We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

Deer Management: Discussion

Summary

The committee examined rising deer numbers, the impacts on forestry, farming, road safety, biodiversity and TB risk, and the new national deer management programme. Witnesses said accurate deer counts are not possible, so management is based on impacts and reporting data; about 79,000 deer were shot under section 29 licences in 2024–25, with over 10,000 more shot under serious damage permits. FRS outlined progress on 15 deer management units, a new tracking app and work to develop a traceable venison market, while members pressed for clearer regional data, fencing, cross-border co-ordination and measurable reduction targets.

Contributions 143–287 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Michael Keegan

As I have said, part of our role is to try to educate hunters. Most would be educated but there are those who are not.

Our role here is to try to educate people as to that fact to try to reduce the numbers-----

Comment on this

With the engagement then with the stakeholders, FRS spoke to 1,500 people or so, but there are 7,000 licenceholders. Is there a plan to get to speak to everybody or what is the story there?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

Just to clarify, that 1,500 is the initial stakeholder engagement process before FRS ever became involved. That was on the IDMSG side of things. The stakeholder engagement we are doing is with hunters and landowners on the ground primarily and, obviously, Coillte, national parks and all the other important stakeholders. That is an ongoing process daily. We are meeting them daily. Our guys on the ground are meeting them all the time and they are putting that message out there with them the whole time.

Comment on this

Dr. Barrett spoke about the number of samples FRS was getting. How do we know that there are 79,000 killed? Are hunters holding their hands up to say they have killed X number of deer? I had burgers and steaks last year and I do not know if they were flagged as "I have killed a deer" or whatever, so how does FRS know that there are 79,000 killed? Do the witnesses know what I am getting at? Is everybody holding up their hand and saying, "I have killed ten in the past year, "I have killed 20", or whatever? How does that work?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

Everyone who gets issued a section 29 deer hunting licence, when they reapply the following year, must give their deer hunting returns for the season they have just completed, so it is self-declaration but they have to tell us what they shot in order to get their licence for the following year. If they do not tell us-----

Comment on this

It is a stab in the dark then.

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

It has always been that way. With the numbers, I think you can only compare year on year and they have been increasing slightly but it is not a huge jump or a huge drop. You would imagine that people are-----

Comment on this

Before 2022 then, before the talks of the deer management strategy group, what kind of numbers were being killed, and what is the difference since FRS got on board? Are there more killed? Obviously, there are more killed every year because the population grows and so on, but what do the witnesses see themselves doing differently from what was done before? People were going out and killing deer already. What do the witnesses see that will be the big impact that they will make on society? We can cut back and set back forest plantations on the road. We can cut vegetation in order that it is more visible for cars and stuff and that there is a bit more of a gap that we can see. All those kinds of things can be done, but what difference are the witnesses going to make to the population of deer?

One other thing is the cost. What is the cost of the deer management group? What is it costing the State?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

From the point of view of what success looks like, going back to a few years prior to 2022, the big elephant in the room in that period was Covid. I mentioned that earlier in this scenario, the numbers in those years previous were probably greatly diminished because less hunting went on during Covid and there was less opportunity for selling venison. The previous deer management forum finished in 2018, and just prior to that there was some engagement around this process. What we hope for is an outcome from this scenario. The initial piece is that everybody would collaborate together from the point of view of addressing the problem and putting infrastructure in place so we are building an infrastructure, first of all. That is the main thing we are doing. We are getting people out on the ground to co-ordinate, getting opportunities for refrigeration and taking in venison in a local area, and building a market around the venison. It is a slow enough-----

Comment on this

Who will pay for the refrigeration?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

We are engaging with the Department on that. We talk about looking for five larders around the country.

Comment on this

And the Government will pay for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

Yes. That is the plan.

Comment on this

What is the cost to the State every year for Mr. Cashman's group?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

The biggest one that has been finalised - and those issues have not been finalised completely yet - is the co-ordination piece, which is a contract for over €3.6 million over four years.

Comment on this

The witnesses are all welcome. To go back to Dr. Barrett's thing on the TB in Wicklow, there are parts of east Galway and other parts of the country that are black spots. Have the witnesses done analyses of TB in those areas where there are a lot of deer?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

That was fairly in-depth analysis that was carried out in County Wicklow. We do not have the evidence for other parts of the country, but absence of evidence does not mean evidence of absence. We simply do not have it.

Comment on this

So they are a part of the picture of-----

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Well, we cannot rule them out as being part of the picture.

