We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

Reduction in the Farmer VAT Flat-rate Addition: Discussion

Summary

ICOS representatives said the 2026 reduction in the farmer VAT flat-rate addition to 4.5%, below the 4.8% livestock VAT rate, leaves non-VAT-registered farmers facing a deduction when selling through marts—unlike private farm-to-farm sales. They argued this penalises smaller farmers and marts, adds administrative and cash-flow burdens, and may contribute to falling mart throughput, while stressing that it is not the only cause. They proposed aligning the two rates or making any adjustment through farmers’ annual tax returns; committee members broadly supported correcting the anomaly and sought disclosure of the formula used to calculate the flat-rate addition.

Contributions 1–163 of 340. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We will start into business at full tilt. I welcome our witnesses and members this afternoon.

Before I begin, I want to bring to everyone's attention that witnesses who are giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence that they give to the committee. This means that a witness has full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that members should not comment on, criticise or make charges against either a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such ways to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members participating online in a committee meeting when their participation is from within the parliamentary precincts. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precincts. Any attempt to do so will result in the member having their online access removed.

The agenda for today's meeting is an issue that we would have raised some time ago. We are scheduled today to discuss the reduction in the farmer VAT flat-rate addition. Our witnesses are from the Irish Co-operative Organisation Society, ICOS. They are Mr. Ray Doyle, livestock environmental sales executive, Mr. Martin McNamara, general manager and society secretary for Clare Co-operative Marts, and Mr. Maurice Lyons, chief executive and secretary of Golden Vale Marts. Cuirim fáilte rompu.

This is an issue that would have come up a number of times with people when they are selling. If the witnesses start with the opening statements, we will do five minutes on them and we will be able to tease it out further with members from there. Mr. Doyle has the floor for five minutes.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

I thank the Chair. Irish livestock marts trade over 1.9 million cattle and 1.5 million sheep annually across Ireland, providing true market valuation and guaranteed payment to Irish farmers. The sector is highly regulated by the Government via the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine regarding livestock movements, animal welfare, hygiene, etc., and the Property Services Regulatory Authority, PSRA, to ensure financial security of payment to farmers.

All livestock auctions are on a VAT-inclusive basis and the livestock VAT rate is currently 4.8%. The 2026 budget has created a negative anomaly regarding non-VAT-registered farmers selling their livestock in the marts that does not occur if the transaction is completed privately between two unregistered parties. The majority of farmers are not VAT-registered and when they sell their livestock through the mart, they are being deducted 0.3% in VAT, which is the difference between the livestock VAT rate of 4.8% and the flat-rate addition VAT rate of 4.5%.

The flat-rate addition is a special scheme for farmers who are not required to register for value-added tax. These farmers are currently referred to as flat-rate farmers. The scheme is designed to compensate non-VAT-registered farmers for the VAT they incur on their farming costs such as fuel and other inputs. Flat-rate farmers are entitled to receive an amount known as the flat-rate addition on their supplies of agricultural activities.

The rationale for the difference in these two VAT rates lies in the fact that Government has cited a Central Statistics Office, CSO-based VAT calculation as the basis for the change introduced in last year's budget. ICOS has requested the formula underpinning this decision and it has yet to be provided by Government. At a recent meeting with the Minister of Finance and departmental officials, ICOS stressed that if the State needed to address balancing within the VAT system, this could and should be managed over an extended period rather than through a sharp deduction in one year that penalised farmers and marts only to be potentially reversed in another year.

The flat-rate addition must be amended to ensure that farmers selling livestock through marts are not disadvantaged. Livestock sales remain subject to the 4.8% VAT rate, where the flat-rate addition has fallen to 4.5%, creating an anomaly that leaves farmers undercompensated. For every €1,000 traded in the marts, €2.80 is now deducted for the flat-rate addition. Many farmers wrongly think that the mart has deducted this amount for itself, and some farmers are now trading privately rather than through the local mart as a direct result of this Government policy.

One might feel that €2.80 per €1,000 is minimal, but the commission that the marts received to sell an animal is not substantial. In fact, it is often capped at approximately €20, so a seller who gets €2,000 approximately for an animal is now deducted €25.72, including VAT, whereas the total deduction was €14.28 in 2025. This is putting marts at a competitive disadvantage because the seller can sell farm to farm to a non-registered-VAT farmer without having to pay the VAT penalty. Administering the VAT flat-rate addition scheme is also a burden for marts as they are required to ensure which sellers are VAT-registered or not, collect the relevant VAT and return it to Revenue.

In the round, the VAT flat-rate addition scheme has been a cash flow burden for marts. Since the inception of the scheme in 1990, there have been 18 years when the flat-rate addition percentage was higher than the livestock rate and 16 years when it was on a par. The only year when it has been less than the livestock rate is 2026. During the 18 years when the flat-rate addition exceeded the livestock rates, the mart sector had to pay the farmer the addition and wait for a refund from Revenue. For example, assume a seller sold on 1 January and was then paid the addition by the mart. The mart would have to wait until late March to receive the repayment from Revenue when doing its bi-monthly VAT return.

ICOS proposes that the VAT rate addition is never set higher than the livestock rate for any individual year. If the State needs to address balancing within the VAT system, this can, and should be, managed over an extended period rather than through a sharp deduction in one year that penalises farmers and marts, only to be potentially reversed in another budget. The flat rate addition should be adjusted to align with the livestock VAT rate so that the scheme continues to fully compensate farmers, as originally intended, without distorting competition or imposing a hidden cost on livestock producers. Marts must not be discriminated against; non-VAT registered farmers must not be financially penalised; and the flat-rate scheme must remain simple, fair and fit for purpose. This is obviously also a priority in the current inflationary climate, which is burdening rural communities with additional excessive costs.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Doyle. I have a list of members offering to speak. Is it agreed that we allow six minutes per member? Agreed. It is a fairly technical matter. Senator Daly has had quite a bit of experience dealing with it. Would he like to speak to it?

Comment on this

There is not a whole lot I can add. Mr. Doyle has explained it all. This is an unintended consequence. Nobody is going to explain or even understand after any explanation how the flat rate VAT figure is calculated. It is a combination of CSO and Revenue information. When this happened and the flat rate went below the livestock rate, this was an unintended consequence of what Mr. Doyle explained has happened in the mart, whereby farmers bring home more money if they sell the animal to an abattoir because of the VAT structure than if they sell the same animal for the same price in the mart.

After last year's budget, I tabled an amendment in to the Finance Bill - it is on the record - to solve this problem. My suggestion at the time was that they would be equalised and this would never happen again, rightly or wrongly; that they would be tied together, coupled, so that if the flat rate of VAT ever went up again, the livestock rate would go up with it or vice versa. I will outline the outcome of my endeavours. There is no secret to the fact that I am a Government Senator. The Finance Bill was on the floor of the Seanad and if I threw a spanner in the works, I would not just have been changing this issue, I would have brought down the entire Bill. There was a discussion on it and we were told that they would meet on it with ICOS, which did happen, and hopefully they would be in a position to sort it out in this budget.

