We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

General Scheme of the Dog Breeding Establishments (Amendment) Bill 2026: Discussion

Summary

Dogs Trust Ireland and the NSPCA welcomed the Bill but urged stronger welfare-focused rules, including broader coverage of breeders, trained staffing, a cap on establishment size and robust traceability. They called for a dedicated, consistent national inspectorate, clearer enforcement powers and public access to inspection and enforcement records. Witnesses warned that large-scale breeding and poor early-life conditions can cause lasting health and behavioural problems, adding to rescue and surrender pressures. They also stressed the need to align rules across the island to limit illicit trade and regulatory gaps.

Contributions 135–284 of 284. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Yes, but Mr. Savage's company is headquartered in Delaware in the United States.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

I live in America.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Savage pay tax in the States?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

I pay tax everywhere. I am registered for Irish VAT.

Comment on this

Senator, we are focused on the Bill, not Mr. Savage's finances.

Comment on this

Sorry, but we have somebody from dogs.ie who has come in-----

Comment on this

Our focus is the Bill.

Comment on this

-----purporting to be from a dog welfare group, because this section is about dog welfare. He clearly is not concerned about the interests of dogs and dog welfare.

Comment on this

The committee members requested or invited witnesses based on their experience, not on their purporting to be one thing or another. The committee invited Mr. Savage to appear in good faith. I ask the Senator to continue on the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

I would be happy to meet with the Senator afterwards if he would like to discuss any of these points.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Savage to answer the questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Sure. The prices of everything have increased. I need to be able to pay my staff. I have staff in Ireland who are registered for PRSI.

Comment on this

How many staff does Mr. Savage have?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

In Cork, I have two staff members.

Comment on this

Mr. Savage has two staff members in Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Yes.

Comment on this

I have the details of a dog breeding establishment licenceholder, which I can provide to the committee. On 31 August, the licenceholder details on the live dogs.ie advertisement were changed from one individual to his brother. What evidence was provided to verify that it is the correct breeder? What safeguards are in place to prevent breeders from altering or misinterpreting-----

Comment on this

Senator, our purpose is the Bill.

Comment on this

-----details in their ads, given that dogs.ie does not physically inspect-----

Comment on this

Our purpose here is the Bill.

Comment on this

Yes, absolutely. Mr. Savage's testimony will inform this Bill. We have to be clear about what his intentions are and who he is supporting when he tries to shape and inform the report. Given that dogs.ie does not physically inspect the puppies advertised, he clearly does not have any-----

Comment on this

I call Deputy Fitzmaurice.

Comment on this

It needs to be noted that any Bill that comes in here should be for the betterment of the welfare of dogs. Whatever the Bill may be, we have to hear from every side of the argument to be informed about it. That is the first thing that needs to be noted.

I commend the dogs that have helped so many young children with autism. I have seen them in schools and the help they have given to children is commendable. The after-training that is done on some of those dogs is incredible and it needs to be noted.

Do the different groups agree that DNA should be taken from every dog, dogs should be micochipped and any dog found without a microchip should be taken, end of story, in order that we have traceability for every single dog?

Comment on this
Ms Corina Fitzsimons

I am happy to answer that on behalf of the Irish Blue Cross. Traceability is one of our main points as regards the Bill. We believe that every puppy should have its parents registered on the microchip.

Comment on this

Yes, that is sound, but what I am asking is this. We have seen dogs go after sheep and we have seen problems throughout rural Ireland with dogs being abandoned. Some people never bother getting the dog microchipped or doing the different things. I am asking for the witnesses' thoughts on whether every dog should have to be microchipped and have its DNA recorded. If a ewe or a person is attacked, we would then have a traceable system. If dogs are caught that are not traceable, they would not be around.

