Welfare, Treatment and Traceability of Horses: Discussion
Contributions 1–195 of 402. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am not and so I will not be participating if that is okay.
Comment on this
People should be aware that there are no audio files of Teams meetings. However, there is no guarantee for members that the meeting will not be recorded by somebody else in error. Members participating from outside Leinster House are advised that they cannot participate when they are offline.
Before we begin, I bring everyone's attention to the notice on privilege. Witnesses giving evidence within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that they have a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. They should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard.
Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse comments should be made against an identifiable third person or entity. Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside of the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts and may consider it appropriate to take legal advice on this matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses, outside the proceedings held by the committee, of any matters arising from the proceedings.
The purpose of the meeting is to examine the welfare and treatment of horses and their traceability. I welcome Mr. Michael Sheahan, deputy chief veterinary officer, One Health, One Welfare; Ms Frances MacAodhain, principal officer, animal identification and movement division; Dr. Avril Hobson, senior superintending veterinary inspector; veterinary and public health policy division; and Dr. James Choiseul, Department of Agriculture, Food and Marine; Ms Suzanne Eade, chief executive officer; Mr. John Osborne, director of equine welfare and bloodstock; and Mr. Jason Morris, director of strategy, Horse Racing Ireland, HRI; and Mr. Denis Duggan and Dr. Sonja Egan, head of breeding, innovation and development, Horse Sport Ireland.
I will allow witnesses from the three organisations five minutes to read their opening statements and then we will proceed to questions and answers. We will start with the Department, followed by Horse Racing Ireland and then Horse Sport Ireland.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman for this invitation to address the committee on the topic of the welfare and treatment of horses and their traceability. I am joined this evening by my colleagues, James Choiseul, Avril Hobson and Frances MacAodhain.
The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine takes its overarching responsibility for animal welfare policy in Ireland and for the welfare of horses most seriously. I welcome the opportunity to demonstrate our ongoing commitment in this regard. The committee’s request to discuss this topic with reference to equine traceability is also welcome. Traceability is an important component which supports animal health, animal welfare and the integrity of the food chain. I can share with the committee the ongoing efforts of the Department, in parallel with the wider EU approach, to improve traceability in the equine sector.
I am conscious that our discussion is framed by the recent RTÉ programme and the shocking and distressing footage that was broadcast showing appalling mistreatment of horses. The public reaction to the scenes broadcast has understandably been one of universal revulsion. The Department shares this view and condemns any mistreatment of horses. As I have said elsewhere, the footage was some of the most sickening I have ever seen. The Department has commenced an investigation into these matters with the support of An Garda Síochána and we can assure the members of the committee and the general public that the full force of the law will apply to those responsible.
It is understandable that scenes like those broadcast prompt people to question how this happened and whether the Department, as the regulator, should itself have identified such activity. This is something we have been reflecting on quite a bit since the programme.
Unfortunately, despite making very significant progress in the area of animal welfare over recent decades, ill-treatment of and cruelty to animals continues in our society. The Animal Health and Welfare Act 2013 was and is very progressive legislation. The Department has in excess of 200 officers authorised under the Act who, during their work, carry out welfare inspections around the country and are out on the ground every day, providing advice and support to the keepers of animals. Members of An Garda Síochána and the Customs and Excise Service are authorised officers, and under a service level agreement, inspectors of the Irish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, ISPCA, Dublin Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, DSPCA, Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board, IHRB, and Rásaíocht Con Éireann are also authorised under the Act. Local authorities are also empowered to appoint authorised officers under the Act.
Authorised officers regularly carry out inspections and investigations, and work towards ensuring the welfare of animals and legislative compliance, with interventions ranging from advice to warning and legal compliance notices. When necessary, legal sanctions are imposed and prosecutions are taken when other efforts to ensure compliance have failed or there is blatant disregard for an animal’s welfare. Since the Animal Health and Welfare Act came into operation in March 2014, 162 individuals have been successfully prosecuted. This figure includes 18 equine-related prosecutions. A number of other investigations are ongoing.
In 2021, the Minister, Deputy McConalogue, launched Working Together for Animal Welfare, Ireland’s Animal Welfare Strategy 2021-2025. This is our first stand-alone animal welfare strategy, and it reflects the significant animal welfare commitments in the programme for Government.
The Department is committed to supporting the welfare of equines and provides support to a number of urban horse projects nationwide. This gives effect to the programme for Government commitment to develop additional urban horse welfare programmes, working with local authorities, charities and community stakeholders. These projects have proven very successful and are aimed specifically at equine welfare and marginalised communities. The projects can foster community leadership and education in responsible horse ownership.
These projects greatly benefit the welfare of equines and of young people from disadvantaged communities or backgrounds. From 2015 to date, a total of more than €1.86 million has been spent on urban horse projects by the Department, with €350,000 allocated for these projects for 2024. I am familiar with a few of those projects.
In particular, I had the opportunity to see the Moyross project in Limerick and the Cherry Orchard project in action. I was very impressed with what I saw in both of those over recent years.
Last December, the Minister provided some €6 million to support the work of 101 animal welfare charities. Of this, €3.3 million went to 24 organisations that have activities that directly support horse or equid welfare. This funding recognises the importance of the role such charities play in education, awareness raising and the dissemination of knowledge to improve animal welfare. The supports provided to these organisations help with actions focused on preventing poor horse welfare outcomes. Prevention is better than cure. However, the work of these charities and our own officers shows that there is still much work to be done in better ensuring the welfare of animals across our society. For example, of the 1,609 animal welfare complaints received by our animal welfare helpline in 2023, 635 related to horses. All of the complaints that come in by phone or email are followed up by our inspectors.
With regard to the specifics highlighted on the "RTÉ Investigates” programme, members of the committee will now be aware that the majority of the recorded footage took place in a building adjacent to, but not part of, the approved Shannonside slaughter plant. This holding is separate from the Department-approved slaughter facility where the Department had a permanent presence during the day on which animals were being slaughtered. This is usually one day per week. This building was not the slaughterhouse lairage where the Department inspected and carried out its ante mortem checks on the animals being presented for slaughter. It was not subject to the specific regulations that govern slaughter plants. However, it was subject to general animal welfare regulations that apply to all holdings where animals are kept. We have asked RTÉ to provide the Department with all footage and any other evidence it may have, and arrangements for the handover of the footage are in train. As you would expect, we are getting full co-operation from RTÉ. The events witnessed are now subject to a live criminal investigation and I can assure members that the investigation will be thorough.
It may be helpful to the committee if I explain in detail the controls that are applied by the Department at the slaughterhouse. The Department staff in the slaughter plant take their responsibility to protect the food chain and ensure animal welfare extremely seriously and carry out their official controls as required under food and feed hygiene law. On the day of slaughter, Department staff, including a veterinary inspector and at least two technical officers, attend the plant from early morning. One technical officer carries out hygiene checks in advance of slaughter. The veterinary inspector and other technical officer, with the assistance of an employee of the food business, undertakes a detailed ante mortem examination of each horse on an individual basis. This involves: scanning the horse for a microchip; cross-checking the microchip with its identification document or passport; checking the markings of the horse against the passport; evaluating the age of the animal; checking the medicines page of the passport to ensure that the animal has not been excluded from the food chain; cross-checking the microchip against the central equine database to ensure the animal has not been excluded from the food chain; checking and evaluating the food chain information provided by the animal keeper; and finally undertaking a veterinary assessment of each animal from an animal health and animal welfare perspective to determine its suitability for slaughter for human consumption.
If the animal passes all ante mortem checks, it moves forward for slaughter, at which time post mortem examinations are carried out by a veterinary inspector, samples are taken for trichinella testing and, where relevant, for checks for residues as part of the national residue control plan. Further checks on the microchip are carried out and the piece of the carcase in the neck area in which the microchip is located is removed and sent for destruction. Further verification checks on age may be performed at this stage. If all checks are passed successfully, the carcases are passed for human consumption. If any checks fail at any stage, the carcases are rejected, excluded from the food chain and sent forward as animal by-products.
Turning to the overarching issue of traceability, our equine traceability system operates within the requirements of and is fully in compliance with EU law. In recognition of the importance of traceability to equine health, equine welfare and the integrity of the food chain, the Department has placed significant focus on improving equine traceability in recent years. There has been a number of significant advances over the last ten years, including the introduction of a central equine database in 2013 and a range of improved security features on equine passports in 2014, such as holograms, etc. In 2014, the Department made it a legal requirement to register all premises where equines are kept, so we now have a register of approximately 29,000 premises where equines are kept. In 2021, the first equine census was carried out and this was repeated in 2022 and 2023. There is now a portal to check the validity of equine microchips or passport numbers, and that was launched in 2023. Also in 2023, the Department provided and made available significant funding to the passport-issuing organisations to support the development and introduction of e-passports, which will help to simplify the updating of information relating to the movement of equines. It is an initiative we are very supportive of.
