Social welfare and long-term unemployment
Hayes raises the hardship of a traumatised young homeless man and challenges the Government’s approach to social welfare, poverty and long-term unemployment. Burke says welfare should be a safety net, not employment policy, and defends support aimed at helping people return to work; the debate includes criticism of the Tánaiste’s remarks and a heated exchange over Hayes’s accountability, with a brief reference to the children’s hospital cost overrun. Nash also condemns the remarks as an attack on vulnerable unemployed people, while Burke rejects that characterisation.
A ten-minute walk from here, in my constituency, there is a homeless shelter. I met a man there recently who was in his early 20s. He suffered abuse as a child, was placed in foster care and is now on the streets in Dublin city. He struggled with addiction brought on by the trauma of his past. He met his partner while homeless, a lovely young woman whom I also met, finding love in a hopeless place. He is quite understandably reliant on social welfare and the State to survive. My first question for the Minister is a simple one. Is the way of life of the man I met, who survived severe trauma and yet, despite all the odds, found love and support, worthy of the Minister's contempt and his party leader's contempt or our society's compassion?
I have to say that I found the comments from the Minister's party leader last weekend utterly deplorable. He chose to put a spotlight on a tiny number of people who are classed as long-term unemployed, just 1.3% of our labour force, using them as a public punching bag. Behind any numbers, though, there are real people. Many are lone parents who, under the Government's policies, will lose their benefits if they take up even a part-time job of 12 hours a week. These policies drive child poverty, which has soared under the Government, something the party leader also failed to mention in his speech at the Ard-Fheis. There are now 260,000 children living in poverty, according to the Economic and Social Research Institute, ESRI. Of course, let us not forget the crown jewel of Fine Gael's legacy to the Irish people over the last 15 years, the gargantuan figure of nearly 18,000 people homeless, 12,000 of them adults, the highest ever on record. That has been on Fine Gael's watch.
None of these points was mentioned by the Minister's party leader in his speech. It was just a lazy attack from a political leader who was out of ideas. The truth is that Fine Gael cares more about distracting the public from its litany of failure than tackling the poverty in our society. It lacks the vision to provide solutions and it lacks the leadership required to face the problems.
Does the Minister agree with his party leader's comments demonising a small group of vulnerable people, and does Fine Gael now stand for turning vulnerable people into a punching bag?
Comment on this
From the man who boasted about making people redundant? Does the Deputy not think that he is hypocritical? He boasted about making people redundant, yet he comes in here and delivers that speech.
Comment on this
Too late. The Minister of State should not be doing it in the first place. He should be setting a good example.
Comment on this
Deputy Hayes was very selectively quoting what the Tánaiste said last week. The Tánaiste was very clear in his speech, in that when life takes an unexpected path for people, they deserve support, that "social welfare must always be there for people when they need support", and that this is "the mark of any decent society". One thing that Fine Gael will not do is what the Deputy is doing, and that is turn its back on those who are long-term unemployed and leave them on the margins of society. We have to ask ourselves a question: should social welfare be a safety net or an employment policy? Our view is that it never should be an employment policy. It should be a safety net. We should work with people to ensure that those who are long-term unemployed are getting every assistance from the State so that they can get into employment. We should not leave them on the margins of society or be afraid to tackle this issue. We should also ensure they can avail of training, personal development and the opportunity that we now have in this economy, having had 18 consecutive quarters of unemployment below 5%. We have a huge opportunity in every corner of our economy right now. Everyone should be entitled to grasp that opportunity for themselves and their families. We are clear that a job is about confidence. A job is about independence and it brings purpose to people's lives. That is why we want to ensure that we support people to get a job, which is so important for their personal development.
It does a great disservice to anyone in long-term unemployment to take the view that nothing more can be done, that society cannot do any more and that Governments will not look at the issue. We will absolutely look at it, and we will look at it to ensure that we get people back into the workforce. It is important to do that and it is an obligation of any government to do so. Our policy is very different from the Deputy's. We are rewarding work. We recognise that a strong economy is needed to drive our public services and protect the most vulnerable. We are clear that there can be many reasons and many complications in life. One thing I always say is that, in my political view, people always deserve a second chance. We as a State want to work with people to give them that second chance.
