Hemp Production: Discussion (Resumed)
Hemp producers and community representatives argued that the crop could diversify tillage, improve soils and supply construction and other industries, but annual licensing and the lack of processing infrastructure and secure markets are holding back growth. The Department said hemp can be licensed for fibre or seed, but current drug-control rules are a matter for Health and commercial expansion depends on industry-led proposals and investment; it said it had not received a viable proposal. Members pressed the Department to show greater leadership and work across departments to address licensing and market barriers. The Department also outlined proposed EU-wide harmonisation of rules for hemp plant products, and the Chair suggested inviting the Department of Health to give evidence.
Contributions 1–149 of 300. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No apologies have been received. I will begin with a note on privilege. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precinct are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Cathaoirleach's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Cathaoirleach in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside of the parliamentary precinct are asked to note they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precinct and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings of the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings. Everybody taking part is in the room and there are no witnesses online.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against either a person outside of the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members participating online in a committee meeting when the participation is from within the parliamentary precinct. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precinct. Any attempt to do so will result in the member having their access removed.
The agenda for today is a resumed discussion on hemp production. The committee will hear from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and from it, cuirim fáilte roimh Dr. Barry O'Reilly, senior inspector, and Mr. James Quirke, agricultural inspector. From Teagasc, cuirim fáilte roimh Mr. John Spink, head of crops, environmental and land use program. From Wild Atlantic Hemp, cuirim fáilte roimh Mr. Daniel Lyons, hemp farmer. From Loop Head Together GLC, cuirim fáilte roimh Ms Margaret Cotter, cathaoirleach.
The opening statements have been circulated. I will give witnesses five minutes to go through the opening statements and then give members the opportunity to ask some questions and get some answers. I draw members' attention to the fact the Teagasc opening statement is the same as last week's so we will not read through it again as they have already heard that. I will give the witnesses the floor and we will start with five minutes from an Roinn talmhaíochta.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and the committee members for the opportunity to discuss the topic of hemp production. The growing and cultivation of hemp has been the subject of some debate in recent years. The Department regularly received hemp related correspondence from interested parties, including on the legislative position and the potential commercial development of the industry. At the outset, I would like to set out the regulatory framework concerning the production of hemp in Ireland. Cannabis and hemp both derive from the species cannabis sativa and contain tetrahydrocannabinol, THC. Hemp is therefore a controlled drug under the misuse of drugs legislative framework and is subject to the strictest levels of control.
Current legislation in Ireland does not allow for the growing of hemp unless a specific licence has been granted by the Health Products Regulatory Authority, HPRA, which operates under the auspices of the Department of Health. The cultivation of hemp is limited to varieties having less than 0.3% content of THC. These varieties must be registered in the EU common catalogue of varieties of agricultural plant species and marketed in accordance with Council Directive 2002-57-EC on the marketing of seed of oil and fibre plants. The licence to cultivate hemp does not permit access to the THC contained in the plant. The stalk, fibre and seed of the hemp plant are not subject to control measures once removed from the plant. However, applicants who apply for a licence to cultivate hemp from the HPRA must personally sign an undertaking that the controlled parts of the hemp plant, namely, the leaves and flower, must not be processed or sold onwards, which are both offences under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1977, and must be destroyed on cultivation.
As the misuse of drugs legislative framework is the responsibility of the Department of Health, questions on this framework are therefore a matter for that Department. Hemp is included as an eligible crop under the basic income support for sustainability scheme. Data from the basic income support for sustainability scheme indicates the area of hemp in 2026 was approximately 11 ha. Hemp has many uses, including in the construction, car manufacturing, paper, animal bedding, clothing and food industries. Hemp is a crop that is agronomically suited to many parts of Ireland and offers potential opportunities for crop diversification and crop rotation. However, the area of hemp production remains low.
The Department previously, as part of a process to fully explore fibre crops such as hemp and consider whether these crops have a viable market, initiated a consultative process in August 2021 to examine the commercial viability of growing hemp for fibre use. In making submissions as part of the consultation, stakeholders were requested to take into consideration the following questions. What markets exist for fibre from crops, including hemp? What are the strengths and weaknesses of fibre crops? What is the scalability of the Irish fibre crop and hemp industry, taking into account market size and value, industry processing capacity and adequate economic returns for all along the supply chain?
The report on this consultation was published in December 2022. The main finding of the report was that the growing of fibre crops, such as hemp, for the purposes of fibre production is not currently viable in Ireland. Potential markets exist for hemp fibre, with its use in the construction industry offering the most significant opportunity. However, the report concluded that the scaling up of hemp crop production would be dependent on numerous factors, including the development of stable markets, significant capital investment to increase processing capacity, and collaboration with all stakeholders along the supply chain, all of which must be industry-led. The report also noted that while the outcome of the consultation did not support the viability of fibre crops such as hemp in Ireland, it is a matter for the industry to address and bring forward a proposal containing viable options for consideration. The Department would welcome any such proposal.
I mention the proposal to amend the common market organisation, CMO, regulation as part of the post-2027 CAP proposals. The proposal allows for harmonised EU rules covering all parts of the hemp plant with a maximum legal THC limit of 0.3%. Discussions are continuing on the proposal under the Irish Presidency.