Comment on this
Ms Corina Fitzsimons

Yes. We fully support the legislation that requires every dog in Ireland be microchipped. We believe it should be enforced. We believe that chipping should be enforced throughout DBEs, so puppies can be traced back to DBEs and their parents because of innate health issues. We also believe that DNA is probably not fit for purpose in the sense that a database would have to be created and someone would have to maintain it. The Bill suggests that inbreeding be banned, which we support. However, in a DBE, if there is a disparity as regards the parents of a dog, how does one prove that a dog is not related to another dog? If the chipping shows the puppy's parents and there are worries about whether that has been falsified, we would ask that DNA be introduced at the cost of that particular DBE.

Comment on this

I put it back to Ms Fitzsimons that 1.5 million calves are born in Ireland every year and identification is given within a few days. There is traceability in every bit of that. What is the big deal about having as much with dogs?

Comment on this
Ms Corina Fitzsimons

I am sorry, but I do not understand the question.

Comment on this

Ms Fitzsimons said that she did not believe we can have the DNA or traceability as we would need a database. If we can do it with the Department of agriculture with livestock, why can we not do it with dogs as well?

Comment on this
Ms Corina Fitzsimons

We should be able to do it in dogs and we have legislation that requires every dog in Ireland to be microchipped. My point was on DNA. I do not know if that is possible. Who would finance it and who would run the database?

Comment on this

Should the likes of the Department of agriculture not do it?

Comment on this
Ms Corina Fitzsimons

If a dog is microchipped, what is the requirement to have it DNA tested unless that DNA is for another point? If a dog is microchipped and traceability works properly-----

Comment on this

Unfortunately, we saw in another sector that horses might have a few microchips in them. At least if we had the DNA, we might have another bit of transparency to make it very clear.

Comment on this
Ms Corina Fitzsimons

Yes, if the resources were there and it benefits dog welfare, we would be all for it.

Comment on this

What are the witnesses' thoughts on small businesses run by, say, a father, mother, son or daughter, where the next generation takes over? Based on this legislation, I have no problem with requiring that if an inspector comes in, there would be a proper roster. Do the witnesses worry about this thing of having a paid member?

Comment on this
Mr. Tim O'Mahony

At any one time, we would have a maximum of 20 broods. We have two full-time members of staff. Each of our broods is maintained by a volunteer so they have a 1:1 ratio. Then the staff ratio would 1:7.5 to 1:10 broods. We have no concern whatsoever about that.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Mahony has no concern about what?

Comment on this
Mr. Tim O'Mahony

About the ratios and having rosters.

Comment on this

Under the legislation, it has to be a paid person, whereas if it was on a farm, a person who has retired and might be helping the next generation would be getting nothing for that work because they might be drawing the pension or whatever. If that person was to be rostered, they have to be there to be accountable. That is right, and I agree with it.

Comment on this

A vote has been called in the Dáil, so I ask that a member be proposed to take the Chair.

Comment on this

I propose Senator Boyhan.

Comment on this
Victor Boyhan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

I will explain the position. There is a vote in the Dáil, which the witnesses can see on the cameras to their left. It should not take that long so the members who left will be back and other members will also come in. I call Senator Brady.

Comment on this

We spoke about microchipping. It is my belief, and it is the law, that every dog should be microchipped. We should go further and have a DNA database with every dog on it. When sheep are attacked, as Deputy Fitzmaurice said, the saliva of the dog that attacked them can be taken from the dead animal to identify the dog that did it. Legislation needs to be brought in. If a vet is treating a dog that is not chipped, there is an onus on the vet to put a chip in the dog and register it to the person who brought it in on the day. That is what we need to strengthen, to start with. If a dog is impounded, it should be chipped in the pound and registered to the next owner before it goes out.

If we started on that basis, we would have something. There is a huge number of animals out that that are not chipped. That is where the whole problem of dog attacks lies.

Our dog breeding facilities are second to none, to be honest. The regulations are there. I encourage anyone to go and visit some of these facilities. They are cleaner than people's homes. The dogs are looked after better than some humans are. They are on heated beds. I have visited a number of them and support the industry.

