driving.
Comment on this
Tax, tax, tax - that is all this Government wants to do to people. Everywhere people turn, the Government is hitting them with higher taxes and higher costs just for the basics. It is no different when we are talking about travel, whether on public transport or keeping a car on the road. The Government's decision to hike up toll charges in January is its latest bright idea to take more money out of the pockets of ordinary people.
Let us be honest. Tolls are a bad policy. They are a bad way to deliver infrastructure. We have rip-off contracts stretching over 25 years that provide terrible value for money. They are a gravy train for the private companies, while taxpayers are left to pick up the tab for tens of millions of euro. These tolls were never a good idea.
Now, in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis, the Minister, who said before the election that they should not go ahead, is jacking them up, hitting thousands of ordinary families who rely on these routes every day. Diesel prices have been hammering these same drivers and insurance costs have gone through the roof. In the Finance Bill, the Minister wants to increase VRT, and then he comes along and jacks up toll charges as well. People have had enough. It is time to put workers and families first. We should have no toll increases, no new toll-funded projects and no renewal of toll contracts when the leases are up.
For many workers these roads are not a luxury or a choice. They are how people get about their everyday lives, yet every year the Government seems to find another way to reach into people's pockets and make life harder for them. The Minister knows damn well because he is the Minister who said toll increases should not happen, but that was before an election. Fianna Fáil forgot about that when they got their seats. The Minister has the power to stop this toll hike. It can be done in the morning. We forced the Government to do it in 2023; the current Government should do it now. It is a political choice and one that it should make. It should make the right choice and say clearly that people have had enough and that it understands the pressure people are under when putting diesel in the car or paying for insurance, tax or the VRT it is pushing up. Pushing up tolls on people is simply a step too far. The Minister should do the right thing, live up to the commitment he made and scrap these toll increases.
Comment on this
The Government parties have made Drogheda a commuter town. To make matters worse for the thousands of daily commuters, the Government has made commuting more expensive. In the depths of a cost-of-living crisis, it has refused to go far enough in cutting excise on fuel and diesel, despite us in Sinn Féin proposing ways for this to be done. In January, commuters will face increased bus and train fares - happy new year, indeed. On top of that, the Government is putting up M1 toll costs locally for us by 10 cent per journey, which will mean the average daily commuter using the M1 will pay over €1,000 per year on that toll alone. For many, it could be close to €1,200.
My opinion on the M1 toll road is the same as it has always been: there should be no toll road in Drogheda. The gold-plated public-private partnership contracts that permit these toll increases are a legacy of bad economic decisions made by successive Fianna Fáil-led Administrations. The M1 Dundalk western bypass PPP contract was awarded to the Celtic Roads Group Dundalk Limited consortium in February 2004. It will run for a 30-year term. The scheme involved construction of an 11 km stretch of road forming part of the N1/M1 national primary route in the vicinity of the town of Dundalk, County Louth. Dundalk got the road but Drogheda got the toll.
I call on the Government not only to scrap any proposed toll increases but to review the PPP toll arrangement on the M1 and end that contract once and for all. Locals in Drogheda have had to live with severely congested roads as commuters divert into the town to avoid paying the toll. With every increase, that congestion gets worse. The slip road tolls are an additional tax on people living, working, shopping and visiting in Drogheda. We have congestion on roads, packed-out buses and trains and commuters are paying a fortune for the privilege of getting to work.
At a time when my constituents face rising cost-of-living pressures in rent, energy, food and fuel, they do not need the Government to inflict another cost hike on them just for getting into and out of Drogheda for work, education or essential health services. It is nothing but another slap in the face to the people I represent. It is in the Minister's power to stop this proceeding in January. He has an opportunity to show the people he sees them and, more importantly, hears them. Scrap the toll hikes.
Comment on this
The issue of public-private partnerships goes back many years in this country. It has been one of the most inefficient and ineffective ways of providing public transport services, particularly road services, yet Government continues to go back to it. The reality is that we have a well-connected group of people on a gravy train and the public is paying for it through Government contracts that were lousy contracts from the very start. Now the Government will allow more increases on those tolls. The people who use the toll routes have little or no other option.
I went to the airport last Saturday morning. I paid a toll going up the N4, another one going up the M50 and the same going back again, and it was like a traffic jam. That is the reality for the vast majority of people in the country, who have to use those roads through no fault of their own. Think of the haulage sector and those delivering goods to our shops and other premises. This is putting up the cost of delivery, which puts up the price of supplies the public has to buy.
All of this is an inflationary gravy train that continues to make it less affordable for people to live. That is the reality most people are encountering as they go about their daily lives. The cost of fuel, housing, rent and everything is going up and up. All these small things make a big difference. When they are added together, they put huge pressure on ordinary working families who are struggling to survive.
The Minister needs to ensure these toll increases do not go ahead, stand by what he said before the last election and recognise where people are. Ordinary workers and people doing their best to survive and manage in our economy need a break. The Minister needs to give them that break by ensuring these toll charges do not go ahead so we have a chance of seeing some relief for ordinary working people and those delivering goods the length and breadth of the country, whether hauliers or the small white vans that deliver goods to our shops. All of them are paying through the nose.
At the end of the day, all of this comes back to the same thing: greasy deals done in the background with small groups of people who got a big payout and everybody else has to pay for it. It is time that stopped. It is time we recognised that that corrupt type of arrangement we had in this society needs to end. The first thing the Minister can do to end it is ensure these toll charges do not go ahead and then look at those contracts, take them apart and ensure we do not continue to see ordinary people paying for this corruption from the past.
Comment on this
Families, workers, students and pensioners all continue to be hit by the cost-of-living crisis. Their food, fuel and rent costs and all their bills have just spiralled out of control. Now the Government heaps further pain on the public by imposing transport fare increases from January. The Government is pickpocketing the public. It does not matter what you do. If you drive, you are hit with tolls and the soaring cost of fuel. If you use public transport, you are hit with fare increases. Sinn Féin is calling for an immediate stop to the fare hikes, free public transport for under-18s and a sustainable public transport system that is accessible and works for everyone. This is an opportunity for the Government to stand up for ordinary people by backing our motion.
The private companies in charge of toll bridges are making record profits. There is no argument for increasing the tolls again in January. Meanwhile, in Dublin Fingal East, the Minister's constituents, as well as mine, are experiencing chaos on the roads. The R132 connectivity project has brought Swords and the surrounding areas to a complete standstill. I stood last night with residents outside Fingal County Council offices to protest the ongoing problems with the project. There is growing anger and frustration over the delivery of this project, particularly the issues with the newly constructed S3 junction and the impact the changes have had on road users. Only an independent assessment of the R132 project will give the public the answers they deserve and need. People deserve a clear, impartial assessment of whether the junction is functioning as intended, whether it is safe and suitable for all road users and what remedial works are required.
A major publicly funded infrastructure project should be properly designed, properly delivered and fit for purpose. What we have is traffic chaos. Journeys of five minutes now take an hour. Emergency service response times are affected. Large vehicles, including buses and emergency vehicles, cannot navigate the turns. Public infrastructure should make journeys safer and more efficient, not create additional problems and uncertainty. There must be proper scrutiny and accountability.
The people of Dublin Fingal East are struggling to pay their bills without increased costs in fares and tolls, while the Minister for Transport, who is also a local Minister, does not, as I understand it, pay tolls for his ministerial car. Perhaps the Minister will confirm that for the House. Sinn Féin calls on the Government to develop affordable alternatives and improve transport investment, not impose additional charges and chaos on road users. The Minister can and must scrap the toll increases.
Comment on this
I represent the youngest constituency in the State, the constituency with the fastest-growing population. Unfortunately, our transport options are not growing in line with the population. The Minister will know that very well if he ever tries to get on a DART or a train, because they are already overcrowded by the time they reach my constituency.
