We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

General Scheme of the Deforestation and Forest Degradation Bill 2026: Discussion

Summary

Officials said the Bill gives effect to the EU deforestation regulation, with primary legislation needed to enable its required penalties; Ireland cannot change the regulation’s core requirements. The Department said Irish farmers and forest owners will generally face simplified reporting, while imports must be supported by due-diligence information and checked on a risk-based basis. Members raised concerns about complexity, replanting obligations, possible future expansion of scope and differences in treatment between private landowners and local authorities. No changes were agreed; officials undertook to provide further information on some questions.

Contributions 1–199 of 408. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Before we begin, for the benefit of the witnesses I will bring their attention to the note on privilege. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings. All of our witnesses today are present in the committee room.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against either a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members participating online in the committee meeting where their participation is from within the parliamentary precincts. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precincts. Any attempt to do so will result in the member having their online access removed. All of the members taking part are present in the committee room and there are no members joining the meeting online at this point. Senator Collins is online at present.

The agenda for today's meeting is the pre-legislative scrutiny of the general scheme of the deforestation and forest degradation Bill 2026. We have officials from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine present to talk through and give evidence on the proposed Bill itself. We will then follow up with questions from the members. We are joined by Mr. Damien Flynn, assistant secretary; Mr. Fergus Moore, senior inspector in forestry; Mr. Patrick Nulty, assistant principal officer, forestry; Mr. Michael Gleeson, assistant principal officer, meat and milk policy; and Mr. David O'Loughlin, advisory counsel. Tá fáilte roimh. The opening statement has been circulated to members and I will allow five minutes for the opening statement and then we will have questions and answers from members. I call Mr. Flynn to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the invitation to assist with its pre-legislative scrutiny of the general scheme of the deforestation and forest degradation Bill.

I am assistant secretary general in the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine with responsibility for forestry and implementation of the Common Agricultural Policy, CAP, agri-environment, on-farm investment and organics schemes.

The main purpose of the Bill is to give effect to the EU deforestation regulation in Ireland by providing for its regulatory and enforcement requirements, particularly its specified penalties. The Bill also makes two amendments to the Forestry Act 2014. I will briefly outline the regulation, explain why primary legislation is necessary,summarise the general scheme and say a few words about implementation.

The EU deforestation regulation, Regulation (EU) 2023/1115, aims to minimise the EU's contribution to deforestation and forest degradation worldwide. It covers seven commodities, namely: cattle, cocoa, coffee, oil palm, rubber, soya and wood, and listed products that contain, have been fed with or have been made using them. The regulation will take effect from 30 December 2026, and it requires these commodities and products may only be placed or made available on the EU market, or exported, if they are deforestation-free, have been produced in accordance with the relevant legislation of the country of production, and are covered by a due diligence statement or a simplified declaration. However, for individual operators or micro or small enterprises, established by 31 December 2024, the regulation will take not effect until 30 June 2027, although this exception does not extend to timber products already covered by the EU timber regulation, for which the date remains 30 December 2026. The regulation has been amended since it was adopted in 2023. The most significant amendment for Ireland was agreed in December 2025. It deferred application by a further year, from December 2025 to December 2026, and introduced a simplified regime for small primary producers, such as farmers and forest owners, in countries classified as low risk. It also removed the requirement for businesses further down the supply chain to submit due diligence statements.

In May, the Commission completed the simplification review that the amendment required. This review did not propose any change to the regulation, and the application dates are unchanged. In July, the Commission adopted a delegated Act adjusting the list of products covered and an implementing Act on the EU information system.

Ireland, like all EU member states, is classified the low risk category. This means Irish farmers and forest owners who are individuals or micro or small enterprises, and who place their own produce on the market or export it, will not need to submit due diligence statements. Instead, they will submit a single, one-time simplified declaration. Where all of the required information is already held in a database that exists under EU or national law, the producer does not need to submit the declaration, and the member state makes the information available in the EU information system instead.

As to why primary legislation is needed, the EU deforestation regulation is directly effective and much like the various regulations enacted at EU level, it must be given effect in Irish law to ensure that it is enforceable at national level, by taking such measures as designating a competent authority and establishing a regulatory framework to carry out checks, take enforcement measures and make provision for penalties. In this regard, the vast majority of EU regulations are given effect in Irish law through regulations made under the European Communities Act 1972, as amended.

Article 25 of the regulation requires that member states implement penalties for infringements of the regulation that are effective, proportionate and dissuasive. A key aspect of these requirements are the specified penalties, including a financial penalty required to be a maximum of at least 4% of an operator's total annual EU-wide turnover.

Regulations made under the European Communities Act 1972, cannot include financial penalties exceeding €500,000. The open-ended nature of the financial penalties required under Article 25 of the regulation means that such a financial penalty is not limited to any specific sum and may exceed €500,000; therefore, the EU deforestation regulation cannot be given effect through the European Communities Act 1972 and must be implemented through primary legislation.

The general scheme has heads in three Parts. Part 1 contains the standard provisions on the short title, commencement, definitions and expenses.

Part 2 deals with the regulation. It designates the Minister as the competent authority and allows other bodies to be prescribed. It makes it an offence to place or make available on the market, or export, a product that does not meet the reputation's core requirements. It also creates offences for breaches of the specific obligations on operators, downstream operators, traders and authorised representatives.

Chapter 4 of Part 2 of the general scheme provides for enforcement, such as the appointment of authorised officers and members of An Garda Síochána. Authorised officers will have established powers of entry, inspection, sampling and seizure, and may serve compliance notices, which can be appealed to the District Court. Such search warrants may also be granted by the District Court. In addition, Chapter 2 of Part 2 of the general scheme protects the identity of people who submit substantiated concerns, provides for information to be shared with other authorities, and allows the Minister to make regulations, including to give effect to future EU measures.