Where I have a problem, however, which Deputy Fitzmaurice touched on, is the ratio of staff. If I have family members, should they have to be paid? If the women’s shed or the old folks' party are regularly coming to visit the facility for mental health reasons, and if they are registered, why would they have to be paid? They are coming to join in for the welfare of the dogs and to walk them and so on. Why do they have to be paid? If they are part of the registration, I do not think they should have to be paid although I do think they should be on a database to say that there are, say, four ladies who come in on Wednesdays and are part of the facility. I do not think they have to be paid, and especially in the case of family members. I am on the farm at home with kids. It is not sustainable to give them a wage but they are still there. Family members should count when it comes to this industry.

The witnesses spoke about online transactions and stated that there should be no cash. You cannot buy a dog online. It simply cannot be done. There have to be proper procedures in place so that a you can visit the facility, where the bitch and her pups are quarantined for disease such that people are not bringing disease in and out, and you can see the level of welfare. Kids should be able to come and pick their pups and know they are in a healthy state and vaccinated. I am completely against what goes on in horse fairs where people are buying pups out of the backs of cars. It drives me mad when you see the likes of Ballinasloe horse fair, to name just one, and the number of pups traded there. That has to stop. That is the sector we need to hit most with this.

Comment on this
Victor Boyhan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

Who is that directed to?

Comment on this

Anyone who wants to take it.

Comment on this
Victor Boyhan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

We will start with Blue Cross, if that is okay.

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Corridan

Somebody who is responsible for pregnant bitches and their puppies has to know what they are doing. They have to have an appropriate level of knowledge to do that. Bringing in groups of people to handle puppies needs to be managed very well because of infectious disease.

Comment on this

I am not referring to handling. When you come to visit, they will be behind a screened area. There will be no handling and there should be no cross-contamination from the outside. You cannot have that, and I understand that as a dog owner myself. There should be no handling of puppies and I understand that, but they should be able to see the mother, or the father if they ask to see the father, and the level of welfare.

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Corridan

Is that if somebody is purchasing a dog?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Corridan

Absolutely. They want to see Mum and they want to make sure the dogs they are seeing is that puppy’s mum because that is not always the case. We see people all the time who have met somebody at a motorway service station or the side of the road and done a transfer from car to car and they have no idea at all where that puppy has been reared. We need to stop that-----

Comment on this

One hundred percent.

Comment on this
Ms Corina Fitzsimons

-----and the public need to understand that if they buy a dog, they need a whole lot of information about where it has come from before they part with their money, whether by card, cash or anything else.

Comment on this

One hundred percent, yes.

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Corridan

The 2018 dog breeding guidelines have a lot of great information. They refer to a documented workforce plan. That has been there for around eight years. It refers to an “appropriate ratio [of staffing] for individual establishments” and refers to a risk assessment of the premises. All of these things should already exist and should be checked and documented. We can talk about whether it needs to be public so that the public can view it - that might not be a bad thing, or there could be a redacted version - but we should have some more transparency in what goes on in these inspections.

Comment on this

The local authority has veterinary inspectors who call out to these premises on a regular basis, so they are scrutinised to the highest level. Let us be quite clear about it. It is the undocumented puppy farms where there are pups being reared at the back of houses, where we do not know what is happening and where they are reared for sale on the black market. That is what we need to tackle. We know where this is happening, or at least we should.

Comment on this
Victor Boyhan An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

I thank Senator Brady. We need to move on. Senator Lynch is next. She has six minutes.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here. This is incredibly important legislation. My first question is for Irish Guide Dogs for the Blind. I am very familiar with that group, as well as other service dogs organisations such as Autism Dogs and My Canine Companion, and the fantastic work they do. Irish Guide Dogs' submission on the possible impacts this legislation could have on the organisation is quite frightening. It would put massive restrictions on the work it does. On the five main points it wanted to have addressed, where do these stand under the current 2010 Act as opposed to the proposed legislation in terms of the recognition of the service dog, breeding limits, the socialisation of puppies and so on? If this goes ahead, what impact will it have on the organisation and how will it limit the service it can provide?

