Review of the Veterinary Medicinal Products, Medicated Feed and Fertilisers Regulation Act 2023: Discussion
The Department said the national prescription system was operating well, reporting major reductions in antibiotic use and asserting that farmers retained choice of supplier, though members challenged its market figures. Senators and Deputies raised concerns about falling sales, retailer and co-op closures, prescription costs, the viability of rural veterinary services and possible illegal supply; the Department acknowledged impacts but said it was constrained by legislation. The Veterinary Council supported prescription controls and professional oversight to address resistance, while Veterinary Ireland criticised the assessment protocol as weakening veterinary oversight and potentially threatening 24-hour farm care. Members called for clearer evidence on the economic effects and requested information on international audits; no resolution was reached.
Contributions 1–169 of 339. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No apologies have been received.
I will go through the note on privilege with the witnesses first. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard. They are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity.
Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from them.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against either a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members participating online in a committee meeting where their participation is from within the parliamentary precincts. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precincts. Any attempt to do so will result in the member having his or her online access removed.
As regards the agenda for today, the first session of today's meeting is to examine and discuss a review of the Veterinary Medicinal Products, Medicated Feed and Fertilisers Regulation Act 2023.
Our committee will hear first from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. We have with us Ms Caroline Garvan, Mr. Brian Leen and Dr. Noreen Galvin. Tá fáilte romhaibh. The Department's statement has been circulated and members have had the opportunity to read over it. We are returning to this question on the new prescription system. We want to examine the way the system is working, or not working, and the implications for animal health, veterinary practice, and farm and rural businesses. We want to get a more detailed focus as well on the competition and the choice that would be there for farmers in relation to their prescriptions and the dispensing of medication. We want to hear from witnesses about the opportunities and the challenges on that. Members are keen to ask about animal welfare, antimicrobial resistance, prescribing practices and the choice of vendors available to farmers, along with the operation of the process. We can take the statement as read but I will give Ms Garvan two minutes to go through it, before we move to a questions-and-answers session.
Comment on this
Our statement provides an update since we last met the committee, in June 2025. The big change has been the change in antiparasitics now becoming prescription-only medicines. As we outlined at the time, this was not only a regulatory requirement but also in the best interests of animal health and welfare because antiparasitic resistance is such a huge problem. To protect farmers' income and support animal health and welfare, antiparasitics were up-regulated to become prescription-only medicines.
The national veterinary prescription system, NVPS, has now been in situ since January 2025. As to where we are now, it is fair to say that, as a Department, we are very happy with the level of engagement we have with that system. We now have 98% of vets uploading prescriptions to the system. The system also allows for our farmers to select where they get their prescription products.
We are happy with the level of engagement by the retail sector as well. About 54% of the retail sector is now dispensing prescriptions on the NVPS. The huge benefit of the NVPS is the oversight we have of the use of veterinary medicines. It has shown a significant reduction in the use of antimicrobials, antibiotics, which has a huge benefit for animal health but particularly for human health. We have now seen a 40% reduction in the overall use of antibiotics since 2020. As regards this system, we have seen a reduction of 29% in the past year alone in antibiotic prescribing by veterinary practitioners. We have seen a 51% reduction in drugs of last resort in human health being prescribed by the veterinary profession in Ireland. This system shows to other member states that Ireland is now moving up the ranks in terms of best in class as to how we prescribe.
The last time we met the committee, the level of prescriptions on the system was quite low because it had just come into play. We now have 1.12 million prescriptions on the database. That is very positive.
In terms of the antiparasitics - and, obviously, we were all concerned-----
Comment on this
Sorry. That is fine. We are happy to take questions.
Comment on this
Táimid ag filleadh inniu ar an gcóras i gcomhair prescriptions le haghaidh beostoic. Bhí buairt ar na baill ar feadh i bhfad go mbeadh an córas seo ag cúngú an rogha atá ann d'fheirmeoirí agus go mbeadh srian ar dheiseanna leigheas a cheannach ó na comhlachtaí éagsúla. Mar sin, táimid ag díriú isteach ar an rogha agus ar an éifeacht a bheidh ag an reachtaíocht nua seo ar leas na n-ainmhithe, na bhfeirmeoirí agus gach éinne eile a bhaineann leis an gcóras nua náisiúnta um oideas tréidliachta.
Tosóimid leis an Seanadóir Daly.
Comment on this
I thank the officials from the Department for coming in. I will give them a bit more time. The two minutes flew. There may be more they want to add. I have just two or three things to say.
I know it is beyond anybody's control that the witnesses in this session are first in today. In an ideal world they would be last because I think there are issues from the other witnesses who are to come, both the vets and the merchants and co-ops, which we will probably need the witnesses here to address. Having read the other witnesses' opening statements, there are a couple of things to discuss.
We all get the European legislation. What was done had to be done in some fashion. Our derogation was over, end of story, and we are all interested in reducing antimicrobial or antiparasitic resistance, so those bona fides are genuine. However, one big issue we discussed at the time was the competitiveness within the market post legislation. From reading the opening statements of both sets of witnesses who are due after the witnesses here, nobody is happy. There are some damning figures in the licensed merchants' statement and, in particular, the co-ops' one. Over 70 licensed merchants have already surrendered their licence. We expect that figure to reach 200 or 250. That is a 63%, 71% and 58% sales drop versus 2025 from the co-ops. Based on those figures, competitiveness has gone out the window. This was a key issue. In the first documentation the committee received from the Minister, it was promised that an integral part of the legislation we would deal with would be competitiveness for farmers. It is the farmer we have to think of here.
