We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

Hemp Production: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Hemp producers and community representatives argued that the crop could diversify tillage, improve soils and supply construction and other industries, but annual licensing and the lack of processing infrastructure and secure markets are holding back growth. The Department said hemp can be licensed for fibre or seed, but current drug-control rules are a matter for Health and commercial expansion depends on industry-led proposals and investment; it said it had not received a viable proposal. Members pressed the Department to show greater leadership and work across departments to address licensing and market barriers. The Department also outlined proposed EU-wide harmonisation of rules for hemp plant products, and the Chair suggested inviting the Department of Health to give evidence.

Contributions 150–300 of 300. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Dr. Barry O'Reilly

In recent years, the vast majority of applications for a licence to grow hemp have been granted so I do not understand-----

Comment on this

Dr. O'Reilly stated that a change is coming under the review by the Chief Medical Officer, CMO. I understand the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs in Northern Ireland is looking at aligning with this as well, so it would be a bit of a farce if one side of the Border, which is outside the European Union, were to align with the rest of Europe and we were to fail to. We need to get our act together. Whether it is the Department of Health, the Department of education or whatever, we need to recognise that this is not a drug. It is an industrial crop and it needs to be treated appropriately. The Department of agriculture, which is supposed to be working for the benefit of developing the agricultural sector in Ireland, needs to step up to the plate and say to the Department of Health that this is ridiculous.

Comment on this

Before I go to Deputy Lawless, it may well be that we should invite the Department of Health to discuss this as well.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. This is important and the committee recognises that there is significant value for farmers in hemp production. The Department needs to show more leadership in this. The industry is crying out for support and regulation that will allow it to produce this product at scale under a multi-annual framework. It needs a processing ability to bring its product to market. The Department is saying farmers can do it if they want to, but they cannot without the infrastructure and processing ability so it is a little disingenuous to say that. The point I want to make is that the committee is fairly unanimous in its support and the Department needs to show more leadership. Whether it is to the Department of agriculture, Health, housing or justice, it needs to happen. It is not good enough for the Department of agriculture to state that this is under the remit of the Department of Health because farmers cannot engage with the Department of Health. It is important that message go back loud and clear because there are major issues, processing being a large one, while licensing being only on a yearly basis is an impediment in itself. People cannot seek infrastructure or funding if they only have a licence to produce it for a year. Where is the bottleneck? How can we move to a situation where mult-iannual licences can be granted? Is it the Department of Health that is stopping it? Will Dr. O'Reilly engage proactively with the Department of Health to take it out of its remit and get this recognised as the commercial crop it is?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

As I said at the outset, we understand what the issues are. We carried out a consultation, which identified a number of things that need to be done to kickstart and scale up a hemp fibre industry here. We have made it clear that we are open to proposals coming from the hemp industry and we will certainly consider those proposals but-----

Comment on this

Can I make this point to Mr. O'Reilly? One of the issues in the consultation was the lack of viability, but last week the committee had important witnesses before it, including a businessman who is willing to invest significant money in a processing plant and farmers willing to grow it. What comes first? Is it the chicken or the egg? The Department says the industry needs to show viability and so on, but the industry says it needs a market and the ability to produce. The bottleneck needs to be unblocked. If the Department of agriculture says viability is the issue and the Department of Health says something else, we will go around in circles and we will be having the same conversation for another five or ten years.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

The consultation was carried out in 2021, which is five years ago. There have probably been developments in the market since then. We have been clear all along that if stakeholders from the hemp industry come to us with a viable proposal, we will certainly consider it. I would like to give that message to the industry, that if there are viable proposals to kickstart a hemp industry here, we will certainly engage with it on that.

Comment on this

Will Dr. O'Reilly outline the process if that were to come next week? Is it the case that the Department of agriculture needs to go to the Department of Health to take it out of its remit in order for it to be recognised as a commercial agricultural crop?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

We would have to consider what the proposal is first to see what the next steps to develop it would be.

Comment on this

Since 2022 and the consultation, has the Department of agriculture received any proposal on hemp?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

To the best of my knowledge, we have not got any proposals. Perhaps Mr. Quirke could answer.

Comment on this
Mr. James Quirke

To recap on what Dr. O'Reilly said, the consultation ended with the conclusion that we were open to submissions from industry. To date, we have not received any submissions.

Comment on this

Can I bring Teagasc in on that point?

Comment on this
Mr. James Quirke

I will just continue on that. Last week in the discussion here, there were mentions of money and investment, but we have not seen them on our end. Until we see them, we cannot decide on it.

From the point of view of it being an agricultural crop, it is already recognised in the Department of agriculture. It gets paid under the basic income for sustainability scheme, BISS. It is also eligible for eco-schemes so it is a viable agricultural crop from that perspective.