My constituency has not been well served by successive Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Governments. This means that for work, for third level education and to go to hospital, we must leave the constituency. There is no primary care centre, no hospital in my area and no college or university. We remain underemployed. The people I represent have to leave in the morning. What do they do? They go for the train or the bus. What is the Government's answer to that? It is going to jack up the cost of public transport on 1 January by 15%, in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis. Public transport then becomes unaffordable or, indeed, people cannot get on one of the disappearing buses or find space on one of the overcrowded trains, so they get into their cars. No matter which way they drive, they are getting caught by the Government jacking up the cost of the tolls. If they turn to the right when they come out, they go up towards Drogheda and they are getting caught. They go across the M50 and they are getting caught. They go down the port tunnel and are getting caught. The Government is getting them in every way. I have written down that they are getting squeezed, but in fact they are getting screwed every which way by the Government. It is not funny. It really is not. It is very serious for people. They are facing very real choices in the cost-of-living crisis. Jesus Christ knows we would not expect much from the Government, but the very least a government could do, if it were listening in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis, is just not make things worse. People are already struggling to get to the end of the week. They got nothing in the budget, absolutely nothing. The vast majority of working people will either be status quo ante or worse off as a direct result. They are now facing the Government jacking up the cost of using the car and the cost of taking public transport from 1 January. Happy new year to them. What does the Minister want them to do? The Government has no policy that gives them the right to work from home. What does the Minister propose that they do? Where are they supposed to make the cuts? Perhaps the Minister will address that in his remarks.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
To delete all words after "Dáil Éireann" and substitute the following:
"notes that:
— over the last 25 years, an extensive motorway network has been built across the State, development of which depended on the use of Public Private Partnerships (PPP);
— toll revenue provides a significant contribution to the maintenance and improvement of the national road network, and it is expected that approximately €282 million in revenue will contribute to the Transport Infrastructure Ireland (TII) investment in the network in 2026;
— the absence of toll revenue would leave a shortfall in maintenance and improvement budgets that would need to be met by the Exchequer, and by extension, the taxpayer;
— the impact of inflation, driven by a number of factors, including supply chain disruptions resulting from the geopolitical situation, energy costs and labour shortages, has had a particular impact on the cost of civil works, such as pavement restoration and other measures to safeguard our national road network;
— the setting of tolls is not at the discretion of the Minister for Transport, but is an annual process undertaken by TII, that takes place in accordance with formulas which are set out in the bye-laws for each toll scheme, with long-term contracts in place for the PPP schemes;
— the Government has delivered one of the largest support packages in the European Union per head capita, amounting to over €1.7 billion in supports from March 2026 to June 2027, to assist households and businesses;
— excise reductions have been extended in full until end of February 2027, thereby maintaining until then a 30 cent per litre reduction in diesel, and 25 cent per litre reduction in petrol;
— the carbon tax increase on auto fuels due to take place on 14th October, 2026, has been deferred until 1st May, 2027;
— motor tax rates have remained unchanged since January 2021, and motor tax receipts per vehicle are in fact in long term decline;
— the Government has implemented significant reforms under the Action Plan for Insurance Reform - December 2020, including the establishment of the Office to Promote Competition in the Insurance Market (OPCIM), rebalancing the duty of care, enhanced data transparency from the National Claims Information Database (NCID), the reform of the Injuries Resolution Board (formerly PIAB), and the introduction of the Personal Injuries Guidelines, and these reforms have delivered measurable outcomes, including:
— average motor insurance premiums falling by approximately 34 per cent since 2016; and
— the share of personal injury costs in motor claims declining from 72 per cent in 2019, to 44 per cent in 2025;
— the development of a more competitive insurance landscape in Ireland, through the OPCIM, has seen insurance now available in areas that previously faced serious difficulties, and the entry of additional supply from new insurers;
— the Government is implementing further reforms to address the cost and supply of insurance under the Action Plan for Insurance Reform 2025-2029: A Stronger Market, A Fairer Future, focused on where the greatest impact on cost and availability can be achieved, including:
— the introduction of a Transparency Code for the insurance industry;
— accelerated publication of the NCID data and enhanced sectoral analysis;
— strengthening of the Injuries Resolution Board;
— reforms to address legal costs, including consideration of caps for certain injuries, a scale of legal fees, and bringing forward legislation to amend the Judicial Council Act 2019; and
— expansion of the OPCIM, and streamlined authorisation for new market entrants, to deepen supply and attract new entrants into the insurance market; and
affirms the Government's efforts to:
— recognise the critical importance of transport investment, with almost one-in-four euros allocated as part of the National Development Plan review to be invested in transport;
— increase investment in road networks and road safety to €9.7 billion during the 2026 to 2030 period, as part of the €24.3 billion to be allocated to transport under the Sectoral Investment Plan for Transport;
— continue the construction of new national road projects, such as the N5 Ballaghaderreen to Scramoge, M28 Cork to Ringaskiddy and the Adare Bypass, and support the delivery of Critical Infrastructure with the Galway City Ring Road being one of the initial projects designated in July this year;
— safeguard the protection and renewal of existing national roads, through pavement repair and renewal, safety improvements and climate adaptation;
— support affordable public transport options through an increased allocation for 2027 of over €1 billion, allowing the expansion of bus services across the State;
— address affordability through the support of free travel for all children up to the age of nine, and the Young Adult and Student Card for those aged 19-25;
— deliver an improved public transport network through the investment of billions of euro in new infrastructure, such as BusConnects, MetroLink, DART+, Cork Area Commuter Rail, Luas Finglas and the reopening of the Western Rail Corridor;
— support our road freight sector, through the Road Transporters Support Scheme and the Diesel Rebate Scheme;
— fully understand the pressures on households that have arisen due to rising petrol and diesel costs, as a result of the conflict in the Middle East, and that it has continuously acted to allay these pressures;
— remain committed to decarbonising our society, increasing investment in renewable energy sources;
— recycle carbon tax revenues, to protect those most vulnerable to fuel poverty through targeted welfare interventions; and
— prioritise and progress further insurance reform to enhance the affordability and availability of insurance, under the Programme for Government 2025 - Securing Ireland's Future, and building on the significant reforms to date.".
I thank the Deputies for giving me the opportunity to speak about the issue of transport, including toll charges. I am sure we can all agree on the importance of ensuring a safe and efficient network of national roads and motorways and that it is vital that the investment that has been made in that network in recent decades continue to be safeguarded. I also welcome the chance to discuss measures that are being undertaken to deliver radical improvements in public transport across the State. As such, I have tabled a counter-motion to the Sinn Féin motion on toll charges.
Deputies might know that there are 11 toll roads in the State, ten of which are on the national road network. Of the ten toll roads on the national road network, two are publicly operated, namely the M50 and Dublin Tunnel. Revenue from these tolls is collected directly for TII by operating companies under contract with TII. These revenues are invested by TII in the operation and maintenance of the national road network. The other eight roads are public–private partnership, PPP, roads, which were constructed and are now operated and maintained under long-term contracts with TII. Revenue generated by these roads is collected by the PPP companies and is used to repay loans arising from the construction of the roads and to fund ongoing operations and maintenance activities. In addition, some toll revenue generated on these roads passes to TII through revenue-sharing mechanisms.
On the framework for setting tolls, toll by-laws for each individual road set out the basis for calculating maximum tolls each year. These are calculated for each vehicle category. TII calculates the maximum tolls for the Dublin Tunnel and the M50 and decides what actual tolls should apply. The PPP companies calculate the maximum tolls for the eight concession schemes and propose the actual tolls that should apply. The mechanism for these calculations is set out very clearly in the individual toll by-laws and is based on the consumer price index. Actual tolls charged may not exceed the calculated maximum toll for each scheme. There is no formal consultative role for me as Minister when it comes to tolls. It is a matter for TII. It is important to note that TII does not have the right to unilaterally change the basis on which PPP tolls are reviewed.
The Irish national road network is now over 5,300 km, of which about 1,000 km is motorway. Since 2000, Dublin has been linked to Cork, Limerick, Galway and the Border with new motorways, augmented by high-quality dual carriageways. Substantial progress has been made in improving the quality of the road network in other parts of the State. It is an investment priority to ensure that the existing motorway and national road networks, which have been greatly enhanced over the past two decades, are maintained to a high level to ensure high-quality service, accessibility and connectivity for transport users.
Many major new road developments in the last 25 years were funded through PPPs, meaning the funding for the building and maintenance of the roads came from both the Government and the private sector. These private sector businesses then charge tolls for the use of the roads they have helped to build. This has allowed for the rapid expansion of our motorway network. A number of these contracts include mechanisms under which, when traffic volumes do not reach a specified threshold level, money is paid by the State to the toll operators. However, it works in reverse. If traffic volumes exceed certain thresholds specified in the contract for each scheme, the excess toll revenue is returned from the toll operator to the State. That is a two-way financial contract approach that has been used in other sectors to encourage private sector infrastructure development. It is important to point out that the only scheme for which the State is currently making payments under this mechanism is Limerick Tunnel, for which approximately €5 million was paid in 2025.
It should also be noted that in recent years inflation has had a particular impact on the construction sector, with the NTA's inflation bulletin indicating that the cost of major civil engineering projects has increased by approximately 54% since 2020. This is particularly felt in relation to products such as bitumen, which are used in road pavement repair, meaning that the cost of protection and renewal of the existing network has increased substantially.
Significant investment has been made across Ireland in recent years to expand public transport services. Deputy O'Reilly will know that too. This includes the roll-out of BusConnects services, enhanced rural transport links through Local Link and increased rail and bus capacity. This investment will increase further over the period covered by the current national development plan. For example, MetroLink is starting. Enabling works will start next year. It is at approval gate 2 stage. There is €6 billion to be invested between now and the end of the decade, with major construction work starting in 2028.
This will be transformational for the Dublin region, with 20,000 passengers per hour in each direction. It is the largest public transport project we will be embarking on.
On Luas Finglas, which we will extend, we have brought that forward. It is approaching a critical milestone to get to approval gate 2. It is a project we expect to procure for next year, starting construction very shortly thereafter.
In regard to the network redesign of BusConnects, we have seen that already. The first two are under construction. We have Liffey Valley into the city and Finglas-Ballymun into the city as well, with further roll-out of BusConnects right across the State.
On the DART+ programme, work is already starting on that. We have started the enabling works on DART+ West. The northern rail line from Dublin to Drogheda, which Deputy O'Reilly spoke about, will see the first new battery electric DART+ fleet rolled out next year, in a boost for people in our area, increasing capacity there as well. The northern line will also see a new Dublin-Belfast Enterprise fleet rolled out at the end of the decade. Already this year, we have invested €140 million from the shared island fund, which has enabled us to bring DART+ Coastal North forward.
The Cork commuter rail programme has finished phase 1 and we are embarking on phase 2. Phase 1 provided new platforms at Kent Station, signalling and double-tracking works, all of which are completed and being advanced.
In relation to the all-island strategic rail review, we are progressing a series of passing loops and new platforms to add capacity and enhance resilience across the network. These works will be completed by the end of the decade in relation to bus and rail services across the State as well. As Deputies will know because I have said it publicly, next year will see one of the largest expansions of services right across the country, with 140 new services to be announced shortly across urban and rural rail, bus and Luas. We have also seen one of the first major recommendations of the rail review progressed, with the reinstatement of the western rail corridor from Claremorris to Athenry. This project will significantly enhance regional connectivity in the west.
Taken together, this is a very ambitious programme, one that is absolutely needed. One in every €4 in the national development plan, NDP, is being invested in transport, or €24.25 billion between now and the end of the decade.