Comment on this

That is perfect.

To Mr. Höna, forestry is being done and grants given to farmers. Why is there not an obligation that a 2.5 m fence is put up? Most deer are eating farmers' grass around the country every day of the week.

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

From a scheme point of view, we are trying to keep the deer out of the forestry, not in the forestry.

Comment on this

They are in it already.

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

I know, but looking at the trends in afforestation that I mentioned earlier, there is an increasing trend for more broadleaves.

Comment on this

But if you are trying to keep them out of the forestry, would it not make sense then to put the fence up high enough to not let them in?

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

In deer areas, as the Deputy knows, the broadleaves have to be protected, so it is up to the registered forester in conjunction with his landowner to choose that option-----

Comment on this

But it is up to the Department of agriculture to decide what the terms and conditions are.

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

We do sometimes. We often insist on deer fencing.

Comment on this

Why would it not be a standard practice? As regards the amount of grass deer are eating, east Galway is tortured with deer at the moment. There are even roads being blocked at night when people would be driving. That is how bad it is. You could see 200 or 300 of them. That is how bad it is around Mountbellew and all that country. Something has to be done because it is causing problems and I ask the Department to look at that.

To go back to Mr. Cashman, we talk about the damage done. Has there been any meeting with the insurance companies? That is where you will know what was claimed or what was not claimed in relation to a deer accident.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

No, we have not engaged with the insurance industry thus far.

Comment on this

Would that not be the quick way of finding out how big of a problem it is, rather than asking TII, which does not have a bull's iota?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

It is something for us to do in the future but we have not engaged with insurance companies so far. It is a question of local information and local areas. As to what we are working on, there are the co-ordinators on the ground, and I know there have been some efforts in areas to concentrate an effort where there was a big road traffic problem. Mr. Keegan might talk about that one a bit, maybe, but there has been a bit of work done around that.

Comment on this

Is it the national parks service that takes over all responsibilities for deer around the country? Are the witnesses aware, as some of them should be, that there is a huge problem of goats around Kinvara in Galway and there is nothing being done? Is there any team or a SWAT team that goes in to try to solve problems, or is it just licensing the NPWS is doing?

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Comer

The National Parks and Wildlife Service provides the licensing for deer hunting across the country but it has responsibility for deer in the national parks and in the nature reserves. I am afraid I am not qualified to talk about goats, and it is probably better for us-----

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Comer

-----to stick with deer, if that is okay.

Comment on this

We will stick to the deer as much as we can.

Comment on this

In relation to the farm relief services, are these fridges or bases in or are we waiting to know if there is money coming from the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

No, they are not in place yet. We hope to have them in in the next-----

Comment on this

So what does a guy who shoots deer do at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

Typically, some hunters will have a fridge themselves or whatever or they will take it directly to the factory, either in Clane or other parts of the country.

Comment on this

Can small abattoirs look after them?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

I will defer to the Department on who can take in venison. Typically, anyone can, but there are specialist factories dealing with it at the moment.

Comment on this

The National Parks and Wildlife Service might be able to tell me this. I was baling in a field last year and I saw what looked like a mini deer. I know there are red deer and the Sika deer, but is there another smaller type of deer?

They came into a field and they were not fit to jump out of it, which was unusual.

Comment on this

They are like small runts of things.

Comment on this
Mr. Wesley Atkinson

Up in the Deputy's part of the world, there are fallow deer. Depending on the time of the year, there could be juveniles, so-----

Comment on this

No, these are not juveniles.

Comment on this
Mr. Wesley Atkinson

They are small; they are the calves. Then, in some areas, there are muntjac deer, which were released by-----

Comment on this

Where did they come from?

Comment on this
Mr. Wesley Atkinson

They were released by people unknown. Depending on the time, at this time of year, we will see-----

Comment on this

Does the NPWS classify them as an invasive species or anything like that? Is anything like that done, no?

Comment on this
Mr. Wesley Atkinson

The likes of muntjac are covered under the open seasons order but there is a 12-month season on them. A lot of the time, when we follow up to check up on our reports on muntjac, if we look at the seasonality, it ends up invariably being a juvenile deer of an other species, such as fallow, sika or whatever.

Comment on this

Okay. One last thing needs to be clarified for the sake of the committee.

Comment on this

I am sorry, Chairman. I have to go to a vote in the Dáil Chamber. Will we be continuing?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I have a good few questions.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzmaurice has the floor. Once he is finished, we are going to suspend for the vote.