I again thank the committee for the opportunity to come before it to discuss the topic of hemp production. I, or my colleague Mr. Quirke, will be happy to take any questions members of the committee may have.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the opportunity to speak here today. I am founder and director of Wild Atlantic Hemp. I have been involved in the Irish hemp industry since 2018. Over that time, I have worked across almost every stage of the sector, from cultivation and processing to research and industry development. Along the way, our company took part in Enterprise Ireland's new frontiers programme. I completed a master's degree in agricultural innovation at Galway University, where I researched industrial hemp. I was a founding member of the Hemp Co-operative of Ireland and I worked with the Food Safety Authority of Ireland, FSAI, and the HSE to establish a hemp processing facility in Kilkee, County Clare.
My work has also expanded into collaborative research and innovation. In 2021, I worked with the Loop Head community to secure funding for Hemp4Soil, an agricultural innovation project funded by the Department of agriculture. In 2023, Wild Atlantic Hemp became a project partner in SOILCRATES, a Horizon Europe regenerative farming project across four countries. More recently, we joined the SCEENE project, a community-driven pilot project exploring biochar production and carbon sequestration.
Healthy soils are the foundation of every successful farm and yet, across Europe, including Ireland, soil degradation is becoming a major issue. This is due to years of increasingly intensive farming. Historically, farmers returned huge amounts of organic matter to the soil. Today, much of that has been replaced by manufactured fertilisers which feed the crop but do not necessarily feed the living biology within the soil. At the same time, due to geopolitical events, farmers are facing rising production costs, particularly for fertilisers, which are produced by the petrochemical industry. I believe this is encouraging us to look again at alternative crops such as hemp and alternative fertilisers such as anaerobic digestate, microbial teas and biochar. These solutions help rebuild healthy, living soils while reducing dependency on imported inputs.
Ireland also faces another challenge. If we fail to meet our greenhouse gas reduction commitments, the State could face billions of euro in climate compliance costs over the coming years. According to the European Commission, one hectare of industrial hemp can sequester between nine and 15 tonnes of carbon dioxide in a single growing season, roughly the same amount as a young forest but in just five months. Once harvested, another crop can often be grown on the same land and hemp has been shown to improve the yield of subsequent crops by 10% to 15%. On top of that, it can be grown with lower fertiliser inputs and, in most cases, without pesticides.
One plant can produce three separate revenue streams for farmers. The stalk provides both shiv - the woody core used in hempcrete or converted into biochar - and bast fibre, which is used in insulation and composite materials. The seed can be processed into oil, protein and dietary fibre for both animal feed and human consumption. Looking ahead, farmers may also be able to generate additional income through carbon farming and carbon credit schemes.
Despite its potential, there are still several significant barriers to the development of the hemp industry in Ireland. Annual licensing is a big problem. Hemp cultivation is currently licensed on a one-year basis, making it difficult for farmers to plan ahead or invest in specialised machinery, drying facilities and processing infrastructure. Market certainty is another big problem. Farmers need the confidence to secure contracts before planting, knowing that there will be a guaranteed market for their crop at harvest. Processing infrastructure is another big issue. Ireland needs regional processing facilities so that hemp can be processed quickly after harvest. Farmers should not be expected to store large volumes of hemp for extended periods while waiting for a processor or factory to acquire it. Supply chain development needs to be looked at as well. Investment is needed throughout the supply chain, from harvesting and decortication to fibre processing and biochar production, to ensure farmers can realise the full potential of the crop.
An Irish company, Kingspan, is leading the way in hemp-based insulation, yet the hemp is sourced through mainland Europe rather than from Irish farms. This is a missed opportunity. We need to be producing these materials here in Ireland. I thank the committee for listening.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas roimh an Cathaoirleach and the committee members for the opportunity to contribute to this discussion on hemp. I am here in my capacity as chairperson of Loop Head Together, a voluntary organisation based on the Loop Head Peninsula in County Clare. It is an area described by its own local authority as being in a state of terminal population decline. Not uniquely to rural coastal communities in the west of Ireland, the two principal economic drivers in Loop Head are agriculture and tourism. The local community is committed to supporting both and also to attempting to turn the tide of population decline. This led to the formation of Loop Head Together, an umbrella group representing approximately 50 partner voluntary organisations across an area of over 200 sq. km and encompassing around 60 km of the Wild Atlantic Way coastline.
In 2021-22, Loop Head Together administered the Hemp4Soil project, a European Innovation Partnership, EIP, project funded by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine through EIP-Agri. The Hemp4Soil project was a pioneering initiative aimed at advancing regenerative agricultural practices through the cultivation of industrial hemp, with a specific focus on enhancing soil health, biodiversity and carbon sequestration and, more broadly, to understand if there was an appetite for industrial hemp cultivation. Conducted as a one-year field study on the Loop Head Peninsula, the project sought to explore the potential of hemp to restore degraded soils without the use of chemical inputs, while also exploring alternative revenue streams for our farmers through crop diversification. This was carried out through assessment of whether industrial hemp, grown with and without organic soil amendments, such as biochar and biochar mixed with farmyard slurry, could improve soil quality and microbial biodiversity on minimally managed lands. There were nine participating farmers, each providing an acre of land, and they were all supported in their licensing and regulatory requirements by the project group.