Comment on this
Mr. Tim O'Mahony

First, I have not looked at the historical breeding stuff. We follow the accreditation standards, which far exceed what is in this Bill. Our ratios are much improved. We have our broodstock holder and our staff ratios. On the volunteers, we provide the support of the volunteers to paid staff. There is a ratio of 1:7.5 volunteers. Then we have the veterinary back-up for each of those volunteers through our association vet and local vets.

We start the socialisation when the pups are born so they get used to the different environments and textures that a pup would come into contact with when they get older. This means they are familiar, do not make strange when they come in for training and are able to support the clients and their independence. The earlier we can start that, the better. It is international best practice.

We limit our broods to 25 pups or four whelps, or whichever comes first. There is a maximum of two Caesareans for any brood and then the bitch is automatically retired. The brood stays with the broodstock holder, so it is very much a social enterprise to support independence and mobility for clients.

Mr. McFeeley wants to come in on a few things.

Comment on this
Mr. Garvan McFeeley

We are registered under the Dog Breeding Establishment Act and have been subject to the current legislation for a long time. It has not really interfered with how we operate our programmes. One of the single biggest changes in this proposal is that we need pups to leave the nest at six weeks. Every day counts. We have a two-week early socialisation programme with volunteers outside the nest. As Mr. O’Mahony says, from day one, we have a programme for the pups in the nest and then, at about eight weeks, the pup goes to a puppy volunteer family for raising for 12 to 14 months. Therefore, that six-week provision would be problematic for us. It would definitely impact outcomes for our dogs and would not benefit anybody.

Comment on this
Mr. Tim O'Mahony

At six weeks, they go off in twos, so they get used to being in a reduced number away from the litter. At eight weeks, they go off to the volunteer for the next 11 months. It all follows a very supportive, developmental project for the pup to ensure it comes in the prime condition for training. We try to use every moment of the pup's life to enable it to deliver independence and mobility.

Comment on this
Mr. Garvan McFeeley

The family who looks after the brood are trained by us and have access to our breeding team and our veterinary support. They have quite an extensive support ecosystem within the volunteers inside Irish Guide Dogs for the Blind. They are trained, they know what they are doing and they get on with it.

Comment on this

I commend Irish Guide Dogs for the Blind on the work it is doing. I have worked with a lot of families who have benefited. I have also worked with families who have raised these puppies and the service is just incredible, so I thank the witnesses very much.

On some of the amendments the Irish Blue Cross has proposed, Deputy Fitzmaurice and Senator Brady covered it in terms of the staff ratio. In terms of the point about setting clear, measurable requirements for socialisation, habituation and exercise supported by records and inspection evidence, how will these be feasible on the ground for anybody who is involved in a dog breeding establishment? Surely we should be looking at effective, efficient measures that actually work rather than trying to introduce lots more things that complicate the system. We should be looking at simplification. I completely get that the measures that are there at the moment are not being properly enforced. There is a massive discrepancy between local authorities and the Department and a lot of these welfare issues are falling between two stools.

Rather than trying to over-complicate, are we not better off focusing on getting the basics right, such as ensuring all pups are microchipped, there is adequate inspection of dog breeding establishments and those that are falling under this are doing the right thing? The vast majority are but a minority are not and they are the ones who need to be dealt with. I am just concerned that if you overcomplicate this too much, the efficiency, delivery and effectiveness of this Bill come into question. It is all well and good to have an extremely extensive piece of legislation but if you do not have a mechanism for enforcement, what good is it?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Corridan

The Senator is underestimating the importance of the first eight to 12 weeks. That first period for a puppy is the equivalent to nine months for a human infant. We are preparing puppies to go into family homes. We are not talking about stock on a farm or in a stall that are reared in a particular way and will live there for their entire lives. They have to be safe going into a family home so it is about preparing them for that. Even the car journey from the DBE to the new home is a stressor. Leaving the dam is a stressor. Leaving their siblings is a stressor. Getting a vaccine and microchip is a stressor. We are doing all of these super stressful things to a tiny animal who is incredibly vulnerable at that point in their lives. We have to make sure the environment they are reared in mimics where they will be ultimately be living as closely as we can. Otherwise, we are doing a disservice to them and we are doing a disservice to the people buying them.