Ms Garvan spoke about the reduction. Another issue we had at the time was the possibility of a bit of rogue trading over the Border. Does the Department have any documentation or proof that the gap being created by the reduction is not being filled by spurious product coming over the Border because of the legislation?
I quoted the merchants, but you can see that the vets are equally unhappy when you read their opening statement. How are we going to square the circle? We are back to square one. We did not achieve or were not given what we were promised here at the outset, namely that this would not affect the choice of farmers or the competitiveness when farmers buy antibiotics or antiparasitics. There are, perhaps, two and a half minutes remaining, so Ms Garvan might answer those questions and then continue with her opening statement. I will come back in again later.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for raising those valid points. It was always a concern the impact that this change would have, particularly on the retail sector and the loss of their businesses to rural communities and the farmer choice. We have two sets of data and we have clear evidence on the trends that are happening out in the field. We know that there are 611 licensed retailers currently in business. We are aware that 122 have ceased operation in the past ten years. We cannot say that they ceased because of this change. We have seen that 17% of licensed retailers have stopped selling veterinary medicines. That is what we know.
Comment on this
The figures I quoted, and I have to take them as I see them, have dropped since 2025, which is one year, and they specifically state that it is in the past year.
Comment on this
As I said, the figure we have is that 17% have stopped selling veterinary medicine. Some of them may have decided to stop as a result of the change because they were not selling a significant amount of product. Those are the figures we have. In terms of the competition and the supply chain, farmers can still absolutely purchase from wherever they wish, but we are seeing a significant change in the trend in the context of the market change, with 54% of overall sales of antiparasitics coming from the retail sector. That is 54%, and 43% is coming from the vets. We are using data relating to prescriptions dispensed, so this is actual product supplied. This is saying to us that the majority of the market share is still with the retail sector. That supports competition in the marketplace. We have also looked at sales data, which the other speakers will probably comment on. That has shown the trends. There has been a reduction in market share. We can see that the market share at the co-op level has dropped by 11%, that the market share at the licensed retailers has dropped by 6% and that he vets' share has gone up by 16%. It is really important to say that in August, September and October of this year, when we look at what product was dispensed, we can see that 66% is coming from the licensed retailers, be it co-ops or licensed merchants.
Comment on this
How does the Department correlate these figures? There is a serious discrepancy between them.
Comment on this
I accept that, but I can tell the Senator that we have real data relating to prescriptions that were dispensed at retail outlets. These figures are accurate. These are absolutely accurate because they come into a database. You cannot get this product without a prescription, and this is what the figures say, namely 66% of the market moving back into the retail sector. That is what the data say.
Comment on this
I would be very interested in the Department's figures, because they do not fit with figures we got from Department of agriculture earlier in the year. I refer, for example, to the fact that 711,000 prescriptions were issued up to June. That was just a snapshot. Some 94% of those prescriptions were being filled by vets, 0.5% by pharmacists and the balance of 5% by the licensed retailers. Those are the Department's figures from June.
Comment on this
From June of 2025, before antiparasitics-----
Comment on this
No, I think it was June of 2025 when we were last here.
Comment on this
No, the figures I have are from June of 2026 as supplied by the Department and the Minister through a parliamentary question.
Comment on this
That is overall prescription medicines. The vast majority of those are the antibiotics that are in the table. The antiparasitics are a much smaller subset, and that is what we are talking about today. The figures that I have in terms of prescription medicines relate solely to antiparasitics. These are accurate. My colleague Dr. Galvin oversees the system, and she has pulled these off the system. These are the data that come into us that are verified as being prescriptions, and it is verified that these products are supplied.
Comment on this
I will be brief, because my focus is going to be on the next set of witnesses. We did not have any say in who was picked to go first. Ms Garvan was just taken first. I want to focus on the review of veterinary medical products. This is an area that Ms Garvan has expertise in. For the record, will she report progress on four key measures, namely reducing the use of antimicrobial products, which is important, measuring the use of these products, reducing the use of antibiotics generally and encouraging responsible use of veterinary medical products. These are important matters. Will Ms Garvan give us hard facts. If she quotes facts and data, please tell us the sources. It is critically important, as we have seen from the previous engagement, that we have those sources, because we need to go back, follow up and validate. Our function is to question the integrity of the systems that are in place and the integrity of the information that is laid before these Houses. This is a serious matter in terms of engaging and giving information to the Oireachtas. It is all recorded and on our system. We must be conscious that what we are dealing with are actual hard facts. Ms Garvan might just touch on those four matters. If she wants, I will repeat them.
Comment on this
Ms Garvan has the measure of them. She might just share the information I have requested with us.
Comment on this
I just reiterate that we stand over the integrity of any data or information I have shared here today. On the reduction in the use of antimicrobials, the data we used comes from the sales data that Health Products Regulatory Authority, HPRA, submits to the European Commission every year. We will be using the national veterinary prescription system, NVPS, data going forward, but we just do not have enough detail in it yet. Anything I say here is based on the HPRA's external data and publicly available reports.