On conviction on indictment, the maximum penalty is a fine of the greatest of €10 million, 4% of the person's EU-wide turnover in the financial year before sentencing, or the potential economic benefit gained from the offence, or imprisonment for up to three years, or both. On summary conviction, the maximum is a class A fine, six months' imprisonment, or both. A small number of administrative offences, such as record-keeping and public reporting, are summary offences only, with a maximum class A fine.

On conviction on indictment, the court may also order the forfeiture of the products concerned and of revenues from transactions in them, exclusion from public procurement and public funding for up to 12 months, a temporary prohibition on placing or making available on the market, or exporting, relevant commodities and products, and a prohibition on using simplified due diligence. These penalties all reflect the penalties required by the regulation. The general scheme also provides for fixed payment notices as an alternative to summary prosecution.

Part 3 makes two amendments to the Forestry Act 2014. Head 39 adds to the Minister's general functions under that Act to include the deterrence of deforestation and forest degradation, including ensuring that forestry operations regulated under the Act are compatible with the EU regulation.

Head 40 adds a new category of exempted tree. It covers trees in a forest whose removal is required for a local authority development already authorised under the planning legislation after the amendment takes effect. Exempted trees may be felled without a felling licence.

On implementation, the Department's approach to enforcement will be risk-based and proportionate. Our emphasis will be on guidance and correcting problems early, with enforcement action and-or prosecutions reserved for serious or persistent breaches.

In conclusion, the Minister and the Department will consider the committee's report carefully in finalising the Bill. I hope this overview is helpful to the committee. My colleagues and I are happy to answer any questions.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Flynn. The Title of this legislation is deforestation and forest degradation. A lot of the time large forests, like the Amazon rainforest, come to mind. Where I live, a lot of large Sitka spruce plantations are clear-felled. Sitka spruce is not a native species. In a lot of places these would be replanted but there are places that are unsuitable for replanting. For example, plantations might have been higher ground, soft ground or along the roadside, etc. and they not be replanted again. There is also legislation on the rewilding of ground and I am interested to hear whether ground where sheep are allowed to graze or it is left without forest will be covered by this legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We have a forestry licensing system in Ireland based on the Forestry Act. Anyone who wishes to clear-fell or remove trees is subject to a forestry licence. That licence can include conditions to address issues, as the Cathaoirleach mentioned, such as whether trees should be replanted or are suitable for replanting. That is the approach and they are covered by the Forestry Act.

Today's legislation is about giving effect to the EU regulation that has been passed in Brussels. It does not affect the current forestry licensing system, which deals with clear-felling or anyone who requires a licence to fell trees.

Comment on this

I will open the debate to the floor. I have four members offering and each will have seven minutes.

Comment on this

I will be helpful because I am conscious that we are at the pre-legislative stage.

This Bill is very complex. Despite some people telling me that this Bill was real easily to read, I spent a weekend reading documentation from the European Union on this and found it an extremely complex system. I will now flag some areas that may be of concern and that is not to say that they will be of concern to other people. Of course they will then be documented in our report at this stage of the process and we may be able to revisit them. I do not necessarily expect the officials to answer them all here but I want to flag them to the Department so that they become part of the dialogue.

First, I want to use the word "simplification". If there was ever a need for simplification, and I can hear the farm representatives and the forestry bodies talking about the need for simplification, then this is one.

Next we need to prepare the stakeholders for this huge piece of bureaucracy. I am not sure if it is all necessary but the reality is that we must proceed as it is part of the European architecture or framework around all of this area.

I will flag issues of concern rather than pose huge questions. Having read an awful lot of documentation for four or five days, the precise geolocation co-ordinates is an issue. Geolocation data will allow claims to be checked in practice. I will flag that idea now because that is what the briefing documents tell me. How will a competent authority in the EU member states check the validity of non-deforestrion claims?

We need to define the term "forestry degradation" and ensure that it is clearly understood because there are many interpretations of that. What does it mean in simple terms? Which forestry land use changes complies with the regulations? There are varying changes of use and we should look at that again. Does a natural disaster count as deforestation? It might. We have had Storm Éowyn and there seems to be an issue. Will other woodlands or other ecosystems be included in the scheme? We need clarity on that.

In terms of data, will the Commission issue further details concerning the satellite imagery tools it uses? What about the right of access to this data? This is part of a bigger international monitoring of forestation on the ground. How does the stakeholders and punters feed into that and check its accuracy? Have they the right to double-check it? Have they the right to challenge that? What are the different elements of the Team Europe initiative? I find the initiative very complex and I ask Mr. Flynn to provide the committee with a briefing note on the Team Europe initiative. Will the Commission issue guidelines? I ask because its questions and answers section are very complex. Therefore, the earlier we can bring the stakeholders into all of this debate the better and we can bring them on a journey. As policymakers, it is big journey for us and we need to bring the stakeholders along in partnership. Effectively, we have a 50:50 split between private forestry investors and others versus Coillte. As I do not know the involvement of Coillte in any of this I ask Mr. Flynn to share that with us because clearly Coillte is an important part of it.

We are all talking about transition. We know how people move from agriculture into forestry. How difficult is it now for people to do the reverse and move from forestry back to agriculture? In certain circumstances, there could be a genuine case. It definitely is easier one way than it is to come back and we need to understand that because that is what the forestry people will ask us.

Finally, the regulation is linked with the EU renewable energy directive. How do these regulations dovetail and fit in with the EU renewable energy directive? Renewable energy is everything. It is a lot of what we are talking about. Even Coillte is involved in that sector but we need to understand that.

I hope that is not too complex. It is not necessary that we have answers today but these are issues the committee would benefit from having more information about. I would like Mr. Flynn to be honest with me and the committee about how much scope we have around the edges of this. If we have none, it would be great to hear that. On an initial look at it, those are some of the concerns I have.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I will go through as many of them as I can and give the Senator a flavour of where we are at. I will start with the last one, about the scope of this legislation and the basis of it. This is an EU regulation so all its provisions are directly applicable to Ireland. The Bill is targeted at giving effect to that regulation. Provisions in the regulation are about making sure we have the appropriate offences to do compliance, do the correct checks and have the right system. The substance of what different people in the supply chain have to do is set by and provided for in the EU regulation. Some of the Senator's questions were on that and some were on the powers in the regulation. I will run through some of that.