The only questions I have are for the people who are coming in after the current witnesses. Can they see an issue with it? Is coupling the best way out of this anomaly for want of a better word? What solution would they like to see to this problem to avoid the issues that have happened? I do not want to get into a big long debate about the whole flat rate thing as opposed to registered VAT. We would be here for a month and none of us would be any the wiser when it was all over. I just want to solve this one anomaly where there is a difference in what farmers bring home if they sell in the mart as opposed to the abattoir because of the difference in the flat rate and the livestock rate. Is coupling them so that they would be the same the best solution? Is it the only solution or is there another solution that the witnesses see?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

I thank the Senator. There are two ways it can be resolved. The first is if they are both aligned, whether it goes up or down. The alternative is that if it has to stay at 4.8% and there has to be adjustment of plus or minus, it would be dealt with at the end of the year when a guy is doing his tax returns. If there is an adjustment it is very easy to know what it is if he has X amount of farm produce sold. It is easy to quantify whether it is a plus or minus.

Comment on this

That would be grand for the farmer doing his accounts at the end of the year but how would that work with the transaction in the mart?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

There would be no change. We would operate at the current rate of 4.8% on livestock produce. It would be a level playing pitch across the board then both from private sales, abattoirs, factories and marts - the sale price is VAT inclusive at 4.8% - end of story. If there is any adjustment, it can be done by aligning the top-up and the VAT rate or by adjusting the tax return at the end of year.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

I will just to add to that. The reason we are suggesting that is because the marts currently are at a competitive disadvantage in that Revenue is imposing the collection of this difference on us. If a farmer sells privately, there is no difference in collection. The problem is that we are being caught for collecting VAT from a non-VAT registered farmer, which is not maybe technically correct because of the anomaly of the way it is structured for the livestock mart.

To expand on Mr. McNamara's point, the way out of that is, the 4.8%, or whatever the livestock rate is going to be, is going to be across the board for all the sectors, both the abattoirs and the marts. If there is an anomaly with the flat rate, like there has been in 2026, it is addressed in the annual returns that every individual farmer makes because not every farmer is VAT registered. That is going to change. If a farmer is registered for VAT, there is no issue. The anomaly is when the non-VAT registered farmer trades in the mart and we collect VAT. The Revenue is forcing the marts to collect it, whereas we contend that should be better placed in the annual returns.

Comment on this

Has Mr. McNamara seen changes in the number of transactions that he could correlate with this being the reason for the changes?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

The throughput in livestock marts this year has dropped by between 8% and 9%.

Comment on this

Does Mr. McNamara put that down to this factor?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

Not necessarily, but it is part of the problem.

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

An awful lot of farmers are complaining about fees this year and people hear it across the country. Last year we had a fee of €20 on a €2,000 animal, this year about €25.60 is coming off in the mart, whereas last year it was around €14 because there was a top-up last year and this year there is a deduction. That is a massive proportion of the mart's fees. Everybody is saying the mart's fees have gone up, but they have not gone up.

Comment on this

That was mentioned in the opening statement. It is part of the anomaly that it looks like the fee has gone up but it has not.

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

It is a burden for marts, but a lot of us are farmer-owned. We are trying to do what we can to help the farmer.

Comment on this

I am conscious that my time is up. Have the witnesses done the sum of what this might cost the State equalise it? Would there be a cost to the State if it were to equalise it?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

After the budget it was said that this was a likely cost to farmers of €60 million. Only a proportion of that is being collected because any transaction through private sales is not being collected. The other point is about 40% of livestock trading is done from farm to farm without any involvement of a collection agency or whatever you like to call us.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

On the point about €60, million the sum directly attributable to the mart is somewhere between €5 million and €8 million. It is not a big ask of the Revenue to regularise the mart situation. Again, it does not seem like a lot of money, but we will pass by a filling station that charges €2.05 per litre and go to the one at €1.99. That is the rationale we have. This year people are looking at their statements. Every penny is a prisoner this year. They are looking at that. We are being disadvantaged for not a lot of money in terms of the overall VAT revenue. The overall budget is €60 million, but to right this wrong for the marts will not cost revenue that amount.

Comment on this

It will be between €5 million and €8 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Yes.

Comment on this

The other figure that was referred to was an 8% to 9% reduction in throughput because of a number of factors including this one. What proportion of that is down to VAT? Would the witnesses say it is half of it or is it predominantly due to it? Is there any indication?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

It would be very hard to quantify exactly what it is. Now that we are in peak season, it is only becoming more highlighted at this point in the year. Farmers are only realising that Revenue is taking so much off every beast they sell in the mart. I foresee this will create an ongoing problem going forward. There is a perception that the mart is a revenue collector rather than providing a service to farmers.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I am delighted that we are getting the opportunity to hear their views on the issue. Like others have said, a lot of my questions are for the Revenue Commissioners and the Department of Finance but it is only right and proper that we have the witnesses in here first. We have two people involved in the marts and the other is involved in ICOS, but I want to congratulate the three of them for the work they are doing. It is not easy for marts at the moment. When I was a young fella, I was brought up in a farm in County Laois. We always had marts in Rathdowney, Portlaoise and Mountrath.

Rathdowney was the first to go, then Portlaoise and finally Mountrath. We are left now with Ballinakill. A mart is important to the farming community. It is where people can meet maybe once a week or month. It is where they chat. They used to go for a pint, but that day is gone. Now, they go into the canteen and have a cup of tea or whatever, and that may be their social outlet for the week. Especially in the night marts we have in this country, everybody gathers together and it is a night out for them. That is really what it is.

Of course it is a huge challenge when somebody comes along and decides to drop the VAT rate from 5.1% to 4.5%. That has consequences on the price the farmer is paying to sell the animal. That is the first thing people look at on the docket when they come out after selling. The witnesses' job in marts is to provide the buyers for the customer who is going in with the cattle. That is the number one thing. If they do not have buyers, we will not go with the cattle, calves or whatever the case may be. The single comment people make when they come out is that the cost has gone up to €25 to sell one, it is shocking money and - I thought I would never hear someone saying it - all that the marts are doing is acting as collectors of farmers' money to give to the Revenue Commissioners. It is a question of trying to get across to farmers exactly what is happening. It has nothing to do with the marts from that point of view.

The question I want answered from the Revenue Commissioners, when they come in, or from the Department of agriculture is how a figure is set or who in the Department set it. It certainly was not a politician. I presume it was not the Minister - I do not believe it was for one minute - who said we would drop it from 5.1% to 4.5%. Do people not realise? In my calculations, roughly 1% is worth €10 million. We can see what the drop is worth to the Department, and the marts are collecting the money and sending it on.

What we are trying to do is protect the mart structure. I know what was going on. A person might go to a yard to buy cattle. There are farmers coming in saying they might go to the mart a bit more, but do they realise what that would cost them, including transport? Look at the VAT it would cost them. It would cost them maybe €30 to sell. This is what is going on. The people who brought this measure in did not realise the carnage they would cause. Stand up everybody and be counted. That is why the marts are not getting throughput. I know it, especially from the number of people who were selling calves privately from farm to farm this year. That is also being encouraged by the co-operative system - by the Tirláns of this world - and there is no point in saying it is not. All that means is that the marts have to push that back as well.

