Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›
Sports Funding
A €350,000 state-funded Kildare pitch, intended to serve grassroots football, is reportedly used mainly by Klub Kildare’s academy, while KDUL clubs say fees prevent routine access; Deputy Farrelly called for an audit of its intended and actual use. Minister of State McConalogue said the Department found no grant non-compliance, directed access concerns to the FAI, and confirmed the existing pitch would not prevent future funding applications.
I thank Deputies Ní Raghallaigh and Cronin for obliging me this morning and changing the order. I thank the Minister of State for being here to hear about this issue. It is not the first time we have spoken about it but I want to take the opportunity to update him and the House on where things stand with the state-of-the-art all-weather pitch that was funded by the Exchequer from 2006 and completed in 2024 as well as where that fits into grassroots and underage football in Kildare.
I will quickly brief the House on the timeline. As the Minister of State will be aware, the Department of sport awarded the Kildare and District Underage League, KDUL, a €350,000 grant in 2006 to develop an all-weather pitch. In 2019, the Department issued a warning to KDUL that if it did not use the grant, it would lose it, and in that same year, the KDUL CLG was dissolved. A year later, the KDUL Academy CLG was formed by three people who were not elected by the KDUL clubs. In the same year - 2020 - the Department gave permission to transfer the name of the grant recipient from KDUL to KDUL Academy CLG.
In 2020, Mr. McNally told The Kildare Nationalist that the pitch at the Killashee House Hotel would be of benefit to both the KDUL teams and Klub Kildare. In 2024, that all-weather pitch was completed. If the Minister of State has been there, he will have seen that it is a very impressive facility and certainly an excellent use of taxpayers’ funds as a capital project.
The issue that remains is that the 31 clubs and over 6,000 children and young people playing underage football as part of KDUL do not have routine access to that pitch. There is a county ground in Kildare for GAA and the intention behind this pitch was to have the same for soccer, but as it stands, we do not have access to it. The pitch is now home to a League of Ireland Academy club called Klub Kildare. That is its home and it is advertised as such on its website. We do not believe that the ultimate purpose of this sports capital grant was to fund that League of Ireland team in isolation. The secretary of the underage league has written to the Minister of State this week, and on behalf of those 31 clubs, the league is trying to establish a series of facts. Ultimately, it is asking for his intervention here. There have been a number of meetings since the last time we raised this in the House and I am aware that the Minister of State looked into the issue at that time. KDUL Academy CLG and Klub Kildare are operating this premises and we have been told that they have offered KDUL, that is, the grassroots clubs, use of the pitch for a fee. This fee, on an hourly basis, would be unsustainable for local clubs but also for the league when it comes to the hosting of training sessions, club finals and a regular presence on the pitch.
While the academy will have full routine access to it, there is a concern that if KDUL wants to apply for sports capital funding in future, a question will be asked about why Kildare needs another county pitch if it already has this ground. We need the Minister of State and the Department to consider the timeline, the change of ownership and the ability of the over 6,000 grassroots footballers in Kildare to be able to access this pitch routinely, not just the academy players, who are a very small cohort, although they are wonderful kids doing excellently.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Farrelly for raising this matter. I recognise the considerable contribution made by volunteers to soccer across County Kildare and the importance of ensuring that publicly funded facilities deliver the sporting benefits for which funding was approved. I also acknowledge that we debated this issue in the House in April last year. I subsequently wrote to the Deputy on 29 May 2025 regarding the particular sports allocation he is raising here again.
The community sport facilities fund, CSFF, supports the development of sporting facilities throughout the country. Public confidence in that investment very much depends on effective controls, both when grants are paid and subsequently. These controls include conditions attached to grant approval, checks on expenditure and supporting documentation, inspections and audit. Where non-compliance is established, sanctions can include withdrawal or recovery of funding and restrictions on future applications.
I detailed these controls in the House previously and they bear repeating. When making applications under each round of the CSFF, all organisations must agree to the terms and conditions of the programme and include a statement that all information provided as part of an application is truthful. All grants under the CSFF are initially allocated on a provisional basis and grantees must provide the documentation set out in the letter of provisional allocation prior to receiving formal approval. In all cases, the letter of provisional allocation informs grantees that submission of false or misleading information to the Department at any stage is treated very seriously. Any organisation that does not comply with the terms and conditions of the sports capital programme may be subject to inspection, have its grant withdrawn, be required to repay all or part of a grant or be barred from making applications for a period of time. All serious breaches of the terms and conditions of the programme will be notified to An Garda Síochána. Grantees must guarantee that the facilities funded will remain in sporting use for a minimum period. This is five years for equipment or capital grants of €25,000 or less and 15 years for any larger capital grants, although we have changed that for the upcoming round to ten years.
