We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Reversing Planned Increases to Public Transport Fares: Motion [Private Members]

Summary

Opposition deputies called for the planned 2027 public transport fare increases—averaging 15%, with some rises up to 35%—to be reversed, citing cost-of-living pressures, overcrowding and unreliable services, and the risk of discouraging public transport use. The Minister of State defended the increases as necessary to help fund operating costs and sustain service expansion, noting a record €1.042 billion PSO allocation and about 140 new or enhanced services in the 2027 planning pipeline. He also pointed to existing fare discounts and major capital investment, while acknowledging reliability and capacity problems. No decision on the motion is recorded in this section.

I move:

That Dáil Éireann:

notes that:

— affordable, accessible and reliable public transport is essential to tackling the cost-of-living crisis, reducing carbon emissions, easing traffic congestion, improving quality of life and ensuring that people can readily access employment, education, healthcare and other essential services;

— the National Transport Authority (NTA) has announced increases to adult public transport fares averaging approximately 15 per cent from January 2027, with some fares increasing by up to 35 per cent;

— these increases will impose additional costs on commuters, workers, students, and families at a time when many households are struggling to make ends meet amid the ever-increasing cost-of-living crisis; and

— fares are due to rise at a time of severe overcrowding and reliability problems on some public transport routes, therefore, passengers will be paying more for inadequate and unreliable services;

further notes that:

— according to figures reported by IrishCycle.com, public transport usage increased by approximately 21 per cent between 2019 and 2025, compared with population growth of approximately 11 per cent over the same period, demonstrating the growing demand for public transport services;

— there were 363.5 million individual journeys on the Transport for Ireland public transport network in 2025, up 5.8 per cent on 2024 levels, while there were 6.97 million Local Link journeys, an increase of 19 per cent on 2024 levels;

— despite record public transport patronage, Census 2022 data showed that 63 per cent of workers still travelled to work by car, demonstrating the substantial potential to increase public transport use if services are affordable, reliable and available where people need them;

— the NTA acknowledges that a 10 per cent increase in fares can be expected to lead to a 3 per cent fall in passenger numbers;

— making public transport more expensive, risks undermining efforts to encourage a modal shift from private cars, reduce congestion and meet Ireland's climate commitments; and

— the €70 million cost of reversing these fare increases amounts to just 1.3 per cent of the Department of Transport's overall budget for 2027; and

calls on the Government to reverse the NTA's planned public transport fare increases from January 2027.

As the Social Democrat spokesperson on transport, I am honoured to move this very important Private Members' motion, which asks the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, and the Government to reverse the political decision to increase the price of using public transport in Ireland by an average of 15%. I would like to welcome to the Gallery representatives from the Cork, Dublin, Galway and Limerick commuter coalitions who have informed Members quite comprehensively about the impacts of increasing the price of using public transport. None of it is good, but the Minister of State knows this. It is a price that he and the Government seem all too willing to pay. I thank my colleague in Kildare Councillor Chris Pender whose work, through a series of freedom of information, FOI, requests, has shown that the Minister of State and his colleague in the Department have been briefed for some time now that under the Minister of State's leadership the number of people using public transport will reduce to coincide with the planned fare increases. He and his colleague are both on the record of the Dáil saying the opposite. In his opening remarks, the Minister of State might clarify how he intends to correct the record on that. Simply put, the decision to increase public transport fares makes no sense. It makes no political sense, it makes no policy sense, and from a cost-of-living perspective and from a climate action perspective, the impact of congestion on our mental and physical health perspective fails all the checks. Why on earth would the Government pursue it?

The Minister of State will undoubtedly tell us about record levels of investment in public transport, record levels of passengers, and that in comparison to our EU neighbours we are not doing too badly. We should all be very clear in this House that the Government is attempting to undo and undermine every positive step achieved regarding public transport policy and the modal shift in recent years. Affordable, accessible and reliable public transport is essential to tackling the cost-of-living crisis, reducing carbon emissions, easing traffic congestion, improving quality of life and ensuring that people can readily access employment, education, healthcare and other essential services.

We are EU leaders only when it comes to the cost of living, with the highest electricity costs, the highest grocery costs, exorbitant rents and sky-high childcare fees. This tone deaf decision will impose additional costs on commuters, workers, students and families when people are already struggling to put food on the table or heat their homes. Fares are due to rise at a time of severe overcrowding and reliability problems on some public transport routes. Passengers, therefore, will be paying more for inadequate and unreliable services. The Minister of State will probably tell us that these fare hikes will ensure the delivery of 140 new routes. Where are they? Where are the plans? The NTA has told the Oireachtas transport committee that this is about maintaining services and it is not about expansion. Where are the plans? This is asking people to pay for phantom plans and all too often phantom buses.

It is beyond regressive and deeply challenging that the Government is falling back on not having had increased public transport fares as a rationale for increasing them now, next year and the year after. The has been Government planning this for quite a number of years now. There were 365 million individual journeys on the Transport for Ireland public transport network in 2025, up 6%. There were nearly 7 million Local Link journeys in the same year, up close to 20%. Those statistics, those people, under the Minister of State's stewardship, will now reduce in number. In some cases, we will see reductions of up to 10% in public transport users, because the Government would rather place the burden of a shortfall in funding for the NTA on those who use the services. The Minister of State should look around the next time he is on a train, bus, Luas or DART. For every ten passengers he sees, he should say good-bye to one. When they go back to their cars, they will contributing to the cost of congestion. To the Irish State, that comes in at approximately €0.5 billion each year. The Minister of State's own Department has modelled the cost of congestion to reach between €1.5 billion and €2 billion each year by 2040, if unmitigated. The Minister of State does not care about these issues. The Government cannot do forward planning; it is simply too fragile. Rather than adopting a sensible, long-term and sustainable approach to social policy underpinned by the capacity on our roads and of our public transport services and the long-term health of our population, it simply adds 5% here and 20% there, playing a direct role in the ever-increasing cost of existing in this country. A good friend told me before that if you find yourself complaining about traffic, you are in traffic. For some, there is a real, tangible helplessness around that. Their job or location might dictate their journey type.

As policymakers, we have not even scratched the surface when it comes to the potential of public transport. We were getting there; it was arguably the finest legacy of the Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil and Green Party Government. For some reason, whether it is a shift in political priorities from moving people to moving cars, roads budgets rather than PSO budgets, it is different now. The Tánaiste, Deputy Simon Harris, will criticise you if you do not go to work; this Government will punish you if you do go to work. People will sit in congestion for hours each day or, if they are lucky, they will now pay more for the privilege of a seat on public transport.

I was worried when I read that the Minister of State rejected out of hand the correspondence sent to him by the Just Transition Commission of Ireland. That should be a major red flag to us all. The calibre of the membership of that commission and the evidence-based work they do should fundamentally underlie and inform our policy work. Did the Minister of State reject it out of hand? How could he possibly disagree with its assertions? Did he make any attempt to seek funding from the annual underspend on ring-fenced carbon tax budgets in his Department? That sum was €160 million last year, in his Department. In good faith, I urge the Minister of State to reconsider this decision and review the evidence. I implore him to back public transport users and champion the need for an even greater number of people to turn away from their cars and to be able to rely on and pay for public transport. It is possible with leadership and long-term commitment. It starts with reversing this decision to increase public transport fares.

Comment on this

I commend Deputy Farrelly on his work on this important motion. The Government's decision to increase public transport fares is particularly maddening in my constituency of Cork East, where commuters are already dealing with serious deficiencies in public transport provision. The commuter rail services from Midleton and Cobh into Cork city have been a tremendous success. They are excellent services that people value enormously, and demand for them continues to grow. However, the overcrowding at peak times has reached farcical proportions. Commuters are regularly packed into two-carriage trains, jammed up against one another, struggling to find somewhere to stand, never mind sit. In September, a train driver had to leave their cab to prevent more passengers boarding at Glounthaune and Little Island because the train was already dangerously overcrowded. Irish Rail acknowledges the problem but its response has been that there are simply no spare carriages available.

In this instance, we have a hugely successful commuter rail service, yet cannot provide enough carriages to accommodate the people using it. It is as if we were living in an impoverished country struggling to provide the most basic infrastructure. I strongly suspect that the Department of public expenditure's ruthless grip on funding the basics has struck again here. Now the Government has the audacity to tell these commuters that they should pay more for the privilege.

If the rail service is a success undermined by overcrowding, the bus service throughout Cork East is an altogether more dismal story. Consider Youghal, a major town with no passenger railway, whose residents have been condemned to endure an appallingly unreliable and inefficient bus service. The journey from Youghal to Cork, a distance of approximately 50 km, can take almost two hours at peak times - two hours to travel 50 km, in 2026. That is when the bus actually turns up. Last Friday, the 7 a.m. service from Youghal to the Munster Technological University campus was cancelled. Imagine depending on that service to get to college or work. Across east Cork, people without cars face enormous difficulties accessing employment, education and healthcare. For those who do have cars, these services provide precious little incentive to leave them at home. How can the Government seriously expect people to make the switch to public transport when the alternative is so unreliable or overcrowded and now increasingly expensive? These fare increases should be reversed. The Government needs to provide enough train carriages, reliable bus services and affordable fares. These are basic expectations in a country with a flourishing economy, and commuters have every right to expect better.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Farrelly for this very timely motion. I welcome to the Gallery all the people who came in to speak in the audiovisual room. I also welcome the four students who are on work experience. They are very welcome and I thank them for all the work they are doing this week. At a time when the cost of living is so high, everything is increasing - grocery prices, the cost of fuel, rents and mortgages, and the cost of education. Now there is a rising cost in public transport. It is one kick after the next and people are really fed up.

I will describe how the NTA has managed to annoy people in Dublin South-Central over the past while. I had four public meetings about the 80 bus from Chapelizod into town. They changed the route, then they had to change it again. There were ghost buses and it was an absolute disaster. The NTA accepted that it was not correct and has almost corrected it. People in Chapelizod are absolutely fed up with the fact that they have a bus that is supposed to be reliable but is not, and now they have to pay more for a service that has not been exemplary. It is the same with the F1, F2, F3 and S4. They are constantly late. People are unable to rely on them. There are three buses going the same route; I cannot understand that. People in Inchicore and Bluebell were told in the summer that there was no money left in the NTA and it could not do anything about the route connecting the community of Bluebell and Inchicore back into Meath Street, where traditionally people have done their shopping. They were told there was not enough money in the NTA. I say to the Minister of State that people pay their taxes for things like bus and Luas services, and they pay their fares. It is not like they are getting that service for free. They pay for it in their taxes and they also pay to use it. The fact that the NTA has run out of money is not the fault of the person who uses the bus or Luas; it is the fault of the Government that has not funded it properly. Maybe we could argue that the NTA has not used it properly but that has nothing to do with the person who is using the bus or train to get from A to B. People are fed up. They cannot keep paying out for the Government not to put in place the public services that should exist.

