We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Social Welfare Bill 2026: Second Stage (Resumed)

Summary

Government speakers backed the Bill’s broad social protection package, highlighting increases for pensioners, carers and families, a €500 cost-of-disability payment, improved fuel allowance eligibility for people living alone, and measures to support disabled people into work. Some also supported stronger penalties for jobseekers who fail to engage with employment services, while stressing that supports should help people find work. Opposition speakers condemned the Tánaiste’s remarks about long-term unemployment and argued that penalties would deepen poverty rather than create jobs; they also called for better employment services and stronger support for disabled people, carers, lone parents and the self-employed. Concerns included the one-off nature and eligibility limits of the disability payment, inadequate increases amid rising costs, and gaps in illness and other benefits.

Bill Social Welfare Bill 2026
Current

No. 105 of 2026 ›

I welcome the second day of debate on the very important Social Welfare Bill 2026. I also welcome the efforts of the Minister and Ministers of State involved in preparing the Bill both for the budget announcement and as it passes its way through the House.

The total social protection package announced a number of weeks ago in the budget is worth over €30 billion. It is worth pausing to note that. There is an increase of €2 billion on 2026. Despite the debate at the weekend, the vast majority of that €30 billion goes to child, family, caring and pension payments. It is a basic floor that we set in our society to ensure that we protect and support people. I am always happy to stand over such a budget.

Some people say that those who are on social welfare get everything and those who are working get nothing. The answer to that is not to detract from those who need the Social Welfare Bill and the basic floor that we have. Rather, it is to ensure that we make work pay and that the taxation of people who work is fair. That is how I would approach the feeling that is often out there.

A huge array of positive measures are included in the Bill. I note the summation of the budget by the Economic and Social Research Institute, ESRI. Dr. Claire Keane, an associate research professor at the ESRI, said:

Policy changes in Budget 2027, and indeed over the last seven budgets, have compensated households on average for price and wage growth. In particular, the lowest income households have been most protected. This is positive given we know that lower income groups spend more of their income on home heating and motor fuels [and so on].

That quote, from somebody who is independent of this House and all the political parties, is important to reference. Over the past seven budgets, this Government and the previous version of it put together budgets that have sought to protect people. If you were to listen to Opposition speakers in this House, you would not be able to reconcile their commentary with that of the ESRI.

I note that the ESRI also makes other observations about the budget. I am not saying that everything was right but when we put it in context, we must say that this budget has done a lot to put money back in people's pockets. For a couple with three children on the working family payment, there is over €1,600 per year. For pensioners, there is over €600. With the living alone and fuel allowance increases, there are further benefits.

I was most pleased by the change to the eligibility for the fuel allowance, particularly for single people. That has changed from 50% of the total available to a couple to 60%, which gives a little more to people who apply for the fuel allowance. It is a valuable tool to prevent fuel poverty. Somebody living on his or her own has many of the same costs as somebody living in a couple when it comes to heating their home. I would like us to go a little further in the years to come.

The area in which we have seen most progress is the cost-of-disability payment. I acknowledge the work of the Minister and the Department, but also all of the different groups that have worked on this issue over several years. We know that the previous process that was introduced and was then withdrawn was an unfair way of categorising people. The Government is determined to try to introduce a cost-of-disability payment. This year's attempt to do that, with a lump sum payment of €500, is an important start. The most important part will be the co-design process that will happen next year to ensure that we have a cost-of-disability payment that affects all people with disabilities. I include in that those people with disabilities who are working. Those with disabilities who are working may not be eligible for this year's payment but when we co-design it, we must recognise that. Whether that is done through a fully refundable tax payment or by increasing the payment or eligibility, I would like to see that next year.

I commend the Minister and the Ministers of State for the work they have done so far.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Bill. A good social protection system should protect people when they need support and must also help people to move forward and build a better future for themselves and their families. We all know that life does not always go according to plan. People lose jobs and families face unexpected challenges with ill health and family break-ups. Circumstances can change overnight, often due to matters that are outside individuals' control. That can be frightening for individuals and families. That is why we need a strong social protection system. As the Tánaiste said at the weekend, it is a safety net that any one of us may need at some point in our lives.

I also believe that supports come with responsibilities. We are exceptionally fortunate to live in a country with high levels of employment and opportunities for people who want to work. Our constituents often tell us that there is a job in this country for everybody who wants to work, yet the latest figures show that more than 52,000 people have been on the live register for a year or more. Being unemployed for a long time, of course, does not necessarily mean that somebody is unwilling to work. Some people face genuine barriers. They may lack qualifications. They may have lost confidence. They may simply need someone to give them an opportunity. That is where the State has a responsibility to help. Through Intreo training, apprenticeships and employment supports, we can help people to develop the skills and confidence they need to return to work. I welcome the Government's commitment to a new pathways to work strategy with a renewed focus on those who find it the hardest to get employment.

I want to say something else about work while I have the opportunity. Sometimes, we forget the benefits of having a job. Working is good for us. It is good for our mental health. There is pride in earning your own money and providing for your own family. There are many opportunities out there. If people get out of bed, get involved and do something worthwhile, there are even opportunities to serve this great country of ours and make a real difference by joining the Defence Forces or An Garda Síochána.

I want to be clear that I am not talking about people who cannot work because of illness or disability, nor am I speaking about people who have given up work to care for a loved one. We all know that caring for someone is a 24-hours-a-day responsibility. I am talking about people who are capable of working, who are receiving jobseeker's payment and who are expected to make a genuine effort to find employment. I do not think that is too much to ask. Getting somebody back to work is not just about saving the State money. It is about helping that person to have a better life.

We must also be fair to the people who do get out of bed every morning, go to work, pay their taxes and help to fund the services and supports on which we all depend. If someone is capable of working and is in receipt of jobseeker's payments, I do not think it is unreasonable to expect them to engage with the supports that are available. If they are making a genuine effort, it should be recognised. However, where someone repeatedly refuses to engage without good reason, there must be consequences. That is why I support the proposed increase in penalties for those who refuse to engage with employment services. Of course, those penalties must always be applied fairly and must also take into account individual circumstances.

I believe that everyone in Ireland deserves the opportunity to reach their full potential. That means supporting people when they need help, giving them opportunities and encouraging them to take responsibility for their own future. Social protection should never be about leaving people behind. It should be about helping people to move forward. That is the balance we should be trying to achieve.

I welcome the measures before the House and am happy to support the Bill.

