We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

Deer Management: Discussion

Summary

The committee examined rising deer numbers, the impacts on forestry, farming, road safety, biodiversity and TB risk, and the new national deer management programme. Witnesses said accurate deer counts are not possible, so management is based on impacts and reporting data; about 79,000 deer were shot under section 29 licences in 2024–25, with over 10,000 more shot under serious damage permits. FRS outlined progress on 15 deer management units, a new tracking app and work to develop a traceable venison market, while members pressed for clearer regional data, fencing, cross-border co-ordination and measurable reduction targets.

Contributions 1–142 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The witnesses are all very welcome. Apologies have been received from Deputy Kenny. Before I start, I will read a note on privilege for the benefit of the witnesses. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on the issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by the witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that members should not comment on, criticise or make charges against either a person outside the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members participating online in a committee meeting where their participation is from within the parliamentary precinct. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precincts. Any attempt to do so will result in the member having his or her online access removed. Everyone taking part is present here in the room. We have apologies from Deputy Kenny.

The agenda for today’s meeting is deer management. We are conscious that the witnesses’ organisations have been getting up and running over the last while. Members are keen to give that opportunity to get up and running as well as get an understanding of where things are going, what the situation is on the ground and what the next steps will be. The committee will hear from the following officials: Mr. Teddy Cashman, cathaoirleach of the Irish deer management strategy group; Dr. Damien Barrett, senior superintendent vet inspector, and Mr. Seppi Höna, inspector grade 1, from the Department of Agriculture, Food and Marine; Ms Catherine Comer, principal officer and director of wildlife enforcement and nature protection, Ms Claire Crowley, assistant principal officer, and Mr. Wesley Atkinson, regional manager, from the National Parks and Wildlife Service; and Mr. Colin Donnery, chief executive officer; Mr. Neil Keane, head of agriculture, and Mr. Michael Keegan, manager of the deer management programme, from the Farm Relief Services Co-Op. Tá fáilte rompu go léir.

The witnesses’ opening statements have been circulated. I will give witnesses the opportunity to read them and then we will move to questions and answers from members.

Members wanted this issue on the agenda to get a handle on where the landscape is at the moment. Farmers and road users will be very familiar with seeing the deer and encountering them at different stages along the way. I understand that the traffic report on a Cork radio station this morning referred to two young deer in the middle of the road on the county bounds. That is nothing unusual. I travel that piece of road often on the way up here. Last week, I came across three deer. I know that many people will be familiar with deer and farmers are fairly well experienced in dealing with them on the ground, whether that has to do with questions about TB, fencing being broken or the various different concerns they have.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

The Cathaoirleach has already gone through the number of people in the room from different organisations, so I will not go through that part of my presentation.

I thank the committee for inviting us to attend today to update it on where we are at. The biggest issue is that deer numbers have increased significantly in recent years in several parts of the country, and this is evident from the impacts seen across the country. Based on the number of deer shot annually and the number of section 42 permits issued, further increases are predicted. Impacts from deer have been noted around the country as part of Ireland’s national forest inventory and the habitat assessments carried out by the National Parks and Wildlife Service, NPWS, as part of Ireland’s reporting requirements on Natura 2000 sites. Further impacts are detailed in recent research carried out by UCC as part of a Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine-funded project relating to wild deer. This impacts forestry, biodiversity, farming, road safety and animal health.

It is important that we have sustainable management of our national wild deer population for the protection of biodiversity, newly planted forestry, pasture and crops, road safety, animal health, public health and, not least, the health and welfare of the deer themselves. The deer management strategy group was established in September 2022 by the Department, with support from the NPWS, to lead a drive to develop a renewed vision and strategy for the management of wild deer and to build on the work of the Irish deer management forum. This group is comprised of representatives from the Department, the NPWS and Coillte.

To inform the work of the group, a public consultation was conducted in December 2022 seeking the views of stakeholders on the management of deer in Ireland. Over 1,500 people responded from a wide variety of backgrounds, including, but not limited to, farmers, landowners, foresters, hunters, ecologists, academics and rural and urban dwellers. The main findings were that the main impacts of deer were considered to be on biodiversity, farming and forestry, and road safety. The main solutions put forward were deer culling, land management practices and a successful venison market. The main constraints to managing the deer population were the lack of collaboration, public opinion and a limited venison market. The findings of the survey were presented to a stakeholder meeting on 27 April 2023 and these findings were generally well received.

Subcommittees involving stakeholders with a particular interest, expertise or representation were established with a view to developing a series of recommendations. Each subcommittee was chaired by a member of the steering group. The subcommittees' remits were legislation, training and education, solutions for land management, collaboration and venison. The recommendations of these subcommittees were presented to the wider stakeholder group on 27 August 2023. There was considerable overlap in the recommendations of the various groups. As I stated previously, the recommendations were well received and, indeed, several farming organisation and hunting group representatives were very positive in their feedback and contributions on that day.

A final report was launched in December 2023 and the recommendations therein were brought in a memo to the Government by the then Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Deputy Charlie McConalogue. This was approved by the Government.