Comment on this

I take that point and I completely agree with Dr. Corridan in that a dog needs the best upbringing it possibly can have. That makes it a much better pet for a family. We are then opening the issue of what we are doing in terms of people who are buying these pets. What kind of environment are they going into?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Corridan

That is about educating the public. That is another thing altogether. Our inspection process is where we can monitor some of this. It is looking at animal-based measures, not just looking at dimensions and whether they are on appropriate bedding. We can look for noise levels and acral lick lesions where they are showing signs of stress. We can look at whether somebody comes in and the animals are behaving fearfully. That tells me things are not as they should be. They are really obvious measures.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. As I have said before, regulations are badly needed. Not only are they needed, they need to be followed through on because people get quite fed up when they are reporting issues and then a while later, dogs are back. I know that from my own experience but we will not go into that. Mr. Savage's company is advertising dogs for sale and there are 30,000 a year or so. Does his company ever spot-check the animals for sale? How are they sold? Is it if I want to sell a dog, I advertise with his company and that is it, nobody sees my dog. Do all dogs need to have microchips?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Yes. The 2019 regulations for animal sale and supply say that dogs have to be microchipped. An ad has to contain certain pieces of information such as what country the dog was born in, the microchip number-----

Comment on this

Is Mr. Savage's company selling dogs from other countries or are they just Irish dogs?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

They would be imported dogs, for example.

Comment on this

Are they all imported dogs?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

No. If a dog has been imported, it would say it has come from a different country.

Comment on this

How many of the 30,000 are imported?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

There are very low numbers. It is less than 500.

Comment on this

Okay. If I got a dog and the dog had behavioural issues, is there a return date on them?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

We supply an example of a contract for people to have a negotiation when they meet a breeder to talk about what happens in those first weeks when something goes wrong.

Comment on this

Issues go wrong years later. There was a certain dog we got and it turned nasty after a few years. They call it "rage syndrome". It was a golden cocker spaniel and it happened because they are so inbred. This obviously was from one of those puppy farms or something; I do not know what. We have to stop that, along with the inbreeding. They are obviously microchipped, so do we know the mother and father of all the dogs?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

That is not stored on the microchip details.

Comment on this

No, but when someone is advertising, are the mother and father or pedigree of the dog advertised?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

It is not listed in the ad.

Comment on this

It would be a little bit more transparent if we could get the information on dams and sires. I am sure for Mr. Savage it would just be another two things ticked on his website that would make it more transparent.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

If you have a pedigree dog and it is registered with the IKC, you can see three generations on the microchip certificate that the IKC produces. It would be possible to extend the microchipping rules to have something similar.

Comment on this

I was reading that there are some people Dogs.ie will not accept dogs from. How does Mr. Savage decide who he accepts or does not accept dogs from?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Generally, it is based on people registering, whether that is registering as a general seller of pets or a DBE. If they are not prepared to do that, we cannot accept their ads. We have probably blocked around 4,000 accounts on the website. We try our best to stop those people advertising.

Comment on this

Dogs.ie has been in business since 2008.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Yes.

Comment on this

I am sure Mr. Savage sees regular customers and there are customers who sell dogs on the website year on year.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Yes.

Comment on this

That is what I am saying. If the parentage were upfront, you would be able to see what bitches were having more litters of pups than they were supposed to, but enough of that.

I get what Mr. O'Mahony is saying about the dogs having to be moved on. I understand all that. They are moved with siblings. These dogs change people's lives so much. There has to be certain circumstances where you are fully monitored. Those dogs get the best lives. They are so sought after. People are crying out for companion dogs, whether it is for autism or for the blind. They are so valuable to our community. They give people a life. That has to be welcomed.

If you are complying with veterinary regulations, and the veterinary regulations are all over this, there has to be some way we can make allowances for certain charities that do such good work for families. A bit of work needs to be done on that. People can come in and inspect any time they want.