Comment on this

Budget 2027 was about political choices, and those choices tell us exactly who had the ear of the Government in the weeks before it was announced and who was left outside the door. It certainly was not the pensioners whom I know who were afraid to turn on their heating, it was not the families struggling to put food on the table and it was not the workers being squeezed in every direction. Instead of addressing the real poverty and struggle people are going through, Fine Gael chose to attack people on jobseeker's allowance. The Tánaiste's disgraceful comments are a dangerous dog whistle and give licence to those who want to vilify anybody who is receiving social welfare. When I was listening at the weekend, I could not understand the hypocrisy of it. The Minister of State will remember the debates we had in the House on JobPath and how the Government explicitly privatised the supports that were helping people get back to work and abolished the local employment services. The Government spent hundreds of millions of euro on private companies to do what it called "activation". That was disgraceful. Fine Gael should not pretend to the people that it is trying to save them by ensuring that people who are unemployed for longer than ten years are held to account and all of that. I am holding it to account. I know this is not the Minister of State, but it makes me really angry. That there has been such waste of money around the privatisation of the social welfare system is disgraceful. There has been duplication and disbanding of the local employment services, which were doing really good work in helping people who needed to get on that pathway. I agree that everybody deserves a job and that everybody who can be working should be working, for their dignity, their lifestyle and everything else. However, for a Government to choose to privatise and then to say that the people the private companies left behind are to be blamed for all of this is totally wrong.

I also wish to raise the way this Government follows people beyond the grave. It follows dead people. These are people who maybe had Alzheimer's disease in the last stages of their lives and who were law-abiding citizens for all of their lives. They reached their late 80s or 90s, got Alzheimer's and forgot to tick a box or fill out a form. The Government comes and persecutes them after they are dead and criminalises them. It takes away their good name by saying that they claimed something wrong. That is totally wrong. I do not believe in anybody scamming or abusing the system, but when you have on the one hand the principles of paying out millions of euro and following people beyond the grave and, on the other, you have everything being taken from the poorest in society, it is not right.

Comment on this

Let us cut to the chase. This Bill is about Simon Harris trying to look tough. He was trying to be the big man at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis at the weekend by targeting the 1.1% of the population who had been unemployed for over 12 months. It was not even original. We all remember the "rat for Leo" line. What was its slogan? It was, "Welfare cheats cheat us all". It is the usual Fine Gael tactic of punching down. Fine Gael insists that it is not the banker, not the developer and not the vulture fund that is the problem, but the man or woman over there. It is the other, the less well-off, the 1.1% of the population. If we focus on the other person over there, we are letting the Tánaiste and his cronies off the hook. We are not focusing on those in power. His answer is to threaten people who already have the least amount of power.

What was the Tánaiste's slogan at the weekend? It was, "An Ireland alive with possibilities". Possibilities for whom? Is there a possibility of ending homelessness soon? When Fine Gael came into government, there were 3,800 people who were homeless in this State. Today, there are almost 18,000. There are almost 6,000 children homeless. What is the possibility of those children having a home this Christmas? What is the possibility of opening the children's hospital? It is the hospital that the Tánaiste signed off on as Minister for Health, which is still not open and which has so far cost the taxpayer an additional €1.3 billion euro. What about the possibility of no child waiting for more than four months for scoliosis treatment? Where was that possibility? I could go on because there are endless possibilities to put the wrongs inflicted by Fine Gael right but Fine Gael will not do pursue them. Actually, Fine Gael cannot do it. It does not have the capacity to fix the problems it created in the first place. It is too long in government.

Social protection is a safety net, not a political punching bag. A Government serious about tackling long-term unemployment would address deprivation, keep young people engaged in education, and have proper employment services, accessible training and decent jobs. What we see is not leadership. Leadership would see Fine Gael stopping the sweetheart deal with the banks. Leadership would see Fine Gael taxing vulture funds on their rental properties.

One of the things from the last budget many people have contacted me about was the increase in the living alone allowance. Imagine having the gall. Imagine being so out of touch to think that increasing the living alone allowance by a measly €3 would make any difference to a senior citizen. You would not even get a cup of coffee out of that €3. Pensioners are impacted by the cost of living like everybody else but pensioners who are living on their own are impacted more because they have to pay for the heating and all the other bills on their own. The Minister of State is involved in this. What planet was the Government thinking of when it issued a minimal, measly €3 increase in the living alone allowance?

Comment on this

Before I speak to a number of the priorities that should be in this Bill, I ask the Minister of State to relay to the Minister, Deputy Calleary, a really important message about the additional needs payment. We are now into the winter. It is going to be a very tough winter for an awful lot of households. The one positive about the additional needs payment is that workers can access it. However, we continually have the issue of people coming to us because they have sought money for X and have been told it is not there. I had a lady yesterday who was told a gas bill could not be covered, yet the number one example for the longest time has been electricity or heating costs. I ask that a direction go out to our community welfare officers and to the social welfare offices across the State. We need that payment to be resourced and we need it to be as efficient as possible for people who will need it throughout the winter period. It needs to be there, it needs to protect and support people and it needs to be run as efficiently and quickly as possible.

One thing missing from this Bill is access to illness benefit for the self-employed. It is a commitment in the programme for Government and the self-employed pay their PRSI. It is always a strange one. I remember that, back in 2015, a survey was done with the self-employed and illness benefit was the top payment they looked for, followed by invalidity pension. Invalidity pension was awarded and of course that is long-term, but if you are self-employed and you get sick tomorrow, the disability allowance usually is not an option because of the household means test, nor is the supplementary welfare allowance, SWA, so we need to see an extension of illness benefit to the self-employed as quickly as possible. If they get ill, they have no access to anything. That is unfair and needs to be dealt with. It is in the programme for Government but it needs to be moved on an awful lot quicker.

On the cost of disability, the cost-of-disability payment should support the cost of disability. That is not the cost of disability if someone is on payment X, Y or Z. It has to focus on the additional cost of a disability no matter what payment someone receives. So many people are locked out of disability allowance because of the household means test. I hope that that will be looked at.

On one-parent families, I always make this case. Maintenance was removed from household means as regards social welfare payments. That was welcome. It is still there across other Departments when accessing other payments, though. Maintenance is for the child or children and it should never ever be treated as household means and all Departments should treat it the same way.

As for the comments the Tánaiste made, I had a motion in the last Dáil on our job clubs and our local employment services. It was a motion that was passed by this House. They were the people in the community who met people where they were at and who did not just look, as JobPath and the private providers do, at a job, any job, to tick a box so that they got paid. The job clubs and local employment services met the person where they were. They had wraparound services. They had all the supports, whether it was with addiction or otherwise. They supported people with what they needed. With the private companies, it is about a job, any job, so that they can get paid. That is their motive. They are companies - it is about profit, and that is what they do. Maybe the Department and the Minister can look back to the job clubs and the local employment services that this House supported in the motion I brought forward. They are a huge loss.

Comment on this

I welcome the Social Welfare Bill 2026. I commend my colleague, the Minister, Deputy Calleary, the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, and the whole team for bringing forward a package of measures that will make a genuine difference to households across the country. Taken together, all of these measures demonstrate a clear commitment to protecting vulnerable households, while ensuring that economic progress is shared fairly across society. It is a practical balance and it is a compassionate Bill that I am please to support.