Comment on this

I will say one quick thing for the sake of the committee. A statement was made earlier that the EU had banned Brazilian beef. If anyone had read what it has done, they would know it has stated that it is on the critical list. It is actually dangerous, and I would hope that the Irish Government would ban it. The EU said it is giving them now until December to get their house in order. That needs to be clarified rather than something incorrect being said in here.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy. We will suspend the meeting. A vote has been called in the Dáil Chamber after which we will continue the meeting.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here. We have a desperate and monumental problem with deer in Kerry. They have us completely overrun. On road safety, the number of accidents is not recorded properly but there have been people killed as a result of deer, there is no doubt about that. Many the young fella's car is broken and they are only after getting insurance. They are paying thousands of euro for insurance and they have a car in flitters and no insurance to cover it. Road safety and health are the real things that must be addressed one way or another. For farmers, then, their grass is eaten. Their fences are broken, trampled, and they cannot keep them up. They are responsible then if their cattle cause a crash after coming out on the road through a fence that is broken by deer because they have ear tags on them.

On TB, Dr. Barrett said only 2% of deer that were tested presented with TB. Is that 2% of the ones that were tested or the total number of deer that were shot?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

It is 2% of those tested.

Comment on this

How many were tested?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

I cannot tell the Deputy off the top of my head, but it is in the hundreds, not in the thousands. It is a relatively low figure. We test what is submitted to us in the regional veterinary labs. We would welcome more submissions and we make this available to hunters and landowners. The plucks can be submitted and we will test them. Of what is submitted to us, that is what we get.

Comment on this

Would they be from the one area?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

That is from all over the country.

Comment on this

I am very disappointed at the full amount of the ones that were tested. That is the like fella that went delivering the telegram down home and he asked how far more had he to go. It was actually my two uncles he asked. They said, "Well, where are you going?" The man with the telegram said, "Mind your own business, only have I far more to go?" We do not know what the percentage is of. I am kind of disappointed about that. Sika deer are classified as vermin now by the European Union. Does Dr. Barrett know that?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Yes.

Comment on this

Does that make any difference to strategies the Department has in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

The NPWS might answer the one on the sika deer first, from the point of view of categorisation and what that means from a Government policy point of view.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Comer

Looking at not just the sika deer but also the fallow deer as well, from a species point of view, even though it is not native to Ireland, fallow deer will never be added to an EU list because it is native to some parts of Europe. Sika deer have been listed as an invasive species of national concern in the EU, including Ireland as well. Both fallow deer and sika deer are of national concern to Ireland. Even within the context of that, it is taken within the whole of the deer management strategy.

Comment on this

The Farm Relief Services Co-Op might answer how it is spending the €3.6 million. Is it paying fellas to shoot deer?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

We are not paying people to shoot deer. We are employing the people on the ground each year. That €3.6 million is over four years. That is employing the people on the ground and putting all the systems in place and so on.

Comment on this

Is that systems to shoot them or what?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

No, to track more so.

Comment on this

That is not important part at all. The important part for the farmers we are representing down in Kerry is to cull the deer and get them out. It does not matter how many of them are there. They will have to be culled, and that means shot. This deer management strategy should have a different title. It is to cull the sika deer that are not native to here.

We are very fond of the red deer and we would be very hurt if anybody shot the red deer, whether stags or does or whatever, as we appreciate those, but the sika deer must be got rid of. We must put road safety first and have no excuses.

What about farmers' viability? I think of the likes of Tim Herlihy in Rathmore who had 30 animals go down before Christmas. Every deer that has been shot, whether by him or those he was paying to help him, when its throat was cut it had lesions. To prove that, he had two of them taken to Cork to be tested and they were rotten with TB. That should be proof enough for anyone. That man adored his cows and adored his heifers and most of them were taken away in a lorry. His neighbour had 66 and 61 of them went down so the whole lot went. Now there is another neighbour with 33 gone down and the vet says it is a new outbreak. Donal Murphy, a widely-respected vet, says he knows from the type of TB it is that it is a new outbreak, so there are deer and badgers causing these men to lose their livelihoods. This is very serious. There are two aspects, which are lives on the road and farmers' livelihoods. I do not know how people can be told to buy venison when it has not been tested for TB. Why are we testing the cattle at all if you can eat deer with TB?

Comment on this

Thank you, Deputy.

Comment on this

Maybe the witnesses will say something about that.

Comment on this

Very briefly, because we have gone over time.

