Review of the Veterinary Medicinal Products, Medicated Feed and Fertilisers Regulation Act 2023: Discussion
The Department said the national prescription system was operating well, reporting major reductions in antibiotic use and asserting that farmers retained choice of supplier, though members challenged its market figures. Senators and Deputies raised concerns about falling sales, retailer and co-op closures, prescription costs, the viability of rural veterinary services and possible illegal supply; the Department acknowledged impacts but said it was constrained by legislation. The Veterinary Council supported prescription controls and professional oversight to address resistance, while Veterinary Ireland criticised the assessment protocol as weakening veterinary oversight and potentially threatening 24-hour farm care. Members called for clearer evidence on the economic effects and requested information on international audits; no resolution was reached.
Contributions 170–339 of 339. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When will those five be complete? What I am trying to get at here is that the Veterinary Council has impressed upon us the importance of its procedure and code, and I agree with that but we need to follow it on in practice. There were five people, veterinary practitioners in the Republic of Ireland, and it is alleged or suggested that they might have fallen short of the protocol. What stage are those five investigations at? It is important because these are the people on the ground who are the practitioners. We are talking about confidence in a system that has to be robust and beyond doubt. There were five, so what stage are they at?
Comment on this
Our business is to review the Veterinary Medicinal Products, Medicated Feed and Fertilisers Regulation Act.
Comment on this
Yes but that is it. These are the vets who are administering this. It is central to it. I did not introduce this. This is in the Veterinary Council's written statement before-----
Comment on this
It would only be relevant, I would imagine, if the five were related to the prescribing.
Comment on this
I can clarify that the five we have are not related to the proper assessment protocol or anything related to-----
Comment on this
I am sorry I have to take issue with the Cathaoirleach now. This was a statement that was laid before us. I am asking. There were five. It may warrant another-----
Comment on this
The Cathaoirleach seems to be getting quite distracted. I am not distracted. I am not one to be distracted. I am very focused. I come here reading my documentation. Dr. Victoria Brownlee has talked about; I have not talked about it. She has suggested it. I am happy to pursue it outside of here because, somehow, the Chair is suggesting I am somewhat distracted.
Comment on this
I have been told a lot of things and if there is one thing, I am very-----
Comment on this
I am very focused. The Chair is cutting in.
Comment on this
I will make the point that it is in the statement that is before us. I respect the Chair; I do not agree with him. In some way, he has sort of stymied my interrogation, which was always respectful. What I will do is submit a written correspondence to the Veterinary Council of Ireland. I will organise for a number of parliamentary questions to be asked through some of my colleagues in the Dáil. There are serious questions to be asked. The witnesses rightly talk about the protocol and they have confirmed that there are five cases, which is interesting and important. I will finish on this. It is important that we have confidence and trust in all our veterinary practitioners within this jurisdiction.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. I am going to say a couple of things and I will let them come back in. Veterinary Ireland is the vets' union, as such, and the Veterinary Council is the veterinary police. Who represents the 30 vets who have been quoted? Mr. Murphy said that allowing them to prescribe was a "regressive" action. Who represents them? I take it that Mr. Murphy is not happy with the protocol but everybody is on the record as saying they want equal opportunity for everybody involved in this sector. How does that happen without the protocol?
Comment on this
From our point of view, it is not equal. For 30 vets to prescribe half the product and 1,400-----
Comment on this
I am sorry for disturbing Mr. Geraghty. The protocol was introduced, and maybe it is not doing what it was meant to do, but it was introduced to try to make it equal.
Comment on this
I understand the point the Senator is making but if you look at it from the vets' point of view, they have to provided 24-hour cover, put vets on the road, and provide vans, insurance, equipment and all the rest of it. If you have half the product being prescribed by vets who are providing a service to farmers and the other half of the product is provided by 30 vets, then 1,430 versus 30 is obviously a higher cost to the veterinary practice sector. We would not view it as equal. If I prescribe stuff to a farmer, provide all his cover, cover him on Sunday nights, weekends, bank holidays and Christmas Day, and some other one can prescribe without that obligation, then it is not equal. To be fair-----
Comment on this
What is the solution then? We will try to be solution driven.
Comment on this
To be honest with the Senator, there is-----
Comment on this
If we remove the protocol, what is Mr. Geraghty's solution to this? I thought I would get back in after the Department. We are making light here of an 11% reduction. I am in business for the past 30-odd years. That last 10% or 11% of sales is what makes them viable because their overheads are the very same. If I get to the end of the year and I have to stop at 90%, I have nothing for myself. It is not just the 11% of the antiparasitic. You will buy the fish in the same shop as you buy the chips; you will not go into one and buy the chips and buy the fish in another. It is 11% or more of a reduction across the board for the merchants and co-ops, in all fairness to them. With that 10%, they are going out of business. If the company I was involved in had its sales reduced by 10% with the same overheads, we would be gone. The 11% cannot be made light of and if you do away with the protocol, I want to know what Veterinary Ireland is proposing in its place because they will definitely be all gone. They will be wiped out totally then.
Comment on this
Veterinary Ireland has not suggested here today or in our submission to do away with the protocol. The unfortunate part of it for us was the national veterinary prescription system, NVPS, was supposed to be there to level the playing field. All the expense we went through to put in the NVPS, with private software and all the upgrades and ongoing costs, was so that if a farmer got a prescription, it would go up in the cloud and he could fill it wherever he or she wanted to.