Comment on this

What role does Teagasc play and what role does it see itself playing in it? Tillage is on its knees. Teagasc has a big role in terms of research and so on. What submissions has it made to the Department on hemp?

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

I do not know that we have made any particular submissions to the Department on hemp. We had a large biomass programme, which ended a few years ago. A lot of work was done in that programme on the production of hemp and how to produce it and that information all sits there. Our view was that it is not a lack of technical information about how to grow hemp. It is the market failure, as other people have been saying. There is no processing facility.

Comment on this

How do we address that? Does Teagasc have a view on whether that needs to be led by the Department or the industry or be co-funded? How do we get there?

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

We have a large research centre funded by Research Ireland called BiOrbic, whose role is to develop the circular bio-economy, and it delivers projects like this, usually in a co-funded model where there is matched funding from the industry.

Lots of people ask how we can benefit from the potential of hemp, particularly to meet our climate targets. Currently, we cannot recognise the carbon sequestered from hemp being used in hempcrete or insulation according to the inventory, so a job of work needs to be done. The inventory assumes that if an annual crop like hemp is grown, the carbon taken up by the crop is released again when it is harvested. If timber is harvested, it goes into harvested wood products and if the timber is used in the construction of a house, the assumption is that the carbon will be locked up for 35 years. We cannot currently do that with hemp. It would require a body of work to do a lifecycle analysis from the production of the crop to the production of insulation or hempcrete, which could be submitted to the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, as published work. The EPA would then have to approach the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, IPCC, for us to be allowed to take credit for the carbon from the hemp locked up in buildings under the inventory. There is a body of work to do, but as I said, there is a Research Ireland-funded centre, which is there to develop exactly this type of thing.

Comment on this
Mr. Daniel Lyons

In the past few years, if you went to Enterprise Ireland, the local enterprise office or the local enterprise board and said that you were interested in hemp and looking for funding, they would have nothing to do with you. They would not even entertain you. Something else was going on in the background. If you went looking for funding from any of the local enterprise agencies, they just said no. They wanted nothing to do with hemp. That was a big issue.

Comment on this

One of the big issues here is that all of the----

Comment on this

Deputy Lawless will get another opportunity. Deputy Fitzmaurice is next.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I have a few questions for Dr. O'Reilly and the officials from the Department. They recognise that there is an opportunity for the use of industrial hemp in the construction sector. Which Department is the lead regarding the policy on hemp? Is it the Department of agriculture, the Department of climate action or the Department of Health?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

When it comes to general crop policy, that would come under the Department of agriculture. We have responsibility for crop policy.

Comment on this

Which is the lead Department in respect of the overall policy document of hemp?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Because hemp is classed as a Schedule 1 drug, it falls under the remit of the Department of Health.

Comment on this

Does Dr. O'Reilly agree that it is falling between a few stools?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

From a regulatory point of view, regulation of the actual crop falls to the Department of Health. From a general crop policy perspective, trying to develop the crop sector here falls to the Department of agriculture.

Comment on this

There was reference earlier to a proposal that was supposed to come. It was stated that no proposal came. What budget is there for any proposals in that regard?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

We do not have any budget.

Comment on this

The Department has no budget but is looking for proposals.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Certainly, we have limited funding mechanisms in the Department, whether it be support for decortication units or whatever. It is possible that there are mechanisms across other Departments or agencies. We would be happy enough to engage with those Departments.

Comment on this

There is no budget for promoting it at the moment.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

No.

Comment on this

There was a guy here last week from Australia who has hemp businesses in other European countries. He is willing to come to Ireland and create employment. I have seen the blocks that are made using it. I have looked at it for a while. That is the market. What have the Department of agriculture officials done under TAMS to facilitate the machinery for people to be able to grow hemp? What gear can people get under TAMS to facilitate the growing of hemp in Ireland?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

There is a lot of----

Comment on this

No, I am talking about machinery under TAMS. I know the list. The Department officials are over that sector in the context of putting forward the policy on hemp and trying to bring it or other alternatives forward. What have they done under the TAMS programme to get machinery included that would help those farmers to make a market?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

There would be a lot of machinery that could be used for the cultivation of hemp.

Comment on this

No, I am talking specifically on hemp. I know the gear they use. Tell me if that gear is in it.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

When you talk about----

Comment on this

I will ask a simpler question. Is there an opportunity for a person to get a grant for a shed, specifically for getting the machinery into it, through TAMS?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

I do not think there are any grants under TAMS for machinery storage but there would be support for cultivation equipment that would and could be used for the cultivation of hemp.

Comment on this

I remember that there was specialised equipment previously. Grant aid from the Department grant could be applied for if that type of stuff was not available in Ireland. Is the Department willing to look at that avenue when it comes to funding for the different machinery that is required? I refer to the equipment for cutting it. We made turf machines in our day. People made turf machines because they had to design them. The stuff for cutting it could be designed. People could gear combines or gear stuff their own way to solve that. It is the gear that is needed for bringing it into the shed, where you need a bit of drying, or to take off one part from the other. There is a name for it - decortisone or whatever.

