Cattle Kill Reduction and Cattle Prices: Meat Industry Ireland
Meat Industry Ireland told the committee that falling cattle prices are being driven by a sharp supply-and-demand correction in export markets, especially the UK and EU, rather than by a uniquely Irish issue. It said kill numbers are down because of live exports, nitrates constraints and the shrinking suckler herd, while processors are operating at about 80% capacity and facing weaker demand for beef cuts. MII accepted the need for more transparency and said it would comply with the Agri-Food Regulator’s requirements, but rejected claims that processors are freely setting prices or operating a race to the bottom. Members pressed the witnesses on farmer losses, volatility, and whether the industry is passing too much of the market shock back to producers.
Contributions 141–280 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I will add a bit to the Senator's question around Brazil. We possibly could have been in a worse situation than we currently are, and that is bad enough, were it the case that Trump had maintained his tariffs on Brazil, which were at 50% and he reduced to 10%. That brought Brazil back into the US on greater volume. Had it not been reversed, we could have been more vulnerable.
Comment on this
Let us keep asking him to reduce those tariffs so.
Comment on this
Am I correct that for farmers or whoever brings cattle to the processing plant in their jeeps and trailers or whatever, the meat is processed and it goes back out on a refrigerator truck?
Comment on this
It gets loaded onto a refrigerator truck and goes out to wherever it is going. It is packed and whatever. Am I right in saying that refrigerator trucks come back into the factory, and that they bring meat into the processing factory in refrigerator trucks?
Comment on this
I would not have thought so, no. They come in on cattle transport.
Comment on this
What I am told is that refrigerator trucks are coming in loaded up, they are being unloaded, and they are being loaded back up again and back out.
Comment on this
With what? What are they coming in with?
Comment on this
Mr. Carroll is telling me this is not happening. I am told that this is happening in plants.
Comment on this
What may happen and what may confuse this is that within companies that have multiple facilities, and they may slaughter animals and dress them into quarters. In other words, they do not debone in the plant within which they slaughter. They will put the carcases on a truck and they will send it to one of their own plants. That is all permitted and it is all done under the control of the veterinary staff in the Department. They have deboning capacity greater than what they require in that second plant and what they do is move it to that second plant, which means they have consolidated their boning and are more efficient in their production.
Comment on this
It is processed and brought back out again.
Comment on this
That is all that is. If people are seeing something else in that, they are completely wrong.
Comment on this
Okay. I am also hearing that there is a mad rush on a Friday evening to go around and collect up meat. If they are in such a hurry to get the meat onto the boat on a Friday evening, and we are saying that our exports are down, a lot of the truck drivers that I am speaking to are wondering why they are driving all over the countryside collecting meat to bring it back out if there is such a decline in exports because they are not seeing it. I am wondering when those trucks go out, wherever they go to whatever country, are they coming back empty or are they bringing back meat? Are they consolidating the costs of driving out there and rather than driving back empty, they are bringing back more meat when they are coming back?
Comment on this
Friday evening is a very busy period for any meat processor because they are rushing out to meet the weekend demand. Thursday evening and Friday evening are the two busiest evenings of the week in terms of meat processing. The volumes are still going out. They are just reduced from what they were. What comes back on those trucks is a matter for the hauliers. I would not be 100% clear. I suspect any haulier involved will try to be as efficient as possible in terms of maximising backloads. They are certainly not bringing back meat.
Comment on this
On that, we will talk about Poland. I know this because it involves a friend of a Polish man. He asked for a break for the weekend. His friend was coming over from Poland with a Polish truck full of meat. It was coming in on a Friday evening, it was being processed and was back out on a Sunday. It was stamped and labelled in Ireland and everything, and had gone out. I do not know whether it was Bord Bia stamped but it was processed in Ireland and back out. Have the witnesses heard of that happening? Is it still happening?
Comment on this
I cannot imagine in any circumstances something like that happening given the fact that-----
Comment on this
Fine, if the Deputy says so. I will not disbelieve what she is saying. However, I could not imagine it, and we would not know about what would happen in any event in that situation. I do not think that would be reasonable for us, understandably.
Comment on this
I do not think anybody is going to give me a straight answer on it anyway.
Comment on this
I am telling the Deputy and I am giving her a straight answer. I do not know anything about such an incident having occurred. How could I? If, however, that is coming back from a European country-----
Comment on this
----- which is what we are talking about, and if that is going back into an Irish processing plant, that is controlled by the Department of agriculture veterinary staff. If there is any illegal element to that which may be asserted by the question, then that will be dealt with by the Department. I cannot imagine it happening because the Department is there from the moment the plant opens, at 7 a.m., before animals go into the lairage to the last light going out. There is a chief vet on site.
