We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

General Scheme of the Dog Breeding Establishments (Amendment) Bill 2026: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

The Department outlined proposed amendments to raise welfare standards, including limits on litters and breeding age, a 1:20 staffing ratio, restrictions on puppy sales, mandatory inspections and stronger penalties. It opposed a hard cap on breeding females, arguing targeted welfare and enforcement measures were preferable, while acknowledging significant gaps in dog-related data and the need for better traceability. Members questioned enforcement consistency, breeder inspections, export and vaccination records, and whether the proposed limits adequately protect dogs. Dog Law Ireland called for a cap, a stricter staffing ratio and an independent regulator; the next stakeholder session had just begun.

Contributions 1–136 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

No apologies have been received.

Senator Andrews is substituting for Senator Joanne Collins at today's meeting.

I bring the witnesses' attention to privilege. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against either a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of Members participating online in the committee meeting where their participation is from within the parliamentary precincts. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precincts. Any attempt to do so will result in the Member having their online access removed.

There is a mouthful in it, but that clears us to get on with our agenda, which follows up on a meeting we had last week on pre-legislative scrutiny of the general scheme of the dog breeding establishments (amendment) Bill 2026. Our agenda today is to further that discussion. We will have two sessions. In the first session we will hear from Department of agriculture officials. We have Dr. James Choiseul; Dr. Mary McCarthy, principal officer; Mr. Dillon Hennessy, assistant principal officer; and Ms Mairead Cooney, assistant principal officer, animal welfare division. Tá fáilte romhaibh. Their submission has been circulated to members. If they take five minutes to go through it, we will move on to questions and answers with Members then.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I thank the Chairman for the opportunity to address the committee on the Bill. I am joined by my colleagues Dr. Mary McCarthy, principal officer; Mr. Dillon Hennessy, assistant principal; and Ms Mairead Cooney, assistant principal, all from the Department of agriculture's animal welfare division.

The Dog Breeding Establishments Act 2010 established the legislative framework for the registration and regulation of dog breeding establishments, DBEs, in Ireland. DBEs are defined under the 2010 Act as premises where six or more female breeding dogs are kept.

The Act is administered and enforced by local authorities, while the Department holds policy and legislative responsibility following the transfer of these functions from the Department of Rural and Community Development and the Gaeltacht from the second half of 2025. The general scheme proposes to amend the 2010 Act to raise welfare standards in establishments, expand the range of offences under the Act and improve the tools available where breaches are identified.

The Department has consulted extensively in developing this Bill, including the work of the high-level dog control stakeholder group, public submissions to the non-statutory public consultation on the Department's upcoming annual welfare strategy, this committee's own report on issues impacting dog welfare in Ireland from 2022, and comparable legislation in other jurisdictions, including other EU member states, England, Wales, and Australia.

The general scheme comprises 17 detailed heads and amends the 2010 Act across three key areas, namely, welfare and breeding, sales and record-keeping, and administration and enforcement. On welfare and breeding, the Bill will place enhanced duties on operators covering the socialisation and habituation of dogs, so that breeding females and pups receive adequate exercise and social interaction. It will introduce a four-litter lifetime limit, extendable to six only with veterinary certification, and a one-litter-per-year cap, giving breeding females rest and recovery time between litters. The Bill will also introduce new minimum and maximum breeding age limits and oppose a ban on inbreeding. A mandatory minimum staffing ratio of one full-time equivalent staff member per twenty breeding females will also be placed on a statutory footing, ensuring animals receive proper daily care and attention, with a two-year transition period. This ratio will only apply to commercial dog breeding establishments.

On sales, the Bill will ban third-party sales from dog breeding establishments. It will be unlawful for operators to sell dogs under eight weeks of age or to sell them from any premises other than where they were born and reared. Prior to any sale, the prospective buyer must show the pup's biological mother on site. DBEs will also be required to notify local authorities of all sales of pups from their premises or risk criminal prosecution.