Comment on this

Decortication.

Comment on this

That gear to make it into a product that we can use. This is where the road block is. There is a road block before we even get there. We cannot even get on the plane to take off. Because of what Deputy Kenny said there about the 0.3 THC limit, it seems that someone in some Department thinks that some fellow down the road might use the industrial hemp that is to be put into blocks in order to get high. Maybe the committee could get guidance as to whether we need to bring in the Department of Justice or how we filter this. Maybe there should be a specialised licence in respect of the use of industrial hemp in the construction industry if that is what we want. We could do it whatever way we want in order to ensure that it is used specifically for that purpose. Would the Department be willing to look at that?

Some of the people who were in last week have sown the gear and have done a huge amount of research. They met the Australians and brought them here. Would the officials be willing to meet some of those people in order to discover how we can make a pathway forward, particularly in circumstances where people are interested in doing this? I was amazed by the blocks. I visited the IDA Ireland office in Athlone. Representatives of Connacht Fibre were there. I was amazed by the blocks that are made out of hemp. They are fascinating. They are handy. Lifting one is not like lifting a concrete block, but they are insulated and so on. I was amazed by what you can do. I was ignorant as to what you can do with it, to be quite frank. Are the officials willing to sit down with those people, to work out even a pilot project in part of the country for year one, to see how we can work this? We have the backing of that guy from Australia. He is willing to bring 35 jobs here. Is that what he said the last day?

Comment on this

The Deputy only has a minute left.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

As I said before, if there are any viable proposals coming from industry or individual stakeholders, we are happy to consider them. Absolutely, we would be happy to meet with any stakeholder who comes forward with viable proposals in order to develop the sector.

Comment on this

I am sorry I was not here for the presentation last week. I understand that hemp can be grown on marginal ground. It is unfortunate, but there is a lot of land in north Longford, Leitrim, parts of Cavan and in my area that is marginal. It should possibly be seen as a catch-crop or another way of supporting smaller rural farmers, where it is not viable to live off the land with a suckler herd, sheep and so on. I am amazed. Who issues the licences for the production of industrial hemp? Is it the Department?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

The Health Products Regulatory Authority, HPRA, operates the licensing system under the auspices of the Department of Health.

Comment on this

If I decided to grow hemp tomorrow morning, who do I go to in order to get a licence?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

The HPRA.

Comment on this

When I want to harvest it, where do I go?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Once you have the licence and you sign up to the conditions relating to it, you are free to harvest the crop. There are certain requirements in relation to cultivating the crop that you sign up to when you are awarded the licence.

The most important conditions are that the leaves and flowers of that crop, which contain THC, a controlled substance, must be destroyed and cultivated. They cannot be processed or sold on.

Comment on this

Where does the Department of agriculture come in if I am dealing with the Department of Health on this?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

The Department of agriculture has certain controls from the point of view of the CAP regulation. Under CAP regulation, it is an eligible crop under BISS, and there are requirements under the CAP regulation in relation to varieties grown below a certain THC content. There are certain requirements in terms of verification of those varieties. We do a certain amount of sampling every year of hemp crops and get them tested to ensure they comply with the legal requirements.

Comment on this

How many licences for hemp were issued last year?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Over the past three years, between 2023 and 2025, there was an average of 27 licences issued annually.

Comment on this

What amount was grown in 27 licences?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

In terms of the area licensed, there was an average of 80 ha per year. It has dropped back in recent years. Ninety ha were declared under the Department's BISS scheme in 2023. That dropped back to 30 ha in 2024 and 2025, and it has reduced again this year.

Comment on this

It has reduced again this year?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Eleven ha were declared under BISS.

Comment on this

If it is so viable and it is so good, why is it reducing?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

As we discussed before, the main issue is the market-----

Comment on this

The market is there. We have been talking about the market for the past ten minutes.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

There are issues in relation to processing. There are no processing facilities there. If a farmer goes-----

Comment on this

We are back to the same scenario, to the processing industry.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

The market is the big issue here-----

Comment on this

No. Do not go to the market. We are after saying for the past ten minutes that there is no problem with the market so we are not going to the market again. The problem is with the harvesting industry. The monkey in the room is the harvesting industry. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

It is probably the processing industry. There are no processing facilities there at the moment.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

I am not sure why. Is it lack of confidence-----

Comment on this

We have men coming in here who are doing a great job. If I have something viable tomorrow morning, people will invest in it. We know the product is there, it is grown on marginal land and the farmers will grow it. There is a problem between the Departments of Health and agriculture which we have not solved. There is a problem with harvesting. It is incumbent on us as a committee to offer solutions. How do we find a solution? We find it through harvesting.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

I am not sure what point the Senator is trying to make.