Hemp4Soil demonstrated that, with organic amendments and no other above ground management, it is possible to grow industrial hemp on traditionally low input systems or what might otherwise be considered marginal land. However, acquiring licences can be time consuming and seed cannot be sown until the licence has been granted. Any delay will potentially impact on seeding date. Delays with licensing delayed our seeding date, which hindered crop establishment. On licensing, the regulatory process is off-putting for farmers. This process needs to be simplified and also changed to multi-year licensing, if there is a will at departmental level to increase industrial hemp production.
From the success of the project's farmer recruitment and outreach programme, a clear appetite for diversification, regenerative farming practices and industrial hemp production was demonstrated among highly diverse groups, including dairy farmers, landowners, the local authority, Teagasc and the general public. However, despite the level of outreach we engaged in, increasing the scale and scope of hemp growing in our community was challenging due to the lack of access to decortication infrastructure and, thus, access to market. This has significantly hampered our original intention to develop a local bioeconomy centred on hemp, although it has not deterred us and we continue to explore this sector. There is a gap between the farmer and the market that needs to be bridged.
In addition to the multitude of purposes for which hemp can be used in industry, we have underscored how, with pyrolysis, it may also be used as an effective soil amendment in conjunction with farmyard slurry. Further exploration of this carbon sequestration potential for this combination would be beneficial and the potential production of hemp biochar, particularly for sub-par crop output that is perhaps unsuitable for use in the shiv or fibre-related industries.
From the perspective of our development group, this project changed how we as a rural and coastal community engage with the broader European research ecosystem. In this regard, we have continued this engagement with academic partners and our local farming community to explore how we can further develop the learnings of this project. We are now creating a living laboratory as part of an EU-wide EIP named SOILCRATES and are leading on an additional EIP, SCEENE, in an effort to explore soil carbon enhancement, part of which involves help production, pyrolysis and the growth of specific plant species, including hemp, within run-off buffer zones. I welcome any questions and thank the committee for the opportunity to speak.
Comment on this
Members will have six minutes each and we may have another round of questions afterwards.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. I have no doubt they were tuned in to last week's proceedings, so there is no point in going back over all the benefits of hemp. Those of us who were not familiar with the crop before our meeting last week are beginning to ask why we are not growing a lot more hemp in this country. As I said last week, I had a Bill written, the agricultural products Bill, which proposed to transfer responsibility for licensing from the Department of health to the Department of agriculture. On the back of some of the meetings I had with some of the witnesses who were here last week, the Bill has gone back to drafting. It is not going away, however.
With the greatest respect to Ms Cotter and Mr. Lyons, most of my questions will be directed at the Department. What level of enthusiasm is there in the Department for this crop? Let us start with the tillage crisis we have. Here is a crop with massive potential. It is an ideal rotation crop and there is a good return from it. We were told last week that a farmer could potentially get a return of between €350 and €400 per acre - not per hectare - from hemp. That is not to mention all the positive uses of the product, including in construction. Teagasc has proved that there is a 10% to 15% yield improvement from hemp in the second year it is sown because of the great work it does in regenerating the soil. Hemp can grow on any kind of land, is easily grown and needs very few pesticides or chemical fertilisers. Everything about it seems to be positive, other than that it is classified and licensed under the Misuse of Drugs Act. Licences only last for one year, whereas multi-year licences are needed.
I know we have no choice but to use this language, but talking about something that is a controlled substance under the Misuse of Drugs Act is in itself an inhibitor and puts people off. Is the Department willing to embrace this product? In its statement, it noted that the stalk and fibre of hemp do not need to be subject to the same control as the controlled substances listed under the Misuse of Drugs Act. Would the Department not embrace a proposal to use hemp fibres and stalks?
Dr. O'Reilly said also that it has to be industy-led but multiple farmers would need to be growing to supply industry. We had people here last week and one person was prepared to invest €20 million in a business. Somebody needs to lead on this and the Department should. With the greatest of respect, there does not seem to be an appetite in the Department to grab the proverbial bull by the horns and be the leader. All the witnesses who were here today and all who were here last week would row in with the Department. All they need is leadership and a central focal point. There is a lot of funding involved but even if funding is obtained, the biggest problem is that if the farmers are not incentivised, encouraged or rewarded by the Department to grow the crop, they will not have the suppliers. The Department is the only one that can pull the farmers and the supply chain for this together. In doing so, it would improve soil regeneration, carbon sequestration and environmental farming. I have spoken for longer than I intended. Dr. O'Reilly might come back to me as to what attitude the Department might have on this going forward.
Comment on this
The Senator covered a lot there. He mentioned tillage-----
Comment on this
I apologise for stopping Dr. O'Reilly. It is not that I am walking out over anything he said but I have to go. I will read his answers after. I have to go to the Seanad to vote.
