We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

General Scheme of the Dog Breeding Establishments (Amendment) Bill 2026: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

The Department outlined proposed amendments to raise welfare standards, including limits on litters and breeding age, a 1:20 staffing ratio, restrictions on puppy sales, mandatory inspections and stronger penalties. It opposed a hard cap on breeding females, arguing targeted welfare and enforcement measures were preferable, while acknowledging significant gaps in dog-related data and the need for better traceability. Members questioned enforcement consistency, breeder inspections, export and vaccination records, and whether the proposed limits adequately protect dogs. Dog Law Ireland called for a cap, a stricter staffing ratio and an independent regulator; the next stakeholder session had just begun.

Contributions 137–264 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Dr. James Choiseul

The work of vets and how they perform is supervised by the Veterinary Council and if people identify some malpractice, it can be referred to the Veterinary Council and there is a process whereby it can be interrogated and it is judged.

Comment on this

I appreciate that answer.

Comment on this

I might not be able to stay for the answer because I have a feeling there is going to be a vote in the Seanad soon. I apologise and I will follow up if I am not in the room. We have heard the term "proportionality" and we have talked a little bit about weighing the balance between making a living and balancing animal welfare issues. It is obviously difficult to hear about where this line is drawn because it can be arbitrary. We have animals that are used as livestock but we are talking about companion animals. Making a living and outweighing that proportionality is awkward. It is not a nice term to use and a lot of people listening in will find it quite unacceptable.

The witnesses have said that having a cap would be arbitrary and they also mentioned looking to other jurisdictions, including Wales and New South Wales, when it comes to the number of dogs being kept by a breeder. With regard to the arbitrary cap, Northern Ireland is introducing a cap of 25. Do the witnesses see issues with this? One breeder in Fermanagh has 800 dogs. This breeder could easily come down here with the dogs. How do the witnesses see enforcement when we have a one-island approach with no border? How do they think this is going to work in terms of dogs in bad breeding establishments in the North being sold if we do not also include a cap?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I know what Senator Stephenson is referring to is a report by a group that was convened by the Minister for agriculture, which made a range of recommendations, including a cap. I do not believe this has approached a legislative phase at this stage. It is still a recommendation in a report.

Comment on this

My understanding is that it is highly likely that it is going to come into place. This cap is very much expected. It might not be 100% confirmed but everyone in the sector expects it to be there.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Again, I-----

Comment on this

It might be speculative but let us say it does happen. We would then have legislation that is weaker than that of our peers in the North of the island, which would be incredibly problematic, given that we know the puppy sale trade is so fluid across our open Border.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

It is very difficult to justify putting a cap on a dog breeding establishment with a good ratio of staff to dogs which is inspected and where the facilities are good.

Comment on this

I take Dr. Choiseul's point but there is a challenge when we talk about behaviour. We have had lots of groups in, and I am sure Dr. Choiseul watched some of the session last week. When we talk about behaviour there is the stress of being bred in an environment where there are multiple puppy litters. The stress these breeding environments put on the dog has a direct impact on its behaviour, including its behaviour when it is purchased and brought into a family home. We see many behavioural issues that have a direct impact on rescues. That is the lifespan we see from these breeding establishments. It is the outcome when there is no cap because there are cramped conditions.

Even if the conditions are good by legislative standards, I do not know how there could be more than 25 breeding dogs, breeding regularly throughout the year, and we expect it not to be a high-stress environment for a puppy. There would be no silence. There would be puppies at different stages of their development throughout the life cycle. There are smells, noise and all of these different things. Last week, we heard about these having a problematic impact on the welfare of the dogs in their future lives. This then has an impact on rescues.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

There are guidelines on what should be the standard for dog breeding establishments for the accommodation for the dog. There is a minimum amount of space assigned to each dog. There is a requirement for noise to be managed, in terms of internal noise in the-----

Comment on this

I appreciate that, and I take Dr. Choiseul's point that those exist, but if we do not have a cap on the number of breeding dogs, it would be incredibly difficult to manage noise. I do not think it is achievable, even with loads of staff. Presumably, if there are loads of breeding dogs, there are loads of staff. Staff are coming in their cars, I hope. They are travelling, getting in and handing over. That also means multiple people are handling the dogs. All of that will have a downward-spiral impact on how the dogs behaviour develops and their behavioural norms. That is our concern, namely, that the way these dogs are bred is having a direct impact on their ability to integrate into households. It is causing a crisis in the number of dogs being dumped on the roads, being put up for adoption and ending up in publicly funded rescue centres or charity rescue centres. I am worried that without a cap, the legislation will not deal with this granular issue.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

As I have said, there are guidelines. As my colleague Mr. Hennessy mentioned, under head 10, the Minister can make regulations on these issues. What Senator Stephenson is talking about is quite specific. We can imagine that over time, with changes in understanding of dog psychology, we may wish to make adjustments. If an inspector goes to a dog breeding establishment and sees the dogs are not being socialised properly, the proposed Bill has the facility for an inspector to instruct, for example, that the number of dogs present in the facility be reduced.

Comment on this

I have one comment to make.

We have been treating dogs being bred as companion animals and pets as if they were other types of animals such as livestock and animals that we use for produce in the economy, and I do not want us to continue to do so. If we do not move on from this frame of mind, and breeders have this frame of mind because they sell the dogs and it is their economic livelihood, the danger is that we have this product which goes into family homes with a lot of negative consequences because of viewing at birth the family pet as a product.

Comment on this

We will have a large number of witnesses coming in for the next session. Senator Brady wants to ask a quick question, as do others. I will only give these questions two minutes, which would be 30 seconds each for four questions.

Comment on this

If I have a family business, are my family members counted as staff even though they are not paid? I would hope not. If they are family and they are counted as staff, can they go on the books as unpaid? Furthermore, we have organisations such as Women's Sheds that like to take dogs in some establishments out for walks, for health issues or for one reason or another. Do they count as staff? They are exercising dogs on the premises.

Comment on this

They are volunteers.

Comment on this

They are volunteers. When the witnesses speak about one to 20 employees, does this include family members who are on the premises but who are not paid?

Comment on this

I will take 30 seconds from each of the members.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

No, unless they are actually an employee-----

Comment on this

One second.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Sorry.