Comment on this

The point is the problem is around the harvesting of hemp. Is that not correct? Is that not the problem we have at this time?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

This crop can be harvested for fibre. You can harvest the crop for fibre. There is no issue with the harvesting. Under the current licensing regime, a person is free to harvest the crop and the stalk of the crop.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

For fibre use. There is absolutely no issue there at all.

Comment on this

There is no processing, that is the point. If there is no processing, how do you process it? There is no processing plant. The reality is, have we investors in this country that want to put up a processing plant? Has anybody come to Dr. O’Reilly wanting to build a processing plant?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

No.

Comment on this

Without seeking anybody, have the witnesses had promotion and engagement with the Departments of Health and agriculture when they went to promote this industry?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

We have a lot of correspondence in relation to hemp and a lot of engagement with different stakeholders. We have been clear all along that if the industry brings forward proposals to us, we will certainly consider them.

Comment on this

Dr. O’Reilly is asking for an individual to bring a proposal. Is that what he is asking for?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Absolutely. As I said in my opening statement, we would welcome proposals.

Comment on this

However, the Department has no funding in place to support proposals.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

We do not have any funding in place, but we could look at what funding options might be available. There could be other funding options available from other State agencies or Government Departments. We would have to look at that.

Comment on this

There is an opportunity here to support rural communities by growing hemp. We certainly cannot sit on this. The Department of agriculture cannot sit on this. Whatever supports need to come in need to come in, and we need to get some sort of acknowledgement that this is viable and can be processed in this country. We are going to go around in circles here.

Comment on this

There is a vote called in the Dáil, so members will have to head over for that. We will suspend the meeting and resume again in ten minutes.

Comment on this

We are still on the first round. Does Senator Eileen Lynch wish to speak? No. Time permits a second round. We will run through the same order.

Comment on this

I apologise again for having to leave the last time. I have not had the chance yet but I will go through the record and get the end of what Dr. O'Reilly was saying. When I was going out, he was saying that it is not financially viable to grow hemp. I am a suckler farmer and it would not be financially viable to be a suckler farmer either if it was not for supports, initiatives and incentives from the Department to keep the industry alive and to promote it. Why is the Department promoting one side of a sector if it will not promote another? I am frustrated at a lot of what I have heard here today.

We need initiative. Leadership was mentioned. We are depending on the Department for leadership. I gave the example of the tillage sector. Some €30 million was put into a scheme to give tillage farmers €110 per hectare, which works out at about €44 per acre. If we used that €30 million to incentivise this, it would be a better incentive for tillage farmers. Somebody should just take the bull by the horns. It has been mentioned that Kingspan is importing this stuff. Someone with the appetite should just show leadership and initiative and pick up the phone to ring somebody in Kingspan. It would be a very simple conversation. That person should ask if, given that Kingspan is importing this stuff, it would fund a processing plant if we incentivised farmers to grow the product to feed into it.

The officials have said they will talk to the Department of Health. It is the HPRA that licenses this product and the Department is in constant contact with the HPRA in respect of veterinary medicines and so on. The officials could be talking to the HPRA in the morning. If there was a will, the industrial side of this could come under the Department of agriculture, which could give four-, five- or six-year licences, with conditions.

I am a bit bemused at Teagasc's outlook here today because, seven days ago, it was very pro-hemp because it sequesters a serious amount of carbon. Today, it is questioning whether the carbon escapes on harvest. Since that was said, I have found out, through a very small bit of research, that the stalk, the lime binder, acts as a carbon sink for 50 years. That is a fact. I do not know why Mr. Spink has put a bit of a negative twist on it. I am a bit bemused by that.

There is a bit of circling of the wagons here. It is a case of ticking the box, getting out of this meeting, getting back behind our desks and not hearing hemp mentioned again until God knows when. We need leadership. We need the witnesses to take the bull by the horns. There is a serious opportunity being missed. If the Department is not going to lead on it, who is? The officials should make that phone call to Kingspan to get the wheels in motion and get the private sector involved in this. It is easy to say it is a question for the Department of health or the Department of enterprise or some other Department. I am solutions-driven. I have come from the private sector. I am very frustrated here today because all we are doing is circling the wagons in the hope that we will move on and talk about something else next week. I am sorry, Chair, but I am frustrated.

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

I am not saying the carbon is lost at harvest. I am saying-----

Comment on this

You said that it has to be proven that it is not.

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

I am saying it is not recognised-----

Comment on this

It has been proven in Europe.

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

It is not-----

Comment on this

It is a carbon sink for 50 years. That is proven. That is in an official document. Teagasc does not have to do its own tests if the tests have already been done somewhere else. As far as I am concerned, it is a stalling tactic.