Not to be too parochial, but Deputy Graves mentioned two things. One was in relation to tolls. I pay tolls when I drive my own car. If a Garda car drives on toll roads, it is, like other services, exempt from paying them and the Deputy knows that. I pay tolls myself. Let us be clear on that. Second, the scheme that has been referenced with regard to the R132 works is a local authority scheme that has been passed by the local authority. It is not part of the MetroLink enabling works. I saw a colleague of the Deputy's and mine making that pronouncement yesterday on social media - not the Deputy. However, we need to ensure that the major transport projects we are looking to deliver across road and rail are actually delivered and we are embarking on a significant phase. We are getting into construction on projects that have been spoken about for a long time. I campaigned on the basis that MetroLink would be delivered and I am going to deliver it. We are going to start it. On Luas Finglas - I see Deputy Ellis sitting beside the Deputy - I said we brought that forward, and further investment in our rail network right the way across the country, as I have outlined there. I refer to things like the delivery of the Galway ring road, which many opposed as well. Work will now be able to commence on that.
These are welcome things. We have a growing population, with 1.5 million people more than we had in 1990, 1 million more cars than we had in 1990, and over 1 million more homes in this country as well. Yes, there are unquestionably areas where there is congestion, but the answer to that is not just more roads like the M50. The answer to that is to improve public transport. That is why every €1 in every €4 being invested under the national development plan is going into transport, with more than ever going into public transport services. Yes, they do need to improve - no one is disputing that - but they are in places. They will improve further through the delivery of very significant projects such as MetroLink.
On Cork Luas, the preferred route is out. It is another scheme that we will commence as well, so the plan is there and is now in implementation. I mentioned DART+ West; I am also going to bring DART+ South West forward. I will be bringing both of those to Cabinet very shortly at approval gate 2. We have already started the compulsory purchase order, CPO, work on lands in that area, too. This is a major expansion of our DART network and that is where the answer is. Investment does need to still continue on our roads to make sure they are maintained to a safe standard, and that is what I intend to do.
Comment on this
Motorways are not a luxury. They are essential public infrastructure. They get people to work, hospital appointments, everyday requirements and home to their families. Motorways keep the entire State moving. They are designed to make our daily lives easier. They should not be treated as a cash cow to drain more money from ordinary people and workers but, in January, that is exactly what the Minister will do, drain more money out of people's pockets.
Fuel is already too high, running a car is already too expensive, but the Minister does not mind because the Government is raking in increased tax revenue. Increasing toll fees is nothing short of another tax on ordinary people, a tax that penalises workers, families and commuters who have no realistic alternative but to drive.
Across Carlow and Kilkenny, since the Government came to power, it has dismantled and reduced people's access to public transport, forcing them back onto the roads. I am speaking about the Expressway route 4. It should be noted that the same Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael TDs who will be voting for these price hikes on ordinary people receive a general travel allowance as TDs to cover their travel. While Ministers are driven around in ministerial cars, never needing to put their hands in their pockets to get to work, the vast majority of people across Ireland do not have this luxury, yet the Minister has decided they ain't paying enough.
It is important that we address the fact that many of these tolls are locked into public-private partnership deals that have operated with little to no transparency or accountability. Why is there such resistance to carrying out a value-for-money assessment on these deals? Taxpayers deserve to know whether these deals are delivering good value for the State or are simply another sweetheart deal for the private sector thanks to Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.
At a time when so many workers and families are struggling, the Government needs to do more than just listen. It needs to act.
Comment on this
In the budget just gone, many of us on this side of the House stood up and called out the Government's so-called tax plan, where the majority of workers received €200 a year, or less than €5 a week. We said at the time, and we have been proved right, that this increase would be wiped out even before workers got it. Mortgages, rents, groceries, insurance, petrol, diesel and school transport are up. I received an email from a number of parents over the last number of days who are very concerned about the 100% increase they are now paying for school transport. Now it is tolls. There is no end to what this Government will do to increase the burden on people. The Government should be there to protect people during a cost-of-living crisis and in most instances I have referenced, it can do more. In fact, in some of these areas, it is the Government increasing the charges, whether it is school transport or tolls.
I am from the Waterford constituency, as the Minister knows. If he comes across the toll bridge in Waterford and is going to Limerick, I ask him to take that drive and pass through all of the towns and villages he has to pass through to get to Limerick. We talk about regional connectivity. It is absolutely disgraceful, yet that road is not being properly funded. In fact, that scheme has been stalled, even though preferred routes are out. It is the same for the N25 to Cork. You get stuck in Killeagh, Castlemartyr and other towns and villages. We have been screaming at the Government to fund these schemes for years. The funding does not come, yet the Government is able to increase toll charges on people during a cost-of-living crisis.
It is unacceptable. The Minister did not address those issues in his own contribution at all. He went all around the houses and talked about anything and everything but those toll increases. The reality is that he is justifying them.
Comment on this
Let us be clear: the reason these toll hikes will raise more revenue is the same reason they are so unfair. Motorists will have no choice but to shoulder the increases. Working people will be forced to pay these higher tolls because for many, there is simply no alternative to driving. How is a nurse finishing a night shift, a carer travelling between houses or a tradesperson carrying tools supposed to get about their day without using a car?
These toll hikes are taking money straight from the pockets of hard-pressed workers and funnelling it straight into Government coffers. It is disgraceful when the Taoiseach defends increases in public transport fares by claiming that the Government cannot fund everything forever. No doubt the same argument will be used when it comes to these, but when it comes to the wealthiest in society, the Government has no difficulty finding money indefinitely to fund sweetheart tax arrangements for vulture funds, the banks and big landlords.
When the Government goes looking for money, does it ever ask itself about those particular sweetheart tax deals? Why do we not change them? No, of course it does not. It is a question that we raise all the time with the Minister. Instead, what the Government chooses to do tonight is to put more pressure on hardworking ordinary people. It is more pressure on people who already cannot make ends meet. It is more pressure on those people who have no other choice but to commute to work. What is the Government saying to them? It is saying tough luck and that they will have to shoulder these increases in the tolls. The people will have to shoulder these increases because the Government is not going to do anything about it, but it is okay, we will find the money when it comes to the vulture funds, the banks and the big developers. That is not on.
Comment on this
It beggars belief that we must bring a motion like this forward tonight. Does this Government have any thought or concern for the people across my own county of Wexford and across the country who find themselves battling with this cost-of-living crisis, mostly caused by successive bad decisions by the Government? This is at a time when the ordinary person and families are struggling as they try to get by from week to week, and some day to day. The cost of living has put the people of Ireland to the pin of their collars. The cost of food, heating oil, electricity and other facets of life has increased.
On top of all that, the cost of driving has more than doubled, with petrol and diesel prices well over the €2 mark. Did the Government ever consider the cause and effect this proposed toll increase will have? All goods are delivered by truck, van or rail to the internal market. If the Government increases the price of petrol and diesel and now toll prices, as sure as night follows day, the price of consumer and perishable goods will increase too, hitting ordinary people in the pocket and making it harder for SMEs and small farm producers to operate on already tight margins, while coping with the highest energy fuel rates in Europe.
At the same time, the Government is taking it in on the tolls. Approximately €600,000 a day is made from the M50. When you add the Dublin Port tunnel, this figure goes to a whopping €680,000 per day. This does not include collecting 23% VAT on public-private partnership, PPP, road schemes, averaging €45,753 per day. Before the last general election, the Minister said there should be no toll increases. How can the Minister justify increasing these tolls? It is literally highway robbery. The only thing missing is a sign stating "Stand and deliver". Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil always claim they are for business. These toll increases are anti-business, anti-family and will hit the working man and woman once again where it really hurts - in their pockets - while the Government and private contractors line their pockets.
Comment on this
Further toll increases from 1 January 2027 are another financial blow to motorists and households already struggling with the rising cost of living. At a time when families are dealing with increasing grocery bills, electricity and heating costs, insurance premiums, mortgage repayments, rent and childcare expenses, another increase in the cost of travelling to work places another financial burden on families. Thousands of workers depend on these roads every day to get to their jobs, transport their children, attend medical appointments and carry out essential daily activities. The cumulative effect of these increases over time in fuel and transport costs and toll charges have a negative impact, not just on the motorists or the commuter, but also on a family's household budget. Haulage businesses and those involved in deliveries, construction and distribution will be affected as well as operating costs increase.
These costs will most likely be passed on to the consumer. The self-employed and small business owner will be particularly exposed as they have less ability to absorb such additional costs. Rural communities will be adversely affected as they have fewer alternatives with regard to public transport options. For many driving, it is often the only realistic way to get to work, access essential services or travel into the city, and will remain so until there is a vast improvement in public transport. We have been waiting for years for both the Luas Finglas and the MetroLink to be built. Until such services are provided, people will continue to rely on their cars for transport.
The M50, which borders my constituency of Dublin North-West, on any given day, especially during peak road usage hours in the mornings and the evenings, looks more like a car park than a motorway. People are now expected to pay more for the privilege of sitting in their car on a motorway that cannot cope with the current numbers using it, resulting in increased vehicular queuing and longer trip times.
Comment on this
Before I call Deputy Farrelly, I will ask the Minister to formally move his amendment.
Comment on this
I moved it in my earlier contribution.
Comment on this
I thank Sinn Féin for the opportunity to discuss this motion this evening. It is a motion that simply asks this Government to wake up and stop saying one thing while facilitating another. Toll increases, as we know, are the latest hit to land on commuters, businesses and families. The cost of groceries in Ireland is the third most expensive in the EU. We have the highest household electricity prices in the EU. We have the highest non-household electricity prices in the EU. We have experienced the highest volatility in home heating oil prices in the EU. The cost of rent in Dublin is the highest and most expensive of capital cities in the EU. We have among the highest childcare fees in the EU. What a record.