As I said earlier, we have seen a reduction in antimicrobial use of 40% since 2020. There was a significant reduction of 18% in 2024 and 2025. This shows the buy in, as members asked about, and the responsible prescribing and use by vets and also by farmers. This has not impacted animal health and welfare. Farmers are moving now towards better husbandry and better animal health management. It is a really positive message. When we go to Europe Ireland is commended on these reductions. The NVPS will highlight it even more from a human health perspective, which is why we are trying to address antimicrobial resistance in the first place. The drug of last resort when one goes into hospital has been reduced by 51% in veterinary medicine. We are not seeing those reductions in human health. What has been done in the animal health sector by vets, farmers, farm advisers, Teagasc and everyone working together is really to be commended. It is a really positive story. We have put a requirement into legislation to justify prescribing now. That is important because we do not want farmers using antibiotics unnecessarily . It is important that we have this justification to protect human health and animal health. This is a very good news story for Ireland.
Comment on this
That is an encouraging response. Ms Garvan is happy with that, and it is progress.
Comment on this
It is significant progress. We would be up in the top seven countries in Europe now in terms of our level of use. We really are nearly best in class.
Comment on this
Is there anything else Ms Garvan would like to say, given that she has a minute and a half left? Is there any other comment in terms of her own observations or the direction in which the Department is going?
Comment on this
Where the Department is going on this is building the leadership and momentum, but it is being delivered by the stakeholders. We have had very positive engagement, collaboration and co-operation on this. It is being delivered through various committees. When we get audited, or when there are others countries coming in, particularly third countries, they ask to see what is our level of antibiotic use. It is a really positive thing for trade and access to markets.
Comment on this
When other countries come in, they will ask for the level of antibiotic use in production.
Comment on this
Does the Department have any information from the last audit that it could share with the committee in relation to this matter?
Comment on this
I would not have it directly. I would have to go on to a different division.
Comment on this
Would Ms Garvan be able to do so?
Comment on this
That information she referred to gives us comfort that there is a stand-alone auditing system where international people are coming in and inquiring. It would be very helpful if we could have that information.
Comment on this
Other colleagues that would oversee those audits. We just feed into them, but they would have the reports.
Comment on this
I would really appreciate if the Department could send in that information to the committee.
Comment on this
I want to touch quickly on a matter that was raised earlier in relation to drugs coming across the Border or being bought online. What engagement would the Department have with the HPRA on this?
Comment on this
We would not engage with the HPRA. It would be our counterparts in the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs up North.
Comment on this
But it would be monitoring illegal or prescription drugs coming into the country, regardless of whether they were being bought on line or whatever. Would the Department be engaging with any outfit, the likes of the HPRA, about monitoring to see if people are buying prescription drugs online? What engagement happens ? Have people buying prescription animal medication been detected?
Comment on this
The first thing to say is that you cannot get antibiotics online. You cannot get prescription-only medicines online at all, except for antiparasitics.
Comment on this
People may be able to get them. Officially and legally, you cannot get them, but, potentially, yes. We would inform our colleagues in Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs on the basis of inspections. If we found product down South, we would tell our colleagues up North, who would then, if that product was supplied from a premises over the Border, carry out the inspection. However, if we find a product on a farm and if a farmer had it, it would be cross-reported for cross-compliance.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their opening statement. Veterinary Ireland states that approximately 30 vets are issuing 50% of the prescriptions for antiparasitics under the proper assessment protocol. Does the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine recognise this concentration, and does it suggest that the protocol is being used differently than intended?
Comment on this
I do not think we can determine the number of prescriptions that are issued. My colleague beside me is verifying whether those figures may be correct. The protocol allows these vets to collect certain information and to prescribe on the basis of a risk assessment if they deem the product is needed. That protocol was developed for animals that do not have clinical disease for which they can prescribe. That was provided for in legislation. The information that is collected justifies the prescription.
Comment on this
My next question is directed to all the witnesses. Do they think the protocol is doing justice?
Comment on this
The protocol was put in place to facilitate a competitive supply chain to ensure that retailers were going to still have access to prescriptions. At the moment, our perspective on the protocol is that it is operating well in that we are seeing nearly 55% of the prescriptions coming through retailers for antiparasitics.
Comment on this
Again, with the information I have, 30 vets seem to be taking over 50% of what is happening.
Comment on this
It is the choice of the farmer to go to the retailer and purchase through the retailer. That is being driven by farmers wishing to purchase through a retailer. Where they wish to purchase from is not something we can dictate to the farmer. The mechanism is there to allow them this choice.
Comment on this
Very good. Has the Department considered the impact of the proper assessment protocol on the long-term sustainability of 24-hour local veterinary services that farmers rely on for emergency call-outs, the likes of disease outbreaks, herd health planning and other issues?
Comment on this
Is this the impact of having a protocol in place on sustainability of veterinary services?
Comment on this
It has not been brought to our attention that it is having a negative impact at the moment, so we have not considered it.
Comment on this
The Department does not have any concern about it?
Comment on this
Having the protocol in place gives the choice to the farmers as to where they purchase from. As to market share, in terms of sustainability of veterinary practices, we would be looking at the economic impact on practices. What we are seeing is that the market share is settling out. At the moment, as I have said, sales from veterinary practices have increased in terms of antiparasitics because of the change. The long-term sustainability of veterinary practices will not be directly impacted by the change we have seen in the numbers, which are, if you like, the economic impact of this change.
