Housing targets and emergency accommodation
Hearne cites a report projecting a major shortfall in the 2030 housing target and highlights homelessness, evictions and constituency cases. The Taoiseach counters with construction and social-housing figures, defends affordable housing proposals and accuses Hearne’s party of obstructing delivery; Hearne says the Government is failing people in crisis.
A new report from Deloitte makes for grim reading. It says the Government has no hope of delivering 300,000 homes by 2030. It is going to miss its target by a country mile, falling nearly 140,000 homes short. Instead of delivering homes, the Government prefers spin and empty promises. In a few minutes, the Taoiseach will stand up and say we have turned a corner again and then he will do what he always does, which is look for someone else to blame. Will it be the planning system, the courts, the Opposition or some vulnerable group he and the Tánaiste pick on? I have news for the Taoiseach: the failure is all his and it is devastating the lives of tens of thousands of people across this country.
In the past week alone, I have been contacted by a man in his 60s in my constituency who is living in his car. He is afraid to go into emergency accommodation because, if he does, he fears he will lose his job. Can the Taoiseach imagine being forced to sleep in your car every night as temperatures plummet and having to try to put on a brave face before going to work in the morning? A 29-year-old woman facing eviction from her apartment also contacted me. She has a good job but every day, she said, she wakes up feeling a paralysing sense of dread because she cannot afford the extortionate rents now being charged for new tenancies. She has no hope of being able to buy a home of her own. Another young man in my constituency has spoken of the nightmare of trying to find new rental accommodation. Even finding a room in shared accommodation is almost impossible. The only ones he has seen advertised are now costing €1,400 per month, which is more than half his monthly salary.
This is the reality of the Government's disastrous housing policies: a multigenerational catastrophe that is destroying lives all over the country. In 2020, the median price of a home was €255,000. Today, it is nearly €400,000. Six years of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael in government have added €140,000 to the price of a home. That is their big achievement. Is it any wonder that 70% of young people are considering leaving this country because they cannot afford the Ireland that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have created? No matter how hard they work, it is never enough. They cannot afford to move out of home, put down roots in a community or even start a family because the cost of housing and everything else in this country is totally unaffordable.
The Government is following the same failed policies and refusing to treat the housing catastrophe as an emergency. It has refused to ban no-fault evictions, reverse its disastrous rental changes, set up a State construction company and stop investor funds buying up property. Does the Taoiseach accept the Government's target will not be met?
Comment on this
I fundamentally disagree with the Deputy's narrative. Ireland ranks as the fastest in Europe in terms of house construction by a considerable distance. At 7.2 units per 1,000 of population, we are more than double the Europe average of three units and triple the United Kingdom's figure of 2.4. Since 2020, we will by the end of this year have delivered 70,000 social houses alone, close to that and maybe more. Going back to between 2015 and 2020, the number was nearly half that if not even less. That is progress. The Deputy will not acknowledge it because he is in opposition and wants to exploit every crisis as best he can. Importantly, the progress is quite significant, with 36,000 new houses last year. In 2020, we were at 20,000 per annum. We will be increasing that again by the end of 2026.
We have also initiated quite a significant number of reforms, which the Deputy objected to and opposed in every single way. Commencements are up 156% in 2026 versus 2025. A total of 35,400 mortgages were drawn down in the first three quarters of 2026. I went through the social houses built and so on. More importantly, the reforms and the work of the housing activation office have made very significant inroads, with the €1 billion that was allocated to the office, constructing railways and new stations aligning with the provision of thousands and thousands more homes.
In terms of the Deloitte report, it relies on historical planning permission lapse rates and does not adequately capture the impact of current Government interventions, increased construction capacity or the measures being implemented to accelerate delivery.
It applies historical permission lapse rates of 25% to 30% from 2017 to 2020 to current and future delivery. That assumes that past patterns will continue unchanged despite significant changes in the policy, planning and investment environment, changes that, by the way, the Social Democrats substantially or totally objected to, be they the planning reforms, zoning or so on that we have engaged in.
I looked at the disposal of lands at Mooretown in Swords. About 249 affordable and 111 social houses are ready to go, with the tender agreed and everything with the local authority. A Labour Party-led motion, supported by the Deputy's party, was a refusal to give that land over for those houses. That is the hypocrisy they go on with all the time. How can the Deputy get up here and talk about housing delivery but just casually say that, because of who owns a crèche, people will not get access to those affordable or social houses for some time yet? The Deputies are so intent on ideology as opposed to substantial and pragmatic progress.
Comment on this
It is incredible to see the Taoiseach getting worked up over this. It is a pity he is not worked up about the 5,830 children who are in emergency accommodation right now.
Comment on this
It is a pity we do not see him getting worked up about the highest number of evictions in this country since the Famine. Not once in his speech did the Taoiseach acknowledge the devastating human impact of this housing crisis on the three cases I raised in my constituency alone, including an elderly person living in their car and a 29-year old being evicted as a result of the measures that the Government brought in.
The Taoiseach talks about the Government's success and affordable housing delivery. It is absolutely pathetic. Just under 600 affordable purchase homes were delivered in the first half of this year. There are half a million adults living in their parental homes. There is a lack of empathy and the Taoiseach is cold in his response. There is a human catastrophe happening right now. These policies of handing public land-----
Comment on this
-----over to private developers is what got us into this crisis in the first place, yet the Government continues with those.
Comment on this
It is very disingenuous and dishonest of the Deputy to say I am cold or not prioritising housing. He knows damn well that I am-----
Comment on this
The Taoiseach stands over so many children being homeless and evicted.
Comment on this
-----and he knows that, since the Government came in two years ago, we have prioritised housing and I continue to prioritise housing. His ideology is what is getting in the way of faster-----
Comment on this
What of the Taoiseach's ideology?
Comment on this
-----delivery in terms of the progression of houses.
Deputy Hearne mentioned individual cases. He did not explain to me why an individual would not go into emergency accommodation.
Comment on this
See? The Taoiseach has no understanding. How can someone go into emergency accommodation-----
Comment on this
No, sorry. Deputy Hearne did not. He simply said that the person would lose a job if the person went into emergency accommodation. Why? How?
Comment on this
Yes. Absolutely. The Taoiseach is so disconnected-----
Comment on this
Deputies, the Taoiseach is responding and you were not interrupted. That is in compliance with Standing Orders. Do the same.
Comment on this
What real empathy means is that when a proposal is on the table for 360 affordable and social houses, people would allow it through for the young people who want to get those affordable houses substantially below the market price. The Social Democrats go on about costs and everything, yet they oppose it. The Deputy's party opposed the provision of those houses because of the ownership of a crèche.
Comment on this
They might be affordable for the Taoiseach-----
Comment on this
Deputy Hearne talks about prices. Those first-time buyers get prices at €335,000 and €375,000-----
Comment on this
-----for a three-bedroom house. That is below the market value, yet Deputy Hearne talks about empathy? He talks about caring. He does not care. He is just interested in ideology and exploiting a crisis.