We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Pholasaí nó ar Reachtaíocht - Questions on Policy or Legislation

Questions in this session

Ireland pays the EU's highest household electricity prices, over one third above the average. Figures have again exposed record August arrears and record long-term debt. As the Taoiseach knows, Irish families are now rationing heat and food just to keep the meters on. Why has the Taoiseach not acted decisively in the way families require to ease this burden? The Government's oil carbon tax cut was a half-measure at best. It got swallowed up by rising prices. The Government made no move in terms of electricity credits, as we advised. It made no move in terms of removing carbon taxes in their totality from home heating oil. Yet, the Government allows families to struggle on and pay what we know - it has been repeated again and again - are the highest costs in Europe, with record numbers in arrears.

Comment on this

The outbreak of war in Ukraine due to the Russian invasion and, indeed, the closure of the Strait of Hormuz and attack on Iran have caused very excessive increases in energy prices. In the budget, we took significant particular measures to protect our population through tax cuts for workers; the cost of disability payment; the very substantial reduction in childcare that will, over time, impact positively on people; the enhancement and increase to old age pensions of €10; and also in respect of the fuel allowance. We have, therefore, taken a range of measures to try to alleviate the pressures that these undoubted increases in energy prices have placed on people.

Comment on this

I am hugely concerned that the Government does not understand the depths of the crisis in Cork University Hospital, CUH. Last week the Taoiseach did not even have the correct details of a crucial meeting between senior HSE officials and CUH management and you misled the Dáil, presumably inadvertently. If he does not have the basic information, what else is he missing? Is he aware that the hospital is operating with zero ICU beds today or that 70 people were treated on trolleys and chairs at the hospital on Monday? Is he aware that hospital doctors are warning that the staffing and overcrowding crisis will cost lives? The only response from the Government to date has been to attack the management team at CUH. Jack Chambers was at it again in the House yesterday. What use is that to patients in Munster? This blame game has to stop. We need solutions before the situation gets any worse. Will the Taoiseach take this opportunity to correct the Dáil record? What is the Government going to do to urgently alleviate this crisis in CUH?

Comment on this

First, I did not mislead the Dáil last week. That is unfair. What I said last week was that my understanding was that the regional executive officer, REO, was very clear that at no stage did he make any reference to instructions from the Taoiseach's office-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy, this is not a back and forth.

Comment on this

-----or anybody from the Taoiseach's office. I want that to be clear because false assertions were made about my office. False assertions were made about my office but the REO has now come forward, based on a recording of what he did say in relation to instructions, but he accepted that was a false assertion. He said that he should not have said that and that it was wrong. He had made an earlier statement to the HSE. What I would say is that I do not know whether he was aware - sorry, I do not think he was aware - that this conversation between the management and the HSE was being recorded. I think there are ethical concerns about that, if I am honest, and perhaps it is symptomatic of a real problem if people are recording conversations between management of the HSE and management of the hospital.

Comment on this

What about the actual crisis in the hospital?

Comment on this

I do not know who was responsible for the recording but I feel, generally, that it is not the way forward for workplace relations.

Comment on this

What about the hospital?

Comment on this

What is the Taoiseach going to do?

Comment on this

On the hospital-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The time is up. Deputy Bacik.

Comment on this

-----I will come back to the Deputy.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

No interruptions is what you mean

Comment on this

I have one minute to answer.

Comment on this

People are still dying in Gaza as they battle the elements. Displaced by Israel, their tents are flooding with torrential rain. The world must do more to hold Israel to account for ongoing violations of the human rights of those in Gaza and the West Bank. Here at home we must also do more. On numerous occasions I have raised with the Taoiseach the denial of visas to students from Palestine who have been awarded scholarships by Irish universities. Due to litigation by those students, the Department of justice has committed to deciding on the remaining student visa appeals by 18 November. However, Gaza is a difficult place to leave, just as it is a difficult place to survive in. The next assisted departure is scheduled for 23 November but an evacuation requires seven to ten days of advance coordination. This is really urgent. Have the names of all students awaiting visa appeal decisions been submitted to the relevant authorities for the 23 November evacuation? How can we ensure that no student is left behind?