I support Senator Daly and salute what he did in bringing it up last year. I have no problem saying that, but I believe in my heart - we will not know until they come in - that this will be changed this year because it is absolutely wrong. The only reason I can think of the system is like this is because they looked at the price of milk and the price of cattle but they did not look at the value of cattle with TB, which was capped at €3,000. A valuer was coming out and valuing them at maybe €3,000, €4,000 or €5,000. We had that discussion in here. That was another blow to farmers at the time. We all know that the grain growers of this country are on their knees as we speak today. This issue is affecting them.

We will not know for a couple of minutes, but if the way I am seeing it is true and 1% is €10 million, it could go up to nearly €60 million. That is very serious. I do not believe that there is anything the witnesses can tell us today that will improve the situation. It is politicians who are elected to here by the public who have to get on to the relevant people, namely, every Minister in the Cabinet, to make sure that this measure is reversed in the budget. It is wrong. What I do not know but would love to know is who actually made the decision and signed off on it. It was a mistake.

I want to say this and I will say it publicly - I encourage people, if they can at all, to keep our mart system going. It is very important. No matter what anybody says, people are getting a true value there.

I am going to say this is well - I know people find it difficult, but online bidding was a huge change. In my father's time, he would not have dreamed of it. He would have had to look at an animal and haggle over everything. However, there are people out there now who are doing it and it has worked well. It will help it.

The other thing that has gone completely is the luck money and that is a pity. When I was a young fellow at the mart, getting the luck money was as important as paying for the animal.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in and for the opening statement. I want to welcome my neighbour Martin McNamara from County Clare today. I am delighted to have him here.

Deputy Aird has gone through nearly everything, but I have a question or two for the witnesses. The scheme is designed to compensate farmers who are not VAT registered for VAT incurred on farm inputs. The reduction has raised concerns about the impact on farm incomes, cash flow and the viability of smaller and medium-sized family farms. Is that true? Who wants to come back on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Without a doubt, because the small- and medium-sized family farms are not VAT registered. They are the smaller backbone of the approximately 130,000 herd numbers that are there. The vast majority of those are small and medium ones and not VAT registered and are being impacted directly by this.

Comment on this

This reduction in the VAT is having an effect on smaller farmers.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

It is having a disproportionate effect on smaller farmers because the larger operators and larger buyers are VAT registered and there is no penalty here. Unfortunately, it is actually targeting the smaller operators.

Comment on this

Where a farmer sells livestock through a mart, will the witnesses explain where the reduction from 5.1% to 4.5% shows up in the transaction? Is the full reduction borne by the farmer or is any of it observed elsewhere in the supply chain?

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

In our mart, it is on the seller sheets. It shows what the deduction is there. Last year, it would have shown what the addition was. It is plainly set out in the seller sheet.

Comment on this

Who really gains and loses out with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

The marts never gained or lost. We basically just administered it and gave the money to Revenue. This year, however, money is being taken off the seller and given to the Government.

Comment on this

What is Mr. McNamara's view? Is the small farmer losing out here in a big way?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

Big time. Last week, we had quite a number of cattle that topped €3,000. Effectively, in that case, there was nearly €8 in VAT per beast taken off on top of the commission. Last year, the seller was getting that. In our situation alone, the top-up to the ordinary farmers, as I call them in our country, was worth €380,000 last year. That was what we gave to ordinary farmers last year in the top-up, which we subsequently reclaimed from Revenue. This year, if the same turnover pertained, we would be deducting €380,000 for the same level of trading. That will just highlight the consequences. It is €760,000 of a twist in 12 months in just one small county alone.

Comment on this

Does Mr McNamara think that if this continues, we are more than likely going to put small farmers out of business?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

They are under pressure in every walk of life anyway, but it is becoming very critical. Last week, a guy came to me and €23 was deducted. We had to explain that that was for Revenue and we had nothing to do with it. We only collect it and give it to Revenue. When this raised its head after last year's budget, our hands were tied. We said that the only recourse people had was to go to their local politicians or whoever because they were the people who dictated these things.

Comment on this

I presume it is not going to affect the large farmer as much as it is affecting the small farmer.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

It is irrelevant to a farmer who is VAT registered because they are paying 4.8% and that is it. They can claim back the VAT that they pay in purchases. It is just the non-registered farmer, and I would say that 90% of the farmers we are dealing with are non-registered farmers. This scheme was originally brought in to compensate those farmers for the input costs and to keep it simple.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

It is the local livestock mart that has been undermined and unfairly treated here. Now some farmers will not come to the mart because they are concerned about the deductions. It is the local livestock mart that is going to be at threat because if our numbers drop further still, we are left with high fixed costs. It is simply the last 5% to 7% of numbers that might give a mart centre a profit. It is the local livestock mart that is actually going to be under more jeopardy if this continues because our numbers will fall further. It is a high-cost model of doing business with a mart if you are being deducted the VAT, when you do not have that deduction if you are selling privately. It is unfair to the livestock mart system. All we are looking for is fairness.

Comment on this

Is it possible we could see more marts closing because of these criteria? We have seen a lot of marts over the last number of years that have closed down. We do not want to see any more of them closing. A mart in Sixmilebridge has got back up and running again. Is it going to be a possibility going forward that we could see more of them closing down?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

As Mr. Doyle has said, marts are under more and more pressure from the regulation that is there, the cost of compliance and the cost of doing business. As I said, that 5% or 10% extra stock is the cream that can be achieved in the profit line without any extra costs. If you keep reducing throughput, however, our game is a numbers game. It is as simple as that.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. It is very clear to me not only that the differential VAT rate poses a threat to marts but also how unfair it is to small farmers who are unregistered for VAT. Most of the questions are for the next witnesses, to be honest, but I thank those present for their presentation. In terms of quantifying the numbers here, across the mart network, what is it costing in terms of that differential? What has been taken out of farmers' pockets that the witnesses are seeing so far this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Ironically, that would be a question for the next witnesses before the committee. They are the people who allegedly have the accurate CSO figures for what the actual turnover is or everything. Our estimate is that it will be a penalty of at least €5 million to €8 million per the mart network, but it could be way higher than that. I do not know because the actual turnover figures will be a CSO figure for the livestock market trading or what was turned over at factory level or whatever. They are all CSO figures which I would not have off the top of my head, unfortunately.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Doyle seeing an increase now as farmers are realising the differential? Is he seeing an increase in terms of private livestock sales? Is that on the increase since January, February or March? Is there a growth in those figures?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

The figures for both private setting and mart setting have been down this year since the start of the year. There is less livestock in the country than there has been in the last five years, on a rolling average. However, the drop in livestock sales is higher than the drop in private sales. We have to assume that differential in percentage is a direct result of the fact that it is now a higher-cost model to trade in the mart. For the first six months of the year, that differential was running at approximately 3% in the drop in private sales versus mart sales for the year to date. The private sales were back about 5% to 7%. Please do not hold me to the figures; they are approximate. The mart sales were back significantly. They were back almost 11% nationally for the first six months of the year. There is a big differential there. I cannot and will not attribute it all to the VAT, but it is definitely a fairly sizable contributing factor to this.