On administration and enforcement, authorised persons will be granted new powers to seize and detain dogs, whether at a registered or unregistered establishment. Penalties for the most serious offences will be increased to €250,000 and-or five years imprisonment, bringing sanctions into line with those under the Animal Health and Welfare Act 2013. It will also be mandatory for each new dog breeding establishment applying to be entered onto a local authority register to receive an inspection prior to its application being approved, and the Bill places the existing practice of publishing the national centralised register annually on a statutory footing.

A new data-sharing provision will also be established on a legislative basis. The Bill will immediately and directly improve animal welfare standards in dog breeding establishments. Breeding females will be protected from intensive overbreeding and from being bred outside permitted age ranges. All dogs housed at these establishments will benefit from a ban on inbreeding and improved welfare standards generally, with pups in particular benefiting from a ban on third-party sales. The new provisions on the seizure and detention of dogs, as well as recovery of costs of housing and caring for these animals, will fill a gap in the current enforcement framework.

Comment on this

It will just fill a gap.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

The proposed increase in fines and custodial sentences will provide an appropriate deterrent for the most serious offences.

The Department is aware that some stakeholders have called for a hard cap on the number of dogs permitted at a single establishment. Legally, an absolute or hard cap will be difficult to justify, and instead, the Bill relies on a package of more targeted measures, including the staffing ratio, improvement and closure notices and so on.

I hope I have given the committee a useful overview of the general scheme. My colleagues and I will be pleased to answer any questions the committee may have.

Comment on this

I apologise for speaking up earlier on. How many of the witnesses have visited commercial DBEs that have over 30 breeding females? Have they all visited those?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Answering on behalf of the group, I do not think any of us have visited such an establishment. It is important to bear in mind that there are biosecurity concerns with visiting such a place. Additionally, the Department itself has vast experience and expertise when it comes to dog breeding establishments, especially on the veterinary side, and that is the expertise we rely on.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Choiseul. I am just conscious of time.

In relation to microchipping and statistics for dogs, two sections in the Department have provided me with different figures. The Department stated that in 2024, 90,764 dogs were newly microchipped. The same Department, maybe a different section, also stated that the local dog statistics report stated that 1,539 dogs were born in all commercial DBEs in Ireland. That is data from the same Department. How can it be so different? How can the huge disparity between the two figures be accounted for?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I will answer first and then if any of my colleagues have any clarifications, they can come in. Yes, there are two figures. We acknowledge that the statistics we have available to us on dogs are generally quite inadequate and inaccurate in some cases, let us say. The Senator mentioned two figures. The numbers relating to dog breeding establishments is the information provided to us by the local authorities on the total number of dogs reported for sale. As part of this Bill, it is our intention to make it obligatory for all DBEs to report on the total number of sales, as that is clearly not being done at the moment.

Comment on this

However, it should be done.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Yes, and it has been made an offence not to do so.

The total number of microchips used every year applies to all pups that are microchipped, not just the ones that are produced in dog breeding establishments, so it is a much larger number.

Comment on this

All right. I thank Dr Choiseul and apologise for rushing him. Does the Department think it is appropriate to license large commercial breeders to produce puppies primarily for export markets such as Singapore? How many puppies are exported from commercial dog breeding establishments or puppy farms to Singapore each year? Why is the Department allowing puppies to be exported to Singapore? Who oversees the welfare of the puppies that are being exported to Singapore? The number of puppies being exported to Singapore is significant. Does the Department have any oversight on that?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Off the top of my head, the number of dogs exported to Singapore specifically is somewhere in the region of 300 per annum, but I would need to clarify that point.

Comment on this

Yes, I know I am putting Dr. Choiseul on the spot, but I ask him to please come back to us with those figures.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

For exporting dogs, there is process involved where a vet will authorise dogs for export. On average, about 8,000 dogs are exported commercially every year.

Comment on this

Not to Singapore.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

No, not just to Singapore. That is the total figure. Commercial exports would apply when more than five dogs are exported at once. It does not account for dogs that would go with individual owners, for example.

Comment on this

With all due respect, it does not seem like the Department has much of a handle on microchipping and the figures and data that should be there to ensure proper welfare standards. It is important to be clear about that.