Let us be honest. For people who take public transport, which I do if I am not cycling or walking, we could get on a Luas and be packed in like sardines. We are absolutely jammed in beside each other. For those who use a wheelchair or have a buggy, good luck trying to get on. It is the same for the bus early in the morning or at commuter times. Those who have any mobility issues will not be able to get on because it is absolutely jammed. There are not enough services but people are now expected to pay more. For those who are struggling, and that is a lot of people, the increase in the fares is going to put people back in their cars, which is exactly what we do not want in respect of our emissions.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Farrelly for the heart he brings to the issue of public transport.

What people find so frustrating about Government is that faced with crises, it just keeps failing to do the obvious. The reason we are here this morning and the reason the Social Democrats have afforded their Private Members' business time to this issue is in a cost-of-living crisis, the Minister of State's Department and the Government are standing over an increase in bus fares. That is incredible. We are simply here because we want the Government to get the basics right. Being able to afford to get to work, college, a hospital appointment or home to a family without eating into a budget that is already overstretched should not be seen as a luxury. They are basic expectations of a functioning government, yet from January, the Minister of State's Department and the Government will preside over a 15% increase in transport fares. I sometimes wonder whether the Government appreciates the level of increased anger in communities. If it does appreciate it, its response seems to be to seek somebody to blame. There is a world in which a leader takes to a stage and instead of seeking to throw people on social welfare under the bus, that leader would talk about how we can get more people onto buses cheaper and for free, but that does not exist in a Government that seeks only to afford blame and never provide leadership. It seems to think the answer is another performance of toughness, another group to point the finger at or another announcement designed to show who it is prepared to come down hard on.

People wake up in the morning and wonder how they are getting to work. They do not wonder who the Government is going to blame for its failures. That is where the Government's attention should be. I could spend every second of these three minutes talking about the failures within our bus and transport services, including the ghost buses, the fact that people are standing at bus stops for over an hour watching two or three full buses pass by and ask how the Government seeks to achieve a service that is worthy of a modern republic that has the wealth to invest in a public transport initiative. At this moment in time, however, all we are seeking from the Government is a commitment that there will not be a 15% increase in transport costs. What does the Minister of State think will be the implications of that? What we are talking about here is a minimal expectation of allowing people the means to get to work or to a hospital appointment or where they need to go using public transport in a way that does not make them have to cut their cloth even further to the bone in a cost-of-living crisis. We have seen what this Government can do when it is able to find money and resources to provide for one particular group. This group we are asking for are simply people who use public transport. It is the Minister of State's responsibility, and the expectation is that he will solve this.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Farrelly for tabling the motion. I welcome the members of the commuter coalitions in the Gallery, in particular, Mr. Alex Garvey, transport advocate extraordinaire in my constituency. In my constituency in south Dublin, a huge number of people are reliant on public transport, including buses, Luas and the DART. Many of my constituents, although not all, are served well by public transport. We say "Hello" to the bus driver when we get on and we thank the bus driver when we leave. Many people are on their way to work or college or simply going about their business. Prams, wheelchairs, younger people getting up so older people can sit down - there is nothing more prosocial in my constituency than our shared use of public transport.

As Dublin has grown and developed, public transport has become more vital to connect us. It has been a major focus of my constituency work because of its impact on the quality of life of my constituents but also because improving public transport is essential to meeting our climate obligations, particularly in cities. Therefore, imagine my shock and, indeed, genuine confusion when the Government decided to support an increase to public transport fares in the middle of a soaring cost-of-living crisis hitting every household in the country and the concurrent breakdown of climate internationally. I cannot think of the more aggressive step taken by a transport Minister in recent memory, and I mean that sincerely. I think of the nurses who are going to hospitals today in lieu of the public pay deal, the older person going to an appointment, the people who are going to school and college today and even the staff here in Leinster House who I meet on the bus occasionally. The Government is punishing the people who are most reliant and most in need of transport. This is punishing commuters. It is deliberately counterproductive to our climate goals. It is a concerted effort by the Government to increase the cost on households. That is absolutely shameful. It is antisocial and deeply regressive. If the Government had any notion of helping our citizenry, it would accept this motion and reverse the increases to public transport fares. I anticipate that it will not, however, because this Government is not for ordinary people using ordinary public transport; it is for something else and now we all have to pay for it.

Comment on this
Seán Canney Minister of State at the Department of Transport Independent

I move:

To delete all words after "Dáil Éireann" and substitute the following:

"affirms the Government's efforts to:

— deliver a significant expansion of new and enhanced public transport services;

— provide more frequent, reliable, accessible and sustainable public transport services;

— maintain affordable fares and roll-out contactless payment systems across the network;

— deliver major public transport projects, to expand capacity and connectivity;

— reduce congestion and support households, businesses and regional growth;

— place the Public Service Obligation (PSO) programme on a sustainable long-term footing; and

— support the achievement of Ireland's climate and emissions reduction targets; and

notes that:

— Budget 2027 delivers a record €1.042 billion allocation to the PSO services across the bus, light rail and heavy rail networks, and this funding supports a significant expansion and enhancement of our public transport network, with approximately 140 new or enhanced services in the planning pipeline for 2027, across flagship programmes such as Connecting Ireland, BusConnects, and new town services;

— following Budget 2027, the Department of Transport has been working closely with the National Transport Authority (NTA) and Transport for Ireland (TFI) operators, to develop a comprehensive service plan for 2027, focused on expanding and enhancing public transport services across the network, and the plan will be supported by the increased PSO funding provided in the Budget, together with projected revenue from the planned fare adjustments;

— the Government also remains committed to the timely delivery of major public transport infrastructure projects, underpinned by a record allocation of €24.3 billion for transport in the National Development Plan (NDP) 2026-2030, and this unprecedented investment will support the delivery of transformative projects across the country, enhancing mobility, reducing congestion, strengthening regional connectivity and advancing Ireland's climate objectives;

— the Government has committed unprecedented levels of investment in transport, increasing funding by almost 87 per cent compared to the previous five-year period, and while the scale of investment is significant, the delivery of major infrastructure projects requires a phased approach, with funding prioritised to ensure projects are progressed efficiently and provide maximum benefit for passengers and taxpayers;

— more than €18 billion has been allocated to public transport capital investment under the NDP and the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund over the period 2026-2030, supporting the advancement of transformative projects including MetroLink, Luas Finglas, DART+, the Western Rail Corridor, the Limerick to Foynes rail line reinstatement, capacity enhancement projects between Hazelhatch to Portarlington stations, Galway to Athenry stations, the Cork Area Commuter Rail Programme and the BusConnects programme, and this investment will also facilitate the roll-out of the new DART+ fleet and the commencement of early construction works on DART+ West route, helping to expand capacity, improve connectivity and enhance public transport services across the country;

— the continued growth in passenger demand demonstrates increasing public confidence in the public transport network, highlights the success of ongoing investment in services and infrastructure, and it also underscores the importance of maintaining and expanding capacity through sustained investment, ensuring that the network can continue to meet rising demand, support economic activity, reduce congestion, and facilitate the transition to more sustainable travel patterns, in line with Ireland's climate objectives;

— last year saw an increase of almost 20 million journeys, or 6 per cent, compared with 343.6 million journeys in 2024, reflecting the growing role of public transport in meeting the daily travel needs of communities across the country;

— a strong example of this progress is Connecting Ireland, which has delivered a step-change in rural public transport connectivity since its launch in 2022, with over 180 new and enhanced services introduced nationwide and almost 8 million passenger journeys recorded in 2024, and the programme is improving access to employment, education, healthcare and social opportunities for communities across rural Ireland;

— a sustainable level of passenger fare revenue is fundamental to the long-term resilience and financial sustainability of the public transport network, alongside Exchequer support, fare revenue underpins the provision of existing services, enables investment in new and enhanced services, and ensures the network can continue to grow in response to increasing demand, while delivering value for money for both passengers and taxpayers;

— the Government recognises that an affordable, reliable and accessible public transport network is essential to encouraging a sustained shift away from private car use and achieving wider economic, social and climate objectives;

— since 2022, passengers have benefited from a range of significant affordability measures, including:

— a 20 per cent cost of living fare reduction;

— the extension of the 90-minute fare;

— a 50 per cent Young Adult and Student discount;

— free travel for children aged under nine;

— expanded eligibility under the Free Travel Scheme, administered by the Department of Social Protection;

— while adult fares will increase, many child fares will be reduced, and young adult fares will remain discounted at 50 per cent, helping to improve affordability for families and young people; and

— free travel will continue for everyone eligible, including the under nines and the over 65s;

— this means 1.5 million people, or almost 27 per cent of our population, enjoy free travel on the basis of their age;

— these measures have been accompanied by strong growth in passenger demand, with a record 363.5 million journeys made across the TFI network in 2025, and this sustained increase in patronage reflects growing reliance on public transport and highlights the need for continued investment to maintain, enhance and expand services in line with passenger needs;

— the NTA continues to work closely with operators to improve efficiency and maximise value for money from both public funding and fare revenue, however, the significant expansion of services in recent years, coupled with increasing operating costs, means that a sustainable public transport system requires an appropriate balance between Exchequer support and passenger fare revenue; and

— against this backdrop, public transport remains highly affordable and competitive, even following the 2027 fare adjustment, fares will remain approximately 8 per cent lower in real terms than they were eight years ago, and the additional revenue generated, alongside continued Government investment, will support improved capacity and reliability, help meet rising demand, facilitate further service enhancements, and ensure the continued delivery of the Government's public transport and climate ambitions.".

I thank the Deputies for their contributions. Before I go into what is in the script, I want to say two things. I think everybody who has spoken and the Government have the same thing in mind, which is to have a public transport system that does not have ghost buses, that is on time, that provides frequency and that gets the nurses and people to school and work and does so efficiently. Every public transport service we put in place is subsidised. There is no public transport service making a profit. I think I heard the work "sustainable" from Deputy Farrelly. I have listened in this House over the past two years to people criticising the services they have or do not have, such as signage not being right, missing buses and all of that. That is what we intend to correct. I just want to say that, so that everybody will have a public transport service that they can rely on and that they can use and continue to use rather than have to contemplate buying a car. That is my role in all of this. I have listened to what the Deputies said and I have taken notes. I was in County Cork last weekend. I was talking to members of the Cork Chamber of Commerce. We talked about all the infrastructure that is being built there for rail and all of the things that are being done there. Again, they told me there is a problem with overcrowding. There is an overcrowding problem in Galway. We are going to rectify that, but what we have to do is have public transport on a sustainable level from the start.