The Department acknowledges that our work on equine traceability is far from over, but these developments, particularly the ones relating to technology and e-passports, will continue to move equine traceability forward. Notwithstanding all the improvement and advances, the “RTÉ Investigates” programme prompts us in the Department to critically examine what more needs to be done. While the appalling abuse of animals witnessed is clearly a national issue, the questions posed about the robustness and effectiveness of the EU traceability system, which is considered among the best in world, is a broader issue. It is clear that we need to work with the EU Commission and other member states to further improve this system.
The EU fraud and food network was due to have a meeting today and I can confirm that meeting took place. A number of us attended and contributed to that meeting. We can give an overview of what happened at the meeting later, if time allows. Considerable progress has been made over the past decade at national and EU levels in tightening up on equine traceability, and I have outlined some of those measures. The recent programme has shown us and our EU colleagues that we need to do more, and we will. Again, the meeting today highlighted that this is a problem in a number of EU member states. There is a fallibility of the system when criminals are determined to beat it.
Considerable progress has also been made over the last decade in dealing with the significant unwanted horse problems we had. The scale of the unwanted horse problem, which is a significant factor underlying horse welfare issues, is now considerably smaller than it was a decade ago. The number of stray or abandoned horses seized by local authorities has fallen considerably over the past decade, from just under 5,000 in 2013 to approximately 400 in 2023. There are a number of reasons for this very significant decrease in unwanted horses, but at least some credit must go the various horse welfare organisations which have done great work in helping to reduce indiscriminate horse breeding, which was a major cause of the problem. The welfare groups, supported by the Department, have worked to educate horse owners to try to steer them away from indiscriminate breeding, but they have also provided very practical support, by organising subsidised horse castration clinics, often with subsidised horse microchipping and passporting as well. These initiatives have had a real, lasting and positive impact on the unwanted horse situation in this country. While I emphasise that the scale of the unwanted horse problem is a lot less than it was, I am conscious that there are still plenty of problems with unwanted horses. I am familiar with problems in Tipperary, Limerick, Cork and elsewhere. It is not that the problem has gone away, but the scale of it is a lot less than it was.
I hope that I have given members of the committee an overview of the Department’s activities in support of horse welfare and the improvements in equine traceability. I will conclude by restating the Department’s commitment to improving horse welfare and traceability. We are determined to take whatever lessons we need to from the RTÉ programme and use this as a catalyst for positive change for how we regulate horses in Ireland. We would be happy to answer any questions.
Comment on this
I am very grateful for the opportunity to meet with the joint committee this evening to discuss the topics of equine welfare and traceability. Joining me are Horse Racing Ireland’s director of equine welfare and bloodstock, Mr. John Osborne, and director of strategy, Mr. Jason Morris. As members are aware, HRI is a commercial semi-State body responsible to the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine and was established under the Horse and Greyhound Act 2001.
HRI is responsible for the overall administration, governance, development, and promotion of the Irish horseracing industry and we proudly do so on an all-island basis. Ireland is seen internationally as a leader in horse racing and breeding, and thoroughbreds that are owned, bred and trained in Ireland compete at the highest level on the world stage. We have seen several examples of Irish success abroad this year. Irish-trained horses prevailed in two of the world’s greatest races, namely, the Derby and the Oaks at Epsom. An Irish-based trainer, Willie Mullins, became the first non-British-based trainer in 70 years to win the UK champion trainer’s title. There were ten Irish-trained winners from five trainers at Royal Ascot last week. The meeting was also a triumph for Irish breeding, with 21 of the 35 winners bred here in Ireland.
The industry generates €2.4 billion to the economy annually and supports more than 30,000 jobs directly and indirectly, many of them in rural communities.
This means that the Government’s annual investment into the industry provides a 35-fold return to the economy.
I want to address the recently broadcast "RTÉ Investigates" programme. HRI, its board, chairman and staff, were deeply disgusted and appalled at what we saw in the programme. The behaviour depicted was abhorrent and is absolutely not the experience of the majority of the 30,000 people who make their livelihood every day in the horse racing and breeding industry in Ireland. We welcome the swift response from the Department of agriculture. We will fully support any An Garda and Department investigations, and eagerly await their conclusion. We hope that the full rigour of the law is applied to anyone found to have behaved illegally towards horses.
Equine safety and care are our top priority. HRI’s welfare department focuses its work under three key pillars - standards, safety nets and traceability. Our budget accounts for €7 million annual expenditure on welfare in 2024. This is in addition to our welfare-related capital projects in recent years such as CCTV provision on all racecourses, traceability enhancements within our racing system, RÁS, together with grant aid for racecourses for welfare measures. In May, we announced a further €1 million funding in the next phase of a capital development scheme to further enhance equine safety at our racecourses. We fund the IHRB’s integrity services, which include both race day and out-of-competition vet inspections, and its best-practice anti-doping programme. We work with organisations such as the Irish Horse Welfare Trust and Treo Eile which connect, support and promote thoroughbreds as they transition after their racing careers. We provide education and training to industry participants and held our first equine welfare symposium in May, which brought together stakeholders from across the sector to discuss the way ahead for equine safety and care. We consider the sharing of information, experience and best practice across the entire industry to be key to achieving excellence in equine welfare. Whole-of-life traceability is an ongoing priority, and we will continue to work with our colleagues in the Department and across all areas of the horse industry to enhance our systems and protocols, many of which in the thoroughbred sector are already class leading.
In 2021, Ireland was the first EU country to implement e-passports for thoroughbreds, which contain five layers of identification, including the thoroughbred’s microchip number and DNA analysis. The first phase of a central traceability system for thoroughbreds has been built by Weatherbys, the only organisation authorised in Ireland and UK to issue passports to thoroughbreds. The next phase will connect different strands of the thoroughbred data in one central database so we can identify a horse’s whereabouts at key life cycle events. We are working with the equine liaison group, organised through the Department, on joined-up process mapping of all horse management, movement and control to enhance our traceability and plug any potential data gaps. Our vision for the next four years, as set out our in strategic plan for 2024 to 2028, is to nurture success and inspire participation in the racing and breeding industries. We will continue to prioritise welfare to cultivate a culture of zero compromise in equine safety and care standards.
A vibrant and well-resourced Irish Equine Centre is a key pillar of equine welfare status, and we hope to see widespread support, including in these Houses, for further investment in its future. Our financial ambition is to increase the industry’s economic reach to €3 billion by 2028. We aim to deliver on major capital projects, which includes a people campus to service the needs of the wider thoroughbred industry and provide a pipeline of future human talent. The development of the new all-weather track at Tipperary Racecourse will create domestic opportunities at all levels of the industry as well as providing the marketplace for Irish racing to grow its annual foreign direct investment, currently estimated to be more than €550 million per annum. HRI will continue to invest in the development of facilities at all 26 racecourses, spread across 17 counties on the island, which are very much at the heart of their urban and rural communities. I am happy to address any questions members may have.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members of committee for the invitation to discuss the welfare and treatment of horses and their traceability today. I am the chief executive of Horse Sport Ireland. I am joined by my colleague Dr. Sonja Egan, head of breeding, innovation and development. Like colleagues in the Department and in HRI, Horse Sport Ireland unequivocally condemns the practices surrounding the abhorrent treatment of horses outlined in the recent "RTÉ Investigates" documentary. The horse abuse in welfare and traceability that we witnessed has no place in our industry or our sports. There is also no place in society for the mistreatment of horses, or any other animals, nor is there a place for the use of animals for any criminal intent. Both the horrific welfare abuses witnessed in the documentary, and the blatant forging of microchips to match passports are grotesque abuses of horses and food chain integrity. Horse Sport Ireland welcomes the full investigation by the Department of agriculture, An Garda and other relevant authorities, into the troubling issues highlighted by the programme. We have offered our full assistance to any such investigation.
It may be helpful to the committee to understand the role of Horse Sport Ireland within the equine sector. HSI was established in 2008 by the then Minister for sport, John O’Donoghue and then Minister for agriculture, Joe Walsh. Our role is to manage, develop, and promote horse sports and the breeding of sport horses in Ireland, which we do in three ways. First, we are the national governing body for equestrian sport and oversee various equestrian disciplines, including show jumping, eventing, dressage, and para-equestrian sport. We also represent the interests of Irish equestrian sports at international level as the recognised national federation member of our governing body, the International Equestrian Federation, FEI. We are also recognised by Sport Ireland and Sport Northern Ireland. Second, we are the operator of five studbooks. The Irish sport horse and Irish draught are two of the best known, along with three smaller studbooks. The Irish sport horse is renowned globally as a top-quality sport horse and is specifically highly sought after in eventing and jumping. In its role as a studbook operator, HSI works with breeders to improve breeding practices and is the passport issuing authority for those studbooks. As a passport issuing organisation, PIO, we provide passports for those studbooks, along with a number of other Irish-based organisations and private companies, including three in the North. Third, we are the provider of national equine breeding services. HSI operates that programme under to the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. We have been operating it since the inception of HSI in 2008 and was recently tendered by the Department in 2022. HSI administers almost 30 different breeding schemes to encourage breed improvement and genetic gain across all sport horse studbooks.