The Senator asked about stakeholders, farmers and simplification. The regulation has evolved. It was passed in 2023. It went through two amendments in 2024 and 2025 because there were concerns at the EU Council and among member states - the Minister, Deputy Heydon, was involved in this as well - about its complexity and how it was being applied to, particularly, EU producers and operatives. This regulation is targeted at deforestation and, particularly, third countries, where there is large-scale deforestation. It has to apply in the EU as well for WCO reasons. We have to be seen to be doing the same as we are applying to third countries.

The regulation has evolved a couple of times through simplification. For example, farmers and forest owners are considered small or micro enterprises - "SMEs", as it is defined in the regulation. An Irish beef farmer will not have to submit a due diligence statement to the EU system. There is a simplified, one-off declaration required. In terms of implementation, the Department is looking at doing that for farmers. We hold a lot of information on our AIM system around traceability. We are developing a system that will be able to make this declaration for farmers based on the information we have and share it on the information system with the EU as needed. We are looking at a solution that will not place an extra paperwork burden or requirement on Irish farmers.

This regulation was first adopted in 2023. There has been a wide range of stakeholder engagement by the Department across many sectors - not just farmers, but also traders and importers. The regulation applies to imports of coffee, cocoa and soya. Obviously, we do not grow them here. There is wide and ongoing consultation, including webinars and bilateral meetings with stakeholders' representative groups. The Senator mentioned there is a lot of guidance available. When you look at this at a supply chain level, it is quite complex. I agree with the Senator on that but it is broken down into clear pathways for Irish farmers and forest owners. Ireland is a low-risk country and they are small or micro enterprises. They only have to do a one-off declaration and, especially for wood, cattle and beef, we are developing a system to do that for them.

The Senator mentioned geolocation. Coming back to Irish farmers and that single declaration, there is not a requirement for geolocation of plots of land. The postal address of the farmer is provided for in the simplification of the regulation. More broadly, the EU has a forestry observatory. There are tools available there to check due diligence statements on geolocation plots put on, say, a forest in Brazil. That is part of the controls and checks the Department will do. The regulation provides for a certain level of checking controls to be applied to the requirements based on the risk level of the country products are coming from.

The definition of "degradation" is provided for in the regulation:

(7) ‘forest degradation’ means structural changes to forest cover, taking the form of the conversion of:

(a) primary forests or naturally regenerating forests into plantation forests or into other wooded land; or

(b) primary forests into planted forests;

We already have a Forestry Act with a range of provisions relating to forestry, including felling or changes of forestry. That Act still applies. The regulation does not impinge on the basic requirements of the Act.

The Senator mentioned forest use change and natural disasters. They are provided for in the Forestry Act. A forest plantation changes its nature-----

Comment on this

It evolves, yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It evolves over time. They are all provided for in the Forestry Act. They would not be considered degradation. We provide for replanting of those forests. We have a reconstitution scheme for Storm Éowyn and Storm Darragh.

The Senator mentioned satellite imagery tools and data. I may have to come back to him on that one.

Comment on this

I am conscious our time is finished.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

We ran five minutes over but it was important we all got the answers to those questions.

Comment on this

Just one thing: the team Europe initiatives. Maybe Mr. Flynn will come back another time on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I will come back on that because it is a very specific thing. I can send that in in writing.

Comment on this

That is great. Thanks.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

We ran five minutes over there but we did need to hear all those answers.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statement. We have an awful lot of forestry in County Leitrim. Senator Boyhan mentioned Coillte. Initially there were thousands and thousands of acres of mountain bog planted with Sitka spruce. That was a carbon sink that was drained and destroyed. The purpose of this Bill is to ensure carbon sinks globally are not destroyed in the interests of agriculture. When many forests come to the end of their lives and are to be clear felled, a condition of the clear-fell licence is they must be replanted, often with the same types of tree that were there before. It is criminal to be doing that in these circumstances. We talk about telling farmers who are farming peatland that they cannot farm it any more and have to re-wet it. If it is private forestry where they have clear felled, they have to go back and plant it again with the same kind of trees. The same imposition is being put on them. It does not make sense. I want clarity around that. Will this mean if a farmer has a piece of land they got a forestry licence for and got premiums for over the years, that 30 or 40 years later when they get a clear-fell licence, they have to replant the land, even though up-to-date scientific analysis would tell us planting that land will damage the ecosystem and impair the carbon sequestration strength of that piece of ground? If that is what this will do, it will have an unintended effect we need to be very aware of.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

As it stands on forestry policy, as the Deputy will be aware, we have the Forestry Act. The requirements of that still apply. This does not change those requirements. The basic replanting obligation when there is clear fell still applies. That is subject to a felling licence. That felling licence takes into account environmental conditions and the replanting obligation can be shaped by-----

Comment on this

But they must be replanted.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It must be replanted. That is the requirement.

Comment on this

It is a nonsense. Up-to-date scientific analysis tells us that you are actually damaging that carbon sink by draining it and planting it with Sitka spruce.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There is provision also, on a case-by-case basis, to convert it back to bog. Under the EU deforestation, it cannot be converted back to agriculture - that is the issue - but it can be converted back to bog.

Comment on this

It cannot go into agricultural production.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, for those products. It cannot be converted back to agriculture for cattle, soya, cocoa or oil products.

Comment on this

Cattle or sheep, for grazing, cannot happen on it which would be natural.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Sheep are okay.

Comment on this

Sheep are allowed.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes.

Comment on this

So it can possibly be used for upland which would traditionally have been grazed by sheep, under this legislation.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, under this legislation, the EU deforestation regulation.