Comment on this
In general, do factories work a seven-day week or what is the story there?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy is taking about the weekend?
Comment on this
Yes. Do the factories work weekends?
Comment on this
They will work weekends when there is an overtime agreement with veterinary staff and when there is a necessity, obviously. I do not think it is happening at the moment, given the volume. I cannot imagine that it is.
Comment on this
Okay. It has come to my attention that there are a lot of cars in car parks. I wonder why the cars would be there at the weekend if things are on a go-slow approach.
Comment on this
There could be maintenance going on at weekends.
Comment on this
I would not think there would be that many cars for maintenance.
Comment on this
I do not know because I do not know the details of what the Deputy is talking about.
Comment on this
I am just bringing it to Mr. Carroll's attention and asking if anybody knows.
Bord Bia conducts audits of processor members, such as those under the meat processor quality assurance scheme. Are those audits announced or unannounced?
Comment on this
To be honest with the Deputy, I do not know.
Comment on this
When HIQA goes into nursing homes, some visits are announced and some visits are unannounced. What is the percentage? With one plant, would it only be a question of if something was happening that was underhanded-----
Comment on this
It is all to do with meat factories.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy talking about meat plants in particular? Is she asking about the Bord Bia audits of meat plants?
Comment on this
Stop for one moment. Our focus is on the numbers going through, the volume and the price. That is what the witnesses are briefed to come in on.
Comment on this
Okay. We will go back to the price. I will not get an answer to the Bord Bia question. They should be unannounced, by right. By announcing the audits, you do not get the same level of transparency. I suppose I cannot ask a question on the Food Safety Authority either, can I?
Comment on this
It is not today's brief but if the Deputy wishes, it can be communicated to the witnesses. I need to move onto Deputy Lawless.
Comment on this
I have one more question on offal.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses before us. The central issue is not necessarily price but price volatility for farmers. Price volatility is creating major financial exposure for farmers because farmers are making commitments months or years in advance about purchasing cattle, buying store cattle, committing to winter feeding, fertiliser and all of the input costs that arise. All of a sudden, the factories combined and collectively pulled the prices. That is leaving enormous financial exposure on farmers. We talk about sustainability across every single sector but the only man we do not talk about, in terms of making his business sustainable, is the farmer. It is shocking that we are doing this. Every few years, it happens. We had a good year last year and farmers invested heavily in farming systems, purchasing cattle and so on. This year, we are back to square one.
The saddest thing is that I know farmers who have purchased at very high prices and their input costs are very high. They now will make a loss. When they bring their cattle to the factory gates, they will make a loss. That is devastating. It is devastating for the farmer individually but it is devastating for a farming family. It is devastating for a son or daughter watching his or her father or mother in this cycle where they are the last person to be looked after. The witnesses will no doubt make the point that these are international markets, etc. My question to Meat Industry Ireland is this: has it taken a cut to its profits? If so, is it making a loss? This summer and at the back end of the year, there are farmers across Ireland who will be bringing cattle to the factory gates at a loss. What percentage of Meat Industry Ireland's contracts has it made a loss on? It is a major issue and we have to address it. I am very interested to hear what the industry's plans and suggestions are around making this model sustainable.
Comment on this
That is an obvious challenge. We addressed that earlier with Deputy Aird. Last year, meat processors made a loss at certain times of the year. The Agri-Food Regulator clearly shows that in terms of the hindquarter and forequarter selling price compared to the price of cattle at that time. Obviously, there was a correction in terms of the retail contracts later in the year. That happened. Yes, processors are also exposed to the vagaries of the market from time to time. As we have said, there is a lot of product going into cold storage at the moment. It will be very difficult to make a return from that product once it goes in and once we have to pay for that. We all accept the challenges this issue creates, particularly for the farmer. What can we do about it? We would be happy to have a conversation on that to see how we could manage that a little bit better.
Mr. Carroll has talked about contracts between finishers and processors. A lot of farmers have contracts and are paid above the market rate at that time when they go to sell their cattle. That might even have been referenced in the farming media recently. That is the reality. That is happening out there but it is very difficult. It is very difficult in other sectors also. We see it in the pig sector. In certain years, it is very good. In certain years, it is very bad. That is farming. That is the business we are involved in at the moment.
