Overcrowding and staffing at Cork University Hospital
O’Callaghan describes severe overcrowding at CUH, including elderly patients on trolleys and cancer patients sent home, and calls for an independent review. Chambers acknowledges the pressure, cites increased staffing and investment, and says patient-safety assessments and a HIQA inspection are under way.
There were almost 70 patients on trolleys and in chairs at Cork University Hospital, CUH, yesterday morning, most of them elderly. Trolley to trolley, they were backed up against one another in bright noisy corridors, some of them beside drafty windows, making rest and recovery impossible. On the "Today with David McCullagh" show this morning, the professor of emergency medicine, Conor Deasy, described conditions as tantamount to torture. The staff in CUH are under immense pressure. They are trying their very best to treat their patients in overcrowded and unsafe conditions.
None of this should come as surprise to the Government because it has been on notice of a developing crisis in CUH all year. Staffing shortages were first raised by the hospital back in April. In August, in desperation, the CEO of the hospital Jennifer Kearney wrote to HSE in very stark terms. She said that conditions at the hospital were unsustainable and it was not safe to enter the winter period with the current level of staffing shortages. Instead of being listened to, her concerns were dismissed and at a meeting with HSE officials she was threatened with performance management. Jennifer Kearney did her best to warn the Government of what was coming but instead of listening to her, the Minister for Health went on the attack. She lambasted CUH and said appeals for additional staff were unrealistic.
Now look where we are. Surgeries for cancer patients have been cancelled at short notice. Women admitted for breast cancer surgery, some already in hospital gowns, were sent home. Imagine enduring the anxiety, fear and emotional strain that comes before a major surgery, only to be told at the last minute that it would not go ahead. No patient should ever be put through this type of ordeal. Nine clinical directors at the hospital have written to the Taoiseach to outline their serious concerns. They said that of the 172 priority posts that are urgently required, just seven have been approved.
The winter is just beginning and the pressure on the hospital is going to increase. What will it take before the Government acts and will the Minister agree to an independent assessment of staffing needs at CUH as a matter of urgency?
Comment on this
I acknowledge the tremendous work being done across our health system by staff in all of our acute hospitals, particularly as we get into the winter period, which brings additional challenges and demand. Since 2020, there has been a record level of investment and staffing increases right across the system - more staff, more beds and more services available universally. We have embedded reforms with the public-only consultant contract and many other benefits are being brought to patients and staff, with a focus on community healthcare in particular. The Minister for Health has led in driving reform, with requests coming in for additional spending.
The pressures facing CUH are facing all hospitals across the HSE as we head into the winter period. This pressure arises from increased demand. Between 2019 and 2025, emergency department attendance has increased by 28% while inpatient day case and outpatient activity has also increased. Emergency department attendances in CUH increased by 11% from September last year to September of this year. Successive Governments in recent years have supported CUH. Look at the staff increases and the low overall level of investment. Between 2019 and 2025, funding increased by 98% from €303 million to €600 million. This has driven notable growth in staffing levels. Some 107 additional beds have been added since 2020, an increase of 19%. Staffing increased by 41% from 3,500 to over 4,870. In this year alone, CUH has recruited and grown its staff complement by 324 from 4,870 to 5,194, which is an increase of over 6% compared to a 3% growth more generally across Department of Health-funded HSE services.
The Government's investment in CUH is clear, but there has to be evaluation of where the staffing decisions were made within management in terms of where they were prioritised and allocated and what those allocations have achieved in the context of significant increases in expenditure and-----
Comment on this
-----significant increases in investment in recent years. The context here cannot just be about more spending, more staffing and additionality everywhere.
Comment on this
We need to balance that genuine request that comes, at times, from management with a focus on reform and the need to strategically deploy staffing in the best way, as the Minister for Health has reflected in recent years.
In terms of the Deputy's wider question, based on an assessment received from the HSE on quality and patient safety, the overall position regarding patient safety in CUH is reassuring, notwithstanding pressures associated with increased demand. The Minister for Health is continuously monitoring this issue. It is reflected in the broader staff increases we have made in recent years and the huge investment in CUH as a critical hospital in the southern region.
Comment on this
Has the Minister nothing to say to the almost 70 people who were on trolleys and chairs yesterday, most of them elderly? He did not even acknowledge them in his response, or what they were going through. Has he nothing to say to the patients with cancer, some of whom were in their gowns ready for surgery and who had to be sent home? He did not even acknowledge them in his answer. Has he nothing to say to them? All he can do is come in here and blame the hospital management, the very management that has been crying out for help to deal with the staffing shortage.
The request is for an independent assessment of staffing need. What has the Government got against such an independent assessment? Why will it not support that? Why will it not action that? An independent assessment is a very reasonable request. There are 1,000 vacant posts in the hospital. There are 172 urgently required to be filled and all the Government is allowing are seven of those to be filled.
Comment on this
I absolutely acknowledge the specific circumstances of patients. There is a responsibility in the hospital and in the HSE region to meet the respective demands with the staffing increases that we have funded and budgeted for in recent years.
On the Deputy's question about HIQA conducting an announced inspection in CUH to monitor against the national standards for safer and better healthcare on 5 and 6 November, of course there has to be evaluation of patient safety in all hospitals and funded healthcare regions. That is a standard that absolutely must be met. There is also the need within the HSE regions to prioritise posts within their budgets.
Comment on this
We obviously have a new control environment in the Department of Health-----
Comment on this
-----and the Minister for Health is authorising specific posts where they are strategically placed in the context of the region. The facts are clear, however. Funding is up in CUH. In addition to many other hospitals,-----
Comment on this
The Minister should answer the question.
Comment on this
-----it is up relevant to the investment in recent years, and that will continue to be the case in the next few years.