Comment on this

The problem is this legislation would conflict with the present Forestry Act 2014 because it will say that you have to replant it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Deforestation that is for ecosystem restoration would be allowed under the Forestry Act.

Comment on this

It would be allowed.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

For ecosystem restoration, yes.

Comment on this

Okay. I am not sure that ever happens, but anyway. The experience of anyone I have come across is that they have to replant. Often they do not want to replant the land. They want to put it back, sometimes to agriculture, to sheep, to grazing or whatever. Often they just want to leave it. They do not want to put trees back on it and they are forced to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The basic obligation is that once forestry is planted, it is a condition that it would be replanted afterwards. If there are environmental considerations, the land use can be changed but that is assessed on a case-by-case basis.

Comment on this

One issue is that we have intergenerational ownership here. When you plant the forest on the land, it will be 30 or 40 years. It is probably the next generation that will benefit from the clear-felling of it and the next generation will have to comply with the obligation that their father, grandfather or grandmother signed them up to. There is a bit of a constitutional right-of-property contradiction in the context of that, although I accept that would have to be tested and it would take a court or somewhere to test that. Does Mr. Flynn understand where I am coming from?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I absolutely understand. I am just quoting what the Forestry Act talks about at the moment. That is the provision. There is a replanting obligation on the land.

Comment on this

I understand what this scheme is trying to do. From a global context, the Department is trying to ensure we will not be buying beef, soya or other products coming from parts of the world where they have cleared away the lungs of the earth - the rainforests in South America or anywhere else, be it south-east Asia or wherever - to produce rubber or whatever. We will not be complicit in that. That is really what it is about, from a European perspective. I understand that also from a European perspective if we are to apply that logic to other countries, we have to apply it to ourselves. That goes without saying.

The difficulty here is we also have to be cognisant of the reality of the farmer on the ground and of our own individual situations. We have had forestry schemes in place for many years where farmers have been paid handsomely enough and have tax-free benefits, etc. Sometimes they are not farmers. Sometimes they are corporations or whatever that have done very well out of it. From the perspective of communities out there, however, it has been a permanent change of land use which has destroyed communities. I can show Mr. Flynn whole townlands where there is not one farmer living anymore, where there is no child going to school and where there is nobody to buy wire, fertiliser or anything because there is nobody there. There is no tractor to break down and no mechanic needed to fix it, because there is nothing there only trees that grow for ten or 15 years. Some crowd comes in from far away and thins them out in approximately three weeks and they are gone again, and nothing happens for another ten or 15 years. That is the experience of communities.

Forestry has a very positive element in one sense but it has very negative other elements as well. We need to be cognisant of that also. The point is that if we are saying today that much of these trees that have been planted, particularly on black soil, was not the best use of that soil and using that soil in its own natural carbon sequestration state was better, are we to have legislation here coming from Europe which will come in on top of the Forestry Act 2014 that will put us in that position to force us further down that road?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The Deputy is correct that it is about the EU not contributing to deforestation globally. There are products, such as coffee, chocolate and all the things we consume, that are produced on that. That is the core.

Comment on this

The cattle feed that we import here too.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, absolutely. The Deputy is correct that this has to apply to the EU the same way as we are imposing it on third-country producers who want to trade with us or place goods on our market. That is the principle for this.

In terms of the forestry piece, this legislation gives effect to what is in the regulation. We cannot change what is in the EU regulation.

Comment on this

Can we make it more flexible?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Sorry?

Comment on this

Can we insert flexibility into it?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. The basic requirements of the regulation have to be implemented. That is law in Ireland now. We are just giving effect to have the powers to make sure that all the things that are provided for in this regulation are delivered and that, where people who do not abide by the rules in these regulations, we have the powers to enforce it and make sure there is compliance.

Comment on this

The Department went to some length to state that Ireland would be low risk and that farmers in Ireland would not have to meet the higher bars, perhaps, that other countries would need to meet where probably there would be rainforests or other issues, or large areas of land would be taken up by forestry that were to be clear-felled. In that context, where the Department is talking about it being low risk, does that relate to the size of a piece of land? For instance, I read somewhere through the general scheme that half a hectare is considered a forest. If it is smaller than that, does that not apply at all?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The definition of forest within the regulation is half a hectare. The definition of forest in the Forestry Act is slightly different. It is 0.1 of a hectare.

Comment on this

There needs to be something done to make them marry up. It does not make sense that they do not.

Finally, as I am aware of the clock, I will ask about pieces of forestry which have not been planted under any scheme. A smaller corner of land that is perhaps very wet may have been left for many years and a natural forest may have grown up on it. There is no obligation under the Forestry Act in respect of such a forestry because they never got grants or anything to do it. It is just there. It exists. How does this work in respect of that? If a farmer wanted to go in and clear some of it away or tidy it up, are they in difficulty there? The part of it that relates to deforestation is one issue but degradation is the other.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes.

Comment on this

Degradation is really just changing the forestry; it is not clearing it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That is within the scope of this regulation. If the land is a naturally generating forest, that is within the scope of this regulation and it would apply to that land.

Comment on this

It would apply. I thank the Chair.

Comment on this

I thank the officials for coming in and for their opening statement.

As we are all well aware, any time there is change there is also concern. There has to be concern and that needs to be looked into and investigated. We are doing the best we can here for the farming communities.

EU legislation has a habit of being transposed into Irish law in ways that often creates huge issues for agriculture in Ireland, and especially for the small family farms which it is vital to protect.

Where is an "operator" defined within the legislation? In head 10, there is reference to micro or small operators. In head 14(2), there is reference to small or micro-operators being able to "substitute the postal address for the geolocation information". The definition needs to be made very clear in our own legislation. For example, with a small Clare suckler or dairy farm being considered as an operator or "a micro or small primary operator", we would need to define exactly what that could be. Maybe Mr. Flynn would provide an update on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There is a definition of what a "small" or "micro" operator is. The qualifying conditions are to fulfil two or more of the following: the amount of turnover of the operator does not exceed €15 million; the balance sheet total of the company does not exceed €7.5 million; and the average number of employees does not exceed 50.

