We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

Cattle Kill Reduction and Cattle Prices: Meat Industry Ireland

Summary

Meat Industry Ireland told the committee that falling cattle prices are being driven by a sharp supply-and-demand correction in export markets, especially the UK and EU, rather than by a uniquely Irish issue. It said kill numbers are down because of live exports, nitrates constraints and the shrinking suckler herd, while processors are operating at about 80% capacity and facing weaker demand for beef cuts. MII accepted the need for more transparency and said it would comply with the Agri-Food Regulator’s requirements, but rejected claims that processors are freely setting prices or operating a race to the bottom. Members pressed the witnesses on farmer losses, volatility, and whether the industry is passing too much of the market shock back to producers.

Contributions 1–140 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Apologies have been received from Deputy Michael Fitzmaurice. He will be substituted by Deputy Michael Collins. Tá fáilte romhat.

I wish draw to the attention of the witnesses that giving evidence from within the parliamentary precinct, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to the committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on the issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on this matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that members should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members participating online in a committee meeting when their participation is from within the parliamentary precincts. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precincts and any attempt to do so will result in the member having their online access removed. Everybody participating is present in the room. There is no member online at the moment.

The agenda for today's meeting is to examine the cattle kill reduction and cattle prices. Members are going to hear from Meat Industry Ireland. Cuirim fáilte roimh Mr. Philip Carroll, chairman, Mr. Dale Crammond, director, and Ms Síle Sweeney, senior executive. Your opening statements have been circulated and I will give five minutes to go through the opening statement on it. Members particularly wanted this issue on the agenda because a lot of concern has been raised from farmers who have had a range of different difficulties, including the price they are getting in the factory, difficulties booking in cattle and still seeing the numbers of cattle going through reducing. It is really a concern for farmers. They are experiencing an increase in their overheads, whether it is for diesel or manure or a range of different issues. To see a drop in the price even though there seems to be capacity in the factory is very much a concern for farmers. We want to try to get an understanding of where things are going there and how we can make sure it is possible to get the best possible price for farmers on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

I thank the Chair and committee members for the opportunity to speak today about processing throughput and cattle prices in the beef industry. I am the chairman of Meat Industry Ireland, MII. I am joined today by Mr. Dale Crammond, director and by Síle Sweeney, senior executive. MII members operate 28 processing sites nationwide, directly employ more than 12,000 people and support many thousands more jobs across the rural economy.

At the outset it is important to recognise the vital role farmers play in supplying the high-quality raw material that underpins our international success. They deserve to be fully rewarded for that contribution and this was reflected in the historically strong cattle prices seen in recent years, especially in 2025. The falling cattle prices in the early part of this year is a disappointment to the sector, and to farmers in particular, following a period of strong growth. Our members are acutely aware of the challenges this creates at a time when the food and drink sectors face multiple geopolitical economic pressures. We have engaged with the sector to share our perspective and will continue with that dialogue.

The Irish beef sector is export-led with 90% of production sold in international markets. Last year, exports exceeded €3.5 billion, up 23% on 2024 even though volumes were 40,000 tonnes below the average of the past decade. This increase was driven by short-term inflationary market conditions. In the UK market, exports rose in value by 25% to €1.6 billion, representing 40% of total market value despite a decline in UK beef imports. As retail prices continued to rise during 2025 it became evident that demand was being affected with volumes down 7.2% towards the end of the year. High prices effectively stalled beef demand across retail and food services. Meanwhile, imported beef from Australia, New Zealand, Poland and Brazil gained market share. Exports to EU markets rose by 28%, generating a further €1.6 billion in 2025. Demand was strongest for forequarter mince and manufacturing beef, while higher-value primal cuts declined as the price gap between beef and other meats such as pork and poultry became more evident. Exports to other international markets fell to €135 million as buyers focused on sourcing closer to home. This reflected a widening gap on price between Ireland and the EU compared with international suppliers.