Comment on this
-----and the importance of the tillage sector. It is an important sector and one we want to increase. A lot of work is being done to increase the area under tillage crops at the moment. There are a lot of reasons for this, which the Senator will be familiar with, relating to climate, the jobs it creates, the value of it and the contribution it makes to the livestock, food and animal feed sectors. There is no reason the tillage sector cannot make a bigger contribution to other sectors, such as the construction sector by providing raw materials. We have a strategy in place, namely, the food vision tillage group strategy. The group was set up in 2023 and its detailed report was published in 2024. A lot of work is ongoing in collaboration with other stakeholders in implementing its recommendations. Adding value is a big part of that. Adding value to the crops is one of the keys to the long-term sustainability of the tillage sector. Tillage farmers are-----
Comment on this
Does Dr. O'Reilly not see the potential of hemp as a lifeline for the tillage sector?
Comment on this
-----constantly looking for areas into which they can diversify and opportunities for adding value.
Comment on this
Would the Department not encourage hemp as one of those areas for added value, diversification, sequestration and soil regeneration? Is that not a nettle that it will grab and run with and try to throw a lifeline to the tillage sector?
Comment on this
What it boils down to is that farmers will grow the crop if there is an economic return for them to make it worth their while.
Comment on this
There has to be an accessible licence. We are talking about the licence here and the Department of agriculture has to get involved with that licence.
Comment on this
Yes, but there are two separate things here. There is the market, which is probably the more important issue.
Comment on this
At the moment, growing hemp is not really a viable option for tillage farmers because there is not the return from the marketplace. We do not have any processing facilities at the moment. If a farmer grows a crop of hemp for fibre production, where does that farmer bring that crop to get it processed? There is a lack of information and data around what the market can return to farmers to make it worth their while economically to grow the crop. Until we address that market situation to create a viable, stable market, to give confidence to farmers to grow the crop and to give them a return that will make it economically worth the while to grow it, we will not get much production of hemp here.
The licensing issue is separate.
Comment on this
For information purposes, the bells could go for either the Dáil or the Seanad and members will be in and out as they called for voting. The witnesses will be able to see it on the screens. We will aim to have a second round of questions, depending on demand.
Comment on this
We are talking about tillage and how we are trying to promote it. At the moment, tillage is decreasing in this country. Do the officials understand that? This is despite the fact that the food vision tillage group was set up and that the Department said it was going to increase. However, it is not increasing; it is decreasing. That is one of the reasons the representatives from the hemp sector came here to talk to us. It is a total contradiction because a gentleman who was before the committee at our previous meeting who was prepared to come into the country to set it up, if farmers were given the licence to sow it. They said that they will harvest the crop and pay for it. It was €350 or €450 an acre or something they said, which is way ahead of what farmers will get for spring barley. As we look at it today, with the forecast for spring barley, farmers will be just waiting on what the price of straw will be. That is not sustainable for anybody who is in any situation. I do not know anything about the hemp crop other than to listen to what was said last week and today but without criticising the Department, there but there seems to be a pushback from it regarding hemp. Maybe it is something that would make up for the loss of the sugar beet crop. We can still see the devastating effects year in, year out that the loss of sugar beet had on the tillage industry. Anyway, I have a few questions. Given that only approximately 11 ha of hemp are currently under cultivation, what are the main barriers preventing greater uptake by farmers?
Comment on this
We carried out a consultation on this in 2021 to explore the potential for growing fibre crops such as hemp and to explore whether these crops have a viable market. One of the things that came out of the consultation was that there are potential markets, particularly in the construction industry. However, in the submissions to that consultation there was a huge lack of detail, first, in terms of the market and what was the current value of it and the current volume of it and-----
Comment on this
I am convinced, beyond doubt, that a farmer would make more money at the moment from hemp than from cereals.
Comment on this
The Department of agriculture is saying there is no market for it yet at the end of the day, Kingspan, one of the biggest companies in Ireland, has to import it from across Europe-----
Comment on this
But the man at the last meeting said that he was prepared to set up-----
Comment on this
I have an important question I want to ask the Department. Has the Department engaged with the Department of Health and the HPRA to explore whether the current licensing process could be more streamlined, while maintaining public safety? Has the Department had that meeting? It is a yes-no answer
Comment on this
That is grand. That answers a lot of questions for me today. What opportunity does the Department see for hemp as a crop diversification option for tillage farmers under the next CAP. Will there be? "Yes" or "No"?
Comment on this
I want to come back to the central question about opportunities for hemp here.
Comment on this
No, I am sorry. I have my questions written out so I really just want a yes-no answer. Is the answer to the CAP question "Yes" or "No"? Will the Department be in strong negotiations?
Comment on this
The result of the consultation we carried out found that to develop a hemp industry here, a couple of things need to happen-----
Comment on this
Sorry, I am not going to listen to that because the Department did not even have a meeting with the Department of Health. Now for God's sake, will Dr. O'Reilly stop and leave it at that?
Since the publication in 2022 of the consultation report, has the Department received any new industry proposals demonstrating the commercial viability of hemp production? "Yes" or "No"?
Comment on this
That is one of the points I wanted to make. As a result of that consultation, we-----
Comment on this
I only have one minute and 48 seconds left. Has the Department had the discussion? "Yes or "No"?
Comment on this
Yes, but will the Cathaoirleach give me extra time? That is grand, thanks.
Comment on this
As a result of that consultation, a number of key factors were identified that need to happen to develop and scale up a hemp fibre industry here. One of those is that we need significant investment in processing. Second, we need all of the stakeholders in the industry to collaborate in developing a coherent and properly functioning supply chain to give confidence to farmers to grow it.
