We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

General Scheme of the Deforestation and Forest Degradation Bill 2026: Discussion

Summary

Officials said the Bill gives effect to the EU deforestation regulation, with primary legislation needed to enable its required penalties; Ireland cannot change the regulation’s core requirements. The Department said Irish farmers and forest owners will generally face simplified reporting, while imports must be supported by due-diligence information and checked on a risk-based basis. Members raised concerns about complexity, replanting obligations, possible future expansion of scope and differences in treatment between private landowners and local authorities. No changes were agreed; officials undertook to provide further information on some questions.

Contributions 200–408 of 408. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Damien Flynn

Those provisions are in the regulation, so we have to provide for them. That is what is in the EU regulation.

As regards how this would work or come to pass, that would be the very end of a long process. We are talking about large companies here. In any event, that would have to be decided by the courts, which would have the discretion to apply penalties.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

So, there will be no penalty on a farmer. There cannot be. All I want is a "Yes" or "No" to that. Are we-----

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There are a range of measures within the scale of penalties in the regulation. There are different compliances depending on proportionality, so they are all provided for. The maximum is the one the Leas-Chathaoirleach read out there.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

What about when the Department wants to take the minimum? I am asking if this is another situation whereby a farmer could get a letter in the post to say the Department is fining them so much because of X.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. It would have to go through the courts system if we were to applying-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It has to go through the courts system. It is not going to be like any previous situation we have seen every single solid day - I am sure other members get the very same stories - with people coming out from the Department, going into a farmer's yard while the farmer is working and checking for compliance with building regulations or whatever, followed by a fine. Every single farmer in the country is getting fined. This is our day to ensure that farmers are not going to be penalised again.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There are a range of provisions on enforcement and compliance. Our approach here is about guidance and compliance; it is about making sure people are compliant. That is the approach we will be taking when we implement this. The Bill provides for an escalation process if there is persistent non-compliance, all the way up to the maximum of going through the courts and a range of potential court prosecutions, if the non-compliance warrants that.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The legislation can extend to peatlands, wetlands and grasslands. If that is the case, will there be fines for a farmer? Can there be fines for a farmer?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Those provisions are not in the EU regulation at the moment.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

There cannot be.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

For those specific elements the Leas-Chathaoirleach called out, fines are not provided for in the regulation. However, the regulation does talk about those potentially coming in the future.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes. What will happen then?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I do not know.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I know because I represent farmers day in, day out as part of my job here. I am telling Mr. Flynn that I am not having any hand, act or part in anything else being brought in to fine farmers. The other day, Department officials went out on an inspection. The Department looked at the planning regulations. All the planning application said was that the bin was supposed to be green. It was stainless steel. The person was fined €3,500. For God's sake, that is what we are discussing here. My job is to protect these people, and that is the job of everybody else in these Houses. The reason I am so vociferous about this is to make sure this is not creating another layer where the Department can fine farmers again.

What resources and staffing will the Department require to operate the authorised officer inspection and enforcement regime set out in heads 22 to 31?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The regulation provides for a certain level of checking, depending on the level of operators involved in having to provide the information. We will be doing that during our normal course of planning across a number of divisions. In relation to cattle or beef, for example, the cattle and beef division will take on that role and do the level of checks and controls that are required. In relation to other food products like cocoa and coffee, that will be built in.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will not be interested in those but we are interested in the cattle one. Here we are again. Whether Mr. Flynn likes to use it or not, inspection is the word that was used again. There is another layer added on.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

When I talk about the controls I am talking about imports. If imports of beef are coming in, there is a level of control that has to be applied in accordance with-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is all right. I am talking about what happens here.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The simplified declaration covers it all. Since farmers are small operators, the one-off simplified declaration covers farmers.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Head 40 exempts certain local authority developments from requiring a felling licence. What safeguards will ensure that this exemption does not weaken forestry and environmental protections?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Local authorities have different projects that they want to implement. They go through a full planning process, which includes the full rigours of environmental assessment. If trees have to be felled, that would be part of the environmental assessment that is done as part of that planning process. This provision would state that the local authority does not have to come back again and get a separate felling licence on its own lands for the felling of those trees because it would effectively be covered, having gone through the full planning process already.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