Does the Department have any traceability system in place for retired breeding dogs? Are breeders at liberty to dispose of their retired breeding stock as they see fit, whether that is by selling them off neutered or euthanasia? The Department has not published the local authority dogs statistics report for 2025, even though it said it would be out in March. Those figures are needed for a dog welfare Bill and the report is nearly a year late. Can we have an update on when that report will be coming out?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

That very useful booklet is published annually and normally around November. That has been the case for the past number of years.

Comment on this

Is it not a year late?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

No. The 2025 figures will be published in November 2026. Regarding what happens to dogs once they have reached retirement age, every dog breeding establishment must have a procedure around how these dogs are treated. There are guidelines from 2019, as members will be aware. This Bill proposes to put those guidelines on a legislative footing, so the Minister can make regulations around them.

Comment on this

Can I ask a very brief follow-on question?

Comment on this

Yes, very quickly.

Comment on this

Is the Department aware that under the current legislation there is no requirement for commercial breeding establishments to provide a vaccine card to a buyer or to vaccinate a puppy to a particular standard prior to sale? Does it there should be a legal minimum standard of parasite control and vaccination? What steps would the Department take if it was discovered that a licensed dog breeding establishment was vaccinating its own puppies? Would that licence be immediately revoked? I ask that because I know that in Cork one large puppy farm is vaccinating its own dogs. I can provide evidence for that. Would that licence be revoked?

Comment on this

That is a lot of questions to be answered in a short time.

Comment on this

That was a very long short question.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Should I answer?

Comment on this

Is it a quick answer?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

We should probably provide a written answer to that because I am not sure that we have the expertise here. As part of the 2019 guidelines, it is necessary for the dog breeding establishment to have a very comprehensive list of data around individual dogs including the sex, when it was born, if it has whelped, and any veterinary treatments the dog has received.

Comment on this

I have only one area I would like to hear an opinion on. The witnesses have dealt with the public consultation and drafted the Bill. The Bill is their baby, as such, yet when it goes through the Houses and is adopted, it will be administered and enforced by the local authorities. In my experience here, I have found that anywhere there are cross-departmental issues, there are cracks, and stuff falls into cracks and gets lost. Given there are 31 local authorities, there are going to be staffing issues. There are a lot of local authorities that do not replace their dog wardens when they leave. There are some local authorities that have dog wardens and some that do not. There are local authorities with pounds and there are local authorities that do not. There are different attitudes that should be the same but are different. Did the witnesses think, with the good work they envisage they are doing, this might have been the time to grab the nettle and bring the whole lot under the Department's inspectors or vets or even create a new body of dog inspectors within the Department? It is a great body of work for which it is ultimately responsible, but it is handing the policing of it to somebody else. Now is the time, when it is in its infancy, to right that wrong, because it is a wrong. There are cracks and when there is more than one Department stuff will fall between the cracks.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I thank the Senator for that question. As he will know, the Department took over policy responsibility for dogs and dog control in August of last year. That was on the basis of a programme for Government commitment that we would do so. That is the basis of how the Department is now responsible for dogs and for dog breeding establishments.

Comment on this

It is only responsible for the policy.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

It is responsible for the legislative aspects of it. In terms of the operational aspect of it, the Department has established service level agreements with all of the local authorities with the exception of one, which sets out how this arrangement should work. We have also put in place for the first time a consolidated inspection form for dog breeding establishments, which runs to about 30 pages. It is very comprehensive.

Comment on this

Who follows up on that with the breeders? Dr. Choiseul said the Department had put this form together. Who goes in and checks?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

That will be done both by veterinary inspectors of the Department, who are working on behalf of the local authorities as authorised officers, and by the dog warden service.

Comment on this

Can Dr. Choiseul see why I have concerns it will not be the same in all 31 local authorities, and therefore, there will not be consistency?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

The objective of the exercise is to bring consistency across the inspection process, looking at things such as how the inspections are done and reaching a consensus approach on how to do that. Consistent inspections across the 31 local authority areas is an important step in that. There is a training aspect, which reinforces that. This year the Department has inspected 178 dog breeding establishments and, given there are 240 DBEs of all categories in Ireland, that figure indicates that considerable effort is being put into this inspection programme.