Comment on this

Does Senator Andrews want to get in?

Comment on this

Will the witnesses determine the process of issuing pet sales licences? There was a recent article in the media about the family with Ireland's largest dog breeding establishment being issued with a pet sales licence by the Department of agriculture. Will the witnesses confirm that house visits are carried out for all applications? Are the inspection reports associated with it subject to freedom of information, as are inspection reports of dog breeding establishments?

Comment on this

I need to get the standing members in. I call Deputy Kenny.

Comment on this

The big issue I find is that we have so many dogs that are unregistered or are not from puppy farms and are outside all of this. Many of them come from pedigree breeders who have one or two bitches and breed pedigree dogs. There are others with this new thing of cockapoos and all sorts of mixed breeds. In my view this can be a dangerous route to go down because some of the mixed breeds can mean very unhealthy dogs. This seems to be outside of the legislation because there are fewer than six bitches. What is going to happen there? How will that be monitored? It is a difficult issue.

Comment on this

There are a lot of questions there and perhaps the witnesses can squeeze in responses.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

I can answer. Staff in dog breeding establishments have to be employed by the business. It is a drive towards professionalisation across the whole dog breeding establishment system.

Comment on this

Does that include family members?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Yes.

Comment on this

If my elderly father-----

Comment on this

Please, Senator.

Comment on this

-----is working on the farm-----

Comment on this

Let Dr. Choiseul answer.

Comment on this

-----is he classified-----

Comment on this

Senator Brady, we have to finish.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

In relation to inspections, yes, all dog breeding establishments are inspected.

Comment on this

Even those with fewer than six bitches?

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Yes, because there is different legislation in the sale of pets regulation.

Comment on this

Let us say, now that Dr. Chioseul has referenced this-----

Comment on this

Please give Dr. Choiseul a chance to answer.

Comment on this
Dr. James Choiseul

Those selling more than five pets or pups in a year are subject to that regulation, as opposed to the legislation on dog breeding establishments, which has a higher threshold.

Comment on this

Will Dr. Choiseul answer the question on inspection reports? Are inspection reports for pet sales available under freedom of information?

Comment on this

We need to conclude the session. We have used the time available and we have a large number of witnesses coming in for the next session.

Comment on this

Perhaps I could write to the-----

Comment on this

No. We have-----

Comment on this

Can I email and get a response?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this

We will now suspend the meeting.

Comment on this

I draw the witnesses' attention to the fact that witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence that they give to the committee. This means that a witness has full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue by the Chair. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity.

Witnesses who give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within those precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.

Our second session today is pre-legislative scrutiny of the dog-breeding establishments (amendment) Bill 2026. The committee will hear from witnesses from Dog Law Ireland, Ms Demi Mullen, Ms Hannah Unger and Ms Carrie McMeel; from the Irish Kennel Club, Ms Pat O'Boyle, president, and Ms Orlagh Murray; from the National Association of Regional Game Councils, Mr. Dan Curley, Mr. John Butler and Mr. John Flannery; and from the Hunting Association of Ireland, Ms Aileen Byrne. Cuirim fáilte rompu.

Their submissions have been received by the committee. I will give each organisation two minutes to summarise its submission and we will then move to questions and answers. I propose we use the same rota as earlier. Depending on time, we will see if we have the opportunity for a second round. We will start with Dog Law Ireland.

Comment on this
Ms Hannah Unger

I thank the Chair and members of the committee for inviting us today. I am here with my colleagues, Ms Demi Mullen and Ms Carrie McMeel. We are all solicitors and co-founders of Dog Law Ireland, a pro bono organisation established in August 2024. Our aims are to make dog law accessible, advocate for better laws and promote better enforcement of those laws. While none of us practices in this area day to day, we have spent countless pro bono hours over the past number of years dedicated to these aims.

Northern Ireland recently published a comprehensive review of dog breeding that proposes a number of measures which go further than, or do not appear in, the Republic of Ireland's heads of Bill. As noted by the NSPCA and Dogs Trust Ireland when they appeared before this committee, a co-ordinated all-island approach to dog welfare and breeding is needed.

We ask the committee to consider four issues. First, the legislation should impose a cap on the number of breeding females that a breeder can have. Without this, we are legitimising industrial large-scale breeding operations. Welfare cannot be meaningfully regulated at these scales, so legislation should begin the work of dismantling this model rather than entrenching it. We also call for a more stringent staffing ratio, as we do not believe one to 20 is sufficient to ensure welfare. As with all legislation, effective enforcement is key. We note that certain obligations contained in the heads of Bill do not appear to be accompanied by corresponding offences for non-compliance. While this may be addressed as the legislation progresses, we believe it is important to highlight the issue at this stage. Ultimately, the effectiveness of these reforms will depend not only on the standards set out in legislation, but also on the availability of robust enforcement powers and adequate resources to ensure compliance. Finally, we believe the Government should establish an independent regulator for dog breeding, dog welfare and dog control. The current system is fragmented, with responsibilities spread across multiple bodies. A dedicated regulator would provide greater accountability, consistency and oversight while helping Ireland meet its obligations under new EU rules on dog welfare and traceability. We are happy to answer questions.

Comment on this
Ms Pat O'Boyle

The purpose of the Irish Kennel Club, IKC, is to advance the health, breeding and sport of pure-bred dogs and promote responsible dog ownership. A voluntary and not-for-profit organisation founded in 1920, we promote the responsible ownership and breeding of dogs through registration, training, education and events. We currently have 25,407 members and in the last 12 months we registered 12,123 pedigree dogs. We have nine native dog breeds, some of which have official Irish heritage status and are acknowledged as a valuable part of Irish culture.

Persons registering or transferring dogs through the IKC agree to be bound by our rules and regulations and our code of ethics. Breeders registering puppies are already subject to significant requirements relating to breeding practices, registration, identification and welfare. Our code of ethics includes not knowingly breeding or selling a dog with health problems. Many of the principles contained within the proposed legislation have formed part of the IKC's regulatory framework for years. We were the first national kennel club in Europe to introduce health-based rules regarding breeding from dogs with potential brachycephalic problems.