What is the position where a person has, say, five acres of forestry and decides to fell the trees and put the land back into grassland?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That would not be provided for. This regulation basically means that a person cannot do that.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That option is finished. That has been done in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It has been done in very small numbers.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It has been done. A farmer can do it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Only in relation to-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The forestry is replanted somewhere else.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Only in relation to cattle. It can be converted, subject to getting approval for a felling licence. It could be converted back to grassland for sheep, for example. This just relates to cattle specifically, or the other products, soya and cocoa, but they do not-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Stop talking about cocoa. We will not be growing that. I will give an example. Let us say someone has 10 acres of land in afforestation but they are sick to the teeth of it because trees blew down and everything like that. The farmer has had enough and wants to put grass into that land.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Land cannot be converted back for grass for cattle. If someone is rearing cattle on that-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is a huge part of this. We fleshed it out here today. That is gone now.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That is already the case.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

People can do it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Someone can apply to change the land use. There is a replanting obligation associated with that. If someone takes out 10 ha, they have to plant somewhere else, subject to going through the process.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Can that still be done?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It can still be done if the land is changed to grassland to rear cattle on it. That is the change.

Comment on this

Those ten acres of forest could be moved somewhere else on the land.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes. Someone could build a house on that land or do something else with it, provided they plant somewhere else.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Will they be able to do that? That is my question. People can do that at present and it has been done and is being done. When this Bill goes through, will that still be the case? Can someone apply to put that land back into grass for cows to graze? I will simplify it for Mr. Flynn. What is the answer? "Yes" or "No"?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. It is not the Bill that is doing that. The EU regulation does that.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

At the moment, people can do that.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

People can do it, subject to a number of conditions and on a case-by-case basis. It does not mean it automatically happens. It does not automatically happen.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That option is gone.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

A very small number of-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is gone. These are the questions that I ask on behalf of the people who put me in here to ask these questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

To be clear-----

Comment on this

What about land converted back into grass, where the farmer ensures no cattle go on it?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

You could not-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The farmer could put sheep on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

People cannot place cattle on the market from that land.

Comment on this

Technically, if a farmer took the fines, they could put it back into grass-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

What fines?

Comment on this

This only comes with what products are coming off it.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That was my last question for the moment. I will start the speaking slots again. The first speaker is Deputy Martin Kenny.

Comment on this

The meaning of forest is set out on page 7 of the draft scheme. It states that a forest has the same meaning in Article 20 of the European regulations, which means land spanning more than half a hectare with trees higher than 5 m and a canopy cover of more than 10%. The next part of it is the difficult part. It includes trees able to reach that threshold in situ, excluding land that is predominantly under agriculture or urban land use. The trees may not have reached 5 m yet, but they have the potential to reach that height. It is the kind of land that Deputy Fitzmaurice was talking about earlier on, namely, scrubland, where whins, sallies and that sort of thing will grow in it. Those will probably never reach 5 m. They are not going to be covered by this. I wanted to get clarity on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I did not have that definition to hand, but that is the-----

Comment on this

One of the fears farmers would have is this. As often happens, an elderly farmer might pass away and a large part of the land is left unfarmed for ten years or more while probate and so on takes place.

Comment on this

I know a farm in probate and it is being held up because of a dispute. If someone wants to go the route Deputy Kenny is talking about-----

Comment on this

If that happens, the land becomes overgrown. If a new person takes over and wants to clean up that land, will that person fall foul of this? That is the question I am asking.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The Deputy is right. That is the definition there. I did not have it to hand when I was asked earlier. That is the definition. It is the 5 m height and the canopy of 10%.

Comment on this

They would not fall foul of it, but they could fall foul of other regulations that are not here, which is what Deputy Fitzmaurice was talking about. I wanted to clear that up.

I raise the point that a person does not have to plant the same piece of land; it can be a different piece of land somewhere else. We often come across cases where a farmer has a piece of land that is forested beside him. It is then clear-felled and he approaches the people who own the forest and asks if he can swap a piece of his land of the same size for the clear-felled field. That can take a bit of negotiation, and some of us here have been involved in those negotiations. The parties can try to get a deal done because it suits the farmer and possibly suits the forestry people as well. Under this proposal, I am not sure if farmers would be able to do that anymore because they are tied to that one piece of land. Does Mr. Flynn know what I mean? Will it be possible for the committee to insert something here to allow that to continue? Mr. Flynn is shaking his head.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No. The basic requirement of the EU regulation cannot be changed. Those definitions are all there.