Comment on this
What is the typical duration of a contract from MII?
Comment on this
What is the typical duration of a supply contract from a meat processing plant?
Comment on this
I am not privy to all of the commercial details the members have but typically, if you are talking about a farmer bringing in cattle in September or October to feed them over the winter period, it would cover the period up to the selling point in the spring.
Comment on this
In Mr. Crammond's view, are there any price or market signals that he can signal to farmers across the country to outline that we expect prices to increase or decrease? That is the point I am making. How long are the contracts, typically, and how can we restore some sustainability in the market?
Comment on this
Typically, the contractors very much focus on the winter finisher. It covers that six- to seven-month period over the winter. How can we give signals-----
Comment on this
Just to clarify, is the Deputy asking about the customer down the street and the contract with the customer? Mr. Crammond is answering about the contract with his supplier.
Comment on this
I am answering about the contract with the supplier who is the farmer.
Comment on this
There is no answer coming on the contract with the guy in the UK who MII is supplying.
Comment on this
In terms of the contracts with the purchasers, we clearly have contracts there-----
Comment on this
That is my question. We are trying to get to the contracts with the purchasers. Those are what we are interested in. If there is transparency for contracts in the meat industry over two, three or five years with the suppliers in the UK and European markets, that will give an indication and confidence to farmers. Perhaps it will outline to farmers that they should actually be cautious here as there are headwinds coming.
Comment on this
In terms of giving signals back to the farmer, there is a role for everyone in that. Bord Bia does a lot of work in that space as well and on updating its market analysis on a weekly basis.
Comment on this
I do not have Bord Bia here in front of me, I have Meat Industry Ireland and I am asking Mr. Crammond. It seems to me that his job, primarily, is to look after the plants. However, if he and his colleagues do not take a longer term view of this and the farmer is continually suffering as a result of this market, ultimately, there will be no plants because there will be no farmers to take cattle to the plants. MII needs to take a longer-term view of this and to ensure the market is fair for the farmers as well.
Comment on this
There are two issues that might be conflated there, as the Cathaoirleach has said. One is the relationship between the farmer and the processor, and the other is the relationship between the processor and the retailer. There are different provisions in contracts. Mr. Crammond has covered the one on the farm level processor. The Deputy said there needs to be transparency in contracts between processors and retailers or wholesalers, or whoever it is that is purchasing. Why would any commercial company reveal the terms of their contracts to each other? First, it would require both parties to agree to that. Second, why would we give all of that information to our competitors?
Where is the logic in that question?
Comment on this
Why are quoted beef prices dropping by about 30 cent per kilogram when the actual prices paid per kilogram are moving much slower? There is quite a significant difference. What is the reason for that?
Comment on this
As I alluded to, that may well be the result of some contracts finishers had with their processors over that winter period. Quotes have been falling back. I do not think they have been falling back anywhere like 30 cent per week but we have seen a decline and we accept that in terms of where cattle prices were.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses and thank them for their statements. How do they see the outlook for cattle prices for the remainder of this year and into 2027, especially in the context of rising costs, rising fertiliser costs, the cost-of-living crisis and the fuel crisis? Do they believe that they will hold up reasonably well or do they have any major concerns?
Comment on this
I do not have a crystal ball so I will be very cautious in my remarks. It is really difficult to say. If you look at the fundamentals of the global marketplace at the moment, things overall still look fairly positive for the beef industry. There is a declining herd in many of the major international markets, which is creating huge import demand into those markets, particularly the US. There is a bit of a challenge with China at the moment in terms of its safeguards but hopefully that will be temporary and be exhausted over the next two years so the fundamentals are still pretty good.
Consumers enjoy eating beef. The market surveys show that consumers want to engage with the beef category again. Unfortunately, prices got a little bit too high and that price elasticity broke. I was in the United States last week. They are more far more loyal to their beef products and their beef consumption than, unfortunately, we are here in Europe and the UK. They are continuing to pay those really high prices. Overall, I would say that the outlook is still positive. Prices are still high. If you look at the data in terms of the average farm incomes on beef farms last year, they are very positive. They probably will fall back this year but they will hopefully still be in profit and we cannot always say that if we look back over the past 20 to 25 years. I would say that it is just about finding that niche. There is a clearly a bit of a reset going on in the market at the moment. We will get to a certain point where the retailers will start to re-engage with the category, hopefully we will start to see some promotions happening again, that will drive that consumption and demand up and hopefully things will things will stabilise in the second half of the year leading into Christmas.