Overall, HSI plays a crucial role in the development and success of equestrian sports in Ireland, supporting both athletes and the equine industry. HSI receives just less than €6.5 million in annual funding from the State comprising approximately €1.8 million from Sport Ireland, €4.5 million from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and a further €1.5million in commercially-generated income. With all of those roles, it is crucial for committee members to understand that at no stage does Horse Sport Ireland perform a regulatory role for the sport horse sector. In the context of equine welfare and traceability, our main role is as one of seven passport issuing organisations across the sector. As mentioned, we are the PIO for five studbooks, the largest being the Irish sport horse studbook, which is second in size nationally to Weatherby’s general studbook for thoroughbreds, as Ms Eade mentioned. Across the studbooks we operate, HSI registers in total approximately 8,000 equines annually, which we estimate to be roughly one-third of all horses registered in the State.
Aside from studbook documentation, horses can be issued with what are known as identity documents. An identity document is a non-studbook document, which can be issued by HSI or Leisure Horse Ireland in the Republic. An identity document, also known as breeding and production books, may or may not have breeding recorded where DNA testing is not mandatory for these documents. The passports issued by HSI and other passport issuing organisations adhere to EU animal health laws and are overseen by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine.
The security features in those passports include the marking charts completed by veterinarians, security paper, holographic identification on certain pages, embossed stamps and seals, and security rivets, which cannot be removed, and relevant veterinary and studbook stamps. These features combined make a passport that has been tampered with very easy to identify. We have brought along sample passports for any committee member who wishes to see at first hand the security features in them.
At the start of the foal registration process, all studbook passports require a hair sample to be taken for DNA verification, and a marking chart is also completed. A registered veterinarian is required to take the hair sample and sign the completed marking chart. The veterinarian is responsible for ensuring that he or she takes the correct hair sample and identifies any markings on the horse by completing the marking chart, which ultimately forms part of the horse’s passport for life.
There has been significant commentary in the two weeks since the RTÉ documentary about the need for digital passports. We are very pleased to inform the committee that Horse Sport Ireland is in the final stages of testing and rolling out a new e-passports system, funded by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. In time, a digital e-passport could contain additional security features, such as annual photographs of the horse, as well as the usual features, such as marking charts. The use of photographs is something that World Horse Welfare, the international equine welfare charity, has advocated.
In the RTÉ documentary, we witnessed fraudulent behaviour by people who sought creative ways to circumvent the system. It was reported by RTÉ that the individuals purchased microchips with numbers to match pre-existing passports. In effect, tampering with the microchip and the horse was easier than tampering with the physical passport. We also saw in the RTÉ documentary that one individual purchased studbook passports from the Northern Irish Horse Board. To do this, a marking chart is required to be completed by a veterinarian and submitted to that board so it can issue the passport.
I wish to return to the fact that Horse Sport Ireland is not the regulator. To give a flavour of some of the movements at international level, our international governing body, the International Equestrian Federation, FEI, is considering a very strong and robust response to general issues with equine welfare that have emerged in recent years. In the main, these issues have been to do with social licence and training methods that may be substandard. In response to concerns regarding social licence, the FEI established an ethics and welfare commission in 2022. It reported at the end of 2023. The FEI and member national federations such as Horse Sport Ireland have formal roles during competition; however, the FEI is taking action for the other 23 hours of the day outside competition.
The IHRB recently presented the licensing, regulatory and welfare frameworks overseen by IHRB in racing to the FEI. That seems to be the direction of travel the FEI is pursuing. The United States Equestrian Federation has taken a lead in recent days by updating its own national rules to include a greater focus on equine welfare and greater power for it to inspect yards, trainers and coaches outside competition. In an Irish setting, we do not have the resources, and therefore additional resources would be required to ensure that an adequately resourced welfare and traceability regime is in place in the sport horse sector. In the near future, we will be required by our international bodies to have such a regime in place. We have neither the resources, the powers nor the remit to license yards, undertake inspections or enforce regulations.
The offensive practices we saw in the RTÉ programme do not reflect the day-to-day reality of the equine sector in Ireland. It is important for committee members to understand that the vast majority of equine breeders, owners, trainers and athletes place equine welfare at the very heart of what they do every day. Many actually take better care of their horses than of themselves. It is essential that any allegations of illegal activity be fully investigated by the appropriate authorities. If such allegations are proven, the individuals in question should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. I thank the committee again for the invitation to appear before it. My colleague Dr. Sonja Egan and I will be happy to address any questions members may have.
Comment on this
Before we hear from members, I want to make a few points as Chair. To say the “RTÉ Investigates” programme was disturbing would be an understatement. To see the way horses were treated was horrific in the extreme. As a country that prides itself on its horse racing industry and horse sport industry, Ireland must have suffered reputational damage if an abattoir like the one in question was allowed to operate under its jurisdiction. The horses were destined for the food chain. There is also collateral damage to our reputation as food exporters. When we allow something like what happened at the slaughter plant to happen, it definitely does reputational damage to our green image and reputation as producers of top-quality food. Therefore, there are many implications. I felt down by what I saw on the programme and how it was allowed to happen under our watch.
Before I refer to specific items, I want to read something Mr. Sheahan said to this committee on 20 July 2021:
I am happy to say we are very satisfied with how the slaughter plant here operates, or how the plants operated in the past. They are operated and regulated in much the same way as beef or sheep slaughter plants. We have a full-time official Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine veterinarian present at all times when slaughter is taking place. Ante and post-mortem inspection is carried out and temporary veterinary inspectors carry out the post-mortem inspection, supported by technical staff. We have very detailed guidelines as to how the slaughter plant operates and, in fact, we have a 51-page standard operating procedure detailing every aspect of how the horses are taken in, the documentary and identity checks, the ante-mortem and post-mortem and so on.
This was said to the committee three years ago during the Covid pandemic, so Mr. Sheahan would not have been present in the room. Relating this statement to the footage we saw this night two weeks ago and saying the Department is extremely disappointed that what happened was allowed to happen in a slaughter plant will take an awful lot of explaining to this committee.
It has been stated that the lairage was outside the jurisdiction of the plant. I cannot understand that; it defies explanation. In any factory I was ever in, Department officials had full access to the lairage. There would be a veterinarian, or at least a Department official, always present in the lairage. That some of the scenes we saw in the programme – including a mare foaling in the lairage while waiting for slaughter, the foal then being dragged out dead and then the mare being dragged out dead, in addition to other horses being dragged out dead – could happen under the Department’s watch is extremely disappointing.
There are several other questions I want to ask. I have asked them before but have never got answers. However, the day of our questions not being answered is now over. How many horses in this country are not microchipped? A number of years ago, we heard a percentage of 18% or 19%. We have been told that horse censuses have been carried out since. However, how can we have any confidence in a system in which a significant percentage of the horses have no identification?
In my part of the country, there have been three road accidents involving horses in the past couple of months. The three horses were either injured or killed in those accidents and, more importantly, occupants of the cars were seriously injured. None of the three horses was microchipped. There are large herds of horses in the vicinity that are let go unchecked. How many horses are exported live from this country? Have we a record of it? The programme the other night highlighted that many horses are being exported as car parts. It seemed to me that it is possible to take horses without any identification from this country to Northern Ireland, get identification for them and then proceed to have them slaughtered elsewhere or sold for another pursuit on the Continent.
How many horses were killed in the plant in Kildare last year? Are all the passports accounted for?
Comment on this
I agree with a lot of what the Chair said on reputational damage and all that kind of thing. That goes without saying. What I said in 2021 I said on the basis that I had been in the plant. It is a small plant killing relatively small numbers of horses. What I saw with my own eyes in the plant was an operation with horses in relatively good condition coming in, going into the lairs we supervise. To clarify, the place shown in the footage is not the lairage of the plant. It is a separate shed beside it. I know people will say that is splitting hairs but there is an actual lairage within the plant, the same way there is in every other beef slaughter plant or sheep slaughter plant, which the horses come into on the day of slaughter, that we do supervise, scan the horses and so on. If I had not seen the footage that we saw last week I would not have believed what was happening in the shed next door was happening. Like most members of the committee, I am from a farm. I have been working with animals all my life. I have seen a lot of bad welfare things. A lot of bad welfare stuff crosses my desk as part of my job because with 130,000 farms out there things do go wrong but the welfare cases, even the very bad ones we see, are usually before of unfortunate circumstances where there is someone with mental health problems or addiction problems, say, and animals go for weeks without food or water and you end up with some catastrophes. However, this was different. I have never in my life seen what we saw on the programme, with the gratuitous violence that was being used on those horses. I have never seen it on horses but I have spent my whole life in and out of marts, factories and assembly centres and so on and I have literally never seen it. I have spoken to a lot of people since the programme and I have not met anyone who has seen that kind of behaviour. If it was not for the hidden cameras, I simply would not have believed it was possible that somebody would do that. Maybe I am naïve but I have been around animals, farmers and horse owners and I simply could not believe that somebody would do that. The programme was absolutely shocking. It was an eyeopener.