Comment on this
If local farm animal veterinary practices become less viable as a result of the change in prescribing a medicine supplied, who does the Department expect to provide emergency out-of-hours cover for farmers if that is the situation that arises?
Comment on this
The out-of-hours cover is part of a veterinary practice service. Veterinary practices provide a clinical service and sell medicines. What we have done should not impact the financial viability of veterinary practices by making them prescription-only.
Comment on this
Is the Department hearing of any concerns to the effect that it may have an impact?
Comment on this
I cannot honestly say that this has been brought to our attention.
Comment on this
The feedback I am getting from other opening statements that I have read through seems to be that there is concern there.
Comment on this
Is this that the change of antiparasitics to being prescription-only is going to impact supply from veterinary practices?
Comment on this
Again, that is not what the data is showing us. The data is currently showing us that veterinary practices are selling more than they were in 2025. They are actually making more money on the antiparasitics. However, it is starting to revert to the way it was in 2025. The market is starting to go back to the way it was. That reversion should not impact the sustainability of veterinary practices.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. On that point, Ms Garvan is saying that it is starting to revert. From when was that data collected? What are we talking about?
Comment on this
From March of this year. In January and February, only about 10% of prescriptions dispensed were coming from licensed retailers. From March, it started to move from 45% to 66%. We are now pretty much back where we were before the medicines became prescription-only.
Comment on this
Does Ms Garvan not think people stockpiled before this came in?
Comment on this
A reduction in sales was seen in January and February. We suspect that there would have been stockpiling.
Comment on this
Anybody with a bit of cop on would have stockpiled before this came in anyway. I am looking at the figures of the Department. That is not what we are getting from other sources, which say that it is going to have an impact. It has had an impact on merchants. It is not as straightforward as going to a vet to collect the medication, whether it is wormers or antibiotics or whatever else, bring it home and that is it - job done. If you go to a merchant, you are asked a list of questions. It is a very complicated system for them. When this was coming in, the merchants should have been assisted financially to set up some kind of a system. We all want to keep our merchants because these are local jobs. It is important that we keep them in our communities. Let us face it, rural Ireland has not had the investment it needed and we cannot lost any more. I hear what Ms Garvan is saying, but I do not see how it is a fair system. Then there is the prescription charge. A lot more could have been done in the run-up to this to make it competitive.
Comment on this
We put the protocol in place to ensure that the retailers stayed in the supply chain. However, that protocol involves a vet who has never been on a farm prescribing for animals. They have to have clinical knowledge in order to prescribe appropriately. Otherwise, farmers are at risk of buying a product they do not need or will not work, which will have a negative outcome in the future in terms of productivity and profitability on their farm. I completely accept that this takes time. That is what we have seen. We have been carrying inspections since June. We were asked to wait. We gave a six-month bedding-in period in order that retailers and co-ops could get up to speed with what was required. It is about changing farmer behaviour. There will be a time delay.
On the protocol, there are specific software tools out there and in some cases you could get a prescription in a couple of hours but in the vast majority of cases you will have to go in the day before. If you want a dose on a Saturday you have to go in on a Friday. This information is key. Otherwise, you could be getting the wrong product.
Comment on this
What about the cost of that though? There is the extra cost of getting it from the merchant.
Comment on this
The cost is for a vet to use his or her clinical judgment and expertise to determine whether you need a product and to ensure you get the right product.
Comment on this
There is no charge for that prescription then.
Comment on this
There is no charge for a prescription then.
Comment on this
My understanding is there is a charge at the retailer for a prescription. Whether a practice-----
Comment on this
Yes. That makes it not competitive.
Enough about that. Ms Garvan mentioned the countries that ask the Department for the audits. Which countries are they? Are they third countries, European countries or what?
Comment on this
Both. I find that a little laughable when we look at the Brazilian beef we were bringing in which is completely different to our standards. I understand why this is done but we have horses and cattle at home. We know our animals. We have been giving them medication for years now. Ms Garvan is saying a vet has not seen the animals but I know, when I look at one of the horses, that they are wormy or they need copper. You know these things because you are farming every day. You know your animals inside out. Ms Garvan kind of says a little bit like farmers do not know their animals. When you have been farming for years you know what you are dealing with. There are a lot of bad actors out there and they are why we are in this situation. We are not getting rewarded for our good behaviour.
Comment on this
I am not saying farmers do not know their animals. I am saying these are prescription-only medicines that require clinical-----
Comment on this
Yes, and they were in every other European country until we changed our route of supply last year.
Comment on this
But Ms Garvan said we are doing better than other people. They had it before us, is that what she is saying?
Comment on this
The antibiotics have always been prescription-only medicine. Only the antiparasitics changed last year.
Comment on this
But other European countries were doing it so why are we better?
Comment on this
Thanks. It is a sad day in one way. Vets, co-ops and ordinary practices are being pitted against one another over legislation. We need every one of them. It is like a football team, you need a full back and a full forward.
This legislation has caused problems. How much has the system the Department set up cost?
Comment on this
Yes. What has it cost from the beginning up to now?