Comment on this

That is a problem.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

What the Deputy is talking about there is the felling of a piece of land and the replanting obligation going to another piece of land, which happens sometimes. It can happen for a range of reasons. For example, somebody wants to build a house-----

Comment on this

It can happen for logical and sensible reasons.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, it can happen for a range of reasons. The constraint here is in relation to putting it back into agricultural use, for cattle, whereby those cattle cannot be placed on the EU market. That is the additional constraint.

Comment on this

Could the piece of land be subdivided? Could the farmer decide to take 0.5 ha and plant it somewhere else?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Under the Forestry Act, the definition of a forest is different.

Comment on this

It is 0.1 ha, which is fairly ridiculous.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It is 0.1 ha and the felling licence fee still applies here. The definition of a forest here only applies to the EuDR regulation.

Comment on this

The other point, which was raised by a couple of people, was in regard to head 5 where it says that potential be put in place for the Minister to produce regulations for other relevant products or commodities but also to change to natural ecosystems like grasslands, peatlands and wetlands. There is a difficulty in that and a danger. I understand that maybe that is looking across the world and saying there are vast areas of bog in Latvia or somewhere, they are digging it all away and the EU wants to try to put a stop to that. However, the difficulty is that if that is going to apply to Ireland, we are going to have the Minister, through legislation here, signed up to or a pre-arrangement made that even before it is a regulation in Europe, we are allowing the door open for it here. There is a difficulty there. I ask Mr. Flynn to explain that. What I took from his previous explanation is that what we are doing here is leaving the possibility of that coming in here, free and easy, without anyone ever having a say in it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The Minister does not have unilateral power to change the EU regulation or to oppose those things, and that is not the intention of what is being provided for here. The intention of what is being provided for here is in relation to the possibility of, down the road, the EU making changes to the regulations. Any changes to these regulations are subject to a wide consultation process involving multiple stakeholders. If, however, changes are made to those EU regulations in the future, the Minister would have the power to implement those changes in that space. The Minister would not be moving ahead of the legislation. It is only if the regulation changed. The power here would only be used if the regulation was changed in the future at EU level.

Comment on this

While it would not be moving ahead of the legislation in Europe, it would be pre-empting the legislation. It would be putting the framework in place to have a regulation in Irish law before there is actually a European one to match it. That is putting the cart before the horse.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I will ask my colleague, Mr. O'Loughlin, to clarify the legal position.

Comment on this
Mr. David O'Loughlin

The basic purpose of that regulation-making provision is that we have here the four corners of primary legislation, a Bill that implements or gives effect to the deforestation regulation. Any amendments that are made to the regulation at EU level in the future could just as easily be implemented by the Minister under the 1972 Act as a statutory instrument, SI, without any recourse to the Oireachtas. What is intended here is to give the Minister a toolbox to deal with potential amendments to the regulation so that the entire EU deforestation provisions under Irish law are all dealt with under the same Act and that the regulations come from that instead of having an Act here, an SI there, another SI there and every time there is an SI made under the 1972 Act, we would have to amend the primary legislation to reflect that and reflect those penalties. Basically, without being too legalistic, it is a technical intention to keep matters neat in terms of implementation as opposed to giving the Minister any specific extra powers. In fact, if the Minister was to make regulations under head 5, or section 5 as it will be, without the equivalent legislation being in place at EU level, the Minister would be acting in a manner which is incompatible with EU law. Then we would have to deal with that issue. It is not really a case of giving the Minister carte blanche. It is, effectively, giving the Minister a toolbox to deal with developments at EU level if and should they arise.

Comment on this

That is fair. I have just one more short question. In regard to the changeover, the legislation says that the land has to be replanted. We now have provisions under the Forestry Act for agroforestry which is a halfway house, whereby trees are planted on the land but there is still some farming going on. Are there provisions in this legislation for agroforestry to be part of the reforestation? Degradation of forestry is basically a change to it. That is why I say that flexibility has to be built into this in some way.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That is something we need to look at and see whether it would qualify. The issue is what qualifies as degradation, as the Deputy has highlighted. We are still looking at that and at whether agroforestry could be considered to not be degradation of land. We will have to revert to the Deputy on that. It is something that will-----

Comment on this

It is an improvement from one end-----

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, but it is gone back from-----

Comment on this

Is it not an improvement in both ways?

