We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Non-Fatal Offences against the Person (Amendment) (Spiking) Bill 2023 [Seanad]: Second Stage

Summary

The Bill would create a stand-alone offence of spiking, punishable by up to 10 years’ imprisonment on indictment, and is intended to make clear the seriousness of the conduct. The Minister confirmed Government support for allowing it to proceed, noting that existing offences can already apply but that prosecutions are rare and evidence-gathering is difficult. Speakers across parties supported the Bill and called for prompt Committee Stage scrutiny, particularly of whether the requirement to prove intent could undermine prosecutions. Members also urged a clear toxicology-testing pathway, better reporting data and practical prevention measures.

Bill Non-Fatal Offences against the Person (Amendment) (Spiking) Bill 2023
Current

No. 45 of 2023 ›

I move: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

It is my very great pleasure to introduce the Bill on Second Stage because this a Bill that I introduced as a Senator along with my colleagues in the Seanad on 25 May 2023. It went through all Stages, including Second Stage on 31 May 2023, Committee and Remaining Stages on 12 July and 25 October 2023, respectively. It passed those Stages in the Seanad, and it was sponsored by the Fine Gael group of Senators at the time, which included Regina Doherty, now an MEP and who continues to be very supportive of this Bill; Senator Ahearn who is now the Leader of the Seanad; Paddy Burke; Senator Maria Byrne, now the Leas-Chathaoirleach of the Seanad; Micheál Carrigy now a TD; Senator Martin Conway; Deputy John Cummins, now a Minister of State; Deputu Emer Currie, now the deputy Government Chief Whip; Aisling Dolan; Seán Kyne, now a TD; Tim Lombard; John McGahon; Senator Joe O'Reilly; Mary Seery-Kearney; and me. It was brought to me by members of Young Fine Gael. It had a campaign, which it rather pointedly called PricklessNights. It was about the experiences that they and their members had in pubs and clubs throughout the length and breadth of this country. They saw that this was an area of concern for people and brought it to us as a Seanad team.

We were very happy to take that and turn it into legislation, the import of which makes it a stand-alone offence in Irish law.

I acknowledge the presence in the Public Gallery of the current president of Young Fine Gael, Jamie Malone, but also his predecessors, Art O'Mahony and Eoghan Gallagher, who was president at the time. I also acknowledge the support they had from Spiking in Ireland, in particular Mary Crilly, whom I spoke to last week about this Bill. She was very helpful in identifying the policy pathway that could be taken to establish this as a Private Member's Bill. It is rare for somebody to have the opportunity to introduce a Bill in one House, bring it through all Stages and then happen to find themselves in the other House to carry on the baton as it is moved here, but it is my great pleasure to do so.

As I said, the Bill puts spiking on its own statutory footing. There is a lot of debate about whether spiking is an offence. It probably is, in reality. Spiking is when a person with a nefarious intention essentially puts a substance in someone's drink that incapacitates, drugs or makes them unconscious. It can also be introduced through a very fine needle or done in some way for them to ingest a substance that causes them to essentially lose control of their faculties and no longer be able to deal with situations they might otherwise be able to repel. The intention is usually for a nefarious purpose, very often for sexual assault or worse. Unfortunately, this is the experience of many people all over Ireland.

When we talk about spiking, we probably imagine it in a nightclub in Dublin. However, that is not the only place spiking takes place. Spiking can happen to anyone, anywhere and of any age in any circumstance, and it does. While this was initiated by Young Fine Gael and we are happy to take on board the research it has done and the feedback it has given us, it is something that affects every sector of society. The danger is we pass this off as a young person's issue when, in fact, it has the potential to affect all of us. Unfortunately, I suspect everybody in this Chamber has dealt with somebody in their constituency who has been the victim of spiking. It is something that happens all the time and, unfortunately, very often those instances are not reported to gardaí, which is another problem.

The debate regarding whether it is an offence comes down to the fact it does not have a stand-alone status in legislation as the offence of spiking. I suspect it is an offence under the non-fatal offences Act already, either as a poison or as a simple assault, as it requires the application of pressure in an illegal context. That argument could be made, but the difficulty is where there is a debate on whether something is an offence, this automatically diminishes the status of that act as a criminal act. Here, we are sending out a very clear signal that not only gives it status in itself, but it also says to anybody contemplating this activity that spiking somebody's drink or food with a substance that is going to incapacitate them is a very serious criminal offence. With this legislation, we are trying to send out a loud and clear signal to anybody involved in this activity that they will be caught, prosecuted and there will be serious consequences. The best way to do that is to give this offence a stand-alone status. That is why this Bill essentially amends the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997 to create that, and I will go through some provisions of the Bill to be clear on what it does.

Section 1 deals with definitions or interpretations within the Bill as it stands, and hopefully the Act as it will be. It talks about the terms used. The main offence is set out in section 2, which describes spiking as an offence in subsection 1 as follows:

(1) A person commits an offence if he or she intentionally - (a) administers a substance to,(b) by whatever means, injects a substance into, or (c) otherwise causes a substance to be taken orally by, another person - (i) knowing that the other person does not consent, or being reckless as to whether or not the other person consents, and (ii) with the intention of overpowering, or sedating the other person, for the purposes of - (I) engaging in a sexual act involving the other person, (II) causing harm to the other person, (III) making a gain, (IV) causing a loss to the other person, or (V) otherwise committing an offence with, or against, the person.

There are a couple of savers in section 2 as well, that in any proceedings for an offence under the section that, "it shall be a defence for a person to prove that the substance was administered, injected or otherwise given - (a) for a lawful reason or with a lawful excuse, or (b) with the other person’s express and conscious consent." That is a saver to exclude any medical treatment or any circumstances where such a substance is used. Very often, the substances used for spiking are substances that have a legitimate medical application but are being used illegally by a person for their effect. Section 2(3) sets out the penalties for a person guilty of an offence stating they are liable "on summary conviction", which is in the District Court without a jury, "to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months, or to a class A fine, or to both". However, in the case it is prosecuted on indictment, paragraph (b) states it will be "on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 10 years". That is a significant penalty. It also sets out that penalty in the context of what I have said regarding the debate as to whether this is an offence, or what way it would be charged in the event a complaint was successfully upheld. This Bill sets out very clearly the range of penalties available to the Circuit Court in the event it is prosecuted successfully on indictment, and that is up to ten years' imprisonment.

The Bill also makes a clear statement about the level of seriousness that plays on the spectrum of criminal offences where we are pitching this matter as being at ten years. It is up there among the most serious offences that could be dealt with by the Circuit Court. We are talking about very serious stuff here. Just imagine what spiking really is. More often than not it affects women, but it is both and can be all ages, but when a person in a pub is on a night out, let us say, and somebody pops something in their drink, injects something into them or puts something in their food, they are incapacitated. They are not necessarily unconscious; they might just be in a dreamlike state, but they are unable to resist actions being taken by a third party against them. They might be removed from the pub or club and taken somewhere quiet or unseen within the place, where they are then massively vulnerable to all kinds of abuse. In the Bill, we have referred to the reasons someone would do this, such as engaging in a sexual act, causing harm, making a gain, causing a loss or otherwise committing an offence. That covers a multitude of things. Of course, this includes rape, which is so often the consequence of spiking, so let us not in any way underestimate the seriousness of spiking, and where it happens, the effect it has on the individual concerned.