Our Tánaiste and Minister for Finance is trying desperately hard to distract us and distract the Irish people from turmoil within his own party and friction within his own coalition. He is trying a sleight of hand magic trick which takes our minds off the dismal performance of this Government on the cost of living, housing, healthcare, education, disability supports and public transport. Quite frankly, it is impossible to see where this Government is succeeding. The Tánaiste is distracting us by kick-starting a debate which he knows has no policy future but turns the societal discourse away from him, away from industrial action in the public sector, work to rule in An Garda Síochána, upheaval in our courts and places scrutiny on those receiving long-term unemployment payments. He has form for this, of course. Not too long ago, he managed to blame asylum seekers for the housing crisis in this country. He has decided yet again to beat down on those who are marginalised.
Ideology is a big word to play with in this House, but it matters. Just like the issue of our tolls and the issues facing our communities throughout the country, Government ideology believes that the private market will provide the solution and save the day. The private market owns the majority of the tolls in the country. When it comes to the toll increases coming in January, ordinary road users will be punished twice for every toll increase - once as they drive through the toll and second for the prices in the supermarket. TII has told us that the toll increases cannot go beyond inflation, but it is a bit of a chicken-and-egg situation because the Irish Road Haulage Association has stated increasing toll charges will just lead to an increase in food costs on our supermarket shelves. Essentially, the private companies and private international investor funds will reap the rewards of revenue collected from our tolls until the year 2052 in some cases, with a guarantee of being able to increase costs baked in annually. This Government yet again outsources responsibility. We pay for that privilege. The companies make the profits and we underwrite the risk. What matters is the cumulative effect on social policy and the Government's responsiveness to this.
Quite simply, people are really struggling. The Minister does not need me to tell him that. People who work hard and reinforce the foundation of the social contract within which we all participate are barely getting by week to week. They are starting to believe that this Government is simply not listening to them and does not see them. It is too distracted and it is complacent. One must question where this ends. What is so frustrating are the levels of services the Government expects people to put up with while in tandem allowing the prices for such services to increase. The M50 is full. There are no more engineering solutions available. The people are paying more to join a bigger, longer queue.
The Government has provided for a significant, and allegedly heavily politically influenced, roads budget for projects throughout this country. The reality we must all accept is that building more roads for more cars will not help us when it comes to journey times, climate ambition and the cost of living, yet this Government is stripping away the positives achieved by recent Governments when it comes to the cost of using public transport. Nothing is safe. You will get abuse from Simon Harris if you do not go to work. You will get punished financially by this Government if you do go to work. You will sit for hours if you want to drive. In some instances, you will do well to sit at all if you want to use public transport. No longer can this Government blame international events as the reason families must choose between heating and eating. The political choices have been made. The contractual obligations have been signed and the friends on the other side appeased. This Government is responsible.
Comment on this
The issue we are facing here is one of a legacy of 30-plus years of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. I did my own PhD on the issue specifically of public-private partnerships many years ago and it was a critical analysis of this form of privatisation of our infrastructure. The Irish public are now paying the price of the legacy of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael's policies of handing our public infrastructure over to private operators. It was neoliberal policies then and that has been continued. It was about privatising the delivery of public infrastructure because the State did not want to pay for it itself. It did not want to take the responsibility because those in power did not believe in the State delivering public infrastructure. While we see public transport across this country struggling, we still have the same public-private partnerships being used in the operation and development of the metro and Luas. We want to see public infrastructure but it needs to be public, otherwise we are repeating the same problems and issues.
In my constituency, there are people looking for the Finglas Luas project to be developed as soon as possible. They want to see it happen. They want to see public transport but the Government is not doing everything it could be doing to progress routes like the Finglas Luas. There are also the issues with buses. There are major problems still with ghost buses or buses not turning up. As I have raised before with the Minister, there are issues with changes to routes that actually mean it is harder for people to use public transport.
Specifically on this motion, I thank Sinn Féin for bringing it forward because it is very important. Right now, we have a cost-of-living crisis and people are literally struggling to cover the basics. According to a recent Eurobarometer poll, a third of Irish households said they had to cut back on their heating in the past year. We are literally seeing people in this country struggling to pay for food and heating.
What is happening on our roads that we have paid for already in our taxes? The Irish public is being utterly fleeced by toll operators across this city and country. They are being fleeced by toll operators while they are struggling to cover the basic cost of living. Toll operators, and many of them multi-billion euro private equity and infrastructure corporations, are acting like modern highway robbery men by squeezing drivers who have no choice but to pay these tolls. The Irish public paid over half a billion euro in tolls last year to drive on the roads we have already paid for with our taxes. This is why the cost of living is so high, because Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael handed our roads over to these private toll operators to engage in what is extortion of the Irish public every day.
The M50 is owned by the State now but it is operated by a private company owned by a massive French corporation whose operating profits on the M50 alone increased to €2 million last year. The operator of the M7-M8 in Portlaoise took in €24 million in tolls last year. It also owns the Dundalk and Waterford tolls. Who is it? A multi-billion euro Dutch corporation. The Limerick toll operator saw its revenue increase by 10% last year. Who is it? It is owned by an English and French infrastructure corporation. This is why Ireland is so bloody expensive. The cost of living here is one of the highest in Europe because of the price and profit-gouging, and in the case of the M50 it is by our own State and Government. It owns the M50. Why will it not stop the toll increases? It cannot say that the cost of living is out of its hands when it can actually stop those tolls being increased. It can stop the toll hikes and intervene. Why does it not stand up for the Irish public? Why does it not actually stop those toll increases when it could do it? The State owns the M50 toll. It is illogical to me that the Irish State would actually be enforcing higher costs on the public when it could be stopping it.
People are really angry and frustrated about this because they do not understand why their own Government is facilitating them being charged even higher for the basics - for a toll on a road which the Irish taxpayer has paid for already. We have paid for it. Why is the Government facilitating that? Why is it pushing higher costs on the Irish public when it could control those costs? It is not true when Ministers get up and say that the cost of living is out of their hands and it is energy costs. The Government controls the tolls and the fares on public transport. It could control that. That is something it could do. What happened to the Fianna Fáil that used to stand up for ordinary people in this country? It is not doing so any more. Now it is standing up for global corporations that are fleecing the Irish public and own the toll concessions on these roads that the Government handed over to them. What we are dealing with here is a legacy of 40 years of neoliberal policies by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, and the public are paying the price every day.
Comment on this
I welcome the chance to speak on this motion. I thank Sinn Féin and Deputy Daly for addressing the issue and bringing forward the motion. I also welcome the fact that the Minister is here to listen to the debate.
For the area that I represent, which is Kildare South, commuting is a way of life forced on families due to the lack of availability and high cost of housing, aligned with the continued rolling back on the advantages of working from home for so many. As a result, commuting on the M7, N7 and M9 has become a nightmare for workers. Workers are leaving their homes at 6 a.m. only to be stuck in traffic for anywhere up to two to three hours. It is a car park. Recently I spoke to a constituent who commutes from Rathangan in Kildare South to Dublin for work each day. That person spends six hours a day stuck in a car and for many commuters this is their daily reality. Many of those I have spoken to now leave their town in Kildare South an hour earlier just to beat the traffic. They arrive at their work an hour or more earlier than is needed and many use the extra hour to sleep in their cars. Such is the reality of their lives, and such is what they do before they go about their daily job. That is the mental hardship that affects their families more and more, and it is an issue on which I continue to get representations almost daily.
Indeed, the Labour Party and I previously proposed a range of measures to address and help the ongoing traffic congestion issues but the Government simply rejected this. More worryingly, it rejected our possible solutions without offering any of its own or even agreeing to trial some of them or bring forward any of the suggestions.
The simple fact is that many commuters in Kildare South have no option other than to take to their cars because of the underinvestment in the public transport system. Towns like Athy, Newbridge, Kildare town, Rathangan, Kilcullen and Monasterevin have become commuter towns. However, the transport infrastructure to meet the capacity and frequency requirements of these growing communities is not there, while public transport does not align to their work schedules. For example, the first train from my home town of Athy to Dublin departs at 6.41 a.m. each morning. That is too late for the many whose work demands that they have to arrive before 8 o'clock, leaving them with no option but to start up their cars and join the car park. Athy, like so many towns, has become a commuting town for the reasons I outlined earlier. In rural Ireland, rural Kildare and all these urban settings, people have no choice but to use their cars. That is why the toll hike is so hard on commuters. They simply do not have any alternative.
They cannot make any adjustments to their commutes and in a cost-of-living crisis, it is unthinkable that Government would impose another increase on hard-pressed workers and families.
Many commuters are also rightly confused about why this is happening now, especially when tolls are taking in so much money. Since 2023, the tolls have already taken in nearly €1.6 billion. TII has earned nearly €700,000 a day, on average, from the M50 and the Dublin Port tunnel. So many workers are today asking why they are being asked to pay more when the tolls are already taking in so much money.
Many of the plans the Government is looking at to assist commuting lack the urgency and commitment needed. We still do not have a date for DART+ South West, albeit the Minister confirmed tonight that he will bring forward a plan to Cabinet shortly. That is very welcome. I have been asking about the priority bus lane on the N7. In fairness, the Minister brought forward the bus lane on the M4 but, according to the latest reply I have received for the N7, design might start next year.