The recommendations have been grouped as short term and medium term. The overarching recommendations of the subcommittees were creation of a deer management agency, establishment of local deer management units, which has been completed under the auspices of the overall deer programme management tender, and changes to the open seasons order, which came into effect in February 2024. The short-term recommendations relate to the appointment of a programme manager and the development of an implementation plan. A procurement process was launched in spring 2024 and Farm Relief Services Co-Op, FRS, was successful in the tender process in early 2025.

The deer management strategy group met quarterly with the programme manager to review progress and implementation of the recommendations of the report. FRS has made good progress in establishing the deer management programme, recruiting staff and commencing the development of local deer management units. FRS will outline in more detail the establishment of those 15 units. This has involved the appointment of an overall programme manager, collaboration with and learning from NatureScot in Scotland, and deer management unit, DMU, selection and establishment. DMU co-ordinator recruitment has been completed for the 15 DMUs. IT systems, including a comprehensive tagging system, are being developed internally to aid the management of the programme.

Other short-term recommendations related to legislative changes involving the open seasons order for deer, review of current statutory instruments and legislation, and a revision of the section 42 permit application process under the Wildlife Acts. The open season order was amended in February 2024 to align with current dates in Northern Ireland. The section 42 application process was streamlined, ensuring a consistent approach across the country. The application process was also moved online, with this facility available since Tuesday, 5 May of this year. Amendments to veterinary public health legislation to facilitate greater local use have been requested.

The medium-to-long-term recommendations relate to the establishment of a deer management agency, enacting relevant legislation, ensuring a consistent deer management policy on State lands, education and training in forest design, and scheme specifications in relation to deer management. The number of licensed hunters is now at 7,000, and that number that has been increasing year on year. The number of deer being shot under licence has also increased under section 29 deer hunting licences and section 42 serious damage permits. The number of deer shot under section 29 during the 2023-24 season was over 69,000, which was an increase on the previous season, and the number of deer shot during the 2024-25 season has increased to 79,000, an increase of 10,000. In addition, the number of section 42 serious damage permits issued increased from 850 in 2019 to 1,339 in 2025, with the number of deer shot under those permits increasing from 5,600 to over 10,000 in the same period. The NPWS manages deer on its own land. The latest figures show that, since the 2024-25 season, there have been approximately 3,751 deer culled by the NPWS in national parks and nature reserves.

Regarding supports to incentivise the hunting of deer, the availability of suitable game handling and storage facilities in the locations where deer populations need to be managed is vital for the development of a sustainable wild venison industry. Funding has been sought and approved for the purchase of five refrigerated larders to store carcases in such locations, preserving the carcases and allowing the game handler an opportunity to collect multiple carcases for further handling efficiently. An incentive to encourage the hunting of small, low-value female deer, thereby reducing the breeding capacity of the deer population, is something we would like to see and we hope to bring a proposal to the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine shortly.

The increase in deer numbers in recent years necessitates a response to reduce the deer numbers to more sustainable levels to prevent negative impacts on forestry, biodiversity, road safety, farming and animal health. The deer management strategy group is co-ordinating a sustainable, collaborative approach in the management of deer. Collaborative and landscape-level deer management is the norm in the wider European context. The group sought the views of all relevant stakeholders and produced a report with recommendations within 12 months of its establishment. The report has been approved by the Government. One of the main tenets of enabling the recommendations of the report has been the appointment of a national deer programme manger and the establishment of 15 deer management units. FRS will provide further detail on how this has been rolled out to date and future plans. However, the importance of this co-ordinated national approach cannot be overemphasised.

The deer management strategy group continues to implement the recommendations of the report in conjunction with the various stakeholder groups. From the outset, this group has gone about its work in a collaborative manner, engaging with the stakeholders, identifying the issues and endeavouring to find pragmatic and sensible solutions. We are grateful for the engagement of stakeholders to date but we need their continued support to sustainably manage the deer population in the years ahead.

I thank the committee for the opportunity to present our work to it and I thank members for their interest. I ask for their support as we progress this project over the years ahead.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Donnery

I thank the committee for giving us the opportunity to speak about the deer management programme that is being implemented by FRS Co-Op under the direction of key stakeholders, including the deer management strategy group that was established in late 2023 by the Department, the NPWS, Coillte and other stakeholders.

We are here today to outline both the progress made to date in implementing an effective, co-ordinated approach to deer management in Ireland, but also to discuss some of the challenges in dealing with this issue.

In February 2025, FRS Co-Op was awarded the contract to implement and deliver a number of recommendations from the deer management strategy group. The scope of FRS Co-Op's contract includes a requirement to appoint a programme manager to oversee this deer management strategy, establish a number of DMUs in deer hot spot areas of the country, engage with State bodies to develop a structured deer management programme, establish a new system for collecting data on deer numbers and management in Ireland, and investigate the market opportunities for venison. FRS Co-Op carries out its work under the direction of the expert group that comprises the deer management strategy group, and we work collaboratively with all of the key stakeholders on that committee.