Most of us in this House will have dealt with constituents who have been the victims of spiking and the possible consequences of spiking up to and including rape. I am sorry to say I certainly have, so we cannot underestimate the seriousness of this matter or the effect it has on this person. Where we have set the tariff for penalties very much says this is a very serious thing. This is a very serious offence. It is not just taking away the autonomy of a person or removing their free will by drugging them, but it is also what is done to them while they are in that state. It is about making a very serious statement about the consequences for anybody who does this, what they are exposed to and with the indictment, it is ten years in prison. Members will know that the decision on whether it goes to the District or Circuit Court is one made by the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP. She will make an assessment based on the Garda investigation file and where it lies. However, in circumstances where we are dealing with the kind of things we are talking about here, I suggest these matters be tried on indictment if it goes that far or if the result of the spiking is the serious criminality I have described. In those circumstances, the person guilty of the offence would be exposed to ten years in prison. That is not in any way unreasonable or over-egged. This is serious stuff, and that is the point we are trying to make here. That is also why putting it on its own statutory footing clarifies any doubt there might be around where this lies in the canon of criminality. It is up there with the most serious offences. There will be no doubt now, when this Bill becomes law, that the people who engage in this kind of behaviour are engaged in serious criminal activity, up there with the worst of it and deserving of serious treatment by the courts.

There is one issue I want to deal with, which is a possible criticism of the Bill that has to be addressed. It is something Mary Crilly spoke to me about in the past week. That is whether there needs to be a statement in section 2(1)(c)(ii), which states that basically the offence is committed when the person intentionally administers a substance by whatever means and does so knowing the other person does not consent or it is reckless, but with the intention of overpowering or sedating the person for the purpose of the offence we are talking about.

The question then is: in a prosecution for spiking under this amendment to the Non-Fatal Offences against the Person Act, is it the case then that the court has to prove that there was intention? There is a concern among many quarters that proving that intention may be difficult and I acknowledge that as a legitimate criticism of the Bill. I have no difficulty, by the way, with amending that and I hope that when we get to the next Stage and deal with amendments from anywhere in this House that we would be able to address that concern, and maybe remove the reference to express intention. We could, maybe, talk about circumstances where it is reasonable to infer that this happened. There are lots of ways we can address that but if there is a flaw in this, in terms of creating an obligation on the prosecution to prove intention on the part of the spiking party, if I can say it that way, then let us address that.

What I want to acknowledge, because he is here, is that Deputy Mark Ward also brought forward a Bill on this subject in the past month, I think, or certainly in the past few weeks. We have had a conversation about this. Sinn Féin clearly acknowledges - as do Labour, the Social Democrats and other parties and Members with whom I have had discussions - that this is an issue that needs to be addressed, so I welcome what I hope will be cross-party support for this.

In regard to making this Bill better, we are open to whatever it is that is required to improve it. If it is the case that the issue of intention needs to be addressed, then I am open to amending the Bill accordingly to ensure it reflects the best possible iteration of a criminal offence that can be successfully prosecuted in our courts, that does not lead to ambiguity, or that does not lead to a situation where a person who has been involved in very serious criminal activity can find a way to escape the provisions of the legislation that we have, in good faith, set out with a view to dealing with exactly this problem.

I do not come here with this Bill suggesting that it is perfect. It is, of course, a matter for this House as to how the final iteration of the Bill comes about. I know the Minister for justice is here and that the matter was considered by Cabinet this week, and I look forward to hearing what he has to say. I welcome the serious and considered approach that Cabinet has taken to this Bill, and I would welcome hearing what the Minister has to say in that regard.

What we have here is an opportunity as a Legislature, with a Bill that has already gone through one of the Houses, to make a very clear statement of our intention - if I could put it that way - to mark this kind of behaviour as absolutely unacceptable and deeply damaging to the victims of that behaviour, and as something we as a State take incredibly seriously, that we will not tolerate and that we are willing to put on a statutory footing to say, "No further with this. No doubt about this". If you are spiking, you will be punished, prosecuted and you will go to jail. There are serious consequences to this. It is a serious legislative statement that anybody involved in this kind of appalling behaviour will suffer the full rigours of the law and the full criticism and penalties available to the court, and they will be held responsible.

Comment on this
Jim O'Callaghan Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Fianna Fáil

I will start by thanking Deputy Ward for bringing forward this very important piece of legislation. Without identifying them individually, I also commend the Fine Gael Senators, colleagues from the previous term, who played such an important role in getting it through the Seanad. It is a significant achievement to get a Private Members' Bill through either House.

As the Deputy indicated, the objective of the Bill is to amend Non-Fatal Offences against the Person Act 1997 by introducing a specific stand-alone offence of spiking. Importantly, it should be noted that the Bill aligns with a programme for Government commitment to strengthen the legislative response to drink spiking. At the outset, I am pleased to say I have secured the Government’s support not to oppose this Bill on Second Stage and I look forward to it passing the House and working with Deputy Ward to ensure we progress it further through the Houses of the Oireachtas.

Deputy Ward indicated that this is not simply a Dublin problem. I agree with him entirely. I know from speaking to my colleagues, Deputies Michael Cahill and Séamus McGrath, who have raised this matter with me on a number of occasions and on the floor of the House, that they have a concern in respect of the incidence of this heinous behaviour, not just in Dublin but in their own constituencies.

As I have said before, spiking is a serious and abhorrent crime that preys on vulnerability. It undermines consent and it can have a devastating impact on victims. This applies even if the spiking is not used to facilitate a further offence. Spiking victims may suffer severe effects on their physical and mental health as well as their emotional well-being. They describe feelings of fear, loss of control, loss of confidence, and anxiety, which can have lasting impacts on their lives. It can be very difficult or even impossible for spiking victims to ever again feel comfortable in social settings after being subjected to such a traumatic experience. Incidents of spiking also have a significant effect on the wider public. Spiking undermines people’s confidence in being able to enjoy a safe night out. It creates fear, distrust in public spaces and uncertainty around personal safety when engaging in night-time entertainment or other social activities.

The programme for Government commitment in respect of spiking appears in the context of measures relating to domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. We are aware that many reported incidents of spiking involve concerns that a substance may have been administered for the purpose of facilitating sexual offences. Data obtained from sexual assault treatment units indicate that approximately 19% to 20% of service users in recent years have reported concerns that they may have been subjected to drug-facilitated sexual assault. As Minister, I am committed to fostering a zero-tolerance approach to all forms of domestic, sexual and gender-based violence and I would like to briefly highlight the work being done in my Department and across the Government to tackle it.

This work is being co-ordinated by Cuan, which is overseeing implementation of the Government's zero-tolerance strategy. We secured increased funding of €5.3 million in last month’s budget to support Cuan and services working to combat such violence, and we now have a total budget of €84 million to deal with the scourge of domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. Among other very good work, Cuan continues to lead the Consent Ed project, a sexual violence prevention resource for young people that complements the social, personal and health education, SPHE, curriculum.

In July, Jennie’s Law was enacted to increase transparency in relation to domestic violence convictions. New offences targeting the exploitative practice of sex for rent were also introduced. These laws were part of a broader Government commitment to combatting domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. Work is also continuing on legislation that will strengthen the law on consent in sexual offences, including how belief in consent is assessed in rape and sexual assault cases.

It is important to point out that the conduct we are referring to when we discuss spiking is already recognised as a serious crime. There are several existing offences under which this conduct can be charged and prosecuted. This is not intended, by the way, to detract from the argument for strengthening the legislation and introducing a stand-alone offence. I very much agree with Deputy Ward in regard to the impact a stand-alone offence can have in seeking to target a certain type of unacceptable behaviour. It is rather to ensure that anyone following these discussions is aware that spiking does constitute criminal conduct. Whether it is drink spiking or spiking by way of injection, victims should report incidents to the Garda, which will be fully investigated and there are significant supports available for victims right now.