We are in negotiations regarding a comprehensive DNA scheme which, aside from giving more robust dog identification and traceability, will link to our existing breed registry, and will codify specific breed health tests which responsible breeders already undertake to ensure the dogs they breed are healthy and fit for purpose within our society. We do not govern non-pedigree designer dogs like the cockapoo or labradoodle, which are unregulated and may not be health tested, etc.

We contend that the legislation before the committee should not create unintended consequences for responsible pedigree and preservation breeding. We ask that the protections in this legislation be scientifically informed, proportionate and capable of distinguishing responsible preservation breeding from irresponsible and intensive commercial dog production.

Comment on this
Mr. John Butler

I am vice chairman of the National Association of Regional Game Councils, NARGC. We thank the committee for giving us this opportunity to make our presentation. Our association, as most people will know by now, is made up of 25,000 members. We have over 1,000 clubs spread throughout Ireland. Almost all of our members are dog owners. The dogs our members own would be classified as working dogs. In pursuit of our chosen sport, those dogs are mainly used to find, flush and retrieve game in the field. Our dogs are maintained and trained to a very high standard. The code of ethics enshrined in our constitution and rules has policies on animal welfare.

All of our members adhere to that code of ethics and the animal welfare issues that we promote from within our association. While our association is not directly involved with dog breeding establishments, we do recognise that Irish people love their pets. What we would like to see is a recognition of working dogs as distinct from pet dogs because there is a very clear distinction there between the dogs you see people purchasing as pets to have in the home and dogs that are there for working purposes. For example, in my own case, I can assure committee members that when I go out to bring my springers out for a walk in the evening, they will reluctantly come along with me and we will head off for a walk. However, if I go in my hunting attire I can see they immediately recognise that we are going into the fields. The perception that dogs do not understand or recognise what they are doing or where they are going, everyone that has ever owned a working or a hunting dog will be able to explain quite the opposite to that.

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Byrne

I thank committee members for the invitation to appear before them today. I am Aileen Byrne, vice-chairman of the Hunting Association of Ireland and a HAI representative on the dog control stakeholder group. I am joined by John Flannery, a past chair of the HAI and also a representative on the group. We have both worked on dog breeding establishment legislation since before the 2010 Act, including through the DBE sub-group.

The HAI is the national representative body for hunting with hounds and supports high standards of welfare, inspection and enforcement. Our concern is that the legislation should continue to recognise an important distinction in purpose and operation. A DBE primarily engaged in breeding dogs for commercial use is very different in purpose and operation from a registered hunt club maintaining an established working pack on a non-commercial basis. Hunt kennels breed selectively to maintain a healthy, sound working pack with the appropriate temperament and characteristics. That distinction is already recognised in the 2010 Act and continues in the general scheme. A hunt kennel may contain a significant number of bitches, but they are working members of the pack and many will never be bred from. Breeding capacity is not breeding activity. A choice of suitable hounds allows for more selective breeding, not more intensive breeding. Hunt hounds live and work as a social pack, requiring practical knowledge of pack behaviour, welfare, exercise, husbandry and individual hound needs. We welcome the staffing exemption for hunt clubs and believe the distinct nature of a working pack should be reflected throughout the legislation. That distinction already exists in law, and we ask that it be applied consistently in this legislation. I also refer the committee to our key recommendations at the end of our briefing document. I thank the members, and we will look forward to their questions.

Comment on this

Before we move to questions and answers I draw the attention of the witnesses to the fact that there are votes under way in the Seanad and so members will be in and out during the session. We have a speaking rota that I propose following from the earlier session rota, but as Senators are not here we will skip on to the Deputies. We will take six minutes per speaker. I call Deputy Newsome Drennan first.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I will start with the dog law. I know there are laws that are in place that are not being implemented. I have said it before. I told some of the group who were here last week of a case of somebody ringing the authorities on bad behaviour they see carrying on. They said they had done everything. They had done the paperwork and got it to the law and then that law will fail them. Looking at the laws that we have, what can we do to get those implemented? What more can we do? It happens regularly that people get animals get taken off them for the right reasons. They go through the courts and are found to have done wrong and it is quite obvious to everybody but they continue to have animals. My own dogs are treated like part of the family. They are our next children. They are like brothers and sisters to my children. However, some dogs get treated with such disrespect. In the opinion of the witnesses, what can we do? What do we need? I do not think giving it to the local councils is enough. There has to be a body that is over them to be sure and to inspect their inspections. When the officials from the Department were here they spoke about biosecurity measures. It does not cut it that they cannot go in. The Department of agriculture has to be able to go in. It can come into my farm at home and inspect it any time it wants. I do not get that. It is there, it has a job to do and its officials should be allowed walk in and inspect animals day or night. What can we do better?

Comment on this
Ms Demi Mullen

I would totally echo that and also the concerns that Dogs Trust Ireland and the NSCPA raised in this regard last week. A lot of our issues come from the fragmentation of legislation in relation to dogs, not just within dog breeding. We see that now as we are looking at dog breeding establishments but may not be considering pet sellers or other dogs that are sold. There is also this fragmentation across dog breeding, dog control and the welfare of dogs. The Deputy is right. It is definitely something that we need to look at. We heard it last week. While the legislation and policy is sitting with the Department of agriculture we then have implementation and enforcement with the local authorities. However, even within that implementation and enforcement, while registration and enforcement is sitting with the local authorities the inspections piece of it is having to be seconded back to the Department of agriculture vets because the vets no longer sit with the local authorities. From our point of view, on top of that, with implementation and enforcement being at local authority level there can naturally be divergence in how dog breeding establishments are treated from local authority to local authority. For us, seeing enforcement being made as simple as possible and that fragmentation really being looked at and considered is something we would love to see. Ideally, we would like to see legislation policy, implementation and enforcement all falling to one key group. That is also something in the EU regulation that is going to become effective. It speaks about countries taking all measures necessary to ensure that rules are implemented. We will have that positive enforcement obligation, and it is really important we consider it. Ms Unger may want to touch on the independent regulator piece. That is really important too.