Comment on this
We made it clear that it is really up to the industry to bring forward proposals around viable options.
Comment on this
Dr. O'Reilly is saying it has not done this.
Comment on this
It has not done this and we are open to receiving proposals like that.
Comment on this
It is a pity those people are not here today because they said they had done it but they have not.
Comment on this
How much investment in the processing infrastructure would be required before hemp production could become commercially viable in Ireland?
Comment on this
We heard from some stakeholders last week about decortication units that can be quite expensive and can cost up to €12 million. The industry is probably better placed to answer these questions and bring forward a proposal to us so we can consider it.
Comment on this
How is the Department engaging with the construction sector, which is where the consultation identified the greatest potential demand for hemp fibre?
Comment on this
We get a lot of correspondence on developing a hemp industry here and on regulation. We have always been very clear in all our engagement with the hemp sector over the past number of years that we are open to receiving proposals from the hemp industry or individual members of the hemp industry, whatever the case might be, and we will consider them. To date we have not had any proposal.
Comment on this
The Department is a long time making up its mind, if Dr. O'Reilly does not mind me saying so.
Comment on this
As I said in my opening statement, the Department would welcome proposals like this and we would see how we could------
Comment on this
The representatives told us last week they had given the Department all the proposals. They were in here and I thought they were magnificent. I hope people will stand up and say there were not if I am wrong. I thought they were great. I thought there was a person there who was prepared to take the raw material and guarantee a price to the farmers of this country. To be fair about it, the Department of agriculture will not guarantee farmers what they will get for spring barley this year. We saw what the co-operatives were offering them. It would not allow some of them to break even.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee and for their opening statements. I have a special welcome for Mr. Lyons and Ms Cotter from County Clare and my first questions are for them. I have heard hemp described as a wonder crop, and we heard it here last week. I know both of them have had heavy involvement in hemp production and its potential on the Loop Head peninsula at community and personal business level. Will they outline the biggest challenges they have faced on their journey to date?
Comment on this
One of the biggest challenges is that when farmers grow the crop they have nowhere to go it at the end of the day so they may as well not grow it. Unless we have a processing facility that can decorticate this, we do not have a product at the end of the day. The money has to be invested in that side. Licensing is another issue. It puts farmers off because it comes under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1977. This is not a drug at the end of the day; it is an industrial crop from which we can build houses, make insulation and make protein for animals and for humans. It has so many potentials but we have nowhere to go with it and nowhere to process it. This is what is blocking the industry at the moment, to be honest.
Comment on this
I have similar views to Mr. Lyons. We found we could break the controlled substance taboo and it was very easy to get over it with farmers through outreach, information and education and we passed that barrier. If we were to go to the Department of enterprise and say we had a lovely business proposal it would ask for our business plan and ask to be shown a five-year plan. How can farmers have a five-year plan when they can only get a one-year license? It is impossible. It is an impediment to the farmer. Regulatory and licence matters are an impediment, whether we like it or not. If we are serious about developing this industry this impediment needs to be addressed. I would also say, just like Mr. Lyons said, there is no infrastructure. When farmers produce the plant, the minute it is cut it starts to release carbon, so we are negating some of the carbon benefits. If we store it, we are releasing carbon. What we need to do is give them access to a market and decortication infrastructure, guarantee the farmers a price, give them access to markets and let them produce it like any other crop.
Comment on this
What benefit do Mr. Lyons and Ms Cotter think this crop has for coastal communities?
Comment on this
It has massive benefits. Not a lot will grow on a lot of the marginal ground there but we can grow hemp. Farmers ring me on a weekly basis looking to do 50 or 100 acres. The drive is there among farmers and they want to grow it. This is a crop that could make them some money.
Comment on this
How does hemp biochar support the farming sector with regard to the water framework directive and minimising the use of fertilisers?
Comment on this
Hemp has a long taproot. I will let Mr. Lyons talk about the science of it. The production of biochar is through the pyrolysis of hemp. It is burned at a very high temperature with no oxygen. There is very little carbon emission from the process. It produces what is effectively like charcoal. It is put back in the ground and it locks in carbon. It is a really effective soil amender but it is organic.
Comment on this
The biochar has tiny capillaries. Normally when slurry is added to land it starts running off into rivers and we have problems but if biochar is added to the slurry it holds onto the nutrients, locks them in and stops them leaching from the soil. It is like a supermarket for the plants. They can tap into it when they need it. It stops all of the run off into the waterways.
Comment on this
Mr. Lyons and Ms Cotter are positive that it is good.
Comment on this
Biochar is also an effective use of a subpar crop. If people growing hemp have a bad growing year and the crop is poor with regard to fibre density or height and may not be of use in the construction industry, it can be pyrolysed and turned into biochar and used as a soil amender. This crop creates a no-lose situation.
Comment on this
That carbon has been pulled out of the atmosphere, locked in and turned into biochar. Then it is put back into the soil, it amends the soil and it puts carbon back into the soil.
Comment on this
That makes sense. What is the feedback from the farmers who have been involved in the hemp pilot project on Loop Head?