These export trends underlined an important point that any discussion of domestic cattle prices or kill numbers must be grounded in global market conditions, consumer purchasing power and structural change within the national herd. Last year cattle throughput fell by over 200,000 head. According to the latest Department of agriculture and Central Statistics Office, CSO, figures the beef kill in the first quarter of 2026 was some 72,000 head lower than in the same period in 2025. That is a contraction of 18.7%. The main factors driving the current supply-side vacuum are the lag effects of live exports and nitrates constraints. In 2023 and 2024 Ireland saw record live cattle and weanling exports exceeding 300,000 head annually. Those animals are now being processed in the Netherlands, Spain and Italy rather than in Irish plants. Dairy bred animals now account for over 60% of the total beef kill. However, the nitrates derogation and implementation of dairy banding have forced many farmers to reduce stock numbers or exit beef finishing entirely in order to remain compliant with nitrates. Alongside the decline of the suckler herd this has effectively placed a hard cap on cattle availability in 2026. We are conscious that winter finishing challenges were more acute this year when finishers were caught in a market correction that moved faster and further than anybody in the supply chain could have anticipated, including processors. Farmers made decisions in the autumn based on market signals that looked reasonable at the time. High input costs, with concentrate feed still 25% above the five-year average, discouraged many producers from winter finishing.

Without price certainty to cover meal and energy costs, the spring supply gap coincided with weaker demand in the UK and the EU, putting further pressure on price.

Irish cattle prices reached historic highs in 2025, driven by genuine supply tightness and strong international retailer demand. The resulting price increases affected demand and made Europe and the UK targets for third-country imports. Competitiveness in our primary markets is now under severe threat from a perfect storm of international factors. The UK market has shifted. Historically, Ireland provided nearly 80% of UK beef imports. Following the UK-Australia and UK-New Zealand free trade agreements, and growth in Polish and Brazilian imports, Ireland's market share fell to 67% in 2025. Australian beef imports into the UK have surged by over 400%, offering a significantly lower-cost alternative to Irish grass-fed beef. There is little scope for us to price ourselves out of this market, nor can we diversify to greener fields where none exist. As a result, our industry is facing a carcase imbalance driven by consumer behaviour. The latest Kantar figures from April show we are experiencing a volume decline in beef steaks and joints by 37% and 70%, respectively, as consumers trade down to cheaper proteins, such as poultry, pork or lower-value manufacturing beef. When prime cuts, which account for 30% of the animal, fail to achieve a premium price, the value of the whole carcase falls. In this market, processors are price-takers competing against lower-cost international suppliers.

Beef processing is a high-volume, low-margin business. When throughput drops by 19%, fixed costs per unit, including labour, energy, refrigeration, transport and regulatory compliance, increase sharply. Running a plant at 80% capacity is significantly less efficient than running at 100%. Despite these pressures, the prime Irish composite beef price closely tracks the export benchmark price. This demonstrates that Irish cattle prices are on a par with our European competitors despite the additional cost of exporting 90% of our beef output.

The 2025-26 cattle supply reduction is a structural reality rooted in dairy sector changes and previous export trends. Cattle prices, while lower than last year's historic anomalies, remain high by long-term standards but are under intense pressure from shifts in consumer spending and aggressive new trade competition. MII remains committed to the long-term viability of Irish beef farming. We recognise the value of farmers' work and the pressure they face when market prices fall and costs remain high. The beef sector is not unique in this regard. Similar challenges have recently affected the dairy and tillage sectors. The strong returns paid to farmers in recent years reflect the sector's dependence on their continued commitment. We aim to remain competitive within the UK and EU markets. We must continue working together to ensure the Irish beef brand remains both premium and competitive in an increasingly crowded global market. I thank the committee. We are happy to take any questions.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Carroll for his comprehensive opening statement. It is a beautiful, sunny day, and I know members would like to be out in it, but they are here to question the witnesses because they are very concerned about farmers' concerns about the beef price. Members made it their business to be here on the sunniest day of the year. I thank them for taking part.

We will do seven-minute slots per member. We will open with Deputy Aird.

Comment on this

We can start with Deputy Collins

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want to give over his time?

Comment on this

Just the first slot. Deputy Collins has to go to another meeting.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Aird and the Chairman, and I welcome the witnesses. I have a few brief questions. In light of less tonnage of beef being exported and a record monetary value for the tonnage exported, why are farmers being hit with €1.20 less per kilo for cattle slaughtered?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

The Deputy is asking about delays in sending cattle for slaughter.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Does the Deputy want me to answer?