Comment on this

We are here going through this but we actually have no say in it at all. On 17 July last, the Government approved the drafting of the Bill. Was there no fight-back from the Government on this? Surely it has a say in what goes on in Europe. Why are we in Europe at all if we do not have a say in it? What fight-back was there on this? The part that really worries me is head 5 because it relates to anything. The reference is to anything above 5 ha. As we know, when land gets handed down, sometimes it is not farmed exactly the same. Land can be rewilded but not on purpose. It is just that it is not in use. There is reference to a canopy cover of more than 10%. Is that more than 10% of the 0.5 ha? What does that 10% refer to?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I will start with the Deputy's first point about the EU regulation and us not having a say. Like any EU regulation, we are part of the legislative process. The Council is part of the legislative process and Ireland has its role in that. This regulation was first adopted in 2023 and through pushback, including by Ireland and other member states, it has been changed and amended to reflect some of the challenges that were arising, particularly around the implementation. For example, the change to the simplified approach for small micro-businesses or operators, which includes farmers and foresters, was very much part of that negotiation at EU level, to try to make the regulation more proportionate for small operators, especially EU producers. Ireland plays a very active role at EU level on this regulation and will continue to do so, as one of the 27 member states and as part of the legislative process.

On the canopy, I will ask Mr. Moore to respond to the Deputy's question.

Comment on this

The reference is to 10%. What does that mean? It refers to 10% of what?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergus Moore

In all forests we must have a definition of what a forest is and different member states have different definitions. A lot of the definitions are enshrined in climate change legislation. In Ireland, for example, in our Forestry Act we defined a forest as 0.1 ha and a tree crown cover of more than 20% of the total area or the potential to achieve this cover at maturity. The reason we went for a low definition for forest cover in our Forestry Act of 2014 was to ensure that all of the forests we have in our landscape are accounted for in our climate change commitments, as opposed to having those forests not being accounted for. When we say 20% of forest cover in our primary legislation under the Forestry Act, we mean that if one were to look at a forest from overhead, visually about 20% of that area should be classified as having trees growing on it. It allows for areas of no forest underneath to be also included in the definition of forest land.

Comment on this

That canopy cover does not include shrub. It is trees.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergus Moore

Yes, it is trees

Comment on this

It is trees of a height of 5 m or trees that have the potential to get there.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergus Moore

Yes.

Comment on this

Shrubs such as gorse can spread like wildfire.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergus Moore

Yes.

Comment on this

They would cover an area quite fast. This is what I am talking about; it is land that is not in use for a short time while it is being handed down. Plants such as these could cover ground fairly quickly. Is this going to be covered by the Bill? The way it is worded is very loose. This is why I am worried. People could get caught in something through no fault of their own.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergus Moore

In the Forestry Act, we have a definition of forest cover as being a 20% canopy. What the EU deforestation regulation is trying to do is come up with a definition that is applicable worldwide. Worldwide, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the UN has come up with another definition, which is the definition we have in the EU deforestation regulation, which is 10% cover. Deputy Newsome Drennan is right that 10% covers the trees but underneath that we have shrubs, hazel and lots of other forest plants and species growing.

Comment on this

They are included, then.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergus Moore

They are included but forest land does not necessarily have to have wall-to-wall forests. Forest land in itself has a feeling of forest when we walk through it.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that basically there can be trees or whatever but once there is a 10% covering, which shrubs will provide, it is counted as if there were trees, for the purpose of it. People are snookered. Seeds that are carried will have the potential. Deputy Kenny said they might not reach that height but they do have the potential to reach 5 m. We have trees popping up in places where they will eventually reach that height. We also have hedges popping up in places. The birds carry the seeds. People will get caught. Head 5 allows the Minister to change the Act with regard to other natural ecosystems, such as grasslands, peatlands or wetlands. People will be tied in. I would not want to be tied into it because at any point it could be changed and people do not know what they are signing up for.