The fare adjustments are necessary to help address the cost of increases experienced across public transport. They will also contribute to the continued delivery and expansion of key transport programmes including BusConnects, Connecting Ireland and DART+. Despite fare revenue contributing approximately 38% of the public service obligation, PSO, nationally, this remains below the European average of 44%, requiring significant Exchequer funding. The Government investment in the PSO programme in 2025 amounted to €850 million, including the additional supplementary allocation of €192 million to sustain and enhance transport services across the network. Further increases in the investment will be coming in 2026 and 2027.

The cost of delivering subsidised transport has risen substantially for different reasons since 2022, with significant increases in costs. Over the same period, fare reduction measures were introduced, including a 20% cost-of-living discount, a 50% young adult card discount and free travel for children aged under nine. These measures have expanded access to affordable public transport, with approximately 1.5 million people - it is important to say this - or 27% of our population now eligible for free or discounted travel. These measures are in addition to what has now been an essential eight-year freeze on fare increases. While delivering important social and inclusion benefits, they have also increased the gap between the cost of operating services and the revenue recovered through fares.

While maintaining affordable fares remains a key objective for this Government, it is equally important for passengers to ensure that sufficient resources are available to introduce new routes, increase service frequencies, improve reliability, enhance accessibility and connect more communities to public transport. That is what the Deputy was talking about when he tabled the motion. It is important to note that while adult fares will increase by an average of 15%, child fares are being reduced in several areas nationally. For example, in the Dublin commuter zone, regional cities, participating towns and Transport for Ireland, TFI, Local Link services, a new reduced child rate will apply, set at 33% of the equivalent adult rate.

Importantly, the determination safeguards existing government-supported fare initiatives, including the free travel scheme, free travel for children under nine years of age, and free companion travel arrangements for those aged 70 and over, thereby maintaining important accessibility and social inclusion supports across the public transport network. Even with these planned changes, the National Transport Authority, NTA's assessment is that fares will remain approximately 8% lower in real terms than they were eight years ago. Notwithstanding any demand elasticity impacts associated with the fare adjustment, passenger numbers are expected to continue growing throughout 2027, reflecting strong underlying demand for public transport. Research consistently demonstrates that factors such as service availability, frequency, reliability, journey times and overall service quality have a greater influence on travel behaviour than fares.

Continued investment is our motto. To further advance these efforts, budget 2027 delivers a record €1.042 billion allocation to public service obligation, PSO, services across the bus, light rail and heavy rail networks. This funding supports a significant expansion and enhancement of our public transport network, with approximately 140 new or enhanced services in the planning pipeline for 2027. We will be publishing that plan before the end of this year. These service enhancements are across flagship programmes such as Connecting Ireland, BusConnects, and new town services. In this regard, officials in the Department have been working closely with the NTA and Transport for Ireland operators to develop a comprehensive service plan for 2027. The Government has also prioritised balanced regional development through continued investment in rural transport services. I see that myself in Galway where we now have local link buses coming from villages and bringing people into the city. They are picking people up from places where there is no other bus service. I see it happening around the country and that will continue. The allocation will also maintain ring-fenced funding for the dedicated rural transport programme, supporting local link services across the country and ensuring that communities in rural areas continue to have access to essential demand-responsive transport services.

As the Deputies will be aware, the Connecting Ireland rural mobility plan is a major public transport initiative developed by the NTA to increase connectivity outside of our major cities and towns. It has seen exponential growth over the last few years, with 185 new and expanded services rolled out since 2022. Over 240 towns and villages have been connected to the public transport network, and it is this investment that the Government will continue to support through the reinvestment of fare revenue. A critical element of this funding is to allow all citizens to access these essential services, and therefore the Department is prioritising ensuring these services are accessible for all, including people with a disability. Accessibility improvements are being advanced through three key strands: embedding universal design in all new infrastructure projects; increasing investment to retrofit legacy infrastructure and supporting a "turn up and go" experience; and expanding independent travel supports, including the NTA's independent travel support scheme to additional urban rural areas.

We fully recognise the significant pressures facing the public transport sector, including those arising from global economic developments and increased operating costs. The Department and the NTA continue to work closely with public transport operators to monitor demand, assess operational impacts and ensure the network remains responsive to emerging challenges. It is therefore essential that measures introduced be carefully targeted and sustainable, ensuring that they deliver meaningful benefits for passengers while supporting the long-term resilience of the public transport system. The National Transport Authority continuously monitors the punctuality, reliability, and demand for services. I have met the NTA in relation to bus services here in Dublin and elsewhere, to make sure that it makes the changes to make the services more workable. It is recognised that reliability and service frequency remain ongoing challenges across parts of the public transport network, driven by factors such as traffic congestion, workforce shortages, particularly among drivers and mechanics, and other operational incidents. I dealt with a Topical Issue yesterday morning in relation to congestion on trains in Cork. Next year, we will be putting additional carriages into the public transport system, freeing up carriages that we can put onto the Intercity routes to help with that congestion. Right now, every available carriage is being used for public transport. Apart from those undergoing scheduled maintenance, every carriage is out there on the rail lines.

The Government is committed to significant investment in our transport system. In budget 2027, we allocated an additional €6 billion for the progression of MetroLink. Total public transport capital investment in the current national development plan period will be over €18 billion. This investment will advance a range of transformative projects across the country, including MetroLink, Luas Finglas, DART+, Cork area commuter rail, the reinstatement of the western rail corridor between Claremorris and Athenry, the Foynes rail freight line reinstatement and BusConnects programmes in Dublin, Cork, Galway, Limerick and Waterford.

Comment on this

I just want to get something straight. At a time when the UN is warning that we are about to breach 1.5 oC global warming; when transport emissions in Ireland are stubbornly high, year in and year out; when 70% of all daily trips are made in private cars; and when we are facing €26 billion in fines from the EU for not meeting our climate targets, this is the Government's answer when it comes to public transport. At a time when Dublin is the third most congested city in the world, when we have the M50 at a standstill every day and when there is no longer a peak time - every hour is peak time in Ireland - the Government's answer is to raise prices on public transport. At a time when wars in Ukraine and Iran have crippled world economies and pushed up fossil fuel prices, hitting the most vulnerable people in our communities who are unable to pay for their energy and their fuel, the Government's answer is to these problems is to make it more expensive for people to use public transport. That is exactly what the Government is doing - making it more expensive. This policy is nonsensical, regressive and is not based on any of the evidence. I would ask the Government and the Minister of State to walk away from it because it does not make any sense.

The Minister of State spoke about the need to have money in order to make the service better for people. I am a TD for the Wicklow constituency and I know how underserved public transport has been. My constituents are continuously calling out a substandard public transport system in Wicklow. They were promised a No. 199 bus, one of the so-called enhanced services. That was meant to start last September but it is the bus that never showed up at all. We have other buses from Go-Ahead that are unreliable because they are constantly being caught up in congestion. They are being cancelled regularly and there are inconsistent timetables. We have bus services in the west of Wicklow that have not been upgraded for 20 years. My constituents and I understand the problems arising from having an unreliable and infrequent public transport service but that service must be affordable as well. That seems to be the element that the Government has forgotten in all of this. It must be affordable. We need to encourage people to move out of cars. While it may not seem like a lot of money to the Minister of State, these fare increases are going to hit the most vulnerable people in our communities. I ask the Minister of State to listen carefully to the speeches today from across all benches and to reconsider this policy.

The Government is currently paying €100 million per month in excise cuts for fossil fuel subsidies for cars. This is €70 million. I ask the Minister of State to change his decision on this.

Comment on this

I am just shocked. Two years into this Government's handling of many different challenges in this society, this one just screams "out of touch". It is not just that it is on top of a cost-of-living crisis, soaring rents and house prices, soaring energy prices and people squeezed at every single juncture of their lives. It is that the Government chooses to increase public transport costs. It is genuinely mind-boggling that it has chosen to do it. It is not just that we are in an energy and climate crisis where we are not reaching our targets by any stretch of the imagination, and where the Government has signalled that it is happy to just take the hit on EU fines rather than do the work to invest in a just transition that could benefit our economy, society and the globe. It is not just that this is a moment in time when every country on the globe is trying to move towards active and public transport as the appropriate direction of travel, pun intended. It is that the Government does not get that people are being so pushed on this. It is that its whole policy direction is wrong. It is what it signifies. What the Government should be looking towards is not just what the Minister of State has covered in his speech, which was all about the shortcomings of the public transport system that we all endure daily. Rather, it is affordability. It is the signal to our population that active and public transport is where we should all be moving to - out of our cars and onto buses, the Luas, DARTs and commutes that actually work for people at a time when they need that so much.

I take this moment to reiterate what our vision of a social democracy is. It is where you pay your taxes and, in return, you get a suite of public services like transport, healthcare, education, childcare, disability services and climate mitigation. These are the things we should be able to rely on to live a life of dignity no matter what challenges we face. This Government does not seem to get that. It instead seems to see relying on the market, privatisation where it can and lining the pockets of corporate interests that lobby it day by day as the best way to resolve all of the crises we face as a society. This is so tone deaf and I wonder if the Government sees the Ireland I see. Does it see the people on our streets hungry and homeless? Does it see the commuters stretched and stressed every day trying to make ends meet and fend for their families? If it did, it would not do this.

Comment on this

The refusal to back down on this particular policy is illogical and really frustrating because the Government has a significant budget surplus, yet it is adding this cost to commuters when there is no reason the Government could not cover it. It could make, in budgetary terms, a simple and small action that would do two things. First, it would help people who are struggling. It would help people who are paying for public transport, and who have to get on the bus or the Luas and take the trains, and who are reliant on it. They have to pay that in order to get to work or to hospital. The Government could actually help them. The Taoiseach gets up week after week and frames it about the budget, how there is only so much that the Government can do, how this situation is out of its hands and how energy costs are spiralling internationally. This is something that the Government could do. It is completely in the Government's control. It could decide today that there would be no fare increases. Let us make that clear to the people of this country.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Independents could do something that would help people and make things a little easier. Obviously, it is a small amount, but it would still be significant. The Government could stop that fare increase. Why will it not do so?