Comment on this
I am sorry to cut in on Mr. Geraghty. When he is talking about the NVPS, can he tell us why, at a cost of €9 million, only 4% of vets are using the one the Department introduced? Why is that?
Comment on this
If you had a trade stand and you had a free app here and one that costs money there, and 96% of people came to the one here, it is obvious-----
Comment on this
It is obvious that they found the only one that was practically workable in a speedy fashion and that they could do their work on. It was slicker.
Comment on this
It is another element of this that was got wrong.
Comment on this
It is very hard to do it without integrating it into your own systems but it does cost money. That is the reality.
If the NVPS was not here, and if we knew from day one that the protocol was going to be there for the merchants and co-ops and we were just going to be doing our own, we could have sent a monthly report to the Department with all the usage figures and it would not have cost us a cent extra. That is, I suppose, how this thing went on, because it went on for a so long. When we started, the NVPS was the solution. We were committed to the NVPS and then the protocol was put in on top of it.
Comment on this
In the 30 seconds left, has Veterinary Ireland a proposal to replace both of them if neither of them are working in Mr. Geraghty's eyes?
Comment on this
The fact that it is near enough half and half is where it is going to settle out. It has gone up to 66% for merchants and co-ops for the past three months. It has settled out. We do not want any more change. Every time something is changed, it costs us too much. What we need to do now is bed down but we need to preserve what we have and make sure we do not lose our 24-hour cover. If that happens, a large amount of practices are finished.
Comment on this
The witnesses are all very welcome. I thank them for coming in. I am conscious of time so I will go straight into questions, if that is okay. My first question is to the Veterinary Council of Ireland. How does remote prescribing fit with the rule that a vet should know the farm?
Comment on this
As part of our code of conduct, we have a client-patient-practice relationship, CPPR. It is establishes the threshold of knowledge needed for vets to prescribe and provide a clinical service and, as Mr. Geraghty alluded to, where the responsibilities for 24-hour care come into play. With the advent of the new SI, the proper assessment protocol replaced the need for a CPPR whereby questions were asked of the farmer and that was relayed to the vet. That is where the level of knowledge is gleaned in that scenario without the vet having ever been on farm.
Comment on this
Are the witnesses comfortable with that from an oversight perspective?
Comment on this
Our position is best practice is achieved through a CPPR.
Comment on this
Are there any changes coming to the rules on prescribing which the committee should know about? They are happy enough.
The council said in the opening statement it remains committed to working with the veterinary profession and relevant stakeholders to support responsible veterinary medicine use. What kind of engagement does it have on a regular basis with the various stakeholders?
Comment on this
As we just mentioned, we recently put out an engagement in relation to the provision of the out-of-hours emergency service. We received a lot of engagement. As was mentioned by Dr. Brownlee, our registrants replied in big numbers but so did the animal-owning public - farmers, pet owners and equine owners. That is one of our more recent ones but we do regularly engage with our stakeholders.
Comment on this
To Veterinary Ireland's experience on the ground, how serious is the shortage of farm vets? What would help?
Comment on this
It is difficult to quantify how serious the shortage is. A number of years ago, I would have said the majority of farm animal practices were advertising, looking for vets and could not fill the positions. That changes depending on the time of year. At this time of the year, there would not be the same shortage. We are seeing a growing migration of vets from the farm animal sector to other opportunities which could include companion animals, the Department of agriculture or providing services to farmers that do not involve out of hours. We see a growing challenge in recruiting people who are happy to contribute to the out of hours provision. That is not only getting out of bed at 3 a.m., it is also being available to calve the cow at 3 p.m. which is an emergency you have to fit in with your regular work. It is difficult to put figures on it because they have changed so much in recent years but over the past ten years, the labour shortage in farm animal practice has been acknowledged as one of the biggest concerns.
Comment on this
It is easier for a new vet starting off to get a 9-to-5 job in the Department. Is that Mr. Lynch's experience?
Comment on this
Not necessarily. One would think so but when you start as a new vet in a practice, for most of us who did veterinary, we did not do it because we were business orientated; we did it because of a love of animals. Most vets when they qualify want to do what they signed up to do. From a farm animal perspective, they want to calve cows and lamb ewes because that is a great experience. Anybody involved in farming and veterinary sees that. There is nothing better than sorting out a cow that is calving and getting a live calf out.
Comment on this
Even 3 a.m. The difficultly is as you move on in your personal life, things tend to change. A lot of us have children and families. As you get older, maybe getting out of bed is more challenging so when opportunities arise for you to move sideways out of a job where you have to be available 24-7, those opportunities may become more appealing.
Comment on this
How has the Veterinary Ireland found the new e-prescription system? Has the cost been an issue?
Comment on this
There is absolutely no doubt that cost has been an issue. Some of what was discussed earlier was the cost of the NVPS. There are several different aspects. The Department had to put in place a system to take in these prescriptions. We did not have a meaningful way of engaging with that without using third-party providers. A third-party provider, by the nature of any business, has to be sustainable. It costs a significant amount of money to develop, buy the licences and buy the IT for it.
Comment on this
My time is gone. I thank Mr. Lynch.
Comment on this
I will go back to 24-hour care. When are we going to get to the stage where that will be impacted?
Comment on this
We predicted the last time we were here a year and a bit ago that if there is a two-tier system, ultimately the unequal bit will become the norm. If there is a subset of vets not required to provide 24-hour cover, then obviously it will be hard to make that a requirement on the remainder. It has not happened yet but the requirement for 24-hour cover is under review now. It is at public consultation stage with the Veterinary Council of Ireland. We do not know how that will come out but generally, in my experience, things that go under review do not come back the same.
