We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Questions in this session
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

We will now move to Leaders' Questions under Standing Order 38. I call Deputy Mary Lou McDonald.

Comment on this

On Thursday, the French President, the German Chancellor and the leaders of other EU states that are also members of NATO are coming to Dublin. Europe's direction of travel is clear: greater militarisation, deeper defence integration and even closer alignment with NATO. It is little wonder, therefore, that leaders and the Minister's Government will be joined by the secretary general of NATO. His presence further underlines the increasingly militarised political environment taking shape across Europe. The European Commission has made that direction very explicit in its rearming Europe plan, which aims to mobilise up to €800 billion for defence investment, including €150 billion in EU-backed loans. These are vast sums being directed towards building up Europe's military capacity and, of course, the arms industry.

That is the context in which this Government is seeking to ditch the triple lock, rush legislation through the Dáil and undermine Irish neutrality with absolutely no reference to the people. The Government's position flies in the face of commitments made to the Irish people during the Nice and Lisbon referendum campaigns. Explicit guarantees had to be secured that EU defence co-operation would not compromise Ireland's military neutrality. The triple lock is at the very heart of that guarantee, so the Government cannot now dismiss it as a technicality. It is, in fact, the mechanism designed to protect our neutrality or, as Micheál Martin said in this House in 2013, it is at the core of our neutrality.

Let us be clear: the triple lock does not prevent Irish peacekeeping. What it does is anchor Irish overseas deployments in international legitimacy and democratic scrutiny.

Under it, our soldiers, their families and the Irish people know that they are acting in accordance with international law, under a UN mandate, and honourably fulfilling their duties as soldiers of an independent Irish State. Tá muintir na hÉireann bródúil as ár neodrachas. Tuigeann siad an tábhacht agus luach a bhaineann leis. Pé rud a cheapann an Rialtas, ba chóir go mbeadh an seans ag na daoine a gcuid tuairimí a chur in iúl. Mar sin de, ní mór reifreann a reáchtáil ar an neodracht.

Whatever the Government may think, Irish people want Ireland to remain neutral. They understand the value of that policy even if the Government does not. Neutrality has allowed us to make an independent contribution to peace and to speak with our own voice rather than following the military priorities of others. The Government now wants to force the Dáil to ditch this key safeguard. It is doing so with its eyes wide open to Europe's direction of travel, with increased militarisation, closer alignment to NATO, hundreds of billions of euro being committed to arms and a clear disregard for the views and wishes of the Irish people. I believe this to be a profound betrayal of commitments made to the Irish people and a direct assault on Ireland's neutrality. The Government has no mandate and no right to abandon Irish neutrality or to ditch the triple lock without explicit reference to the people. What is it afraid of? It should put the question to the people and make its case. Bring the issue to a referendum.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Jack Chambers Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation Fianna Fáil

This is more misleading nonsense from Sinn Féin with a flavour of Euroscepticism, which is what we have heard from the party for many years. The Deputy's presentation is completely disingenuous. This legislative change is all about reform and keeping alive the Irish tradition of peacekeeping. The Deputy is willing to abandon that proud tradition of peacekeeping. As a Government, we are not. That is the fundamental difference between us.

Without the reform we are proposing, Ireland will no longer have the capacity in many instances to participate in peacekeeping around the world. Without the reform we are proposing, our military will no longer have any meaningful international role. Does the Deputy understand that? Does she have any heed of or care for what that would do to recruitment and retention in the military? She needs to be honest with military personnel and their families at this point.

With the illegal and immoral invasion of Ukraine, the element of the triple lock that requires Russian approval for the deployment of Irish peacekeepers became unfit for purpose. The Government will not allow Russia, China, Britain, the US or anyone else to have a veto over our independent foreign and security policy. To whom does Sinn Féin want to give that veto?

Comment on this
Deputies

The Irish people.

