Reduction in the Farmer VAT Flat-rate Addition: Discussion
ICOS representatives said the 2026 reduction in the farmer VAT flat-rate addition to 4.5%, below the 4.8% livestock VAT rate, leaves non-VAT-registered farmers facing a deduction when selling through marts—unlike private farm-to-farm sales. They argued this penalises smaller farmers and marts, adds administrative and cash-flow burdens, and may contribute to falling mart throughput, while stressing that it is not the only cause. They proposed aligning the two rates or making any adjustment through farmers’ annual tax returns; committee members broadly supported correcting the anomaly and sought disclosure of the formula used to calculate the flat-rate addition.
Contributions 164–340 of 340. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am sorry to interrupt, but the mart would be registered for VAT so it should be charging 23% if the Department's way of looking at it is correct. A mart would be registered so it would be charging 23%.
Comment on this
We will let Mr. Egan answer.
Comment on this
I appreciate that factually, economically, or from the perspective of the farmer and the mart, what the Deputy is saying is correct but from the perspective of the VAT directive and the VATCA, when these situations arise, when supplies are made in this manner, the law applies a deemed sale between the seller and the mart and the mart and the buyer. It completes the supply chain for VAT purposes.
Comment on this
Does the Department have to run everything by Europe in terms of changing things?
Comment on this
These provisions are provided under the VAT directive.
Comment on this
Is it Europe that dictates all of that?
Comment on this
If it is under the VAT directive, national law has to be in compliance with that and it removes discretion. We have to abide by that.
Comment on this
Does Mr. O'Sullivan think it is a fair system that small farmers - not big farmers who are registered for VAT - with five or ten cattle in County Clare - a mart manager from Clare was in before us - will, with the adjustment, end up with €380,000 less in their pockets this year compared to the year before if the figures work out the same, which it looks like they will, yet there is no difference or change if I decide to sell to Mr. O'Sullivan or go to the factory, which is basically promoting a certain side of the business? Does it not look like the small guy is once again being tossed over to get out of cattle, given the way it is being handled, when those are the figures? Does Mr. O'Sullivan not think that the anomaly is a problem? Without there having to be an EU law, will the Department change one of the figures to ensure that they are level and do not cause this anomaly?
Comment on this
Where there is selling through a mart by an unregistered farmer, the mart charges a flat-rate addition. That is EU law. If it is a sale from one unregistered farmer to another, there is no VAT. That is also EU law. If it is an unregistered farmer to a meat processor, there is a livestock rate. It all depends on the channel.
Comment on this
I am giving the reality on the ground. I have cited County Clare, but multiply that by every county – Roscommon, Mayo, Galway, the lot – where weanling sales in particular would happen at this time of year. Clare would actually be small compared to Galway, Mayo, Roscommon or the rest of the west, which is where most of the weanlings are. Those farmers will be €380,000 down. What extra amount has the Exchequer taken in in the first eight or nine months of this adjustment? Mr. O’Sullivan talked about €60 million or something. What has it taken in so far?
Comment on this
For every 0.1% change in the flat rate, it is approximately €10 million. When it went down from 5.1% to 4.5%, I believe that €61.5 million was the Exchequer gain, as it were.
Comment on this
What has been taken in in the first eight months of this year?
Comment on this
We do not have a figure to hand for the flat rate. What we can say for the livestock rate-----
Comment on this
No, I am asking about the flat rate. Mr. O’Sullivan said that there would be an adjustment of €60 million. If we are two thirds of the way through the year, have we €40 million taken in? I bet the Exchequer has not got anything near that.
Comment on this
The way VAT is worked out, it does not go down to that level of granular detail, so we do not have those figures to hand.
Comment on this
Okay. I was interrupted a couple of times, so the Chair might give me another minute.
On the technical system that is used, the officials have given us a formula. Will they put meat on the bones of the formula so that we can get a grasp of it? Obviously, the officials are expert at doing the maths. If possible, and rather than just being told a number and multiplying it by 100 or whatever, will they give us something that puts meat on the bones of the figures and explains it to us in detail?
If it wanted to, could the Department level the figures out on one side without having to go to the EU? Could the Department have them level so that it would not cause a problem like it is doing at the moment or is there an option - we would not really be in favour of this, as we would rather it be levelled out – whereby a farmer could align it at the end of the year and marts would not have to do the paperwork?