In particular, I welcome the introduction of the new cost-of-disability payment. For years, people with disabilities and disability organisations themselves have highlighted a reality that many of us take for granted, which is that living with a disability often means facing additional costs every single day, be those medical expenses, assistive technologies, home adaptations or simply the extra energy costs associated with living with a disability. Those costs add up quickly and are a constant. The €500 cost-of-disability payment is, therefore, a welcome acknowledgment by the Government that these additional costs are real and that they deserve a dedicated response.

However, we all recognise that this is a very complex area and a lump sum payment is a very important start but as we continue developing this policy, there is merit in considering how existing supports can better recognise the realities of living with a disability. Let us take fuel costs as an example. Many people with disabilities spend significantly more time at home. Some people have conditions that make them particularly sensitive to cold temperatures and many disabled people simply need more heat and face higher energy bills as a result. That is why there is a strong argument for looking at measures such as automatic access to the fuel allowance for people on long-term disability payments. We should be examining ways to ensure that supports reach those with clearly identifiable needs, regardless of their means.

I welcome the increase in the disability allowance earnings disregard and the expansion of employment supports. Our goal should be to create a system where people can work the hours they are capable of working, where they are capable of working them, without fear of losing the supports they depend on. Disability is not a one-size-fits-all experience, and our welfare system should reflect that.

I would like to use this opportunity as well to raise the issue of foster and kinship carers. These are people who open their hearts and their homes to children who need stability, care and support. Foster carers play a critical role in our child protection system and they deserve support. As we begin looking ahead already to budget 2028, could the Minister give careful consideration to the concerns advanced by both foster care and kinship care organisations? Significant progress has been made in many areas of social protection but there is a strong case for examining the financial supports available to these carers and ensuring that they are adequately recognised for the vital role they perform. Could the Minister consider-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I thank the Deputy very much.

Comment on this

I am delighted to speak today on this Bill. There is plenty in it to welcome - right across the board, from the State pension going over €300 a week for the first time since the foundation of the State to really important increases for carers and children. To me, the real strength of this Bill is the targeted supports for people who are most vulnerable. That is something on which I want to commend the Minister. I want to say why that matters so much. An increase across the board is welcome, there is no doubt about it, but for the people under real pressure, rising costs can eat that up very quickly. Targeting identifies the people who are carrying extra costs that others are not and puts the help right where they need it. To me, that is how we make every euro count.

There are two groups in particular I want to home in on here today: people with disabilities and people living on their own. For the first time ever, there is a cost-of-disability payment. It starts with a €500 lump sum next year for people on long-term disability payments, and it will be developed further, working directly with disabled people and their advocates. That is an absolutely massive step. The State is acknowledging just how much more it costs to live with a disability. The Bill also makes it easier for disabled people to get into work if they want and are able to do so. The wage subsidy scheme drops from 15 hours a week to eight hours. Someone on a disability allowance will be able to earn over €9,000 a year without losing a cent of their payment. That is going to make a real difference to people right across the country.

I want to see the same thinking for people living alone. This Bill makes a real start. The income limit for the fuel allowance for a single pensioner was always half of what a couple got. This Bill brings it up to 60% - €641. To me, that is the system finally catching up with what every person living alone already knows. One person cannot run half a house. There is no one to split the bills with and the heating, electricity, insurance and car all cost the same. The Society of St. Vincent de Paul says a person living alone needs nearly 80% of what a couple needs just to get by. The living alone increase is moving again, too; for the first time in five years. That is a welcome start, but I want to see it pushed ahead in the next budget and subsequent budgets.

As rural affairs spokesperson for Fianna Fáil, I also welcome the rural dweller pilot, which is expanding to 500 places. It lets over-50s in rural areas earn a top-up on their payments by doing part-time work with local community groups. My ask of the Minister is not for one big number, but to use the momentum from this Bill to keep the focus on targeted support for people with disabilities and people living alone. Will the Minister make sure that Carlow and Kilkenny get their fair share of those rural dweller places? I will be doing absolutely everything I can to get that over the line.

This Bill shows what targeted support can do for the people who need it most, so they can get some breathing space and live with dignity. Let us keep it going.

Comment on this

I am glad to get an opportunity to speak on the Social Welfare Bill and to raise with the Minister of State a case of a constituent of mine, a 44-year-old man who has cerebral palsy. He has been on the disability allowance payment since he was 18. This week, he received a letter from the Department seeking that he would complete a very comprehensive set of paperwork to indicate whether there has been any change in his medical condition or his personal circumstances. I hope the Minister of State is paying attention because this is his Department messing up. Who does it expect will have to go through all this? Is it this 44-year-old man who has cerebral palsy, who is doing his best to live an independent life, or his elderly parents? This family has made a correlation - I do not know whether there is one - between Rambo Harris's remarks about cracking down on social welfare payments and this letter that has come through their door. I am going to be raising this directly with the senior Minister and asking him to intervene, but I want to say it very clearly: this young man is not a burden on our State. He is an absolutely invaluable addition to our local community and he is much loved and appreciated, and our systems should reflect that. The systems within the Department should reflect that. There needs to be a system in place whereby it does not send somebody with a profound disability a form of this nature, asking them to reaffirm the situation as it has been every year since they were 18 when they are now 44. That is unfair and verging on the cruel. I will be writing to the Minister in this instance asking him to intervene and ensure that this request is withdrawn.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

Will the Minister of State ensure that his Department shows a bit of humanity when dealing with cases like this?

Comment on this

I want to open my remarks by referring to what the Tánaiste stated at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis at the weekend. As many people have said, it was absolutely appalling. I welcome that the Minister has somewhat distanced himself from them, but it goes without saying that this is what the entire country believes is the Government's approach to social welfare recipients. The Tánaiste has called for us to bring in a system that is already in place and penalties that already exist. Where is he going with this? Is it to push people and jobseekers who are getting penalties of €90 already and who are living on €150 a week further into financial penury and God knows what? Is it totally to remove the floor of decency from anyone? We have a number of job activation schemes and have had for many years. The system is tough and is engaged with people who are not engaging with these services, and the penalties are in place. What is the Tánaiste's messaging here? We know that when he walked into the Ard-Fheis, he said he wanted to appeal to people who used to vote for Fine Gael and maybe did not any more - maybe those voters who are attracted by the Minister, Jim O'Callaghan's language and movement on immigration. Those strongman politics may be working for one Minister in Fianna Fáil on one issue, and disgusting as it is, the Tánaiste is now trying to appropriate it for Fine Gael and make it work for him.

When Fine Gael is in trouble, it always reaches for someone vulnerable and some group to punch down upon to distract from its own poor ratings and to put attention on a problem that does not exist. If a problem does exist, there are remedies for it and they are in place. It was one of the grubbiest and most disgusting things I have seen in my time in politics. The Tánaiste needs to listen to what the Minister for Social Protection is saying in relation to the social protection system. This Bill is not perfect. It does not go anywhere near where we want it to go. However, it certainly does not reflect the tenor and atmosphere of the Tánaiste's statement over the weekend. There is some distance there.