I said that the Government had approved this, but it does not look like very much. It does not provide us any safeguarding at all. I get that there are fines but it is not the fines that worry me. It is the bit before the fines that ties us into this and we have no way out of it. That is the worrying bit, as is the fact that we do not have a say on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

On that point, the EU regulation is directly applicable in Irish law. That is the way EU regulations are applied. The regulation was developed and agreed at EU level and the Bill is to give effect to the regulation that applies. The obligations in the regulation apply in Ireland as they do in all other member states. The negotiation of it and how it came to pass happened at EU level.

Comment on this

Farmers' trust in the EU has broken down in recent times. We saw this with Brazilian beef. Speaking to farmers, we hear about the hoops the EU puts them through but it then lets Brazilian beef flood the market. We can see how people will have massive issues with this. Basically, they have no say in what is going to happen to them. It is as if their land is not theirs any more but the Government's land or the EU's land. What have we got ourselves into?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The objective of the EU regulation is to avoid deforestation and forest degradation for a number of strong environmental and climate reasons. This regulation is aimed at ensuring that any product put on the EU market does not contribute to deforestation or forest degradation, including products from third countries. That is the objective of the regulation. How it has been formulated was negotiated at EU level, and this is how the EU is approaching trying to achieve the objectives whereby the EU is not contributing by buying products that are produced on, or placing on the market products that are produced on, deforested lands or forest-degraded lands. That is what the regulation is aimed at trying to do.

Comment on this

Some of the terms in it are very loose and that is an issue.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will let Deputy Newsome Drennan in again later.

Comment on this

No, I will be leaving but I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach and I thank the witnesses for coming in. The legislation is very loose.

Comment on this

Was the Department involved in advising the Minister on the legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The Department advises the Minister and the Minister contributes to it.

Comment on this

I mean the forestry division.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

What advice did it give the Minister? Was it to support the regulation?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The regulation evolved and has a lot of provisions.

Comment on this

I am asking whether the witnesses advised him to support it or go against it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

When a regulation comes up at EU level, a decision has to be made.

Comment on this

A regulation is negotiated by the Council of Ministers. My question is whether the forestry section of the Department advised the Minister to go with it or against it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

In terms of voting on the regulation when it was passed, Ireland supported it.

Comment on this

The witnesses supported it. The Department might be well aware of a farmer who had a piece of ground and wanted to transfer forestry, and it supports this transfer being stopped.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The regulation has-----

Comment on this

"Yes" or "No"? It is a straight question.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The regulation has had lots of elements to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Deputy Fitzmaurice has called out one of these elements.

Comment on this

Yes, and the Department supported it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We have also pushed for lots of things to change in the regulation. We have also-----

Comment on this

Hold on. Let us look at what is in it that is a problem. That is supported. Am I right that the objective of the legislation was to stop the likes of the rainforests and places like those being cut down? Is that fair to say?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

It is to stop the EU contribution to it.

Comment on this

Someone here might want to plant somewhere else, which will still help the environment, but we are going to stop them from doing it. The waters are pretty muddy regarding an area owned by someone who dies, God forbid, and ownership is then in dispute for five or ten years, by which time it is covered. Then there will be questions to answer and let no one cod themselves. The Department supported this.

Will the witnesses tell me whether there is an open book on the change of peatlands and grasslands with regard to deforestation? I think "ecosystem" was the word used.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Wetlands.

Comment on this

Is that in relation to deforestation or the use of these grounds down the road? The gate is open and it does not have to come in through this.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The regulation does not apply on those lands at the moment or those land uses.

Comment on this

I know that. What I am saying is that the gate is open and the Minister's hands are tied from now on but there is a measure in the EU regulation regarding peatlands, wetlands and grasslands. These are the three that have been brought up. That is where I am very worried. What is it about these three types of land that power is being given to Europe under the regulation to change something in them?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Article 34 of the regulation states the Commission will assess the impact of expanding the scope of the regulation to other woodland and to ecosystems other than forests.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

That is what Article 34 of the regulation states but this would have to go through the full negotiation process.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

In Europe, yes. It is an EU regulation.

Comment on this

No one who is elected here or the farm organisations would have a say in it. And, by the way, the Department is supporting it. I would not have supported that legislation.