I will give an example of how spiking could be dealt with under current law. It is important to note that if somebody is subjected to spiking or believes they are subjected to spiking, there are laws that can be used at present. I do not want people who are out - and I am sure no one in the House wants this for people who are out at present - to think, if they are subjected to spiking, that they do not have a legal basis on which to make a criminal complaint. Spiking may be charged as poisoning under section 12 of the Non-Fatal Offences against the Person Act. It criminalises anyone who intentionally or recklessly administers a substance capable of interfering substantially with another person's bodily functions, which explicitly includes unconsciousness or sleep and would certainly encompass an intent to stupefy or overpower. The offence of poisoning carries a maximum penalty of three years' imprisonment.

Depending on the nature of the substance that is administered, it may also be possible to charge a perpetrator with endangerment under section 13 of the same Act. This provides that it is an offence to intentionally or recklessly engage in conduct that creates a substantial risk of death or serious harm to another. The offence of endangerment carries a maximum penalty of seven years' imprisonment. In addition, it may also be possible to charge a perpetrator with assault causing harm in spiking cases where the substance is administered via injection. This offence now carries a maximum sentence of up to ten years' imprisonment.

I wish to emphasise that where spiking is perpetrated in order to facilitate the commission of a further substantive offence - for example, rape, sexual assault or theft - the perpetrator may also be charged with that offence or, where that offence was not completed, an attempt to commit that offence.

The principal question is not whether our criminal laws currently apply to spiking – they do - but, rather, whether a specific stand-alone offence will materially improve the effectiveness of the criminal justice response.

Since this Bill was first introduced in the Seanad, my Department has engaged heavily with An Garda Síochána and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions on the issue of spiking. We have also engaged with Forensic Science Ireland to gain further insight into practical issues around evidence-gathering and testing. Data provided by An Garda Síochána indicates that there were 107 reported cases of suspected spiking in 2022, 52 reports in 2023, 61 reports in 2024 and 58 reports in 2025. However, robust data on spiking remains limited due to under-reporting, evidential challenges and delays in toxicological testing. Clearly, a difficulty in these cases is that any testing to confirm spiking must be done quickly. Most drugs leave the body within 12 to 72 hours, so testing needs to be carried out as soon as possible. Unfortunately, the effects of spiking - be it from drugs, alcohol or otherwise - may leave the victim in a state of confusion. Blackouts and memory loss are common symptoms. By the time the victim has recovered, it may be too late to successfully perform a forensic toxicology test. As highlighted during my Department’s engagement with An Garda Síochána, evidence-gathering is a significant challenge in these types of cases. Notwithstanding that, it should not be a barrier to our proceeding with this legislation but it is something we need to recognise. If people believe they have been spiked, it is important they try to get a toxicology test carried out as quickly as possible to ensure that evidence is available for any subsequent prosecution.

I would say, in passing, that even where there is a delay in reporting an incident, victims should know there are other ways and means of gathering evidence. They should still contact An Garda Síochána as soon they can. The perpetrators may have been caught on CCTV or there may have been witnesses to the crime. Most night-time places or bars will have extensive CCTV footage. It may be possible to identify a perpetrator inserting a substance into a victim’s drink.

The question of whether current criminal legislation adequately addresses spiking has been the subject of a detailed policy review by my Department. It examined the prevalence of spiking, the adequacy of existing criminal offences and the potential options for reform, both legislative and non-legislative. A number of legislative options have been examined, including the creation of a stand-alone spiking offence, as advocated for in this legislation. This Bill gives us a welcome opportunity to further consider this approach. The creation of a stand-alone spiking offence would provide a clear legislative condemnation of the conduct. Legislation is important, not solely for the wording of the legislation but also the message it sends out to the public at large. It would recognise the serious nature of spiking and the significant public concern associated with such behaviour.

Against this, however, some concerns may arise around duplication and interaction with existing offences, increased complexity for prosecutors and uncertainty regarding the practical operational benefits that would arise from the introduction of a new offence. There may also be a question around the intent element of a stand-alone offence and how the intent to commit a further offence might be established. However, I hear what Deputy Ward has said in this regard. I am happy to work with him on this legislation. If amendments need to be made, they can be made on a subsequent Stage.

However, the fact our criminal law does not currently contain a specifically labelled spiking offence may give rise to public concern regarding the visibility and deterrent effect of the existing legislation. We have done it before in respect of stalking and other certain types of behaviour, which could have been covered by existing criminal law at the time. Therefore, I do not think it is a barrier to introduce legislation simply because there is an existing law that covers the offence.

Also, based on my Department’s engagement with the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, it appears that a low number of prosecutions are occurring under the existing poisoning offence for spiking incidents. When we think of poisoning, we are thinking of something else as opposed to the type of offence that is the subject matter of this specific stand-alone legislation. Additionally, as the poisoning offence carries a maximum sentence of three years, it is not an arrestable offence. Therefore, the detention of a suspect for further investigation of such an offence is not permitted. This represents a significant practical challenge. For these reasons, it is important to give full and proper consideration to any potential options to strengthen our legislation in this area.

In any case, it is clear from the work and engagement carried out by my Department that the challenges in tackling this crime are not solely legislative in nature. Nonetheless, I am supportive of it and I will seek to work with Deputies in respect of this legislation. There is a benefit in having a stand-alone piece of legislation.

With regard to other measures not solely legislative in nature, barriers to prosecution can arise due to under-reporting, evidential challenges, delays in toxicological testing and uncertainty regarding the causes of reported symptoms.

When it comes to non-legislative initiatives to combat the spiking of drinks, last year, the Department of culture launched a new safety training initiative, Safe and Sound, aimed at a wide range of businesses in the night-time economy, such as pubs, restaurants and nightclubs. The free online training is specifically tailored to provide night-time workers with an increased awareness of their responsibilities and duty of care, as well as training to identify and reduce risks. It offers modules, including drink spiking prevention and response strategies.

More broadly, the implementation group for the report of the night-time economy has been in place since 2022. It was established to oversee the implementation of the recommendations of the night-time economy task force. These include a range of actions aimed at tackling the challenges to a safe night-time economy. This year, a dedicated night-time economy subgroup was formed to develop strategies to support a safe, welcoming and inclusive night-time environment for those enjoying a night out or working in the night-time economy. Other initiatives to tackle spiking include awareness campaigns undertaken by the Government in conjunction with Aontas na Mac Léinn in Éirinn as well as educational initiatives delivered through the sexual assault treatment units. The Health Service Executive has also released public health guidance around spiking risks and prevention, along with a number of harm-reduction initiatives that can be found on the HSE's main website and on the HSE’s drugs.ie website.

It is important to ensure supports are available and accessible to anyone who may be a victim of spiking and, crucially, that victims are fully aware of these supports. Aside from the medical services and An Garda Síochána, victims will find support from the Crime Victims Helpline and the sexual assault treatment units, among others. While the majority of spiking incidents involve young females, these supports are available to victims of all ages and genders.

Having said all of this, there is a significant benefit to further considering a stand-alone spiking offence, including increased visibility of the conduct and enhanced public awareness. For these reasons, I am not opposing this Bill. I look forward to seeing this Bill proceed to Committee Stage for detailed legal scrutiny and further consideration and engagement on its provisions, as well as any amendments that may be required. I am happy to work with Deputy Ward and others in respect of this piece of legislation.

Comment on this
Mark Wall An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

We have nine other Members who have indicated that they wish to speak on this important Bill. The first speaker is Deputy Mark Ward.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Bill. I commend Deputy Ward on getting it to this Stage. As he said, there is not one person in this Chamber today who does not know someone impacted by spiking. Sinn Féin will not be opposing this legislation at this Stage. I welcome Deputy Ward’s openness to work with Members on amendments because there are ways to strengthen this Bill. I will touch on them as I speak. They will make the Bill stronger as well as easier to enforce.