Comment on this
Okay. I remember four years ago I brought in an aspiring person who was trying to set up a system. It was Martin Blake we met at the time. That system, VetPal, is running now. A lot of places are using it. Statistics would tell you, from what the officials are saying there, that 70 to 100 are gone out of the system and there are predictions that more will go in the next year. That may or may not happen. Has the Department done an analysis? My understanding is when you buy antiparasitics, whether you buy 10 g, 20 g or 2 g there is a rebate on the bulk buy. If you lose a percentage of the people buying from you then there is no rebate. Has the Department done an analysis of who has lost the rebate because they are selling less stuff?
Comment on this
Why would that not be done so we would know what the overall effect is? Does Ms Gavan understand me? If you are getting a rebate it is money coming in. If you lose that and you are selling less then you are not viable. The Department should be doing an analysis with co-ops, ordinary persons and the vets - because this is not about one or the other or pitting them against each other. The officials do not know who has lost the rebate because they were 10%, 5% or 8% down. That 10% could put someone out of business. Do the officials understand my point? Why they do not do that or try to analyse that?
Comment on this
We would not be privy to that kind of information.
Comment on this
But does the Department not have to do an analysis? If the Department sees someone going does it not ask what the reason is and how much did they lose, so an informed decision can be put together? I will put it another way. Say another 100 go. Will VetPal be on the go then? Will it be able to sustain that? Let us say it went in the morning, though I hope it does not. First of all, the Department has given it no help and second if it goes, where does that leave the co-ops or the private operators that use it? It is gone and there is nothing. What is the Department going to do then?
Comment on this
We are very much aware of the service VetPal provides. We have met the retailers on this matter and we are giving it consideration because we understand the dependency there is that 90% come through VetPal. It is under consideration by the Department should an intervention be required in that regard.
Comment on this
My fear is what the Department would do if someone decided we are shutting this down because there are another 100 gone and it is not viable. Are the officials aware?
Comment on this
-----of the critical importance of VetPal in the business model for the retailers.
Comment on this
Okay. It has been thrown around but I am going to ask about it because there is no point in hiding behind the corners. Was a deal done before this came in about vaccines? How is it merchants are not allowed give vaccines? The smaller operators are not, is that correct?
Comment on this
There was no deal done around vaccines. The protocol that was put in place was to support the change in relation to antiparasitics. There was no change in relation to vaccines so it was deemed there was no need to intervene with vaccines.
Comment on this
Okay. If vaccines were to be spread out more, would it not make others more viable?
Comment on this
In our opinion the protocol is there for antiparasitics only and it requires a vet does not have to visit a farm. In order to prescribe vaccines as part of a herd health plan you have to have continuous and ongoing knowledge of a farm, of the management, of the biosecurity - of all things as well as just infectious disease. We do not deem a protocol where a vet does not have that real relationship with a farmer as being appropriate for the supply of vaccines.
Comment on this
I welcome our guests and thank them for their submissions. The three largest co-op retailers in Ireland have seen their year-to-date sales drop by a massive 63%, 71% and 58%, respectively, versus last year as a result of the new policy being enacted by the Department. That is staggering. Over 70 merchants have already surrendered their licence or left the category and it is expected it will reach 200 to 250 over the next 12 months. That is an even more frightening figure. I support Deputy Fitzmaurice's call for an analysis of what is happening and the impact on all those affected since the new policy was introduced. The bottom line is individuals and families are being deprived of a livelihood and are being forced out of their jobs and their business. That is wrong no matter what way you look at it. I have very serious concerns. I know people in my native county of Kerry who are under enormous financial pressures as a result of these measures introduced by the Department. Businesses in Kenmare, Killorglin, Killarney, Dingle, Castleisland and Cahersiveen - I could go on - have been hugely impacted. It should not be the business of the Department to put this pressure on established businesses and successful businesses, to be fair about it.
I believe that these small businesses in Kerry and throughout the country need assistance and support. They deserve our support and the Department's support.
Comment on this
The Department at all times has worked to engage with and support the licensed retailers as much as possible within the confines of the legislation. As Senator Daly mentioned, it is in everyone's interests that they became prescription-only medicines. It is particularly in the farmer's interests in terms of protecting animal health and welfare. Resistance is widespread. If we did not change them to prescription-only medicines, farmers would not have effective disease treatments. We would not have sustainable farming in this country without this change. We had to do the change. Then the Department looked to see what we can do to support the retail sector. We put in this protocol to allow retailers have an arrangement with the vet in order to get the prescription so that they could sell the product. That was the mitigant that we put in place.
It is really important to remember, however, that the benefit in this change is for the farming sector and agrifood sector. Yes, we are working to ensure that the impact is minimised, particularly on the retail sector. Again, I will go back to the real-time data on the prescription system. A total of 129,000 prescriptions are dispensed from retailers for antiparasitics. Of those, 100,000 are coming from the retail sector, or licensed merchants as we used to call them. A total of 29,000 are coming from the co-ops. The co-ops are being impacted more than the licensed merchants. What we have seen in our inspections is that the licensed merchants have worked very well with the system that Deputy Fitzmaurice referenced. The vet pass system is working on the retail side. Their market share is returning. It is the co-ops that seem to be struggling a bit. I am sure they will talk about that when they are here. They are the sector that we are seeing. Again, the overall drop in the market share was 11% for co-ops and 6% for the licensed retailer. That is just for antiparasitics. It is not in terms of their overall sales of medicines or overall business model.