Comment on this

First, the situation in Gaza and the level of suffering inflicted on the civilian population, who are not responsible for the actions of Hamas, is shocking and an affront to human decency. Israeli strikes continue, humanitarian aid remains blocked and civilians continue to suffer. There is a sustained and deliberate attempt by some to make the prospect of a two-state solution impossible. There has been an election in Israel and I do not want to comment in respect of that until a new government is formed, other than to say that internationally, we should be doing everything we possibly can. Ireland continues to strongly support Palestine with additional funding. We have provided about €145 million in support to the people of Palestine since January 2023. That includes new funding of €41 million for the people of Palestine in 2026, and €78 million to UNRWA since 2023, with a further €20 million this year.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you Taoiseach, the time is up.

Comment on this

On the visas, I will revert to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I have to raise again with the Taoiseach the fact that the people of south Tipperary have no consultant ophthalmology service. There is no public eye service and this situation is now going into its third year. There is no consultant-led service, no optometry clinic and no nurse-led clinic. As a result, there is a huge waiting list of almost 3,000, including hundreds of children who have never been seen and hundreds of patients with conditions like glaucoma who have either never been seen or who need follow-up care. Many families are being forced into private treatment even though they are already under serious pressure from the cost of living. This is obviously unacceptable. Twice we have been promised what is called a "blitz clinic" to deal with the urgent cases and the backlog but that has not transpired, so now we have neither a permanent nor a temporary solution. Will the Taoiseach intervene to ensure that there is a public eye service in south Tipperary?

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for raising what is a very significant issue for the people of Tipperary. The Deputy knows that the post is funded and quite a significant effort has been made to recruit someone for that post. At different times people may have accepted but not taken up the post. There have been sustained efforts to recruit to the post. In the interim, measures have been taken to provide services to people in respect of ophthalmology. The post is funded and efforts will continue to recruit.

Comment on this

In the Dáil last week I raised the case of a fisherman in west Cork who was out fishing in his trawler for five days and who ended up with a fuel bill of €22,580 for those five days. This is not sustainable. Bord Iascaigh Mhara, BIM, is due to roll out a fuel subsidy based on the size of a boat very soon. Inshore boats of between 6 m and 12 m will get €2,200. Boats of between 12 m and 18 m will get €4,400, while boats of between 18 m and 24 m will get €21,600 and those between 24 m and 40 m will get €26,500. There needs to be a new category if those with trawlers are to have any small chance of surviving. This new category should be 15 m to 18 m because someone with a 17 m trawler only gets €4,400 but someone with an 18 m trawler gets €21,600, even though they are both out in the same waters, in the same big ocean, fighting for their basic survival. The smaller boats are out in similar waters to the bigger trawlers. Will the Taoiseach communicate with BIM and the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, and ask them to see if a new category can be added? If not, more trawlers will end up tied up at the pier.

Comment on this

The Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, deserves considerable credit for his engagement with fishers and their representative organisations. He was insistent on a fuel subsidy and support scheme for fishers, which was well received. I have not gone into the specifics of the modus operandi of that particular scheme but I will refer the Deputy's points to the Minister.

Comment on this

One of the greatest supports to first-time builders in rural east Galway over the last few years was when the development levy waiver was in place. First-time builders that I speak to in east Galway tell me that they are happy to pay for their water connection because they are getting water and for their ESB connection because they are getting electricity. However, when it comes to the development contribution to the local authority, they cannot see the point of it. I say that because they do not see footpaths or street lighting outside their homes and, particularly in rural areas, they have to make a much bigger investment in a septic tank and do not have access to a public sewer. Scrapping that development contribution for first-time builders in rural east Galway and across the country would be a really welcome development. I would appreciate the Taoiseach's thoughts on the matter.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for raising the issue. We have provided a range of very substantial supports for first-time buyers in particular, including the help to buy scheme and the first home scheme. In terms of development levies, we did have that waiver. That led to a substantial number of commencements and gave an injection at the time but it could not be sustained forever. We just have to balance the level of expenditure on housing more generally, which is up to €9 billion this year. We have changed the planning guidelines and those changes would be supportive of rural first-time builders and buyers. It is about balance, really, in terms of how we support housing, particularly in rural Ireland. The vacant and derelict property grants were originally designed primarily for rural Ireland, particularly the derelict element because young couples could get the opportunity to get a substantial grant to refurbish and move back in.

Comment on this

I am sure that the Taoiseach is aware of the great news that the judicial review against the Galway Port redevelopment has been withdrawn.