Comment on this

Yes, please, if Mr. Carroll does not mind.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

They have to some extent. I have heard a lot about it and have spoken to the farm organisations around this particular issue. When we talk to members, they tell us that while there are delays, they are not lengthy and they do not arise in all processing plants. The problem was a little more difficult four to five weeks ago but it has been ameliorated quite considerably. In large part, the issue we face in the sector is one where the supply chain is not functioning. What is happening is what always happens and is always the case in a regular market scenario when a market is relatively stable. We have sufficient capacity. As I indicated earlier, we are working at about 80% capacity at the moment. We would normally be working in the first quarter of the year at full capacity. We can cope with that in all circumstances except when the market is not functioning. That is what is happening at the moment. There is no cold store in the country that has capacity for processed product. I had that fully verified yesterday and again this morning. What you do when you are processing is to process to contracts. The contracts are not there at the moment at the level they would normally be expected to be because our output going into the UK has dropped by 10%. That is the problem we are facing at the moment. We expect that position to work its way through the system over the next short while. We also know that production is likely to scale back for the next short while. We hope that balance will be there. However, I do not think the problem is as great or as comprehensive across the country as has been suggested.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Carroll. Why are EU cattle prices €1 per kilogram ahead of what Ireland is paid?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

We always face a challenge exporting into these markets. We are the number one exporter into many of the markets, including the UK. There will always be a premium for UK beef produced in the UK market under the Red Tractor brand so our objective is to try to maintain that position as the number one importer. We still very much are in that space. However, as Mr. Carroll said, we are coming under more pressure from imports, particularly from the likes of Australia, imports from which have soared by over 400%. It now has an unrestricted quota of approximately 30,000 tonnes per annum, and that is going to grow over the next 15 years. After 15 years, that trade is going to be fully liberalised. We have long-term challenges exporting into the UK market.

If you look at the price tracker across the board, we are running approximately 20 cent behind EU prices at the moment in the prime composite price versus the export benchmark price. That is where it should be. The price does not include the cost of transport for getting that product to the European markets. There should be a deficit there in terms of the price we are achieving. Last year, we ran ahead of the EU price and that was solely down to a bit of concern in the marketplace around supply. There was a lot of concern that there were going to be cattle constraints in Australia, the US and other markets. There probably was a bit of panic buying last year and we benefited from that. Because we are the first importer of choice, we were able to reap the benefit.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I read the opening statement. Like the Cathaoirleach, I acknowledge that it is a lovely day outside. However, there are very dark clouds over the whole beef industry.

I will open my remarks by sharing some statistics for where we are at the moment. This time last year, bulls were achieving €7.95 per kg. I know of bulls that were killed on Monday for €6.70. Today, the price quoted is €6.40. That particular person and farmer, an ordinary individual, like the witnesses, me or anybody else who is farming, can see what they are losing.

I will share another statistic. Look at cattle bought in during October or November, say at €2,420. When they were sold in March, they went for €20 less at €2,400. Those cattle had to be fed at a cost of €350 a head. That €350 is for nothing other than food. Those farmers are down €350 per head.

What is the traditional family farmer, who we are always talking about, to do? Here is a family farmer who traditionally had a suckler herd. Last year, everyone was in good humour and they got a great price with it. Now we are being told that was a flip. I know people who got bulled heifers back into the game again and were delighted with themselves and they are now back to square one or maybe even in a worse position than they ever were.

Take what is happening now. We have the factories coming in contract rearing where I, as a farmer, can just rear the calves for the farmer and that is the way it is going. Where is family farmer going to be? The old, traditional way is going to die completely because there is so much volatility in the market that no single farmer can carry that burden. We see will see it today.

We talk about being Bord Bia audited. For what? Now look at the market being flooded with Australian beef, Brazilian beef and everything. None of them are audited. We are audited here, producing the best beef and now we are getting a slap in the face with our beef losing €350 and €400 a head. I want the people to understand the pressure that is out there at the moment and the human mental pressure this is causing people. I want to ask a few questions but I am giving that from the heart, speaking on behalf of people I have spoken to who are at their wits' end for the last three weeks. These are young farmers we are encouraging into farming. They are in such a volatile market that the witnesses cannot tell me where we will be this time next year. Nobody can tell us. Nobody could tell us that beef would be at the price it is today. I had a quotation at €6.40 and going down. If I asked where it was going to stop, the witnesses will not be able to tell me. Nobody would be able to. That is the market we are living in and that is the way these people are being asked to farm.

I want to ask a couple of question. If cattle prices are historically strong, can the witnesses specify clearly what proportion of the retail beef price is actually returning to the primary producer, the farmer, versus retained, processing and retail margins? Can I have a quick answer to that because I do not have much time?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Is Deputy Aird asking what proportion of the retail price is going back to the farmer?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

I do not have a calculation for that figure. However, let me come back to where Deputy Aird started and I will try to work my way around to answering that question. The Deputy has given us exactly what our assessment is of where we see this market. He has talked about volatility. Volatility is acutely extreme at the moment in this short period of one year. It has gone from a situation where at the end of 2024, which the Deputy will remember from the farming-----

Comment on this

I am sorry but I have to ask the second question.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

No, but I just want to-----

Comment on this

I cannot waste my time. I will be honest. I have three minutes left and I know exactly what Mr. Carroll is going to say to me.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Deputy Aird has talked out all the issues and I am trying to explain to him that it is exactly what we are feeling in the market. What we are seeing in the market is a complete downturn in the value that is coming at processing level from retailers, wholesalers and other buyers.