From our perspective, all farmers and forest owners are small micro-operators. I know it is a very wordy way of putting that. It does not call out farmers and foresters, but that covers all of them. That is clear. We were pushing at EU level to get that change in there to make sure that the category was well-defined and that in particular for us, from a domestic point of view, that it covers farmers and forest owners. That definition covers all of them, as far as we see.

Comment on this

Is the Department happy with that definition?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Are small farming communities and all covered?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Absolutely. They are fully covered.

Comment on this

That is vitally important. I am concerned about how the scope of the legislation might creep in the future. Head 5 allows the Minister to extend the Act to other wooded land, grassland, peatland and wetlands. Why is this needed now? Will there be a requirement for the Minister to come back to us and the farming community, which is important, for consultation before any change can be made? Again, my county of Clare has large areas of the Burren, Shannon Callows and bogs that could be impacted in the future.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Any change that refers to extending the Act to grasslands, peatlands or wetlands that is provided for in the regulation would be decided at EU level. It would not be decided by the Minister. The Minister cannot do that unilaterally. What that head provides for is that if there was a change at EU level - that would have to be negotiated at EU level and Ireland would be part of that discussion - the Minister would have the powers to implement it if there was any change down the road in basic EU regulation. The Minister would not have the powers to unilaterally do anything in that space. This gives the Minister the power to implement if the EU regulation changes after it is negotiated at EU level, rather than him having to come back for another piece of primary legislation.

Comment on this

If it happens at EU level, the Minister has no choice other than to go with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That is the basic principle of this regulation. If there is an amendment of the regulation at EU level, it applies in Ireland. If there is an amendment down the road to one of those things, it will apply in Ireland. The Minister may have to amend some of the powers to reflect that. If the EU regulation changes, the Minister will have the power to make regulation to implement those.

Comment on this

Are the Minister's hands tied at that stage? Will he have any choice?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The same principle of the EU regulation has been negotiated at EU level. An EU regulation is directly applicable into law in Ireland if the decision is made at EU level. Again, that would be a whole process. In terms of those issues, the Commission has said that the regulation provides for a review in 2030, five years after it was adopted in 2025. That is where some of that discussion may happen, but there is nothing on the horizon at the moment to say those issues will be amended. Again, that is an EU process and Ireland would feed into that process as one of the 27 member states.

Comment on this

Head 40 exempts local authority developments from felling licences. Why do farmers and private foresters still need a licence when the local authorities do not? Will any exemptions be extended to landowners in these situations?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The proposal in head 40 is in relation to local authorities for lands that they own or lease. It is their own land, and it is just to give them the authority, if they have gone through the full planning process already on a project they want to deliver on their own lands, such that they would not have to go through the felling licence process as well. That is what head 40 is trying to provide for. It avoids that duplication of consents that are required under planning and the felling licence. It is only on their own lands. It is not on private lands.

Comment on this

If a landowner went in for a planning application to put up a slatted house or whatever and there are trees to be felled on the land, could the licence automatically come through the local authority then for that purpose?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. Any trees that need to be felled for something like building infrastructure would require a felling licence and that has to go through the licensing process.

Comment on this

Could it not build up to something similar like the head 40 exemption? Could that not be looked at in this case?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That is a fundamental part of the felling licence process. As the Deputy will be aware, that is quite a complex process.

Comment on this

Yes, I am.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It would be quite difficult to allow that to happen because it is a much broader scope.

Comment on this

If it was included in the planning application, it would make it easier for the local farmers who, as we are well aware, have enough concerns, as well as criteria and red tape to meet. Again, simplifying things is always very important. If it is at all possible, could it be looked at? Now is probably the time do so. I thank the witnesses for their time.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. Are local authorities only allowed to fell trees or forestry if they already have planning permission?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes. If an application has passed the full planning process, so if they have a project-----

Comment on this

Will they not be allowed to do that in the future?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

If a local authority has an infrastructure project and it might require the clearing of some trees, at the moment it goes through the planning process, which includes a full environmental assessment and all of those things, and it then has to go back and go for a felling licence as a double consent.

Comment on this

If they have a plan in place at the moment, they can work away-----

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes.

Comment on this

-----but in the future, can they put in for a plan to go and build a housing estate or whatever else on land where there are already trees? Regardless of having planning permission in now, can they fell trees in the future to put in a housing estate or whatever else they are going to do without getting a licence?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Any planning application has to through the full planning rigours.

Comment on this

What I read on this seems to be that if they have planning permission already in place, they can fell the trees. However, I am talking about in the future. If they would like to build a housing estate on land that has a forest on it, but no plan has gone in for it, can they fell it a year or two down the line and go and plant? Are they basically exempt from any of this?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Regarding the Deputy's second point about a new planning application, as part of the planning application process, that would be sufficient. That is what this head provides for. The local authority would not need a separate felling licence in the future.

Comment on this

In other words, the State can do what it likes.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It is subject to the full planning regulations, which require a number of consents. There is quite a bit of duplication in terms of environmental controls as part of-----

Comment on this

If we, as farmers, were to knock down a forest on one part of our land, we would have to replant it somewhere else on our own land to be compliant. If we take down ten acres of forestry, we have to put it back up somewhere else. Do the local authorities have to replant forestry on some other part of their land, if they fell it for a housing estate or the likes? The witnesses can come back to me on this, if they do not have the information.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We will come back to the Deputy on it.

Comment on this

It cannot be one rule for one and another for somebody else. If we cut down whatever number of acres of forestry and we do not want to plant it on that land, we have to plant it somewhere else. Is it one rule for one and another rule for others?

Let us look at ash dieback and land that has been passed down from one generation to the next. The original farmer signed up and got all his payments throughout the couple of years and the land is then handed down to his son or daughter. They are stuck with that forever. It is like a noose around their neck. They can never claim back that land to put cattle on it.