The second thing pausing it would do is send a signal that we want people on public transport, and that we support them and want people to get out of their cars. In my constituency, I have been campaigning to get a proper public bus service that would work for people and with them. We have got some changes that have made a difference, but it is still not a quality public service that people can rely on. There are still issues with ghost buses and overcrowding on the buses. People cannot get to work. They cannot rely on things. They cannot get to the hospital. There is so much wealth in this country. It comes back to what my colleague said earlier about a social democracy. The difference between the Social Democrats and Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael is that we believe in public services, and we will fund them to make sure that they work for people and that everyone in this country has access to decent public transport.

Comment on this

Sinn Féin supports this motion and we thank the Social Democrats for tabling it.

The planned public transport fare increases are unfair and completely out of touch with the reality facing ordinary people. Families are being squeezed from every direction between rents, mortgage repayments, grocery bills, energy costs among the highest in Europe and childcare costs. Now, the Government wants commuters to dig even deeper into their pockets. The NTA intends to impose fare increases averaging 15%, with some increases reaching as high as 35%. That is clearly not a minor adjustment. What makes it even more insulting is that passengers are being asked to pay more for a service that too often fails them with overcrowded trains, buses that never show up, delays and cancellations. The Government wants them to pay more for this privilege.

The truth is that this decision exposes a fundamental contradiction at the heart of Government transport policy. Ministers constantly tell us that they want people to leave their cars at home and that they want to tackle congestion and reduce emissions. They claim that they are serious about climate action, but the same Government is proposing to increase the cost of public transport. That makes absolutely no sense. The NTA's figures acknowledge that a 10% increase in fares can result in a 3% drop in passenger numbers. The truth is that Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Independents know that higher fares will push people away from using public transport. This undermines their so-called objectives on affordability, climate and modal shift. Unsurprisingly, they are pushing ahead anyway. It is rhetoric rather than action and not a credible plan.

Particularly frustrating is that these fare increases are being proposed at the wrong time. Public transport demand is growing rapidly. Between 2019 and 2025, it increased by approximately 21%, which is almost double the rate of population growth. In 2025 alone, there were 363 million passenger journeys on the Transport for Ireland network. Local Link carried almost 7 million passenger journeys, which is an increase of 19% in a single year. What is the Government's response? It is to make it more expensive for them. These passenger numbers should have been the signal to advance capacity, improve reliability and accelerate investment. Instead, the Government is penalising people for using public transport.

Communities in my constituency of Kerry and throughout rural Ireland continue to wait for transport services that they were promised years ago. The roll-out of Connecting Ireland has slowed dramatically. Many villages remain poorly connected and bus services that were in place a number of years ago have now been reduced or have disappeared altogether. I am talking about routes from Kilflynn to Abbeydorney and from Lixnaw to Tralee in particular. Young people in those areas without access to a car remain isolated. Older people are struggling to access services, but the Government's priority is to increase fares and communities are being left behind.

The Government will undoubtedly claim that there is no money, but according to the motion before the House, reversing these fare increases would cost approximately €70 million. It sounds like a significant figure until you put it into context. That is approximately 1.3% of the Department of Transport's overall budget for 2027. The Government is asking commuters, students and working families to pay more to save an amount that barely registers. It tells us everything we need to know about the priorities of the Government.

Sinn Féin believes that public transport should be affordable, reliable and accessible. We believe that investment should focus on passengers, not balance sheets, and that rural communities deserve the same level of ambition as major urban centres.

We believe that the Government should go much further than preventing these fare increases and that is why we called for free public transport for all under-18s in our recent alternative budget. When families are under relentless pressure, that measure would reduce costs, tactical child poverty and encourage sustainable travel habits from an early age.

We are clear. These fares are wrong. They should be scrapped immediately and we support the motion.

Comment on this

Every day, commuters are forced onto unreliable and overcrowded services. I have constantly highlighted issues from my constituency where people are becoming unwell on overcrowded services or are being left on the train platform or the side of road. It is simply outrageous that the Government believes that my constituents should have to pay even more for the substandard services that they have to travel on every day.

Public transport is an essential public service for people to go about their daily lives. It is not a luxury, yet in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis, the Government is telling people that the cost of yet another everyday essential is going to rise. It stands in direct contrast to the claims that the Minister of State and his colleagues make that the Government is encouraging more people to use public transport when even the NTA itself has said that passenger numbers will fall as a result of this fare hike. Only four new services were introduced this year, which demonstrates a shocking lack of commitment to public transport from the Government. Now, it is expecting hard-pressed commuters to pick up the slack for its failure to properly fund our public transport system. That is unacceptable. The Government needs to stop this fare hike from going ahead.

The Government also needs to address the service issues that I have raised in here many times before. Services are at crisis point. In particular, there is a lack of rail services and rail carriages. The town of Athenry has been waiting two years for its promised bus service while people are forced to cram onto severely overcrowded trains. The people of Gort, Kinvara and the wider south Galway area regularly contact my office in relation to lack of capacity and options on bus services and trains, with commuters being left on the side of the road because the services are full. The town of Loughrea and villages like Craughwell have fewer public transport services now than they did five years ago when they lost their Bus Éireann service. Too often, people are left stranded on the roadside as buses arrive in Loughrea completely full or well behind schedule. It is impossible for local people to rely on these services or to plan their day around them. A town the size of Loughrea and its surrounding villages deserve far better than that. We urgently need to see hourly services from Loughrea and surrounding areas to be restored. That is the bare minimum that residents there deserve. The NTA must include this in its plans for 2027 alongside the dedicated bus service for Athenry and improvements on those routes serving the south Galway area. Crucially, we need to see additional capacity on rail services.

Comment on this

Proposals from the Government to increase public transport fares by up to 33% are entirely unjust and nonsensical. These fare increases will not impact as many people in Monaghan or Cavan, as we have very little access to bus services at all. It will not impact rail users in Monaghan or Cavan either, given the deprioritisation of our county by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael following the strategic rail review. However, those who do have access to services are going to be expected to pay additionally for buses that turn up late, if they turn up at all.

What will we get? The CEO of Bus Éireann got a €50,000 pay increase last year, bringing her total pay to €260,000. Dublin's bus chief saw an increase from €200,000 to €260,000. Irish Rail's chief's salary increased by €75,000 to €300,000. Of course, it should not go without mention that this is occurring at the same time that the Government is planning to increase road tolls, many of them on roads whose costs have been paid back to the private operators many times over already.

To add insult to injury, departmental officials confirmed to me at the Committee of Public Accounts last week that they intended to double the cost of the school transport scheme next year. In the last three years, school buses have increased in price from €50 to €100. Now, people are going to pay €200 for their school bus transport next year. That is if they can get a school bus. So many pupils cannot get a school bus to school. It is ridiculous and is all happening under the watch of Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil and the so-called Independents. Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil seem to think that a person should be punished for having the audacity to go about their day-to-day life, be that going to work or hospital appointments or kids getting to school. This racket of ripping off commuters while lining the pockets of already lavishly paid executive needs to come to an end now. The transport system is already in chaos. It is broken for many users. The Government needs to rethink its proposals.

Comment on this

I thank my colleague, Deputy Pa Daly, who tabled the original motion on fare hikes to the floor with the Dáil. I want to thank Deputies for tabling the motion this morning because it gives the Government a chance to reflect on what is a very, very, very bad decision - a decision to punish commuters in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis. Last night, we debated the Sinn Féin motion on toll hikes. The Government is determined to get people every which way if they have the audacity to leave their house.

In my constituency of Dublin Fingal West, we do not have a college, a university, a minor injuries unit or a primary care centre. As economic studies have shown us to be, we are underemployed for the population. My constituents been very badly served by consecutive Governments, including Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the so-called Independents, who are not even a little bit independent because they nod every time the Government says it has a really bad decision to make. As a result, my constituents have no choice. They have to leave the area where they live in order to work, to go to hospital or to go to college.

What does the Government do? It is after jacking up the fares already. Last year, it put fares up for people who had the neck to live in Dublin - to be Dubliners, for the most part. The Government took them out of the Dublin commuter zone and now they pay more already. They are Dubs. They live in Dublin. They take the train from Dublin, usually into town, and they are getting punished for that. Now, the Government is going to put fares up again. They have no choice. If they need to go to hospital, if they have an appointment or if they want to go to college, they have to take public transport or they have to drive. The Government is getting them every which way. If they take the M1, the M50 or the port tunnel, if they are standing on the side of the road waiting on a ghost bus or one that only eventually arrives, the Government is going to get them. If they are squashed onto overcrowded trains, it is going to get them. There will not be any enhanced services. The NTA has confirmed that to me. There will be no new bus routes next year, no investment beyond that which has been announced and announced to death.

Regarding battery-operated trains, we know they are coming because we can see them sitting in the station. They are just not yet operational. For the moment, my constituents, who keep being told that they will get battery-operated trains at some point - indeed, they will - have to squash onto overcrowd trains and the Government is telling them that they have to pay more. The Government gives them absolutely no option. It has starved the area of resources and now it is telling them this. If I could have the Minister of State's attention for a moment, the very least the Government should be doing in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis - I would not expect more than the very least from it - is not making things worse for people.

Comment on this

I thank the Social Democrats for giving us another opportunity to discuss this important issue. The Government wants to get people out of cars and onto public transport, so one would think that the very first thing it would do is make public transport more accessible. Increasing public transport fares in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis is bonkers. Common sense would tell us that, but when it comes to Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and, as in the Minister of State's case, the Independents, common sense is not very common.

Not only is the Government expecting people to pay more, but it is actually asking them to pay more for less. It expects families, workers, students, pensioners and other commuters to pay more for less. Services are not being delivered and ghost buses are becoming the norm. Major public transport projects are years behind schedule. In my area, we have the Clonburris development. There will be over 10,000 homes there. I was on the council when the plan was being developed. Services like transport, schools and other public amenities were meant to go hand in hand with this development. We spent hours debating this and trying to ensure that the plan was fully integrated. Not everybody agreed on the plan at the council and people had different ways of doing things, but we all agreed that we had to have adequate public transport in the plan.

In fairness, to South Dublin County Council, it played its part and produced a plan but successive Government Ministers have not been doing their jobs. One of the big areas where we are being let down is public transport. The continual delays to DART+ South West have had a huge impact on residents. I am frequently contacted by residents who bought homes in a strategic development zone. This was approved and fast-tracked on the promise of sustainable, high-frequency, high-capacity public transport. Instead, homeowners, residents and commuters have been left with an under-resourced rail service that is already failing to cope with the current demand. Peak-hour services are constantly beyond capacity. Passengers at Clondalkin and Fonthill train stations are regularly left to stand in cramped and unsafe conditions, and sometimes they struggle to board the trains at all. Carriages are frequently excessively hot and stuffy, creating an unpleasant passenger experience.