Comment on this

I take all that on board. It is just something I have an issue with. I am a farmer. If I have basic income for sustainability, BISS, scheme issues, Department officials comes out to inspect me. It is the Department that is the paymaster and it is the Department that decides the terms and conditions of that scheme. There is continuity. The Department has its service level agreements with the 31 local authorities, just as there is one planning law in the country at the moment. However, if we talk to any person involved in planning, they will say there is no comparison between applying in Westmeath and in Offaly, albeit that it should be the same. I have genuine fears by virtue of the fact it is being segmented 31 separate ways across 31 separate entities that are, indeed, laws unto themselves. They are stand-alone councils. This would be the ideal time for the Department to take full ownership of this, not just on the policy and legislative side, but the inspections as well. It is not as if the Department does not have inspectors or vets.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

All I can do is reiterate that it is a Government decision. We have taken a very proactive approach to delivering on it by looking at the inspections and seeing how they can be made more uniform across the country.

Comment on this

Senator Andrews asked whether the Department had checked out dog breeding establishments with over 30 breeding females.

On that question, Dr. Choiseul said there were biosecurity issues. What did he mean by that? Were those issues about going onto somebody else's establishment?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

If someone has a role in inspecting dog breeding establishments, he or she needs to be cognisant of the fact that he or she is going onto someone's business premises and needs to make sure that disease is not being introduced.

Comment on this

We are farming back home. An inspector can come onto our farm at any time. The Department should be aware of all that anyway. It is not like some Joe Soap coming off the street and walking onto a farm, so I do not think biosecurity should be an issue.

Can I ask about inbreeding, which Dr. Choiseul talked about? How can that possibly be monitored when we do not even have DNA samples? How many dogs have DNA samples? For how many animals can we prove who the dam or sire is? We are miles away from that. We are years away from it. We know how long it took to get there with cattle. Even with horses, we are not up to scratch yet. The thoroughbred industry is pretty good, but not so much on the show jumping side of it or half-bred horses. We are actually years away from a lot of the things that are in this Bill.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

On inbreeding, I agree that DNA technologies are fantastic and we are finding new applications for them every day. The example of cattle is one of the successes. It is also something which has been mooted for horses generally, not just for thoroughbreds, and that is part of the Wall report, which the deputy may be aware of.

On dogs, it is not envisaged at this juncture that DNA will be a measure by which it will be decided whether a dog is inbred. The reason is that there may be easier ways of doing it. As I mentioned previously, if a dog is held in a dog-breeding establishment, details about the dog need to be known, including the microchip number. An examination of the documentation around that should give sufficient evidence to establish whether the sire and the female are closely related.

Comment on this

I still believe that, although Dr. Choiseul is saying inspectors do not step onto premises for biosecurity reasons, we need to get to a stage where inspectors can walk into any establishment at any time of the day they choose. Without spot checks, we will never get on top of wrongdoing.

I will continue because I am going to run out of time. Consider the part that states an animal must not be sold from the premises where it was born before it is eight weeks old. We had representatives of one of the charities in last week. It moves dogs onto another premises to handle them and so they can learn to become dogs for the blind or for people with autism. Dr. Choiseul said there are exemptions for hunt clubs, boarding kennels and so on. Would that include charities? Would they be allowed to move a dog off a farm before it was eight weeks old, or would something have to be written into the legislation to allow them to do that?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

We are aware of this concern in respect of dogs for the blind and so on. From our interpretation of the Bill, we believe there should not be an issue. First, it does not involve a transfer of ownership. The dog is being moved to another location for habituation and training purposes, but ownership remains the same. There is an exclusion for charities in the Bill but, as the issue has been raised, it would be remiss of us not to examine the legislation again. The point may seem obvious to us, but if it is not clear in the legislation it needs to be clarified.

Comment on this

It would be a good idea to visit some of the charities to see what exactly is happening on the ground. We do not want to hamper the work they are doing and the joy they bring. They provide a lifeline for people, so we have to consider that.