Comment on this
I think we all want the co-ops, licensed merchants and vets to do well, survive and have their livelihoods. I fully understand what Ms Garvan is saying with regard to animal welfare. I cannot argue with her on that one. At the end of the day there is a human side to all of this as well. It is having serious consequences. Surely there is a better way. That is all I am saying. I do not know the answer. As I mentioned already, Deputy Fitzmaurice mentioned carrying out a review or an analysis. Maybe that is the way forward. We should look at it because these people deserve our support.
Comment on this
We understand any impact on a person's livelihood is very stressful, but we are confined by legislation. We are confined such that they had to change their route of supply. As I said, we have put in mechanisms to support them within the confines of the legislation.
Comment on this
As the time available to us for this session has expired, I need to bring this session to a conclusion. We will be bringing forward the next group of witnesses. We will suspend while the next group of witnesses comes in. I thank the witnesses for the information, for contributing and for their participation in it. We will suspend now.
Comment on this
I will start with privilege. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity.
Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.
I welcome the witnesses for this session. From the Veterinary Council of Ireland, tá fáilte roimh an Dr. Victoria Brownlee, Ms Niamh Hogan and Ms Aideen Neylon. From Veterinary Ireland, cuirim fáilte roimh Mr. Conor Geraghty, Mr. Donal Lynch and Mr. Finbarr Murphy, chief executive. Their opening statements have been circulated and the members have had the opportunity to read over them. I will give the witnesses two minutes to give the opening statements and then we will go into questions and answers. We will start with the Veterinary Council of Ireland.
Comment on this
The Veterinary Council of Ireland welcomes the opportunity to address the committee on this review of the Act. I am joined by my colleagues. Our key contributions today cover three areas. First is the responsible prescribing of veterinary medicinal products. Veterinary medicines are essential tools in the prevention and treatment of disease. However, their prescribing, supply and use must be informed by sound clinical judgement and appropriate professional oversight. This is particularly important in the context of antimicrobial resistance, which remains one of the most significant One Health challenges. The council strongly supports the principles enshrined in legislation that antimicrobials must be prescribed prudently and only where clinically justified.
Second is the importance of the client-patient-practice relationship. The Veterinary Council of Ireland has a binding code of professional conduct which requires veterinary practitioners to exercise their prescribing privileges in a prudent manner supported by appropriate knowledge obtained through the client-patient-practice relationship. Amendments were made to the code following the specific provisions for antiparasitic veterinary medicine products, but veterinary practitioners must still have sufficient knowledge to make informed prescribing decisions in all circumstances and in relation to all veterinary medicines.
Third, veterinary practitioners play a critical role in addressing antiparasitic resistance. There is widespread antiparasitic resistance in livestock in Ireland, and addressing it requires professional oversight and informed parasite control. Prescription requirements under the Act support a targeted, risk-based approach to parasite control, and veterinary practitioners are working with animal owners to develop prevention management strategies. The council supports a robust, proportionate and evidence-based framework for regulating prescribing, use and supply of veterinary medicines.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair. The implementation of the Act must be reviewed in accordance with the aims of the legislation. The primary aim of the legislation and its parent regulation, Regulation EU 2019/6, is to ensure that antimicrobial resistance is addressed by reducing the use of prophylactic use of antimicrobial products; measure the use of these products by species; reduce the use of critically important antibiotics; encourage responsible use of veterinary medicinal products; and deal with the up-regulation of antiparasitic medicinal products to prescription-only medicines following the Health Products Regulatory Authority, HPRA, decision to remove the derogation in Ireland. This included maintaining and facilitating all existing channels of supply to farmers once they had obtained a prescription for this category of medication. There was also an emphasis on the critical need to reduce the incidence of antiparasitic resistance, the increased incidence of such being the reason the derogation was removed. As outlined in Veterinary Ireland’s submission, since the formation of Ireland's national action plan on antimicrobial resistance, INAP, the veterinary profession has overseen a significant reduction in the usage of antimicrobials. The reduction in the usage of critically important antibiotics is even more impressive.
In its discussions with the Department of agriculture and in previous submissions to this committee, Veterinary Ireland highlighted that the costs associated with the introduction of the national veterinary prescription system, NVPS were significant and no assistance was offered to veterinary practices to implement it. Notwithstanding the costs and the logistical challenges, the NVPS has been fully implemented. As predicted by Veterinary Ireland, the free IT system provided by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine is only being used by 4% of vets, with 96% using third party software at their own expense.
The Minister inserted a clause in the Act to provide for a proper assessment protocol which allows a vet to prescribe outside the normal rules of the code of conduct of the Veterinary Council of Ireland, in that the vet does not have to have a relationship with the farmer or any knowledge of the farm to prescribe an antiparasitic. Veterinary Ireland finds this provision regressive, anti-competitive and a threat to the provision of 24-hour care to the farmers of Ireland. There can be no improvements made to the increasing problem of antiparasitic resistance when prescribing can take place without any proper veterinary advice. It makes a mockery of the act of prescribing.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Murphy. We will stay with five minutes and work back through the same list we had. Then we will see whether any time is left.
Comment on this
My first question is for the Veterinary Council. Will Dr. Brownlee expand on its management strategy? She said it has a management strategy for dealing with farmers. Will she give us a briefing on that?