Comment on this
What should the Government, the Minister, the Department and this committee do to ensure stability, success and good prices going forward for the farmer?
Comment on this
I would address that in a number of ways. It is a very important question and I am glad the Deputy asked it because there is a role for everyone here from Government level to industry level working collaboratively with the farmers. That is what we have always tried to do. Mr. Carroll alluded to how Food Vision 2030 is being reviewed at the moment. We need to look at that very carefully. The Minister, Deputy Heydon, needs to come onto the pitch in that regard. We need to review that to see whether it has really worked for the beef sector over the past five years and whether the schemes we have are the most effective schemes. A lot of money is going into the beef sector. A lot of public funds are going into the sector. Is that money being used in the best possible way? I would like to see some kind of review around that going forward.
The industry has put a lot of money into schemes to support farmers. We funded the national genotype scheme to the tune of €7 million. We are funding the Teagasc signpost future beef programme, which is costing us €250,000 a year. We have helped fund Animal Health Ireland. The industry is really committed to trying to put the best industry we have in place so we can continue to market the beef we produce and return the best price to the farmer.
Our cost base at an industry level is under pressure. IBEC has made a number of recommendations to the Government on electricity prices. We need to see the Government do something in terms of subventions for some of the fixed costs. The labour rates in this country are out of control. I put that on the record. The Government increased permitted salaries by 30% overnight from €23,000 to €30,000 two years ago. It has increased them again this year from €30,000 to €32,691, which is a 9% increase. There is no justification for that. CSO wage rate data will show that the rate of increase is closer to 3%. Those sorts of decisions are really going to put the processing sector under pressure. The Government has indicated it wants to take the cost of employment permits to approximately €40,000 by the end of the decade. That decision needs to be revisited. It is a combination of factors; it is not just one.
Comment on this
What are the witnesses' views on prices paid to farmers for TB reactors? Do they believe they are fair? Do they believe should be increased? I am asking that in the context of my office being approached by farmers who are being left out of pocket.
Comment on this
We will come back on the issue of TB. There are a few factors at play there in terms of Department compensation schemes, etc.
Comment on this
I will add one point relating to what the Deputy said. The most significant problem our economy faces, apart from other things that are outside of the food sector, is the fact that energy costs here are way too high. Everybody knows that but nobody seems to be doing anything about it. What we really would like to see at the bare minimum is that we can reduce our energy dependency and our energy costs down to the average at European level. I do not think that is too big of an ask but if we do not start preparing to get to that point, we will be in even more trouble as we go forward. That applies to farmers and processors.
Comment on this
Quite a few of them do. I would not be around all of the detail of the structures of those. Many of those plants have a continual renewal in them but they have solar energy.
Comment on this
I am conscious of time as two more members have not had an opportunity to speak yet and we are coming close to the appointed finishing time. Members have other questions they are keen to get in on as well, so I must give priority to those members who have not yet spoken. Senator Lynch is next.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their attendance today. MII's initial statement very much outlines the situation. As we know, there has been a fall of almost €2 per kilogram in the past 12 months, which has crippled finishers. We know that while the price of calves is still quite high, for heavier cattle going to kill, we have seen a drop of almost €400 in the price since the start of the year. We know all of this and the witnesses outlined that very well but how do we solve it and what is the best way we can deal with it? Up to now, the Bord Bia sign denoting grass-fed origin was always our unique selling point. Do we need to do more in terms of marketing?
I appreciate from looking at what the witnesses set out that demand for more expensive meat has gone down because the cost was so high. From a marketing point of view, is there anything we can do to counter that? Our beef industry is incredibly vulnerable given that 90% of beef is exported. Markets and the international economy are volatile so we are very much at the mercy of that. The witnesses mentioned the massive drop in our exports to the UK and how a lot of New Zealand beef is coming in there, which previously would not have been the case. The UK-New Zealand trade deal has obviously made things a lot easier but when you look at the like of Dawn Meats, which is a member of MII, you see that it has bought into Alliance, which is a big meat producer in New Zealand.
There is a lot of speculation and hearsay, although it is only hearsay, that the likes of Dawn Meats is using its Irish connections to feed New Zealand beef into what had been Irish contracts. That is commercial business; I get that. If that is happening, however, that is very difficult for us here. Dawn Meats falls under MII. I accept that Dawn Meats is providing a cheaper product and there is a cost-of-living crisis, etc., but how can we resolve that?