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

Chairman, just to briefly answer the Deputy, Farm Relief Services are 50 years supporting farmers and that is why we are interested in getting involved in this. As for testing, TB will obviously need to be tested for at the factory level when venison is going into the food chain. That is obviously going to be critical. I live at the foot of the Slieve Bloom Mountains in Deputy Aird's constituency and every day on the way to work I pass deer on the road. We understand the challenge, which is a massive one, as was said earlier.

Comment on this

Thank you. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae.

Comment on this

Thank you very much, Chairman. I warmly welcome the deer management strategy group and indeed many of my friends from Coillte, the Department of forestry, FRS, the NPWS and all the witnesses who are here as we are all trying to achieve the same thing, which is reduce the amount of deer roaming, because the figures have exploded. I thank the Minister, Deputy Heydon, for his involvement to date. When people talk about strategy, of course you have to have a strategy and to know what you are doing. You have to have a plan and know how you are going to go about tackling a problem. The refrigerated units were something I was very supportive of in every way, and it is the same with the Minister. Those units are going to be very important to the work that is being carried out. On the issuing of the section 29 and section 42 licences, I thank the NPWS very much for its proactive and workmanlike way of dealing with those, which is very much appreciated. Of course, we need more people. We need more hunters on the ground. We need for it to be financially sensible for them to go out. It is a sport for many people but sport can be expensive. It needs to be financially sensible for individuals to be out.

On the work FRS is doing, Mr. Keane and others know I am very supportive of that. I always have been and always will be. I appreciate it is a very difficult problem. When FRS staff are going around the farmers want them to be out there and to cull the deer, but the whole operation is not as easy as deciding to go out and shoot them all. That is what we want to do as we want to reduce the numbers but you can be very simplistic and point the finger at the witnesses and say they are failing. That is not true, as they are working at it, but we just want it to accelerate it.

It is true we have an awful problem in County Kerry. There has been an explosion in the population of not just sika deer but red deer, which also need to be culled. The NPWS is very accommodating when farmers come along saying we have a problem. Whether it is red or sika deer the NPWS understands the difficulties and we appreciate that, especially with the national park in Killarney. The numbers have exploded and that is why we have so many accidents on our roads and so many farmers being affected. A farmer can put up a new fence and see it becoming destroyed after a couple of weeks simply because of deer jumping it. This simplistic view that you can fence them in or out is rubbish. Pointing the finger at Coillte, the Department of forestry or at anybody is not helpful in this situation. Every one of us, be that Coillte, the Department, private landowners or the NPWS, all want to achieve the same thing.

Coming back to the TB issue, every one of the witnesses knows the Minister is very serious about reducing the TB problem we have throughout our cattle herd nationally, which itself is very serious. The reports we received that formulated the Minister's policy on TB did not actually show deer were a big problem but on the ground we know they are. Take places like south Kerry where deer were not very prevalent at all. They started to come in and as soon as the deer came in the incidence of TB started to rise. The problem is whether we proved it scientifically. We did not, simply because there was not enough testing. There is not enough testing going on but wherever testing is carried out there are an awful lot of instances of TB. The statistics do not back us up because we are not doing enough testing. There has to be a big focus put on the eradication of the female deer because that is the key to this problem. Since I heard it being discussed here, no more than a person would know a cow from a bullock or a bull, any person who has a gun licence and owns a rifle will know a female from a male deer. There is no problem in the world in that distinction. We rely on these people. I hope there will be a strong emphasis put on tackling the problem.

Coming in here, the one thing I wanted to say, Chairman, is it is not us against the witnesses or anything like that. We are representing the same people they want to help and what we want to achieve is a much reduced deer population because it has gone out of control. We all have to work together. How you will tackle any job and how you will do it right is not trying to blame anybody or criticise anybody but just to say we all have a job of work to do and we are all going to pull together and do it. I am supportive of the witnesses and thank them for the work they are doing. I do not envy FRS in that it is a difficult job. I thank its representatives for the fact it goes around and has meetings with farmers and everything. That can be very difficult because farmers are hurting. You know well, Chairman, that if you set new grass and of a morning you see 30 or 40 deer in that field, you would be cross enough if it was five neighbouring cows, never mind 40 deer where you cannot give out to the person who owns them. I thank the witnesses for the work they are doing. I am very supportive of it. I was, I am and I always will be.