Overall, the aim of FRS Co-Op’s deer management programme is to transform deer management efforts from a fragmented, reactive model toward a more structured, evidence-based and sustainable approach nationwide. After being awarded the contract, FRS Co-Op appointed Mr. Keegan as programme manager to oversee and manage the deer management programme for FRS. In line with the recommendations from the Government’s deer management strategy group, our first move was to establish 15 dedicated DMUs that covered areas identified as deer hot spots. Following this, we then moved to appoint a dedicated co-ordinator to each DMU, which would allow us to facilitate and manage a more strategic approach to deer management in the areas covered by each unit, with each DMU co-ordinator essentially working in collaboration with landowners, farmers, local hunters and other stakeholders. FRS appointed its first DMU co-ordinator in June last year and all positions were filled within two months. Alongside this, FRS also developed a dedicated and bespoke IT system to record the key data points around the deer management programme.

Given the complexities of implementing this programme, engagement and collaboration are key priorities for FRS. To this end, FRS has put significant time into meeting with key stakeholder groups such as individual farmers, farmer representative organisations, hunters, hunting organisations, private foresters, environmental groups, policy-makers, meat industry representatives as well as State bodies like Bord Bia, ESB, Bord na Móna and Coillte, with a focus on engagement, discussion, consensus building and education. We have participated in public meetings of farmers and hunting groups to answer key questions and provide further information about the local DMUs and co-ordinators. Additionally, FRS has participated in knowledge transfer events with international colleagues to discuss best practice in deer management. We visited Scotland and worked with NatureScot to understand the challenges it has seen in Scotland. Last October, we took part in the NPWS’s successful cross-national knowledge transfer events with Scottish wildlife services, discussing topics such as managing deer populations on high-amenity areas, policies, and local deer management.

We have also proactively engaged with local and specialist media outlets to ensure that information about the deer management programme is relayed to key stakeholders, and to encourage landowners, farmers and hunters to engage with FRS to make this work. Our stakeholder engagement efforts have been particularly important to connect with the hunting community in Ireland, where we have focused on providing information on the deer management programme. We have always emphasised that the deer management programme can only succeed with strong collaboration with local hunters and other stakeholders. FRS Co-Op's approach to implementing the deer management programme is to act as a co-ordinator between landowners and hunters, helping to connect landowners with a deer problem with local hunters or groups that can provide a solution. This is particularly important in areas where co-ordination, scale or consistency has been lacking up to now. This collaborative approach has been a central principle of the strategy group’s work and one we strongly support.

On top of this on-the-ground work, FRS has also focused on improving data collection and reporting of deer numbers. Historically, one of the greatest barriers to effective deer management has been the lack of reliable, shared data on population densities and cull numbers. To combat this, we have invested in a dedicated IT system for our deer management programme, including the development of a mobile app called DeerConnect, which will allow hunters to identify locations of deer sightings and track deer kills. This will provide important data around the geographic spread of deer in Ireland. The DeerConnect app is currently at the live-testing phase to test its functionality, with approximately 200 users actively using it right now. Since the live-testing phase commenced last month, the feedback from hunters is that it is working very well and we will soon officially launch the DeerConnect app to support our data collection work.

The other key piece of work that we have commenced in the past year was to begin market research on the opportunities for venison and to investigate new routes to market for venison meat. We have had very positive engagement with Bord Bia and the meat processing industry to begin investigating the market opportunities for venison. In particular, the data collection system as part of the deer management programme will help close the traceability loop for venison that will be key to unlocking viable market opportunities.

Overall, the first year of work for FRS has largely focused on the establishment of the key structures to underpin a new era of effective and strategic deer management in Ireland. With these structures in place, we have now moved into the Implementation phase of our deer management programme and we expect to see a significant increase in our data collection programme around the recording of deer sightings and harvests as our on-the-ground co-ordinators continue to work with local landowners, farmers and hunters. This will ultimately be the foundation for a deer management programme that is sustainable and delivers results.

I sincerely wish to thank the hunters and representative bodies for their engagements, all the farming groups, the Minister and the previous Minister of State for their support for the programme.

I look forward to any questions members may have.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. A lot of farmers and road users will be very familiar with seeing deer around and coming across different incidents involving them. We all know that there seems to be a bigger population out there. How do we know how many are in an area? Is there some technique to get an estimate? How do we know if we are at the point of overpopulation? What is the threshold?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I will answer part of the question and I will hand over to Mr. Höna for the second part. We have been very careful in relation to deer management not to focus on numbers, as such, because there is really no effective way of counting numbers of deer. We focus on the impacts they are having. It is easier to measure the impacts than the actual deer numbers. More road accidents in an area are an impact, for example. Mr. Höna has figures around this that might provide a bit of background in terms of the best way of approach this.

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

I thank the committee for having us here today. To put it into perspective, every five years, we do what is called a national forest inventory. We basically do an assessment of the state of play of the forests. As part of that, we do impact assessments to see what impacts deer are having on our woodlands. The last one was done in 2022 and the previous was done in 2017. That showed a nearly 25% increase in the damage we were seeing at plot level. We know definitively where the damage is at forest level. As part of the 2023 report that Mr. Cashman alluded to in his opening statement, we are looking at impacts because it is very difficult to count deer. Sometimes, we like a number but it is very difficult to put a real number on it. We are looking at reducing the numbers and hopefully seeing the impact on agriculture and farmland going down.