When it comes to this Bill, we welcome that the Government has finally made a move on a cost-of-disability payment. We called for €30 a week. The Government has started with €10 a week. It is not enough but it is a start. Hopefully, we can see improvements in this area. Hopefully, this can become a fundamental of the social protection system. Domiciliary care allowance remains the forgotten or most poorly treated social protection payment. We all know the difficulties with domiciliary care allowance. It is the most difficult payment for applicants to get. They are made to jump through so many hoops. They believe they have to put in the application, which will be refused, so that they can then appeal. That is how people feel when they are applying for domiciliary care allowance. It is the one payment that did not get an increase in this budget. Again, those in receipt of or applying for domiciliary care allowance cannot help but ask why they are always treated differently and why they are always treated so poorly.

I echo what my colleague Deputy Wall, the Labour Party spokesperson for social protection, said yesterday when he gave a fantastic speech and a fantastic analysis of where this Bill is deficient in relation to carer's allowance. The 600,000 family carers in this country save the State €20 billion a year in unpaid care work. As Deputy Wall said, that is the equivalent of another HSE. The Government continues to fail to plan to build capacity in this area and in residential and independent living options for people living with disabilities. It is more than 20 years since the Labour Party first called for the removal of the means test on the carer's allowance. It is about time that we saw genuine movement in this area. This Bill goes some way, but it does not go anywhere near enough. I reiterate that the Tánaiste's comments at the weekend were an absolute disgrace and he needs to apologise for them.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

We will take the Members who are here. I call Deputy Boland. I propose to allow Deputy Gibney to take five minutes. Is that agreed? Agreed. She was at a committee.

Comment on this

Deputy Gibney can go first.

Comment on this

I thank the Ceann Comhairle and everyone. I really appreciate it.

In the context of this Bill, I wish to raise issues that affect people with disabilities and lone parents. Regarding working disabled people, on paper we supposedly have a system that promotes independent living and supports disabled people to enter the labour market if they wish. The Government continuously bandies about slogans over how important it is to make work pay. For too many people in this country, the prospect of a promotion, extra hours or a pay increase is not a cause for celebration but instead is a source of fear and anxiety. Those who receive disability allowance and have medical cards spend their whole lives walking a tightrope where they cannot earn enough to live comfortably but they also cannot risk losing the disability support they receive by going over an arbitrary income limit. Instead of making work pay, many people with disabilities are trapped in a catch-22 where they are much worse off in work. This undermines their agency, independence and right to participate in society. Systems like these are part of the reason that Ireland has one of the lowest rates of employment among disabled people in Europe at 32.6%, compared with an EU average of 51.3%.

Similarly, there is no effort to make work pay in this Bill for people parenting alone. The Government has repeatedly failed to sufficiently increase income disregards for the jobseeker’s transitional payment and the one-parent family payment. This means that lone parents cannot afford to enter employment, once again trapping them in a cycle of poverty. Since 2000, there has been a reduction of more than 55% in the amount of income that lone parents can earn before these payments are impacted. This makes it harder - not easier - to enter employment. This is not making work pay. I mentioned the reduction that has taken place since 2000. I had a child in 2000 as a lone parent. It kills me - it was one of the motivations for me to get into politics - that from about 2011 onwards people were so much worse off as single parents. It became so much harder to have a child and rear a child alone and navigate the Byzantine system of supports that are available for people who parent alone. They are negative incentives left, right and centre for them in terms of entering into work.

I wish to discuss one-off measures and means testing. The once-off €500 cost-of-disability payment provided for in this budget is only available if a person already qualifies for another long-term disability payment, the vast majority of which are means tested. This crucially misses the entire point of a cost-of-disability payment. It does not matter how much a wheelchair user, a person who uses mobility aids or a person who needs assistive technology makes; they still have a series of huge unavoidable costs simply because they have a disability. That is what we are talking about in the Social Democrats when we talk about the cost of disability. Regrettably and regressively, the payment in next year's budget is once-off. People who have expressed their frustration to my office about this have explained that their disabilities and the costs associated with them will not evaporate in the next 12 months.

As arts spokesperson for my party, I wish to speak about disabled artists and to highlight a particular aspect of their experience which often remains unseen. Disabled artists face huge barriers when it comes to accessing arts funding and measures that are meant to support them in their craft. This is something I have raised with the Departments of Culture, Communications and Sport and Social Protection. The lack of a formalised system for income disregards related to the Arts Council's funding and the basic income for the arts scheme leaves disabled artists in an administrative mess at best and at worst without the vital supports they need to live in dignity. For many, this creates a chilling effect where they are too afraid of losing their medical cards or other crucial supports to even apply for funding that should be available to them. I thank the DADA Campaign group, which has highlighted this, as well as many other disabled artists who continue to push for change in this area. Awards, grants and commissions for artists are not income. They are a total project budget. However, our social welfare system does not systematically recognise this and often treats them as personal income. If we want equal access to arts in this country and if we want to benefit from the fantastic talent and work of disabled people, we need to recognise them in our systems.

Let us talk about what solutions look like. The situation for disabled people in employment, one-parent families and disabled artists can be solved by the same thing, which is viewing people with disabilities and people parenting alone not as an exception to be worked around or, worse, ignored but as a fundamental feature of the rich and diverse tapestry that makes up our society. We need to recognise why supports are there for people in the first place and look at the wider context of their living and working realities. If a system does not reflect the lived reality of so many disabled people and lone parents in this country, it is the system that must change. Inclusion is not about pity. It is not about charity. It is a duty that we have to every single person in this country to ensure they can live a good and dignified life. Má tá muid ag iarraidh tír a bheith againn ina bhfuil cothrom na Féinne ag gach duine, caithfidh muid córas a chruthú a aithníonn na difríochtaí agus éagsúlachtaí inár bpobal. Is féidir córas a chruthú atá in ann freastal ar na héagsúlachtaí seo ach, faraor, níl sé seo le feiceáil i bpolasaithe an Rialtais. If we want a country of equals, we need systems that recognise the variations and differences in our communities.

Comment on this

I welcome the many positive measures contained in the Social Welfare Bill and the improvements across a wide range of social welfare supports, including the cost-of-living disability payment. I very much welcome progress made on the carer's income disregard. I acknowledge the substantial scale of this social welfare package of almost €31 billion. It is one of the largest investments made by the Government in any area. This reflects the value that this Government places on supporting pensioners, carers, people with disabilities, jobseekers, workers and families. I particularly welcome the increases in maternity, paternity, adoptive and parents' benefits. However, these remain flat-rate payments despite being funded through PRSI contributions. As I have raised repeatedly in this House, the time has come to deliver on the programme for Government commitment to expand pay-related social insurance benefits, starting with supports for parents.