As I mentioned in the Topical Issues debate I had with the Department, the extra carriages that are needed for overcrowded trains are being promised, possibly, for the middle of next year. These overcrowded routes are the ones where we need to see most of those new carriages. However, there is no urgency being shown to address this commuting chaos. What is the Government going to do? It is going to increase the tolls and put more hardship on working families that they simply cannot take. It is time that commuters and workers got something back from this Government to help cushion the chaos. It is not an increase that is needed. It is time the Government reduced the fares on these routes and put some money back in the pockets of those who are keeping this country going day in, day out.
Comment on this
I appreciate that Minister of State is not in the Department of Transport. I will put my concerns on the record in the hope that the Minister for Transport, despite having left the Chamber, will recognise them. I thank Deputy Pa Daly of Sinn Féin for bringing forward this motion.
From 1 January, someone driving through the Fermoy toll road on the way to work and back five days a week will pay €24 a week in tolls alone. Over 48 working weeks, that is €1,152 before he or she puts a litre of diesel in his or her car. For that worker, the increase in 10 cent a crossing is another euro a week on top of the €23 he or she is already paying and it comes out of the same pay packet as groceries, fuel and insurance. Every increase can look small on its own. The worker has to pay them all.
I support the call in this motion to stop the January toll increases. The Government should intervene and keep charges at their current rates. We talk about how much people in rural Ireland rely on their cars. We should also talk about people who rely on public transport because they do not have a car or cannot drive. A bus that arrives after someone's shift starts is no use to them. If the last bus leaves before they finish, they are left looking for a lift. This can decide whether someone takes up a job in the first place.
I welcome BusConnects in Cork and I want to see a Luas line built but BusConnects is still unfinished and the Cork Luas line is taking far too long to move forward. I cannot keep telling my constituents to wait and see while Dublin marches ahead with new projects. I welcome investment in Dublin. It is the first time I have said that in this House. I expect the same urgency for Cork and communities across the country that have spent years waiting for better services.
I acknowledge the very good work on the Cork commuter rail programme. The people delivering it deserve huge credit. We need to see that same urgency on buses and light rail so that someone coming in by train can get from the station to work, college or a hospital appointment without spending half the morning getting there. In the meantime, the Government has allowed public transport fares to increase as well. The Labour Party would reverse those increases and invest in services that people can rely on. In rural Cork, that means early buses, late buses and timetables to let someone make a connection without losing an hour of their day.
The same urgency has to apply to the roads we need. The Government must get on with delivering the M20 motorway. Cork and Limerick are two of the largest cities in this country. A safe, reliable road between them should be a national priority. Along the N20, people sit in traffic on their way to work and watch heavy goods vehicles pass through their communities. Every year of delay is another year they, residents and businesses are asked to live with it. We need to see the Mallow relief road progressed in its own right. The Government must get the M20 moving and get the Mallow relief road moving alongside it. People in Mallow should see progress on both projects. The Government should get the design and planning work done, commit the funding and be ready to move to construction as soon as the approvals are in place.
Once we build the M20, we want people to use it. We already have motorways and national roads that people can use without paying a toll. They connect communities and give drivers a route that takes them out of towns and villages. That is what the M20 should do too. We can see the issue in Fermoy and Rathcormac. The bypass was built to take through traffic out of those communities. Every toll increase gives drivers another reason to start using the old road again. If more traffic goes back through those towns and villages, the people living there will have to deal with it and the consequence of it as well. If we are building the M20 to take traffic off the N20, why would we charge people to use the new road and give them a reason to stay on the old one? We need to build the M20 between Cork and Limerick, and I am sure the Minister of State will agree with me on that, but we need to open it toll-free and keep it toll-free.
On roads that are already tolled, we must examine a monthly cap for regular commuters and consider removing tolls when private operating contracts expire. We must stop the January increases, give Cork a clear timetable for completing BusConnects and moving the Luas forward, give people in Cork and Limerick a commitment that the M20 will be delivered as a priority and will be toll-free, and give people in my hometown, Mallow, an assurance that the Mallow relief road will progress alongside the M20.
The people outside of Dublin have consistently spent too long waiting to be told what is coming. They deserve to see it delivered. I am looking through the different bullet points in the Minister's speech. Eight or nine of those 12 bullet points refer to projects that are ongoing within the capital. That is extraordinary. If I handed that to a constituent of mine, they would laugh at me and ask me what is happening in their community, constituency and city to help them with commuter chaos, with trying to get to work or a hospital appointment or trying to bring their child to school.
I saw recently that after a Cork County Council municipal district meeting, some businesses in Mallow have considered not reopening after the Christmas period because they are sick of having to put up with traffic that is coming through the main street. We must get on with it and progress the building of critical infrastructure like the Cork to Limerick motorway and the Mallow relief road. We must also ensure that when we build roads like this they are used and =people do not have a reason to start using the old one again. We must also ensure that, once built, we keep the M20 toll-free.
Comment on this
I thank Sinn Féin for bringing forward this motion on the cost of living and toll charges. In particular, I support the call for the Government to stop the proposed increases in January.
Regarding the additional pressures that are being put on families in this country, we are in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis and households across this country are struggling to keep up with this never-ending rise in household bills. The rising costs of rent, energy, food and car insurance are putting massive strains on families. We are now in a unique position where everything is record high. We have record high energy arrears and record high energy costs.
Motorists are already experiencing significant financial pressure due to the cost of fuel, motor insurance, and motor tax.
In rural Ireland, the limited public transport that we have is a significant issue. For people living in rural Ireland and rural communities, travelling by car is not a luxury; it is simply a necessity because the services are not there. Many people have no alternative but to rely on their own vehicles to access employment, education, and essential services. The impact of the rising toll charges is particularly concerning for my constituents in Donegal who have to travel considerable distances by car to attend hospital appointments and access other essential services. That alone has caused hardship in Donegal because over the past year the cost-of-living crisis and the cost of fuel have meant that somebody travelling from Donegal has had to spend extra money they simply does not have to attend hospital appointments and pay toll charges. It is unacceptable that we are discriminated against but we are.
The proposed increases would be yet an additional financial burden on people who have little or no choice but to make these journeys because they have to access these hospital appointments in Dublin. They have no choice but to travel by car because they live in rural communities where there is no bus service that can take them from their community straight to Dublin. They have to jump in a car and drive at an additional cost.
Toll charges already present a considerable expense for rural road users who depend on national road networks to get to main cities and access essential services throughout. This is particularly difficult to justify when private toll operators have recorded millions of euro in profit, and yet the public does not benefit from this. The cost-of-living crisis, particularly the aspect of the ongoing fuel crisis, is having a real and immediate impact on families like mine, among other families in Donegal. Despite having two incomes, households are dependent on cars. They need to be able to access two cars because there is no proper infrastructure in place for travelling. Where there is a bus service in Donegal, we have town bus services that are barely hanging on. We are so far behind what is going on that we need as much infrastructure and help as there is.
Letterkenny, for example, is a town that is in the midst of a traffic crisis. I encourage the Minister, whenever he gets the opportunity, to come to Letterkenny on a Friday and just look at the carnage there because it is unacceptable. It has been unacceptable for years. That town is suffering, and we need as much help as possible. For us to continue, this Government needs to realise it is getting it wrong and leaving rural Ireland behind.
Comment on this
I support the proposal to freeze toll charges. Toll charges are adding to the already high cost-of-living for people. As we have gone through a period of high inflation over the past five years, it has gone up at a rate we have not seen for a few decades, and that has piled pressure onto people and workers, people who are trying to get to work, among all the other costs they have. The problem is that come January, the Government is going to heap more costs on these people by increasing public transport costs. Up to 13,000 people commute from Laois every day, many of them by train or bus, and their charges are going to go up. Tolls are going to go up but some people have to drive. A lot of people drive to Dublin and have to use the M50 to get to work and hospital appointments. That cost is going to go up again. They already pay €7.80 for a round-trip and that is €39 a week in tolls alone to get through the M50. That is a huge burden on people. Before the election, I remind the Minister that the Government halted increases on tolls.
I ask the Minister to look again at the increase in public transport fares in double digits of 15%. That is excessive by any standard, and it is going to put huge pressure on people who are commuting from Laois and other counties. It will discourage people from using public transport at a time when we are trying to get them to use it and reduce greenhouse gas emissions and congestion on the motorway. When going to Dublin, there was a one-hour rush hour in the morning and the same in the evening but it is now three or four hours at each end. That is what it is in the morning and evening. I ask the Minister to halt the 15% increase in bus fares, to revise that and not to go as far as 15%. I ask him to halt the planned toll increase.
On energy, we had one of the cheapest electricity systems before it was "liberalised". That was the word used. In other words, that was before it was privatised and opened up to the private market. We now have the most expensive electricity system in Europe, according to Eurostat, and data centres are only paying almost half of what households and small businesses pay. The Government needs to change that. We have a situation where there are 230,000 households in electricity arrears alone. The Government should reduce the VAT on electricity charges for the winter period. It should bring in legislation or put in place measures to force data centres to pay the same as householders and level out the bills so that householders and small businesses are not paying as much.
To move to health costs, 42,000 people, men, women and children in County Laois are covered by private health insurance. Another 38,000 have either a medical card or a GP visit card. Some 15,000 people have nothing at all. There is a huge cost for them if they need medical care or any kind of procedure. The average cost of a policy now is €1,950 per year. That is a huge burden. It is almost €40 a week for a pensioner and €80 a week for two pensioners and they often find when they go to use the private health insurance that it does not cover the procedure they are getting, so they have to pay anyway.
We agreed on Sláintecare almost ten years ago, in 2017. It was supposed to be implemented over a ten-year period but here we are nine years into it and we are not near the finish line in terms of getting a public system in place like other European countries which have had them since the Second World War. We need to move on that and modernise our health system to a universal health system.