Comment on this

I understand that a public consultation was done with over 1,500 different inputs to it. The plan that was put together was based on that. Other than going out shooting, were other proposals recommended arising from that, for example, in terms of road safety or other measures?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I have the proposals and I will read them out, along with the percentages that went with them, to give a background. We asked what the importance was of a range of options in addressing the issues and impacts. Deer culling was the highest at 86.3%. Supports for landowners and land managers to control deer was 78%. A commercially successful wild venison market was 69%. Increased access to education and training for hunters was 69%. We asked about enabling hunters and gamekeepers by contracting them. These options were all to do with culling. Amendment or extension of the open seasons order, which we spoke about, was 63%. Increased exclusion of deer from important woodland areas was another option, which related to fencing more than culling. Access to professional deer managers was another option and is what we have been implementing. Reclassification of sika and fallow deer as invasive species was another option and has happened at a European level lately. We can get into that one along with the NPWS, which will be able to give the background to that. Another option listed was a financial incentive to cull deer. We are working on that one. Legislative amendments or modifications was another option. That is what came out of the report.

Comment on this

That is the range of options. I want to move on to members. We will do six minutes per member, which gives us a chance to come back for another round if needed.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I have a couple of questions to ask and I will give them the opportunity to respond in the six minutes. I am looking to get more of a picture in respect of this. Is it regional? Are there specific areas that we might call black spots, for want of a better term? Deer are not a problem until they are a problem. We do not have a problem with deer, and then all of a sudden TB breaks out in a bovine herd and deer are the problem. There might be a view among people that there are no deer in an area until one night someone driving their car hits a deer. Is it more regional? Are there black spots or is it across the entire country?

In the context of the control of herd of wild deer, a couple of things crossed my mind during the opening statements. Mr. Cashman mentioned Northern Ireland. What is the story in the Border area? Deer do not know where the Border is and do not respect it. That is one thing.

I do not like the word “cull”, but when it comes to control of the wild deer herd, what rights are there on private right? There was mention of State land, Coillte and the National Parks and Wildlife Service. If there is an issue in an area where the numbers of deer are dwelling, if you like, on private land, what rights exist?

It was mentioned that part of the plan is to develop a wild venison market. If you develop that market, achieve the goal and get the herd to a controllable number, having eliminated a lot of females, will it be possible to service the market?

Those are my questions. Between the three groups there are four minutes.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

On the final question, if we got to that level we would be delighted. That would be a real measure of success if we did not have enough venison to supply a market here.

Comment on this

It would be a success on the one hand.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

It would be successful, I guarantee the Senator. I will hand over to FRS to answer the three previous questions on black spots in specific areas, the scenario in Northern Ireland and issues regarding private land because they relate to ongoing management.

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

The Senator made a good point on venison. They have a phrase in Australia, "Eat the problem." If we get to that point and the problem is resolved through the sale of venison, everyone would be happy.

Comment on this

I was in Australia. They eat roadkill.

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

One of the things that is not in place at the moment but that we are trying to provide is a traceability system for venison. The system we are trying to put in place will facilitate tracing. I will ask Mr. Keegan to answer on the black spots and where we have set up the DMUs.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

I thank the committee for the opportunity to speak here today. This is a national programme. We have to try to achieve an element of national coverage. When we looked at setting up the deer management units, we examined the evidence that was publicly available on where the problem was deemed greatest. We are, however, trying to have as much national coverage as possible. As the Senator said, deer are not a problem until they are seen. What tends to happen is that they spread. County Wicklow is probably the biggest county in the country for deer. Areas that might not necessarily have a deer problem could become the County Wicklow of the future if they are not managed in a sustainable way. Just because there is not a massive deer problem in an area does not necessarily mean that there does not need to be structured management in place.

On the North of Ireland, I agree that deer do not recognise borders. However, we only have jurisdiction in the South at the moment. Going forward, it would be a question about whether there can be some cross-Border collaboration. It would be a good idea, and it will be needed. We have had contact from people in the North, but, as stated, we do not have any jurisdiction there. We are trying to get our house in order first.

On private land, landowners and people who hold shooting rights are the only ones who have rights on the relevant land. We do not have any rights on anyone’s land. We can really only work with the people who are willing to work with us. Ultimately, the landowner retains the right as to who he lets onto his property.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I am from Graiguemanagh in County Kilkenny. Kilkenny is a very popular destination for stag and hen parties, but it is a different type of stag that is causing problems down our way. I know we have a lot of enthusiastic young bucks in this room. Kilkenny has too many stags. Half are sleeping in bushes and the other half are eating bushes. It is a huge problem.

I will start on the area of road safety. Because of the huge increase in the numbers of stags and deer, particularly in my part of the country, an awful lot of incidents and accidents have occurred. The local authority has been very responsible in relation to putting up signage, etc., but it is a major issue. Have the witnesses any evidence or data about the number of vehicle collisions that occur annually? Is there a breakdown per county? Are some counties affected more than others? In my constituency, whether it is Thomastown, Graiguemanagh, Freshford or places in the south of the county, there are numerous issues.