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

I am saying it is not recognised in the inventory so the country cannot benefit from it. It could be if that information is presented to the EPA.

Comment on this

We are putting up barriers here. Instead of grasping a potential positive, every time I make a suggestion or ask a question, a barrier is put up and I am given a reason not to do it. It is very frustrating. While it might not be a silver bullet, this is a crop and a product that will go a long way towards rescuing our tillage sector. The Department should be leading on that. We are throwing €30 million out on a scheme to provide €44 per acre. We should invest that €30 million in trying to get this up and running with Kingspan or some other company. It is like the sugar beet model we had years ago. If we get this thing up and running, I guarantee it will be the saviour of the tillage industry.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Lyons to respond very briefly because we need to get to the next speaker.

Comment on this
Mr. Daniel Lyons

The only reason it would be putting carbon back up into the atmosphere is that we do not have a processing factory, which would allow us to lock in the carbon. If the farmers grow it, they have nowhere to go with it. It rots in the field.

Comment on this

They have been told they can burn it. If they have to burn it, the carbon is going back. That is what is happening. They have nowhere to go with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Daniel Lyons

You may as well burn it because there is no processing factory. That is the only reason it would put carbon back into the atmosphere. We are not processing the stuff.

Comment on this

We need leadership on this. We need someone who will not say that it is someone else's problem, baby or initiative.

Comment on this

Last week, we heard about hemp production from the industrial and construction sector. One person said that they wanted to invest millions in this country rather than importing it because they cannot source it here, which is very unfortunate in a country which is, as we are all well aware, ideal for growing it. We are also aware of the Kingspan investment that was announced during the week. Can the Department officials explain why the terms of reference for the study into the commercial viability of hemp was restricted to fibre use only? Did this narrow focus contribute to the finding that the crop is not viable?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

It was restricted to fibre use only because that is what was set out in the previous Government's programme for Government. It was a programme for Government commitment that a consultation would be done on the potential for fibre crops and whether there was a viable market for them. That is essentially the reason it was restricted to fibre use only. In addition, apart from the seed, processing the other parts of the plant is not allowed.

If I may come back to Senator Daly's point on doing another study on market viability, we have always said that we will consider proposals but we have not seen any. It would be very useful. We hear different figures on market returns and so on. It would be useful to have a proposal that would substantiate all these figures and that would go into detail on the current value of the sector, the current volume and so on.

Comment on this

My time is being used up now as well. Does Dr. O'Reilly think it was a mistake for the consultation to consider fibre use only?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

That was set out in the programme for Government so it-----

Comment on this

Does Dr. O'Reilly think it was a mistake, however?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

At the moment, the plant can only be used for fibre production or the production of seed. You cannot use the other parts of the plant to add value under current legislation.

Comment on this

Is the Department undertaking a review of hemp's viability on a whole-plant, multimarket basis, to include construction-grade hemp and bio-composite manufacturing, both of which are established markets in other member states? Do we have a problem here that is preventing us from going down that road?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

I am sorry; could the Deputy-----

Comment on this

Does Dr. O'Reilly want me to read it out again for him? Is the Department undertaking a review of hemp's viability on a whole-plant, multimarket basis, to include construction-grade hemp and bio-composite manufacturing, both of which are established markets in other member states? What is the Department's view? Is the Department going to undertake a review?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

We have done the consultation on hemp as a fibre crop. The outcome of that was fairly clear. A number of things have to happen before we can develop a fibre industry here. Two of the main things are that we need investment in processing and that we need collaboration among all of the stakeholders, including growers, processors and manufacturers. We all need to work together to develop a properly functioning supply chain to give confidence to investors and to the farmers who will actually grow the crop.

Comment on this

We need to marry the views we heard today and those we heard last week as regards hemp. This is from Teagasc. All of us in agriculture look up to Teagasc. We ask it for the best advice. It does a lot of research. A lot of public money goes into it. The report from Barry Caslin from last year was very clear that Teagasc held two conferences on this matter. It said that Teagasc was absolutely in favour of this crop and that it saw it as something that could save the whole industry, into which fewer and fewer people are going. It is awful to see what is happening at the moment. We have a situation where it is not paying people to do something. They are barely breaking even and depend on the price of straw. The last thing any person who has any interest in producing food wants to see is solar panels being installed on good land but that is what we are now seeing around the countryside. People out there are saying that this would at least give them a steady income. We are here as elected public representatives representing the section of the community we are talking about here today. We have to look at the best advice we have got from Teagasc. The conclusion here was that industrial hemp for fibre and hurd should be treated as an agricultural and materials policy matter. These are the finest of people. Cian O'Reilly prepared this. These are people who have done a huge amount of research into this matter.

That brings us back here today. I have something to say to Margaret Cotter. I have been involved in the all-Ireland national competition, the IPB Pride of Place Awards, before.