The UK and Brazil do not currently have a trade deal but there is speculation that something could happen. How would such a trade deal affect Ireland? As bad as things are, that kind of trade deal could crucify the exporting of Irish beef to the UK.
We have always had Brazilian beef coming into this country but since the EU's adoption of the Mercosur agreement we have not seen as great an influx as much as we thought we would. Earlier this month, the European Commission announced its decision regarding the non-compliance of Brazilian beef, as we knew and as we said, with EU regulations surrounding the use of antimicrobials and antibiotics. If Brazil is found to remain non-compliant with that by the stipulated date in September and if, therefore, its beef is excluded from Mercosur and banned from coming into the European Union,will that have an effect and will it be an opportunity for Ireland to take advantage?
Comment on this
The Senator has raised quite a few issues and I will try to answer. Between the UK-New Zealand free trade agreement and the UK-Australia free trade agreement, I would worry more about the Australian agreement because of the quantity involved, which is 30,000 tonnes straightaway while the New Zealand figure is 12,000 tonnes. The Senator mentioned that Dawn Meats invested in Alliance Group, which is predominantly a lamb plant. It supplies some beef and I suspect some beef may have been coming into the UK before Dawn Meats made its investment. That is a commercial matter and I will not say anything more on that. Dawn Meats has made that investment.
On Brazilian beef, clearly if Brazil negotiated a trade agreement with the UK, it would create further pressures in the marketplace. An agreement has a long way to go. The Labour Government in the UK is a little bit challenged at the moment and I am not sure that negotiating a trade agreement with Brazil is at the top of its agenda.
We have to wait and see what happens with Brazil in terms of the audit by the EU Commission. The EU has put a marker down to Brazil to say that it is up to them to prove that they can meet our sanitary and phytosanitary, SPS, requirements. There is a lot of suspicion out there that they cannot do that. That is now a matter for the Commission. If the Commission grants that approval, then it will have to conduct audits at a very significant level to ensure that that is the case. As an industry, we can only ask that those checks and balances are being carried out and that the product that is coming into our marketplace is fair.
We must remember that we export 90% of our products all over the world. We cannot completely close our markets off to trade either. It would be nice to be able to do that but we live in the real world and we will have to accept some level of competition coming into our markets. What can we do about that? We need to double-down on what we are good at. We have built up a very positive reputation, and rightly so, for the world-class beef products we produce. We need to double-down on that. We have the highest standards of animal welfare and when it comes to climate in terms of the carbon efficiency of our product. We really need to focus in on these issues again.
We need the Bord Bia quality assurance schemes more than ever. If we want to maintain our place among blue-chip customers in Europe and the UK in the face of these increased imports coming in, we cannot walk away from these standards. We actually need to double-down on them.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Crammond saying that the reduction we are seeing in the UK market is not directly linked to the associated cost and that it is not necessarily down to the cost of living? Yes, we need all of these standards, but do we need to put them out there more in the context of our product?
Mr. Crammond mentioned the increased amount of dairy beef that is exported to the UK. Is that the problem? Before, dairy beef had almost a stigma and nobody wanted it, whereas now consumers seem less concerned about what animal the meat comes from. Do we need to focus more on our quality and sell it on its USP, or is it more about getting it out there because of the cost of living and the cost that meat here reached that was the problem in markets, as well as all the other issues around new trade agreements? What can we do? We can do nothing about other trade agreements.
Comment on this
No, we cannot; the Senator is right. We are only starting to see the challenges to the beef industry caused by Brexit. Both the dairy beef and suckler beef sectors massively contribute to our output. As I said earlier, we will always try to match the products to the marketplaces that will pay the highest price for the individual products. That is very straightforward and we work very closely with Bord Bia on that. I reiterate that we must keep doubling back to what we are good at, and we need to do that now more than ever.
Comment on this
I apologise, I had to attend another meeting earlier. I thank Mr. Carroll for his opening statement.