Comment on this
Families and workers are being pummelled by a cost-of-living crisis. We have sky-high rents, high energy costs, which are the highest in Europe, and food costs running at an increase of 5% per year. Car insurance is up, as is vehicle maintenance. Transport costs are to go up on 1 January by 15%, or in some cases, 30%, or 35%. Diesel costs a minimum of €2.07 a litre and petrol costs well over €2 per litre. We have half a million people in arrears on electricity and gas bills, and prices for goods and services over the past five years have increased by approximately 22%.
Increased toll fees are another imposition on hard-pressed families, and a tax on workers going to work. For people in rural areas with little or no public transport, travelling by car is a necessity; not a matter of choice. They should not be penalised further. As we know, the Minister for Transport told us before the last general election that toll increases should not proceed but that was then, before the general election, and this is now. He is now playing a different tune.
In constituencies like mine in south Tipperary, motorists are battered in every direction. Travel by car is a necessity, not a luxury. There is little or no public transport. If a person works in Abbott in Clonmel, Boston Scientific, Bulmers, Medite, Tipperary University Hospital, Tipperary County Council or in any of the general business areas, they must travel by car at a considerable cost. If a person attends third level in Clonmel in the Technical University of the Shannon, or goes shopping or for entertainment at Clonmel, they must drive a car.
On the other hand, if a person has to leave the county for work, the situation is much worse. Some 17,900 people leave the county for work each day, and they also must drive. Workers from Carrick-on-Suir and Tipperary town are hugely impacted by outward journeys to work. Carrick-on-Suir, located on the Waterford-Kilkenny border, sees a substantial share of its workforce leave both town and county daily for Waterford. Tipperary town is particularly badly affected. Out of roughly 1,800 residents at work, only 40% work within the town. Some 60%, or 1,080, must commute to other Tipperary towns but mainly along the N24 to Limerick.
These workers are already under severe financial pressure and cannot afford any more increases in travel-to-work costs. What these workers need is a reduction in fuel prices, a cap on fuel prices and a cap on EV charging costs, which have increased substantially in the past month. The ESB has increased its EV charging costs, and so has Energia. What these workers need most of all is local employment. The Industrial Development Authority and the Government need to provide new employment opportunities, job creation and investment in these towns.
There is no need for these increases. Private toll companies have recorded millions of euro in after-tax profits, and those profits are growing all the time. The public-private partnership is a rip-off, and these tolls should be nationalised.
Comment on this
I put out a statement on toll charges the other day. I said, "Enough is enough." It is becoming beyond a bloody joke, to be honest with the Minister of State. It is hurting every day of the week the same people, mainly the working people because if you are not working, you do not have to commute, but if you are working, you do have to commute. People are being hit very hard. I cannot understand for the life of me a Government that is so tone deaf and out of touch. It does not realise that those are the same motorists putting €100 of petrol or diesel into their cars and paying €45 in tax. They have to pay this continuous tax to keep their motors. They pay for insurance, tax on their cars, tyres and repairs. It is just one thing on top of the other. I would love to calculate what it costs a motorist doing a daily run. I assure the Minister of State it is a phenomenal amount of money. It is hurting people very hard at a time when they cannot afford to put fuel in the car or home heating oil in their tanks, and we know why. It is a huge cost.
At the same time, people are hit in the pocket when trying to buy groceries or pay their electricity bill. There are arrears on electricity bills. About 350,000 people cannot pay them at present and, again, that is hurting the working person. It is no wonder they cannot pay them because they are taxed to drain every bit of blood out of them. I cannot understand a Government that has no understanding of that and thinks that if it gives something in the budget, it has given enough, but then it takes it in so many different ways.
The problem with a lot of these communities is that they have no rail connection. I have often heard about Connecting Ireland. Those words are the biggest farce ever because Connecting Ireland does not connect Ireland, has not connected Ireland and has failed miserably in its so-called achievements. I have to travel 80 km in my constituency before I can see rail. Astonishingly, in the 1850s there was rail within 3 km of me. Now I have to travel about 80 km, 85 km or 90 km to get to rail. That is not acceptable in this day and age.
Solutions can be put forward. There are good operators out there, like West Cork Connect, that are willing to connect people with rail every morning, but for some reason the powers that be are doing everything in their power to make sure that does not happen. Again, I cannot understand that. It is another kick in the teeth to people who do not want to go through the toll bridges and are trying their best to find another way. They will not be allowed do that.
The condition of the roads is beyond belief in some cases, as is the lack of funding. Where is the money going? That is what we would like to know. This is a cash cow of the highest order. Billions of euro are after being collected at tolls. Where is the money going? It is not going back into areas where it should go. I was screaming recently about passing bays on the N71. I do not know if the Minister of State has ever been down along there. Come into Bandon and west of Bandon into Clonakilty, drivers can come in behind a tractor for maybe 45 minutes, on a journey that should take 20 minutes. That tells us there is no movement in understanding the people's pain out there. That is the cause of accidents afterwards. From Clonakilty to Skibbereen, it is the same story. People get stuck behind a tractor or a lorry. They have to do their business, but there is no way for the ordinary person trying to get from A to B, in a bit of a hurry, and trying to stick within the speed limit. They are caught doing 20 km/h or 25 km/h for maybe 20 or 25 minutes and then they hit the pedal as hard as they can. It just shows the lack of vision.
Passing bays are important. They have been promised. We might get them in 120 or 130 years. If we live like Methuselah, we might get the bypasses. Two have been promised in Bandon but not delivered. There is an announcement every year. We will see what will happen. We will have another announcement soon about Inishannon, a Clonakilty bypass or a Bantry bypass. I cannot understand for the life of me why nothing can be delivered. Nobody wants to hear about another report. They all want to hear when a bucket will hit the ground. That is all they want to know and that is all they want delivered. No more rubbish reports. That is kicking the can down the road and a handy way to say, "Listen, we are doing something", but the people are not fools.
The people the Government is hurting hardest are the hauliers. They are in dire despair and they tell me that every day of the week. They just do not know where they will be. A gentleman I met in Dunmanway recently said to me, "Michael, I am afraid to turn the lorry on." That tells you how far it has gone. I just had to take him at face value. He was a cattle haulier and he told me, "It is frightening."
As I said, where is the money going to? I am on the transport committee and I listened to the Minister say recently that for greenways there was going to be €360 million. Is that where the money is going - €360 million for, in most cases, greenways, walkways and cycleways that railroad through people's farms? I see the Southern Star picked up on one of my stories - mind you, it never acknowledges me - in the Dáil. It was about Tim O'Leary's farm in Ballinascarthy. Imagine a farmer being told, "We will shove your old sheds and parlour aside and take the walkway through it." Another gentleman told me the other day that he explained to a lady, "You cannot take the walkway through where you have planned because that is going to be a graveyard." To hell with that. Sure they can all be cremated. God almighty, the ignorance that is out there. They can use the term CPO and they are using State funding of €360 million, which is being wasted, instead of taking away the ditch, widening the road and taking the roadways down there. This is not acceptable.
Talking about EV chargers, we need to look at the ones out the back here because they do not work most times.
Comment on this
I support the motion, which recognises the huge additional costs facing people trying to get to and from work.
There are a few things to talk about in relation to tolls. First, there is a certain logic to putting in a toll so people have to pay for the construction costs over a period. It also makes a certain logical sense that the people using the toll road most should be the ones who pay for it the most. I am in agreement with the concept, but once the toll roads are built and the money is going into the Government coffers, it is a different question. It is about whether the toll road is actually helping people or whether it is just a money-making exercise. Is it encouraging people to rat-run through different communities? I have mentioned this before in relation to my constituency of Dublin Mid-West, where the M50 is routinely congested so people will rat-run through Lucan village to go to Blanchardstown, Clonee, Dunshaughlin or Navan. They will face the same congestion going that way - they queue for hours - but, crucially, they avoid paying the toll. If the toll on the M50 were got rid of or even staggered along the way, we would find people would more likely use the main route.
As an aside, the M50 is no longer a Cork-to-Belfast route; it is an internal ring road and should be dealt with as such. In road terms, we need a motorway west of Leixlip or west of Maynooth that bypasses the urban area totally. That is coming from someone with a green background who thinks we need to massively invest in public transport and alternatives to people driving.
There is such a thing as toll avoidance or traffic diversion or leakage. It has been documented by State bodies like Transport Infrastructure Ireland, which has looked at this in internal assessments. It has planned for multi-point tolling in the past. It has done studies on it which acknowledge that people are trying to avoid the tolls by exiting at one gantry and then going back in further down the road. We have had research from Europe that shows that on the Euroroutes drivers, especially HGV operators, will recalculate routes to avoid the tolled sections.
While hauliers will obviously make a financial saving from that, it comes at the cost of congestion in towns around Europe. That also happens in Ireland. This goes back to 2011 and the AA Ireland commuter behaviour survey. That was one of the biggest studies on behaviour. It involved 13,000 drivers and tried to map behavioural responses to road tolls. The study established that 60% to 70% of Irish motorists said they would change their travel routes and use secondary roads if tolls were increased or if new toll points were introduced on their regular commute. Basically, tolls have an adverse effect on local traffic management and increase congestion. County Cork was mentioned. Fermoy is a case in point. You would think the M8 would help avoid congestion but, as a result of the tolls, people are still clogging up Fermoy because they are trying to avoid the tolls. There is a happy medium to be found. We should fund the toll roads when they are being built and we should make a degree of contribution when those toll roads are being used by more people. However, there are cases where the tolls absolutely need to be abolished at this stage. I would include the M50 and some of the older toll roads on national routes in that category.