The project was nominated for what they did. To get nominated for that, anybody who ever served on a local authority would be absolutely delighted. Here we are, and I am asking everyone present, including my colleagues on the committee here today, if we see any light at the end of the tunnel for this in the next five years. Whoever will be sitting on this committee in the next five or ten years will say that the tillage allocation in this country has decreased. I would be nervous to say what the number of hectares would be but at the moment they are going into solar panels and so on. For me personally, there is nothing as bad as seeing solar panels on good ground. This is why we are here today and we are asking the Department. My argument is that one can push the buck over to the Department of Health but the bottom line is that Department of agriculture issues the licence. In this matter, the Department of agriculture is responsible for the progress of whatever the alternative is - let us say spring barley or, as I call it, a replacement for beet. The crop ticks all the boxes for that and it seems to be a no-brainer not to do it. I do not see any will whatsoever in the Department of agriculture to stand up and say, "We acknowledge that this could be a very good rotational crop in the tillage industry." It is not going to happen. What alternatives are there then? To be fair to the people who came in here, they were guaranteed a price. Everybody is guaranteed a price for something. Take the milk industry, for example. We are guaranteed a price and we are told at the beginning of the year that it will not drop below such a price, so we can we can make alternatives for it. Just like the Cathaoirleach-----

Comment on this

Thank you, Deputy. I call Deputy Newsome Drennan.

Comment on this

-----I would love to come out of this meeting and say, "Yes, there is light at the end of the tunnel", and for something to happen.

Comment on this

Deputy Newsome Drennan has the floor.

Comment on this

The Chair did give a lot of the others over two minutes. I have it written down here because I want to present it to the Chair at the end of the year. That is all I want to say.

Comment on this

Deputy, we are on round two-----

Comment on this

I would ask the Department of agriculture to please do something. That is all I ask.

Comment on this

-----and the Deputy is taking time from the other members. Deputy Newsome Drennan, please.

Comment on this

I went through the parts on the Department of Health and the Department of justice. The other one that should be consulted in this is the Department of the environment. What I can see is that, basically, nobody is talking to anybody. If France has 60% of the market, I presume it has its own research done. The French are our counterparts in Europe. We spend a lot of money on research when we could and should be using and feeding into each other's research. Has the Department or Teagasc looked into any of the reports that were done in France? If it has 60% of the market, it is doing something right.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

I am not too sure about the agronomy of hemp production in France but-----

Comment on this

So the Department has not looked into it. That is okay. I do not want to waste my time. If the Department has not looked into it, that is fine. I think the Department should look into it. As a farmer, we want to produce food or crops. We like to go out and see when the crop is starting, when it is finalised and when we harvest it, or if it is cattle when we bring them to the factory. That is what we farm for. We do not farm to see solar farms or wind farms sitting on our land. That is not what we want. There is a lot of research done already and we can see that it is good for our environment. We have to look into it. All Departments should be looking into this. I am pleading with the witnesses to talk to the Departments of justice and housing, and the environment section. The environment section should be jumping in on this. If there was a will, this could be done.

I want to give the rest of my time to Ms Cotter or Mr. Lyons. Does Ms Cotter want to talk about the project? Mr. Lyons studied industrial hemp. They have one and a half minutes between them and I will give them the floor. I thank them for coming in.

Comment on this
Mr. Daniel Lyons

To be honest, in my opinion it is an absolutely fabulous crop and it is a no brainer. We have the problem where Ireland will be fined in the coming years over the greenhouse emissions. We are talking about ten to 15 tonnes of carbon pulled out of the atmosphere in one single growing season. If we can get a decortication factory up and running, we can lock in that carbon. We can build houses and make insulation. The seeds can be used for protein for animals and humans. There is no end to the potential for this product, to be honest. To me it is absolutely a no-brainer. Farmers are ringing me weekly looking to grow 50 or 100 acres. The drive is there for farmers to do it but there is nowhere to go with the product at the end of the day. Basically, they may as well let it rot in the field, the carbon can go back up to atmosphere and we are just wasting our time at the end of the day. It is an absolutely fabulous crop with massive potential. We are missing a trick here, to be honest.

Comment on this

It is a bit like going around in a circle. We had people here last week who were willing to put the investment in, then we have Departments that are failing this industry, and then we have our witnesses who have done research and projects. Without one piece being fixed in the puzzle we are going to keep going around in circles and, like Deputy Aird said, whoever is here in ten years' time will still be going around and saying "Lads, what have you done?"

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Cotter

To be perfectly frank, what this really needs is multi-stakeholder engagement. Unless we get that, it will not work.