It is full steam ahead for Galway Port. The proposals include a new deepwater port not reliant on gated docks that will cater for larger ships, a new naval berth and access for cruise shipping, freeing up inner lands for housing, leisure and recreation. It will also assist in preventing flood surges and protect the city. The port will allow and have rail connectivity. There is space for strategic oil reserve storage as required in an unstable geopolitical international environment. Funding is partly via land sale, own resources and loans. However, the ports policies as they are and were, and the draft ports policy do not support Galway's ambition. I ask the Taoiseach to engage with the Minister and the Minister of State in the Department of Transport to ensure that new ports policy is positive for Galway's redevelopment.

Comment on this

I welcome the good news of the withdrawal of the judicial review. This follows the good news in respect of the Galway ring road and infrastructure projects in general across the country. It reflects the work of the Minister, Deputy Chambers, and the accelerating delivery task force recommendations and their implementation. There is a new impetus in trying to get projects done quickly. I am familiar with the plans of the port. I visited some years ago and am fully au fait with the ambition of Galway Port. The ports policy has been approved by Government. We changed it on its journey to enable Government, if necessary, to fund capital developments in ports. Prior to this ports policy, the view was that they had to wash their own faces, so to speak, in terms of revenue and expenditure. However, given the nature of certain expenditures the ports will have to engage with the ORE on renewable energy and so on. From time to time there may be a need for support like Rosslare with Brexit where the State intervened to support it.

Comment on this

I ask the Taoiseach to intervene in the imminent closure of Little Wonders disability service in Castleblayney, County Monaghan. The service has been in operation since 2019. Following significant operating costs and wage increases in the sector they have come to the decision they will have to close. They have a service level agreement with the HSE, which is refusing to give them additional money to keep the service open. The service supports 25 children daily with another 50 on a waiting list. I ask the Taoiseach to intervene to ensure this service stays open. The HSE needs to support this service and provide adequate funding so the service can remain open. There have been protests and meetings. Parents and children are very distressed at the imminent closure of this service.

Comment on this

The Government has provided funding for wage increases following the work of the joint labour committee in respect of early childcare workers. I am not familiar with the details of this specific facility and service but I will seek the background to this from the HSE on what the story is.

Comment on this

There is a serious crisis in home help and elderly care in the community in County Kerry. Community hospitals have empty beds because they cannot recruit or even fill the vacancies they had. That is putting extra pressure on University Hospital Kerry where people trying to get home help for their loved ones who cannot come out of hospital are forced to either pay privately or wait a year to access home help. There are cost overruns as part of it but they should not be punished for this relatively small amount. I ask the Taoiseach to commit to funding to ensure people are not delayed and can access the services they need to take people out of hospital and give them proper care in the community.

Comment on this

Approximately 60,000 people receive home care every day. The budget has expanded exponentially over the past number of years. There were issues with recruitment and getting a sufficiency of people to take up posts over the past two years. About 26 million hours of home care are being delivered in 2026. I hear what the Deputy is saying and I will engage with the HSE in respect of the issue he has raised.

Comment on this

I am sure, like many Members in the House this morning, I received a number of phone calls from families who, in turn, had received phone calls from their schools about a potential bomb threat. This was not just one school.; it was hundreds of schools throughout the country. We can only imagine what those families went through this morning. Thankfully it was a hoax, but in some cases, including two schools in my area of Kildare South, they were evacuated. What is the Government doing about this threat to our way of life and democracy? Is An Garda fully aware of what is going on with this important matter?

Comment on this

We are aware a number of schools received a threatening email this morning. The Department of justice has liaised with An Garda Síochána at senior level with regard to this incident. The Minister for Education and Youth has spoken to the Minister for justice and her officials have been in constant contact with An Garda Síochána. An Garda Síochána has received several hundred calls and will liaise with each school in turn, noting that with the volume of calls this may take some time. An Garda Síochána has advised the Department and is advising schools that based on its review of the threat, there is no need for schools to evacuate as these are generic email threats. If a school has received this email, it is advised to contact the emergency service at 999 and follow the advice of An Garda Síochána. The Department of Education and Youth wrote to all schools this morning to advise the same.