Comment on this

I thank all the witnesses. I have listened to a lot of the contributions. It is certainly a problem in my area, which is the opposite side of the Slieve Bloom Mountains to Deputy Aird. I was driving home last night after a meeting in Carlow and I encountered 12 deer on a couple of kilometres of road. I am aware it is a black spot for deer but unfortunately these black spots are becoming more and more prevalent. If I look at my 10 km of road from Kinnitty to Birr, where once there was one spot you would see deer there are now eight or ten. There are no civil works, signage or fencing that is going to address that.

However, there is a growing frustration out there that it is not being dealt with fast enough. The witnesses referenced the number of killings on an annual basis. It can vary significantly county by county. I think they mentioned that 79,000 had been killed. What would they say is an optimal target in relation to the annual culling of deer?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I would go to back to what I mentioned earlier. We cannot really target a number because we do not know what the overall number in the country is as such.

Comment on this

What if it was based on resources?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

That is a very difficult one to answer. What we are trying to do is build an infrastructure to control deer and reduce the impacts they are having. That is what this whole project is about. To arrive at a number is virtually impossible. I cannot answer that question definitively. Does Mr. Keegan wish to comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

As Mr. Cashman said, we are trying to put the structures in place to make this more efficient. What happened in the past was that hunters were kind of doing their own thing with whatever landowner they were working with. That was very successful in some cases but not in others. We are trying to put the structures and recording system in place along with a tagging system and an app. We have the tags here if anybody wants to see them. It is to try to get a better end-to-end system where we know where and when the deer was shot and all the rest right up into the factory. As Deputy Healy-Rae said, it is a very tricky thing to do. It is a brand new approach. It has never been done before on a national scale.

Comment on this

If we are still killing 75,000-odd deer in five years' time, will it be sufficient?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

The best way I can answer that is to say that structured deer management has been in the UK for many years - decades really - and they are still struggling in a lot of areas. We cannot just say that we will kill X amount and that is it, we are done. It requires a sustained approach. We cannot just kill a certain amount and walk away finished. It is and will be an ongoing thing. If we want it to be successful, it has to be an ongoing thing over many years.

Comment on this
Mr. Seppi Höna

To develop that further, what we want to see in the mid-to-long term is a reduction in impacts, be they road traffic incidents or impacts on protected habitats and forestry. I alluded to the national forest inventory and the impacts that we had seen in our five-year assessment. If we see reduced impacts, that will guide us on whether we are shooting enough deer. For example, people in the Deputy's constituency might say that they are not seeing as many issues as before. That will really be the guiding factor.

Comment on this

We are not expecting deer to learn the rules of the road. Depopulation will be the answer as far as I see it.

If I may touch on testing and times of testing, is the current sample adequate or does it need to go further? A number of a few hundred was mentioned, but we do not a have a definitive figure.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Is that in the context of TB testing?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

Will the Deputy clarify his question?

Comment on this

If we look at the testing that is being carried out at the moment, we are talking 200 or 300 and we have no definitive figure. How much does a test cost and how long is the turnaround time? I am just trying to get a sense of whether we should be doing more.

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

The tests are over €50 each and they take ten to 12 weeks to culture. Mycobacterium bovis is a slow-growing culture. The real issue is that the number of submissions is low. We would have the capacity to culture more if more plucks were submitted, but they are not being submitted.

Comment on this

Does Dr. Barrett see any particular reason for that?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

With submissions, people are motivated when TB is suspected. If the suspicion is not there, the motivation will not be there. We have to remember that TB is one of several reasons to manage the deer population. Focusing solely on it is not the right thing to do. We need to look at why we need to manage deer in the broader context.

Comment on this

A number of people have claimed to me that where disruption has occurred as a result of new infrastructure, it can lead to deer transitioning to new areas and being seen in areas where they were never seen before. I just wanted to make that point.

On licence renewals, the whole area of section 42 permits, one shooter, one farm and so on, are any modifications required?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

I do not understand the question.

Comment on this

In relation to the whole area of licence renewals and section 42 obligations, is there any need for modifications?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

We recently brought the whole system online and reviewed the whole process from start to finish to try to streamline it and gather all of the information up front. We have done a certain amount of work on that. It only went live last week, so it is very early days yet.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I would like to expand on that a small bit for the Deputy. From the start of this programme, there was an issue around section 42 permits and the standardisation of procedure. It was much easier to get one in Wicklow than in the rest of the country and many hunters expressed a lot of dismay about that in the last few years. To be fair to the NPWS, it has moved heaven and earth to get this thing streamlined and uniform across the country, so there has been quite a bit progress in the last two years in this particular area, which has been well acknowledged by those in the hunting community. It was one of the asks that has been delivered on.