Comment on this

Mr. Carroll can see what has happened because they are bringing it in without it being Bord Bia audited. They do not have to do that.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

The impact of the euro-----

Comment on this

I apologise. I want to ask the next question.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Can I just answer the question?

Comment on this

No, I am sorry but I do not want the answer from that.

Comment on this

I will give Deputy Aird-----

Comment on this

Is the Chair going to give me extra time?

Comment on this

I will give Deputy Aird extra time to give Mr. Carroll a chance to answer.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair because I have ten questions to ask here today. Be fair to me. I have ten serious questions to ask on behalf of the people out there.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

I am happy to step in. If you look at the work the Agri-Food Regulator has done over recent times, we have had very significant engagement. There is a lot of publicly available information now that shows the selling price of the beef leaving the factory. If you look at what has happened, the hindquarter selling price has declined from about €9.64 last September to about €8.75 today. That is closely matching the fall and the decline in cattle prices over that period. The forequarter is the same, albeit it has not quite declined at the same rate. That is because most of the high-value cuts, as the Deputy knows, are from the hindquarter. We are seeing challenges now in the manufacturing beef market also. Those forequarter prices are going to fall back. That is the evidence that shows the challenges in the marketplace at the moment.

Comment on this

That is grand. Can I go onto my second question or is the Chair giving me more time? I have the answer to that.

Comment on this

Keep going. Deputy Aird is within time.

Comment on this

I got that answer. The farmers are losing €350 to €375. How much is the factory losing? That is the answer I will give back. My second question is that given that MII represents 28 processors, how does it respond to repeated farmer concerns that a small number of processors effectively set the price in a highly concentrated market? What is MII's answer to that? Yes or no?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Processors follow market signals. If we look at 2025, and the Deputy should not say it is not relevant, because it is, the Deputy saw where the prices went from €5 to €7.50 or thereabouts.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

That was following what was happening in the market. So, the proportion of payback to farmers is represented in those historically high figures. The exact opposite happened at the beginning of this year, where those wholesale prices dropped back quite significantly along the lines of the figures Mr. Crammond mentioned. There was a proportionate response to that in the marketplace. We must bear in mind that every European country, including the UK that is not in the European Union, has seen the same fallback in prices that we have. This is not uniquely Irish. This is European. It is across the globe.

Comment on this

It is about bringing in beef.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Everybody is doing the same thing in the market at the moment because everyone is facing the same market environment.

Comment on this

I want to acknowledge publicly the work the live exporters do in this country and thank them for the work they do. We sent out over 300,000 cattle out of this country this year and I do not have the figure for the calf exports but I can tell you-----

Comment on this

Use the extra time for questions.

Comment on this

I was just saying that. Farmers will argue at the moment that the recent price drop was sudden and severe. What specific actions did processors take to avoid passing volatility disproportionately onto the primary producer, namely, the farmer?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

We acknowledge the challenges in the marketplace at the moment. That is very clear. If we look at the sheep price and where it is at, it has continued to go very high. That is in response to market demand. We have the Eid festival at the end of the year. The exact opposite is happening in the beef sector recently. The demand simply is not there. There is beef going into cold storage at the moment. As Mr. Carroll said in his opening statement, we have seen beef steaks and beef joints decline by 37% and 70%. That is really significant to what has happened in the marketplace. The consumer has ultimately pushed back against the high price of beef in Europe and the UK and we are seeing a market correction at the moment. That is the basic reality of what has happened. That is difficult. We understand it is very difficult for finishers at the moment. They obviously had a very good year last year when prices went up very high and it is a very difficult year for them at the moment.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Crammond take half his salary next year? No, he would not. Does he know what I mean?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

That is a bit of an irrelevant question.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

It is. We acknowledge the difficulties the farmers are facing.

Comment on this

We are losing €350 this year and Mr. Crammond is telling us we made it last year, which we did not, as it was up around €200 last year. We are, therefore, in a negative situation straight away. My next question is, will MII commit to full, real-time transparency on pricing formulas, contract structures and export returns so farmers can independently verify how prices are set?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Yes.