When Deputy Ward was speaking, I was thinking that usually it is a row between one side and the other in this House. This might be an opportunity to have cross-party collaboration on something that will benefit the people we represent. I would like to see this Bill go through the Houses of the Oireachtas with that cross-party collaboration and some amendments to make it stronger. It is not a case of my Bill being better than Deputy Ward’s or anything like that. It is just something we need to get across the line.

I took an interest in this Bill. I know three young women very well who have been victims of spiking in the past 12 months. Thank God, none of them were victims of secondary events but the lasting impact the spiking incidents had on them is still ongoing. We need to be cognisant of that. As I said, I tabled a Bill on spiking two weeks ago to make spiking a stand-alone offence. The Bill that we are discussing today aims to make spiking an offence when there is an intent to cause certain harm to the victim. That intent is outlined in the Bill as engaging in a sexual act involving the other person; causing harm to the other person; making a gain or causing a loss to the other person; or otherwise committing an offence with or against the person.

Like Deputy Barry Ward, I have engaged with stakeholders such as Spiking in Ireland and Mary Crilly. They tell me that the intent to commit an additional crime could be difficult to prove. I have to accept their bona fides on that. I have also engaged with victims and survivors of spiking. Aoife Rose O’Brien, one of our councillors in Wexford, has been an activist on this for a long time. She gave me permission to tell her story if I needed to do so, which I did when I introduced my Bill. She is of the same opinion as me.

We often speak about spiking in the context of what might happen next. In other words, whether someone intended to sexually assault, rob or otherwise harm the person that they spiked. We need to recognise that the act of spiking is already a violation. A person’s bodily autonomy has been taken from them. Their ability to make decisions about their safety has been interfered with. Their consent has been disregarded entirely. This is harm in its own right, regardless of what follows.

As the Minister said, there have been 278 spiking incidents reported to the Garda since 2022. Sexual violence centres estimate this is only the tip of the iceberg but none of the reported incidents since 2022 have resulted in a prosecution under the current legislation. This tells me that the current laws are clearly not working and people are being let down.

What is often lost in the conversation about spiking and crimes like this is the lasting impact on the person who experiences them. The impact does not necessarily end when the substance leaves the system. It can follow them into their next night out or social gathering. It is important that we do not wait for something worse to happen before we acknowledge that the person is harmed. Spiking should not have to lead to sexual assault or robbery to be a crime. The absence of a further offence does not mean the absence of a victim. That is why the Sinn Féin Bill would make spiking a stand-alone offence. This is the first area in which we will either make amendments to strengthen the Bill or support Government amendments to it, whichever comes first.

Another area which was not really touched on - the Minister touched on it slightly - and in the context of which we would like to see the Bill strengthened relates to the introduction of a statutory toxicology pathway for victims of spiking to assist them in both their care and their pursuit of justice. At the moment, this does not exist. From my engagement with the HSE, I am informed that there is currently no national reporting mechanism or specific data that captures presentations for suspected spiking. Therefore, it is not possible to provide a verified national figure for the number of individuals who have presented to hospital emergency departments with suspected spiking incidents. As the Minister said, robust data is not there. Such data would be invaluable to protect the victims and also give them the answers they are looking for because they do not know what substance has been in their system. It is very frightening when you do not know what has been injected or dropped into your drink. It would also inform us and other stakeholders about what substances are being used to spike people. That would help us to combat what is happening.

The HSE also informed me that it would be very supportive of the development of a clear national pathway for the management of suspected spiking presentations and would work in collaboration with other healthcare services, An Garda Síochána, forensic services, laboratories and other agencies to develop these pathways. That is an area in respect of which we will table amendments. Anyone who presents to the Garda or the health services and feels they have been spiked would be referred to this statutory toxicology pathway. The Minister did advise people to get toxicology reports as soon as possible if they feel they have been spiked. It does not always happen that way. I offer the example of Aoife Rose O’Brien's story, which she told me and which I spoke of when I introduced my Bill, in this regard. She was spiked. She woke up in a strange home having been sexually assaulted. When she got back to her own home, she called CareDoc to come out. She told the person from CareDoc that she felt she had been spiked but did not disclose the sexual assault. The person would not test her and sent her to Wexford emergency department. She went to the hospital and told the staff that she thought she had been spiked the previous night. She did not disclose the sexual assault. They would not do a toxicology report. She felt then that she had to disclose the sexual assault. Like a lot of the people who are victims and survivors of sexual assault, feelings of embarrassment, shame and so on came in, but she wanted to know what was in her system so she had to disclose the sexual assault at that stage. After that she was referred to Waterford Hospital, where she did get the toxicology report some 24 hours after she had been the victim of spiking. Luckily enough - or unluckily - the substance was still in her system so she was still able to find out what had been put into her. It is not easy to get a blood test or a toxicology report if you go to your doctor or the emergency department. A statutory toxicology pathway would help with this.

As I said, the impact of spiking does not end when the substance leaves a person’s system. It can follow them on their next night out or social gathering and the next time someone wants to buy them a drink. Spiking is an insidious and violating crime. It catches its victims off guard and often leaves them with little recall of what happened beyond the fact that they have been spiked.

While not part of the legislation, I would like to see an awareness campaign in the lead-up to Christmas, particularly as a couple of the people who contacted me were spiked around this time last year. We know that Christmas is a time of celebration, enjoyment, parties, work events and family nights out and gatherings, but, unfortunately, the risk of spiking can increase during the festive season. I ask people to be vigilant and to watch each other’s backs over the Christmas season.

Victims might wrongly blame themselves for being spiked. I want to be very clear: there is only one person to blame and that is the perpetrator of the crime. As Deputy Barry Ward said, and I think everyone else would agree, there have to be consequences for that.

Comment on this

I am pleased to speak in support of the Non-Fatal Offences against the Person (Amendment) (Spiking) Bill 2023. I want to thank Young Fine Gael for its sustained campaign to have spiking recognised as a stand-alone criminal offence. I also want to thank Deputy Barry Ward for the great work he has done and the Minister for justice for being here for the debate on this Private Member’s Bill and for showing his interest in it.

Let us be clear. Spiking is a sinister act. It involves deliberately giving a substance to another person without their consent, whether through drink, injection or by any other means. It is a serious violation that can leave victims vulnerable, traumatised and fearful. In some cases it is linked to other serious offences including sexual assault. This issue commands our attention. The Garda received 339 reports of spiking between 2020 and the end of 2025, with women accounting for 87% of reported victims. This is a problem that affects communities across the country, including rural Ireland.

The Bill addresses an important gap in the law by creating a stand-alone offence of spiking that will carry a maximum penalty of ten years in prison. That is a significant increase on the penalties available under broader poisoning legislation and reflects the seriousness of the behaviour involved. I particularly acknowledge the work of all the people who have brought the Bill to this point by means of the longer, safer nights campaign, which engaged with young people, victims’ groups and industry representatives, and who are helping to keep this issue firmly on the political agenda. As already stated, I commend Deputy Barry Ward, the Minister for justice, Young Fine Gael and everyone who played a part in bringing this Bill before the House today. I welcome the words from Sinn Féin and other Opposition parties that we are all rowing in the one direction in respect of it.

While legislation is essential, it must be accompanied by effective investigation and support for victims. People who have been subjected to spiking must be assured that they will be taken seriously when they report it. Nobody should have to fear being deliberately drugged and placed in danger while enjoying a night out or a social occasion. That is why this Bill is very important.

I was only elected to the Dáil at the most recent general election. I spoke at the session before this on drugs, and now here we are discussing spiking.