Comment on this
We were a bit shocked when we had a farm open day and a farm walk. We were expecting what we would normally get for a small EIP project. We are not in a very central location. We are as far flung as we can get on the west coast. We were expecting a local turnout but we had in the region of 80 people, including farmers from all over the country who had got wind of this and wanted to see it. They wanted to see a real-life working farm where it is growing, not out of a textbook but real life and boots on the ground. It was remarkable. The farmers on Loop Head thought it was incredible. Within 100 days there is a fully developed crop. It is quite amazing. Again, there is no access to market and people were very put off by the regulatory process. We supported the farmers with it but they did find it very offputting.
Comment on this
We went through the licensing step-by-step with them, which involves phone calls over and back. When an application for a licence is made to the Department one thing is issued and when the licence comes back people have to start again. It can take a couple of weeks to get the paperwork together. Some farmers will say they are not bothered because it is too much effort to through.
Comment on this
And then they will have to do it again next year.
Comment on this
If the guidelines were reviewed do Mr. Lyons and Ms Cotter think more people would get involved?
Comment on this
The appetite is there and it would definitely be lot easier for farmers to make an application for five or six years. The licensing could be taken out completely and given to the Department of agriculture because at the end of the day it is not a narcotic. It is a building material and it has many other uses. This needs to change.
Comment on this
I compliment Mr. Lyons and Ms Cotter on the fabulous and fantastic work they have been doing. I hope they get more support. I have some questions for the Department and I hope I will be able to ask them in a second round of questions. Keep up the good work.
Comment on this
The first time around people would want to start before Christmas, to be honest, for all the ins and outs of it. It is a little bit quicker once people have gone through the process already because they will know what to do but it is a headache come the next year when they have to find all of the paperwork. It is quite an annoyance to be honest.
Comment on this
Not usually, once people have everything in order. As I have said, it is not wanted beside a school or on a main road. At the end of the day it makes absolutely no difference because no one is going to rob this crop as a narcotic. It is absolutely useless in that way.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee. As I said last week, this is probably one of the most interesting topics we have had since I have been a member of the committee.
Dr. O'Reilly was speaking about the Common Market. What work is going on with that? What exactly is that going to achieve?
Comment on this
A lot of negotiations and discussions are taking place on the proposals for the next CAP. There are various different regulations. The CMO regulation is part of that, which essentially manages the agriculture and food products on the European market. As part of that, there is a proposal to harmonise the marketing of all parts of the hemp plant. At the moment, hemp is an eligible crop under what is called the basic income support for sustainability scheme, subject to certain conditions that the crop has to be grown from a variety included in the common catalogue. It has to include a THC content less than 0.3%. It has to be grown from certified seed. It can be grown in the EU. That is the CAP regulation but different member states have different national measures on the basis of grounds of public health, where there are different levels of restrictive measures.
Comment on this
They are different European countries.
Comment on this
Different member states have different restrictions on the use of certain parts of the hemp plant. It would come under drugs legislation. That has to do with the level of THC in the plant. It is a-----
Comment on this
Will that take it out of the Department of Health? Is that what Dr. O'Reilly is trying to do in order that there will be no need for legislation if it is below 0.3%?
Comment on this
At the moment, the hemp plant is covered under the misuse of drugs regulation. There is a restriction on the processing and use of certain parts of the hemp plant. These are the parts of the hemp plant that contain THC.
Comment on this
In order to create a level playing field for all farmers across the EU and to ensure the proper functioning of the European market, it is proposed to harmonise the marketing of all parts of the hemp plant.
Comment on this
A licence would still be needed if they are going to harmonise all parts. Dr. O'Reilly was asked what meetings he has had with the Department of Health. He did not have any with it. What about the Department of justice or the Department of housing? At the end of the day, most of this crop will be used for construction. It is the important bit. The cost of fertiliser is rising. We have environmental targets to meet. This seems to be an absolute no-brainer. Dr. O'Reilly should be running out looking for farmers to do this in order that we are not paying a huge fine. We do not have long left. This is a no-brainer. Why have the four Departments - health, justice, housing and agriculture - not come together? If they have not, they should organise a meeting with the witnesses next week because it is important that we meet our targets, which we are not going to, but let us get as close to them as we can. These crops are done in five months and sold to harvest.
People were in here last week. One man was getting blocks from France. France is supplying 60% of the market. He reckons that he is paying double the price of what it could be produced for here. Another man who appeared before the committee is willing to invest in the mechanical and production part of it. I know Dr. O'Reilly or someone in the Department listened to the agriculture committee last week. What is stopping us? What is stopping us from going forward with this? Unless I am missing parts of the puzzle here, it is an absolute no-brainer.
Comment on this
We engage with the Department of Health on licensing and so on. We carried out a previous consultation back in 2018, prior to the one carried out in 2021, where we engaged with the regulatory authorities, the Department of justice, the Department of Health and the HPRA. One of the main conclusions of those involved in the regulation of hemp was that its regulation should be continued to be regulated by the Department of Health and should be subject to strict levels of control. That was the view of the regulatory authorities at the time. If farmers want to grow a crop of hemp to produce either fibre or seed, they can do that at the moment. They have to have a licence because essentially the plant is a schedule A drug under the Misuse of Drugs Act. They have to have a licence-----
Comment on this
It is very difficult for a farmer to work one year and then to be unsure if he or she will get the licence next year. It is difficult for farmers to start sowing crops like that. The other side of this is that this crop is grown generally from spring into the end of summer. There is less risk. There is less risk of rain and floods. The Department of agriculture will place a strong emphasis on forestry but if a farmer sows a forest for 30 years and one storm knocks it, he or she is gone, whereas with hemp - I have done the calculations - a farmer will get more money every year if the crop produces a decent crop. Hemp farmers actually make more money than they would for forestry but if winds come, a farmer is gone or cleaned out.