He outlined that export values were up 23%, at €3.5 billion, even though volumes had significantly reduced, while the UK value increased by 25% to €1.6 billion. However, I read recently in the Irish Farmers Journal that winter finishers are reporting losses of between €300 and €500 per head. We are exploring lower volumes, it generates far more value and yet, unfortunately, farmers are losing money. It would appear that once again the premier producer is paying the price. What steps are being taken to ensure that beef farmers in County Clare and other parts of the country get a fair share of the value being generated in the export markets?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his question. It is really around what has happened in the market here. People can clearly see where that value transferred in 2025. Every farmer in the country experienced that in their wallet. What actually happened was a surge was created because there was deemed to be a tightness in supply in the market. That was consequent on the very strong publication around what the reduction in supply was. In the UK, it was around 2%, in Europe 2.5% and it was similar elsewhere in the world, particularly in Ireland as we saw from the 214,000 animals that were not available on the market last year. There was a genuine squeeze in supply at that stage and throughout the year - I touched on this a bit earlier - until the point at which the price on the market became so high that there was a resistance to it. Bear in mind that there is the farmer, the processor, the retailer, the wholesaler and the consumer, all of which are influential in the market. What was happening in 2025 was that fellows were beating up themselves and everybody else to get as many animals as they could to fill the contracts they had agreed with the third party - the wholesaler and the retailer. That is where we have ended up. As a consequence, we got too high. People made a decision, particularly consumers, that they could not afford this and would buy something else or would buy cheaper beef products. That is why we have seen that value reduction in forequarters and hindquarters and the cuts associated with those. Everything has been affected. For example, in 2026, the visible lean, VL, content of the meat product has reduced from €6 per kilo in the wholesale market to €4 per kilo. That is explaining why prices have dropped.
Why would prices be higher in Ireland when we do not have that market, apart from us being a first importer into the UK market? We are not a first importer into the wider European markets. Every single one of the countries we are being compared with in the benchmark price are all big countries with populations greater than 20 million, so that is their internal market.
Our internal market numbers fewer than 5 million, and consumers right now, driven by price, are buying less beef product. We have seen that 49% - half the population - are saying that. If the price is way up and there is resistance in the market, it is only going one way. How can we correct this? Mr. Crammond has talked at length during the meeting about how we can reach the point where there is balance in the market. That is where we need to be, but balance is not there yet. I ask the committee to also bear in mind that - we have almost catastrophised it, but it is not a catastrophe - we are dealing with a short cycle in which farmers and processors alike have been dealt a body blow. That is the truth, but we do not influence that. An adjustment is taking place now. That adjustment does not seem to be complete yet.
There has always been volatility. Every year, there is a degree of volatility and we have had the greatest level of it in the past 12 months. However, when we get to a stable position, I hope, as Mr. Crammond does, that we will get to a price point again where we are competitive, can sell everything and increase the value of VLs, steak cuts and round cuts. I hope we can get to that point in the autumn, but I cannot predict it. No one can, because no one was able to predict the highs and lows we have reached now.
Comment on this
I hope that will happen.
I am running out of time. Independent butchers in County Clare and across the country depend on consistent, competitive prices and access to quality Irish beef. Given the increased concentration in beef processing, what assurance can Meat Industry Ireland give smaller independent retail butchers in the hearts of rural towns and villages that they will not be disadvantaged in access, pricing and supply allocation, relative to the large retail companies?
Comment on this
We appreciate the small independent butchers in the industry. We need all the routes to market we have at the moment, given the difficult place the market is in, so I do not think there is any discrimination going on against any small independent butchers.
Comment on this
It would not want to be going on, because we want them to survive and continue in business.
Comment on this
There is concern out there with some of them.
The opening statement pointed to record live calf and weanling exports of more than 300,000 annually. These animals are being purchased in the Netherlands, Spain and Italy. Why is that the case? From the perspective of food security, carbon footprint, local added value and supply chain, we need to actively reconsider why we have closed almost all our local slaughter houses.
Comment on this
In some ways, we have been victims of our own success when it comes to live exports, with the quality of cattle farmers in this country produce. We would love for those animals to stay in Ireland, be processed in Ireland and have that added value in our facilities. Ultimately, that would benefit everyone, but we operate in a European marketplace. Live shippers are very active in marts and markets all over the country and they will continue to be active. That creates a level of competition in the marketplace, which we have to accept. That is the commercial reality we operate in at the moment.
Comment on this
I presume that will continue going forward.
Comment on this
I cannot see anything changing dramatically around that. There are some concerns about the Dutch situation and live calves being shipped there, but up to this point nothing has happened in that area. There has probably been some fall-off in live exports to Poland this year because of bluetongue, but the option to sell to the marts is available to farmers and to the live exporters to buy the cattle. It has always been a part of Irish farming to some degree.
Comment on this
We have exceeded the agreed time. I have a few questions and a number of members are keen to get in a few questions as well, so if it is agreeable, we will do a quick-fire round from members and I will ask a few questions.