I am calling on the Chair, and I hope it will be seconded, to ensure that our committee will be put on the record as objecting to this.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister of State, Deputy Christopher O'Sullivan, would have to do that. It is a proposal coming from the EU.

Comment on this

I think the Department is selling out the farmers of this country by leaving an open gate. This is going to affect wetlands, peatlands and grasslands down the road. What will it affect? What is going on is the endgame. Look at the nature restoration law. It has nothing to do with this legislation, to be quite frank about it, but a side knife is being thrown in. I will say that the Department was always accommodating if a farmer had an equal type of ground that they wanted to plant where they wanted to make a bit of agricultural land out of it. Now, they can make agricultural land out of it, but they cannot put cattle on it because they cannot sign that declaration. That is what the Department has signed up to and recommended that a Minister sign up to. I think the Department is selling out farmers in this country with that legislation. It should never have recommended it. It should have told the Minister to oppose it. Or is the game that the west, the north west and the area that has the peaty ground and most of the forestry will definitely be hung out in the next round with new legislation?

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Department's job is just to introduce this proposal.

Comment on this

No, it advised the Minister.

Comment on this

It was done without any real farmers giving advice.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

No, the Department did not advise that. Mr. Flynn can come back in there for a moment, if he wants to. Please allow Mr. Flynn to come in to answer the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The Government decides how it is going to approach it.

Comment on this

What was the Department's advice to the Minister?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Look, there was a range of advice.

Comment on this

What was the Department's advice to accept the legislation or not? Mr. Flynn said earlier that it was.

Comment on this

Who signed off on that?

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Please let Mr. Flynn answer the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The Minister is the one who has the power to make decisions.

Comment on this

The Minister goes on advice.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

We provide all the information. He makes an assessment.

Comment on this

What was the advice? Was it to accept it?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There was a wide range of advice. The Minister makes the decision, on behalf of the Government, regarding whether Ireland will sign up.

Comment on this

Mr. Flynn made it clear to me earlier on in answering a question that the Department had advised the Minister. Let us be clear on this.

Comment on this

It would be the Minister, Deputy Heydon, who is over it. To be clear, the Department advised the Minister not to oppose this legislation.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

No, I did not say that. I want to correct the record if that is what I said. We provide advice to the Minister. The Minister decides whether Ireland should support something or not.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Were the stakeholders invited in? Did the Department talk to everybody?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes. This legislation would have come up regularly with stakeholders in discussions.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Department would have spoken to all of the forestry organisations and to all the farming organisations.

Comment on this

What about this committee? Why were we not informed?

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Department has all of that done, and all of those parties-----

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There was a wide range of stakeholder engagement on this regulation. That informed our approach, even when the regulation was passed initially, to looking for amendments to be made as well.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is Mr. Flynn saying that the farming organisations, and the forestry representatives, but mainly the farming organisations, agreed to the following situation? Let us take the example of a farm today, where a farmer decides to plant 30 or 40 acres because of his age and other reasons, perhaps medical or whatever. That land was good land. The farm is then passed down to a son, daughter, nephew or whoever it is and they want to farm that land. I thank the Department because that person could go to it, sit down and make their case for putting those 40 acres back into use as a platform for suckling, beef, dairy cows or whatever it is while replanting elsewhere. In fairness to the Department, it would agree to that. Today, though, with what we are doing, we will have to put in amendments to this proposal straight away to do that.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Let me just say this. As we speak, there is forestry on good land around Ireland. That is going to change. That is where we would say in any reasonable debate that we were open to this, but that will be closed today. I see all of the planning applications coming in for solar panels on good agricultural land. Will the same thing happen here? When that land is taken out, it will be taken out forever. This committee could not agree to that.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am looking forward to hearing what the farm organisations have to say. Mr. Flynn told us that there had been an engagement, but was there agreement on this one?

Comment on this

Which farming organisations were involved in that engagement? Which ones got it?

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Did they agree to this?

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzmaurice was here last term. Was there any engagement with the committee?

Comment on this

This really does affect farmers. It seems to me that whoever has made this decision, whether the Minister, Deputy Martin Heydon, or whoever, any farmer who has read this would have the cop on to know that they would not know what they would be signing up for.

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt Deputy Newsome Drennan, but ironically enough, a State body is exempted.