Comment on this
I welcome our guests today. I have three questions, one for Dr. O'Reilly, one for Ms Cotter and one for Mr. Lyons. Dr. O'Reilly mentioned the proposal to amend the CMO in his statement presented to us today. We got it in advance, and he read it into the record today. He mentioned the proposal to amend the CMO regulations as part of the post-2027 CAP. He said that the proposal allows for the harmonising of the EU rules, covering all parts of hemp plant and the maximum legal THC. He also mentioned that discussions are ongoing on the proposal under the Irish Presidency of the Council of the European Union. Could he fill us in on the background a little bit? Where is the trajectory of all of that going? Where is it anticipated that this might be going?
Comment on this
I will speak about why there is a proposal on harmonising all parts of the hemp plant. Essentially, because of the bioeconomy, there are opportunities to use other parts of the hemp plant other than fibre. In order to try to exploit the maximum potential from the hemp plant, there is this proposal at the moment. At the moment, however, different member states have different levels and tolerances for THC and hemp products, so different member states would have different restrictions in terms of the marketing of certain parts of the hemp plant. This is what this proposal is aiming to do.
Comment on this
Will Dr. O'Reilly share a copy of that proposal with the committee?
Comment on this
It is new to me, and I think it would be interesting to try to get some understanding in relation to it. In terms of the trajectory of that and the discussions, these are under the EU-Irish Presidency. Clearly, our Minister for agriculture could carry some influence in relation to this, if influence was required. I am simply not in the possession of all of that, and I do not think any member of the committee is either. I suggest to Dr. O'Reilly that the committee would get a memo on that and where it is envisaged to take that. Would that be okay?
Comment on this
That is great. I appreciate that.
Ms Cotter had an interesting paper. I congratulate her on her work. Clearly, she put a lot of research and development into this area. That is important.
Teagasc was in here last week and it has a specific role in research, innovation, farm diversification and education. It has a very broad remit. What is the Ms Cotter's organisation's experience and relationship with Teagasc? Has it found it to be a positive one or a helpful one? Did she expect more and get less? She might share with the committee, in one minute, what the dynamic is in the relationship with Teagasc.
Comment on this
We have had an incredibly positive relationship with Teagasc. I could not overstate that. We launched the hemp for soil project in Teagasc at its hemp event in 2022 in Ashtown. Teagasc, in our relationship with it, is very innovative, forward-thinking and very supportive. From our experience, it wants the best for the farmer and it is willing to put its money where its mouth is. It will stand by the farmer and support them. It will support the research on behalf of the farmer. We are a voluntary group. I do this in my spare time. I have a day job.
Comment on this
I am not a scientist and I am not a farmer but I really believe in this crop and in what it can do for my local area. Teagasc has been great in that regard.
Comment on this
In summary then, it is a positive experience.
Comment on this
Has Ms Cotter's group plans, going forward, for more collaboration with Teagasc on their work?
Comment on this
Yes. We have two ongoing projects. One is to create a living lab. That is across four European countries. It is part of the Soilcrates EIP. We are a member of that project group so we will be liaising with Teagasc on the creation of a living lab in County Clare. We also have the SCEENE project on soil carbon enhancement. We will also be liaising with Teagasc on that.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Cotter very much for that. It is a really positive takeaway and I am glad to hear it.
Turning to Mr. Lyons, in the last paragraph of his submission, which was also excellent, he said the Irish company Kingspan is leading the way in hemp-based insulation. That is exciting. Kingspan is an amazing company. It is at the edge of this area in construction and is very impressive. Has there been any dialogue or engagement about contract growing of hemp for Kingspan?
Comment on this
Kingspan has said there is not the decortication. There is not a factory here at the moment. It had to go to Europe, which is leading the way. We are falling behind. We seem to be the only country in Europe that is not doing something with hemp. Kingspan is actually importing it, which adds carbon credits to material that could be produced here.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Lyons feel there is potential for further collaboration and engagement with the company? Is it willing? I do not know what the relationship is.
Comment on this
Absolutely. Why would it import hemp if it could be produced here?
Comment on this
How is that progressing in terms of Mr. Lyons's organisation?
Comment on this
It has not progressed at all because, as I said, that conversation is not even happening because there is no infrastructure here. The company is looking to Europe at the moment. We do not have an infrastructure here. We do not have a decortication plant. We cannot produce the material for the company at the moment.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Lyons have any knowledge of the quantity of material Kingspan is currently using?
Comment on this
I do not have information on that at all. It bought the whole line of HempFlax, which is a German company that produces a lot of material. I do not have the figures on that but I assume it is quite substantial.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. Their contributions have been very enlightening in terms of our understanding of this debate and I thank them for coming before us.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses very much for their contributions, which I read with great interest.