Supporting working families is not just good social policy; it is good economic policy. It strengthens workforce participation, helps employers to retain skilled staff and gives families greater financial security. Recent analysis from the Parliamentary Budget Office has highlighted the substantial surplus in the Social Insurance Fund, which now has reserves in excess of €20 billion. While those reserves have important long-term purposes, in particular relating to pensions, I ask the Minister to examine whether a portion of that strength can be used to improve PRSI-funded supports for working families.

I have repeatedly raised the need for a public awareness campaign around entitlements for parents. Too many families, in particular fathers, remain unaware of important supports such as paternity leave and parents' leave. Supporting fathers to spend more time with their children in those early months benefits children, families and society as a whole.

I want to touch on unemployment activation and Intreo. Many Intreo employees provide an excellent service and work hard to help people. However, it would be wrong of me to ignore the criticisms I regularly receive from my constituents who are service users. I continue to hear concerns from people who find the system overly bureaucratic, inflexible and difficult to navigate, in particular those trying to move from welfare into entrepreneurship or self-employment. These are people who are taking the initiative and trying to create jobs, build businesses and become economically independent, yet many of them report that the system can place obstacles in their path when it should be helping them to succeed.

I ask the Minister to examine whether these schemes are sufficiently flexible and tailored to individual circumstances, in particular for those seeking to establish their own businesses. The question is very simple: if someone wants to move into entrepreneurship, are we making that journey easier or harder? I encourage the Minister to review these schemes, engage with Intreo teams and ensure activation services are genuinely supporting entrepreneurship, self-employment and business creation.

I welcome the substantial social welfare package and the significant investment being made in social protection. I urge the Minister to move swiftly on the programme for Government commitment to expand pay-related social insurance benefits, beginning with supports to parents, and to ensure a renewed focus by Intreo on entrepreneurship within our employment activation system so that people seeking to build businesses and create jobs are supported and not discouraged. If we get those two areas right, we will strengthen families, our economy and our social protection system.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister had a good time last weekend at the nasty party Ard-Fheis. Poor Simon Harris was not allowed to debate the motion he wanted to debate on Fine Gael embracing the anti-woke politics that have just been rejected by the American electorate. He is slightly late. Instead of being able to vote on that, he decided to use his Ard-Fheis speech to signal a further move rightward. The party is in a competition with Fianna Fáil on that one. Unemployed people, older people and those who are struggling were collateral damage in the Fine Gael vice signalling. It was red meat for the Fine Gael base by creating a false narrative, which thankfully was rejected by the Minister at the start of the debate, about there being loads of people on the dole as a lifestyle choice.

The Bill does the same thing. It does something, whereas Simon Harris was not doing anything. He did not propose any policies whatsoever. It was simply a rhetorical flourish. The Bill is about increasing the penalties for non-compliance with activation measures to €100 per week. One of the most disturbing aspects of the debate that then unfolded was the attempt by the Tánaiste to portray and pretend that this is being done out of concern for the children of the long-term unemployed. Happy Christmas, kids. Fine Gael - that is, Scrooge - is going to cut your parents' dole but do not worry, it is somehow actually for your own good.

This is a Government that has stood over an increase in the rate of child poverty in one of the richest countries in the world, where one in ten children are being deprived of necessities. Fine Gael and the Government, in terms of these policies, are now implementing extra-hard punitive measures which will punish children even more and drive more children into poverty. The Tánaiste is fond of saying, "Let's be clear on this". Let us be clear on this: cutting someone's dole does nothing to help them to get a job. All it does is make their life and the lives of their children harder. People who are already poor and stressed out as a result of poverty are put under more pressure and this will not make it magically easier for them to find a job. It will not fix someone's mental health or addiction issues. Putting resources into public services would do that, but Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil are not interested in doing that. All it will do is make life harder for unemployed people, which is what the Tánaiste's speech, or parts of the Bill, are about. It is about performative cruelty which has marked this Government, in particular, since the start. It is about kicking the unemployed and immigrants and hoping people will be distracted by that and not see what the Government is up to every day of the week.

This was an attempt to say to the people who are struggling, who go out to work, who pay a lot of taxes and who are struggling to pay mortgages, childcare and bills and to heat their homes that the problem they face is lazy unemployed people. The number of long-term unemployed people is historically low, at about half of the EU average. Only 8,000 people are unemployed year after year, in the words of the Tánaiste. It is an act of mass distraction to say, "Look down here, not up here at the people we represent". Google walked through the front door of the Department of Finance before the last budget and asked for a tax change, which it got and which was worth €300 million for one company. The fast food giants got €400 million in tax breaks and the developers got another €300 million in the change to VAT. The Government is seeking to distract people from such massive corporate welfare.

I ask the Minister to confirm that the Tánaiste was engaging in disinformation when he told RTÉ that 52,000 people are long-term unemployed. The true figure is 38,900. The reality is that a large majority of those have been unemployed for less than two years and that the number unemployed for over two years has fallen by 80% in the past ten years.

My final point concerns older people, who are disproportionately unemployed because of discrimination that exists in the workforce. The system recognises that by exempting people aged 62 and older from having to engage in labour activation measures, but the Tánaiste went after them. They were also collateral damage. Many people who worked their entire lives now find themselves out of a job and the Tánaiste is going after them.

Comment on this

I am not sure whether the Minister will act on the Tánaiste's speech last Saturday evening. I saw some of it and thought for a moment I was watching Nigel Farage on the BBC or Donald Trump on Fox News. I hope we will not swing further to the right in this country. We have seen the damage that was done in other countries across the world, including Britain and America, and the division it creates.

I support helping unemployed people in getting back into employment. We should try to tackle long-term unemployment. There should be good activation measures so that people can get good jobs and have a reasonable quality of life. That should be the aim and we should continue to do that. That is where our focus should be, not on the type of populism we have heard. On this side of the House we are often accused of being ideologically hung up on different things. The Tánaiste's speech was the most ideologically right-wing economic speech I heard at an Ard-Fheis for a long time. What is the Fianna Fáil position on it?

There are increases in this Social Welfare Bill. All increases are welcome. The problem is that we are chasing higher and higher prices. That is the issue. We have had a number of debates on the cost of living in recent weeks, including yesterday.

I will say to the Minister and Government Deputies that they can keep chasing higher rents and higher electricity prices. However, the energy companies will make more profits, and the landlords and the developers will make more profits because the house prices are getting higher, which means the mortgages get higher.