Comment on this
Ms Hannah Unger

Yes. Picking up on the point about overseeing the enforcement side of things, under the EU regulation that is coming into place the competent authority is going to have more responsibility in that area. Those additional tasks could either fall to the Department of agriculture or potentially we could be setting up an independent regulator. The thing is the additional tasks that will be coming down the line are maintaining a national register, operating interoperable microchip databases, inspecting dog breed establishments, running public awareness campaigns, co-operating with authorities across Europe and things like that. There is international precedent for it. There is a regulator in South Australia called the Dog and Cat Management Board and it has responsibility for things like education, policy development, data collection and overseeing enforcement. The gold standard would be to set up a regulator in this jurisdiction answerable to one Department similar to how the Medical Council, the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland and other regulators currently operate. It could look at things like co-ordinating national education campaigns on responsible dog ownership, facilitating a dog theory test prior to getting a licence, collecting data on dog attacks, sheep worrying and all of that. There is so much scope for everything there.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Unger. I just want to move on. Are the hunt groups aware of any checks that have gone on in farms or breeding establishments?

I contacted the Department to find out how many checks are done. Are the groups aware of any?

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

Yes. Any of our members who are registered under the Dog Breeding Establishments Act have inspections yearly with the local dog wardens and the local Department of agriculture vet. Previously, it was the Department of environment vet.

Comment on this

So it happens once a year.

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

It definitely happens once a year.

Comment on this

It is announced, I assume.

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

It can be announced or unannounced. It varies. The feedback we have been given by those inspectors is that they are checking people who have already registered and are meeting their requirements.

Comment on this

They are not the problem.

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

They are not, and the feedback from the inspectors I have spoken to is that they have been wasting their time. The legislation was set up to control unregistered dog breeding establishments, but all it ended up doing was that the people who registered were visited. The inspectors' time was tied up with that rather than with finding unregistered dog breeding premises.

Comment on this

What we should take from that is that laws should be put in place for people who are doing a bad job.

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

The Act was originally intended for commercial breeding. The word "commercial" got dropped at the last minute when the legislation was being drafted. Anybody, including ourselves, who has been working with it realises that this was a huge mistake because all that happened was that inspectors visited premises where they might be more than the number of bitches stipulated in law. However, some of these were not breeding any pups. In our association, it is against the rules to sell pups. The only time a hunt kennel breeds is to keep its numbers up.

Comment on this

The hunt kennels keep the pups, yes.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statements and contributions. Everyone is on the same page. We all want to see this done properly where it is appropriate and stopped where it is not appropriate.

I am aware of the great work the Irish Kennel Club does, especially with pedigree dogs, maintaining breeds and so on. The registration and the way the pedigree of animals going back through the years can been seen is vital and shows that, in the context of progeny, things are correct and taken care of properly. A small number of people abuse the system in a big way. The number of large-scale entities that are abusing it is probably small enough, but it is about going in there, sorting it out and dealing with it properly. There are also a lot of people who have small numbers of dogs. They do not care. They do not treat them or any animal they have around the place right. The problem is dealing with them. That is one of the issues I have. Often, people used to say that the law is only for the law-abiding. That is the problem here. The law-abiding will do the thing properly but those who do not will not, no matter what law we have. It is really about ensuring we have adequate enforcement. That is the major aspect of all this which was missing from the previous legislation. That legislation may not have been strong enough, but it was not enforced in any event. Enforcement is the big issue we have to deal with. I wonder about the role of the local authorities. Do the witnesses believe theirs is the appropriate body to carry out the level of inspections and enforcement required?

Comment on this
Mr. Dan Curley

It is a problem. There is no doubt that 28 different regions doing it - and we have the same problem in other elements of law we are involved with - means that, unfortunately, you get different interpretations. That is the way it is done and the way it is probably going to continue to be done, but there needs to be some kind of oversight body to ensure there is some consistency across the board on it. A suggestion we have is that the Minister might set up an independent committee that would involve all the groups and that would try to work that out and get consistency. With 26 different groups implementing it, you are going to have the problem to which I refer. It is one way of doing it. A central one might be better, but I am not sure the Department is going to go there. If it sticks with the local authorities, there needs to be some kind of committee that can issue directions or maybe administer small slaps on the hand or whatever is needed to get some consistency. That is our view. The Minister should probably have that committee anyway to have oversight and get all the representations from the working dog sector. Farmers obviously have working dogs as well. Then there are the pets plus the registered dogs in the kennel clubs.

Comment on this

So there needs to be a co-ordinated overview. One of the big issues with that is information. There are a number of different agencies or outfits that are doing microchipping. They do not talk to each other and we do not know who is who or what is what. There is a big issue in that regard. We do not have clear information, and what information there is is not correlated anywhere. There is also the area, which the witnesses from the kennel club mentioned, of designer dogs that are inbred. These dogs can look very well - although beauty is in the eye of the beholder - but the breeding can be dangerous and very unhealthy for the dog. In that context, do the witnesses feel that both this proposed Bill and the other legislation coming forward will deal with those issues or does more need to be done?

Comment on this
Ms Pat O'Boyle

We agree with Dog Law Ireland about a regulatory body specifically for dogs, under the Department. We also believe the regulations and enforcement should not be based on ideologies or philosophies but scientific premises. We are very strong on that.

Comment on this
Ms Orlagh Murray

With a lot of these mixed breeds, while the word is that they are healthier, they actually are not. Most pedigree breeders do extensive health testing on their breeding dogs and bitches before they ever try to get them to produce puppies. The Irish Kennel Club suggest we also look at health testing as part of the regulatory body. We need to be making sure. The DNA is out there now. DNA in regard to healthy dogs is available. There is health testing for hips, eyes and elbows. Different breeds have different specific problems but the science and the information is there and very available to anybody who wants to get it. If we can use that information as part of the regulatory initiative that would help, because, as a nation, we would then be producing healthier dogs.

Comment on this

Ms Murray mentioned DNA, and it is used in other sectors. A strand of hair is sent off to a central body which records the DNA of the animal. Is it going to be very expensive to set up that kind of regime within the whole dog community?