In the brief time I have left, I call on the Government to bring forward DART+ South West; to increase carriage capacity along the line, particularly at Kishoge, Clondalkin and Fonthill stations; and to address the overheating and ventilation issues and the continual delays of trains.

Comment on this

The mixed messages coming from the Government are infuriating people. On the one hand, the Government talks about developing sustainable public transport systems, investing in active travel and encouraging people out of cars and onto public transport, but here we have an increase in public transport costs. It makes no sense whatsoever. The Government should be using the billions we have in extra taxes to invest in public transport now, specifically more buses, more trains, better active travel and cycling lanes. We have a more expensive and deteriorating bus service in Dublin West. People are deeply frustrated with ghost buses, electronic noticeboards that do not work and trains that are rammed. Irish Rail tells us that it is at capacity, and no extra carriages will be available soon. I was contacted recently by young people from Edmund Rice College who told me they are often left standing on the platform when they cannot get a train because it is full. Safe cycling routes from Clonsilla and Ongar are not an option at the moment due to several dangerous pinch points. In ever-expanding areas like Tyrrelstown, Kilmartin, Hollywoodrath, Ongar and Hansfield, public transport provision lags well behind development. The development of 18,000 new homes in Dunsink was recently in the news, but the NTA tells us that the public transport system it is based on - the Luas - is years away. The NTA will not even look at its provision until the mid-2030s.

The Metro West from Tallaght through Blanchardstown to the airport has been knocked on the head until at least 2042. It was supposed to run past my house. Dublin West has a population of 140,000 people and yet does not have a direct bus service to the airport. How shocking is that? If the Government is really serious about getting people out of their cars, it should invest in our public transport network, introduce free fares for all children and young people, and provide the funding now. It is there. There are billions in surplus for more reliable and frequent bus, rail and metro services. The Government should give the NTA the money now to kick-start Metro West and the Luas to Tyrrelstown through Dunsink lands, and to ensure Dublin Bus has the funds to get more buses on the road. We all know we cannot continue to keep filling our roads with cars. The M50 is at capacity. The Government has been told this for the past year. Nothing more can be done with it. All of us here are asking the Government to give people a genuine opportunity to get out of their cars by investing in a fast, reliable, efficient and cheap public transport system.

Comment on this

I strongly support this motion. The planned hike in public transport fares is nothing less than a slap in the face to ordinary workers and families throughout the country. These workers and families are already being squeezed to the limit due to the continuous failure of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil Governments to combat the cost-of-living crisis. When Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael hike fares, they are penalising those who are simply trying to get to work in town or attend appointments. It is an insult to tell people in rural areas to switch to public transport to help to save the environment while the Government chips away at existing routes. This year, the Expressway 4 bus route has been massively reduced, forcing scores of people back into their cars. I walk around Dublin and all I see is an endless selection of buses and trains, but when I go home to south Kilkenny, there is no bus to Kilkenny city. Scores of families cannot even get access to a bus to school. All we hear from Fianna Fáil is about all the new services for Dublin, but what about the rest of the State? At Kilkenny city train station, people with mobility issues struggle to access the platform. For years, they have campaigned for the lift at MacDonagh Station to be opened. The lift there was handed over 19 years ago, and for 19 years it has been closed to the public. The Government cannot even open an elevator in Kilkenny, but it wants everybody to pay more. For how long have we had to listen to the Government telling people to get out of their cars and use public transport? It is punishing people for doing so. For years, Sinn Féin has pushed for affordable and accessible public transport. We should be here talking about expanding services, reducing costs and making public transport the easiest and most affordable option for everybody, but instead we are here opposing the Government's price increases for a substandard service. I do not know about the Minister of State but people come to me regularly telling me about the cost-of-living crisis, and surely to God they are coming to members of the Government as well. They should open their eyes and see what is going on here. People cannot afford to pay more. It is as simple as that.

Comment on this

I thank the Social Democrats and Deputy Farrelly for bring this motion forward. I also welcome the commuter coalitions from across the country and thank them for their vital advocacy work for public transport across the country. The Labour Party will of course be supporting today's motion. This week, the Minister is not with us because he has his climate hat on and is leading the EU delegation at COP31. I am sure the Minister is going to talk to delegates there about Ireland's climate ambition, about delivery, about how seriously our Government takes the climate crisis and about the actions required to mitigate its impacts. Blah, blah, blah. The Minister can wax lyrical all he wants on the international stage about Ireland's commitment to positive climate action. The reality at home is not only that he and this Government are failing, but that they are actively undermining the efforts to reach our climate targets. The fare increase is just one example.

Last week, the Labour Party released its climate scorecard. This is a comprehensive analysis of Government climate commitments made since 2020. When Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil entered into a coalition with the Green Party in 2020, the programme for Government made 148 commitments relating to the climate and environment in its Green New Deal section. Six years on, 60% of those commitments remain undelivered, with many outright reneged on. Some 78% of priority recommendations on climate and the environment made by bodies like the Climate Change Advisory Council, the SEAI, the European Commission and the Citizens' Assembly on Biodiversity Loss have been ignored by the Government. We know that transport accounts for roughly one fifth of our emissions. It is a sector where we have been failing for years. Emissions have effectively been stuck, not falling. The first carbon budget for transport was exceeded. The SEAI has told us that since September of last year, the sector has effectively been suspending the allocation it was given for the period from 2026 to 2030. The second budget is only 37 million tonnes, and we started that period already in deficit. Any overshoot of the carbon budget is carried forward and deducted from what we have left. This means that every tonne we fail to cut now makes the next cut harder and more expensive.

The EPA projects that even under a "with additional measures" scenario, we will only reach about half of our 2030 emissions reduction targets in the transport sector. What do we do about it? The answer is not some great mystery. It is the same answer that every serious analysis has given for years: avoid, shift and improve. The shift is the part where public transport does the work. When a person leaves the car at home and takes the bus, it is the most direct climate action our transport system can deliver. We should be rewarding that choice, but what does the Government do? It makes it more difficult for people to use sustainable transport. From January, the NTA will increase adult fares by an average of 15%, and in some places the rises will be far higher. This is absolutely ludicrous. We know the impact this decision will have. The NTA has told the Joint Committee on Transport that higher fares will mean fewer people using public transport. Where will they go? They will go back to their cars. They will go onto the motorways that are already full and into the city centres that are already clogged. This policy will increase emissions and increase congestion on our roads, and it will do both on purpose. Anyone who knows about and cares about public transport, climate or quality of life is baffled by this decision.

The only way that this could possibly make sense, in the context of a cost-of-living crisis, extremely healthy public finances and a climate crisis, is if the Government is actively trying to drive down numbers on public transport because of the massive capacity constraints we are currently seeing on our train and bus routes. This must be seen as an acceptance by this Government of its own failures to add capacity to our public transport routes.

We all know the pressures that our public transport system is under. Deputies from across the country have spoken about it. My colleague, Deputy Wall, has been to the fore in highlighting the dangerous overcrowding on commuter rail journeys from Kildare to Dublin. It is happening across the country. There has been a sustained failure over decades to invest in more buses, train carriages, lines and routes. Now, when people want to use public transport, the Government is either unable or unwilling to respond by providing the necessary extra capacity so it puts the fares up to help to manage the issue. This same Government has been able to find €1.2 billion to cut excise duty to keep fossil fuels cheaper, but we cannot find the €70 million it would cost to keep public transport fares down.

It is hard to think of a policy more perfectly designed to move people in the wrong direction. It is anti-climate and anti-worker. The people bearing the cost of this decision will be young workers on modest wages, students, people in commuter towns with no alternative, who will see their travel bills jump, and people in Dublin, Limerick, Galway and Waterford, where fares are being restructured upwards. If we want people outside the cities and in rural communities to leave their cars behind, we need services that are frequent, affordable and reliable. Higher fares push in the opposite direction.

Government backbenchers have expressed their concern about these fare hikes in committee and on social media. If that concern is genuine, they should put their money where their mouths are and stop the crocodile tears. They have a vote and should use it to support this motion.

The Labour Party's position is clear. We want these increases stopped. We want public transport and active travel funded as the essential services they are. Rather than hiking prices on public transport users, we want to move towards free public transport, starting with students and young people, because this is part of the society that we want to build. This is what people should be able to expect as a basic. It is where our climate commitments tell us we have to go.

Comment on this

I thank the Social Democrats for bringing forward this important motion. I want to speak to the issue not because I am a public transport user but because I have received hundreds of messages, with pictures, examples of which I hold in my hand, from my constituents in Dublin Fingal West, particularly around the issue of overcrowding. I want to put on record some of the issues they have sent to me and some of their experiences regarding their journeys on public transport.

Increased transport fees in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis is not a good look. Is the Government listening to people who are already put to the pins of their collars, week to week? Let me tell the Minister of State some of the experiences that my constituents have shared with me. The 33X and 101X bus routes are overcrowded with people sitting on floors and stairs. There are disabled people who are struggling to access services and people are regularly refused boarding because buses are already full.

Rush and Lusk train station is not in Rush and is not in Lusk. That has become a mantra for me in this Chamber. I have raised the issue repeatedly. The bus timetables do not sync with the train timetable. Commuters are forced to drive, but there is no car parking at 7.30 a.m.

I witnessed a passenger faint right next to me. Councillor Mark Boland provided the first aid that day. I have had two more reports in the past two weeks of other fainters, which delays trains and delays people getting to work. People are left waiting for a second or third train because there is simply no room, particularly on the recent truncated trains, as my colleagues from Sinn Féin and Fine Gael experienced yesterday.

Checking the TFI app has become a way of life because buses disappear. The bus services do not properly accommodate getting students to St. Joseph's Secondary School on time to start school in the morning. The last two trains in the evenings do not sync with the bus timetable at Rush and Lusk train station, which means people either have to walk the 30 or 40 minutes to either town or get a taxi, which costs €15 or €20. That is just getting to and from work. Buses are cancelled due to congestion. In the middle of this travel chaos, the Government thinks that increasing fares is acceptable on a transport system that is increasingly creaking at the seams.

Public transport should be a public service and not a financial burden. My constituents are not asking for luxury. They are looking for a service on which they can travel safely and get to work for a fare they can afford.