This has been within the Department's remit for the past year. It seemed quite obvious that it should be under the remit of the Department. We have rules that are not being implemented. We know of people reporting issues and cruelty to animals. Somebody might come out to look at those animals, but then the owners go through the court system and are told they cannot have animals or whatever it is. Then they may appeal and are allowed to have animals again, and in a lot of situations they continue to mistreat animals over and over again. I know of such cases. The laws are just not protecting these animals. We have laws in place and we should implement them. If people do wrong, their licence should be taken off them. They should not be allowed to have animals, no matter what kind.

Apart from producing this legislation, what has the Department done in the past year in which it has had responsibility for DBEs? There are cases going through the courts and, as we were told last week, people just come back out again. People are getting fed up complaining and ringing up to report people only for their complaints to fall on deaf ears for years at the end of the day.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

If someone is prosecuted and appeals, and is successful in that appeal, that is the legal process.

Comment on this

Some of those people have gone to jail for this and still have animals.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Sure. Anyway, as I have said, it is the rule of law. The existing DBE legislation sets out that if someone has violated the rules around animal welfare or the provisions of the Dog Breeding Establishments Act, that person can be excluded from having a dog breeding establishment in the future. The draft Bill is increasing not only the penalties but also the number of possible infringements. It is tightening things up, including in respect of notifying that a sale has taken place. If it is passed, it will be a stricter Act than the current one.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statements and contributions. I wish to raise just a couple of points. The first concerns getting the dogs in, getting the registration done and doing all that is required with the vet, including vaccination. I am aware of what is required from the past. We had wolfhounds that had pups and we brought them in, got them vaccinated and did all the work. The issue for me would be more about people who have huge numbers of dogs. I am aware of getting up every couple of hours to deal with dogs. They have to be fed, the pups have to suckle and they have to be looked after, especially for the first couple of weeks. It is difficult and it is hard work. I am conscious that, in some cases, the necessary care and the attention to detail are not show by some people. They are simply in the business to make the maximum profit from it. That is the issue most people have.

At the end of his statement, Dr. Choiseul said there is pressure to put a cap on the number of bitches that can be in any establishment. He said it would be difficult to do so.

I would like to tease that out a little. Why does he feel there would be huge difficulty in that? For what reasons would that be a problem? Having certain numbers of personnel in place and having a ratio is well and good, but nobody can check that all the time. That is the problem people see through that particular issue.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I will take the Deputy's last point first. He will know from reading the Bill that we are proposing a staffing ratio of 1:20.

Comment on this

Is that 1:20 pups or bitches?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

It is 1:20 bitches. This will be obligatory. Currently, there is a ratio of 1:25 but it is optional. This will have benefits for the welfare of the animals. There is then the whole issue of putting a limit on the number of dogs in a dog breeding establishment. It is an emotive issue. It might appear to people that if the number of dogs present in a dog breeding establishment is reduced that will automatically improve the welfare of the dogs, but that is not necessarily the case. Even in normal life, individual dogs are mistreated. As long as the structures are in place, the facilities available and the staff present, and the staff have the expertise and know what they are doing, it is very difficult to argue that we need a cap. It would be seen as being an arbitrary decision to make.

Comment on this

At the moment, to become a dog breeding establishment, there have to be more than six bitches. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Yes.

Comment on this

If it is less than that, it does not fall under the legislation.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

That is true, but there is-----

Comment on this

I imagine that most of the people who will be breeding pedigree dogs would have fewer than six bitches. They might have one or two at most, in many cases. In fairness, the vast majority do a very good job, are very conscious, and love their dogs and what they do and all of that. The larger numbers is where people see the biggest danger. They bring the pups in for them to get microchipped. There is then a registration. How many microchip agencies are there? How many different groups are providing microchips?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

There are four.

Comment on this

Are they linked?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

No, they are not. That is one of the issues. It means that-----

Comment on this

Is that being dealt with?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Yes. Earlier on in the year, some of my colleagues were here talking about the microchipping of dogs legislation.