The Chair asked a few questions. He said that if there was a second microchip, surely that would ring alarm bells. It does. Since about 2016, if there are two microchips in the horse then the carcase goes in the skip. The investigation is still at an early stage but I will outline our understanding of what was happing in the programme where we saw a microchip being inserted into a horse. Every time something new crops up, we try to close that loophole. We had heard rumours that it was possible to order a microchip from say, China, for the sake of argument, to match an existing passport. We had never actually come across such a microchip but, from the programme, that is our only explanation. We saw the footage of a horse having a microchip put into it. Either that horse did not have a microchip or else they have some mechanism of killing that microchip. More than likely, it did not have a microchip, so it had a clean passport. They ordered the microchip to match the clean passport and they put that into the horse and this horse was already recorded on the database. It would appear this is how they beat the system but the investigation is at an early stage. We had some discussion at our meeting with the other countries this morning and that seems to be the consensus on the most likely explanation. That is a new development, that you can order a microchip and ask for a specific number and get a microchip delivered with that specific number to match the existing passport. As my colleague from the HSI said, it has become difficult to damper with the passport because of the holograms and all sorts of things. It is not easy to tamper with the passport. This seems to be the next trick that people have come up with, where they are ordering a microchip from wherever you can get it from. I do not know where they get the microchips but there is obviously some nefarious organisation that you can order them from. The investigation is at an early stage but that is where it looks like it is leading. We will be getting the footage from RTÉ. We do not know if this is a one-off thing or how many horses were involved. I do not know how long their hidden cameras were there. I presume they were there for some months. When we see the footage we will have some idea of how widespread the practice was but we do not know at this stage.
Comment on this
We do not know that. We think the horse population in total is about 90,000 to 95,000. My colleague Ms MacAodhain might be better able to answer that. We do not know how many horses are not microchipped. We have a sense that the number of unidentified horses is much less than it was. I use the example of Ballinasloe fair. We did an operation with the Garda some years ago where, for the first time, gardaí set up checkpoints on the gathering for Ballinasloe fair and we accompanied them. The first year we did it, probably 10 years ago, the number of horses arriving at the fair without passports was very high. I would say 10% or 20% had passports. On the day, the approach we took, with the agreement of the Garda, was simply that we told people that if they came back next year without a passport they would be turned away and-or prosecuted. The second year we did it, the number of horses without passports was very small and, the third year, virtually no horses turned up, even in Ballinasloe, without passports. That is just one sample. Ballinasloe is a big fair and it is one sample. It is impossible to give an accurate answer about how many horses are in the country without microchips but every indication we have is that there are generally far fewer unwanted horses, abandoned horses, than there were but as the Chair will be aware, there are still plenty of problems.
Comment on this
We have figures for that. The Chair mentioned car parts and so on. I know that was mentioned in the programme and it was mentioned this morning at our meeting with EU colleagues. We are not really clear what that is about.
They talked about horses being misclassified as tractor parts or something like that. All our horses exported through Rosslare and Dublin have a health certificate. We know exactly how many there were. I do not know the figure off the top of my head but can provide those figures. We have exact figures on how many horses go out through Rosslare and Dublin.
Comment on this
Most of the horses that are going without traceability are not going through Rosslare or Dublin.
Comment on this
No, the fact that there is free movement between ourselves and the North is an issue.
Comment on this
Deputy Kerrane is next and I will stick with ten minutes because a lot of members want to contribute. If we have to have a second round of questions, we will stick to ten minutes in this round.
Comment on this
The voting block could be at 7 p.m. so it might be wise to have a substitute for the Chair to keep the meeting going.
Comment on this
He can leave the Chair if he wants to leave at 7 p.m.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in and for their opening statements. Most of my questions are for the Department. First, Mr. Sheahan said he still has not received the footage. It has been two weeks and I imagine the investigation that has been launched will very much need that footage. When does he expect to receive the footage?
Comment on this
There have been meetings between ourselves with RTÉ and there is no difficulty about providing the footage. There are a few legal issues RTÉ needs to sort out as regards chain of evidence, as I understand it. That has not stopped the rest of the investigation taking place. The investigation is now broader than just Shannonside Foods. Other issues cropped up during the programme and those are also the subject of Department and-or Garda investigation. We expect to get the footage shortly. There have been a few meetings about exactly the process and An Garda Síochána is very much involved.
Comment on this
It was made clear by the Minister that the Department became aware of the footage before it was aired on RTÉ. That was stated on the Dáil record. On what date did Mr. Sheahan or the Department see the footage?
Comment on this
We did not actually see the footage before the programme. We were given an indication by RTÉ as to what would be in the programme but we did not see the footage in advance. We saw it at the same time as everybody else.
Comment on this
When was the Department given the indication of what would be in the programme and that it would be aired?
Comment on this
I could not give the exact date. I would have to check. It was two to three weeks before the programme. I cannot remember exactly. My colleague can give me the exact date. It was 22 May.
Comment on this
Was that written correspondence from RTÉ to the Department informing it of what would be aired or what the issue was?
Comment on this
I am guessing it was by email but could not be certain of that. It was more than likely an email.
Comment on this
There was clearly nothing of any magnitude in that correspondence that would have constituted concern over continuing slaughtering. What I am getting at is that the shutdown happened after the programme was aired rather than on the back of the Department being informed. I take from this that the Department received very little information when RTÉ corresponded with it on 22 May.
Comment on this
It was more a series of questions. We were kind of speculating. I have to admit, when I saw the programme, particularly the welfare angle, I certainly did not expect to see that.
Comment on this
Obviously, this is not the first time we have seen abuse of animals, via "RTÉ Investigates", abuse of animals. In July last year, we saw similar footage of horrendous abuse of calves. From a response to parliamentary questions I received form the Minister last week, I understand that evidence is still being gathered for that investigation, which is a cause for concern a year later. It would lead me to wonder how long this investigation will take. I presume it will take a lot less time because the place has been shut down and there are consequences to that. It must be embarrassing for the Department that it learned of this not for the first time, no more than the abuse of calves a year ago, on television and not via its own people on the ground.
Comment on this
Yes, as I said I think earlier in reply to the Chairperson, and just to focus on the welfare abuses, if the hidden cameras had not been in there, I would never have believed what was shown on them. I grew up on a farm and have been around animals all my life. I have been in and out of marts and meat factories all my career. I have never seen anyone do what we saw on that footage. I probably would have found it hard to believe if I had not seen it on the television programme. I would have found it hard to believe that somebody would do that.
Comment on this
With regard to the antemortem checks that are carried out, Mr. Sheahan said in his opening statement that a number of people undertake a detailed antemortem examination, including veterinary inspectors and other technical officers. In his own words there was violence against the horses. How could it be when animals, one by one, are inspected during such a detailed examination that such violence would not have been spotted on the animals before they went to slaughter? Are records of those inspections kept in Shannonside Foods in the abattoir, specifically with regard to the antemortem checks?
Comment on this
Yes, records are kept. Even though the violence we saw inflicted on the horses with pipes and sticks and whatever was horrendous, it probably would not be enough to cause damage that would be visible on the horse at antemortem inspection. Unless it was really severe and repeated, it probably would not be enough to see bruising on the carcasses or whatever. In the normal course of events, the antemortem inspection is carried out in the plant. A certain number of horses do get turned down. When I look back over the records it is mostly not for welfare issues but to do with the passport not matching the animal, difficulties in finding the chip and things like that. Animals do get picked up and do not actually pass antemortem inspections and have to be killed and go for animal byproducts and not for human consumption.
I have had detailed conversations with our vet in the plant. In the shed next door, the treatment of the horses was terrible - we have already said that - and there were some sick horses in there. There was a dying horse and all that kind of appalling stuff. From talking to our vet in the plant and from what I saw the day I was there a couple of years ago, the horses presented in the plant are in relatively good condition. They do not come into our lairage in the abattoir. They do not present sick horses. They do not present dying horses. They do not even present lame horses. I had discussions regarding lameness. They never present an animal that is severely lame. Occasionally, a horse will be presented who is very slightly lame such that it would not be fit for racing or something like that but not lame from a welfare point of view. They are quite careful or clever - whatever way you want to put it - to only present animals that in relatively good condition despite what is happening next door, which is unspeakable.
Comment on this
I will put my final few questions together. Obviously there are consequences now that the abattoir is shut down. It leaves people with two options - one, to abandon the horse or two, to export it. Did the Department consider the possibility of stepping in and running the show at Shannonside Foods, and running the abattoir as opposed to shutting it down? Due to the consequences of export and abandonment because the operations are shut down, I presume that means the Department will move the investigation as quickly as possible. I presume whoever is running the investigation has been given a timeframe of when it should conclude. It would be good to know that, if possible.
Mr. Sheahan made it clear there were five complaints about the premises in recent years and from what he stated at the Committee of Public Accounts meeting last week was that most, if not all, of those complaints concerned individual horses or animals. The look of them or them being skeletal or whatever was the issue was that was reported. When the Department officials went out and looked at those horses, were photographs of those horses taken at that time? Will Mr. Sheahan confirm whether the five complaints were all concerned with individual animals and not any one building?
I presume there was never a complaint about potential, possible or alleged violence on the premises?