If, going home to Portlaoise this evening on public transport, some of the many people I will meet ask me what my day was like, which they do ask, I will say that this has been the worst day I have ever had. I never thought, when I was a young person socialising, just like every one of us here, that spiking would ever happen.

I remember when the drink-driving legislation came in. It was a huge change in that, from then on, you would have to have a designated driver. There were arguments about who drove the previous night and so on. The legislation worked and everybody co-operated, and everybody was able to enjoy themselves. Then drugs, which we spoke about here today, came on the scene. I said there was none of that when I was socialising, when I was going to school. You would hear an odd titter about drugs or whatever, but now they are all over the place in my town, Portlaoise, and in every other town and village in County Laois. Everybody will tell you this. In not that long a time, that has happened.

Now we are talking about spiking somebody's drink, by injecting or other means. It does not matter how it is done if it is done. It is awful for young people. It is frightening for their parents to think it can happen. They themselves and their parents before them could go out at the weekend, have a social night out with their friends, meet people, share stories and whatever the case may be, have a few drinks, go to a disco and be 99.99% sure they would come home safe. Now a fear is being instilled in young people and we are going to end up in a situation in which young people will be fearful of going out. That is going to destroy the whole social fabric for young people. We can see what happened during the Covid epidemic, when young people could not go out, and all the consequences of that. There is going to be a fear instilled even in parents that this can happen. Vulnerable people can be preyed upon. All I can do is ask all young people, when they are socialising with their friends, to keep an eye out. It nearly reminds me of the day when the drink-driving legislation came in. Somebody among a group of friends is going to have to stay completely alert now so that if something happens, they will be lucky enough to see it.

That is why I am saying I want to support this Bill. What I do not know, and I was asking my colleagues here, is how long a Bill takes to go through the Dáil. I am told it can take a couple of years. We are all public representatives. Every one of us here is in agreement on this Bill. In my opinion, this is a test of democracy at its best, to see what we can do to put this Bill through as fast as possible, because we owe this to the young people of Ireland. It is not only young people who will be affected. Look at what we are after speaking about today. Look at the statistics on drugs. Look at what is happening. This is the start of a trend. Another drug is involved. It is the start. We could stand up here and ask what the people who came before us were doing that they did not bring in tougher legislation for drugs. It is with us now. It is my responsibility; it is my colleagues' responsibility; it is all our responsibility. All I can ask is that this Dáil, the seat of democracy, pass this Bill as quickly as possible. All hoops have to be jumped through to do that. That is how we can turn around and say to our young people that we are representing them to the best of our ability to ensure they can go out and socialise in a safe manner.

Comment on this

I completely agree with the sentiments of Deputy Aird in that we all want to work on a cross-party basis to see a good, new revised law passed quickly in the Houses. I commend Deputy Ward for bringing the Bill here from the Seanad. It will have the support of the Labour Party. I am pleased to hear that the Minister is not going to oppose it, which means it will, hopefully, proceed to Committee Stage. We will put a bit of pressure on the Minister or the Chair of the relevant committee to arrange for that as soon as possible.

Spiking is an incredibly serious crime that unfortunately seems to be increasingly prevalent. It is a horrific, predatory thing to do to someone. It is so frightening for a victim and so undermining of their personal sense of human dignity. Of course, it will affect how you go about your life, including your social life. I cannot imagine the effect after an event like that. It is something that all of us across the House want to see a crackdown on.

The Labour Party's previous justice spokesperson, Aodhán Ó Ríordáin, had proposed an amendment on this a number of years ago. We have councillors in Cork, including Ciara O'Connor, and in Galway, including Mayor Helen Ogbu, who have been calling for change in this regard. My colleague Deputy Eoghan Kenny is going to go into that a little later.

I have read the Bill, sponsored by Deputy Mark Ward. It is interesting in that it requires no intent, which presumably is because of the difficulties in proving intent, which was spoken about. It is definitely worth thinking about. There is a new UK law or an updated UK law going through at the moment that does include a requirement for intent in a spiking offence. It is an intent to injure, aggrieve or annoy, which is an interesting definition in itself, but it is pretty broad for these purposes. I definitely support the toxicology testing pathways that Deputy Ward has put into his Bill. That is food for thought for the next Stage. We certainly agree that there is a need for a standalone offence of spiking. We will have a few constructive suggestions on the drafting and how it might be amended on Committee Stage. I trust that they will be taken in the spirit in which they are intended, to make this the best law that it can be.

In the context of the increasing influence of toxic masculinity in our society, it is important for us to talk about how misogynistic and chauvinistic views and talking points, often propagated online, can very quickly translate into the real world and result in physical acts of violence, often sexual violence, against women. Spiking is another example of this.

We know that an alleged spiking incident is being reported to the Garda on average once every six days. A total of 339 cases of a person's drink being spiked or an individual being unknowingly injected with a drug were reported between January 2021 and December 2025. This may only be the tip of the iceberg, given the stigma that persists in relation to reporting. We as an Oireachtas need to eliminate that stigma and make it clear to victims that they are not at fault in any respect and that reporting is absolutely vital to the prosecution of these crimes. We do not, unfortunately, know how many prosecutions have taken place because there does not seem to be any court data available. This is because spiking is not a standalone offence. That is another reason to make this change.

The existing offence on our books is punishable by a maximum sentence of three years, but I think it is clear that the existing provision does not capture the essence of spiking as opposed to poisoning, the difference being the motive, which in the case of spiking is generally to enable the commission of a sexual offence. There can, of course, be other motivations, but the commission of a sexual offence is clearly the most egregious and common motivation and, in my view, should be the primary focus of this law. For us in the Labour Party, this makes spiking a more serious standalone offence that deserves a lengthier maximum sentence.

Aodhán Ó Ríordáin tabled an amendment to the 1997 Act a number of years ago that would have created a new offence, based on the then UK law, which we called administering a substance with intent. The definition, just for the record, was that a person who administers to or causes to be taken by another person, C, a drug or other substance, knowing that C does not consent to what is being done and with intent thereby to stupefy or overpower C so as to enable himself or herself or any other person to engage in sexual activity with or involving C is guilty of an offence. That was the definition we had put forward. The intent to engage in non-consensual sexual activity was central to our previous definition of spiking. The then Minister, Deputy McEntee, pointed at the time to the existing offence of poisoning as already covering this offence but, in fairness, things have moved on since then.

There seem to me to be two important differences between spiking and poisoning offences that are justified as stand-alone offences. The spiking offence should be more serious, given the underlying intention, and it should entail a longer maximum sentence than three years. Ten years would seem appropriate here. The maximum sentence of three years for poisoning means that it is not an arrestable offence and the Garda instead have to proceed by way of summons. My understanding is that an offence has to be punishable by five years or more before gardaí automatically have powers of arrest.

Second, the current poisoning offence states that inducing sleep or unconsciousness is covered, which suggests that anything less than that, such as stupefying people or overpowering their faculties while they remain conscious, may not be covered by the existing law. This is relatively speculative because I do not believe there are any decided court cases on this precise point, but in general a criminal statute has to be given the interpretation most favourable to an accused. Some of the most common drugs suspected of use for sexual assault or that can be used to commit physical and sexual harm can sedate or incapacitate victims without necessarily making them unconscious, but making them more vulnerable to attack. The definition in Deputy Ward's Bill refers to the intention of overpowering or sedating someone, and it is arguable that that covers a case of someone who has been incapacitated without being made unconscious, but perhaps that definition could be looked at again in that light, just to be certain about that.