Comment on this

Last week and this week have been very useful from the point of view of getting to the core of what the issues are here. There are a number of issues and a market is one of them. Processing is a big issue to try to get that. We do have people in the industry, some of whom were here last week and others who are in the insulation business who are saying they have a market and a means of moving that forward and are prepared to make the investment. They are, however, hesitant to make the investment as long as they see the farmer having to overcome obstacles when it comes to regulation. We need to get both to work together. In fairness to the people from the Department of agriculture, or from any State agency, sometimes they will come into committee and we can be tough on them. That is fine and that is what we are here to do, and the witnesses understand that and we understand their position, but what we want to try to do here is get a solution. As Ms Cotter mentioned, what really needs to happen is multi-stakeholder engagement and getting everyone around the table and working this out. At the same time, we have a big barrier here and the big barrier is the Department of Health saying hemp is a narcotic. What we are talking about growing here is as far from a narcotic as Sitka spruce is. That is the reality, yet Sitka spruce is used, promoted and grown. It gets grants and tax-free status and all the other stuff because it has carbon sequestration benefits. This product has the very same benefits but it is pushed in the other direction. We need to change that. Ultimately, what we need is that stakeholder engagement. That is the challenge for the Department here more than anyone else because the Department is in the driving seat and needs to lead that engagement.

I mentioned Sitka spruce. Forestry is an example. The forestry industry was developed in Ireland by the Department. It was Coillte that developed the model of forestry we have now. Coillte went out around the country, including up beside me up on the mountains above Ballinamore and Drumshanbo, and planted huge areas of what was actually bog, which is very bad to plant. It planted that model of trees, whereby they were planted close together in rows and thinned seven or ten years later. Coillte came up with the model, found how it grew fast, and found the right type of trees that grew very quickly. Coillte perfected the model and then the private sector took it over. In other words, it was the State that had the deep pockets to take the risk.

We are not asking for the State to have the deep pockets to take the risk here. We are asking the State to be the enabler to ensure that this industry can get off the ground. A big part of being the enabler is removing this issue we have of health as a barrier. In fairness to the Department of agriculture, I know it has a job to do but part of that job needs to be working with the industry to try to remove that barrier and to work out a system whereby we can get industrial hemp. I do not understand, in some ways, why the actual growing of the crop needs to be licensed. I would have thought the only part of it that needs to be licensed is the seed. The seed needs to be licensed. If we license the seed, then only seeds that produce THC of below 0.3% can be sold.

As that is the only seed that can be bought, under licence, then farmers can experiment and plant two acres without the need for a licence because the seed is licensed. That would be my logical solution. It would mean that farmers can produce small amounts, see how it works and then decide whether to plant more or not to continue. One of the problems that arises when hemp production is mentioned to farmers is that they will say they are not going to risk planting 20 acres of their land with hemp when the outcome is unknown, but they would risk two or three acres. Then, however, the farmers discover that they have to go with a big licensing sector. What we need is the Department to become the enabler to get everyone around the table. If it took that on, it would be a huge benefit to emerge from this meeting.

Comment on this

I agree with the sentiments expressed by Deputy Kenny and that the Department needs to show leadership regarding the whole industry. Is it possible that hemp seed can be licensed?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Hemp seed is not a controlled substance because it does not contain any THC. It becomes controlled when planted because that is when the hemp plant is cultivated. A licence is required for the cultivation of hemp. Hemp seed can be freely marketed and used but a licence is required for planting.

Comment on this
Mr. Daniel Lyons

The seed is under licence already. It is grown in Europe. It is all tested. It is already below 0.3% THC. When someone buys seed it all has to go through certification. The seed that is bought from a licensed place is already certified. It is below the limits so, yes, that is quite possible.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

It is not a case of licensing seed. I look after seed certification in the work that I do. Any seed that is used for the production of hemp must first be included on what is called the common catalogue of varieties of agricultural plant species, be below 0.3% THC and meet other requirements in terms of distinct thickness, performance and suitability. There are a lot of regulations that govern seed production. Hemp seed has to be certified in accordance with a particular regulation, meet certain purity requirements, etc. That is all done officially.

The harvested seed can be freely marketed. It is when the seed is planted that a licence is required because the plant is being cultivated. In order to cultivate the plant, the seed must meet certain requirements, which includes the 0.3% limit.

Comment on this

If someone buys the seed under certification, why do they need to change it when they plant it?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

It is because a person is actually cultivating. The seed itself is not a controlled substance under the misuse of drugs regulation.

Comment on this

If a seed is under a certain strength when it is sown, why would it get stronger after it is sown?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

When a seed is sown that hemp plant or certain parts of it, because it belongs to the cannabis family, will inevitably contain the narcotic or psychoactive substance called THC. That is why the plant is controlled. There are controls on the seed but it is actually when the seed is planted that regulation comes in.