Comment on this

Will that resolve the issue of being unsure of the numbers? There is an issue there where you are not sure whether-----

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

As it currently stands, if you have a chip number, you can go to the four individual databases and check against those but that is-----

Comment on this

That is an arduous process.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

It is arduous and laboursome. This new database will allow a person to go into one place and check.

Comment on this

Can a person also check if they have been properly vaccinated and all of that?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

No, I do not believe-----

Comment on this

For instance, if the dogs are for export and they are leaving the country, they have to be vaccinated for rabies and they have to be over 12 weeks old to get the vaccination. I think they have be 15 weeks old. What would give people reassurance is if clear and concise records are kept and those records are accessible. That is what we need to see happen. Will we have that between this and the other legislation?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

My colleagues in the animal transport area of the Department who are looking at this area are currently exploring it. They are looking at the technical aspects about bringing these four databases together. They are giving consideration to connecting the chip number with the licensing, which is also an issue. If a person buys a dog licence online, for example, they have an option to put in the chip number, but it is not obligatory. It depends on those discussions and how practical it is. Options are being considered at the moment.

Comment on this

I am sorry I missed the presentation. Regarding the database, how many inspections does the Department carry out on dog breeding establishments on a yearly basis?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

This year to date, we have conducted about 171 inspections of the 234 dog breeding establishments. That would not include inspections undertaken by the dog warden service.

Comment on this

That does not include the local councils. Does the Department notify the breeding establishments that it is coming?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

No. Of the 171 inspections completed this year, 43 of those were unannounced inspections.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

A total of 171 inspections of dog breeding establishments have been completed so far in 2026. About a quarter of them, 43, were unannounced.

Comment on this

What were the main concerns found by the Department on inspection? Could Dr. Choiseul give us five of the top concerns?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I do not have those details with me, unfortunately. I can tell the Senator that there were 22 improvement recommendations. We clearly found something in 22 of those locations. Five of those dog breeding establishments were issued with a closure order.

Comment on this

Were there reinspections?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

There would be if they found something which necessitated a return visit. That is the normal procedure.

Comment on this

Regarding the vaccination programme and the vaccination of dogs, does Dr. Choiseul think it is appropriate that there be a database on the four chips in this country? People can order chips in from China for their dog and chip the dog themselves. Regarding the database in the Department, there is no joined-up thinking. When I bring a dog to the vet, the vet will scan it and vaccinate it, but there is no one who will send me to register that dog to me if I am a breeder. When the pup is born, it should be registered to the breeding establishment straight away. The onus should be on the breeding establishment to register to the new owner the day the pup is sold or transported or anything else. The same as we have with cattle, there would then be a proper database. Does Dr. Choiseul agree that this is the way the system should work?

Do not get me wrong - there are breeding establishments out there that are doing this very well and have a proper business out of it. They are second to none and can stand up in society. I was in Ballinasloe last weekend. The number of pups that are traded out of the back of vans and cars at the horse fair in Ballinasloe was shocking. To call a spade a spade, it is shocking. That is where we need to step up to the plate here and stop illegal trading of pups out of illegal establishments. That is something the Department needs to look at. We need to look at it as a society. There is no onus on people who are buying them to register them. Then we see the lovely pet reared at home and all of a sudden the kids get fed up of him and he is thrown out on the side of the road or goes into a kennel. This is the reality that happens. We have seen that. During Covid, there was an increase in the number of pets that were bought. When Covid was over, we saw an increase in numbers in our kennels and dog pounds. The people who are doing it right are doing it on a scale. I am not targeting those people here, but we need to target the people who are doing this illegally. Does this Bill actually give the power to local authorities to go in where they know there are illegal breeding establishments?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I should have said it already but I did not get a chance.

I commend Senator Brady and Deputy Kenny, because there are many dog breeders who are doing a really good job.

Comment on this

Yes, I am not getting at them.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I do not think anyone here is castigating them or all dog breeding establishments because of the actions of a small minority-----

Comment on this

I am not blaming them at all.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I think it is important-----

Comment on this

I suggest it is not a small minority, but that is for another day.