Comment on this
On the last question first, the flat rate every year will land where it lands at what is deemed to be full compensation. With the livestock rate, there is some policy discretion. That rate can go as high as 4.9% and it can go down as well, so there is discretion there.
Comment on this
If, for example, the flat rate was below 4.8% for the coming year, there would be discretion to bring the livestock rate down to match it in that sense.
On the previous question around putting more flesh on the bones of the formula and how it is calculated, I might defer to my Revenue colleagues who undertake that exercise.
Comment on this
At the high level, that formula annually is the unregistered farmers input VAT divided by the unregistered farmers’ agricultural output and multiplied by 100 to give a percent. That level of flat rate calculation is in accordance with the EU VAT directive. It is arising from our obligations. We have to review that rate annually. We take the annual rate and we use a rolling three-year average to come up with what that flat rate is.
Comment on this
I believe everything Mr. Jenkinson is saying. All I am asking is-----
Comment on this
All I am asking is for the formula to be sent to us.
Comment on this
The officials can give us the detail of it. I need to get on to the next speaker, please.
Comment on this
Send us the whole lot – the meat and the bones. That is all I am looking for. Is that possible?
Comment on this
We can provide the Central Statistics Office, CSO, reference data that is provided to Revenue-----
Comment on this
Yes, but I mean the whole lot - the meat and the bones - so that we will understand. That is all.
Comment on this
-----to enable us to do that technical exercise.
Comment on this
And the figures showing the difference in money terms between the first eight months of this year compared to last year and in the amount of cattle sold. Even the first six months or eight months, whichever way the witnesses can get it.
Comment on this
Sorry, but would the Deputy mind clarifying? It is the comparison between the first eight months of this year-----
Comment on this
If €60 million were to be taken in in a year.
Comment on this
Since January, how much extra in VAT revenue money has been taken in?
Comment on this
I thank the officials for their submissions and opening statement. In calculating the flat rate, everything that the non-registered farmer purchases is taken into account and multiplied across the entire country, and then everything they sell is taken into account and multiplied out, with one then divided into the other and multiplied by 100. I understand the formula. My question is on how the Department can ascertain what each of those numbers is. That is what we need to try to get. Obviously, it is a very technical thing to be able to trace and track and I would like to know how the Department can trace that accurately. I would imagine it would be quite difficult.
The officials said that this was governed by the EU VAT directive and they had to comply with that for the calculation. I understand that and that is fine. It is quite strict and detailed in how that happens. However, the livestock rate, which is different and seems to have stayed quite static the whole time, can fluctuate and there is more scope for that to happen. One is at 4.5% and the other is at 4.8% now. If the livestock rate was brought down, would that be an advantage or a disadvantage to the farming community or to Revenue?
Comment on this
The Deputy asked about data from the CSO, what was involved, how we got that data and what it included. That is macroeconomic data specifically for the agricultural sector inputs and outputs attributed to unregistered farmers. We receive the data from the farming sector as a whole and Revenue provides that 85% of unregistered farmers avail of the flat-rate scheme, so we apply that 85% figure to the data provided by the CSO. As I said to Deputy Fitzmaurice, we can provide some more detailed CSO general data around that calculation.
The second question was on the livestock rate fluctuating and if there was policy discretion to lower it and what would the impact be. Is that correct?
Comment on this
There is policy discretion in that regard by the Minister for Finance to set that rate but it has to be set within the parameters of what is allowed under the VAT directive. The VAT directive enforces that the rate is under 5% and can be as low as 0%. If it is not in that range, it would need to be one of the other rates already provided for, namely, the standard rate of 23%, the reduced rate of 13.5% or the second reduced rate of 9%.
Comment on this
There is scope at the Minister's discretion to match the flat rate which is tighter and there is not the same flexibility.
Comment on this
There is. If the objective is to match the rates, however, the flat rate would have to be below 5%.
Comment on this
I understand the role of Revenue is to raise taxes and to bring in taxes to the Government. That is fine but the scheme set out here with two rates of VAT is really about giving farmers an opportunity to not be out of pocket because of the VAT situation. That is my understanding. It is not for Revenue to try to raise a pile of money. That is not the ambition of this scheme.