Comment on this

Deputy McDonald is casually throwing around accusations about Ireland's neutrality. Of course, she has form in that regard. For years, she has been making the claim that our neutrality is being attacked. In fact, Sinn Féin declared it dead in 1972, 2003, 2008 and on many other occasions. Neutrality is about Ireland's ability to act independently and not to have legal obligations to participate in any conflict. That will not change. If we really value our independence when it comes to foreign policy and defence, our decisions on whether to participate in peacekeeping initiatives should not be subject to the veto of any other country.

My party was clear in our manifesto before the last general election on the need for reform in this area, and that is reflected in the programme for Government. The Defence (Amendment) Bill will provide for the removal of any foreign veto in relation to the dispatch of Defence Forces members for service outside the State as part of an international peacekeeping force. Any modification to the triple lock continues to require the Government of the day and a majority in this House to approve the dispatch of Defence Forces personnel to take part in peacekeeping and any similar missions. The proposed changes are a reassertion of our neutrality and of our right to make our own independent decisions and to act as an independent country. This reinforces Ireland's ability to pursue an independent foreign policy by removing the power of the UN Security Council's permanent members to veto our national sovereign decisions and will allow the Defence Forces to respond to crisis situations affecting our citizens with more agility and effectiveness.

Stop being disingenuous. The Deputy's mask has slipped again in trying to attack the European political community meeting. What is it that Sinn Féin has against the European Union? It is a union that has shown incredible solidarity against the illegal invasion of Ukraine and in many other areas of policy that matter to people across this country.

Comment on this

Focus on the question.

Comment on this

The reform being made here is simply to reinforce the sovereign decisions of the Dáil and also of the decisions of the Government in the context of the veto within the UN Security Council, which is a change that does have a mandate, was reflected in the general election, and is something that the Government wants to progress.

Comment on this

Let me be explicit for the Minister. We will challenge the €800 billion of proposed spending in defence, armaments and warfare. Every day of the week we will challenge the European Union and the Government on that. This is the only honourable thing to do. The Government chooses a different course but does not even have the integrity to be honest about what it is at. Just so the Minister knows, peacekeeping missions by definition require a UN mandate. In the absence of a UN mandate, it is no longer a peacekeeping mission. It is actually as simple as that. The Minister knows well the direction of travel of the European Union towards NATO, towards armaments and towards warfare. We wish to keep Ireland out of that. We wish to retain our noble tradition of neutrality, the very thing that has allowed us to make our contributions to the world.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Minister, Deputy Chambers, to respond.

Comment on this

The Minister asks about the veto. The Irish people have the veto on this and the Minister has no right to ditch our neutrality-----

Comment on this

Sinn Féin Members are the only ones-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy McDonald's time is up.

Comment on this

-----without going and asking for the democratic permission of the Irish people to do so.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy McDonald's time is up. I call the Minister.

Comment on this

We are not proposing any sort of military alliance. The Deputy is completely misleading the Dáil in what she is suggesting. We have no intention of joining NATO. There is no plan to join NATO and there is no mandate to join NATO. That is not what we are doing.

Comment on this

There is no mandate to get rid of the triple lock.

Comment on this

Deputy McDonald is completely misrepresenting the position of the Irish Government, day in and day out.

Comment on this

This is a reform to remove the veto of Sinn Féin's friends in Russia and others. What does it have against that? Why does it want to acquiesce to major powers and give them the right to decide or veto where we deploy our troops?

Comment on this

Is the Minister actually that ignorant or naive?

Comment on this

This is a reinforcement of the democratic position of this Parliament, it reinforces the democratic position of the Irish Government, and we have no plan to join any military alliance. We co-operate with other EU member states, primarily in the interests of peacekeeping-----

Comment on this

Then put the case to the people.

Comment on this

That is our central focus. That is where we have a strong record and we want to continue that record for the years to come.

The Deputy should speak to military families. Speak to them when-----

Comment on this

They live in my constituency.

Comment on this

Are you telling them that they will be deployed nowhere into the future because of your policy on this position?

Comment on this

They want fair pay.