My second question is on the estimated deer population throughout the country. Is there a guesstimate as to how many deer there are? Is there a breakdown per county? Are some counties particularly challenged in comparison with others?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

On road safety, we had interaction Transport Infrastructure Ireland, TII, a couple of weeks ago to see what figures it has on this. I do not have figures with me. TII has reasonably good figures for national roads – motorways and otherwise – but there is very little information available for deer sightings or accidents involving deer on tertiary or secondary roads.

Comment on this

I can give Mr. Cashman details of three-----

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I know.

Comment on this

-----that happened within a mile radius of my house in the past three months.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I know that. The problem is that they are not recorded on a database.

Comment on this

Those incidents were recorded and reported to gardaí.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

There needs to be a change in how they are recorded in order that there is a standardised procedure. All it says on the form, as I understand it, is “struck an animal”. It does not say what kind of animal or whatever. We will engage with TII again on this. It asked for collaboration with us on this. We will collaborate, but we do not have very good information outside of that relating to the main motorways. TII has responded with regard to particular areas, for example, in the Cathaoirleach’s constituency. It has started to increase the amount of deer fencing along the Macroom bypass because there have been major reports of deer sightings and of deer crossing the road. It is responding to what it is seeing on the major infrastructure. It said that to us. That is one example. We need to build more data on that matter, we need to engage with An Garda Síochána and others and we need a more solid response.

I will ask the National Parks and Wildlife Service to comment more on that matter. Mr. Atkinson might have more on it and on roads.

Comment on this

No, that is fine. It is more just the number of deer in Ireland or the guesstimate in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

When I came into this role four years ago, I was told that there were 600,000 deer in Ireland, plus or minus 200,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

That gives the Deputy an idea of the accuracy of the figures we have for deer. It is impossible. All we know is that the numbers increased dramatically over the Covid period because there was very little hunting done. We were dealing with a large rise in numbers up to 2022 when there was a fall-off in hunting and much less consumption of venison. A lot of time was lost.

Comment on this

On the basis of Mr. Cashman’s data, are there certain areas which are particularly exposed at the moment? One of the presentations contains a breakdown of the different deer management units.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

What we are relying on is some of the work done by Dr. Simone Ciuti and his team in UCD. They have identified six hot spots for deer throughout the country, including Donegal, Wicklow, Kerry, south Tipperary and parts of Galway. I am missing one area, but that will give the Deputy an idea of the areas where there are very high concentrations of deer.

As as Mr. Keegan stated, it is a question of trying to deal with other areas before they also become a problem.

Comment on this

In terms of forestry, how much money will be set aside or spent annually to try to protect plantations from damage caused by deer?

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

I can come back to the Deputy on overall expenditure. We did some analysis. We will take the reference years from 2023 to 2025, inclusive. In 2023, we fenced over 18,500 m. In 2024, we fenced 22,000 m. In 2025, we fenced 52,000 m. What we are seeing is a significant increasing trend. That coincides with landowners preferring to plant broad leaves. With the ash reconstitution scheme, some farmers are offering to go back in with broad leaves. We obviously have measures to help those farmers protect their forests, so we are seeing a significant increase in demand for those measures to protect from deer. The trends are all going upwards with regard to this matter.

Comment on this

Roughly, how much would 52,000 m of fencing cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

One would be talking about well over €1 million. Contractors are charging about €20 to €22 per metre, roughly speaking, so it is a very costly measure.

Comment on this

Over 70,000 deer were culled last year. Are specific targets set every year in terms of culling or is it done on a case-by-case or year-by-year basis?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

This comes back to the issue about impacts rather than numbers and the impacts we will be working through because there are no real means of doing the numbers. The NPWS might give a bit of background to the numbers that are there already as to where they come from just to give an idea of what that is about.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Comer

I can give the numbers for the 2024-25 season. The Deputy is right. The figure was just under 80,000. If we look at that in comparison with the 2023-24 season, we can see that just under 70,000 were culled. This means that there was an increase of 10,000 in the number culled. The numbers are published on the website. These are the ones relating to deer shot under the provisions of section 29. Licences for hunting are granted under the latter. There are numbers of deer that are shot under section 42. Under that section, permits are granted for shooting deer that are causing serious damage. In 2025, the number was just over 10,000, which was quite similar to 2024. The numbers are all published and are widely available online.

Comment on this

The venison market has been identified as fundamental in terms of the success and sustainability of the overall plan. What are the major barriers with regard to developing a market? What work is happening in terms of the traceability issue that many processors have? Can the witnesses drill down into that for us and provide a good outline in respect of it? Will the deer connect data system or the app have any bearing or benefit when it comes to developing the market?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I will hand over to Mr. Donnery, because he has done a lot of work in that area.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Donnery

I will give the Deputy an idea from field to fork of how we see this working. The hunter has an app. When he shoots an animal, he takes a picture of it and the app geotags where he shot it. Effectively, he tags it with a bar code. That goes into the system and tracks where the deer has come from into the factory. We have a problem finding out where deer are, so there is a deer sighting aspect to the app in order that farmers and hunters can take pictures and geotag where they see deer.