Comment on this

I would suggest it is a small minority but it is the legal aspect. How do we stop this with the legal aspect of it?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

The point was made about dogs being bought in a car park, or something like this. These points are covered in the dog breeding establishments Bill. Number one, pups under the age of eight weeks need to be shown with their mother to a prospective buyer. Second, no dogs can be sold other than from the place where they were born and bred.

Comment on this

How do we stop this? It is going to continue. With the legislation, how do we actually we stop this? Who has the power at a horse fair or wherever these are traded? Is the power with the Garda, the local warden or the local council? Who has the power to seize this pup, see if it is microchipped and prosecute the people who are at this?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

In terms of dog breeding the local authorities are the entity that have operational responsibility for the Act. It would be dog wardens, or veterinary or authorised officers working on behalf of the local authority.

Comment on this

Has a dog warden the power to stop a person walking a dog to see if it is microchipped?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Yes, I think there is-----

Comment on this
Dr. Mary McCarthy

On the street. That is my understanding.

Comment on this

Is that in legislation?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I will pass on to my colleague.

Comment on this
Dr. Mary McCarthy

Dog wardens do have powers outside when dogs are outside on public roads. They would have powers.

Comment on this

How many dog wardens would carry a scanner with them?

Comment on this
Dr. Mary McCarthy

I am not aware of those figures.

Comment on this
Dr. Mary McCarthy

They would though.

Comment on this

They would not have it with them.

Comment on this
Dr. Mary McCarthy

Under the Control of Dogs Act-----

Comment on this

I have one or two very quick questions on this. The first relates to the 20 litters that are proposed in the Bill and that there would be one person to look after 20 litters of pups at the one time. Given that a dog could have three or four pups and another dog could have ten to 15 pups, is 20 litters a realistic figure? What is it based on? Would a figure of one person per number of puppies make more sense? Where does the number of 20 come from? What is the basis for it?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

As part of this we looked at other jurisdictions and what they do so. In the case of Wales across the Irish Sea, and New South Wales in Australia, they both have staff ratios of 1:20. That was the basis of it. It is also about recognising that these are commercial entities and people's right to make a living has to be balanced with the welfare aspect. Hence the 20-----

Comment on this

What I am getting at is if there is a 1:20 ratio, and there are 20 dogs with litters of four or five puppies, and I have 20 litters with ten to 15 puppies, then I have a bigger load to mind. I have more dogs to handle and to mind compared to the other person who has 20 dogs with litters of four puppies each. It does not stack up it and it does not tally with the workload or the animal welfare concern, I would imagine. Should it be based on the number of puppies that a person is responsible for rather than the number of litters?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

It would probably be difficult to identify the number of pups they might have at any particular time. Basing it on the number of females is because the female is the basic unit within a dog breeding establishment. I guess that would be the case. The existing threshold or ratio is 1:25, so we are proposing that this be lowered to 1:20. This would be in keeping with international standards, or where standards exist, let us say, it complies with those.

Comment on this

I want to follow on from Seanadóir Andrews's question. Dr. Choiseul said 8,000 are exported. Does that include the occupied Six Counties or just the Twenty-six Counties?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

That would be commercial exports supervised by the Department of agriculture.

Comment on this

In the Twenty-six Counties.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Yes.

Comment on this

Does the Department know how many are exported from the island of Ireland by any chance?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

No. I would not have that figure.

Comment on this

Does the Department know how many are exported versus sold on the internal market each year?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Exported versus sold on the internal market-----

Comment on this

Does Dr. Choiseul have those figures?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

As I may have said already, our statistics and figures around dogs and dog breeding establishments are not great. It is something we would be hoping to address. A rough estimate can be done. We know the number of dog breeding establishments that fall into each of the categories of less than 16 females, 16 to 30, and so on. A calculation can be made on that basis.

Comment on this

I will move on if we do not have the facts. What was the scientific rationale behind the new minimum breeding age? Certain breeds need time for skeletal development, which would then show any congenital issues that could be present. Sometimes, up to a two-year period can be needed before these congenital issues appear. Why would we consider breeding before then, for the welfare of both mums and pups?

