We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Eviction of family with autistic children

Summary

O’Callaghan raises the imminent eviction of Yvonne Nolan and her three children, including autistic teenage twins, and criticises the unsuitable one-bedroom offer and uncertain respite placements. The Taoiseach says he opposes the eviction, describes the case as complex, and says respite will continue while accommodation is addressed.

I spoke to Yvonne Nolan yesterday. Yvonne and her three children are due to be evicted from their home today by a vulture fund. She is trying to put on a brave face for her children but she is struggling. Her 16-year-old twin boys are autistic and non-verbal and have severe and complex needs. They have no idea they are going to lose their home and Yvonne has no way to explain it. Their home has been specially adapted to keep the boys safe and yet the initial response from the State was a one-bed apartment in Dublin city centre - a one-bed for a mother, her teenage daughter and her two autistic teenage sons. It is absolutely scandalous.

Yvonne has been begging for help for months. She repeatedly asked for a permanent residential placement for her boys but was told nothing was available. It was only after she went to the media that an emergency placement was eventually found. She was told yesterday that her boys would be placed in temporary respite accommodation, but this means her sons being transferred between two separate places during the week. This arrangement is only on a week-to-week basis. She has no guarantee of what will happen next week or the week after. There is no clarity about what comes next and what will happen to her children.

There are now a record 18,065 people living in emergency accommodation. This includes more than 5,800 children, so Yvonne and her family are not alone in this pain. What is happening is inhumane; there is no other word for it. Yvonne told me that the very last thing she wanted was to go to the media but that she was left with absolutely no choice because her boys were being put at real risk, with no permanent residential place to live and no idea when one will be available. This is a catastrophic failure of not just planning but care. Exactly as the Before We Die campaign has been trying to tell the Government, the State is knowingly failing these boys and thousands of other disabled people across the country.

Yvonne and her family need the Taoiseach's help. The eviction needs to be halted at least until the end of the school year. The HSE needs to provide a permanent home for her two sons. Yvonne and her family need enough time to plan for this transition. Will the Taoiseach call on the vulture fund to halt this eviction?

Comment on this

First of all, I am always reluctant to go into the specifics of any individual case in the House and in public because invariably there can be complexities behind every individual case that may not always be apparent. One always has to be careful and cautious about doing that and extrapolating from any individual case. That said, I do not believe any eviction should take place in this case. I do not know the full circumstances behind the decision to seek an eviction but that would be the first point in terms of prevention of the eviction. I think there is perhaps complexity in this case that may not be immediately apparent, so I am not going to comment any further on it because we are often restricted.

On the broader point about housing and residential, I have met the Before We Die campaign. The Ministers for housing and disability have taken steps to ensure all future housing allocation will have a ring-fenced quota from local authorities in respect of social housing allocation for people with disabilities. More work has to be done in fleshing that out but it has already been communicated to local authorities.

This year, we will go close to 10,000 social houses. In the decade from 2020 to 2030, we will have well over 80,000 social houses built if not more. There has been extraordinary growth in the delivery of social housing since 2020, which no one wants to acknowledge but it has been hugely substantial. Within that, there has to be room for people with disabilities, just as we have ring-fenced housing for elderly people and people who need housing. The same should apply to disabilities. That is the direction of travel the Government has taken and a recent Cabinet subcommittee meeting reinforced that position.

On social housing, about 61,569 homes were added to the social housing stock between 2020 and 2026. That compares with 34,800 social homes provided by local authorities and the capital assistance programme between 2015 and 2020. We are now doing nearly 62,000 compared with 35,000 in a previous five-year period. That is huge progress on the social housing front. We are going to keep that momentum going because there are another 40,000-odd in the pipeline already over the next two years at different stages of construction, and within that we will provide for people with disabilities. There is work to be done in tying up local authorities with approved housing bodies and then the health services will have to provide wraparound services-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Taoiseach. Deputy O'Callaghan

Comment on this

-----but we are not going to wait for that. We are going to get houses built for people with disabilities.

Comment on this

The Before We Die campaign has been warning the Taoiseach again and again that there need to be plans in place to meet the residential needs of people with disabilities. Does he think it is in any way acceptable that this family was offered a one-bed apartment for a mother, her teenage daughter and her two autistic sons? Does he think it is in any way acceptable that what is now being provided are temporary respite placements where her two teenage sons will have to move every week from place to place? They do not even know how long that respite place will be there for. They are told it will be there for a week and that they might get another week, or another week after that. That is no way for people to be treated. When will the Taoiseach and the Government get their act together and provide the housing needed for people with disabilities and their families so they are not thrown into a crisis and an emergency? Plans need to be in place so they can make transitions together as a family in the time they need.

Comment on this

My understanding is the family has been told respite will be continuous until the complex family situation is dealt with and addressed in terms of accommodation.

As I said to the Deputy before, the situation is quite complex but our priority is the family and the children in that case. I have met with Before We Die. The Tánaiste and I, along with key Ministers, met with Before We Die. It was a very positive and engaging meeting. We will continue regular meetings and we are solution-driven in respect of the issues raised by the Before We Die campaign, which I would not conflate with this case. It is not the same.

Comment on this

They are absolutely connected.

Comment on this

The Before We Die campaign is a broader issue in terms of parents getting older and wanting to have certainty and security about where their adult children will reside in case either parent or both parents pass. That is the core issue, along with others, the Before We Die campaign put before us in respect of housing.

Comment on this