A range of measures has been put forward and the Minister may disagree with some of them, and that is fine. A whole suite of measures has been put forward by various parties and individuals, a lot of which I agree with, but not all of them. We really need to bring down the cost of living and the cost of doing things and of going about your business in terms of insurance, energy, transport, etc. However, instead of that, we are driving costs up sky high. The social welfare increase is 3%. If we are talking about €10 on €300, it is about 3.3%. It does not keep up with all of those high costs, particularly energy and costs like it that which have gone up 9%, 10%, 12% in the past year. All increases are welcome but we are not doing enough because of runaway prices. We are starting in a different place.

There was a proposal for two-tier child benefit. There is an argument for and against it. However, the Economic and Social Research Institute, ESRI, study showed that it would lift 55,000 children directly out of poverty from those households that are on the lowest incomes. While it did not make it this year, it should be kept under review. I know there is an argument for and against it and questions about the families just above the threshold. That has to be considered. However, it is worth reviewing again.

I want to raise the issue of temporary teachers. The pay-related jobseeker's benefit was to stop people falling off a cliff edge when they finished work as the next thing was their income was a quarter of what it was last week. That is obviously shattering for people. I have had teachers contact me who do not have permanent contracts. When it comes to the school holidays, they are back on jobseeker's benefit and they are falling off the cliff edge at that point. Their income is down to 20% or 25% of what they were getting when they were teaching. I know how the calculation is done in terms of PRSI weeks, etc., but I ask that Department officials look at that again because teachers and people in the education sector in particular are in a very difficult situation.

The last issue I want to raise is referred to as Xs and Os, or casual jobseeker's allowance or jobseeker's benefit. Earnings of €20 a day are disallowed. As far as I can remember, that has been the same for the last quarter of a century. Some people's work by its nature is casual and temporary. It might be one day this week and three days next week. We should be helping people to maximise that and maximise the benefit of it to make sure we help to make it viable for them to continue to do that, instead of them giving up altogether and signing on for five days. That would at least keep people in work. I ask that the €20 that is disallowed be increased. The rest is reckoned at 60%. I ask that the Department officials take note of that. It is a quarter of a century since that €20 threshold has been changed.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom fáilte a chur roimh na tograí ar fad atá sa Bhille Leasa Shóisialaigh. Is tograí iad a léiríonn na luachanna atá ag mo pháirtí faoi aire a thabhairt dóibh siúd nach bhfuil an méid céanna acu is a bhfuil ag daoine eile sa sochaí, nach bhfuil sé de chumas acu an méid is mó ioncaim a bhaint amach dóibh féin, agus atá fágtha taobh thiar. Is iad sin na bunluachanna a bhaineann leis an bpoblachtánachas, agus cuireann sé áthas orm iad a fheiceáil á cur chun cinn ag Aire de chuid Fhianna Fáil sa Bhille seo.

I welcome the Social Welfare Bill and a number of particular provisions therein. I particularly welcome the very solid and strong focus on the likes of the working family payment and the child support payment, which are direct interventions from the State to continue to make work attractive for people - things that exist in our social welfare system at this moment in time and that are important to revive families that are working, not only economically - and I praise all those families who do work and who instil the ethic of work in their families - but also in terms of the supports that exist in our social welfare system to make sure those families are supported through things like the working family payment and the child support payment.

I also welcome the fact that we have now put in place a permanent cost-of-disability payment, and I want to pay tribute to the Minister's leadership in securing that particular item of expenditure, putting it in law so that it becomes a budget line in and of itself that future governments will have to continue to enhance and develop. That is in response to very direct pressures from people we all represent in this House.

There is continued progress being made on the carer's disregard threshold, which is a very welcome step forward. More and more people are now being taken out of that threshold. Of course, we need to continue to move at pace to bring more people out of it and to get rid of that overall means test in its entirety but there has been very solid progress made in that regard.

I know the Minister is particularly passionate about the need to solidly and directly address child poverty in our country at the moment. I welcome the steps that have been taken in this budget and the engagement the Minister has had with me in this House on what models we can look at in the future to further support those families and further bring down that proportion of children who live in poverty in our country. Whether that is through the means-tested child benefit model or the taxable child benefit support, I think we are now developing the corpus of evidence both across the ESRI and from the Department to allow us to identify the best policy interventions we can take to really deal with child poverty, and not only to deal with it in a way that gives those children in poverty a decent standard of living but also in a way that continues to show them that in this economy, we reward people who work and we see that a job is not just an economic value creator but it is also something that gives purpose and gives people a stake in society. That is something our social welfare system does at the moment and it is something that I think the Minister is continuing to enhance with the measures he is bringing forward. I look forward to continued progress in the sphere of child poverty, and I very much commend this Bill to the House.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Social Welfare Bill. The legislation delivers on the commitments made in budget 2027 and provides meaningful support to both individuals and families who continue to face cost-of-living pressures. I also welcome the increases in maternity benefit, paternity benefit, adoptive benefit and parent's benefit, together with improvements for carers. These measures recognise the invaluable role played by parents and families in our communities and provide practical support at important stages of our family lives. Importantly, the Bill also improves means-test arrangements and increases earnings disregards. This means people can work more while accessing important supports.

For communities across County Louth, this legislation will support pensioners, carers, people with disabilities, working families, and those on lower incomes at a time when many households continue to feel financial pressures. However, we cannot stand still. Reform is needed, and on a couple of occasions, I have raised the issue here of working families who, through no fault of their own, have suffered as a result of being ill. I am looking at the illness benefit. I remind the Minister of the case I brought to him last year where a widow who had lost her husband got sick and could not access illness benefit, notwithstanding that she had paid all of her PRSI. I remind the Minister of the small retailer in County Louth who had to go into hospital and close his business for six months because he could not access illness benefit. Reform is needed.

Many of the Opposition think it is absolutely right that no penalties should ever be faced if someone does not engage effectively and continuously with the employment services. Pathways to work is a way where the State needs to be encouraging people to engage and find work. In an economy that is at full employment, there are people who are not engaging with their local Intreo centre. They need to be brought on a journey. They need to be supported but when they do not engage, they need to be penalised. That is an unfortunate fact. Nobody wants to see it. We want to encourage people to work because it brings value and brings dignity. Working and leaving your house every day to go out to meet with people and contribute to society is not something that you should be ashamed of. It is something you should take pride in. When we talk about penalties, let us remind people that it was the Labour Party Minister, Joan Burton, who brought in the first penalties in 2011. We need a carrot at all times. We need to support our people but when the carrot does not work, the stick needs to come into action. We talk about putting money into people's pockets but we have to ensure the money goes into the right people's pockets.

Comment on this

I will address the elephant in the room.

Last weekend, at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis in my home city of Cork, the Tánaiste said the dole should be a safety net, not a way of life. He promised penalties for people who will not engage in employment schemes and that has been backed up already by the previous speaker from Fine Gael. The party is doubling down on that. The Taoiseach, however, has rejected those statements. Which is it? Are Fine Gael Party members, including its backbenchers, making those remarks as a statement or soundbite or do they reflect Government policy? Will the Minister clarify that for the House? The Minister who addressed the House earlier seemed to clarify it.