Comment on this
For suckler farmers, we depend on our vets and 24-hour care. Especially in the equine industry, they never foal during the day. We cannot survive without them. It is as simple as that. What can we as a committee do to assist in making sure that does not happen?
Comment on this
The key is veterinary practices are there to do veterinary practice. That involves seeing sick animals, certification, doing surgery and prescribing medicines. We would like to be left to do our bit and let everyone else do their own thing. We see a constant creep into areas that keep us viable and keep the service going to farmers to try to replace some of the costs others have, rather than allowing these costs to be absorbed of factored into the price of whatever service they currently provide.
Comment on this
Farmers definitely do not want to see a rise in the cost of vets either. We cannot take the hit either. It is about assistance.
We did not see the impact assessment or it was not done. A lot was said the last time around before this came in about how it was going to work and that nobody would be affected. The merchants are saying they are affected. At the end of the day, we do not want people using more antibiotics than they need. We saw that with the beef that was imported here. We do not know what effect that will have on our health when we end up going to the hospital. It more than likely will have an effect and there will be higher cost on us eventually.
Is there anything the Veterinary Council of Ireland would like to add? We have one group saying they cannot survive and everyone is in the same situation. We knew when it was coming in that it would be very difficult for the merchants. It is about trying to keep people in business as well and generally looking at rural Ireland. For me, it is probably easier to go to the vet because I am going for something else and I get whatever products I want there. Can I wait 24 hours if I decide today is the day to worm animals? Probably not. Is there a way we can make it fairer and an easier system? One does not want to outdo the good - vets have a relationship built on up on the farm. If you go to a merchant, you may be going to somebody who does not know you or your animals.
I do not know what the easy way to do it is. Do the witnesses have anything to add?
Comment on this
I can be brief. The council put together a workforce review report looking at the sustainability of practitioners on the ground, both nurses and vets. As part of one of those recommendations, the Department has been asked to look into what financial supports can be put in place to assist us in continuing to provide the vital services the Deputy outlined.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Hogan. The time available for this session has concluded. I am conscious that some members still have a number of questions they would like to ask. In private session, we will write down those questions and send them to the witnesses afterwards.
On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for taking part and for the information they provided. We will suspend the meeting while the next group of witnesses comes in.
Comment on this
I will quickly go through the privilege notice with the witnesses. Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings held by the committee of any matters arising from the proceedings.
The witnesses for this session are from Merchants Alliance Ireland: Mr. Ollie Ryan, Mr. Barry Larkin and Mr. Ray Doyle. Cuirim fáilte rompu go léir. The opening statement has been circulated. We will give the witnesses t two minutes to summarise it before we go to questions and answers from the members. I propose to use the same rota as earlier. Members will have five minutes and, depending on the number of speakers, we will see whether there is an opportunity for another round.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation. I represent Merchants Alliance Ireland, MAI, which brings together the Irish Co-operative Organisation Society, ICOS, the Independent Licensed Merchants Association, ILMA, and Acorn Independent Merchants, AIM. We represent the licensed merchants, co-ops and agri-stores that have supplied animal remedies to Irish farmers for generations. Our members are rural businesses that employ local people, carry farmers on credit through the season and provide competition in the supply of agriproducts.
We last appeared before the committee in June 2025, six months before antiparasitics became prescription only. We informed the committee of the expected financial implications if the Department did not amend the statutory instrument, SI, to include vaccines.
What was the committee promised? Since 2020, successive Ministers and officials have assured the committee that the regulation would not be anti-competitive in respect of the merchant channel. In 2020 and 2021, the Department promised an impact assessment. None has been published. In March and June 2023, the then Minister said the goal was to have no reduction in the number of outlets and to keep all current supply lines open, and that he did not want to see merchants and co-ops going out of business.
The Department's own figures clearly illustrate that its current policy is failing in respect of those intentions. Its first national veterinary prescription system, NVPS, newsletter reports that over 1 million prescriptions were in the system for its first 20 months. In that time, 320 licensed retailers dispensed prescriptions through it, and a single dispensing event is enough to be counted. A year ago, of 93,000 prescriptions, just 89 were dispensed outside a vet practice. Antiparasitics account for only 10% of all line items on that system.
We will go through where the sector is today. It is an uneven playing field. To outline what will happen next if nothing changes, I will hand over to Ray Doyle.
Comment on this
The committee has heard a lot of figures bandied around today, and we contend that many of them are flawed. I will just give the headline figures. I appreciate that I am out of time.
In the period April 2025 to September 2026, the veterinary channel sold or dispensed €260 million worth of product, while merchants and co-operatives sold €60 million. In the previous 12 months, the veterinary channel sold €200 million and we sold €70 million. Those are the stark figures that bear this out. Many of the other figures the committee has heard fudge the real issue. The real issue is that we are haemorrhaging market share for a product we sold for generations because of the change in the legislation. We are going out of business very quickly, given the number of merchants we have lost.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. For the record, perhaps I should have said during the previous session that Donal Lynch is my vet and Ollie Ryan is my merchant. My question is simply how the two of them can progress this issue on an uneven playing field, as Mr. Ryan put it. The submission was cut short. I need to hear both sides. I asked earlier what would happen if the protocol were removed. The end of the submission sets out possible solutions. Perhaps the witnesses would put a bit of flesh on those proposals from their perspective.