Comment on this
That is right. It is meant to allow farmers to be unregistered and therefore they can escape all the filing and administrative requirements. It is not meant to be a subsidy in any way because it does not allow for overcompensation. Farmers have the option of registering for VAT and claiming all their VAT inputs, as all registered VAT taxpayers do, or they can go into this scheme. This provides for administrative simplification and reduced burdens for them. We understand that approximately 85% of farmers have selected to go into this scheme so they value it.
Comment on this
Is it fair to say the bit of windfall Revenue has got from this because of the discrepancy is really an unintended consequence?
Comment on this
I do not know if one could call it an unintended consequence but the general idea is if all those farmers were VAT registered, there would be a Revenue-neutral impact.
Comment on this
Revenue is trying to achieve the same through this but in this particular case, it has not achieved the same. It has cost farmers and rural communities up to €60 million. We are not sure exactly of the number.
Comment on this
Farmers have been fully compensated for their VAT inputs in the year in question on an overall basis because that is how the formula is determined.
Comment on this
They have been compensated for their VAT input yet there is a gain to Revenue in excess of €60 million.
Comment on this
That would imply there was a difference between their VAT inputs and outputs over the three-year calculation period. Perhaps they had lower inputs or higher outputs. In any given year, the formula is designed on an overall basis to produce full compensation for the VAT input.
Comment on this
In the years they were at parity, which was a long time, Revenue did not have a gain and farmers did not have a loss or a gain either. Everything was at parity. If you were to do that again by reducing the livestock rate to match the flat rate and were that to happen every year, would that have a negative impact on the farmer or on Revenue?
Comment on this
If you take reducing the livestock rate in isolation, generally reducing a VAT rate for farmers or any taxpayer is good thing for them and it would have a negative Exchequer impact, albeit a relatively modest one.
Comment on this
Although you would be offering the flat rate, which would match it.
Comment on this
It would be a policy decision in terms of matching it. The flat rate takes into account all the VAT inputs including the livestock rate so they are separate. One is a separate scheme to the tax rate.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. It is important that Revenue realises farmers are being penalised when bringing their cattle and animals to the mart as if they were to sell them privately. The marts are regulated. They are really important economically, socially and in many other aspects. This anomaly is wrong and must be addressed. We cannot have farmers disincentivised from selling their cattle and sheep, etc., at the mart.
Farmers have paid VAT on all of their inputs in relation to rearing their animals such as vets, fertiliser and fuel, etc. They go to the mart, they expect to get that VAT back and they see a discrepancy. That is causing major pain and difficulties for a lot of farmers. It is not just farmers but the marts as well.
My first question is about the interpretation. I believe Revenue's interpretation is incorrect in the assertion at the moment. The mart plays a similar function to the likes of DoneDeal but DoneDeal does not collect VAT. Will the witnesses explain that? What is the material difference between DoneDeal and a mart? If I sell an animal at a mart, the mart is never registered on the book of that animal. It is direct between one farmer and another and the mart plays the role of a facilitator similar to how DoneDeal operates.
Comment on this
I cannot speak to the tax implications of a third-party taxpayer subject to confidentiality provisions in the tax code but I can explain the difference generally. Marts are subject to the rules that generally apply to auctioneers. There is a deeming provision in EU and Irish VAT law that where someone acts for another selling their goods, they treat the sale by the seller, the farmer, to the mart as a deemed sale even though, as the Deputy outlined, the sale is between the seller and the purchaser. I believe sites that facilitate sales do not act as auctioneers. They might be list sales but I do not think they are involved in actually selling the goods. There is a critical difference. The auctioneer is directly involved.
Comment on this
There is very little difference in reality. The mart and an online platform like DoneDeal operate a facilitation service, a matchmaking service - a way for the farmer, the seller, to engage with the purchaser. That needs to be looked at. I propose that Revenue review that. It seems to be based on an incorrect interpretation.
Comment on this
Is it because there is an auctioning licence involved? The auctioneering licence facilitates the sale. Is that the reason? I am only assuming that is what is different. In a DoneDeal situation, it is only an advertisement.
Comment on this
It is not because they have a licence, it is because they act as an auctioneer. If you advertise sales, for VAT purposes, the transactions are in no way similar.
Comment on this
That is my point. It is because it is an auctioneer.