Comment on this
Ms Pat O'Boyle

We are in advanced negotiations with an international organisation that I have used to test the DNA of my dogs. At the moment, it is voluntary. You do it yourself. You take a cheek swab, this goes to the organisation and it comes back with the information. There are about 360 genetic pairs for hereditary diseases or afflictions for dogs. Our intention is to make that mandatory for our members. The committee should bear in mind that we registered 12,000-odd dogs last year, and I think 232 of those were pet dogs. We would offer our scheme, as soon as it is available, to everybody who wants it. The pet dogs we register are non-pedigree or are designer dogs coming out of these breeding establishments. We register them as pets because some small animal welfare people use us for that purpose. It is easy to do. I cannot fully understand why the committee was informed previously that it is a huge challenge, because we think it is doable..

We are forging ahead to do it for our members. Any dogs registered with the Irish Kennel Club will have to comply.

Comment on this

Is it expensive?

Comment on this

I call Deputy Ní Raghallaigh.

Comment on this

We should have an opportunity for another round.

Comment on this

I have to speak in the Chamber.

Comment on this

Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe as ucht a gcuid ráitis tosaigh. I have a couple of questions for Dog Law Ireland. I am very interested to know more about the EU regulation. It was the basis of a lot of answers in the previous session. Ms Unger has already given us some insight into what is coming down the track, namely important changes and things that are perhaps not captured in the Government's general scheme. Does Dog Law Ireland want more time to speak about that? I would be very interested in hearing what it has to say. I will go on in case the witnesses from Dog Law Ireland do not wish to comment.

The Minister, Deputy Heydon, stated that there could be potential legal issues with introducing a cap on the number of breeding females a breeder can have. As far as I am aware, he appears to be taking advice from the Attorney General on this issue. Is Dog Law Ireland aware of any potential legal issues in introducing a cap? Will it share its opinion on why the cap is necessary? Are there examples of comparable limits in other sectors that may assist in assessing its legality?

Comment on this
Ms Carrie McMeel

It is important to note that the regulation is a lot wider in scope than the general scheme. It covers breeders, sellers and shelters, with rules also dealing with foster homes, online advertising, imports and traceability. It strengthens several areas. It also includes socialisation, staff competence, veterinary oversight and safeguards around breeding. It also improves identification, links, databases, verifies online adverts and strengthens controls on exports. It uses a tiered and risk-based approach. Some smaller operations have fewer duties but that does not mean they are outside the scope of the regulation. Larger operations are caught by the full regime. Some of this does overlap with the scheme but the EU framework is much broader, more detailed and more connected. We are saying that Ireland should design its national system thinking about this legislation because it is already in force. Most of the provisions will apply from 31 August 2028. We should use that lead-in period to prepare the records, systems, staff and enforcement arrangements needed.

Article 30 of the regulation is of particular interest to us because it confirms that the EU rules are a minimum standard, not a ceiling. Ireland can introduce stronger welfare and traceability rules where stronger protection is needed. Any of the rules will still have to comply with EU legislation. They must be fair, proportionate and not create an unjustified barrier to EU trade. We should use the scheme from the start. This is Ireland's chance. We have been known as the puppy farming capital of Europe for such a long time so we should use this opportunity to change the legislation we have now and join it up from the start.

Comment on this
Ms Demi Mullen

I will outline why we think a cap is necessary. It is about dog welfare, which is obviously central to the general scheme. That is its purpose but it is also for public safety and consumer protection. We appreciate we are not veterinary or behaviour professionals but any evidence we have seen has supported the view that there should be a cap. In October 2022, the joint committee on agriculture, food and the marine produced a report, Issues impacting Dog Welfare in Ireland. It recommended a maximum limit of breeding bitches permitted at a dog breeding establishment to ensure better quality of welfare for dogs. We were also really impacted by the evidence given last week by the NSPCA and Dogs Trust in particular when they spoke about going to dog breeding establishments.

It has been mentioned before but we urge the committee to consider the Northern Ireland expert advisory group's finding in this regard. It is calling for a cap of no more than 25 adult dogs, both male and female. Its recommendation is backed up with ample credible evidence. It highlighted that its own experience of visiting breeding premises aligned with the general view across the range of stakeholders consulted including the veterinary profession that breeding facilities housing large number of dogs cannot feasibly provide for their necessary levels of behavioural or social needs. From looking at censuses and studies the NSPCA and Dogs Trust have done is that it seems like the public really wants this. They want better welfare. That is one of the requirements for us

Deputy Ní Raghallaigh mentioned the legality. I will let Ms McMeel comment on that.

Comment on this
Ms Carrie McMeel

It is difficult for us to comment because we have not seen the advice so we do not understand the exact concern. The Minister has indicated that a hard cap would create legal difficulties. We would welcome the opportunity to understand those concerns. We can assume they relate to property rights and the right to earn a livelihood which are very important rights but they are not absolute. The State can regulate law for businesses where it is necessary to protect animal welfare. The scheme already does that. It places limits on breeding ages, litter frequencies, Caesarean sections and staffing. It also allows authorities to allow breeders to reduce their numbers. We can see that in other sectors. We saw it with fisheries in the context of operating with catch limits. The EU milk quota system limited production and Ireland prohibited fur farming on welfare grounds with the operators compensated. They are not direct comparisons with dog breeding but it demonstrates this can and has been done. Like Ms Mullen said, we support a cap on this.

Comment on this

We heard in the testimony from the NSPCA and Dogs Trust about the importance of rearing well-bred, stable dogs into family homes. Will the witnesses give their views on the public safety element of this and any dog control issues arising from that?

Comment on this
Ms Carrie McMeel

Just to caveat, we are not behaviourists. However, we have heard evidence from welfare organisations and those who work with dogs every day which shows that responsible training from an early age does matter. We have understood that a dog's behaviour is shaped by many things including genetics, health, early experiences with training and responsible ownership. I think Dogs Trust said last week the first few weeks of a puppy's life are so important. Puppies need gentle handling, positive contact with people every day, learning the sights and sounds they can expect when they go into homes. Without those early experiences, they may develop fear which can be harder to handle safely. That does not mean every poorly socialised dog will become dangerous. The scheme would require dogs to be socialised, which we welcome, but those duties need clear standards, trained staff and inspections to assist.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I am aware of the fantastic dog welfare advocacy undertaken by Dog Law Ireland year round. How would a single portal for identification and traceability improve dog welfare, consumer protection and public confidence in the view of Dog Law Ireland?