Another point I would like to raise is the reports we have heard of the takedown game, where lads essentially go around spiking people's drinks in nightclubs as a dare or for the craic. That is obviously unacceptable in its own right, but I think it would not technically be covered by the current definition in Deputy Ward's Bill, which currently would criminalise spiking for the purpose of engaging in a sexual act, causing harm to the body or mind, including pain or unconsciousness, making a financial gain or causing a financial loss, or otherwise committing an offence with or against another person. It is likely that spiking just for a laugh, so to speak, will continue to be unlawful under the existing lesser offence of poisoning. Arguably, because of the absence of the most serious sexual assault intent, it is a less serious offence and therefore should attract a lesser penalty, but overall it might be more coherent to combine the old and new offences into one two-tier offence. That would mean a basic offence of spiking with no further purpose which would be arrestable with a sentence of five years and an aggravated form of spiking with the purpose of committing a sexual offence attracting a sentence of ten years. They could both be inserted into the 1997 Act. That is something we might propose if Deputy Ward's Bill reaches Committee Stage, as we hope it does.

All of this is to underline the need for a separate offence. It is to support Deputy Ward in his endeavours in pursuing this legislation and it is to support the victims of spiking who are at the heart of everything we are talking about today. Like the Minister said, whatever we do and however we go about this legislatively, we want to improve the effectiveness of the existing law.

Comment on this
Mark Wall An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Labour Party

Before I call Deputy Kenny, I let Members know that they are entitled to ten minutes, but we want to try and get everybody in, so if anyone can finish up that minute earlier to allow everyone to get in, it would be very much appreciated.

Comment on this

I will do my best. I reiterate our support in the Labour Party for this Bill and genuinely thank Deputy Barry Ward for bringing this Bill before the Dáil. I acknowledge his colleagues and those who worked on it in the Seanad. It passed the Seanad in October 2023 and, three years on, we have an opportunity to move it forward. I support it going to Committee Stage.

I am the youngest TD in this house. I might not look at it anymore but I absolutely am. It is interesting to listen to Deputy Aird reference the fact that maybe, when he was going to school, it was not an issue or it might not have been spoken about, particularly with regard to drugs. I have grown up with it. I have never been in an environment where the presence of drugs and spiking is not ultimately an issue. It is a reality that, unfortunately, we live with across the State. I often think of the words, which, thankfully, none of my own friends have said to me, "I think I have been spiked." Do people believe the person immediately, do they take it as a joke or do they take it seriously? If they do, where do they go for help? If they get to an emergency department, can a sample be taken in time? The Minister referred to that issue. If people are unsure about making a report to the Garda, who explains those options to that group of young people?

We are asking those questions of people who may be frightened, disorientated, and unable to remember several hours of their lives. They may be trying to piece together what happened from messages on their phone or from what friends can tell them. The State should have worked out where they can go and what happens when they get there. I acknowledge my Labour Party councillor colleague, Ciara O'Connor, who is vice-chair of the Cork city local community safety partnership, who brought this issue before Cork City Council. Her motion was passed unanimously, supported by Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, and every party and Independent. It is the same with Labour Party councillor Helen Ogbu in Galway City Council. I note Labour Party councillor Cathal Rasmussen, who chairs the Cork county local community safety partnership. Those newly established local community safety partnerships are working. Across our cities and counties, these partnerships can bring gardaí, health services and community organisations together to improve how we respond to issues like this when someone reports suspected spiking.

A national strategy would give them a clear plan to work from. I recognise Dola Twomey and Mary Crilly of the Sexual Violence Centre in Cork. Through Spiking in Ireland and Safe Gigs Ireland, they have taken this issue to festivals and to music events. When I have been, they have listened to people who have experienced spiking and made sure that those experiences are heard nationally. I am proud that Cork has helped to lead that work. The people who have come forward also deserve to see and to lead the change. As Deputy Ward said, spiking can happen literally anywhere. It is not just, as we sometimes think about it, in a nightclub, in a pub or at a festival. It can happen anywhere. It can happen in a room full of people that a person knows. That is, unfortunately, the reality. Consent is ultimately at the centre of it. If somebody deliberately gives you a substance without your consent, they have taken a decision about your body that only you have the right to make. That violation matters in its own right. It matters whether or not a sexual assault, a theft or another offence follows.

Deputy Ahern referred to section 2 of Deputy Ward's Bill, which would create a specific offence of spiking. It covers deliberately giving someone a substance, including through a drink or by injection, where the person doing it knows there is no consent or is reckless about consent. As drafted, it also requires an intention to overpower or sedate the person for one of the purposes set out in the Bill, such as causing harm, making a gain or committing another offence. It provides for up to ten years' imprisonment on conviction on indictment. On Committee Stage, I would appreciate it if we could examine how that requirement to prove a particular purpose could work in practice. I was thinking earlier of the case of somebody who deliberately puts a substance into another person's drink and then later claims that was actually only a prank. How would the proposed offence apply and what would the prosecution have to establish about that person's purpose? We should test that wording against cases like this before we settle the law. As Deputy Ahern said, the Labour Party has raised this before. In March 2023, former Deputy Aodhán Ó Ríordáin moved an amendment in the House to create a specific offence for spiking intended to facilitate sexual activity. This June, Senator Laura Harmon called for a public information campaign on spiking and for clear national reporting and support procedures for sexual violence and harassment across further and higher education.

Students should know who to contact, what help is available and what happens after they come forward. I would appreciate it if the Department of justice would commit to a dedicated way of recording suspected spiking and to regular publication of national figures. We should be able to see how many incidents are reported, how many lead to charges and what happens to those cases. That would help us see where people are encountering difficulties and whether changes to the law and to services are actually making a difference.

I support there being a prevention campaign and practical training.

I am a former part-time barman. If the State could provide practical training to bar staff, security staff and event organisers, that would be roundly supported, not just by people in this House but people working in the industry as well. Ultimately, if a person who believes they have been spiked, or a friend, comes up to a member of staff and says they suddenly feel unwell and they believe the drink has been spiked, the member of staff should know how to help and how to preserve anything that might be of evidence as well. What we should look to achieve here is ensure that the next time someone is able to say to a friend or staff member in a nightclub or bar that they think their drink has been spiked, we can stand over the answer they receive as to where to go, who will help them and what will happen next.

I fully support the Bill. It is essential from the perspective of a young person. We have referenced the fact that it is not just young people who are affected. From the perspective of a young person who has grown up in a society where there has never not been an issue of spiking or drug-taking, legislation like this is essential to provide younger women predominantly, but also younger men, with some advice and guidance and to show that the State supports them. I appreciate the Bill.

Comment on this

I will be brief to facilitate my other colleagues to speak. I commend Deputy Barry Ward for bringing the Bill to the House. I also thank members of Young Fine Gael who, for some years, have worked solidly on this legislation. They brought it in because of their personal experience. Having spoken to numerous members of Young Fine Gael, it dawned on me that back in the day, when I used to bop my heart out at Thee Place in the Rossnaree and no doubt the Minister of State, Deputy Ardagh, bopped her heart out in Copper Face Jacks, we had many things on our minds, but spiking was not one of them. What struck me most when I heard Deputy Aird speak was how times have changed. As a result, the changing times must be reflected in the law we make. Nothing is as important as the spiking law at the present time. As the Deputy said, we were talking about drug intimidation but spiking itself is an offence that is horrific and affects families. The valuable contributions we have heard in the Chamber in regard to consent are equally important because of the very idea that somebody is going to put something into your drink that takes away your bodily control, does not give you the possibility of consenting and takes away your consent. I again point to the statistic that this affects 87% of women, which is absolutely horrifying.

As I said, when I used to go out and about, I had many things on my mind, but I was always confident that I would get home safely. That is not the case now for young people. Are we putting young people in a position where they are even going to fear going out in the first place? Some have spoken about the Covid effect, how Covid affected young people and their attitudes towards socialising. Surely this is not going to be another roadblock. Surely we can do something that does not put the fear of God into them about simply enjoying a night out with friends. This legislation is very important.