Comment on this

Mr. McNamara mentioned that there are two possible solutions. The first one would be to align the VAT on the flat rate and also on the livestock. The second one is the suggestion around aligning the taxation at the end of the year. Do the witnesses have a preference? What is their proposal in relation to both of them? What are the concerns they have around each?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

In a short answer, we would not mind which one it is, as long as it is fair to us. The next witnesses might have their preferred option, but obviously aligning the VAT rates, like they have been for 16 of the last 24-odd years, would be the preferred option because it is fairer to everybody.

Comment on this

Given that the witnesses are essentially doing the job of Revenue in this regard, in terms of collecting VAT from an unregistered VAT farmer, which is unique in many respects, have they calculated the financial cost and the human cost to their network of actually engaging in that? Is Revenue providing any type of assistance in relation to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

We do not have a cost for it, but we have always actually administered it. Before, when it was a top-up, we were actually giving them the top-up. As I said earlier, if you sold an animal on 1 January, we got it back from Revenue at the end of March, whereas the farmer got it on 1 January. We had that cash flow cost, plus the administration cost. We would have to figure out who is registered and who is non-registered every few years and make sure that is correct, so there was a lot of administration with it. As I was saying earlier, a lot of us are farmer-owned so our objective is to do what we can to help the farmers. We were happy to do that, but now it is causing significant damage to our business. That is why we are here. That is why we are raising it as well.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I think there are a few critical things here. Mr. McNamara stated earlier that in his own mart €380,000 went to Revenue, and before that it was going back to farmers, to put it simply. Would that be fair to say?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

Last year, with the top-up being where it was, we paid out €380,000 to our local farmers in the top-up of VAT, and we had to finance that on a bi-monthly basis until we got the refund back from Revenue. This year, we are deducting that at source.

Comment on this

There was €380,000 less in Clare marts around Mr. McNamara's area. If we multiply that around the country, especially with weanling sales at the moment, it would account for a lot of money. Less money is going into farmers' pockets, to put it very bluntly.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

That is correct. If we take the complete flip, if we have the same turnover, which we will not have this year, it would be a switch of €760,000. They are penalised to that effect this year.

Comment on this

Let us call a spade a spade here, in fairness to marts. I think the public out there needs to know. Marts have been blamed in the wrong for the last six, eight or 12 months. Everyone said they had gone up in prices but it was actually the VAT that they had to collect for Revenue. To be clear, and I heard Mr. McNamara stating this, if you go into a factory it is not applicable and if you do a private person-to-person sale it is not applicable. Marts have the only disadvantage in this. Is that fair to say?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

That is correct.

Comment on this

There is only one way of solving it. I know Paul has done a good bit of work, in fairness to him. Would it be the simplest way if both were aligned? With the best will in the world, farmers have enough to do besides thinking of more stuff going into the accountants at the end of the year, and more pulling and dragging in the line of what you have to do. Would it be the simplest way if all politicians here made sure that inside the next two weeks it was lobbied fairly strongly to align them? Would that make it the simplest solution to everything?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

That would be good.

Comment on this

Right. I know Mr. Doyle spoke about the formula. I was talking to Brendan Egan this morning as well in Castlerea about this. This formula is like an invisible formula. No one seems to get it. We might try to get it. I might put a proposal to the committee that every one of us would ask Revenue that we would be supplied with this magic formula of how it is done up in order that we could supply it to the witnesses, if the committee agreed with it.

Comment on this

I second that the committee would request that.

Comment on this

We would get the formula and send on a copy to ICOS, if it is looking for it, and to all the co-operatives. Mr. Doyle will look after all the marts around the country with it so that people would know. It would be a help. Does it put more of an onus on the marts? Do they have resources to put into that as well with staff to make sure it is paid to Revenue? Does that cost them more?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Yes, it does because we have to now ascertain who is VAT registered and who is not to have the invoices correct in the first place, and then there is the associated paperwork to make the deductions. As Mr. McNamara and Mr. Lyons have said, we have to finance it.

Comment on this

Just that people looking in will understand, when you sell an animal in a mart, if they are €3,050, that is inclusive of VAT.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Yes, and therein lies the problem. When you buy an animal in a livestock mart ring, it includes VAT, whereas most of the livestock produce is traded on a VAT exclusive basis and then the VAT rate, whichever that is, is added back. At the fall of the hammer, it includes the embedded livestock rate.

Comment on this

What happens when you kill an animal?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

I will let Mr. McNamara take that.

Comment on this

If it is €6 or €7 a kilo, is that plus VAT?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

If it is €7 a kilo, it is €7 a kilo inclusive of VAT. If you are VAT registered, the factory will apply the 4.8% VAT inclusive on the €7. If you are a flat-rate farmer, they will apply the 4.5%. We have documentation to prove that.

Comment on this

If you are a farmer to farmer-----

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

With a farmer to a farmer, a thousand is a thousand.

Comment on this

A thousand is a thousand. It is very hard, if you are Revenue, to know where you are picking up this money in the figures given. If the marts are losing business over it and there is more trade going on farmer to farmer, obviously, Revenue will not be getting that. It is nearly a red herring for it, going by what the witnesses are saying.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

That is why we contend that probably the correct place for it is at people's annual tax returns. I understand the problem and the issues that this may be adding to the burden of tax returns for farmers, but it definitely is the most logical one if you are Revenue because it traps all the possible VAT, privately and marts, whereas in the current situation we are the only ones getting penalised.

Comment on this

The next speaker is Deputy Kenny. He has a fairly strong view on this and has been raising it with us.

Comment on this

Yes, it is something I have brought up a few times and I put a couple of parliamentary questions to the Minister. First, I thank all the witnesses for their presentation. It was very worthwhile. On 25 June I got an answer to a parliamentary question that said €61.5 million would be the gain to Revenue if it reversed it to the way it had been before. That is approximately the kind of numbers Revenue seems to be calculating it on. I assume, when it was a situation that the VAT rate was at 5.1%, it was approximately €60 million annually that was going to the farmers and therefore was a positive for the farmer. For many years, as we know, it was equal, and therefore it balanced out each way.

The other thing Mr. Doyle raised in his opening statement was that ICOS was not given access to the formula. I had a parliamentary question on 7 July and the reply stated that "The flat-rate scheme is governed by Articles 295 to 305 of the EU VAT Directive and, as required under Article 296, the level of the flat-rate addition is reviewed annually by reference to macro-economic data". The formula that is used, which is calculated each year, is that the "Flat Rate % = (VAT Incurred by Unregistered Farmers on Inputs ÷ Agricultural Output of Unregistered Farmers) × 100". Obviously, you would have to put numbers in place of that formula and work it out, but that is basically what they are doing. They are taking the difference between the two and dividing them and then multiplying them by 100. That seems to be the formula that is used. In the opening statement from Revenue it repeats that this is the formula it uses, so it has put it out there in the public before. I do not understand why it did not give it to the witnesses, which is very peculiar, but we will ask the officials about that when they come in.