Comment on this
The rates need to be aligned, as Senator Paul Daly said. On the farmer flat rate, I understand there are EU rules that could preclude raising that but it is within the gift of the Government to reduce the VAT rate on livestock. Are there any rules, EU or otherwise, that would prevent the Irish Government in this coming budget from aligning the two tax rates, in other words, reducing the livestock VAT rate?
Comment on this
There are no rules that would prevent them being aligned, as they were for many years a long time ago, except that the livestock rate must stay below 5%. The flat rate lands where it lands. If it goes to 5% or higher, it is not possible to align them because the super-reduced rate must be under 5%. If the flat rate was under 5%, there would be policy discretion to align the two.
Comment on this
That would be wise. I propose that the committee write to the Minister and recommend that we align the two, especially in years when we can do so at under 5%. It would spare marts, farmers and the entire sector an enormous headache.
Comment on this
I thank the officials for coming in and for their opening statements. If the rate were to remain at 5.1%, what would the estimated Exchequer cost have been in 2026? What assessment did the Government make of that cost against the potential impact on farmers' income?
Comment on this
The estimated cost of reducing the flat rate from 5.1% to 4.5% was €61.5 million. As for the assessment of the impact, this is not something we have policy discretion over. The rate comes from a predetermined formula and we receive the number each year from Revenue. If there is a change from one year to another, that new rate is applied. That is basically how it is determined.
Comment on this
With the evidence presented to the committee today showing that farmers are carrying a genuine financial loss as a result of the reduction, will the Department commit to looking again at the 4.5% rate rather than leaving farmers to absorb the cost?
Comment on this
This exercise is undertaken every year and at the end of the exercise, we are presented, if there is a change, with a new number, which can be higher or lower than in the current year. In some cases it can be the same. The number is essentially deemed to be full compensation for the VAT inputs of farmers within the scheme.
Comment on this
Very good. The flat-rate addition, FRA, is based on agricultural input and output data. What happens when a three-year average hides a sharp increase in particular costs faced by livestock farmers? Can the data the decisions are based on respond quickly enough to current conditions?
Comment on this
The three-year rolling average smooths out those peaks and troughs - the fluctuations in the rates - such that there are not large variations in the rate of the farmers' flat rate addition from one year to the next.
Comment on this
Then it would not have a major bearing on a farmer.
Comment on this
What I mean is the individual rate calculated in a given year could mirror inflationary pressures, increases in agricultural output or increases in the agricultural inputs farmers incur, but those fluctuations are smoothed out by the averaging of that annual figure over the three-year period.
Comment on this
I welcome the officials. It is really marts we are talking about. We will get on to talking about grain and milk as well today. The concept of the co-ops setting up marts was that farmers could trade their cattle. It came from the towns and villages that had fairs. I think Killorglin is the only fair in the country now. Maybe there are one or two more. Little did farmers think, when they were setting up these co-ops, that they would be penalised because there would be an auctioneer in between. That is what we are talking about. They are being penalised because there is an auctioneer.
My questions will have "Yes" or "No" answers. The drop from 5.1% in 2025 to the 2026 rate of 4.5% was the biggest reduction in the FRA in many years. The officials have told us how that was calculated. I might not agree with them but I will accept it for the moment. I understand every 0.1% change in the FRA is equivalent to €10 million in the agriculture sector. Is that correct? That will have a "Yes" or "No" answer. The officials will know that as they are collecting it.
Comment on this
If I can just take last year, the decline from 5.1% to 4.5% was just over €60 million and that would mean for every 0.1% change in the flat rate, it was a ball-park figure of €10 million.
Comment on this
It was €10 million and there was a 0.6% change. How much money did the Department bring in on that?
Comment on this
The estimated gain for the Exchequer at that time was, I think, €61.5 million.
Comment on this
Yes, and that is why we are here. The Department took €61.5 million out of farmers' pockets. The officials should not forget that. It was the same with milk and grain, was it not?
Comment on this
It covers agricultural produce and agriculture-----
Comment on this
Members, as public representatives, know from the meetings they have had with grain-growers that this is probably one of the worst years there have been. The same can be said about milk, with the warm year this year, the cost of inputs and all that. In that situation we are taking money out of farmers' pockets instead of trying to keep them in business. We are talking about the people who are not VAT-registered and the majority of Irish farmers are not VAT-registered. The people who are VAT-registered get the VAT back. That is a different situation. That is important.