Comment on this
We did not consider taking over the running of the plant. The Department has never done such a thing. I do not know if it would make any sense or be appropriate. As the Deputy pointed out, it creates a potential problem in that it is the only slaughterhouse for horses on the island of Ireland. At the Committee of Public Accounts someone asked me about the likelihood of someone else stepping in or whether the Government or the Department could do something. At the time I said that, given the negative publicity and the toxicity around the issue of slaughtering horses, I was not sure that anybody would be rushing in to take over. However, since then, we have actually had a number of approaches to potentially provide a slaughter service for horses. I am slightly surprised at this but we have had four approaches that I am aware of and there might even be a few more. These are all credible approaches from credible people. Having said that, I do not want to give the impression that suddenly someone is going to open a slaughter plant for horses. It is one thing to express an interest in doing it and ask what would be involved, but it is another thing to bring it to fruition. However, at least it is good some credible people are inquiring about it. From the discussions I have had with a couple of them, they have genuine reasons for wanting to step in and help. We are all aware that if there is not a slaughter option - we see what happens in America - the alternative is that horses get exported and that could perhaps be a much worse outcome.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming here today. I will try not to go back over old ground. The Chair already referred to the most startling point in Mr. Sheahan's opening statement. This is the admission that nobody ever visited the building where most of this took place. It is cloaked, to some degree, by saying it was not part of the lairage, but it was covered by general animal welfare regulations that apply to all holdings where animals are kept. I grew in an idyllic rural area on the edge of a small town. To give some context, there were three women who used to walk from the town every evening. They knew nothing about farming but they used to walk down a quiet boreen. One evening they said that the cattle were lowing a lot in that slatted shed. On the second evening they asked the farmer was there something wrong with the cattle and he said no, "That's just an ould fashion they have" . However, on the third evening it was still the same and one of them went home and felt uncomfortable about it and decided to make a phone call about it. That call resulted in a major animal cruelty case. I find it astonishing that a vet and two officials visited on the day of the slaughter and nobody ever checked the building. Mr. Sheahan himself attended the premises three years ago. Has any Department official ever visited that building?
Comment on this
Not that I am aware of. It will be interesting when we see the footage. As we understand it, about that building next door, typically the slaughter plant operates on a Wednesday. I think it operated for 37 days last year. As far as we understand, horses come into that shed on the evening before and then they come into our lairage in the plant on the Wednesday morning.
Comment on this
I am conscious of my time. The Department was aware of the shed and that it was part of the operation, because the animals came into it on the previous evening. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes, I was not aware myself, but that would appear to be the pattern.
Comment on this
I know it is not part of the lairage but there would be an obvious expectation and understanding that the building was part of the slaughter chain. If that was the first point where the horses come in, surely somebody in the Department, during the lifetime of this horrendous operation, should have checked? Ultimately, two bodies are responsible for this - Shannonside Foods and the Department, as the regulator and overseer of this area. Nobody in the lifetime of the operation checked. Three women who knew nothing about farming and did not have veterinary degrees had enough common sense to suspect there was a problem. Is Mr. Sheahan telling me that nobody in the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine thought at any stage to have a look in that building?
Comment on this
Not that I am aware of. It is fair to say that if or when another slaughter operation for horses gets up and running, one of the lessons we will have learned is that without a doubt-----
Comment on this
That is great hindsight but, on reflection, does Mr. Sheahan think that if he had gone and looked inside that building when he visited the plant three years ago, he could have averted what happened?
Comment on this
As I understand it, the building is empty other than the evening before, when the horses come in.
Comment on this
I know, but Mr. Sheahan was aware that the horses were coming from that building. I cannot understand why nobody ever suggested looking inside the building.
Comment on this
In hindsight that certainly makes sense. However, as I said, we had five complaints about the farm next door. As I understand it, I do not believe any horses were present in the shed on any of those five visits.
Comment on this
We have a vote coming and we have the other two bodies here. I understand and we have seen from the Committee of Public Accounts that the other two bodies probably do not have that much of regulatory or enforcement input in respect of what happened. However, they do have a major responsibility with regard to passports. Horse Sport Ireland will know that this has been a hobby horse of mine - excuse the pun - for the lifetime of this Government. I have said it to the officials from the Department and to the Minister and all have been dismissive. We should not have this situation with horse passports. My advice to Horse Sport Ireland and Horse Racing Ireland is that they should not come back to this committee unless they have addressed the issue of passports. In 2021 Horse Racing Ireland introduced the first e-passport for horses in Europe and, three years, later we are in the first phase of a central traceability. That needs to be addressed.
I have specific questions for Horse Sport Ireland. In 2023, 75% of foals were sold with no passports.
Comment on this
There is a vote in the Dáil. The Senators can continue with their questions. Deputy Flaherty may resume his questioning when we return.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming here today. Some weeks ago, I spoke in the Seanad about Horse Racing Ireland. I am very supportive of our amazing horse sports industry. I thank the witnesses for the parts they play in that. Sadly, we had the "RTÉ Investigates" programme. People, both urban and rural, including the farming community, were outraged by the unwarranted violence revealed in the programme. I salute the makers of the programme. They are looking in here tonight, by the way. They are clearly conscious that this meeting is going on. Of course we have to be careful in that criminal and regulatory investigations are going on and we cannot undermine these in any way. I will make my remarks keeping this in mind. We do not know the extent of the surveillance undertaken by the makers of the "RTÉ Investigates" programme or how they were assisted internally or externally by other parties. Clearly, they engaged and had access to a number of premises and places. We do not know how much more information the makers of the programme have. There may very well be a follow-up investigation or further evidence may come to light. I welcome the fact that an investigation is going on; that is really important.
We have a wonderful industry and an obligation to protect it in terms of both rural development and international reputation. We hope that will continue. We have a challenge about what is to happen to horses that finish a life in sport or whatever. That is a challenge that is coming out of this.
From the Department's point of view, I want to be careful about what I say but it is a disgrace. It would not be tolerated in any other sector. I do not know what ministerial or departmental investigations are going on but serious questions have to be asked of staff in the Department of agriculture. In the private sector, if someone had a role as overseer, inspector or investigator and failed as dismally as the Department appears to have failed, they would be sacked. It is about accountability. People have to consider their positions in the Department of agriculture, quite frankly. I want to get that message out loud and clear. After all these investigations, some people have to accept they failed and look at the door. That is an important point to make.
Mr. Sheahan appeared before the Committee of Public Accounts and clearly accepted under cross-examination that he had responsibility for the welfare of animals and that it was within his remit. That is not in dispute. He volunteered that to the Committee of Public Accounts. What is his view, on reflection? I am shocked that he is shocked. He told the committee today that if he had not seen the footage, he would not believe it had happened. He is a professional and is saying that. Is he seriously telling us that at no time did he have any idea or suspicion something like this was going on?
Comment on this
To pick up on the point about "Prime Time", I echo what the Senator says. It was a fantastic piece of work by "Prime Time" and was public sector broadcasting at its best. I highly commend Conor Ryan, whom I do not know, and whoever else was involved in making the programme.
I reiterate what I said earlier. I grew up on a farm, have worked with animals all my life and have never seen anything like what we saw on the footage of the programme. Of people I have spoken to since, nobody else has ever seen something like that happen. I still find it hard to believe somebody would do what we saw on the programme. I can excuse that 20 years ago we still had sticks in the marts and people would occasionally use the stick too much, with a view to making animals move in a particular direction or whatever-----
Comment on this
Sorry to cut across Mr. Sheahan but I am conscious of time. Can I ask a few questions? I thank Mr. Sheahan for that. Given he had an oversight role in this, is he part of the ongoing investigation? Is it an investigation into himself, effectively? He is in the Department and the spotlight is on him and his officials. Is he party to this investigation or is there a stand-alone unit in the Department or externally reviewing Mr. Sheahan's subdivision within the Department's role in these matters? Can he be concise in his response?
Comment on this
Within the Department is a specific stand-alone division called investigations division. It used to be called the special investigations unit. It takes the lead but obviously the Garda is significantly involved in this investigation as well. There is also a European dimension and the equivalent of-----
Comment on this
Is Mr. Sheahan directly involved in these investigations?
Comment on this
Has Mr. Sheahan stepped aside from that, given the potential element of conflict?
Comment on this
It is not a question of stepping aside. The investigation is led by the investigations division. By and large, it has a hands-off approach but asks us questions when it needs to. For governance reasons, a deliberate decision was made a couple of years ago that the division would report to a separate-----
Comment on this
That is grand. That reassurance is all I want.
Comment on this
-----stream within the Department of agriculture.
Comment on this
I want to ask Ms Eade about HRI. She has overall responsibility but I get the impression she has limited enforcement powers. Am I right in saying that?
Comment on this
Our job is talking about the promotion of the industry so we focus on three areas for welfare. Those are standards, safety nets and traceability. There is no enforcement requirement there, so most of our time is spent on funding welfare aspects of the industry, whether that is the Irish Equine Centre or the funding that goes into the IHRB. During a racing career, it is fully funded to make sure of the welfare side. Education and training has been a bigger part of what Mr. Osborne has focused on in the last while. The safety net aspect involves funding bodies like the Irish Horse Welfare Trust and Treo Eile, a wonderful organisation that opened a few years ago. Thankfully, those people are able to rehome race horses when their career is over. That has been our focus.