We had some research on consumer habits in terms of venison. Funnily enough, younger people are much more interested in it. Venison is a really lean meat that is high in protein. Young people are much more interested in high-protein foods at the moment. Obviously, the Irish market is the number one market. We also looked at the UK trends. There is a growing trend in terms of high-protein products.

Comment on this

This app is in the testing phase.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Donnery

Yes.

Comment on this

When it is rolled out nationally, is it going to be the antidote to unlocking matters in terms of the processors?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Donnery

If we look at what is happening at the moment, deer carcases are arriving into meat factories and nobody knows where they have come from. Hunters come along and say that they shot them somewhere. The app basically closes that loop in terms of understanding where the meat is coming from. We need to promote the shooting of female deer in order that we can trace where it is going.

Comment on this

Is the current lack of traceability preventing processors from dealing with venison?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Donnery

I would not say it is preventing them processing animals. One of the challenges in the marketplace relates to the fact that the price which hunters are being paid for venison is quite low, at somewhere between €1.50 and €2 per kilogram. In order for hunters to be incentivised to get more, the research shows that if it is a traceable product, it is going to attract a higher price in the marketplace. The latter would mean that hunters would be getting a higher price, which, in turn, would mean that, hopefully, more deer would be shot.

Comment on this

In terms of the geographical availability, without naming names, what kind of processors are accepting these animals? Are there geographical constraints in certain areas? What are the barriers?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Donnery

There is certainly a geographical challenge. Hunters living in the midlands will typically have to drive for an hour and a half or two hours to drop off carcases. They are only receiving €2 per kilogram, so it is nearly costing them money to get there. A proposal is going to the Department about providing larders and fridges in those regions and introducing an incentive scheme for hunters to make up for the low price per kilogram. If we can promote the product in the market and if retailers charge more for it, one would hope that the price for the hunter would be driven up, which would mean more deer being shot.

Comment on this

Where are the proposed locations for the larders?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

We have five proposed locations, namely Boyle, Wicklow, Roscrea in County Tipperary, Kilkenny and Wicklow.

Comment on this

One issue in Mayo is where forests are felled, which displaces deer onto the lands of nearby farmers. What level of co-ordination is happening to try to prevent that? I refer, for example, to notification. Is that happening such that if a forest is going to be felled, a management system might be put in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

We will hand over to Mr. Sweeney. Coillte would know more about that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ken Sweeney

I can speak for forestry as a whole, but, in the context of the deer management units, when forests are felled, deer are being managed at a landscape level. If it adjoins someone's land, they will be working with their colleagues, whether they are private foresters or Coillte foresters, and will be notified by the DMU of the plans relating to the relevant. Efforts will be increased in certain areas to mitigate whatever is coming down the road. It is about managing deer at a landscape level by means of a collaborative approach involving all landowners. The same would work each way with the things that are happening in farming practices. By their nature, deer will move about. If there are pressure points or something happens, they will move to more favourable areas. Instead of reacting to that, it will need to be planned.

Comment on this

Is that happening in practice?

Comment on this
Mr. Ken Sweeney

That is what is going to happen as part of the deer management units, which are in the process of being set up.

Comment on this

When is that due to happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Ken Sweeney

The deer management units are in the process. A number of deer management units are up and running.

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

The deer management units are set up and we are working collaboratively with Coillte as part of the deer management strategy group, DMSG, overall. That is an ongoing process.

Comment on this

Is this collaborative process established? What is the system at a local level?

Comment on this

The Deputy’s time is up.

Comment on this

I apologise.

Comment on this

There will be another round.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here. In County Laois, we have places like the Slieve Bloom Mountains, Emo and Abbeyleix that have a lot of deer. When the motorway went through Portlaoise, Coillte or Transport Infrastructure Ireland had fences on both sides of it. That stretch of the road is not as bad for accidents with deer as the stretch of the road from Abbeyleix to Durrow, where a lot of accidents happen and which is not fenced. I wanted to make that point. I am not saying fencing will stop it, but it certainly is a help.

At what point will the Government move from strategy and co-ordination to setting measurable national deer population reduction targets and what are those targets? I ask for a one-minute answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

In relation to Abbeyleix and that particular stretch of road, I raised that issue with Transport Infrastructure Ireland when we met with it last week. You can see the black spot on the road. I had heard quite a bit about it. When you go beyond the hotel and head for Durrow, there have been serious issues along that stretch.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

The TII said it was one of its priority areas, but I am not sure what was done with it. I raised the issue with them, particularly that piece in County Laois, because I knew it had been quite an issue.

From the point of view of measurable targets, that issue comes back to numbers and not being able to measure them properly. I will come back to FRS on this, but this programme is only about a year old from the point of view of implementation. The policy piece has been gone through for three to four years but the implementation is only in place for probably about a year. It is going to take a collaborative approach between all the Departments to get there. However, we will get there, because there has been good Government support on the financial side to get this up and running. We have funding for the co-ordinators who are looking at the issues around larders and the incentive projects, but it is very much going to be on the whole issue around the impacts both on national and private lands and in forestry. The other point I will make is there has been a lot of collaboration with the NatureScot on this to understand how this has worked abroad. That company is 20 years at it.