Comment on this

It will be on the committee website as well.

Comment on this

It will be on the website as well. That is basically how it is calculated. The issue we run into here is that what I get from what we have got from Revenue and from the answer to this parliamentary question is that the flat rate is something that will possibly vary each year, depending on macroeconomic data and all of that, and that is governed by this EU directive. It will be very unlikely that Revenue will be able to change that or set that. However, it can change the livestock rate. There is nothing preventing Revenue from doing that. My understanding is that Revenue could bring it down or up to meet whatever the flat rate is at, and that would equal it out. Have the witnesses got any information as to whether there is any reason Revenue would not be able to do that? From what I have read in all the documents we have been provided with, there seems to be no reason or no inhibition that would put it in a place where it would not be able to do that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

No. When we met the officials in Revenue, they were not as descriptive as the Deputy but they did refer to that three-year moving average, not just a simple one-year one which the Deputy mentioned. In our meetings with those in Revenue, they were reluctant to touch the flat-rate addition because the statement was there could not be three rates of VAT, from my recollection of it. Regarding dropping the livestock rate, back in 2000, the livestock rate used to change in every budget. Then the livestock flat-rate addition would move then in lockstep. That is the obvious redressing of this, rather than Revenue relying on the three-year moving average. What it has given sounds simple but yet we still do not know what the weighting or the contribution of each agricultural produce piece goes into that.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance can change the VAT rate. As we know, he introduced - or renewed - a VAT rate for the hospitality sector at 9% last year. The Department can do that at any time. There is this thing that it cannot be done. Of course it can. That is not an issue at all.

In my part of the country we have a lot of marts. The Golden Vale mart in Carrigallen is beside me and last Saturday there were sellers with weanlings at €2,500 each. I was envious of the man who was going to buy them and try to make money on them after, but there you go. Obviously, there is a good price for cattle at the moment. There is a bit of competition in the mart and that should, you would imagine, be bringing livestock to the marts. I do not know whether it is doing it or what the issue is that it has fallen back. It is hardly this alone. There must be other things that are causing that. What other issues do the witnesses think are pushing farmers away from using the mart?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

There is definitely a drop in numbers. The national herd has definitely dropped in numbers, and that is a combination of good and bad news. We have had very high live exports for the past ten years. We have eroded some of the substrate we would have had to sell in the marts. This is a contributory factor to that. We are not in any way suggesting it is just the VAT rate has dropped our livestock numbers but-----

Comment on this

It is not the only thing. Does Mr. Doyle think that the fact that there are fewer cattle in the country is probably the primary reason?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Yes, it is, but it is accentuating it when farmers go to trade them. If farmers are selling less stock than they did, they are most definitely focused on the lower numbers they have. Again, we are highlighting the fact that there are a lot of microscopes on this from every farmer selling animals and it is-----

Comment on this

It is the fact that they see it on their ticket when they come out of the mart.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

It it is simply unfair to the marts when no other sector is getting hit with this. That is our main contention here.

Comment on this

If they sell farmer to farmer, neither farmer is registered for VAT and therefore nobody is charging anybody VAT. When farmers sell their animals elsewhere, if they sell it to the factory or to other places, technically could Revenue start to put an obligation on farmers to include this in their VAT return? They do not have a VAT return because they are not registered, but on their tax return?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Again, that could be a question for Revenue afterwards. The Revenue interpretation here is that the mart has purchased the livestock, the mart itself is VAT registered and then it sells the livestock to the seller. We are just an agent to the transaction, but Revenue interprets it that we have purchased from a non-VAT farmer, the mart itself is VAT registered, and therefore you must account for the VAT because you have sold it to the seller. We never buy the animals. Our contention to Revenue is we have not bought the animals and therefore it is incorrect to levy this VAT deduction on us.

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

A few years ago, a farmer selling for €1,000 at the mart would get the VAT top-up. I believe there have been 18 years where the addition percentage has been above the livestock rate. If the farmer did that through the annual return system, they might be able to get the top-up in that annual return. For most of the years, the farmer has actually been getting the top-up. By going farm to farm, the farmer would actually be losing out.

Comment on this

The way it stands now, the farmer is getting caught.

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

They are now selling in the mart but for the bulk of the time, they were getting the benefit of the top-up.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here today. It is quite a simple issue even though it is quite a technical one. I wish to go back to discuss the effect on sales. I know that Cork marts are down about 10% or 11% this year. Macroom mart is my local mart and it has seen a decrease. Obviously, this matter does not account for all of that, but how big a role does it play? Given its impact on marts in local towns combined with other factors, are we likely to see mart closures in the future? Things like this obviously do not help. It is probably only the cause of a percentage of the decrease this year, but it is definitely playing a part.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

It is definitely not the sole reason. There are a number of contributory factors. It is an issue and has been coming more to the fore in recent times. Marts might trade 40% of the business from September to December. There are guys who some days might be selling €120,000 or €130,000 worth of cattle on a day. The 0.3% of that is fairly substantial and the farmers will start asking where it is going.

Comment on this

We are seeing such a rise in farm-to-farm sales and private sales because they are not affected by that when dealing with non-VAT registered farmers. In doing that, however, farmers are losing the protections provided by the mart in terms of pay guarantee, traceability and price. Will this have a negative impact on trade and price if there continues to be an increase in private sales over mart sales?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

Down the years, no matter what came and went, the marts were always the price setters for livestock and all private sales or any other sales were related in one way or another to the mart prices. We saw it with foot and mouth disease in 2001. The minute the marts opened, the price of cattle shot up by €150 the following week. We also saw it after Covid. There were restrictions during Covid and everyone was locked down. No one knew what anything was worth. The marts are critical infrastructure for the trade in livestock and they need to be nourished. The farmer always has a choice when he comes to a mart. They can say "Yes" or “No” when the final hammer comes down. They are still the owner of those animals until they give the go-ahead. It is imperative that the structure of the marts be maintained for farmers in general.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

I might add to that. The marts obviously secure and guarantee payment because they register with the PSRA. That piece does not happen with farm-to-farm trading. As Mr. McNamara said, if more people decide to trade privately, they will not know what the true value is and the payments cannot be as safe and secure as a mart registered with the PSRA. This leads to a perfect storm situation with fewer sales in the mart, more people not knowing what their livestock is worth and people dealing through less secure methods of payment for that livestock.