Comment on this
Mr. Tim O'Mahony

Absolutely. The other thing we should add is that we stay with a dog during their working life and beyond. When a dog graduates to a client, we do aftercare visits to check in on their welfare. The welfare is non-negotiable at any stage of any of our dogs' lives. We know it brings the ultimate benefit for our clients. We are accredited by the IGDF and ADI, which are international standards that govern access and could equally apply here.

Comment on this

I have just one quick one.

Comment on this

I cannot, I am tight on time. I need to move to Senator Boyhan, who gave up time earlier in the first round. He has three minutes, and then I have Deputies Whitmore and Ní Raghallaigh.

Comment on this

I will address Mr. McFeeley on two things. He made the point about the six or eight weeks, which has been very helpful here today. He has brought clarity to that. He also talked about the siblings and less distress being exacted on the pup. That was important and is something I think we learned here today.

I want to ask the Irish Guide Dogs for the Blind about best practice. It has a track record of best practice in terms of its breeding. IGDB gives them a number and letter so it knows where every pup bred under its programmes is by year, letter and the naming of the animal. Maybe not now, but it might be helpful for IGDB to share that process because we could learn a lot from understanding how it registers and tracks all its bitches. Obviously, it is clearly learning and does not have all successes because some do not want to be successful partnership dogs. However, it has bloodlines and breeding lines that it has exchanged across Europe. Certainly, when I was involved, it was in South Africa and the United States.

It is critically important for us to understand the bloodlines in breeding dogs. As regards best practice, I can think of no other organisation here that would have an established system that is tracked all the way through the life of a dog, from beginning to end. The organisation might share that in the next week or two, if it has time.

Comment on this
Mr. Garvan McFeeley

We would be delighted to do that. Regarding a question the Senator raised with Mr. O'Mahony earlier, we are subject to the Dog Breeding Establishments Act and have been for many years. Some of the provisions in this suggested amendment are problematic for us, so they are the ones we are looking for an exemption on, not an exemption from the Dog Breeding Establishments Act.

Comment on this

That clarity is very important, because everyone acknowledges the significant and important work the organisation does for independent mobility and all that goes with that. The organisation might share the tracing, tracking and best practices on how that starts from the beginning through matching stud dogs to bitches and then how the pups are registered, numbered and tracked. That is something we want to get a handle on.

Comment on this
Mr. Garvan McFeeley

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I have a question for Mr. Savage. It is very important this legislation and the discussions here are based on experience and expertise, because that is how we are going to develop the most robust and appropriate legislation. Mr. Savage said his purpose here was to share his data and what his experience shows. I have some yes or no questions. Does Mr. Savage have any veterinary experience?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

No.

Comment on this

Do you have any breeding experience?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

No.

Comment on this

Do you have any legal experience?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

No.

Comment on this

Do you have any animal behavioural or welfare experience?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Yes, I have attended some conferences.

Comment on this

Do you have any experience in genetics husbandry?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

No.

Comment on this

The document Mr. Savage developed may not be used to represent breeders but certainly it is to influence and engage them. There were a series of recommendations in that document. Is Mr. Savage saying that document came from and was written using ChatGPT?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Yes.

Comment on this

Okay. I know I am not a member of this committee, but I do not think it is appropriate to get advice or information from someone who has not pulled the information from their own personal experience but instead from ChatGPT. It is dangerous, it could risk the welfare of animals and I am not sure how many dog breeders are actually coming in. I do not think there is any sort of large-scale puppy farmer coming in to the committee, but they will have fed into this piece of information. I ask that it be disregarded. I do not think it is an appropriate level of documentation to be taken into account during this legislation.

Comment on this

Members agreed to call witnesses based on their expertise and knowledge.

Comment on this

Absolutely. That is 100% what the members need to do.

Comment on this

The members have nominated the witness to participate.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

It is an analysis from ChatGPT

Comment on this

I think that was based on what they expected his expertise to be. This is no disrespect to Mr. Savage, but he has a website-----

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

The Deputy can have a look at the message that says this is an analysis from ChatGPT.