Comment on this

I have to move on. Mr. Cashman can talk all day but the Cathaoirleach will only give me six minutes. How will the proposed deer management agency differ in powers and accountability from the current multi-agency structure that already exists? Can anyone answer that? Our witnesses can think about it. I will move on to the next question.

I will ask about the sale of venison. I was very upbeat going home from the Dáil last night when I heard on the late news that the EU is banning Brazilian beef. I jumped up out of my seat on the train. I was very happy that I defended that against the odds of some people in the Oireachtas who did not. I would prefer one slice of deer meat to a slice of Brazilian beef any day. I ask everybody here today to please ensure they put some of that ring-fenced money into trying to promote the sale of venison. That is all I want to say. I will leave that at that.

What safeguards are being put in place to ensure biodiversity protection and deer welfare remain central as culling activities increase? They are going to have to increase. That is a very quick question.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I will refer to the NPWS on safeguards from the point of view of biodiversity because that is its area. I will go to its representatives on that and come back to the other two questions after that.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Comer

In relation to biodiversity, there is ongoing monitoring of areas around the country. The NPWS is constantly looking at that and we have to report at EU level on that at various stages. That is ongoing. The most recent reports were sent last year following a five-year monitoring programme. It is done on a five-year cycle. On an ongoing basis that is happening already.

Comment on this

I have a question about TB. There are suggestions that there is no scientific proof that deer are transferring TB. When deer are tested, what is the percentage of deer that are shot that test positive for TB? Can someone can answer that question so we can put it to bed?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

The answer to that question is not quite that as simple. When we look at the submissions sent in from across the country, of the plucks from deer submitted to our laboratories and what level of them have TB, overall nationally it is 2%.

Comment on this

It is 2% that have it.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

It is 2% in that context but it is a bit more complex than that in the sense that we have research linking whole genome sequencing in County Wicklow, and the same strains of TB have been identified in that area in cattle, badgers and deer. Further research has shown the density of deer is a factor in this as well. Where there is a high density of deer, particularly in areas where there is a high density of sika, there is an increased risk found.

Comment on this

Is Dr. Barrett is saying sika are more prevalent in carrying TB than the other deer?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

They seem to be. It is very hard to untwine that-----

Comment on this

My time is nearly up and I have to ask this question. When you go to the factory with cattle, you can see straight away when sorting the animal that there are TB lesions on them. That will be detected straight away and they can see it. With the deer, is it the same thing? These are the questions the public are asking me.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

They do not go to a factory the way the cattle go to a factory.

Comment on this

I understand that, but they do skin them.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

They are eviscerated in the wild out in the open. Hunters are trained in to identify this. We ask people to submit samples for our culture, but the truth of the matter is we do not get-----

Comment on this

Will Dr. Barrett answer the question? There is public money involved in this. If someone is out hunting, we know what happens when the deer is shot; they blood the deer. At that stage, can the Department not put something in place to be able to say five deer were shot last night in the Emo area, for example, and the five of them were positive for TB.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

There is no public money. They are not receiving incentives at the moment.

Comment on this

We gave €3.6 million. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

That is not for the hunting of deer.

Comment on this

Is there no money?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

We are discussing the potential for incentives to encourage people to hunt deer but that is not on the table yet.

Comment on this

Surely to God, if anything comes out of this meeting, it is whether we could get money for those people who are hunting so that when they shoot the deer they can say that deer has lesions. That is the most important thing to come out of here today. We can talk in circles about TB and whether there are carriers. Everybody tells me it was the outbreak of the deer. When they lived in an area, there was no TB but then there was an outbreak of TB. A person could be in an enclosed area like I am in the middle of a town and get an outbreak as well. The only thing I could blame is rabbits because there are plenty of them. What I would like to see is a positive outcome saying that the person out shooting deer, who is licensed and doing everything right, and is doing the country a favour by trying to keep them culled, that when the Department does the job, it should be able to record that. It is most important to say yes, they had lesions, or no, they did not. My time is up.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Deer may be a part of an epidemiological picture but it is one part of several risk factors, and we need to consider all of them.

Comment on this

Before I go on to the next speaker, Dr. Barrett had a number of figures about TB and the deer; one was 2%. He said it was part of the picture. Does he want to elaborate on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

I went on to say that when we did whole genome sequencing in an area in County Wicklow, we found that the strains of TB in cattle, deer and badgers were identical. They were related.

Comment on this

What kind of percentage?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

In that study in County Wicklow, we were looking at about 16% in that area.

However, the numbers are probably exponentially larger there than in other part of the country.

Comment on this

I thank all the guests for coming in and for their opening statements. I am from County Clare, whose eastern part is very much affected by deer, as the guests are probably well aware. This has a serious effect on forestry, biodiversity, farming, road safety, which is a big issue, and animal health. These all give rise to serious concerns to people on the eastern side of the county. I see there are 15 deer management units throughout the country. Are there offices located anywhere throughout the country?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

We have 15 deer management units across the country. We have FRS offices in most of the regions.

Comment on this

Where is the office in the Clare region?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

We have an FRS office in Ennis.

Comment on this

Very good. It is good to know that. I might get the details off Mr. Keane.

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

Sure.