Comment on this

Yes, is the answer. That is fair enough.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

That is right through the regulator and the regulator will have additional powers next year and we will comply with that. We have complied with every request that has come from the regulator and that can be independently verified as well.

Comment on this

If 90% of the beef was exported, how does MII justify the claim that Irish cattle prices are fully market effective when Irish farmers have no meaningful domestic price-setting influence?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

We do export 90% of the beef. The Deputy is right. Therefore, we are very reliant on what that market demand is in the international marketplace. It will not be driven by what is happening here domestically. It will be driven by what is happening in the main market. Forty-eight percent of our beef goes to the UK and 48% goes to the EU. We have a very small percentage that goes to third-country markets outside that. By and large, the price of beef and what we get is determined by that marketplace, not how many cattle we kill here domestically and not the other issues Deputy Aird is making reference to. It is the marketplace in Europe and the UK in the main.

Comment on this

I have five more questions.

Comment on this

The time Deputy Collins did not use has been consumed now. I call Deputy Kenny.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair and I thank the witnesses for their work. I want to acknowledge that 90% of the beef produced in Ireland is exported and that is a huge volume of product we are exporting all over the world, which is bringing huge income into the country and creating a lot of jobs in the country as well. We want to acknowledge that, of course. There are a number of issues around all of this. In 2025, prices went up considerably for the farmer. It also went up for the consumer. We have seen that in the shops as well. Clearly, that is because there was a scarcity.

It was not just scarcity of cattle in Ireland but across Europe and the world. It pushed the price up. When prices go up, demand starts to come down at some point. Have we reached that equilibrium where demand is low and pulling prices back down? Is that what is happening, or has the volume of product from other places started to rise?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

That is where the competitiveness has come into it. It is a new level of competitiveness. The way the Deputy has analysed that is exactly the way the market has moved over that period. One of the key issues with any commodity is that if the price goes up as quickly and as sharply as it did in 2025, there has to be a ceiling. It hit the ceiling probably around July or August last year, when retailers started to adjust their purchasing strategies. That meant there were far fewer promotions of the beef product itself. By not supporting the beef sector, they were piling a cost on the consumer and the consumer reacted to that. From then on, we had high prices and volumes reduced significantly. The level of demand reduced but the price at the retail counter did not reduce. That affordability issue hit very sharply towards the end of the year. We could see trends in that but, coming back to the Deputy's question, we could not anticipate the drop that was going to happen.

The Deputy is also correct that I cannot tell him what a price will be next week or the week after. We do not yet know how long it will take to get that balance back into the market. That balance is very much dependent on what wholesalers and retailers do in the market on the pricing structure, and how that then impacts the consumer. In polls on consumer attitudes, 49% of consumers in Ireland have said that they are buying less beef. In the UK, it is about 45%. The figure is similar - I forget exactly what it is - across European markets. When we look at the French, Dutch, German, Italian and Polish markets in particular, all of those prices have dropped significantly since the beginning of the year, as ours did, too. That is telling us that this is a European and even a global problem. We can trace it back to where we see that, if the Deputy wishes.

Comment on this

The problem is that the price is dropping for the farmer but the cost of inputs has remained high and is likely going to remain high. We see the price of fertiliser climbing through the roof. We have a crisis in our suckler sector. I am from a part of the country where there is very little dairy and it is mainly suckler. We produce the weanlings that go to the better parts of the country, are fattened and produce the beef. Farmers have been getting a decent price up to now. That is starting to fall back but the input costs have not fallen and will not be falling.

What is going to be done? We are going to have fewer cattle, as was acknowledged in the opening statement. The volume is going down, yet we have high prices. If the prices start to drop, the volume is going to drop through the floor. That is an issue for everybody in the room, farmers and processors.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

The Deputy touched on the sucklers in that context. Suckler levels have been in decline, probably at a rate of 3% over a considerable number of years, and there has been a 5% reduction over the last few years. The first time that stabilised was 2025. That was directly related to the price, or at least we believe that was the case. Through the Food Vision process, although they have not been finalised yet, we think we have agreed some work streams around the suckler supports that are required to maintain the herd at that level. We do not believe we are going to have a major supply shock on our side. It depends very much on the vulnerability we have in the existing markets. The reality about those markets is that no matter what way we look at it, we are selling a commodity into international markets. We are not the first importer. We probably are the first importer in the UK, but the UK will always favour its own product first. The very same happens in any other country. We have no internal market of substance like other countries. We are always the second importer. For the first time now, because of the volumes coming in from Australia, New Zealand, Brazil, Poland and all the other places I mentioned, we are now more vulnerable to lower cost product coming in. The evidence of that is in the figures we mentioned earlier, the 10% decline. It is difficult but the plus side is that what happens in China and the US also affects those importers into the UK. If those markets opened up a little bit more, importers would concentrate on those markets instead of the European markets. That is probably where we will get the stability back into the market.