I received a message this morning. My correspondent told me that they are on more money than ever before but they are scrounging every week to make it to Friday. An unexpected bill, they told me, does not mean dipping into savings or cutting back on a few luxuries, but means going without lunch because they need to ensure they have enough money to top up their Leap card. Their weekly food bill is over €300. There are no luxuries because there simply is not the money. Their health insurance is due in January and they are genuinely having to question whether they can afford the €200 per month. Their childcare cost has increased because their provider has pulled out of core funding, which is a considerable issue in Dublin Fingal West. My correspondent asked what is their reward for all of that. They do not get a seat on the train. They barely get a hand-hold on the train. They are physically crushed against the door because apparently the basic dignity of a safe, comfortable journey to work is too much to expect. The Government now wants them to pay more for the privilege.

I ask the Minister of State what is going on. The reality is that so many people are one unexpected bill away from a crisis. I am asking the Minister of State to do the right thing. Reverse the hikes and do better for the people who are just looking for a bloody break.

Comment on this

I thank the Social Democrats for bringing forward this motion. The proposed increase of 15% to fares, with some rising by as much as 30% next year, is a deeply disappointing backwards step. People cannot afford these additional daily costs. It is unacceptable that passengers have to pay significantly more for services that are already falling short, especially when there is no commitment to long-overdue investment and improvements needed to justify the increases.

Donegal is a prime example. There is still no rail network in the county. We once had one. Everything was taken out of the county and nothing was put back. The county is completely forgotten and neglected when it comes to public transport and essential infrastructure. From the lack of gas connections and the lack of reliable broadband to poor roads, electricity and water infrastructure, the county is constantly being left behind. When it comes to investment and development, people in Donegal rely heavily on buses. When you are in rural Donegal, you have to rely on one bus per day to take you to a connecting town. Otherwise, you will have to take a car. Particularly in Letterkenny, the traffic is chronic.

I have been contacted many times by people who have been left stranded on the side of the road for hours because their buses did not come and they could not get into college or work in time. That is the reality on the ground for people in Donegal. It is completely unacceptable.

I will share one example of how we have been neglected. My children go to college and I am contacted by numerous parents. If they miss the bus in the morning or the bus does not show up, they cannot get in. They have to try to scramble to get a lift. This is happening in every small town outside the urban areas in Donegal. People are neglected and forgotten. It has been going on for years. We need to get a grip on this issue and put proper bus services in place for rural Ireland.

Comment on this

For years, "get out of your cars and use public transport" has been the mantra of this Government and previous Governments. These fare increases drive the public in the opposite direction. It is simply madness. An affordable and reliable public transport service is needed to deal with daily living and the cost-of-living crisis, to ease traffic congestion and reduce carbon emissions, and to simply do the normal things, such as going to work and college, attending hospital appointments and doing the shopping. These increases, which are 15% or even as high as 30% or 35% in some cases, run counter to all accepted public transport and climate change initiatives. Other European countries are moving in the opposite direction, which is to reduce fares and even to provide free public transport. These fare increases are happening at a time of inadequate services, inadequate facilities and overcrowding on trains and buses. The travelling public are being asked to pay more for less. These increases should and must be stopped.

As I have done in the past, I highlight the unacceptable situation at Clonmel Railway Station, which is a hub for trains and Bus Éireann buses.

Large numbers of people wait there for connecting trains and buses. They wait outside the station in all weather - hail, rain and shine - while the station building remains closed. There is no access whatsoever to services there, including toilets, rest rooms or waiting areas. I have raised this issue repeatedly. I am told that internal works are eventually going to be done to provide a passenger waiting area, accessible toilets and changing areas and staff facilities. However, this will not happen until 2028. This is a very minor job in an existing building and should be commenced immediately. I ask the Minister of State to intervene with the NTA and Iarnród Éireann to ensure that happens.

Comment on this

I thank the Social Democrats for bringing forward this excellent motion. The arguments for low-cost and free public transport are unanswerable. This would be a win for climate, a win for the cost of living, a win in reducing traffic congestion and a win for general quality of life. A government that cared about any of those issues would not be increasing fares during a climate and cost-of-living crisis. This Government knows, because the NTA has told it, that increasing fares will reduce public transport use. That is going to mean worse traffic jams. Everyone who is stuck in their cars for hours watching their life slip away day by day should thank Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael because they are the ones that knowingly make choices that make it worse.

I wish to introduce an important fact into the debate. The NTA has told the Committee of Public Accounts, of which I am a member, that in all cases the operating cost per passenger is lower in 2025 than the 2019 equivalent figure. For city buses, the cost per passenger fell from €2.08 in 2019 money to €1.91 in 2025, which is an 8% drop. For commuter rail, it fell from €4.15 per journey to €3.80, which is an 8.4% drop. For intercity, it fell from €17.09 to €14.48, a whopping 15% drop. However, we know now thanks to a freedom of information request that the Government decided to increase fares by up to 25% in October 2025. It was a Government decision, not an NTA one, so we can stop pretending it is the NTA's fault. Nobody should be fooled. Even allowing for increases in fuel prices, which are partially offset by the VAT reduction and the electrification of buses, the Government cannot say it is increasing fares because of rising costs. It is increasing fares because it wants passengers to pay a bigger share of the overall cost of public transport. They are the passengers who are doing everyone else a favour by reducing pollution, traffic congestion and carbon emissions. The NTA tells us the reason for the drop in operating costs per passenger is growth in passenger numbers but the Government is increasing fares in the knowledge that this will cause passenger numbers to fall. Why is this? Maybe it is because the services are so hopelessly overcrowded and the Government has no plans to address that, so it wants to drive people out of public transport to reduce demand.

The final thing to say is that this can still be stopped. I encourage the campaigning and organising to continue. We have until January. We can stop this outrageous increase.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Farrelly for bringing forward this motion and the commuter groups for their ongoing pressure on this issue. Since this fare rise was announced, the mantra we have heard from the Government is that commuters who use bus and trains have a choice between one of two things. They can have affordable fares or they can have more and more frequent services but they cannot have both, according to this Government. The message we have to send from this Chamber is that is not true. This is a political choice Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have made. It is possible to reduce fares, make them more affordable and increase services. That was done, led by the Green Party, in the last Government. We cut public transport fares for everybody by 20%. We introduced the young adult travel card and we got the finance in place for under-nines to go free. At the same time, we increased bus services. There were 56 new or enhanced bus services in 2024 and in 2023 there were 85. It is therefore possible to make life more affordable for commuters and to improve services if the political choice is made and the political will is there, but it is not there with this particular Government. To add insult to injury, this Government has decided to impose these significant fare increases, which are well ahead of inflation, in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis in January when everyone is going to be struggling at best. The only commitment or promise we have from this Government is that it will come back again in January 2028 and January 2029 with more fare demands.

Freedom of information requests went in about this decision. When it was announced, Darragh O'Brien told us that this was about putting fares on a sustainable basis. That is not the case. This is about is about getting Jack Chambers and the Department of public expenditure off Darragh O'Brien's back. We know that clearly from the freedom of information requests that came out there. This is a political decision and a political choice. It is a money-saving choice. It has nothing to do with sustainability. It has nothing to do with the roll-out of new services next year. It can be reversed and there is going to be huge anger come January when commuters see the very significant hit they are taking in their pockets.

Comment on this

The fare increase is a very unfair one. Last night we were fighting in relation to the tolls. Today we are discussing fares for people who are trying to go to work every day of the week, getting up early in the morning, especially the working person, and paying these exorbitant amounts for fuel. In €100 of petrol, €45 is already tax. This is a tax-hungry Government and there is no doubt about that. It wants to hit people for the little bit of transport they are getting in the morning and sometimes in the evening. It could be €5.20 for people coming in from an area like Bray for a return ticket.

At the same time as that, there is no great delivery of the service either. I know it well from my own area because of the many tenders that were put out to start new routes last year that collapsed because there was no money. That was a nicely held secret by the Government all year but apparently there is money since the budget, so I would like to know about the Kealkill-Bantry-Macroom route. Maybe the Minister of State can tell me whether that is open. The people of Kealkill have no transport service, which is terribly unfair. I have attended meetings there and communicated with people back and forth. What about the tender that was put out for Clonakilty, Timoleague, Grange and all that area down there, including Barryroe? There was a tender put out there a year or a year and a half ago. Nothing happened. Is that transport service now going to be resurrected? Is it going to be run?

We might move to the train service we do not have in west Cork. There is no connectivity there. Connecting Ireland is not connecting Ireland when it is not connected. I do not know when we are ever going to come to the stage that we might be connected. A train service came to Schull in the 1850s but in 2026 you have to travel as far as Cork, which is 70 or 80 miles away, to get a train. There is something wrong somewhere. The Minister of State could tell me this is never going to happen. I could accept that, although I do not like the thought of accepting it. Certainly, bus connectivity from west Cork to the train station should be a priority. West Cork Connect has put forward very workable solutions in that regard, but unfortunately they are falling on deaf ears. The problem sometimes is that the main government bodies like the NTA or TII - there are so many of them, lord God, that you would want an instruction book on who is in charge of what - are afraid of something. I do not know what they are afraid of. It is as if they are in competition with the private operators instead of saying that if those operators can do it, let them put a plan together and get it across the line. It has been put to the relevant bodies but it has been stalled, looked at and not looked at. It is not going to happen, again because there is a real hunger out there not to connect Ireland.

Comment on this

There is. I can show the Minister of State plenty of places that are not connected. This is one example. Surely to God there should not be a place in any part of Europe that is 80 to 90 miles of roadway from the nearest train. At one time, the railways travelled to Bantry on a separate route and to Schull on another route. If we could do it in 1850, there is something really wrong when we cannot even bring it to Bandon in 2026. The Taoiseach has a lot of lovely plans for Cork - I have no issue with that; it is brilliant, because Cork needs it - but he has no plans for connectivity for west Cork.