We will absolutely talk about the long-term unemployed. We will absolutely look forensically at the 52,000 people who are long-term unemployed and we will work with every service in the State to get them into employment. We will not ignore them or leave them on the margins of society. We will work to bring them into employment and do what every responsible society does, which is to ensure that everyone who can work, who is available for work, makes their contribution. That is key in any functioning society.
Comment on this
The Minister is right that there are differences in our policies. We would not stand over the homeless figures that he stands over. We would not stand over the figures for children in poverty that he stands over. We would have different policies in social protection that would help lone parents, tackle addiction and get people off the streets.
The Minister does not really get it.
Comment on this
How could Fine Gael possibly hope to lead the country if it is willing to disparage thousands of its citizens? The Minister for Finance, Simon Harris, said last weekend that penalising the long-term unemployed was "what taxpayers across this country expect us to do". What taxpayers really expect is a Government that actually tackles problems instead of one made up of epic wasters who cannot deliver basic services.
Can the Minister tell me how much the cost of the national children's hospital has increased since its inception? It has increased by over €1 billion. As an accountant, can the Minister tell me then whether it is the long-term unemployed who are the problem in this country or whether it is a man - his party leader - who has spent his entire adult life in the political system failing upwards?
Will the Minister stand by this version of Fine Gael that demonises the most vulnerable in our society?
Comment on this
Deputy Hayes's disingenuous approach knows no bounds. If he is putting himself up as a prospective Government Minister, will he answer one question? When will Deputy Hayes go out to meet the media? He is a democratically elected politician in this House and he will not even stand on the plinth to be held accountable by the media in this country.
Comment on this
Deputy Hayes will not do that. He is walking away. I am happy to stand on my record and on Fine Gael's record of driving up employment in our country.
Comment on this
It is a terrible record. The Minister should not be happy.
Comment on this
We will never ever let people languish in the margins of society without giving them help and getting them into employment.
Comment on this
People who are able to work and available to work should be getting every assistance from the State to get them into employment-----
Comment on this
That is not what the Government is going to do.
Comment on this
-----to give them the opportunity of confidence, independence and purpose. That is what my party stands for. Deputy Hayes is just trying to take advantage of one line out of context in a speech where I pointed out that social welfare should always be a safety net. It is never an employment policy. That is the difference between Deputy Hayes and me. I have the courage of my convictions to stand out on that plinth and argue my case, and Deputy Hayes does not. He walks off the pitch and hides.
Comment on this
His colleagues will not stand beside him. You will not get caught on that one again, Gary.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Hayes want to apologise for his own posts?
Comment on this
Order, please. Do not make it personal, Minister of State. You breeze in here and make those personal-----
Comment on this
No, sorry. Do not disrupt Leaders' Questions, and do not do it in the way that you are doing it.
Comment on this
At the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis this weekend, there was a deliberate focus on unemployed workers. I cannot let the week pass without condemning on the record of the Dáil the Tánaiste's premeditated attack on those who are reliant on our social safety net. Dumping on the tiny number of long-term unemployed is the worst kind of divisive dog-whistling designed to distract from the Government's failures. We have seen similar tactics deployed from Fine Gael and indeed Fianna Fáil against migrants and civil society bodies. It is never an accident. It is always about punching down on the most vulnerable. If we are serious as a country about supporting people with complex lives to work, we also need to be serious about tackling low pay, and the Government evidently is not. The coalition has abandoned its promises on a living wage and its promises on statutory sick pay. Every single workers' rights initiative brought to this Chamber and to the Seanad by the Labour Party, like our Seanad Bill to protect workers from extreme weather yesterday, has been voted down by the Government. The Minister decided to put the needs of SMEs above those of workers. Good government can accommodate both.