Comment on this

I will be stopping if it says that.

Comment on this

But you build websites-----

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

It was heard when I shared it.

Comment on this

Does that document show that?

Comment on this

Mr. Savage builds websites, which is a fantastic business to be in, but I do not think it gives him the expertise to participate in this legislation. That is my point.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

I was here to share-----

Comment on this

I had a look at his website and when you go onto it, the puppies are absolutely gorgeous. They are all dolled up with beautiful green leaves in front of them. Does Mr. Savage think this represents the life these puppies have experienced? This is from a DBE farmer who is registered for 300 dogs. From an advertising standards perspective, would this meet the honest advertising standards advertisers are expected to apply?

Comment on this

Our time is limited, so can we keep a focus on the Bill rather than the person?

Comment on this

That is fine. Mr. Savage has said it is about transparency, and I think we need to bring some transparency to his participation and documentation.

Comment on this

It is important we keep our focus on the Bill rather than the person.

Comment on this

This is about the lives of puppies, what they experience and how they are sold and portrayed. I have not ever been on a large-scale puppy farm. I wrote to 14 of them and I did not get one response back saying I could go on and see it. There is an issue about transparency. We have to ask ourselves why they do not want any eyes on how they produce these puppies, but we also need to have a discussion about the advertising and responsible advertising of pups.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

The Deputy will remember that I also reached out to her office in December-----

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

-----and offered to bring her. We have also shared her request on Facebook.

Comment on this

Yes, and none of them came to me.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

We also shared it to the breeders. That might be more of a reflection on the Deputy than us. We tried to help the Deputy.

Comment on this

We need to keep our focus on the Bill.

Comment on this

I am not saying it is a reflection on Mr. Savage. I am saying it is a reflection on an industry that does not want any eyes on it. That is what it is a reflection of.

Comment on this

First, I commend the Irish Blue Cross and all the fantastic work it does. I also want to follow on from Deputy Whitmore and the idea of transparency. I have a question for Mr. Savage. Before I go into any questions, I need to know if Mr. Savage is coming to the committee to represent the best interests of commercial dog breeders or to support the welfare-based model being proposed by Dogs Trust and NSPCA. I want to understand why he is here.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

We were invited, so I am happy to give our input. Often, the numbers say the reason the pounds are full is because of dog breeders. It was in my opening statement that I wanted to clarify the breeds filling up the pound, at least from my analysis, do not seem to be coming from DBEs.

Comment on this

Dogs.ie recently changed its policy to allow large-scale commercial breeders to advertise where it did not previously. Why did it change that policy?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

I know five years seems recent.

Comment on this

Why did Mr. Savage change his policy?

Comment on this

Can we keep the focus on the Bill?

Comment on this

Is Mr. Savage not here to feed into the Bill? Do we not need to have all the information we can? He is sitting here because of the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

Is it better to have transparency when a dog is sold?

Comment on this

All I want is transparency.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

When a breeder has 100 bitches, we add that into the advertisement so that it is clear what size of an operation they are licensed for.

Comment on this

It is not clear because it is down at the very bottom of the advertisement.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

It is right beside the contact information.

Comment on this

We might give the witness the opportunity to speak.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Savage

It is right beside the contact in little pixels on your phone - have a look at it. You cannot see the telephone number without going past this. It also says this establishment is a registered seller of pets or a dog breeding establishment. If the Senator has some feedback he would like us to review, I am happy to do that.

Comment on this

I think we need to look at this. There is a lot the organisation could do. I thought I was going to get six minutes, but I agree with Deputy Whitmore about that document. I know I am not a member, but perhaps the members who invited him in were not aware this was ChatGPT slop. I want to put on record that I agree with the Deputy on that.

Comment on this

That is what it is - slop.

Comment on this

That concludes the time available to us for this session. I thank everybody who has taken part in it, and for their insights on the Bill. We will continue with pre-legislative scrutiny on the Bill next week. In the meantime, that concludes today's business.

Comment on this