Comment on this

Sixty five years ago this month, the thalidomide drug was withdrawn internationally from availability, although not in this jurisdiction. In this jurisdiction, there are approximately 40 survivors, 12 of them unacknowledged by the State in terms of the effects this drug had on them and the lifelong disabilities and injuries they suffered as a result, none of which acknowledges the guilt their mothers felt. Many of those women are dead. There has been a protracted process to achieve three things for the survivors of thalidomide. These are a proper heartfelt apology for State's failure to act, a medical scheme that deals with their significant personal medical issues and a fair compensation scheme. Two years ago, the Government wrote to them expressing regret. Will the Taoiseach now give those survivors a timeline as to when these matters will actually be resolved? Can it possibly be done by 27 November to commemorate that 65th anniversary? These people should not have to wait any longer.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste, Attorney General and I have been involved in a number of meetings with the thalidomide survivors and unacknowledged survivors. We met them four times this year. I am as frustrated as anybody. We are committed to a State apology at the conclusion of the resolution process. In terms of medicals, we have provided a comprehensive enhanced pathway. Significant Government support and funding have been provided for that pathway. In July 2024, we issued a detailed and enhanced package of health, social care and independent living supports co-designed with thalidomide survivors currently available. An expanded National Thalidomide Advocacy Office is now in place. We also have a draft pathway for unacknowledged thalidomide survivors. This was tabled last month following engagement with representatives of the thalidomide survivors group, legal representatives and medical representatives. We want to get this-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Time is up, Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The people of Letterkenny have waited many years for a relief road known as the Bonagee link. It has led to traffic misery not just for the people of Letterkenny but for people across County Donegal travelling to work and hospital appointments and for visitors to our county. There is utter bedlam regularly. The TEN-T project has been brought forward for a number of years. It takes in the relief road, the dual carriageway to Lifford on to the new A5, and the Ballybofey and Stranorlar bypass. Donegal County Council and the people of Donegal are asking the Taoiseach to make this a critical infrastructure project and make it progress urgently as soon as possible so we can deal with the traffic bedlam in Letterkenny and the other major roads issues in the county.

Comment on this

That project is progressing. The Deputy can be assured that the agencies and statutory agencies involved and responsible for this will progress it. I do not mean this badly, but we have big projects like wastewater drainage schemes and things like that. On roads, we expect Transport Infrastructure Ireland and the county councils to deliver them once they are through the planning processes and so on. However, we do not put every road project on the critical infrastructure list. We have to prioritise some of the very big ones to make sure they progress through. However, I will certainly talk to the Minister for infrastructure to see if any particular issues are holding this back now.

Comment on this

On the Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026, on 28 April, the Taoiseach told this House that planning law was planning and the seven-year rule was there. Basically, if someone is operating an Airbnb for seven years, he or she does not need planning permission. Yet the national planning statement still requires established operators without the necessary permission to apply for retention even where they have been operating for more than seven years. A presumption in favour of permission is not an exemption and a simplified application is still an application with no guarantee of its approval. A planning application can incur many difficulties.

These are families that have spent years building businesses and supporting tourism in County Kerry and throughout this country through their own hard work and investment. They took genuine reassurances from the Taoiseach's words. Will he now ensure the legislation and planning rules deliver the seven year exemption his statement led those operators to expect or is he withdrawing that assurance today?

Comment on this

The position in the legislation reflect comprehensive legal advice from the Attorney General but there has been unnecessary scaremongering on this issue.

Comment on this

Not on my behalf.

Comment on this

I saw the Deputy's recent post and it was a bit over the top, if I may say so. The Deputy mentioned the presumption of entitlement to planning if you are there for more than seven years and the simplified application. We are endeavouring to meet the legal frameworks to enable people. We did agree on the 20,000 threshold. The Deputy was in government when we agreed that.

Comment on this

I appreciate that.

Comment on this

There has to be a balance here in enabling people to get housing in communities. We were criticised for the 20,000 threshold but in rural Ireland and areas where tourism is important, we want to facilitate people to maintain short-term letting, that is, in areas below that threshold. This is a mechanism and a framework to enable us to do this without any potential legal ultra vires act.

Comment on this

October was one of the worst months on record for hospital overcrowding. University Hospital Cork, CUH, had 1,215 patients on trolleys. It was the second highest in the country. The CUH chief executive said their hospital had lost half the CT scanning capability because it cannot fill radiographer posts. Three hundred people are waiting for scan currently. We are now looking at patients taking up beds while waiting for scans, while others are on trolleys.