Some constituents have called for something that I have heard mentioned here during this debate, namely, a cap on tolls for commuters. I am a member of the Committee on Enterprise, Tourism and Employment, which has heard stories of how difficult it is for young people to get the experience needed to get a full-time job. Often they are trying to work in jobs that are not related to their master's or other degree. They are being discouraged by the fact that it is going to take them a hell of a lot of money to get from A to B and that they will have to travel a long distance. They are trying to make ends meet. They realise that affording a house is a good few years ahead of them. If we are trying to help hard-pressed people, even if the Minister of State does not support this motion, there should at least be a cap on tolls for people who commute. They are not commuting because they choose to. They are not commuting to speed past the little towns and villages around Ireland and gain an advantage over other people. They have no choice but to make that commute because they cannot get on the train or because the bus takes too long or does not get them where they want to go. Even when sitting in congestion for an hour or an hour and a half, the quickest way is to take their cars. That is a sad reality of Irish life. You cannot be expected to commute for two hours a day each way to keep a job. We need to think about the small people who are suffering right now. The tolls are just another unnecessary penalty on people who are trying to better themselves. We need to look at cutting these types of costs.
Comment on this
What makes the promised toll increases particularly frustrating is the way they are being imposed on people who are already contributing. Indeed, they are the most heavily taxed transport users in Europe. Motorists pay fuel tax, carbon tax, VAT, motor tax, vehicle registration tax and a range of other transport-related charges, which generate billions of euro annually for the State. Despite these enormous contributions, the answer always seems to be the same, that they should pay more and that we should tax out of existence those who are contributing That seems to be the approach. People are disillusioned. These are the people who get up early in the morning. We are talking about the small businesses, the companies that generate employment in rural Ireland. They are the ones unfairly carrying this burden.
This burden is particularly felt in counties like my own county of Offaly and across the midlands. Earlier this year, figures released to me by Transport Infrastructure Ireland showed that a staggering €23.7 million was collected at the M7-M8 Portlaoise plaza in 2025 alone. That excludes VAT. That is just one toll plaza. In one year, €23.7 million was taken from motorists, commuters, farmers, small businesses, construction companies and hauliers travelling through the midlands. It is unfair and needs to be looked at. A hands-off approach or saying that it is a matter for TII is just not good enough. The Government must send a message. We need to support our businesses and companies, which create a lot of employment, and those who get up early every morning, commute and ask for nothing but to be treated fairly. That has to be the case. That figure of €23.7 million deserves to be reflected upon. It represents farmers, tradespeople, families and hauliers who are simply trying to get from A to B. Despite collecting almost €24 million in a single year from that location in Portlaoise alone, we are now told that toll charges should rise again. That is unacceptable.
As I said earlier, the Government's position has always been that this is a matter for TII. People are fed up with the buck being passed. A message must be sent to Transport Infrastructure Ireland that further toll increases are not acceptable. People are being taxed out of existence. The USC was meant to be a temporary measure. People are still paying it. It is unfair to continue to tax people to the extent we are.
Comment on this
As legislators, there is an onus on all of us to be responsible to the people who are working hard. For people who are on the road every day and who are paying tolls and tariffs, those charges are now a serious expense. Motorists who drive ordinarily sized cars feel the pinch, but if you are driving a larger van or an articulated vehicle, the cost is enormous. These people are on the road all day every day. It puts an additional financial burden and hardship on the companies that run those individual vehicles. We have to look at this in an holistic and serious way. Along with Deputy Nolan, I had the privilege of attending the Irish Road Haulage Association's conference, where we heard at first hand the difficulties, trials and tribulations of these hard-working companies. We are an island nation. Who hauls everything that lands in a shop throughout this country? It is hauliers. They are the people. They have the additional cost of fuel but also tax, including road tax, insurance and tires. Everything is now so expensive. There are also the wages. It is all an expense and it all presents difficulties in trying to keep those wheels rolling.
The Government and all of us have an onus not just to say that it is a matter for TII and to leave it at it. We have to intervene. We have to be able to stand up for these people. That is our job. Our job is to stand here, to try to make our voices heard and to try to get a consensus that the proper thing to do is to really look at this. Of course, we live in the real world. We know that our motorways need maintenance and that there are costs involved. We see it ourselves every day with the maintenance that goes on late at night. We see it happening in the cutting at the edge of the road and all of the work that goes on every day. Having said that, you have to be fair to motorists, the people who have to travel the roads every day. They are not travelling the roads for the fun of it. They are going from A to B to work. That is something we spoke about here earlier and that we should speak about a lot more. We must try to reduce those costs and to stop the continuous spiral. If the Cathaoirleach Gníomhach had a graphic in front of him showing the increasing costs, it would actually be frightening. I do not want to eat into anybody else's time.
Comment on this
We have a very real cost-of-living crisis. We are experiencing rising costs in transport, transport services, electricity, home heating oil, gas, groceries, eating out and going for a couple of drinks. Our people are struggling. This is an everyday occurrence now. In many cases, people are stretched to their limits. There is a very real and huge cost-of-living crisis.
In that context the increased toll charges are being noticed by the general public. People are not fools. Public-private partnerships and increased charges must be controlled. We need to look at price gouging. What is happening in our little country beggars belief. To build a modest room onto a house, such as an en suite bedroom, you need at least €30,000. Labour costs have increased significantly, and especially during the past three to four years. Buying anything today has got to the stage of almost guessing a price, and this is at the expense of every family and household. The general public is wising up to what is happening. People see it every day. Pricing is being abused, and "abused" is the correct word. The woman of the household is seeing it in particular because, in most households, it is she who does the shopping. We have to bring a halt to this serious increase in prices right across the board. It is as simple as that. I would like to see action from the Government and the Minister in this area.
I welcome the €500 disability cost-of-living payment in the recent budget. We also need to introduce a €500 tax credit for disabled workers. They were left out of this budget, as were those who cannot avail of the €500 disability cost-of-living payment. I would like to see progress on that. It is only fair and right that we look after the working disabled and those who are not able to access the €500.
Comment on this
Thousands of motorists in my constituency have consistently raised two issues with me, and they have been calling my office, especially given the debate tonight. The first is the M50, which others have mentioned. One of the best ideas floated around the House, and something we should definitely look at, is a weekly commuter toll cap, with discounts for people earning under a certain amount or, in particular, for critical workers such as doctors, nurses, SNAs and teachers. With this increase, they could be paying hundreds, if not thousands, of euro a year from their hard-earned money. It does not make sense. It is as if we are penalising people who have to work. I had to use the M50 for my previous job. People are paying every single day to sit in traffic. If the increase could be justified with a guaranteed plan for additional lanes or traffic easing, then maybe it could increase, but that has not been discussed at all.
Constituents of mine who are not as savvy about technology as others drive on the M50. They struggle with eFlow and with setting up their accounts, and some of them have lost their accounts, misplaced passwords or got new vehicles. They ask why, when they pay their penalty, they are not automatically set up again by eFlow. A child might be sick, or they might be busy at work, and they might forget to pay by 8 o'clock the next day. We are all very busy. We understand how it works. They should automatically be set up again.
With my last minute, I want to raise the East Link. It opened in 1984. The original private toll agreement ended in 2015, over a decade ago. Why are motorists in my constituency and on the south side stopping at toll booths? We built this connecting bridge to ease traffic in the city but today motorists still have to slow down and still have to pay. It makes no sense. How much time is being lost? What is the impact on congestion in Dublin? What would it cost to replace the booths with barrier-free tolling? I worked on this when I was a councillor, with some of the councillors who are in the Gallery today. If we removed the M50 toll barriers to improve traffic flow, why can we not do the same on the East Link? How can a toll increase be justified when we need to sort out the M50 car park and the car park on the quays? I am not asking for roads to be maintained for free. I understand that the money has to come from somewhere, but we need to state clearly where the money is being spent and where it is flowing and let the Irish people know that the purpose of transport infrastructure should be to keep people moving, not to keep them queuing.
Comment on this
I thank Deputies for their contributions, for the points they have raised and for bringing these important topics to the House. As set out in the remarks of the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, and in the amendment, the Government is committed to ensuring the continued improvement and maintenance of our national road network. This requires the ongoing investment of Exchequer funding, supplemented by toll revenue. The Minister also referred to the extensive investment taking place in our public transport system to ensure that more citizens have affordable alternatives to the private car. This investment is advancing projects in urban areas, such as MetroLink and Cork commuter rail, as well as in rural areas, such as rural bus services and the western rail corridor.
I take the opportunity to highlight some of the continuing investment taking place on our national road network as well as the measures the Government is taking on the affordability of transport. Over the past 25 years, the Government has invested heavily in our national road network and an extensive motorway system is now in place. The motorway network has expanded almost tenfold since 2000. The programme for Government includes commitments to increased funding for new roads and for the protection and renewal of the existing road network. It is the Government's intention, as part of the €24.3 billion to be allocated to transport under the sectoral investment plan for transport, to increase investment in road networks and road safety to €9.7 billion in the period 2026 to 2030.
In 2026, approximately €800 million in Exchequer funding has been allocated for national roads. This has enabled the continued construction of the N5 Ballaghaderreen to Scramoge, M28 Cork to Ringaskiddy and Adare bypass projects. This funding has also allowed multiple major projects at an earlier stage of the project life cycle to progress. They include the Galway city ring road, which is the first road project in the State to be designated as critical infrastructure. Other projects, such as the Limerick to Foynes project, the N/M20 Cork to Limerick project, the Donegal TEN-T project and the Slane bypass, have also progressed this year.