Comment on this

That is positive. I am hearing from people in Clare that although co-ordinators are out meeting people, the people do not see any improvement on the ground. For how long has the co-ordination been in the county?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

To answer that one, I will go back to FRS. We are up and running for only a little over a year at this stage, so maybe the Deputy will want to talk to Mr. Keegan about it. It will take time.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

We have 15 deer management unit regions and nine co-ordinators covering the 15.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

Three of those are part-time and six of them are full-time. They have been employed only since 11 August, which was when we had full employment. There was a period of training for the staff, which took a bit of time. The co-ordinators have done a huge amount of work on the ground, including stakeholder engagement. It is going to take time. It is important to point out that this is the first effort of co-ordinated deer management on a national scale ever to take place in the country. There will be a lot to be learned along the way. We have done a huge amount of work trying to establish what best practice looks like and what good looks like. To that end, we met representatives of NatureScot and have a great collaboration with it on a number of occasions. Its representatives have been over to us and we have been over to them. International evidence shows that this is not a short-term process. It will take a good few years to put something in place that works really well and properly and to start to see results on the ground. Our function here is to put the structures in place. The stakeholder engagement is key to that.

Comment on this

Very good. As far as I can see, and based on the word I am hearing, the deer population is increasing in Clare. Do the guests have any idea of the number of deer culled in the past 12 months in the county?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

Ms Crowley might know if we have information on section 29 licences in Clare.

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

In County Clare, 3,289 deer were shot under section 29 deer hunting licences in the 2024–25 season. The statistics are obviously a year behind. Under section 42 in Clare, the figure was 183.

Comment on this

So, it is approximately 3,400 deer, according to the 2024–25 figures.

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

Yes.

Comment on this

Do the witnesses have any idea whether the deer population in the county is increasing or decreasing?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

We have no figures for that, to be honest. Until we have a scenario where we are taking out large numbers of deer every year, the population will not decrease. First of all, we need to stabilise the population. A point that needs to be made on this is that we are seeking to create a sustainable population of deer, not exterminate or eliminate them. Having a sustainable state is what we are after. That will take time. We do not have figures to say which way the population is going. We are only working off indications from road traffic accidents and impacts on forestry and farming. We are building infrastructure to measure the numbers.

Comment on this

Of the 3,400 deer culled in County Clare, have any been tested for TB? Are there figures on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

We would not have those figures to hand here today.

Comment on this

It seems to be still a concern, even though we are told the percentage is very low, at 2%. The figure mentioned for Wicklow was 16%, if I am not mistaken.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Yes.

Comment on this

Would any of the deer culled in the county have been tested?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

I cannot tell the Deputy that at this moment. I do not have figures on that for County Clare.

Comment on this

Would it be possible to find out and get back to me on it?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

It would by all means be possible to find out the figures for County Clare and revert to the Deputy.

Comment on this

That is very good because TB is a serious concern in my county. Unfortunately, many farmers have suffered because of it. We believe the badger is the main carrier of TB but there are also concerns about deer.

Comment on this

I seek clarification. There is a figure of 2% for deer tested and found to be reactors. Not every carcass is got back, so 2% is only part of-----

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Two percent of what is being submitted.

Comment on this

So, there could be a whole swathe of other-----

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Yes, there could. We do not know. We cannot comment on the others.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Barrett.

Comment on this

On this topic, how many were actually submitted out of the 79,000 killed last year?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

I do not have that number to hand but it would be very small, much lower than----

Comment on this

Less than a hundred?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

It would be in the hundreds, at most.

Comment on this

How do you get one of the 7,000 licences issued? What criteria must be met to obtain a licence?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

You have to apply online to our new system. As a first-time hunter, you have to have certified training. You have to prove you have been trained-----

Comment on this

Trained to shoot a gun?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

No, trained in deer hunting. There are three specific training courses approved, and you have to have one of those completed and submitted proof you have completed it. You also have to have a firearms certificate from An Garda Síochána, with limits assessed at local level. NPWS staff on the ground will make an assessment. Quite often, they will know the people concerned and therefore know whether they have competency on top of the fact that they have training.

Comment on this

I presume the training would allow a shooter to tell a male from a female and such things from a distance.

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

They should be able to identify the species.

Comment on this

They should be able to, but possibly not.

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

I am assuming they do.

Comment on this

I reckon there are many hunters shooting for the craic. It is a matter of whatever comes in front of them. The talk is of culling females. How will the Department go about that? Obviously, there are more females than males. Is there any plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I might hand over to Mr. Keegan on that. He has more experience in this area.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

Part of our role is to try to educate both hunters and landowners about best practice. As a farmer and someone who has spent his entire life shooting deer, shooting them has become second nature to me, but there are many people who might need a little help, particularly when starting off.

The hunter competence assessment programme, HCAP, certificate is geared towards exactly what the Deputy described, namely, identifying species, sex and all the rest. It is not that difficult during the season to see the difference between male and female. It is clear. The males have antlers and the females do not.

Comment on this

I know but I am referring to spotting them from a distance.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

Suffice it to say that if you are doing this and have all the proper equipment, you will clearly see the difference. It is not that difficult.

Comment on this

And are the hunters aware that the idea is to cull females?

Comment on this