On the traceability aspect, Mr. Morris just moved out of the role of racing director and he would have focused on ensuring full traceability during the racing period.
Comment on this
That is not whole-of-life traceability.
Comment on this
Not yet, but it is all the racing career. We put in massive enhancements in the racing system. I can honestly say our racing system in terms of traceability is world class. I am very confident in that.
Comment on this
Does Ms Eade feel she should have more powers or does she feel that is for the Department?
Comment on this
That would be the Department. We rely on its policies.
Comment on this
In relation to Horse Sport Ireland, will Mr. Duggan touch on whole-of-life traceability and the challenges around it? How can we improve it?
Comment on this
Our role in that regard is as a passport-issuing authority. We see foals from birth through to notifications of end of life when horses die. In international competition, horses registered with an Irish studbook will be given an FEI passport, which we provide to the horses people will see in a month's time at the Olympics, for example. We have a certain level of visibility but we are not a regulator so it is limited.
Comment on this
Again, it is back to the Department. We are hearing clearly the regulatory aspects of this go back to the Department of agriculture.
Comment on this
That is for the welfare aspects. In terms of regulation, the IHRB fully regulates the racing.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses under unfortunate circumstances brought about by the programme. My party colleague, Deputy Flaherty, got into the passport issue with Horse Sport Ireland and, because of time constraints, I was to follow on from that if he was not finished. I am in an awkward position now that he is gone so I will leave that with him.
I ask Mr. Duggan to explain the following from his opening statement:
Aside from studbook documentation, horses can also be issued with what are known as identity documents. An identity document is a non-studbook document[.]
Will he explain how that works and why there is a need for duplication? Is it duplication? Can a horse live its life on just the identity document? Will Mr. Duggan talk a bit about the beginning of the programme? I know about the cruelty. I should have said, as I normally do in these situations, that I am a horse owner and breeder and a director of a rural racetrack. Any human being would find it hard to watch what was in the "Prime Time" programme but it was a bit more difficult for people who own, work with and love horses to see how they can be treated.
The programme started with the export of horses whose ages were turning out to be wrong. They were a lot older than the age they were being sold. I think “The man from RTÉ” was a song. The man from RTÉ found two microchips, just like that. How can that happen?
Comment on this
My colleague, Dr. Egan, answered some of those questions. Very briefly, on the issue of age, it is my understanding that the footage to which the Senator is referring is regarding an Irish sport horse, which would have been registered as a particular age in our studbook. In effect, that horse was re-passported and sold to Sweden. I think that is the footage to which the Senator is referring. It is my understanding that in Sweden one can insure a horse once it is under a certain age. Under those circumstances, that might have been the motivation to re-passport the horse and knock a few years off its age.
Comment on this
It came across very clearly in the programme that the transaction was done on this side. There was another horse that again had a false identity. It was not the horse it was meant to be either. If you remember rightly, a girl fell off the horse because it was supposed to be a calm jumper and it said as such in all its breeding information and documentation. However, it was a glorified thoroughbred. She tried to jump it over small poles and fences and we all know they are not ideal for jumping. Those changes happened on this side and were made by the seller. How can that happen?
Comment on this
I will come in on the point of the two horses of which the Senator is speaking. When any passport issuing authority registers a horse, they will receive signed documentation that is stamped by a vet. Any passport issuing organisation, PIO, will rely on a vet to sign and stamp a set of markings to show they have taken the markings themselves and that they have either identified or inserted a microchip. So-----
Comment on this
Yes, I know how the system works-----
Comment on this
Based on the allegation of which we are speaking in the programme - and I do not want to get too far into it because of the investigation that is under way - it appears as though a secondary microchip was inserted. That could occur in a number of ways. There is a small number of microchips that can be reabsorbed in horses. Where that is the case, the original vet will notify us that that has happened. We will then update it that there are two microchips in the system. In another case, a person might forge a vet’s signature or stamp, or the vet could be in on the alleged illegal activity-----
Comment on this
I am conscious of time. The bottom line is that the system is not working, and it can be tampered with. If I bought a 13-year-old horse but found out three months later that the horse is actually 22 years old, I would question a system in which that could happen. The system can be tampered with and it is not working. If it is not working, it needs to be fixed. Half of my time is now gone, and I am still on the subject of Horse Sport Ireland, so I need to move on. Hopefully I can come back if there is a second round.
With regard to the Department and Mr. Sheahan, I do not know where to start. I am not a vet or a mortician, but I am a farmer. I have been in abattoirs where cattle and beef carcases were rejected for very minor injuries that may have happened during loading and unloading. As I said, I am not a vet or a mortician, but what happened to those horses, as was seen on screen, would have been very evident on the carcase. I do not know how that did not happen.
I want to provide a quote from the court case in Limerick. We have been warned to be careful here, but this is in the public domain. One of Mr. Sheahan’s colleagues is quoted in the court case in Limerick as saying that the “slaughterhouse documents on the food chain status of the horses were created by Shannonside Foods Ltd. retrospectively after the kill.” I want that to be explained to me. If the paperwork that goes with carcases, horses, microchips and passports are all being done retrospectively, then there is no inspection process here at all. Horses could be killed on a Tuesday, a Monday or a Friday, and they are the carcases that the paperwork is matching up with. How can inspectors or vets oversee this situation? Their own colleague is saying in the court case that the paperwork was done retrospectively. There is therefore absolutely no inspection regime being done here at all. I am not saying this did happen, but there is nothing to say that another batch of horses were not killed the next day and that they are the carcases that matched the paperwork. There is no one checking the paperwork. In a situation where there are cattle - and I have been in abattoirs - there is a stamp on the carcase, there is a year tag, and everything is correlated before the vet or inspector leaves. No paperwork is done retrospectively. Can the Department explain to me how that is being allowed to happen? Can it confirm or deny the reservations and worries I have about the consequences of what could be going on if that was a system that was being allowed to operate?
Comment on this
I cannot, actually. The person who was in court on our behalf was one of the people in our investigation division, as I mentioned earlier. I read the same report that the Senator read. This referred to a bunch of horses that were killed on 5 June, if I remember rightly, and those carcases were detained on the foot of concerns about traceability. Like the Senator, I was a bit surprised about the issue of retrospective paperwork or whatever-----
Comment on this
With the greatest of respect, Mr. Sheahan said he is surprised or shocked, but he is a Department official. The person who said it in a court of law is a Department official. It was the Department that was inspecting this process. It is the Department that is accountable. We have heard from the other bodies, but the Department is the enforcer here. It was one of the Department’s people who said this. It is on record.
Comment on this
I think I am safe in saying this and that it does not interfere with the case. That appeal was decided and it is on record here before me. Mr. Sheahan says he is surprised but that is not an acceptable answer to me. I am quoting what is written in black and white before me, which states that a colleague of his is saying that the paperwork was done retrospectively-----
Comment on this
-----post-ops. Being surprised about this does not wash.
Comment on this
I would have to come back to the Senator with an answer. That is not my understanding.
Comment on this
As a layperson, can you see how the system is broken, if a Department vet is saying that the paperwork was being done retrospectively? This is the same Department that was supposed to be inspecting and following the horse from life through the abattoir process and making sure the carcase matched the passport and microchip.
Comment on this
As the Senator knows, and as I understood, in any other meat factory I have ever been in, the food chain information comes in at the same time as the animals, such as sheep, cattle or whatever they may be. Therefore, I am afraid I do not know exactly what happened. That was certainly not my understanding of what was happening in the plant with food chain information. It was my clear understanding that it was the same as in every other plant and that the food chain information came in at the same time as the horses.
Comment on this
There is a breakdown in the process. There is a breakdown in the Department. There is a breakdown in communication within the Department. As I said, and I hate getting people to repeat themselves, but this is a Department official who said this, and Mr. Sheahan has said that he has seen the same statement. It is on the court record.
Comment on this
That is an admission by a Department official that the paperwork is being done retrospectively.
Comment on this
I cannot help the Senator anymore, I am afraid. I would have to-----
Comment on this
Does Mr. Sheahan not think he needs to go back to Agriculture House this evening and do something about this? It should not have happened. This is on his watch.
Comment on this
That is where I am coming from. We cannot change the past. We are all here with a view to improving the future.
Comment on this
If it was the case, as it seems to have been according to what came out in court, that food chain information was being retrospectively changed or written, etc., that does not seem to make any sense. Clearly, that is not acceptable. That is not my understanding of what normally happens.
Comment on this
I say this with the greatest of respect and, for legal reasons, I will not mention any of the people who are involved. I am as straight a man as you would meet on a day’s walk, but if an opportunity like that was afforded to me and if it was going to be so easy to fill out paperwork after the deed is done, it would be very tempting in any walk of life. If you leave loopholes, people will jump through them. It appears to me that there were blatant gaps here, and not just loopholes. I do not know-----
Comment on this
-----how we are going to get to the bottom of it, but-----
Comment on this
I cannot help the Senator any further. I will certainly try-----
Comment on this
What are you going to do about it? You said you have seen it yourself in black and white. It is a Department official. It should not have happened. You are shocked that it did happen, but you are agreeing that it must have happened-----
Comment on this
What are you going to do about it? That is the question.