Comment on this

The voting bell is running, with five or six minutes of it gone. We will suspend the meeting and return after the vote, which will leave us approximately 15 minutes to go through any other questions.

Comment on this

I thank all the witnesses for their attendance. I have a few questions. I apologise if they have been touched on already but I was attending another committee meeting. I note from both the reports and witnesses' replies earlier that, essentially, we do not have a fully comprehensive way to monitor the population of deer within the country.

However, it would seem that we have seen a massive increase in the past five to six years, maybe as a result of Covid when fewer people were culling. Do the witnesses have any thoughts on that?

In terms of controlling the population, looking at encouraging the hunting of small, low-value female deer was mentioned. What measures are the witnesses looking at in terms of that encouragement? Where are we with the delivery of that part of the proposal?

I noted that, quite interestingly, 68% of stakeholders at the initial forum back in 2021 or 2022 mentioned that public opinion was a constraint in dealing with the deer population. How does the group plan on addressing potential public backlash against increased culling? As much as I hate to say it, it is very much a rural issue and one where we see a big difference between rural opinion and urban opinion. For those who are dealing with them, they are a pest on agricultural land. They are causing more accidents on roadways. The Cathaoirleach and, I believe, Mr. Cashman touched on the N22 and the bypass of Macroom. I am from that area as well, so I am very much aware of a massive increase in the incidence of deer jumping out on the road - not just on the bypass, but on parts of the N22 generally, both east and west of Macroom. How do we deal with that in terms of public opinion when the report has foreseen that public opinion could be a massive barrier to dealing with this?

May I also get an update as to where we are in terms of the establishment of the deer management agency and where the budget is going to come from for that? We currently have collaboration between the NPWS, the Department of agriculture and Coillte, but what will that procedure look like for the deer management agency in reality?

May we get some further information in relation to the hazard that deer pose to biosecurity? Obviously, they are mentioned a lot when it comes to TB. There is uncertainty as regards the extent of the role they play there. I appreciate that other members have mentioned it, but how do we deal with that? Are there any other biosecurity concerns related to the massive increase in the deer population that we are seeing across the country?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I thank the Senator. I will deal with a couple of those questions and hand over a couple, if that is okay.

The public opinion question is quite an interesting one to address. The biggest problem we have with deer is that they have no natural predator in this country. There are no other means of dealing with them without reducing the population. An example that I often give relates to the Phoenix Park in Dublin, where there is a natural population of deer that has been there for centuries at this stage. They are controlled every year to a certain level and that maintains the population. It does not just reduce or increase the population; it is maintained at a certain level that is healthy for the population of deer. There is intervention for that to happen, however. What we are trying to do as part of this is roll the idea out across the country that we can maintain a population of deer at a level that is sustainable for the deer. There are places in the country where there are too many deer for their own good. There is a lack of food for deer because the population is too high in areas where they are seriously grazing. From a public opinion point of view, the point we would put across is that we are trying to maintain a sustainable deer population nationwide. That is the focus here. It is nothing else. It is not extermination or elimination. None of those words is being used. It is sustainable population of deer. That is an important point to make.

On the other point the Senator made about taking out female and young deer, there is an incentive scheme being developed for that. It is not finalised completely yet, but the idea is that we would incentivise the taking out of female and young deer. However, there needs to be a structure put in place around that from the point of view of reporting and verification. That is being worked on at the moment. Once that is developed properly, there is a good chance that we will be able to roll out a scheme like that. However, we need to be sure that if taxpayers' money is being put into something, there is a means of being able to verify what is happening for that money. That is a responsibility that we have as a Government agency or subagency. That is an important point.

The other question was on the national agency for deer, which is contained in recommendations. That has not been developed a whole lot yet. It is one of the long-term objectives. It is something we will have to look at into the future from the point of view of finding some place for the storing of information, national policy and that kind of thing. We are starting by getting something done and getting infrastructure on the ground, but there will have to be more negotiations within Government bodies to see how we can advance an agency and what that might look like. There is a good bit more discussion to be done around that.

I do not know if there was any other issue raised, but one matter we might return to from the questions that were asked earlier is that of testing. That was not one of the Senator's questions, but Mr. Keegan might come in on standardised testing.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

All deer that are sold into game-handling establishments go through a system. If someone wants to sell deer to a game-handling establishment, they must sign a trained hunter declaration form. On that trained hunter declaration form, while no hunter is a veterinarian and is not qualified in veterinary medicine, they are asked to submit details of any abnormalities that they find on the carcase at the time of culling, whether that be a suspected TB lesion or whatever the case may be. They deer are then inspected by Department of agriculture vets and are randomly sampled for TB, so it is not true to say that they are not tested, as such. There is a bit of testing going on through the factories.