Comment on this

Meat Industry Ireland represents 28 processors. Many of them also have processing plants in the UK and other countries. An issue that farmers continually bring up is that those plants can be used to control the prices. When prices get high in Ireland, they can source their product from somewhere else to the detriment of the Irish farmer, without whom, because of the volume of beef we produce here, many of the processors would not exist in the first place. Does Mr. Carroll understand that problem? We have a food regulator that looks after the situation in Ireland. Unfortunately, a lot of the companies in Ireland have operations elsewhere that the food regulator has no view over.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

Looking at the marketplace, the Deputy is right that many of the Irish processors have operations in the UK as well. They are still processing----

Comment on this

And as far away as Latin America.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

They are still all processing domestic cattle in the main, in the UK market and the Irish market. They are exposed to the vagaries of the marketplace in the very same way as our processors are here. I do not see the issue there, to be honest. The cattle are being processed domestically. We will continue to try to return the best value to the farmer. It is not in anyone's interest to see beef prices go down the way they have over the last couple of weeks. We got to a stage last year when there was a lot of positivity in the sector. We were engaging with Teagasc and looking at updating some kind of roadmap in terms of profitable suckler beef systems of production. We all want that and we very much value the suckler herd in terms of that quality beef it is putting into the system.

Comment on this

How will it compete with the others? How is the suckler herd going to compete with dairy and other sectors? It is really backs to the wall.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

It does compete. Certain markets really demand that product, such as the Italian market in terms of protected geographical indication, PGI, and what we sell into that marketplace. That suckler beef is really valued. We are not in a position to say we prefer one beef over the other. The reality is that 60% of our beef now is coming from the dairy herd and we have to respect that also. It is about marketing all those cattle, sending them to the best markets possible, returning the best price to the farmer, and hoping the public supports can close that gap, as has probably been the case over the last 20 to 30 years.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in today. We have talked about this in this room before and I have talked about it all my life. Farmers, unfortunately, are price-takers and always have been. For the sake of argument and playing devil's advocate, one could say that the man Deputy Aird talked about gave €350 too much to the store but he gave it in good faith. How can we predict what is happening for the farmer going forward? The processors our witnesses represent have contracts. If I sign any kind of contract in business or whatever, there is a price agreed as well as a tonnage or whatever agreed. When do the goalposts move? If you sign a contract to supply beef to a supermarket, a multinational like Tesco, a different country or whatever, you sign a contract for X amount of tonnage at so much per tonne, kilogram or pound. You get less money next week but you are supplying the same contract. When do the goalposts move? When does that price change? How come we cannot predict it and say that, when the contract runs out, the price is going to be renegotiated? It could be on the Agriland website next week that major contract renegotiation is going to happen at the end of July with China, Japan or whoever and there is potential that beef prices might fluctuate and the farmer would get some kind of forewarning.

I ask the witnesses to clarify something. They have these fixed contracts going forward at a fixed price but they still bring down the price every week, depending on whatever whim or humour they are in on a Monday morning.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

I do not think that is the case.

Comment on this

Mr. Carroll should know. It is not a question of whether he thinks it is; he should know.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

I am told that is not the case. Let me put it that way. There are significant contracts among different processors with farmer finishers in particular. We deal with the finishers to a large extent. We do not know what the nature of those contracts are because that is a commercial matter for individual companies. One is not going to find that between a farmer and a processor nor a processor and a retailer. That is off territory, from our perspective here. I can tell the Senator that there are significant contracts but not all farmers want contracts. Not all farmers look for contracts.

Comment on this

I am not talking about farmers having contracts. I am talking about the processors having contracts that they are-----

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

The processor contracts are the very same. They do have all of the things, I suspect, that the Senator has suggested they have in the contracts. One of the key things they have is a supply contract for a particular period, probably at a particular price. When the market situation changes, then there have to be adjustments. As the Senator said, one cannot produce to a contract, the value of which was formulated in the early stages, and expect when the entire market explodes, as it does, that one can continue to do that. The way in which that was represented back to farmers was that clearly processors had to meet those contracts but what they had to do in 2025 was compete for the animals, which is what drove up the price. The farmer got the return from the competition that was going on between the processors, retailers, wholesalers, and buyers generally. That is how it is reflected back.