Comment on this
There are two solutions. The problem, which the Senator outlined succinctly, affects all farmers in Ireland, but especially smaller farmers. They are being denied a competitive outlet for products because of the protocol in place. There are only two solutions. A high-cost model that was not there before has been imposed on us. We have to employ vets to work with the protocol as endorsed and designed by the VCI and the Department, and they do so. We have to pay them for their services, and rightly so. That cost may need to be subvented because that is now a cost to us that we cannot pass on. As alluded to in earlier comments, farmers can simply go to their local vet and ask for the product. The private vet does not levy an additional prescription charge. We have to do so because we are employing these vets to write the prescriptions.
One of the options is a subvention on the prescription for us. As we outlined clearly in our submission, we get no subvention for the provision of veterinary services, whereas local private veterinary practitioners, PVPs, get significant levels of State funding for the provision of certain aspects of those services. We are not getting any of that funding. We are simply incurring the cost. The first possible solution, therefore, is a State subvention towards the cost it has imposed on us.
The second possible solution is to widen the range of products that registered vets can prescribe.
There has been great deliberation, particularly by Caroline Garvan, in this regard. There has been a fudging of the issue to say that it is an antimicrobial issue. It is not. We are talking about anthelmintic use primarily. Added to that is the use of vaccines. The greatest tool to driving down antimicrobial use and resistance is increased use of and access to vaccines. That is written into the primary legislation set from the EU, which this is transposed from. There must be greater access to vaccines. The addition of vaccines to the protocol and the employment of registered vets to write the prescriptions are the only two avenues we have to solve this problem and allow everyone to stay in business. Currently, we are going out of business much quicker than we predicted the last time we were before the committee.
Comment on this
There has been a lot of debate this evening - Mr. Doyle touched on it - about the NVPS and how it is not working or fit for purpose. The figures in the opening statement have been disputed. Does Mr. Doyle wish to flesh them out a bit more? We will need to go back, maybe in writing, to the witnesses who were in earlier to give them the opportunity to respond to what has been said here.
Comment on this
As I said, I completely dispute those figures with the Department. They are completely flawed in the way they have been portrayed today. There is a figure of 54% of the prescriptions for anthelmintic products coming from the retailers. That is because of the anomaly where the vet channel can retrospectively put up the prescription for the product, whereas we cannot. We cannot dispense the product until the prescription is issued. Therefore, of course, it is going to look like the retailers have more.
The NVPS is a work in progress, as was touched on today by witnesses from Veterinary Ireland. It was a car crash from the start in that it was slowly and incorrectly developed. Veterinary Ireland’s opening statement details how its members do not use it. Rather, they use third-party software providers, which has a cost. I agree with Veterinary Ireland for once that this cost has to be passed on or absorbed by someone. The NVPS is ineffective in its use and maybe not fit for purpose completely. It is getting there but very slowly, hence the questions I have regarding the flaws and information we were given.
Comment on this
For the purposes of the committee, where is Merchants Alliance Ireland at with the Department on this? What meetings or communication has it had with the Department on this since it was implemented?
Comment on this
We have had several meetings and our message has not changed from what I said to the Senator about there being two solutions. We have sought subvention for the obvious cost we have to absorb. More importantly, the increased use of vaccines is the logical use of the protocol for prescribing. It is illogical to stop greater access to vaccines by farmers if the Department is trying to be sincere about its intent on driving down the use of antimicrobials.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their opening statement. Merchants Alliance Ireland stated more than 70 merchants have left the category or surrendered their licence. What percentage do those 70 merchants make up out of the total number of merchants? Have they all ceased trading entirely or have they simply stopped selling animal remedies? Have many of them been taken over as part of the consolidation of the agri-retail sector?
Comment on this
I will answer that. It is anticipated that this group represents about 600 outlets, approximately 350 of which are engaged with the NVPS. If the Deputy does not mind, I will talk about the NVPS for a second. We are all questioning the NVPS figures. I have no doubt that the Department’s figures quoted earlier are accurate insofar as they relate to the NVPS, but I question the number of people who are engaging with the NVPS. This group is of the opinion that merchants have no choice but to engage with and dispense their product through the NVPS. Maybe that is why 54%, or whatever it was, of antiparasitic prescriptions are dispensed by the merchants. There is any number of prescriptions from the vet side that are not making their way onto the NVPS. Despite the Department’s claim that 98% of vets engage with the NVPS, I question the number of antiparasitic prescriptions getting onto the NVPS. To go back to the Deputy’s question, there are 600-odd outlets represented by this, of which approximately 350-odd are engaged with the NVPS. Therefore, that figure of 70 merchants represents about 20% of the businesses engaged with the NVPS and animal health. It is a significant amount.
Consolidation of the agri-sector does not tend to happen. Consolidation is not removing co-operatives, branches of co-operatives or branches of merchants. As explained earlier, if 20% of the income avenue of any business is taken away, it becomes unviable. If that happens in Cork, Kerry, Clare, Dublin, Limerick or wherever, that business closes down. Competition of supply is being removed. We are already working with our hands tied behind our backs. The challenges of a farmer getting a prescription fulfilled through a merchant have all been clearly outlined, but continuing down this road is anti-competitive and it will remove supply. Keeping the supply channels open was a key requirement of this regulation at the outset.
Comment on this
What solutions can the witnesses see to protect merchants?
Comment on this
One of the solutions is to add vaccines to the proper assessment to make smaller merchants more viable. It is a growing market. I always say that prevention is better than cure. In this case, science is with us. It would make an awful lot of sense if they were added to it. It would help with the viability of smaller merchants and keep them viable, especially the co-operative chain, which is seriously haemorrhaging business on this.