Comment on this
What did happen, as the Senator knows, is that the 65 carcases, or whatever the number was, were detained and have been destroyed. The court upheld our-----
Comment on this
There again, with the greatest of respect, if it had not been for the RTÉ programme, would that case even have happened? Would those carcases be destroyed now?
It was your job before the programme, if you were doing your job, to make sure that never happened. A knee-jerk reaction post the programme, as has been quoted somewhere else, is not good enough.
Comment on this
Regarding the fact that normally the horses came from this premises next door, that place had been shut down at the time and when the slaughter happened on this day. It may be something to do with the fact that the horses slaughtered on that day came from a variety of places. That may have had something to do with the food chain information but I am only speculating. I do not know. I would have to come back. I would have to check with my investigations division colleagues and come back on that.
Comment on this
I am conscious that my time is up but I am also conscious that TDs are not back. Can I do my second round now?
Comment on this
I am sorry, the Leas-Chathaoirleach wants to go in himself. I forgot about him. I reserve the right to come back.
Comment on this
I have one question for HRI just before we finish. When we have meetings like this coming up we get correspondence from people. I got some correspondence that HRI would have got information in 2022 about irregularities with microchips internationally, or whatever. In such a circumstance, if it is true, what does HRI do with that? As has been pointed out to Senator Boyhan, HRI is not the regulator but if it does get information from a whistleblower, for want of a better word - and I was told HRI did - what happened that information?
Comment on this
I received an email in 2022 from a person who is involved in a group that is active in this area. It established a list of approximately 110 horses over a four-year period that were Irish in origin but were known to be in the Netherlands or had passed through the Netherlands. This was brought to my attention and I made inquiries of colleagues in the Department of agriculture who had also received similar correspondence. It was not something over which we had any particular authority or in which we had ability to intervene.
Comment on this
But did HRI pass it on to the Department?
Comment on this
Finally, when the Department got information, did it have the authority to pursue it?
Comment on this
As far as I know, the Dutch authorities had actually contacted our investigations division - I presume it was around the time of that incident - to say they had some concerns about horses from Ireland that could not get into the food chain here but had gone to the Netherlands. Some illegal activity had happened, as far as I understand, regarding the issuing of new passports to them in Holland, or something like that. The Dutch authorities asked, as I understand it, for our assistance, and our investigations division offered whatever assistance they looked for at the time. That is how I understand it.
Comment on this
Senator Victor Boyhan will come in before Senator Daly then.
I want to acknowledge the contributions made by Horse Sport Ireland and Horse Racing Ireland, and I have no questions for them.
I watched the investigation by Conor Ryan and the "RTÉ Investigates" programme. I watched half of it. I actually turned it off; I could not watch the other half. It was shocking stuff altogether; the worst I have ever seen in my entire life. That would be the response of the majority of our society towards it. I cannot even quantify the knock-on implications for our industry. The damage that has been done is absolutely frightening. The hearings today and the Committee of Public Accounts hearing are helpful but clarity is required on a few issues.
We might start with what investigations are actually happening at the moment, and who is leading what investigations there are into the "RTÉ Investigates" programme?
Comment on this
Everything that came out in the programme is being investigated. The investigation is being led, as I mentioned, by our investigations division but there is also considerable Garda involvement in the investigation.
Comment on this
It is a special unit. It is what used to be called the special investigation unit, SIU. It is now called the investigations division.
Comment on this
It is effectively full time on this issue.
Comment on this
Are there any timelines regarding when this investigation will be over, or what conclusions will be brought on the issues?
Comment on this
I do not have any timeline. In my experience of dealing with investigations, they always tend to take longer than we think they are going to take. There are a couple of cases-----
Comment on this
Can the Leas-Chathaoirleach say that again?
Comment on this
Does a file then go to the DPP from the special unit or where does the file go? Who has the responsibility for sending the file? Does the unit in the Department or An Garda Síochána send the file?
Comment on this
I think it depends on who is leading on it but, in general, I would imagine in this case at the moment it is being led by ourselves. I think, but I am not sure, that there is some discussion with the serious crime unit - I am probably calling it the wrong name now - in the Garda about whether it might be taking the lead rather than ourselves on certain other issues that came up in the programme. As I mentioned, apart from the national issues that came up - the welfare abuse and whatever - there is an international dimension to this as well.
Comment on this
As I mentioned earlier, the meeting earlier that was organised by the European Commission, which we attended, also had representatives from law enforcement agencies, including Europol. It is playing a significant role in co-ordinating this investigation internationally, and the ramifications of it. It sought our assistance and we confirmed that we will be assisting it in every way we can.
Comment on this
Regarding the potential that the food chain has been breached with contaminated product, is there any investigation happening on that, and if so, who is leading that investigation?
Comment on this
I might ask my colleague Dr. Hobson to answer on the RASFF issue. She might clarify about the notification that has been issued.
Comment on this
The product is all exported because there is no culture of eating horse meat in Ireland. With the FSAI, we have notified another member state where the product has gone, alerting it to where the product would have gone to so it can follow up.
Comment on this
That would be for the member state to look into. We have told it about the potential fraud. The 65 carcases that were detained went as category 1, which is for disposal. They were not exported.
Comment on this
What potential size of product could have been exported and could have gone into the food chain? Is there a figure on it?
Comment on this
Whatever animals were slaughtered either go out in carcass form or some of them are boned out, and they are exported. We have a residue programme where we do monitoring. Obviously, there was evidence of tampering and fraud in the supply chain and that was one of the reasons we removed the-----
Comment on this
We are not issuing the recall. How the system works is that there is a step back or a step forward. We have notified the other member state where the product is with our concerns, and it is up to that member state to take whatever action it deems appropriate.
Comment on this
We have alerted them that we have closed down the slaughter plant and-----
Comment on this
How many carcasses went through that slaughter plant that the Department is concerned about?
Comment on this
It is very difficult to tell because there was evidence of fraud in the supply chain. There was evidence of some fraud but they passed through the controls. As Mr. Sheahan outlined in the opening statement, there are controls and procedures in place at the slaughter plant. There is a full antemortem and a full post mortem. We have our records of carcasses that did not pass post mortem. In our checks, there were animals that did not pass post mortem or antemortem.
Comment on this
My problem here is we have no idea of how much is potentially going to be in the food chain that could be of a product that is not suitable for human consumption.
Comment on this
I will have to double-check but I think there were 13 slaughter days this year. The product goes through full antemortem and post mortem inspection. There was evidence of issues in the supply chain relating to the horses that went into that slaughter plant, and we-----
Comment on this
Could Dr. Hobson safely say, or could she speculate, that every animal that went through that abattoir is under investigation in some way or another?
Comment on this
We have provided the information to the other member state, and it may come back.
Under the EU, because food fraud is recognised, there are food fraud alerts. We have provided the other member state with a food fraud alert. They can come back. That went last week and it is up to the other member state to come back to look for further information. We have provided them with information.
Comment on this
Regarding the issue of the investigation teams, the Department mentions there are two investigation teams - one from the Garda Síochána and one internal in the unit itself. I am very much aware of how the unit operates. Regarding the governance of the Department and how the Department looked at this, I hope I am not hearing that we are having the Department special unit look at the culture within the Department and how things operated. Have we looked at external investigations of the Department, the protocols and how the management of the Department looked at this unit, or are we expecting the special unit within the Department to investigate itself? What is the third phase of this investigation?
Comment on this
Could the Leas-Chathaoirleach repeat the question on the third phase?
Comment on this
We have a special unit, which I am aware works within the Department. I know how they operate. They are looking at the abattoir and how it works.
Comment on this
The investigation has gone beyond the abattoir into other matters that were raised in the programme.
Comment on this
Given the culture within the Department itself and how we ended up in this situation, maybe there are structural changes involved. Maybe changes in legislation are required. Maybe there is the issue of having a database, something similar to what is there on the bovine side that provides traceability all the way through. All those issues need to be on the table at this stage. Those issues were considered during the BSE crisis for the bovine herd and within a matter of months, a scheme was put in place - it ran through Clonakilty at the time - that was effective in providing traceability through the entire bovine herd.
It is beyond belief that we are stuck in a situation where we do not have the same scenario when it comes to the horse industry. Have we learned anything from the 2013 scandal and the processes that happened at that time, in particular, when it came to horse meat getting into the food chain? I am asking what will be the next phase. If it has not learned from 2013 and if it has not taken into consideration what worked in 1996 in the BSE crisis, what will be the long-term focus on how the Department can change its approach?
Which entity will conduct that investigation? It will not be the Garda Síochána and I hope to God it will not be the special investigation unit. There has to be a third phase to this and I have not heard who that is tonight.
