Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›
Children in Care
The Government is finalising a national policy on informal kinship care, informed by consultations with children, families and stakeholders, with recommendations expected next month. The Minister said guardian payment eligibility and other support barriers would be considered, while Deputy Hayes urged stronger financial and pension support for carers.
2. Deputy Eoin Hayes asked the Minister for Social Protection the steps his Department is taking to honour the programme for Government commitments to enhance outcomes for kinship carers; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [80125/26]
Comment on this
My question is about the programme for Government commitment to improve outcomes for kinship carers. As the Minister might know, about 12,000 children are living in family arrangements with kinship carers. About 5,000 of these are cared for by grandparents. I expect that the Minister will talk about the national framework for alternative care that is due to be published next month. It may be worth reminding him that, 34 years ago, the Government ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. We still have not honoured those rights.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy very much. He will be aware that matters relating to foster care are the responsibility of my colleague, the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality. However, we acknowledge the very important role of all carers, including foster carers and kinship carers. Along with my colleague, Deputy Erin McGreehan, I met with the Irish kinship care group last year. I am very interested in this space and I am fully committed.
The programme for Government contains a commitment with regard to kinship carers. As the Deputy said, the Department of Children, Disability and Equality is in the process of developing a national policy on the rights of children who are living in informal kinship care. Officials from my own Department have been participating in this group in the context of the various guardian’s payments administered by my Department. Considerable work has gone in from our side. I understand the deadline to complete the work is next month. To date, our work has looked at the scoping exercise on informal kinship care in Ireland. The exercise includes a review of: the existing relevant legislation; the current reality for families in informal kinship care arrangements, including an analysis of their current access to supports; national and international literature and international perspectives; and examples of international best practice.
As part of this work, the Department of Children, Disability and Equality is ensuring that the voice of the child is present from the earliest possible stage. Consultations have been carried out with children and young people with experience of informal kinship care arrangements. That approach is aligned with Article 12 of the UNCRC and the requirement that children's views must be considered and taken into account in all matters affecting them. The Department has also completed a consultation, via survey, with parents of children with experience of informal kinship care and has conducted research to better understand those experiences. As the Deputy will appreciate, this is a sensitive and complex issue. The Department has engaged deeply with stakeholders. Based on that analysis, it is currently finalising draft policy recommendations.
Comment on this
I appreciate the engagement and work of the Minister and his officials on this matter. The Minister is absolutely right that the view of the child needs to be central to this. When we look at the domestic experience, until now, full State supports have not been guaranteed to these children or to their families. I will give the Minister some figures. Tusla has estimated that the cost of special emergency arrangements to care for a child where there is no kinship care or foster care available is about €14,000 per week. Foster care costs over €400 a week while kinship care costs about €240 a week. The Minister can see the inequality. We know that outcomes are way better when people stay with their families. We need to make sure that people are able to access supports such as the guardian's payments, that these payments actually honour the rights of children and that the Minister's Department gives sufficient State support to these families and children.
Comment on this
We are looking at all of those issues. The Minister, Deputy Foley, is leading out in her Department in relation to this work. The Deputy will agree that extensive work has been done, including ensuring that the voices of children and teenagers who have experienced kinship care are included.
I have a lot of meetings in this job, but the meeting I had last year with Deputy McGreehan and the kinship care group is genuinely one that stands out in terms of the dedication, commitment and absolute love of the kinship carers. That is not to say that it does not happen everywhere, but this was a particularly special bond and is something that people have taken on in very difficult circumstances. We need to ensure that they are getting the maximum support.
My officials have been engaging extensively with the Department of Children, Disability and Equality. We have contributed extensively to the work in terms of our schemes, and I certainly look forward to working with the Minister, Deputy Foley. There are a number of Deputies, alongside Deputy McGreehan, who are involved in this space. I see Deputy Nolan here, and I have taken parliamentary questions from her in this space as well. All of us have a duty to assist people who are involved in kinship care in terms of the work they do and the considerable commitment they give to that work.
Comment on this
I strongly support the Minister's work on this and his commitment, and I cannot echo enough his sense of feeling in terms of how he has met the kinship carers. It is really important.
One of the things that has come up in this is that the carers must evidence abandonment a lot of the time to qualify for the guardian's payment. That is actually really difficult. If there is a parent who, for example, suffers from addiction, is in prison, is involved in criminality and all those kinds of thing, the child could then be placed with another family member such as a grandparent, aunt or uncle. If they have any contact at all with the parent, they could be disqualified from the guardian's payment. That is what Kinship Care Ireland has said. That is extremely stringent and does not honour the rights of the child to proper support and care from the State. I ask the Minister to look at this matter in particular. Only about 20% of children in kinship arrangements are there due to dead parents, so the contact barrier is a significant issue. In particular, I also ask the Minister to consider the pension arrangements for kinship carers because they do exceptional work on behalf of the State.
Comment on this
These are all issues that are being considered as part of the report and part of the work that the Minister, Deputy Foley, is conducting. There are issues and qualification criteria across all of our schemes, but when we get the report from the Department of children, we will analyse it. I will go through it and see where we can reduce any barriers that are there to make their jobs and commitments a lot easier. There are a range of complex qualifications around all of our schemes, and they are there for a reason, but we certainly do not want to get in the way. I am very cognisant of the sensitivity and complexity of this issue, but the Deputy will agree that considerable work has been done by our colleagues in the Department of children, led by the Minister, Deputy Foley. It is work that recognises that complexity and sensitivity and engages not just here, but also in international best practice in this area, so that when we have recommendations, they will be as contemporary and responsive as possible to the situation people who are in kinship care are in.