Comment on this
It is far worse than that figure of 70 merchants. It represents those merchants who have delisted from the Department’s system. There are maybe treble that number who have ceased trading but have not delisted. They have not bothered to delist in case something changes but they have, essentially, stopped trading veterinary medicinal products because they cannot afford the fixed costs that are now in place with writing prescriptions or the lack of footfall they are now getting. As was touched on earlier, farmers are simply migrating to where there will be no prescription fee or where it will be much simpler to get the product. That is what is happening. It is far worse than the figure of 70 merchants.
Comment on this
Over how many years has this been happening? We are saying it is 70 merchants, while Mr. Doyle is saying it is much more than that. Is that over the past couple of years or over the past 12 months?
Comment on this
It has only been impacting in the past 18 months. The speed of this has astounded us. The last time we were before the committee, we warned that this was going to happen. We anticipated it would take several years. It has happened in the space of, essentially, 18 months.
Comment on this
I can see it accelerating, as is borne out by the figures I provided in the opening statement. Three of the largest co-operatives in the country have had their sales decimated by between 50% to 70% in certain cases in the space of 12 months. That is a startling figure. It is not solely down to this issue, however. As was touched on earlier, it has been a dry year, etc., and there may have been stockpiling, but it is a frightening figure for merchants to remain viable if 50% of their sales are gone.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. From looking at this, veterinarians get funding from the Department for the counting of the eggs to see, basically, a sample for worms. The whole objective is to stop using as many antibiotics, wormers and so on. That is the main aim of the game. The spanner in the works for Merchants Alliance Ireland is that it comes at a cost to its members, yet the Department is funding the veterinary aspect. We are all working at the one goal, so why is there not some funding for Merchants Alliance Ireland on that end to make it a level playing field? What work has been done? What has Merchants Alliance Ireland done with the Department to try to make this a level playing field?
Comment on this
We have met the Department. Some of our engagement has been very good. There has been a lot of work in progress. We touched on funding. It is an uneven playing field at the minute because all of the funding for this industry goes towards the vet channel. Looking at our industry, including my own industry, we carry an awful lot of credit.
Since the introduction of the NVPS, the cost of running the prescription system involves an extra staff member. It is very expensive. We do need some funding and our solution is what I alluded to earlier, namely that if we added the vaccines to the proper assessment, it would give us a wider range of products, it would bring in more income and it would absorb a lot of the cost of employing extra staff members or the extra hours people have to work in order to make it work.
Comment on this
You would imagine that for smaller merchants, getting an extra staff member is huge whereas bigger co-ops can spread their staff around. Mr. Ryan said that the issue of funding was touched on. Was it stated that it will be looked at?
Comment on this
There has been no huge communication on this matter. As I said, our solution would have been to include products and that would absorb the cost.
Comment on this
Who has the Merchants Alliance Ireland said this to? Mr. Ryan is saying it here, but has anybody said that they will look at it or that it is workable?
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct. The central point of the legislation for the Department, farmers and everybody regarding anthelmintic resistance is that we should be seeing declining sales of anthelmintic products for the next ten years. We have been corralled into a product range that will decrease over the next ten years. This excludes vaccines, which everybody agrees have to increase in use in order to reduce antimicrobial resistance. The last time we were here we thought the powers that be had consigned us to a slow extinction of our business, but it is happening at a frightening pace. There is no solution other than a subvention of the prescribing cost or an increase in the number of products we can actually sell and retail under prescription, and, I might add, under veterinary supervision. It is not as if we are looking for something that will be deleterious to agriculture or farmers. We are looking to support them more, which is what we have always done.
Comment on this
On the impact assessment that has not been done, I presume Merchants Alliance Ireland has asked for it. Is it done but not reported or is it being undertaken? What has Merchants Alliance Ireland been told?
Comment on this
The impact assessment was requested about five years ago. The Department said it would do it and that it would be carried out. It was mentioned at this committee when we were first here two or three years ago. It was mentioned again last year but has yet to be delivered.
Comment on this
It has not been done. It is as simple as that.
Comment on this
We have been asked a couple of times whether it would make sense to carry out the impact assessment. That is not news to those in this room. It has been raised here three times before, like many of the other topics.
Comment on this
There are two categories of prescription-only vaccines. There is the category of vaccines prescribed by a vet and the category which are exempted from prescription but which are de facto prescription because are dispensed by pharmacies or vet practices. There are two distinct categories. The VCI referred to CPPRs. A pharmacist does not have to have a CPPR to issue de facto prescriptions for POME vaccines. There has been an inference that the vets we employ are dumbing down the VCI regulations or are acting like second-tier vets, which was indicated earlier. If this is the case, how come a pharmacist can effectively dispense and de facto prescribe a vaccine product but we are excluded from using vets to prescribe vaccines?
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. Would it be fair to say that in the view of Merchants Alliance Ireland the impact assessment is very important?
Comment on this
It would be, but it is almost too late now. It would have been good to have had it a couple of years ago before all the rules were put in place. The rules are in place now and we are living with the impact of what has transpired.
Comment on this
What is the magic bullet?
Comment on this
It has been mentioned a couple of times already. If we could increase the number of products that we could prescribe using our vets and dispense through our stores-----
Comment on this
Are the co-ops using VetPal or do they have their own vets?
Comment on this
It is a combination. Some of the smaller co-ops use VetPal and, perhaps, some of the larger ones use their own. It is a combination.