We have people with ash dieback in their plantation.

That was meant to be their retirement scheme. This could happen to them again so you can understand why they do not want to replant. What kind of fines are there for not replanting? Have fines been collected for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

With regard to people who plant land, forestry is a voluntary operation. People-----

Comment on this

It is voluntary for the original farmer who gets into it but it is not voluntary for the next generation. They did not sign up to it. They absolutely did not. It is not voluntary. It cannot be.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

At this moment in time, the change in land use is entered into voluntarily.

Comment on this

That is the case originally.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes. The obligation under the Forestry Act is to maintain forest cover. We have a policy of trying to maintain and grow our forest cover. Ireland has traditionally had very little forest cover. There are lots of benefits from forestry across the board.

Comment on this

I understand that but it should be voluntary and it is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We are trying to grow a resource that provides a multitude of benefits. That is why that obligation to maintain the forest cover is there. It is a policy discussion. I fully accept what the Deputy is saying.

Comment on this

It is not voluntary, however.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Well-----

Comment on this

It absolutely is not. It is for the original person who plants the forest. That is absolutely voluntary. If I have a piece of land and want to plant forestry on it, that is absolutely voluntary for me. It is not voluntary for the next generation, however. They are completely tied up. This has to be looked at. They should not have that noose around their necks. They get this land but have to do with it what the generation before has done. We want people to grow forestry but we do not want to push them into a corner and make them do it. Mr. Flynn did not get back to me on the fines.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I have that-----

Comment on this

If somebody cut down forestry and rewilded the land rather than planting forestry again, that is okay under this deforestation thing, is it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

On fines, the approach to the deforestation regulation is very much about supporting people, guidance and compliance. It is very unlikely that fines would issue. That would only happen in very extreme cases.

Comment on this

I do not mean fines under the regulation. I mean if a farmer or landowner was to chop down a forest and not resow it. You are supposed to sow it again within a certain number of years, two years or whatever it is. If they did not do that, what kinds of fines apply? Have many people been fined?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I will have to come back to the Deputy on the level of fines because-----

Comment on this

Yes, that is perfect.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

-----I do not have that data to hand.

Comment on this

On the legislation, is it just for the EU? If I was to chop down a forest, turn the land back into grassland and put cattle grazing on it, those cattle could not be exported. I believe they, or any proceeds arising from them, could be taken. Is there a provision for products that we import? Let us look at Brazil and the whole Mercosur deal. How are we to know exactly which cattle coming from Brazil were grazed on land that had been forestry before being turned into grassland? On the whole Mercosur trade deal and the Brazilian beef coming in, it if were not for what the Irish Farmers' Journal and the IFA did, such beef would probably be in the food chain right now. We cannot depend on third parties to do the work for us, for Europe, that is, to go to see who are the good actors and who are the bad actors. How are we going to manage that?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The regulation provides for that. Where imports are being placed on the EU market for the first time, the person placing it on the market is the person responsible for making sure they have all of the due diligence statements and all of the information about where the product came from. That all has to be entered into the EU system. Part of the controls and checks we do is to take a percentage, which depends on where the products are coming from, and to check that all of the documents and all of the information are correct. It absolutely does apply to imports. That is very much being targeted. The person importing those products and placing them on the market in the EU in the first instance is the person who has to make sure------

Comment on this

They are doing their own homework.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. They are required to fill out a due diligence statement, which has to be put up on the EU system. That can then be controlled and checked. That due diligence statement number has to be put on the customs declaration. It all has to be documented. This regulation provides for all of the things that importers have to provide to prove the product being imported into the EU did not come from land that was deforested.

Comment on this

Will Europe have boots on the ground to check things in those countries or will it just be a paperwork check?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We will be doing the checks and controls. Like all member states, we will have to prepare an annual report. That will feed into ongoing discussions at EU level about compliance and what is happening. Another reason we are putting in the legislation is to allow for fines and prosecutions if people are-----

Comment on this

You will not be able to find them, however. It sounds like people are doing their own homework. If I am selling a product in another country and do all my own paperwork, you might say that paperwork all looks lovely and dandy but is somebody in that country going to check? The Irish Farmers' Journal had to do the work in going out to the country to find out what was really going on. Is Europe putting funds in place to send people to those other countries to check? You cannot have people doing their own homework.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

On how it is controlled, the geolocations are very important. These are part of the due diligence statements. They can be checked. If a due diligence statement includes a geolocation tag relating to a deforested area, that is very clear. That then becomes-----

Comment on this

They will be checked regularly.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, a percentage is checked depending on the country involved. As the competent authority, that obligation is being put on us. If products are coming into Ireland, we have to do those checks. They are set at different levels. We do control checks. If an issue arises, we follow through on it. That is why we need these enforcement powers. Ultimately, penalties will apply if it is found that-----

Comment on this

Will it be up to Ireland------

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is four and a half minutes over.

Comment on this

Will it be up to Ireland to send somebody out to see what is going on or will it be a European thing?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

This legislation gives the Irish authorities the power to bring somebody through the courts system here if they are proven not to have complied with this. In the case of a product coming from a third country, that person would be the importer. They are providing evidence as to where they are sourcing the product so-----

Comment on this

The other thing is-----

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Deputy, I am sorry but you are five minutes over. Fair is fair.

Comment on this

Sometimes it goes to a different country before coming to Ireland. That is the other side of it.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

I will let you back in or the next Chair will. I am next on the list myself that is why I was trying to move things on.