Comment on this

Surely be to God, a State body has to go through its own procedures. I was listening earlier and I heard the Deputy talking about councils. How come that bit for State bodies was able to be written into it? When farmers were transferring a bit of ground, the Department, in fairness, was always good at that. I will always say that. I worry about the peatlands. They are not in the provision now, but as I said earlier, it is like signing up for the mortgage and the bank saying it can do whatever it wants in ten years’ time, five years’ time or 20 years’ time.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I ask Mr. Flynn to come back in here.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

On the stakeholders, at the EU level, there is a multistakeholder group involved in this. All the farm organisations are part of that multistakeholder group. They would have been involved in how this regulation came to pass. All EU member states voted in favour of it. The European Parliament voted in favour of it. That is what happened with this regulation, just to be clear. That is the process. This proposed legislation is to implement an EU regulation that has to be implemented in Ireland. That is what this Bill means, just to bring it back to the Bill. It is to make sure that we can implement what is an EU regulation.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

If I can put it this way, we can talk all we like, but there are no amendments and no nothing. This has to come in by 30 December.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Well, on the substance of the EU regulation, and the obligations and all the requirements in the EU regulation, we cannot amend those. We are not in a position to amend them.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Right. What we spoke about as being the situation heretofore, where a farmer could sit down and negotiate with the Department about changing five acres here to five acres there, is finished.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

In a particular scenario, where we are talking about a farmer wanting to change it to agricultural use and to rear cattle on it, this regulation does prevent that.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The farming organisations agree to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I am not saying they agree to it. I cannot speak for the farming organisations and say they agree to it.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

No, but Mr. Flynn said they were stakeholders.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, but lots of stakeholders feed in different opinions on different things, and that comes in-----

Comment on this

What it is really showing is that the stakeholders' involvement is only a box-ticking exercise.

Comment on this

They are not ticking it.

Comment on this

The one part about it is that every country's department advises a minister. Let us be clear about how the game works. The Council of Ministers is the most powerful body in Europe. Let no one say it is not. Whatever Department is involved, though, if it is justice or whatever, a Minister gets the brief from the Department involved. There is no point in saying otherwise. You can say a Minister makes a decision. Generally, a Minister makes the decision based on what they are advised to do by their Department. We will be requesting all of the information that was handed to the Minister on this issue. I reiterate that we are opposing it. It has been seconded. I ask the secretariat to note that decision coming out of this meeting.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We can note it, most certainly, but we might not get it.

Comment on this

We should be able to get it.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It cannot be amended.

Comment on this

I want it noted that we are opposed to it and we all agree.

Comment on this

I just want to understand one thing. Who actually voted on it? Was it voted on by our MEPs or was it voted on just by the Minister? How did that happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

There are procedures in Europe for voting at the Council, so the European Council would vote on it and then the European Parliament would vote on it as well. They are the co-legislators for this regulation.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Are both of those votes over?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Yes, the regulation has been adopted since December and it was amended a couple of times. It was adopted originally in 2023. There was an amendment to defer it for a year in 2024. There was then a further amendment. The regulation that we are enacting now was adopted in 2025.

Comment on this

There was clearly not a lot of input from farmers, so.

Comment on this

I worry about what is coming down the line with the sidetrack. That has nothing to do with deforestation. The spirit of any piece of legislation was to deal with deforestation and now they have another room built on in the way that they can shaft farmers in ecosystems, wetland, peatland, etc. That is what they are doing and we have let it happen. The Department is saying that farming organisations supported it.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

I did not say the farming organisations support it.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Mr. Flynn did not say that.

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

Do not misquote me. There were stakeholder consultations.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Mr. Flynn said there were consultations and he does not know whether they supported it or not. Is not that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Damien Flynn

The farmer organisations definitely supported the simplification that we need in terms of the declaration, etc.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will have a meeting on Friday week. We will have to discuss this further. In fairness, the timeframe is short. No amendments can be put into it and-----

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

-----the members are very dissatisfied.

When you talk about deforestation, you talk about the Amazon regions. We are talking about a small island. We are talking about one particular thing that we were able to do, which was to move afforestation from A to B, and that is gone now. That is what the committee is very upset over today.

I thank everybody for coming here today.

Comment on this