Comment on this
Ms Carrie McMeel

We can all chime in on this. The single portal would hold all the key information about a dog in one trusted system. The scheme already has all the building blocks for that. Some are very positive. It includes records of birth, stronger sales notifications and a better information chain between authorities. If those records were linked to a dog's microchip, that would create a reliable history about the dog throughout its whole life. The microchip tells you which dog it is, traceability tells you where that dog came from, who bred it, who sold it and what happened afterwards. For buyers, that creates consumer confidence. Before paying a deposit, they can check the puppy, the breeder and the establishment to see if they are legitimate and properly recorded. For enforcement bodies, it means better visibility. Inspectors could also follow ownership and breeding and health records, identify any unusual patterns and interview more quickly when there are welfare concerns which ties in with the enforcement questions asked earlier. It all goes hand in hand.

The Northern Ireland advisory group recommended a central system linking breeders, microchip owners and ownership records with a public search facility but the EU regulation supports greater traceability through domestic databases and verification systems. Ultimately, this is about giving every dog a traceable history from birth onwards. That will help protect buyers, creating consumer confidence. It will support enforcement and most importantly improve animal welfare.

Comment on this

A couple of years ago, the Minister who was then responsible, Heather Humphreys, introduced a populist decision to ban XL bullies. At the time, she referenced cross-Border alignment. How important is that? In the view of the witnesses, do we need an all-Ireland approach to any legislation that would be introduced?

Comment on this
Ms Hannah Unger

The recent report published in Northern Ireland was mentioned a couple of times. It contains a number of excellent recommendations. If they were to become law it would be really important that we take an all-island approach to dog breeding in particular because if there are significant differences between the regimes, North and South, there is a real risk that breeders could gravitate towards the jurisdiction with less demanding regulatory requirements.

One of the key differences at the moment is that the Northern Ireland expert group recommends a cap of 25 adult dogs per breeding premises with an additional requirement that there can only be one licence issued per premises and one licence issued per named individual.

There is no cap being proposed in the general scheme published in the Republic of Ireland. We would have real concerns that large-scale Northern Irish breeders who are currently registered for hundreds of dogs could relocate south of the Border. There is a cap in Northern Ireland.

The expert group in Northern Ireland also recommended the minimum breeding age to be set to 18 months, whereas here, it is being indicated that it will be set at 12 months. In regard to litters, Northern Ireland is recommending a maximum of four litters per breeding female and it cannot be extended to six if a vet allows, which is what is being proposed here. In regard to caesarean sections, only one will be allowed in Northern Ireland whereas two will be allowed if the heads of the Bill become law here.

On the staff-to-dog ratio being recommended, it is 1:10 in the Northern Ireland report. It also stipulates that training is required, which is level 3 or equivalent training. The proposed staff-to-dog ratio for the current Bill in the Republic of Ireland is higher. It is at 1:20. There is no mention of specific training but the Bill does allow the Minister to make regulations around training. There are also other really important things contained in the report that are not contained in the requirements.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Unger. I am sorry for interrupting her.

Comment on this
Ms Hannah Unger

That is fine.

Comment on this

There is an all-Ireland dimension and it is really important that is factored in. I acknowledge that there is an EU perspective and I know Deputy Ní Raghallaigh mentioned it.

Last week, we had the owner of Dogs.ie, which is an online sales platform that facilitates the sale of puppy farm dogs, in my view. In October 2022, the joint committee on agriculture produced a dog welfare report. It welcomed the development of technology that could verify online ads to sell dogs. It recommended mandating for all online platforms, which, to sell dogs, would require the incorporation of a two-step verification system in their advertisements. At the time, there was only one database that could support this verification in technology and I think that was Fido. I wonder, in the intervening four years, has the Irish Kennel Club invested in its database technology to support the two-step verification process?

Comment on this
Ms Pat O'Boyle

At the moment, we are in the process of looking for a new computer system that will be able to do that. We can probably do it with our existing piece of software but it would cost a lot and we are better off trying to get a new system for this. We have no relationship with Dogs.ie whatsoever.

Comment on this

No, I would not want to have any relationship with it either. I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Ms Pat O'Boyle

I think the Senator was out at the time but we, at the moment, are involved in implementing a DNA system that will capture an awful lot more than that. It will be mandatory for our members to register their dogs, including their DNA. As we mentioned earlier, we do not see that as a challenge at all.

Comment on this

Would that be DNA sampling-----

Comment on this

I call Senator Daly.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach. I will be brief; I apologise for the fact that I had to go and vote. I heard most of the submissions; the witnesses were in the middle of them as I went. What I raised with the Department - and I thought it was interesting the witnesses also raised it - was about having a dedicated regulator. I would like to hear their opinions on it. I have their submissions; I will look back at the transcript and we will incorporate the submissions into the report but I raised this with the Department before the witnesses came in, in regard to the cracks when there is cross-departmental responsibility. If it is the Department of agriculture that is ultimately responsible, it should own this and have full responsibility. If it has enough inspectors and vets for all other schemes under CAP, it is a Department man who inspects you, not somebody who is subcontracted in - for want of a better phrase - from another body. We have 31 local authorities. No two will operate the scheme but, yet, they are all meant to be policing, administering or enforcing this law equally. You will have dog wardens and maybe vets in a local authority who will retire, and a financial controller, who is trying to make a budget balance, will defer re-employment until the following year's budget or whatever. This is what happens in the real world. My contribution to our submission would be along those lines.

While the witnesses mentioned it, I would like to hear other people's opinions on it and how they think it could work. We can get this Bill spot on but, if it is not enforced and administered correctly, it would be a waste of time.

Comment on this
Ms Hannah Unger

Was that mine?

Comment on this

It was Ms Unger who said it.

Comment on this
Ms Hannah Unger

I am happy to answer it. It is something we have always called for. We think it is really important. As has been referenced, it is fragmented at the moment. We have a situation where licensing rests with the local authorities. Inspections are being carried out by Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine vets seconded out to the local authorities. Enforcement then falls back on the local authorities. Dog patrol also still rests with the local authorities and then the animal health and welfare report rests with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. It is really fragmented and setting up an independent regulator answerable to one single Department is definitely preferable. As I mentioned earlier, that is how other regulators work, such as the Health Information and Quality Authority, HIQA, the Medical Council and the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland. They are all answerable to one Department, which is the Department of Health.