Comment on this

People are not joining because you are not paying them properly.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I remind Members to speak through the Chair and allow all contributions without interruption. Deputy O'Callaghan, please.

Comment on this

There were almost 70 patients on trolleys and in chairs at Cork University Hospital, CUH, yesterday morning, most of them elderly. Trolley to trolley, they were backed up against one another in bright noisy corridors, some of them beside drafty windows, making rest and recovery impossible. On the "Today with David McCullagh" show this morning, the professor of emergency medicine, Conor Deasy, described conditions as tantamount to torture. The staff in CUH are under immense pressure. They are trying their very best to treat their patients in overcrowded and unsafe conditions.

None of this should come as surprise to the Government because it has been on notice of a developing crisis in CUH all year. Staffing shortages were first raised by the hospital back in April. In August, in desperation, the CEO of the hospital Jennifer Kearney wrote to HSE in very stark terms. She said that conditions at the hospital were unsustainable and it was not safe to enter the winter period with the current level of staffing shortages. Instead of being listened to, her concerns were dismissed and at a meeting with HSE officials she was threatened with performance management. Jennifer Kearney did her best to warn the Government of what was coming but instead of listening to her, the Minister for Health went on the attack. She lambasted CUH and said appeals for additional staff were unrealistic.

Now look where we are. Surgeries for cancer patients have been cancelled at short notice. Women admitted for breast cancer surgery, some already in hospital gowns, were sent home. Imagine enduring the anxiety, fear and emotional strain that comes before a major surgery, only to be told at the last minute that it would not go ahead. No patient should ever be put through this type of ordeal. Nine clinical directors at the hospital have written to the Taoiseach to outline their serious concerns. They said that of the 172 priority posts that are urgently required, just seven have been approved.

The winter is just beginning and the pressure on the hospital is going to increase. What will it take before the Government acts and will the Minister agree to an independent assessment of staffing needs at CUH as a matter of urgency?

Comment on this

I acknowledge the tremendous work being done across our health system by staff in all of our acute hospitals, particularly as we get into the winter period, which brings additional challenges and demand. Since 2020, there has been a record level of investment and staffing increases right across the system - more staff, more beds and more services available universally. We have embedded reforms with the public-only consultant contract and many other benefits are being brought to patients and staff, with a focus on community healthcare in particular. The Minister for Health has led in driving reform, with requests coming in for additional spending.

The pressures facing CUH are facing all hospitals across the HSE as we head into the winter period. This pressure arises from increased demand. Between 2019 and 2025, emergency department attendance has increased by 28% while inpatient day case and outpatient activity has also increased. Emergency department attendances in CUH increased by 11% from September last year to September of this year. Successive Governments in recent years have supported CUH. Look at the staff increases and the low overall level of investment. Between 2019 and 2025, funding increased by 98% from €303 million to €600 million. This has driven notable growth in staffing levels. Some 107 additional beds have been added since 2020, an increase of 19%. Staffing increased by 41% from 3,500 to over 4,870. In this year alone, CUH has recruited and grown its staff complement by 324 from 4,870 to 5,194, which is an increase of over 6% compared to a 3% growth more generally across Department of Health-funded HSE services.

The Government's investment in CUH is clear, but there has to be evaluation of where the staffing decisions were made within management in terms of where they were prioritised and allocated and what those allocations have achieved in the context of significant increases in expenditure and-----

Comment on this

It is 1,000 staff short.

Comment on this

-----significant increases in investment in recent years. The context here cannot just be about more spending, more staffing and additionality everywhere.

Comment on this

It is 1,000 staff short.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy Quaide did not ask the question.

Comment on this

We need to balance that genuine request that comes, at times, from management with a focus on reform and the need to strategically deploy staffing in the best way, as the Minister for Health has reflected in recent years.

In terms of the Deputy's wider question, based on an assessment received from the HSE on quality and patient safety, the overall position regarding patient safety in CUH is reassuring, notwithstanding pressures associated with increased demand. The Minister for Health is continuously monitoring this issue. It is reflected in the broader staff increases we have made in recent years and the huge investment in CUH as a critical hospital in the southern region.