I have listened to all the contributions. There are amendments to be made and considerations to be had. I welcome both Deputy Ward's willingness to have this treated as a cross-party issue and as cross-party legislation because it affects us all. When the legislation goes through, we will have to look at educating young people and staff members in bars, restaurants and discos. As the Deputy pointed out, it does not only happen in those settings, so we have to educate people to know that this is not a prank or a bit of craic; this is very serious. It can affect another person's physical health but also their mental health and, therefore, it has to be treated as a stand-alone offence.

The Minister was right when he spoke about poisoning. When we talk about poisoning, we do not see poisoning and spiking as the same sort of thing. Until we have spiking as a stand-alone offence, and until we start talking about spiking and educating people, not just young people, about what it actually means and does to somebody, we will not have the achieve the desired effect with this legislation. I commend the Bill. I also commend Deputy Ward and Young Fine Gael.

Comment on this

I very much welcome the Minister's support for this Bill and the cross-party support we have seen today, with very constructive amendments suggested for Deputy Ward to consider. Let me be clear: spiking is not a prank, it is not harmless and it is not a joke gone wrong. It is an abhorrent, deliberate act, one that affects women and men in society and takes away a person's control. It creates fear and leaves victims dealing with consequences long after the incident itself. That is why I welcome this legislation to create a specific offence of spiking. It sends a clear message that this behaviour will be treated with the seriousness it deserves.

I acknowledge those who have worked for years to bring this issue to the point where we are debating it on the floor of this House today. In particular, I congratulate successive executive teams of Young Fine Gael, who, in 2023, identified this issue, long before it received the level of public and political attention it deserved. Well done to Jamie Malone and all his colleagues in Young Fine Gael. In their campaign, they engaged with young people across the country, through surveys, petitions, policy development and legislative proposals. They ensured that this issue remained firmly on the political agenda.

What is particularly encouraging about this Bill is what it says about the role young people can play in shaping our country. The Bill shows that when young people get involved, use their voice and bring their experience to the table, they can influence public policy and help change law. That is democracy at its best. It is a powerful reminder that politics is not something that happens to people, but something people can help shape. The Bill also sends an important message to young people across Ireland that their voice matters, their ideas matter and they can make a real difference in Irish society when they choose to get involved.

I also recognise the work of my colleague, Regina Doherty, and others in the Seanad who championed this issue and helped bring it into the political spotlight. Equally, I acknowledge Deputy Barry Ward, who has continued that work and helped progress this legislation to the floor of the Dáil. I agree with the Deputy's comments on strengthening the Bill. I have no doubt he will work on a cross-party basis to do just that. I congratulate Young Fine Gael's campaign, Prickless Nights. If I may be so bold, would the world not be a better place if we all had a prickless night? Ultimately, this Bill is about protecting bodily integrity and personal autonomy and ensuring that those who seek to exploit or harm others face appropriate consequences for their actions. It is a sensible Bill that addresses a genuine concern, and I am very pleased to support it.

Comment on this

This is vitally important legislation and I thank Deputy Ward for bringing it to the House. The Social Democrats support the Bill and all of the objectives behind it.

When we first look at this legislation, the immediate reaction is to ask why we have not done this already. Spiking is a disgusting, predatory crime. Spiking is already criminal under existing law but the fact that we are still debating whether it should be explicitly recognised as a stand-alone offence is frankly disgraceful.

This is a very basic question of safety, of consent and of somebody's right to have control over his or her own body. A woman should be able to go out with her friends, have a drink and enjoy her night without somebody deciding they have the right to take that control away from her. For far too long the conversation around this has placed the responsibility on women - watch your drink; keep your hand on your glass; do not accept a drink from somebody; and do not go anywhere on your own. Let us think about what we are asking women to do: to spend their night anticipating somebody else's decision to harm them and then risk being asked afterwards whether they took enough precautions. Where is that same insistence when it comes to the behaviour of men? Where is the expectation that men challenge their friends, take women's concerns seriously and intervene when they see somebody behave in a predatory way?

The responsibility for spiking lies entirely with the person who does it. No woman should ever be made to feel she has failed to keep herself safe. This Bill is a step towards putting that responsibility where it belongs but it must be followed by proper enforcement, support for victims and a response that takes people seriously when they come forward.

We will support the Bill and we should all get on with progressing it. Most Members who have spoken have talked about how we need to bring some rapidity to bringing this Bill before a committee and advancing it. I again thank Deputy Barry Ward and will fully support the Bill on every Stage through its progression.

Comment on this

I commend Deputy Barry Ward on the work he has done on this Bill and, in particular, as all the speakers have mentioned, the members of Young Fine Gael. I spotted a few of them in the Gallery and they are very welcome. Their contributions are also very welcome. The Young Fine Gael president, Jamie Malone, and former Young Fine Gael president, Eoghan Gallagher, have put a lot of time and effort into highlighting the need for stronger protections in this area. I fully support the Bill. It is shocking that my daughters on a night out must consider the possibility they could be unknowingly administered drugs or alcohol or even subjected to needle spiking. No one should have to live with that fear. The consequences of spiking can be devastating. Victims can suffer serious physical and emotional distress and lasting anxiety long after the incident itself.

The Bill addresses an important gap in our criminal law by creating a specific offence of spiking and, as Deputy Gannon said, this should have happened before now and it should be a specific stand-alone, seriously punishable offence. While perpetrators may in some cases have been prosecuted for related offences, the absence of a distinct offence has made it more difficult to ensure accountability. This legislation represents an important step forward.

I have one suggestion I would like to see considered at a later stage. My understanding is that as currently drafted, the Bill requires the act of spiking to be linked to a further offence such as overpowering or sedating a person, engaging in a sexual act, causing harm, making a gain, causing a loss or other offences. I question whether that additional requirement is necessary. The act of secretly administering drugs or alcohol to another person is in and of itself a serious crime and a serious violation. The act itself is wrong. A victim should not have to prove that some further offence was intended or carried out before the law fully recognises the harm that has been done by that specific administration of drugs, alcohol or other substance. Where a person deliberately spikes another individual's drink or otherwise administers a substance without his or her knowledge or consent, that alone should constitute an offence regardless of what happens afterwards.

I hope the Aire Stáit will consider progressing this Bill in the coming months during Government time. I thank everybody for their work so far.

Comment on this
Catherine Ardagh Minister of State at the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Fianna Fáil

I thank the Deputy Barry Ward for championing this Bill through the Seanad and Dáil. I thank all the Deputies for their contributions in respect of this Bill. I reiterate the Government as a whole, including me, are committed to combating spiking. It is clear that efforts to stamp out this deplorable crime require a wide Government response that must involve non-legislative measures, including training for barmen and so on. As Deputy Kenny outlined, evidential and forensic challenges will remain relevant regardless of whether additional offences are introduced. However, it is important to fully assess any potential legislative reform options as part of this Government's examination of effective responses to spiking. As such, this is an important Bill, which I will be pleased to see progress. Due consideration must be given to potential benefits of creating a stand-alone offence, including increased visibility of the conduct and enhanced public awareness.

I come from a generation where we went out as a group of girls and we always minded the drinks. We never left the drinks unattended. Now, the phenomenon of needle spiking is absolutely abhorrent and something that is very new to me. It makes this type of crime even more egregious. That is why this Bill has moved on and there is an urgency as well in making this a stand-alone offence. This is not just an increase visibility but so that victims know it is an egregious offence and that perpetrators know it will not be tolerated and the rigour of the law will be brought to bear on them for committing this type of crime.