Comment on this

Mr. Doyle spoke briefly about the ICOS engagement with Revenue. What is the feedback from Revenue in general? Other than the ICOS pre-budget submission to the Department of Finance, which I have seen, what kind of engagement has it had with either the Minister or departmental officials?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

Senator Daly facilitated a very good and productive meeting with the Department of Finance and Revenue officials on this. We discussed at length the issues that we have again repeated here today. What the committee will hear later from them will not be news to them or to us. They understood our situation, but having said that, they were simply stating the fact that this was EU regulation regarding flat-rate addition. It is a three-year moving average. Their hands were tied and that is the way it was. The interpretation that the mart has bought the animals and sold them again was one that they did not seem to want to comprehend or swallow. That is one of our contentions. We never own the animal. We are simply an agent in the transaction. That is the hook that means we must collect the VAT under the VAT legislation.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Doyle to clarify that. The point he has been making about the mart as a collector of VAT for non-VAT-registered people when at no point during the sale is it the mart's animal-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

If two non-VAT-registered farmers-----

Comment on this

How is that obligation on the marts? Is that under the VAT legislation? If the marts refused to do that and the farmer had to do it directly-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ray Doyle

We are VAT registered and are obliged to provide a VAT code. Therefore, we must collect the VAT. Revenue has interpreted this as us having bought and resold the animals, so we must collect the VAT. Obviously, this extra piece is paid to Revenue. However, if the exact same animal is sold privately between two non-VAT-registered farmers, there is no obligation to collect the VAT because two non-VAT-registered farmers have bought and sold an animal, so there is nothing to collect. The mart itself is VAT registered. The non-VAT-registered farmer is deemed to have sold it to the mart but we have not bought it.

Comment on this

How is it deemed to have been sold to the mart? That is the part I have difficulty with.

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

That might be a question for the Department of Finance. My understanding is that that is in the VAT legislation. The Department has deemed that there is a VATable transaction at that point.

Comment on this

That is despite the fact that the ownership at no point passes to the mart. It passes to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

At no point does it pass legally, but legislation is there that captures the mart and makes the mart do this. That is my understanding.

Comment on this

I am sorry that I missed the opening statement. There are lots of issues here, but the one massive issue is that farmers are being hit and numbers are dropping. Farmers are getting out of farming because of one issue after another. For example, on Brazilian beef, they cannot compete with these guys. It might seem a small difference in the VAT, but this is added to the cost of diesel and everything else. These things are all added on. It is the cost of running a farm, the cost of fertiliser, the cost of feed. It is never-ending. That is €61.5 million gone from rural communities. A lot of small villages can no longer field a GAA team. They cannot keep schools open. They are losing teachers. This is money taken directly out of those communities.

We are suckler farmers. We do not finish the cattle and would normally sell straight to the mart. We use Kilkenny. It is great going into the mart and bringing the kids in. They get to learn about the trading of cattle. They do not learn that if people are selling cattle out of their own yards. They do not see the trading. The kids would have their own cows, which calve. They bring in their offspring and it is a great learning curve for them.

I am not registered for VAT. If Deputy Kenny was selling me a VAT-rated animal privately, would there be a VAT collection there?

Comment on this
Mr. Maurice Lyons

Is the Deputy asking about a case where neither of the seller nor purchaser is registered?

Comment on this

No. I am asking what happens if Deputy Kenny is registered and I am not, and we are selling privately. Would VAT be collected from Deputy Kenny anyway? He would have to do his VAT-----

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

On a private sale like that where there is a VAT-registered farmer, what is called a docket can be done where Deputy Kenny would issue the Deputy with a docket for €1,000. It would be broken down between the VAT exclusive amounted and the VAT amount. Deputy Newsome Drennan cannot reclaim it but Deputy Kenny has pay that as a VAT-registered farmer.

Comment on this

It is the same as doing VAT returns for a business after selling a product. If I go through one of the marts, my name is on the blue card and I sell that animal on. It passes through the mart, the mart does not get its name stamped on the blue card and the person getting the animal becomes the new registered owner. The mart is not the owner. The farmer is using the service and we are paying for that service.

It just does not make sense. The mart is not the next owner.

If I was going through the factory and bringing my animal - and if I was registered for VAT, which I am not - it would be the final owner. You are selling to the factory. It is the owner. It is not going to be passed on to another farmer and that is the end point but the mart is completely different, in that you are going in one door and out the other and that is it. It just seems to be one hit after another.

Going back to when it came in first, farmers were blaming the marts. That is what it was. They were blaming the marts and they just could not understand what was going on here. I think that is well and truly cleared up now anyway but how many more things are going to happen? As Mr. McNamara said about the VAT, they did it for businesses, big chains, McDonald's and the like and were able to just give them the VAT cuts. I do not see how; they are saying it is the EU they have to follow that. It is a little bit like what are they doing with the €61.5 million because it is not coming back to us.

I have read their opening statements and what they are going to say is that there is nothing they can do and their hands are tied. What can we do here? It is for the greater good of rural Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

It is very simple, and at the simple stroke of a pen, it is parity. Up or down, it is parity. That is a simple stroke of a pen. It may not need any legislative change; what you call a special instrument, or whatever the case may be, can be introduced. It is a very simple thing. It is uncomplicated and all it is doing is applying equity right across the board for people trading in livestock.

Comment on this

When it came in, what kind of notification did the witnesses get that this was going to happen? There would be more administrative work on their behalf to sort out who is flat-rate registered and who is not, and the to send on that extra money to Revenue. Did anybody speak to the witnesses about it?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

The only notification we got was when it was announced in the budget. There were different interpretations at the time of how it was going to apply and we sought clarity on how it would apply to ourselves. It was only at that point we realised that it was going to be a negative in a farmer's statement. At that stage, as Senator Daly said, it was coming up to the Finance Bill and there was pressure to try to get it on the agenda and get change there but there were time constraints. I think something definitely needs to be done before this budget.

Comment on this

The witnesses sought clarity. No clarity came to them. They went looking for it, basically.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin McNamara

We had to go look for it.

Comment on this

Okay. I thank Mr. McNamara.

Comment on this

First, I thank the witnesses for coming in here this evening and clarifying. I was not here all the time but I was listening to them on the television monitors. I thank them for explaining what has happened. It is certainly a lot of money out of farmers' pockets and out of circulation. They said it would mean a loss of €380,000 in Clare. I do not know how many marts are there or what the population of cattle is or sales, but it will certainly be more than that in Kerry. I am disappointed with that because I know, as does every fellow with a cow or a calf, that there is no sign that the Revenue Commissioners or anyone giving you a hand to pull a calf in the middle of the night when there is a battle on to see whether he will survive or die.

It is very wrong that the Revenue Commissioners are doing this and I cannot understand how this Government can stand over something like that. We are listening to a lot of boasting and bragging about what was given out in these packages going back a few months, and then it comes around that certain fellows did not get the package at all because they were not up to date with Revenue, as they had infringements with slurry and small things like that. They were not entitled to and did not get the package, or the Revenue Commissioners said; they were not paid anyway, there was money left over and there is still money left over. Here we see Revenue and the Government going deeper into farmers' pockets at a time that they are fighting very hard to survive. The price of milk has gone down. Cattle are staying level, maybe, but at the same time they are way down from last year. At the same time, costs are going up, whether it is for meal, fertiliser, diesel or anything. Everything is going up day by day.