Comment on this
Mr. Dillon Hennessy

I thank the Deputy for the question. The 12-month age limit is in line with the current approach in jurisdictions in Northern Ireland and England. It is also informed by the Irish Kennel Club guidelines and the UK kennel club guidelines, but it should be stressed that the 12-month limit is an absolute floor in all cases. Exactly as the Deputy said, different dogs of different breeds have different ages at which they reach physical, sexual and skeletal maturity. Primary legislation like this is the appropriate place to set absolute ceilings and absolute floors but it does leave scope. The Bill grants the Minister an extensive regulatory-making power at head 10. There is scope then to introduce specific and more tailored breeding age limits. It also allows for flexibility for those to be adjusted as scientific or veterinary knowledge evolves. It will also allow us to align with the EU regulation on cats and dogs and their welfare, which will be setting its own minimum breeding age limits.

Comment on this

Is the Department confident they will adhere to this? How does the Department monitor to make sure that they are? Is it just with inspections?

Comment on this
Mr. Dillon Hennessy

Yes. That would be a matter for record-keeping and inspections of the establishments.

Comment on this

On the suggestion of a maximum age of eight years old, I want to know the rationale behind increasing that with veterinary approval. Where is the welfare protection here? Surely we should be looking at reducing the maximum age, not increasing it, if we want to ensure that the mums are not spending more than half of their lives in dog breeding establishments. I just do not understand that.

Comment on this
Mr. Dillon Hennessy

That eight-year limit, with veterinary approval, for any breeding outside of that age range is drawn from multiple other jurisdictions.

I believe the approach of the Irish Kennel Club and the UK kennel club is that this is fairly well established as a maximum limit. I believe it is also the maximum age limit for breeding under the EU regulation.

Comment on this

We copied what they are doing and this is the rationale behind it. What is the maximum we can have?

Comment on this
Mr. Dillon Hennessy

It is evidence based and well established and it also has built-in proportionality in that any further breeding would have to be certified and approved by a vet on a case-by-case basis, looking at the individual dog involved.

Comment on this

It does not seem to have the animal's best welfare in mind, in my opinion. There should be a minimum recuperation period for mums between pregnancies and especially after C-sections. At a minimum, this should be in line with the EU regulations. It would break up the breeding cycle and improve the welfare of the mum. Did the Department give any consideration to this when drafting the general scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Dillon Hennessy

Yes, absolutely, that was one of the considerations we looked at. The limit of one litter per year is potentially more protective than the approach in the EU regulations that Deputy Ní Raghallaigh outlined. Certainly, allowing for sufficient recuperation between breeding intervals was a consideration and that is why we have gone with the approach we have, which goes further than approaches in other jurisdictions.

Comment on this

Go raibh maith agat. I have one quick question about the lifetime limit of four litters, which can be increased to six on veterinary approval. What is the science-based rationale behind this? Did we just go with the regulation? Surely the welfare of the mum should be a hard cap. It would allow the bitch to adapt to life outside of a dog breeding establishment and be rehomed. Why should she be kept in a breeding facility for more than half of her life?

Comment on this
Mr. Dillon Hennessy

To answer the question on the four-litter limit, again, this is from recommendations from stakeholders, including some of the stakeholders who were before the committee last week. Again, it is an evidence-based figure. To refer back to proportionality again, the provision for the number to be increased to six would only be with veterinary certification, which would involve an inspection on the dog to allow for case-by-case flexibility.

Comment on this

I would be very sceptical about veterinary approval as a lot of these large-scale dog breeding establishments have their own vets and they travel across the State. I do not know whether this is enough protection. Has the Department thought about this? Has any consideration been given to, let us call them, cowboy vets? The witnesses know the ones who travel around the State from here to there, signing off on things. There just does not seem to be enough of a safeguard, in my opinion. I am not naming anyone, sorry; it is just stories.

Comment on this

Deputy Ní Raghallaigh cannot make a statement like that. That is far too loose.

Comment on this

Is Senator Brady saying there are none of them?

Comment on this

That is loose.

Comment on this

I am not naming anyone.

Comment on this

Let us keep the focus on the witnesses.

Comment on this

This is happening and I am curious whether we can safeguard or prevent it from happening.

Comment on this