With the reduction of the flat rate in 2026, many farmers are questioning the value of remaining in the flat rate scheme at all, particularly with the high cost of machinery. Should they be registered? We do not often have people from Revenue and the Department of Finance in the committee together. What is their opinion?
Comment on this
If I can clarify a previous comment, I said that €61.5 million was recorded as a gain for budgetary arithmetic purposes. However, the counterfactual would be that for the farmer, if they were VAT-registered, there would be no gain. It is revenue-neutral by design. I wanted to clarify that point. The gain is for budgetary arithmetic purposes only. It is a notional gain in that sense.
Comment on this
Should the farmers who are not VAT-registered become registered?
Comment on this
All farmers have that option. This is done on an overall basis, so if a farmer feels there is an advantage to becoming registered due to their being able to claim all the VAT inputs, which would give them more than the flat rate-----
Comment on this
What is Mr. O'Sullivan's opinion? I am asking him.
Comment on this
I do not have the information. Individual farmers are able to decide. They have the option.
Comment on this
Representatives of the Irish Co-operative Organisation Society, ICOS, were in earlier, as were representatives of two marts. Sellers through marts are suffering a financial loss due to the FRA being at 4.5% and livestock rates being at 4.8%. There is a huge problem there for the marts because the Department decided to change the rate. It was such a big change that it impacted on farmers, who are paying extra money.
Comment on this
The rate is set by a predetermined formula. Sometimes, it goes up; last year, it went down.
Comment on this
That is the Department's predetermined formula. The Minister will be making an announcement in a fortnight's time. I am not asking Mr. O'Sullivan anything about what it will be, but is it the case that whatever he and his colleagues present to the Minister, that will be it? How do they calculate the rate? Will it stay the same?
Comment on this
We are subject to budget secrecy on that.
Comment on this
Budget secrecy - that is very funny. I will put my neck on the line and say Mr. O'Sullivan is not going to get that. No Minister can stand over what happened last year. We will see what happens. I do not believe everything I am hearing today. As far as I am concerned, farmers are furious that they are out of pocket. The marts are losing because when the docket comes out to a farmer, that farmer does not look to see who got what. As far as the farmer is concerned, the mart took the money from him and paid back the Revenue Commissioners. Senator Brady knows, because he is at many marts every week, that people look at the docket and think, "Jesus, it cost €25 to sell that bullock". That is the money people are looking at, and it is what is causing haemorrhaging at the marts. It is very unfair.
It is impossible to explain to non-registered farmers selling their few cattle why they are losing €280 on every €1,000 worth of animal. How do people manage that? It is very difficult for them. They are taking less for their grain this year from the VAT point of view. They are getting less money in a year. That has been very difficult for them.
I am waiting eagerly to see what is going to be done in the budget. I would like to have the witnesses back here again after that. If I am wrong, that is fair enough, but if I am right and this is reversed, I would love to have them back in to see their calculations and how it happened. I believe in my heart that this is wrong. I would say the witnesses do too. We will see what the Minister for Finance says. That will be the proof.
Comment on this
I wonder whether the higher prices for cattle will determine the VAT rate. I do not know whether that has anything to do with it.
Comment on this
I wonder whether the good prices the year before have anything to do with it.
Comment on this
I just want to say that there is no such thing as dear cattle, as was stated here by another member.
Comment on this
Perhaps I should have said more expensive.
Comment on this
The witnesses will correct me if I am wrong, but I think there has been a breakdown in both communications and explanations here today. Flat-rate VAT is the farmer's friend. I am a flat-rate farmer who is not registered. I do not want to be doing returns. As we have been discussing, I do not want to be a collector for Revenue at the marts. The flat rate of 4.5% is meant to compensate me for the equivalent in VAT I have paid on my inputs. We have heard about the gain of €60 million. Far be it from me to be on the side of either the Department of Finance or Revenue in this argument, but the facts are that if €60 million is gained from the reduction from 5.1% to 4.5%, and the microeconomic information from the CSO said €60 million would be lost from the VAT farmers were paying, it means it is net neutral. That has not been explained here today. There is no loss to the farmer here if the calculation formula is working. Am I right about that?