Comment on this

Has the Minister nothing to say to the almost 70 people who were on trolleys and chairs yesterday, most of them elderly? He did not even acknowledge them in his response, or what they were going through. Has he nothing to say to the patients with cancer, some of whom were in their gowns ready for surgery and who had to be sent home? He did not even acknowledge them in his answer. Has he nothing to say to them? All he can do is come in here and blame the hospital management, the very management that has been crying out for help to deal with the staffing shortage.

The request is for an independent assessment of staffing need. What has the Government got against such an independent assessment? Why will it not support that? Why will it not action that? An independent assessment is a very reasonable request. There are 1,000 vacant posts in the hospital. There are 172 urgently required to be filled and all the Government is allowing are seven of those to be filled.

Comment on this

I absolutely acknowledge the specific circumstances of patients. There is a responsibility in the hospital and in the HSE region to meet the respective demands with the staffing increases that we have funded and budgeted for in recent years.

On the Deputy's question about HIQA conducting an announced inspection in CUH to monitor against the national standards for safer and better healthcare on 5 and 6 November, of course there has to be evaluation of patient safety in all hospitals and funded healthcare regions. That is a standard that absolutely must be met. There is also the need within the HSE regions to prioritise posts within their budgets.

Comment on this

We obviously have a new control environment in the Department of Health-----

Comment on this

Where should the money go?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputies, please.

Comment on this

-----and the Minister for Health is authorising specific posts where they are strategically placed in the context of the region. The facts are clear, however. Funding is up in CUH. In addition to many other hospitals,-----

Comment on this

The Minister should answer the question.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I thank the Minister. Time is up.

Comment on this

-----it is up relevant to the investment in recent years, and that will continue to be the case in the next few years.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I call Deputy Bacik.

Comment on this

We are at the eleventh hour again as Government and union representatives return to the Workplace Relations Commission, WRC. I want to express my solidarity with public sector workers facing the prospect of another strike on Thursday, potentially. All they want is fair pay and respect. We all know that the talks are ongoing. We hope for a speedy resolution. I will say this, however. It was not respectful for the Government to wait so long to engage meaningfully with unions when the last pay deal ran out months ago.

This morning, we heard stories from one group of public sector workers on the front line, with a shocking report from Cork University Hospital on David McCullagh's radio show. We heard a harrowing account of conditions at CUH for healthcare workers and patients alike, with 70 patients on trolleys in corridors and waiting areas in emergency departments. One woman described her elderly mother asking for help to go to the bathroom for two hours. All resuscitation beds are full and there is no capacity for fresh admissions. One medic said patients were experiencing a form of torture, while staff are working in intolerable conditions compounded by a severe staffing crisis.

As we know, the hospital CEO, Jennifer Kearney, said the hospital was short more than 1,000 staff coming into the winter period. That is a shocking figure. Doctors are now warning that people will die because the hospital cannot deliver timely, quality care due to the Government's recruitment freeze. Indeed, we learned that CUH may now face quarterly fines of €300,000 for non-compliance with labour laws on breaks and hours. Yet, the Minister for Health has the temerity to insist that CUH is operating on par with other hospitals. In today's The Irish Times, Beaumont emergency consultant Dr. Peadar Gilligan points out that the ordinary state of affairs in Irish hospitals is unsafe. Unsafe conditions have become the norm, so CUH being on par with other hospitals is of no reassurance, not to nurses preparing to strike again when they know their best efforts are no guarantee of safe care. It is not reassuring for patients either now being told they may not receive treatment until the new year. It is not reassuring for sick people in chairs in emergency departments, deteriorating while they wait to be seen.