We do not have passing bays on the roads. We do not have bypasses being funded. It is one problem on top of the other. The other thing I do not like is the NTA's attitude - I hate to use the word "attitude" - but it is not listening to solutions that could be made; small-time solutions. I look at areas like Drinagh and Caheragh that have an opportunity to be connected by a transport service because there is a bus travelling close by but it will not take in that little bit extra. It is as if to say, "This is the way it is". Some collar-tie pencil pusher is pushing this in Dublin but does not understand how west Cork works. Somebody may have to wait an extra five or ten minutes because a service is provided in a place like Drinagh or Caheragh. We should use the existing service not put in a new service at a huge extra cost. I do not understand some of the stuff that goes on. There is a bus coming from Castletownbere. Could it not slip into Kealkill and take people from there into Bantry? Would it put ten or 15 minutes on the whole journey? We asked that a bus could go from Castletownsend on to the loop, where it would take in a whole load of extra people but it was refused. Again, we asked for a loop from the Mizen, where I live, taking not one extra minute but it could take ten or 12 extra customers but we were not listened to. I am on the board. I am a volunteer. I never took a brown cent for being on that board. We want to deliver but we are not being given that opportunity. The NTA has its door shut to me, as a public representative, and to everybody else. It is as if it is saying, "We make a decision. You listen to us and scratch your - I am sorry - you know what, after that." That is not good enough. It needs to work with the people. If small changes could be made, maybe they could save the State a fortune in money while, at the same time, deliver a service which would be welcome.

Comment on this

Gabhaim míle buíochas leis na Social Democrats mar gheall ar an rún seo freisin. What does the Minister of State have against commuters? In every direction the Government takes there seems to be an attack on commuters. Hundreds of thousands of commuters are currently living in a commuter hell and being assaulted with never-ending congestion and prices in terms of their daily commute. If we use petrol or diesel, when we go to the petrol station and put 100 quid in the tank, €45 of that will go to the Government in tax. If we use the motorways, the Government has hiked up the tolls yet again, even for tolls that the Government owns that have been bought and paid for. If we use an electric car, we are actually being charged the highest electricity prices on the planet. Indeed, if we charge on the street, we are likely to get a charge that is actually more than the cost of petrol. The congestion is incredible. I came up from Navan yesterday on the M3. It took two hours to travel from Navan to Dublin yesterday morning. It regularly takes between three and four hours for a return journey from anywhere in the commuter belt into Dublin. Could the Minister of State just listen to this for a second? I know he has lots of notes in front of him but this is important and I want him to understand this.

Comment on this

Stop being patronising.

Comment on this

Currently, the M50 is a car park for most of the day. It is at full capacity. One of the solutions to that is to take people from counties like Meath on a rail line into the county. There are 80,000 commuters in Meath. Some 60,000 of those use a car to get into Dublin every day. The Minister of State could have a material effect on all of the commuters in that region by building the Navan to Dublin rail line. The Navan to Dublin rail line was built in three years with picks and shovels in the 1860s. The current phase was started in 1994 and it will not be complete by 2036. That means if a person started work in 1994, they will be retired before it is built. The key thing is that it does not have a start date before 2030. It does not have a ring-fenced fund before 2030. I am imploring and begging the Minister of State at this stage to bring the billed start date for the Navan to Dublin rail line to before 2030 and do hundreds of thousands of people in the commuter belt a massive favour? His decision could have a material effect on the lives of hundreds of thousands of people, never mind climate change and all the costs associated with that. We cannot go on with the situation as currently outlined. Tomorrow, we have the outlining of the consultation stage of the rail line project but it is moving at glacial speed. I urge the Minister of State not to be a passenger on this bus but to be the driver of the bus. He should not just wait for the NTA to make decisions; he should make the decision.

Comment on this

I joked before that it was a cunning plan by the Minister to push fare prices up to keep demand down, with so many overcrowded buses and trains. However, it is no joke for the people who are suffering as a result of this collective incompetence. It makes no sense whatsoever to hike public transport costs in a time of climate crisis, when costs are rising everywhere, and when some people have no alternative to public transport.

At the same time, the Minister is restricting car parking in new developments in my constituency - Dublin Mid-West, in places like Saggart, Seven Mills, Adamstown and Kilcarbery - ostensibly to encourage people to use a transport service that does not exist. There are people fainting on trains in my area and buses that are either full to the brim or cancelled without warning. The Minister is confusing car ownership with car usage. Of course, the people in social housing get even fewer spaces. Going by Simon Harris's comments, none of these people work, none of them have kids that need access to schools and childcare, and none of them have relatives that visit. We have had the media reports of people regretting moving to these areas because of the services not being in place. Between the Opposition and the Government parties, they have made a mess of my constituency. When I was mayor, along with a group of Independents, we tabled over 350 motions to the Clonburris strategic development zone, SDZ, to try to tie in housing with facilities, housing with train stations opening and housing with bus services tied in. It was voted down multiple times, and the behaviour of some councillors was woefully abusive. One would think that we would learn given all the capacity constraints we have now but no, in the recent rezonings, every single rezoning in Lucan, Clondalkin and Saggart has had no tie-in with facilities and infrastructure. I said it ten or 15 years ago, that these problems were going to happen. Now they are going to happen in another ten or 15 years because of bad planning.

Comment on this

I am glad to get the opportunity to say a few words about the rising costs. A lot of people who use public transport on a constant basis are very worried about the proposed increases and it is giving them great concern. It is at times like this that we certainly appreciate free transport for those people with disabilities and the elderly people who can travel free and use their passes to travel where they want. The Ministers and the Governments that put this system in place in the past deserve continuous credit for it and for having the foresight to understand what was needed into the future. I make no bones about it: the Taoiseach, Charlie Haughey, played a big role at the start of that to ensure that many people would have free transport. We appreciate the public transport that we have. As I said, many people are worried about the increased cost but a lot of people are worried also who do not have transport. Many parts of rural Kerry still do not have public transport. While a lot of areas do, there are a lot of rural places that are very isolated that need a better service. I refer to places like the Black Valley, Beaufort, places in east Kerry, Shrone and rural places like Aunaskirtaun. We need to have some kind of a public transport system in those places as well.

The other matter when we are talking about transport is the lack of taxis. There is certainly a deficit of taxis in rural villages like Kilgarvan, Kenmare, Gneevgullia, Scartaglin, Barraduff and Rathmore. While there are a few constant operators who are very greatly appreciated, there are times that you cannot get a taxi in any one of these places. The other thing is that it is taking so long for people to get licensed and to get on the road. It is very cumbersome and that needs to be addressed as well because it is putting off a lot of people who might be interested in providing a service and trying to make a bit of a living for themselves. They see that it is taking too long and they are going in a different direction. In rural places and centres, during the week there are no taxis to be had to get in or out of these places. Not to have some form of public transport is a big disadvantage to a local pub, meetings or anything that is taking place.

While the Minister of State sitting there, I wish to raise a matter I have raised several times. A lot of people come by rail to Killarney. A lot of people leave Killarney on buses. It is a sad reflection that the two stations - the railway station and the bus station - are not connected in Killarney. A person cannot cross a bridge to get from the train station to the bus station. They have to go down around past the Great Southern Hotel and up the Fair Hill before they can get into the bus station. That proposed bridge was on a programme but we have been told that it has been dropped because it is too expensive. The Lord God Almighty, given the number of tourists and people who come from the train station, and we appreciate them coming, to send them around the block with luggage, cases and all their stuff so they can get on a bus is unfair and it has to be addressed. The Government has money for a lot of things. I am not hitting out at the Minister of State but I am telling him that this will have to be addressed. It has to be put on a programme again because we have been told that it has been completely wiped off the list to be done. That is something that is very important. Again, I said-----

Comment on this
Darren O'Rourke An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

Deputy-----

Comment on this

How much time do I have?

Comment on this
Darren O'Rourke An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

You had five minutes.

Comment on this

Sure, the other fella never came.

Comment on this
Darren O'Rourke An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

Is the Deputy going to use his time?

Comment on this

I will say a few more bits and I will go away then.

Comment on this
Darren O'Rourke An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Sinn Féin

Okay. Go ahead.

Comment on this

We have a lot of public transport and we appreciate it. However, the people who do not have it are still suffering. We need to expand it.

There are very big coaches and mid-sized coaches. We have the biggest one going through Kilgarvan. Two of them meet sometimes at the bad turn in the middle of the village. They are having fierce difficulty passing one another. Maybe, a size down from the largest one would help if that could be managed. I am sure the buses are not that full. We appreciate the consistency of the times. They are doing a great job. It would be easier for drivers if we could have a size down from the bigger coach. This would not be a very small one or anything like that but just a size down from the very large one. It would be common sense.

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer Minister of State at the Department of Transport Fine Gael

Gabhaim fíorbhuíochas le gach Ball a bhí páirteach sa díospóireacht tábhachtach agus iontach seo. Bhí mé ag éisteacht le tuairimí na mBall. I thank Deputy Farrelly for bringing the motion before the House. To be fair, I have taken many of the Deputy's Topical Issue debates. He has been a long-time advocate of public transport since he came into the House. The Deputy's bona fides are not questioned at all. I wish to make that comment at the beginning because I know where the Deputy is coming from. To be fair, he has been very consistent.

All of us in the House share a common position. We want to see public transport available and to be accessible, reliable and improved for all people who use public transport. As a Minister of State in the Department with responsibility for rural transport - and I will speak to that in a minute - it is important that the conversation and the debate that we have here recognise that there are challenges. I am not immune or removed from reality. I heard Deputy Gibney's remarks, who I have great respect for, but I live in the real world. I do not need her to tell me about the cost of living. She does not need to tell me about what is happening in my constituency. I am out and about every day. I am an ordinary person; I am a gnáthdhuine. I walk around my people. I live among my people, and I know what is happening.

Comment on this

The Minister of State’s policies do not seem to.

Comment on this

Bhí mé ag éisteacht leat. Do not tell me that I do not know because I do know. I understand full well. I use the public transport in Cork city and I can speak to that too.

The fundamentals are that for a lot of people if we talk to them, it is that ghost bus that we speak about and that real-time information that is paused or not right or it is the bus that does not turn up. To be fair to the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, and the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, we are committed to that public transport investment and that sustainability of the public transport system. I pay tribute to the Dublin Commuter Coalition for its great work and I thank it. It is not about advocacy. It is about putting forward a policy and plan. I fully understand the criticisms. I get it. I have an issue in my own area where we need to see an enhanced connectivity piece in terms of the Ballinora Waterfall-Bishopstown area. Deputy Gogarty is right. All of us can reflect on us. Sometimes, we do not have that joined up thinking approach that we need to have. It mystifies me as to why we cannot do that, particularly when we have council development plans and the national development plan. We all know and recognise what is needed.

Deputy Gibney referenced the direction of travel. We all want to move in that direction where we have a more reliable and people-centred system and a public transport system that is working. By and large, it is working. If we look at the volume of people using it and the number availing of it, it speaks to it. This is not a deflection point but I was on holidays this year in a particular part of America and the public transport system was congested. If I closed my eyes and listened to some of the comments here, I saw that happening in the city that I was in. Trains were full and the information was not right. That is an example. The Government is committed to funding. The budget shows that increase. As the Minister of State with responsibility for rural transport, I am ambitious to see more people using our public transport. I refer the Deputies to rural transport and to look at the success of it. More and more people are using it. Passenger numbers and routes are being increased. To that end, with other Ministers, I am meeting with the NTA to discuss 2027. I am meeting the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, and Minister of State, Deputy Canney, regarding a plan around Connecting Ireland for 2027.