Comment on this
I mentioned the role of the veterinary practitioner in engaging with farmers on prevention strategies. I might hand over to my colleague Ms Hogan to talk about it.
Comment on this
The Veterinary Council of Ireland advocates for an integrated, herd health approach to the supply of veterinary services. The prescribing of products is only one arm of the services provided by vets. The clinical skills we provide is another arm, as is the advice for which farmers value us across Ireland regarding risk mitigation practices and identifying areas on farms where changes can be made to improve animal health and welfare. Does that address the Senator's question?
Comment on this
Yes. To talk about animal health and welfare, there would have to be a site visit to a farm, which would incur a cost.
Comment on this
Yes. Vets working within a client-patient-practice relationship, CPPR, would not have to visit a farm on every occasion, but they would have to have an intimate knowledge of the management practices and operation of the farm.
Comment on this
Regarding dosing, can a farmer walk into a veterinary clinic and ask for a certain dose based on what he sees on the farm or does the vet need to do faecal samples or dung samples?
Comment on this
Vets working within a CPPR are charged with deciding what level of information is necessary, depending on each clinical presentation. It is down to each farmer, what the herd needs are, the history of the farm and what the weather has been like. It is very individual, according to the needs.
Comment on this
Going back to the co-ops, they have to have a licence to sell the medicines, but their sales were down 11% last year. Is it not the case that vets are trying to take over the whole system and do away with that function in the co-ops?
Comment on this
The Veterinary Council does not have any remit in the sale of medicinal products. We have control over the prescribing of said products but we are not responsible for the routes of sale, so I am not sure.
Comment on this
Is it within the veterinary practices?
Comment on this
Yes. The question might be more for Veterinary Ireland.
Comment on this
Ultimately, farmers decide which avenue to go down. Vets typically do not advertise products. Plenty of co-ops and certain categories of merchants advertise quite visibly. Farmers have to make up their minds which avenue they will purchase their antiparasitics on. There has been a sort of even split over the years, but the veterinary portion has probably been growing a few percentage points per year for the past ten years. That is probably down to more farmers valuing the advice they are getting from their vet. It could be that vets are becoming more competitive and so on.
This year, there was an 11% drop, to the end of September, in the sale of products into co-ops. We cannot answer how that happened because merchants do not seem to have that issue. It is an issue in the co-ops, the cause of which they have to identify themselves.
Comment on this
If I have to go in for a prescription and the vet has the product I want on the shelf, I will not go out again to a co-op 12 km down the road. I will take it off the shelf. That is the reality of the situation. Why would I drive around the country to a co-op when it is on the shelf in the veterinary clinic where I am?
Comment on this
More than half of the people who go into the co-ops and the merchants get their prescriptions under the proper assessment protocol, where they fill out the questionnaire and have the prescription filled by one of the vets providing that service for the co-ops and merchants. That was put in place by the Minister to make it easier for the co-ops and so farmers would not have to go the vet first and then back to the co-op. They can do it all in the co-op or merchants.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses.
As I said earlier, a long time ago, everyone was living in harmony. People could go wherever they wanted. In the vet or merchants, they could get their antiparasitic products. Now, when they need the thing, they need a vet, whether it is in the merchant or the veterinary practice. A vet has to write a prescription somewhere. We are hearing that what appears to be happening in places is that farmers go to a place that is not a veterinary practice. If they go to the vet and see their jeep outside, they will know the vet is there and they can shoot in, say what they want, the vet will write the prescription, the farmer gets the dosing and away with you. The problem we are hearing about day in and day out, and there is no point in hiding from it, is that people can go to a store and, as Mr. Geraghty said, fill out the form and they have to get a vet to issue the piece of paper. The vet may be there or it might take a few hours, so the person might have to go away. As Ms Garvan said earlier, it is like planning to cut a field of grass when fine weather is coming. Farmers nearly have to plan a few days in advance whether they go to a merchant or the other place to get what they want, whereas they can to go the vet on the day.
That is why. The facts speak for themselves. If 70 places have closed, including 11% in one and 6% in another, we know people went across the Border to vets to pick it up. Have the witnesses seen an increase in sales?
Comment on this
In Mountbellew, where I am from, I have not. All of our licensed merchants are still open. There is a co-op next door, as well as Greens, Maddens-----
Comment on this
I am talking about the situation countrywide. I know pretty well the area Mr. Geraghty has referred to. These statistics provided earlier are backed up by the Department.
Comment on this
-----and the 6% figures refer to wholesale data, to which we have access. The stuff is sold into various channels and some of that might still be on shelves. It is the only sales data we have from which to make a comparison from year to year. The pack sizes for antiparasitics were reduced by 11% until the end of September, which would indicate less of that was sold. That could be because of prudent prescribing or because it was sold prior to 1 January.
Comment on this
We had one of the finest summers ever.
Comment on this
Some years we had rain throughout the summer and people had to dose constantly, whereas people this year may not have had to dose as much because the ground was dry.
Comment on this
We do not know why the figures are what they are, but 11% fewer products are being sold. The financial data seems to show an 11% drop for co-ops and 6% for merchants, although the latest figures show an increase in the number of prescriptions being filled. We do not have those figures yet.
Comment on this
One submission states that vets around the country have received €25 million to upgrade computers or whatever. Is that value for money?