Comment on this

I am sorry. I did not say they were not testing.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

No, I know the Senator did not, but it had been spoken about earlier. We are actively encouraging hunters and farmers on the ground who wish to partake in the programme to submit plucks to their local district veterinary offices, DVOs, for testing because without the evidence, we obviously cannot act on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

The Senator had a question about biosecurity. Does anyone from the NPWS want to talk about biosecurity? Are there any issues that they feel are important there?

Comment on this
Dr. Damien Barrett

I can take that one. The Senator is probably concerned about spillover from the deer into cattle. We have looked at a couple of different diseases, including viral diseases such as Schmallenberg virus and bovine viral diarrhoea, BVD, that were surveyed a couple years ago. The levels of BVD in particular were minuscule in the deer population.

To follow on from a point that was made, there may be an idea here that all the infection is going from deer to cattle. It is actually going both ways. There may be spillover from cattle to deer and spill-back from deer to cattle. Mr. Cashman mentioned the scenario in the Phoenix Park. There was a problem with TB in deer in the Phoenix Park and the resolution of that problem was to stop raising cattle in the Phoenix Park.

Comment on this

Before we do a quick second round, I have one or two questions. Mr. Keegan mostly answered the question I had about the testing, but when we spoke about the renewal of the licence, he referred to asking about how many the person had shot in the previous year. Does the organisation ask about how many samples people have sent off or is there a way of encouraging them, when they are doing their renewals, to prompt them to get TB testing done?

We have been given figures for all over the country. The witnesses will not have the information now, but they might be able to send us on a breakdown, either by county or by deer management area, of the kinds of figure that would be shot each year split across section 42 permits, section 29 licences, the NPWS and any other ones as well.

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

I will just answer the first question. We only ask for the number of deer shot, the species and the sex. We do not look for anything else in relation to TB in the current process.

Comment on this

Would it be worth taking the opportunity to prompt hunters to send a pluck?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Crowley

I am sure it can be considered in the group.

Comment on this

We have ten minutes. There are three people and three minutes quick-fire.

Comment on this

I thank everybody who is here today. I would not envy their task and what they are trying to do. This is something new. Years ago, the people engaged in shooting were doing it for us, unknown to themselves and everybody. There has been an explosion in the deer population. For their own good, there has to be an attempt to reduce the number. They are destroying all of the vegetation in rural and mountainous areas because there are too many and eventually nothing will be left for them. What contingency plans are in place if hunter numbers plateau or decline while the deer population continues to rise? Years ago, everyone I knew had a gun but, as far as I can see, there are now very few people with guns. The three recognised deer organisations opposed extending the male deer season. Why did they disregard the expert advice? What evidence shows that the extension has improved deer management outcomes?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I will take the second question first, if that is okay. There was quite a bit of discussion in an open forum on the deer hunting season with stakeholders, which those organisations also attended.

Comment on this

I am only asking the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

The decision taken was that the hunting season would be extended, in line with the hunting season in Northern Ireland. They would be made uniform. That is what we did. We made the system uniform with Northern Ireland. Ms Crowley might add to that, but that is basically it. That is what we did.

Comment on this

That is grand. That answers my question.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

That was agreed at an open meeting and that is what was said. That is what was done.

Comment on this

Has the strategy group assessed whether intensified hunting pressure is simply displacing deer into new areas and making populations more nocturnal rather than reducing numbers?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I will hand that over to Mr. Keegan.

Comment on this

Mr. Keegan might say something on that because that is all I am getting from farmers.

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

Hunter numbers was the other one.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

Deer hunting is not straightforward. I have been at it all my life. More hunters do not necessarily equal more success. The right type of hunting, targeted hunting, is far better than flooding an area with people who, as the Deputy said, are simply displacing animals. Part of our job is to put the structures in place to create an effective system, get people talking to each other and try to come up with a co-ordinated approach, as opposed to what has happened in the past, whereby people were working in silos on their own and doing their own thing. If we are successful, we will need that to be part of it. We need hunter and landowner buy-in and we need all of the people here today to buy in. We need the committee to push this on the ground. All landowners and stakeholders have to be part of this if it is to be successful.