Comment on this

What contracts and markets have been lost? We must take into consideration the fact that the number of animals being killed every year is down. The CSO announced today that it is down by 14.8%. The type of animal is a younger animal or a dairy-bred animal. That means the tonnage must be way down. Have we lost major contracts? If so, how come that is not being publicised? We are hearing a good news story every year about our beef exports. According to Bord Bia, everything is up, we have new markets and trade missions going all over the world and they are all bringing back good news but we are killing lower numbers of smaller cattle in tonnage terms. If we talk about tonnage and forget about financial yield and animal numbers, our beef exports are way down. Is that what the witnesses are telling us?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

The volume of beef exports is down. That is very clear and the statistics show that. Carcase weights increased last year on the back of the good prices, I suspect. Farmers kept cattle a little bit longer so the average carcase weights were up.

Comment on this

Our suckler numbers are way down and we are depending on dairy-bred beef, so I would imagine carcase weights are not -----

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

They were up by about 25 kilos, on average, across the industry. That helped in offsetting some of the reduced throughput. We lost 213,000 animals from the kill last year. We are down about 70,000 so far this year. The Bord Bia prediction is that we will come out somewhere near where we were last year, at about 1.59 million animals. However, a lot of that will depend on what happens the market in the second half of the year and whether we can get some buoyancy back into the marketplace.

Comment on this

Is there no way of predicting what might happen to the market? We hear about hedging and fuel prices and that good, progressive companies have their fuel prices hedged. Can it not be predicted what will happen going forward?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

It really is difficult to try to predict what the market is going to be. If we all knew that, we might all be in very different roles. Price is a supply and demand issue. We have to understand that the market is very transient. What the market is like today may be very different in two months.

Comment on this

Is there a race to the bottom within the market?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

No, absolutely not.

Comment on this

How come we hear about Irish quality beef being displaced by what we know is coming from Brazil? Is there a race to the bottom within the market? Quality does not seem to matter any more.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

We do not know how much product is being displaced by Brazil. We are starting to see an increase in southern hemisphere beef coming into the UK. We have seen some of the UK retailers trial that beef. They have got on all right with it. The margins are very small. The concern is that they will look to grow that over time but as Mr. Carroll said, we operate in a global marketplace. China now has a 55% tariff on Brazilian beef going into that country above a certain quota level. That is going to create a short term challenge over the next two years but that-----

Comment on this

Our quality maintained us for a long time.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

Of course it did.

Comment on this

It sounds like it is gone now. That is not going to be-----

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

I disagree. Now more than ever we have to really look at what got us to that place in the first place and really focus on brand Ireland and Irish beef.

Comment on this

Can we not command a premium price for a premium product?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

That is the objective in the marketplace to try to compete against these cheaper imports. We will continue to try to do that but the consumer-----

Comment on this

However, we seem to be lowering to the price of the inferior quality product. We are going down and fighting them in the muck, in the gutter.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

The inferior quality product undoubtedly has had an impact but the bigger issue is consumer sentiment and consumer challenges. We are in a cost-of-living crisis. In the UK, the situation is very difficult. The consumer has moved away from beef. That is the reality. If we look at consumer sentiment and the work Bord Bia has done through its survey, 70% of consumers say that they want to purchase more beef over the next year or two. There is positive sentiment there but it is going to have to be at a price point that has been lower than the price we saw last year. That is what the market reality is telling us.

Comment on this

I have a question on cattle that come in for slaughter where it is discovered that they potentially have had TB. Inspectors find lesions and the farmer does not get anything for the animal. The State pays the farmer for the cost of whatever number of cattle come in. What actually happens to that herd or to whatever number of animals are suspected of having TB? What happens to the meat? Does it go into cold storage? Does it get used for something else?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

I am not 100% sure of that. I know there is an insurance scheme that farmers can opt into so that if certain animals are condemned in the factory, the farmer will get paid for those animals. That certainly happens. There is a scheme there under which the farmer will get paid. At certain times we will see that six or seven kilos might get trimmed off a carcase if there is a lesion. That is removed. Again, the farmer should get paid for that.