Once grantees have formal approval, they may commence work and draw down the grant. The drawdown of grants involves the submission of documentation, which is checked within the sports capital programmes division and must include invoices that detail the work carried out, proof of payment of these invoices by way of bank statements and a signed certificate of compliance with the terms and conditions of the programme.
The Department has a detailed non-compliance policy, which is used to examine any suspected instances of non-compliance with the terms and conditions of the fund. On the rare occasion a serious instance of non-compliance occurs, the grantee is required to repay the Department any money paid that was not used for an approved purpose.
As per the relevant departmental guidelines, a system to carry out annual spot checks of capital projects is in place. This is designed to help the Department to ensure compliance with relevant guidelines. Each year, officials from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General examine a sample of CSFF payments as well.
We have previously discussed the concerns that the Deputy raised about the grant associated with the Kildare and District Underage League and the relationship between the league, KDUL Academy CLG and Klub Kildare. In responding to that debate in April last year and in my letter of 29 May 2025, I outlined the Department’s position on the information available at that time.
In summary, the Department is satisfied that there is no evidence of non-compliance with the terms and conditions of the funding in respect of the grant in question or on the part of the grantee. I also confirmed that any questions regarding structures and-or governance around KDUL Academy CLG are best addressed by the Football Association of Ireland. My objective is to protect public investment and ensure that grant-funded facilities deliver their intended sporting benefit. I am happy to consider any further specific evidence that the Deputy wishes to provide and to ensure that he receives a further substantive response on the issue he raises here today.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for his detailed reply and for his comprehensive correspondence at the time. It enlightened many individuals and stakeholders on the debate at the time. However, I question what evidence his officials need to simply conduct an audit. How many KDUL matches have taken place on this pitch since we spoke last? Zero. How many matches have taken place as part of the KDUL calendar of games since its inception in 2024? Zero. KDUL teams are not playing on this pitch because they have to pay for the privilege, despite being funded for the pitch in 2006. It is alleged that the entity that was dissolved was dissolved without the clubs knowing. The new entity, with three unelected directors, was set up without the clubs knowing but acting on their behalf and is now in direct ownership and maintenance of this facility for the purpose of a League of Ireland academy. If the Minister of State, or the Minister of the day, gave €350,000 for a League of Ireland academy all-weather pitch, I would be championing that in here and saying, "Well done". That is the type of investment we need. The problem is this was for grassroots football in Kildare. This was for the thousands of children who played football at club level in Kildare, not for the elite footballers. The purpose of this grant was for grassroots football, and now there is no grassroots football presence on it. That is why we need the Minister of State's intervention. Bringing this to the FAI will not resolve anything. I am just asking for an audit of its intended use and its current use. That will suffice. That will tell us where things stand and what the perspective would look like for future applications.
Comment on this
In relation to the discussions we had on the issues Deputy Farrelly raised on the floor last year and my subsequent response to him, the Department has looked at the matter and assessed the grant, the awarding of it and the process involved. The Department is satisfied that the terms and conditions in relation to the drawdown of the grant have been satisfied. There is no issue from the Department's point of view with regard to the use of the funds, the delivery of the facility and it meeting the terms and conditions of the scheme.
I understand the point that Deputy Farrelly is raising in relation to access and who exactly is using the pitch, the challenge around that and the dissatisfaction from a number of grassroots clubs with the level of access they have to the pitch, but that is a matter for the FAI, as the overall governing body for football, to engage with all involved on to try to ensure that there is as practicable and as accommodating an approach as possible that maximizes the benefit of the facility for football and for access to those wanting to play football across the county and in the general area.
It is obviously a desire of the Department to make sure that the investment we are putting into every facility gets as much of a return and dividend as possible in terms of sporting benefit and participation. As a Department, we cannot be involved in the micromanagement of each facility other than to make sure that the administration of grant funding is all done appropriately and is in order, and if it is not, to intervene and act. In terms of this grant, the Department is satisfied that everything is in order from the point of view of the terms and conditions of the scheme. I suggest that everyone at local level engage with the governing body, the Football Association of Ireland, to see if there can be further accommodation there.
There is no issue with any future grant. The fact that there is an AstroTurf pitch in an area is not in any way going to impede another additional grant application. We acknowledge that there is a need for more AstroTurf pitches. There is a dearth of them. Something we want to achieve out of the next funding round is that there be more such surfaces across the country. There is no area that I am aware of that has a sufficiency.
Comment on this
The weather last winter certainly spoke to that as well. We want to help to address that issue, and likewise in this case here.