Comment on this
Mr. Daniel Lyons

The seed is already certified seed. The seed that people buy has already been bred. It does not go past 0.3%. When someone buys that seed, they will have gone to a certified body to buy the seed and when the seed is planted that should be enough. I know where the Senator is coming from. Basically, if someone buys that seed that should be enough. It is already certified, it does not exceed 0.3% THC and the buyer is certified to grow it then.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

No. The seed itself is not a controlled drug.

Comment on this
Mr. Daniel Lyons

Yes, but people are buying a controlled seed when they buy the seed.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

Absolutely, but that is separate regulation.

Comment on this

I am glad to get the opportunity to contribute. I welcome the witnesses.

We have had interesting debates, including a number of months ago when we had tillage farmers in here. They are crying out and are at the end of their tether. The whole lot of them are nearly gone, which is a crying shame. Now we see, as Deputy Aird said, solar panels taking over the countryside when that is not what farming is about at all. We must protect the people in the sector. I can see a reluctance among the witnesses from the Department to promote the growing of hemp. Surely the Department should be able to give a green light to farmers or tillage men and should be there to be consulted and to provide help. Instead, it has pushed it back on them to come forward with a plan. Hemp is not a traditional crop and we know little about it. Is the fact that hemp can be used for drugs at a later stage the reason the Department is reluctant to promote hemp production?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

There is no reluctance on our part. We have always made it clear that if there are viable proposals, we will actively consider them. In the consultation we carried out, we found there was a distinct lack of information on the viability of growing hemp for industrial use, particularly at processing level. We do not have processing facilities here. If we do not have processing facilities and information on what the market can return to farmers, in terms of a price that would encourage farmers to grow the crop, it is difficult for farmers to have confidence in growing it.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I am saying. The Department has not given hemp production the green light and is not giving any information or incentives. Some of the witnesses said that representatives of the Department of Health should be here. The Department of Health put the children's hospital in the wrong place and now it cannot open it. That is bad enough. Would I ask that Department's officials to come in to talk about hemp when it is agriculture we are talking about? If the Department of agriculture has some problem with the fact that hemp can be used for drugs afterwards, and I know that is a reality, the witnesses should be upfront and say that. I can see there is something stopping them. They have told us that if some hemp producers or whoever approach the Department with a proposal, the officials will deal with them. We are at nothing, to be honest, and we have been here all day. At the same time, I can see that next year a whole lot of tillage farmers will be gone. That is a shame because they have tractors and machinery, the know-how and land. There should be more of an outcome given what is wrong. As with anything else that the Department of agriculture wants farmers to produce, it is waiting for us to come forward. There is no tradition or background in growing hemp. We are calling on the Department to help us. That is what this committee is about - helping farmers. The officials have to be honest with us and tell us what is on their minds because they have not done so all day.

Comment on this

I need to bring this session to a conclusion. I thank the witnesses for their contributions. We heard a lot of insights. There is definitely a view among members that we need to continue this conversation. There may be aspects that we want to tease out. Before we conclude, I will give each witness one minute to make a quick point or two or add to the conversation.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Cotter

I believe we have identified today that the issue is the gap between the farmer and the market. It is a matter of processing. It is a little unrealistic to say that the industry needs to step in. If I were about to invest heavily in a processing facility but the raw material was not available, it would be a very unwise investment. We need to time this so the incentivisation of farmers coincides with investment from the private sector, perhaps in a processing plant, and so there will be access to the raw material. The production of the raw material takes 90 days. This is not complicated. It does not take 20 years. We need to time the process. We need to incentivise farmers, and we also need industry to say that when the farmers are incentivised and they, the processors, get the raw material, they will bring in the processing plant. If the two activities are allowed to coincide, we will no longer have to have this conversation.

Comment on this

Are there any other takers?

Comment on this
Dr. Barry O'Reilly

The Department of agriculture is responsible for crop policy. We have an important role to play in developing the crop sector here. We take that seriously and put a huge amount of work into that area.

On hemp, as I said at the outset, we are very open to engagement. What is lacking at the moment is a robust proposal from industry, particularly with a financial analysis of how to kick-start the hemp sector here and on its viability. Those in industry also have a responsibility to put the proposal together. We are happy to engage and to consider any proposals made.

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

I obviously gave Senator Daly the impression that I was not supportive of this. I am just saying that, as an organisation, we are about looking for opportunities to support farmers and the agriculture sector. All I was trying to do was point out that there is an issue in terms of the country being able to benefit from hemp production and its use in construction. We can sort that out. There is a solution. However, as things stand, there is-----

Comment on this

There is a lot about carbon credits-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

To be able to benefit from the carbon sequestration.

Comment on this

It should not be holding the sector back.

Comment on this
Mr. John Spink

It should not hold it back. There is a solution. All I was pointing out is that, as things stand, there is a job to be done to square that up.

Comment on this

Tá go maith. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their contributions and insight. As there is no further discussion today, the meeting stands adjourned.

Comment on this