Irish farmers are producing quality, grass-fed beef with traceability from farm to fork and they feel their work is not reflected in the price they get in the factory at the end of the day. Meat Industry Ireland depends on them. They are its suppliers. Without them, its factory has no purpose. Has it looked at what would be a break-even price for them, for example, a suckler farmer or someone who is finishing, because they are under pressure in a whole range of areas? Does it look at the pressure its suppliers are under when it is making out a price? Is that taken into account in any way?
The price of beef for consumers in the market, whether in the butcher's shop, supermarket or restaurant, rose dramatically last year. Meat Industry Ireland thinks it is on the way down. In what kind of timeline does it expect that to reach the market for consumers?
Comment on this
I will not speak for retailers because, ultimately, they make their own decisions. They are the purchasers of our product. I hope that, as the price has fallen for the farmer, it will be reflected in the retailer price and that retailers will start to engage again in serious promotion efforts in the second half of the year to drive demand. That is what I will say on that.
On the first question, we fully acknowledge that without farmer suppliers, we do not have an industry. Despite everything, there is a good relationship between farmer suppliers and processors. We all want the best for the industry. Everyone in this room wants the best for the Irish beef industry, but from time to time, as we are seeing at the moment, we are simply challenged by the vagaries and transience of the marketplace. However, things can improve and I hope they will and we will get back to an even keel with less volatility in the marketplace. Volatility is the key issue and it has been talked about a lot today.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Carroll and Mr. Crammond for coming today. They came here as witnesses. A few weeks ago, other witnesses were here and - you could not write the book - they told us we had to bring in Brazilian beef as a buffer in case we ran out of Irish beef. Today, though, Meat Industry Ireland is telling us that every cold store in the country is full and we cannot sell it, and that that is why the price of beef is dropping. It is no wonder Irish farmers are frustrated. They are gobsmacked by why they are hearing today. That is my question.
Comment on this
That is not the reason the cattle prices have reduced. That completely ignores everything we have said today about how the market across the globe, including Europe and the UK, has declined substantially and quickly. That is the reason. The cold stores are full because there is no demand in the market at the moment at an appropriate price.
Comment on this
But we are bringing in Brazilian beef to prop up the market.
Comment on this
Meat Industry Ireland does not want to hear it. It is the truth.
Comment on this
Deputy, the truth of the matter is that 174 tonnes of Brazilian beef was imported to this country.
Comment on this
It does not matter whether it is a half day's production. It should not be here.
Comment on this
I remember the beef going into intervention. I was fattening cattle at the time.
Comment on this
Yes. I got my point across, and-----
Comment on this
To be fair, I have given the Deputy additional time and we need to move to Deputy Newsome Drennan.
Comment on this
I will come in on the issue of beef offal. It was valued at €155 million in 2025, which was up 12% on 2024.
The farmers get paid only for the dead weight. That offal then goes from there to elsewhere, whether as pet food, to medical or to all these other areas, but the farmer does not get paid for this. The farmer does not get paid for the fifth quarter. I know there are processors that are also involved in pet food manufacturing. Is that kind of like "Sure I will take that and throw it into my other plant and I will make, make, make, win, win, win"? The farmer does not get anything for the fifth quarter.
Comment on this
No, the fifth quarter, or the offal products, is considered in the price of cattle the farmer pays. We have a challenge in the international marketplace in that we would like access to a lot of markets to export that offal and we do not have access to some of those markets at the moment, particularly into China, if we could resolve the bluetongue issue. Ultimately, the farmer buys the animal. As regards the price of cattle, it is the overall price of that animal that is considered in setting that price.
Comment on this
There is live weight, dead weight and the weight they get. The head and the other bits are cut off but they are all usable. Is about €138 to €155 basically the value of it? Then there are the hides and so on. I know there are truckloads of hides going abroad. Somebody is making money on this. What I am saying is that if a plant has a dog, cat or other pet food company to make whatever food and it is taking that product, it is making money because it has somewhere to go for it. Is it the case that these people whom I am talking about - and the witnesses know whom I am talking about - should be paying the farmer for it?
Comment on this
No. I think the situation is that once the animal goes into the lairage, you are buying the animal. That means you own every single part of that animal because you have paid for it.
Comment on this
But you are paying them only for the dead weight, the throat and the-----
Comment on this
Why not put an offal weight on it and a price for it?