It is worth noting that 6,329 people are on jobseeker's allowance for more than ten years and, additionally, 30,000 are in receipt of it for more than five years. In total, that gives a relatively small number. Perhaps the policy should be to help those people. The Government should be examining why 30,000 people have been unemployed for more than five years. Is it an education problem? Is it that they have not engaged properly with supports? I do not believe it is a question of not properly engaging. Some people are just left behind by society. Some people need to be helped a little bit more rather than being kicked while they are down. If only there were a Minister for further education, or a previous Minister, who had planned for that. If only a previous Minister for further education had looked at this issue as a whole and asked what he could do to improve it. Instead, he was busy on TikTok.

We should not be lecturing people who are down and out and finding things difficult. I really do not know one person drawing the dole who is tripping the light fantastic. Nobody wants to be on the dole. Nobody wants to be on that amount of money, worrying about whether they will put food on the table or pay the ESB bill, gas bill or whatever other bill arrives. In fact, most people on the dole with whom I have engaged are afraid of the postman's knock and the next bill that is coming through their door.

The elephant in the room that the Tánaiste did not mention whatsoever is that figures released by the Department of Social Protection earlier this year show that 347,736 people with non-Irish nationality are receiving a social welfare payment. That includes child benefit and pensions and, of course, some of those people are working and paying their tax. Nobody should be criticised for that. However, in the interest of fairness and for the benefit of the House, will the Minister publish a full breakdown of every payment under every scheme by nationality and duration of claim? That would be a far fairer way to approach the issue in this House.

Independent Ireland will support the Bill. I do not think anybody in this House will say we should not give an extra €10 to pensioners this year. However, its provisions only scratch the surface. Prior to the election 24 months ago, the Minister's party promised the people of Ireland a State pension of €350 per week. That is what was promised to get the Minister and his colleagues sitting on the benches on that side of the House, but they have not delivered it. Shopping bills have increased by an average of 5% to 11%. The Minister gave an increase of €3 in the living alone allowance. I have listened to Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Members talk about what a great budget it was and what a great social welfare package is being given. People will not get a pint of milk and a sliced pan for €3. It does not buy a pound of butter, which costs €4.81 at the moment. It buys approximately 2.5 kg of potatoes. It certainly will not buy a pint anywhere in the country. It buys approximately 1.6 litres of petrol at the moment. The Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil Members saying this is a great budget and pointing to the fabulous increases in payments are not taking into account the cost of living. In the past 24 months, we have seen shopping bills go up by about 11% and an increase in fuel costs of 18.3%. There are now 500,000 people in this country in arrears on their ESB or gas bill. Where is the €350 per week the Government promised?

Widows and widowers, who are often the forgotten people in society, are faced with a deeply unfair situation. We know that when somebody passes away, approximately 80% of previous income is needed just to keep that household going. The cost of insurance, heating and lighting does not change. Too often, however, we see people's incomes decreasing by 50%. Will the Minister look seriously at a property tax exemption for pensioners? Currently, a deferral of payment is offered, at a 3% rate on top, for those on incomes up to €25,000, or €40,000 for a couple. That charge follows people into their grave. There are a number of people who should not be paying property tax after they reach 65 years of age. Will the Minister examine whether it is a possibility to introduce such an exemption in years to come? It is a very unfair tax for a lot of older people who are finding it tough to pay the bills, keep the lights on and heat their home.

I also highlight the situation of carers and those with a disability. Another promise Members opposite made before occupying their seats on that side of the House was that they would abolish the means test for carers. Where are they with that? We all understand what carers do for this country. I have often asked the Minister, Deputy Calleary, and other Ministers who is taking care of the carers, who do a tremendous service to the State. The Minister knows it, I know it and every Member of the House knows it. The means test must be abolished. If people make promises to get to that side of the House, the least they should do while they occupy those seats is fulfil those promises.

Comment on this

The colleagues who have spoken have all pointed out the virtues of this Bill. I endorse what they said and I congratulate the Minister on all the reforms he has introduced and the improvements he has made to the system since his accession to the Department.

As I have very little time, I will use it to address the question asked by a number of speakers about certain events that happened at the weekend and where my party stands on the matter. Let me be very clear about that. The Tánaiste apparently got a flash of inspiration on the road to Cork. It is easily known that he was not travelling on the Limerick road because it is so hazardous that a person would not have time to feel inspiration or anything else. That flash of inspiration led him to discover who was responsible for all the ills facing Irish society. Who were these great blockers who were preventing measures that would reduce or eliminate all our ills at a stroke? It was the poor, he found, specifically those who are long-term employed; the people with no money. Party leaders are supposed to talk about policy at their party conference. I do not know what type of policy this is. To me, it is not policy. It is a man in a suit pointing a finger at a very vulnerable group of people who cannot answer back and then claiming that is leadership.

If the Tánaiste did a small bit of research - it is not very difficult to find this out - he would discover, as Deputy O'Flynn and others have said, that only a tiny percentage of the social welfare budget is spent on the long-term unemployed. They have to share that budget with those in receipt of jobseeker's benefit, who, by definition, are short-term unemployed, short-term jobseeker's allowance recipients, people who are ill, pensioners, bereaved partners and all the ancillary benefits that attach to those various payments. In fact, if we were to reduce to zero the amount paid to the long-term unemployed and let them all starve, it would have very little impact on the overall budgetary figures.

This trick is not new or original. We saw Leo Varadkar engage in it as well. It is a very simply trick. It involves picking out a group of people who are small and voiceless enough that there will be no political risk to singling them out and promising a crackdown. What happens then? The audience cheers, the media get a headline and the Minister gets to look decisive. I do not want to unduly take up the time of the House and I am aware that my colleague Deputy Brabazon is speaking next. All I will say in conclusion is that when Leo Varadkar tried that stunt some years ago, it looked a bit weird and strange and everybody saw through it. Now it just looks utterly ludicrous and nakedly cynical.

Comment on this

There has been a lot of talk in the past week about social welfare and whether it is a good or bad thing.

I am of the firm belief that we must have a strong social welfare system that protects the most vulnerable in our society. Yes, those who can work should work but there are many who are unable to work or have limited capacity to work. It is the duty of the State to ensure that there is a safety net for those who are unable to work, those with a disability, the elderly and parents. I welcome the measures outlined in the Bill and the increases across the associated social welfare payments.

The programme for Government made a commitment to phasing out the means test for the carers' allowance during the lifetime of this Government. I urge the Department, the Minister for Social Protection and the Department of Finance to do everything possible on that commitment sooner rather than later. Many feel that the means test is a slap in the face and that the State is simply not doing enough to recognise the enormous contribution that carers make. There are people who dedicate their lives to caring for loved ones. By providing care that would otherwise have to be delivered through public services, carers also save the State the significant expense of €20 billion a year, by some estimates. That contribution deserves proper recognition.