Comment on this

It is all right. We will let the Cathaoirleach Gníomhach go a number of minutes over too.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

I will be brief because most of the stuff has been covered. I want to get my head around what is going on here. We cannot alter the EU regulation in any way. It has been decided.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

We are doing pre-legislative scrutiny with a view to finding the best way to implement the regulation but we cannot change it in any way. The regulation is the regulation.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We cannot change the basic provisions of the regulation. We are bringing forward primary legislation because the level of fines provided for in the regulation go beyond the European Communities Act. That is why it is not coming forward as a statutory instrument but as primary legislation. That is why it is being brought forward as a Bill.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Why do we have to do a Bill at all? I am playing devil's advocate here to a point. We examine EU regulations in all of our private meetings but this is the first time I have ever seen legislation having to be done to implement one.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

As I have said, what is catching us is that the level of penalties provided for in the regulation go beyond what is allowed for under the European Communities Act. The Act provides for the implementation of EU regulations by statutory instrument but only where the maximum fines involved are €500,000. The provisions-----

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Why is the legislation we are talking about here just mentioning fines and their increase? It seems to me that we are bringing in a lot of stuff that will complicate things, for the want of a simpler phrase.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We are bringing it forward this way so that if there are changes down the road, it will be much cleaner to have a Bill we can amend by regulation rather than having to keep coming back with more primary legislation on specific elements.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

I will go back to what Deputy Newsome Drennan said about Brazilian beef. We will use it as an example. Is this legislation retrospective? Is there a date that people are allowed to deforest to? It would be okay to have beef cattle being reared on that land but there cannot be any future deforestation. Does it count if animals are being reared on land where there was once a forest? Will this legislation apply retrospectively?

Turning to something else Deputy Newsome Drennan said, how do we identify 100 cattle that are now grazing on the forested land but end up in a feedlot and are killed or exported along with 100,000 other cattle from everywhere? How do we know which cattle came from where and how do we know what is coming into the country?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

On it being retrospective, this applies to land going back to 2020.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

If land was deforested before 2020, it is not covered by this regulation.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes. The burden here is on the person placing the product on the market in the EU. The regulation sets out all of the things people have to do to satisfy themselves, as importers, that the product complies with all of the due diligence and requirements needed to prove it did not come from deforested lands. That includes the geotags, etc. All of that has to be there, all of it has to be substantiated, and all of it can then be checked and controlled.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Right. Mr. Flynn mentioned timber in his opening statement. Without being smart or flippant, timber is not going to be exported or imported unless there is deforestation. How does that fit into the overall scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Wood is provided for in this, and there is already a strong EU timber regulation. This regulation is building on the EU timber regulation. It will be repealed in 2029 after this regulation is implemented fully, so it does apply to timber. Regarding all of those statements that timber should not be coming from deforested lands, that is what this regulation is aimed at.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Timber production is deforestation by nature. There may be an intention to replant, but when people are using a log, it will not have been replanted. How will we know that it will ever be replanted in future?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The Amazon forest, for example, is a primary forest. Timber should not be coming from that. That is deforestation.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

It is specifically a primary forest.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes. If we are talking about the Amazon rainforest, this provision covers it.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

If I have a 30-year-old forest here that is cut down with a licence and exported, but then I dig in when all of the timber is gone and used and I say that I am not sowing that again, is there a comeback there? That would be deforestation if I did not replant. It will not be known to the Department that I have made that decision until the timber has long since gone and been sold and used.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Deforestation is defined as a land use change. If a primary forest is clear-felled and that timber used, that is a land use change for primary forests, or Amazon forests, in that regard. Forest management is about proper regeneration of forests, encompassing harvesting and replanting, including in tropical forests. That process can be valid and can be proper forest management as well, and can be allowed if it is properly managed. All of those things have to be justified in the risk assessment and the due diligence statements provided to support the products being imported into the EU market.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

It is a tricky one.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

This regulation has-----

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

Timber probably should be dealt with separately, because it is a tricky one.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

This regulation is trying to address deforestation and degradation for all of the reasons we would say those processes are negative. There was a different regime before this proposal, and this is trying to build on that. It can be quite challenging to do that. We can see the complexity involved in terms of gathering data, having different people in the supply chain and determining who is going to do what. It is not easy. It is a complex thing, but this regulation has set out a set of rules that are trying to achieve those goals, and we have to implement and enforce them.

Comment on this
Paul Daly An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fianna Fáil

I thank Mr. Flynn.

Comment on this

I was listening to the meeting earlier on the phone. If we went against this as a committee, could we stop it?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The EU regulation applies-----

Comment on this

I am asking a straight question. If this committee went against it, could we stop it?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Ireland has to implement this regulation and has to have the power of it.

Comment on this

Right, so we cannot stop it. Basically, we are a box-ticking exercise for this regulation. Is that where we are?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No, I would not say that.

Comment on this

We cannot stop it. If we felt that we did not agree with it, we could not stop it. That is what Mr. Flynn is saying.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The EU regulation is directly applicable in Ireland, so the rules-----

Comment on this

I want to be clear about what Mr. Flynn is saying. It is not a bomb question. If this committee decided that we did not agree with this piece of legislation, could we stop it, yes or no? I want a straight answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We cannot stop the EU regulation applying in the EU-----

Comment on this

All right. That is what I wanted to know.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

-----in terms of how we are implementing it or the provisions we have provided for.

Comment on this

I am asking this because I would like Mr. Flynn to elaborate on what this proposed legislation can do in respect of other things down the road that the member states would have to bring in without the need for primary legislation in their respective parliaments. I am thinking of peatlands in particular because they were mentioned earlier, but also of other areas.

Mr. Flynn probably has a house. If Mr. Flynn and I went into a bank manager in the morning to sign our mortgage, and the bank had written on it that down the road it could change the terms and conditions and do whatever it wanted with the house, would he sign it? That scenario would ask no more of us than this legislation does in respect of signing up to something stating - I was listening to Mr. Flynn speaking with Deputy Kenny earlier - that if the EU changes the goalposts, a member state does not have to put those changes in primary legislation. The Minister’s hands are tied, to put it simply. Is that not correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There are treaties and legislation governing how EU legislation applies.