The reduction from 5.1% to 4.5% is having a very adverse effect on farmers who go to the mart. We are not blaming the witnesses; they are only collectors and they are not gaining or losing out of it but, at the same time, there are more administration costs to sort it out. It is wrong because you should not be trying to get VAT out of a man that is not registered for VAT, or a woman either. It is very wrong. That is the real point of it. When there is an advantage to sell privately, every sale less for a mart is jeopardising. We have a small mart in Kenmare and we value and treasure it. It is very handy for people in Kilgarvan or Sneem to make it off with a small amount of calves, sheep or whatever and we appreciate that mart. It is struggling as it is something like might prevent a few sales. Yes, farmers had their noses cocked about this. The marts are taking away more when they look at the slip and every bob counts.

I am glad that the witnesses have explained and highlighted it because the Revenue Commissioners and the Minister for agriculture need to address this issue. Like Mr. McNamara said there, it is just policy. The Minister for agriculture, who is the Minister of the day, and the Minister for Finance will have to rectify this in the budget one way or another and sort it out because farmers are being hit left, right and centre for every cost. Every cost is going against them. The dosing, the sprays and all those things have gone lightning mad dear altogether. To keep the land and the cattle in shape is costing way more and the margins are way less.

Some people might think this is not much. What is it? It is 0.7% or 0.8% but that is out of the poor farmers' pockets. Like I said, there is less help around every yard now. There is no one to help a farmer. They are living far more dangerous lives. There is no one waiting to help them. We see so many farm accidents, simply because they are on their own. They are on their own when they are dealing with Revenue, as far as I can see, because they are being robbed, left, right and centre. It is up to us in this committee to highlight it, or above in the Chamber when the budget talks start, and to let the Government know that farmers have had enough.

I saw a small farmer - a really small farmer, and he was not even in County Kerry - and he explained his position to me. I asked him how he got on with the package he was supposed to get for the diesel. He replied he did not get it because he had an infringement with the slurry and they said he was not entitled to it. It is the same way with the farmers who were not up to date with these very same Revenue Commissioners, who are taking this massive amount of money out of them again. If they were not up to date with their accounts, they did not get the package either. What is good for the goose is good for the gander.

Chairman, I am asking that we highlight this strongly and unanimously. I am not longer a member. I cannot vote here but I can certainly talk on behalf of the farmers and the people of Kerry who have been disenfranchised by this wrongful act.

I am asking the committee, as a unit, to make it plain and simple to the Minister for agriculture that he will have to reverse this along with the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

The Deputy's point is well made.

That is everybody who has offered to speak. As the time has been used up, that brings this session to a close. We have a number of other witnesses whom we will have in again later, so we will suspend the meeting.

Comment on this

Before we begin, I draw to the witnesses' attention that witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings. All the witnesses participating in this session are present in the room.

The agenda is that we are continuing on the reduction in the farmer VAT flat-rate addition. We have had considerable discussion on it, and there is quite a bit of detail in the documentation the witnesses have sent forward for members to review.

The committee will hear from the following: from the Department of Finance, Mr. Niall O'Sullivan, principal officer, domestic and indirect tax policy; and Mr. Ciaran Denny, assistant principal, VAT. Fáilte romhaibh. We also have representatives from the Revenue Commissioners: Mr. Cathal Jenkinson, principal officer; and Mr. Chad Egan, principal officer, indirect taxes policy and legislation division. Fáilte romhaibh.

The witnesses have circulated the various documentation on the topic. I will leave them five minutes for the opening statement, and then we will go into questions with the members.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

I thank the Cathaoirleach and committee members for the invitation to speak to them about the reduction in the flat-rate addition payment for farmers who avail of the flat-rate scheme. I am a principal officer with responsibility for indirect taxes in the domestic and indirect taxes division of the Department of Finance. I am joined by my colleague Mr. Ciaran Denny, from my unit, and colleagues from the Revenue Commissioners, Mr. Cathal Jenkinson and Mr. Chad Egan.

Along with other officials who are present, I am bound by budget secrecy not to comment on matters that may be the subject of budget decisions. This includes any possible change to the farmer's flat-rate addition or to the livestock rate in the upcoming budget.

Given the committee's invitation, I will make a brief statement on the farmer's flat-rate scheme and the underlying legal basis for it as set out in the EU VAT directive. Following that statement, I will be happy to discuss issues of particular interest to committee members.

The farmer's flat-rate scheme is a simplification arrangement specifically permitted under the EU VAT directive. It is designed to reduce the administrative burden for farmers by allowing unregistered farmers to be compensated on an overall basis for VAT on their inputs while remaining outside of the VAT system, thereby avoiding the burdens associated with registration and filing. The scheme allows unregistered farmers to add a percentage charge, known as the flat-rate addition, onto the amount they invoice VAT-registered businesses whom they supply with agricultural goods and services in the course of their farming business. Unlike VAT-registered businesses, unregistered farmers are not entitled to a deduction for VAT incurred on individual inputs using their farming business. Instead, the scheme permits them to charge and retain the flat-rate addition in order to compensate them on an overall basis for the VAT across all their inputs. The Department understands that over 85% of farmers avail of the flat-rate scheme.

Under EU law, the level of the flat-rate addition is reviewed annually in order to ensure that the scheme continues to allow for the unregistered farming sector to be fully compensated on an overall basis for the VAT it incurs. In any given year, the review may result in an upward or downward change to the flat-rate addition or it may lead to the rate remaining unchanged. In each case, however, the percentage applied is the one shown to give the unregistered farming sector full compensation for its input VAT as allowed by the directive. The flat-rate addition itself is calculated using a statistical formula and must be based on macroeconomic data as set out under the directive. The technical exercise of calculating the flat-rate addition is undertaken by the Revenue Commissioners, and Revenue advises the Department of the outcome of this technical exercise in order that any change in the rate can be included in the budget. My Revenue colleagues can answer any questions committee members may have on the calculation of the flat-rate addition.

I will say a few words on the livestock rate. Following the reduction of the farmer flat-rate addition to 4.5%, it is the now case that it is lower than the long-standing 4.8% VAT rate applied to livestock. The flat-rate formula takes account not only of the inputs taxed at the livestock rate of 4.8% but also of those taxed at the standard VAT rate of 23%, the reduced rate of 13.5% and the second reduced rate of 9%. Therefore, there is no direct alignment between the flat-rate and any particular VAT rate, including the livestock rate, as the flat-rate calculation fully reflects on a continuing basis the actual VAT exposure of the flat-rate farming sector across the entire range of inputs. The fact that the flat-rate is currently set at a level which is below the livestock rate does not create any unfairness in the tax system or mean that farmers are disadvantaged, in the same way as farmers were not advantaged for the many years when the flat-rate was set at levels which were above the livestock rate. It is the case, however, that due to the business model operated by livestock auction marts and the current differential between the flat-rate and the livestock rate, some farmers may now prefer to engage in direct sales to other farmers or sales to meat processors. While the individual difference in any one sale is marginal, where a farmer is making multiple sales there may be a sufficient difference to incentivise sales to channels other than marts.