This is not just the case for patients and staff in Cork. Trolley numbers across the country are up 12% on last year. This September was the worst on record for overcrowding nationally, with more than 12,000 patients treated in inappropriate locations. The Minister boasted earlier about levels of investment in Cork and in the national health service but as Deputy Sherlock, Labour's health spokesperson, said, there is a huge gap here between the reality of healthcare budgets and the sort of wishful thinking in which the Government is engaging. She points out the gap between funding allocation for health services and the budget. She points out that the HSE is on course to record the second largest health deficit ever of over €1 billion. The Minister is telling us the HSE broke even last year when it actually recorded a deficit of close to €250 million.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I thank the Deputy. The Minister to respond.

Comment on this

People are asking where the reality is. Will the Minister admit that the Government underfunded the health service this year? Will the Government lift what is a recruitment freeze in all but name to guarantee patient safety?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Minister to respond, please.

Comment on this

It really is just such a lazy narrative from the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is really not.

Comment on this

More spending; that is Labour. It just wants more spending.

Comment on this

Spend the money; it is understaffed.

Comment on this

It is understaffed.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I am sorry; through the Chair and without interruption.

Comment on this

The Government is lowballing here.

Comment on this

By any metric, the Irish health system is well funded compared internationally. We have a €27.4 billion budget in 2026. It has increased in the last few years by €10 billion. That is underpinned by workforce growth in terms of the number of whole-time equivalents by over 30,000. The workforce was at 133,000 as of September 2026, a 30% increase since 2019. The health system has been a central priority for this Government in terms of public investment and the expansion of public services and that has been reflected over the last series of budgets. However, it is important that we balance the big increase and expansion in the service with the need for a control environment that is sustainable. That is what the Minister for Health is doing with the Department of Health in respect of the different regions. If we look at the facts around CUH, we see that funding has grown from €303 million in 2019 to €600 million, with a notable increase in staffing levels and 107 additional beds.

Comment on this

It is 341 beds short.

Comment on this

Of course, there are going to be requests. In debates around health spending, the Opposition always looks for more. Ultimately, it comes down to the wider investment, what way it is organised and how it is delivering across our system. What is the balance between investment in acute care and investment in community healthcare when there is always demand within our hospital system? That underpins the wider policy when it comes to Sláintecare. The same is true of the budget in 2027, where we have continued to prioritise investment in our health system.

Just saying that it is not enough is not a policy position in itself, which is what we hear repeatedly from Deputy Bacik. The facts speak for themselves around investment and staff expansion and that will continue, particularly as we have seen increased demographic demand in recent years.

I will speak briefly to the Deputy's question and point around the public service pay talks. I am not going to comment any further except to say that negotiations are confidential. It was positive to see a conclusion and resolution at the independent group, chaired by Kevin Foley. We want to see intensive engagement continue through the day so that we have a successful outcome for all parties. That underpins a Government that wants to prioritise public service expansion, support workers on the front line and ensure that the health system continues to be well funded in the years to come, but it is about how we organise that in the context of the budgetary growth in recent years.

Comment on this

With respect, the response there was laughable. The figures speak for themselves. The health service is in deficit, the HSE is in deficit and the Supplementary Estimates give lie to the figures the Minister has quoted. We know that the health budget is not a reality. It is a work of fiction. Patients and healthcare workers deserve a budget based on reality and on an acknowledgement that there is chronic short-staffing across the system.

Quite apart from the psychodrama that we are seeing playing out between the Taoiseach, the Minister and hospital management, the most disturbing feature of the CUH controversy is the patient safety issue. That is the real core of this. The warning bells have been ringing loudly for some time now, yet the Government's response has been to focus on how concerns were communicated instead of looking at how to fix the problem by addressing the chronic shortfall in staffing. We have seen a bombastic, arrogant reaction, just as we saw from the Minister for justice, Deputy O'Callaghan, in his response to concerns about the legal aid scheme and in the Government's response when the public sector unions signalled how badly the cost of living was hitting their members.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Deputy. I call the Minister.

Comment on this

What we need is a budget for the health service that is rooted in reality-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Your time is up, Deputy.

Comment on this

-----and enables hospitals to recruit enough staff to treat patients and ensure patient safety.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Minister to respond.