Exchequer funding has also been used to invest in the protection and renewal of the existing national road network. This investment, which is supplemented by toll revenue, helps to ensure that our road infrastructure is kept to a high standard and that safety levels on the network can be improved. While final allocations for 2027 have not yet been announced, national road projects listed in the NDP and the sectoral investment plan for transport will continue to progress in 2027. It is anticipated that the Adare bypass and the N5 Ballaghaderreen to Scramoge projects will be completed in 2027. Overall, the funding of €9.7 billion announced for road networks and road safety for the period 2026 to 2030 represents a significant increase on that provided in the first half of the decade and will allow more projects to proceed.
In budget 2026, €940 million was secured for the public service obligation, a significant 43% uplift on the 2025 allocation. This allocation has ensured that existing public transport services can operate reliably and sustainably throughout the year in the face of growing passenger demand and increased operational costs. It has also allowed for the continued delivery of targeted fare initiatives, including free travel for all children up to the age of nine and the young adult card for those aged 19 to 25, as part of the NTA's national fares strategy.
In budget 2027, over €1 billion has been allocated to public service obligation, PSO, services across the bus, light rail and heavy rail networks. This is a record investment in the PSO funding allocation and supports the continued expansion and enhancement of our public transport network, with approximately 140 new and enhanced services in the planning pipeline for 2027 across flagship programmes such as Connecting Ireland, BusConnects and new town services. The 2027 allocation also prioritises the advancement of ongoing programmes and commitments in line with operational readiness and resource availability.
In recognition of its essential role in Ireland's supply chains, the Government unveiled a package of supports for the road transport sector in the face of escalating fuel costs in April. Central to these supports is the €120 million road transporters support scheme, RTSS, which complements reductions in the excise rates, the NORA levy and the increased rebate rate allowed under the diesel rebate scheme. The RTSS opened for applications in May 2026 and provides financial support to licensed hauliers, the own-account sector and commercial coach operators to help meet the challenges posed by increased fuel costs arising from the war in the Middle East. More than 4,400 applications were received during the application window. Additionally, approximately 120 late application requests were received during a dedicated late application window between Monday, 20 July and Friday, 24 July 2026. An appeals portal was provided from noon on Wednesday, 21 October until noon on Friday, 6 November to allow applicants who had been refused support for one or more vehicles to request a review of that decision. Approximately €77 million has been paid out to date under the scheme, with further payments anticipated during the ongoing appeals procedure.
Last month, Ministers at the Department of Transport secured Cabinet approval to extend payments under the RTSS for a further two months, for September and October. Funding of €73 million has been allocated to continue to assist haulage and passenger operators with high diesel prices. Applicants do not need to reapply for these additional payments. They will be issued directly to applicants once the appeals process is complete. In addition to the RTSS, the diesel rebate scheme has been in place since 2013 and remains available to licensed haulage operators in respect of vehicles over 7.5 tonnes and diesel prices over €1.43, including VAT. An enhanced rebate of 12 cent per litre is being provided until the end of December.
The Government has delivered one of the largest support packages in the EU per capita, amounting to over €1.7 billion in supports from March 2026 to June 2027 to assist households and businesses. Excise reductions have been extended in full until February 2027, thereby maintaining until then a 30 cent per litre reduction in diesel and a 25 cent per litre reduction in petrol. The carbon tax increase on auto fuels due to take place on 14 October 2026 has been deferred until 1 May 2027.
I thank the Deputies for raising these matters and initiating this discussion. However, for the reasons that the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, and I have outlined, the Government is opposing this motion. The Government wishes to see the national road network, into which so much public investment has been made in recent decades, safeguarded for future generations. Toll revenue is an essential component in achieving this. However, we are mindful of the many cost-of-living pressures that households and businesses face. Therefore, we have continued to increase investment in public transport across Ireland and to provide targeted financial measures to those most impacted.
Comment on this
Coming up to Christmas, many families are struggling with the cost of living. Disposable income is not available in the way it used to be and increased bills continue to come through the doors. The Government, supported by its Independents, needs to drop the spin and look at the reality: Ireland is officially one of the most expensive countries in Europe for energy, housing, transport and electricity. Ireland has the third-highest cost in Europe for everyday groceries. That is not an accident. It is a direct outcome of political choices made by Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Independents in government. They are the architects of this cost-of-living crisis.
Every morning, long before the sun rises, the hard-working people of County Meath are already on the move. Our tradespeople, nurses, teachers, SNAs, public sector workers and factory workers, the very people who keep this country running, are hitting the roads to provide for their families. Whether they are driving down the M3 or the M4 or are looking at gridlock on the M50, commuters from Meath have been hit from every single angle. They face relentless toll increases and punishing fuel costs. If they try to do what this Government asks and choose public transport, they are met with ever-increasing fares.
How can this Government, in good conscience, tell people to give up their cars when it is simultaneously pricing them out of every single option to get to work? They get up early, they work all day and they do everything right. What do they get for it? Many people are struggling to survive. Elderly people are lying in bed under two coats, terrified to turn the heating on. Parents are walking through supermarket aisles putting basic food items back on the shelves because the total at the till climbs every week.
What is this Government's grand strategy? It is to claim it is monitoring the situation. Sinn Féin has put forward solutions time and again, yet the Government simply does not listen and does not care. It is simply pricing people away from public transport and making it unaffordable to travel to work. The cost-of-living crisis is affecting many people. The Government now has an opportunity to support Sinn Féin's motion and prevent the toll and public transport increases.
Comment on this
These planned toll increases must not go ahead. People are already under enormous pressure from the surging cost of petrol and diesel. The Government's decision to add on yet another cost is a slap in the face for many of them. During a cost-of-living crisis, the Government seems determined to make things a bit more difficult for people. Previous toll hikes have been suspended and there is absolutely no reason why they cannot be suspended again.
From January 2027, users of the Limerick Tunnel will pay €2.40. In 2021, people paid €1.90, so the costs facing people have increased. The Government has opted time and again to impose further costs on them. Figures from TII show that taxpayers have paid €74.5 million to date to a private operator over a 14-year period for the Limerick Tunnel. In 2024, €5.7 million was paid in fees. That is €110,000 per week to a private operator. These moneys were paid because of lower-than-expected traffic volumes in Limerick Tunnel. Taxpayers, in addition to paying the toll, are being forced to compensate the private toll road company for the low number of vehicles using the tunnel.
The PPP contracts that permit this extremely generous traffic guarantee are a legacy of bad economic choices and decisions made by successive Fianna Fáil-led Administrations in the early 2000s. These road toll contracts represent poor planning, a total lack of foresight and dreadful value for money for taxpayers. The tunnel, while it is a wonderful piece of infrastructure, is far too close to the city centre and the toll is too high for many motorists to allow it to reach its maximum potential of removing traffic from the streets of Limerick city. It was a poor deal and now costs taxpayers millions of euro in penalties every year. The least the Government can do now is stop the increases for 2027.
Comment on this
Once again, we see workers, families and ordinary commuters being forced to pay the price for the Government's failure to protect them. This time, it is through another hike in toll charges. For many people in County Clare, these tolls are not optional; they are unavoidable. People travelling to work, parents bringing children where they need to go and families travelling to hospital have little or no realistic alternative. What is the Government doing but piling more pressure on them?
People are already struggling with the cost-of-living crisis. Petrol and diesel prices are putting enormous pressure on household budgets; yet, instead of providing some relief, the Government is handing commuters another increase, another kick in the teeth. This is not about keeping pace with inflation. The operating profits from Limerick Tunnel increased by 10% in 2024 following previous toll increases, with almost €12 million in profits being generated. Who exactly are these increases benefiting? It certainly is not ordinary people. They will have to pay more to sit longer in congestion and they have no choice but to use these roads.
Penalising people with higher costs will not cut congestion; it will only give bigger profits to the operators of gold-plated PPP contracts. The reality is that years of failure to deliver an adequate public transport system in Clare have left people dependent on their cars, and they are now paying a tax upon a tax upon a tax. They are being penalised because the Government has failed to provide alternatives.
I find it particularly galling to hear Ministers talk about listening to communities while at the same time introducing policies that make life harder for those very communities, giving big profits to PPPs and big bonuses to CEOs while people are struggling.
What about the Minister during the election? He said the increases should be scrapped and were too high. What happened? Why is he now pushing for these hikes? Previous toll increases have been paused and there is no reason for the Minister not to do so again. Stand by election commitments, do not make ordinary workers and families pay another price for this Government's failure, review the tolling policy and the PPP policy and stop these toll hikes.
Comment on this
TII has the idea, and the Government is going along with it, to give extra money to operators of the Fermoy scheme, income from which has gone up from €11.9 million in 2015 to €18.9 million in 2024; to the Dundalk scheme, which has increased from €23.5 million to over €40 million; to the Limerick scheme, which has increased from €12.5 to €23.9 million; and to the Waterford scheme, which has gone from €5.4 million to €11.4 million. Is it any wonder, when this and the previous Government have abolished town councils, denuded water services of staff, privatised bin collections, outsourced housing and put no State involvement or investment into energy? In the past few years, there has been more poor planning and governance. Commuters pay the extra amount but they see that battery-operated trains are not being used. We see a rail line to Foynes being built that will never take passengers, a shrivelling number of new bus services and increasing public transport fares across the State.
We reject the statistics the Government amendment contains about the cost of insurance having decreased since 2016 because if you look at 2014 figures, it has increased by almost 50%. I reject what it says about supporting affordable public transport options. In fact, public transport fares are being increased by 15%. I reject what it says about decarbonising society when we see no State involvement in and no significant advancement towards renewable energy, offshore wind or solar.
The Government has a choice. It should stop these toll hikes, order a review of tolling policy and examine relief schemes for regular commuters. Workers and families have paid enough and they have had enough. Motorists are not a cash cow. Scrap the toll hikes and support this motion.