Comment on this
We would imagine that if they were all using the one system it would make it more efficient, rather than hiring a vet.
Comment on this
VetPal is used widely by the licensed merchants that are still in business. it is crucial for them. What we are concerned about is how viable VetPal is.
Comment on this
If the figures add up, and we do not know whether or not they will, and more people go onto the system that is there at the moment - in fairness, Ms Garvan from the Department has said it - the fear would be that it would be catastrophic if there was no system for the smaller guys and co-ops using it. Is that fair to say?
Comment on this
What engagement has Merchants Alliance Ireland had with the Department of late or over the past year to see what can be sorted to make sure there is a service there?
Comment on this
In fairness we met the Department recently and the main topic was VetPal and its viability. There is concern in the Department and there is great awareness of how vital it is to our channel. Without VetPal we are gone and it is over. Our fear is that the cost of running VetPal is not viable. Ultimately, what will happen next is that the cost of the prescription will go up. With that will come unforeseen circumstances whereby smaller merchants will realise that it is not viable for them. If the cost of a prescription on VetPal doubled, it would put an awful lot more small merchants out of business. There is concern in the Department regarding addressing this issue.
Comment on this
To cut to the chase, and I do not know whether the committee can make a recommendation to the Department, am I correct in saying that if someone buys a lot of stuff, no more than for someone in another businesses such as oil, there is a rebate? If less is sold then the rebate will not come back. The witnesses agree that this is correct. We have to do analysis to know what the big problem is. This must be root and branch analysis, which would mean that those who went out of business and those who are still in business would have to show their books, and show that basically the trade is not there. To put it simply, there should be no hiding when trying to prove a point. The Department needs to do this. It is not something to be done over a year; there should be full analysis. The committee can talk about proposing it and seconding it or whatever in a private meeting. This committee does not have legal powers so there is no point in saying we are magic.
In fairness to the Department, it has talked about the system that is there and it is aware of it. We will give them a bit of space on this.. We need to find out why some vaccines cannot be provided. I do not fully understand this. Farmers can administer a vaccine up the nose of a young calf if they get that vaccine in the chemist. I do not know why we cannot try to stabilise the whole thing. I do not want vets, merchants and small operators pitching against each other because of legislation. As I said earlier, we need everyone. I heard the earlier debate regarding vets, small animal practice and 24-hour cover. A doctor does not have a choice about treating a baby, an elderly person or a middle-aged person, or about treating a head, a toe or a nose.
The three ladies who were there said that we should put forward a proposal where veterinary practices should not get to decide that they treat dogs and cats, but no big cattle. That is my honest opinion, and we should be looking at that. I thank the witnesses for their time.
Comment on this
The message is quite clear from what the witnesses are telling us. Will they give us a breakdown of the fixed costs they incur when it comes to licensing and the vets' prescription fees?
Comment on this
VetPal was introduced last January. The first cost you have is your prescription. You have to get a prescription now.
Comment on this
It is €3.50 a line. It can average between €10 and €20. The second one is the most important one. It is staff time and the amount of work that goes into making sure that the proper assessment from the farmer is correct. There are a lot of costs in that.
Comment on this
Have the witnesses done a costing on it?
Comment on this
For me, it is one extra staff member. I had to take on one extra person to do it.
Comment on this
On a given day, how many prescriptions would Mr. Ryan put through his practice?
Comment on this
I cannot give the Senator a straight answer, but roughly speaking, it could be between 50 and 100 some days, but between 30 and 70 would be the average.
Comment on this
Is there a seller's licence fee on that as well?
Comment on this
There is a subscription every month for VetPal. We have to pay that. It is €600 a store per year, so we have that cost as well.
Comment on this
Yes. It is all cost. There is a lot of cost.
Comment on this
What I am taking out of this is that if merchants got the vaccines and could sell them as well, it would spread out the load and the dilute the costs because if they have another product on their shelves, it would alleviate some of the problems. Merchants Alliance Ireland has had discussions with the Department of agriculture. How far on are those discussions? I would love to go in reverse order and bring the witnesses from the Department back in to answer questions but unfortunately, we cannot do that. Can we be truthful on how far they have gone? We need to know where we are at.
Comment on this
We have asked for this since this started in 2019. We said that it was the only way it would make financial sense to keep all the players in the business. The Department's stated intention is that it wants to keep the actors in the business and to create the maximum amount of availability for farmers; as is ours. We are not seeking to undermine or put the veterinary channel out of business. We are seeking to ensure our viability on this. That is where we are with this. The discussions with the Department have continually been around our need for the addition of a certain level of vaccines; not them all. Someone touched on it earlier; the POM vaccines are split into two divisions. It is as simple as this; we are not even asking for access to them all. We are just asking for a certain portion of it, so that it would be possible for our veterinarians to write and dispense them. At the end of the day, the vast majority of farmers will continue to buy their vaccines from their PVP, but the farmer needs choice, and for those farmers who want to avail of the choice with us, they should be given it. That is all we are saying. However, at this moment in time, the Department is refusing.
Comment on this
Merchants Alliance Ireland is asking for the market to be left competitive and for the Department to give farmers a choice
Comment on this
Exactly, and the Department is refusing. It wants it maintained as it is.
Comment on this
Regarding the NVPS, will the witnesses elaborate on that? They said that some veterinarians are not uploading onto the system, yet merchants have to upload everything onto it. Will they elaborate on that?