Comment on this

The reality of the health budget is that it has increased by over €10 billion in a short number of years. That is an exponential increase. The reality of the health budget is that we have nearly 30,000 more staff working in the health system in the last number of years. We have to ensure that the health budget is sustainable and affordable into the long term. What is the Deputy suggesting? Is it just endless exponential increases that ultimately are not sustainable?

Comment on this

Look at the actual need honestly.

Comment on this

We have prioritised funding our health system and by any metric, the expansion has been unprecedented in the last five to six years, particularly coming out of Covid when we had to increase capacity in our acute hospitals. That has happened with the significant staff increases universally.

The Government takes patient safety very seriously. That is why the HSE's quality and patient safety team carried out an assessment at CUH, and there is obviously work being done by HIQA to ensure that safety standards are upheld.

We need to ensure as well that the overall funding envelope in health has a control environment that works and is sustainable, and prioritises community healthcare in the context of Sláintecare.

Comment on this

The gathering of European leaders and, significantly, the head of NATO in Dublin this weekend highlights the misguided priorities of this Government and European leaders. It seems that European leaders and this Government think there are endless billions for weapons, militarism and war. However, the treatment of working people looking for a pay increase that matches inflation is much less of a priority. The same can be said of the patients in CUH whom a consultant has described as being tortured in that hospital because of the lack of staff and resources. Is it not a stark contrast? I do not know how much money is being spent but the Minister might tell us. I would say millions are being spent to roll out the red carpet for all of these EU leaders and the head of NATO, and to wine and dine them in the National Gallery.

Regardless of what happens with the pay increases, workers have had to go out on strike to get a pay increase from a Government that is trying hold back on them. It refuses to give them a pay increase that will keep pace with inflation unless they go out on strike and threaten another strike. That is really my question to the Minister. How come there are endless billions for weapons of war, but we get contemptuous treatment of working people who are just fighting for a decent pay increase, or indeed of people looking for our hospitals to be properly staffed and resourced? This Government signed up to these priorities of rearming Europe. Let us remember that the European Union is the biggest trading partner of the Israeli regime, which is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. It is arming that regime to the teeth, but this Government wants to involve us in the plans for more militarisation. Many of those countries are selling weapons to Israel to massacre Palestinians. There is even dual-use technology going from this country to the Israeli military while it is committing genocide. This Government wants to do more of that, but it is holding out on ordinary working people who are just looking for a pay increase that will ensure they are not losing income and working for less because of the cost-of-living crisis caused by the warmongering of the United States, Israel and many of the powers that want more money spent on weapons. The Government is going to do away with the triple lock and deal another blow to our neutrality in order to serve that agenda. Do its priorities not need to be re-evaluated?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Deputy. The Minister to respond.

Comment on this

The Deputy raised a number of points. As I have said, I want to respect the confidentiality of the process under way at the Workplace Relations Commission. We want to have a credible and fair deal for workers, particularly prioritising the low paid. I am limited in what I can say, except to say that negotiations are ongoing. We had positive engagement yesterday through Kevin Foley, who chaired that process. We want to see a pay deal for workers. A lot of what the Deputy has said is a complete misrepresentation of the position. He knows clearly that we are absolutely independent in our foreign policy and our reforms of the triple lock. Like Deputy McDonald, Deputy Boyd Barrett wants to continue to hand a veto to Russia-----

Comment on this

No, he does not.

Comment on this

-----China, Britain, the US and many others. Why he would not support a reform that involves this House deciding on the independent deployment-----

Comment on this

Because the Government cannot be trusted.

Comment on this

-----of troops to continue and sustain our proud record of peacekeeping is extraordinary.

Comment on this

They do not trust themselves.

Comment on this

It is extraordinary.

Comment on this

It is not peacekeeping if it is not in the UN, is it?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy Murphy, please.

Comment on this

He throws about the issue of NATO here and there.

Comment on this

He can call it peacekeeping, but it does not make it peacekeeping.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Members, please.