I do not want to carry on the way the House carried on a while ago with the "He said, she said" sort of carry on. What I need from the Taoiseach - from a Corkman to a Corkman, representing a hospital our constituencies need - is a commitment to sanctioning the posts for CUH which are needed to restore the CT capability before Christmas.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for raising this issue in a constructive manner. We are concerned about increasing pressures on hospital across the length and breadth of the country, particularly on CUH. October has been a challenging month and the winter will be challenging. CUH has a substantial number of radiographers. I am at a loss as to why one of the CT scanners in the emergency department is not up and running. That should be prioritised. Moves are being made by the HSE to support the hospital. I believe there should be continuing engagement between HSE South West and the hospital management in respect of the issues facing it and to try to get this dealt with in a structured way through the established procedures.

HIQA was there recently on an announced inspection in respect of safety issues. We have to use HIQA, the patient safety office and so on to identify safety risks, etc. The more important point is that we will do everything we possibly can to support the reduction of pressures on people.

Comment on this

I want to return to the issue of Little Wonders. Families of children with disabilities in Monaghan and Cavan often describe their lives as a battle a day. They feel they have to fight for every service, whether it is occupational therapy, physiotherapy, speech and language therapy and respite. Many of those families describe the Little Wonders facility as their lifeline because this fantastic facility often fills the gaps in disability services. There is now a cloud hanging over the Little Wonders facility. Parents and friends along with the children had to protest yesterday because of the fear they have.

My request to the Taoiseach is very simple. Will he appraise himself of the situation and directly intervene with the HSE because I believe a missive from his office can fast track what is absolutely logical, that the Little Wonders facility must be safeguarded into the future? It has to have the contract that will allow that to happen and to provide the peace of mind to those families who feel they always have to fight for these services.

Comment on this

I am not familiar with the background as to why the contractor, it seems to me, is withdrawing the service. I will talk to the Minister in respect of this but we provided funding for increased pay. Provision was made in last year’s Estimate for that and this year’s Estimate for next year as well in terms of fulfilling the agreements with the unions in respect of pay increases for childcare workers. I will try to get the background to this.

Comment on this

I want to continue to raise issues relative to the transport system in Galway city and the traffic issues people suffer. Traffic in Galway is always bad but there has been a particular spike in the past week for an unknown reason. It is not unusual for that to occur. Last week we welcomed fully planning permission for the city bypass. That needs to be complemented with adequate public transport infrastructure. There are two significant public transport projects in the city: the cross-city link and the Dublin Road bus corridor. The bus corridor received planning permission in 2025. I sought an update from the NTA last week as to when we might see work on the project and I was a bit disappointed and taken aback to read that construction will not commence until 2029. That seems to be in contrast with much of what we talk about in terms of accelerating infrastructure, which the Taoiseach referred to in earlier replies. Can that timeframe be reduced so that the construction of the Dublin Road bus corridor starts sooner?

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say it has planning permission?

Comment on this

It has full planning permission.

Comment on this

I will talk to the Minister for Transport and ask him to engage with the NTA on its timelines in respect of that. I do not know whether that is a funding or a prioritisation issue on the part of the NTA but I will certainly talk to the Minister in respect of it.

Comment on this

I want to raise an acute social issue with the Taoiseach. Since April 2018, about 3,000 children have left care, either residential care or foster care, in some shape of form. I was shocked to learn that when they turn 18, they are often directed to emergency accommodation, to apply for housing supports and put on social welfare. Many come from very traumatic circumstances. I have met many of them. Some fall into addiction to cope while many end up homeless. Part of this is due to the supports available to them and how those are extended beyond the age of 18 when they are still in a vulnerable situation. When I was 18, I could not navigate many things, not to mind set up a life as an adult myself. Part of this is also about joined-up thinking and making sure the proper agencies are collaborating with one another to give these people a better start in life through educational supports, therapeutical supports and so on. What will the Government do about children leaving foster care, rehabilitative services and care services?

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that this is a critical moment in the life of a young person who has been in care with the care services and I have discussed this with the Minister for children. She is very supportive of the idea that we need to provide a greater continuum of services but also a safety net, particularly in terms of housing and social supports. I am familiar with initiatives that are being taken in Wales in this respect for young people leaving care. The Minister has brought some measures forward relating to this specific issue but we can do more to enable people to make the transition, which can go in many directions if the level of supports are not comprehensive enough in the early stage of transition from care into society.

Comment on this