From the Department's perspective, there was mention of current legislation in Ireland. I am always glad when I see it described as "current" because that means it can change. That is one of the things I look forward to. To go back to the part of it where the officials talked about the CMO and how this is being negotiated at the moment, my understanding of that is it is to get an even playing field across all the countries in Europe so we will have the same regulation in all the countries. Right now Ireland probably has more strict regulations than a lot of other countries in Europe. Would that be fair to say? The 0.3% THC limit was mentioned. This product really comes from the seed. We know if certain seeds are grown a product has a lower percentage than that so if the seed grows lower than that percentage are we looking at a scenario where it will not require approval or licence from the Department of Health? Is that the direction of travel?
Comment on this
When the Deputy talks about Ireland being more restrictive, Irish legislation restricts the processing and sale of certain parts of the hemp plant. Upon cultivation they have to be destroyed. They are drugs under the misuse of drugs regulation. That is in line with a lot of other European member states, so we are not on our own in that regard. Regardless of-----
Comment on this
Do other member states have one-year licences or multiple-year licences?
Comment on this
I understand they have multiple-year licences.
Comment on this
-----the licensing operates in other European countries but just in terms of the broader legislative framework, we are in line with some other European countries with respect to our restrictions on certain parts of the hemp plant. Hemp belongs to the genus - the family - of cannabis.
Comment on this
It is a schedule 1 controlled drug under the misuse of drugs regulation. It is there for public health reasons. These regulations are in place for reasons of public health.
Comment on this
Yes, but the plant which is grown for industrial hemp, which is what we are talking about here, has a THC percentage lower than 0.3%. Thus, that particular plant does not have a narcotic use. Does Dr. O'Reilly accept that?
Comment on this
According to the current legislation it is a schedule 1 drug under the Misuse of Drugs Act.
Comment on this
Yes, it is a schedule 1. It is when the stalk, the seeds and the fibre are removed from that plant. These are the parts of the plant that do not contain any of the narcotic THC.
Comment on this
But even the flower and the leaves have lower than 0.3% THC.
Comment on this
They are still regarded as schedule 1 drugs. To be fair-----
Comment on this
Is that not folly? Does Dr. O'Reilly not see the folly of that?
Comment on this
To be fair, any provisions, when it comes to the misuse of drugs and public health provisions, are not a matter for the Department of agriculture but for the Department of Health and it is not appropriate for me to comment on it.
Comment on this
I understand that but if I put a bottle of wine and a bottle of grape juice in front of Dr. O'Reilly and said both come from the grape and therefore both have to regulated the same way, he would say that is ridiculous, would he not?
Comment on this
These are questions that are more appropriate for the Department of Health, to be honest.
Comment on this
We do not have the Department of Health here. We have the Department of agriculture here and farmers have to deal with the Department of agriculture. If farmers want to grow hemp it is the Department of agriculture that deals with this.
Comment on this
Not necessarily. As it is classified as a schedule 1 drug hemp is subject to licensing from the HPRA, so the licensing does not fall under the Department of agriculture.
Comment on this
Dr. O'Reilly is a representative of a Department of the State that is about promoting agriculture, the farmer's prospects of being able to make a living from the land and trying to sustain communities living in rural Ireland. Does he not understand this is a product that has potential and that because there is this folly in place whereby it is treated as if it were a drug when it is not it is inhibiting the Department of agriculture's ability to do what it is its responsibility to do?
Comment on this
It is currently, under the legislation. Any changes to that legislation are a matter for the Department of Health. In terms of-----
Comment on this
But the Department of agriculture has not met the Department of Health to speak about this.
Comment on this
We engage with the Department of Health on this but any change to this legislation or licensing is a matter for it. On the production of hemp for fibre use or seed use, farmers can do that at the moment.
Comment on this
I have spoken to farmers who have told me they want to grow hemp and if it is found they are going to grow the hemp close to a main road the issuing of a licence is frowned upon because it is thought people passing on the road are going start pulling the leaves off the crop. Is that the reason for it? We had an expert here last week who informed us that to grow the hemp that would produce cannabis you would need to have temperature in excess of, I think, 35° C. You might get it started, maybe, some of these days but it would not grow. Where it is grown illegally it is done in attics with big lights to keep it going. It makes no sense. I go back to the point that a bottle of wine and a bottle of grape juice come from the vine but they are different products. Just because they come from the same plant they should not be licensed the same way, and they are not, so why do we licence this the same way?
Comment on this
It is because under the legislation at the moment these are controlled drugs.
Comment on this
And that is a matter for the Department of Health.
Comment on this
Can I tease that out a little with Dr. O'Reilly? Is it primary legislation that needs to change or could we look at regulation changes?
Comment on this
The misuse of drugs regulation does not fall under the remit of the Department of agriculture so I cannot comment on that.
What I can say is that if farmers want to grow hemp for fibre or seed use - those are the two things hemp can be used for at the moment - they can apply for a licence.
Comment on this
They will generally get it. I accept that.
Comment on this
To my knowledge, there are no obstacles or impediments to getting a licence to grow hemp at the moment.
Comment on this
I have one final point. I know my time is running out, Chair-----