To Deputy Healy-Rae's point regarding the rural hackneys, I changed the rules to make it easier to have more rural hackneys in rural Ireland. There was not a word about that from the Deputy today. He mentioned the bridge in Killarney. That is a matter that is to be taken up with Kerry County Council and Irish Rail.

I do not for one second think that everything is perfect. It is not. As the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, said in his contribution, service availability, frequency, reliable and the overall service plus the fares have the impact. What we want to see and what I have spoken to is that strong sustainable foundation that will deliver new and enhanced public transport services. The importance of BusConnects is critical. Deputy Rice is here in the Chamber. We have seen the success of the light rail in terms of commuter rail in Cork with Cork, Midleton, Glounthaune, Cobh and Mallow. New stations are being opened to deliver and connect more people. It is fact.

Deputy Collins spoke about west Cork. I have not had one request from the West Cork Connect group for a meeting. I hope Deputy Rice will testify. The Deputy and I are fairly available in Cork. We are not living in an ivory tower. I am around and available. I was in west Cork over the summer, and I met Deputy Collins in Schull. To be fair, let us have a real conservation. We all regret and can all speak to the closure of the west Cork railway line back in the 1960s and as to why it happened. What would the cost be of a west Cork rail today? What is the cost of the Cork and Youghal line? I am all in favour of having the Cork and Youghal line developed.

I heard Deputy Quaide's contribution. I would like to see the Cork to Youghal line or the Midleton to Youghal line being reopened but what is the cost? Who pays for that?

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Quaide's point.

I am sure he will agree with me that the Midleton-Cobh-Cork line he is on is phenomenal and a great success. We were told 20 years ago it would not happen, but it has. I heard his comments and will take them back to the relevant people.

We want to strengthen transport connectivity not just for the urban commuters referenced by Deputies, but also for rural Ireland. Deputy Ward spoke about Donegal, which has one of the best rural transport services in the country, but we did not hear about that today. Rural Link providers are doing a phenomenal job. Next year, I want to see the continued expansion of Local Link throughout the country. The towns bus programme shows that public transport can be a success. There is evidence last year from the first ever smart demand responsive transport pilot in Achill, Killarney and Limerick city. Notwithstanding the challenges we face, working with the NTA we can ensure that we can deliver for people.

I have heard the concerns and remarks. We all subscribe to the premise of affordable fees. The fare increase that has been proposed is about putting the financial stability of the public transport system in place and continued investment. I do not want to strike a note of discord because I am fundamentally on the same page as Deputy Farrelly, but nobody has spoken about how we will pay for it.

Comment on this

I am not going to have a row, but let us live in the real world. The Government has increased the pot of money for the Department. We do not have money up the wazoo to spend on everything. We have made choices. We are making the choice to improve the electrification of the fleet, connect more people, improve commuter rail, the Luas for Cork and MetroLink.

Deputies have spoken about the cost of living. The Government has intervened repeatedly to support and assist people, as it should. I understand that affordability is a key priority, but we must achieve balance in the terms of the need for service improvement, expanding the network, enhancing reliability and providing the better public transport we all want. I pay tribute to the men and women who work in our public transport system because they do phenomenal work.

There is more that unites us than divides us. I want more people to be connected and a better offering and better public transport system. I look forward to working with everybody, in particular the NTA, which is the body determining the decisions, to ensure that our public transport system delivers more people affordable, on-time and reliable services with certainty.

Comment on this

The Minister of State is a gas man. He has said he is of the people and in touch with the people. The move the Government is making is out of touch and is putting more strain on those families he understands are under strain due to the cost of living. This move does not understand those people. His argument is that money does not grow on trees yet the Government has a massive tax surplus, running into hundreds of billions of euro. It is gas and the Minister of State is a gas man coming to the House to debate that.

He fundamentally agreed with us but his actions and those of the Government do not show that. These fare increases put more pressure on people. He referenced some facts, and that is a fact. From January, adult fares will increase by an average of 15%. In my constituency, Dublin Central, short fares will increase by 33%, which is another fact. The Minister of State wants to talk about facts. That is a third more for the same journey on a bus and there is the same uncertainty about whether the bus will turn up on time. We hear about ghost buses across my constituency and the country. Someone taking two short journeys a day, five days a week, will have another fiver taken out of their pocket. The Minister of State knows it is not just about a fiver. People are under pressure. Over 48 weeks, the fare increase will result in an increase of €240. The Government and Minister of State, a normal person in touch with the people, might consider that a small amount, but for some people it is a significant amount and affects putting food on the table or choosing what bill to pay next.

Living in the city does not mean people can simply walk everywhere. For older people, people with disabilities, parents with young children and someone coming home after a long shift, walking is simply not an option in some places. These are essential journeys and people should be able to afford them.

The Government is asking people to pay more for journeys they are already not getting enough out of. In my constituency, when a couple of bus stops, including the North Strand bus stop, were removed, residents had to start a local campaign for months to fight for a bus stop to come back, in an area where high numbers of people with disabilities and people over 65 are registered. I know that because I live there. There was zero consultation from the NTA on this.

Regarding Home Farm Road, the term "shambles" simply does not cover the plan that has been put in place up there. There are different road layouts, which send buses down small pedestrian roads where schools are located. We are talking about increasing fares. It is a merry-go-round with the NTA at the best of times. We know the demand for public transport has grown, with over 363 million journeys in 2025. It is a fact that that is a good thing but that should be the reason to invest further, improve services and build on that progress. Instead, the Government is putting up another barrier for people using public transport.

The NTA acknowledges that a 10% increase will lead to a 3% fall in passenger numbers. The Minister of State has said he is a normal person who is in touch with the people. This move is not in touch with how people are living and the cost-of-living crisis.

Comment on this

I missed the full debate. I was chairing a health committee meeting but I did catch some of the debate and some of the Minister of State's response. He will appreciate my example, being from Cork. I was going to town on Saturday to catch the Kingfishr gig, and the sign at my local bus stop said it would be there in three minutes. I ran to the bus stop and waited, where the sign said it would be there in five minutes but then the bus just disappeared. The sign told me the next bus would be in 25 minutes, but that then got delayed. I would have walked to town in the time that I would have been waiting at that bus stop. That is not a privilege other people have, as Deputy Ennis just said.

There are real issues. The Minister of State will be aware of the frustration because we have the same constituents. The real issue in Cork is that the bus fares have already increased by 26% this year. That is going to be felt further across the county and into other services. A constituent of mine and the Minister of State emailed me recently me to say that Cork city bus users have felt the pinch since June when fare increases went up, and that is now set to spread to rail services. This is all happening against the backdrop of further delays to the Cork Luas project and the lack of progress on BusConnects. This decision is tone deaf. We cannot keep asking people to pay more while receiving less. These fare increases are also being implemented during one of the worst cost-of-living crises this country has seen, but it is also completely disconnected from our climate goals.

Almost every day a constituent contacts me regarding public transport. I sit here in the Dáil and listen to people who are struggling to pay their rent and bills and to put food on the table. Many of those who are struggling will have waited today in the rain at bus or train stops, for buses to turn up that are overcrowded, as we saw last week on "Prime Time".

Constituents will often delay raising issues regarding buses being cancelled or delayed. It was reported recently that 36% of Cork city buses operated off schedule during the first half of the year, showing up late or leaving earlier than timetabled. This is one third of services, and now people are being asked to pay more. Someone from Cork said to me recently that it is just another price hike. Everything else is a price hike so why not this too?

People are incredibly frustrated about the rising cost of public transport. but they are also worried about the climate. The Minister of State asked how we are going to pay for this. We seem to have plenty of money to pay for climate-related fines. We need to address this to have a real transition away from fossil fuels. The fare increases are a stark contrast to our climate targets. We need to get people using public transport. People feel they cannot use it because it is unreliable and costs are increasing. Therefore, it is crucially important that these hikes are reversed and that we meet our climate targets by providing people with access to affordable quality public transport.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for his response and colleagues across the House for their contributions on the debate on public transport fare increases. If we are ever wondering about the cost of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil doing business with the Regional Independents, it is on issues like this that it manifests.

Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil and the Green Party were record-breakers in terms of public transport costs and public transport users. As soon as we said goodbye to the Green Party in that Government and welcomed the regional Independents, who have championed tar, tar and tar - that populist narrative of really local issues - the Government has collectively taken its foot off the gas when it comes to the real priority, which should be moving people, not moving cars.

Ultimately, we should not be debating whether public transport costs are going up. We should actually be congratulating the Government on driving those prices down. If we took our climate obligations seriously at all, we would never look at raising public transport prices. Actually, we would ideologically move to one day having free public transport for everybody,-----

Comment on this

-----the maximum use of public transport and not giving out and saying that we cannot pay for everything, which is what our Taoiseach said in response to these announcements.

We have heard an awful lot this morning about overcrowding on our public transport network, whether that is on rail or on buses. A legitimate and tangible thing to do from a Government perspective when there are capacity issues is to increase capacity. The illegitimate thing to do when there are capacity issues is to raise the prices to drive people away from using public transport. That is really unacceptable at a time when we should be trying to encourage people towards public transport. We now have a Tánaiste and Minister for Finance who will give out to you if you do not go to work and a Government that is preparing itself to punish you financially for going to work. On 1 January, you will pay more for your bus, your toll, your train and, whichever which way, commuting to work.

Public transport increases will come to about 1.3% of the Department's budget in 2027. The National Transport Authority needed €70 million to sufficiently keep its budget aligned. The Government has put that cost on the end user, even though the Minister of State's Department had an underspend of ring-fenced carbon tax budgets of over €100 million in 2025. The Minister of State has told me that the Government cannot spend everything and asked where it would come up with the money. That is where the money is. It is sitting there and is ready to be used by just changing the subhead from a carbon tax to an NTA budget supplement. That would negate the need for putting this on families.

This Government has taken its eyes off the prize. This is a political choice. This is the Taoiseach, the Minister of State and the wider Government's choice to raise public transport fares. Time and again, it has been the wrong choice. I ask that the Government change its mind today. Reverse this decision and do away with public transport fare increases.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The division is deferred until the weekly division time this evening.

Comment on this