Comment on this
I wish to raise just two small things. First of all, it was mentioned - and it was mentioned here before - how companies use meat products from other countries that they mix in with Irish products sometimes to produce their output. I am just wondering about contamination and cross-contamination in respect of all that. Brazil is obviously the one people look to, but I refer to other countries as well, where they are producing output where they have got products that have some Irish meat in it and other ingredients and products from other countries. How much regulation is there around all that and ensuring that there is not any contamination in respect of that?
Comment on this
The Deputy is suggesting that there may be a mix of imported beef in product we are exporting. Is that what he is suggesting?
Comment on this
Well, in product we are exporting, but it may be product-----
Comment on this
But we are not. If that is the question, we do not do that.
Comment on this
It is 100% Irish beef that is exported and also Irish beef-----
Comment on this
That is when we are talking about raw beef, but in some cases it may be processed a little further than that, where it may be a product that is exported, not just the beef.
Comment on this
But Meat Industry Ireland's members are all primary processors in the main, so we are processing that primary product and selling it outside the country, as the Deputy knows.
Comment on this
And they are not suppliers of meat from other countries outside or in the EU.
Comment on this
My other short question is about the exports and the export of product to other countries. It was mentioned that there were so many cattle exporters abroad and cattle are now being slaughtered in other countries. Obviously, whatever-----
Comment on this
But the big benefit of that to the farmer in Ireland was that it created a competition and a market, and that is huge value for them as well. Does that mean that if we continue to export at reasonably high levels, we will see more and more of a shortage for the processors here?
Comment on this
As I said, we would clearly prefer if those animals stayed in the country and were processed and had that value added here in our processing facilities. With respect, though, the reality of the marketplace and those live exporters will continue to come in. I do sometimes wonder how they are able to come in and purchase cattle at the prices they do so, export them outside this country and still make money from them. As I said, though, that is the reality we live with.
Comment on this
Perhaps if processors were to trade at a better price, they would not-----
Comment on this
I am very concerned looking at the reduction in the kill last year. We are already down, I think, 80,000 year to date this year. Now, I appreciate that at the moment prices are down and ours are among the lowest in Europe. That is grand, and that is all to do with the market, but when we see such a vast reduction year on year in terms of the animals being killed and being produced here, do the witnesses think this will be a major problem in the future in terms of reduction? It will lead to food security problems. I understand that at the moment, due to the volatility of the market, the price is down - that is grand - but I do not think we are talking enough about the massive reduction. When lads get out of keeping cattle, it is very difficult for them to get back into it. At the current prices, a lot of lads are saying it is not worth it for them. I think this will lead to further problems down the road in terms of our output.
Comment on this
We fully accept that the price of cattle has fallen and that has created a difficulty in the marketplace. We also have to reflect that, by historic levels, cattle prices are still at a very positive level and a lot of farmers will continue to make money in beef this year. Do I share the Senator's concerns? Absolutely. Of course we share them. As regards that whole piece around the generational renewal, we are really going to have to engage in that in a serious way in the context of the next CAP. We have the Presidency of the European Union now. First of all, the Minister needs to ensure that we get a proper budget for our next CAP and then that there are appropriate resources allocated to that issue around generational renewal. As I have said, and despite what some people think, we will always try to return the maximum value from the marketplace to the farmer. That leaves a gap from time to time, and the public and the EU purse and the national purse have always been there. We need to continue to have those resources available to us. That is the system we operate here. Food security has moved up the agenda, thankfully, at a European level. It had fallen down the agenda a lot. We need to keep it up there now and we need to ensure not just that we talk about food security but also that the appropriate budget is allocated to ensure that that becomes a reality.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas le gach duine. Mar a luaigh mé cheana féin, tá feirmeoirí an-bhuartha mar gheall ar an bpraghas a fhaigheann siad ar na beithígh agus ar an bpraghas a chuireann an monarchana ar fáil dóibh. Is é sin an fáth ar theastaigh uainn an t-ábhar seo a phlé anseo inniu – chun díriú isteach ar an mbealach a dtagtar ar an bpraghas agus chun a chinntiú go mbeidh todhchaí ann d'fheirmeoirí mairteola ach go háirithe.
Leis sin, tá an t-am breise caite againn. Mo bhuíochas libh go léir, go háirithe ar lá breá grianmhar mar seo. I thank everybody who has participated, especially on such a sunshiny day and with people keen to be out there. It really reflects the intensity of feeling among members and farmers about the price they are getting for their beef. I thank the witnesses for their participation on behalf of the committee. That brings today's discussion to a conclusion, and the meeting now stands adjourned.