Comment on this
We received a 50% grant for a computer, up to a maximum of one computer valued at €3,700. In fairness, most bought computers for €1,000. The figure of €3 million is just one example. Every practice got one computer, half the cost of which was covered up to a value of €3,700. Computers are generally priced at a third of that. It was a help; one computer in an office to run an outfit such as ours is small enough. We, like VetPal, use private software, but it is a different company. Again, it is a very small market. There are only 435 practices and two actors. When that is split in half, it is similar to the number of businesses as VetPal has. Our IT costs increased significantly due to NVPS, which was entirely predictable. Costs for my practice are €20,000 more this year than last year. That is just the way it is. If something is regulated and people have to put IT in place, that will cost money. That has to be absorbed. Those costs are reckonable across all veterinary practices.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their opening statements. Most farmers will say that access to medicines is important. Access to a local vet in an emergency is also essential. Will Mr. Geraghty outline whether the current system will strengthen or weaken the long-term viability of farm veterinary services in rural Ireland? What changes may be needed to ensure they are viable?
Comment on this
The provision of large animal vets to farmers has been the subject of scrutiny in this committee a number of times. The last time we came before the committee we had Veterinary Council of Ireland data and I am sure the council will speak to that. The data showed that the number of vets involved in farm animal practice in the six years to the end of 2022 had reduced by 21% nationally, across all regions, not just west Donegal or anything like that.
There are 3,982 vets on the register at the moment. When I started, there were around 2,000. It is not a supply issue. There are nearly twice as many vets but fewer deal with large animals. There are more attractive ways of making a living than doing what we do, but ultimately we need to make sure we retain the ability to provide a service to farmers. In order to do that, we need to maintain all of our income streams. We are not looking to take over anyone else's; we want to maintain our own. The big fear when the Bill was introduced was the creation of a two-tier system of prescribing. One group of vets had to provide 24-hour cover and do everything, while another group did not have to provide any service or cover or have any of the costs but could still prescribe. The question for the Veterinary Council of Ireland is how to enforce a requirement on one group but not another. It is almost impossible.
The requirement for 24-hour cover is currently under review by the Veterinary Council of Ireland. In my expense, anything that was under review is never the same. That is our fear. Putting in the proper assessment protocol was a risk. We have not seen the results, but we will know how it will work out at the end of the review.
Comment on this
What are the views of the Veterinary Council of Ireland?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. On the out-of-hours consultation, the review was undertaken as part of a broader view of the review of our code of conduct. It is also an action in our workforce report. It involves a consultation and there has been a huge amount of engagement from veterinary practitioners and nurses. We received the data and the analysis is in progress. There are no findings from the data yet, but we will consult further. I will hand over to my colleagues to discuss what is required at the moment in terms of out-of-hours and emergency care.
Comment on this
Under the code of professional conduct, which is binding on veterinary practitioners, vets in clinical practice are required to make appropriate provision for 24-hour emergency care for animals that are under their care. This is an important professional application designed to protect animal health and welfare and ensure continuity of care, in particular where an animal requires urgent treatment or develops complications after treatment. It is important to note that it does not mean that an individual veterinary practitioner must personally be available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Emergency cover can be provided through appropriate arrangements with other veterinary practitioners or practices, and clients must be informed of that service when they sign up with a veterinary practice. The code provides that emergency cover should at a minimum be emergency first aid and pain relief. They are the requirements under the code of professional conduct with regard to 24-hour cover.
Comment on this
Is there any concern that may not continue, given the way things are going?
Comment on this
The council is obliged, under the Veterinary Practice Act 2005, to publish, maintain and review codes of professional conduct for veterinary practitioners. We have a code of conduct. A key obligation under the code is the provision of 24-hour cover. We are carrying out a consultation, but that does not necessarily mean there will be any changes to the code.
Comment on this
I want to focus on the Veterinary Council of Ireland. The witnesses have placed great emphasis on the Veterinary Council of Ireland's professional code of professional conduct and client-patient-practice relationship, CPPR, rather than the questions. The Veterinary Council of Ireland code of professional conduct is binding on all veterinary practitioners registered in Ireland and establishes the professional standards and governance for veterinary practice. The code requires veterinary practitioners to exercise their practice privileges in a prudent and informed manner, supported by the appropriate knowledge obtained through the CPPR.
Will the witnesses explain, from a disciplinary perspective, the ones that have failed and raised concerns about this practice? I want to hear, in very frank terms, how many people the Veterinary Council had to discipline or take disciplinary action against in the past 12 months in relation to the breach of code, which are either under investigation or have been investigated or partially investigated? This relates to the professional code that was referred to, which is in the witnesses' statement.
Comment on this
I am on track. I am on the statement that has been laid before us and read. I want to focus in on the code that the Veterinary Council has rightly emphasised the importance of. It is very important. How many investigations are ongoing at the moment in relation to breaches of the code talked about here today?
Comment on this
The council has a framework that deals with complaints. We received 60 complaints last year. Out of those, five were referred to inquiry, if that is the stat the Senator is looking for. They are mainly from members of the public in relation to the clinical care that is provided to their animals.
Comment on this
To tease it out and be more helpful, 55 were moved on. They were not deemed as warranting further investigation.
Comment on this
They did not reach that seriousness threshold.
Comment on this
Okay. That is great but there were five that clearly were serious issues.