Comment on this
I would not say that we did not learn from 2013. We learned a lot from 2013. I mentioned some of the steps that have been taken since then to try to tighten the system up such as the central database, the extra security features on the passports, and the move towards funding of the e-passport system, the 80% grant that we gave, etc. We have done a lot but, unfortunately, as we now know from the programme, criminals are, once again, a step ahead of us. This latest thing that seems to be possible is, as I mentioned, ordering a specific microchip to match a passport, which is something that we had heard rumours about but we had not actually seen. I am not certain that that is the case, but that seems to be the way the evidence is leading us.
As regards follow-up, this is not only an Irish problem. It is an EU problem. Today's meeting, which was prompted partly by ourselves, with the other member states, and involving Europol, is one step in the process. As I say, when the Dutch contacted us two years ago, they led us to believe that the reason some Irish horses were going to Holland and getting into the food chain illegal was they had failed to get into the food chain here. I suppose that give us some reassurance that our own controls were working but, obviously, it was not as simple as that. Other countries that were on the meeting this morning all relayed similar issues. They are all struggling with trying to come up with ways of having a more foolproof horse identification system.
Comment on this
If we can do it for the bovine industry, which we have done competently, particularly from 1996 onwards, and the amount of work that has been done on traceability all the way through has made sure we are the world leader, I am lost for words to think why we do not have the same scenario. If I, as a farmer myself, had an animal on the farm that was not registered, I would be breaking every law in the land and that animal would not be on that farm if it was over 42 days of age unregistered because the Department would rightly move in. I do not understand why we have not had the same approach when it comes to this industry. For the life of me, I do not understand how we are in this situation, after what we saw in 2013 and after the experience of what happened in BSE in 1996.
The third phase of this investigation is probably the most important phase. My question refers to the lessons within the Department and who is to run that phase. Has the Department come up with a proposal of who will be the person, entity or body that will look at how we need to make sure that this does not happen again? We have, effectively, as a nation, left product get into the food chain that is potentially not suitable for human consumption. That is exceptionally damaging for the State and I fundamentally believe the third phase of the investigation is potentially the most important one.
Comment on this
I cannot say we have a definite proposal to tell the committee about today but, as the Leas-Chathaoirleach can understand, we have been giving a lot of thought to what needs to change and what do we need to do differently. The European angle is one. We are meeting with our Northern Irish counterparts on Monday where we will be discussing some of the cross-Border issues that have cropped up and that are something of a difficulty. Then we intend to sit down and see what else do we need to do.
It is frustrating. I am frustrated when people ask why we do not have as good a system as we do for bovines. It is a good question. It is not an excuse, but there are complications with horses. When we look at why is there an incentive for fraud and criminality when it comes to horses getting into the food chain, the simple reason is that what is different about horses is we have this aspect of horses being marked out of the food chain which we do not have in cattle. A lot of horses, as members will probably be aware, and Senator Paul Daly said he has horses, get marked out of the food chain for various reasons. One of the single biggest issues is that if they are ever administered bute, which is one of the commonly-used anti-inflammatories, they are marked out of the food chain for life. When a horse is marked out of the food chain, its value is significantly less. For criminals, that creates a big incentive to identify some way they can beat the system and get this horse that has been marked out back into the system.
Comment on this
What I cannot get over here is the traceability element. I am sorry, I will return to Senator Victor Boyhan next.
With bovine operations, there is traceability all the way through so that we know where the animal lives, who owns it, where it is going and how it is run. If that animal is destroyed or died, we know where the knackery is. We know everything about it. Therefore, there is traceability all the way through the system. Even with that issue regarding giving an animal an anti-inflammatory, we will not have a horse that is 200 years old on the system. It does not work like that. This is a wake-up call to make sure that we learn from our lessons. On the lessons that we learned from 2013, I am of the view we have not learned enough and a lot of work needs to be done, in particular, on that issue.
Comment on this
There is definitely still a lot of work to be done. I could get my colleague, Ms MacAodhain, who is more our expert on the equine ID and traceability, to give the committee a rundown on some of what has been done, in particular, the e-passport system, which is definitely the way forward.
Comment on this
I have no more questions to ask the representatives of Horse Sport Ireland or Horse Racing Ireland. It was helpful to have them here. I want to continue to support them in their work. I acknowledge the important work they do.
I am sorry for Mr. Sheahan if the focus is on him but that is his job and responsibility. I have one or two more areas to ask about. Dr. Hobson mentioned another member state. Is she in a position to tell us the member state to which she was referring?
Comment on this
That is important. There is clearly a market for horse meat there anyway. We have confirmed that there is an international dimension to this topic because Europol is involved. There is clearly a great deal going on, and there may also be many others involved. I am not comfortable with the idea that there is an internal investigation going on even if it is a unit within the Department. I do not like the sound of that, especially in the context of openness and transparency. There is an element of circling the wagons in any organisation and of protecting the institutions and the ethos that prevails. I call for an independent external investigation into these matters because one is needed. We need to instil confidence in the public at large, who are appalled and horrified by what has gone on. My message is that we should have an independent external review. It is, frankly, not good enough to have an internal review. That would not be tolerated in the Prison Service, the Department of Justice or any other Department. Many people would be bellyaching in the Dáil about internal or external reviews, but I do not hear a call for an external review. I am making a clear call. We need an external and independent review by experts who are competent in this area. I want to carry that forward. I do not know how comfortable the witnesses would be as part of an internal structure. Perhaps it is time the Minister comes back before the committee and we talk to him about the issue. Perhaps the investigation division of the Department needs to come before the committee so we can understand its work better. To what extent is the Food Safety Authority involved in all of this?
Comment on this
I will refer that question to my colleague, Dr. Hobson, who liaises more often with the Food Safety Authority than I do.
Comment on this
The Food Safety Authority falls under the auspices of the Department of Health, as the Senator probably knows. It is independent of our Department and its role relates to the safety of food. We have liaised quite closely with the authority. It is responsible for issuing the fraud alert so we have met its representatives. They attended the EU-wide meeting today.
Comment on this
Did the Food Safety Authority issue the food alert?
Comment on this
It did so on our recommendation. The procedure is that it goes into a database that is managed by the Food Safety Authority on behalf of Ireland. It is the central competent authority. We are a competent authority within that structure.
Comment on this
The Department recommended that a food fraud alert should issue.
Comment on this
That went through channels and the Food Safety Authority has issued the alert on the recommendation of the Department.
Comment on this
Last week. I am getting mixed up with the days but it was last week.
Comment on this
It took until last week to do it. There is a process or a chain involved.
Comment on this
There is a process it has to go through. It was early last week. I think the programme was the previous week.
Comment on this
To clarify, there are other food alerts going around Europe at the moment in respect of the same case.
Comment on this
Are they alerts relating to the same plant?
Comment on this
No. Other member states, on the basis of the "RTÉ Investigates" programme, have looked internally. We have one slaughter plant that has now closed and that has stopped slaughtering horses. Other member states have numbers of slaughter plants, so there are other-----
Comment on this
How many of these food fraud alerts does Dr. Hobson think there are? In what jurisdictions are they?
Comment on this
Some have issued from the Commission and a couple of member states have been notified. Some fraud alerts are between two member states. All of those have come out since the "RTÉ Investigates" programme. We would not necessarily be privy to all of them. We would not be privy to the details of an alert between two member states but we are aware of a number of other fraud alerts. I completely agree with all the statements that have been made about traceability. It is en EU-wide problem; hence the meeting that was called today.
Comment on this
I am conscious that we are somewhat constrained in what we can say despite the knowledge of other information we have. There is an ongoing investigation. I thank the witnesses for coming. The Department is in a difficult place ,but it is in everyone's interests that we have a fully open, transparent and fair process. It is important that there is a fair process and we do not lose sight of the kernel of the problem rather than focusing on the personalities alleged to be involved. We have to tread carefully. I thank the representatives of the organisations for coming before the committee and giving up their time. They have stewardship responsibilities and governmental responsibilities, which they fulfil well. The only message I want to share is one that Mr. Sheahan might want to discuss with his colleagues. We should have an independent and external review. There is clearly much fact-finding going on in the Department but it cannot be a complete process, and certainly not one that the public will have confidence in if it remains an internal investigation and even if Interpol, the Garda, the Food Safety Authority and other organisations are involved. I thank the witnesses for giving up their time to come before the committee.
Comment on this
I will go back to what I was asking about the information that came to the Department via HRI and what action was taken in response to the irregularities. I think our guests said that the issue was highlighted most in the Netherlands. What action, if any, was taken by the Department on the basis of that information?
Comment on this
Is the Senator talking about the list of horses that Mr. Osbourne mentioned?
Comment on this
I must admit that I do not know the answer to that. I was not directly involved so I cannot help the Senator. I do not know what exactly was-----
Comment on this
Would it surprise Mr. Sheahan to hear that a person allegedly provided that information and got no satisfaction? Due to the inaction, that person's next port of call was RTÉ.
Comment on this
I do not know. I cannot comment because I was not aware of any-----
Comment on this
A stitch in time saves nine. This whole fiasco could have been avoided, apparently and allegedly. As I say, we get information and cannot verify the sources at times. However, that is allegedly the case.
Comment on this
If action had been taken, RTÉ would never have been approached to pursue this investigation. Unfortunately, Mr. Sheahan, that brings me back to the Department's doorstep.