Comment on this
The only issue we raised here was the anomaly that arose whereby when the rate came down to 4.5%, it went below the 4.8% livestock rate and that created the issue at the marts. There is no €60 million loss to farmers here at all. People need to understand flat-rate VAT.
The anomaly is the difference between the 4.5% rate and the 4.8% at the mart. That was the issue that was raised. The question is whether those rates can be equalised. As a beef farmer, my question is why they are different anyway. My only output is livestock. My inputs are fertiliser, diesel, VAT on diesel and you-name-it VAT. My only income is livestock. Why am I not on the flat rate of 4.5%? Why am I on 4.8%? I do not know why there was ever a difference.
The rates need to be equalised but in fairness to everybody involved here, this claim about Revenue gaining €60 million by the reduction in the flat rate is wrong. That is an equalisation. Flat-rate VAT is the farmer's friend, and it is important to say that.
Comment on this
If that is the case, where is the extra money going?
Comment on this
We are paying less VAT because there are reductions in fertiliser. As a result of the green issues or whatever, we are paying out less VAT. That is if the calculation is working.
Comment on this
Is Senator Daly saying we are paying more on our diesel?
Comment on this
Is he saying nitrogen is cheaper this year than last year?
Comment on this
I am talking about the VAT paid out by farmers. If that equation is working right, the farmer is VAT neutral. Flat-rate VAT is VAT neutral. It means farmers are paying less VAT if they are collecting it.
Comment on this
As I said earlier, this is designed as an administrative simplification. It is meant to be revenue neutral. It is meant to fully compensate farmers who otherwise would be registered and claiming under inputs. It is meant to be revenue neutral in that respect.
Comment on this
It is very complicated and hard to understand, but it is revenue neutral.
Comment on this
It is meant to be, but, right now, it is not.
Comment on this
No, it is revenue neutral if the calculation is working right. If the sum is working right, it is still revenue neutral. That is why it changes; it is based on the sum.
Comment on this
I want to know about the livestock rate. Why is there a difference and can the rates be equalised?
Comment on this
The livestock rate has been 4.8% all the way along since January 2005. It has not been changed since then. As I said earlier, there is policy discretion to change the livestock rate within certain parameters.
Comment on this
Why were the rates allowed to drift apart and decouple?
Comment on this
I can see from the information on historical rates that they were decoupled in 2007. Up until then, they were at parity. At that point, the flat rate was higher. It was 5.2% that year. I presume that at that point, the decision was made to decouple them. They have been decoupled ever since. There may have been one or two years where they happened to be the same but, in essence, they were decoupled from 2007.
Comment on this
I know Mr. O'Sullivan is bound by budget secrecy but does he think it would be a good idea for the two rates to be coupled once the flat rate is below 5%? Would there be a cost on the Exchequer to couple them? Let us say there is no change to the flat rate this year and we wanted to bring the 4.8% livestock rate down to the 4.5% rate to couple them, is there a cost to the Exchequer to do that?
Comment on this
There is a modest cost to reducing the livestock rate. I understand that for every 0.3% reduction in the livestock rate, there is an estimated cost of €2 million to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
That means it would cost about €12 million to decouple the rates.
Comment on this
It is an Exchequer cost. A lower rate means a cost to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
No, it does not. It could mean an increase.
Comment on this
Would it cost about €8 million in a given year to reduce it from 5% to 4.8%?
Comment on this
If we reduce it from 4.8% to 4.5%, for example, that cost would be around €2 million.
Comment on this
All it would cost to equalise the rates, as they stand at the moment, is €2 million. If we wanted to decouple the rates as they are today, the cost would be only €2 million. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Is that the gain then? If Mr. O'Sullivan is saying it will cost €2 million, then that is the money the farmers are paying in now.
Comment on this
No. Any reduction in the livestock rate is a cost to the Exchequer. As I said, at 0.3%, that cost is estimated at around €2 million. That is a cost to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
That is on the livestock rate, not the flat rate.
Comment on this
Is that to take it to 4.8%?
Comment on this
What about the other sectors then, including grain?
Comment on this
Essentially, when the flat rate is determined by the formula, that incorporates all the VAT inputs, including the livestock rate. I just want to clarify that.
Comment on this
At what stage? Mr. O’Sullivan referred to the formula. To change the formula, he said it would be put from 4.5% to 4.8%. Is that correct?