We have had an economically mad VAT cut for profitable hospitality companies. We have new regulations to allow teenagers work until 11 p.m. in food businesses, but the Government denies them the dignity of a full minimum wage. A new test is on the horizon. Yesterday, the Dáil was told that the Government has not yet received any notification of collective redundancies at Dealz. Those employed in the 70 Dealz shops across Ireland will be particularly worried in the run-up to Christmas. I do not need to remind the Minister who Gordon Brothers, the owner of Dealz, is. On 12 June 2015, its actions saw almost 500 staff of Clery's dumped onto O'Connell Street with nothing but the dole. In the dead of night, they liquidated the company that ran the iconic department store, while simultaneously flipping the finest building on our national main street to a company called Natrium, which told the workers it was not their employer. Nobody, as far as they were all concerned, was responsible. This cynical property play sickened even business leaders who called this behaviour out.
Gordon Brothers has form. It is the worst kind of asset stripper imaginable. It is back in the news again because Poundland in the UK and Dealz here in Ireland are under threat. The Clery's debacle shows what this gang is capable of and why we should be wary. I worked long and hard, as the Minister knows, to introduce a Clery's law to ensure that workers who were caught up in insolvencies would have a right to be heard and to be consulted on their redundancies. That is now law. The Minister's first job is to work to ensure that the company has a future here and the 3,500 jobs are protected. We have all been aware of the possible threat to jobs since September. What has the Minister done since then? Have his Department and its agencies engaged with Gordon Brothers? If not, why not? Will he ensure that if the nuclear button is pressed, workers at Dealz will have the full protection of the law?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Nash for his important question. I would robustly push back on anyone who tries to categorise my party as one which punches down on those who are unemployed. I have been very clear about the context of the Tánaiste's speech over the weekend at the Fine Gael Ard-Fheis and the way he pointed out that the mark of any decent society is the way it supports people when they are unemployed. Critically, our view is that you never turn your back on people who are unemployed. You try to get them back into the labour force to give them independence and purpose in life and to ensure they are not left on the margins of society. Too many people, too often, ignore those who are in long-term unemployment. We will not do that. Our new pathways to work programme will target people with training, assist them with personal development and get them back into the workforce, which is key.
On the issues the Deputy raised, I stand by the record of this Government on employment rights. Looking at the work we have done, I was clear about bringing forward an action plan on collective bargaining and resourcing it. I was also clear that irrespective of what position the European Court of Justice took, I was still going to come forward with our plan. We brought forward in the previous Government a ban on zero-hour contracts and legislation to protect tips. Remote working has taken hold in society. I brought forward the protection of employees during insolvency legislation, another key support for employees. Now we are bringing forward pregnancy loss leave. There is more legislation improving the lives of employees up and down our country. As I articulated in the previous response, we have done work on the new public service pay deal, with an 18% increase to protect lower paid workers over 33 months. This demonstrates that the Government is working to protect those who are in employment.
I am aware of the reports that Poundland has filed notice of its intention to appoint an administrator to the company in the UK. I appreciate the uncertainty for all during the media reporting, given that this situation is currently evolving. I confirm again that we have not received a collective redundancy notification from Poundland or Dealz at this juncture. Employers must comply with a number of legal obligations during the collective redundancy process, as the Deputy is aware. I know he was involved in those areas during his term as Minister of State. The obligations include the 30-day information consultation process with employees' representatives and notifying me as Minister of any proposed collective redundancies 30 days before any dismissal would take place. We will be strict in ensuring engagement and protection for workers.
The Deputy mentioned the difficult process of the closure of Debenhams and Clery's. The Government did significant work in that regard with Solas and our training agencies. In particular, there was €13 million to resolve the statutory redundancy payments for Debenhams workers at that time. In the new legislation we have brought forward, we are working on this. I acknowledge Deputy Nash did a significant proportion of that work with the Duffy-Cahill report in that period.