Comment on this
Again, it was touched on earlier. There may be valid reasons for it because they have their software company that is integrating with the NVPS and there may be an issue in certain practices. There may be very good reasons for it but we need to get to the bottom of it. That is what is happening in practice. We have to upload before we can dispense. I am not saying all the time, but that is not the case in some veterinary channels. The farmer can go in request the product and the prescription can be validly put up a number of days later because it is provided for in the legislation.
Comment on this
Do merchants have to put it up first before they can administer it?
Comment on this
Mr. Doyle mentioned the figures of €200 million and €70 million at the start. Can I get those figures again because they are important?
Comment on this
The figures run from April to September in both years, and up until September 2026, €260 million euro worth of product was dispensed or sold through the veterinary channel. There was €60 million sold through our channel. In the 12 months previous to that, 2024-2025, there was €200 million sold through the veterinary channel and €70 million through our channel. Their channel has gone up by €60 million. There are very good reasons for that. There are extra vaccines being sold as a result of bluetongue, etc. Again, we are not comparing apples with apples which is always a problem with figures, but what is an apple with an apple comparison is our figure from €70 million to €60 million because there are no vaccines currently in it. We are asking for the possibility that vaccines be added to that protocol, and we can have a sporting chance of maintaining what we are currently doing.
Comment on this
We are here to get solutions and we have worked very well together. I hope that a resolution is found between the merchants, the Department of agriculture and Veterinary Ireland and that the vaccines, or some of them, are added so we can then move on and everyone can have a fairer playing field. That might be a way out of this.
Comment on this
In the time remaining, I propose that Deputy Clendennen take a talking slot and the remaining be split between the standing members.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Chair for accommodating me and I welcome the witnesses. There are two Offaly men, so it is good to be in their company in the room. The disadvantage in terms of competitiveness is one thing but there is a geographical inconvenience for farmers here as well in relation to where there have been delistings. Is that a fair point?
Comment on this
Yes. The Deputy is talking about parts of rural Ireland where there was a merchant and now there is nobody, such as down the west coast in Mayo and in other parts. One of our members who is not here today, Terence O'Shea, says that there is a huge area in Kerry that is not being covered at all. It is a huge loss when a small merchant goes.
Comment on this
From a farming perspective, is that a risk if a farmer does not have easy access to the product?
Comment on this
In terms of delistings, the witnesses referenced 70 so far, and that is ahead of pace. What do they envisage by the end of 2027 in terms of delistings in this area?
Comment on this
You could put a pin in a dart board. We do not know. We are astounded by the speed of what has happened,and if it remains as is, there could be several hundred, and I am not being sensationalist in saying that.
Comment on this
In relation to the turnkey costs of those merchants that have decided to delist, the witnesses mentioned the prescription line, staffing and so on. For those smaller merchants who have had a problem around viability, what is the floor in terms of an estimated cost to be able to provide this service? I am talking about the bottom-line turnkey.
Comment on this
How long is a piece of string? There are the staff costs. The smaller merchant now has to dedicate staff to make sure that the information required to give the veterinary to write the prescription in the first place is compliant. Mr. Ryan alluded to it. He has an extra staff member involved who does nothing else. A small stand-alone merchant now has to take a large amount of time to complete the protocol to just potentially dispense or sell an anthelmintic product and the number of sales is decreasing anyway. It is almost impossible for me to give the Deputy a figure. All I can say is the figures are borne out with the number of them who have ceased trading and delisted completely with no intention of returning.
Comment on this
The witnesses mentioned the formal review and the impact assessment and the hesitancy and lack of progress on the part of the Department. What do they think its concerns are in relation to carrying out that assessment?
Comment on this
I think Mr. Larkin alluded to it earlier. It is after the horse has bolted. This should probably have been done two or three years ago. We know now where we are at. The assessment is now that there will be a mass exodus of rural merchants and the future does not look great for a lot of them. A lot of smaller merchants are one-man shows. There is one man running the office or the shop and the whole lot and a guy in the yard. That is a lot of places. With the cost and the time they have to engage in VetPal or the NVPS, it is just not viable for them. It is important to highlight that.
Comment on this
Are there any costings on what a potential subvention to support merchants would cost?
Comment on this
It is very difficult to quantify. It depends on the level of turnover of animal health within a business. For example, it could be 20% of the turnover in a business in Roscommon and €10,000 might cover the IT cost but in a business in west Clare, it could be 50% of the turnover and it might need another staff member, so that is €50,000.
Comment on this
What I am getting at is what does a package look like in relation to support of a potential subvention in terms of an ask of a Minister for Finance in a budget? I am conscious of time and I do not want to overindulge but-----
Comment on this
I would go as far as saying that if an analysis were done on the cost of the IT systems required by a merchant and on the number of scripts required and their cost, there is the answer, more or less.
Comment on this
In terms of priority, should it be a State subvention, a range of products or the introduction of vaccines? Is it an either-or scenario or should there be a priority among those three?
Comment on this
If a State subvention were provided on an ongoing basis it would be wonderful, but an increase in the range of products would be the first ask because then we would know where we are going. We are not asking for anybody other than a vet to prescribe these products. A State subvention would be welcome but it is about how long it would be provided for.
Comment on this
People want to live and work without it.
Comment on this
I have a couple of questions I will be proposing, as Deputy Fitzmaurice was saying, at a private meeting. They are for the VCI and the Department. I will throw one in here. I do not want to throw a curveball but the Act's title is the Veterinary Medicinal Products, Medicated Feed and Fertilisers Regulation Act. How is the fertiliser register working out?