There is scope to reduce the livestock rate to match the flat-rate payment if it is the case that the flat-rate addition for 2027 is below 4.8%. It should be noted that the flat-rate is calculated based on the estimated liability for farmers over three years, including that applied to livestock.

The work on the rate for the farmer's flat-rate addition will be finalised in advance of the budget. As with any other year, as I said before, the flat-rate could increase, decrease or stay unchanged, depending on the macroeconomic figures used to calculate the rate.

In summary, any change to the farmer's flat-rate addition is determined by the requirements of EU VAT law and does not permit the Minister of the day to change the manner in which it is calculated. I hope this information has been helpful. Within the context of budget secrecy, my colleagues and I would be happy to take any questions members may have.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. O'Sullivan. I am conscious that further documentation was circulated to members as well.

I call Deputy Newsome Drennan.

Comment on this

As I said in our earlier session, any money that comes out of farmers' pockets in the mart is a direct hit on rural Ireland, and that is an issue for all of us. We are mostly rural and it is a direct hit. When money comes out of local communities, the schools and everything else decline. That cannot happen.

I would like to get my head around the flat-rate. Mr. O'Sullivan says it is set by the EU. How is the Minister able to change VAT rates here? Can the witnesses explain that to me? I am talking about hospitality.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

VAT rates can be changed. We can apply reduced VAT rates if it is a category of goods or services in annexe 3 of the VAT directive. Reduced rates can also be applied in circumstances where there has been an historical derogation. It entirely depends on whether goods or services are in annexe 3, they have been subject to an historical derogation, or the specifics of the EU VAT directive. In the case of the flat-rate scheme, that is covered by Articles 295 to 305 of the VAT directive. The directive sets out in some detail how it is to operate and specifies the formula. That is essentially what we must follow.

Comment on this

If we were to decide to change it, what would happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

Let us take last year as an example. Last year the rate was reduced from 5.1% to 4.5%. The figure of 4.5% was determined by the formula to give full compensation on an overall basis for the farming sector. If we were to decide last year, for example, to keep it at 5.1%, that would be a situation where it was deemed to be overcompensation and we would be in clear breach of the VAT directive because within those articles it specifies that over-compensation is not permissible.

Comment on this

Would that mean a fine for Ireland? How would that work out?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

In those circumstances, we would anticipate that the Commission would be straight on to the member state and would probably initiate infringement proceedings.

Comment on this

Changing the VAT rate to 9% for hospitality-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

Sorry, I did not hear that.

Comment on this

We changed the VAT rate for hospitality to 9%. Is that not-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

That is covered by a different part of the VAT directive and there was that flexibility.

Comment on this

Is there absolutely no flexibility on this unless Europe says so?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

Not unless those articles were changed. We have to follow the formula that is set down within those articles which cover the flat-rate scheme. Again, in that context, over-compensation is not permissible and infringement proceedings could follow. In fact, the Commission could also decide, in that context, that we are required to shut down the scheme.

Comment on this

When the flat rate changed, did the Department foresee that there would be issues within the marts or was that just overlooked? I have been speaking to guys from the marts and they basically had to go looking for information on how this was going to work. Farmers are telling us that it is the marts' fault, that they did it. One can see, therefore, why people are choosing to sell privately because then that does not matter.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

We do understand that the differential between the flat rate and the livestock rate may be creating an issue for marts.

Comment on this

Technically, they do not own the animal. It is not their animal. The marts do not go on the blue card.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

The fact there are two distinct transactions with marts for the purposes of VAT law is prescribed within the EU VAT directive. Again, it is not something that we have discretion on.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy clarify that? What two transactions? If I sell-----

Comment on this

I am selling to the mart and then the Cathaoirleach is buying from the mart.

Comment on this

That is not what is happening on the ground.

Comment on this

There is one transaction between the buyer and the seller.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

For the purposes of VAT law, there are two distinct transactions taking place.

Comment on this

Let us say a mart-----

Comment on this

Just a second please. Even though one person is selling to another, there is a different interpretation of what has happened.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

Correct me if I am wrong, but this is prescribed in the EU VAT directive.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Sullivan needs to explain that one.

Comment on this

If there were underground marts, let us say, this obviously would not happen then. The marts are just facilitators. That is all they are. They are not actually-----

Comment on this

They are matchmakers, exactly. They are not on the blue card so one can see why people are confused by it all. Mr. O'Sullivan said that he cannot comment on what is going to come up in the budget. Is there a chance that it is going to be changed in the budget?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

Every year, no matter what the year, there is a chance that it will go up, go down or stay the same. That is all I can say, really, on that point.

Comment on this

For a long time it had been stable.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

I have the historical rates in front of me and yes, for most of the years since 2015 it has been above 5%. It was 4.8% in 2024 but in most years it has been over 5%

Comment on this

Yes, between 5% and 5.64%.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

That is correct.

Comment on this

I am still stuck on this VAT interpretation. One person is selling to another but the VAT law interprets that as two transactions. It seems that if a farmer walks in with an animal and sells it and another farmer walks out with an animal, Revenue sees that as two totally different transactions. How can it have such an alternative view?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall O'Sullivan

I will ask my colleague to elaborate further on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Chad Egan

Section 22-----

Comment on this

It sounds a little like a fairytale.

Comment on this
Mr. Chad Egan

What happens is that for VAT purposes, there is a deemed sale between the flat-rate farmer and the auction house or mart and then from the mart to the purchaser. It provides, for legal and VAT purposes, a deemed sale. The Cathaoirleach is correct that outside of VAT, there is supply from-----

Comment on this

It does not reflect the reality of one farmer selling the animal and the other person buying it. That interpretation is not matching up with what actually happens on the ground.

Comment on this
Mr. Chad Egan

It is provided for in the Value-Added Tax Consolidation Act, VATCA, and the directive that these types of transactions involving marts, buyers and sellers, that there is a deemed sale between the seller farmer and the mart, and then between the mart and the purchaser farmer. That has been in place for decades.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I want to query what Mr. Egan just said. If I sell an animal in the mart and Willie buys the animal, it is Willie's name that goes down, not the mart's. How can the mart be involved in the middle of it? The mart is basically a facilitator, that is all.

Comment on this

The mart's name does not even go on-----

Comment on this

On the card of the animal, it says that it goes from Michael to Willie. All the mart does is take the money off Michael and provide a service to auction the animal. The mart does not own the animal at any stage. Why are the marts caught in the middle of this?

Comment on this
Mr. Chad Egan

The Deputy is absolutely correct in terms of documentation and the marts but for VAT purposes, in these types of sales, where someone acts for another in the selling of goods-----

Comment on this

Does that not need looking at, if that is the complication? It is not factual. We are talking about VAT and it might be EU law that is tying us up but we are talking about something that is not factual. If Willie buys the animal from me and Aindrias is facilitating that, how can we be making Aindrias the responsible party in the middle of it?

Comment on this