I also welcome the introduction of the new €500 annual cost-of-disability payment. While it is not enough, it is a start. People who are living with disabilities often face additional expenses that the rest of us simply do not have to consider, be they transport, heating, specialist equipment or everyday living costs. This payment is a welcome acknowledgement of those challenges. It is long overdue and I hope it is something we can build upon in future budgets.

Another group I want to mention is people who live alone and particularly older people. Living alone is expensive. The electricity bill, the heating bill and the cost of maintaining a home all fall on one person when there is nobody to share those expenses with. We need to continue to look at how we can better support people living alone, especially as energy and household costs remain a significant burden.

We have a responsibility in this House to protect those who need it. The measures outlined in this Bill and the recent budget are welcome. I hope to see the Government going forward during its lifetime.

Comment on this
Dara Calleary Minister for Social Protection Fianna Fáil

Gabhaim buíochas leis na Teachtaí ar fad as na ráitis agus na tuairimí a nochtadh sa díospóireacht thábhachtach seo. Bhí sé suimiúil go raibh i bhfad níos mó daoine ag caint air seo ná mar a bhí le cúpla bliain anuas. Cuirim fáilte roimhe sin.

I thank all Deputies on all sides of the House for their contributions. Deputy O'Reilly and I, as veterans of this debate, will note that there has been a lot more participation in this debate than there has been for some years. That has to be welcomed and I look forward to continuing interest.

The Bill underpins a budget for 2027 of €30.9 billion, which is an increase of 7% from last year, with over €1.15 billion in new measures. Many Deputies were making references to the fact that the budget did not provide for particular measures and particular increases, or that programme for Government commitments have not been delivered. It is simply not possible to include everything that I would wish in the Bill. All the suggestions have been noted but it is my intention to deliver three more social welfare budgets during my time as the Minister for Social Protection. The commitments within the programme for Government will be delivered on.

I just want the Members to know the overall impact of the budget. The ESRI post-budget analysis found that the changes to tax, welfare and childcare supports in budget 2027 are, on average, ahead of forecast price growth of 3%. They are broadly in line with forecast wage growth of 4.1% for 2027. Those in the lower income deciles gain the most, helped by the cost-of-disability payment and increases in the child support payment. In the context of the cost-of-living pressures that are currently facing people, it is important that we place this on the record of the House.

Deputy O'Reilly and others raised the issue of child poverty. I agree that one child in poverty is one too many. The social welfare budget package includes a number of targeted measures to this end, including increases in the child support payment, increases in the income threshold for the working family payment, an increase in the earnings disregard for a one-parent family and jobseeker transition payments. The holiday hunger programme, which was initially a pilot programme, will now become a permanent initiative next July, which will benefit 40,000 children.

A question was raised by Deputy O'Reilly and others about the introduction of the second tier of child benefit as a means to tackle child poverty. We launched a public consultation in May this year on a potential targeted child payment as well as a proposed working age payment. That consultation concluded in June. Submissions were received from representative bodies, advocacy organisations, service providers and members of the public. The complexity of this issue is shown where the ESRI has recently given us revised proposals as we work through the detailed design of a potential new scheme. The previous ESRI proposal and previously assigned model would potentially have seen up to 100,000 families losing out on existing payments. The new proposal corrects that but this demonstrates the complexity involved here. We do not have a magic wand but we are very focused in relation to it.

Deputies Brabazon, O'Dea and others raised the issue of the carers' allowance. Again, I will point out that within my first two budgets we have increased the carers' allowance disregard for singles and for couples by 84%. This means that a couple on over €126,000 will now be able to get a full payment without being in any way affected by the means test. In fact, they will be able to earn over €155,000 and still receive a partial payment. The programme for Government commits to the abolition of the carers' allowance means test over the lifetime of this Government. I think I have made very significant progress in these first two years but I also have an eye to existing carers. We have to support existing carers also.

I want to thank the Deputies for their comments on the cost-of-disability payment. That payment will be made in the week commencing 15 February 2027 to some 240,000 recipients at an estimated investment over €119 million. I acknowledge that many Deputies are concerned about groups that are included and not included in the payment next year such as disabled workers who are not in receipt of social welfare payment and pensioners. We had a very constructive meeting last week with a group representing disabled workers who are not in receipt of a social welfare payment and we will have further engagements with the Department of Finance on their issues. As I noted in my opening statement yesterday, respecting the feedback from a very extensive consultation process that has taken place we will now engage in a co-design process with disabled people and their representatives on how the payment will be structured and delivered from 2028 on. One query was raised yesterday in relation to the permanency of the cost-of-disability payment. I can confirm this is a permanent measure. I expect the co-design process to conclude in the first half of 2027. I will bring a recommendation to Government ahead of budget 2028.

A lot of contributions were made on the supports provided to the long-term unemployed. I clarified my position and that of the Government on that yesterday evening. Our public employment service is about helping people to take practical steps towards employment. It is delivered through Intreo and its partners. It brings together employment advice and income supports, and it helps jobseekers to identify the opportunities and to access the assistance they need. More than 50,000 people are currently receiving tailored support from dedicated job coaches through our Intreo partners to help them move towards employment. As I mentioned yesterday, the number of people who have been on the live register for a year or more is at its lowest level in two years at approximately 52,300, of whom 46,400 would actually receive a payment. Of those 52,300, a total of 17,700 have been on the live register for over a year. This is in the context of 2.84 million people who are currently in employment in the State. The live register is not a stock. It is a flow of people who are moving every week into and out of employment, progressing to training and education and into employment places. Some 58,800 people either entered or exited the long-term live register over the past 12 months. We are finalising the publication of the successor pathways to work strategy to strengthen efforts to support people who are long-term unemployed and who face barriers to enter the labour market.

I have reiterated the word "people" on many occasions. The discussion coming down and reducing people to numbers is not helpful nor is it fair. Behind those numbers are individuals, families and sets of circumstances that are different for every person.

For some, unemployment is a short-term experience. For others, it can be a much longer and more difficult journey, for reasons that are not always immediately apparent or obvious. Our responsibility as a Government is to ensure that the right supports, tailored opportunities and tailored pathways are there to help people who can and want to work. This is a responsibility I take very seriously and an approach my Department will continue to take.

We will not be able to deliver the benefits of the Bill without the extraordinary team that works for the Department of Social Protection across the country. Once again I thank them for their work, and I thank all Deputies who have thanked them for their work. All the employees of the Department are dedicated to their roles. All of us have regular engagement with those who person the Oireachtas line. I acknowledge all of them. This progresses the delivery of commitments that are set out in the programme for Government. This provides for increased resources to reinforce a strong social safety net provided by the social protection system. There is work to be done in terms of the programme for Government commitments and I look forward to further progressing them in the three social welfare Bills that remain. I commend the Bill to the House.

Comment on this