Comment on this

Yes, and they do get paid, whether it is through the insurance or through the State. My question is about what happens to the meat. We know it is fine for human consumption. It is not dangerous, if an animal has TB. Do Mr. Carroll know what happens to that meat?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Is the Senator asking what happens to the meat?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

The meat can be sold.

Comment on this

Does the factory get it?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

The meat can be sold in the market.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

I am not sure.

Comment on this

The witnesses can come back to us on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

I presume it is used in the market but we can come back and clarify that.

Comment on this

I would appreciate that.

Comment on this

Could the witnesses verify and clarify that? They can come back to us on it later.

Comment on this

The factory does not pay for it. It is the insurance or the State that is paying for the cattle and the factory gets-----

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

I think so but I will double-check that. It is a detail that I do not-----

Comment on this

The witnesses should know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

We will find out. We will get the answer for the committee.

Comment on this

The Department pays the difference in the price.

Comment on this

If the answer is not immediately there, the witnesses can follow up with the committee.

Comment on this

It is out there.

Comment on this

That meat is still going on the shelf but they are not paying for it.

Comment on this

They pay less for it. Whatever the animal is valued at, they pay less and the Department-----

Comment on this

But the consumer does not know.

Comment on this

No, the consumer does not know.

Comment on this

If the witnesses could get back to us and clarify that-----

Comment on this

Please come back to the committee with clarity on that point, rather than the uncertainty, back and forth.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Can I just make it clear-----

Comment on this

It is a hugely important point.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

There is no-----

Comment on this

One moment, please. It is a hugely important point to clarify. If there is uncertainty on it, we want to remove that. If it is not going to be clarified here and now, immediately, that is okay. The witnesses can send on the information to us and we can get clarity on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

We will do that, of course, but it is an issue of clarity around the pay system relating to a reactor animal but there is no food safety issue.

Comment on this

No, and that is not what I was getting at.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

I thought that might have been what the Senator was suggesting.

Comment on this

No. The question was more around who was benefiting-----

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Fair enough.

Comment on this

-----from that animal.

That is really my question.

I could be wrong in my figures and my understanding of this. The witnesses might just clarify. They are saying there was 14.5% less. Sorry, I have lots of figures written down and I do not know what they are for. They were saying to Senator Daly there was 14.5%-----

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

Sorry, wait and I will see if we can-----

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

The drop in weight.

Comment on this

Yes. There was 14.5% less in the kill. Am I correct in saying that the exports are not 14.5% down? Is there a slight variation in them?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

Exports have fallen as well. Obviously, there are fewer cattle being exported.

Comment on this

Is it by 14.5%? Is it the same as what the kill is?

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

What might be confusing about this is that the kill level, or processing level, was down 14%, that is, the volume, but the price was higher. The value in 2025 was higher by somewhere between €550 million and €600 million. That is probably where that confusion lies. That is directly attributed to the price that the product was sold for. Notwithstanding that we were selling less product, the value of what was sold last year was greater than it would otherwise have been had we been at a higher level.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

If you look at the performance this year in January and February, in terms of the statistics we have, the export values increased by 7% but the volumes declined by 11%.

Comment on this

Going from last week's announcement by the EU where it took Brazil off the safe imports list, if it is a thing the Irish Government decides to follow suit on and decides not to take it, might it change our market if Brazilian beef is taken off? Will it rectify quicker than we are hoping? I know we still have others importing into us.

Comment on this
Mr. Philip Carroll

There are two parts to that. The first is the volumes that are going into the UK, which is different, as the Senator knows, from the EU. We do not know whether they will follow that course. The other part of that from an EU perspective is the Mercosur agreement kicks in and it will directly impact that. We will have to wait and see what happens in September and whether the Commission enforces what is a provisional threat at present.

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

The way I would describe it is the Mercosur is a very significant threat. We stood shoulder to shoulder with the farm organisations in opposing that agreement, but it is probably not the main short-term threat, as I would see it. That is probably driven just by the increase in Polish imports coming into the EU and the increase in Australian imports coming in. In the short term, they probably will be a bigger challenge. In the long term-----

Comment on this

Very quickly, with my last-----

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

-----Brazil will certainly come back on the agenda.

Comment on this

There only a few months from now until September. Will Brazil hugely up its exports to us to get as much in as possible?

Comment on this
Mr. Dale Crammond

Obviously, it is not able to export at the moment because it is not meeting the phytosanitary rules. The Commission is reviewing that at the moment. I imagine that Brazil is working hard to try and justify. That will be challenging. That is really a matter for the EU Commission in terms of the decision it makes ultimately around that and we will have to abide by that decision.

Comment on this