Comment on this

We have no intention of joining NATO. We have no intention of joining any military alliance. The Deputy knows as well as I do that the Constitution prohibits such an act. European Political Community meetings are important in the context of Ireland's role within the European Union. I know that like Sinn Féin, Deputy Boyd Barrett is Eurosceptic and would take a much different approach to Ireland's role in the European Union.

That is not something the broader Irish public would support either-----

Comment on this

Go and check with the people in a referendum.

Comment on this

-----in terms of the Deputy's position with the European Union. Ireland's defence spending is set out. We have moderately increased our defence spending in recent years, again supported by the work of the Commission on the Defence Forces in supporting expansion of equipment and a lot of respective improvement to pay and conditions for people who work across the Defence Forces. A lot of what the Deputy has said is just rhetoric and a complete misrepresentation of the Irish Government, which is well respected, by the way, in the European Union, led by the Minister, Deputy McEntee, the Taoiseach and others, in terms of what we have said about Gaza-----

Comment on this

-----and the shocking atrocities there and elsewhere. We have been consistent. We have been recognised in the European Union and the UN for how we have spoken up on behalf of the people of Gaza and elsewhere. That will continue within the European Political Community and all other European Union engagements.

Comment on this

Anybody who cares about our neutrality, opposes war and militarisation, and is concerned about the ongoing complicity of the European Union with the genocide being perpetrated by Israel against the Palestinians should be on the streets at 5 o'clock at The Spire, where we will be marching to the National Gallery, where, among others, the head of NATO will be. Which bit of what I have said is not true? Is it not true that the head of NATO is going to be there? It is not true that the European Union is the biggest trading partner of Israel that is committing a genocide? Is it not true that the policy of ReArm Europe is to double arms expenditure in Europe from €400 billion, which has already increased by multiples over recent years, up to €800 billion? That is not true, apparently, is it not?

Comment on this

That is NATO. It is not the EU.

Comment on this

Is it not an attack on neutrality that we will be sent on military missions - our sons and daughters, potentially - which are not authorised by the United Nations?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Deputy. You time is up. The Minister will respond.

Comment on this

By whom are they authorised - NATO or the European Union?

Comment on this

It is complete and utter nonsense-----

Comment on this

-----to talk about sending our sons and daughters away because of some decision by some other military alliance. It is a complete mistruth.

Comment on this

It is a complete and utter mistruth. Stop scaremongering.

Comment on this

Why are you scrapping the guardrails then?

Comment on this

You can continue to engage in your street politics and your division, but you know it is not true. You know there is no mandate for it. You know there is no intention to do it. Stop misrepresenting the actual position of the Government to the people of Ireland.

Comment on this

Then take your case to the people.

Comment on this

What is the Minister talking to Mark Rutte about?

Comment on this

There is a growing budget for defence spending by many European member states. Does the Deputy know why? It is because of Russia and because of the risk of what Russia is doing in Ukraine and the risk across the eastern area. Deputy Boyd Barrett did not mention Russia. He rarely mentions Russia in all his contributions.

Comment on this

The Deputy rarely mentions Russia, except he is willing to keep Russia's veto-----

Comment on this

Nobody is proposing an alliance with Russia. The Minister is proposing an alliance with NATO.

Comment on this

-----when it comes Ireland's foreign policy and Ireland's position in the context of deciding our own affairs.

Comment on this

If you are that sure, bring the case to the Irish people in a referendum.

Comment on this

It is complete inconsistency and hypocrisy and a complete misrepresentation of the truth. Deputy Boyd Barrett knows our consistent position in all international affairs.

Comment on this

The focus of our reform is on upholding our strong role in peacekeeping.

Comment on this

Put the question to the people.

Comment on this

Why are you scared of democracy?

Comment on this

Even Sinn Féin met NATO when they went to Kosovo.

Comment on this

Bring your case to the people.

Comment on this

Your Sinn Féin colleagues met NATO in Kosovo.

Comment on this