Comment on this
The Senator is right; it is a curveball. That is a significant cost and headache for co-ops and merchants to administer at the moment and it is ongoing. The number of unintentional errors that have to be corrected in the database is causing a headache at the moment. We are very concerned, no more than the NVPS, that when the final version is worked out there may well be some errors there that might cause problems for farmers that were not intended. Mr. Larkin might want to comment on this.
Comment on this
It is an unfair and unreasonable ask, without any financial subvention, on any merchant trading fertiliser. It is a huge administrative burden. There is constant engagement with the Department of agriculture to correct problems that have arisen in the previous month. Farmers are also very annoyed that their data is not absolutely correct all of the time. The Department might give a different idea that it is going well.
Comment on this
Is there a problem with the rebate? The €40 per tonne people will get back will be based on that. If Mr. Larkin is saying there are issues with it, will it cause problems for farmers in getting that money back?
Comment on this
It is likely to be the case that the farmers have had a chance to look at their 2025 data. The Department of agriculture extended the deadline. It looks like moneys will be given on the amount of fertiliser within the farmers' agrifood remit. The easy response from the Department of agriculture will be that it gave time to fix it. Will it come back on top of the merchant? If it is wrong, it probably will.
Comment on this
Suffice to say the merchants did not come out well from this Act.
Comment on this
For the committee, for fertiliser, if we look at most EU legislation it is now taking out the small men. Even if we look at the big bodies, be it Irish Water or whatever, they want to be dealing with four or five contractors and that is it, goodbye. The same is happening with EU legislation. The guy in the local shop down the road who was selling 500 tonnes, 800 tonnes or 1,000 tonnes, where you went with the fertiliser spreader and threw in a few bags, is being blown out of the water because they do not have the resources. No one seems to see this. In fairness, we can kick the Department all we want but this is EU legislation.
Mr. Doyle will love me for this question. It was said that at the moment the vets probably have an advantage. Let us say that there was some sorting out of the vaccines issue. How can the other side be balanced? It is like two people sitting on a see-saw. With the likes of calves, for example, it was well-known in parts of the country that you had to buy the calves in a certain place. You had to buy the milk and the meal off them. You had to do everything, so you were tied in. We are sort of throwing it at the vets now that you are tied in. How can it be balanced to make sure that it is a level playing field for the small guy, the co-op and the vets? This is where we need to get a balance because I do not like some of the stuff I saw down through the years, where people basically had to stick with one thing. We see at the moment that if people are sending milk in places they basically have to buy the nuts and buy everything off them and they might get extra money for the milk if they do that. I do not like those types of things where people are snookered, to put it simply. How do we make sure we keep that balance right?
Comment on this
I would prefer to call them incentives rather than a penalty.
Comment on this
To be fair, it is as simple as this; competition solves everything. In all the submissions I have made at this committee that is all I have ever sought and that is all the co-ops seek. There are so many co-ops, private merchants and veterinary practices around the country there is more than enough competition to ensure fair play. Even some of the incentives that the Deputy touched upon with one of the co-ops, that in itself had good and bad years because of the price of calves, meal and everything else. That was because there was sufficient competition in the marketplace from plenty of co-ops and merchants. I am here today representing the co-ops and here are, for want of a better phrase, the two counters to that. They will ensure that no co-op will be allowed to create a monopoly on any one farmer in particular.
Comment on this
The issue of fertiliser was touched upon. I see a lot of fertiliser coming in to the co-ops at the moment. I believe it is forward bought. Is that the case?
Comment on this
Some co-ops do take the option to purchase forward but not every co-op does. It is a bit like buying feed ingredients for their mills; some co-ops will and some will not. Again, it is an individual decision they might make or take an informed financial decision on.
Comment on this
I have seen a lot of fertiliser coming into Ireland in the past weeks. Does this give us an indication that we are expecting some global catastrophe and that fertiliser will get scarce? Is there something happening on the world fertiliser trade market or something out there that we should know about?
Comment on this
Not at all. It is just that a significant amount of fertiliser needs to be moved. It is a logistics problem really. Some 40% of the fertiliser for next season is in the country by the end of January and that needs to start happening now. About 80% is in by the end of April.
Comment on this
Is 40% of it already in the country?
Comment on this
No. It starts coming into the country by about the end of January. We are talking about a couple of hundred thousand tonnes of fertiliser, so that needs to start happening. We will see a lot of fertiliser being moved in, as we said. That is for next season. From the people I know, it has nothing to do with a world catastrophe or anything like that.
Comment on this
The cost of fertiliser at the moment is X. If the price on the global market goes down, who sustains that?
Comment on this
Market equilibrium will have to come into play. For people looking to buy fertiliser the price is totally dictated by gas prices. In the middle of summer, the price of gas was around 170 pence a therm and in the last couple of weeks it has increased to 250 pence a therm.
So, if you did not buy at an elevated price of 170 pence per therm and waited until now, you are going to have very expensive fertiliser, but who knows what is going to happen next spring? As I said, it is a logistics challenge. You have no choice but to bring it in now and see what happens in the spring. Who is going to sustain it? Ultimately, the farmer sustains everything really.
Comment on this
The farmer sustained the cost of increased price of prescription, increased price of animal health products and the lack of availability of animal health products.
Comment on this
The time available to us has expired. If there are other points the witnesses want to raise, they are welcome to send them on to the committee. The committee will be meeting in private later in the week, when we can discuss them in further detail.
Comment on this
I propose that we meet to discuss the things we have talked about.