We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Health-service funding and staffing

Summary

Bacik says the health budget is unrealistic, the service is short-staffed, and recruitment restrictions threaten patient safety. Chambers points to increased funding and workforce numbers, argues that spending must be sustainable and well directed, and cites patient-safety reviews at CUH.

People are asking where the reality is. Will the Minister admit that the Government underfunded the health service this year? Will the Government lift what is a recruitment freeze in all but name to guarantee patient safety?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Minister to respond, please.

Comment on this

It really is just such a lazy narrative from the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is really not.

Comment on this

More spending; that is Labour. It just wants more spending.

Comment on this

Spend the money; it is understaffed.

Comment on this

It is understaffed.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I am sorry; through the Chair and without interruption.

Comment on this

The Government is lowballing here.

Comment on this

By any metric, the Irish health system is well funded compared internationally. We have a €27.4 billion budget in 2026. It has increased in the last few years by €10 billion. That is underpinned by workforce growth in terms of the number of whole-time equivalents by over 30,000. The workforce was at 133,000 as of September 2026, a 30% increase since 2019. The health system has been a central priority for this Government in terms of public investment and the expansion of public services and that has been reflected over the last series of budgets. However, it is important that we balance the big increase and expansion in the service with the need for a control environment that is sustainable. That is what the Minister for Health is doing with the Department of Health in respect of the different regions. If we look at the facts around CUH, we see that funding has grown from €303 million in 2019 to €600 million, with a notable increase in staffing levels and 107 additional beds.

Comment on this

It is 341 beds short.

Comment on this

Of course, there are going to be requests. In debates around health spending, the Opposition always looks for more. Ultimately, it comes down to the wider investment, what way it is organised and how it is delivering across our system. What is the balance between investment in acute care and investment in community healthcare when there is always demand within our hospital system? That underpins the wider policy when it comes to Sláintecare. The same is true of the budget in 2027, where we have continued to prioritise investment in our health system.

Just saying that it is not enough is not a policy position in itself, which is what we hear repeatedly from Deputy Bacik. The facts speak for themselves around investment and staff expansion and that will continue, particularly as we have seen increased demographic demand in recent years.

I will speak briefly to the Deputy's question and point around the public service pay talks. I am not going to comment any further except to say that negotiations are confidential. It was positive to see a conclusion and resolution at the independent group, chaired by Kevin Foley. We want to see intensive engagement continue through the day so that we have a successful outcome for all parties. That underpins a Government that wants to prioritise public service expansion, support workers on the front line and ensure that the health system continues to be well funded in the years to come, but it is about how we organise that in the context of the budgetary growth in recent years.

Comment on this

With respect, the response there was laughable. The figures speak for themselves. The health service is in deficit, the HSE is in deficit and the Supplementary Estimates give lie to the figures the Minister has quoted. We know that the health budget is not a reality. It is a work of fiction. Patients and healthcare workers deserve a budget based on reality and on an acknowledgement that there is chronic short-staffing across the system.

Quite apart from the psychodrama that we are seeing playing out between the Taoiseach, the Minister and hospital management, the most disturbing feature of the CUH controversy is the patient safety issue. That is the real core of this. The warning bells have been ringing loudly for some time now, yet the Government's response has been to focus on how concerns were communicated instead of looking at how to fix the problem by addressing the chronic shortfall in staffing. We have seen a bombastic, arrogant reaction, just as we saw from the Minister for justice, Deputy O'Callaghan, in his response to concerns about the legal aid scheme and in the Government's response when the public sector unions signalled how badly the cost of living was hitting their members.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Deputy. I call the Minister.

Comment on this

What we need is a budget for the health service that is rooted in reality-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Your time is up, Deputy.

Comment on this

-----and enables hospitals to recruit enough staff to treat patients and ensure patient safety.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Minister to respond.

Comment on this

The reality of the health budget is that it has increased by over €10 billion in a short number of years. That is an exponential increase. The reality of the health budget is that we have nearly 30,000 more staff working in the health system in the last number of years. We have to ensure that the health budget is sustainable and affordable into the long term. What is the Deputy suggesting? Is it just endless exponential increases that ultimately are not sustainable?

Comment on this

Look at the actual need honestly.

Comment on this

We have prioritised funding our health system and by any metric, the expansion has been unprecedented in the last five to six years, particularly coming out of Covid when we had to increase capacity in our acute hospitals. That has happened with the significant staff increases universally.

The Government takes patient safety very seriously. That is why the HSE's quality and patient safety team carried out an assessment at CUH, and there is obviously work being done by HIQA to ensure that safety standards are upheld.

We need to ensure as well that the overall funding envelope in health has a control environment that works and is sustainable, and prioritises community healthcare in the context of Sláintecare.

Comment on this