We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Neutrality and proposed peacekeeping reform

Summary

Boyd Barrett criticises the Government’s defence priorities and warns that reform could allow troops to be sent on missions without a UN mandate, challenging the Government to seek public approval. Chambers rejects claims of NATO alignment or planned military deployments, says the reform preserves Ireland’s peacekeeping role and independent decision-making, and defends increased defence spending amid security risks.

The gathering of European leaders and, significantly, the head of NATO in Dublin this weekend highlights the misguided priorities of this Government and European leaders. It seems that European leaders and this Government think there are endless billions for weapons, militarism and war. However, the treatment of working people looking for a pay increase that matches inflation is much less of a priority. The same can be said of the patients in CUH whom a consultant has described as being tortured in that hospital because of the lack of staff and resources. Is it not a stark contrast? I do not know how much money is being spent but the Minister might tell us. I would say millions are being spent to roll out the red carpet for all of these EU leaders and the head of NATO, and to wine and dine them in the National Gallery.

Regardless of what happens with the pay increases, workers have had to go out on strike to get a pay increase from a Government that is trying hold back on them. It refuses to give them a pay increase that will keep pace with inflation unless they go out on strike and threaten another strike. That is really my question to the Minister. How come there are endless billions for weapons of war, but we get contemptuous treatment of working people who are just fighting for a decent pay increase, or indeed of people looking for our hospitals to be properly staffed and resourced? This Government signed up to these priorities of rearming Europe. Let us remember that the European Union is the biggest trading partner of the Israeli regime, which is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. It is arming that regime to the teeth, but this Government wants to involve us in the plans for more militarisation. Many of those countries are selling weapons to Israel to massacre Palestinians. There is even dual-use technology going from this country to the Israeli military while it is committing genocide. This Government wants to do more of that, but it is holding out on ordinary working people who are just looking for a pay increase that will ensure they are not losing income and working for less because of the cost-of-living crisis caused by the warmongering of the United States, Israel and many of the powers that want more money spent on weapons. The Government is going to do away with the triple lock and deal another blow to our neutrality in order to serve that agenda. Do its priorities not need to be re-evaluated?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Deputy. The Minister to respond.

Comment on this

The Deputy raised a number of points. As I have said, I want to respect the confidentiality of the process under way at the Workplace Relations Commission. We want to have a credible and fair deal for workers, particularly prioritising the low paid. I am limited in what I can say, except to say that negotiations are ongoing. We had positive engagement yesterday through Kevin Foley, who chaired that process. We want to see a pay deal for workers. A lot of what the Deputy has said is a complete misrepresentation of the position. He knows clearly that we are absolutely independent in our foreign policy and our reforms of the triple lock. Like Deputy McDonald, Deputy Boyd Barrett wants to continue to hand a veto to Russia-----

Comment on this

No, he does not.

Comment on this

-----China, Britain, the US and many others. Why he would not support a reform that involves this House deciding on the independent deployment-----

Comment on this

Because the Government cannot be trusted.

Comment on this

-----of troops to continue and sustain our proud record of peacekeeping is extraordinary.

Comment on this

They do not trust themselves.

Comment on this

It is extraordinary.

Comment on this

It is not peacekeeping if it is not in the UN, is it?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy Murphy, please.

Comment on this

He throws about the issue of NATO here and there.

Comment on this

He can call it peacekeeping, but it does not make it peacekeeping.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Members, please.

Comment on this

We have no intention of joining NATO. We have no intention of joining any military alliance. The Deputy knows as well as I do that the Constitution prohibits such an act. European Political Community meetings are important in the context of Ireland's role within the European Union. I know that like Sinn Féin, Deputy Boyd Barrett is Eurosceptic and would take a much different approach to Ireland's role in the European Union.

That is not something the broader Irish public would support either-----

Comment on this

Go and check with the people in a referendum.

Comment on this

-----in terms of the Deputy's position with the European Union. Ireland's defence spending is set out. We have moderately increased our defence spending in recent years, again supported by the work of the Commission on the Defence Forces in supporting expansion of equipment and a lot of respective improvement to pay and conditions for people who work across the Defence Forces. A lot of what the Deputy has said is just rhetoric and a complete misrepresentation of the Irish Government, which is well respected, by the way, in the European Union, led by the Minister, Deputy McEntee, the Taoiseach and others, in terms of what we have said about Gaza-----

Comment on this

-----and the shocking atrocities there and elsewhere. We have been consistent. We have been recognised in the European Union and the UN for how we have spoken up on behalf of the people of Gaza and elsewhere. That will continue within the European Political Community and all other European Union engagements.

Comment on this

Anybody who cares about our neutrality, opposes war and militarisation, and is concerned about the ongoing complicity of the European Union with the genocide being perpetrated by Israel against the Palestinians should be on the streets at 5 o'clock at The Spire, where we will be marching to the National Gallery, where, among others, the head of NATO will be. Which bit of what I have said is not true? Is it not true that the head of NATO is going to be there? It is not true that the European Union is the biggest trading partner of Israel that is committing a genocide? Is it not true that the policy of ReArm Europe is to double arms expenditure in Europe from €400 billion, which has already increased by multiples over recent years, up to €800 billion? That is not true, apparently, is it not?

Comment on this

That is NATO. It is not the EU.

Comment on this

Is it not an attack on neutrality that we will be sent on military missions - our sons and daughters, potentially - which are not authorised by the United Nations?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Deputy. You time is up. The Minister will respond.

Comment on this

By whom are they authorised - NATO or the European Union?

Comment on this

It is complete and utter nonsense-----

Comment on this

-----to talk about sending our sons and daughters away because of some decision by some other military alliance. It is a complete mistruth.

Comment on this

It is a complete and utter mistruth. Stop scaremongering.

Comment on this

Why are you scrapping the guardrails then?

Comment on this

You can continue to engage in your street politics and your division, but you know it is not true. You know there is no mandate for it. You know there is no intention to do it. Stop misrepresenting the actual position of the Government to the people of Ireland.

Comment on this

Then take your case to the people.

Comment on this

What is the Minister talking to Mark Rutte about?

Comment on this

There is a growing budget for defence spending by many European member states. Does the Deputy know why? It is because of Russia and because of the risk of what Russia is doing in Ukraine and the risk across the eastern area. Deputy Boyd Barrett did not mention Russia. He rarely mentions Russia in all his contributions.

Comment on this

The Deputy rarely mentions Russia, except he is willing to keep Russia's veto-----

Comment on this

Nobody is proposing an alliance with Russia. The Minister is proposing an alliance with NATO.

Comment on this

-----when it comes Ireland's foreign policy and Ireland's position in the context of deciding our own affairs.

Comment on this

If you are that sure, bring the case to the Irish people in a referendum.

Comment on this

It is complete inconsistency and hypocrisy and a complete misrepresentation of the truth. Deputy Boyd Barrett knows our consistent position in all international affairs.

Comment on this

The focus of our reform is on upholding our strong role in peacekeeping.

Comment on this

Put the question to the people.

Comment on this

Why are you scared of democracy?

Comment on this

Even Sinn Féin met NATO when they went to Kosovo.

Comment on this

Bring your case to the people.

Comment on this

Your Sinn Féin colleagues met NATO in Kosovo.

Comment on this