A lot of the time when people are spiked they are second-guessing themselves. As others pointed out, sometimes people might be spiked in a familiar surrounding like a house party. They might be among friends or acquaintances and it might be weeks or months later that they realise they were spoked that night and it might come back to them. A lot of the time, women who are affected by this. Let it be known that it is a very devious crime and there is no questioning the serious nature of spiking. It is evident there are significant public concerns associated with such behaviour and whether more can be done to address it. We need to address it.

Once again, I acknowledge the work that has been done in the development and congratulate the members of Young Fine Gael, who are in Gallery. I fully acknowledge and support the intentions behind the Bill and I look forward to engaging further on how we can adopt spiking as an offence following the passing of the Bill in the House.

Comment on this

I thank all those who took the time to contribute to this debate and to add substance to what we have been discussing. I acknowledged the other Bill brought forward by Deputy Mark Ward earlier. I was particularly struck by the speech given by Deputy Aird and the context of young people being in fear when they go out, which is at the heart of this. I said at the very beginning of this debate that the Bill is not about young or old; it is about anybody who might be the victim of spiking. I thought Deputy Aird's description was quite striking of how things have changed over time - and many other contributors said this as well - and the fact that we have moved from the simple situation of going out and having a good time with friends wherever that might be. There is the fact that has now changed to put a fear in everyone is deeply regrettable. I also welcome his sincere comment, since we are apparently all agreed on this, about accelerating the passage of the Bill. There is the capacity to get the Bill through, and quickly. We do not have to wait for years for this to become law. I acknowledge this is something that affects everyone but I also acknowledge that 87% of people who are affected by spiking are women. By the same token, 59% are aged between 18 and 25, so although it can happen to anyone, there are certainly people who are more vulnerable. Some 47% of cases are likely to happen in Dublin, for example, and 55% in licensed premises. Even with those statistics, there are quite a lot of scenarios that are not covered by them involving men, for example, older people, people outside Dublin or people in domestic homes.

I acknowledged my colleagues in the Seanad in my opening contribution. I also acknowledge the work Ms Regina Doherty, MEP, has done this week promoting this issue and joining with us, and the work Young Fine Gael did to bring this to the fore in the first instance. Their collective efforts in their campaign but also the liaison they have had with Members of the Oireachtas has been positive. I also acknowledge two transition year students Blackrock College, Tom O'Donovan and Freddie Horne, who have been with me this week and helped me in preparing some of the statistics and hard data for this speech. In terms of the debate, I particularly welcome the expression of support from the Minister and Minister of State and the indication the Government is considered this and will not oppose the Bill. The Minister said at the outset that this also relates to a commitment in the programme for Government to strengthen the law in this area so I welcome that and look forward to the co-operation of the Government in this regard as well.

He quite correctly outlined that a range of offences can be used to prosecute the kind of behaviour we are talking about but he also acknowledged that having a stand-alone offence is important form the point of view of highlighting this as an issue and making sure it is clearly something that is unacceptable.

What is also interesting in relation to what Deputy Ahern said is that, because it is not a stand-alone offence, it is very difficult to garner statistics on the number of actual prosecutions for what we term "spiking" and, more importantly, the number of convictions that have occurred. The Minister also referred to the fact that, in addition to this offence, it would be open to the DPP to prosecute somebody for the offence that he or she intended to commit after the spiking has taken place or that he or she has attempted to commit after the spiking has taken place. He is, of course, right about that. I do not take away from it. However, I acknowledge that prosecuting attempted offences is substantially more difficult than prosecuting offences that have been committed. The statistics for convictions for attempted rape, for example, are minuscule.

Coming back to the point about intention, Deputy Ó Muirí also mentioned this. The administration of the material in spiking, in and of itself, is a serious matter. I acknowledge what has been said about the loss of bodily and emotional integrity and the effect it has. I think Deputy Butterly also referred to the huge effect it has on a person's emotional stability after a spiking, as well as potentially on their physical health, as a significant offence. I am not saying we need to hold on to the intent bit in this Bill.

To come back to what Deputy Ahern said about certain things that I will term "japery in general", these are not covered by the Bill. That is correct. I do not want a situation in which we unduly criminalise somebody who is doing something in jest, however ill-advised it is. The damage it causes in and of itself is clear and acknowledged, but it is not really the intention of the Bill to target that behaviour. We are trying to target not just the administration of a poison or substance, but also why that is being done and the consequent effect. The intention bit is there to acknowledge that the crime is massively exacerbated by what the person who is spiking actually does afterwards. I would, therefore, favour instead a recategorisation in section 2 using wording such as "where there are reasonable grounds for suspecting", or something similar, which might make it easier from a prosecution point of view to establish the offence.

As I said at the outset, though, I acknowledge all the supportive remarks from colleagues on both sides of the House and that there is cross-party support for this Bill. I look forward to working with all colleagues to find a formula of words or combination of elements within the Bill that is acceptable and progressive and will result in a law that can be prosecuted in real terms. We know there are laws passed by these Houses that do not really find their way into the courts for the simple reason that they are inoperable or unworkable. We should not in any way allow the Houses to pass a law that might find itself in that position.

I acknowledge what Deputy Mark Ward said. While this may feel like there is a feast of Deputies Ward here, he has done work on this issue and it is worth acknowledging. He spoke about the statutory toxicology pathway and that is really important. I am not sure about the statutory basis for it. I think that might complicate and delay things, but the point he makes is absolutely relevant. I am referring to the idea that we should be preparing people to seek out the toxicology information in the case of an event like this, and that there should be a clear pathway for them to obtain it, because that is really important evidence for prosecutions.

Deputy Eoghan Kenny also referred to training for people in licensed premises, for example, to deal with somebody who suspects he or she has been poisoned, spiked or administered a substance. These are really important measures. I support the idea that we would put in place a known toxicology pathway for people and use a public information campaign to ensure people know that when something has happened there is something they can do and there are steps they can take.

There is so much positivity around the Bill. What is important to take away is that there is an opportunity for us to pass something here that will make a tangible difference to the lives of Irish people, young and old, urban and rural, in public and in private. An issue has been identified not just by Young Fine Gael, but by individual Members of the House, groups such as Spiking in Ireland and groups that work with victims of sexual offences. They know this is happening. We have heard the statistics from a number of speakers during the debate. The fact that this is happening is a problem. Nobody is saying it is acceptable or lawful. There is also a recognition, though, that there is not a very clear legislative basis for prosecuting somebody for spiking as a stand-alone offence. The Bill will change that.

I ask that, in the spirit of cross-party co-operation and the support we have received from the Minister and the Minister of State, we do not allow this legislation to languish in a lottery waiting to be selected. The reality is that as a Government-backed venture, I do not get opportunities to bring forward matters like this very often. I rely on the lottery at this time of the week to bring a matter forward, and we are lucky that this Bill was picked out of that lottery. Let us not wait for the lottery to get this legislation moved on further, whether on Committee Stage before the justice committee or the committee of the whole Dáil, or on Report Stage later on. Let us positively move this on because there is an acknowledgement that this legislation is needed, that it advances a situation we know is problematic and that it addresses the issue in a way that puts it up in lights. As I said at the outset, it shows anybody contemplating this criminal, hurtful and damaging behaviour that it will not be accepted or tolerated, that it will be prosecuted and that there will be consequences.

I am very grateful not only to all the people I mentioned in Young Fine Gael and my colleagues in the Seanad who initiated the Bill three years ago, but also to those Members of the Dáil who have taken the time on a Thursday evening to come here to debate this issue, give their views and constructive commentary on the Bill and say what they think is good and what they think can be changed.

I am open to that. Let us get on and do it. Let us get on and make spiking a stand-alone offence and do something that will make a tangible difference to people across this island.

Comment on this