Comment on this

In fairness, the question was asked by the other members. Will any changes come back to us so we can get a say in it? The answer is "No", so what we are signing up to now is this legislation that can move left or right or up or down. It can go on to some other area. The EU has the competence on it and we have no say. Is that fair to say?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It is subject to the EU process and the legislative process in the EU.

Comment on this

We have no say here as public representatives.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Well, I am not going to-----

Comment on this

Well, I am saying it. Could Mr. Flynn elaborate on the peat side of it regarding where the rules can move to or what can be done? Where are the goalposts? How far can these goalposts move out?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

In terms of forestry, the felling licence process is a whole process and that provides the conditions for when trees can be cleared or cut down or when there can be a change of use. As it stands at the moment, they are looked at on a case-by-case basis, including if there are environmental reasons to be considered. There can be case-by-case consideration of when replanting obligations can be different or can be changed as part of a felling licence process.

Comment on this

I will come back to what a previous speaker said about the definition. I heard sedge being brought up or the example of the farmers in the agri-climate rural environment scheme, ACRES, for example. A riparian zone might be closed off for five years. The owners might not top it. They do not have to top it. They can top it, but they do not have to do so. I am wondering about a case where the suckers of small trees or furze bushes started growing on land. I was listening to Mr. Flynn carefully, and he said it did not have to be forest specifically. I am talking about a situation where land became what we will call a rough area.

After five years, you go in with the digger to whip it out and you have cattle on it again. Going by what Mr. Flynn is saying, I would worry about this classification. That is where I am coming from on this. Would he agree that, under this legislation, sucker trees or furze growing that are not a planted forest but have become what we would call a sedgey area or rough bit of ground could come under this classification and you could be in trouble then?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It depends on the case in question. It depends on whether that is an established forest and if it qualifies as one.

Comment on this

Mr. Flynn said that it did not have to be an established forest. We all know that, with wind, you will see spruce shoot across seeds. When they start growing, you have suckers that are not planted. You also see odd bits of birch and stuff in bad ground. I am talking about boggy, bad ground. You see areas after about four or five years that have gone wild, to put it simply. Would someone be caught under this legislation if they did not keep their land constantly managed? This is the worry I have for the ACRES farmers.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Other wooded land is not covered by the EU deforestation regulation, EUDR. It is only forests, as in the definition of a forest, in the regulation. I would have to look into the detail of what the Deputy has described and whether it would qualify. I do not have that in front of me.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Flynn come back to me on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes.

Comment on this

This would be a worry for a lot of farmers, especially in the west, south west and many other parts.

The other issue is the traceability of timber. Am I correct in saying that, down the road, people who own forests will have to have a consultant or someone who will back up that their timber came from their village or wherever and show that it was not from an area that was cut down or went into agriculture from forestry, for example, the rainforest? What sort of a cost would be involved for the ordinary person in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The regulation has different people in the supply chain who have to do different things. The person first placing the product on the EU market - the first transaction - is where the heavy lifting is done, if you are not a small or micro provider.

Comment on this

What about if you are small and micro?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

If you are small and micro, you have a single declaration. If you are an Irish forest owner or Irish cattle owner, you have a one-off simplified declaration. That generates a number-----

Comment on this

Mr. Flynn mentioned cattle there. Is he saying that a farmer will have to say that their cattle did not come from where a forest had been cut down?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, that is what this regulation provides for.

Comment on this

Will every farmer have to do this?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. We have come up with a simplified approach. It is a one-off declaration, because these are all small and micro businesses. We are looking at developing a system to do that for the farmers and submit them to the EU system. We are using the AIM system and we have the traceability-----

Comment on this

If a farmer has peatland that they developed or shored, for example, on a mountain, and has cattle or sheep on that land, and the EU decides under the nature restoration law that that peatland would be better put in for rewetting, could the EU block them from farming that peatland if the farmer produces an animal and signs this declaration?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. This only relates to forestry and deforestation. This does not relate to the other issues the Deputy is talking about with wetlands, peatlands or rewetting. This only relates to forestry to ensure that land has not been deforested previously or turned into agricultural use when it was once a forest.

Comment on this

Just to make this clear because people need to know, once this is in, it will relate to forestry and a farmer will have to sign a declaration saying that the cattle they are selling have not come from where there used to be primary forestry that has since been cut down.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, where the land was not converted to agricultural use.

Comment on this

I would worry about that, because I hate signing a blank cheque. It could hop in your face.

Comment on this

It only goes back to 2020.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I would like to ask a few questions to ask, and then we will go around again if we want to.

Head 5 will allow the Minister to extend the legislation to peatlands, wetlands and grasslands by regulation. What criteria will be used before that power is exercised by the Minister?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That power would only be exercised by the Minister if it is decided at EU level that there is an amendment to the regulation that provides for those things.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Therefore, after this meeting today, and exactly as Deputy Fitzmaurice was saying, this could come up at an EU meeting and the Minister could agree with it. It could then come back to everybody who has cattle on their peatlands or whatever. That could happen.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

This regulation came through that process-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I do not know what farmer in this country would want a situation like that.

Ireland is classified as a low-risk country under the EU deforestation regulation. How much of a compliance burden will remain for Irish farmers and timber operators despite the simplified due diligence provisions?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Forest owners and cattle farmers are considered small and micro; they qualify under that heading. That requires a simplified, one-off declaration that their produce is not coming from deforested lands. The Department is developing a system to make that declaration on their behalf. We have the data already and are in discussions with the organisations. We are developing a system whereby we will be able to make that declaration. It is a one-off declaration, and that is the only burden for farmers and forest owners.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Will the farmer have to make the one-off declaration?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We are putting in place a system - we already have data on our systems - that we believe will comply with what is required for this one-off declaration. We would be able to do that on behalf of farmers and submit it to the EU system.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Bill provides for penalties of up to €10 million, or 4% of EU-wide turnover. How does the Department justify the proportionality of these sanctions, particularly for smaller businesses?

Comment on this