Comment on this
No. The flat rate formula is essentially determined within the EU VAT directive. We are conflating the flat rate with the livestock rate. The livestock rate is 4.8%. There is discretion to reduce that. With the flat rate, whatever the formula and whatever number it generates at the end of every year, that is the number that goes through.
Comment on this
Could that go over 5%? That is what I am asking.
Comment on this
If the flat rate goes over 5%, there will be a differential between the flat rate and the livestock rate, because the parameters for the livestock rate mean it has to stay below 5%.
Comment on this
It happened in the past, for quite a number of years.
Comment on this
It has not happened since 2007. Is that what Mr. O’Sullivan said?
Comment on this
The first time they were decoupled was in 2007, when the flat rate was higher than the livestock rate. Until that point, they were at the same rate.
Comment on this
Okay. It would be good if we could get them back to the same rate at this time. It would stop a lot of the confusion, especially for the marts, if everything was on par, at the one rate.
Comment on this
I am glad that the witnesses are here. A discrepancy has arisen in the last while. The marts came to this committee, and Martin McNamara clearly told us that there was a cost to the farmer. Now, a lot of people are trying to say there is no cost to the farmer.
Comment on this
There is a cost to the livestock rate.
Comment on this
Is it costing the farmers money?
Comment on this
All right. This is based on the claim that there are two transactions in the mart when the man takes the cattle to the mart. This is why the farmers are liable for this. In fact, there is only one transaction. A farmer takes in his cattle. The mart is the seller. It never put the cattle into its herd. The mart does not have a herd, or I never heard that it had. Maybe a few times, I went home after selling cattle, and the next thing, the buyer threw them up. However, that is all I was told – that the buyer threw them up. They would be there inside a pen. I would then be told to come for them and take them away. The mart never kept them. They are not the mart's cattle.
I cannot understand why the Department is basing its theory on this. It means that it has to go after these fellows and take money out of their pockets, simply because it is saying there are two transactions. Point out to me where the two transactions are. A farmer goes into the mart and the auctioneer sells them. There is nothing more to do. The mart never puts them into its herd. There is no such thing as two transactions. The auctioneer is on site. It is the same as someone trying to tell me that a house or a farm is for sale, and the auctioneer stands up to sell it, and the next thing, maybe after a few hours or a few days, the buyer throws up the property. Is the auctioneer stuck with it? There is no such thing. There is only one transaction. I do not know how the Department makes out that there are two transactions. The auctioneer is only there for a purpose. The mart is only providing a service to pen the cattle, walk them into the ring and sell them. They are not put into the mart’s name. I refuse to agree that there are two transactions in the first place. Answer that.
Comment on this
There is one economic transaction. There is a seller and a buyer. For the purposes of VAT law, which stems from the EU VAT directive, there are two transactions. That is what is specified in the directive.
Comment on this
I am afraid Mr. O’Sullivan was never at a mart because that is not what happens. You could have all the degrees in the world, but I know what happens in a mart. To have two transactions would mean the seller goes in and gives the animals to the mart, and he would register the animals, the mart would register the animals in its herd, if it had such a thing, and then it would sell them. There would then be two transactions, but that is not what happens. The auctioneer is inside, up on the stand. He sells the animal, and if there is something wrong, the animal goes back to the seller. The mart is never stuck with the animal.
Comment on this
That is my point. The witnesses are wrong from the start.
Comment on this
Thank you, Deputy. We need to move towards getting a decision on where we stand on it. Can the two rates be linked or bound together, as they seem to have been in the past when they moved along and were matched together each year? Would there be a consequence for farmers and the Exchequer if the two bands - the flat rate and the livestock rate - were bound together?
Comment on this
They can be matched, as I said, subject to the parameters. Essentially, the livestock rate must be beneath 5%. If the flat rate happened to land beneath 5%, there would be policy discretion to match them. Any reduction in the livestock rate would have an Exchequer cost, and I have explained that for every 0.3% reduction, it is approximately €2 million.
Comment on this
I want to let the witnesses finish up their business, and we can then get on with-----
Comment on this
It was said here today that farmers did not lose money.
Comment on this
Can I just ask this, Chairman? You gave four minutes extra.
Comment on this
I need to conclude with the witnesses. We are going to move on and do our own business. We need to suspend the meeting.