Especially with the upcoming EU regulation, there are going to be additional responsibilities for the competent authority. All of those responsibilities could just go to the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine or the gold standard would be setting up an independent regulator. As I referenced earlier about the Dog and Cat Management Board of South Australia, there is precedent in other countries where independent regulators have been set up. It could be a companion animal regulator as well, if people felt that something specific to dogs was too narrow but there is cause for setting one up.

Comment on this
Mr. John Butler

I thank the Senator. From our perspective - and the Senator touched on this, as did Deputy Kenny earlier - people have said that dog ownership is not a complex area and is a very simplistic thing. It is really a little bit more complex than what we are saying it is. There is fragmentation in dog ownership at the moment and there is no oversight body looking after it. You get a dog licence in the post office and you register to be a dog breeding establishment somewhere else. If you have a purebred dog, you register it with the Irish Kennel Club. There is a large cohort of dog ownership outside of all of that and the one thing we do not want to see is over-regulation.

I can give members an example where it can go very wrong. One of the largest cohorts of dog owners in this country is elderly people. Sometimes, the canine companion is the only bit of companionship that person has. We have spoken here about setting up different organisations, bodies, rules and regulations but one thing we have not mentioned in any of this is cost. I do not want to see - and I would ask to committee to ensure this - a situation where it becomes cost-prohibitive for a person to own a dog in Ireland. It is very important to take that on board when any legislation is coming down.

The scrutiny on the Bill is 100% right and should happen but we need to take on board that there are a lot of responsible dog owners in this country. There are a lot of people involved with dogs for hunting or who have dogs as pets and for companionship in their homes. They are all very responsible people who look after those animals to the very best. Many vets around the country will tell you that. We do not want to throw the baby out with the bathwater here and legislate against or make it unaffordable for people to own a pet in the country. By all means, bring in legislation and, as Deputy Newsome Drennan said earlier on, implement the legislation that is already there and have consistency of oversight.

That is the one thing that falls down. We have seen it, as a colleague here has said, in other aspects of it. We have seen where certain regulations depend on the postal code and where people live as to what type of legislation will be implemented in that area. We do not want to see that coming into the ownership of dogs. I ask this committee to really consider that we do not over legislate the ownership of dogs. By all means, legislate for proper animal welfare for dog breeding establishments but do not over legislate.

Comment on this

We should have an opportunity for another round of questions from members but before that I want to ask some questions. I imagine that a pack of hunting dogs can range in size from a handful to a much larger number. How large are the larger packs? Of the top 10% of packs, are they comprised of 100 dogs or more than that?

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

The majority of them would be less than 100 dogs. Most of our packs consist of what we would refer to as 11 couple of hounds, and 21 or 22 hounds would be an average size pack. Some of the larger packs, and there is a very small percentage that hunts two or three days a week, could have 30 couple or 60 dogs.

Comment on this

It has been said that the NARGC breeds its own replacements.

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

We breed our own replacements. A pack could be comprised of 60 bitches and be a full bitch pack but they may only breed one bitch every 18 months for replacements. A working dog is not bred until it is proved it has all the required traits.

Comment on this

Would the packs have one, five, ten or 20 dogs with pups?

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

No. A kennel might have 60 bitches and they may only breed two bitches in a year. That is the big distinction that is required because there is a huge difference between bitches that are capable of being bred versus bitches that are being bred. That is why our members are already registered under the Dog Breeding Establishment Act, not that they are commercial breeding premises. We have packs that are registered under the Dog Breeding Establishment Act that only breed a litter every 18 months or two years.

Comment on this

From the point of view of inbreeding, do you have replacements? Is there a sale of dogs from one pack to the other? What happens?

Comment on this
Mr. John Flannery

We do not sell any dogs but we do gift to another pack. If someone wanted one of our pups we would give a pup to another pack. All of our dogs are microchipped and traceable the same as any other.

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Byrne

The drafts and bloodlines are in studbooks that date back 100 years or more. That is a record of registration and identification.

I want to reply to the cross-Border analogy that has been mentioned. In Northern Ireland, hunt clubs, similar charities and non-commercial organisations are explicitly exempt from the dog breeding establishment legislation. That clearly demonstrates that non-commercial kennels operate under fundamentally different circumstances and that the working packs of commercial breeders should not be subject to the same regulatory burden. That is our main point. It is not that there should be differentiation. We should be appropriately regulated for the activity taking place in the establishment. A pack environment has different methods of management; it has a social hierarchy and a pack of working hounds has different needs. All of that should be considered when putting through the regulatory requirements and it should be consistent throughout the legislation.

Comment on this

Staying with the cross-Border aspect, though moving away from hunting to right across all breeding and non-breeding establishments, is there anything in this proposed legislation that would watch out for a dog that was with an establishment on one side of the Border for some period and had a number of litters there but moved across the Border and is being bred on the other side of the Border? Is there anything in the proposed legislation to cover that? What is the likelihood or possibility that somebody would breed a dog on one side of the Border and move them across, after a while, to breed again? Does the Irish Kennel Club register the movement of dogs on either side of the Border?

Comment on this
Ms Pat O'Boyle

We keep a record of what goes between our registered puppies and dogs who go from the Republic of Ireland to either Northern Ireland and the rest of Britain. Last year, up to 30 June this year, over 12 months, 463 dogs were flagged by us as crossing the Border as pedigree dogs and we do keep an eye on that.

Last week, somebody asked about dogs going to Singapore. We had none but we had 47 going to the USA. As a matter of interest, one of the dogs that went to the USA was brought home at our member's expense because the breeder was not happy with the dog's welfare in the USA and that breeder has kept that dog.

In terms of the legislation before us, perhaps it is not strong enough given what has been said about the legislation and it could be looked at.

Comment on this
Mr. John Butler

The Chairperson asked about the size of packs in terms of hunting dogs and working dogs. Our members are not involved with large packs of dogs. Our members would typically own one or two working dogs and there is a distinction between a different type of pursuit and hunt clubs. Sometimes people look at a hunting dog and think the owner must have a pack of dogs. The vast majority of our members own one or two working dogs and not all of those dogs are registered. They would all have a full dog licence but they need not necessarily all be registered dogs.