Comment on this

I have a question on shooting stags. There seems to be an awful lot of people shooting stags.

Comment on this

I need to get to Deputy Cooney.

Comment on this

I again thank the witnesses for coming in. They have outlined their concerns and we have outlined ours. I commend Deputy Michael Healy-Rae. We are all here to support the people we represent and that is very important. It is important we continue to do that. Has any assessment been carried out on the potential consequences of deer management and broader wildlife management activities if the REACH restrictions are met and munition proceeds?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Keegan

I do not know whether anything is in place yet. As far as I know, lead ammunition is still usable. There are copper and other non-lead alternatives which will do the job just the same. The NPWS is using those non-lead alternatives in its culling efforts to quite good effect. Mr. Atkinson may wish to speak on that.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Comer

No decision has been made on that. There has been a move to change what is covered in the REACH piece. Those in the national parks in general have already moved away from lead in parks.

Comment on this
Mr. Wesley Atkinson

In the main national parks we use copper ammunition in rifles. We are ahead on that. It is also informing, as we use it all the time, how it behaves. Our experience in that regard will feed into any of the meetings Ms Comer and others have. We have been using it now for two or three years. It is different and like anything else we have to try new things, but we have been using it for three years now.

Comment on this

Copper has been used for a number of years.

Comment on this
Mr. Wesley Atkinson

For three years.

Comment on this

It appears the use of lead will die out. I presume European legislation is causing this.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Comer

It is European legislation, but there is no position on it at a European level. It has not been decided on in Ireland, as such.

Comment on this

Why was a decision taken to move to copper a number of years ago? My time is nearly up.

Comment on this
Mr. Wesley Atkinson

In the national parks, we are not just managing deer but also habitats and other species, such as large raptors around eagle reintroduction and so on. The gralloch or pluck is left on the ground. A decision was made to take lead as a contaminant out of the system in order to protect species.

Comment on this

I echo what my colleagues have said. Any move to bring deer numbers under control has to be welcomed. Reference was made to Northern Ireland. Is there any need for a deer management strategy group North and South? Do organisations have relationships with the relevant groups in the North?

How would the cost of refrigeration work? Does a hunter pay a fee for storage? What is the design of the system? Is there an incentive for a hunter to take a clipping from a deer's ear after it has been shot and send it in? Has any work been done on that, say, for TB testing? Hunters could have their equipment and as they shoot deer, sample them and stick it in the post - job done. Obviously, there would be a cost but to get proper data, is that the way we have got to do it? What data do the witnesses expect to collect over the next number of years?

Comment on this
Mr. Teddy Cashman

I will take the first question on Northern Ireland. We have had no official contact with the agencies in Northern Ireland. Dr. Barrrett and I visited Baronscourt Estate to understand how it was managing deer and we learned a lot on that trip. That happened at the start of the process and is something we can repeat. We visited the estate to see what it was doing, the scenarios there and to be informed about what is happening over the Border. It is not that we did not engage; we did and have engaged with the estate on a number of issues since then. It is not an official engagement, but we have visited the North and been informed as to what it was doing. I will hand over to Mr. Keane on larders and data collection.

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

On larders, there need be no cost to the hunter. That is the proposal that has gone in on the five fridges. In terms of the incentive piece, we are looking at incentivising hunters to shoot more animals. We can capture any amount of data. Reference has been made to TB, clippings, plucks and other such things. What goes in there is a decision for the Department but the system will allow that. There are two points of data collection. The hunter takes a picture of the deer when it is shot and puts data into the app. The second point is when the deer reaches the factory. We can test for things there.

It is like a double-check. That will help the validation process in terms of the animal, whether female, etc., but also in terms of any payment to a hunter.

In terms of what data we are collecting, species numbers, numbers of deer, locations, etc., we need as much information as we can get. That, hopefully, gives us a baseline going forward.

Comment on this

When would we see that data? Will that be a year?

Comment on this
Mr. Neil Keane

In a year's time. We should have a full year from now. We are in the test phase at the moment. From September coming to September 12 months, we should have a lot of data at that point.

Comment on this

Perfect. I thank Mr. Keane.

Comment on this

Between farmers and road users, there is a wide range of people who are coming across the deer. It has been really helpful to get an understanding of where things are at at the minute with the roll-out of the management plan. There was a lot of useful data presented earlier.

If the witnesses feel there are questions that they did not get the opportunity to answer, I ask them to write in to the committee on it because it is a topic that we will be returning to with a further meeting. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their participation.

Comment on this