Comment on this
Ms Demi Mullen

I wish to reply to a point that has arisen, and it arose last week. I refer to the overall broader idea of exempting certain groups or treating certain groups differently under the legislation. I know that the current legislation already does that in certain instances and the general scheme continues that. One thing that we think the committee and the Department should be particularly careful about is that there are distinctions made in EU regulation. There are exemptions for certain classes of dogs, and they talk about customs dogs and police dogs. There are a few different elements involved. I would say that distinctions do not arise within the EU regulation and we will have to comply with that. When we are looking at the general scheme and our legislation we really need to think about that because this regulation will be applicable. As Ms McMeel mentioned, if we do not consider it now then we will reach a place, when it does become applicable, where we are considering how to implement these rules and can we effectively enforce them if we do not have our own national legislation. I ask the committee to please bear in mind that there are distinctions under the legislation. For example, last week the representatives of the Irish Guide Dogs for the Blind talked about exemptions and the hunt club and stuff. To me, they do not immediately stick out as exemptions that are in there. In general, it is charities but I am not 100% certain and perhaps others might confirm that. It is something that it is important that the committee keeps in mind because we will have to comply with the regulation and there are fewer distinctions within that.

Comment on this
Ms Carrie McMeel

I would like to home in on something important that has been said about the cross-Border relationship. Traceability really stood out in the Northern Ireland recommendations. They suggested a public search register where people could search the whole background of the dog. I know that the EU regulations have strong traceability obligations as well and we think that is something the Bill needs to consider too so people can see where a dog is from and its history rather than just looking at a microchip, which identifies the dog but does not give its full history.

Having in the back of the mind how that cross-Border relationship would work would be really helpful if we were to have something similar here. That was proposed in the scheme.

Comment on this
Ms Aileen Byrne

Exemptions were mentioned. The HAI is not looking for any exemptions. We are already regulated, but we are asking for appropriate treatment, not preferential treatment. The 2010 Act uses biological capacity to define a dog breeding establishment. Once in that legislation, the number of bitches capable of breeding should not be used as the mode of defining every regulatory input into that.

Comment on this
Ms Orlagh Murray

The IKC would like to highlight that the regulation should have appropriate regard to actual breeding activity, commercial activity and welfare outcomes, rather than relying disproportionately upon the number of dogs resident at a premises. This point cannot be stressed enough. Responsible preservation breeders should not inadvertently be treated precisely in the same manner as, let us say, intensive commercial dog breeding establishments.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Murray. Do members want two minutes each?

Comment on this

No, I am fine.

Comment on this

Yes, please. It was mentioned that there is a large number of responsible dog owners, and there are a lot. However, that should not hide the fact that there are serious difficulties with animal welfare, and dog welfare, across Ireland. We can see this when we look at the rescue centres and how they are being overwhelmed by dogs being dumped and abandoned. There are so many rescue centres across the country, and they are dealing with the effects of there being no, or little, enforcement of the laws. Nobody is in favour of poor dog welfare. That is clearly not acceptable. Nobody believes that there should be poor dog welfare. I have heard different presentations, last week and this week. There is a lack of enforcement, and I think that is agreed by everybody. There are minimal inspections. The statistics are almost non-existent, and if they do exist, they do not add up.

This situation allows the development of puppy farms and commercial dog breeding establishments across Ireland. It is, therefore, in the interest of everybody who is genuine about dog and animal welfare, including responsible owners, to ensure that there is regulation enforcement and proper statistics. This last aspect does not seem to exist at all. Turning to Dog Law Ireland, does the Government’s proposed Bill adequately address backyard breeders and puppy sellers, or should the definition of "dog breeding establishments" be reconsidered? This issue might have been touched on already.

Comment on this
Ms Hannah Unger

That is a really good question. Dog breeding establishments only account for a certain portion of the market. Additionally, dog breeding establishments are exporting dogs in any case, in certain situations. There is a huge issue with backyard breeders. A rescue centre that we work closely with, Wicklow Animal Welfare, has told us that it rescues approximately 400 to 500 dogs each year, and that 90% of them come from backyard breeding situations and 95% are not microchipped. We think, therefore, that it would be helpful to bring more breeders within the scope of the proposed legislation, and make it easier for inspectors to issue closure notices and prosecute people for running unregistered dog breeding establishments.

The Social Democrats’ Bill amends the definition of a "dog breeding establishment" to reduce the number of breeding females from six to four. To be honest, it would be great if we could just deal with all types of breeding in the one piece of legislation, because at the moment we have two regimes. We have the Dog Breeding Establishments Act 2010, and then we have the pet sellers regulations of 2019, which cover any breeder who sells or supplies six or more pet animals in a calendar year. As a result, and shockingly, dogs in dog breeding establishments currently have greater legal protections than those owned by registered sellers, even though the breeders are carrying out the same activity. There is just no reason for that distinction.

If the general scheme proposal were brought into law tomorrow, this would mean that dogs in dog breeding establishments would benefit from the new age restrictions, the maximum number of litters, enhanced welfare provisions and the Lucy’s law provision, but the provisions would not apply to dogs born to backyard breeders. Particularly regarding the Lucy’s law provision, if people are selling a dog from a dog breeding establishment, the prospective buyer needs to attend the premises. If people are buying a dog off a backyard breeder captured by the 2019 regulations, however, that sale could take place in a car park, for example. There is just no reason for that distinction, so we also need to deal with the backyard breeding situation.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Unger. I thank everybody for their contributions. I am going to bring our meeting to a conclusion.

Comment on this

Could I just ask one very brief question?

Comment on this

No, our time has elapsed at this stage. If particular points were raised that the witnesses want to address or flesh out a little bit further, I ask them to drop a note in to the committee afterwards. The committee has been assessing the proposed legislation, and we have met other witnesses and had submissions from a wide range of different groups. We will now be looking to put together a pre-legislative scrutiny report and send it to the Minister.

I will bring our business here today to a close. I thank everybody for their contributions. Go raibh maith agaibh go léir.

Comment on this